Judiciary Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (21)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1514
· 4 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…entative Armstrong's here. Without objection, let's move to House Bill 1514.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1251
· 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…Congratulations, Representative All right, going back up to House Bill 1251”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1177
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…sed upon Representative Tucker's request, I'm going to move House Bill 1177 to the deferred agenda. Does anybody else have any other bi…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1236
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “We're going to continue to pass over House Bill 1236 and House Bill 1248 at the request of the speaker. And Repr…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1248
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “We're going to continue to pass over House Bill 1236 and House Bill 1248 at the request of the speaker. And Representative Walker, i…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1055
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1055 Hammer TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF "MARITAL PROPERTY" FOR PU…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1095
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1095 Johnson CONCERNING THE REQUIREMENTS FOR A CONCEALED HANDGUN…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1152
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1152 Watson CONCERNING THE ABILITY OF AN AUXILIARY LAW ENFORCEME…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1173
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1173 Tucker TO AMEND AND MAKE CONSISTENT THE OFFENSES OF SEXUAL…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1175
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1175 Tucker TO REQUIRE LIFETIME REGISTRATION ON THE ARKANSAS SEX…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1265
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1265 Richey CONCERNING THE POSSESSION AND CARRYING OF A CONCEALE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1268
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1268 Murdock CONCERNING THE USE OF AN IGNITION INTERLOCK DEVICE.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1417
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1417 Sturch CONCERNING THE OFFENSE OF SEXUAL SOLICITATION; PROVI…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1433
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1433 Baltz TO PROHIBIT A REGISTERED SEX OFFENDER FROM LIVING NEA…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1444
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1444 Ballinger TO REVISE CERTAIN EMINENT DOMAIN LAWS THAT ARISE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1542
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “Shepherd HB1542 ADDRESSING THE SEALING OF A PERSON'S FELONY RECORD WHEN THE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1577
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1577 Hammer CONCERNING THE OFFENSE OF ARSON; AND CONCERNING THE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1578
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1578 Hammer CONCERNING OFFENSES INVOLVING RIOTS, INTERFERENCE WI…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB102
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB102 Rice TO CLARIFY THE LAW CONCERNING THE FINES, FEES, AND COS…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB20
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB20 J. Hendren CONCERNING THE OFFENSE OF AGGRAVATED ASSAULT UPO…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB42
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB42 Hutchinson CONCERNING FITNESS TO PROCEED AND LACK OF CRIMIN…”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 14, 2026
The committee will come to order, the chairman sees a quorum. A few items of housekeeping before we get started. Without objection, based upon Representative Tucker's request, I'm going to move House Bill 1177 to the deferred agenda. Does anybody else have any other bills? Um, representative rushing.
Can I have a personal point of privilege, please? Sure. You're recognized. I would just like everyone in this room to know and on our committee that we have a birthday in the room and
Speaker 7
0:46
our, uh, chairperson there representative shepherd is his birthday today. So happy birthday. Thank you.
I appreciate it. Thank you very much. Going back to the regular agenda, I understand Representative Tucker wants to pass over his bills, so we'll do that.
We're going to continue to pass over House Bill 1236 and House Bill 1248 at the request of the speaker. And Representative Walker, is he still in the room? Rebecca, we'll go see if you can track down Representative Walker. He was just here, so we can take up his bill. Representative Armstrong's here. Without objection, let's move to House Bill 1514.
You're recognized to present House Bill 1514. Thank you, Mr. Chair and members
Speaker 16
1:48
of the committee. House Bill 1514 is just a really decent bill that I've been working on with the Attorney General's office. that would instate a law that would hold you in a misdemeanor offense if you were to improperly use or alter the state seal. Over the summer, it was brought to my attention that there were some constituents
down in our more rural proportions of southern Arkansas that had received letters for collecting purposes from a collection agency and that it improperly used the state seal. We also had a member of our state senate run for office and actually used the state seal, the United States seal, I believe, and flipped it upside down, and there are a few pharmaceutical companies that have also used it. So we did some homework to make certain that it didn't impede with the Supreme Court law that was already in place
for misproperly using any of the state seals or logos, And there was a case that was cited by the attorney general's office with the United Networks of America, which is a pharmaceutical company that was improperly using the United States still as well. And so we're just trying to put this in place to ensure that none of our constituents or citizens are taken advantage of or scared into paying monies to an agency or an organization that may improperly use our state still. And I'd appreciate a good vote.
Any questions? Representative Blake Motion at the proper time Okay No one has signed up to speak for against the bill Representative Armstrong, would you like to close for your bill? Mr. Chairman, thank you Appreciate a good vote Representative Blake, what's your motion? Do pass Okay, we have a motion, do pass Is there any discussion? All in favor, say aye Aye Any opposed? Motion passed Congratulations, Representative All right, going back up to House Bill 1251
Representative Walker, welcome back to House Judiciary. And you're recognized to present House Bill 1251.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I don't have my full voice, and I apologize. But I miss being over here. I want you to know it. I have Bill 1251, which is a bill by its title concerning the temporary abatement of the requirement of a person to pay court-ordered civil penalties,
cost, fees, fines, or restitution while that person is incarcerated or confined to a hospital, and to prohibit the denial of public assistance based upon a drug-related felony conviction. The bill is pretty explanatory. Have all of you had a chance to read the bill? I have several people who are here to testify on behalf of the bill, and I'd like for them to come up.
All right, it looks like we've got a list of seven or eight different people that have signed up to speak for the bill. Representative Walker, if you could go ahead and conclude your presentation, then I'll allow each of these individuals to make a statement.
