House Meeting
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (61)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1243
· 5 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1243 AN ACT FOR THE DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE AND ADMINISTRATION - R…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1498
· 5 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1498 AN ACT FOR THE ARKANSAS AGRICULTURE DEPARTMENT - CAPITAL PR…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1603
· 5 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1603 AN ACT FOR THE STATE BOARD OF PHARMACY APPROPRIATION FOR TH…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1614
· 5 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…ent will be adopted representative gene moves that we place house bill 1614 back on second reading for the purpose of amendment without…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1214
· 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1214 AN ACT FOR THE DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY CORRECTION APPROPRIA…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1596
· 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…you, Mr. Speaker. Colleagues, the remaining bills with your House Bill 1596, 1598, 1599, 1600, 1601, 1605, 1606, 1615, 1616, 1617, and…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1605
· 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…quest to pull one bill from the package All right, proceed. House Bill 1605.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1619
· 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…h our foster care need for the rest of this year. we've got House Bill 1619, which is the Health Services Permit Agency, also 1620 Depa…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1638
· 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1638 AN ACT FOR THE DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION- ARKANSAS SCHOOL DEA…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1639
· 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…tion, and House Bill 1638, Arkansas School of the Deaf, and House Bill 1639, this would be the School of the Blind. Any questions”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB289
· 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB289 TO REVISE THE COMPENSATION PLAN UNDER THE UNIFORM CLASSIFIC…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB328
· 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…right, Representative Charlotte Douglas moves that we place Senate Bill 328 back on second reading for the purpose of amendment without…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB56
· 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB56 AN ACT FOR THE OFFICE OF LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR APPROPRIATION…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1493
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1493 AN ACT FOR THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES - DIVISION OF C…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1598
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1598 AN ACT FOR THE ARKANSAS NATURAL RESOURCES COMMISSION REAPPR…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1599
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1599 AN ACT FOR THE STATE MILITARY DEPARTMENT REAPPROPRIATION.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1600
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1600 AN ACT FOR THE DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY CORRECTION REAPPROPR…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1601
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…ll 1596, House Bill 1598, House Bill 1599, House Bill 1600, House Bill 1601, House Bill 1606, House Bill 1615, House Bill 1616, House B…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1606
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1606 AN ACT FOR THE ARKANSAS HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES REAPPROPRI…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1615
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1615 AN ACT FOR THE DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE AND ADMINISTRATION - B…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1616
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…ll 1600, House Bill 1601, House Bill 1606, House Bill 1615, House Bill 1616, House Bill 1617, House Bill 1618.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1617
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1617 AN ACT FOR THE NORTHWEST TECHNICAL INSTITUTE REAPPROPRIATIO…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1618
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1618 AN ACT FOR THE CROWLEY'S RIDGE TECHNICAL INSTITUTE REAPPROP…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1620
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “Bill 1493, House Bill 1619, House Bill 1620, House Bill 1638, and House Bill 1639. Turn the machine, Mr…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB133
· 2 mentions in chapter
Matched: “Motion to Reconsider SB133”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SJR8
· 2 mentions in chapter
Matched: “SJR8: Amendment 1”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1019
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1019 Cozart 1 TO AMEND THE MEMBERSHIP OF THE SCHOOL LEADERSHIP C…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1038
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1038 Davis .1 TO ALLOW THE MULTIYEAR REGISTRATION OF PERSONAL- U…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1048
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1048 D. Meeks TO PERMIT VOLUNTARY RESPITE CARE; TO CREATE A LICE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1172
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1172 Tosh 1 CREATING A SENTENCE ENHANCEMENT FOR CERTAIN CRIMINAL…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1215
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1215 Love TO AMEND THE LAWS REGARDING THE PRACTICE OF MASSAGE TH…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1250
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1250 M. Gray TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS DENTAL PRACTICE ACT; TO CREAT…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1319
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1319 Shepherd 1 TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 23 OF THE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1320
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1320 Shepherd 1 TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 5 OF THE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1432
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…mmittee on aging children and youth to whom was referred to House Bill 1432 and House Resolution 1032.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1501
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1501 McCollum TO MODIFY AND REPEAL LANGUAGE REFERENCING THE SUPE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1513
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1513 Holcomb TO AMEND THE ELIGIBILITY REQUIREMENTS FOR THE ASBES…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1521
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1521 Richmond 1 TO ALLOW COUNTIES TO BURN STORM DEBRIS BASED ON…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1523
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1523 Sturch CONCERNING THE TRAINING OF MEMBERS OF THE BOARD OF D…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1526
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1526 M. Gray TO MODIFY ACT 143 OF 2017 TO SPECIFY THAT A CRIMINA…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1536
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1536 M. Gray TO AMEND THE MINORITY BUSINESS ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1545
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1545 Sullivan TO ALLOW THE DIVISION OF CHILD CARE AND EARLY CHIL…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1552
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1552 McNair TO ALTER THE REQUIREMENTS FOR A LIFETIME TEACHING LI…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1566
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1566 Hammer TO AMEND THE PROVISIONS OF LAW CONCERNING THE DISPOS…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1569
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1569 C. Douglas TO REDUCE THE STANDARD LICENSING FEE FOR CERTAIN…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1586
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1586 Payton TO AMEND CERTAIN PROVISIONS OF THE WORKERS' COMPENSA…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1589
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1589 Vaught CONCERNING THE APPLICABILITY OF CERTAIN ETHICS LAWS…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1609
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1609 Tucker TO INCREASE FLEXIBILITY IN THE LAW REGARDING FREQUEN…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1641
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1641 Wing TO INCREASE THE TOOL ALLOWANCE FOR CERTAIN EMPLOYEES O…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1642
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1642 Wing TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE APPOINTMENT OF THE CHI…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1643
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1643 Wing TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE STATE AID ENGINEER OF…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1644
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1644 Tosh TO CHANGE THE FILING DEADLINE FOR FRANCHISE TAX REPORT…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1650
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1650 Barker TO TRANSFER THE STATE BOARD OF PRIVATE CAREER EDUCAT…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HR1032
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ldren and youth to whom was referred to House Bill 1432 and House Resolution 1032.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB148
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB148 G. Stubblefield(C. Fite) TO CREATE BORN-ALIVE INFANT PROTEC…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB159
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB159 J. English (Drown) CONCERNING THE DEPARTMENT OF VETERANS AF…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB174
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB174 J. English (Drown) TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE DUTIES O…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB277
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB277 Hickey (McNair) CONCERNING THE PROCEDURES FOR OBTAINING TIT…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB284
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB284 Hester (Eubanks) TO ESTABLISH A RETAIL OFF-PREMISES PERMIT…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB340
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB340 J. Hutchinson (Pilkington) TO CREATE THE WRONGFUL BIRTH CIV…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB42
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB42 J. Hutchinson (Capp) CONCERNING FITNESS TO PROCEED AND LACK…”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 13, 2026
Unknown speaker
0:00
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
All right, members, the House will be called into order at this time. I invite you to stand along with our guests in the galleries, our press, and our staff to be led in prayer today by Mark Husband from Delta Fellowship, from Helena West, Helena's guest, Representative Ritchie, and then to remain standing for the Pledge of Allegiance that will be led today by Representative Greg Letting. Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
Speaker 18
8:25
would you please bow your heads and your hearts with me as we make our requests to the Lord let's
pray oh Lord our God God the Father God the Son God the Holy Spirit you are incomprehensible and yet you condescend to listen to the prayers of your people and so we come before you this morning with humility and gratitude for who you are and what you've done revealed and recorded in your Holy Scriptures. We thank you, Lord, for the nation we live in and for the state of Arkansas, for the representatives here who are elected to lead the people. God, would you please quicken
the minds of these leaders during this time of deliberative session, and would you fill them with wisdom as they make decisions? Father, fill the hearts of all your people here with your Holy Spirit and make their minds the mind of Christ. Lord, pour out your common grace in this room in a special way this hour. Lord, help us to acknowledge and to remember your kingship and help us to rest in your sovereignty this morning. Conform our desires with your word and forgive us
of our sins and we pray, Father, not our will but your will be done. And we pray all this in the name of the one who, at the cost of his own blood, has fully paid for all the sins of his people and has completely freed them from the dominion of the devil, the Savior of nations, the Lord Jesus Christ. Amen. Amen.
All right, let's cast the ballots, Mr. Clerk. With 99 present, the Chair sees a quorum. Any request for leave? Representative Fortner.
I request leave for Representative Hendron. All right, is
leave granted for Representative Hendron? All right, so noted.
Representative Michael John Gray, you're recognized. Leave for Representative Milton Nix. All right, so leave granted for Representative Milton Nix. All right, so noted. Representative Lane Jean moves at this time that we dispense with the reading of the previous day's journal without objection. So ordered. Any reports from select committees, Mr. Clerk? Are there any reports from standing committees? All right, please read the reports, Mr. Clerk. Mr.
Speaker, we are a committee on aging children and youth to whom was referred to House Bill 1432 and House Resolution 1032.
Beg leave to report that we have had the same under consideration and herewith return the same with the recommendation they do pass. Respectfully
submitted, Charlene Fite, Chair. Is there any unfinished business? Are there any executive communications? Okay, members, before we pick up our calendars for the day, we'd like to take a moment to
recognize our doctor of the day and our nurse of the day we have with us is our doctor of the day here from Little Rock we have Dr. Omar Atik and then our nurse of the day is Miss Sherry Bernard All right, members, we also, I want to take just a quick moment here to acknowledge a
very special birthday that we're going to have tomorrow miss Helen from right on the other side of Lane and and David there is going to be celebrating her birthday tomorrow so make sure you get a chance to wish her happy birthday before you leave today
All right, Representative Charlotte Douglas moves that we place Senate Bill 328 back on second reading for the purpose of amendment without objection. Read
never mind members we'll pick that up at a
later time so that will conclude our morning hour this time we're going to I recognize Chairman Gene to present our budget calendar for the
day. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Colleagues, we've got four amendments.
House Bill 1214, Department of Community Corrections. Any questions on the amendment? Seeing none, I'd appreciate a good vote on the amendment. All right, Representative.
Representative Jean moves that we place House Bill 1214 back on second reading for the purpose of amendment. Without objection, read Amendment No. 3, Mr. Clerk. Amendment No. 3 to House Bill 1214. All right, members, he's, Representative Gene has explained the amendment. Would anyone like to speak against the amendment for the amendment? Representative Gene has signified to me that he is closed for the amendment, so the question now before the House will be the adoption of Amendment 3 to House Bill 1214.
All in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed, say no. All right, the ayes have it. The amendment will be adopted. All right, Representative Jean moves that we place House Bill 1243 back on second reading for the purpose of amendment. Without objection, read Amendment No. 1, Mr. Clerk. Amendment No. 1
Explain the amendment. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Colleagues, this is an amendment on House Bill 1243,
Department of Finance, what this does. I think if Representative House did a lot of work on this, they're adding a security force over the DF&A building across the street for security reasons. I think we're adding, Representative House, five officers, is that correct? Five officers. Anyway, this is the amendment to do that of that bill. Any questions? Appreciate a good vote on the amendment. all right members
you've heard an explanation of the amendment would
anyone like to speak against the amendment for the amendment mr. chairman signify that he is closed for the amendment so the question now before the house will be adoption of amendment one to house bill 1243 all in favor say aye opposed say no let the ayes have it amendment number one will be adopted to House Bill 1243. All right. Representative Jean moves that we place House Bill 1498 back on second reading for the purpose of amendment. Without
objection, read Amendment No. 1, Mr. Clerk.
Amendment No. 1 to House Bill 1498. All right, Mr.
Chairman, you're recognized to explain the amendment. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Colleagues, amendment on House Bill 1498 is the Agriculture Department. It changes one word. This was caught by the legislative audit. It adds grants to the regional and county fairs. It just said regional county fair improvements. This just adds grants to this bill. That's all this amendment does. Any questions? Appreciate a good vote on the amendment.
All right members you've heard an explanation of the amendment. Would anyone like to speak against the amendment for the amendment chairman signified he's closed for the amendment so the question now before the house will be the adoption of amendment one to house bill 1498 all in favor say aye all opposed say no all right the eyes have it the amendment will be adopted representative gene moves that we place house bill 1614 back on second reading for the purpose of amendment without objection read
amendment number one mr. clerk amendment number one to house bill 1614 Chairman, you're recognized.
Explain the amendment. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Colleagues, House Bill 1614 is the higher education reappropriation. What this does is a reappropriation at the end of June 30th when we go into the next year. These are funds that have already been approved. And this session right now, the year we're in right now, what it will do, Mid-South over in West Memphis has asked for a greater flexibility on some
maintenance money to put in for operations and renovation that's what the language has changed on it and that's all this bill does the money has already been appropriated and it's just a reappropriation because they will not fill up finish the project this year it'll go on into next year any questions appreciate a good vote on the amendment all right members
for an explanation the amendment would anyone like to speak against the amendment for the amendment chairman to signify his clothes for the amendment so the
question now before the house will be the adoption of amendment number one to house bill 1614 all in favor say aye all opposed say no or if the ayes have it
the amendment will be adopted mr. chairman you're recognized thank you mr. Speaker colleagues, Senate Bill 289. This is the compensation plan under the governor's budget. And if you remember when we got here in January, we all got a copy of the RSA and that's
on this right now. It's $24 million. And I'll go into detail, as detailed as you want on the questions what it does is add about 18.8 million dollars to raises and we're redo defining the the pay categories we're doing away with all the c in the 901 system we're going to have a brand new system that we're going to go through that'll be over the oversight of legislative council uh it is a raise i think we had five million dollars in merit raises of this year's budget
it'll be 24 million for next year. And after this is all said and done, the minimum wage for anybody working for the state of Arkansas will be $22,000. And we've got several now in the $17,000, $18,000, and $19,000. So this is a substantial raise. And we'll have four categories. We'll have general salaries, we'll have IT salaries which is information technology we'll have a
medical profession which takes care of the folks at UAMS salaries and we'll have senior executive salaries and I'm gonna for anybody's got questions on this I think it's been well vented through the budget and also the personnel committee over there we've had this in hand that this is going to be done before we came into session, so any questions, I'll entertain them. Representative Walker,
for what purpose? Question. I can ask for your question, sir.
