Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

Education Committee

March 9, 2017 ·Committee Room 138 ·2:05:08
Video Transcript

Summary

Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 13, 2026

HB2095 G. Hodges TO ESTABLISH VOTE CENTERS ON THE CAMPUSES OF STATE-SUPPORTED POSTSECONDARY AND HIGHER EDUCATION INSTITUTIONS; AND TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING … -43:20

The chair, Rep. Bruce Cozart, called the meeting to order, confirmed a quorum, and announced that the committee would hear Senate Bill 427 - a cleanup bill for the treasurer’s office. [0:00]

Grant Wallace, chief deputy treasurer, presented SB 427, explaining that it codifies the treasurer’s day-to-day management authority over the 529 college-savings program and permits committee members to expend appropriated funds for program promotion activities. [0:39] [0:52] [1:14]

Rep. Stephen Meeks asked whether there is accountability for those expenditures, and Wallace responded that the board would oversee and monitor the use of any appropriated funds. [1:49] [2:12] [2:20]

Warrem 2:33

The committee unanimously approved House Resolution 1040, recognizing the Lakeside Legacy Program partnership between Lakeside High School, Hot Springs and National Park College, after a motion to pass was made and a voice vote recorded as “aye” with no opposition. [2:51] [3:10] [3:21] [3:51] [4:22] [4:27]

Representative Rick Beck then introduced House Bill 1222, the Arkansas Parental Empowerment for Education Choice Act of 2017, describing an education-savings-account system funded by private contributions that qualify for a 65 % state tax credit, capped at $6.5 million in the second year and limited to a 1 % annual award per district. [4:53] [5:27] [5:57] [6:30] [7:04] [7:37] [9:20]

Committee members questioned the bill’s budget impact, student-transfer limits, tax-credit mechanics, eligibility age (up to 22), priority enrollment (low-income, military-dependent, siblings, then lottery), and how funds would be disbursed directly by nonprofits or reimbursed rather than paid to parents, noted the governor’s neutral stance, and discussed why the ESA model was chosen over expanding the existing Succeed Scholarship, citing examples from other states and emphasizing service to poverty-affected students. [8:15] [8:47] [8:58] [9:01] [9:20] [9:53] [10:49] [11:00] [11:33] [11:58] [12:53] [13:15] [13:47] [14:40] [14:50] [15:28] [15:35] [15:38] [15:45] [16:01] [22:08] [22:13] [22:48] [23:21] [23:37] [24:22] [24:51] [24:55] [25:23] [25:38] [26:44] [27:23] [27:57] [28:28] [30:44] [31:04] [31:10] [31:17] [31:49] [32:04] [32:08] [32:22] [32:47]

Testimony from a range of stakeholders-including supporters such as Virginia Walden Ford and Dr. Charles E. Williams and opponents such as Superintendent Bobby Hart and Representative Stephen Meeks-debated accountability mechanisms, potential segregation, rural school consolidation, and cited the fiscal impact statement showing a $6.5 million reduction in general revenues in FY 19 rising to $7.1 million in FY 20. [55:47] [56:17] [56:31] [56:36] [56:45] [56:49] [1:02:24] [1:02:56] [1:03:31] [1:04:06] [1:04:34] [1:04:37] [1:04:41] [1:05:08] [1:05:39] [1:05:45] [1:06:05] [1:06:10] [1:06:42] [1:07:08] [1:07:23] [1:07:45] [1:08:00] [1:08:06] [1:08:32] [1:09:02] [1:09:41] [1:14:30] [1:15:09] [1:15:40] [1:16:11] [1:16:29] [1:16:32] [1:16:38] [1:16:42] [1:17:15] [1:17:19] [1:17:46] [1:17:57] [1:18:20] [1:18:37] [1:18:45] [1:18:58] [1:19:35] [1:20:04] [1:20:08] [1:20:39] [1:21:11] [1:21:50] [1:22:27] [1:23:01] [1:23:18] [1:23:25] [1:23:36] [1:23:50] [1:23:56] [1:24:05] [1:24:10] [1:24:30] [1:24:41] [1:24:55] [1:25:13] [1:25:44] [1:26:19]

The committee then announced the end of the testimony period, indicating that no motions or votes were taken at this stage and moving the bill forward for further consideration. [58:49] [58:59] [59:30] [1:00:02]

After a motion by Representative Mark Lowery to pass the legislation, the committee voted, recording ayes from several members and nos from others, with at least twelve affirmative votes, resulting in the passage of HP 1222. [2:02:54] [2:02:59] [2:03:21] [2:03:31] [2:04:01] [2:04:31] [2:04:57]

