May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 13, 2026
HB1828 Warren CONCERNING THE ARKANSAS TITLE INSURANCE ACT; AND TO CLARIFY THAT NO CAUSE OF ACTION EXISTS FOR NEGLIGENCE BY AN INSURED AGAINST A TITLE INSURANCE… 28:38
Representative Farrar and other members asked whether the bill would bar investors from flipping a contract or collecting a profit fee before closing, seeking clarification on when a license would be required.
[29:22][29:31][29:56][30:31]
Ms. Everett voiced confusion about the bill’s language, stating that an unlicensed person may make an offer and assign the contract if they intend to close, but cannot embed a third-party fee without a license, and the committee noted the exemption language was unclear.
[32:12][32:47][33:21][33:51][38:05]
Gary Ice, Executive Director of the Real Estate Commission, testified that the legislation only exempts non-brokerage activities; simple contract assignments are not brokerage services, so no licensing exemption is needed for flipping transactions.
[39:02][39:08][39:41][40:15][40:46]
No member spoke against the measure, and the chair recorded a unanimous motion to pass HB 1828, which was adopted.
[38:35]
Rep. Bruce Cozart introduced HB 1828 to clarify that contractors are not liable for liens on work omitted from their contracts; the committee moved the measure to a vote and approved it unanimously.
[1:17:55][1:18:30][1:19:01][1:19:17][1:19:33][1:20:02]
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Committee, I'm going to ask for Wes Lesane, if he would. Is he here yet? That's great. We'll proceed without Wes. If Wes comes in, Mr. Dunn, I guess he's outside. All right. I will go ahead and present my case, and then hopefully Wes will be here in just a minute. To refresh everyone that was here last time and bring those of you who weren't up to speed, House Bill 1828. This bill is a bill that affects title companies, and first of all, I want to make clear I am president of a title company. I'm running this bill because I understand how title companies and our underwriters operate. This bill has one purpose, to prevent the closure and title company from being included in a cause of action for negligence for lack of reasonable care in searching and disclosing the state of title to a piece of property. The insured party has a title insurance policy that protects them from defects in the chain of title to their property. This is the only item we are being removed from as far as a cause of negligence. The consumer is fully covered. If the closer or company has done anything else to adversely affect the customer, they are free to take action. This simply takes the closer and company out of the line for being sued when the customer is fully protected for that very issue by the underwriter. We, the closer and company, are just serving as their agents, the underwriters' agents. We are one and the same when it comes to the title insurance policy. Lastly, this is codifying existing case law. And my expert is now here, so Wes Lesane, he is legal counsel for Lenders Title. Sir, if you would introduce yourself and who you're
Thank you, Chairman Collins. My name is Wesley Lesane. I'm general counsel for Lenders Title Company, and I serve as the chair of the legislative committee for the Arkansas Land Title Association. Ladies and gentlemen, title insurance is significantly different from most other forms of insurance. The primary purpose of title insurance is to eliminate risks that have happened in the past. To achieve this goal, title insurers perform an extensive search of the public records for its own use and benefit through its appointed agents to determine whether there are any adverse claims to the subject real estate. Those claims are either eliminated prior to issuance of a title insurance policy or their existence is accepted from coverage under the policy. Title insurance is a contract of indemnity, which generally states that if the status of title to the insured property is different from how it is represented, and if the insured suffers a loss as a result of a covered title defect, the insurer will reimburse the insured for that loss and any related legal fees and expenses. The insurer also has a duty to defend the status of title to the insured property, and the cost of defense does not reduce the policy limits. With respect to the search that is performed prior to the issuance of a title insurance commitment and policy, and that is the subject of House Bill 1828. The title agency is acting as the agent of the insurer in evaluating the risk and liabilities related to the insured property and not as an agent of the insured. Accordingly, no legal duty arises between the title insurance agent and the insured with respect to the search. Rather, the insured has contractual recourse against the title insurer under the title insurance policy, which does not require that the insured prove any fault on the part of the title insurance agent or insurer. For instance, a policy is issued and it was later determined that title to the property is unmarketable as a result of a defect or encumbrance, and there are no relevant exceptions or exclusions to coverage. The title insurer is liable under the contract, which is the title insurance policy, regardless of whether or not reasonable care was exercised by the title insurance agent in performing the search. The insured is not required to prove that the insurer failed to exercise reasonable care either. Conversely, the insurer does not have a defense to a claim that the insured failed to exercise reasonable care. The issues are decided applying the terms and conditions of the policy to the facts, not by analyzing fault. And as Representative Warren previously mentioned, this only seeks to codify existing case law in Newberry v. Scruggs and Chicago Title Insurance Company v. Riverview Development, Inc. And I'll be happy to take any questions if you have any. Representative Payton, you recognize for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
You made the—I forgot your name. Sorry. Wes Lesane. Mr. Lesane, you made the statement that the agent is not the agent of the insured, but the agent of the insured's company, insurer. That's correct. Does the agent that we're talking about here ever charge a fee for that title search to the insured? Yes, a fee is charged to the insured
I am not your agent because I am not subject to you controlling how I conduct that search or dictating anything with respect to that search. It's simply because of the way that title insurance is priced within the state of Arkansas and because rates are not regulated, that's a manner for which the agent can recoup its cost in conducting that search to enable it to issue the title insurance policy, which
you're asking me to relieve you of all liability. MR. You are asking me to do a job for me to be able to issue a title insurance policy that anewers to your benefit and protects you. It's a requirement that I do the search in order to
Per our agency agreements, the title insurance premium is split between the agent and the insurer. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Are there any other questions? Seeing
I would just say that I appreciate Wes being here. The customer is fully covered by the underwriter. I know you're asking if they're relieved of all liability. The customer is never uncovered by when they get the title insurance policy, they have full coverage that the search that we've been done, if it is not done exactly right, the underwriter has to cover them. They go to the underwriter, they get taken care of. We're the agent for that underwriter. We make sure that they're covered. So there is no lapse of coverage here. So with that, I would ask for a good vote. If I could make a
Representative Payton's questions. Actually, at the close, we're going to have the members going to do the close, and then we went through those other periods. And now we're to the point of the pleasure of the committee. I move due pass on House Bill 1828. Is there any discussion? All in favor? Aye. Any opposed? The ayes have it. Congratulations, Representative Warren. You passed your bill. Thank you, Commissioner. Next on our agenda is House Bill 1840. Representative Johnson, are you here? Representative Johnson, are you here? Seeing Representative Johnson's not here, we're going to move to House Bill 1890. Representative Tucker, are you here? Representative Tucker, are you here? Seeing as Representative Tucker's not here, we're going to move to House Bill 1900. Representative Bentley, are you here? Representative Bentley, are you here? Seeing as Representative Bentley is not here, we're going to move to House Bill 1958. Representative Gray, are you here? Representative Gray, are you here? Seeing as Representative Gray is not here, we're going to move to House Bill 2042. Representative Drown, you're recognized to present House Bill 2042. Representative Drown, if you have the people at the end of the table introduce themselves and who they're with. Hello, Doyle. It's
since they are the subject matter experts. Thank you, Representative Drown. We're here to present this bill today to make some technical changes to the provisions of the real estate license law regarding real estate license exemptions. What this bill would do is amend exemptions to real estate license law because the way it stands is it's a bit vague as to whether or not you have a contract and you are trying to purchase it for your own benefit. The issue that we are trying to address is that you have certain people that are for a fee that are putting properties under contract and then assigning them or transfer them, transferring them to investors. And again, they're doing this for a fee. And so we feel that in order, if you look at the definition of a real estate licensee, it is basically someone who is transferring property, selling property, buying property, or leasing property on behalf of someone else. And they're doing that for a commission or other fee like a commission. And so we are not trying to ruin a practice where individuals are able to buy things for their own benefit and transfer them to a wholly owned LLC or something of that nature, but to prevent this practice where people are taking properties, putting them under contract, and then basically selling them off to investors, so to speak, and charging a fee for it. And they are doing this even though they are not licensed real estate brokers in the state of Arkansas. Members, are there any
that correct? Actually, you have to be a licensed real estate broker. There are some exemptions for attorneys. But by and large, yes, you have to be a licensed real estate broker. All right. So
this bill would ensure that going forward, only licensed real estate agents would be the ones that would be able to sell property for a fee. In other words, are you saying that there are people out there that are acting like realtors or pretending to be a realtor and collecting a fee on houses or property that they purchase, and then turn around and sell it someone
else. That is correct. They're, in essence, fulfilling the role of a real estate licensee without the benefit, the public protections of having a real estate license. Representative Rushing, you recognize for a question? Okay, I just want
to make sure we're clear, and I know the answer to this question, so I'm just asking it to get it out on the table. So this does not apply to investors that are buying a piece of property to develop where they can subdivide lots off and sell at the time of closing back-to-back.
