May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 13, 2026
HB1762 Brown TO ALLOW AN EMPLOYER TO MAKE A MATCHING CONTRIBUTION TO AN EMPLOYEE'S TAX-DEFERRED TUITION SAVINGS PROGRAM AS AN EMPLOYEE BENEFIT. 2:48
Rep. Sarah Capp introduced HB 1762, explaining that it would let Arkansas employers match up to $500 of an employee’s contribution to a 529 college-savings plan and deduct the amount from corporate income taxes (not a credit).
[3:29][3:44][4:16][4:52]
Rep. John W. Walker and other members raised fiscal-impact concerns, estimating that combined employee and employer deductions could cost the state roughly $12 million in lost revenue and noted that no fiscal impact statement had been provided.
[7:55][8:22][8:54][9:19][9:29][11:12][11:43][12:15][12:38][12:44]
Testimony from Speaker 68 and Rep. Frances Cavenaugh clarified that the bill is intended to encourage even modest monthly contributions (as low as $10) and that the employer deduction would work similarly to the employee deduction.
[13:00][13:31][14:04][14:31][14:34][14:48][15:03][15:11]
The committee moved to a motion to pass the bill as amended, voted “aye” with no opposition, and reported HB 1762 passed.
[16:52][16:54][17:16]
Rep. Les Warren presented SB Warren, proposing to expand the Arkansas School for Mathematics, Sciences and the Arts to include 10th-grade students, change board meeting frequency, repeal the campus-transition language, and permit up to five international students per class with a $35,000 tuition.
[20:24][20:59][21:33][22:03]
Rep. Stephen Meeks asked about recruitment costs and confirmed the program would begin with Chinese students, using existing partnerships and a nominal fee covered by tuition.
[23:15][23:43][24:20]
Rep. John W. Walker objected, arguing that the $35,000 tuition for a private school diverts resources, raises concerns about limited minority representation and elitism, and questioned the benefit to Arkansas students.
[24:53][25:26][25:57][26:29][27:00]
After discussion, the committee moved to a motion to pass the bill as amended, which was approved unanimously.
[31:58][32:03][32:27]
HB1576 C. Douglas TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ACADEMIC FACILITIES PARTNERSHIP PROGRAM CONCERNING APPROVED BUT UNFUNDED NEW CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS. 37:10
Rep. Stephen Meeks introduced HB 1576, proposing that if an approved academic facilities partnership project is rescinded or otherwise unfunded, its reserved $10 million allocation be offered to the next approved but unfunded project below the line.
[37:15][37:45]
The committee did not advance a motion or vote on the amendment during this meeting.
[37:15][37:45]
HB1907 C. Douglas TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING THE ACADEMIC FACILITIES PARTNERSHIP PROGRAM. 37:55
Rep. Stephen Meeks explained HB 1907, which would allow unspent funds from the academic facilities partnership program to be reallocated to the next approved but unfunded project, with each project having a right of refusal.
[38:19][38:54][39:00]
During Q&A, members asked whether emergency situations could change the priority list; Meeks clarified that once the list is set, projects cannot move up and must use their own budgets for emergencies.
[39:00][39:26][39:41][39:54]
The committee proceeded to a due-pass motion, voted “aye” with no opposition, and reported the bill passed.
[40:09][40:18]
C. Douglas TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING PUBLIC SCHOOL HB1925 C. Douglas TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING PUBLIC SCHOO… 41:39
Rep. Stephen Meeks introduced HB 1925 to increase the review-conference period for academic facilities partnership applications from 20 to 75 days, giving districts more time to correct deficiencies.
[41:39][42:14][42:50][43:23][43:33][43:56][44:30]
Director Brad Montgomery testified that the current workload requires the extended timeframe, noting 144 conferences for 260 applications and that a 75-day window would address the backlog.
[43:26][43:31][43:33][43:56]
A brief clarification debate occurred over whether the period should be 75 or 90 days, with Meeks confirming 75 days as the final figure.
[44:58][45:01][45:11][45:26][45:33]
HB2207 Boyd TO ABOLISH THE ALLOCATION OF ENROLLMENT POSITIONS AT THE UNIVERSITY OF ARKANSAS COLLEGE OF MEDICINE BASED ON CONGRESSIONAL DISTRICT AND ARKANSAS RE… 50:21
The chair, Representative Justin Boyd, explained that HB 2207 would repeal the statutory allocation of enrollment slots by congressional district and allow the UAMS College of Medicine admissions board to admit students based on qualifications rather than geography.
[50:25][50:42][50:50][51:00][51:10]
Representative John W. Walker questioned why the existing system, originally intended to boost minority enrollment, was being removed and asked for justification, while Boyd could not provide a specific reason but cited anecdotal district-shopping by applicants.
[50:42][50:50][51:00][51:10][51:13]
HB1611 Tucker CONCERNING THE BASIC LANGUAGE OF INSTRUCTION IN PUBLIC SCHOOLS. 51:21
The committee considered HB 1621, a school-board election-timing bill introduced by Representative Lowry, hearing testimony from Representative Walker about potential loss of minority representation, Chair Boyd emphasizing local control and the existence of a diversity office, and multiple stakeholders-including the Arkansas School Boards Association, county clerks, and business groups-who discussed turnout, cost, and partisanship concerns.
[51:37][52:09][52:39][53:17][53:32][53:48][54:21][54:32][54:55][55:27][55:54][56:00][56:16][56:30][56:34]
After the discussion, the committee moved to immediate consideration, and a motion to pass the bill was approved unanimously with all members voting aye and no opposition, thereby reporting the bill out of committee.
[56:39]
HB2243 Davis TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING SCHOLARSHIP PROGRAMS. 1:31:00
Representative Davis’s HB 2243, which amends scholarship program provisions, was presented by Speaker 226 who outlined changes to scholarship amounts and eligibility, and Deputy Director Tara Smith clarified the new 2.5 GPA requirement for non-traditional students with college credit.
[1:31:30][1:32:06][1:32:13][1:32:20][1:32:39][1:32:42][1:32:45][1:32:49][1:33:16][1:33:52]
Representative Walker questioned the reduction of standards, and after brief discussion the chair noted no further speakers and moved to vote, resulting in a motion to pass the bill as amended that was adopted unanimously.
[1:35:58][1:36:04][1:36:10]
HB1575 Lowery TO LIMIT THE AMOUNT OF FUND BALANCES A SCHOOL DISTRICT MAY MAINTAIN. 1:39:15
Speaker 223 introduced HB 1575, noting that Arkansas school districts held a $790 million net legal fund balance and proposing a 20 % cap with a five-year phase-in to compel spending on priorities such as pre-K, tutoring and teacher bonuses.
[1:39:19][1:39:54][1:40:28][1:41:10][1:41:43][1:42:14][1:42:45]
Speaker 266 explained that HB 1621 mirrors the fund-balance cap of HB 1575, retaining the 20 % limit but allowing local boards, with state board approval, to exceed it for special circumstances and noting the need to address confusion over fund-balance definitions.
[1:57:57][1:58:28][1:59:03][1:59:13][1:59:36][2:00:11]
After brief comments, the chair called for a do-pass motion, which passed unanimously, enacting the bill as amended.
[2:01:17][2:01:39]
HB1608 Della Rosa THE BY ACCOUNTABILITY OF STATE DEVELOPED CONCERNING SYSTEM THE ARKANSAS UNDER THE EVERY STUDENT SUCCEEDS ACT. 2:03:20
Speaker 68 introduced HB 1608, stating its purpose to align Arkansas’s accountability system with the federal ESSA by shifting from a single-measure to a multi-measure framework that includes four core indicators-academic achievement, student growth, graduation rates, and English-learner progress-and a flexible fifth indicator chosen by the Department of Education.
[2:03:35][2:04:06][2:04:37][2:05:07][2:05:39][2:06:11][2:06:45][2:07:15][2:07:24]
Representative John W. Walker asked whether early-childhood outcomes could be incorporated, leading the sponsor to explain that while the bill’s language focuses on grades 3-8, the flexible fifth indicator can be used to address earlier grades and that the department will continue stakeholder engagement to refine the metrics.
[2:07:46][2:08:02][2:08:16][2:08:54][2:09:03][2:09:27][2:09:30][2:09:36][2:10:01]
The sponsor noted that recent Senate action removed prior ESSA guidance, leaving the bill to rely on the law itself and pending federal guidance, and affirmed ongoing development of tools such as a K-2 assessment to support early-grade measurement.
[2:12:25][2:12:44][2:13:17][2:13:47][2:14:11][2:14:21][2:14:26][2:14:51][2:15:21]
HB1666 Sabin TO REQUIRE INSTITUTIONS OF HIGHER EDUCATION TO PROVIDE INFORMATION ON MENTAL HEALTH AND SUICIDE PREVENTION SERVICES TO ENTERING STUDENTS. 2:15:54
Representative Mark Walker presented HB 1666, citing Texas SB 1624 as a model and arguing that a modest, under-$10,000 program to provide suicide-prevention and mental-health information to incoming college students is both cost-effective and has broad institutional support.
[2:16:25][2:16:55][2:17:26][2:18:02][2:18:33][2:19:05][2:19:37][2:20:10][2:20:45]
After no questions were raised, the committee moved a do-pass motion which was approved, enacting the bill.
[2:20:51]
HB1740 Lowery THE RE-ENROLLMENT OF HOME-SCHOOLED A OR ENROLLMENT CONCERNING STUDENT IN A PUBLIC SCHOOL. 2:22:47
Speaker 223 outlined HB 1740, creating a statutory process for homeschooled students to return to public schools that requires a transcript, a norm-referenced assessment score at the 30th percentile, and a portfolio of coursework to verify placement.
[2:22:52][2:23:25][2:24:02][2:24:13][2:24:36][2:25:07][2:25:33][2:25:38][2:25:51]
Following brief clarification questions, the chair called for a do-pass motion, which passed unanimously, adopting the bill as amended.