For now, my presentation is concluded. Okay. All right. Members,
without objection, I'm going to go ahead and allow these six or seven individuals to make brief comments for the bill, and then we'll go back to the list on any others that
may have signed up to speak for the bill. It doesn't appear that there's anybody else signed up. If you would, state your name and if you represent any particular entity, and then you may make a
Speaker 29
5:54
brief statement. My name's Zach Hudson. I'm one of the leaders and founders of the Hope Group at Pulaski Heights Baptist Church. To speak on behalf of this bill, I see and have dealt with myself people being released from prison, not able to receive food stamp benefits, and also, in addition to that,
having sometimes thousands of dollars worth of fees that they acquired while they were incarcerated hanging over their head. This puts a huge financial strain on people that are already in a less than favorable position that, as a society, we're supposed to be trying to help succeed and become rehabilitated. This is absolutely detrimental to that, for them to not be able to receive the same assistance that everyone else is if they qualify otherwise for, and to also have these fees over their head.
Not everybody goes into incarceration in good standing with their, you know, civil fees, but a lot do. And if they were in good standing with it then, they were incarcerated and not able to remain in good standing. I don't see why we should be holding that against them at that point in time. Thank you. All right. Thank you for your comments.
All right. If you would state your name and who you represent, you may make a brief statement. Okay. My name is Jennifer Robertson.
I'm representing the HOPE group and the HOPE bill. It's just really hard for us to come out and try to be productive citizens. When I went into prison, Owing $2,100, and I came out Owing $4,300. So, I mean, I really try. I'm trying my hardest. I know I did what I did, and I paid for that. But it's hard for me to make it out here. I work a minimum wage job, and I'm barely making it. I barely put food in my house because I do pay my fines and I do keep caught up on everything and that's all I have
Thank you for your comments You're recognized to state your name who you represent
and then you may make a brief statement My name is Billy Lawson and I'm also here for the Hope Group and the bill I also have a drug charge and I went in and did my time I am also on a fixed income and with having the charges I have I can't get no assistance at all, and it's almost impossible for having the fixed income I'm on to provide for me and my family.
And I just want to say that this hope bill is so important to people like us that have these charges to reach out and just help us because we have done our time for the crime that we did. And also some of us even go further. You know, we go on and get rehab. We reach out, you know, to churches. And I just so agree and so forward for this HOPE bill. Thank you. Thank you for
your comments. You're recognized to state your name, who you represent, and you may make a brief statement.
Yes, my name is Linda Gilbert, and I'm representing the HOPE bill. The HOPE group is the group that I'm a part of, and I'm trying to come across that maybe our employees, for some of the public assistance, places uh the dhs and stuff maybe be more educated because i had uh it took me like four months to get public assistance and that was only because of a discrepancy in the computer program and i think they were going by an old program they mentioned so i'm really hoping that maybe they
can get updated more often and that they can be more educated thank you thank
Speaker 45
9:46
you I'm Brandy Allen. I'm also with the Hope Group, and I'm for the bill. You know, I went into jail, only into prison. I only owed $190, and when I come out, I owed $690.
dollars um also they had tried to serve me with a misdemeanor warrant for my arrest for a warrant that or a court date that i was in their custody the state of arkansas's custody when they gave me the um warrant also you know i um came out owing 23 000 in child support for the 13 and a half months that I was locked up. Um, you know, I work, I, I come out, I come, you know, I've worked full
time since I've got out and you know, the back child support and the back, the, the late, the court fees, I, I, I, I barely make enough to live on. Um, so yeah, I'm definitely for the bill. I have a question for her.
I have a question for her. Um, Um, we, that's fine. Maybe you could, you could address it in your closing. I will. Normally the rules don't allow for a noncommittee member to ask a question.
Speaker 52
11:00
Thank you. Thank you. Thank you very much. Thank you for your comments. Good morning. My name is Dale Sharp. I work with the Phoenix Recovery Center women, uh, the ones you've just heard from. I also do some work with Hidden Creek re-entry program. I have a daughter that was incarcerated for 12 years. She is out now. I have learned through working with these individuals the tough time they have when they get out, making it in society.
The ones you've heard about were there for drug charges. That's most of the people in prison are there for drug charges. They're not bad people. They're not violent people. They suffer from the addiction of drug disease. When they get out, I take them to acquire their IDs, Social Security cards. I do a lot of transporting. I watch them go through the anxiety of trying to make it back into society. They have to pay parole fees. They report to their parole officer.
Most get minimum wage jobs, and these jobs are part-time for the most part. So trying to make it part-time on a minimum wage job is very, very difficult. Minimum wage is $8.50 an hour, so take that times about $30, and you see what they make. And when you hear the fees they have to pay, it is almost insurmountable, and what it causes is an anxiety level through the first several months of release, and anxiety is a drug addict's worst offender.
Most of them are working in recovery. They've acquired a sponsor. They're going to recovery meetings, either CA, NA, or AA. They're trying very hard to make it, but the anxiety continues to attack them. So we're asking that you please consider the bill and please vote for this bill to help these people so they do not have to go back into incarceration, into an overcrowded situation that we already have. Thank you very much.
Thank you. All right. it appears we have two other individuals who have signed up to speak for the bill. The first is Paul Calvert. Mr. Calvert, you're recognized to speak for the bill. Yes, sir. generally i wouldn't
come up and speak in favor of a bill that um recommends more welfare benefits
um and generally i'm um in favor of um of penalties being carried out which i think Look, in this bill, what it does is it gives lenience to people who have a hard time paying their criminal debts. But one of the reasons why I am in favor of this bill is because I think that there are incredible impediments to employment right now, just to the general public, but I think that it's an even worse position for people with a criminal record.
