Education Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (2)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1042
· 4 mentions in transcript
Matched: “…there he is. He's back there. Yes, he is. We will now hear House Bill 1042. Is that correct? Yes, sir. House Bill 1042 again. Deja vu.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1650
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1650 Barker TO TRANSFER THE STATE BOARD OF PRIVATE CAREER EDUCAT…”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 13, 2026
We're going to get started with that. We need one more, but we're going to start. Chair sees a quorum. All right, we're going to get started just as soon as everybody gets in their seat. We'll have one in a minute. All right. Representative Barker, you are recognized to
present your bill. thank you mr speaker and thank you committee and i'm sorry to put us in this afternoon um
this won't be nearly as interesting as this morning but hopefully it won't be as lengthy either um this is a very simple 27 page bill yes i know that sounds like an oxymoron but it really is um the meat of the bill is only on pages one and two everything else from section two on it's just change in code where we change a name because... Excuse me just a second. We are now starting. Do
I have to back up and do all that? Okay, thank you.
No, you don't have to back up. Go ahead.
This bill just transfers the Board of Private Career Education under the authorization and supervision of the Department of Higher Ed. It's an efficiency bill. There have been some issues. There have been some financial problems with the board. They weren't able to meet payroll, things like that. This is basically what that is. If there are any questions, that's why Dr. Markham is here.
All right. Do we have any questions? I don't see anybody, Rick Walker. I don't
you're recognized. I know you must be colorblind. I believe I am. Tell me, if I may, thank you, Mr. Chair. Tell me, why are we regulating private career education, or is that just a name of something?
I'm not sure. You mean the existing board? Well, apparently we're regulating prior education. Is that a board, apparently? But what is that, and why are we regulating
Speaker 24
2:31
it if it's private? Maria Markham, Department of Higher Education. From my understanding, working with the task force that worked on this analysis, it's really a revenue-raising agency and a little bit of consumer protection on the back end.
it's for any private career education non-credit type of programming or organization that wants to teach students post-secondary skills in the state it just requires that they pay a licensing fee and they're on record as providing these services in the state and then on the back end should one of those private institutions cease to do business in the state then they coordinate making sure that the students get their transcripts if the student is in process
that they find another program similar in the state. So it's a little akin to what we do with out-of-state for-profit or stand-alone for-profit institutions that come in and offer college credit, but this is for the non-credit type of programming. Follow up. You're welcome. So
you all do regulate private operations and education? Yes, Representative Walker, we do. thank you
any other questions committee all right I'm seeing no questions
committee anyone the audience will speak against the bill for the bill would you like close for your bill oh you want I'm sorry you got another question no we have a quorum now we just got it yeah we have a quorum I have enough okay I'm a I'm going to let her close for a bill. That's okay. That's what I was going to do. Okay. Well, it doesn't matter. If somebody want to make a motion, make a motion. Representative, we have a due pass. Is that right? We have a due pass.
All right. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? No. Congratulations. Your bill has passed. Thank you. I am waiting. If you guys will hold with me for just a second, I'm trying to find out if we have – there he is. He's back there. Yes, he is. We will now hear House Bill 1042. Is that correct? Yes, sir. House Bill 1042 again. Deja vu.
Okay, just to let the committee know and the presenter know, this bill has failed in this committee once. If it fails again, it is dead for life. It will not be resurrected. resurrected. I could get that out. Representative Smith, I believe we have the bill coming around for one to look at it. Okay. And did somebody leave? Who left? Who left?
We can hear it without voting on it. Let's go ahead and hear it. If somebody
comes in, then we can vote. We'll hear. Okay. Go ahead and present your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Colleagues, you've heard all the arguments, the positives and negatives on this bill. I will tell you that I have worked with attorneys on this, Brad Phelps. We made 13 or 14 corrections and changes to language in the bill.
We removed sections of the bill that were questionable. I also work closely with Corey Cox and the Attorney General's office on this bill. What you have now is the final version. It's the same version I ran recently with all of those changes already made, amendments. But I want to just run through a couple of things, and then I'm going to stop talking because it's either a yay or a nay on this bill.