[2:26:09][2:26:41]
HB1457 C. Douglas AND DISTRICT PUBLIC SCHOOL OPEN-ENROLLMENT AN TO PUBLIC A ALLOW CHARTER SCHOOL TO DEVELOP A PLAN FOR THE USE OF AN ALTERNATIVE METHOD OF INST… 2:27:15
Representative Stephen Meeks explained that HB1457 would let charter schools develop alternative instructional plans for snow days-such as online lessons or take-home folders-so missed days could be made up without extending the school year.
[2:27:17][2:27:47][2:28:23]
He responded to the chair’s query about teachers’ contracted days, noting that many plans require teachers to be reachable by email or phone during the cancelled-day period and that accountability provisions are built into the proposals.
[2:28:30][2:28:55][2:29:00][2:29:29]
Following a brief clarification that the bill specifies a limit on the number of make-up days, the chair moved to pass the measure, the motion was seconded, and the committee voted “aye” with no opposition.
[2:29:43][2:29:48][2:29:52][2:29:56][2:29:59][2:30:07][2:30:17]
The committee adopted HB1457, recording a unanimous “aye” vote and passing the bill.
[2:30:17]
I'd like to call this meeting to order. Chair sees a quorum. Barely. All right. Welcome, everyone. Good to have you here today. all right this morning we've got some guests in the committee with us today probably have more than I have a list of but I do have some from Fayetteville area and Springdale area and if you would I have Matt Parker an art teacher from Fayetteville High School if You'd stand, Matt, and then I have Danny Darrow. Is that correct? He's the band director at Helen Tyson Middle School. Is that right? No, I have Helen Tyson also. Is that right? Okay, you're the band director. And then Helen, is that correct, next to you? Or who's, there's another? Helen is at the middle school. Okay, all right. I just got all this. She wrote this all together, so. Helen Tyson is the name of the middle school. Middle school, okay, all right. Man, that's, well, I've never been there, so that's probably the reason. All right. All right, well, we're glad to have you all today, and I hope you enjoy. All right. Thank you. At this time, we're going to, I've got to figure out which one I'm hearing. Ms. Brown, HB 1762, is that correct? Turn your mic on, and are you going to testify today with her? Okay, you might as well go ahead and introduce yourself and who you're with, and
Mr. Chairman. I believe you have an amendment? We have an amendment. All right, if you want to explain your amendment. Um, this, um, amendment basically identifies the tax, it's some definitions, um, uh, taxpayer employee and taxpayer employer, and, um, and it also, the main thing it does is it identifies who would, would, uh, be responsible for any taxes due if there was an unauthorized withdrawal from a 529 plan from an employee's account with the employer okay need
a motion adopt amendment I have a motion all in favor say aye any opposed no all right we I believe the eyes have that before you start I do have a question to I guess this deals with school employees and employers does not this is all employees all employers okay that's that's the reason I was wondering why this bill came to education but anyway we'll hear it go ahead
and explain your bill please I guess because it promotes education basically this bill and and you all should have a handout this proposed legislation allows an employer in Arkansas who matches their employees' contribution to their 529 college savings plan to deduct from their Arkansas state corporate taxes up to $500 per contributing employee. Now, that is not a tax credit. That would just be from their adjusted gross income, not a tax credit to the employer. This would only apply to employees contributing to an Arkansas 529 plan. This legislation is being proposed to encourage companies to offer as a fringe benefit matching contributions into a 529 college savings account. It would continue the promotion and importance of starting to save for one's child's or grandchild's post-secondary education. Finally, this would be another tool in the toolbox to promote and grow the Arkansas 529 college savings program and at the same time provide a greater benefit to the businesses and parents and grandparents of our state. basically what this plan does is it allows an employer to match up to five to five hundred dollars of an employee's contributions into their child's five to nine plan which a lot of employers offer this as a payroll deduction and it's offered as an employee benefit but this would now allow employers to match up to five hundred dollars and
i'd be glad to answer any questions represent walker you recognized thank you does this amount of 401k uh kind of situation for a big employer like tyson i just mentioned so tyson i didn't like tyson or um or um or um stevens and they want their employees to participate in this, then they in effect get a tax break if the employers participate because they are able to deduct from their adjusted gross income the amount of the contribution they
employee benefit. I understand. You're recognized. Now, is this to strengthen, is this designed to strengthen somebody's access to public education or to higher education? What a 529
plan does is it basically allows, previously I don't think this was frequently offered as an employee benefit but the 529 plans have been in existence for quite some time now and what they do is they allow people to save for their child's college education or probably post-secondary education for technical school or whatever the money can be used not only to pay tuition it can be used to pay for room and board any kind of books computers whatever that student needs to advance their education. Follow-up, Mr. Chair. That
you, Mr. Chair. My question, and I apologize if you covered this while I was out of the room, by allowing this benefit to take place, I'm assuming that it would result in a lower tax liability for the employer. Do we have any idea or any projections on what the fiscal impact to the state budget would be due to these
contributions? I requested a fiscal impact and did not receive one. We have no idea of knowing. To be perfectly honest, a lot of parents have not taken advantage of these 529 opportunities, and this is our opportunity to encourage them to do so. So we don't at this time feel that it's going
to the budget. Rep. Walker, you recognize for another question. Thank you. As I understand it, there is an amount of $6 million that could go into the – that could be allowed in the first year, seven, the second year, eight, nine, ten, and so forth, that would be to the parents. If this is a matching amount up to $500, doesn't that mean that the employers would also be putting in $6 million, $7 million, $8 million as time goes on? Here's my question since I'm limited. So if you allow the parents to do it and then their employers match it, that means we can assume that if parents put in $6 million and get deductions and then employers put in $6 million and get deductions, that's $12 million in deductions, and that's $12 million in tax revenue that is lost to the Treasury, and that results in some amount of loss to the State Treasury. Is not that what would really happen? The Treasury loses in relation to the amount of money that is put into these set-aside funds. Representative, this is not a one-for-one match, this would be capped at $500 per employee per tax year. So there is some cap to the tax deduction that employers would get to take. So to say that a parent would be able to contribute the full amount, if they contributed over $500 and got that tax deduction up to the $5,000 that the individual is allowed, the employer is capped at only $500 as opposed to the $5,000 that an individual is capped at. But to follow up on your question a minute ago, regarding the purpose and drive behind this, when I think of this bill, I think of a single mom who's working as hard as she can and saving as much as she can to put a child into college that could be the first generation to attend college or higher education. And I would see that this would be a benefit that we as a state would want to do to invest, to support that mother, to be able to provide that opportunity for that child. And that's something that we would be on the forefront across the country. There are only two other states that do this. And we would be on the forefront within our 529 program to make that dream a reality. And I think it's something that we would want to make as a priority as a state. We are able to figure
out. To recognize. That's your second one. Go ahead. We're able to figure out from this scenario that if $6 million goes in and $500 is one-tenth of $5,000, which is the limit, we know then that that would be an additional million. So that would mean it would be $6 million plus $1 million from the private person. That would be $7 million. million. We need a fiscal impact statement. The other thing is this. When you have the laudable purpose of having single moms be able to help their kids, this is not limited to single moms. It can be working moms, too, who make $50,000 a year. So let's not sell it as trying to help single moms who make $1,000 a month, $2,000 a month. It helps people who have money more so than it helps people who don't. Thank you.
I would like to respond, if a parent only contributes $500 a year, they're not going to make very much progress towards accumulating much by the time their child reaches high school graduation. So the idea is that this $500 that we would allow employers to match is strictly to incentivize and to get their employees to thinking about this. And then one correction, Mr. Walker, it is not a direct dollar-per-dollar. What's contributed is then deducted from the state taxes. It is not a tax credit. It just reduces the taxable income upon which the basis upon which the taxes are calculated. Representative De La Rosa, you recognize. If I could get just a tad bit of leeway, I want to
We're going to kill out testimony. Let's put it that way. Can I just go ahead and make a motion due pass then? That would be fine. It's a multi-part question. And one, the minimum contribution that a person can make to a 529 plan is $10 per month, I believe. Yes, ma'am. That's correct? That's correct. So a 529 plan is not aimed at rich people. A 529 plan is aimed at those who want to put away even minor amounts of money in an investment that they otherwise couldn't necessarily make that the state is handling to try and grow it so that by the time their kid gets college age or any of their children, because it can apply to siblings as well, have a chance at going to college. Yes, ma'am. And my understanding is what you're trying to do with this bill is to say in order to encourage even that $10 a month or that $15 or whatever it is that they might be able to afford, you will allow the employer to make a contribution into the 529 plan and let them get the same deduction that the employee would have gotten if they had contributed into it. the same way that a grandparent can put money into it and get a deduction or anybody else is allowed to put money into a 529 savings plan for a child and get the deduction. You're just trying to open it up so that employers may also get that same benefit as a method of encouraging them to encourage their employees to participate. Do I understand the program? Yes, ma'am. Well said. Motion at the
mr chair to try to figure out the possible physical impact of this can you tell us how many 529 plans are already in the state of arkansas and multiply that by 500 and that could tell us the deductions that might be able
to be taken of the two plans that we have in the state of arkansas the arkansas only accounts are somewhere somewhere around a little over $13,000. That's both combined. Yes,
ma'am. And if we did $500, that's a total of $6.5 million. Okay. I don't know. Let me do this again. That doesn't sound right. Is it right? Okay. Okay, $6.5 million in deductions that could be taken. And if we say our highest rate is 6.7% that someone, so I guess we could take points, six, seven.
impact. We are not required to have a fiscal impact on this because it's not a K-12 issue. So I just want to make sure the committee understands that. Okay. Why isn't
This has nothing to do with schools. This is all employers. So this is not a – I mean, it might affect K-12, but this bill should never have been in this committee. I'm just going to tell you this. It does not directly impact K-12 schools. So I have them. I'm ready if y'all are ready. You want to close for you, Bill? Thank
you, Mr. Chair. And I do apologize. I did request that it go to insurance and commerce, but somehow it ended up here. And with the shortage on time, we just decided to leave it where it was. I would ask for a good vote. Arkansas would be the third state in the country to offer this kind of benefit to our parents and our children and to encourage them to set aside money for college education. And I would appreciate a good
do pass as amended from Representative De La Rosa. Is that correct? That's correct. Any other talk on the motion? Okay. All in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed, no. Congratulations. Your bill has passed. Representative Warren, will you go ahead and take the other table, and I'm going to have an announcement before you get started. We have some people in the back of the room over here, some red shirts you'll notice. And these are speech and hearing pathologists, students and practitioners from various colleges and universities from around the state. And it looks like it's student advocacy today. I'll get that right. We're glad to have you all. Thank you for coming today. and there will be lunch today at capitol hill from this group y'all are all preparing that right okay good all right thank y'all for being here representative warren you have senate bill and it's the only senate bill we will hear today and the only reason committee that we are presenting one senate bill today is because uh mr and i'll get it right alder dice i try to say that wrong every time corey i'm sorry could be here uh he is the uh in fact i'm just gonna let him introduce himself and uh tell him who you are unless i'll let y'all present as soon as he does that
the arts represent warren you're recognized to present the amendment first okay all we're doing is Deleting two words that are currently in the bill. We're taking out the part that deals with students
from other states. Removing states or and adding two sponsors. You're also adding two sponsors. Oh, that's right. That would be yourself and me. All right. Do I have a motion? I have a question on the
amendment. Yes, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair. My question on the amendment is currently what you're trying to do with the bill is to allow students of other states and countries to be able to come and to pay tuition and fees. If we adopt this, I guess we're eliminating the opportunity for students from other states to come. That's correct. Is there a reason why we want to eliminate the opportunity for students from other states to be able to attend?
