Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

Education Committee

March 14, 2017 ·Committee Room 138 ·1:29:29
Video Transcript

Summary

Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 13, 2026

SB519 TO AMEND TITLE 6 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING EDUCATION REQUIREMENTS FOR HISTORY IN THE CLASSROOM; AND TO EFFECT A SEPARATE HOLIDAY FOR DR. MARTIN LUT… 0:53

Representative Monte Hodges introduced Senate Bill 519, which would create a separate state holiday for Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., retain a day of proclamation for General Robert E. Lee, and add a curriculum-development component on both figures and related history. [0:58] [1:03] [1:40] [2:15] [2:46] [3:19] [3:50] [4:21] [4:52] [5:26]

Governor Asa Hutchinson and Committee Chair Representative Bruce Cozart testified in strong support, arguing that the bill balances historical recognition, promotes unity, and could enhance Arkansas’s image and economic development. [6:07] [6:30] [7:04] [7:40] [8:14] [8:47] [9:22] [9:56] [10:27]

Committee members raised substantive questions about the necessity of date changes, potential economic impact, mixed public-opinion polling, and possible compromises, while public testimony included opposition from former Marine Robert Freeman, who said the bill diminishes Lee’s legacy, and support from the Arkansas NAACP president emphasizing cultural sensitivity and the need to separate the holidays. [11:11] [11:36] [11:39] [12:06] [12:32] [12:36] [13:08] [13:44] [14:15] [14:48] [18:31] [18:47] [19:22] [19:52] [19:58] [20:07] [20:33] [20:58] [21:38] [22:11] [22:42] [22:55] [23:09] [23:16] [23:25] [23:49] [27:44] [28:03] [28:11] [28:43] [29:02] [29:13] [29:43] [30:37] [31:18] [31:50] [32:26] [32:51] [32:59] [33:17] [33:29] [33:38] [33:43] [33:56] [34:02] [34:34] [35:08] [35:45] [36:17] [36:51] [37:23] [37:55] [38:32] [39:05] [39:40] [40:13] [40:45] [41:17] [41:51] [42:25]

Additional witnesses such as Mark Johnson suggested a reconciliation commission and a joint commemorative day, Representative John W. Walker questioned equating Lee’s military role with King’s moral leadership and raised concerns about racial representation, and opponents like Robert Edwards and Reginald Murdock argued the bill would eliminate the Lee holiday and advocated for a split or retention of both holidays. [55:14] [55:45] [56:17] [56:51] [57:24] [57:59] [58:34] [59:13] [59:44] [1:00:18] [1:00:51] [1:01:25] [1:01:55] [1:02:53] [1:03:02] [1:03:37] [1:04:08] [1:04:39] [1:05:13] [1:05:44] [1:07:35] [1:07:55] [1:08:32] [1:09:03] [1:09:38] [1:10:05] [1:10:09] [1:10:13] [1:10:40] [1:11:16] [1:11:52] [1:12:28] [1:12:59] [1:13:32] [1:14:02] [1:14:38] [1:15:09] [1:15:43] [1:22:06] [1:22:16] [1:22:48] [1:23:20] [1:23:51] [1:24:26] [1:24:59] [1:25:29]

Supporters, including Senator Jim Hendren and Representative Monte Hodges, emphasized the educational benefits of separating the holidays, urged unity, and moved the measure forward, which was approved by a voice vote after a motion to deem it passed. [1:16:21] [1:16:47] [1:17:19] [1:17:52] [1:18:23] [1:19:00] [1:19:32] [1:20:05] [1:20:35] [1:21:08] [1:26:03] [1:26:30] [1:27:01] [1:27:40] [1:28:11] [1:28:44] [1:29:09] [1:29:16]