And so this is actually – to me, this is – my testimony today is hopefully to encourage Republicans and Democrats as well to fight to get rid of these employment impediments, to make it possible in many cases and easier in other cases for people to actually gain employment once they get out of prison and just for people in general. I mean, right now, there's all kinds of occupational licensing.
There's minimum wage. There's all kinds of things that basically make it illegal to engage in honorable work. I mean, you can't even cut hair without a license, for crying out loud. I heard a story about a guy recently getting out of prison, and he knew how to cut hair. He was cutting hair in prison. He got out, and it was illegal for him to engage in this honorable form of employment because it was against the law, not because it was immoral. And so today I'm going to actually stand up and support welfare for criminals because I think our current government system is driving people back to crime when you make it illegal for them to work.
So please vote for this bill. Thank you for your comments. We have one other individual signed up. Charles Robertson
Speaker 63
15:49
signed up to speak for the bill. You're recognized. Thank you. To follow up with what Paul was saying, I'm against the welfare state. However, when society shackles an individual's ability to feed themselves or the family, it then becomes society's burden to make sure that they are taken care of. So let us first take the shackles off, but if we're not going to do that,
then it becomes our responsibility to take care of them. That's all. Thank you for
your comments. Representative Ballinger, do you have a
question? You're recognized for a question. Yes, Mr. Chair, it's a question for Representative Walker. Currently, there is no prohibition of giving food stamps or any other benefits to a person because of the fact that they have a criminal conviction. Is that correct? What I'm wondering is, what is the problem that's being addressed by the first part in section one of your bill?
So lines 5 through 10 on page 2, I guess, of the
bill. Representative Ballinger, what we are trying to do is make it possible for for persons who have been convicted of drug offenses to be no less favorably treated than
persons who come back into society who have been convicted of murder and other felonies that may be of more serious proportion. Okay, so
is this specifically designed to address the issue of the drug testing for people with welfare benefits? Is that? Not good. No,
this doesn't have anything to do with drug testing. It's basically trying to even the field so that people who have been convicted of felony drug offenses can be treated like other felons who come back into society and get some public assistance.
Okay, but are you saying that currently, if you're convicted of a felony drug offense, that you are not eligible for these welfare benefits? Yes. Okay, that's actually, that's surprising to me. I didn't know that was the case. So I guess then my other question, may I have a follow-up, is in general with what you're looking to accomplish, I actually agree with the problem that you see and that you're trying to address.
I'm actually on the board of a reentry ministry in Northwest Arkansas, and it's an issue that I think is real important. I mean, if you don't want your prisons overcrowded, then you keep them out of prison, and you help bridge them back into a different kind of community than what got them in prison. So I agree 100%. One of the things that is a big burden to them are their fees and costs and all that. So all that is 100% legitimate. Now, one of the things I also balance that with is I also come in here and I say, you know, that we should find the criminals and the bad actors to pay for their crime.
I also agree that that's true as well. So now we're in a little bit of a conflict here, and, you know, I do think it's hard for people to pay them back. But what I've also found is that typically the courts are fairly flexible. Now, maybe what you're trying to do is address some courts that aren't, and I'm not familiar with those courts. I mean, do you have specific instances where the court is not being flexible with somebody on repaying their fine? Go ahead, I'm sorry.
Well, I think that it's generally to the court's discretion, but in terms of pay, part of the problem is that the fans often continue while one is incarcerated, and they multiply so that when one comes out, one owes far more than one owed going in. So it becomes very difficult. And now, while a judge may have some discretion,
there are no standards by which that discretion may be exercised. So if a judge doesn't like a particular offender or even the offense in the scenario you set up, the judge may deny leniency in terms of fine repayment to that particular person. So we're trying to have a standard across the board that all judges have to generally apply. Representative
Whitaker, you're recognized for a question.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative, thanks for bringing this bill. It's something that's dear to my heart too. But I do have a question on your very last paragraph of the bill. There's some language there that says there is no limit to the number of times a person may appear before the court to address the payment of his or her remaining court-ordered civil penalties, etc. I'm just curious, have you gotten any feedback from the bench on what sounds like an unlimited number of times a person can show up in your court asking the same question?
The answer to that is no, I haven't had any feedback. But here's the deal, if a person is unable to pay his or her fine at the designated time, then the person is obliged to return to the court and explain to the court that the person is unable to do so. Failure to return would impose an additional fine. Yes. So that adds to the obligation. So if a person is, because of
the nature of her or his circumstance, unable to obtain employment or whatever, the thing that they would be doing is, as long as they're unable to obtain employment, just make sure that they do the reporting, just like they must report to the probation officers and the other, and then go in and explain to the court their circumstance. I don't know that that would be a hardship on the court, but I think that the judge also has the opportunity to. My guru here is telling me I have to use the word discretion to court.
Of course, the court has the power to relate to it as he or she sees fit, which we call discretion, and it's complete. Follow up.
So what you're anticipating here is that this would be a court initiated come back in or how, I guess, and I know this may just be too deep in the weeds for what you're actually seeing here. But how is this unlimited chance to come back in the court exercised?