Bills discussed (64)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1222 · 2 mentions in transcript
Matched: “…ive Dotson, you are recognized to take the table to present House Bill 1222.”
Pre-2017 bill
HR1040 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HR1040 Warren CELEBRATING THE LAKESIDE LEGACY PROGRAM.”
Pre-2017 bill
SB427 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB427 Hickey TO AMEND THE POWERS AND AUTHORITY OF THE SECTION 529…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1017 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1017 Cozart TO ALLOW THE TEACHER FAIR DISMISSAL ACT OF 1983 TO B…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1020 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1020 Love TO CREATE THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY PROMISE LOTTERY SCHOLAR…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1027 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1027 Eubanks TO PROHIBIT A SCHOOL DISTRICT FROM USING PUBLIC FUN…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1029 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1029 Lowery TO EXCLUDE PRINCIPALS, ASSISTANT PRINCIPALS, AND CEN…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1044 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1044 F. Allen TO ALLOW A STUDENT TO CHOOSE WHICH GRADE IN WHICH…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1408 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1408 C.Douglas CONCERNING WHO MAY SERVE AS A PROCTOR OF A TEST O…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1456 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1456 C. Douglas TO ALLOW A SCHOOL DISTRICT TO WAIVE PHYSICAL EDU…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1457 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1457 C. Douglas TO ALLOW A PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT AND AN OPEN-EN…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1458 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1458 C. Douglas TO REQUIRE A STUDENT TO PARTICIPATE IN VISUAL AR…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1459 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1459 C. Douglas TO PROVIDE FLEXIBILITY IN THE AWARDING OF COURSE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1510 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1510 Gonzales TO CREATE THE DEMOGRAPHIC PREFERENCE DISCLOSURE AC…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1517 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1517 A. Mayberry CONCERNING SCHOOL NURSING AND TO MODIFY THE REQ…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1575 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1575 Lowery TO LIMIT THE AMOUNT OF FUND BALANCES A SCHOOL DISTRI…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1576 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1576 C. Douglas TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ACADEMIC FACILITIES P…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1579 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1579 Vaught TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1583 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1583 Dotson TO CREATE RECALL ELECTIONS FOR MEMBERS OF SCHOOL DIS…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1607 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1607 Della Rosa TO LIMIT THE USE OF AN ENGLISH LANGUAGE LEARNER'…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1608 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1608 Della Rosa CONCERNING THE ACCOUNTABILITY SYSTEM DEVELOPED B…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1610 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1610 Tucker TO PROVIDE ARKANSAS BETTER CHANCE PROGRAMS LOCATED W…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1611 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1611 Tucker CONCERNING THE BASIC LANGUAGE OF INSTRUCTION IN PUBL…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1621 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1621 Lowery TO CHANGE THE DATE OF THE ANNUAL SCHOOL ELECTION.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1646 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1646 Cozart TO AMEND VARIOUS PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CON…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1648 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1648 C. Douglas TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERN…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1666 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1666 Sabin TO REQUIRE INSTITUTIONS OF HIGHER EDUCATION TO PROVID…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1671 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1671 Tucker TO GIVE CHARTER SCHOOLS AUTHORITY TO WEIGHT ADMISSIO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1672 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1672 Tucker CONCERNING ADMISSIONS POLICIES OF CHARTER SCHOOLS; A…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1673 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1673 Tucker CONCERNING APPLICATIONS FOR OR AMENDMENTS OF PUBLIC…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1674 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1674 Tucker TO CREATE A COMMUNITY PUBLIC EDUCATION BOARD.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1689 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1689 Cozart TO AMEND PROVISIONS CONCERNING PUBLIC SCHOOL FUNDING…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1701 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1701 Love TO ESTABLISH A PILOT PROGRAM TO MAKE GRANTS TO HISTORI…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1710 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1710 S. Meeks TO REVISE THE CIVICS AND WORLD HISTORY REQUIREMENT…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1738 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1738 C. Douglas CONCERNING ETHICS OF MEMBERS OF A BOARD OF DIREC…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1740 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1740 Lowery CONCERNING THE ENROLLMENT OR RE-ENROLLMENT OF A HOME…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1791 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1791 Tucker TO ESTABLISH A FOOD PANTRY MATCHING GRANT PROGRAM TO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1802 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1802 Lundstrum TO ALLOW CONTRIBUTIONS BY AN ARKANSAS TAXPAYER TO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1805 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1805 Sturch TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING POSTSECONDARY…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1820 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1820 Dotson CONCERNING SCHOOL DISTRICT WAIVERS; TO REQUIRE THE S…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1831 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1831 Leding TO ALLOW AN OPEN-ENROLLMENT PUBLIC CHARTER SCHOOL TO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1856 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1856 F. Allen TO ESTABLISH THE ARKANSAS EARLY LITERACY ASSESSMEN…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1874 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1874 Lundstrum TO ALLOW CONTRIBUTIONS BY A TAXPAYER TO A TAX-DEF…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1897 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1897 Baltz TO REQUIRE STATE-SUPPORTED INSTITUTIONS OF HIGHER EDU…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1898 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1898 Baltz TO REQUIRE STATE-SUPPORTED INSTITUTIONS OF HIGHER EDU…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1905 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1905 C. Douglas CONCERNING DELAY OF OPENING OR EARLY RELEASE OF…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1907 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1907 C.Douglas TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNI…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1917 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1917 Walker TO LIMIT THE SALARY AMOUNT OF AN ADMINISTRATOR IN A…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1924 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1924 C. Douglas TO ADD THE CLASSIC LEARNING TEST AS AN ALLOWABLE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1925 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1925 C. Douglas TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERN…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1929 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1929 Cozart TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1934 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1934 Lowery TO ENSURE THAT PERSONALLY IDENTIFIABLE INFORMATION N…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1936 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1936 Lowery TO REVISE THE ACADEMIC FACILITIES WEALTH INDEX.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1995 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1995 Della Rosa TO AMEND THE OFFICIAL HOLIDAYS; TO REFINE THE TE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2095 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2095 G. Hodges TO ESTABLISH VOTE CENTERS ON THE CAMPUSES OF STAT…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2117 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2117 Sorvillo TO REQUIRE CAMERAS IN CERTAIN CONTAINED SPECIAL ED…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2207 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2207 Boyd TO ABOLISH THE ALLOCATION OF ENROLLMENT POSITIONS AT T…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2243 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2243 Davis TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING S…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB178 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB178 Files TO DELAY THE INCLUSION OF A SCORE ON THE WRITING PORT…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB26 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB26 A. Clark TO INCREASE TEACHERS IN HIGH NEEDS SUBJECT AREAS;…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB27 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB27 A. Clark TO INCREASE THE NUMBER OF TEACHERS IN A CRITICAL T…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB329 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB329 A. Clark TO RAISE THE PRICE THRESHOLD FOR THE PURCHASE OF C…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB337 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB337 Hester TO REPEAL THE ACADEMIC FACILITIES EXTRAORDINARY CIRC…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB519 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB519 D. Wallace TO AMEND TITLE 6 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING…”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 13, 2026
okay everyone I need everybody to find a seat that can the audience is probably going to be standing there's not much else we can do with that like call this meeting to order chair sees a quorum madam chair you have anything you'd like to say today you ready for the marathon it's been marathon week here at house education at this time we're going to hear senate bill 427 you are recognized to present
▶ Play
that thank you mr chair um i will turn it directly over to grant wallace with the treasurer's office this is a cleanup bill for the treasurer's office dealing with the 529 plan so
▶ Play
Speaker 15 0:52
i'll just let him explain it to you real quick grant wallace chief deputy treasurer for treasurer milligan again as Representative Delores to explain, this is a technical cleanup bill that just clarifies the ability for our office to manage the 529 college savings program day in and day out. Obviously, the board will still exist to oversee, but this just gives us the ability to do those day-to-day management duties that come up. The office has done that for nearly a decade now, but it was not in statute, and we just want to make sure that it clearly is in statute giving us accessibility. The second thing the bill does also allows any member of the committee to expend their own appropriated funds to benefit the program. So it does open up for the Department of Higher Ed or the Teacher Retirement System to participate as well and do promotion activities and things like that to benefit the 529 program.
▶ Play
Any questions, Committee? Representative Meeks, you're recognized. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chairman. The only question that I have is the second part you talked about where a member of the committee may expend funds appropriated for a member of the committee for the following benefits. Is there any, I'll say, accountability or oversight of how those monies are being expended to make sure the committee member is expending them on appropriate expenses, or do they kind of get a blank check, or can you talk to
▶ Play
Speaker 15 2:12
us a little bit about that? The board would have to oversee and kind of be able to manage and kind of monitor that work because it would, again, have to be in conjunction with where the program is going to go and what the board is wanting to take the program. So, yes, sir. Okay, so the board
▶ Play
would monitor its own numbers. Okay, all right, thank
▶ Play
you. Any other questions, committee? Anyone in the audience like to speak against the bill or the bill? Would you like to close for your bill? closed. What's the will of the committee? Got a motion to do pass. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no. Congratulations, you passed your bill. Representative Warren, you're welcome to take the end of the table to present House Resolution 1040. Isn't that a tax bill? It's not even tax season. We'll go here 1040. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'll make this
▶ Play
short and sweet I am here with probably the easiest pull that mic just a little closer to you okay is that better that's better I am here with probably the easiest item of business that you will have today I am here simply to get you to approve a resolution that will recognize lakeside public schools and hot springs and national park college who have worked together on a program at Lakeside that's referred to as a legacy program and I'll just read you a couple of sentences here. Whereas Lakeside High School in Hot Springs, Arkansas is officially designated as a satellite campus for National Park College by the Arkansas Higher Education Coordination Board and the Higher Learning Commission. Through the Lakeside Legacy Program students at the high school will have the chance to earn up to 66 hours of of college credit and associate degree by the time they graduate high school. I think we're the second high school in the state to do this, and it is a great opportunity for the students there. And also I want to say what a great job our two-year college and the schools in our area do working together. So we just want to recognize them for that. So I would appreciate a good vote. Any questions
▶ Play
from the committee? I don't think we even have to go to the audience on that. We have a motion. Have a motion to pass. All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? Congratulations. You passed your resolution. Thank you. At this time, what everybody's been waiting for, Representative Dotson, you are recognized to take the table to present House Bill 1222.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee. Today, I'm pleased to bring before you House Bill 1222, the Arkansas Parental Empowerment for Education Choice Act of 2017, the bill you've all been waiting for. I realize this is a complex and lengthy bill, but the purpose of this bill is really quite simple. So, I'd like to sum it up as briefly as possible and then take questions on specifics as the committee wants to answer them or ask them the purpose of this bill is to create an opportunity for students to have access to educational services that specifically meet that individual students unique needs this will be done through an ESA or education savings account model that enables parents to pay for educational services for their student with funding made available available to them in the ESA for things like tuition, textbooks, tutoring services, assessments, fees, contracted services with the public school district, transportation, and other specialized services such as speech-language pathology, occupational therapy, physical therapy, etc. The ESAs will be administered by a nonprofit organization set up in the state of Arkansas for this purpose. The eligible nonprofit organizations will fund these accounts through private contributions eligible for state income tax credits in the second year of the program. One hundred percent of the tax credits eligible contributions must go to fund ESAs directly. The nonprofit organization will be responsible for their own administrative expenses with these funds that are not eligible for a tax credit. Tax credits will be available at rate of 65% of the contributed amount, ensuring that for every dollar of tax credit the state allows at least $1.53 in contributions is going directly to fund a student's educational needs. Depending on the first year's non-tax credit eligible contributions and the student utilization of those funds, the Department of Finance Administration will be authorized to make up to a maximum of $6.5 million in tax credits available in the second year of the program. The amount of tax credits will be capped at a maximum of 10 percent. The growth on the max will, they can grow by up to 10 percent each year. The nonprofit organization will make awards of ESAs based on available funding with priority going to low income free and reduced lunch eligible applicants and military dependents before anyone else. This is a complete program that I've worked extensively with the various departments that will be affected by this to ensure that it is as easy as possible to set up and to oversee. This program is designed for students with their individual and unique needs in mind. As I promised before, I'll be brief and stop right there and take any questions any questions committee
▶ Play
reps engage you're recognized thank you mr.
▶ Play
chair I'm sure like everybody else I've had a plethora of emails does this bill in any way take money out of state budget that goes to run our public schools no if a follow-up if I may you recognize currently we have a system in place where kids can be moved can if parents want their children to to go to another school they can currently do so but that is limited so there cannot be a mass exodus from one district to another correct that wasn't a
▶ Play
question here's my question perhaps the Walker he's been
▶ Play
taking notes from I have I learned from represented Walker that was the statement that was a preface as he would say the question is this does this bill in any way limit the amount of students that could possibly transfer out of a district in a particular year yes
▶ Play
there's a hard cap on an annual basis of 1% of students in an individual district that the nonprofit organization can award an ESA account to so for instance if there's a thousand students in a district 1% would be 10 students the nonprofit organization can award no more than 10 ESA's to that specific school district 10 out of a thousand 10 out of a thousand thank you that's all I represent Walker you recognize your question I was hoping if there were
▶ Play
other questions they'd go first because I know you'll limit me so if there are some other questions I'd prefer that they go we are going to limit the two questions
▶ Play
each pardon you are going to limit the two questions each because we have a lot of testimony in the audience you recognize go well hmm I'm not saying you can't get back in a queue if we have somebody else but right now you get to then
▶ Play
I'll get questions of the other people who speak. Thank you. Mr. Dotson, is this a voucher bill? No. It's an education savings account
▶ Play
bill. What's the difference between a voucher bill and an educational savings account bill? Well, a voucher bill is tuition and fees to a particular school as that particular school accepts that voucher. This is funding that goes into an education savings account for a parent to be able to direct the funds for the educational needs of their student, which is not limited to simply tuition and fees. It actually has the ability for the parent to have flexibility in how they use those funds for their students' education. And as I mentioned in my opening remarks, they can use that not only for tuition and fees, but also for assessments, contracted services with the public school district, tutoring services. If a child needs specialized training in math or science or something like that, they can use the funds in these accounts. for those types of educational expenses so it's far more flexible for the parents to be able to use and tailor-made the educational needs for their specific student.
▶ Play
Are there any other questions? Representative Eubanks, you're recognized.
▶ Play
Thank you Mr. Chair. Representative Dobson, does this only applied to k2 k-12 correct follow-up uh i noticed on page 16 and maybe 17 uh if i can get there real quick I thought it online 20 I thought there was an age yeah on page 16 I'm seeing eligible student reaches age 22 that a savings account for expenses under that are eligible until a student reaches age 22 but okay maybe maybe
▶ Play
I can be a little bit more specific in the answer this is a k-12 student is the only ones eligible to set up or have funds deposited into an account the funds that are available in that count for eligible expenses if a parent doesn't use all those funds in the current school year they can roll up to 50% of of those funds over into the next school year and apply those funds for other educational services beyond graduation from high school, including college tuition, technical services, and things of that nature through age 22, but no funds will be actually deposited, no new funds will actually be deposited into the account for that student's use beyond high school so it's k-12 as far as the depositing of funds in the account but the usage of those funds are for the educational needs of that particular student for as long as they need them up until age 22 i think maybe that does that answer what your question was yes thank
▶ Play
you representative deffenbaugh you recognize for a question
▶ Play
thank you mr chair uh okay representative Dawson, you might just remind us again, or I probably missed this, but the actual handling of the money, you know, when somebody, you say a parent or student needs, you know, something in particular, how does that, how do they get that? I mean, does the store bill the account? Does the account give the money to the parent? So I'm just not clear on that.
▶ Play