Is that correct? That is correct. I've been a real estate attorney for over 15 years, and we've dealt with several situations where you have someone who, for example, will purchase a piece of property and then transfer it from one LLC to another entity with investors that allow him to develop the property. And that is absolutely still allowed as an exemption, provided that they're not charging a fee or a commission for that. So we do not feel that this bill at all hampers people from investing in real estate and things of that nature. REPRESENTATIVE FERRARA, YOU'RE
MR. CHAIR. I THINK YOU JUST ANSWERED MY QUESTION. ON FORECLOSED PROPERTIES, YOU HAVE ATTORNEYS AND BANKS SELLING THE PROPERTIES. SAY IT AGAIN. ON FORECLOSED PROPERTIES, YOU HAVE BANKS AND ATTORNEYS SELLING THESE PROPERTIES. ARE YOU GOING TO LIMIT THAT? WOULD THE SPILL LIMIT THEM FROM DOING THAT? I THINK YOU JUST SAID TO DO IT FOR A FEE. IT WILL NOT. BUT THEY'RE CHARGING A FEE TO DO IT. I JUST WOULD
THAT LIMIT THAT? IT WILL NOT. WILL NOT? OK. Thank you. Are there any other questions? Representative Murdock, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Chairman. Kind of along the line where Representative Farr – I'm over here. Oh, I'm sorry. Sorry. You good? Sorry about that. Okay. Kind of along the same lines where he was in terms of seeing who's going to be excluded included in this legislation to make sure we're not, no unintended harm done or consequences from this. So give me an example of what makes you bring this legislation to us. Give me a drill down example. If I may, I'd
like to answer that question. And I think the best way to do that is just give you an actual example. Yes. From a hearing that we did last year. And it was a situation where a homeowner in Maumelle was attempting to sell their property. Their name's Crossland. Lisa Stassi made an offer. No, I don't need the names. Buyer made an offer on the property and got the seller to agree. She also did a memorandum of the agreement at the same time that said that a third party, In this case, it was an escrow company in Florida, Franklin, Franklin Escrow in Florida, would be involved in this transaction if and when it closed. And if it did not close through this particular buyer, that Franklin Escrow had a 10-year lien on the property to collect their fee. Fee for doing what? We were never clear on. They did nothing in the transaction. So the buyer never closed on the property, never exercised. The property owner then listed with a real estate company, put the property under contract, and prior to closing, a local title company discovered the lien that was required to be cleared before that property owner could go ahead and close. The lien from the escrow company? From the escrow company in Florida. So this is the business model that this particular bill is aimed at, and it is becoming more prevalent. We're investigating another one similar, and I think it's important for the committee to understand that we're only investigating the ones where people complain. The ones where no one complains, they go on to closing, they find this lien, and they simply pay it and move on. So this is a business model where this escrow company in Florida agrees to train people how to do this on the ground. They make offers on properties. Maybe they close, maybe they don't. But whether they do or not, this escrow company is a third party that now has an interest in this real estate. And so the defense for this particular person, this buyer, was that she was exempt because she had an equitable interest in the property. And that's the purpose for this bill is to set that aside and say that if you're operating for a third party knowingly going in for any reason other than ownership. And if you look at that, I think it's Section 3.1C. I have that backwards. What is it in the bill? It is Section 3.C.1. And if I may, it says that a person or entity shall not, under any circumstances, qualify for an exemption under this section if they obtain an equitable interest in real estate with the knowledge that the interest was obtained on behalf of a person or entity that intends to gain an interest in the real estate other than that of ownership. If they intend to gain the interest and move on to close as an owner, there's no problem with this. Only if they gain an interest for reasons other than ownership, just like the example that I gave you, where they're really just embedding a fee into the transaction and contributing nothing
to it. Right. So just a little drill down. So if the homeowner is getting some professional service or help in the selling of the property or in disposing of their own asset, what I want to make sure of is that we're not limiting them to who they can do business with in terms of assisting them in this process. I'm trying to make sure there's not an exclusivity that's being carved into this arrangement that don't allow for the free will of the owner to dispose of their asset in the means and matter that is their right. You understand what I'm trying to make sure? I do. And so if
you were trying to sell your property, you have that exemption not to be required to be licensed. If you ask your neighbor to help you sell your property, as long as your neighbor is not charging you a fee in the process, they can help you sell your property. But once they step in providing brokerage services, then yes, if they're assisting you in the sale of your property. Now, if your neighbor makes an offer on your property and between that time and closing finds another buyer that's willing to pay them more than they're going to pay you and they can assign the contract, they're free to do that. This doesn't preclude that. So you can assign contracts, flip contracts. That's not the issue. The issue is drawing a third party into this who is not going to be an owner, who is just simply injecting a fee into the transaction. Without
a licensure is the problem for you because they may inject the fee and provide a particular service, but that still is not okay because what you're focused on is that they're not a licensed individual. That's right. Okay, I think I understand you. Representative
Just for my clarification, I'm not sure how this works. Would this affect any online service like Zillow, anything like that? I'm not sure. Do they take a fee out of that transaction? No. They do not? They do not. So this wouldn't affect any one
listing like that? No. Zillow charges on occasion by a volunteer, charges a fee to an agent to market that agent online, but not market property. Okay. Thank
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Actually, I think most of my questions got answered with what your reply was to Murdoch. But let's just go back to the example you gave of the neighbor made an offer, then found out somebody else would pay more, and so that neighbor is now not purchasing for the purpose
of ownership. No. But they're still okay. Right. They're okay because they, at the time that they made the offer, maybe they had an intent or not, doesn't matter, they are involving a third party for the purpose of ownership. Well, I appreciate the
Chair. Okay. Any other questions? No questions from the committee. Is there anyone that would like to speak against the bill? We have Ms. Kathleen Everett has signed up to speak against the bill. Ms. Everett, you're welcome to come to the end of the table. State your name and who you're with, and then you'll
be recognized to speak against the bill. My name is Kathleen Everett, and I'm the executive director of the Real Estate Investors Group in Northwest Arkansas. I come here after having several discussions with the Real Estate Commission, Doyle, and all the people you've spoken to today, and I applaud the intent to allow for investors to purchase properties with the intent of assigning their interest in that contract, I think that we're all on the same page in terms of intent. I don't believe that the language that's stated in this bill actually says that. And there's a lot of confusion within the real estate investing community about this practice that we call wholesaling. And wholesaling is essentially, as they explained it, I go and purchase a property from a seller with a contingency or an inspection period that is a reasonable amount of time, and then I take that contract and speak with the other investors I know within my sphere of influence, within the people that I work with on a daily basis and assign my interest in that contract to them for a fee. And, again, I think that the Real Estate Commission and Mr. Yates and everyone involved wants to keep that practice going. And this is a longstanding traditional practice for investors to do a variety of things, everything from establishing a pool of capital so that they can begin to invest in their own properties. It allows for more people who flip houses, who take derelict and vacant properties and rehab them, bring them back to appropriate use to fair market value and increase the inventory, increase the inventory of houses as well as rental properties. And this is a service to the community in the process of doing that. They make huge contributions to the labor pool, to the state and local tax burdens. we make a contribution to our community, not only in better housing, but also in labor and money and taxes that have been paid. Again, I think we're all on the same page. My problem is that this language does not really express that. There was language that was discussed in our deliberations that was suggested, and I'll just read it briefly. I'm not sure how we would go about inserting that language, but I think it would make things very, very clear and allow our investors to continue this practice without fear of prosecution for something that they've been doing forever. And the language would read, this section in no way precludes an individual or entity from their ability to assign a contract. That's simple. It's English. It's something that everyone can understand. And I would recommend that that language either be added or whatever. I don't know how you guys do it, but I think that language would make it easier. The ideal way to do it is before
we get here for the real estate people and the people that have different issues to work out the language and get it written into the bill via an amendment so that it comes here and everybody says, we've worked this all out and now we're sitting here to tell you that. That's the way it usually works. But it sounds like, and I know you've talked to me a couple times too, so I'm really confused with all the conversations why we can't do alignment. So I'd like to try and get there as quickly as we can and land this plane. So here's my question. What I'm hearing is people are being semi-duped, semi-duped into giving you a 10-year right in order to collect money when the property is sold, even though you're not really selling the property. So help me understand what I got wrong when I
said that. Okay. The 10-year right was clearly an abuse of the system, and I think we all can agree that there are abuses of the system. Not, of course, by our people, but there are abuses of the system that exists today. Through the Real Estate Commission, there is a vehicle for addressing those abuses, and I think the Real Estate Commission does a tremendous job of investigating and putting the information on the table, but I don't think that a bill or a law should be written to put out one particular fire and eliminate a longstanding traditional practice for a very healthy, productive industry. Representative Farrar, you're recognized for a question. Thank
flipping properties? I believe what this bill does is if you invest in a property, number one, I think what this bill says is that you must have the intent to close on that property and purchase it for your own use, at which time you can sell it to another investor or to another buyer of whatever capacity in whatever manner you would like. Uh, what you can't do is sell that property or sell, uh, yeah, sell that property to anyone else before you close and you cannot collect a fee for doing that. So it's the interim where, uh, as a, I don't know how much you guys know about the, uh, the real estate industry today, but there are not a lot of, uh, derelict and vacant properties left most of those deals are already taken up okay are you I'm sorry
mr. chair are you are you calling profit a fee if I put if I bought simple I buy a home $10,000 sure I have an investor comes me I want that house I said for 15 that's $5,000 profit is that a fee yeah I would I would say can I can we get sir the gentleman to ask what I'm sorry what's the question represented back to you yes could we get the gentleman that's
running this bill to answer that question yeah when it would so so what we're gonna here's here's yes here's my question the process we have here is speak against the bill speak for the bill close for the bill that's the process that we have so if what we're saying is we want to see if we can work out a solution what I'd rather have is those folks to go over in the corner and anyone that wants to work on the solution with them to work on the solution and then we can have for and against and when we get to Representative Drown he can say in his clothes we now have a solution everybody agrees so if that's where we're at I'd like to do that if you're just thinking it's a question we want someone else to come up ma'am if you're okay with them sitting during your time that we can have them come there and answer the question that way is that what you're
to make sure. All right, so whoever that is that needs to answer that, please come back to the table. Doyle, you want to do it? Yes, I can do that. All
then, please. I keep barring chairs. Thank you. Yes, and I did have an opportunity to speak at length with Ms. Everett about this, and I think there is just confusion. And what she is asking for is in the bill. And I would direct you to it if it's in front of you again. No person will have this exemption, ownership exemption, from having to be licensed if they obtain an equitable interest in real estate with the knowledge that that interest was obtained on behalf of a person that intends to gain the interest in real estate other than that of ownership. So in Ms. Everett's case, she makes an offer on property. She intends to flip that contract to someone else who will then close. She has that exemption. There's not a problem with that. However, if she operated in the example that I gave you where she makes an offer on the property, whether she intends to close or not is not an issue. But if in that contract she embeds or involves a third party who seeks to gain interest in this property with intention other than closing, then she does not have that exemption. So that's the difference between the two. What Ms. Everett wants is already in the bill. Now, we can restate it a half a dozen different ways underneath that, but it will still come back to the same thing. that as an individual, unlicensed, you could make an offer on property, you could flip that contract to someone else who would intend to close, but you cannot do it if you're involving a third party who is just attaching a fee but will not close.
from the bill. So are you suggesting that he's misreading the language, or are you saying that that's not what he's saying is not true? I guess what I'm asking for is, if we're going to do this at the end of the table, what is it specifically about the language that you think does not accomplish what he's saying it does? Yes, sir. It is definitely about the language.
I mean, it wasn't clear to me, and I don't believe it would be clear to our investors, who are not attorneys, but I'm really excited that we all are wanting to accomplish the same thing. Okay. Representative Farrar, do
I think I know. I'm going to go back to the thing. I purchase a home, and an investor comes to me to buy that house from me. Yes, before you close. What you're saying is, I guess, He can't close. If he intends not to close on the house, and he's an investor to flip it again, he can't do it. Because he's buying it from an investor that has no intention of closing on the house, and he doesn't close either. He's going to, instead of selling for $10,000, he bought it for $15,000,
now he's got to buy it for $20,000. Okay. He can't do it. Party A buys a home or initiates a contract for that home. Party A owns an equitable interest in the purchase of that contract. Party A sells the contract to or their interest in the contract to Party B, who then intends to close it. Party A does that for a fee, collects a fee, a profit, you know, whatever you want to call that, and has the right to and has no intent to close on that property but does include to sell it or flip it to party B, whoever that would be.
Right, and he's saying that's fine unless it's a third party in between that. So if party B decides I want to flip that house, then that can't be done under this law. Well, actually, it would be the buyer entering into a contract and involving a third party at that point in the contract that has no intention of closing, that is just embedding a fee into the transaction. I guess my question was, is it a profit fee? No, no. The Real Estate Commission does not consider profit as a fee. Okay, well, if it's a profit, it's not a fee, all right. But if she's saying it is, and that's the margin
Chair. And again, I know the answer to this question. I just want to get it on the table and make sure that everyone's clear. When we're talking about assignments of the contract to someone else, we've got a contract and we assign it to another, which we see every day in the practice of real estate. We are fine with that. You can still assign contract. Is that correct?