But the bill, House Bill 1042, primarily deals only with the respect for the rule of law. We don't have the luxury to choose which laws we obey, which laws we choose to disobey. It also respects the taxpayers of the state of Arkansas. It respects the intended purpose for higher education. It provides support for higher ed administrations to oppose petitions such as the one that circulated on our campus in Jonesboro, Arkansas,
arkansas state university in that petition there were comments made that right now is the time to seize the moment and establish sanctuary campuses across not only arkansas but the united states and the number mentioned in that petition was 80 I believe it was 80 campuses are considering becoming sanctuaries. I would like to also inform the committee that this bill does not focus on dreamers,
does not focus on those young people that have come up through our education system, the DACA agreements. it focuses on merely one thing do not establish a formal sanctuary status on your campus the penalty for doing that would be loss of state funds i've had some administrators reach out to me and say brant we're not going to speak out negatively against the bill we're not going to
try to hurt the bill you for running it we actually like it it's it's a it's a good bill but they they prefer to remain anonymous i've had numerous calls and uh messages from faculty members who agree with that and so without getting into personalities and all the the rhetoric I think this is a good bill, and I would ask for a good vote. I'm willing to take questions.
Any questions? Representative Speaks, you're recognized. I
just want to make a statement. I really appreciate you bringing this to us. The last couple of days, that's what's been in the news, And I really, I don't think that we can hide from shelter much longer. We're very, I feel very secure where I am, but I think that Arkansas will change.
And I really appreciate you doing this and getting ahead of the game. Thank you.
Any other questions? No other questions? from you're recognized so
Speaker 44
9:55
just to summarize is all this bill does is say that we want federal law and state law to be upheld on our college campuses
we're not imposing any new laws we are not going after anybody we are just simply saying as a body that we support the laws that are in place and we're just sending the message that we want those laws
upheld. Thank you, Representative Douglas. That is right. That's it. And that's it. I have, if I've said it once, I've probably said it five or six hundred
times in the last five weeks i am we we took out language that might be misconstrued as racial profiling we we just simply said and i've said this over and over if you're here and you're in at the university we're glad you're at the university i'm talking to undocumented that are there. These are great students. But I said, instead of jumping out onto news media, being
manipulated or handled by people who have maybe another motive, just keep going to class. Get your degree, graduate, go be successful, and change immigration law at the federal level. We can't do that at the state level. But we don't want sanctuary campus status. I don't, and many other Arkansans don't either. And so that's what this bill does. Thank you. Yes. Reverend Walker, you recognize.
If that's all this bill does, Representative, then why don't you make this a resolution that conforms with or to what Representative Douglas said. By making a bill, it necessarily imposes obligations upon state
actors and state officials. Well, I appreciate the question, and you know what? I considered that, and the problem with a resolution versus a bill that may become law is a resolution has no binding quality.
I want some teeth. If we're going to go through the motion to do this, let's back it up with some action. because people change their minds. And today I'm being told by numerous universities around our state, we don't want a sanctuary status on our campus. We're not going to do it. We appreciate what you're trying to do, but we've already, you know, are trying to deal with this at the local university or college level.
But people change their mind. And in the last two weeks, there have been numerous, what I would say, town hall meetings or activist organizational meetings. And so the pressure is always going to be on our administrators, from the president down to the chancellors. and I just think what one thing could we do to help our administrators be able to say to a group
of students that are well intended they're sympathetic but maybe they don't fully understand federal law they can say we sympathize with you and your cause but we can't break federal and state law. Simple
as that. You're recognized. Follow-up. On last night's news, I saw Senator Cotton in northwest Arkansas taking questions from constituents in a situation where they were exercising their free speech rights. Would this not prohibit the assertion of free speech
rights by students in your community, I guess it's Arkansas State's community, or elsewhere in college environments throughout the state of Arkansas? No, because
we are not restricting that freedom of speech, the right to free speech. All we're saying is no formal sanctuary status. That's it. As a matter of fact, I've been invited April 1st by one of these groups up in our area, and I'm trying to work out that date
I've got a son that's deploying for a long deployment and he leaves on April 1st but if I can work it out I'm going to go to one of those meetings and I'm going to meet with these folks again I've not dodged anybody I've met with several folks but I think this I think there are people out there that are trying to promote the fact that well you're going to lose free speech. ICE is going to show up and round you up. And I've said, that's not in the bill.