If the minimum salary for all state employees who work to a minimum of 2,080 hours a year is $22,000, does that mean that we have advanced to the point where the minimum wage in the state is at least $10 an hour. Say that again. The work year is at 40 hours a week for 52 weeks is 2,080 hours. $10 an hour times
2,080 is $20,800. Does does this mean that we have progressed to the point in Arkansas where the minimum wage is at least $10 an hour for state employees? That's what I would do. I think your math is correct.
I want to say thank Representative Ken Bragg. He's been the House sponsor on this and certainly if I leave if he needs to come
down and add anything on the for and against, certainly Representative Bragg come down there and
do that but do I have any any other questions represented Brown
for what purpose you recognize for your question thank you mr. chair being a representative Jean I had a constituent stop by to see me and she was concerned that having been a 30-year employee that she might not be treated
as well, salary-wise, as a new employee coming in. Could you address that? Are all our current employees getting a raise, or how are new employees
to our existing employees? There's roughly 31,000 state employees, excluding the universities in the state of Arkansas. From what I understand, this will affect about 25,000. Who's being left out, and they'll do their own pay plan,
is the highway department, game and fish, higher education, and the constitutional offices. That includes the House, the Senate, all the constitutional offices, Supreme Court, and all the judgeships in their offices. They'll have a separate one coming later, but people that are in all the departments, All the commissions, they're about 25,000, and I don't know where your friend works, will be affected by this pay raise.
And if their minimum is already on this pay scale, they'll receive a 1% increase. If they're already at the minimum, after these new pay scales are adopted, they'll receive a 1% pay increase. Thank you. any other questions all right members I appreciate a good vote remember your one vote is for the bill and the emergency clause mr. speaker have the clerk read
the bill for the third time mr. clerk please read the
bill for the third time Senate bill 289 all right members you've heard an explanation of the bill would Would anyone like to speak against the bill, for the bill? All right, the chairman signified he's closed for the bill. So the question now before the House will be the adoption of House Bill, excuse me, Senate Bill 289. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. All right, voting on the bill and its emergency clause.
everyone voted okay let's cast the ballots mr. clerk with 93 yeas zero nay and zero present bill and its emergency clause have passed mr. chairman you're recognized
thank you mr. speaker colleagues we're going to jump to house Bill 1603, because it's the only appropriation house bill that we're going to do today.
This was brought before by Representative Les Eves. What this is, is $275,000 out of revenue and fees that the pharmacy do on their own, and it's to fund, correct me if I'm wrong, five scholarships five scholarships for Arkansas colleges and if somebody will come back and spend three years in a community of under fifteen thousand this will be a scholarship and if they use this money and they don't do that it's
a loan that they'll have to pay back but it's not out of general revenue any questions I appreciate a good vote on House Bill 1603 Mr. Speaker had the clerk read the bill for the third time Mr. Clerk please read the
bill for the third time House Bill 1603 all right members you've heard an explanation of the bill would anyone like speak against the bill for the bill the chairman to signify these closed for the bill so the question now before the house be the
passage of House bill 1603. Prepare the machine Mr. Clerk. Putting on the bill and Suburgency Clause. Everyone voted. Let's cast the ballots Mr. Clerk. With 88 yays, 0 nay and 0 present the bill and its emergency clause have passed. Chairman, you're recognized.
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Colleagues, we're gonna go to our second page. We're gonna do our one Senate bill, Senate Bill 56, Office of the Lieutenant Governor. It's the only other appropriation that we have on today's calendar. It's the Office of Lieutenant Governor. $341,000 did not change from this year. Any questions? Appreciate a good vote on the bill and the emergency clause. Mr. Speaker, let the clerk read the bill for the third time. Mr. Clerk, please read the bill for the third time.
Senate Bill 56. All right, members, you've heard an explanation of the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill for the bill? Chairman has signified he's closed for the bill, so the questionnaire before the House will be the passage of Senate Bill 56. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Voting on the bill in
Mr. Clerk, 88 yeas, 0 nay, and 0 present, the bill in its emergency clause have passed. Mr.
Chairman, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Colleagues, we've got five supplemental bills in today's budget, which is money that's going to help finish out the rest of the year, gives them more spending authority. The first one is going to be House Bill 1493, Department of Human Services, Division of Child and Family. What that is, we had budgeted $91 million for foster care.
Next year we're going to have a $118 million budget, that's in the governor's budget. This is another $14 million that we're putting in there to help with our foster care need for the rest of this year. we've got House Bill 1619, which is the Health Services Permit Agency, also 1620 Department of Finance and Administration, and House Bill 1638, Arkansas School of the Deaf, and House Bill 1639, this would be the School of the Blind. Any questions
on those five supplemental appropriations? Seeing none, remember your one vote is for each one of the bills and the emergency clause. Mr. Speaker, has the clerk read the bill for the third time. Mr. Clerk, please
Bill 1493, House Bill 1619, House Bill 1620, House Bill 1638, and House Bill 1639. Turn the machine, Mr. Clerk. voting on the bills and their emergency clauses
everyone voted let's cast out the ballots Mr. Clerk 87 yeas, 0 nay and 1
present the bills and their emergency clauses have passed Mr. Chairman you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Colleagues, the remaining bills with your House Bill 1596, 1598, 1599, 1600, 1601, 1605, 1606, 1615, 1616, 1617, and 1618,
or reappropriations these are mainly capital improvement that these agencies are doing they need the money to finish over for next year because they're not gonna be able to get through the projects this year there's no new monies money it's already budgeted any questions
on any of these representative house for what purpose request to pull one bill from the package All right, proceed. House Bill 1605.
Pull it out of the batch. Vote on it today. Okay, any others? All right, colleagues. Remember your one vote is for each one of these bills in the emergency clause.
Mr. Speaker, have the clerk read the bill for the third
time? Mr. Clerk, please read the bills for the third time. House Bill 1596, House Bill 1598, House Bill 1599, House Bill 1600, House Bill 1601, House Bill 1606, House Bill 1615, House Bill 1616, House Bill 1617, House Bill 1618.
Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Voting on the bills and their emergency clauses. All right, has everyone voted? All right, let's cast out the ballots, Mr. Clerk. 87 yays, 0 nay, and 0 present. The bills and their emergency clauses have passed. Mr. Chairman, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
The last reappropriation for the day is House Bill 1605, which is the Capital Zoning Commission. I think what they're pulling over is $15,000 that they already have budgeted to purchase a low-speed vehicle. I guess when they're cruising the area, they got to check the code out. I hope they're not checking you out, Brother House. Any questions?
representative davis you recognize for what purpose question you recognize for your question thank you mr speaker
mr chairman could you just explain to me one more time just to make sure i'm clear on reappropriation what is that exactly where so they this is money left over from a previous appropriation money the year we're in right now that's budgeted
what this does gives them authority to take it over till next year to spend it because they're not going to spend it this year all right thank you for representing the house for what
purpose question you recognize for your question do you know if we have already passed their appropriation bill yet if you don't know it's a it's a bad question I know I'm not for sure I can I can find out find out thank you thank Mr. Speaker. Any other questions? Remember,
your one vote is for the bill of emergency clause. Mr. Speaker, let the clerk read the bill for the third time. Mr. Clerk, please
read the bill for the third time. House Bill 1605. All right, members, you've heard an explanation of the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? Representative House,
you recognize, speak against the bill. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Representative Lowry just informed me that we have passed their appropriation. We have had problems with this particular agency. They have come to my attention. I know that they have come to the attention of our representatives from the Little Rock
area. The Capital Zoning Commission exists to basically keep the neighborhood looking good around the Capitol and the governor's mansion, a worthy cause. However, we now have some pretty serious documented evidence that this commission has treated its constituency, that is those people who live within that area, with contempt and disdain, lack of respect, and general discourtesy to the point of, I think,
three lawsuits within the past year for failure to provide due process, due consideration. Currently they are discussing expanding their jurisdiction westward towards Flandersmith's College. I don't know whether that has happened or not, but for some reason I have been the sounding board for many complaints of the residents and I do not know why that is happening. For that reason, because the residents of this area, many residents, I can call, for
instance, Judge Marion Humphrey, who also has a lawsuit against this commission, have asked me to oppose this appropriation, and so I rise to do so. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. All right, members of the
representative House, spoken against the measure. Would anyone like to speak for the bill? Against. All right, for. All right, Representative Sabin, you're recognized to speak for the bill. Thank you,
Mr. Speaker. I actually don't relish having to come up here to do this
and certainly to speak in opposition to anything that my good friend, Representative House, would have to say. The only thing I'd like to say to this body simply is that this commission exists for the most part in my district, which includes the state capitol, and Representative Blake's district, which includes the governor's mansion in that part just south of 630 here. And everything Representative House said is accurate in the sense that, you know, there definitely have been some complaints and some issues with the leadership of capital zoning. I will assure everybody here that I'm intimately familiar with them.
I've spent a lot of time in person with a lot of the complainants as well as the people who operate the commission. I know we've been urging the commission to make changes and improvements in how they operate. they've assured us that they would do so. You may even remember a year or two ago, Senator Hutchinson was engaged in this particular cause, and we worked out a pretty good compromise in terms of creating an appeals process for those who had problems with some of the decisions that capital zoning was making
and allowing them an appeals process that's directed through the Department of Arkansas Heritage. And so I wasn't actually prepared or planning to come up here today. I didn't know there was going to be controversy over this re-appropriation, which again is not new money. It's a small amount of money, as Representative Jean said, I think $15,000, and it's not new money. I think they're going to use it for a good cause. And all I would ask of all of you is just like any other issue that sort of affects y'all's districts locally, that y'all are more familiar with than everybody else, is let this re-appropriation come through today.
We're working on this. I think improvements have been made. They'll continue to be made. We're on top of it, and I would just ask for a good vote on this today. Thank you very much.
Representative Saban has spoken for the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? Chairman, would you like to close for the bill? You're recognized to
do so at this time. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Representative Lowry is right. It's now Act 35. The governor has signed their appropriation, so they already have their appropriation,
and this is the reappropriation from this your money to next but that's just to be just to be clear
on it all right members the question now before the house will be the passage of House Bill 1605 for the machine mr. clerk
everyone voted everyone voted all right let's cast it the ballots mr. clerk with 52 yeas 21 nays 7 present the bill has failed to pass okay members we're going to move now to the yellow calendar excuse me red calendar
All right, we're going to backtrack, try to pick up the motion to amend. Representative Charlotte Douglas moves that we place Senate Bill 328 back on second reading for the purpose of amendment without objection. Read amendment number one, Mr.
Clerk. Amendment number one to Senate Bill 328. representative Douglas
Speaker 129
41:27
thank you mr. speaker this is just to amend on some sponsors onto a bill thank you for a good vote. All
right members heard an explanation of the amendment. Would anyone like to speak against the amendment or the amendment? Representative Douglas has signified she's closed for the
amendment so so the question now before the house will be the passage excuse me the adoption of amendment number one to Senate bill 328 all in favor say aye all opposed say no all right the ayes have it the amendment will be adopted Representative Ballinger, for what purpose? Motion.
All right. Let's hear your motion. I move we suspend the rules and place SJR 8 back on the calendar for second reading for
the purposes of the amendment. That is a proper motion. It's non-debatable. All right, so members, the question now before the House will be the suspension of the rules
to be able to place SJR 8 back on second reading for the purpose of amendment. All right. representative Walker for what purpose you're recognized for your question sir can we have discussion on this it's it's non-debatable sir it's just a suspension it's all this vote is it's just whether or not to suspend the rules in order to put it back on second reading for the purpose of amendment and
Speaker 140
43:42
on this I'll think about it thank you I'll I'll take that under advisement. That's
my request. Okay. Members, we're going to go ahead and proceed. The motion is to suspend the rules to allow SGR-8 to go back on second reading for the purpose of amendment.
All in favor say aye all opposed say no All right Members we're gonna put this on the board mr. Clark for the machine
all right is everyone voted all right let's cast the ballots mr. clerk all right 63 a's 26 nays and zero present the motion has passed mr. clerk read
Read Amendment Number 1 to SGRA. Amendment Number 1 to Senate Joint Resolution 8.
Representative Ballinger, you're recognized to explain the
amendment. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Simple, this is the amendment that actually increases the caps both on the punitive damages and on the non-compensatory damages from $250,000 to $500,000. It also gives back the rulemaking authority
to the Supreme Court. It retains our oversight and ability to also propose things that could be interpreted as rules, but it gives them the ability to kind of manage themselves. So it was an amendment that we ran yesterday. I apologize we're having to deal with it. It was on the member's own calendar, but it was objected to this morning. We were hoping to try to get everything done if we could and give you guys a good weekend, but it doesn't look like that's going to be possible. And so since the objection this morning, now we're dealing with it here on the floor. It's not typical that it is objected to a member's own, but I guess this thing is exciting enough
that people are paying attention to it and trying to do those kind of things. So having said that, I
would appreciate a good vote on this amendment in particular, which raises
the caps. Representative Walker, for what purpose? Question. You're recognized for your question, sir. In that this has not been generally discussed with all the members, would you tell me what the limitation is upon non-economic damages, punitive damages, and the power of this court,
I mean of this body, to any effect, say that the Supreme Court cannot be the adjudicator of disputes between parties who have been injured in the state of Arkansas. Okay, a lot of that deals with
the actual resolution, but some of that deals with the amendments we're dealing with, so I'll address that directly. The amendments deal with the caps. So prior to this amendment, the caps were set at $250,000 for non-income damages, $250,000 for punitives,
or three times the compensatory damages. Now what we're dealing with is we've increased that, We've doubled it at the will of this body. Several people have asked for that amendment. And so we have listened to them and tried to build a consensus and bring people together on this. And I appreciate the vote for the willingness to spin the rules so we can try to get at least this part of this thing done today. And that's essentially what it does is it increases those caps. Now, we don't touch the made whole part, so the compensatory damage.
I know you understand that, but for everybody else, if a person actually has any loss, that's still, there is no caps on this. And in fact, these caps are really not caps. What we're doing is setting the floor by which that it can be capped. Actually, what we're doing is bringing back, and this goes to the third part of your question, it brings back the policy-making back to the policy body, which is the legislature, so we can start making decisions about what caps are, or should be there, and how much should the caps be. That's all policy debate that I think should happen here.