That's correct. Representative Payne, do I can ask for a question? Thank you. And just so I can get clear in my head, when we talk about what they can't do, this bill just says that if they're going to do it, they have to get licensed. That's right. So we're not stopping anybody from doing anything if they get licensed. So if they're the investor, they're in the business and practice of doing this repeatedly, it's just a matter that they need to get licensed.
If they're doing it the way I described, not the way that Ms. Everett described. If they're doing it that way, they're simply making an offer and flipping that contract to someone who's going to close, they don't have
you do it that way. Thank you. All right, Ms. Everett, you have the floor, So you can continue your comments against the bill, or if you're done, then that's fine, too.
I would just reiterate that there is a great deal of confusion and fear among our investors that are preventing them from bringing opportunities to the house flipper, TO POTENTIAL LANDLORDS WHO ARE, AGAIN, MAKING A CONTRIBUTION TO THE COMMUNITY. MY OBJECTION IS THE LANGUAGE IS NOT CLEAR.
ALL RIGHT. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. ANY MORE QUESTIONS FOR MS. EVERETT? SEEING NONE, IS THERE ANYONE THAT WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK FOR THE BILL, AGAINST THE BILL? IF NOT, OH, EXCUSE ME, ARE YOU FOR AGAINST THE BILL? FOR. FOR THE BILL. OKAY. introduce yourself and who you're with. Ms. Everett, you're free to leave the end of the table, please. Thank you very much, sir. If you'd introduce yourself and who you're with, you're recognized to speak for the bill.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm Gary Ice. I'm Executive Director of the Real Estate Commission. I'd like to offer some clarifying language. This is a bill addressing exemptions. And to have an exemption, you've got to be exempt from something. What we're exempting people from is a requirement to have a license for because they provide brokerage services. Brokerage services are defined as providing services on behalf of another for compensation. What Ms. Everett is referring to is not brokerage services, so there's no need for an exemption for what she's doing. An example would be I buy, I decide I want to buy properties and sell them. That's not brokerage activity. I'm buying, I'm selling. Residential real estate. But if things start going well, I hire Doyle. Doyle has to have a real estate license. He's going to help me buy and sell. Let's take it to assignments. I make an offer on property. I get a contract that has an assignment clause in it. My practice is I buy properties, it's got an assignment clause, I'm going to go out and find a buyer. I'm doing everything. Nobody's doing it for me. I like my business model, I want to do a lot of volume, I go to Doyle, I say, Doyle, I want you to find me properties that I can obtain that has my assignment clause in the contract, and then we'll find a buyer. Doyle needs to have a real estate license. He's providing brokerage services for others. It's on behalf of others. The bill says that, on behalf of others.
Thank you. All right, thank you. Any questions? Seeing no questions, is there anyone who would like to speak against the bill, for the bill? Seeing none, Representative Drown, you recognize
close for your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. You now understand why I had these folks come to the table and talk about the bill. Being a person that's not involved in real estate, I have involved these folks in property owner's rights issues that we're working on. And the one thing that I take away from this is this is a consumer protection bill that is working on the best interest of our Kansans. And I
appreciate a good vote. I move do pass on House Bill 2042. Is there any discussion? Seeing none, all in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative Drown. You passed your bill. Representative Drown, you're recognized
Yes, without objection, we'll do 2044 next since your two are consecutive. And Mr. Cox, if you introduce yourself and who you're with, and you guys are recognized to present House Bill 2044. Mr. Chair, members, Corey Cox. I'm
Members, when we took office, of course, there are things that you see that may not make a lot of sense when you come in because you don't have the historical perspective of who all was involved when certain decisions were made. One of the things that popped up is that we realized that we have in our office certain registration requirements that are also required in the Secretary of State's office. The bill before you is charitable registration. If you represent a charity, you have to go to the Secretary of State's office and register. You have to go through all of the hoops that they require. Then you have to come to our office and register. We began talking to the Secretary of State's office about this and came to the conclusion that this was duplicative, that it didn't make a lot of sense, especially when you're talking about a charity that doesn't have much money and they may be hiring some attorney or someone to do work on both ends. The only thing this bill does is it changes where they have to register the information that they send to us. They are currently required to send everything in here. We have changed one date in here so it reflects what the Secretary of State's filing dates are instead of just a date that someone pulled out of the air and said that this is due on this date. Otherwise, we still have enforcement authority. It does not change enforcement. The Secretary of State has to share this information with us. But when you think about what the Secretary of State does, they register people, whether it is somebody that wants to start an LLC or they even deal with voter registration. I mean, this is the business that they are in. Uh, people that are looking for information on charities are not naturally going to go to the attorney general's office and look, we don't have a webpage up that list everybody that registers they do. So one, it allows for more open information, uh, uh, for the information to, uh, be disseminated to the public easier. They have the mechanisms in place, uh, to do this in, um, uh, we just think that, that it makes more sense. It will not cost the state any more money. Hopefully, it ends up saving money in the long run. It is obviously okay with the Secretary of State, or they'd be up here saying that we're doing something they don't want done. So I would appreciate your consideration and would be welcome to answer any questions you may have. Are there any questions
It will not increase staffing right now. It's not reducing staffing because the people that do this have other jobs, but it might. We'll have to see what it does. Okay. Thank you, Mr.
is there anyone in the audience that would like to speak against the bill, for the bill? Representative Drowne, are you closed for your bill? I'm closed for the bill. I do pass on House Bill 2044. Any discussion? All in favor? Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative Drowne. You passed House Bill 2044 and you're now recognized to present House Bill 2043. Thank you, Mr. Chair. As
who you're with again. Yes, sir. Members, Corey Cox, Attorney General's Office. Likewise, this is a bill dealing with the registration of telephonic solicitors, those folks that call asking for money for charities, folks that are making these calls. Currently, they register with us. The only thing this does is changes it that they will have to register with the secretary of state. We retain enforcement. Uh, again, it makes more sense that, uh, they have the, uh, the registration secretary of state has worked with this, us on this and they are, are in favor of it as well. So, uh, any questions
I'll, I'll be glad to answer them. Are there any questions from the committee seeing them? Is there anyone who would like to speak against the bill for the bill? If not representative Drowney are you closed for your bill? I'm closed for the bill. I move do pass on House Bill 2043. Is there any discussion? All in favor? Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative Drowney. You've passed House Bill 2043. Thank you, members. The next bill on our calendar is House Bill 2054, Representative Hammer. Are you here to present House Bill 2054, Representative Hammer? The next Next bill on our calendar is House Bill 2061. Representative Hammer, are you here to present House Bill 2061? Representative Hammer. Seeing that he's not here, the next bill on our calendar is House Bill 2086, and without objection I would like to set a special order of business for Wednesday, March 22nd for Representative Saban for House Bill 2086. So, Carol, if you'd put that in the calendar and agenda for next Wednesday. The next bill on our list is House Bill 2087, Representative Sabin. Are you here to present House Bill 2087? The next bill on our calendar is House Bill 2135, Representative Sabin. Are you here to present House Bill 2135? Seeing as he's not here, the next bill on our calendar is House Bill 2139. Representative Whitaker, are you here to present House Bill 2139? Representative Whitaker is not here. The next bill on our calendar is House Bill 2213. Representative Henderson, you're recognized to present House Bill 2213. Thank you, Mr. Chair, committee.
What we have is, what I'd like to look at is a little consumer protection bill. So it shouldn't do a whole lot. It makes a whole lot of sense when you really get into it. What the gist of the bill is, if you have a Kroger card or a Target Red card or a
CVS pharmacy card. Excuse me, Representative Henderson, just for members of Manacotta, House Bill 2213. Representative Henderson is presenting House Bill 2213.
You recognize Representative Anderson. And it deals with other discounts, like military discounts for, say, Representative Collins or Representative Richmond, or senior discounts like Representative
we have, H-Bill 2213 is a bill that helps retailers continue to offer these discounts, and these discounts are offered to everybody every day. There was a lawsuit in 2015 based on the Arkansas Price Discrimination Act of 1903, and I don't think it was really in the intent back in 1903 to foresee what we were living in today over 100 years ago. But what we want to do is there's a federal law out there, the federal price discrimination law, the Robinson-Packenum Act, which we want to make this law mirror that act so we can be in compliance and we can offer these retailers the chance to offer these discounts.
And with that, I'll... Are there any questions? Representative McCollum, you're going to ask for a question, and Charlie Spakes, if you would like to introduce yourself and who you're with, you'll be able to answer questions as the
ask for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm just trying to make sure I understand that this gives retailers the ability to choose whether or not they can use said discounts?
That is correct. Okay. And just to give a little history, like you said, it was a 1903 act, and the reason they had this act is to prevent manufacturers from treating favored wholesalers and distributors better than the mom and pop stores on pricing. So the intent of the law, we believe, is not to make where retailers can't offer any discounts discounts that are general applicable that aren't discriminatory.
Representative Payton, you're right to answer for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. On page two, the paragraph starting with line 27, I'm perfectly comfortable with all of it, except for I want to understand your interpretation on the religion aspect. And I know of a specific case, I think, in Searcy with a pizza place that was giving discounts. If you brought your church program from church on Sunday afternoon, is that going to be considered religion?
No, I don't believe so. This is not targeting that. But this is our part in that is that's to mirror discrimination law that you can't discriminate based on religion or any of that. So this wouldn't, I don't believe that would
apply. And I think that line really defines who we cannot discriminate from, whether it's religion, sex, color, race, national origin. We want to make sure in this law that we do not discriminate.
Well, we're talking about what the employer can discriminate on. And if they're saying we're going to give a discount for you bringing your church program on Sunday afternoon, I could see where a
lot of people would think that's religion. Um, well, currently there, unless we change this law, they wouldn't be allowed to do that anyways. That would be illegal under that, um, read literally, I mean, without this
that case. Well, there's a new lawsuit out, unfortunately, is why we're bringing this, but if read literally on the act, it does appear to make it illegal to offer those. Thank you.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Are there any other questions for Representative Henderson? Seeing none, is there anyone here to speak against the bill, for the bill? Representative Henderson, would you like to close for your bill? I'm closed. I move do pass on House Bill 2213. Is there any discussion? All in favor? Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative Henderson. You passed your bill. The next bill in our calendar is HB 2240. Representative Gonzalez, are you here to present HB 2240? Representative Gonzalez, you're recognized to present House Bill 2240. Thank you, Mr.
Chair. This is a bill that Representative Hammer and I worked on last session. Believe it or not, we got something wrong. We misnamed it, called it concierge services, and the correct term for it is direct primary care agreement. So this is just reaffirming that direct primary care is not insurance, not subject to insurance regulation, and renaming it from concierge service to direct primary care. Are
Gonzalez? Seeing none, is there anyone here to speak against the bill, for the bill? Representative Gonzalez, are you closed for your bill? Yes, sir. Representative Lundstrom moves do pass on House Bill 2240. Is there any discussion? Seeing none, all in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative Gonzales. You passed House Bill 2240. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Committee. The next bill on our calendar is House Bill 2251, Representative Gassaway. Representative Gassaway, are you here to present House Bill 2251? Seeing he's not here, the next bill on our calendar is House Bill 1166. Representative Rushing, you're recognized to present House Bill 1166.