Bills discussed (1)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
SB519 · 4 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB519 TO AMEND TITLE 6 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING EDUCATION…”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 13, 2026
I'd like to call this meeting to order. Thank you, everybody, for being here today. I am going to ask the audience to please refrain from any outbursts, No clapping, no talking, yelling, screaming, crying, all those things. That could happen. And also from the committee members, please don't do those either. So anyway, we're only going to plan on hearing one bill today. I believe it might take longer than we probably want to be here anyway, and I do apologize for the inconvenience of the late hour. The session went a little longer than we thought today. So being all of
▶ Play
that heard, Representative Hodges, you are recognized to present Senate Bill 519.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair, and thank you, committee. It's been an honor to serve on this committee for both of my terms, and I appreciate you all letting me bring this bill to you today. Most of you are probably familiar with it. You probably have seen it in the newspapers. so you're familiar with mostly what it does but it's an important bill and it's one i'm proud to be running today i think this is something that's past due that we should separate the holidays recognizing general lee and dr king personally both of these men are important to me they're important to our country and and to our history but i think they're important for different reasons and they're important to our history in different ways. They represent different times in our country's history, and I think they represent different things to people. And I think we should recognize both of these men, give them their due, appreciate what they did for this country, learn from them what they did right, what they did wrong, but do so on a day that recognizes them in their own right. i am the great grand great great grandson of a confederate veteran so you know this is something that's personally important to me i represent uh peerage national military park is in my district obviously a reminder of the war and the people that gave their lives there and and died for what they believed in. I haven't been able to confirm it, but an elderly relative of mine who we just lost this year told me that I have relatives who fought on that battlefield that I now represent. I've got a friend who lives in Biloxi, Mississippi, and I've been down to Jefferson Davis's house twice now. I've toured the facility. I've been to the Confederate at a museum down there, learned about the war and Mr. Davis and General Lee. So the history of our state, the history of our country, it's something I'm familiar with, I really care about, and I think we should honor. And in no way are we attempting to dishonor that history with this bill today. In the same way, I think Dr. King and the way that he led in the civil rights movement really had a profound impact on this country and in our state and on me, and I don't think I have to recount all the reasons that we should appreciate Dr. King and the movement that he led. I think that probably goes without saying, but I think his contributions to this country and to our state and to our discourse and all the rights that we all now get to enjoy mean that we should recognize Dr. King on his own day without him having to share it with anyone else to show our appreciation for what he's done for us. One thing I wanted to emphasize, the reason we're in the Education Committee today is because this bill does include an education component, and I think it's really important. You can look in the bill and see on pages 2 and 3 it outlines what we're going to be doing in regards to education, but the key takeaway here is that really for the first time, we're ensuring that from this point forward, young people in the state of Arkansas will be learning about the history, about these two men and about the issues that they dealt with. and the course content developed to teach those subjects will have to come in front of this committee as i said i've been on this committee both of my terms i would like to return next term if i'm lucky enough to have one but whatever contents develop whatever we want to teach our kids whatever the education department comes up with will be presented to this committee and we can make sure that going forward young people in arkansas are taught the history that they need to learn. That's something that we're not really guaranteeing today, but if this bill passes going forward, we can have that guarantee, and I think it's important that our students really get to learn the history of the Civil War, of the Civil Rights Movement, of Dr. King, and of General Lee. We are blessed today to have a guest here who has endorsed and supports this bill, and with that, with your permission, I'd like to turn it over to our Governor, the Honorable Asa Hutchinson.
▶ Play
Governor, I just ask you to state your name and who you are for the
▶ Play
record, and you are welcome to speak. Asa Hutchinson, Governor of Arkansas. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm delighted to appear before the committee. Committee members, thank you for your courtesy in extending me as the executive branch. It's the honor to appear before you and to speak on behalf of this bill. I want to express my appreciation to Representative Hodges for his leadership and hard work on this bill. The last session of the legislature, this bill came up. It was probably in this committee. and I stayed in my office upstairs quietly for the bill that gave Dr. King a holiday, but I had other priorities in that session, and I did not lift a finger to help that. And I said if it comes up again that I wanted, I believe it is important enough for me to be here to support it and to ask your support for it as well. I believe that this is important because we all have a shared history. As Grant mentioned, I live just a few miles down from the Pea Ridge National Military Park. My ancestor, Colonel Alexander Simpson Hutchinson, from Nashville, Howard County, Arkansas, served in the Confederate States of America. I love the Civil War battlefields because it's a time of reflection. It's a time of history. You see the division in our country. You see extraordinary times of leadership, and you learn from that. And that's why this education bill, I think, is important, because it's an education bill that emphasizes for our students that you can look at the leadership qualities, challenges, and lessons from the Civil War and learn from it. And it's balanced with an emphasis on another moment in history. And as I mentioned the Civil War, history marches on, and it marched on, and it marched on, and thank God for the Civil Rights Movement of the 1960s, in which, again, too many were silent. But during that time, there was a courageous man, Dr. King, that not only set an example of courage and commitment to justice and equality, but he actually gave his life for that cause. And I think it was a singular moment that deserves a single day of recognition for his contributions to making America a better place. And so it's not a diminution of one person over another. It's saying there's a contribution that I think, whether it's General Lee or my ancestors, would look upon the march of history and say this is the right thing to do. right thing to do. And so that is really the case I make is that this, I believe, is the right thing to do in terms of history, in terms of recognition of a historic figure, but also for the unity of Arkansas. I think this does help unify our state. I think it recognizes the contributions and extraordinary time in Arkansas history of Dr. King. And so I do think that it is important. It does provide teaching of both those in the Civil War and the leadership principles of that in our schools, and also Dr. King and the civil rights area and other civil rights leaders that can be taught in the school, and that's why it is an education bill. I know that some of you have expressed reservation. Some of it is out of just, well, maybe there's a better way. Maybe we could find a different day that we could recognize General Lee, and we don't just like the date that you've chosen. Well, it was a date that is a memory of the day of his death, and we celebrate people's death. We remember them, whether it's All Saints Day or whether it's a continuity of life and the elevation that someone enters eternity. And so it is a day of significance that we would be remembering Robert E. Lee. But it's not a holiday. Absolutely, it's not a holiday. This is about a separate day for Dr. King and then a day of proclamation and recognition for General Lee. It provides that education. I would ask you that if you are, I know many of you support this and will support it, but some have reservations, but I would urge you that this is of such import to the people of Arkansas that it deserves a vote on the full House and our Assembly. And so I'm asking your support for it, your recognition of it, the importance of Arkansas and our future. It is a moment of history recognizing an individual that changed America for the good.
▶ Play
Thank you. You ready for questions? All right. Representative Sullivan, you're
▶ Play
recognized for a question. Thank you. Representative Hodges, I'm one of the ones that has some reservations. as you have been mentioned, you know, is it possible for one to support the educational and the importance and recognize the importance that's been demonstrated here today of both the parties but still oppose the changing of the dates?
▶ Play
Speaker 26 11:36
Well, he asked that to you. I'd be
▶ Play
happy to answer any question. I mean, I think all of us are kind of in that pretty close to the same place. We recognize the great accomplishments of Dr. King and certainly the impact it's had on the people of Arkansas. We recognize the need to have that entered into the curriculum and have that taught in school. We recognize the value that Arkansans put on their history and their culture, and some do. And when I hear from my constituents, that's one of the things that they bring up is let's just leave it the way it is and go ahead and change the curricular part, change the education part, and honor the men and their accomplishments without touching the day. And my question is, is it possible for one to support the things that you're doing educationally but still be opposed to changing the
▶ Play
day? Representative Hodges, will you yield? Sure. Well, certainly. That could be in your heart, and it's just not in this bill. This bill is an educational bill that also separates the day and gives Dr. King a day of recognition into self, which is a national holiday. And so to me that stands alone. And so when you vote on this bill, you either got to vote, yes, we're going to give them a separate holiday, or no, we're not. And I think it's important, this was posted, I understand, on Facebook, that the Mosaic Templars Cultural Center that was closed on that holiday and it says that it's closed Monday, Robert E. Lee's birthday, and it shows the incrogrity of having the same celebration on the same date. And I think that that, to me, is the issue here in this bill. Clearly, it's an education bill that gives an opportunity to teach lessons of civil rights and the Civil War leadership in our classroom, but it also is a day of separation so that they would have separate days of recognition.
▶ Play