The main reason is we want to keep the focus in this country on Arkansas students. We are wanting to add an international component to this, and that's the main focus is to get some international students in here, and I will go more in detail on the international students when I present the bill. Okay, motion to the proper
amendment. I personally they'll tell you that I did not care for an Arkansas state school that was set up as an Arkansas state for kids here to have to bring other states into it. I think other states should set up their own but we'll do that. So we have a motion on the amendment to pass You have a question? Okay All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed no? Okay. Amendment passes you've presented as amended now Thank you Mr. Chairman. As
chairman of the foundation board for this school, I want to begin by telling you that this school is a shining star for the state and one of the top 25 high schools in the nation according to publications such as Newsweek and the Washington Post. I invite each one of you to come over and be my guest any day and take a tour to see what this school is providing to the students of Arkansas. This bill seeks to make some changes to the current legislation for this school. Number one, We have only allowed students in the 11th and 12th grades to be enrolled in this school. We have deleted this specific language and replaced it with high school students. We believe that there may be some students who would be entering the 10th grade who are greatly accelerated in their learning, possess the maturity for a residential experience, and would greatly benefit from an alternative point of entry to ASMSA. Number two, the required meetings for the Board of Visitors is being changed from monthly to at least quarterly. Number three, the reference to the school transitioning to become a campus of the University of Arkansas is repealed. This has been accomplished, and ASMSA has been a University of Arkansas campus for the past 14 years. lastly the language is being changed to allow for students from other countries same ages to attend the school four points that I want to make on that there will be a limit of five international students per class these candidates must exceed the standard criteria for admission and be exceptionally prepared for the college-level curriculum offered by ASMSA. Secondly, the students will be charged an annual tuition of no less than $35,000 to attend the school each year. This will cover all costs incurred by the school and provide additional revenue to be used for campus expansion and or improvements. No additional staff are required to implement this program. Thirdly, the addition of these international students will not reduce the number of students attending from Arkansas. Fourthly, this is in keeping with other schools across the country, like ASMSA, who seek to include an international component to their curriculum. ASMSA already has existing programs in Chinese and Japanese. The current students have been very receptive to their programs, and many have taken part in exchange programs already. Corey and I will be more than happy to answer any questions at this time. Representative
Meeks, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm supportive of what you're trying to do here and look forward to voting for it. The only question that I have concerning this is talk to us a little bit about the recruiting efforts. If you want to bring international students in, I assume you've looked at where you're going to try to recruit these international students from, what the cost of that recruitment effort is going to be, and how many students do you think might avail themselves of? No, please. Excellent. Primarily, we intend to begin with the Chinese market. Certainly, we have a longstanding partnership with University of Central Arkansas's Confucius Institute. Last year, we were designated as one of five Confucius classrooms in Arkansas. Our peers in three other states that have international enrollment are primarily working with China and South Korea as partners. So given the limited scale of the program, which I think is the second part of your question, 10 total students from international countries, five per year, starting with China, seems to make the most sense. Our peers in Kansas and Missouri are working with an organization called Markham International that does help identify students. There is a nominal fee that is associated with that, but we believe that's built into the cost of tuition, which, as Representative Warren mentions, is $35,000 per year. All
the proper time. Rep. Walker, you're recognized for a question. Mr. Chairman, please don't limit me right now. Let me say that I want to get my question in. Is this a two-stage question? It's a question with a preface. I'm concerned that we have decided to try to have a private school in Arkansas at a cost of $35,000 per student to the state of Arkansas when the state contributes $6,000 to other students and where there's no reason to say that some students from our public schools or other schools are better than others. And there's no reason that when you pull the cream of the so-called crop, the highest achieving students together, if you put them all together, They're certainly going to be in the top 25, so that's no great accomplishment. Everybody knows that you do that. And my concern is that what you are doing is furthering that concept of elitism at the expense of the state, in a state which is struggling hard, mightily, to be able to cause its students to do well. And here's where I'm going with that. We don't have a proportionate number of black students in the school. And we don't have a proportionate number of black staff or Hispanic. And the question then is why should we go and get foreign students and give them more access to what somebody thinks is a benefit than our resident students, our local students have? Other than to say we're doing something that makes the school even better and that much better than all the rest of the schools in the state of Arkansas. So why should we as a public policy continue to promote that kind of concept other than to say we've got a great school and our kids do well? I don't know anybody who's been to that school who's come to the legislature or who's most of them don't even stay in the state of Arkansas. So if you could just tell me what the benefit is. I've looked at the studies. More leave. Some do come, but there's no great showing that that school is of great worth to us other than as something as a showpiece for the county over there and for the state. Can you tell me why should we keep that school? Now, I'm not in favor of getting rid of it, but I'm simply saying why should we do it? That is not even
what this bill is about. Well, in a sense it is because what we're doing is adding a chance to add 10 foreign students. It changes nothing on the Arkansas side of it. It still goes to the
all. Let me answer, please. Representative Walker, I would love for you to come with me and meet some of the students, several minorities that I have gotten to know very well. We have minority instructors. this school is making a difference we we had one minority who showed up at that school with a pair of shoes that were kept together by duct tape and we are helping kids like that there there is no income data that's used to choose these kids we're helping them make a difference but I understand but let me also give you a piece of the puzzle as well I have chaired the foundation board for this school we are very very limited in how we raise funds we we do not have this school is 20 years old and we just we've been trying to expand we have been in dilapidated buildings we have one new building that thankfully the state helped us to a large degree but we have been raising funds every way that we know and we had a plan for a new building that a second building classroom building it was going to cost eight million dollars we worked and worked as a foundation board raising money oakland foundation gave us three hundred thousand we had a grant from a previous student who died that went on to work for google we got money from his foundation These kids now are starting to go into positions of leadership in companies now that the school is 20 years old. We're starting to get money to help grow this school. And, yes, we're working on trying to get these students back to Arkansas. We have to have opportunities for them. But the fundraising is very difficult. That building that we had for $8 million, we had to condense to a $4 million building in order to get classrooms for these kids. So I want you to come over. Let me take you on a tour. Let me introduce you to some of these people. We're fighting hard to make this school the best it can be with the resources that we have. And I think a lot of what you're asking, we're working hard to overcome. Do you have another question, Representative?
on. They cannot hear you. I think it should be supported only for the reason it shows us what can be done with our students and with people of goodwill trying to work to promote higher educational achievement within a context where that subject is valued. And the diversity is important if it's international. It just needs to be considerably increased across the board. And I've seen some signs of that, but your passion for it is promising and hopeful. Thank you. Thank you, Representative Walker. Seeing no more questions, I'm going
let you close for your bill. Well, I think it's pretty evident that I am passionate about this school. I think that I have been able to watch some of these kids coming out of this school. Their test scores on ACT have soared while they've been at this school. The kids have gone on to some of the top schools, but we have a strong percentage of our students that stay in Arkansas schools. The Arkansas schools are now working with these students at an early age. We have made great connections with the Arkansas institutions of higher education, and they are connecting with them. This bill allows us to have an international component that is very common among these type of schools across the nation. We are working hard to make this one of the top schools of its type in the nation. So this bill allows us to take a step in that
you're recognized. Have a motion to do pass as amended. All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no. Congratulations, you passed your bill. Thank you. madam chair you are recognized representative tucker after madam chair is finished i will hear yours just to let you know a bunch of them uh we're going to hear 1907 first i'm sorry we have about We're going to try to hear four from her if we can. You go until you have to leave. She has another
committee she has to go to. And I don't want to overstep my bounds with the committee, so I can come back as well. 1907, I don't feel like I'm transmitting.
you. There we go. There you go. Thank you. So 1907 is really just a continuation of a process that's been in place within the facilities department, which is under the Department of Ed. This bill merely continues the same funding, which is $10 million, for warm, safe, and dry systems. It's not an extra $10 million coming out of the budget. It is $10 million that comes out of the allotment that goes to facilities for building projects and for repairs. These warm, safe, and dry money goes to schools that need projects such as air conditioning, they need a new roof, electrical, plumbing, foundation programs. This is upkeep, and a lot of schools struggle to have the money to put into these projects, so they apply to the partnership program. The current rule would place these types of projects as the last priority starting in 2019 to 2021. If there's not enough money, the last priority may not get any money. So what we're doing is setting aside $10 million like we've done in the past. This is a bill to continue, that $10 million being set aside so that those projects will not be a last priority, but they will have a pool of money to go to them. Now, the other priorities are growth and space. Those are schools that are growing. Those are schools that have an economy to support maybe their growth and their buildings in a better way than the schools that are not growing. So I think this is very important for our schools, the majority of which need this money in Arkansas. And I would take questions and move for a due pass at the proper time. Mr. Speaker, I have a seat for you if you
and i think you've already answered this but this is a continuation of what's already been going on so we're not taking the money from other projects and putting it in these projects these money's already going to these projects we're just going to make sure it's going to keep going to these projects is that a correct summation the 10 million was in rule within facilities and this moves
it into code Okay. Representative Kavanaugh, you recognize. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Douglas, I just want to make sure that I understand that this bill will actually help our more rural schools with a declining enrollment that might not be able to keep their children warm, safe, and dry.
to close for your bill? I'm closed. What's the will of the committee? I have a do-pass motion. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? Congratulations. You passed your bill.