Okay, so the expenses will be paid directly from the nonprofit organization to whatever that educational expense happens to be. So if it's tuition, the nonprofit organization will have some flexibility in how they set up their administrative processes on whether or not they're going to pay directly through an invoice possibly on a monthly basis for tuition or something along those lines, or if they are going to set up a process for receipted reimbursement for eligible expenses that the parent might pay out of pocket and they reimburse them. The only things that the parent can actually receive a direct payment to them is for transportation services that they can claim up to 10% of the funds in a given year in that fund for mileage reimbursement to transport their student back and forth to
▶ Play
Speaker 79 15:35
school. follow up yeah so other than the the
▶ Play
exceptions you just quoted the the really the paranoid and or the student is not going to handle the money directly
▶ Play
correct they don't ever get cash in hand and in fact there's a specific prohibition prohibit prohibition in the bill uh that if they go to get a refund for a service or something like that that the refund must go to the eligible non-profit for that student's account not in cash reimbursement or anything to the parent or the student. Okay thank you.
▶ Play
Speaker 83 16:08
Round two, Representative Walker. I've
▶ Play
been trying to figure this out and I figured that by not really going into it into detail you didn't want us to know too much about it so therefore I'd like to suggest that, and you tell me if this is correct, let's assume Corporation A with a purported beneficent purpose earns a million dollars and that corporation or individual is entitled to take $100,000 as a tax deduction that reduces the person's taxable income. I used a million-dollar example of that, that reduces the person's taxable income or the corporation's taxable income to $900,000. And then if they give away, that $100,000 will then give them the additional tax credit of 65% of some figure. So that for that figure of 10%, a person gets almost $200,000 to $250,000, on my hypothetical, in terms of a tax deduction. So doesn't this operate basically to give those people who have wealthy money, a great wealth, an opportunity to just take more wealth at no expense to anybody? because they've given the $10,000 to begin with, the $100,000 in my hypothetical. That's what they're giving to this so-called savings account. And now you're going to not only let them take the normal tax deduction, and then they'll have the adjusted federal tax deduction as well, and then you're going to give them money for paying their normal taxes. They get money for their normal taxes that they're going to pay. Now, how much is the justification for that, and how do we benefit as a state or a nation from that?
▶ Play
Okay. To answer your question, let me go back up to your statement. Your premise is wrong as far as how the tax credits will actually operate. You have tax deductions and you have tax credits. The reason for my brevity in my opening statement is to allow enough people to come and speak for or against it so you guys can have a lot of opportunity to hear testimony. However, to get in the weeds of tax policy and how this works, taking your particular example of a million-dollar income and $100,000 worth of eligible taxes that that corporation or individual would owe, they would be eligible under this bill for up to 50 percent of their state tax liability in your scenario that would be about fifty thousand dollars worth of funds to to receive a tax credit on in order to receive the tax credit on that fifty thousand dollar contribution they would have to contribute about $76,000 to the program itself. Somewhere in that, my mouth may be slightly off, but around $76,000 of that $50,000 contribution would have to go into the nonprofit organization's account for the purpose of educating students. 100% of that contribution has to be spent on education funds. their tax benefit for that $50,000 or that $76,000 contribution is just like any other contribution federally it's it's a tax deductible contribution however at the state level they don't have any tax deductibility on that $76,000 contribution they only have the available tax credit of $50,000 on that portion if I may
▶ Play
Mr. Chair you recognize so in that example they get even more by way of deductions because after they make the contribution for which they're able to take from both their federal and state taxes, that means that they not only get the 10% from the state, they get 6%, I mean from the feds, they get 6% from the state. And then if they make a contribution, and then they're able to get another tax amount by paying in this $76,000 that you mentioned, and then they get a deduction on that. Doesn't it look like, I figure if I did my math, I'd come up with the right answer. It looks like corporations are for $76,000 extra, being able to get $350,000 worth of benefits. Now, tell me, have you all run the numbers on this, and is there a document that we could see that would demonstrate the tax benefit to the donor and the tax benefit to the state so we can make a comparative assessment of both? I'd like to use your example. My question, no, is there a document? That's all I want to know. Yes, there is. Can I see it now? You should
▶ Play
have something on your desk on that. I have, but I don't see that. I don't see that. There's one next sheet over there. You just, not that
▶ Play
one. The other one under your hat. That should have some numbers on it for you. This doesn't address it. This doesn't address the benefit to the individual. This doesn't address the benefit
▶ Play
to, let's just say, WMC. Okay, let me address your question here, and I will use your example. So let's say that a corporation has $100,000 worth of tax liability, as you suggested, and they made a contribution large enough to max out the amount of tax credits that they could potentially get in the state income tax credits, which in your example that would be in order to get $50,000 worth of tax credit, they would have to make a contribution of $76,923. That corporation is likely in a 35% federal marginal tax rate. 35% of that contribution would be taxed. They would get a tax-deductible reduction in their overall federal income of $76,923. 35% of that amount is $26,923. dollars so in essence they get the exact same amount back on their federal combined with the state tax credit as their contribution so it's a it's a free contribution to the corporation or the individual they can contribute if they're so desire to to fund educational services but it's a dollar 53 for every or 76,923 dollars actually in that instance worth of education savings account funds available to parents and students in the state. Show me where that's reflected on this piece of paper. Representative Walker, I think the big
▶ Play
one may have that in it. I just
▶ Play
got to note that that may have it, some numbers in the big ten page. I can't ask questions unless
▶ Play
I have the data. Why don't you look at that and let me go to
▶ Play
the next one. I'll come back to you. That's fine. Representative Sullivan, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
I just want to clarify on this voucher question. The voucher is, well, I have the definition pulled up here. The voucher is a government-funded program used for private schools funded by the government, whereas this program in the ESA is funded through private funds. Did I hear you correctly? That's correct. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Hodges, you're recognized.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Dodson, on page 9, the bill spells out the prioritization for students. And if I'm reading it correctly, it looks like the first year you would start with the fourth. the fourth item where it's children who qualify for free and reduced lunch would be given priority, and then in following years, their siblings would be the next in priority as well as anyone who was waitlisted. Is that correct? And
▶ Play
then that would follow by children of the armed forces? Correct. So in that prioritization schedule on page 9 that you're looking at, in the first year of the program, You're actually starting with item number four, like you said, skipping item number five and going to item six. Wait a second. Sorry. Item number, item four, five, skipping six, and then going to
▶ Play
seven. Okay. Quick follow-up. At first year. Okay. And who will be creating the system for this prioritization, and will the Department of Education or DF&A get to approve whatever model they come up with?
▶ Play
On application, the nonprofit organization has to submit all of their methodology and how they're going to operate and administer that before DF&A actually gets to approve them for an eligible nonprofit organization in the state. DF&A will be limited in the amount of non-profit organizations they can approve for applications to five. So there cannot be more than five non-profit organizations producing an excessive administrative burden on DF&A to track and manage more than five organizations in the state.
▶ Play
Rep. De La Rosa, you recognize for a question? Thank you, Mr. Chair. I actually have a tremendous number of questions on this, but I will limit it to the one that I don't think anybody else is going to ask or that's not going to be addressed from the audience. So my question is, why do it this way? I mean, this seems like we're putting in a whole middleman that's going to have administrative costs and is convoluting the system. We're going to have more reporting. DF&A is going to have more to mess with. You've got tax credits, this whole complex system. Why don't we just expand the Succeed Scholarship?
▶ Play
Well, that would be a completely separate program. The reason for doing it in this particular manner is I studied various programs around the country. There have been five states, I believe, that have currently adopted. There are several that are in consideration, so I'm not sure exactly where they're at in their process this session. There may be some that have already approved it. The education savings account model. So the education savings account model as a delivery system is something that was very attractive as far as how parents can use the funds for their students' needs. However, in all those states, there are state-administered programs that the state deposited money, appropriates money on an annual basis, and it can be a fight back and forth. And you do have direct funding of education to private schools from state coffers, just like any other program that's out there. Then there's a second model that's out there that are tax credit scholarships. Tax credit scholarships have been very successful, but those are voucher programs, scholarship to a specific school as far as a delivery model. This merges both of those together. Both have been challenged in court, and the tax credit model has held up constitutionality all the way, I believe, through the Supreme Court, where the education savings account model, they continue to have challenges as far as delivery when there's state tax contributions directly into private schools. So this is a blending of the two to ensure that it's a functional program. It's a little bit more cumbersome and complex to start, but as far as the administration overall, there are plenty of examples across the nation where nonprofit organizations administer these types of programs, have used a basis of those languages from various states to come up with the language in this bill, with certain unique Arkansas tweaks. I've worked extensively with the Department of Finance Administration to make sure that this is a streamlined and as cumbersome less administrative process as possible. So as far as the tax credits, they worked extremely well together with me to ensure the language in this bill is functional and complete and ready to go. Follow-up, Mr.
▶ Play
Chair? We recognize. i still don't understand um so the succeed scholarship we were taking money and we're giving it to students whose parents want to send them to a private school because public schools aren't meeting their needs now right now it's because of ieps we were now opening that up to foster kids by what we just passed earlier so if we're wanting to give money to parents to send their kids to private schools which is what this is trying to do but through a voucher system why don't we just use the money that that this is going to cost and cut out the middleman cut out all this other mess because we've already got a system in place already and it's accountable to us and everything i don't understand why we wouldn't just expand that another 100 slots or 200 slots or whatever it is on a first come first serve basis for low income students i mean to me that seems like it would accomplish the same goal as to what the goal of this is but without all the separate plan and all that so that's what i'm saying that's why i think i'm asking the question nobody else is asking everybody's asking the details about this i'm asking why are we doing this versus succeed scholarship expansion
▶ Play
like i said as i've studied various models all across the country and this is the plan that i came up with i will support that as well i would love to see that happen um i didn't run that bill um this is the bill i've got in front of you so sometimes we're limited to what we have in front of us and and i've spent the better part of six months working on this one to get it to the point today to where you can have the opportunity to
▶ Play
vote on it well i apologize for not asking that question yesterday or any of the numerous times that you've asked me before but i just thought of that actually this morning and i wanted to make sure the question is so i'm not trying to thank you i'm not trying to kill you i know i'm known for doing that but i'm not trying to do that i just genuinely just thought
▶ Play
of it this morning and why are we doing this so so i apologize yeah another bill like
▶ Play
this might kill him representative lower you recognize thank you mr. chair representative dodson i know you you answered this question a while ago uh from questioning of by representative hodges but i just really wanted to emphasize or have you emphasize for us that the priority ranking of students that are eligible obviously the first three don't apply in the first year because they refer to students who uh receive the scholarship or the excuse me the savings account benefit in the previous year which makes the fourth the highest priority which are NSLA students right students that we commonly refer to as poverty students where they where we are experiencing a significant poverty gap uh problem in education we we no matter what we do we seem to not be able to close the poverty gap and I just wanted you to confirm for me that that's what this focus is in the very first
▶ Play
Speaker 126 32:04
year absolutely and and then an ability for those students
▶ Play
to carry over from year to year yeah if you actually look at the priority list there the first year of the program if there are funds available no one else can get these until all of those have been filled so any applicants that are our NSL students as you said free and reduced lunch eligible students if they were in a public school they would be filled first and foremost in in priority depending on how much available funding is there. Then the priority status would go to military dependents in the second year before it opens up to anyone else in that first year. Then it goes back to the regular priority status in subsequent
▶ Play
years. Follow-up, Mr. Chair. So in other words, we're definitely not talking about a program that is to benefit privileged students. We're talking about students who maybe have not been able to have the privilege of
▶ Play
choice. They are first priority and get filled completely as far as however many applicants, but they also go to the top of the priority list right behind renewals in subsequent years and siblings of students who already have one, so we keep the families together. But in subsequent years, those that have been on a waiting list in prior years, if there wasn't funding available that are NSL students, and then new applicants that are NSL actually jump a front of everybody else that might be on a waiting list from previous years. Thank you
▶ Play
Speaker 131 33:37
very much. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative
▶ Play
Walker, you're back for a question. This is an interesting place. and I guess you're interesting as well and so is Representative Lowry and he's talking about how with all of the efforts we have undertaken we have never been able to close the poverty gap we really never tried to do so now I wonder if we can have if this is limited to 1% now and the legislature sets it at 1 And what's there to keep us from next year making it 10 or 20 or 50? I think you'll be here to do that. You will probably
▶ Play
Speaker 100 34:29
be attempting to do that. My life expectancy is over.
▶ Play
That's not what this bill does. So you're voting on this bill. Well, what future bills might come is as unpredictable as yourself. Whoa.
▶ Play
Speaker 137 34:48
Representative Sturge, we better go on to you. Hard to follow, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Speaker 141 34:58
Representative Johnson, thank you for taking our questions. I guess Representative Del Rosa kind of sparked an idea in my head about If we are doing the 65% tax credit on what they're donating to the nonprofit, is that correct? You said the 65% of what they're donating is a tax credit, not a deduction, but a tax credit. Correct. So why couldn't we then, if we're asking parents to keep up, some with receipts of tuition and books and different things that they're doing, why couldn't we administer it as far as the state goes and say at the end of the tax year on their state income taxes, give them a 65% tax income credit on all their eligible expenses for homeschooling or private school or whatever? I
▶ Play
think there may be some similar type bill over in the Senate that kind of does something along those lines. We certainly could if we've got the votes and the willpower to do so. Did you find other states
▶ Play
Speaker 141 35:56
that did it that way? You talked about the constitutionality of it,
▶ Play
and I wondered if that was. There are some states that have tax-deductible expenses for parents. There's generally various amounts of limitations on those, and I believe there's some folks in the audience that are going to be able to testify what other states are doing more in depth and detail. I haven't studied every single state program, but I do know that there are some people here who have. So I would imagine they might be able to answer some of those outside of Arkansas. As far as the reasons why in this bill this is done this way, extensive conversations, debate, back and forth, struggling with details and how can we make it work in our state budget and make it as revenue neutral as possible so there's no impact long term to the financial structure of the state, as well as limited impact to any particular district, but maximum impact to individual students who participate in the program and to try to make it as streamlined as possible for them so they can apply to a non-profit organization. Many students who would try to participate in a program like this, they're not necessarily the students that want to have any state control over something. And so they actually have a higher comfort level applying to a non-profit organization for funding via that private source. And so it's kind of one of the reasons why this was administered and put together and developed into what you see before you today, which was the longest I've ever worked on
▶ Play
a single particular bill. Ripson Gates, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. A question and a follow-up, if I may. Maybe. Thank you. Walker gets to ask too surely I can earth two and a half okay preface it with my statement like Walker does okay can these nonprofits spend any of the tax credit money on administration and if not where do they get the funds for administration of their
▶ Play
programs so just like any other non first answer your question no they can't 100% of the funds that are tax credit eligible funds have to go toward education savings accounts directly so 100% of any tax credit eligible fund which as I said before for every dollar of tax credit that we have out there, it'll take $1.53 worth of contribution for that dollar worth of tax credit to be claimed. So $1.53 goes into an education savings account fund for distribution to students' education savings accounts for the purpose of funding those education savings accounts. So your second part of your question which is your single question the eligible the the nonprofit organizations administrative and operating cost they have to raise that money just like any other nonprofit would be able to raise their money they can receive contributions and and those are tax-deductible contributions but they would have to raise those funds and keep those in a separate account from the education funding account. Follow up, if I may, Mr. Chair. Well, he answered
▶ Play
two questions. Well, it wasn't really. It was a Walker question. It was two or three parts. I'm learning. He's the master. Okay. Aside from receiving a tax credit, and we recognize the benefits of that, but aside from receiving a tax credit, why would any corporation donate money to a nonprofit that established solely for providing education that promote all outward appearances is already available to people? Why would a corporation do that? I
▶ Play
Speaker 49 40:07
would believe they believe in the
▶ Play
mission and the purpose of the contribution where they're, why does anybody contribute to any particular organization? You believe in that mission of that particular organization. The mission of these organizations will be for education. So if you want to have education advanced in the state of Arkansas and you make a contribution to this, you're ensured that 100% of that contribution is going toward education services and in the state of Arkansas. Thank you. Representative McElroy, you're up. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm dumb as
▶ Play
a boxer with hammers, so you're going to have to explain this to me a little more. Couldn't the nonprofits do this now without a tax credit?
▶ Play
There is a possibility for someone to set up and have administer their own private program, yes, but they wouldn't be eligible for tax credits, so the actual contributions may be much more severely limited in how much they actually are able to raise for this
▶ Play
purpose. Well, the word tax is public money. I mean, that's public money. So if you say a tax credit, that's public money once removed or shortstop. So you can decide where your money goes. I understand that part. I don't like where feds are spending my money sometimes. But I think we're getting in some deep water. Does the governor support
▶ Play
this? uh the governor's to my knowledge is neutral on this he's not saying he supports it and he's not
▶ Play
Speaker 49 41:56
saying he's opposed to it thank you so much representative beck
▶ Play