Representative Meeks, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, Representative. Thank you, Governor. And I'm going to ask a tough question here, and that's what I get paid the big bucks for. We definitely honor both these men and both the accomplishments that they have both produced and the differences that they've made in all of our lives as far as that goes. But the unfortunate truth is to the average Arkansan, they probably really don't care very much about this issue. Half of them, they see it as an extra day off of work that they get on a Monday in January for the bankers and government employees, and the other half of the Arkansans are upset that they don't get the day off that everybody else gets. and so the question that I have is you know we talked about the importance of these two men having a separate day or you've talked about the importance of these two men having having a separate day for the average Arkansan or maybe I can back up a little bit we have tackled a lot of tough questions this session and I've actually was proud to carry a couple bills that you know you supported and dealt with economic development my time here in the General Assembly I'm the senior member of the house this is the first time I've seen a sitting governor come and appear before a committee to promote a bill and so the question that I have is apart from the appearance of we're trying to be politically correct with our history by separating these these two out why is is this so important? Or how would you counter that argument that we're not trying to be just politically correct with our history here? You know, the General Assembly, our forefathers set these holidays on these specific dates. And before I support changing what our forefathers did, I'm looking for a very good reason. And the only reason I've heard so far is, you know, we need to give, you know, Dr. King his own separate holiday. And I just don't know if that's a good enough reason to support this measure. I definitely understand the educational components, but I think those components, we could do those regardless. The main question is do we want to separate these two holidays
▶ Play
or not? Well, thank you for the question, and our forefathers were in 1947, and so it was 1947 that the Robert E. Lee holiday was created. Why did they go from 1965, the conclusion of the war to 1947 without that day of recognition? I don't know. It was 1947 that the holiday was created, and I think he was recognized before the holiday was created. He'll be recognized if the holiday is moved to a day of proclamation. Dr. King, of course, it was in later, I think in the 80s, that he was recognized nationally with the holiday, And so it's been sort of a shifting tide in Arkansas. But you ask the question, though, why is this important? And you're right. Some Arkansans, they go about their work. They don't think about it every day. I would suggest that the accelerator bill, there's probably a lot of Arkansans who roll their eyes and say, I'm not sure what that is either. But that's our leadership. I think we have to determine the importance as well as the public mood. And I believe that it is important because I look at other states. I look at Baltimore. I look at South Carolina. Baltimore had riots in the streets because it was divided. There was not any unity after a terrible tragedy. And in South Carolina, the state came together in a time of healing even after, you know, an African American was killed in a church and the church forgave. it set an example for the nation extraordinary and as governor I sit there and I look and say are we going to be like Baltimore are we going to be like South Carolina if we have a tragedy that occurs in our state and I would like to think that this is important enough that it that it is a healing moment for our state I think it is a unifying moment for our state between the minority community and others and and it is important I haven't talked to a minority group yet that it's not important so to me that makes it important for all of us and it's it's justified in terms of history and it is justified in terms of contemporary life if I could add
▶ Play
to that You know, as the governor said, the holiday was created in 1947. It was also moved in 1985 to where it is today. After President Reagan signed the bill creating the Martin Luther King holiday in 83, General Lee's holiday was combined with it in 1985. So the holiday has already been moved a little over 40 years ago, for one thing. you know you mentioned everyday arkansans maybe not caring and talk business actually did a poll on this question and uh if ruby brock is here or any of them i'll give you credit for doing the poll it showed that 39 percent responded they were in favor of this um 33 percent opposed and the remainder 28 i think um didn't know or probably didn't care so two-thirds of arkansans either supported it or didn't have an opinion um so i do think the majority of of the citizens of arkansas do support this bill and thirdly you know you mentioned some of the economic development bills that you mentioned and the governor has done a lot of work as far as going around the the nation and and the world advocating for arkansas and if he says this bill is important to economic development when we now have a 3.8 unemployment rate i'm going to trust him
▶ Play
I just want to follow up on that last statement that you made about this bill is important for economic development. Could you flesh that out as to how this would be important
▶ Play
for economic development? I've never used economic development necessarily as a reason to support a bill, but yes, I think it does have an economic impact on our state. We're one of only three states that recognize the two holidays together. If you talk to some of the major companies in our state, image is important as you recruit top talent to our state, and I want to recruit top talent to our state. And I think this does have a negative view of our state whenever you see those two holidays separated together, and it makes it more difficult to recruit top talent. Representative De La Rosa, you recognize. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I've actually got two
▶ Play
Speaker 48 20:58
questions, but I'll just stick to one for now and try and come back to the other. I received an e-mail last night from the NAACP saying that they supported this bill, that they viewed this as a compromise, that their preference was that Robert E. Lee get no recognition at all whatsoever. Um, but any recognition at all was, was what they compromised with that, that he would get a gubernatorial proclamation and this, this email said they supported this bill because it was a compromise with them. And so my question is, was any compromise made with the Sons of the Confederacy?
▶ Play
Uh, I have, uh, met with, uh, various groups, many different groups and listened to all points of views and working with Representative Hodges and Senator Wallace. This bill was coming up with. Any legislation is somewhat of a compromise, but it's important to have the support of different groups. And I really appreciated the tone of the sons of the Confederacy, the daughters of the Confederacy, as I met with various groups. They, you know, Cherish history, they cherish that memory of Robert E. Lee, but they also have regard for Dr. King, just a difference in viewpoint as to the separation of that. They wanted to have a paid holiday for Robert E. Lee to have an equation there, and we can't afford another state holiday. And so I was rather firm in that position that we don't have a separate state holiday or create a new state holiday. And so once you reach that conclusion, you have limited options there. And so this was the consensus that we came up among those that were drafting the bill.
▶ Play
You have another question? You're recognized for a follow-up if you'd like to have a follow-up now. Okay. Representative Barker, you're recognized
▶ Play
for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. The governor mentioned looking at other states in this bill. Did you consider Virginia? How is Virginia St. Lee's home state? How did they handle the two
▶ Play
holidays? Yeah, thank you, Representative Barker. It's my understanding the state of Virginia back in 2000, They had recognized King and Lee on the same day and back in 2000 made the decision to separate the holidays, you know, General Lee's home state.
▶ Play
Representative Kavanaugh, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Hodges, since we are on the education committee, I'm going to ask an education question. Do you feel that separating these two into two different days will allow us to teach more about Robert E. Lee and the Civil War and what it meant to Arkansas history, and then at the same time be able to teach about Dr. King and what his legacy was to Arkansas also? Is that going to give us the ability to teach more of both of them?
▶ Play
Speaker 48 24:19
I certainly think so. Rebs of Del Rosso, you recognized. One last question. I've heard you both state that this is healing. I actually view this as very divisive, and I question your interpretation of the polling numbers because you said that 38% support, 33% oppose, 19% were undecided. Well, you could just as easily take those that oppose and that are undecided and say a majority opposes this or is undecided. So you could take that either way. So I would not say from those numbers that this is something that Arkansans want. What makes you think that this is healing and not divisive? Because the messages I've been getting, not one person has asked me to do this, and I have gotten tons of emails asking me not to do this. So what makes you think that this is
▶ Play
healing and not divisive? Well, thank you. Just to clarify, Representative De La Rosa, the talk business poll, I believe, showed 39% approved, 33% disapproved, and the remainder didn't have an opinion. That's all I was saying. So two-thirds, as I said, either supported or didn't have an opinion. As to the second part of your question, in my experience, 99 out of 100 bills that we run down here, if you get e-mails, it's opposed. That's just sort of the nature of government. When we run a bill, we're changing the status quo, and when you change the status quo, you're going to upset someone. There are some people who don't want the holidays separated. I know that. I think the governor knows that. But we feel that passing this bill means that we can recognize both men on their own day without disrespecting either one of them. And, you know, I just haven't been persuaded that moving this recognition or separating these two men's recognition is in any way disrespectful or divisive. I just don't see that argument.
▶ Play
Representative Haas, as you mentioned a while ago, that Virginia did separate those days. Do you know what day they moved Lee to? I don't. Okay. And how many states have done that? Do we know that answer? Right. Only
▶ Play
three remaining states, Arkansas, Alabama, and Mississippi. I don't know how many other states had recognized both men on the same day and what they've done.
▶ Play
And so most southern states had celebrated Lee's birth at some point probably. I wouldn't say all of them, but probably most of them. And so over the years, this has kind of gone away, but we're down to three or four states that still have that. Okay, thank you. Any other questions? Representative Sturt, you recognize for a question? I
▶ Play
didn't really have a question, Mr. Chair. I Googled it because I wanted to know
▶ Play
Speaker 76 27:30
too. Virginia moved it to the Friday before Martin Luther King Day, and they also celebrate Stonewall Jackson on the same day. And so MLK was born January 15th. Robert E. Lee was born January 19th, so they kept it in January.
▶ Play
Okay, thank you. Representative Sturge for that information. Any other questions from the committee? Seeing none, we're going to go to testimony from the audience, and we'll go to the against on the first side. Robert Freeman, you were recognized to come speak against the bill.
▶ Play
Mr. Chairman, I just want to thank again you personally and also the committee for allowing me to appear before you today.
▶ Play
You're welcome, Governor. Thank you. Mr. Freeman, you are recognized to take the end of the table to speak against. Yes, sir. You may go to the end. Mr. Freeman, if you'd state your name and who you're with, you're recognized to speak against the bill. Sir, good afternoon, members of the committee. Make sure that mic is on. There should be a green light on there. Push the push and put the green light on. There you go. All right, yes. State your name and who you're with,
▶ Play
Speaker 80 29:02