Thank you, Mr. Chair, I bring to you today House Bill 166. We have been working on this bill, been working with the Landlords Association and the Realtors Association also have involved part of the Attendance Association. Well, they don't really have association, it's a coalition is what they call themselves. But this is a residential quality of standards bill. As each of you know, over the last several, several years, we always continue to get a landlord-tenant bill put in front of us, and we never can come to a conclusion. Arkansas is a state that does not have a landlord-tenant, and so we tried to make this as simple as we possibly could. We want most of the issues to be covered in a lease or rental agreement. The only thing that we're asking is that the bail would ask that in the rental agreement that the landlords would agree to provide potable water, heat during cold weather, functioning roof, working electricity, and the sanitary sewer system. This also does give some rights to tenants. It allows them that if these problems occur and the landlord does not take care of the problems within 30 days, which is an amendment that we made on behalf of some requests of some of our members when we first presented it. And we went from 14 days to 30 days. If the corrections are not made within 30 days, then the tenant does have the right to get out of the lease if their rent is current and there is no damage that is to the property and recover their security deposit. I think that this is a very good compromise on trying to get everybody on the same page and actually having something in place. I think it's very important that we have this type of legislation in place to protect our eviction bills that are coming through the process. We've had one that's already passed. We have another one I think that will probably pass as well. And in order to keep those bills in process and being legal with our eviction to be able to get tenants out when they are bad tenants, then I think that this will help solidify that we have some standards that we need to go by. So I am willing to take any questions and I do have people here to help me if
to ask a question, you're recognized to ask a question. I do. Representative Rushing, I like the fact that you added the water and the heat. I think that's the right thing. Functioning rate of electricity and sewer, those all make perfectly logical sense. I do have questions on page one. It talks about air conditioning. I've had a problem with tenants that will, and this is last May, a tenant took the weed eater and cut the line between the house and the air conditioning and said the weed eater did it, and I needed to pay for it. And I said, no, then you need to talk to the weed eater about getting the money back. And they said, no, it's my right to have air conditioning. And I said, no, it's not. It's May. August is coming. I would get your money together so you and the weed eater can get this fixed. there are some there I'm just wondering this this leaves the landlord holding the bag on a lot of different issues that's just one of many what what recourse does the landlord have in that type of situation because it is I believe
you're free to answer Representative Lundstrom's question. Certainly. My name is Cliff McKinney. I'm an attorney at Quattlebaum Grooms and Toll, and I'm here on behalf of our client, the Arkansas Realtors Association. And I believe that that particular issue is addressed on page two, starting at line 24, where if the damage was caused by the deliberate or negligent act of the tenant, then this does not apply. So if in your case where the tenant was negligent with his weed eater and cut the line, that would be his responsibility, not the landlord's. Right. But if
I choose to wait the 30 days, I'm now in noncompliance. And my renter can say, you're not in compliance, and you don't meet the quality standards of the implied quality standard of having air conditioning. Now I'm left holding the bag. Well,
the way this is written is at least what the intent of it is, that in that situation, the 30-day clock would never start because you didn't cause the situation to go out. The situation where the air condition was not working was caused by the tenant's negligence. Therefore, the 30-day clock never starts. And it would also, my understanding
would also be that because it was a tenant, uh neglect of the tenant that would not allow them to get out of the lease that would not allow them to retain those security deposit they would still be obligated to that lease because it was neglect of the of the tenant that's correct and there's an earlier
talked about, and I don't mean to tear it all apart. I do think there's some things that what Representative Rushing has brought in are very good. But there are also some things in this where we are, for example, what is an implied quality standard? Who decides implied quality
standard? The implied quality standard is supposed to be limited to those three issues that are specifically listed beginning on page 1 at line 32 and continuing on page 2 lines 1 and 2 which would be the the functioning HVAC system if it was there at the time of the lease and then the electricity potable water sanitary sewer system uh and then the functioning roof and building envelope okay at
some point are we going to have code enforcement come in between each renter and tell us that we we pass code i mean who decides that right now if a renter likes this property they rent the property they take or they look at the lease they look at the property and they rent it if they don't like it they walk that's just part of being in a capitalist situation i got to bring my best game every day If they don't like it, they walk. But here, the tenant has the right to have an attorney look at it, an inspection. How long should I wait and hold that property open for them to
do all that? It's addressed in this bill as well, and it says that in no way that the property be held. Senator Hickey on the other end wanted this amendment made, which was a very good amendment that says that we cannot hold it, that that property will not be held while a tenant is making those inspections. He can rent or you could rent to anyone else that came along. So there's no obligation to you. If that tenant decided to come in tomorrow and said, I'm going to bring my inspector and you had someone come this evening and wanted it just like it was, then you have that right without waiting for him to do his inspection. Right. I see that.
But one of my concerns is once we put this into law, who's to say it can't come back and somebody put out a clause that says, do you have to wait five days? Are we opening up Pandora's box on some of this? I
I'll withhold the rest of my questions. All right. Are there any other questions? Seeing none from the committee, are you through, Representative Walsh, or do you have more questions? I'll wait and listen to testimony. We're done with the presentation of the bill. We're moving to speaking for and against. Thank you. All right, so is anyone here to speak against the bill? You're recognized to speak against the bill. When you come to the end of the table, please say your name and who you're with.
Good morning. My name is Lynn Foster. I'm a faculty member at the UALR Law School. And although any opinions I express are my own and not those of UALR. You've probably been told that this bill is a good first step, and that is not correct. Although looking at the face of the bill, that would not be apparent. You should oppose this bill, and there are numerous reasons why. So these are my own opinions, they've been formed by over 15 years of studying and teaching Arkansas and general landlord-tenant law by serving on a national committee that with involvement from both landlord and tenant representatives worked on a model landlord-tenant law for over four years, by serving on the Arkansas non-legislative commission to study landlord-tenant law during 2012, and by hearing regularly from tenants, landlords, and their attorneys from all over the state. growing agreement that Arkansas landlord tenant lies unbalanced to the disadvantage of tenants and that that and that this is bad a bad thing and I congratulate representative running rushing and the co-sponsors of this bill and I know that many of you are here in this room for attempting to do something about the problem unfortunately HB 1166 is going to do little to solve the problem of defective rental premises and it may even hurt tenants in some cases And although you're being asked to view it as a first step, many, if not most, of the groups that have opposed an implied warranty of habitability for tenants will most likely oppose any further change. So why is this bill not a good first step that will benefit tenants? First, the bill places very few responsibilities on landlords, fewer than virtually any other state. This bill only requires a landlord to supply heating and air conditioning if they worked at the beginning of the lease. That's what the bill says. It only requires landlords to supply electricity, water, and sewage that complied with the code when they were installed, even if that was 50 years ago. This bill only requires landlords to supply a functioning roof and building envelope, whatever that is. And I think deciding what that is is going to probably cause some litigation. The essence of an implied warranty of habitability is that the law requires a landlord to provide habitable premises. This bill does not do that. That requirement is nowhere in this bill. Most states require landlords to comply with housing and building code provisions that materially affect health and safety. That's not in this bill. Most states require landlords to keep common areas safe and clean. That's not in this bill. This bill will not help the tenant living with black mold, which is a problem in this state, or an infestation of rats, cockroaches, or bed bugs. This bill will not help the tenant whose outside door lock is broken or nonexistent. Second, in the case of a natural disaster like the tornadoes that leveled Bologna or the flooding from severe rains that happen frequently throughout this state, under this bill the landlord has no duties at all and yet that is when a tenant may be in the most need of habitable premises third this bill contains no enforcement mechanism if the landlord breaches this duty the land the tenants only remedy is to wait 30 days for the repair and then move out it's as though you leased a car from a dealer and it broke and after 30 days the dealer said we're sorry we can't fix it, so goodbye, go lease a car from somebody else. In all other states, a tenant can sue to force a landlord to repair and sue for rental damages. In most other states, a tenant can refuse to pay rent and counterclaim to an eviction lawsuit by raising the landlord's breach of the implied warranty of habitability. In most other states, if the repair is not expensive, the tenant can make the repair and deduct it from her rent. None of these remedies are available under this bill. Fourth, there's nothing in this bill to prevent a landlord from including a provision in the lease that requires the tenant to waive the rights that are given under this bill. There's nothing in the lease to prevent a landlord of a month-to-month tenant from making the repair and then evicting the tenant a month later. Most states provide these protections to tenants along with the implied warranty of habitability. Good landlords already provide what this bill mandates and more. Bad landlords will be seeking to evade the requirements of this bill, and this bill will allow them numerous ways to do that. Fifth, there's currently a common law remedy constructive eviction which exists for tenants whose premises have become totally unlivable because of a landlord's inaction. A provision added to this bill a week or two ago cuts off either party's common law remedies for landlord non-compliance this bill does not require that landlords return any prepaid rent would a tenant who has terminated the lease be able to recover any prepaid rent it would seem not it's also possible that a landlord's common law rights will be cut off by this bill in ways that the sponsors have not anticipated so I think there can be some anti landlord unintended consequences here sixth the bill gives tenants rights they already have such as the right to purchase a plug-in smoke or carbon monoxide detector or the right to show the lease to an attorney before they sign it. In essence, what this bill has done is taken a very basic implied warranty of habitability bill from 2015, House Bill 1486, which this committee heard back in 2015, much of the wording is straight from that bill, and strip it of almost every tenant right and almost every landlord obligation. House Bill 1486 was two years in the drafting, and both landlord and tenant representatives were at the table during that process. It was supported by the Landlords Association of Arkansas two years ago. I believe the association supports this bill as well. I believe that they're going to tell you that this morning. Tenant representatives were not involved at all in the drafting of this bill. They didn't even see this bill until January. Tenants' rights are an economic development issue. Employers whose employees rent are not going to be interested in Arkansas as a state in which to operate a business. This is also a public health issue, particularly our children's health. Pair this problem that there is a definite connection between substandard housing with health problems and the fact that Arkansas ranks ninth nationally in child hunger and virtually all of these children live in rental housing and we have a situation that does not bode well for Arkansas's future and the future of its citizens. We have another bill this session, House Bill 2135, a bill that will not overly burden landlords and that has been introduced by both landlords in 2015 and tenants' representatives. Thank you for your time. I know I've taken up a bit of it, and I'm happy to answer any questions that you
may have. All right. I see no questions. So is there anybody that would like to speak for the bill? Thank you. Sir, you're recognized to come and speak for the bill. Are you Randy Thompson? Okay. Please introduce yourself and who you're with, and you're recognized to
speak for the bill. I'm Randy Thomason. I'm the president of the Landlord Association of Arkansas, representing members of our group. We do support this bill. It's not a perfect bill, but I don't think there is such a thing. And as Ms. Foster said, it is a step, even though she doesn't believe it's the right step, it is a step in the right direction, in my opinion, in our group's opinion. We're not going to go from no standard to a very high standard in one step. But this lets us start to address what we would consider slumlords, which gives all of us a bad name. I know there's many members in the House and the Senate that have properties, and everybody's concerned about what it would do. This is a step-by-step approach, and getting a very basic standard to make sure that we have landlords that follow at least some basic health rules and security rules is the first step to get there. It's very hard to get all the parties involved on the same page because everybody has their own interest, from code inspectors to cities to legislators to landlords to realtors, and everybody has their – and tenants' rights people. They all have their wants and don't wants, and trying to get everybody together on one page is very difficult, and I think this is the first step to get us there, and
I'm willing to take any questions. All right, seeing none, is there anyone that would like to speak against the bill, for the bill? Do all you recognize to
speak for the bill? Again, please introduce yourself and who you're with. Thank you, Chairman. Different hat. I am representing the Arkansas Realtors Association as a director on the board and a past president. And I just want it on the record that Arkansas Realtors Association is in favor of this bill. I would echo what has been already mentioned to this committee. It is not a perfect bill, but it is a good first start. I would remind members of this committee that Arkansas Realtors Association considers landlords and tenants our clients. We deal with both, and we think this is a good first step to put something in place that does set some guidelines.
you like to close for your bill? Yes, thank you, Representative Collins. I would just like to say in response to Ms. Foster's statement that this is not a habitability bill. I mean, it is a quality of standards bill, and we recognize that it is not a full habitability bill. And we recognize that this is the first step on trying to move towards that direction without overburdening the landlords, but also giving the tenants the right to protect them from the slumlords that we all know that are out there, which I think that most people in this body and most landlords that I know, they do the right thing, and they are always out there to protect their tenants. And so with this, I would move and ask for a good vote. Thank you. Make a motion.