you recognize thank you mr chair and this may be a question for someone later on because it's a tax question how does this deduction that a corporation the hundred thousand dollar deduction that they would take how does this differ from a deduction that could be taken say for something else like a food bank deduction or if a corporation wanted to help that is it different from that yeah deductions and credits credits I'm sorry I said deductions I meant credits well if they're if they're making a contribution to any other non-profit organization just like the first year of this program there are no tax credits available. So the first year of this program will be limited to however many tax deductible contributions are made. Those are just like any other contribution to any other nonprofit organization right now where you reduce your total taxable liability off of the gross and then you only pay taxes on the remainder where a tax credit is directly linked to the contribution itself and you receive a certain amount of reduction in taxes that you owe based off that so so in terms of the deduction it would be the same as any other organization non-profit organization set up in the first year of the program completely all right in the second year of the program that's when tax credits would would kick in all right so the next follow-up please you recognize the amount of money that could be transferred for a student into the account all right how was that amount determined uh it's equivalent to whatever the current year's foundation funding is so in essence it's tied to a link in in what we determine here is the adequate need for an educational expense or funding for a student's education in one year so it'll fluctuate depending on what we determine or what you would you determine in this committee okay but just one more quick one so would that be the amount that say a public school would get the minimum amount that a public school would get the minimum foundation funding amount that the the public school would get for the student that's the equivalent amount that would be available for that student's use in an education savings account. This year, that would be $6,646. Thank you. Representative Meeks, you recognize me.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm going to go against the grain and only ask one question. All right. In anticipation of this bill coming this session, myself and a couple other members had the opportunity to go to Arizona to one of the states that has currently implemented this program and got to see firsthand the benefits that this program was providing. Specifically, we had the opportunity to go to two different schools that provided or had special needs students as part of their mission, if you will. They serve special needs students. And it was this program that allowed a lot of those students with special needs to be able to go to these specialized schools, and in both those cases, they were both supported by, not financially, but they were both supported, or they created a good symbiotic relationship with the local public schools because the schools weren't able to meet the needs of these, the special needs of these students and by transferring transferring these students to these private schools or charter schools I could better meet the needs of these kids the students were better off they had the needs that their needs being met the public school was better off because that was I won't say less money but they had less expense trying to meet the needs of those students at the same time they were trying to meet the needs of every other student and so it created a benefit for the public school so I've seen where this program what sold me on it is this program created benefit for the public school it created benefit for the private school and most importantly it created benefit for the students and essentially that's what we're trying to duplicate here so I'm wondering if you can maybe either expound on that or simply wouldn't you agree absolutely agree Representative
▶ Play
Davis you recognize. Thank you Mr. Chairman. Representative Dodson I've got a question about some of the details if we can about how expenditures are paid out of the ESAs. So I think somebody may ask this before I got here I apologize I was come in a little late but um so if somebody qualifies for they're chosen for an ESA they have an ESA account and they choose to go to a private school those funds are dispersed directly from the non-profit organization to the to the school is that correct they don't actually go through it would be a
▶ Play
process that the parent or the that the nonprofit organization was set up administratively yes that is one way that they could do so but they could also provide a system of receipted reimbursements to the parent if the parent directly paid for it and then got received submitted a receipt for an eligible expense the nonprofit
▶ Play
could reimburse them for that okay and that was the other situation I was going to ask about if someone was homeschooling in there so they've got expenses on their own buying books and science kits or whatever, so would they essentially just being reimbursed, submit a receipt, get reimbursed for those
▶ Play
expenses? As long as they're eligible expense, that would probably be the simplistic way, but there's a certain amount of flexibility the nonprofit organization will establish and set that up on the front end, their process, and, of course, their processes have to be approved in their application on how they're going to administer the program. Approved by who? DF&A.
▶ Play
Okay. So DF&A would approve whatever mechanism the nonprofit wants to set up for administering how those funds are dispersed.
▶ Play
Right. If you look at page 8, that is the page where the expenses, the funds received. On page online, probably 13, somewhere around in there, it starts out. That the eligible nonprofit shall develop a system for payment of funds that allows for A, direct payment from an education savings account to education service providers, B, reimbursement to a parent via check, electronic funds transfer, or other payment deemed to be commercially viable or cost-effective, and except for reimbursements under D1 of this section, shall not issue funds directly to the parent. Okay, perfect. That's what I wanted to see. Okay.
▶ Play
All right, thank you. Representative McGill, you recognize. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I also had the privilege of touring a couple of those schools out in Arizona, and I did notice the makeup of those student populations, and it troubled me. How are the students selected to attend these schools? criteria do you use to determine which students will be attending and which will not the students that are awarded
▶ Play
education savings accounts are by application of the student to the nonprofit organization so the the parents of the students are the ones who would apply there's an order of priority on who receives the funds but then the parent are the ones that go out and determines where they actually use those funds for their educational the educational needs for their particular student so they go out just like any other private paying student this doesn't change any of the choice choices that a parent would have available to them today this just gives them a mechanism to be able to pay for and afford the
▶ Play
choices that are available to them today follow-up mr. chair you're recognized i understand that part but Somewhere in this, someone says, let me review your application. And then someone says, this child is not a good fit for our program. That's
▶ Play
what I detected. Not for this program. What we're talking about is a nonprofit organization makes the awards of these education savings accounts based on the priority status that we talked about before. First and foremost, let me see if I can find it here. I think on page nine there, if you look at that. First, to eligible students who receive funding in the prior academic year, so renewals are first and foremost in priority status. Then siblings of those get the next priority status. Third, though, would be to any students who are eligible for free and reduced lunch that were on a waiting list from a prior year. Fourth, which is where the first year of the program actually starts, fourth in priority status are any NSLA eligible students or free and reduced lunch eligible students, they would get priority status based on available funding, then would go fifth to military dependents sixth would go to all other students that were on a waiting list from the previous year and seventh would be to all other new applicants that are out there if they're not funds available in any given year or any priority status that year then it's a random anonymous lottery that will determine which students get the awards in that particular priority level to expend all the available funds so there's there's no there's no subjectivity on who gets it it's a random anonymous lottery once the parents get awarded the account then they're free to use those funds as long as they're for eligible expenses in whichever way they deem necessary to educate their student.
▶ Play
Since I allowed it a while ago, I'll do it again. So what you're telling me is that the applications arrive, and the first 100 applications, they're reviewed, and everybody's accepted. All the applications are approved.
▶ Play
If there's funding available, then they all get approved, yes. So
▶ Play
there's no scoring on the application? All they need is the application, all kids that apply are accepted if they're in the first group of lottery.
▶ Play
As long as they're an eligible student, and so eligible students, if you look at page two, the bottom of the page on line 33, it says, eligible students means a resident of this state who is eligible to enroll in a public school in this state at any level from K through 12. So, if they're defined as an eligible student, then as long as there's funds available, all of them that apply will get it. If there are not enough funds available, that's when it goes to the random
▶ Play
Speaker 185 54:19
anonymous lottery. Okay. Thank you. You're in. There we go. I think what might clarify this is the, say, if I had a child that was wanting to go to a certain school, that school has the ability to reject that child. Even if I've got the money, and that might be where Representative McGill was going, even though I might have that scholarship in hand and I apply to that school, they could still reject
▶ Play
that student this program does not address any uh private school admission processes right this doesn't this doesn't make a state mandate for any school to accept any student whatever their processes are this just gives the parent the ability to pay for or have funds available to them that for the most part these parents wouldn't be able to to fund or
▶ Play
have the choice available to them. I think that clears that up. Thank you. Ref. Senator McElroy, you're first. Could we, what type fiscal impact will this have on, could we get somebody from DFNA to kind of explain how it increases in 10%? State your name and who you're with
▶ Play
and you're recognized to speak. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Joel DePippa, Senior Counsel with the Department of Finance and Administration. Our fiscal impact statement that we've released shows, beginning in the second half of this biennium, a $6.5 million reduction in general revenues. That's based on the 65% tax credit that can be granted against the up to $10 million of donations to the nonprofit organizations. The escalation mechanism allows for up to an additional 10% of that amount to be issued in each subsequent year. So for example, it would go from 6.5 in fiscal year 19 to 7.1 in fiscal year 20, a little over 7.8, possibly the year after. You have
▶ Play
Speaker 189 56:31
a follow-up? You recognize. If
▶ Play
we're not using public funds for private schools, how come our money is going down? Well, sir, this
▶ Play
would create a tax credit for the private donation, which would then be taken against their Arkansas tax liability, which is the basis for our fiscal impact showing that reduction in GR. Yeah. Thank you so much. Reps.
▶ Play
Gates, I'm going to let Ms. Cavanaugh go first. she has not
▶ Play
had a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Dotson, I just want to clarify because I've heard a lot of people ask me this question. I just want you to verify yes or no. Is this a correct answer? So we'll all know the people actually receiving the savings account lottery. They win the money. Say they are not at, are they, are they, are they not getting a tax credit or deduction they are not
▶ Play
receiving a tax credit or deduction follow up you recognize
▶ Play
thank you so the only people that would be getting any type of tax benefit from that would be those that might make a donation to
▶ Play
the non-profit correct okay the funds in that education savings account are not considered taxable income though to that
▶ Play
Speaker 115 57:53
parent or that student president gates you have
▶ Play
one minute you have to 11 o'clock okay I have a question for Joel with DFNA if I could did your calculations on the cost include the reductions of services that would be generated by the state if someone chose an alternative form of education those services are no longer needed thus freeing up uh capital for the students that are there we're
▶ Play
familiar with that argument representative however that's beyond the scope of our fiscal impacts we look at the four corners of the bill and based on previous information from previous tax years apply that to what is on the paper so is that is that a no that is not considered in our fiscal impact because that is something beyond the scope of the four corners of that bill okay i'm going to
▶ Play
interpret that as a no All right, we are through with testimony from the committee. I'm going to read a little statement, then I'm going to tell you the process we're going to go to. This is a reminder for all of those that will be providing testimony on the bill, please show respect for the legislative process and those testifying on this issue, even if you disagree with their opinions. Properly and respectfully address committee members as representative. The chairman should be called or addressed as Madam Chair or Mr. Chair. after the chairman has recognized you clearly state your name and the organization if any that you represent address your remarks to the chairman and to the members of the committee that may be asking you that question keep your remarks focused on the bill that is being discussed do not rabbit off on something else and get to chasing something please keep your remarks brief and the point is done in discussion your support or opposition to the bill avoid references to personalities groups or other matters that are not discussed in this proposed bill please observe proper decorum at all times and all pictures printed materials and props presented to this testimony must be approved by the chairs in advance of testimony so if you have not already brought something up then it probably will not be presented and thank you for coming to the capitol to spend your time here to work on this today all right at this time we will start hearing testimony that here's the here's the way this is going to go we've already spent real close to an hour on this bill we want to be fair with everybody on all processes of bills that come through this committee i think the longest one that has been in this committee has been about an hour and a half we are going to surpass that today so what we were going to do we are going to stop at 12 o'clock today that's going to give us almost an hour for testimony i'm going to tell you that if you come to testify we will do for and against you will have five minutes in that chair and when I tell you your time's up you can stay in that chair if there's a question to be asked if there's not a question for you you will move out and let the next one come in we will start with the against side is any problem with the committee on those rules yes sir mr. chair may I
▶ Play
I suggest that we limit each person to two minutes with an opportunity for questions up to three that'll be about the same
▶ Play
thing yes sir I'm good with that if the committee is fine with that any objection from committee on that you know it'll still hear the same amount pretty well but that's that's fine we are we're gonna we have quite a few people signed up for and against but I know with due respect we have had a marathon year already in this committee I just don't want to belabor the process of hearing the same testimony over and over. So if you have someone that is speaking in your same organization about the same thing, I would ask that you please pass that baton to somebody else that we would hear from that has a different testimony. That's totally up to you. You don't have to do that, but that would be my recommendation. Dr. Randy Barrett is a business. Okay. We are ready to start, and we'll give you two minutes to speak, and then we'll let you sit in a chair to see if we have some questions. All right, Dr. Randy Barrett from Gentry Public Schools, you are recognized to be first and against the bill.
▶ Play
Please state your name and who you're with, and you're recognized. Ah, start over. Don't count that against my two minutes, please. You're recognized. I'm Randy Barrett, and I am superintendent of schools in Gentry, Arkansas, and I am speaking today against the bill. I like what you said to us about respecting the people in the process. I respect all of you. I'm just against this bill, not against the people that wrote it or the people that support it. So having said that, would you look on the bottom of the first page, the one that says each child in the state should have an opportunity to receive an appropriate education? I don't know what that means as a superintendent. And I have a general idea of what adequate means because that's been the subject of conversations for a long time. But I'm not sure because there is no definition in the bill in the definitions of what appropriate is. I look on the bottom of page two, and I look at who an eligible student is. It's basically every child in the state. And I also think about that these kids right now are being served by traditional schools, conversion charters, open enrollment charters, private schools, parochial religious schools, virtual schools, or home schools. But as I look at this bill, you can take your pen and mark off traditional conversion, open enrollment, because the parents that send students to these schools will receive no benefits from this bill. I looked at the median income of Arkansas last night, and it's about 40. Are you ready for questions? Time's up on your two. Yes, sir, I am. If you have any
▶ Play
questions, Representative Walker, you recognize me. What is the median income that you were about to address? I'm
▶ Play
going to suggest it's lower than what most people in this room make. $40,000, I think, was the last count. And the reason, if I may follow up on your question, sir. You've got up to five minutes in that chair. Thank you. The reason for that, sir, that I bring that up is because the concept of the bill is great. is great. The problem is I have students in the Gentry School District because I know the parents and I know the students that are never going to be able to access this. The 10% of the contributions, that's $600. They're not going to be able to transport a child somewhere else to go. We have no private schools per se in our district. So I have a concern about that. Representative Hodges, you're recognized. Thank you. Can I get your name one more time, Doctor? Yes, it's Randy Barrett. Okay, Dr. Barrett, thank you. You stated that the bill uses the words appropriate education and that you don't know what that means, and I wouldn't expect you to know what that means for every student, but is it possible that the parents of the students know what an appropriate education is for their child? Yes, sir. I think I concede that point. But I also believe that education is a function of the state. And the state, I believe, has told us that public schools now are providing an adequate education, being funded with taxpayer dollars. So I'm not sure if this bill was saying that we need a better school, a more adequate school, so that they will have that opportunity.
▶ Play
Representative Sullivan, you recognize me. Yes, sir. Thank you. I've talked to a number of parents in my districts who have children with dyslexia and other needs. So are you saying that there are no parents in your school and your district that may have some special needs that you would refuse to give them the opportunity
▶ Play
to seek that opportunity through this waiver? No, sir, I'm not saying that at all. Thank you. Rep. Walker, it was short. We have 27 seconds left. Are you able to provide those needs as requested by the questioner through IDEA and other funds in SLA?
▶ Play
We are making an honest attempt, sir, to provide adequate, and we like to think better than adequate, services in our school for all of our students, whether they're special education, ESL, whether they're living in poverty. Yes, sir. Time's up. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Representative. Thank you for
▶ Play
the opportunity. At this time, we'll call up Patrick Wolfe to speak for the bill. If you'd please state your name and who you're with,
▶ Play
you're recognized to speak for the bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair and Representatives. My name is Dr. Patrick Wolfe. I'm a distinguished professor of education policy at the University of Arkansas in Fayetteville, but I share these opinions today with you as my own opinions. They don't represent necessarily the position of my employer. They represent 20 years that I have spent studying private school choice across the country. And the results are summarized in a handbook or a little handout that I believe you were provided To avoid having to speak like an auctioneer, I will just provide a very quick summary of that. And that is, I've traveled all around the country to study private school choice because private school choice has spread all across our country. You could land in the eastern shore of Maryland and travel all the way across the United States using a northern or a southern route, And you would never set foot in a state that doesn't have a private school choice program until you hit the extreme Pacific Coast. And those states are crazy, of course. They're crazy because they are missing out on all the benefits that private school choice provides. Students who participate in choice programs achieve higher test scores two, three, four years after participating. They graduate from high school and attend college at significantly higher rates as a result of access to private school choice. Also, private school choice programs save money. This has been confirmed by 30 careful fiscal impact studies that look at both the revenue side and the expenditure side. And the bottom line is that it's less expensive for government to educate students in the private sector through choice programs than it is to educate the same student in the public sector through the formula funding mechanisms. So basically, better results. All right, your two minutes is up, so I'm
▶ Play
going to let them start asking questions to you.
▶ Play
Okay, thank you, Mr. Chairman. Professor Gates, you're first. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'll talk real fast. Dr. Wolf, if there is a move of some of the population to an alternative education format, either homeschool, private school, or whatever, thus reducing the population in our public school system, In your research, did that give more money to the system, the public school system, to better educate the students that are there?