Does the parolee ask for this court time? Does the judge call them in? How do you anticipate that working? Well, the way I
would anticipate it working is that a person would have a time certain for making a fee payment, and then that person has to either make the payment or report to the court. So what the person would be doing is reporting to the court and the court would be hearing his or her explanation. And in that circumstance, the court would be able to
determine what to do, which would be exercise his or her discretion at that
point. Thank you, sir. Representative Rushing, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Walker, I just have one question. And, you know, we all hear the horror stories of the abuse of the SNAP benefits and them being sold to get cash and purchase drugs. And while I typically don't think this is something that we do all, that this happens all the time, and I think most of you all know that,
if someone is found guilty of a drug felony and then also guilty of abusing the SNAP program benefits, How does this bill address something of its nature? Is it covered under the SNAP eligibility rules or is this something that would need to be addressed in
this bill as well? I don't think it, I don't think Representative Rushing that it has to be addressed in this bill. We're talking about persons who have been incarcerated, who have been found guilty of felonies. And they are in the general population either working or seeking work.
And they have these impediments that restrict or limit their ability to obtain employment and to otherwise feed their families and go on with their lives. Now, if they get SNAP benefits, then they, of course, are obliged to follow the regulations of the SNAP benefit recipients. Follow-up, if I may, Mr. Chair. Okay,
but I think what the question that I'm actually asking is if they have part of their drug felonies that they went to prison for
related back to that they were on maybe possibly SNAP before, and now that we're going to allow them to get back on SNAP, and could they not go about the same sorts of activities that they had before by selling the benefits to get money to purchase drugs instead of feed their family? And is this addressed in the eligibility for SNAP, or is this something we need to maybe pull down this bill and look at adding that to it and then bringing it back? I'm in support of the bill other than that one possibility.
Well, I think that if they violate the provisions of SNAP and a prosecutor chooses to prosecute them for that, then that would be a new offense. There would be no reason to deny them the benefits because of what they may do with respect to misuse of SNAP benefits. I mean, that's prospective. We're dealing with things that have already happened.
All of these people that you've heard have already been convicted. They are impeded. They have no opportunity to either get full employment or to be treated, and then they have inordinate burdens. We're not talking about what will happen under the new SNAP requirements that have been imposed upon them by recent legislation. I would prefer that they rise or fall on the basis of the past circumstances
rather than what they will be doing or may do in
the future. Representative Walker, I have just a couple of questions, and we have a few other representatives that have questions as well. And I just want to make sure that I understand the various aspects of this bill. With regard to Section 1, which Representative Ballinger and Representative Rushing have asked about, As I understand it, this eligibility issue and the actual language of the bill which you're offering,
it would only apply with regard to a person who's been convicted of a drug-related offense. And more specifically, if they were convicted of multiple offenses, this provision only relates to the fact that they couldn't be denied based because of the drug related of felony offense. If they were charged and convicted with other offenses, this bill would not affect whether they could or couldn't be eligible.
Is that correct? That's right. Okay, and then my second question is as to these various sections related to court-ordered penalties. And as I understand it, this bill would prohibit a court from entering an order invoking such penalties while an individual is incarcerated. Would you agree that the court could actually, after incarceration, could at that point enter an order invoking such penalties?
Well, I think that the court always has the power to invoke such penalties after the fact upon hearing. It just can't be an arbitrary thing. The person has to be given notice of the basis for the additional fees and then an opportunity to be heard and to be represented by
character. Sure, and really my question goes, even setting aside the due process aspects, I'm just kind of wondering so I can understand the actual effect of this bill.
An individual who was, maybe an order was entered at the time they were sentenced. That would still, that penalty would still be binding on them. That appears that the following sections of your bill would then say, it just can't be collected or otherwise enforced while an individual is incarcerated. and then up to 60 days after they leave incarceration. Yes, sir. That's right. But this bill does nothing to affect the actual penalty that's been invoked.
There's no forgiveness of anything that's owed, and there's nothing that would address whether there's additional expenses or other fines, penalties that could be assessed in the future. Is that correct? That is correct. Okay, and thank you for answering my questions. I just wanted to make sure I understood the key components to this bill. And then we've got a couple other questions. Representative Blake, you're recognized for a question.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Walker, correct me if I'm wrong.
But if someone is charged with a felony and they come out and And they go back into a household, now a drug felony, now their entire family can't get SNAP benefits, right? That's the way I understand it works. And this legislation will solve that problem? Yes. Thank you. Motion at the proper
time, Mr. Chair. Representative Smith, you're recognized for a question.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative
Walker, I have spoken with some of the constituents in my area and not necessarily about this bill, but regarding incarceration, felony, drug convictions, and that type of thing. Some of them, when they're taken into custody and booked, even before their court dates, local sheriff's departments, whatever, they will say, oh, you missed a court date in another state.
Things will pop up. So what I'm wondering is, does your bill, if it passes and gets through to law, would it also make some kind of reasonable accommodations to an individual that may serve their six or eight months in our system and then be extradited to another state? Would it take care of that as well, or is this only because on page 2, line 29 and following, it talks about local county jails.
I'm just wondering if after they serve their time here but then are transferred to another state, would that end those benefits, or would our law still provide those benefits to their family while their family member is incarcerated? Thank you.
Well, I guess I would try to analogize this to a person who's been convicted of murder in Arkansas and been released and is otherwise eligible for food stamps or other Arkansas benefits.
That person would be entitled to his or her benefits, and if another state wishes to extradite that person, then the extradition rules would apply. Whether the person is actually extradited becomes a matter, becomes another legal process that this bill does not address. So what happens in the next state is not affected by it. Representative Dalby, you're recognized for
Chair. I want to make sure I understand.
It appears that there is a shift. The first part of this bill is people who have been convicted of drug offenses. And then we move to Section 3, and it makes it broader for conviction of a criminal offense. So that would be any criminal offense. Am
I correct in the way it makes that shift? Right now, the only people who are ineligible for these benefits are persons who have been convicted of drug offenses.