This time will be 1576. 1576, committee. Thank you, Mr. Chair. this is also deals with facilities and we saw as I've worked on facilities really all three of my terms we saw that and I'm going to read this because it's a little complicated this deals with the situation where facilities divisions approves a partnership project but can't fund it we don't have enough money every year for all the projects sometimes that are approved that typically would occur with warm, safe, and dry projects where the Facilities Commission has by rule established a maximum expenditure of $10 million annually. So this bill would require that should a project be rescinded by a district, the case would be the school board doesn't vote for the project, so an approved project will not be funded, but the money was set aside, or possibly their millage was not passed and the money was set aside for them, but they can no longer take advantage of it. So that funding reserved for that project would be offered to the first approved but unfunded project below the line. So in other words, if we had the first 10 projects approved and funded, and one project returned their money because a millage wasn't supported, this just allows a system for the facilities to go below the line to the next approved project that was unfunded and offer them the possibility of that funding amount. If they don't want it or if it's not enough for their project, then they have the right of refusal, and you would go to the next project. So this just assures that you spend the money set aside for that funding cycle completely by offering it to the projects that are below the line that are approved but not funded. A little bit complicated. I hope I explained that correctly. Representative Meeks, you're recognized for a question. Thank you. And I think I understand where you're going with this. The only outside-of-the-box kind of question that I have is we go down the list, and I like the idea of the prioritization. Does this allow any flexibility? So, you know, school XYZ has an emergency catastrophe come up that would it prohibit them from, if that was more of a priority because of the emergency catastrophe end of the world type scenario, would it allow them to move up on that priority list first, or would they have to wait and lie behind somebody who's just trying to, you know, put a beautiful new awning on the side of their building or, you know? It's my understanding that once that priority list is set, that you don't move up, you know, in the list after that funding has been dedicated to your school. Okay, so it's kind of an irrelevant question then? Well, you would have to dip into your own, you know, your own school budget at that point. and I hope I'm speaking correctly about that. Yes, I'm getting nods. Any other questions? Seeing
pass. Representative Walker, you have a question? I have a due pass. All right. We have a due pass on the motion. All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? Congratulations, you passed your bill. 1925, you do have an amendment on that one. We'll have
to present that amendment first. I would like for the facilities director, Brad Montgomery, where did you go? There you are. If he would help me explain this one. This is your amendment
don't want to really explain it. The amendment changes a timeline in there. We're changing two numbers, and we'll explain why that's important to the schools. But I'd ask for a due pass on the amendment. We
have a due pass motion. All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? Congratulations. You may pass. You may try to pass your bill, hopefully, as amendment. Thank you, committee, for... It's
all sleep deprived this uh this bill and i'm just going to give a brief overview because uh it's it's even still complicated to me and i've studied it for a year but last session we passed a bill that allowed for a review conference by schools who were submitting their projects to ask for partnership money. We asked for a review process so that the schools that might have a mistake or they might have had information that was deleted would have a chance to visit with the division and correct those mistakes before their project was thrown out. So I feel like it was a pretty good success, but I'll let him speak to that. maybe more of a success than we would like for it to have been. But we've gone back and tweaked it just a little bit and realized that some of the time that we allotted for the review process did not give us enough time for the division to get out and actually visit those schools. And we feel like under Director Montgomery's leadership, that is an important piece that needs to have time for them to get out to those schools and actually look at what's going on. So we have set that in there and given them time for that piece, and then also that gives them a little extra time in case a school did have some mistakes within the time frame to come back and correct their mistakes before the deadline. So it's supported by the school and the division. I think it's a win-win for everybody, but I'd like for the director to be able to speak to this.
to pull that a little closer if it's on. Yes, Brad Montgomery, Director of Division of Public School Academic Facilities and Transportation. Madam Chair, I actually did an excellent job summarizing the process with the division and the language of this bill just so that the committee understands there were 260 applications for the 1719 biennium 144 review conferences occurred for those applications so to address what madam chair mentioned earlier more districts are catching on and learning the process and utilizing the process and what this has created was a time vacuum for the division in order to review those those applications 144 applications cannot be reviewed in just a matter of a few weeks whereas the previous legislation gave the division 20 days to conduct a review conference with the school district and so in this legislation and with the amendment the division will have 75 days in order to conduct the review conferences and again it It addresses one of the things that she was concerned about was an opportunity for the districts to correct a deficiency once informed by the division that a deficiency existed in their application. Ready for questions? We are. Representative Walker, start
75. We actually had two or three different numbers there, and we've consulted and consulted, and we've come up with the perfect number, and we feel like it's 90.
please any other questions all right we've had one testimony for us i'm going to see does anybody want to testify against the bill not seeing anyone would you
ask for a due pass. I have a motion of do pass as amended. Anyone want to say aye for it? All right. I kind of messed you up there, didn't I? I'm not going
come to the table. And he has a couple of bills he wants to run. Which one would you like to do first, Representative Tucker? I'm only going to do 1611. You're only going to do 1611. Okay. All right. Committee, we're going to hear 1611. I believe this is a bill we re-referred with an amendment on it. Is that correct? That's correct. It's already been amended. It's engrossed in the bill, so you're recognized to present
your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Yes, sir. This is a bill that we passed out of the committee before, and I just heard some concerns on the floor from members that the intent of the bill could be better clarified, and so that's what I tried to do with the amendment. This is the bill, if you recall, where the teacher came. It's about the English language in schools. And so what the bill originally did was what the law currently says is that the basic language of instruction in schools in public and private shall be the English language only, and then there's a $25 a day fine for anything to the contrary. And so the bill originally struck the word only and also struck the fine. And I still think we should strike the fine because I think that's fairly archaic to find a teacher to do that. I think it should, if anything, it should fall on the district or somebody else. But anyway, back to the point of the bill. The concerns that I heard was that, you know, we were opening the door to kind of teach, you know, in other languages. And that's not the goal. The goal is to help teachers, to put teachers in a position to help kids learn in English. And so we're going to keep the word only in. So it still says the basic language of instruction shall be the English language only. But then it just says it's not a violation if an educator communicates with a student in the student's native language in order to help facilitate that student's ability to learn English and learn in English and become proficient in English. So that's what we were trying to do all along, and hopefully this language better reflects that intent and eases some of the heartburn that I heard about it on the floor. I have
questions. Representative Sullivan. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and I appreciate the intent. I just wonder what it does now. I mean, has anyone ever been fined for this? So,
you know, the chairman and I actually discussed this. I don't know. Maybe not. But what I do know is that it does affect teaching out in the state because they're worried about being fined. And so, you know, the teacher who appeared with me before, she had a personal experience where she had a kid who needed to learn French, and she's a French teacher, and she couldn't do it. And so after she had that experience, she communicated with other teachers about it, and she had conversations with teachers all over the state who basically are afraid of being fined if they do, if they engage in this sort of conduct. And so my guess is, you know, and I've reached out to the department, I don't think probably anybody ever has been fined, but it does affect conduct out there, and this would just give the teachers peace of mind to be able to most effectively help the kids in their class. Thank
a motion to do pass from Representative McElroy. All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no. Congratulations, you passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, committee. Representative Boyd, are you in the room? You are recognized. Take me to the table. 2207. 2207, committee. You know, we haven't killed a bill yet today. Mr. Chair, thank you. So
Present your bill. This is House Bill 2207, and I'm going to be very quick in the presentation, and then I'm happy to answer whatever questions. But it's very simple. Right now, there are laws regarding how UAMS College of Medicine admits people to the College of Medicine. And so what this does is it repeals those laws and allows their admissions board to figure out who is best qualified to be accepted in the UAMS College of Medicine. That said, I'm happy to answer any questions. Any questions? Representative Walker, you recognize.
I don't know that I can answer that. I just know that I hear stories from people from other districts that go rent apartments in different districts in order to get into medical school. And so what this does is it just allows the best people as defined by the admissions committee to
be admitted into the College of Medicine. A question? You're right. All right. Thank you. Now, the purpose of that bill originally, long before any of us in this chamber came, was to increase minority participation. And it was to fulfill requirements of a court order, which I helped to secure, to increase minority enrollment, it, which at that time was one person black per year to the medical school, and then they increased it to two, and we got them to increase it to 15%. And the point was that you were to have, because that was consistent with the state population, and then the university came up with the notion itself that there should be geographic diversity just as there was diversity with respect to electing congresspersons. Now, there's going to always be some fraud, but are you aware that most of the African-American doctors who have been trained in recent years have come from East Arkansas and South Arkansas? And if you eliminate this and you use a standard, we know what the average student's SAT score is, or ACT score is from East and South Arkansas, white or black. and we know what it is from North Arkansas so that means that by eliminating this standard you will be eliminating a safeguard which ensures at least some degree of minority participation and now the enrollment is less than seven percent I don't know why what the benefit is by changing it and it doesn't it doesn't get it anything any get it up at all so I'm trying to understand what motivates this other than the consideration to knock out opportunity for those who claim residence in the areas that are east of yes east of four of interstate 40 and interstate 30 coming after you get to Little Rock that's what we're talking about those students don't do well on as well on the test as those in round Fayetteville. Mr. Walcott, thank
you very much for your questions, and you bring up some good points. So let me do my best to try to address it to help you understand we're really not that far off. I'm for diversity. UAMS has an office of diversity. They will continue to have that office of diversity. There's nothing in this bill that says anything about changing diversity. What it would do is it would allow more local control at the admissions committee for them to define who is best qualified because at some point in time when you get as you have lower grade points lower MCAT scores it becomes harder and harder to graduate people there I just feel like they're better qualified at deciding that than than the legislature so to me it's not about diversity it's about allowing the best people to become physicians at a state
ask a question. Do we have any other questions? I'll give you one more question. Thank you. Are you aware that at the university now there is considerable diversity that has come about, not necessarily because of the standards you're talking about, but because of the sensitivity of the university, and the university itself wants to keep that criterion. I mean, have you asked them
whether they want to keep it if that's your question yes sir i have asked them and uh the so one they are officially neutral if you will that's that's what if they come to the end of the table and and testify they will say they are neutral on this uh number two they what happens is this is the only academic medical college in the entire country that has criteria has a law in place. So every time the Joint Commission comes and visits with them, they have to explain why they have this law on the books and what it needs to be. No other academic medical college seems to need to do this. I'm very sensitive to diversity. I hope you understand that. This isn't about diversity. This is about investing tax dollars into a state-funded institution and allowing them to determine the best students. And some of that determination is going to be based on diversity. I mean, so I understand
Representative Vaught, do you have a question? Thank you, Mr. Chair. So what I'm hearing is, is that you believe that there is adequate diversity population on there already and that you do not believe that this old method is still needed. Is this correct?