This isn't an immigration bill. But in some of the comments made by the basic promoter of this petition, the comment was actively resist federal and state law enforcement. And that's, we're lawmakers for crying out loud. We believe in the rule of law. And that's what I'm trying to say we may not like our federal immigration laws as they are now, but we can't change them here, but we can influence those changes. So I don't think it will restrict anyone's free speech.
Rep. Gates, you recognize me. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. With Mr. Walker down here, I learned when I was having to sue some former employees in federal court on their theft of property, I was amazed when their attorney asked me if I specifically told them they could not steal the items which they stole. I thought it was obvious. I mean, and, you know, I mentioned I didn't tell them they couldn't steal that or the pictures off the wall, and that's when my
attorney kicked me underneath the table. The problem is we already have laws. We have laws that they're very obvious to most of us the problem is is when people seem to not understand the obvious and so this basically restates from a dictate from the state to the colleges this is basically the college is responding back to saying we're complying with these federal and state regulations and not going to offer a sanctuary city is that a fair understanding
of what this does that's reasonable yeah well there are attorneys involved so we can't use plausible
reasonable understand within limits thank you anyone else any other testimony from committee anyone in the audience like speak for the bill against the bill against okay you are welcome to come speak against the bill if you will take a seat on the end anywhere down there that there's a microphone available please state your name and who you're
with and you will be recognized to speak against the bill you turn it on
and gentlemen my name is Leticia Reta and I'm a central organizer for I can Arkansas United Community Collision and we are in an organization that operates in empowering immigrants around the state in seven communities in seven immigrant centers and I'm originally from Mexico I've been living here in this country from the last 23 years and I'm proud
mother of three and my kids are I'm glad some of the kids are in this in in the high school and they're pursuing a higher career but myself personally as well as an immigrant community with whom I work are deeply concerned about the possible persecutions of Mr. Smith proposed HB 1042 were passed today which is why we will stay and last time that you debated this bill are back again today. We fear that this bill will open the possibility of any students in
Arkansas universities and college campuses to be stopped and asked about their immigration status due to their accent, ethnicity or appearance and will the sensitive or a school from having common-sense conversations about how to welcome and recruit the students from all walks of life. As a nonprofit, we actively work with universities across Arkansas and reaffirm the representative Smith is proposing legislation for a problem that does not exist. No university in Arkansas has taken a step to create a sanctuary on
their campuses yet. An unnecessary targets a group of students that are They're already facing challenges in pursuing and completing the higher education here in Arkansas. Our dreamers have to pay two to four times more their education than any other students who graduate from Arkansas's high schools and face uncertainty future right here now to the policy changes we know are being considered by the President Trump administration. If DACA were to be called, we have to call to 9,000 students here in Arkansas will be
immediately become a target of HB 1042, given that this bill does not ensure the campus administrative security will receive the necessary training in how to handle such a quickly change and immigration environment. This is what we feel that HB 1042 adds no value to the policy debates about higher education in Arkansas and only opens the potential for crediting a wage amount of diverse students who want to see and attend
our great Arkansas universities. Even our governor made a statement after this bill was debated last time that has not necessarily And it's not necessary to be in this here in Arkansas. We are here today because we strongly believe in Arkansas in the civic process. And we ask you to please vote no in this bill. In the state, we invite you and the representative Smith to work with our immigrant communities
to create policies that could instead help all the students. And to them, this state achieved greater potential. And we are proud that Arkansas has never passed a legislation that negative targets our immigrants. And we ask you to please keep us a state where we can all work together to fulfill our dreams in all
our students. Thank you. Are there any questions for her? Thank you. Appreciate your testimony.