So this only puts the persons who have been convicted of drug offenses on the same field, playing field, if you call it, with persons who
or other offenses. Follow up, please. And I understand that, but I'm looking at page 2, line 25, through page 3, line 1, And particularly line 27, it says, for a conviction of a criminal offense.
And my question is, are we broadening that from a drug offense to any criminal offense? And a second part of that question, when you move to line 36, confined to a hospital or inpatient facility for mental, physical, or emotional condition, is that confinement based upon the conviction of the criminal offense? or is that just anybody who might have gone into the hospital? So I really have a two-part question in regard to this Section 3.
Representative Walker, why don't you have your associates sit down next to you? I allowed some leeway there. Generally, we don't allow individuals to approach, but if you would, go ahead and state your name and who you represent, and then maybe you can help us with some of these questions.
All right, my name is Omavi Shakur. I guess I'm just a concerned citizen in that case. But so the first part of your answer is no. It does not broaden the class of people who are now eligible for the federal benefits.
Now, why it doesn't broaden that is because the only class, the sole class under the federal legislation in 1996, The only class of people convicted of crimes that are ineligible for these benefits are people convicted of felony drug offenses. So right now, there are no other class of people convicted of offenses that are banned from these benefits. So could the language say only people convicted of felony drug offenses?
Yes, it could say that, but effectively, the effect is the same as if it only said that. So the answer to your first part of your question is no. The second part of your question, the answer to that is that it only applies, so convictions. Can you restate your second, the second part of your question again? Let me, since we now
have you at the table, maybe so that we'll be on the same page. I understand the drug felony part of the bill and the SNAP part.
I understand that. That's not my question. My question is, and maybe I'm reading section three wrong, page two, section three, when it talks in line 23 and on, and particularly line 25, it says a person's not required to pay and a court shall not issue a warrant or impose a monetary penalty for failure to pay court-ordered Civil penalties, costs, fees, fines, or restitution for a conviction of a criminal offense, and then it goes on. So my question is, I'm not worried about that first part on the drug offense and the SNAP part.
I'm wanting to know, are we now saying that anybody for any crime, that their fines, fees, court costs, and everything are abated while they are
in prison? Correct. So, sorry, I misunderstood your question before. So, yes, this means that if you're convicted of any crime and the judge orders that you pay X amount of dollars, right, then you have to 100% pay that complete amount that the judge ordered that you pay.
The only difference is that while you're incarcerated, the payments don't continue to accrue like the ladies and gentlemen that testified before said that they continue to accrue. And so what it does is puts these people in the same position as they would have been had they been placed on probation or parole instead of being incarcerated, and ensures, it maintains, that they have to pay 100% of the fines or fees that the judge ordered that they pay.
The only difference is that they're not penalized for being incarcerated additionally by their fines and fees continuing to accrue. So they 100% have to repay that debt to society. Follow up
to my second question in that same section. Yes. Line 36 of section 3 on page 2. It says, confined to a hospital or inpatient facility for a mental, physical, or emotional condition. Is that based upon their underlying conviction, or is it I'm in the hospital because I have pneumonia,
so therefore abate my fines and
fees? So if they're inpatient, right, if they're inpatient, so for any inpatient hospitalization, and the reason for that is because, one, it doesn't cost society anything because they still have to pay 100% of the fines and fees assessed by the court. Two, if you're hospitalized, you're not getting income, and so it would defy reason. It would stand against reason to have your fines and fees go up, like the ladies testified, while you're inpatient, right?
Not outpatient, but inpatient. So if you're only inpatient for a week, it doesn't really have any significant effect. But if you're inpatient for, let's say, two or three months, and usually fines and fees are, you know, you have to pay on a monthly basis, then that's the only effect it has, practical effect, is inpatient for a month or more. So that's the only practical effect. Representative Maddox, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr.
Chair. Well, I'm going to be frank, I have numerous concerns about this bill.
I think the intent is good, but what Representative Dalby was touching on, And we've talked a lot about fees and fines and court fees, but this also
includes restitution, does it not? Right, and it does not affect the amount of restitution you have to pay. Sure. So if let's say somebody, you know, injures, let's say somebody steals $1,000 from a person, right? Then that person has to pay every single cent of that $1,000 back. And so it doesn't really have any practical effect on restitution.
I guess my point is, and what Representative Dalby pointed out, is this addresses all crimes, basically. And wouldn't you agree with me, there are certain situations where a defendant may actually have the means, they may actually have some money, they may have a family member who can pay it, and judges have discretion to order it paid or to not order it paid. Is
that correct? So this doesn't take the judge's discretion away at all. This does not tie the judge's hands at all.
The only difference is that people, once they're released, they have that 60-day grace period. But again, they have to pay every single cent. And so it does not take, the judge's initial order is not affected whatsoever. The only difference is that these are late, There's late payment penalties that are being assessed on people that are being incarcerated and hospitalized.
That's, and so it's not any decrease kind of sentence or anything like that. It doesn't tie the judge's hands up. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
And I guess I've got to follow up from that because to follow up on Representative Maddox's question, It would preclude any collection of any restitution while a person is incarcerated. I mean, so it does seem like it does restrict what a judge may or may not allow.
Is there something that I'm missing? It just, it affects the timing, but it
doesn't affect the actual order. Okay, and that's what I wanted to get to Representative Walker's earlier answers to my question. It's not excusing any amount that's owed, it's just an issue about when it's actually paid. Right. But that's still, to Representative Maddox's concerns, if there were other funds available, and particularly with regard to restitution, this would excuse the payment of restitution until that person is actually out of leaves incarceration.