and you recognize and speak. Good afternoon, members of the committee. My name is Robert Freeman. I'm a former United States Marine Corps officer, having served service before and during the Vietnam War. I live in Hot Springs, Arkansas. And I'll come here today to oppose Senate Bill 519 to remove for no other reason than socialist political correctness Robert E. Lee's birthday from his position on the calendar, where it was established in 1947 by act of the Arkansas legislature of that time, would degrade the importance and supreme patriotism of one of the truly great men of the United States and reduce his name almost to insignificance. In not only the eyes of our current citizenry, but also future generations. If the Arkansas legislature truly desires to relocate Robert E. Lee's birthday to what it regards as a more appropriate date on the calendar, let it be effected so that it remains, in essence, a holiday and not just an easily overlooked remembrance day. I regard Washington's birthday as a very appropriate date because both men were Virginians and because Lee married one of Washington's descendants and because his lifelong dedication to preserve Arlington House and its surrounding property gave to the United States the most recognized hallowed ground on this continent, Arlington National Cemetery. Additionally, a full-length bronze statue of Lee, which Edward Valentine completed early in the 20th century, stands in Statuary Hall in our nation's capital. When Charles Francis Adams, grandson of the sixth President of the United States and great-grandson of the second President, was asked to speak at Washington and Lee College On January the 19th, 1907, for the centennial celebration of Lee's birth, he said afterward that he thought more highly of the address he gave there than of anything else he had ever done. Toward the end of his long speech, which was delivered in the chapel next to Lee's recumbent statue, Adams said this, and I quote, Speaking advisedly and in full reflection, I say that of all the great characters of the Civil War, and it was productive of many whose names and deeds posterity will long bear in recollection, there was not one who passed away in the serene atmosphere and with the gracious bearing of Robert E. Lee. From beginning to end, those parting years of him will bear well the closest scrutiny. There was about them nothing venal, nothing querulous, nothing in any way sordid or disappointing. In his case, there was no anticlimax, for his closing years were dignified, patient, useful, sweet in domesticity, they in all things commanded the respect of the country. Therefore, gentlemen, I urge the legislature to consider carefully every aspect of Senate Bill 519 before reaching a decision, a decision that may later prove to be a grievous mistake in the hearts and minds of the citizens of our state. And I thank you very much for your time. Are there
▶ Play
any questions, committee? I have a question. Representative De La Rosa.
▶ Play
Speaker 48 32:59
Do you view this proposal for moving the holidays as being disrespectful to General Lee because it's being moved to a date that is not a state holiday? Yes, I do. Yes, I do. Is that your position? Yes, I do. That's why I quoted Washington's
▶ Play
Speaker 80 33:17
birthday. What is more appropriate for a Washington and Lee holiday than the very college in Lexington, Virginia, called the Washington and Lee College? I do not disagree.
▶ Play
I just wanted to be clear on that. Thank you. Yes, I do.
▶ Play
Speaker 87 33:38
Are there any other questions? Thank you, sir. Appreciate your testimony.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Cazork. Ladies and gentlemen of the committee. I may have not said that correctly, but please state your name and who you're with. You
▶ Play
Speaker 91 33:56
are recognized to speak for the bill. My name is Rizal Aaron. I'm the president of the Arkansas State Conference for the NAACP. The email, I'll begin by addressing Representative De La Rosa's comments in reference to the email that was sent on behalf of the NAACP. It was sent in the context to the portion that you were referring to that we did not have a negotiation with the governor in reference to compromise. When I mentioned compromise in the email, it's because we decided not to fight against the bill, even though it still had a day to recognize General Robert E. Lee. And so that's what I meant when I referred to compromise. And I'm glad to hear that some of you, if not all of you, have taken the time to read that email. I, too, am a Marine Corps veteran, infantry, 03-31, heavy machine gun, also Army National Guard, helicopter, crew chief, and door gunner. And I appreciate the position of the opponents of this bill. I understand the position. But this is more than just about Robert E. Lee. in reality we have to look at the underlying issues that we face as african americans in reference to celebrating this as a joint holiday and when we speak to our members and and we talk to our family members and our friends and members of the naacp their perception is different than and what, of course, the Sons of the Confederacy may be. When we think about Robert E. Lee and Dr. King on the same day, it reminds us of the things that were suffered by slaves at the hands of people that wanted to keep them as slaves. As I mentioned in the email, most of the, matter of fact, all of the southern states that wanted to secede and fight against this mentioned in their declarations. And they made it clear that the primary reason to fight against this was to keep their property, which at that time was slavery and slaves. And to us, Robert E. Lee and Dr. King being celebrated on the same day is a reminder of that torture. It's a reminder of that slavery. It's a reminder of the things that our ancestors and forefathers suffered at the hands of what was considered a legal act or law at that particular time. And I just made a few notes, and I'm going to address those notes briefly and move out of your way. Earlier it was mentioned about social, political correctness in in reference to the gentleman that spoke against this bill. This is not about social and political correctness, but even if it were, I believe that the majority of people, if not all the people around this table or in this room that are legislators try to be politically correct in almost everything that they do. But this is not about political correctness. This is about understanding the emotional impact that this bill has on all of the people, citizens that are citizens of Arkansas. I saw a picture the other day and it was a young innocent white child and he was standing and he was watching black men being hung and he was smiling and in the background where of course his elders is probably kinfolks and friends and what have you and I started out by saying the child was innocent and he in fact was but what he was being what was happening to him and I'm sorry this is what what was happening to him was not what how he came here it was what was taught to him and when our children see Dr. Martin Luther King and Robert Ali celebrated on the same day. It brings back those memories, especially for young men and young women of my age, 49 years old, and certainly my mother who is now in her 70s. We don't just look at Robert E. Lee and Dr. King holiday as simply Robert E. Lee and Dr. King. We look at it as the history that brought about the celebration of Robert E. Lee. And that's why we initially opposed any day for Robert E. Lee. But again, I feel that this is a compromise that he's able to have a different day to be celebrated. And we're able to celebrate Dr. King's holiday separately as well. Last week I was in Atlanta with Dr. Bernice King, the daughter of Dr. King. I was there for a few days at the King Center. And this is one of the things that we talked about was how Arkansas was one of the few states left that still celebrate the King and Lee Holliday together. Now imagine her history being a young girl in her father's house being bombed and set on fire, her father being assassinated, and then part of the history was based on what the Confederacy believed was right because it was law. and then imagine how she felt when we were having the discussion and the look that was in her eyes and the hurt and the pain that she felt knowing that there were still southern states that still thought that it was appropriate to celebrate Dr. King's holiday with the Confederate General Robert E. Lee. No disrespect to any of your forefathers or ancestors by any means, One of the things that I've learned is that we have to respect people, and people have done things wrong, and then when they learn to do better, we respect that they've done better. But people, especially in the African American community, are still hurting every time this holiday comes about, every time we see this holiday, every time we hear about it. Because it's a reminder of that little innocent young boy standing there watching these black men being hung and tortured. It's a reminder of the history of slavery. The gentleman earlier mentioned the Arlington Cemetery. Before the Arlington Cemetery came about, it was a refuge for former slaves. Former slaves were living there because they had nowhere else to go. It was torn down and a graveyard was built and displaced all of those former slaves. And so when we talk about the history of slavery and the history of the Confederacy, we have to take into account all of the issues that come with it, not just the part that we see when we talk about, well, there's a cemetery now, I'm a veteran myself, and I respect the living and the dead. But the reality is what happened to get to that cemetery is not very often talked about. And so for this reason, the NAACP of the state of Arkansas, and not just Arkansas, but even our brothers and sisters at the national level, do in fact the support of this bill and separating the King and Lee Holliday for the reasons that I've stated. And if you truly want to heal the community of Arkansas, all, if you want to consider racial sensitivity and cultural sensitivity, if you want to consider the hearts of young men and young women, such as myself, that I have to deal with these memories every time this holiday comes around, if you're sincere and you're serious about doing something about this and making it better for all of us, then you would support this bill not because of political correctness not just simply because it's the right thing to do but because if you represent and i believe that you do all of the people of this great state of arkansas then you'll have it in your hearts and in your mind to do the right thing by making a simple decision this is not a complex decision a simple decision to celebrate these the celebration of these two men on the same day for the sake of all of the citizens
▶ Play
of Arkansas. Are there any questions? Representative Sullivan, you're recognized.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair, and I appreciate your words. And I think, sincerely, there's a strong feeling to separate the two. The gentleman suggested another day for Robert E. Lee. Would you be willing, would that be a good compromise? because you mentioned the sincere feelings on both sides of people, and you mentioned that we're not doing things to be politically correct, but what we can try to do to move people down that road further towards reconciliation. So would you be supportive of moving the Robert E. Lee Day to, as was mentioned earlier? Well, I think that that's already a part
▶ Play
Speaker 91 43:25
of this bill to move Robert E. Lee Day to a different day.
▶ Play
But not on the date the gentleman suggested. I think he suggested moving it to the Washington's birthday day. I
▶ Play
Speaker 91 43:37
think I would have to take some time to consider that, but it is in my opinion that I'll put it this way simply. This bill has been coming up for so many years now, and the legislators have continued to kick it down the road because of the great conflict or the opposition to the bill and the problems that it creates. And so right now our focus should be on passing this bill to end this fight. And then once we've ended this fight, then we can enter into the next phase. And if that's establishing a holiday on Washington's birthday or whichever day that the gentleman suggested, it, then that should be looked at after we've gotten done with this. And I can only give my personal opinion in reference to when that day is celebrated. I personally do not have an issue with them celebrating that day on Washington's birthday. That is not an issue for me, but that is my personal opinion, and that's not the opinion of the State Conference