Does anyone else like to speak for the bill? Against the bill? Have one you'd like to speak against, come on now. I think we heard from you last time, didn't we? Yes, sir. State your name and who you're with, and you're
recognized to speak against the bill. My name is Andres Ramos, and I'm with the Arkansas United Commission. I'm here to say you something. I'm an immigrant, as you can tell. And my son was born in Mexico.
He came here when he was one year old. And now he's in college. And since he is not a resident, they told me I had to pay double. I was talking with Mr. Smith before. I was telling him that my son, in order to pay the college, I had to pay for him because he don't make enough money to pay his own college, right? Because he had a job, but if he don't have an education, he's not going to make enough money to pay the bills.
So he is paying more than anybody else, you know, U.S. citizens. Like he says, we have the – he told me that the only U.S. citizens has the right to deserve all that stuff. Plus, I have a little business, and I'm paying my taxes, too. I mean, you know, I'm paying taxes like anybody else. I'm doing what I'm supposed to do in this country, and I'm working with you all the time. But I'm just thinking why doing this, because he's a dreamer right now.
But what happened at one point in time, he lose that. He's going to be a target. He's going to be the first target, not even the people that is not already in some kind of immigration or something. He's right, we need to change the federal law. But like I told him, what we need to do is stuff that belongs to federal law. That's them. If somebody commit a crime or something at the school and it has no papers or something, that's why we have ICE, we have another agencies, federal agencies. Why he wants to do the job
that he's not supposed to do. I told him, as soon as this law passed, you are going to point a person that don't have the papers. He said, I won't do that. Of course he won't do that, but he's the one starting to start to doing this and this it doesn't sound something for me because you know everybody in this in this in this country I believe has the right as a human being to to go to college with
any preoccupation because you are thinking about immigration and you are not going to focus in your study right then I don't I don't believe in in in And just because my color is not who I like him, I be treated different. And I tell him that's a racist, and he said it's not. So how come it's not going to be racist if you are telling the eyes, you are telling those federal agencies, you are telling them, you know, this student doesn't have immigration status or something.
So that means it's something that you don't want in your country. It's something that, like I told him, we're forgetting what this country is made for, you know? And then I just, like I said, the taxpayer, he was worried about where his money's going, too. I'm worried, too, then, because I'm paying my taxes, too, the same as him. So it doesn't make sense talking about taxes, because everybody's paying taxes. Wherever they go, that's not our problem, you know? We're not asking for the university to be a sanctuary
like everybody's thinking. where we are thinking, or where we are more, the worry be like, we don't want that. We just want our kids, or any other kid come from another country and go to the school. Like I told him, how you notice in the hospitals, you go to a hospital, the people there, most of the people is from different countries. This country is begging for people to come
like as a nurse or doctors, because we need some. Like he said, only the white people in the city, American citizen people deserve that. Why they don't go? Because they have everything and it's something that I really don't want to talk about that. But I mean, as an immigrant, we tried, we came to work. If somebody came to make crimes or something like that, that's why we have a federal law, you know, and they are going to take him back to wherever they come from, because they made a crown.
But can you believe, like he said, can you believe if somebody's a criminal already, he's gonna be able to go to a college? I don't think so. Plus, if he's thinking that way, or anybody else thinking that way, if somebody goes to the college with no paper, he's gonna be a criminal according to the law? I don't think so. And then that's something like I just broke out that, you know,
it's something that I don't like that, to be treated like that. Thank you. Would you want a question for him? Okay. All right. Thank you, sir. Reps
of Kavanaugh, you recognize? I'd like to have a motion to limit debate. All right. Make your motion.
Motion to limit debate. To what? To five minutes. Five
minutes per side? Total. Total. We have a motion to limit debate to five minutes total.