Correct. They're not required to pay it. They may pay it, but they're not required. And the only thing the court can't do is issue a warrant or impose a monetary penalty for failure to pay said order. Thank you for your answers.
Any other questions from the committee? All right, Representative Walker, would you like to close for your bill? I'm closed. Thank you. Representative Blake, what's your motion? Do pass. We have a motion, do pass. Is there any discussion?
Representative Ballinger? Thank you, Mr. Chair. From my perspective, as I said, I volunteered, I don't know, probably more than 1,000 hours to work with addicted folks through the ministry that we have in our church, Reformers Unanimous Ministry, and then for years I've worked with Reentry Coalition in Northwest Arkansas, which is a great group, and then now I'm on the board of a reentry ministry. I think that this is something that we should look at in one way that we can save money for the state is by helping people transition out, handing them a bus ticket and 100 bucks.
That is not a win, that's a loss for the state and for the individuals and for everybody. However, what I'd have a little bit of concerns about is, too, is functionally the way this would work. Either it does something or it does nothing. And so if it does nothing, then we're back to the judiciary having the authority and the discretion to make decisions. And if it's just basically a resolution from the legislature saying that we want you to work with folks,
then I could almost support it like that, but I'd want to make sure that that's really all it does. If it does something, then what we're doing is absolutely taking discretion away. And one thing that helps these people who are reentering is a lot of people got where they were because they have not taken responsibility for their actions. And having this burden over top of them, you know, if they are willing to work through it and they're willing to deal with that adversity and they have a judge who's smart and kind and willing to allow them, you know, if they get into a hard spot to have some flexibility, that is going to help them in the end.
Even if it's hard, you know, while they're incarcerated, they're going to cost the state anywhere between $45 and $75 a day or more while they're doing it. They're not paying rent. They're not paying for their food. Now, it's not the best accommodations in the world. But that's the reality is when they're incarcerated, they are costing the state money. You know, if there's still occurring penalties, that isn't necessarily a bad thing that they are, you know, being required to pay a little bit back for the burden that they put on the state's side. Now, you know, if you want to argue about whether a person really should be locked up, I think there's good reason to talk about that.
But I think in this bill, you've got to assume that they were locked up for good reasons. And if they're not, then that's altogether a different bill that we need to deal with. The other thing I have a little bit of concern about is I think that we deal with two totally different issues that probably shouldn't be combined in one bill. They probably ought to be in two different bills. One is we're dealing with the entitlements and who's qualified for entitlements and who are not. And the other, we're dealing with individuals who are on repayment of penalties and fines when they're incarcerated.
And I just don't think those relate enough to create the nexus that's required in order for it to satisfy constitutional muster. Having said all this, I think your heart is 100% in the right place. I think what you want to do, I would like to try to help you to do it. I just wouldn't want to make it where the burden was lifted and it was so easy for the person not to have to pay it back that that burden is taken off from them,
because I think that burden is something they should bear and would be good for them to bear it. But at the same time, I don't want people to be locked up because of the fact that they have fees and fines if they're willing to work hard in order to repay those fees and fines. But anyway, having said that, I mean, I totally support what you want to do, and, you know, my heart is with your heart on this. I just don't think that this is the best way to do
it. Any other questions, comments, discussion? All right, the motion. I would have, if I may, listening to Senator.
I'll allow a brief comment. I'm receptive to
the comments of Representative Ballinger and would be willing to have the bull pull for the time being to visit with him and others. And I just point out that I believe it, we both believe it's a good bill. We do have evidence that a report through a report from the Yale School of Medicine that 91% of people released from prison don't have reliable access to food.
You're aware of that and you're sensitive to it. So for that reason, I think that we can improve the bill, make it more clear to me, Representative Dalby's concerns, and I'd be happy to withdraw
the bill for that purpose. All right. Thank you, Representative Walker. Representative Blake, in light of Representative Walker's comments, would you be willing to withdraw your motion? Yes, sir. Okay. Committee, thank you for your questions. Representative Walker, thank you for bringing this bill and for being willing to work with the members of the committee.
We'll leave it on our regular agenda and see if there can be some consensus reached before it is brought back in front
Speaker 140
48:06
Thank all of you for listening. All right, committee, we'll wait just a second.
Let's let some of the commotion die down and then we'll get back to our agenda.
All right, committee, we're going to go back to our agenda. Is Representative Murdoch here? All right, we'll pass over House Bill 1268. Senator Hendren, we're going to pass over Senate Bill 20. But I would anticipate that probably being run on Thursday, just for everybody's information.
Representative Sterch, Senator Rice, this bill, they're looking at an amendment on Senate Bill 102. So that may be something that comes back in the near future. Representative Balz, Representative Hammer.
Senator Hutchinson, we think Senator Hutchinson's going to be back in here shortly to run Senate Bill 42. We've already run House Bill 1514, House Bill 1542 I'm looking at an amendment to clean that up. And then House Bill 1577 and 1578, we're waiting on some information on those.
So let's, if the committee will be patient for just a few minutes. Let's see if we can get Senator Hutchinson back in here. Thank you.
Senator Hutchinson's on his way back down. There's actually an amendment to that bill that Rebecca has put on your tablets,
adding Representative Whitaker, and actually, why don't I, Representative Whitaker, you want to make a motion to amend? Absolutely, I so move. Okay, we have a motion to amend Senate Bill 42. Is there any discussion? all in favor say aye any opposed representative Whitaker I'm not sure what
been amended and as soon as Senator Hutchinson gets back down here we'll let him present if the bill is amended.