I don't think that this will affect the diversity. the diversity i think there's an office of diversity i think there are other ways to ensure diversity and i just think that this is adding regulation that we don't necessarily need thank
somebody gave me a due pass thank you what's will of committee i have a due pass from representative deffin ball all those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? No. Motion carries. You pass your bill. Congratulations. Mr. Lowry, which bill are you going to run first? 1621. This is a school board election bill, I believe. Is that correct? okay you have two minutes okay thank you you recognize
the procedure bill thank you thank you mr. chair uh this is uh hb hb 1621 relates to changing uh the dates of school board elections uh typically school board elections have been held at a time that does not coincide with any other elections and what we've had more often than not are very low turnout I think it the the main argument is to make that at the at the point that almost half of our state budget is allocated to education we want to make sure that we have the best candidates the best school board members that are out there and so this bill gives the option to school districts and and i want to focus on the word option uh gives them the option of either setting their school board elections uh at the may primary date or in the odd the off election years the same equivalent date may or november i think we saw i know i saw very specifically in pelaski county school district uh this last year when school board elections were held at the november election, not only was, I mean, obviously there was higher turnout because of the presidential election and all the other races, but there also was heightened interest in the school board elections because it was held at that. I know in Maumelle, for instance, a forum was held for all the candidates, and most of the focus and most of the interest, much to my chagrin, because I wanted them to be interested in my race most of the people there were there to hear the school board candidates and I think that that's that's a good thing not only for the democratic process but also for the proper oversight of the millions and millions of dollars that we send to school districts to make sure that we do have contested races that we do have candidates that we also have the public at large engaged in who their school board candidates are and you know one example for instance we had two school districts this last time because they were under state control and the state was able to set the school board election time at 1281 in the 90th assembly empowered districts to choose to hold their school board elections plaskey county school district has an example. In their 2010 election, which was the last time that they'd had an election on the September date, they had 2,368 people who voted. In 2016, with it being held at the November election date, you had 50,000 people voted. So that was a 2,113 percent increase in participation in voting on school boards. You had the same basic difference with Helena, West Helena. The National School Boards Association gives us figures that says 53% of superintendents around the nation reported that their district school board elections were always held on the same date as state and national elections. Over 27 states hold all or most of their school board elections on the first Tuesday after the first Monday in November only two states hold school board elections in September Arkansas is one of them so we would be following the the great trend that is out there in the nation we would really be aligning ourselves more with what other states are doing as far as school board elections so that is my my summary of the
Chair. Representative Lowry, thank you for your bill. I'm looking through it real fast, and we've had several bills, or at least it feels like we've had several bills that have dealt with school elections before and last session and this session both. I'm wondering, does your bill contain any provision for bond or millage issues, their elections?
No, it doesn't. And I know that there's great interest in that issue, but that's separated from this. This is just dealing with school board elections.
than the others? They have told me that they are more supportive of this bill than another bill that has been filed that gives only the November date. Okay, so this will give them a better option. They like having the option, and the thing that's been pointed out to me is that the May option is a better one because you can get your new school
I have some of the individuals back at home have talked to me a little bit about that this might create some more hardship on the ballot as far as setting up the ballots and things. Have you heard anything about that?
We have gotten considerable feedback from the county clerks and have adopted language that they have provided for us and so the county clerks association has given me empowered me to tell you that they are not opposed to this bill they're they're neutral on it because they recognize that there is going to be some additional work of coordinating school district lines with legislative lines and all those things you know providing the various ballots but they do appreciate the amendments that have been made to alleviate a lot of their concerns and so they're neutral on the bill
do we know how much that might be the fiscal the fiscal impact uh as far as state dollars is revenue impact is zero the counties actually will my understanding is that there would be a savings of money because you're not having separate elections. There is going to, you know, there's going to be some expense in terms of the various ballot alternatives that you're going to have, but it's going to be less money because you're holding separate, I mean, you're not holding separate elections anymore.
President Walker, you recognize? Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm going to tell all of you that I apologize for being the most outspoken person here. But the reason I am is because there are forces here trying to basically reinstitute segregation. And it's in subtle ways that one doesn't understand. This bill would never have come up had it not been, Mr. Lowry, for black people being able to take the dominant position in the Little Rock School Board because they have the majority population and by doing this this gives you an opportunity to if this if the board winning if the board is returned to have a majority overwhelm the minority that was interested in education and the same and that only affects Pulaski County now the point question here is Mr. Lowry what does this do for education I don't want the answer here. We know that school board members don't do anything except on recommendation of the superintendent. And the only thing they can actually do is hire a fire superintendent and approve things or disapprove things that are recommended. So why do you want to change this process, which has worked fairly well until it got out of hand in a community where you had gross white flight and you had a majority board and a majority community assume control of the schools in the largest city in the state why would you do this I mean other than race it doesn't let me go it doesn't affect Pocahontas it doesn't it doesn't affect Malvern it doesn't affect the schools in Northwest, Fort Smith, no other place than Little Rock. So why do
you want to do it? Representative Walker, it affects every community because this is not just limited to Little Rock or to Pulaski County. It's for the entire state. And I think the main reason is that we need, you know, I've heard when I have discussed with groups like at the School Boards Association about millage elections, for instance, that millage elections should be held at November so that there's more buy-in. And the feedback I get is, well, we only want informed voters. Now, I've heard a lot about disenfranchising voters related to voter ID, but there's nothing more disenfranchising than saying, we only want informed voters, which means lower turnout. School districts need buy-in. They need the support of their community at large, and they're not going to do that if they only have 2,000 people turning out to vote for either school board members or even for millages. For us to be able to turn this around to have more public support, more widespread community support, I think we need to have more participation, and this is not about race. Helena West Helena, for instance, requested the November election. They specifically asked for that.
I think I – was that a follow-up? I guess I'd like to say this. I'm not, I mean, obviously, subtlety and intent are hard to discern. And all of these bills that come from you seem to be directed toward changing the racial imbalance. Point of personal privilege, Mr. Chair. That is a direct attack on me. I don't think that is right. Let's refrain from that. I will, but here's the concern. And when you talked about what happened in Pulaski County and that election, you went from a board that had three blacks out of seven on it to one black out of seven by changing the election date. Thank you.
Is there any other questions, Committee? I do have people signed up for and against this bill. I have Tony Protho. You're recognized to speak against the bill. please state your name and who
you're with and you're recognized tony prothro arkansas school boards association uh we oppose this bill because as you all know uh when you have an election in september it's non-partisan and we believe that moving the election is going to to some degree make that partisan uh the the bill we currently have in september so the focus is solely on kids When you move it to some time other than in September, we're going to see, we believe, as in talking with some of our sister states who have moved to November elections, you're going to see partisanship coming in. Board members will be running, not based upon how they're going to impact schools, but in many cases, their stance on gun control or some other hot topic button. It's going to lose that intensity and that focus on our kids. also you talk about uh the cost for running for office currently you know when it's in september you have people who are running many times on limited income and also these are unpaid servant leaders there's no pay for the job when you start throwing them in with the rest of all the officers that are running it's going to take a significant amount of money for them to be able to be seen their voices heard in a lot of the communities across the state of Arkansas. So, once again, during that time, they're going to be lost in the shuffle, and the kids are going to lose overall through this. I'll be happy to take
And looking at the bills that we've had in the past that have run, we testified for the one that gave the board members the choice between September and November when Senator English presented that in 2015. But when we look at the rest of the bills that we see that are running, dealing with school elections, those usually restrict it to just November. So it is preferable that there is some choice there, that a board could make a choice between May and November, specifically for the purposes of November has so many issues with timelines with board members coming on halfway through the year budget process things of that nature whereas in if it is a May option for a school district they're there before the budget process begins they're able to vote on so many other things and be a part of that academic year so
be preferable. When you're saying the two bills, I suppose that you're talking about Senator English's bill, which restricts it only to November. We see this as the lesser of the
with Forward Arkansas. This was one of the, well, the school elections were one of the recommendations that made it into Forward Arkansas's vision report in 2015. It was much debated by our steering committee when that made it into the report, and I just wanted to share a little bit of the background as well as the recommendation. on the pro side it was clearly recognized that this would likely increase voter turnout in school elections as representative lowry said that it would bring arkansas school elections in line with the majority of states and school districts around the nation and that it could potentially save on the administrative cost of elections on the flip side it was recognized that this could make it more difficult for candidates in school elections to ensure that their messaging reaches the electorate. Originally part of the reason why school elections were moved to a special election format was to ensure that there were those informed voters who knew that they were voting specifically on the school election issues and this could result in voters voting in an election where they have more information uh due to advertising and other things that have come out with regard to other elections on that ballot when compared to the school elections on that ballot but as i said after much deliberation the language in our vision report was that we recommended changing the timing of school board elections to coincide with state or district elections the The Steering Committee clearly wished for Arkansas laws and policies to encourage candidates in school board elections to be engaged and well-informed. There was also a clearly expressed desire for school districts to be able to maintain some degree of flexibility and local control in setting their election dates. We believe that this piece of legislation is generally supportive of our vision. That being said, there are provisions in this bill that just don't touch on one way or another the specific language that I just shared with you, the folks who are tasked with implementing those recommendations forward's implementation working group is a very highly qualified and very diverse group. And I understand you may be hearing from some of our IWG members who take opposition to some of the provisions in this particular bill. And I just wanted to say at the front end, that's fine with us. we pride ourselves on being the folks who can keep a table that folks can come to and discuss education policy and a vision for our state. When they disagree on things, they can get up from the table and come over here and express their opposing views and we'll keep the table for them to come back to. So I just wanted to say we are very encouraging of your thoughtful deliberation here. Thank you. Representative Eubanks, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. So do you
director of AAEA and I think Mr. Biggs did a good job of laying out pros and cons and there are pros and cons to this you know some of our concerns on on this is with it being such a minor election that school board members' cost may go up if they're trying to compete advertising and campaigning with some of the other larger elections out there, and that may get lost in the shuffle. And as you know, it's hard in many places to get good people to run for any office, much less school board members. So that's a concern, and I mean, this is a policy decision. And before I'm asked a question about which bills would we prefer, it would be this one. We worked with Representative Lowry somewhat on this, and it doesn't move the millage elections. Of course, if that's moved and if it becomes harder to pass a millage, that would add more responsibility to the state. So out of the multiple bills, I don't know how many is out there, but we would prefer this one. But we do have some concerns with it. Representative Walker, you recognize. Isn't it as
important to have as many people vote in a millage election as it is in a school election? Absolutely. Why would you want a lower threshold for millages than you do for citizen participation? It's not
the threshold. What we're concerned about is this getting lost in the shuffle because there's going to be so many other elections going on at the same time that people won't be focused on the school election. And we want them zeroed in on who's gonna make the best school board member or millage or whatever the issue is and in with it being such a minor part of that process if it's moved and that that's our concern follow-up mr. chair it's not that people won't vote we want people to vote like represent Lowry said now that's the democratic process we'd like them all vote
follow-up please you recognize isn't it isn't it historic that in many cases school elections and millage elections have been held concurrently? Yes, sir. Thank you. Representative Eubanks, do
you have a question? Thank you, Mr. Chair. Dr. Abernathy, I know you're familiar with the Paris School District that I served on that school board. The first time I was elected to that position, there was only a total of like 200 votes that made that decision. Do you not think it would be better if more people participated in that decision rather than just such a small number? because so many people that normally vote just don't turn out for a school board election. Now, I disagree that they may not think it's important because I think it's very important, but, I mean, 200 people made that decision, I mean, and it was in the whole district.