▶ Play
Yes, Representative, because the funds raised locally don't leave. So basically when a student leaves the public school system, eventually state funding no longer goes to that district for that student because they've left. But the local money all stays there and is distributed across a smaller number of students. So per-pupil spending goes up in local public school districts when private school choice programs are launched. Representative Hodges, you recognize.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Dr. Wolfe, could you, I've heard some concerns about allowing students to go to private schools or concerns generally about school choice in that there's not the same accountability that you would get in public schools? Could you just touch
▶ Play
on the accountability part of this? Representative, the idea of school choice is that accountability is shared by the government that oversees the program and parents who have such a strong vested interest in the success of their student. With a system like this, a tax credit funded education savings account, you will have public servants in the Department of Finance and Administration and at other places that are approving the nonprofits, that are overseeing and sanctioning their methods for granting the tax credits and distributing the education savings accounts to make them accessible to the parents. But on the education side, basically you have parents, first teachers of all of our children, who are making the decision about the kind of educational program that's going to work best for their child. And what ESAs allow them to do is to customize the education and modify the education if necessary. So if a given education provider, be that a private school or be that a tutor or a local public school that's providing direct services for a child through an ESA, if those services are not meeting that child's needs, the parent has the ability to quickly modify that and change it. And that's the sort of accountability because basically we all know as parents if our students don't succeed, that's a problem for us. And so we're going to take action to make sure that education providers are delivering for our kids. Rep. Walker, I ran out
▶ Play
of time on him. Is it a burning question? Yes, it'll be brief if you allow it. Go ahead.
▶ Play
Dr. Wolfe, you are the leading advocate of vouchers in the state, being the distinguished professor of education at the University of Arkansas, committed to absolute school choice. Is that fair to say? Is that fair to say yes or no? That's all. No,
▶ Play
Representative Walker, that's not fair to say. I'm committed to sound scientific research on education policy interventions, and the evidence has compelled me to share with you the positive results of private school choice.
▶ Play
All right, thank you. Your time is up. Dale Query, you are recognized to go to the end of the table and speak against the bill. We'll try to be a little bit flexible on this, ladies and gentlemen. I know it's kind of hard to make five minutes work perfectly, so state your name and who you're with
▶ Play
and you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. My name is Dale Query. I am executive director-elect of Arkansas Rural Education Association and retired superintendent of 42 years in public school. I, too, have looked at the research. If you will Google voucher research, there's a plethora of things that come up, and there are studies for, there are studies against, and if, as a researcher, you discount both of those and take the middle, the research the overwhelming research shows that vouchers do not improve student achievement now we're talking about public money here we're talking about money this year that's in the state treasury and we're talking about money next year that will not be in the state treasury so my concern is with the quality of education for the kids. Senator or Representative Dotson has put a lot in this bill regarding accountability and testing for his kids, and I think that's a wonderful piece to put in there. And I know you've worked very hard, and I commend your work and your passion for doing what you think is best for kids, because that's why we're all here. We all want to do what's best for kids. The Representative McGill's question about stratification, the research shows over time the stratification piece that he referred to is possible for voucher students. not not not all students but for voucher students they get to the school the private schools ease them out for one reason or another because they're not as strong or whatever the case might be that's what the research says
▶ Play
Speaker 77 1:16:29
so all right it's question time okay
▶ Play
thank you all right represent gates be recognized thank you
▶ Play
mr chair i represent nine school districts nine superintendents many of mine are rural school districts some of which have already been closed down in busing kindergartners an hour and a half a day to another school district would you not foresee that some of our rural schools that have been closed down because of the small populations that if those parents did not want their kindergarten or their first grader to be on a bus an hour and a half that this might be a remedy for them to be able to afford a some alternative education in those rural school districts that have been
▶ Play
closed down i would not disagree with that no sir i would say that partnering with your local school district and excuse me i got a little allergy thing and meeting the needs of those kids is what every educator is all about what every superintendent is all about is meeting the needs of those kids and doing what needs to be done in those circumstances partnering with the local school district and
▶ Play
meeting those needs all right if i could a follow-up if that school district has closed down Representative Gates, no follow-ups. Oh, sorry about that. This takes too much time. All right. Representative Hodges, you're next. Thank you, Mr. Chair. If you could help me just clarify something I've been sort of having trouble with here. It seems like there are some rural school districts, and you represent rural districts? Yes, sir. Who, from what I understand, don't really seem to have many choices to begin with. So if a lot of rural school districts wouldn't be affected by this bill, if, as Representative Dotson has said, the funding for other public schools wouldn't be affected and there's no other choice options for a lot of rural schools. And given that we have to make policy for the entire state, and
▶ Play
Speaker 261 1:18:37
some areas do have choice and do need this bill or might benefit from this bill, then why
▶ Play
are the rural school districts opposed to this? The opposition is for the accountability piece. I said before, we take the test, but it doesn't say what happens to those private schools with those test scores. With public schools, we get on academic distress, we get a letter grade, we get all those kinds of things that the state accountability piece does. If we have to have a voucher bill in Arkansas, I recommend that the Friedman model, who introduced this in 1955 and got a Nobel Peace Prize for economics, and that's where the voucher piece started, i would recommend that we follow his recommendation and that would be that all entities receiving state money are held to the same accountability principles as everybody else including public schools so if we send those kids to those private schools and if we look at their achievement levels and they're doing very well then by golly in public schools we want to do the same things we want to share that information we don't uh we we want what's best for our kids thank you you're out of time and
▶ Play
i will remind the committee the people in the audience we do not clap we do not yell we do not talk to anyone while we're doing presentations please thank you mr chair thank you appreciate the opportunity sorry represent mccroy run out of Miss Angela Thompson Johnson I'm sorry Johnson and I and I would remind the people that are testifying less time introducing less time talking just present the facts you'll do a whole lot better in that two minutes state your name and who you're with you're recognized thank you I appreciate your
▶ Play
time today my name is Angela Johnson I'm a mom I'm here representing my family my husband and Jeff and I are the proud parents of four children one typical learner three with special learning needs so as a parent with three children with very different learning needs we have had to be very careful and discerning about where they attend school we're a middle class family so we kind of fall in that gap where we don't qualify for assistance based on income but we also don't have the level of income needed to support the education options that we really need for our kids our oldest child emma attended public schools in little rock through middle school but we knew that in high school she was going to need a special environment to really meet her needs and so we ended up using our savings to fund her private school education the good news is she did really well she was well prepared she's a freshman now at arkansas state university she's doing great she aspires to be a school counselor someday because of the support that she received in high school. So the bad news is we used our savings to pay for high school. So we're now using retirement funds that we had saved to pay for college. We have twins who are in public school. They'll be transferring next year from E-STEM to Little Rock School District School. But our most urgent immediate need is for our middle son, Ethan, who will be entering high school. He's 14. He's in eighth grade now and will be in high school next year. He's a gifted student. He has a high IQ. If you met him, you would love him immediately, but he does have severe dyslexia and dysgraphia, a double whammy, and so he has some very special learning needs. It was identified early, but unfortunately did not receive the the interventions that he needed immediately to address his learning needs. So after two years of one-on-one daily reading intervention at his school, he entered the fourth grade on a first grade reading level. So we were panicked, parents at that point, but did a lot of research. We worked closely with our school and the special education department, and we were able to introduce him to the Barton Reading Program, which is an Orton-Gillingham evidence-based reading intervention specifically for kids with dyslexia, and he has done great. He's worked really hard. Are you ready for questions? I have a long story to tell. I know. I'm sorry. It's just kind
▶ Play
of the way we're going to do today. You may get to finish that up as they ask questions. Representative Sullivan. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chair. I hear that story quite a bit and appreciate what you've done. And since our state is, I think our reading levels are 30% statewide or 40%, I can understand your situation. Do you feel adequate as a patient, as a parent, to make the determination as to what's an adequate education for your child? Or do you feel like you need a professor from 1955 making that determination for you? I feel very qualified to make
▶ Play
that decision for my child. I've watched him every day struggle and learn. I know it works. I know it
▶ Play
doesn't. Thank you. Any other questions? Representative Eubanks, you're recognized.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. The way this bill is written, would you qualify for the education savings account?
▶ Play
We would qualify. We wouldn't be prioritized at the top of the list. We would end up probably in the lottery at the end, but it would be a chance. Any other questions? I'm sorry, no
▶ Play
more questions. Thank you for your testimony.
▶ Play
Mr. Andrew Bagley to speak against the bill. Please state your
▶ Play
name and who you're with, please. My name is Andrew Bagley. I'm the president of the school board in the Helena West Helena School District. And since this is affecting the entire state, I think it's very important that you realize what you're opening the door to if you pass this bill. Most of the private schools in my area were formed in the 1960s clearly to avoid integration of the schools. I have one private school in my county, featured in Time Magazine on November 14, 1969, as a leader in what was then a growing segregationist academy movement. to this day they have never admitted a child of a minority group that's what you're opening the door to i don't think we as a state want to pass a bill that would say that we're going to sanction funding being diverted to schools that are formed for that purpose that's the reality where i live and so i'm urging you to vote against the bill for that reason i don't i think arkansas should not open that door particularly when we're separating Robert E. Lee from Martin Luther King we don't need to pass a bill that will open the door to funding academies that were funded for that purpose and there's nothing in this bill that prevents that I've read it I've had all your relatives read it there's nothing in this bill that prevents that from happening and that gravely concerns me because if there's anything that has hurt our part of the state more it was that moment in time and those schools forming and us not handling that correctly. So if you have questions, I got it done in less than
▶ Play
two, Mr. Chairman. Thank you. Representative, I think Lowry was first. He double-dipped over there. Didn't know if you were really there or not, so go ahead. Yeah, I was
▶ Play
kind of there. Thank you, Mr. Chair. so the example that you're giving us of this potential abuse is something that happened over
▶ Play
50 years ago no i'm telling you that school still has not admitted a minority student
▶ Play
so you're talking about one school uh over the whole state that one example is supposed to be the one that's that
▶ Play
that's the most egregious example that's the one that time
▶ Play
magazine featured let's talk about accountability on when it comes to public schools we have 240 schools in the state 245 schools that are scoring at either a d or an f where's the accountability uh and you have the
▶ Play
academic distress law you can take us over i know full well about takeovers and that's a lot of accountability uh that the state has you've got a lot of accountability that you put on the public schools and all i'm saying is that you do not need a bill that opens up the diversion of state funds to a school that has not admitted a minority student ever. I think that is bad public policy, and in this case, that is the reality. I don't think we should run away from that, and this bill is not a good bill because it doesn't prevent that kind of thing from happening. A minority child could qualify for the scholarship, and institutions such as those could find a reason not to admit the child, and there's nothing that that family can do on that. Representative Walker, you recognize her. Mr. Chair, Mr. Bagley, I think I want to first commend you for staying in Helena when many of the middle class people in Helena were cutting bait, taking their money and resources with them and going up to northwest Arkansas and some then running for office and serving in the legislature. Thank you, Mr. Walker. I love my home and I think it's a wonderful place and when you retire from this, we'd love to have you. And I guess my question is this. In terms of education, are you trying to do more than cause these children to be able to have stuff in the head but you're causing them to have full learning that includes uh the opportunity to have diverse experiences absolutely we're trying to work hard every day we've got a millage on the ballot right now that quite frankly i should be home campaigning to put votes in the box for because early voting's going on uh where we are wanting to upgrade the facility so we can have quality arts facilities quality fine arts programs we employ people beyond the standards to reduce class size, math and literacy coaches to work with teachers. Our test scores at Central High School, which is the one in academic distress, are up for four years in a row. We missed it by .074%, and my superintendent's over at the Arch Ford Building now, I think, discussing that matter. So we're doing our dead-level best, and we're doing it at a time when resources are steadily declining for us to work with. And I think that that's also something that you need to consider when you've got a fiscal impact statement. as you're cutting general revenue at the same time you're trying to cut taxes and a lot of other things, do we want to open this door and further make it difficult through less resources for us to do an already difficult job? I mean, we're working our tails off. Time's up. Thank you,
▶ Play
Speaker 193 1:30:09
Mr. Chair and representatives. Representative Hodges, you'll be up on the
▶ Play
next one. I know he wanted to ask a question, but we were running way over time. Who's next? Is Mr. Paul Calvert in here? I know he was. There he is. You are recognized to speak for the bill.
▶ Play
My name is Paul Calvert. I'm from Faulkner County area. I'm not speaking on behalf of any organization, just for myself. um i believe that private funding is always the best solution for the general education of children in a free society currently publicly funded education is a huge welfare program but it's highly dysfunctional for some children and it is excessively expensive but allows the results that we often see coming out of some schools i did a little simple math here recently and my finding is that if all of k-12 education in arkansas was funded with a system like this it would save about two and a half billion dollars each year to taxpayers i think it's a cool program it's a way to um to allow parents to raise their own kids and educate them as they see fit and also avoid paying the almost eleven thousand dollars a year that the current expenditures are for public schools from right now here in the state of arkansas um on average and so i think it's kind of cool in addition to saving about two and a half billion dollars in tax funds each year It would also reduce the influence of the big government agenda in the lives of impressionable children. At the end of the day, we can call this a pro-choice education bill. I think it's a cool idea. I wish it was a
▶ Play
whole lot bigger than $10 million. You're ready for questions? Yes, sir, please. Representative Hodges, you were first. If you have a question. If you don't, then I'm ready for someone else. Who do I have? Nobody? Any questions? Thanks, sir. Yes, sir. We have Richard Abernathy up for the next one. Dr. Abernathy, you can state your name and who
▶ Play
you're with. You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Richard Abernathy, Executive Director of AAEA. You know, we keep hearing about special needs kids and what this bill could possibly do for them. we already have that in secede scholarship what we're talking about here is a universal voucher program universal educational savings account we've talked about eligibility of kids not only are traditional kids that are attending public schools eligible but all the kids in the state of arkansas will be eligible when you look at this bill even those kids who have never attended public schools um you mentioned there's been several times mentioned about how this program could save the state money that's based on certain assumptions because there are very few studies in state of art in the nation regarding universal voucher programs. Most of those states that save money, they put restrictions on who can actually participate in the program. Ours is not. Ours does have some restrictions on there, but then today it's going to take a certain population or percent of the population who are currently attending traditional schools, public schools, in order to move over to private schools and home schools in order for the state to save money. So you're not going to save money with this on the financial impact report you saw it is in fact taking money out of general revenue so it is a diverting tax dollars so these are in fact public monies the one thing or another thing that has not been brought out was that this bill particularly discriminates against public school parents you know they are not eligible to participate in educational savings account to send their kids to college whereas if you're attending home school or a private school, you in fact can divert some of those dollars that you receive from the educational savings account to pay for your kid to attend college. I would have loved to have some money like that to pay for my kids to go to college. Public schools' parents do not have that ability to do that. When you look at studies, and there's all kinds of studies, and like Mr. Quarry said, there are studies that's pros and cons on vouchers and what it does for you. Some of the
▶ Play
Speaker 290 1:34:33
studies that y'all have seen are all about the positive. on question Representative McElroy you're first
▶ Play
thank you Mr. Chair down in my district we've got small schools small rural schools we're barely making the numbers down there now if this passes could you see could it possibly affect us in more school consolidation with children having to ride further on a school bus because we've just barely got the numbers and barely got the money to survive now can you see this happening Yes, sir.
▶ Play
I do think that that could be an unintended consequence from this. You know, the bill has in there a 1% cap in the bill, but when you read that a little closer, that 1% applies to a nonprofit in one particular district. There's five nonprofits that can be approved. So every one of those five nonprofits could have a 1% in a particular district, so you could dwindle those numbers fairly quickly. Representative Sullivan, you recognize me. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chair. I think I just heard you advocate for universal ESAs, even though it would draw a lot of money down from the state budget. Was I correct in hearing that? No,
▶ Play
I think what you heard was that would be for a PSA. For instance, my kids, I'm tired of sending them to public parks, and so I'd like a PSA that would allow me to pay for country club dues or a jungle gym in my backyard and we'll set it up where the state can pay for my decision as a parent. I think that was more what you heard of Representative. Representative Meeks, you're recognized for a question. Thank you. Thank you, Dr. Adam. My question is, if you look at kind of the characteristic of those who are for and against this bill, what I've seen so far is essentially three private citizens have come to speak for the bill, and I've seen three organizations who are trying to protect their territory speaking against the bill. so I'm wondering if you could also speak to that because I am a I'm a homeschool parent I am paying taxes in to support my local public school now I've got a great local public school that that I'm fortunate in that aspect but I am paying tax dollars into the public coffers to be able to support these public schools and what this allows is allow some of those parents who are paying taxes in to maybe get some benefit back from those taxes that they are paying in so I'm wondering if you could kind of speak to those two things for me you know and you know obviously I'm sure there'll be a lot of traditional school parents or charter school parents that would like to be down here speaking as well and and they have other things to do so I understand what you're saying there that the thing on public school funds should always be used for a public purpose and a good the good of the whole community and not a select group or a select few and that's what our tax dollars would be spent for. Just because you didn't choose to participate in what's being offered out there doesn't mean that your dollars shouldn't support the overall public good. I guess that would be how I would answer that representative. Time's up.