And I actually, I think that the deference that has been shown to the judiciary for decades, for many decades prior to Amendment 80 in the late 90s, is exactly where we should be. And actually, that's why the third part of this amendment exists, because it still gives the courts all of their rulemaking authority. However, in the last several years, since 2003, when the first Judicial Reform Act was passed, The court has said several things as rulemaking, things like joint and several liability, basically how liability can be handled, things like whether or not an expert witness has to be actually certified as an expert witness, several things caps.
They've said that that is part of their rulemaking authority, and so they have ruled things that were passed out of this body as unconstitutional under Amendment 80. So what we're trying to do is just rebalance that to give some authority back here so that we can have debates for many years to come. I hope you're around and you will help me debate to make sure that we have reasonable
the judiciary reasonable authority to take care of their own business. Follow-up, please. Yes, you recognize your follow-up. Could you explain the rationale for placing the limit of $500,000 for non-punitive damages or non-economic damages,
whatever that means, where persons are in varying circumstances which may include an awful circumstance of a disabling injury which will last for 30 to 40 years and require care prospectively, and if that care is not authorized or provided by the award, it must
be taken on by the public itself. How can we pass that to the public rather than to the wrongdoer or the tortfeasor and make the person whole in terms of the damages that he has sustained. Could you explain that? Yeah, you actually have three
way we got to that number is this body deliberated and effectuate policy. And they said, you know, Bob, I like your resolution. I think that we do need
to do something with tort damages. We should do something to control. However, we think the cap of $250,000 is too low. And so in discussions, in order to try to build consensus, we increase that cap to $500,000, which is what this policy body does. It's that policy. So that's what we did with that. The second part of your question that, that, that we dealt with, or the last part of your question anyway, was, you know, how do we explain this to the public? And then, you know, how do we deal with the fact of the made whole? Well, like I said, the made whole part of it, the compensatory
damage, the things that people actually lose is not changed. We're not touching that at all. And the punitive damages while there's a cap of 500,000 minutes, or the greater of the three times compensatory damage, which is a relatively broad standard that exists already within the practice itself. So you can actually get punitive damages, the number could be in the multiple millions if their compensatory damages are enough. And the issue with the non-compensatory damages, the idea, the policy reason behind it is to try to create some sort of stability, that a person can go into business and operate
and be able to feel like that they can have some certainty as to the expenses that they could experience in a lawsuit. However, I think that we should do so in a way that's going to protect the public and is in the best interest of the public as a whole. I think that we've done that. We've created a balance because this body is wise. And what I'd want to do is reiterate this, is we're talking about the amendment here, not the resolution as a whole. It's whether or not you support increasing the cash from $250,000 to $500,000.
It's whether or not you support giving the authority back to the judiciary to set their own rules without our review and approval. And that's essentially where we're at on this amendment. And I'm not the kind of guy that thinks we shouldn't take questions. What I would ask of this body is make sure the questions are about this amendment so that we can deal with it. We're going to have lots of debate, lots of opportunity to have debate over this resolution. but I know that all of us would like to go home and I'd be happy to answer any real questions if you want to kill this amendment because you don't think that we should increase the caps from $250,000
to $500,000 then come down the well and kill this amendment but you know if you have just have legitimate questions I want to be here as long
as I can to help you with these amendments Representative
Mayberry for what purpose? be recognized for your question Representative Ballinger I appreciate your sentiments there And help me, does the change in this cat, does that affect a change in a cat toward life or toward a death?
It does. So historically, what has happened is that every time that you go in and you have a case of a wrongful death, you ask somebody to set the price on that. Now, what I would say is you can't, right? What I'd say is, you know, what is the profit of man if he gains the whole world and loses his soul, right? So the idea is that it's so invaluable, you couldn't cap it a billion dollars and it actually put any weight. However, so for our system to work, you've got to do something.
And so every time that we do it, either a judge, if there's no jury, or a jury, and then the judge can actually change the jury's verdict, you know, somebody puts some sort of price on it. and so what we're doing here is we are saying okay 250,000 because this body is folk we visited with the with the senate and the senate said okay we're willing to do that we'll double that we'll make it a half of a million dollars in order to to create some things but but that's not all so if you have a loss of earning potential throughout your life then then that's still there I mean all of those
things and and if there is a wrongful act so it would weren't punitive damages then the punitive damage would rest, and you'd get three times whatever that earning potential could be in life. So we still could be talking about millions of dollars in verdicts, but it'll have to be a situation where it'll have to be warranted that it's based on actual loss rather than something that's a little more amorphous. And we can create a little bit of stability and uniformity throughout the court system. Representative Whitaker, for what purpose? Question, Mr. Speaker. You're recognized for your question, sir. Thank you, sir.
Representative Ballinger, I noticed that the language limiting contingency fees remains in the bill. Why don't we make any effort to limit the fees of insurance and corporate attorneys on their hourly fees? Because if you've ever seen one of these bills, you might think they're excessive too. Well, let me say, Representative Whitaker, that actually is something that could
be done without a constitutional amendment. And so what I would say is that if that's your interest, then you could file a bill. Bill filing deadline doesn't happen for a couple weeks.
And so that's probably something that you could do outside of the Constitution. Within this bill, you know, I can say that it still rests. It still exists. You know, I can understand some person having some consternation about that, you know, not being completely happy about it. But one of the things that I would say is that is debatable. In 2019, 2021, we have the opportunity to come in here and make arguments with those policy decisions. Well, before that, we didn't have that opportunity. The court continues to say that's outside of Violet's Amendment 80.
It's outside the purview of the legislature, and so we have no ability to debate it. I think that's a policy decision, something we should wrestle with. It's something that we should work on. And so let's do that going forward. I look forward to working with you on trying to set good policy for
the state. Follow-up, please. You're recognized, free follow-up. It's curious to me that it requires a constitutional amendment to interfere with the private contracts of plaintiff's lawyers, but not defense lawyers. Thank
you. Yeah, well, we, and that's probably true,
it's because the court has taken some of those positions in the past, so, you know, we actually interfere with private contracts all the time, and you know as well as I do that we are officers of the court when we operate within the court, and so there's all sorts of restrictions and limitations that we operate on all the time when we practice, even in our fees, that we can be violation of things. But that actually is really not within the purview of this amendment. That was left out. So the question of this amendment, and whether we vote for this amendment, is do you support
increasing the limitations from $250,000 to $500,000? Do you support allowing the court to have its rulemaking authority subject to, not to our review and approval, but ability to amend if there's something in particular we need to deal with?
Representative Flowers, for what purpose? Question? You're recognized for your question, ma'am. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. A couple of questions ago, Representative Ballinger, you answered about placing a monetary value on life
in the case of an accidental death. And you talked about earning potential. how is this determined or calculated or considered in the case of a child um who doesn't have any earning potential well what i'd say is actually that child does have earning potential in fact they have
some of the biggest earning potentials because they're a child and they will live out a full life so the in the in that case of the death of a child there's a jury instruction that's
provided that we we submit to him all the time and that and we tell the jury that they should take into account his potential earning throughout his life. And so that is something that's provided to the jury and will continue to be provided to the jury. And so in that situation, is it difficult to prove? It's easier if you've got a guy who's making $100,000 a year to prove he's going to earn $100,000 a year. But you can deal with the averages. And when you talk about the averages of a lifetime, you're talking about a substantial amount of money. So there would be monetary damages in that case. It'd be up to the attorney to make sure that he makes that argument.
good trial attorneys are going to make that argument and the jury is going to get a jury instruction saying that they should consider that. Thank you. Follow-up,
Mr. Speaker? Follow-up, Mr. Speaker? Will this be the third one? No, second. Second? Okay, sorry. I've been having distractions. First follow-up, second question. Sorry. I've had a lot of people distracting me here and I just got so many people
standing up. I want to be fair. Yes, ma'am. Go ahead. Proceed. Thank you. The other question I had was about punitive damages and my understanding has always been that the nature of punitive damages
is to impose a penalty on an offending defendant or respondent, I guess. And so with that being something that I understand is defined based upon what would be a fair penalty for the size of the corporation, And I know we always hear about the historic McDonald's verdict, which obviously is an incredible outlier.
But even with that, obviously a penalty of a million dollars against McDonald's would be different from a million dollar penalty against a medium or small business here in this state. So with that said, how do we reconcile with what the purpose of a penalty is and placing an sort of arbitrarily low cap, what would that do for your larger companies, you know, in terms of being able to impose a penalty?
I would say it would be a whole lot easier to have some penalty at $500,000 rather than $250,000. And that's what this amendment does, is it increases that. In fact, it's three times compensatory or $500,000. So what this amendment does is increase that. So in answer to your question, it will be more of a penalty under this amendment, which is what we're debating here. Now, having said that, going back to kind of the meat of your question, you know, that we'll debate when we hear the full resolution.
The truth is that there is usually some sort of monetary damages, and if it's a really bad act, there will be big monetary damages. Those big monetary damages, three times that can be a lot of money. And I think that this is the thing, is that we've got to weigh those policy decisions. However, in this amendment, it increases that from $250,000, three times compensatory $250,000, to three times compensatory or $500,000. So if you're not okay with this increase, vote this thing down. If you are okay with this increase and you think it makes the resolution better, then I would say support it.
If you don't support it, I appreciate the questions. I want to answer every question that's out here. But come down here and speak
against the increase in these caps, and then we'll move forward. Representative Davis, for what purpose? Question. You're recognized for
your question, sir. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Representative Ballinger, is this your
bill and your amendment? This is my bill that I'm carrying in the House, and this is my amendment. Is your understanding that if
state agencies had adjourned prior to 4.30 yesterday afternoon that this would have been on a member's own amendment calendar today?
Yes, in fact, it was on a member's own amendment calendar, too, but it was specifically objected to because of the fact that we actually went a little long yesterday and didn't get out before 4.30. All right, thank you. Thank you. I appreciate a
good vote on this. All right, members, you've heard an explanation of the amendment. Would anyone like to speak against the amendment? All right, Representative Walker, you're recognized to speak against the amendment.
And members, I will reiterate that this is for the amendment. This is not for SDR 8. That
will be heard next week. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I speak against the amendment for a number of reasons apparently the $250,000 cap was too low to get the approval of some of the members of this august body
and you signed on for a $500,000 cap meaning that you'll go to the public in support of a $500,000 cap with the expectation that the public will be more supportive of a $500,000 cap than it would be of a $250,000 cap. I submit to you that the $250,000 cap if we go to the public should be the one that goes to the public, so that the people can deal with the reality of the situation.
I want those of you who are not lawyers to understand several things. When you talk about damages, I don't see Representative, I do see Representative Miller here, and I hope that he doesn't take offense at my suggestion here. But the cost of a catastrophic injury is huge, far beyond the ability of all but the top
two or three percent to shoulder by him or herself over a lifetime when that injury occurs in one's youth. So you say, according to Representative Ballinger, that a person will be able to get three times his wages. If a person in Arkansas has a minimum wage for $22,000 working for the
state, three times $22,000 would be $66,000 would be the limit of what that person would be able to get. And that cannot in any way address a catastrophic injury, the catastrophe will then have to be subsidized by the public, running up our health care costs and the costs of everything else that we have.
The further suggestion is made that, well, you can get punitive damages. It is very, very rare that anybody gets punitive damages in a case. A punitive damage case is one where there is particularly egregious behavior on the part of a wrongdoer, so egregious as to warrant a penalty to make a point. There are only a few of those situations.
In addition to that, we have in our experience here in Arkansas of recent vintage, an award to a person in a nursing home by jury of $5 million. And because of manipulations and deceit and fraud and dishonesty and lack of public integrity, That amount was reduced to a million dollars, causing some of us here to want to be able
to cause at least one of the actors who wore a robe in that situation to be capable of criminal punishment upon a finding of guilt. But the main point was that the jury was in a position to look at the circumstances there and make a determination of the value of that person's circumstances. These are not cases where the... Representative
Walker, hold on one second. Representative Payton, for what purpose?
Let's hear your point of order. I don't think his argument's germane
to the amendment at this point. Members, I'm going to have to agree with Representative Payton. We're steering a little off of the amendment. We're getting back on more to the SGR 8 discussion, which will be next week. So Representative Walker, if we could please just confine this to the amendment, the changes in the amendment and whether or not we want to proceed with those. Thank you. Well, I respectfully
but the speaker has the power, and as I come before you most of the time, I know that I have an expectancy of no more than 25 votes. But most of the people who will be affected by this will be people not of my color, and it will not be people who are of my circumstances, but the people who do the wrong are corporations or insurance companies or are insured by insurance companies, and they have deep pockets,
and they should not be allowed to have something like this by an amendment submitted to the public and say, oh, it's not a big deal, and we need it. Remember, there has been no suggestion that the present system that we have does not serve the public interest. Thank you for listening to me. Members, Representative Walker.
Thank you for your indulgence. Thank you. Representative Walker has spoken against the amendment. Would anyone like to speak for the amendment?
Representative Davis, again, I'll remind the members to stay on topic on the amendment. Thank you,
Mr. Speaker. Members, I just want to remind us all that we're talking about a member amending their own bill. We do this every day without discussion. I would encourage you to vote for this amendment. allow Representative Ballinger to amend his own bill in a way that many people in this chamber have asked him to amend his own bill.
And then we will debate this in full and have a vote up or down on Monday. Thank
you. Representative Holcomb, for what purpose? Motion. Let's hear your motion. Mediate consideration. Representative Holcomb, I'm going to hold off on taking that motion just yet. I want to make sure that people at least have a little bit more opportunity for input on this. All right, members, Representative Davis has spoken in favor of the measure. Would anyone like to speak against the amendment?
All right, Representative Brown, you're recognized to speak against the amendment.