That was before I went to Paris, and I don't know if you were opposed or unopposed or not. Obviously, that makes some difference, but... I was opposed. That surprises me, Representative Eubanks. We, Representative Eubanks, we want everyone to not only have an opportunity to vote, but go exercise that opportunity. I don't care if the election's in September or November or May or June. They need to exercise their right to vote. And obviously we want everyone informed on all the issues they're voting on. But absolutely, if people don't vote, then they don't have any right to
complain. Thank you. Representative Eubanks, evidently you won that, though. I think my election, my first one, I was unopposed on the guy that was only 275 that voted. All right, we have Kenny Hall to speak for the bill. Please state your name and who you're
good morning, committee. My name is Kenny Hall. I'm with the Arkansas State Chamber of Commerce and the Associated Industries of Arkansas. and we have a very strong interest in education and workforce development and have for a very long time. I've worked for the organization for over 18 years and I've seen us in many, many educational issues and we have been on this issue for probably 8 to 10, maybe even 12 years. So we see this as a very important issue to make sure that the people we represent, which includes over 1,100 businesses across the state in every county. We have most of the business associations as members. We have almost all of the local chambers of commerce as members, certainly all of the larger ones, and probably all of the economic developers. So when we come speak, we are analyzing issues based upon that very diverse business interest. And as I was trying not to rehash any issues about the specifics of the bill, two things have really hit me about this bill. First of all, it's leadership. I've been involved in sports for all my life. I've watched all of you work in politics here for 18 years. I've watched businesses grow and develop. And in every case, the ones that were successful, they were the ones that had good leadership. And I think it's been stated multiple times the importance of a large number of people having a voice. It's the essence of our democracy. And I've been a resident of Pulaski County now for 18 plus years. This was the first school board election I knew that existed. The first time I knew who the candidates were. The first time I actually looked into who the candidates were. And I was very, very pleased that that happened. I disagree with the concerns about it getting lost in the election. I mean, we have presidential elections, we have your elections, we have all kinds of elections going on at the same time. I just see them all working together. I also disagree with the statement about partisanship. This state adopted Amendment 80 a few years ago and moved the judicial elections from partisan to nonpartisan. And I have not seen, well, it will never go away, but I don't think it's been a huge problem. So at any rate, we strongly support this bill and appreciate Representative Lowry bringing it. President Walker, you reckon I am?
Thank you, Mr. Hall. I'm a member of the chamber, as you know. I pay my dues. I'm concerned about correlations and also chamber participation with the broader community and the concept that where you have success, you have good leadership. It's my observation that more often than not where you have success, it's good connections, and you get an additional $300 million or $400 million on a connection where somebody else may not get that, and maybe business does that. But in terms of the chamber, isn't it fair to say that in the Little Rock election, which precipitates this, the chamber stayed out of that in the last election, didn't participate, didn't put any money into it because they knew that they could not influence the outcome of four of the wards. and you knew that at that time the people wanted to do something to improve their schools rather than have the chamber continue its mission of failing the kids in southwest Little Rock? No, sir. First of all, we're— You said no. Now, here's my question. Isn't it true that— That's a double question. You've got to start asking the first question. He answered my question. My question, he said no, and that was all. Isn't it true? That was a no. Now, isn't it true that those students in southwest Little Rock have never had an opportunity to have equal education as those on the west side of the freeway and in the heights and in the rich parts of Little Rock?
I have no idea. Thank you. I lived in southwest Little Rock in the formative years of my life, and I really enjoyed it. But back to your first question that I did not get to answer. We are the State Chamber of Commerce. We're not the Pulaski County Chamber. We're not the Little Rock Chamber. We're not the North Little Rock Chamber. Our role is to represent the businesses across the state. So it was not our role to engage in that election, and we never engage in local elections because there are local chambers of commerce in place to deal with that. The leadership issue, I may have misstated. I'm kind of like Representative Cozart. I'm kind of bleary-brained right now. I'm not sure things are coming out the way I intend them to. But what I was referring to was the ability to get quality people like Representative Eubanks to serve on their local school boards because the leaders are the ones that make the key decisions that result in good results. That's the reference I was making to in regards to leadership.
a question. thank you mr. chair in in my school district there in Fort Smith my understanding is this would be quite confusing to our constituents because we use our representatives our school board members are elected by zone and so could you address that? How would that impact us? I'm not sure I follow a problem. I mean,
every election involves some sort of district. All of the representatives are from districts. Just about everything that has multiple representation is divided up, unless it's like, I guess there are some cities that vote on pluralities, but most have wards. So I'm not following how there would be an issue and I appreciate
I can I can answer that question is we've already discussed the multiple ballots that you would have to have but this really would only impact school board elections in terms of the overlap and all of that in the even election years in the odd election years these would be standalone school board elections so you would And you would only, half of the time, you would have no problem as far as those overlapping. Now, one of the ways that we're coordinating that is that school board members have odd-numbered years of service, and so everyone would come up at one point or another in an even election year. But anyway, that was the issue the County Clerks Association looked at, and they had decided that they would not oppose based on that
issue. Thank you. Representative Walker, is it very important? Yes, it is. It's pertinent to the answer. How is that fair? How is it that in one year you have huge numbers of people voting and in the next year you have what you perceive to be the problem, small numbers of people voting? How is that fair?
The school board candidates would have staggered terms so that at one point or another the candidates would either be coming up for an election or re-election in a high turnout election or a low turnout. And it's about as fair as you can make it. It really would be the luck of the draw on terms of drawing those terms. Rep.
have a motion. Do pass. We have a motion to do pass. I will hear that motion. Is there any? I move for immediate consideration. I also have a motion for immediate consideration. All in favor of immediate consideration, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? All right, and we have a motion on the table. All in favor of the motion, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? No. Ayes have it. We have two hands. We'll have
I need to run someone in before you run your other bill. Representative Starch, you still have your witness here. Thank you Mr. Chairman, I believe we have an amendment, we're going to pass that amendment out. Oh, I'm sorry. This is bill number 2243. I was having to wait to see the amendment sit. Oh, I'm sorry. If you know your amendment, you're welcome to present it. Are you waiting on the amendment? No, sir. You can go ahead and present your amendment. Folks,
the amendment is actually requested by the Department of Higher Ed. It's a date change from June 1st to a date that they'll determine on the eligibility. I appreciate a good vote.