Good job. All right. Any other discussion on that motion? All those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no. Motion carries. Is there anyone else in the audience would like to speak for the bill, against the bill? You have five minutes from what we just got. So come on down. state your name and who you're with if you're with a different party or just whoever okay my name is you may have to get a little closer to that mic my name
Speaker 72
27:31
is Eunice Montoya and I'm not
here with anybody okay um I personally am not affected in any kind of way but I do ask that y'all vote no for this because it does affect the people in my community I'm very fortunate to have U.S. citizen born parents and I was able to get a higher education. I am an RN and I have worked in several different jobs. I have participated in my community and I just ask of you to please consider not voting no for this bill because it does not help our community and I am the first
of my family to graduate from college my parents my dad has a third grade education and my mom has a sixth grade education and in order for us to better ourselves i think we need to educate ourselves and so without allowing these students to participate in a higher education we will not be able to do that thank you thank
you is there anyone else like speak against the bill
or for the bill would you like to close for your bill
yes I will I want to remind the committee that this is an emotional issue I don't doubt that I've spent 20 plus years of my life working with immigrants working in refugee camps building schools for orphans, 600 orphans in Burma. I oversaw that over a three-year period.
I know what it means to be uprooted, to try to get to a better place, because I've been around that for years. That's not what this bill is about. This bill is simply about establishing a formal sanctuary policy on a campus. That's it. Nothing more and nothing less. I think in all of the meetings that I've had with these kind and sweet people,
I've tried to present that to them. This is not about immigration. This is about recognizing the rule of law. Now, we as Arkansas legislators can choose today whether we're going to support this bill or not, but I'm telling you that from the messages that I'm getting, text messages, phone calls, e-mails, that there is an emboldened feeling among some of the more angry protesters
that should this bill fail today, more than likely there will be more pressure put on our campuses to do this. There's nothing in this bill that indicates room-to-room dorm searches, profiling of any kind and yet that's what they've been told and that's the emotional appeal and we have fear created you could hear that in the voices but when people that are good at
manipulating the suffering the least of these among us it's just wrong and I'm going to ask for a good vote because I think actually this will take pressure off of our campuses, our administrators, and we'll be able to move on. Thank you, committee. All right. Ladies
and gentlemen, you've heard testimony from our presenter and from others, and what is the wills committee? I have a due pass from Representative Sullivan.
All right. All those in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed no. No. I'm sorry. Your bill has failed. and it wouldn't do a roll call I'm going to tell you you can call a roll call if you want to there's only 11 of us one no vote is all it takes if you want to do a roll call we will put them on the record if you want to do it I have to have that call from the committee I need one more hand alright we have a roll call give us just a second
Speaker 80
32:12
we'll get everything ready Representative Meeks Representative Meeks Representative Deffenbaugh Representative Deffenbaugh Representative Eubanks Representative Eubanks Representative Walker Representative Lowry Representative Lowry Representative McElroy Representative McElroy Yes.
Representative McGill? No. Representative Davis? Representative Davis. REPRESENTATIVE DE LA ROSA? No. REPRESENTATIVE HODGES? REPRESENTATIVE HODGES. REPRESENTATIVE BEK ED? REPRESENTATIVE BEK ? REPRESENTATIVES SULLIVAN? Yes. REPRESENTATIVE SPEAKS? Representative Gates
Representative Vaught Representative Starch Representative Starch Representative Kavanaugh Representative Barker Representative Barker Ms. Douglas Ms. Chairman I'm sorry,
And that is the second time, so that bill is dead. If you want to bring back a resolution, that might be the way to try. Thank you. Thank you, everyone. I think that's all the business we have before the committee today, and I appreciate you all coming back.
Agenda
HB1650 Barker TO TRANSFER THE STATE BOARD OF PRIVATE CAREER EDUCATION TO THE DEPARTMENT OF HIGHER EDUCATION; TO AMEND THE POWERS AND DUTIES OF THE STATE BOARD OF PRIVATE CAREER EDUCATION; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Bruce Cozart
Unverified
Chair
Unverified
Speaker 12
Representative John W. Walker
Unverified
Speaker 24
Representative Brandt Smith
Unverified
Representative Nelda Speaks
Unverified
Speaker 44
Representative Mickey Gates
Unverified
Speaker 62
Leticia Reta
Unverified
Andres Ramos
Unverified
Representative Frances Cavenaugh
Unverified
Speaker 72
Speaker 80
Speaker 29