Motion do pass. All right. So we have a motion do pass on the table. Is there any discussion on the motion? All in favor? Any opposed? No. The ayes have it. Congratulations, Representative Rushing. You've passed your bill. Next bill on our agenda is House Bill 1750, Representative Cozart. You're recognized to present House Bill 1750. Thank you,
Mr. Chair, committee. What I have before you today is a lien bill. It's an act to amend the law concerning the notice of lien upon residential real estate. And I'm just going to give you a little brief on what this basically is. Being a builder, I do a lot of contracts for people on remodels and new homes. And we often, if we're building a home complete, we would have everything included in that bill or in that contract. But a lot of times we do remodels and also sometimes we build a home for someone they want to hold out. They want to supply their own appliances or their own flooring or, you know, it could be many things they want to supply their self. Well, when that house is done, everybody needs to be paid or you're going to have a lien filed upon that property. So what we're trying to do here is if the contractor does not have it in his contract to do the flooring, he should not be held responsible for that lien coming back towards him. So we want that lien holder, our lien person, they would have to file that back on the homeowner. So what we're trying to do is clarify it up that if that's something that's left out of my contract is not in my contract, I am not responsible for that lien. As a contractor, we have a deal we have people sign, which is called an important notice to the owner, and basically it says that they understand that the contractor, subcontractor, labor supplier, architect, engineer, all those things in that service is entitled to a lien against that property, and if not paid in full, the services, materials, fixtures, anything in that, can be held from the contractor's final payment. So that would be that, but if we can, there again, if they had that and bought that material or made arrangements to buy that material and I did not, it should not be in my contract and I should not be responsible for it. So that's kind of what we're asking for today is to fix that to where that that lien would go directly to the purchaser of that product. Short bill, maybe complicated, maybe simple, I'm not sure. I'll be glad to entertain any questions.
Thank you, Representative Cozart. Members, is there any questions for Representative Cozart for discussion? We have a motion at the proper time. Any discussion or questions? All right. Is there anybody who would like to speak for the bill? Against the bill? Seeing none. I'm closed. What is the pleasure of the discussion? What is the pleasure of the committee? Motion to pass. All those in favor? Aye. Opposed? Congratulations, Representative Cozart. Thank you, Madam. Thank you, Committee. All right. We have next, 1751. Representative Cozart, do you want to run 1751? I believe the
All right. Let's not have that bloodshed. All right. Representative Collins, 1753. We'll come back to Representative Collins. Hang on just a second. Senate bill 498. Okay. We'll pass over that one. House bill 2014. Representative Saban. Representative Saban. Or excuse me, Balz. Representative Balz. Representative Balz. All right. We'll pass over that one. No. Oh, I'm sorry. I'm sorry. You have the seat. Representative Balz, please tell us about House Bill 2014. Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you,
Madam Chair. I'd ask Representative Farrar to join me at the end of the table, please. Committee, what we're bringing for you today is something that's been around a long time. It has personally worked in my family's health, and I'll just explain just a little bit about what it has done for us. My wife, four years ago, had some back problems, L4 and L5 bulging discs. They told us if she had surgery, it might last two years, and she'd be worse off than what she was. We went to an orthopedist, and he said that she was a candidate for this. She went in, they pulled her blood, spun it down, got the stem cells out of it, shot it back in on L4 and L5 vertebrae. In 10 days, she was pain-free. She's still pain-free today. Cost me $1,700. That was fine. It's been around for quite a while. There's good success with it. We would like to see the insurance company pay for it. could put about $100 to $125 million back in the coffers in savings. Would love to see this. I think Representative Farrar has seen positives in his line of business also, and I'll let him relate that to you.
Thank you, Representative Balz. Yeah, members, I'm a physical therapist, and I've seen this RPR therapies, and I've seen the stem cells. I had a patient, a weightlifter friend of mine, tore a rotator cuff, wound a candidate for surgery, went in, had the plasma injections into the muscle, regenerated the muscle, and he's today, no problems. You're looking at a $30,000 surgery to a $1,400 injection. So we feel like that this would save the state money in the Medicaid system, the state employees. Instead of having an expensive surgery, you do this. Like Scott said, this has been around since 1903. This is not experimental. This has been doing. It's just not being paid for by the insurance companies. We think it would be a great savings. I see these patients. I have a patient right now. The doctor told her she needed a total knee. Went to the orthopedic surgeon. You're not a candidate. You're too young. You're overweight. So she went and had the injections. Fine today. Not a problem with it. So you're talking about a $50,000 total need by the time it's all over with for a set of injections that's going to cost her about $2,000. So we'd like to say, we just feel it's going to be a big savings to the insurance companies and the state, and we'd like to just see them pay for these procedures. Like I said, it's been around forever. And they said they have an 85% success rate on their surgery and no infections at all. They haven't had an infection since they've been doing this. So even a total knee or total joint surgery is a 1% fail rate or injection rate or infection rate. So we think it's better and safer and a cost savings to the
It seems like kind of a no-brainer. Why don't insurance companies do this voluntarily? Not real sure. We're probably going to find out here in a little bit.
know. We had one company that did 120 procedures in the month of January, saved over $3 million. And we're not advocating one company over another one or one doctor over another one. It's just a procedure that works. What's the success rate? 85%.
And what we want to do is just give the physician another pathway. Okay, you know what, maybe you don't qualify for an orthopedic surgery, but let's try this. Or give the patient the opportunity to say, well, you know what, maybe I'm not a candidate. I don't like to be under anesthesia. Let's try it this way. And the ones I've seen don't require another surgery if they have it done. And I've seen a bunch of these in my office.
So it's a real good procedure. Are there any other questions? Seeing none, is there anyone here that would like to speak against the bill? For the bill. So Max Blue Cross Blue Shield is okay with this? Okay, well, we're either going to have to go speak against the bill or not. So, here, what I want to do is, what I want to do is, I want us to understand when we're putting mandates and raising costs, and then we wonder where the costs come from and why the costs are there. And the answer is every time, because we do good things. We help people. We help old people. We help injured people. We help disabled people. but then we look around at each other and wonder why our health insurance rates going up why does everything cost so much and we don't know why and the answer is because we help people and i'm not saying it's a bad thing i just want us to understand what we're doing and so if you would just share if you don't know the numbers max you know just give us an approximate just so we understand as we do it what we're doing because i'm the guy that has to go and tell people we need managed care and we don't understand why we need it and when we're doing stuff to make sure why we need it. I want people to understand it. So
just let us know. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, members of the committee, Representative Farrar. I really don't have a lot of information on this bill. I know that our medical directors did look at it. It is a procedure, like there are many procedures out there, that are alternatives to traditional evidence-based medicine. I think the issue is whether or not you all want to force insurance carriers in the state to pay for something that is not evidence-based with regard to the standards that are used by medical directors to set carrier's policy. I will be happy to try to get specific numbers. I am not here to advocate that this procedure does work or does not work. I think there are a lot of procedures out there that are alternatives to traditional medicine that do work, but the question is whether or not you want state tax dollars as well as consumers to pay for procedures that do not have large studies of people proven
a question? I guess I'm asking if you agree. I think many times U.S. medicine is so innovative and so technology driven, both with medications and procedures, that insurance companies often lag behind in their data and their information and don't add paying for procedures to the procedure codes that they reimbursed. You know, I mean, you know, we had the discussion about tomography. I think there are lots of procedures that actually would save the insurance company money in the long run, but they're slow to adapt them because the insurance payment method is not caught up with the technology that's out there. The only thing
I can tell you, Representative Ferguson, is that we review our medical policies on an ongoing basis. And I believe that our medical directors are up to date with all the latest evidence-based studies that are done. That's what we base our policies on. Is it true that there are cutting-edge technologies and services every day? Absolutely. But I think that that is a different bucket than what you want an insurance carrier to cover. And there has to be some parameters on which that coverage is decided. It would be wonderful if carriers were able to cover everything that helped everybody, but the cost of insurance would become unaffordable. And that's a discussion that many of you have been involved with on an ongoing basis. So what I want to do, again, I open
the door, so I understand that. And if we want to spend a lot more time on it, we can. I just wanted to make the point of open the door several times. They're going to be back in January, and they're going to say we need an X percent rate increase. And you know what all of us are going to say? What in the world happened? How did that happen, that they need a white, white, umpteen, those greedy son-of-a-guns, there they go again. Why? Right? And so, and again, it's not about this. We're going to do this because, you know, we've done the others, and that's okay. But I just want us, when the other side of the coin comes over to us, I just want us to be aware of it. That's it. So I'm ready to close the door, but we can keep going if others want to continue.
Well, I'd like to say I don't think my insurance premiums have ever went down, whether we add a new procedure or not. They continue to go up. And what I'm saying on this procedure, we're going to save money from a $50,000 surgery to whatever Blue Cross Blue Shield says the reimbursement rates to, to a procedure that's been around since 1903. It's not experimental. The research is out there. You just
Okay. Representative Henderson, you're right. Can I ask for a question? Thank you, Mr. Chair. I guess you mentioned something about evidence-based, and I'm a firm believer in that. but what have you or Blue Cross Blue Shield done to have you looked at this drug, looked at this procedure, and what's your evidence so far? How far have you gone to check and see if there's something here that you might be missing?