Speaker 32
55:21
Senator Hutchinson, thank you for making your way back down here. Well, thank you for the invite. We hope that
the Senate will extend the same courtesy to all House members as we go to the Senate to run bills. We let House members
Speaker 158
55:41
run bills any time they want to. Unfortunately, we don't have this luxurious of accommodations for you. This is my first time in this committee room, and the House clearly has a bigger budget than we do in the Senate.
All right. I think maybe we should bet committee rooms on tonight's game. If we win, we get this committee
room. You're recognized to present your bill. We've already amended it for you.
Speaker 158
56:15
All right. So, members, this bill is a Bar Association bill, and they're welcome to join me if they'd like to. But it tries to accomplish what we tried to accomplish a few years ago,
which is bifurcating the mental evaluations for a criminal defendant. Currently, the way our courts are handling this is if there's a fitness to proceed evaluation evaluation that needs to be done to see if a defendant's fit for trial, that they're also ordering a criminal liability. That's not the right term, but seeing if they had the mental capacity to understand between right and wrong when they committed the actual crime. And that
is a far more intensive and expensive and time-consuming evaluation. This bill simply It strikes a lot, and it's kind of voluminous, but really all it does is clarify that judges in court shall only issue a fitness-to-proceed evaluation and do that first, and only if there's been a request, which oftentimes they're getting evaluated when they haven't even pled that defense.
But only if they plead that offense or request, there'll be a criminal liability evaluation. It should save money, should speed up the process. Prosecutors are good with it because they can get to trial faster. Criminal defendants are in the defense bars. Criminal defense bars are good with it because their clients may not be sitting in county jail for nine months awaiting an evaluation.
If they are, in fact, deemed to be unfit for trial and the county jails are good with it because they don't want them sitting in their county jail either for that long, just
waiting for an evaluation. All right. Any questions? All right. I see no questions. It does not appear anybody has signed up to speak for or against the bill. Representative Whitaker? Motion to add. Okay. Senator Hutchinson, are you closed for the bill? I am. Representative Whitaker, what's your motion?
I move do pass. As amended. All right, we have a motion. Do pass as amended. Is there any discussion? All in favor indicate by saying aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion passes.
Speaker 158
58:55
Thank you. Congratulations. You run a very well committee. I wish I had this good of a committee on the Senate. Don't tell my members I said
that. They can watch it for themselves since we live stream, so.
Representative Ballinger, I believe, is going to go ahead and he's going to run Senate Bill 20 for Senator Hendren. Representative Ballinger, you're recognized. Thank
you, Mr. Chair. All right, Senate Bill 20 is something that I think is kind of a good pairing or match with the bill that Representative Tosh ran that created sentence enhancements for
law enforcement. Well, what this does, this actually creates a new offense of aggravated assault upon a law enforcement officer or employee of a correctional facility. So we're in a little bit of a, have a little bit of a cultural phenomena that's going on where in our society, where it's getting to be cool, at least in some groups and with some people, to assault law enforcement officers. I think that that's not a large portion of our population that's out there and thinks that that's a good idea. However, we do know and we do see that there are individuals who are promoting that idea.
And so what this is, is the idea is to try to create a little bit of a deterrence from doing so. So if you look, it's a, I don't know, eight page bill. But most of what you see is after the offense is created on page two through three, with the elements as to what it would do, is just applying this new crime that's been created, this new offense has been created, to the different code sections,
or a person who commits a violent offense is prohibited from getting a license or doing other things. Having said all that, I'd be happy to answer any questions that I can quickly make up an answer to. Representative Charlene Fite, you're recognized for a question. You did say you were going to ask me some hard questions, so here we go.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. And actually, this is because I am not an attorney and I'm not law enforcement, so I'm not really sure what a class Y felony involves.
Well, it essentially is about the highest end of a felony. Now, I don't do criminal law personally myself, and so I can't tell you what the likelihood of what the sentence the person would get out of that. But it is basically a high-end felony, and I know there's other people who do could tell you. Representative Tucker, you're recognized. Representative Ballinger, if I told
you a class Y felony was punishable by 10 to 40 years in prison, would you agree with that?
Yeah, I would agree with that 100%. Because you'd never leave me wrong, Representative Tucker.
Any other questions from the committee? All right. Representative Blake, you're recognized. What's the
current penalty for assault versus a law enforcement officer or correction officer? So there's
actually not one. So that is the point of this bill is this. Now, assault, there is a penalty on, but there is not an aggravated assault there is. But in this case, what we're doing is creating a specific offense that if you're targeting a law enforcement officer, then it moves it into a new crime.
Now, obviously, prosecutors don't have to prosecute under this. They can prosecute under the current regiment. But this creates just kind of a heightened offense for assaulting law enforcement officers in the line of duty. Any other
questions? All right, it does not appear anybody has signed up to speak for or against the bill. Representative Valinger, would you like to
close for the bill? Yeah, I'd appreciate the attention given to this and would
appreciate a good vote, and move do pass. All right, we have a motion do pass.
Is there any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion passes. Thank you. Congratulations. All right, committee, I believe we've gone through everything on our regular agenda and taken up everything that was ready to run today. I anticipate the next several meetings will be somewhat similar to this. We'll just take up bills as they are ready to run.
If you have something that you would like to run, please give me a heads up and I'll try and let the committee know. But otherwise, just we've obviously done a lot of work to shorten our agenda here. So we'll continue to try and pare it down further and further. If there's no further business before the committee without objection, we're adjourned.
Agenda
HB1173 Tucker TO AMEND AND MAKE CONSISTENT THE OFFENSES OF SEXUAL INDECENCY WITH A CHILD AND SEXUAL ASSAULT IN THE FOURTH DEGREE; AND TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF "SEXUAL ABUSE" UNDER THE CHILD MALTREATMENT ACT.