▶ Play
Thank you. At this time we have Alyssa Luland. Is that correct? I may have butchered that a little bit. I'm not sure. Did it put you? Okay. Please state your name and who you're with,
▶ Play
and you're recognized. My name is Alyssa Lawland. I am here as a mother. We have four children, ages 14 through will be due in August. We come from a standpoint on a military side. I know it's a little bit different. We're probably more of a can of worms than you want to get into, but when we get airmen in new families, the options for their education is very limited. If you're not knowing how long you're going to be here, it's hard to say, let's go purchase a home in a really good school district 20 miles away and then up and leave and sell your home. So a lot of people choose to live on base. With that, we're stuck in a school district who they're working really hard on it. But as far as the options, when you come from a different state, if you're used to different, one example is my friend has a son with Down syndrome. so she's very limited on where you know unless she's traveling very far distance she's out of pocket for everything so um just those kind of options for the military side of our families and having the ability to choose where our kids are going to be able to go to school and knowing that when we're also introducing um families onto the base my husband has about 24 troops and so when they come in and they're young it's easy to talk to them about you know well if you live here this is this school district if you live here this is this school district most of them can't afford to live off base and so giving that option to them and this savings is really going to be able to get the education they need for their children and give them the empowerment to say this is what I need my kids to do and this is I don't think any parents going to send their kids to a school district they don't agree with, or a private school or homeschool if they choose not to do that. I think they really have the interest of their children. So that's kind of our stand on that. It's not very lengthy. All
▶ Play
right, are there any questions? Wow, you must have done a real good job presenting that. Nobody has any questions. All right, thank you. I have Albert Snow to speak against the bill.
▶ Play
Speaker 304 1:40:22
State your name and who you're with. You're recognized. Dr. Albert Snow, and I'm superintendent of schools in Fort Ice, Arkansas. I felt like this was one of the most important bills to come before the state legislature since I've been a superintendent here, and I am speaking against it. Now, I am a member of the AAEA and Superintendents Association, but I'm not speaking for them here. I'm a superintendent, and one of my major roles is to represent the parents and students of my district. We are a district that has over 70 percent poverty level or free and reduced lunch which is how the federal government judges that. We also have large numbers of special education students and it is my opinion that this bill does nothing for the students in my district which takes in part of Dallas County, Callum County, and Columbia County. There are no options. We do not have a private school available the furthest or the closest is probably in pine bluff so when you sell this as being for low-income students in this state it does not apply to all low-income students and even if those parents were to do that to choose another option it'd be at least an hour one way on a bus if not more and many parents even with the help of this ESA would not be able to provide transportation even being reimbursed would not be able to provide transportation also my district serves a large number of special ed students and we are working every day to meet their needs we provide one-on-one aids we provide nurses if necessary we have a dyslexia program as mandated by the state and sometimes it's not the program that parents want but there are more than one program for for dealing with that so i'm just here representing my district saying that we don't see a benefit from it and the only thing that it will do for for our school district is to reduce the amount of money in the general fund which we depend on to help serve our students all right any questions
▶ Play
reps and Hodges you're recognized thank you are
▶ Play
Speaker 213 1:42:55
there any low-income homeschool families in your district benefit from this program yes sir there are any other questions represent Larry yes thank you
▶ Play
mr. chair so your argument I mean you just answered representative Hodges question that there are free and reduced lunch in sla students but your argument is that because there are pockets of the state where transportation uh or distance is longer than the 15 20 miles that that totally under undermines the motivation or the good intent behind this
▶ Play
Speaker 304 1:43:29
bill so i i'm a i'm a pro-choice advocate okay i'm just saying that in many areas of the state there is no other choice but the public schools and Um, I just want the committee and the state legislature as a whole to realize that there are other places in the state that need representation also. Okay. We've had several people talk about West Helena, for example, and others. It's not speaking to everyone in the state. Follow up, Mr. Chair. No
▶ Play
follow up. Okay. Let me make sure. If there's nobody else, we'll get you back. Anybody else have a question? then you're recognized okay thank you so
▶ Play
he's got one more question if you want to
▶ Play
want if you want to hear one more question uh so so really the limitation of this bill is the the percentage cap that we put on this that uh does not allow uh a private school or an operator to be able to set up near Fordyce? It's the limitation, the
▶ Play
Speaker 304 1:44:40
number limitation. Well, there could be private operators to set up in this district. That is true. My concern there is what standards would they be held to and what kind of accountability that they would have. I'm a school that's been in academic distress. We are no longer in it. That's a lot of accountability that we face every day and i'm concerned that a pop-up school would not be held to the same standards or provide an adequate education all
▶ Play
right thank you any other questions thanks sir miss virginia ford is that correct Please state your
▶ Play
Speaker 313 1:45:46
name and who you're with. My name is Virginia Walden Ford. I'm actually speaking as a private citizen. That'll
▶ Play
Speaker 314 1:45:52
be fine. But also, I've worked for many, many years with low-income families all around the state to talk to them about what their needs are. I believe the Education Savings Accounts will allow these families, those that have talked so desperately and with so much need, to have an opportunity to have the resources to share in the education of their children. I cannot even tell you how many parents have come to me and said, my child needs tutoring, my child needs a computer, my child needs to be in another environment that will serve him better. Years ago, one of my kids was failing in the school he was in. This was a school that just was not serving his needs. And as a result of getting a scholarship to attend another school, we saw total changes in his behavior, how he performed in school. Now, he's an adult now. But in the preceding years, I have talked to hundreds of thousands of parents all over this country, and the conversation is always the same. How can I be a part of my child's education? What can I do to make sure that I'm giving my child everything he needs? And resources are very important for those families. They need to be able to have the money to do that, and this bill really addresses that. I hope you'll help them. You know, I get calls day after day after day after day. For full disclosure, I did work in Washington, D.C. as an organizer on behalf of the D.C. Opportunity Scholarship Program, Mr. Walker.
▶ Play
Franklin Walker, you are recognized. Thank you. Thank you for the privilege, Jim. I don't know whether the committee should know it, but her father was the first African-American administrator in the central office in Little Rock, and he was a big proponent of public schools, not school choice.
▶ Play
Speaker 318 1:47:52
I am, too. And my
▶ Play
dad, but... Let me ask my question. Okay. I knew you. As a representative of the Heritage Foundation and the other organizations, you're a big supporter of vouchers. Why isn't
▶ Play
Speaker 314 1:48:10
this a voucher bill? Because it provides money for resources that serve children well. As Representative Dawson said earlier, vouchers, the money goes to the parent, and goes to school, but these are resources. I mean, I run a reading program in my neighborhood in inner city Little Rock every Thursday. We have 18 kids that come to learn how to read, and they come and use my laptop because they don't have the funds available. These families would all benefit from this particular legislation, and my daddy would be standing right here with me. Since you brought him up.
▶ Play
Isn't the problem in Little Rock lack of resources in the schools in southwest Little Rock? Isn't that one of the major problems? That's yes or
▶ Play
no. I don't want a long time. No. Representative Sullivan, you recognize. Thank you. We've heard a lot of the public educators rehearse the barriers. As a matter of fact, we just heard from the superintendent in Fordyce that there are all these barriers out there that would prevent this from being actualized by families. Do you think families who are really engaged would welcome the opportunity to have these resources to solve those problems in creative ways? Absolutely. Absolutely.
▶ Play
Ripson Murdoch. You don't get one. McElroy. Thank you, Mr. Chair. You were talking about
▶ Play
the resources. We're all short on resources, and DF&A tell us it's going to take $6 million out. There's just so much to go around. Are we not robbing Peter to pay Paul? We have to take it from the public schools and give it to another school.
▶ Play
Speaker 314 1:50:00
I think this particular bill is so innovative in not doing that. I think that somebody asked earlier, why would corporations want to give this money? Because people really care about what happens with kids, and particularly in this country. And, you know, these kind of programs all around the United States, and I have been really privileged, and, yes, I do work with Heritage, and I work with Institute for Justice, and I work with Ed Choice, because I believe so strongly that parents need to hear from somebody that was a parent about how these programs can benefit them. I'm going to tell you, I don't know what would have happened to my son had not. I was a single mother raising three kids, didn't call home to Arkansas because my parents probably would have come and got me because I wanted to prove
▶ Play
something. Time's up, thank you. Bobby Hart, you're up to speak against the bill. We are down to one more four, and I believe that will end this because it's going to be right at 12
▶ Play
Speaker 325 1:51:13
when we get there. You're going to
▶ Play
be the last against. Bobby Hart, the superintendent of
▶ Play
Speaker 327 1:51:20
Hope Public Schools in Hope, Arkansas, and I want to thank the representative for his bill and his passion on education as well as everyone in this room right now. I think we all share a common goal, and that is to improve educational outcomes for every student in our state. Thank you to the chair and the committee for allowing me to speak today. I sit today in opposition of HP 1222, and you'll forgive me because I left my notes on my phone, so if I'm glancing down, please forgive me. But while in my opinion there are a number of things wrong with issues with the bill, I'd like to point out three of its major shortcomings. All, to quote my friend and colleague John Rollins from Springdale, all means all. This bill doesn't provide equal access to the program, and in fact it chooses winners and losers and children. If private schools themselves are the solution to the educational ills in the state of Arkansas, then by all means, let's open the doors for all children. Secondly, the bill takes money from state revenue. In a time when all facets of state government are in peril financially, taking more dollars away will only exacerbate these problems. DF&A has already demonstrated to us that state revenues are not meeting forecasts and growth projections are down. The bill's physical impact statement lays out a $6.5 million shortfall or revenue decrease in 2018 and estimates by 2025 an $11.5 million revenue decrease. A decrease in state revenue of this magnitude is not only going to impact public schools, it's also going to impact highway appropriations, it's going to impact prisons, it's going to impact DHS allocations. Lastly, I want to say that the passage of this bill will begin to establish two separate systems of education in the state. Brown v. Board in 54 stated that separate but equal was not acceptable. I'm going to have to stop you right there.
▶ Play
We're going to have questions. I'm sorry. Yes, sir.
▶ Play
Representative Deffenbaugh, you recognize. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Just one quick question, and this may be a little bit different line of thinking, but after hearing all the testimony and most especially um from superintendents and people that live in districts that are uh basically remote mr hart do you think that uh this could possibly open up the door uh for some more consolidation talk and issues we've gone through that before so after hearing that it makes you think that uh you know you want to make some of these districts, or some of these people in these districts just have a better opportunity. Do you think you had to open up the door for that? I think the possibility is
▶ Play
Speaker 327 1:54:13
there. As you continue to take state dollars away, you're going to have to find to do more with less, and that's where we got into the situation where we had to consolidate school districts. So I think it's very real and very possible. Thank you. Representative Lowry. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
following up on your all means all statement and we're all about wanting to give the best opportunity to students does uh along those lines does does the hope school district allow school choice for the students no sir it does not we claim an exemption through a federal
▶ Play
Speaker 327 1:54:43
desegregation order okay so in that case all does not mean all in terms of
▶ Play
allowing students to have opportunity i'll i'll leave that to the federal judge i generally don't argue with
▶ Play
Speaker 327 1:54:53
those folks okay Thank you. Representative Meeks, you recognize me. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
▶ Play
One of the arguments that we've heard this morning against is the concern about public school funding. The state currently invests $2.5 billion every year, roughly half of general revenues, into public education. Every year that I've been in the legislature, we have increased funding, including this biennium, to education. The fiscal impact on this bill, $6.5 million, obviously not jump change, But in the grand scheme of things, it's very tiny compared to what we're asking compared to the public school funds. This General Assembly has done nothing to indicate that we're going to send less money to public schools. So could you please talk to us about why we continue to hear this fear that we're taking money away from public schools when this bill does not do that and the General Assembly has never indicated that we're reducing or
▶ Play
Speaker 327 1:55:55
taking money away from any public school? Yes, sir, I'd be glad to answer that. I think if you go back and look at the past history of the last two sessions alone, you've gotten reports from Auden and Pacas and adequacy reports that indicated at least a 2.4% increase in funding, and you've funded in this session, or past sessions, excuse me, a .9 increase in funding. So the tendency there is not to adequately fund. It's to pay just enough to survive and advance. All right. Well, time's up. Thank you. All right.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:56:27
Our last testimony is from Charles Williams to speak
▶ Play
for the bill. And then we will allow for Mr. Dodson to close after that. State your name and
▶ Play
Speaker 332 1:56:53
who you're with, and you're recognized. I'm a matter-of-fact person. Please
▶ Play
Speaker 335 1:56:58
state your name and who you're with. My name is Dr. Charles E. Williams. I'm a community active pastor of 45 years. We have had superintendents up to testify about failing schools, And this is what this bill is all about, is giving parents a choice and giving children a chance. We've got to get these kids out of these failing schools. When the impact hit Little Rock and we discovered we were operating the largest system that was failing, and now they're asking the citizenry to give them more money to further the matter of failing schools. I was hoping Mr. Walker and some of these advocates in here now would speak up against when our public school had to be put on probation in Little Rock, but I heard it doesn't problem. And I'm trying to see the greatest traffic that we can ever give is to send a child to a school that is failing. And we ought to be ashamed of ourselves, and I'm asking this committee, let's pass this bill because there's a need for it. you juggling money but what about these kids lives thank you mr. chairman
▶ Play
Speaker 333 1:58:17
all right are there any questions see see
▶ Play
represent Walker you recognize I thank you dr. Williams I appreciate your coming and in terms of your representations regarding advocacy for equal and full schools I I think it's It's fair to say in the words of a song that has these words, you will never, never know
▶ Play
Speaker 335 1:58:43
me. Oh, you made millions off of school systems. We know that. We know you.
▶ Play
Absolutely unfair and wrong. But you entitle your opinion. Well, you are. Okay, okay. As you seek. Point
▶ Play
of order. No opinions here. Representative Hodges, you're recognized. Or you have one? No, that was a point of order. Point of order. I'm glad. We think we all got it about the same time. Reps and Gates.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. So I assume that you currently have a school system for educating people. No, I think choice is the principal
▶ Play
Speaker 335 1:59:19
thing. Parents ought to have a choice. My question
▶ Play
is this. Children ought to have a chance. My question is this. If we give parents the ability to choose the best course of action for their children, when that money goes to educate that kid and that those parents are satisfied with the results of that education have we not best served that child by giving the parents the ability that in the interest of their child how to best educate them and if it means moving them to homeschooled or private schooled or a different school or or additional school that we've not met the needs of that child short-term and long-term? Of course. I think that parents
▶ Play
Speaker 335 2:00:06
should have the right to choose what school, but if you're talking about constantly sending a child to a school that has failed, that's unfair. Nobody in this room will admit that it's right to send a child to a failing school.
▶ Play
Speaker 333 2:00:21
Give the parents a choice. Committee, I'm
▶ Play
going to ask that you all will start your deals out with a question, not a question, and a double question. Please. Representative McElroy, you're recognized. Do you
▶ Play
have children in the public school district here in Lower
▶ Play
Speaker 335 2:00:38
Ones? I took my child and sent him to the Episcopal School and said to them, don't give him anything. If he doesn't earn it, he graduated cum laude. We refuse to send our children to the failing system. Any other questions? Seeing none,
▶ Play
thank you, sir. Representative Dotson, would you like to close for your
▶ Play
bill? If he didn't, he did. Thank you, Mr. Chair, committee. I know we've been here quite a while, and I'll be brief. I just wanted to point out something somebody had asked me over the course of testimony. I wanted to clarify that one of the eligible expenses is in the bill that up to 10% of the funds can be used to help offset the cost of computer hardware or software and other technological devices. So really the emphasis in the bill on the student being able to get all of their educational needs is hopefully accomplished with that sort of an expense eligibility in the bill. I think as far as this bill is concerned, it is designed with the unique needs of the individual students in mind. Please think if you will for a second of a parent and their student and what this option could mean for that individual student who receives an ESA and their family. This is a program not everyone will use, obviously not everyone wants, but I ask you to think about those kids the one kid that if they get this ESA that that child will be able to use that parent and that family will be able to use for the educational needs of their student and the impact that will be not only in their education today but for the next generation of their family I appreciate a good vote.
▶ Play
Representative Lowry, I believe, has a motion. Yes, motion do pass. All right. Group, we have a motion of do pass. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. No. Let me get my back on the ayes. Have it. Congratulations, you passed your bill. And we do
▶ Play
Speaker 344 2:03:21
have a roll call. Representative Meeks Aye Representative Deffenbaugh No Representative Eubanks Aye Representative Walker No Representative Lowry Yes Representative McElroy No Representative McGill No Representative Davis Yes Representative De La Rosa? Representative De La Rosa? Representative Hodges? Representative Beck? Representative Sullivan? Representative Speaks? Representative Speaks? Representative Gates? Representative Vought Representative Vought Representative Starch Representative Kavanaugh Representative Barker
▶ Play
Speaker 351 2:04:31
Representative Douglas Congratulations, you passed your bill Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee. That was great. Yes, sir.
▶ Play
Speaker 352 2:04:57
You got 12. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10. I count 12, sir, so yes, sir. What I counted? I have to go on any further now. No, sir. Any other business come for the committee? We had already changed our mind. They changed their mind. I appreciate it. No, yeah. No, no, no, no. I don't know.
▶ Play