Representative Henderson, as I mentioned, AND OUR MEDICAL DIRECTORS REVIEW POLICIES ALL THE TIME AND COVERAGE POLICIES FREQUENTLY. WHEN THIS BILL WAS INTRODUCED, WE SPECIFICALLY HAD THEM REVISIT IT. AND THEY ONCE AGAIN REITERATED THAT THERE ARE NO CLINICAL STUDIES AS FAR AS A LARGE SCALE by the various groups that they consider disinterested parties who have done large-scale studies on this particular procedure. Well, I
do appreciate you reviewing this, but we really need clinical studies. If you're going to talk against a procedure like this, that actually could be life-saving, if nothing else, for individuals. And according to Representative Farrar, he sees this a lot in how good it does people, that you would think that he's just one guy and there's many people out there, many therapists out there that sees this procedure that you would investigate a little bit more and
I'm sorry, and I'm not disputing what Representative Farrar says, that this procedure has indeed helped folks. There are lots of procedures and lots of treatments that do help people. That's a separate issue from whether or not an insurance carrier includes that as part of their coverage policy. I think there is a different way of measuring it, something that may help a small group of people may not meet the threshold that are used by carriers or Arkansas Blue Cross in including it in its coverage policy. I mean, I'll be happy to try to get you the details of what our medical directors looked at in arriving at our policy with regard to this particular issue.
up. You're recognized for a question. Well, I guess my question would be, is this procedure covered by Medicare or other carriers, any carriers that we know of? Where does it stand with Medicare? No, this is not
is there anyone who would like to speak for the bill? Anyone else that would like to speak against the bill? Seeing none, Representative Balz, are you ready to close for your bill?
there any discussion? Representative Payton, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Since Chairman Collins made a lot of comments about the industry and the environment and how this may affect it, I just want to remind the committee that the insurance companies in many situations are on a cost plus contract. cost plus 25% in the Arkansas Works program. And so lower costs are not always in their best interest on profit margin. Thank you. Okay, is there any other discussion
on the motion? We have a do pass motion on the table. All in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative Balch. You passed your bill. Okay, now what I want to do in the calendar is, first thing I want to do is without objection, I want to remove House Bill 1271 from the deferred list, and it'll be on our agenda for Friday. The second thing I'd like to do without objection is skip down to Senate Bill 658. Senator Raper, you're recognized to present Senate Bill 658. Senator Raper, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. First of all,
I'm thinking about an amendment here to go ahead and amend to cover PTSD for all legislators. at this stage of the session. But I do also want to say right out the gate, Mr. Chairman, that this will be a quick presentation. But I also want to thank the members of this committee. We're carrying a lot of the bills that are coming out of this committee, and we appreciate the work that Chairman Collins is doing as well as the committee. Members, I think some of you were here a couple of sessions ago when we handled in the Insurance and Commerce Committees the issue of consumer litigation funding. consumer litigation funding was a practice by which many people that were involved in litigation around the country would have people offer them an opportunity to have some money up front on the pretense that if they got a positive decision in their lawsuit that they would not owe that they would pay the back the lender and if they did not that they would not owe a dime they were being charged somewhere between 200 and 500 percent interest when that bill came through our committees the last session, we actually had the U.S. Chamber of Commerce. We had African-American Chamber of Commerce Organization, Hispanic Organization, as well as the state chamber, as well as the trial attorneys that both supported that bill. I was told that's the first time they had ever done such a thing. The reason they had done it is because of the egregious nature of the interest that was being charged to people in that situation. I called it payday lending on steroids. What we have in Arkansas, the history, is that in the 2000s, 2000 to 2008, we had the situation come before this state. The attorney general got involved, the legislature was aware, and moves were made that really drove out predatory lending out of the state of Arkansas. And what's happened is that some of the very same entities that were run out of the state have appeared back now in the state with a new name operating in North Little Rock and Hope, Arkansas, and they've changed their interest to fees. Well, Amendment 89 to the Arkansas Constitution states the following. Maximum rate of interest permitted. The parties to a contract may agree in writing to the payment of interest not exceeding the applicable rate of interest if any set forth in the Arkansas Constitution Amendment 89, which happens to be 17% interest that's the usury correct cap that we have in the state of Arkansas unfortunately in this situation we have people that have come back they've tried to come back with a new name with new phrase ology and you can literally go on to their website and pull up the APR and it will show you 280 percent interest I am all for helping people that are down on their luck but i am not for at all taking advantage of people much like the gentleman that came and testified in our committee who was a purple heart recipient he said he went to a similar lender he borrowed five hundred dollars members they asked him to pay back thirty five hundred dollars he said there's no way that i could do that he's building up to nine thousand dollars representative doug house is not here with me because he's in another committee but he'll be carrying this on the floor and he told me he said jason i have counseled veteran after veteran and soldier after soldier and their wives who when the soldier was out on an assignment was deployed the wife had to go get help they got sucked into this situation they were threatening them to put them in jail members it's something that we simply don't need to have happening in the state of arkansas the governor has announced his support for the bill i think he's informed the chair as well, and the Attorney General, of course, supports it as well. AARP is here to testify for the bill. I know we're late in the day, so I don't know how many will get to testify, but this is a bill where we can come together and say, you know what? We are fine with people doing business, but we don't want to see them take advantage of people charging 280 percent interest. That's not helping anybody. I'd be glad to take questions, Mr. Chairman. And you also have before you a handout, which I believe chairman authorized which talks about the practice as well and a great
for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Senator Raper, I'm looking through the bill, I'm sorry, I'm just, on the, like, the HR block tax, the tax preparation people, they do a loan, would this affect them at all?
No, sir. As a matter of fact, and members, I will tell you, and I apologize, when I looked at the language for this, the Bureau of Legislative Research actually recommended that we repeal. That's why this bill is so large. The operative language on here actually is on page three. If you go to page three, if you have the bill, you can turn to that. What you'll see there is on line 23. It says, Loan includes payments for interest, expenses, and charges incurred with the making of the loan. And then it says the maximum rate of interest provided by Section 457-104 applies to a loan obtained under this section. That's Amendment 89. And so what you have happen is the consumer litigation funding legislation that we actually passed to close the door on that predatory practice last session, that actually was in the Credit Services Act. And what's happened is that payday lenders began to call themselves credit repair organizations. Literally, members, if you went in there today and asked for a $500 loan and you happen to not have good credit, they're going to say, I'm sorry you don't qualify. If you've got a family member that will sign with you, we'd be glad to make the loan. If you don't, we'll guarantee it for you. But by the way, when you do guarantee that, your $500 loan now will have on top of the 17% interest, it's going to have a $200 charge for us to guarantee you the loan. that takes them to over 260% interest. You can see that laid out in your piece before you. This is the part where if it walks like a duck and talks like a duck, it's a duck. They are charging people right up front. It's not like a situation where they default and then somebody's going to have to pay. No, they're getting that $200 right up front added on top of them, And that's when you end up with situations where the veteran that came and testified, $500, and they said you owe us $3,500 over the next four paychecks. It's wrong. All right.
Representative Payton, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Senator Rayford, I had at first confused this bill with another bill that exists. I don't know if you're aware of, but we've had some bills come through that are clean up from two years ago because a name, a label that we put on something was different, and your label is Credit Repair Service Organization, CRSO. There's another bill that is a credit service organization without the word repair in there. Are we talking about the same entities? What I am told is that the people that actually run
the two entities that I've talked about have gotten a couple of members to file bills because they want to do another end run and have you actually codify that practice in the state of Arkansas. Members, I can tell you right now in the state of Alabama, Republicans and Democrats are coming down to shut the door on this right now in the state of Alabama. So it is the same type of organization? It's the same thing they're trying to call it. Look, I did mission work. I'm fully aware of small installment loans, but they didn't have 280% interest. I will tell you, honestly, they almost tricked me into the very same thing my first year down here in the session, because I knew about small installment loans. They help people that need small loans. But what they fail to say is that, oh, yes, we used to be payday lending. Now we've come in from this angle, and we do have fees. So, members, it was a situation where I had to learn the hard way the first session that I actually was getting duped. And, again, with the consumer litigation funding issues that this legislature has already handled in the last session, and with the fact now there's no question about it, this is predatory lending. Look, if you want a good business, go out there and help people. You can charge them 17% interest, but you can't come in and, as Senator
Representative Eves, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. So on your bill, would these credit repair organizations be able to loan small amounts, you know, $700, $800, $900? I've seen here language where they can obtain loans or they can obtain. They're currently
doing them up to $1,000. And Representative Eads, if they'll do it under the usury cap in Arkansas that every other single financial institution is held to, they're perfectly welcome to do it. I will tell you the Attorney General's office has an open investigation right now on this practice. They cannot tell me what's about to happen, but I think the handwriting is on the wall or they would have said that they're going to relinquish and there's no further investigation.
specifically tailored, though we had to repeal and restate all of the language again, It's specifically tailored, and I had the attorney general's office vet it twice to make sure that all this is saying is that you can't come in and try to name a new section and charge people up front and get out of the usury cap. It's saying 17% is the cap under Amendment 89 that we allow for any organization to charge interest on.
Good question. Representative Murdoch, you're going to ask for a question. Thank you. I think I'm okay with what you just did with Representative Eves, I think, but I'm going to repeat it again anyway. So we know about the predatory people, but there are some good lenders that are not your institutional lenders that may loan $1,000, $1,500. But what you're saying is whoever does it will be subject to Amendment 89. You've got it. Okay. So whoever does it. You
and I have been down this road before a long time, and you supported that last bill, you're exactly right. It's just saying that you're going to be held to that same standard usury cap of 17%. Right, so
exactly right. Okay, thank you. Yeah. In fact, I'm basically advertising that there's a business opportunity in Arkansas if you'll come out there and not abuse
people. Any further questions? All right. Is there – seeing no more questions, is there anyone here to speak against the bill? All right, you're recognized if you want to come to the end of the table and introduce you. Oh, I'm sorry. Yeah.
hat, Mr. Chairman. You'll see that he's for my bill. Okay. So there's no one here to speak against the bill. Are you Mr. Klein? I am. Okay. Mr. Klein, you're recognized to speak for the bill. And if you can be brief, that would be helpful. I'm sure if there's any new kerfuffle, Senator Raper will be able to handle it in his clothes. So if you introduce yourself and
who you're with. My name is Hank Klein, and I'm a resident of Sherwood, Arkansas, and I'm a volunteer with AARP. And I'm here this morning to speak for this bill, not against, for the bill, because I think it's good for consumers in this state. and would aid in closing down Cash Max Loan Services, a credit service organization that today charges 280% interest. Senate Bill 658 completely amends the Credit Service Organization Act of 1987, and even though the current law makes it very clear that CSO fees should be included in the Arkansas user limit of 17%, This bill makes it very clear that those loans, including all fees and charges, could not exceed our constitutional user limit of 17%. And I am in hopes that this bill will stop lenders like Cash Max Loan Services, who currently operates in north of Little Rock and Hope, Arkansas. They've been there for about nine months now and making high-cost predatory loans. They make a $300 loan at 280.82% payable over the next four paydays using this CSO model. I won't go into all the details. He knows those, and they're good statements that are in this bill. CashMax arranges with a company called NCP Finance out of Dayton, Ohio, to fund the loans at the Arkansas interest usury limit of 17%. Then CashMax adds a fee for arranging the loans of 263.82%. Total interest is 280.82% for a $300 loan with four installments over the next four paydays. The owner of CashMax operated a similar operation called CashNow using CSO loans in eight stores in Arkansas from April through December of 2008. After Attorney General Dustin McDaniels ordered the payday lenders to close down in March of 2008, the owner of Cash Now converted those stores to this CSO model and continued to operate until he was finally closed down by the Attorney General on December the 15th of 2008. Now he's back up to his old tricks here in Arkansas again, except this time the loans are even more expensive than they were in 2008. Please vote yes for Senate Bill 658, and let's keep the high-cost predatory lenders out of Arkansas for good. Thank you. All right. Thank you for
your testimony. Is there anyone who would like to speak against the bill, for the bill? Senator Raper, you're recognized close for your bill. I think the issues are pretty
clear, and I want to thank the members who have talked with me about it. I want to thank also Senator English. issue actually submitted an attorney general's opinion request that dealt with this issue because it's in her district. Appreciate the governor's support, and I would appreciate the committee's support. All right. What's the move on the committee?