I have a motion on the amendment. I have a motion on the amendment. All in favor say aye. Any opposed, no. All right, you may present your bill as amended. Your amendment has passed. Thank you,
Mr. Chair. Colleagues, House Bill 2243 is actually not my bill but Representative Davis' bill, and he asked me to run this for him today because of his absence. So I'm not going to pretend that I know everything about it. I have his notes, and I will do my level best for Andy. But this bill is actually brought to us by the Department of Higher Ed. It includes some technical changes to two different scholarships to align appropriate language with both. It deletes a scholarship that is no longer being awarded due to absence of funding. So I just kind of briefly go over what I know, and we have a representative from the Department of Higher Ed to answer any technical questions you might have. But Section 3 is probably the biggest section. It's the substantive difference, suggest is the amount of the former governor's scholarship, which was always lower until the scholarship last session, you might remember. We had the governor's scholarship and had the governor's distinguished scholarship, and we ended up combining those and changing some qualifications for those. The amounts would be up to $10,000. Originally, it was up to $10,000 for the governor's distinguished, up to $4,000 for the governors. And so what we're doing now is the new change is the lesser of $5,000, or tuition fees, room, and board, and so forth, for less than a 32 on the ACT, and the lesser of $10,000 for tuition, books, room, and board for above 32 on the ACT. So that's the changes in the amounts. Section 4, there's a language striking the second effort scholarship that went to the top 10 GED scores. That scholarship was never implemented. There was never any funding for that scholarship, so they're asking us that we just clean up the code. Section 5 changes slightly some of the Arkansas Academic Challenge lottery scholarship for non-traditional students. Formerly, it was based on a high school GPA of 2.5, a college GPA of 2.5, or an ACT of 19. Now what's being proposed, if the student has college hours, that the GPA stays at a 2.5 minimum, must be used to qualify. So for clarity, GPA for any college must be taken for that eligibility. and with that I'll answer any questions all right
apologize for being us talking too much but I'm trying to understand 2.5 is C plus if it's if it's C plus why are we reducing the standards in order to qualify for a scholarship now favorite but I want to know why you're changing it that's down in the
that question my name is tara smith i'm the deputy director for the department of higher education in regard to the 2.5 this is dealing with the non-traditional students that apply for the academic challenge scholarship if you're familiar with a traditional scholarship it's a 2.5 excuse me there is no gpa requirement it it's a 19 it used to be a 2.5 or the 19 so the non On the non-traditional side of it, it's the same 2.5, as well as continuing eligibility requirements once they receive the scholarship is also a 2.5. I'll explain kind of what was going on that prompted us to need to clean the language up. In some situations on the non-traditional student population, they could have qualified under three criteria, either a 2.5 high school GPA if they graduate from an Arkansas public high school, or a 19 on the ACT, or a 2.5 college GPA. So we had a situation where a student may have had a one-point, they did have some college hours, they applied for the nontraditional scholarship, and they had a 1.5, I'm just using an example, a 1.5 college GPA. Well, they could have qualified for the scholarship because they graduated from Arkansas high school and had a 2.5 high school GPA. But by the time they got to the end of the academic year, being a recipient of the academic challenge, there was no way they could have brought their GPA up to meet continuing eligibility requirements. So this change will allow for, if a student has received any college hours, we're just going to look at their college GPA to determine their eligibility for the scholarship, and it would be a 2.5. If they do not have any college hours, then we would look at their either high school GPA or ACT
score. What about Mr. Tear? You're recognized. I'm trying to understand why you don't have the same requirements for both and that they be the minimum requirements you set forth for the so-called nontraditional student. Now, as I understand it, the nontraditional student is one who may have gone to college and failed and now is trying to get back in college. I mean, why don't you have the same standard for everybody, whether they fail or not, and give them, if it's a second-chance opportunity, give
them a second chance. I mean, with regard to the way this scholarship was set up, I mean, this was up to the determination of the legislature that set these standards originally with regard to that 2.5. But we've got a situation where we have students that we're letting into the scholarship that are never going to meet continuing eligibility requirements because they have so many hours with a low GPA that they would never be able to bring it up to meet continuing eligibility. So to be able to be eligible for the scholarship, and they've already had college hours, that's why we're suggesting that it would be the appropriate thing that they would have to have a 2.5 college GPA if they've had college hours to meet eligibility requirements to obtain the scholarship. Are there any other questions?
amended right as amended all right have a motion do pass as amended all in favor say aye any opposed now congratulations you passed your bill represent larry you're back up uh wait before you do that i have uh represent mcgill i keep forgetting about him he
has an announcement he'd like to make Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you for taking this short break to allow me to introduce one of the legendary statesmen that have served in the House of Representatives. He's my mentor, former Speaker of the House, Representative B.G. Hendricks. Would you stand and be recognized, B.G.? Thank you very much. If you're on the Senate end today or on the House end today, We're going to recognize B.G. for his tremendous service. He served more than 20-plus years in the House of Representatives and served as a Speaker of the House and on one occasion was selected by speakers across the nation to represent them in conferences and events around the nation again. We're glad to have you
I do. You go ahead and present your amendment. this is the the net legal fund balance cap and through considerable feedback from various stakeholder groups the amendment that you have before is agreed upon language there was concern about whether one of the ways to be able to alleviate the fund balance that you might have over 20 percent would be to transfer funds to a building fund and and the the language previous just said new construction so we needed clarification that that would also include repairs renovations replacing an hvac system not just construction that is uh from ground up so that's that is um the amendment and yes that's what it covers i have a motion on the amendment
Mr. Chair, and thank you, members. This is a bill that I've referenced a number of times, both at School Boards Association and Educational Administrators Conference and in Education Caucus meetings, and it's something, frankly, that I just kind of stumbled on about eight or nine months ago when one of the many conversations about Lakeview came up about our constitutional requirement to fund adequately. So I started looking at, you know, do we also have a responsibility to make sure that the money is spent adequately? And that has been the long time push-pull since I've been on education committee when we talk about the funding matrix being just a funding matrix. We make recommendations we send it to school district we I mean we painstakingly go over line items and yet we know that the school superintendents and the districts can actually they don't have to follow that as a matter of fact the polling we've seen show that I think the number is about 60 percent of superintendents either minimally or not at all refer to the matrix in making their spending decisions. So I looked one step further and I found that there are considerable fund balances that school districts have. Right now the net legal fund balance, which is what we're impacting here in this bill, for all school districts at the end of the last fiscal year was $790 million. That's money that has been appropriated to the schools, money that's been sent by the state or maybe been sent by voters and voting for millage elections, and yet the money is not being currently spent. And I understand all the arguments about, well, we're saving for a rainy day, but the truth is at the point that many of our school districts have students not reading at grade level, we have a poverty gap that we've thrown money after, but we've not been able to close the poverty gap, I would say that the rainy day is now. I would say that it's absolutely storming and we need to do something to make sure that our school districts are actually spending the money on this generation of students that this money was intended for and stop being concerned about a generation or two down the line. because frankly we have a great imperative to make sure that you know whatever the the and we have some recommendations in here and it's certainly not without limitation but it points to that the school districts can transfer the money into building fund if that's what it was intended for or they can use it on quality pre-k they can use it on anything in closing these poverty gaps you know we've got some school districts that frankly are sitting on so much money in legal fund balance that they could afford to hire one-on-one tutors. They could give bonuses maybe to teachers to stay after school and work with these students that are experiencing that poverty gap. The money is there. And so this bill places a cap of 20% of net legal fund balance. The net legal fund balance, it's a very technical term, much like I found out in the last session when we were looking at assessment these are not easy issues assessment I mean it had my head spinning well school finance really has my head spinning but the definition of net legal balance is there on the first page the combined balance for a public school district's teacher salary fund operating fund and debt service but it also points out very clearly that what is not included is national school lunch fund, ALE money, English language learner, professional development. That's not included in net legal. Now, the question might come up, well, how did you arrive at 20%? The rule of thumb, and I have asked about this in committee meetings, and I've also asked in terms of talking with educational administrators, is there a best practice for how much money you should have saved up? And typically, I hear either two or three months of your budget or 10% to 15%. Other states have taken a look at this issue. As one example I give you, the state of Kentucky actually had a commission that looked at the issue of fund balances, and they arrived at a 15% cap. I've gone with 20% because it's such a new, novel concept for us to tell districts that they need to be spending money. I thought 15% might be too punitive. We've also put into the bill so that school districts are not having to just go out and spend a great deal of money or spend recklessly. We give them five years to actually get down to the 20% figure. They have to show on an annual basis that they are moving towards that figure at a 20% per year level. The Department of Education would be monitoring this. There are also provisions in here if there are one-time emergencies or also one-time infusion of dollars. Some feedback that I got is that there was, for instance, we're coming up on the final payments of the DSEG settlement. So if one of the school districts in Pulaski County, and all of them are under 20% now, that one-time settlement or that last settlement payment may put them over the 20 percent and so the department of education would be promulgating the rules on you know what would what would compose of a an emergency need or a one-time infusion and to be able to grant waivers to the school district to not meet that 20 percent uh immediately there has been as i've already said there's been considerable feedback and input uh and i have tried to accommodate in every case uh the language the amendment that you just adopted was a significant part of that of making sure that we clearly define that that new construction can also include renovations repairs uh my understanding out of the building fund also purchase of new buses fits in that So I could go on and on, and I'm not going to do that. I think the better proposition would be to answer any questions that you might have. But most of the stakeholders that have been engaged in conversations are supportive of this, and I'm sure that you will hear from them. Anybody have a question? Anybody else
don't know what's what's happening but a lot of these a lot of people here come from districts that have been called declining enrollment districts I don't know how many people around here in those districts I think a good number are and I think they have an equal duty as I to raise these issues now I'm not including in these conversations that that you all work out and have before you get to a bill. But here's my concern. You've had a number of these, almost all the districts in this state are declining enrollment districts, except maybe 50 to 60, and then some others are stable. For the declining enrollment districts, their budget balances have constantly declined, And they still have 10% or 12% because, or it's for to establish the rule of thumb that you should have enough money to pay your bills for two months, which is like 12% of your budget. And people follow that. There's no rule about it. Now, if you've got a declining enrollment district and a declining budget district, and your budget should be, say, $20 million, dollars, but it's because of declining enrollment down to 15, and they have 20%. And then if somehow or another they get more money or it comes in, you're saying that the standard, the threshold for determining this 20% is going to be their current budget or their past budget at its apex look and maybe I can answer
very quickly and help you this does not set a mandated 20 percent if you're at 14 percent you do not have to reach 20 percent this only affects that if you are over 20 percent you have to spend down to 20 percent all