▶ Play
Speaker 100 44:57
of the NAACP. I appreciate that. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Lauer, you have a question? Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm just curious if there has ever been a conflict in the celebration of Martin Luther King where a parade permit has come in conflict with the celebration of Robert E. Lee or an event has had to be canceled or moved because the two events were on the same
▶ Play
Speaker 91 45:20
day. I'm not aware of any such instance. I've been State Conference President since October last year. My predecessor is here, and he may be able to reply. Oh, never mind. He's had to leave. But I was going to say he may be able to answer that question better. But I'm not familiar with any incident that has occurred in reference to that. Okay. A follow-up. You're recognized. And I know this
▶ Play
Speaker 100 45:43
is kind of a setup question. I apologize. But it just really concerns me when I hear revisionist history. It was the Union that actually removed the freed slaves from Arlington and created a reservation which later became a cemetery. Were you aware of that? It was the Union and not the Confederacy. Actually, I was not,
▶ Play
Speaker 91 46:03
and thank you for the information. Okay, thank you. Representative Meeks,
▶ Play
you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. And my question is kind of a follow-up maybe to Representative Lowry. One of the concerns or one of the reasons that your group is supporting this separation is because of the slavery issue, which I'm sensitive to the fact. But also taking a look, and I just pulled the statistics up, and that in the United States, and according to the census in 1860, that there were about 4 million African Americans who were in the southern states. Of those 4 million, there were over 250,000 were not slaves, and of those 250,000, roughly 10,000 lived in New Orleans, and of the 10,000 that lived in New Orleans, roughly 3,000 of them owned slaves. So the ownership of slaves was not strictly whites owning slaves. There were a lot of African Americans that also owned slaves. and I'm assuming that y'all are aware of that, that that is a fact of history. And I'm wondering, a lot of the concern is over the racial divide of the country and that this is an attempt to heal that. Can you talk to us a little bit about how this would go about healing that divide? And I assume that's the main motivation
▶ Play
Speaker 91 47:40
for your organization, is that correct? Well, our organization is involved in protecting the civil and human rights of all people, not just our people. And so we have to be cautious when we speak in terms of generality. First, to respond to your comment in reference to black folks owning slaves. Black folks owning slaves did not make slavery right. Oh, I agree. by any means, and I understand the history of slavery clearly. What we also have to be cautious about is Googling history because sometimes we look at things, and as our illustrious president was saying, there's fake news or fake information, and so I'm concerned about your representation in regards to your comments referencing black folks owning slaves, and this is why typically when something like this happens and people want to say that it's not about black and white, usually when that comes up, somebody likes to try and turn the conversation around. And basically what I hear in your comment I think is that it's okay if white folks did it because black folks did it in New Orleans also. It is not acceptable on any level to own anybody for anyone to own anybody. Now, getting to the latter part in your question. I'm speaking from my personal experience and the experience of my family members, my son, my daughters, and my mother, and also the members of the NAACP. See, when you refer to your organization, our organization is comprised of black folks and white folks and Asian folks and all kinds of folks. It's a melting pot of people in the United States and across other countries. And when I speak on behalf of the Arkansas State Conference of the NAACP, I'm speaking on behalf of the white folks that are in our organization, the black folks, the Asian folks, and all of the people that are members across Arkansas in our 27 units and branches across the state. And so we have to be cautious about identifying the NAACP just with y'all or black folks, because that's not what it is. And so, again, getting back to answering your question, the way this feels is that those members of those 27 units of the NAAC across the state of Arkansas that support this bill and that feel the same emotional harm that I feel and my children and my mother feel, So those people, once this bill is passed, can feel a sense of relief, knowing that the people that they've elected and placed into office understand racial sensitivity, cultural sensitivity, and understand the needs of all of the citizens of Arkansas and not just the citizens in that demographic area. And considering demographic areas, you represent different areas in the state and based on where you are determines what kind of messages you get in support or against the bill. For example, if you go down south and where there's been a majority of po folks or the majority of black folks, then of course down there the percentages are, the chances are that those people are going to support the separation of the holiday. When you get into demographics in other areas that some of you represent that are majority white areas, then of course when you get phone calls and emails, those people are going to say we need you to vote against this. And so we have to set demographics to the side. And again, we have to get back to not political correctness, but simply what is the right thing to do in this situation. That's how this will begin to help some of us to have a sense of relief. When we get ready to celebrate Dr. Martin Luther King's holiday, and we don't have to explain, or I don't have to explain to my grandchildren when they're ready to ask those questions, why we celebrate the history of slavery and the history of civil rights all in the same day. It begins, not only it doesn't begin, but it helps to further the
▶ Play
healing process. Well, the point that I guess I was trying to make with that was a lot of times the slavery issues divides us among race, that it's blacks versus white, when the reality of the situation is that there are white and black slave owners. In the north, there are white and black abolitionists. As a matter of fact, in New York, the majority of the people that voted for adoption of the Constitution were actually the African-American community. And so I appreciate the comments that you made that your organization is just not African-American, that you have black, white. And so I guess what I'm trying to say with this is I don't want this to become about black versus white. I want this to be about what's best for everybody, for the
▶ Play
Speaker 91 53:35
state. If I may respond, I agree with what you're saying, what's best for the entire state. But so far, when we continue to refuse to pass bills that separate these holidays, we're only considering one side of the state, not both sides of the state or all of the state. When I say both sides, I'm talking about people that support or oppose this effort. And so if you want to do something that benefits the entire state or all of the people or majority of the people, then it seems to me a compromise, as is in this bill, is appropriate because it does not eliminate celebrating Robert E. Lee. And I need to be clear when I say this. I don't support any day for Robert E. Lee. but because this bill celebrates or continues to celebrate Robert E. Lee, I believe that this should satisfy the majority of the people or the citizens in Arkansas because if we continue to have this holiday together, only one side is satisfied, only one side is happy, only one side is
▶ Play
celebrating. Any other questions? Thank you, sir. You're welcome. Appreciate your testimony. Mark Johnson, you're recognized to speak against the bill. And I would advise the committee, let's try to stay on the bill and don't rabbit track too far off. We're getting a little ways off the bill at times. I noticed you didn't
▶ Play
Speaker 115 55:11
say that until I sat down, Mr. Chairman. Well, I said it to the committee. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm Mark Johnson, and I'll make clear I am not here representing any political or other organization that I might be affiliated with. I'm here as a citizen of Arkansas of about six generations. I'm probably the only one in the room that was here in 1985 when they created this joint holiday, and I remember it. The general grumbling at the time was, well, they're just looking for another excuse not to deliver the mail. And I recognized, I thought at the time, it seemed a little unusual. and the real reason that I oppose this bill is probably different from anyone else. I just hate to see a missed opportunity. I appreciate the previous two witnesses and I especially appreciate I never thought I'd be sitting at the end of this table opposing something but my friend Representative Grant Hodges who wasn't around in 1985 when we worked on that and especially wouldn't imagine opposing something supported by my friend Governor Asa Hutchinson who the following year I would be campaigning with him to try to get him elected to the U.S. Senate but he ended up okay so I'm not going to worry about that but my point is that I have a long history of how this came about and I think that when I stopped and thought about it the person that jumped in my mind was my high school principal And since this is an education bill and an education committee, I want to talk about what he said. We had some what at the time seemed like some major racial divides in my high school. In perspective, they were almost insignificant and minor, but it caused enough for the principal to actually come into one of my study halls and talk about a subject that was kind of taboo. You knew there was a racial tension in some cases, but you didn't bring it up in the late 60s, early 70s. And he talked to us very straight, and for once in my life I actually listened to him and remember what he said. He said, we must find a way to meld our cultures. We're all Americans. We've had a rough time getting from here to there. uh i thought recently i'm actually in the midst of reading a book right now called april 1865 and of course that was the month of general lee's surrender and when you you know the history and if you if you don't know this let me help you on this it wasn't like general lee showed up at appomattox and shook hands with general grant and the war was over everybody went home there was so much tension and so much bloodshed and frankly what we would today call terrorism on both sides. It was a bloody, bloody war and it was literally families torn apart and brother against brother and father against son. And you don't heal from that overnight. And here we are 150 plus years later and we're still trying to to heal and i i oppose this bill reluctantly because i really have to stop and apply as a rotarian the four-way test is it the truth is it fair to all concerned will it build goodwill and better friendships and we be will it be beneficial to all concerned And I came up here with the idea of simply saying to the committee, if you do separate these holidays, and I'm really not opposed to the separation, I feel a reconciliation commission or something like what they had in South Africa at the end of apartheid might be something that we could all take a lesson from and learn. But if indeed it's the will of the General Assembly to separate these holidays, I came up here with the idea that I would recommend April 9th as the holiday. Because on Palm Sunday, April 9th, 1865, General Lee sat down at a table with General Grant and he surrendered. and instead of going to meet General Johnston and carry on the war and to encourage guerrilla activities by southern soldiers and have the kind of things that if any of