Reset it. We've got a due pass motion from Representative Henderson. Is there any discussion? Seeing none. All in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Congratulations, Senator Raper. You've passed your bill. All right. Next, without objection, what I'm going to do is jump down to House Bill 2022. I know Representative Letting has been waiting to do that. And then again, without objection, when we're done with House Bill 2022, we'll adjourn the meeting. We're going to have our next meeting at 8.30 a.m. on Friday, and I believe we'll be able to cover the bills on the agenda Friday morning. So without objection, we'll hear House Bill 2022, and then we'll plan to adjourn and come back Friday morning. Yes, and there's also a handout with this bill, we're going to be handing it out. Some people may be concerned that it may be a little bit sensitive, but the reality is it's a medical issue, so I don't think there's any problems with the handout. Representative Letting, you're recognized, present the bill, and you've got folks with you at the end of the table, you can have them introduce themselves and who they're with as well. Thank you, Mr. Chair. There is also an amendment for this bill. Do we need to take care of that before they introduce themselves?
that's recommended by some good people at UAMS. Do we have an amendment, Carol? Yes. All right, so I move that we adopt the amendment to House Bill 2022. Is there any discussion on the motion? All in favor? Aye. Any opposed? We've adopted the amendment, and now Representative Letting, you're recognized to present HB 2022 as amended. Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee, I'll be brief. They should be distributing those,
yes. We know that mammographies save lives. When women have mammographies, particularly as recommended once a year beginning at the age of 40 and up, that we are able to detect breast cancer earlier and are able to save more lives. The problem is that a standard mammography doesn't always catch the tumors. There's an issue with women's, the density of their breast tissue. About half women have dense breast tissue as opposed to fatty breast tissue. A standard mammogram, if it identifies a potential tumor, it shows up as white against a gray background if the breast tissue is fatty, but if it's dense breast tissue, you're basically looking for a white object against a white background, so it's much more difficult to spot. As a result, women with breast tissue, sometimes they don't are diagnosed as early, breast cancer goes undetected, and it is either more costly and more difficult to treat or it could cost the woman her life. What we're trying to do here is make sure that if a woman, if a doctor decides that a woman who has been screened might need a follow-up screening, a more advanced screening, that she is able to do so. Right now, this traditional screening is an essential health benefit, but an ultrasound or a 3D x-ray is not. So what we're trying to do here is make sure that those procedures are covered. There would still be a copay for the patient. We're not trying to make this free. But these procedures can cost anywhere from about $150 to $400. And for a lot of women in the middle class, that can be a decision of whether or not to put food on the table or pay a utility bill that month or get this advanced screening. In states that have done this ahead of us, it shows that they are able to cut down on the number of biopsies. They are able to detect breast cancer earlier. And so there is a benefit, a financial benefit, down the road to being able to address these issues much earlier. And I have two lovely people here who could talk about this in much greater detail than I. Let's see
if we've got any questions from the committee. Seeing none, is there anyone here that would like to speak against the bill? the bill. You want to speak against the bill, Max? Okay. And obviously we'll have time during the speak for Representative Lenning for your guest to speak as needed. Max, if you introduce yourself and who you're with, you'll
recognize I speak against the bill. Thank you, I'm sorry. Max Greenwood with Arkansas Blue Cross. I had the pleasure of visiting with Representative Leading and his two doctor guests before the meeting about the procedure and about what they're trying to do. And while I'm not here to advocate for or against the actual efficacy of the procedure, I did want to bring to your attention, once again, the fact that this would become an essential health benefit. It would shift the cost to the carriers. And our estimate is that it would add about $5 million just for the screening of this procedure to the annual cost of female screening. That does not include an additional 150 plus dollars for the diagnostic test. And I just thought that we should at least present that information for you all to consider.
So the point about the money, and Representative Murdoch is raising a great question about fiscal impacts, but I've seen the fiscal impacts on these things. We just have one on the last one, they're a bunch of hodgepods, nobody will put a number on a piece of paper, so they turn out to be a waste of time. It just says, who knows, it's going to impact us. So I don't want to insist on that. The reason is, you know, we've gone through the drill now several times, and, you know, this issue is at least as worthy, and the people are at least as worthy as all the other issues where we've increased our insurance costs dramatically. I just want everybody to know when it comes time for them to come and say, the insurance rates are going up umpteen percent. If anybody says anything about it, like, how in the world did this happen? I had no idea this was going to happen. I will call you out by name and said, I told you, it's on video. Are there any questions for Max? Representative
Ferguson, you're recognized for a question. And we talked earlier. So, you know, I just think very much like the previous thing we talked about, I think sometimes insurance companies haven't kept up with technology. Tomography is very new, and it actually saves having follow-up ultrasounds and follow-up MRIs and follow-up biopsies, which are very invasive in the long run. So you might be spending $5 million, but you might be saving $20 or $30 million on follow-up exams and on surgeries where the patient ends up with a metastatic breast cancer instead of a simple lopectomy or just a biopsy. So, I mean, I think the $5 million, if you're just looking at the cost of that test, is one thing. But you have to consider the whole picture, all the buckets, as Charlie said, I think in the long run, not only are you saving women the agony of a biopsy, but you're also saving them more expensive procedures down the road. Does insurance not, I mean, I guess you don't see it that way,
but. Representative Ferguson, I mean, you know, you are absolutely correct. You cannot put a price tag on certain things that individuals undergo. There is no way to put a price tag on that. When we establish our coverage policies, we look at guidelines and evidence of various groups. After visiting with Dr. Gales and Dr. Smith this morning, I did reach out to our medical directors to determine if the evidence that they had looked at was recent. And I did receive a response back that the guidelines that they have reviewed with regard to our coverage policy is as recent as 2016. And these are groups that include the USTPA. It includes the American Cancer Society. It includes various groups that have no direct attachment to this particular procedure. All right. Representative Murdock,
Chairman. So not to – I want to diametrically – I want to oppose what my able chairman seems to be asserting, that every time we bring about a new or an innovative or possibly effective treatment or plan, that it gives a blank check to increase premiums. I don't agree with that. But I think what Representative Ferguson just mentioned, when we look at the whole pot of what these new things may do to decrease possibly. So I want to publicly say what he's continued talking about. Well, when you ask about the increased cost and the provider comes back and says that they want to increase their fees or their costs, then I do want to say that there's an argument. There may be an argument. There may be justified increases. I'm not saying that's never possible. But it's not just always that because we bring something new that it increased costs. It could be that what we're bringing new can make it better from a care standpoint and a cost standpoint. So let's make sure we think about that as we come to the end of the table as well. So I understand what the chairman Collins is saying, but I don't know that that
means increased costs. Representative Murdoch, if I might, just to be clear, we do cover this. It is just not covered as a screening procedure, and that is what this bill does. Basically, what this bill does is allow for this procedure test to be used in lieu of a mammography. Absolutely, but
sometimes screening, and I'm not in the health care field, but sometimes screening is a source of preventive maintenance that can help us drive down costs instead of us getting well into the, you know, whatever the sickness or ailment may be that may cost us more money. So screening is a measure of preventive that I think is good as well. Yes, sir. Thank you. Representative Armstrong, you're going to ask
Two questions, I guess. Number one, when you do come back, indeed our chairman's statement is factual and I don't want to be called out by name on anybody's record. So when you do come back and you do ask for more funding because your costs have increased or your premiums have increased, would you all be willing to bring a comparison of what you've saved in wake of the potential savings that you have on the table? You only mentioned that you're going to incur more costs, but I heard you mention nothing about, through Representative Ferguson's statement, the advancements in technology and the paths in which we're going, that there may be some potential cost savings there. Would you be willing to go back to your team and whenever you guys come back, offer both halves of the pie, the savings as well as the cost? I'm not sure I understand your question, Representative. So whenever you come back, if there is a time, hypothetically speaking, for a rate increase in the future, are you going to offer the entire picture of saying we have identified some potential savings in lieu of this rate increase, or will you just say, hey, you guys
passed this, and now we need more? When we file rate increases, there is specific information that is required by the Arkansas Insurance Department that goes along with those rate request filings. Included in that are actuarial formulas that include a lot of math, yes, and the entire picture. Now, it is not broken down by every CPT code that we pay for. I don't know that the department would even... It can happen. I mean,
I work in this business right now, and we do it for CPT codes in our laboratory business in order to identify our savings, so it can be done. And I just want to make certain that you bring that to us, if at all possible. And can I
I think it's a fantastic question. I think it's a fantastic question. And maybe what we need to do is, and again, maybe it's informally, but maybe you can do it even for this committee, which is to say, here are all the mandates we've added. Here's where they cost more money in the system. Here's where they have avoided costs because of the preventative series, et cetera. And not just for this particular one, but for all the mandates, the ones that I've called out or the ones that others have called out or other ones. I think it's a great idea so we can see. Because we think, obviously, we've got some great ideas, and our great idea is we think we're lowering costs. And if we think we're lowering costs and we're doing that, then, my goodness, rates ought to be going down and not up. And so we need to see some facts that countervail that argument.
Do you all currently cover tomography? We do. Okay, and mammograms. You cover both? Yes, so mammograms are part of the essential health benefits in ACA plans, so there is no out-of-pocket cost to the member or to the consumer. We, um, ultrasounds and the digital, um, topography and biopsies are diagnostic. They're not, they're not used for screening. So they do have an out-of-pocket cost to the member. Representative Ferguson,
Representative Payton, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. So my question is, how is this the same or different than the example I'm going to give you? A couple of years ago, I had some pains and problems. The doctor said it might be my gallbladder sent me to the hospital to have an ultrasound on my gallbladder. Now, without diagnosis, I guess it could rupture and cost a whole lot more to fix. But that ultrasound was covered other than I had to pay a deductible. So how is this the same or different
than that situation? I am not a doctor, but the way I understand your question, ultrasounds are covered for various purposes. What this bill does is ask for ultrasound and breast, I can never get the word correct. Thank you. 3D mammograms to now be included in the essential health benefit packets so there is no out-of-pocket I'm sorry, there is no co-insurance or co-pay to the consumer. That's what this bill does. So if a mammogram says you need to go have an
questions, is there anyone who would like to speak for the bill? Okay. Ma'am, if you'd state your name and who you're with, you're recognized before the
ma'am. Sir, are you going to want to speak as well? Can you kind of do it together? So we can, because I think this is going to be a slam dunk. That's just a wild prediction, so, slam dunk coming, just as a week. And I'm Dr.