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The only reason I'm asking you to vote against this amendment is because I'm not an attorney and I don't know how this all works, but if we would like to see the cap raised to a million,
does that mean that voting for this $500,000 cap settles the issue? So if it does, I'm asking you to please vote against this amendment. All right, members, Representative Brown has
spoken against the amendment. Would anyone like to speak for the amendment? Representative Ballinger, would you like to close for your amendment? All right. Members, Representative Ballinger has signified he has closed for his amendment, so the question now before the House is the adoption of Amendment Number 1 to SJR 8.
all in favor say aye all opposed say no all right I'm gonna rule the eyes have it amendment number one will be adopted to SGR 8
mr. clerk please read amendment Amendment number two to SJR 8. Amendment number two to
House Joint Resolution 8. Representative Gassaway, you are recognized to explain amendment number two to SJR 8.
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Members I want you to know that I have great respect for everyone in this chamber and it It took a lot of deliberation on my part to decide to file a Second Amendment on this bill. This is not something that I necessarily wanted to do, and I just want everybody to know that I have great respect for everybody here and everybody's opinion. But the debate on this topic has been something that has been just railroaded through with
very little debate about amending our Constitution on some of the most important issues that affect the people of this state. And what I'm proposing to do is to give you an alternative for us to consider and to have a thoughtful, meaningful debate about if we do tort reform, how we need to do it. And what I would submit to you is that many of us in this body campaigned on tort reform.
And among the Republicans in this body, it's not that we're opposed to tort reform, but we have an obligation to the people of this state that if we're going to amend our Constitution, that we do this thoughtfully, and that we be considerate about it, and that we do it in a responsible way, and that we do it in a reasonable way. And so what I offer you today is an alternative to SJR 8 and an alternative to the amendment
that has been made to SJR 8. And so what I'd like to do is to begin and explain to you what my amendment does that SJR 8, in its original form and in its amended form, doesn't do. The first thing that my amendment would do is that we would put into the Constitution the ability to sanction attorneys who file frivolous lawsuits.
Because that's one of the big arguments about why we should pass this tort reform is so that we can stop frivolous lawsuits. We have to cut down on the number of all these frivolous lawsuits. And so if we really want to do that, what I would submit to you is my amendment, more narrowly and very targeted, will cut down on frivolous lawsuits by targeting attorneys with sanctions who file those lawsuits. And then also allowing a judge to award attorney's fees to the party who has to defend a case
against a frivolous lawsuit. Now you say, what's the distinction? The distinction is this, if you look at SJR 8 in its current form, or in the form that it's been amended to that we just did, it doesn't contain that provision. And so for all of you who want to fight frivolous lawsuits, if you really want to do it, my amendment is how you do it, not with what's been presented to you here today. The next thing that my amendment does, that the other amendment doesn't do, and we need
to talk about this, we need to have a fair debate about this, is SJR 8 limits attorney's fees at one-third, and as amended, at one-third of the net recovery. Now, you all say, well hey, we don't like attorneys anyway, so what do I care if we limit their attorney's fees to one-third of the net recovery? And many of you may look at me and you say, Gassaway, we know you're an attorney. And so we know that you're probably for this because you think it's going to make you a lot of money or because it's made you money in the past.
Not true. I was a prosecutor. I put people in the penitentiary. I didn't do this kind of stuff. I tried a lot of cases, but it wasn't million-dollar verdict cases. But this is wrong on principle, and I'm going to tell you why. Because that one-third cap on the net, that is designed purely to prevent people from being able to hire an attorney. Because there are people in this state, you know, the corporations, they can pay an attorney $250 an hour. They've got the ability to go hire the best attorney they want and pay
them $250 an hour. But the poor people of this state who get injured in an accident through no fault of their own, they don't have the money to go hire an attorney at $250 an hour. And so to get an attorney to take their case, an attorney will take that case on a contingency fee. And the attorney gets no money up front to do that. And what you're going to have happen if you pass SJR 8 in its current form that my amendment changes is you're going to have people who have meritorious claims, who have legitimate claims, who are
going to take it to an attorney. An attorney is going to look at it and they're going to say, you know what? With a cap on my feet at one-third on the net recovery, I can't make any money with that case. And they're going to say, I'd like to help you, but sorry. And so that particular provision, if you think that's about limiting frivolous lawsuits, it's not. What it's going to do is it's going to limit all lawsuits, and it's going to limit
the good people of this state from being able to hire an attorney at their most vulnerable time when they've been injured and seriously hurt. And on top of that, it's not conservative. You know, we campaign and we talk about free market principles. We're conservatives and we believe in the free market. We're conservatives and we believe in the right of individuals to contract. But yet, just because you don't like attorneys, you're going to come in here and you're going to say, we're going to limit what an attorney can make off a case to one third of the net. That's not conservative. That's not free market. That's not capitalism.
That's not what Republicans believe. But because you don't like attorneys you'll do that. But if this was a real estate agent, what if we proposed that we were going to cap real estate agents' fees at 3%? It'd be an uproar like you've never heard. What if we came in here and said we're going to cap what a lumber company can make off their profits of the sell their lumber at 5%. You people would go crazy and say, that's not capitalism. That's not free markets. We can't do that. But because you don't like attorneys, you're going to
do that. And then what the proponents of this are going to do is they're going to use that to try to sell this bill to the general public. It's a selling point, but it's bad for the people of the state of Arkansas. It's going to limit access to the courts. My bill doesn't do that. My bill puts a cap on attorney's fees because that's what you want. And if you want it that bad, then let's do it. But if we're going to do it, let's do it fairly. And so what my bill does, what my amendment would do, is it would cap attorney's fees at one-third of the gross recovery. And while that's not fair, and while that's not capitalism, and while that's not free
markets, it will at least allow an attorney to make enough off a case to be able to take that poor person's case who comes in. And so that's why my amendment's better. The other thing that my amendment does, that SJR 8 in its current amended form doesn't do, is my amendment would raise the cap on non-economic damages to a minimum of one million dollars. Now I know you say, that sounds like a lot of money. A million dollars. Well here's the problem with that. There are people in
this state who are injured in terrible accidents, who are permanently injured for the rest of their life, who are seriously disfigured and will have to deal with that disfigurement for the rest of their life. And if you cap it at $500,000, the reality is they'll never get $500,000. By the time negotiations take place and attorney's fees and different things come out, it'll be a lot less than that. And I'm talking about people who've been involved in
accidents where their car exploded and they've been burned beyond recognition and they have to undergo a year of skin grafts and maybe they lose a limb, maybe they lose multiple limbs, maybe they're paralyzed, maybe they're blind, maybe they don't have the ability to procreate and reproduce anymore. And you're going to limit that in SJR 8 as it's currently proposed to $500,000 And I'm going to tell you, that's not right. That is morally not right. The other thing that my bill does is it makes some exceptions where there would be no limitations that would apply.
There would be no limitation in the event of intentional conduct. There would be no limitation in the event of gross negligence. And there would be no limitation in the event of death. And you say, why is that important? Why is it important that we not limit, that we put no limitations on death? Well, I'll tell you why. Because 75% of the people in this room campaigned as pro-life. And you couldn't wait to get that endorsement from the Arkansas Right to Life and stamp it on your mailers and send it out to everybody.
But the question that you have here today is, are you really pro-life? Are you going to put a value on if a child dies in an accident who has no economic value? like my seven-year-old daughter when my wife and daughter were involved in a head-on collision two weeks ago. My daughter doesn't have any economic value. She's seven years old. She doesn't earn an income. And if she would have died in that accident, the maximum under this amendment that has been passed today on her life would be $500,000.
If a person who's in a nursing home, like my dad who's in a nursing home, who worked for 50 years and paid his taxes and was a law-abiding citizen and raised a family and climbed in attics and pulled wire and put in heat and air units and worked hard. If he died in a nursing home today, he has no economic value today. And you would say his life is worth $500,000. And I'm going to tell you folks, that is wrong.
That is morally wrong, and I'm not going to sit over here and let it happen. And so I've proposed an amendment for you that will allow you to vote on a pro-life position and say, we're not going to put a limitation if someone through neglect and through abuse causes somebody's death. If some child dies in some horrific accident, we're not going to put a value on their death. My amendment will not put a value on that. And that's why mine's a better amendment. And the last thing that I've heard in the discussions of this debate
is that we need to limit the court's rulemaking authority because we need, and this is what I heard from people, that we need to do it like the federal system does it. And so what I said was, you know what? That's fair. If we're going to do it like the federal system does it, though, let's look at what they actually do. And so what my amendment does is we took the Rules Enabling Act that the United States Supreme Court and the U.S. Congress use for proposed rule changes.
And I took the Rules Enabling Act and I changed Judicial Conference to Judicial Council, and I put it right in this amendment. So you want to do it like the feds do it? Fine, let's do it like the feds do it. Because my amendment does it exactly like that. And so for those reasons, colleagues, I believe that my amendment is a better amendment and I'd ask you to support it. Thank you. and would be happy to entertain any questions all right representative peyton for what purpose
you mr speaker representative gazaway i'm trying to work out the mechanics of how this would work we just amended it five minutes ago or 20 minutes ago and i don't see how your amendment could have been drafted in a way to you know delete these lines and add these lines and all be engrossed. With the amendment that happened 15 or 20 minutes ago, that'll be engrossed over the weekend. Wouldn't it be wiser to pull your amendment down
and get it drafted in a way that it mirrors the amended bill to be presented next week? Well, I think that's a good question, and since
I was in State Agencies Committee yesterday afternoon, I knew that the amendment came out, and so I called Matthew Miller over at BLR this morning and I had my amendment drafted to be an amendment to the amendment. So it has taken into consideration the amended language that we just passed. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. All right.
Representative House, I think you were the next to stand. I'm going to go to you. All
right. Question, you're recognized for your question. Representative Gassaway, please explain how the hospital lien comes into play when you're talking about net recovery?
Well, and that's really a question. That's really up in the air under SJR 8 as it's proposed and as it's been amended. My understanding is it allows the legislature to set, because it doesn't define what net means,
and so it allows the legislature to define what net means as it's currently proposed. And the problem with that is if net means after the deduction of liens and after the payment of medical bills, you may have a case where there's $300,000 in damages. A lot of that's medical bills. If the attorney's fee is on the net, that could be as little as... If there's $300,000 total in damages and $200,000 of that were medical bills
for an intensive care stay that lasted six months, you'd be limiting an attorney to $30,000. And these cases don't resolve quickly. And so what you have happen is you'd have an attorney that would be entitled to a third of, say, $100,000, but it may take them three years to get it, which a $30,000 fee sounds like a lot of money until you divide it by three years, and you realize that's $10,000 a year, and then you realize that that's less than $1,000 a month. I mean it's not a lot of you know so if you limit the attorney's fees on the on the net
it's really going to deny people's access to the courts and that's the problem all right I think next I saw
representative Davis for what purpose question you recognize for your question we're speaker representative Gassaway has your amendment been
presented to either the Constitutional Amendment subcommittee of state agencies or the full state agencies committee? No. What time did you file this amendment? I filed it this afternoon.
I'm sorry, I filed it this morning. It's been available for barely over two hours, correct? I'd
say that's accurate. Thank you. All right, Representative Hammer, I believe you
were the next to stand. For what purpose? Question, please. All right, you're recognized for your question. Thank you. Only because you brought it up in your defense or in your presentation of your argument for this amendment, I'd like to ask you one possibly follow-up question. From personal experience, I have tried to help constituents and send them to attorneys with cases under $250,000 or even under the proposed $500,000,
and they've called me back and said the attorney wouldn't take the case because they weren't going to make enough money. So you make the argument a while ago about it's going to create situations where attorneys would turn away cases now, and I would perceive that a majority of those cases probably dealt with poor people. So what would be your response to that, seeing
how it currently now exists? Well, what my bill or what my amendment would do is really follow pretty much industry standard.
Right now, most attorneys who contract on a contingency fee will contract for one-third of the gross recovery. Now, many times those contracts will go on to say that in the event of trial or arbitration, if that's commenced, then the fee would go up to 40%. My bill doesn't allow that. It just caps everything at one-third of the gross recovery. But I'm not sure if that answered your question. Follow-up, Mr. Speaker. You recognize free follow-up.
And I'm uncomfortable on this question, I'm going to declare it, but we were put, I think, all
of us in an unfair position, and so I feel compelled to ask you this question.
You referenced using a personal illustration of your daughter, and nobody in this chamber would want to be in that position with any of our children. But we're debating a number that's going to establish a criteria, so I'm wondering what number do you think, in the event that would have happened, that the value of your daughter's life would have been? because I think if you're going to make that part of your argument for why we ought to do this, there needs to be a defined number because otherwise there's not enough money to replace any of our daughters' lives. And I'd like to hear your response to that.
Thank you. Absolutely, and I think that's an excellent question.
And so much like what Representative Ballinger said, you can't really put a value on human life. Human life, in one respect, has an intrinsic value that's priceless. And so to even attempt to put a value on human life one could argue would be impossible. Now we realize in our civil justice system, somebody has to do that. And so I think the question that we have to answer is, is that somebody going to be the legislature
who we're going to set across the board what we think the value should be? Or are we going to do it like it's currently done? Because there are no limitations in Arkansas currently. Are we going to do it like it's currently done? that if in the event that case has to go to trial, and Republicans are about local control, right, that we let a jury of 12 people from your community decide in that particular case what kind of value they would place on that. And do I think it's perfect? No. Because I
think any time that we have to place a value on human life, it puts us in a very difficult position. But I think as opposed to allowing this legislature to set an arbitrary across the board value, we let a jury in a case by case on a case by case basis listen to the facts listen to the circumstances and they make that decision and that's the true definition of local control since we're about local control and so that's how I would propose to answer that Representative Michelle Gray
For what purpose? Question. You're recognized for your question. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Representative Gassaway, you came yesterday and testified in committee, and you alluded to the fact that you had been meeting with the governor and that the governor was supportive of your amendment. Would you please speak to that? Well, that's
not what I said. What I said was on video. I mean, you can go back and watch it, so I'm not concerned about that. But it is true that I have and others have been involved in meetings with the governor's office.
It's true, I believe, that the other side of this debate have been involved in meetings with the governor's office. I certainly do not propose to speak for the governor or what the governor wants or wishes. What I would say is that I've been in meetings with him. There were suggestions made on things that could be done. And so I took that into consideration in drafting this amendment. Now, by no means am I saying that this amendment reflects what the governor wants. I'm not saying that so explicitly. I mean, you can go out and try to make a big deal that I got up here and said that this is what the governor wants.