HB1175 Tucker TO REQUIRE LIFETIME REGISTRATION ON THE ARKANSAS SEX OFFENDER REGISTRY FOR A PERSON CONVICTED OF RAPE WHEN THE RAPE INVOLVED THE USE OF FORCE
HB1177 Tucker INCREASING THE AVAILABLE SENTENCES FOR CERTAIN SEX OFFENSES WHEN COMMITTED AGAINST A FAMILY OR HOUSEHOLD MEMBER.
HB1236 Gazaway PROTECT THE LAW OF PRIVACY A TO MEMBERS FAMILY SURVIVING OFENFORCEMENT OFFICER WHO DIES IN THE LINE OF DUTY; AND TO EXEMPT CERTAIN LAW ENFORCEMENT RECORDS FROM DISCLOSURE AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1248 Williams TO CREATE AN EXEMPTION UNDER THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT OF 1967 J. CONCERNING CERTAIN LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIVE RECORDS.
HB1251 Walker TO CREATE THE "HELPING OUR PEOPLE EXCEL (H.O.P.E.) ACT OF 2017"; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES.
HB1268 Murdock CONCERNING THE USE OF AN IGNITION INTERLOCK DEVICE.
SB20 J. Hendren CONCERNING THE OFFENSE OF AGGRAVATED ASSAULT UPON A CERTIFIED LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER OR AN EMPLOYEE OF A CORRECTIONAL FACILITY; TO PROVIDE A MORE SERIOUS PENALTY FOR KNOWINGLY DISCHARGING A FIREARM AT A LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER.
HB1417 Sturch CONCERNING THE OFFENSE OF SEXUAL SOLICITATION; PROVIDING FOR IMPOUNDMENT OF A MOTOR VEHICLE; AND PROVIDING FOR HUMAN TRAFFICKING AWARENESS EDUCATION FOR EDUCATORS.
SB102 Rice TO CLARIFY THE LAW CONCERNING THE FINES, FEES, AND COSTS THAT MAY BE ASSESSED FOR A VIOLATION OF THE MANDATORY SEAT BELT USE LAW.
HB1433 Baltz TO PROHIBIT A REGISTERED SEX OFFENDER FROM LIVING NEAR A FACILITY WHERE A PERSON WITH A MEDICALLY DIAGNOSED MENTAL DISABILITY OR PHYSICAL DISABILITY RESIDES.
HB1055 Hammer TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF "MARITAL PROPERTY" FOR PURPOSES OF DIVISION OF PROPERTY IN AN ACTION FOR DIVORCE.
SB42 Hutchinson CONCERNING FITNESS TO PROCEED AND LACK OF CRIMINAL RESPONSIBILITY; AND J. CONCERNING A MENTAL EVALUATION OF A CRIMINAL DEFENDANT.
HB1514 E. Armstrong TO CREATE THE OFFENSE OF IMPROPER USE OF OR ALTERING THE STATE SEAL.
Shepherd HB1542 ADDRESSING THE SEALING OF A PERSON'S FELONY RECORD WHEN THE PERSON IS A FIRST-TIME FELONY OFFENDER.
HB1577 Hammer CONCERNING THE OFFENSE OF ARSON; AND CONCERNING THE STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS FOR ARSON.
HB1578 Hammer CONCERNING OFFENSES INVOLVING RIOTS, INTERFERENCE WITH EMERGENCY MEDICAL SERVICES PERSONNEL OR FIRST RESPONDERS, DISORDERLY CONDUCT, AND OBSTRUCTING A HIGHWAY OR OTHER PUBLIC PASSAGE; AND ESTABLISHING CIVIL LIABILITY.
HB1095 Johnson CONCERNING THE REQUIREMENTS FOR A CONCEALED HANDGUN LICENSE FOR A n CURRENT OR FORMER MEMBER OF THE UNITED STATES ARMED FORCES.
HB1265 Richey CONCERNING THE POSSESSION AND CARRYING OF A CONCEALED OR UNCONCEALED HANDGUN; TO ESTABLISH A LICENSE TO CARRY AN UNCONCEALED HANDGUN; AND TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS.
HB1152 Watson CONCERNING THE ABILITY OF AN AUXILIARY LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER TO CARRY A CONCEALED HANDGUN AND TO BE EXEMPTED FROM THE LICENSING REQUIREMENTS TO CARRY A CONCEALED HANDGUN.
HB1444 Ballinger TO REVISE CERTAIN EMINENT DOMAIN LAWS THAT ARISE OUT OF PROPERTY RIGHTS SECURED UNDER THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION, ARTICLE 2, § 22.
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Matthew J. Shepherd Chair
Unverified
Representative Laurie Rushing
Unverified
Speaker 7
Speaker 16
Representative John W. Walker
Unverified
Speaker 29
Jennifer Robertson
Unverified
Billy Lawson
Unverified
Linda Gilbert
Unverified
Speaker 45
Speaker 52
Paul Calvert
Unverified
Speaker 63
Representative Bob Ballinger Chair
Unverified
Representative David Whitaker
Unverified
Representative Charles Blake
Unverified
Chair
Unverified
Representative Brandt Smith
Unverified
Representative Carol Dalby
Unverified
Speaker 81
Omavi Shakur
Unverified
Representative John Maddox
Unverified
Speaker 138
Speaker 140
Speaker 152
Speaker 154
Speaker 32
Speaker 158
Representative Charlene Fite
Unverified
Representative Clarke Tucker
Unverified