Well, just a couple of things I want to sort of correct that were said that are not quite correct. First of all, we're making a distinction between tomo and the mammogram. They're all the same thing. Traditional mammography is a 2D mammogram. Tomo synthesis is just a 3D mammogram, and it's just an evolution of the technology. It's been around for a while. It was investigational up until 2011. In 2011, it was passed by the FDA, and it's been in mainstream practice since 2011. There is a huge body of research and evidence that shows it's the superior technology to the regular traditional 2D mammogram. It finds more aggressive cancers. And so absolutely, it's going to decrease cost downstream because if you find an aggressive cancer when it's small and treatable, those patients likely will not require chemotherapy and more aggressive surgery. And so that's one point. The tomography or digital breast tomosynthesis, you're going to hear all those names. It's just a fancy name for saying it is a 3D mammogram. It is just the evolution, improving technology from the traditional 2D mammogram. And so the 3D mammogram is for screening. I think it was a little misleading saying it was just for diagnosis. That's absolutely not true. It is a screening test, and when we use it as a screening test, we potentially reduce the need for an additional ultrasound or reduce the need for additional views because we are able to see what we need to see. The representative said the enemy of mammography is dense breast tissue. It's that white tissue on a mammogram. Cancers are white, so when we're trying to see something white on a white background, you can see the difficulty with that. The 3D mammogram helps us to get around that. If you envision a photographer being in front of a door trying to get detail of that door, and there's a tree in the way, if they're straight on, that tree is going to keep them from being able to see a lot of the detail. But if they're able to step to the side of the tree, they're going to get more detail on one side. If they step on the other side of the tree, they're going to get more detail. That's what the 3D mammogram allows us to do, especially in those patients with dense breast tissue. That white, dense tissue, if you're able to come off the angle, you might be able to detect that breast cancer. Well, if we're able to detect that cancer on a screening mammogram, then we're going to help that patient by finding it earlier and decreasing the morbidity and the death rate with those cancers. And I really don't have much to add.
I would say that, as Dr. Barnes-Smith said, this is not considered investigational anymore, And other insurers have looked at this, including Medicare, and it is covered under Medicare and other insurers, including other Blue Cross Blue Shield programs. Thank you very much. Does anyone like to speak
Thank you. The only thing I'll add in closing is that New Jersey did this a couple years ago, and there's been a study that's shown that this led to a decrease in biopsy. So we do believe that this will absolutely catch cancer earlier and save
lives and save everybody money down the road. Thank you. All right. Do we have a motion? Representative Ferguson moves do pass on House Bill 2022 as amended. All in favor? Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative, letting you pass your bill. Thank you, committee. Without objection, we're going to adjourn at this time. We'll meet again at 8.30 on Friday morning. Thank you. We're adjourned.
HB1828 Warren CONCERNING THE ARKANSAS TITLE INSURANCE ACT; AND TO CLARIFY THAT NO CAUSE OF ACTION EXISTS FOR NEGLIGENCE BY AN INSURED AGAINST A TITLE INSURANCE AGENCY OR AGENT FOR LACK OF REASONABLE CARE IN A TITLE SEARCH.
28:38 - 4:40:45336 segments36 speakers
Representative Farrar and other members asked whether the bill would bar investors from flipping a contract or collecting a profit fee before closing, seeking clarification on when a license would be required.
[29:22][29:31][29:56][30:31]
Ms. Everett voiced confusion about the bill’s language, stating that an unlicensed person may make an offer and assign the contract if they intend to close, but cannot embed a third-party fee without a license, and the committee noted the exemption language was unclear.
[32:12][32:47][33:21][33:51][38:05]
Gary Ice, Executive Director of the Real Estate Commission, testified that the legislation only exempts non-brokerage activities; simple contract assignments are not brokerage services, so no licensing exemption is needed for flipping transactions.
[39:02][39:08][39:41][40:15][40:46]
No member spoke against the measure, and the chair recorded a unanimous motion to pass HB 1828, which was adopted.
[38:35]
Rep. Bruce Cozart introduced HB 1828 to clarify that contractors are not liable for liens on work omitted from their contracts; the committee moved the measure to a vote and approved it unanimously.
[1:17:55][1:18:30][1:19:01][1:19:17][1:19:33][1:20:02]
HB1840 Johnson CONCERNING THE APPLICATION OF INSURANCE PROCEEDS RESULTING FROM FIRE DAMAGE TO PROPERTY COVERED BY PROPERTY INSURANCE.
HB1890 Tucker TO ESTABLISH AN ARKANSAS CROWD FUNDING OPTION; AND TO REGULATE EXEMPTIONS UNDER SECURITIES LAWS.
HB1900 Bentley TO AMEND INSURANCE COVERAGE FOR HEALTH THE REQUIREMENTS FOR MEDICALLY NECESSARY FOODS USED IN THE TREATMENT OF INBORN ERRORS OF METABOLISM.
HB1958 M. Gray CONCERNING THE CREDIT SERVICES ORGANIZATIONS ACT OF 1987.
HB2042 Drown TO CLARIFY PROVISIONS CONCERNING REAL ESTATE LICENSE EXEMPTIONS; AND TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE INVESTIGATION OF COMPLAINTS BY THE ARKANSAS REAL ESTATE COMMISSION.
HB2043 Drown CONCERNING THE REGULATION OF TELEPHONIC SELLERS.
HB2044 Drown TO MODIFY THE REGISTRATION OF CHARITABLE ORGANIZATIONS BEFORE SOLICITATION; TO AMEND ANNUAL FINANCIAL REPORTS AD FISCAL RECORDS REQUIREMENTS OF CHARITABLE ORGANIZATIONS; AND TO AMEND REGISTRATION OF PAID SOLICITORS.
HB2054HammerTO REPEAL THE ARKANSAS HOUSING TRUST FUND ACT OF 2009.
HB2061 Hammer TO MODERNIZE THE FIRE RATING SYSTEM IN ARKANSAS; AND TO ESTABLISH THE ARKANSAS FIRE RATING BUREAU ACT.
HB2086 Sabin TO PROTECT THE PROPERTY RIGHTS OF CITIZENS; TO PREVENT THE ABUSE OF THE POWER OF EMINENT DOMAIN BY PRIVATE PIPELINE COMPANIES; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB2087 Sabin TO OPEN ADDITIONAL BUSINESS OPPORTUNITIES TO COOPERATIVE CORPORATIONS AND ASSOCIATIONS; AND TO PROMOTE THE PURSUIT OF CAPITALISM IN STRUGGLING COMMUNITIES IN ARKANSAS.
HB2135 Sabin TO CLARIFY THE OBLIGATIONS OF RESIDENTIAL LANDLORDS AND RESIDENTIAL TENANTS; AND TO REQUIRE MINIMUM HABITABILITY STANDARDS FOR TENANTS OF RESIDENTIAL REAL PROPERTY.
HB2139 D. Whitaker CONCERNING FRAUDULENT TRANSFERS AND VOIDABLE TRANSACTIONS.
HB2213 Henderson CONCERNING ARKANSAS PRICE DISCRIMINATION; TO ALLOW RETAILERS TO OFFER DISCOUNTS TO CUSTOMERS; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB2240 Gonzales TO EXEMPT DIRECT PRIMARY CARE AGREEMENTS FROM INSURANCE REGULATION.
HB1750 Cozart TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE NOTICE OF A LIEN UPON RESIDENTIAL REAL ESTATE; AND TO CLARIFY THE MEANING OF A DIRECT SALE.
HB1751 Cozart TO CLARIFY THE RESPONSIBILITIES OF AN INSURER FOR APPLICATION OF INSURANCE PROCEEDS FOR ROOF REPAIR; AND TO PROVIDE FOR PROPER ALLOWANCES ON A ROOF REPAIR INSURANCE CLAIM.
HB1753 Collins TO CLARIFY THAT THE SUBROGATION AND REIMBURSEMENT RIGHTS OF PARTIES TO AN INSURANCE CONTRACT ARE TO BE DEFINED BY THE INSURANCE CONTRACT.
SB498 Irvin TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF "HEALTHCARE PAYOR"; TO PROHIBIT WAIVER OF ALTERNATIVE PAYMENT SYSTEMS BY CONTRACT; TO PROVIDE A LEGAL ENFORCEMENT MECHANISM TO ENFORCE ALTERNATIVE PAYMENT SYSTEMS.
HB2014 Baltz TO REQUIRE HEALTH INSURANCE COVERAGE FOR REGENERATIVE INJECTION THERAPY USED AS A NONSURGICAL TREATMENT OF MUSCULOSKELETAL PAIN AND CONNECTIVE TISSUE INJURIES; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB2048 Rushing TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING CASUALTY INSURANCE COVERAGE AND MORTGAGE LIEN PROTECTION.
SB208 Maloch TO AUTHORIZE THE BANK COMMISSIONER TO CONDUCT EXAMINATIONS OF TECHNOLOGY SERVICE PROVIDERS; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
SB579 Standridge CONCERNING THE VALUED POLICY LAW.
SB658 Rapert TO CREATE THE CREDIT REPAIR SERVICES ORGANIZATIONS ACT OF 2017; AND TO REPEAL THE CREDIT SERVICES ORGANIZATIONS ACT OF 1987.
SB763 J. Hutchinson TO RESTORE CERTAIN RIGHTS TO A NONPROFIT ORGANIZATION.
HB2022 Leding CONCERNING MAMMOGRAMS UNDER AN INSURANCE POLICY; AND TO DEFINE "BREAST ULTRASOUND".
HB2102 Lemons CONCERNING THE RESULTING LIABILITY UNDER A WARRANTY DUE TO A BUSINESS NAME CHANGE.
HB2193 Hammer TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING DRIVERS EXCLUDED FROM A MOTOR VEHICLE INSURANCE POLICY; AND TO IMPOSE CRIMINAL LIABILITY ON THE INSURED DRIVER AND THE EXCLUDED DRIVER IN CERTAIN CIRCUMSTANCES.
HB2212 Magie TO PROHIBIT THE USE OF AN ALL-PRODUCTS CLAUSE IN A HEALTHCARE PROVIDER CONTRACT; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1145 C. Douglas TO RESTRICT A JOINT TENANT'S ABILITY TO SEVER A JOINT TENANCY WITH RIGHT OF SURVIVORSHIP IN REAL PROPERTY; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1271 Hammer TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS HEALTH INSURANCE INNOVATION ACT OF 2017; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB18 38 S. Meeks TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE HEALTH SAVINGS ACCOUNTS OF CERTAIN STATE EMPLOYEES.