I'm telling you, this is not what the governor wants. And I never said that. And it's on video, so I'm not concerned about it. But I understand what you're trying to do. So I hope that answers your question.
Follow-up. You're recognized for your follow-up. Thank you,
Mr. Speaker. I love being called a liar in front of my peers. I appreciate that, and I would also like to say that I was on the committee yesterday, and I was led to believe that the governor was supportive to the fact that I actually texted with the governor's office to see if that was true, as that might sway my opinion.
I will go watch the video. Thank you. I withdraw my
follow-up question. All right. Thank you. Representative
Rushing, for what purpose? Question. You're recognized for your question. Representative Galloway, Galloway, sorry about that. You did mention earlier about real estate fees, and so that kind of made my numbers start clicking. And so let's take into account that I sold a $500,000 house, and your client won a $500,000 case.
I'm going to collect $30,000 off of my 6% commission that I have now. You're going to collect $166,000 off of your based on a third. So are we talking about people, or are we talking about money? Well, I
think that's a good question, and it comes down to, again, if we're talking about free markets and capitalism, I mean, what the market will bear. And so that's traditionally been the business model and the way that this situation is handled.
These cases, and what you have to understand is the attorneys who take these cases have to invest, and many of them, a significant amount of their own money into the case because it requires the hiring of experts. It requires, you know, deposition fees, expert witness fees. There's just a lot of money and a lot of time that gets tied up in these cases when an attorney has no guarantee of winning that case. And so, you know, an attorney may spend $100,000 on a case in the course of investigating it, in the course of, you know, preparing
with the expert witnesses and so on and so forth, and they may not ever get a dime out of that case because they may not win. And so, you know, it's a huge risk on the attorneys who take those cases. And it... So I just don't think it's comparing apples to apples with your analogy, but... Follow-up, Mr. Speaker? Yes, ma'am,
you recognize for your follow-up. Thank you. Well, with all due respect, when a real estate agent writes a contract, we invest a lot of money in it.
There's a lot of times that we pay for a lot of fees up front before where there's no guarantee that this property is even going to close. We put a lot of money and time and effort into the same thing without collecting one dime until the property closes. And so, you know, we're working for the people like the attorney should be working about the people. But right now, I feel like that you're talking about the money. So, again, are you talking about the people or are you talking about the money? Well,
I think it's both. I mean, obviously, my concern is people's access to the courts.
And so if they have no access to the courts, then they have no remedy at all. And so in that regard, I do think that it helps the people. And my comment, and I hope that it wasn't taken this way, but my comment certainly was not against real estate agents. The only reason I mentioned real estate agents was for the purpose of illustrating that if we propose to be free market and we propose to be capitalist, then I think that, you know, if we're going to limit attorney's fees, then we could say that about any profession across the board. And so we need to be very careful about doing that. So that's
my response. All right. Representative Dotson, for what purpose?
Question. You're recognized for your question. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Representative Gasway, during your testimony, you mentioned something that I've been sitting here a little bit concerned about and something I've been hearing going around a little bit and it seemed to me as if you stated that or implied that if someone were to not support your amendment that in effect they would be not considered pro-life the there's
There's various organizations that are out there that have endorsed people for their pro-life stance on issues, and as you said, everybody wants to be pro-life that wants those endorsements. Well, as I hear that, that term in most people's minds, at least in mine, means a much different thing when you put it on a postcard it has to do with whether or not you support or you don't
support abortion. So I want to give you the opportunity to clear that up. If someone does not vote for your amendment, are you saying that they are pro-abortion? No. Representative Sterch, for what purpose?
Question, Mr. Speaker. You're recognized for your question. Thank
Speaker 234
1:38:07
you, sir. Representative Gassaway, I will be honest with you.
After state agencies yesterday, I subjected myself to an hour-long conversation with my local bar association. And so I've got all these terms in my head, and of course I'm not a lawyer, and I'm trying to figure out, you know, what is considered this and what is not considered that. And you're right in your testimony as far as what they told me that they do typically charge 40% on their gross settlements, and they take their expenses for experts or whatever out of that. What my question is, you know, with liens or medical bills or whatever,
are you saying that the way it is written now, 33% of the net, that the bills and things would come out of that before they even got
their fees? Well, I think it's not clearly defined. My understanding of the way SJR 8 is written, and I suppose I could be wrong, is that the legislature will define what the net means. And so right now we really don't know. I think the concern is that the net would be after the liens and after all the medical bills and that sort of thing, so it would leave the attorney's fee to be on a very small portion,
which is asking the attorneys who take these kinds of cases, which, again, is not me. I've been a prosecutor. But the attorneys who take these kinds of cases, they're taking a huge risk with the potential for very little reward. I
Speaker 234
1:39:37
your follow-up. So that would come through enabling legislation later. It's not necessarily in SJR 8 or even in your amendment. Well, SJR
8, my reading of it says that it would be limited to the net recovery,
but it allows the legislature to define what net recovery means. Okay, members,
you've heard an explanation of the amendment. Would anyone like to speak against the amendment? All right. Representative Collins you're recognized to speak against the amendment members I will
remind everyone again just like on amendment number one let's stay to the merits of the amendment and not to SGR 8 proceed representative
Collins you recognized thank you mr. speaker boy this is the slickest move I've ever seen and I've been down here for a while. This is slick. It is so difficult to make change in this state. We are 49th, 48th, 47th, over and over and over again.
In 2003, this legislature passed a law that would improve our court system, the CJRA. Through court cases, the lawyers and the judges effectively nullified it. 2009, we tried risk pools, killed. 2011, we tried to refer out tort reform, killed. 2013, more tort reform attempts, killed. Last time, loser pay and other legislation. Making change is so difficult.
Representative Gassaway is one of my favorite people in the whole world. I know he's been trying like crazy through the proper process to get his ideas incorporated. The reality is, this is an attempt to gut tort reform once again. That's the bottom line, and I'd urge you to
vote no. All right, members. Representative Collins has spoken against the measure. I have Representative Miller up next to speak in favor of it.
Representative Miller, you are recognized. Come to the well and speak in favor of amendment number two
to SJR 8. Thank you, Mr.
Speaker. In order to keep with speaking on this amendment and not SJR 8, I want to, well, start off by telling you I'm not an attorney or a particularly bright person. So I'm not gonna talk to you as such today.
My problem with this whole thing so far, the biggest sticking point with me has been the caps on damages. The reason I'm down here to speak for Representative Gassaway's amendment is what it does in lifting the caps, raising the caps up, and then removing them in certain circumstances. There's a point that I think needs to be made
that I think maybe has been missed so far, and that is, folks, in a situation where someone dies due to negligence, there is no amount of money that's going to bring that person back. $250,000 doesn't bring somebody back from the dead any less than 10 million dollars or vice versa does that make sense okay no amount of money is going to bring anyone back from the dead and loving family members would much rather have
their loved one than 10 million dollars i said loving family members now just to clarify but here's the thing where the money is important and I can speak to this from experience because I've been fortunate or unfortunate enough to visit a good number of our medical institutions here in Arkansas
for some reason or another, and we're blessed to have good ones. We really are. We're very blessed to have great hospitals. But when you are not a doctor and you maybe don't have friends or doctors and you may not have family members and you're in a hospital in an acute care situation or a nursing home, it's nice to know that you can trust the people who are taking care of you. Right? I mean, thank you, Representative Blake.
I'd like for folks to follow along with me here. It's nice to know that you can trust who is taking care of you when you cannot physically take care of yourself. Folks, if someone knows, if an institution knows, hey, we have to stay on top of our stuff because if we allow some CNA or LPN or whatever to come into work
that's hot on drugs and she messes up and doesn't change her rubber gloves, he or she messes up, doesn't change her rubber gloves from helping someone go to the bathroom and then dresses their wound on their skin and they die of sepsis a week later. that's a serious situation that's negligence and that can happen as easy as falling off a grease log now the reason I bring that up is right now that
is handled very well by the threat of a higher threshold of a lawsuit more money I like the amendment that went from 250 to 500 I don't like it enough to support it I like this amendment better because it makes institutions have to think it makes folks have to think and make sure that we are doing the right things and we're not messing up it's not about bringing
someone back from the dead the money after they're gone or whatever it's about the protections in the beginning it's that the the person folks I'm and I'll use me as an example I have economic value I've been very fortunate since my accident representative Walker you did not offend me earlier I've been very fortunate since my accident to have been able to run a business and work be down here I have economic value to my family so but there may be someone who has an
injury identical to mine that has not been as fortunate who didn't have the family the support group and just the the breaks the opportunities that I've had and now we're going to say that their life is worth less than mine and I dare say that is immoral and wrong and I believe that is the point about being pro-life representative Dotson was hitting on earlier we're not saying that
anyone is for abortion if you support this or don't support this but it's about the value of human life and the appreciation for human life I believe I'm adamantly pro-life I believe life starts at conception and we should value it and that doesn't end after after you're born so I just hope that you'll think about some of these things I'm not getting off in the weeds on all this technical crap because I'm not real good at that but uh anyway appreciate you
hearing me out members representative Miller has spoken in favor of the amendment would anyone like to speak against the amendment representative payton you're recognized to speak against the amendment
i'll tell you i just thought it'd be really fun to come down here and take an opposite side from representative miller right after he talked but uh i mean y'all know me, or most of you know, that I love a good debate. And there's a lot of very important things
contained in these amendments and in this bill. And you know also that I have fought vehemently against, and for every now and then, but usually against something. And many times I've been tempted to try to file a hostile amendment. And I just want to talk to you for a minute about procedure and decorum in the house as we all file bills and somebody would hijack each other's bill
by introducing a hostile amendment i mean that that's a pretty high threshold and uh you know a member gets their bill through committee they do some amending to the bill they get a consensus and a way to get it passed through committee and for it to come to the house floor and be hijacked with a hostile amendment is something that we should really consider to be a big step and be cautious in starting that because it could, you know, it could affect many of us and many bills in the future. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. All right, members, Representative
Payton has spoken against the amendment. I have Representative Mayberry that was up next to speak for the amendment. thank you mr speaker
oh what a day um i think most of us if not all but but most of us in this chamber are in favor of tort reform i was told by one representative yesterday that it seems like
everybody who's from here is against business, and that's certainly not true. But when I look at the life issue, and that's why I come down here to speak today, is with regards to the life issue, that has become a central part of this discussion it seems. And as many of you know, I've been down here countless times over the last however many years
to talk to you about life. I've spoken about unborn life. I've spoken about the life after the birth for those who may not be as physically or mentally gifted as some of us or some of you in this chamber. I am president of Arkansas Right to Life I'm not standing here today
as president of Arkansas Right to Life and speaking on behalf of that organization the Right to Life organization as an organization has not taken a position on SGR or SJR 8 I am standing down here as Andy Mayberry an individual and as a state representative who is doing the best job that I can to represent my constituents. But I do think that it's important
to look at what the mission statement of Arkansas Right to Life is. And again, I'm not saying that that organization has taken a position on this. I just want to read to you a couple of paragraphs from that mission statement. The legal protection of the right to life of innocent human beings is the basic issue upon which all other issues of human rights and justice depend. It is the pivotal human
rights issue today because once we abandon the basic democratic principle of equality that all, and it's in all caps, all human beings deserve the protection of law no matter what their size, their age, or their degree of dependency. Then the rights of all of us are less secure. I'm going to skip on down to the last paragraph and it says that
the members of Arkansas Right to Life are active in the pro-life movement within Arkansas. all. We come from different social, economic, racial, religious, age, and political backgrounds and we are bound together by a common dedication to protecting all human life. Our cause is to foster and protect society's traditional respect for life. Hold on one second. Representative
Farrar, for what purpose? He's not talking about the amendment at all. For what purpose?
Statement. For what purpose? Port of order. All right. Port of order. Let's hear your port of order. Speak about the amendment, amendment
only, please. We're getting off on the weeds. My intention with what I'm saying is to go to the part of the amendment where we have in currently, under the current amended version, has a $500,000 cap that has no restrictions with regards to the loss of life. All right, here's what
we're going to do, Representative Mayberry.
We're going to give you just a tad bit more
latitude on this, but make it quick. Yes, sir. Let's speed this up. Yes, Mr. Speaker. So the last sentence, our cause is to foster and protect society's traditional respect for life by supporting the civil and human rights of the unborn, the defenseless, the aged, the disadvantaged, and all human life. I don't know how I could stand here and say that it's okay to just arbitrarily pick a number out of the air as a legislative body and say that that's the maximum value for human life.
And certainly I don't mean to imply in any shape, form, or fashion that if you don't vote for this amendment and that you vote for SJRA that you're not pro-life Because I know there are some outstandingly pro-life people who do support SJRA in its current form, the amended version of it. I don't mean to imply that at all. I would just simply say that if you are pro-life, please take a moment to take a more introspective look at this and understand what we're talking about today.
I would appreciate a good vote on the Second Amendment. All right. So, members, Representative
Mayberry has spoken in favor of the amendment. I think I have Representative Davis up next to speak against the amendment if he still wishes to do so. You're recognized at this time. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I'll be quick because I think a
lot of people are thinking about saying the same thing. But we have rules and we have a process around here.
We do not file amendments less than two hours before we come into chambers and then expect to take a vote on that amendment. I would
respect to due process. Thank you. All right, members, Representative Davis has spoken against the amendment. I have Representative Richmond up next to speak in favor of the amendment.
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Colleagues, you probably realize I don't particularly like lawyers. I never have. I am for tort reform, but my opinion on lawyers doesn't change anything. Just like ticks in the woods have a place in nature, lawyers have a place in our society. But what I want you to consider is that what we do here, and I'm going to vote for the First Amendment to reform tort,
or I'm going to vote for the second one, it doesn't matter. But what I'd like for you to consider is that what we're doing here is we're going to pass something on to the people to make a decision. And we need to send them the best bill, because I guarantee you the trial lawyers right now are loading up their magazines with the ammunition and getting ready to spend millions of dollars to defeat whatever we have here, no matter what it is. So whichever amendment, whichever bill that we send out there that has the best chance of winning, consider that.