you are Vietnam veterans, you know what a guerrilla warfare would be like in something like that. Can you imagine that in our country after what we had just gone through, over 700,000 casualties in our country? We're not talking about in Europe or in Asia. here on these shores our country wasn't even a hundred years old i believe that we were blessed from above i believe god wanted this country to survive and that's why in that critical month general lee asked if his soldiers could keep their horses and mules because they would need them for the spring planting and general grant agreed and the officers were allowed to keep their side arms and we laid down our arms on both sides and we went home and we're still 150 plus years later still trying to finally heal and i i'm again i have no problem with the idea of a of a celebration on the day of of president washington who was of course his his wife's My great-granddaughter was married to General Lee. I appreciate the fact that there's Washington and Lee University, and there's a tie-in. But I also believe, to be fair to all concerned, there should be equal holidays. And, again, I like April 9th, not just because it was a day of surrender, because it was a day when our country went in a direction, maybe we're not all the way there yet, but in a direction of healing when it could have been so much worse. When you look at the French Revolution and you see that could have been us, that could have been us except for people like General Washington. And when you see what happened in so many other countries, because of General Lee and General Grant reasoning together, two bitter opponents, we brought our country together. And remember in our preamble of our Constitution, it talks about a more perfect union. It doesn't say it's a perfect union. Our goal is a more perfect union. So I ask that you change this bill to be respectful of both sides and equal holidays and to have a proper recognition for General Lee, not because he was a southern general, but because he was a man who saw the big picture. he reached his hand out across that table and shook General Grant's hand and made the effort to bring our country together. The honor we could do to both Dr. King and to General Lee is to meld our cultures, is to, in the words of Dr. King, judge by the content of one's character and not the color of their skin. And I'll be happy to answer any questions, Mr. Chairman. Representative Walker, you recognize
▶ Play
for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
▶ Play
You're, I understand your spirit. When we talk in terms of Washington and Lee, we're talking about a president and a general, The president set, to a great extent, the tenor for the course of the nation, while the general commanded an army. The general was not the philosopher of the attitude of the South. He was one who implemented it, having come from West Point. And King, on the other hand, was one who was seeking to tear that down because it was a barrier to human progress not only in America but throughout the world. So he was a world philosopher seeking to bring about the standing of man in relation to man and to bring about a different world order. So what he sought was different from what General Lee sought. General Lee was a warrior, like General Eisenhower, and like Douglas MacArthur. Now, there should be some difference accorded to generals who fight and who lead the charge and get in the battlefield, and those who, in effect, set the tenor and the course of what the war is about. The war, I don't believe, was ever embraced by General Lee, but he fought for it. He was not to be regarded as a southern bigot, but nonetheless he adapted to that side and became, to an extent, a symbol. And Dr. King sought to erase that symbol so that we could go on with our business and do those things that you would like to have done. Do you see the difference? And the other thing that I would add, when we started talking about Washington and Lee, one thing that I'm always reminded of is... I think if there's a question in there somewhere. I think it will be. I'm thinking as you seek to correlate Washington and Lee, has it ever occurred to you that you don't find very many persons of your race with the last name Washington or Jefferson? and most of them that you'll ever find in America are persons of my color. Have you ever thought about that?
▶ Play
Speaker 115 1:05:47
Actually, I've never thought about that, Representative Walker, and I appreciate you calling to my attention. I would say that while this is certainly not that opportunity for all of us to, as I use the term, meld our cultures and have healing, this is a legislative committee trying to deal with a piece of legislation. I do want to just clarify that I was not the one that originally mentioned the idea of celebrating General Lee's memorial on the same day as President Washington's memorial. But, again, President Washington was also a general before and probably would, like Eisenhower, probably wouldn't have been president if he hadn't been a general before. But I appreciate your comment and take it to heart, and I'll be happy to answer other questions, too, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I have no other questions. Thank you, sir. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Speaker 25 1:06:38
Chairman, committee. You have a question for
▶ Play
him? Okay, okay. We're good. We're good. You go ahead and get up. I think we're done.
▶ Play
Speaker 125 1:06:51
Yes, sir. Do you have a point of information there, Representative Star? No. I just want to see if we can make a motion to limit debate to five minutes per person, including
▶ Play
questions. It's a proper motion. I really don't want to hear that motion because we only have two more left to speak that I have on the list, and I don't think that would be fair to them. I understand. So I'm not going to hear that motion. Is there anyone who would like to speak for the bill? Against the bill, I have Robert Edwards. I think the last two gentlemen will be pretty brief. Hopefully he doesn't have ten pages. state your name and who you're with and you'll be recognized
▶ Play
Speaker 129 1:07:35
i'm robert edwards and i live in benton arkansas and i'm just kind of here for myself but to be clear yes i do serve as the commander of the arkansas division of the sons of confederate veterans but i'm not here representing those but just to be clear many of y'all do recognize me in this room and yes i am the state commander. I'd like to take a few seconds just to clarify a couple of things. Representative De La Rosa, you asked did the governor, did he coordinate any of this with us? No. We did get an opportunity to meet with him in his office on September the 6th, myself and the president of the United Daughters of the Confederacy. We met with him, and he told me that he was going to separate these bills. But as you see here this bill does not separate them it eliminates robert elise as the previous speaker just said that he thought that whatever was done they should be equal and i think i agree with that and none of the bills that the governor discussed has ever talked about separating but he uses that word but he really means to eliminate robert elise holiday so but no he did not we did leave him a Two-page memorandum telling why, and we gave him three opportunities for collaboration, and we never heard back. I did, on October the 16th, receive a letter from him on a really nice gold-embossed letterhead with a black-and-white copy of the proclamation where he commemorated the death of Robert E. Lee. I didn't appreciate it. I was kind of offended by it. So, Representative Hodges, you mentioned something about economic development. This came up two years ago in the state agencies when we were – we got to spend 19 visits with – well, 21. I only made 19 of those visits two years ago. And one of the things was about economic developments. The other two states that share these holidays would be Mississippi and Alabama and their economic development as well. Mississippi has, at that time, had two brand-new automobile manufacturing plants. Alabama had five. And one of the reasons, if you want to do economic development in state Arkansas, you have to do something about torque. And I understand
▶ Play
that's in the works. No, no, no, one other thing. The government wasn't in the land. Oh, one of
▶ Play
Speaker 129 1:10:13
the alternatives we gave to the governor for holidays was what Virginia did. And to be perfectly clear, we started out the conversation with the government. We don't want a new holiday. We're taxpayers. We don't want to create a tax burden. We don't want to create a new holiday. But let's work within what we've got. And we recommended the Virginia option. You can have Friday for one. You can have Monday for the other. It's still only one. You don't get both Friday and Monday, but if you've got to pick and choose, this would serve that purpose. Now then, I'm an old man, and since everybody else has been in the military, I guess I'll tell you, I was in the military, too. I was in the United States Air Force. I lived at so much it extended for a year. And I was in during Vietnam, and it wasn't a pleasant time, but I did my time in the armed services, too. And toward the late 60s, early 70s, we started talking about this very thing, about cultural sensitivity and racial sensitivity. And the Air Force and then the FAA, when I went to work for them, we actually had seminars we had to go to called Human Relations. By the way, I'm also retired from the Federal Aviation Administration. I was the Director of Technical Operations for the state of Arkansas. So I've been in government my whole life. In the 80s, we kind of switched the focus. We called it the race relationships. and we all took the same courses again and then the 90s we called it diversity and I got lapel pins with five little stick figures and five different little colors on them and we had to wear our lapel pins to show that we had graduated from my diversity training. Then about the turn of the century we changed it to cultural diversity. I've had a lot of training on diversity and cultural sensitivity, and I agree with it, we need to be sensitive to the folks that live in our communities, in our state, and all the way around it. But one thing I did see, I learned that cultural diversity, racial diversity, is not just a one-way street. It has to work both directions. Other ways, right, you get a European roundabout, and you just chase your tail, you're running in circles the whole time. It takes action and reaction from all involved in order to have a cultural sensitivity and a diversity. So, we've heard some folks talk about heritage. I had heritage. The governor had, and Representative Hodges have heritage. I did. You know, we all have parents. We have two of those. We have four grandparents, eight great-grandparents, 16 great-great-grandparents, grandparents and eight of those were males and three of mine didn't return from that war they died two of them had property no slaves but they had property that was confiscated during the war and the southern claims commission denied many claims so yes when we look at that time we have hard feelings too but I don't dwell on them I tried to move beyond those I find it interesting that we can look back 60 years ago to 1957 and we don't talk about segregation we talk about desegregation and that's a good thing we have made a national brown sign out on 630 says central high school national historic landmark and that's probably a good thing too you know It would cost tax dollars to keep it up, but anyway. But we don't dwell on that. We have been able to move beyond that. I know folks that have been married 25 years, and when they first started out, they had nothing. They look back 25 years later, they're doing pretty good. But we can move back from those periods of poverty and say, wow, we made a long stride. We can look back to 1957 and say, I'm glad we're not there anymore. but we can't let go of 1865 for some reason we refuse to let go and there's a perfect example of that propaganda on that Facebook page nothing about Martin Luther King I'm sure it was omitted and that was added for a purpose and that was to generate controversy Now the preponderance of this controversy, if y'all will recall, started about 2015 when we had a new governor take office. At least in my 35 years of living in the state of Arkansas, that's the first controversy I recall over this issue. I don't care for controversy. I care for how I just like to live my little life. try to help folks in my church try to do things for my community so i think back i think it was something maybe called brown versus the board of education kansas said separate is not equal i would like to y'all strongly consider voting this bill down not being for this bill because it is not a division of holidays. It is the elimination of Robert E. Lee and separate is not equal. Thank you, Chairman, Committee. Thank you for your time. Do I