Agenda

SPECIAL ORDER OF BUSINESS - MARCH 9, 2017, 10:00 AM

Number Subtitle Sponsor

RE-REFERRED TO COMMITTEE

Subtitle Number Sponsor

HB1611 Tucker CONCERNING THE BASIC LANGUAGE OF INSTRUCTION IN PUBLIC SCHOOLS.

REGULAR AGENDA Subtitle Number Sponsor

HB1575 Lowery TO LIMIT THE AMOUNT OF FUND BALANCES A SCHOOL DISTRICT MAY MAINTAIN.

HB1583 Dotson TO CREATE RECALL ELECTIONS FOR MEMBERS OF SCHOOL DISTRICT BOARDS OF DIRECTORS; AND TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING SCHOOL DISTRICT BOARDS OF DIRECTORS.

HB1608 Della Rosa CONCERNING THE ACCOUNTABILITY SYSTEM DEVELOPED BY THE STATE OF ARKANSAS UNDER THE EVERY STUDENT SUCCEEDS ACT.

HB1610 Tucker TO PROVIDE ARKANSAS BETTER CHANCE PROGRAMS LOCATED WITHIN A SCHOOL DISTRICT FUNDING EQUAL TO THE FOUNDATION FUNDING AMOUNT FOR EACH EARLY GRADUATE OF THE PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT.

HB1621 Lowery TO CHANGE THE DATE OF THE ANNUAL SCHOOL ELECTION.

HB1646 Cozart TO AMEND VARIOUS PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING PUBLIC EDUCATION.

HB1666 Sabin TO REQUIRE INSTITUTIONS OF HIGHER EDUCATION TO PROVIDE INFORMATION ON MENTAL HEALTH AND SUICIDE PREVENTION SERVICES TO ENTERING STUDENTS.

HB1671 Tucker TO GIVE CHARTER SCHOOLS AUTHORITY TO WEIGHT ADMISSION LOTTERIES AT THEIR DISCRETION.

HB1672 Tucker CONCERNING ADMISSIONS POLICIES OF CHARTER SCHOOLS; AND TO ALIGN CHARTER SCHOOL ADMISSIONS REQUIREMENTS FOR A STUDENT WHO HAS BEEN EXPELLED FROM ANOTHER SCHOOL DISTRICT WITH ADMISSIONS REQUIREMENTS FOR SCHOOL DISTRICTS.

HB1673 Tucker CONCERNING APPLICATIONS FOR OR AMENDMENTS OF PUBLIC CHARTERS UNDER THE ARKANSAS QUALITY CHARTER SCHOOLS ACT OF 2013.

HB1674 Tucker TO CREATE A COMMUNITY PUBLIC EDUCATION BOARD.

HB1689 Cozart TO AMEND PROVISIONS CONCERNING PUBLIC SCHOOL FUNDING AND INDEBTEDNESS; TO AMEND FUNDING PROVISIONS CONCERNING PUBLIC EMPLOYEE HEALTH INSURANCE; AND TO AMEND PROVISIONS CONCERNING EDUCATION SERVICE COOPERATIVE FINANCING.

HB1701 Love TO ESTABLISH A PILOT PROGRAM TO MAKE GRANTS TO HISTORICALLY BLACK COLLEGES AND UNIVERSITIES TO PROVIDE EDUCATIONAL PROGRAMS TO OFFENDERS WHO ARE RECENTLY RELEASED OR SOON-TO-BE RELEASED FROM INCARCERATION.

HB1710 S. Meeks TO REVISE THE CIVICS AND WORLD HISTORY REQUIREMENTS TO GRADUATE FROM HIGH SCHOOL.

SB26 A. Clark TO INCREASE TEACHERS IN HIGH NEEDS SUBJECT AREAS; AND TO PROVIDE ENHANCED ARKANSAS ACADEMIC CHALLENGE SCHOLARSHIPS FOR TEACHERS WHO AGREE TO TEACH IN THE HIGH NEEDS SUBJECT AREAS.

SB27 A. Clark TO INCREASE THE NUMBER OF TEACHERS IN A CRITICAL TEACHER SHORTAGE AREA; AND TO ESTABLISH THE TEACHER CANDIDATE LOAN FORGIVENESS PROGRAM.

SB337 Hester TO REPEAL THE ACADEMIC FACILITIES EXTRAORDINARY CIRCUMSTANCES PROGRAM.

HB1738 C. Douglas CONCERNING ETHICS OF MEMBERS OF A BOARD OF DIRECTORS OF A PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT; AND TO CREATE THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS ETHICS REVIEW BOARD.

HB1740 Lowery CONCERNING THE ENROLLMENT OR RE-ENROLLMENT OF A HOME-SCHOOLED STUDENT IN A PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT.

HB1791 Tucker TO ESTABLISH A FOOD PANTRY MATCHING GRANT PROGRAM TO BE ADMINISTERED BY THE DEPARTMENT OF HIGHER EDUCATION.

HB1802 Lundstrum TO ALLOW CONTRIBUTIONS BY AN ARKANSAS TAXPAYER TO A TAX-DEFERRED TUITION SAVINGS PROGRAM ESTABLISHED BY ANOTHER STATE TO BE DEDUCTED FROM A TAXPAYER'S INCOME TAX.

HB1805 Sturch TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING POSTSECONDARY COURSES IN UNITED STATES HISTORY, UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT, AND THE UNITED STATES CONSTITUTION.

HB1820 Dotson CONCERNING SCHOOL DISTRICT WAIVERS; TO REQUIRE THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION TO GRAN A SCHOOL DISTRICT WAIVER PETITION IF AN OPEN-ENROLLMENT PUBLIC CHARTER SCHOOL DRAWING STUDENTS FROM THE SCHOOL DISTRICT WAS GRANTED A WAIVER.

HB1831 Leding TO ALLOW AN OPEN-ENROLLMENT PUBLIC CHARTER SCHOOL TO USE A WEIGHTED LOTTERY IN ITS ADMISSIONS PROCESS BASED ON CERTAIN STUDENT CHARACTERISTICS.

HB1834K. Hendren TO PROHIBIT A PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT OR OPEN-ENROLLMENT PUBLIC CHARTER SCHOOL FROM INCLUDING IN ITS CURRICULUM OR COURSE MATERIALS FOR A PROGRAM OF STUDY BOOKS OR ANY OTHER MATERIAL AUTHORED BY OR CONCERNING HOWARD ZINN.

SB329 A. Clark TO RAISE THE PRICE THRESHOLD FOR THE PURCHASE OF COMMODITIES THAT SCHOOL DISTRICTS MUST PROCURE BY SOLICITING BIDS; AND TO PROVIDE FOR ANNUAL ADJUSTMENTS IN THE PURCHASE PRICE THRESHOLD BASED ON INFLATION.