Everybody has their points, and I think a lot of people have kind of taken ownership of those points, but consider what will win. That's what we need to send. Thank
you. All right. Members, Representative Richmond has spoken. In favor of the amendment, would anyone like to speak against the amendment? Representative Ballinger, you're recognized to speak against the amendment.
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Hey, I'm sorry, members. Boy, I had no idea that this was going to happen. It would have been nice to actually have this discussion beforehand while we were making the amendments. Maybe we could have done something. But let me say this. If you've actually read it, you'd have to go to the website. You'd have to look it up. You'd have to pull it up because it really just got filed right before we came in here. And I just don't think that that is an honest and sincere effort in order to try to... And this is the thing. Representative Gadsway is a little bit of a victim, a victim of attempts over and over and over again
to kill tort reform. And I'm just saying that I feel like that's probably where we're at. We've worked real
Speaker 164
1:58:31
hard. Hear your point of order, Representative Blake. He's not pertaining
to the bill. He's actually talking about one of the members. I wish he would go back to the amendment,
please. All right. Representative Ballinger, try to stay on point if we can. Absolutely.
What I'm speaking about is the intent of the amendment. So I'm speaking directly to this amendment and what this effort, what the procedures, what we're dealing with right here.
And so, you know, I have visited with the governor's office. He does support my amendment. He thinks of my amendment. He supports tort reform, and it makes it better. I noticed that Representative Gathaway did not say that. Now, I don't think that that should be the ultimate conclusion of what we pass and what we don't pass. But at the same time, I do think that it's important for us to be considering when we're going to be dealing with the legislation in the future. There's a lot of things that we need to do and we need to get done as a body.
A lot of policy we need to debate. A lot of good things that can be done. And that's what my amendment and resolution would do without this. The problem is under this amendment would actually gut most of that. So I appreciate a no vote. All right, Representative Gassaway, would you
like to close for your amendment? You're recognized to do so at this time.
Thank you again, Mr. Speaker. And thank you members. I want you to know I want you all to know that what I did here today was was in no way intended to be any disrespect toward this institution or toward any of the members. And I hope Representative Gray knows that there's certainly no disrespect meant for anything that I said in that exchange or with any of the other members. But I believe that this issue of amending our Constitution is of such importance that we have to take time to deliberate
about it, we have to be thoughtful about it, and we have to try to do this in a responsible and a reasonable way. And this thing came out of the Senate with such head steam that there was very little debate. I mean, my understanding of the Senate is that they restricted the a limited debate to 10 minutes. I know Rose Mims, who was there, didn't even get an opportunity to speak. They scheduled a special meeting in state agencies yesterday afternoon to take
this up after session. Then they limited the debate, and there were several people there who only got to speak, had to share 10 minutes in order to talk about this. I tried to file an objection to it this morning so that we would have the weekend to talk about this and to debate it further and to explore the different thoughts that were out there. And then there was a motion made to try to push it through today. But then people want to try to put this on me
as if I'm the one who interjected this at the last minute. That's not fair. If this thing had not been tried to be railroaded through then I would not have had to have done this. And I hope that nobody holds that against me from now on because I think it's about debating the ideas. This is an issue about ideas. We're talking about amending our Constitution, and it shouldn't be something that's done in a railroaded fashion. And so I've offered you an alternative today, an
alternative that I think is reasonable, and that I think respects the people of the state of Arkansas. I'm not here for the insurance companies. I'm not here for the lobbyists. I'm not here for the nursing homes. I'm not here for the wealthy and the powerful. I'm down here for the people of this state, the hardworking people. I'm here for that person that's in a nursing home. I'm here for that person that's seriously and permanently disabled. That's who I'm down here to represent. And I think this bill gives you a good
alternative. And I'd appreciate a good vote. Thank you.
all right members the question now before the house will be the adoption of amendment 2 to sjr 8 all in favor say aye all opposed say no all right mr clerk prepare the machine
has everyone voted everyone voted all right let's cast out the ballots mr. clerk with 36 yeas 48 nays and three present the amendment number two has failed to be adopted are there any more minutes mr. clerk okay all right send the
bill to engrossing mr. clerk all right members here's what we're gonna do we're gonna take a five minute recess everybody catch your breath kind of refresh for a minute and then we'll come back and we'll proceed with our red calendar. So five-minute recess, do not go far. Thanks.
all right members the house is going to be called back into session nope skip all right everybody listen up all right this is how we're going to go we're going to work through some house bills as many as we can get through till one o'clock okay that's going to comprise our schedule for this for the rest of today all right so we're going to go to a one o'clock we're going get through as many as we can. That's up to you guys on your questions and your
presentations on how many of those we get done. All right, so Mr. Clerk, please read House Bill 1589. House Bill
1589 by Representative Vaught concerning the applicability of certain ethics laws to members of school district board of directors and amending portions of Arkansas law resulting from Initiated Act of 1998. Representative Vaught, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
Today I bring to you House Bill 1589. I've had several constituents and several people around the state ask me if school board members have the same, if they have any ethics, do they live by any standards? And so in light of several school board members, that wasn't right, was it? In light of the fact that we've had several kind of rogue school board members, we've kind of wrote just a basic accountability type bill here, and I would appreciate a good
vote. All right, members, you've heard an explanation of the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill, for the bill? All right, Representative DeVaugh has signified she's closed for the bill, so the question now before the house will be the passage of house bill 1589 prepare the machine mr. clerk All right, everyone voted.
Okay, let's cast it to ballots, Mr. Clerk. With 89 yeas, 0 nay, and 0 present, the bill has passed. All right, members, we're going to pass over the next item on the agenda, and we're going to pick up with House Bill 1048. Mr. Clerk, please read House Bill 1048. House Bill 1048 by
Representative David Meeks. Permit voluntary respite care to create the licensure exemption concerning voluntary respite care and to declare an emergency. Representative Meeks, you're recognized.
Present your bill. thank you members I'm going to be try to be as quick as I can because I know time's running short but our foster care system now has over 5100 kids in and it's been steadily increasing and with the governor's support and with your support and support of folks around the state we're working on ways to try to curb that you know some of the ways that we can do it is actually within the foster care system with resources, with getting parents the help that
they need. That's a job that our attorney ad litems, our CASA workers, and so many others do on a daily basis. And we're proud of the efforts that they're doing in order to help our children and in order to help our families get back together, get their lives right, and then be able to go on and carry them out. One of the things, though, that we can focus on a little bit more is how do we actually keep children from coming into foster care in the first place? And of course, you know, again, we can try to offer them resources, but today
I'm proposing to you legislation to also help in a different way, and that is with safe families. This is a program that runs in 30 different states, four countries, and has been highly successful. These are states that run the gamut from blue states like Illinois and Oregon to red states such as Oklahoma and Mississippi. So what does my bill do? It basically just clarifies that these organizations can run in the state of Arkansas and then give some
parameters as to how they're to run. I'm not going to go through everything because, again, of the time, but I do want to just again try to summarize what it is. It's a volunteer, meaning mom and dad and whoever it is can voluntarily do this. They don't have to if they don't want to. So that's number one. The Safe Families Organization, what they do is they get host families who are willing to take in a kid for a short length of time, and the bill caps it out as a year with the power of attorney. They take the kid in
while mom and dad are able to get their life right. These are not the most severe cases because those, obviously, they will go and come into foster care. So these are, for instances, such as mom and dad are having problems with their marriage and they need to be able to get their marriage back in order. And so they will place that kid with a host family. It may be a medical condition where a single mom has to go in and get a surgery and she is not going to have the capability for several weeks
in order to be able to take care of the children so they can be able to put it with that particular host family. Members, this is a good bill. There's a lot of other things that I could tell you, but again, because of time's sake, I'm just going to go ahead and stop there. I would appreciate a good vote, and I'll be willing to maybe, not maybe, but I will be willing to take any questions that you may have on this bill. All
right, Representative Charlene Fite, for what purpose? Question. You're recognized
for your question. Thank you for bringing this bill, Representative Meeks.
Could you tell us in how many other states this
has been successful? Again, it's been operating in 30 states. It's been an operation. The original one I started back in 2005 in Illinois, and they've had over 28,000 kids that have gone through the Safe Families Program, again in 30 states, and they've had success. I mean, we're talking about over 90% of the kids have gone back to their mom and dad or to a relative. Those that have not, you know,
there are, again, extreme circumstances where they may have to be pulled into foster care or into another situation. But the 90% rate, you know, we can't even, we're not even matching that with our own foster care system. So it's a great, great program. Thank you for asking that question. Any other question, members? if not I appreciate a good vote all right members you've
heard an explanation of the bill would anyone like speak against the bill or the bill all right representing the mix is signified he's closed for the bill so the question now before the house would be the passage of house bill
1048 prepare the machine mr. clerk voting on the bill and its emergency clause all right has everyone voted let's cast out the ballots mr clerk with 89 yeas zero nay and zero present the bill and its emergency clause have passed representative dotson for what purpose
uh motion all right let's hear your motion mr speaker having given notice on senate bill
133 i move for reconsideration all right that is a proper motion it is debatable representative dotson you are recognized to come and address your
motion thank you mr. speaker members making the motion to reconsider this bill from the other day
just to have the opportunity to vote on it again the other day when this came up i had some questions i've spoken with the insurance commissioner my my concerns and questions were unfounded so I've gotten those addressed and I think this is actually a good bill that's vitally needed and necessary to give Arkansans options for insurance coverage in the state of Arkansas and so I'd appreciate you
joining with me to vote for this motion and let this bill be heard again thank you all
right members you've heard an explanation of the motion would anyone like to speak against the motion for the motion representative Dotson which are you closed for your motion all right you recognized to do
so at this time thanks again and I would certainly appreciate a good vote
on this motion all right members the question now before the
House will be the motion to reconsider Senate Bill 133. All in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed say no. All right the ayes have it. So now the question before the House is going to be the passage of Senate Bill 133. Prepare the machine Mr. Clerk all right is everyone voted let's cast the ballots mr. clerk with 63 a 16
nays and one present the bill has passed all right members picking back up with our calendar here we're going to pass over at the request to the sponsor the next item and we're going to pick back up with House Bill 1641. Mr. Clerk please read House Bill 1641. House Bill
1641 by Representative Wing to increase the tool allowance for certain employees of the Arkansas State Highway and
Transportation Department who work on highway equipment
recognized to present your bill. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. This bill, first and foremost, does not ask for any more additional appropriations. This is merely allowing the Arkansas Highway and Transportation Department to internally adjust their tool allowance, which is currently $40 a month, to raise it to $45 a month. These maintenance workers, 141 positions, rely on this allowance to be able to give
them the tools that they need to be able to handle all kinds of things, from busted culverts to trucks that need to be changed from winter season to spring season. And again, they are able to handle this with funds that already exist. They just need the authority from us to be able to adjust that internal budget to raise it $5 a month. Won't cost anybody a thing. They have the money. I'd appreciate a good
vote. All right, Representative Wing has explained the bill. anyone like to speak against the bill for the bill all right he's signified
he's closed for the bill so the question now before the house would be the passage of House Bill 1641 for the machine mr. clerk everyone voted all right let's cast out the ballots mr. Clark with 90 yays zero a and zero present the bill has passed all right members we're going to skip over the next two items on the agenda we're going to pick back up with house
bill 1644 mr. clerk please read house bill 1644 house bill
1644 by representative Tosh to change the filing deadline for franchise tax reports
bill thank you Mr. Speaker, friends, this is a bill that was brought to me by the Secretary of State, and it was brought to them by a legislative audit. This is a business-friendly bill. What it does, it allows our stock corporations now the flexibility and time-saving and efficiency
when calculating their annual franchise tax. Under current statute, now they have to submit that report at the end of their physical year, and they also have to submit the report again at the end of the calendar year on December the 31st. So actually they're having to have this report figured up and having to hire an accountant twice to get this port in under current law. So this will eliminate the report that has to be submitted on December the 31st
and it will allow them to submit their franchise report as to what they owe only one time a year and that will be at the end of their physical year. So take any questions. If not, I'd appreciate a good vote. All right, members, you've heard an explanation of the
bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? For the bill? All right, Representative Tosh signified he's closed for the bill, so the question now before the House will be the passage of House Bill 1644. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk.
Everyone voted? Everyone voted? All right, let's go to the ballots, Mr. Clerk. With 90 yea, 0 nay and 0 present, the bill has passed. Mr. Clerk, please read House Bill 1552.
House Bill 1552 by Representative McNair to alter the requirements for a lifetime teaching license. representative an area
recognized explain your bill thank you mr. speaker
members 1552 does exactly what it says it came out of education with no objection I appreciate a good vote are you've heard an explanation of
the bill would anyone like speak against the bill for the bill represent that man air signified he's closed for the bill so the question now before the house to be passage of House Bill 1552. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk.
Everyone voted. Let's cast out the ballots, Mr. Clerk. With 85 yeas, zero nay, and zero present the bill has passed mr. clerk please read house bill 1523 house bill 1523 by representative Sturge concerning
the training of members of the board of directors of a public school district representative
Sturge you're recognized to present your bill thank
Speaker 234
2:29:05
you mr. speaker colleagues house bill 1523 was brought to me by the school boards association currently right now in
statute school board members are required to receive nine hours of training by December 31st of the year after their election. But the penalty for not receiving training is actually on the school itself. If this doesn't get done, then the school can receive some probationary citations from ADE and eventually leads to some funding being withdrawn. So all this bill does is put the onus back on the school board member, a personal responsibility on the school board member for not receiving training instead of the school itself. No known opposition, and I
appreciate a good vote thank you all right members you've heard an explanation of the bill would anyone like to speak against the bill for the bill our representative search has signified he's closed for his bill so the question now before the house be the passage of house bill 1523 prepare the machine Mr. Clerk everyone voted all right let's cast it the ballots Mr.
Clerk with 89 yeas 0 nay and 1 present the bill has passed All right, Mr. Clerk, please read House Bill 1250. House Bill 1250 by Representative Michelle
Gray to amend the Arkansas Dental Practice Act to create additional exemptions to the practice of dentistry and dental hygiene and to modify dentistry specialty licenses. Representative Gray, you recognize, present your bill.