▶ Play
have any questions? Seeing none. Thank you, sir. Senator Hendren. You are recognized to take the other end. If you would please state your name and who you're with, you'll be recognized
▶ Play
to speak for the bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, members of the committee, Senator Jim Hendren. But I'm not here as Senator Jim Hendren or as the majority leader. I'm here as a kid who grew up in Gravette, Arkansas in an all-white school and had a lot to learn about race relationships after I left that school. And when I went to engineering college, and I was still basically in an all-white college surrounded by some kids from other countries, but still very few interactions with African Americans. My interactions with African Americans began when I joined the military, which was shortly after college. And that's where I began to learn that I didn't know much. and I will just tell you one of the most exciting things to me about this bill, and I serve on the Senate Education Committee, is that it came through the Education Committee because we spend a lot of time arguing about whether it should be this day or that day or this date or whatever. To me, the most important aspect of this bill is we need to do a better job of educating our kids across this entire state about our history, the good and the bad, about our culture, the good and the bad, instead of just picking what is convenient to us. I just came back from the American Legion headquarters. They've got a display over there that shows the Arkansas veterans who have given their lives since 2003. And you know, one of the things you notice over there is there's African Americans and there's whites. and one of the things I appreciated most about my military service is they taught me to respect each other as Martin Luther King said not by the color of our skin but by the content of our character and by the kind of people that we were I set an education committee and I watched and I watched some of my colleagues across right across the table from me be hurt by some of the things that were said and it was offensive to me and I determined then I was going to come down here and and and try to represent that we can do better. Those of us who have a deep faith know that one of the things we're taught is we should esteem others better than ourselves and the fact is I think that's what this bill is about. While the fact that these holidays are joint may not be offensive to you. The fact is you should know that it is offensive to many of your colleagues and your friends. And I think we have a duty and we have an obligation to put them first. I think this bill is overdue in coming. I think that nitpicking about method is petty and looking for an excuse to kill this bill. I think we should all leave here with a purpose that we are not just going to try to honor and respect each other, but we're going to do a better job of teaching our youth to do the same. Because if there's one thing that I think we are failing at in education, it is that. We are choosing sides, we are criticizing, and we are practicing division rather than commonality. So I just urge the committee to think about the value that this message sends to this state, to this country, and most importantly to our kids like me who grew up in a school that didn't get to experience interracial diversity and didn't get to experience the value that that brings. But thank God I left, and I learned to respect people, and I learned to be sensitive to the fact that they didn't grow up like I did. I went and saw Hidden Figures, and I went and visited with Senator Elliott the next day. And I asked her, did you live that? Did you experience that? And she told me she did. And she told me some of her personal experiences. i don't look at the world like she does because i haven't lived that and i haven't experienced that but i tell you what i think as a legislator we have an opera we have an obligation to try to be sensitive to other people's experiences and life outlooks it is not the same as what we many of us have experienced and so i i implore this committee to put this issue behind us to separate these holidays and show the honor and respect that I think is deserved and merited. And again, quit looking for off-ramps and reasons to nitpick and be against this bill. Our state deserves better. And I appreciate this committee giving me the opportunity to come and speak
▶ Play
for it. Are there any questions? Seeing none, thank you, sir. All right, we have our last one coming up to speak against the bill, Loy Mock. This will be our last testimony. Mr. Mock, you're recognized to speak. You'll state your name and who you're with. Former representative of this
▶ Play
Speaker 143 1:22:02
chamber. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and ladies and
▶ Play
gentlemen of the committee. I'm Aloy Mock from Bismarck, Arkansas. I'm a retired AT&T employee, and also, like the chairman said, I'm a retired Arkansas legislator, too. But anyway, I come for this committee today as a concerned citizen and patriot. Specifically, I come to ask that you preserve a day set aside to recognize Robert E. Lee. I believe in the value of looking at history, warts and all, not by omitting people or events that are based on sentiments or lack of understanding. Whether we are looking at teaching of history or venerating the individuals who helped make it, we have a responsibility and should endeavor to do just that based on the true recording and documentation of those actual facts which make up our time-honored past. We should weigh those truths to ensure that we do not intentionally or unintentionally elevate certain elements or events that are out of proportion to others. Both Robert E. Lee and Martin Luther King deserve to be recognized. In the case of Martin Luther King, it's because of his fight for the humanity and brotherhood of all races, not because of the protest and violence associated with the movement overall. We honor him because of what resulted from that movement as a whole. In the case of Robert E. Lee, it's because of his dedication to the idea and principles of self-government, upon which his nation's founding documents are based, that his family played such a vital role in helping to create, and because he believed in the call of duty until his dying day. Not because of the issue of slavery, which is not to be blamed for, no more than George Washington is to be blamed for either, whom we also honor by celebrating his birthday and his also enumerated in his bill. I'd like to stop and make a point here. Many people think that the Confederate Army was just entirely a Caucasian race. No, it was served by several races of people. There were black Confederates who served. there were jewish confederates who served there were oriental confederates native american confederates it goes on and on i'd like to make another point that i'm i'm also a member of the sons of confederate veterans and nelson winbush is a member of our organization he is a grandfather served in the confederate army he's a black confederate well nelson winbush he won the the sons of confederate veterans highest award years ago and and our i mean our organization's highest award sorry about that our organization's highest award and that award is the robert e lee award and that's what we're all about we're not we're not uh just exclusive to one race it is different races of people in our organization and by that being said both of these men have merit both have been maligned by issues taken out of context and mistakenly credited to them by their detractors let us not fall victim to the transgression of being contemporaneous it is our job and responsibility to ensure that they're each honored based on the true facts of history so that we may present a complete picture of history as a whole. Robert E. Lee was an honorable man and deserves to be recognized as such. Arkansas has an opportunity to be a catalyst for truth and the representation of history as a whole, not by misinformation that results in bias and disproportionate views of our history. When we honor Robert E. Lee on his holiday, we're also honoring his family who contributed as much as any other american family towards the creation of our founding documents which i stated previously to which general lee was duty bound and most certainly abided by him and for this i actually vote against senate bill 519. thank you for your time and i'll be
▶ Play
glad to field any questions are there any questions seeing none thank you sir representative hodges would you like close for your bill do appreciate everyone's patience tonight we are running late in the hour but represent Hodges you're recognized to close thank
▶ Play
you mr. chair thank you committee I want to thank everyone who came and stayed tonight to speak both for and against I respect everyone's viewpoint on this issue and I appreciate you taking the time to let us know your thoughts on this bill. I just want to point you again to this board over here from this year. As most of you probably know that this building is the Black History Museum and Google issued an apology this year for that screenshot there the bill the law that we have now allows for this type of confusion it allows for this kind of division for the people who say that what we're trying to do here by separating these holidays is divisive. I think we all want unity. We all want to get along better, but if the way we avoid division is to keep two holidays together that shouldn't be held on the same day, I don't think that's the solution. There are a lot of ways we can do better, a lot of ways we can move forward as a state, a lot of ways we can make up for past mistakes, but keeping these two holidays on the same day isn't going to solve the problem. You heard several people here that spoke against the bill offer a variety of different solutions for when we could move this day, and I assure you that myself and Senator Wallace and Governor Hutchinson considered all of them. But as you could tell, even the people that came to speak against this bill didn't have a consensus on where the day should be. And I'll submit to you that there is no perfect solution to that. But I think the solution that we've come up with in this bill works, and it is a good solution. And like Senator Hendren said, I think we can nitpick it all we want, but at the end of the day, what we're trying to do here is separate these two days and honor each man individually. This bill is clearly important to our governor. He has never come to a committee to speak for a bill before. I think he's made that clear that this is important to him. It's important to Senator Wallace and to the 24 other senators who voted for this bill. It's important to myself. It's important to many of our colleagues in the House. And I do believe it is important to many of our citizens around the state. And so to the members of this committee, I would ask you to join me. Let's give each of these men their final resting place here in the state of Arkansas. Let's allow our colleagues the opportunity to vote on this bill. Let's finally get this done. And from now on, ensure that young people in the state of Arkansas are learning their history and make some hear ourself. Thank you. And I move due pass.
▶ Play
Speaker 148 1:29:09
We have a motion of due pass.
▶ Play
Speaker 81 1:29:16
All right. All in favor, say aye. Aye. All opposed, no. No. I'm going to say the ayes have it. Congratulations. You passed your bill.
▶ Play