SB427 Hickey TO AMEND THE POWERS AND AUTHORITY OF THE SECTION 529 PLAN REVIEW COMMITTEE AND THE INDIVIDUAL MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

HB1874 Lundstrum TO ALLOW CONTRIBUTIONS BY A TAXPAYER TO A TAX-DEFERRED TUITION SAVINGS PROGRAM ESTABLISHED IN ANOTHER STATE TO BE DEDUCTED FROM AN ARKANSAS TAXPAYER'S INCOME TAX.

HB1897 Baltz TO REQUIRE STATE-SUPPORTED INSTITUTIONS OF HIGHER EDUCATION TO OFFER TO THEIR STUDENTS A PANIC BUTTON ALERT SYSTEM.

HB1898 Baltz TO REQUIRE STATE-SUPPORTED INSTITUTIONS OF HIGHER EDUCATION TO OFFER STATE EMPLOYEES AND THEIR DEPENDENTS A REDUCED TUITION RATE.

HB1905 C. Douglas CONCERNING DELAY OF OPENING OR EARLY RELEASE OF SCHOOL.

HB1907 C.Douglas TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING THE ACADEMIC FACILITIES PARTNERSHIP PROGRAM.

HB1917 Walker TO LIMIT THE SALARY AMOUNT OF AN ADMINISTRATOR IN A PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT.

HR1040 Warren CELEBRATING THE LAKESIDE LEGACY PROGRAM.

Warrem

2:33 - -43:20

The committee unanimously approved House Resolution 1040, recognizing the Lakeside Legacy Program partnership between Lakeside High School, Hot Springs and National Park College, after a motion to pass was made and a voice vote recorded as “aye” with no opposition. [2:51] [3:10] [3:21] [3:51] [4:22] [4:27]

Representative Rick Beck then introduced House Bill 1222, the Arkansas Parental Empowerment for Education Choice Act of 2017, describing an education-savings-account system funded by private contributions that qualify for a 65 % state tax credit, capped at $6.5 million in the second year and limited to a 1 % annual award per district. [4:53] [5:27] [5:57] [6:30] [7:04] [7:37] [9:20]

Committee members questioned the bill’s budget impact, student-transfer limits, tax-credit mechanics, eligibility age (up to 22), priority enrollment (low-income, military-dependent, siblings, then lottery), and how funds would be disbursed directly by nonprofits or reimbursed rather than paid to parents, noted the governor’s neutral stance, and discussed why the ESA model was chosen over expanding the existing Succeed Scholarship, citing examples from other states and emphasizing service to poverty-affected students. [8:15] [8:47] [8:58] [9:01] [9:20] [9:53] [10:49] [11:00] [11:33] [11:58] [12:53] [13:15] [13:47] [14:40] [14:50] [15:28] [15:35] [15:38] [15:45] [16:01] [22:08] [22:13] [22:48] [23:21] [23:37] [24:22] [24:51] [24:55] [25:23] [25:38] [26:44] [27:23] [27:57] [28:28] [30:44] [31:04] [31:10] [31:17] [31:49] [32:04] [32:08] [32:22] [32:47]

Testimony from a range of stakeholders-including supporters such as Virginia Walden Ford and Dr. Charles E. Williams and opponents such as Superintendent Bobby Hart and Representative Stephen Meeks-debated accountability mechanisms, potential segregation, rural school consolidation, and cited the fiscal impact statement showing a $6.5 million reduction in general revenues in FY 19 rising to $7.1 million in FY 20. [55:47] [56:17] [56:31] [56:36] [56:45] [56:49] [1:02:24] [1:02:56] [1:03:31] [1:04:06] [1:04:34] [1:04:37] [1:04:41] [1:05:08] [1:05:39] [1:05:45] [1:06:05] [1:06:10] [1:06:42] [1:07:08] [1:07:23] [1:07:45] [1:08:00] [1:08:06] [1:08:32] [1:09:02] [1:09:41] [1:14:30] [1:15:09] [1:15:40] [1:16:11] [1:16:29] [1:16:32] [1:16:38] [1:16:42] [1:17:15] [1:17:19] [1:17:46] [1:17:57] [1:18:20] [1:18:37] [1:18:45] [1:18:58] [1:19:35] [1:20:04] [1:20:08] [1:20:39] [1:21:11] [1:21:50] [1:22:27] [1:23:01] [1:23:18] [1:23:25] [1:23:36] [1:23:50] [1:23:56] [1:24:05] [1:24:10] [1:24:30] [1:24:41] [1:24:55] [1:25:13] [1:25:44] [1:26:19]

The committee then announced the end of the testimony period, indicating that no motions or votes were taken at this stage and moving the bill forward for further consideration. [58:49] [58:59] [59:30] [1:00:02]

After a motion by Representative Mark Lowery to pass the legislation, the committee voted, recording ayes from several members and nos from others, with at least twelve affirmative votes, resulting in the passage of HP 1222. [2:02:54] [2:02:59] [2:03:21] [2:03:31] [2:04:01] [2:04:31] [2:04:57]

HB1924 C. Douglas TO ADD THE CLASSIC LEARNING TEST AS AN ALLOWABLE COLLEGE ENTRY EXAMINATION FOR THE PURPOSE OF RECEIVING RECEIVING SCHOLARSHIPS.

HB2095 G. Hodges TO ESTABLISH VOTE CENTERS ON THE CAMPUSES OF STATE-SUPPORTED POSTSECONDARY AND HIGHER EDUCATION INSTITUTIONS; AND TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING VOTE CENTERS.

-43:20 - 2:05:08 420 segments 54 speakers

The chair, Rep. Bruce Cozart, called the meeting to order, confirmed a quorum, and announced that the committee would hear Senate Bill 427 - a cleanup bill for the treasurer’s office. [0:00]

Grant Wallace, chief deputy treasurer, presented SB 427, explaining that it codifies the treasurer’s day-to-day management authority over the 529 college-savings program and permits committee members to expend appropriated funds for program promotion activities. [0:39] [0:52] [1:14]

Rep. Stephen Meeks asked whether there is accountability for those expenditures, and Wallace responded that the board would oversee and monitor the use of any appropriated funds. [1:49] [2:12] [2:20]

HB2207 Boyd TO ABOLISH THE ALLOCATION OF ENROLLMENT POSITIONS AT THE UNIVERSITY OF ARKANSAS COLLEGE OF MEDICINE BASED ON CONGRESSIONAL DISTRICT AND ARKANSAS RESIDENCY.

HB2243 Davis TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING SCHOLARSHIP PROGRAMS.

SB519 D. Wallace TO AMEND TITLE 6 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING EDUCATION REQUIREMENTS FOR HISTORY N THE CLASSROOM; AND TO EFFECT A SEPARATE HOLIDAY FOR DR. MARTIN LUTHER KING JR.

SB178 Files TO DELAY THE INCLUSION OF A SCORE ON THE WRITING PORTION OF THE ACT ASPIRE ASSESSMENT IN A DETERMINATION OF THE ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE OF A STUDENT, PUBLIC SCHOOL, OR PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT.

HB1517 A. Mayberry CONCERNING SCHOOL NURSING AND TO MODIFY THE REQUIREMENTS FOR A SCHOOL NURSE.

HB1457 C. Douglas TO ALLOW A PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT AND AN OPEN-ENROLLMENT PUBLIC CHARTER SCHOOL TO DEVELOP A PLAN FOR THE USE OF AN ALTERNATIVE METHOD OF INSTRUCTION TO BE USED ON DAYS WHEN SCHOOL IS CANCELLED.

HB1459 C. Douglas TO PROVIDE FLEXIBILITY IN THE AWARDING OF COURSE CREDITS; AND TO ALLOW A PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT TO DEVELOP AND IMPLEMENT A PLAN THAT ENABLES A

MATTER TO EARN COURSE CREDITS BY DEMONSTRATING SUBJECT STUDENT COMPETENCY.

HB1576 C. Douglas TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ACADEMIC FACILITIES PARTNERSHIP PROGRAM CONCERNING APPROVED BUT UNFUNDED NEW CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS.

HB1579 Vaught TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING BACKGROUND CHECKS FOR PUBLIC SCHOOL EDUCATORS AND EMPLOYEES.

HB1607 Della Rosa TO LIMIT THE USE OF AN ENGLISH LANGUAGE LEARNER'S SCORE ON A STATE- MANDATED ASSESSMENT FOR PUBLIC SCHOOL AND PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT ACCOUNTABILITY PURPOSES.

HB1648 C. Douglas TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING PUBLIC SCHOOL ACCOUNTABILITY.

HB1856 F. Allen TO ESTABLISH THE ARKANSAS EARLY LITERACY ASSESSMENT PROCUREMENT ACT.

HB1925 C. Douglas TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING PUBLIC SCHOOL ACADEMIC FACILITY REVIEW CONFERENCES.

HB1929 Cozart TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING THE ADVISORY COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SCHOOL ACADEMIC FACILITIES.

HB1934 Lowery TO ENSURE THAT PERSONALLY IDENTIFIABLE INFORMATION NOF STUDENTS IS PROTECTED.

HB1936 Lowery TO REVISE THE ACADEMIC FACILITIES WEALTH INDEX.

HB1995 Della Rosa TO AMEND THE OFFICIAL HOLIDAYS; TO REFINE THE TEACHING OF HISTORY IN THE CLASSROOM; TO SPECIFY THE TEACHING OF CONTENT RELATED TO DR. MARTIN LUTHER KING JR. IN CONJUNCTION WITH THE CORRESPONDING HOLIDAY.

HB2117 Sorvillo TO REQUIRE CAMERAS IN CERTAIN CONTAINED SPECIAL EDUCATION CLASSROOMS UPON REQUEST.

HB1017 Cozart TO ALLOW THE TEACHER FAIR DISMISSAL ACT OF 1983 TO BE WAIVED IF A PUBLIC SCHOOL OR PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT IS UNDER STATE AUTHORITY AFTER BEING CLASSIFIED AS BEING IN DISTRESS.

HB1020 Love TO CREATE THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY PROMISE LOTTERY SCHOLARSHIP PROGRAM; TO PROVIDE FUNDS TO EVERY CHILD BORN IN ARKANSAS TO BE USED FOR COLLEGE TUITION.

HB1027 Eubanks TO PROHIBIT A SCHOOL DISTRICT FROM USING PUBLIC FUNDS TO PAY A TEACHER'S OR CLASSIFIED EMPLOYEE'S MEMBERSHIP DUES IN A PROFESSIONAL ORGANIZATION.

HB1029 Lowery TO EXCLUDE PRINCIPALS, ASSISTANT PRINCIPALS, AND CENTRAL OFFICE EMPLOYEES WITH A MULTIYEAR EMPLOYMENT CONTRACT FROM THE DEFINITION OF "TEACHER UNDER THE TEACHER FAIR DISMISSAL ACT OF 1983.

HB1044 F. Allen TO ALLOW A STUDENT TO CHOOSE WHICH GRADE IN WHICH TO TAKE THE COLLEGE AND CAREER READINESS ASSESSMENT.

HB1408 C.Douglas CONCERNING WHO MAY SERVE AS A PROCTOR OF A TEST OR ASSESSMENT ADMINISTERED UNDER THE ARKANSAS COMPREHENSIVE TESTING, ASSESSMENT, AND ACCOUNTABILITY PROGRAM ACT.

HB1456 C. Douglas TO ALLOW A SCHOOL DISTRICT TO WAIVE PHYSICAL EDUCATION REQUIREMENTS FOR A STUDENT WHO PROVIDES PROOF OF PHYSICAL ACTIVITY; AND TO EXEMPT A STUDENT WITH A PHYSICAL EDUCATION WAIVER FROM PHYSICAL EDUCATION GRADUATION REQUIREMENTS.

HB1458 C. Douglas TO REQUIRE A STUDENT TO PARTICIPATE IN VISUAL ARTS OR PERFORMING ARTS IN EITHER GRADE SEVEN OR GRADE EIGHT.

HB1510 Gonzales TO CREATE THE DEMOGRAPHIC PREFERENCE DISCLOSURE ACT.

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Bruce Cozart Chair Unverified
58 segments
Chair Unverified
7 segments
Speaker 15
4 segments
Representative Stephen Meeks Unverified
21 segments
Representative Les Warren Unverified
4 segments
Representative Rick Beck Chair Unverified
85 segments
Representative Monte Hodges Unverified
32 segments
Representative John W. Walker Unverified
44 segments
Representative Jon S. Eubanks Unverified
6 segments
Representative Gary Deffenbaugh Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 79
1 segment
Speaker 83
1 segment
Representative Dan Sullivan Unverified
6 segments
Representative Mark Lowery Unverified
13 segments
Speaker 126
1 segment
Speaker 131
1 segment
Speaker 100
1 segment
Speaker 137
1 segment
Speaker 141
3 segments
Speaker 49
2 segments
Representative Mark D. McElroy Unverified
9 segments
Representative Andy Davis Unverified
5 segments
Representative George B. McGill Chair Unverified
7 segments
Speaker 185
2 segments
Representative Aaron Pilkington Unverified
6 segments
Speaker 189
1 segment
Representative Frances Cavenaugh Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 115
1 segment
Patrick Wolfe Unverified
10 segments
Dale Query Unverified
9 segments
Speaker 77
1 segment
Speaker 261
1 segment
Angela Johnson Unverified
7 segments
Andrew Bagley Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 193
1 segment
Paul Calvert Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 290
1 segment
Alyssa Lawland Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 304
9 segments
Speaker 213
1 segment
Representative Jim Dotson Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 313
2 segments
Speaker 314
9 segments
Speaker 318
1 segment
Speaker 325
1 segment
Speaker 327
9 segments
Speaker 332
1 segment
Speaker 335
9 segments
Speaker 333
2 segments
Speaker 344
3 segments
Speaker 351
1 segment
Speaker 352
2 segments