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. This bill amends the Arkansas Dental Practices Act. Let me back up a little bit. So I filed this bill much earlier in the session and had a lot of controversy around it, and I essentially promised everyone that I would not run the bill until we had it amended so it was amenable with both the Dental Association and the DSOs, or Dental Services Organizations. So myself and several other legislators, along with the Dental Services Organizations
and the Dentistry Association worked a number of hours and weeks trying to get this right. So what we did is we took out a lot of what was in the original bill and substituted it with language that was amenable to both. So we ran the amendment just yesterday in committee, in committee, and we were actually still working on the language during scope week, so we didn't
get it done until yesterday. But what it does, three main things. It clarifies the Dental Practice Act by providing that any person who provides or does the following is not deemed to be practicing dentistry. If they own or lease equipment, they own the buildings, or they own some of the administrative function, these DSOs, that's not considered practicing dentistry. And it also So a very important piece to me, at least in this agreement that everyone came to, was that it does not allow these DSOs or management-type companies to have any say-so in direct patient care.
So they can't dictate quotas, they can't have any say-so in how the patient is taken care of, and all the records do stay with the dentist. The second section, it expands access to dental care by allowing out-of-state licensed dentists who are in good standing to both apply for dentist positions and provide charitable care for a limited four-day basis. So we're allowing licensed dentists from Missouri, Texas, wherever, whatever other state, as long as they meet our qualifications, to come in and do on-the-job interviews or to come in and do charitable care but only up to four days.
And they have to submit all their documentation to the board to make sure that they are certified to do that or licensed to do that. And the last section, we're expanding access to dental care by allowing specialist dentists to provide general dentistry services as long as they practice at least 50% in their specialty area. So this three main points that we've made here, to my knowledge, there's no known opposition. And again, the Arkansas Dentist Association worked tirelessly on this,
and so I can't thank them enough for helping us come to this agreement. But I'd be glad to take any questions. Seeing none, I would appreciate a good vote. Thank
you. All right, members, you've heard an explanation of the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill, for the bill? Representative Gray has signified she is closed for the bill I'm going to backtrack here Representative Ferguson was waving and I had missed her so I apologize you're recognized to
speak for the bill okay just because I'm having people text me and say are you okay with this yes absolutely and I really appreciate Michelle's Representative Gray's work on this it's it's been unending hours. A lot of this came out of, you may know that several years ago the board was sued because they wouldn't let orthodontists clean teeth. So a part of this, it would allow specialists to do some general dentistry. And we also have a Mission of Mercy where we've needed dentists
from out of state to come work, but they weren't allowed to because they didn't have an Arkansas license. So this will allow those dentists to come in and work Mission to Mercy or other charitable events around the state. I think there's some in Northwest Arkansas too. So it will allow that and then those four days would also allow these dental service organizations to bring a dentist in, see how they work and let that be an interview process. So absolutely, you know, the dentists are for this, the dental service organizations, it's an agreed on bill.
All right, members, Representative Ferguson has spoken in favor of the measure. Anyone want to speak against the measure? All right, Representative Gray is signifying that she is now closed for her bill. So the question now before the House will be the passage of House Bill 1250. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk.
everyone voted everyone voted all right let's cast the ballots mr. clerk with 90 gays zero nay and zero present the bill has passed mr. clerk please read house bill 1513 house bill 1513 by
representative Holcomb to amend the eligibility requirements for the asbestos abatement grant program. Representative Holcomb, you recognize to present the bill. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Real
simple bill. Actually, all it does, ADEQ has $150,000 in grant money. What it does, it increases the population eligibility requirements for the asbestos abatement grant program from $30,000 to $50,000. One other thing that it does, it amends eligibility structures under the grant program to include a building that is at imminent risk of collapse. And that's pretty simple. That's it. And if it says you have questions, I'll appreciate a good vote. Thank you.
All right, members, you've heard an explanation of the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill or the bill? All right, Representative Holcomb signified he's closed for the bill, so the question now before the House will be the passage of House Bill 1513. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk.
Everyone voted. All right, let's cast it to ballots, Mr. Clerk, with 86 yeas, 0 nay, and 0 present. The bill has passed. Mr. Clerk, please read House Bill 1215. House Bill 1215 by
Representative Love to amend the laws regarding the practice of massage therapy to include the practice of cupping. Representative Love, you're recognized to
Colleagues, House Bill 1215 does exactly what it says, it's going to allow massage therapists to practice cupping after they've finished educational requirements. If there's any questions? Everybody .
All right. You've heard an explanation of the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? Does anyone want to speak for the bill? Representative Richmond, you're recognized to speak for the bill.
I think. Thank you, Mr. Speaker, I apologize, but Representative Love ran out of the, well, before I could ask a question.
Now, as a member of the Naval Service, I've had the opportunity to visit many foreign and exotic ports of call throughout the world. And I have to say that after my Marines have come back from shore leave, they've described many things that do happen out on the shore of these places, but I've never heard cupping. When you close, could you please explain what it is that we're talking about? Thank you.
All right. Representative Richmond has spoken in favor of the measure. Would anyone like to speak against the measure? Representative Love, you're
recognized to close. Okay. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. So cupping is basically the device used to actually move energy throughout the body, as explained to me. That is cupping. Thank you, and I appreciate a good vote.
All right, members, the question before the House will be the passage of House Bill 1215. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Has everyone voted? All right, let's cast out the ballots, Mr. Clerk. 87 yeas, 1 nay, and 0 present. The bill has passed.
all right mr clerk please read
house bill 1501 house bill 1501 by representative mccullum to modify and repeal language referencing the superseded
elder choices program representative mccullum you recognize this time to present your
bill thank you mr speaker so this is uh very much a cleanup bill um very much uh dhs bill with Division of Aging and Adult Services. So last year we
combined Elders' Choices with I almost said Alternative Facts. Maybe I've just been watching the news too much or listening to the Alternative Facts about cupping for adults with physical disabilities. So it's combining the waivers, it's changing the statute to create the new name of AR Choices. And thank you for your time and I'd appreciate a good vote. Alright, members you've heard an explanation of
the bill would anyone like to speak against the bill for the bill
rest representative McCollum has signified he is closed for his bill so the question now before the house will be the passage of House bill 1501 prepare the machine mr. clerk everyone voted all right let's cast out the ballots mr. clerk with 92 yeas 0 nay and 0 present the bill has passed
mr. clerk would you please read house bill 1609 house
bill 1609 by representative tucker to increase flexibility in the law regarding frequency of payment of wages. Representative Tucker, you're
recognized to present your bill. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Mr. Speaker, this is just a clarification. In employment law, I was brought to attention by a friend of mine who is one of those ticks in our society, an attorney. She represents employers, and the way that the law reads right now
is employers are required to pay their employees semi-monthly, and that means exactly twice per month. The intent of the law was to make sure people get paid at least twice per month. Not exactly twice per month, but that's the way it reads. And so if your company pays your employees every other week, then there are two months a year where you have three pay periods, and so you're in technical violation of the law at that point. Or if you pay your employees on a weekly basis, then you're in violation of the law 12 months a year. And that was not the intent, and there are clients of this employer lawyer who is a friend of mine who are concerned.
it's not enforced but it could be enforced at any time so this just clarifies you have to pay your employees at least twice a month but if you pay them more frequently than that you will not be in violation of this law that's it seeing no questions I'd
appreciate a good vote all right members you've heard an explanation of the bill would anyone like to speak against the bill for the bill all right representative Tucker is signifying that He is closed for the bill,
so the question now before the House will be the passage of House Bill 1609. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Everyone voted. All right, let's cast the ballots, Mr. Clerk. With 90 yeas, 0 nay, and 0 present, the bill has passed. Mr. Clerk, please read House Bill 1566.
House Bill 1566 by Representative Hammer to amend the provisions of the law concerning the disposition of fetal remains.
Representative Hammer, you're recognized. Explain the bill. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. This bill is intended to bring everything in line with regards to the Arkansas Final Disposition Rice Act of 2009 as far as the disposition of fetal remains. The Hospital Association is agreeable to this. And just to get to the point, what this will do is eliminate the potential which is currently allowed to sell fetal remain parts for an abortion clinic.
And that's what the bill is about. Appreciate a good
vote. All right, members, you've heard an explanation of the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? For the bill? All right, Representative Hamer, would you like to close for your bill? He has signified he has done so. So the question now before the House is the passage of House Bill 1566. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk.
Has everyone voted? All right, let's cast it to ballots, Mr. Clerk. With 90 yeas, 0 nay, and 0 present, the bill has passed. All right, Mr. Clerk, please read House Bill 1526.
House Bill 1526 by Representative Michelle Gray to modify Act 143 of 2017 to specify that a criminal background check shall include the taking of fingerprints to authorize licensure by endorsement for optometrists and to declare an emergency.
Representative Gray, you're recognized to present your bill. Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and I'll make this much faster. We passed a bill earlier in the session, licensure by endorsement to practice optometry. It's now Act 143. The criminal justice information law unit of the FBI contacted us and let us know that we missed a little bit of language in our bill when we authorized background checks. We did not say they had to be done by fingerprint. We have to have that in statute in order for it to actually be legal. So that's all this bill does is cleans that up and puts in statute fingerprints.
I would appreciate a good vote. Thank you.
all right members you've heard an explanation of the bill would anyone like to speak against the bill for the bill all right representative gray has signified that she is closed for her bill so the question now before the house will be the passage of house bill 1526 prepare the machine Mr. Clerk voting on the bill and its emergency clause has everyone voted
everyone voted all right let's cast the ballots Mr. Clerk with 92 yeas zero nay and zero present the bill and its emergency clause have passed All right, Mr. Clerk, please read House Bill
1545. House Bill 1545 by Representative Sullivan to allow the Division of Child Care and Early Childhood Education of the Department of Human Services to independently promulgate rules concerning child care facilities.
Representative Sullivan, you're recognized to present
your bill. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. This bill puts the rulemaking authority back to the department. Finally the Child Care Commission must approve all of those. This brings the commission in line with other commissions like the Long-Term Care Commission, Health Care Commission, Emergency Medical Services, Trauma, People with Disabilities, Children's Behavioral Health Care Commission. This puts those all back at this commission back in line with the rest of them.
all right members you've heard an explanation of the bill would anyone like to speak against the bill or the bill all right representative Sullivan at this time has signified that he is closed for his mill so the question before the house will be the passage of House bill 1545 prepare the machine mr. clerk
all right has everyone voted everyone voted all right let's cast out the ballots with 84 yeas three nay and one present the bill has passed all right members we're going to pass over the next item on the agenda and we're going to pick up with House Bill 1650.
House Bill 1650 by Representative Barker to
transfer the State Board of Private Career Education to the Department of Higher Education to amend the powers and duties of the State Board of Private
emergency. Representative Barker you recognize to present your bill. Thank You Mr. Speaker. House Bill 1650 is a simple efficiency bill. It does just what it says. It's a type 2 transfer to transfer the State Board of Private Career Education over to and under the authority of the Department of Higher Ed. There have been several financial as well as operational problems that brought
this transfer about, but the Board will remain intact in an advisory capacity. There's no known opposition to this bill it hits a trifecta if you will it shrinks government it produces efficiency and it saves money so with that I would appreciate a good vote thank you all right members you've heard an
explanation of the bill would anyone like to speak against the bill for the bill representative Barker signified that she is closed for her bill so the
The question now before the House will be the passage of House Bill 1650. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Has everyone voted? You're voting on the bill and its emergency clause. Everyone voted? All right, let's cast out the ballots, Mr. Clerk. 92 yeas, zero nay, and zero present, the bill has passed.
All right, members, I think we've got enough time we can get in the first of the Senate bills. That's probably all we're going to have time for today. So at this time,
Mr. Clerk, would you please read Senate Bill 42? Senate Bill 42 by Representative Kapp concerning fitness to proceed and lack of
criminal responsibility and concerning a mental evaluation of a criminal defendant. Okay. Okay. Actually, members, I just got
And having had some discussions with leadership on this,
I think we probably won't have enough time to squeeze in the next item and get us out of here. So what we're going to do is hold the rest of the calendar for Monday, and we'll pick up with those that we passed over today on Monday. So at this time, I'm going to recognize Representative
Ladyman. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. After the announcements, reading of the bills, placing the calendars on the desk, amending members-only bills with their own amendments, members withdrawing their own bills, finalizing resolutions,
reading communications, and any remaining committee reports, I move we adjourn until 1.30 p.m. Monday. That is a proper motion,
non-debatable. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. All those opposed, say no. No. All right, the ayes have it. Motion carries. Any announcements? I'm going to start in the back with Representative
House. Joint retirement, 10 o'clock Monday morning. Representative
Collins, you're recognized. Insurance and Commerce is going to meet at five minutes after one in room 149.
Insurance and Commerce, five minutes after one in room 149. We're going to hear SB191. all right members you've
Speaker 317
2:54:21
READ THE COMMITTEE, REPORTS MR CLERK. MR. Patrick McLeary, Committee on State
Agencies, to whom was referred House Bill 1-15-81 and Senate Bill 3-40-8. Beg leave to report that we have had the same under consideration and hear with the
return the same with the recommendation they do pass, respectfully submitted. Bob Ballinger, Chair. Mr. Speaker we are committed on state agencies to whom was referred House Bill 10-10 and House Bill 15-90. Beg leave to report that we have the same under consideration and hear with return the same with the recommendation they do pass, respectfully submitted Kim Hamer, Presider. Mr. Speaker we are committed on Insurance and Commerce to whom was referred House Bill 16-04. Beg leave to report that we've had the same under consideration and herewith to turn the same with the recommendation that do pass as amended number one respectfully submitted Charlie Collins chair. Mr. Speaker we are committee on insurance and commerce to whom was referred House Bill 1377 House Bill 1527 House Bill 1585. Beg leave to report that we've had the same under consideration herewith to turn the same with the recommendation that do pass respectfully submitted Charlie Collins chair.
read the bills mr. clerk house bill 1668 without objection read the bill second time house bill 1668 judiciary house bill 1669 without objection read the bill a second time house bill 1669 public health house bill 1670 without objection read the bill a second time House Bill 1670 Transportation House Bill 1671
Without objection read the bill a second time House Bill 1671 Education House Bill 1672 Without objection read the bill a second time House Bill 1672 Education House Bill 1673 Without objection read the bill a second time House Bill 1673 Education House bill 1674. Without objection, read the bill a second time. House bill 1674. Education.