Agenda

SB519 TO AMEND TITLE 6 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING EDUCATION REQUIREMENTS FOR HISTORY IN THE CLASSROOM; AND TO EFFECT A SEPARATE HOLIDAY FOR DR. MARTIN LUTHER KING JR.

0:53 - 1:29:28 216 segments 26 speakers

Representative Monte Hodges introduced Senate Bill 519, which would create a separate state holiday for Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., retain a day of proclamation for General Robert E. Lee, and add a curriculum-development component on both figures and related history. [0:58] [1:03] [1:40] [2:15] [2:46] [3:19] [3:50] [4:21] [4:52] [5:26]

Governor Asa Hutchinson and Committee Chair Representative Bruce Cozart testified in strong support, arguing that the bill balances historical recognition, promotes unity, and could enhance Arkansas’s image and economic development. [6:07] [6:30] [7:04] [7:40] [8:14] [8:47] [9:22] [9:56] [10:27]

Committee members raised substantive questions about the necessity of date changes, potential economic impact, mixed public-opinion polling, and possible compromises, while public testimony included opposition from former Marine Robert Freeman, who said the bill diminishes Lee’s legacy, and support from the Arkansas NAACP president emphasizing cultural sensitivity and the need to separate the holidays. [11:11] [11:36] [11:39] [12:06] [12:32] [12:36] [13:08] [13:44] [14:15] [14:48] [18:31] [18:47] [19:22] [19:52] [19:58] [20:07] [20:33] [20:58] [21:38] [22:11] [22:42] [22:55] [23:09] [23:16] [23:25] [23:49] [27:44] [28:03] [28:11] [28:43] [29:02] [29:13] [29:43] [30:37] [31:18] [31:50] [32:26] [32:51] [32:59] [33:17] [33:29] [33:38] [33:43] [33:56] [34:02] [34:34] [35:08] [35:45] [36:17] [36:51] [37:23] [37:55] [38:32] [39:05] [39:40] [40:13] [40:45] [41:17] [41:51] [42:25]

Additional witnesses such as Mark Johnson suggested a reconciliation commission and a joint commemorative day, Representative John W. Walker questioned equating Lee’s military role with King’s moral leadership and raised concerns about racial representation, and opponents like Robert Edwards and Reginald Murdock argued the bill would eliminate the Lee holiday and advocated for a split or retention of both holidays. [55:14] [55:45] [56:17] [56:51] [57:24] [57:59] [58:34] [59:13] [59:44] [1:00:18] [1:00:51] [1:01:25] [1:01:55] [1:02:53] [1:03:02] [1:03:37] [1:04:08] [1:04:39] [1:05:13] [1:05:44] [1:07:35] [1:07:55] [1:08:32] [1:09:03] [1:09:38] [1:10:05] [1:10:09] [1:10:13] [1:10:40] [1:11:16] [1:11:52] [1:12:28] [1:12:59] [1:13:32] [1:14:02] [1:14:38] [1:15:09] [1:15:43] [1:22:06] [1:22:16] [1:22:48] [1:23:20] [1:23:51] [1:24:26] [1:24:59] [1:25:29]

Supporters, including Senator Jim Hendren and Representative Monte Hodges, emphasized the educational benefits of separating the holidays, urged unity, and moved the measure forward, which was approved by a voice vote after a motion to deem it passed. [1:16:21] [1:16:47] [1:17:19] [1:17:52] [1:18:23] [1:19:00] [1:19:32] [1:20:05] [1:20:35] [1:21:08] [1:26:03] [1:26:30] [1:27:01] [1:27:40] [1:28:11] [1:28:44] [1:29:09] [1:29:16]

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Bruce Cozart Chair Unverified
25 segments
Chair Unverified
25 segments
Representative Monte Hodges Unverified
23 segments
Representative Dan Sullivan Unverified
6 segments
Speaker 26
1 segment
Representative Stephen Meeks Unverified
14 segments
Speaker 48
5 segments
Representative Sonia Eubanks Barker Unverified
2 segments
Representative Frances Cavenaugh Unverified
1 segment
Representative James Sturch Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 76
2 segments
Speaker 80
8 segments
Speaker 87
1 segment
Speaker 91
36 segments
Speaker 100
4 segments
Speaker 115
17 segments
Representative John W. Walker Unverified
6 segments
Speaker 25
1 segment
Speaker 125
1 segment
Speaker 129
16 segments
Representative Joe Jett Unverified
2 segments
Senator Jim Hendren Unverified
10 segments
Speaker 143
1 segment
Representative Reginald Murdock Unverified
8 segments
Speaker 148
1 segment
Speaker 81
1 segment