House bill 1675. Without objection, read the bill a second time. House bill 1675. State agencies. House bill 1676. Without objection, read the bill a second time. House bill 1676. City, county, local. House bill 1677. Without objection, read the bill a second time. House bill 1677. Joint budget, House Bill 1678, without objection read the bill a second time, House Bill 1678, aging children and youth, House Bill 1679, without objection read the bill a second time, House Bill 1679, joint budget, House Bill 1680, without objection read the bill a second time, House Bill 1680, rev and tax, House Bill 1681, without objection read the bill a second time, House Bill 1681, rev and tax, House Bill 1682,
without objection we build a second time house bill 1682 rev and tax house bill 1683 without objection we build a second time house bill 1683 rev and tax house bill 1684 without objection we build a second time house bill 1684 rev and tax house resolution 1033 without objection we build a second time House resolution 1033 education
Speaker 317
2:58:18
the desk will remain open as needed for the reading of the bills upon completion of the items named in the adjourn resolution the house will be adjourned until 1 30 p.m monday
Agenda
CALL TO ORDER
PRAYER AND PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
ATTENDANCE
MOTION TO AMEND
Number Sponsor Subtitle
SB328 A. Clark DPA 1 (C. Douglas) TO REQUIRE A PERSON TO APPLY FOR A K-6 TEACHING LICENSE OR A SPECIAL EDUCATION K-12 TEACHING LICENSE TO SUCCESSFULLY PASS A STAND-ALONE READING TEST AND A MULTI-SUBJECT TEST AS A CONDITION OF LICENSURE.
End of Morning Hour
CONCUR IN SENATE AMENDMENT
Number Sponsor Subtitle
HB1172 Tosh 1 CREATING A SENTENCE ENHANCEMENT FOR CERTAIN CRIMINAL OFFENSES TARGETING A CURRENT OR FORMER LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER, FIRST RESPONDER, OR HIS OR HER FAMILY; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1320 Shepherd 1 TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 5 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING CRIMINAL OFFENSES AND THE CRIMINAL LAW.
HB1319 Shepherd 1 TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 23 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING PUBLIC UTILITIES AND REGULATED INDUSTRIES.
HB1038 Davis .1 TO ALLOW THE MULTIYEAR REGISTRATION OF PERSONAL- USE MOTOR VEHICLES
HB1019 Cozart 1 TO AMEND THE MEMBERSHIP OF THE SCHOOL LEADERSHIP COORDINATING COUNCIL.
HB1521 Richmond 1 TO ALLOW COUNTIES TO BURN STORM DEBRIS BASED ON COUNTY-DECLARED DISASTER EMERGENCIES.
REGULAR BILLS
HB1589 Vaught CONCERNING THE APPLICABILITY OF CERTAIN ETHICS LAWS TO MEMBERS OF SCHOOL DISTRICT BOARDS OF DIRECTORS; AND AMENDING PORTIONS OF ARKANSAS LAW RESULTING FROM INITIATED ACT 1 OF 1988
HB1536 M. Gray TO AMEND THE MINORITY BUSINESS ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT ACT TO INCLUDE WOMEN-OWNED BUSINESSES.
HB1048 D. Meeks TO PERMIT VOLUNTARY RESPITE CARE; TO CREATE A LICENSE EXEMPTION CONCERNING VOLUNTARY RESPITE CARE; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1569 C. Douglas TO REDUCE THE STANDARD LICENSING FEE FOR CERTAIN MILITARY MEMBERS AND VETERANS.
HB1641 Wing TO INCREASE THE TOOL ALLOWANCE FOR CERTAIN EMPLOYEES OF THE ARKANSAS STATE HIGHWAY AND TRANSPORTATION DEPARTMENT WHO WORK ON HIGHWAY EQUIPMENT AND FACILITIES.
HB1642 Wing TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE APPOINTMENT OF THE CHIEF OF THE ARKANSAS HIGHWAY POLICE DIVISION OF THE ARKANSAS STATE HIGHWAY AND TRANSPORTATION DEPARTMENT.
HB1643 Wing TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE STATE AID ENGINEER OF THE ARKANSAS STATE HIGHWAY AND TRANSPORTATION DEPARTMENT.
HB1644 Tosh TO CHANGE THE FILING DEADLINE FOR FRANCHISE TAX REPORTS.
HB1552 McNair TO ALTER THE REQUIREMENTS FOR A LIFETIME TEACHING LICENSE.
HB1523 Sturch CONCERNING THE TRAINING OF MEMBERS OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS OF A PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT.
HB1250 M. Gray TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS DENTAL PRACTICE ACT; TO CREATE ADDITIONAL EXEMPTIONS TO THE PRACTICE OF DENTISTRY AND DENTAL HYGIENE; AND TO MODIFY DENTISTRY SPECIALTY LICENSES.
HB1513 Holcomb TO AMEND THE ELIGIBILITY REQUIREMENTS FOR THE ASBESTOS ABATEMENT GRANT PROGRAM.
HB1215 Love TO AMEND THE LAWS REGARDING THE PRACTICE OF MASSAGE THERAPY TO INCLUDE THE PRACTICE OF CUPPING.
HB1501 McCollum TO MODIFY AND REPEAL LANGUAGE REFERENCING THE SUPERSEDED ELDERCHOICES PROGRAM.
HB1609 Tucker TO INCREASE FLEXIBILITY IN THE LAW REGARDING FREQUENCY OF PAYMENT OF WAGES.
HB1566 Hammer TO AMEND THE PROVISIONS OF LAW CONCERNING THE DISPOSITION OF FETAL REMAINS.
HB1526 M. Gray TO MODIFY ACT 143 OF 2017 TO SPECIFY THAT A CRIMINAL BACKGROUND CHECK SHALL INCLUDE THE TAKING OF FINGERPRINTS; TO AUTHORIZE LICENSURE BY ENDORSEMENT FOR OPTOMETRISTS; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1545 Sullivan TO ALLOW THE DIVISION OF CHILD CARE AND EARLY CHILDHOOD EDUCATION OF THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES TO INDEPENDENTLY PROMULGATE RULES CONCERNING CHILD CARE FACILITIES.
HB1586 Payton TO AMEND CERTAIN PROVISIONS OF THE WORKERS' COMPENSATION LAW ENACTED BY INITIATED ACT NO. 4 OF 1948; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1650 Barker TO TRANSFER THE STATE BOARD OF PRIVATE CAREER EDUCATION TO THE DEPARTMENT OF HIGHER EDUCATION; TO AMEND THE POWERS AND DUTIES OF THE STATE BOARD OF PRIVATE CAREER EDUCATION; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
REGULAR SENATE BILLS
Number Sponsor Subtitle
SB42 J. Hutchinson (Capp) CONCERNING FITNESS TO PROCEED AND LACK OF CRIMINAL RESPONSIBILITY; AND CONCERNING A MENTAL EVALUATION OF A CRIMINAL DEFENDANT.
SB284 Hester (Eubanks) TO ESTABLISH A RETAIL OFF-PREMISES PERMIT FOR THE SALE OF WINE AT GROCERY STORES AND TO PROVIDE ADDITIONAL GRANT FUNDS TO SUPPORT ARKANSAS WINE PRODUCTION AND WINE TOURISM IN THE STATE.
SB340 J. Hutchinson (Pilkington) TO CREATE THE WRONGFUL BIRTH CIVIL LIABILITY PROTECTION ACT.
SB277 Hickey (McNair) CONCERNING THE PROCEDURES FOR OBTAINING TITLE TO A MOBILE HOME OR A MANUFACTURED HOME.
SB148 G. Stubblefield(C. Fite) TO CREATE BORN-ALIVE INFANT PROTECTION.
SB159 J. English (Drown) CONCERNING THE DEPARTMENT OF VETERANS AFFAIRS; AND TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING CERTAIN EMPLOYMENT REQUIREMENTS AND QUALIFICATIONS OF THE DIRECTOR AND OF VETERANS' CLAIMS SPECIALISTS.
SB174 J. English (Drown) TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE DUTIES OF THE ARKANSAS VETERANS' COMMISSION; AND TO INCREASE THE AMOUNT OF AUTHORIZED ANNUAL STIPENDS AND EXPENSE REIMBURSEMENT FOR MEMBERS OF THE COMMISSION IN CERTAIN CIRCUMSTANCES.
BUDGET CALENDAR
Bills to Be Amended
HB1214 AN ACT FOR THE DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY CORRECTION APPROPRIATION FOR THE 2017-2018 FISCAL YEAR. 3
HB1243 AN ACT FOR THE DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE AND ADMINISTRATION - REVENUE SERVICES DIVISION APPROPRIATION FOR THE 2017-2018 FISCAL YEAR. 1
HB1498 AN ACT FOR THE ARKANSAS AGRICULTURE DEPARTMENT - CAPITAL PROJECTS GENERAL IMPROVEMENT APPROPRIATION. 1
HB1614 AN ACT FOR THE INSTITUTIONS OF HIGHER EDUCATION REAPPROPRIATION. 1
Bills to be considered which have been introduced by Senators
SB289 TO REVISE THE COMPENSATION PLAN UNDER THE UNIFORM CLASSIFICATION AND COMPENSATION ACT AND TO AMEND VARIOUS LAWS CONCERNING EMPLOYEES OF INSTITUTIONS OF HIGHER EDUCATION AND STATE EMPLOYEE SALARIES AND BENEFITS.
Bills to be considered which have been introduced by Joint Budget Committee
HB1493 AN ACT FOR THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES - DIVISION OF CHILDREN AND FAMILY SERVICES - FOSTER CARE PROGRAM SUPPLEMENTAL APPROPRIATION.
HB1596 AN ACT FOR THE ARKANSAS COMMISSION ON LAW ENFORCEMENT STANDARDS AND TRAINING REAPPROPRIATION.
HB1598 AN ACT FOR THE ARKANSAS NATURAL RESOURCES COMMISSION REAPPROPRIATION.
HB1599 AN ACT FOR THE STATE MILITARY DEPARTMENT REAPPROPRIATION.
HB1600 AN ACT FOR THE DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY CORRECTION REAPPROPRIATION.
HB1601 AN ACT FOR THE DEPARTMENT OF ARKANSAS STATE POLICE REAPPROPRIATION.
HB1603 AN ACT FOR THE STATE BOARD OF PHARMACY APPROPRIATION FOR THE 2017-2018 FISCAL YEAR.
HB1605 AN ACT FOR THE CAPITOL ZONING DISTRICT COMMISSION REAPPROPRIATION.
HB1606 AN ACT FOR THE ARKANSAS HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES REAPPROPRIATION.
HB1615 AN ACT FOR THE DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE AND ADMINISTRATION - BUILDING AUTHORITY DIVISION REAPPROPRIATION.
HB1616 AN ACT FOR THE RIVERSIDE VOCATIONAL TECHNICAL SCHOOL REAPPROPRIATION.
HB1617 AN ACT FOR THE NORTHWEST TECHNICAL INSTITUTE REAPPROPRIATION.
HB1618 AN ACT FOR THE CROWLEY'S RIDGE TECHNICAL INSTITUTE REAPPROPRIATION.
HB1619 AN ACT FOR THE HEALTH SERVICES PERMIT AGENCY - OPERATING EXPENSES SUPPLEMENTAL APPROPRIATION.
HB1620 AN ACT FOR THE DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE AND ADMINISTRATION - DISBURSING OFFICER - PERSONAL SERVICES - PAYPLAN EXTRA HELP SUPPLEMENTAL APPROPRIATION.
HB1638 AN ACT FOR THE DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION- ARKANSAS SCHOOL DEAF SUPPLEMENTAL APPROPRIATION.
HB1639 AN ACT FOR THE DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION- ARKANSAS SCHOOL FOR THE BLIND SUPPLEMENTAL APPROPRIATION.
SB56 AN ACT FOR THE OFFICE OF LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR APPROPRIATION FOR THE 2017-2018 FISCAL YEAR.
ANNOUNCEMENTS
SJR8: Amendment 1
SJR8: Amendment 2
Motion to Reconsider SB133
SB133
POINT OF PERSONAL PRIVILEGE
READING OF THE BILLS
ADJOURNMENT
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Speaker 2
Speaker 8
Representative Jeremy Gillam
Unverified
Speaker 18
Representative Jack Fortner
Unverified
Chair
Unverified
Representative Lane Jean
Unverified
Representative John W. Walker
Unverified
Speaker 71
Representative Karilyn Brown
Unverified
Speaker 78
Speaker 97
Representative Douglas House
Unverified
Representative Andy Davis
Unverified
Representative Warwick Sabin
Unverified
Speaker 129
Representative Bob Ballinger
Unverified
Speaker 140
Speaker 156
Speaker 157
Representative Andy Mayberry
Unverified
Representative David Whitaker
Unverified
Representative Vivian Flowers
Unverified
Representative John Payton
Unverified
Speaker 148
Representative Jimmy Gazaway
Unverified
Representative Kim Hammer
Unverified
Representative Michelle Gray
Unverified
Representative Laurie Rushing
Unverified
Representative Jim Dotson
Unverified
Speaker 234
Speaker 19
Representative Charlie Collins
Unverified
Representative Josh Miller
Unverified
Representative Joe Farrer
Unverified
Speaker 256
Representative Marcus E. Richmond
Unverified
Speaker 164
Representative Charles Blake
Unverified
Speaker 20
Speaker 22
Speaker 143
Representative DeAnn Vaught
Unverified
Representative Stephen Meeks
Unverified
Representative Charlene Fite
Unverified
Representative Carlton Wing
Unverified
Representative Dwight Tosh
Unverified
Representative Ron McNair
Unverified
Representative Nelda Speaks
Unverified
Representative Mike Holcomb
Unverified
Frederick Love
Unverified
Speaker 298
Representative Austin McCollum
Unverified
Representative Clarke Tucker
Unverified
Representative Dan Sullivan
Unverified
Speaker 307
Speaker 310
Representative Jack Ladyman
Unverified
Speaker 317