right now here's my concern Mr. Key knows this and we're in court on it but I mean but I'm a legislator here we had one district, and there may be others, which was a declining enrollment district and a declining budget district, and it went down from large amounts of money to virtually nothing where it was told that it was in fiscal distress until an error was corrected. And it was determined that $3 million or more of its money was going to another school district as a result of tax revenues being allocated improperly. And then when they got their money, then all of a sudden it appeared it looked like they have a windfall and their kids in the meantime were being deprived and the like. How does it affect that kind of district where a district that's been declining for 10 years in terms of finances, it finally realizes that it's got enough money to have covered all the expenses for the past and that money is there in the bank and more is going to come in. how does that affect that kind of district about your legislation
as I mentioned the Department of Education would be promulgating the rules there is reference in the bill to the commissioner may grant a waiver request under this subsection for up to one year if the commissioner finds that the request is necessary based on the unusual and limited circumstances unusual and limited could be anything and we're leaving that to the department It could be a one-time infusion of money. It could be an emergency spending, something that you have to spend money on. And also to answer your question about declining balances, Channel 4, Drew Petrimo did a report recently on this particular legislation, and he asked me school districts within driving distance he could go talk to, and he went to the Carlisle School District. They were at 65%, 45% over this threshold, and the superintendent said, well, we've been saving money up to cover declining enrollment. Well, the truth is they get money for declining enrollment. I mean, they're already getting extra money there. So the savings of money, that argument doesn't wash in terms of saving up money. The other issue is that some school districts have the flexibility to have put money into the building fund, but they have been concerned that that would trigger a declining balance flag. And the Department of Education, BLR, has said in open committee that all they have to do is notify the school district that they're transferring money to the building fund, that that's the reason why they would have a declining balance. This legislation would also give another reason why that they would not be placed in the fiscal impact if they had a declining balance because we're mandating that they spend down at 20% if they are over
has a question. I don't think I have anybody in right now. You're recognized. All right. Now, in terms of the Carlisle situation that you mentioned, In order for those students who are in the declining enrollment posture to have the same educational opportunities that they were promised and which they began school with, it's necessary for them to have teachers and courses and opportunities and everything. And by having that opportunity, isn't it fair to say that that's a prudent decision to be left and made at the local level? Well, again, declining enrollment funds
is not a part of this bill. It covers that. Now, in Carlisle, we're talking about a loss of 100 students over 10 years. So you don't have to save up tens of millions of dollars to be able to plan for that. And we've given them the opportunity to spin down gradually. Like I said, in the case of Carlisle, they're 45% over this 20% mark, which even by your admission is higher than the best practices that is recommended of 12%. So we've given them plenty of leeway there. There's another question. Representative Beck,
you recognize for a question? do you have one you didn't have a question okay your your last question oh i'm sorry miss cavanaugh i'm sorry go ahead thank
you mr chair uh representative lowry in the bill we tell them the different ways that they could spend this in five years we've all been talking about how teachers are not paid enough and that we don't do anything to increase the pay of the teacher How come if we don't address that in here specifically, either talk about raising teacher salary or some type of bonus to
them? Good question. This is on page three if everyone else wants to follow along. What we've put in here are just some suggestions of issues that have been brought before us many times of where we're coming up short on money, pre-K programs, remediation programs, career and technical. But the key phrase there on line nine is without limitation. in other words this list is just these are suggestions the problem about and this would be up to a school district i don't the legislation does not prohibit money being used on teacher salaries the only problem with it is that would not be recurring money that would be extra dollars that they have over a five-year period and so it'd be up to the school district that they want to go ahead and make that shift knowing that once they've gotten down to 20 percent they're not going to have this overage to to continue the teacher salary in year six seven eight nine ten and on out into the future follow-up please
you're recognized I realize a salary but a bonus is a one-time bonus I mean we for me we keep talking about teachers aren't paid enough and you're saying that they're holding money that they should be using in the schools and one of the key things that we should be doing is paying our teachers more so we go through all this in this bill telling them this is where we recommend that you spend it but we make no recommendation for them
to spend more money on their teachers well it is it is um i mean i i still want to retain as much belief in local control as a as a powerful model but we at this point we really have to do something about the 790 million dollars and this is not you know this is not exclusive there's there's another fund the building fund that is at 804 million dollars so between those two funds you're talking about 1.6 billion dollars that school districts have that they could be spending they could be spending it on these teacher bonuses they could be spending it on one-on-one tutoring to close poverty gap i mean frankly we could probably have a 35 page bill if we listed everything every needed area that they should shift money to. I just put four references in here and then made sure that we said without limitation. Representative Sullivan.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Tell me about the 20% just kind of we talked about earlier seems arbitrary but a larger district who has more flexibility 20% is different than a smaller district who doesn't have flexibility the economy of scale would seem to say that a smaller district would need a larger budget yet this seems to be a one one size fits all regardless of what that number is well economy
of scale may come into it but you know i was asked at one point to consider language that says that a school district could retain two million dollars or twenty percent whichever is a greater figure and I'll give you an example where that doesn't work a district that has a three million dollar budget why should we then allow them to hang on to two million dollars which is 67 percent of their one-year revenue so if you start getting into these trying to come up with a fixed number you really create some some problems that undermine and really gut the intent of this bill but 20 percent still gives a lot of flexibility because you're looking at your total one-year revenue the 20 is based on all the revenue that you receive in one year you can retain 20 of that uh at least 20 if you're over that then you have to spend down to it so we're not mandating that sorry we're not mandating that they spend they spend down to zero that they really have to at least the best practices is 12 and i and i went with the 20 figure because it is such a novel concept to go beyond just a recommendation and having, frankly, legislation that mandates it. All right. Reps. Walker, you have
to move. It's 12 o'clock. I'm not going to take it. Thank you. All right. Thank you. Any other questions, committee? I do have testimony for and against this bill. And I'm trying to remember who's first. The only
Well, it looks like it's only one. Richard Abernathy. He wants to speak four against the bill. Four. I'm just kidding. He's for the bill. I actually just want
to sit down here to speak in favor of a bill for a change that we hadn't been able to do. But we thank Representative Lowry for working with us, and if you recall, this was actually a recommendation that we made to this committee back in January of 2016. There's been a lot of confusion on fund balances, what it's for, what the need is, and I'd be glad to go through that. I see the eyes drooping, so you probably don't want to hear it. But working through our committees, we came up with a 20%. And Representative Sullivan, you're exactly right. There is economy of scales on smaller schools versus larger schools, and we understand that that's why we also wanted in the bill uh for those anomalies that we don't know and so if the local district and in school board and the state school board determined that there may be a need for an additional monies above the 20 percent then they they have that authority through this bill to approve that um our official position just so you know is tabled because we've been waiting on this amendment uh represent lowry took 95 percent of what we sent him to amend it and so i feel at the end of the day that's why i'm speaking for it so i'd be glad to answer any questions if you are there any questions one other comment on that in in the blr report uh shows that schools just spend 99 plus percent of the foundation dollars that come out to them so what we're talking about on fund balance is local dollars and local monies that that the taxpayers
have come up with to support their school. All right, Rex. Walker. Thank you. Why can't I understand state money, but with the local people why exercise control over the local monies that they raise for whatever purposes they raise at millage or otherwise and require them to spend it almost contemporaneously with the raising?
confusing. Why do that? The issue has been the confusion among policy makers and school personnel on the definition of fund balance and what it's used for. For instance, Representative Kavanaugh, we recommend our schools pay our teachers as much as possible because that's what we need to do and our teachers deserve that. The reoccurring part of it, like Representative Lowry said, is an issue on some of these dollars. But Representative Walker, these are, in our opinion local monies but most of the millage from local monies has been from our millage and I'd say I'm not gonna give a percent but most of that is due for construction projects in excess debt service revenue to operate those schools so if they're using that to operate those schools then those monies are already earmarked for those particular projects any other questions seeing
I would. Thank you. Thank you, members, and thank you for that endorsement. I will tell you, and I'm kind of surprised they didn't sign up, but in another committee I was presenting a constitutional amendment resolution related to the state and local school districts becoming true partners and basically getting ourselves out from under the shackles of Lakeview and mention the fund balance issue. And I had two organizations come and speak against that resolution but said that they will definitely be in committee to speak for my fund balance cap bill. And I'm sure that they promised me they'd be here. But anyway, the AEA and the Arkansas Advocates for Children and Families said that they support the concept of putting a cap on fund balances so that the money is spent where it should on the kids. So that would be my closing. I'd make a do-pass motion. As amended. As amended, thank
you. I have a do-pass motion as amended. All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? No. The ayes have it. Your bill has passed. All right, can I get you to skip over the next one, please, for just now, your next bill. De La Rosa, Representative De La Rosa is going to run one real quick, and then I've got Representative Saban after that. I think we have an amendment for Representative De La Rosa's bill. I'm sorry, let me get that. That is bill number 1608. eight, and you're recognized to your amendment. Do you have it, or do you have your amendment? He's passing, and I do
have it. You go ahead and present your amendment, and then we'll vote on it. Well, the amendment is basically an entire replacement of the previous bill, and that was basically so that you could see. So
replace it? It's rewriting the language that was in there. It still does the same thing, but it's now in alignment with language that the Department of Education wanted. But it was changed so much that I was afraid if I presented it with a delete this line and move this, nobody would be able to follow it. So
I just did a complete replacement. Take a motion to use the amendment. I have a motion of do pass on the amendment. All in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? No. You passed. You may present your bill as amended. All right. So
if you look at the amendment on the paper and don't look at your tablets because it's being replaced. What this bill does is the original concept behind this was that I thought the legislature should be directing the Department of Education regarding our accountability plan. We continuously hold them accountable and complain to them that we don't like what's coming out of education, but yet we have given no direction specifically as to what our expectations are in education. And I really didn't think that was quite fair to hold people accountable to something when we haven't told them what it is they ought to be doing. Um, so what this bill seeks to do, uh, first of all, it's in alignment with ESSA. So, uh, and that's actually why it's, we've struggled with the language in this is because they're struggling trying to get their, their accountability plan together to, to turn in. And then, um, this will just affect the A through F portion of it. We're not, I'm not trying to affect, uh, the state accountability, state accountability plan that's, that's going to the feds. um just because it's too it's it's too difficult to try and do that at this point in time um so this would only affect a through f but this is going to align with what you will see from the department of education coming soon um for what their state accountability plan is going to be the key point in this um is that we're trying to move from a single measure approach to accountability to a multi-measure approach to accountability um there were lots of suggestions for what the multiple measures could include and the way this is written and again this is so that it aligns with s s allows you to have a fifth indicator so the first four indicators are going to be in alignment with basically what s requires the real the real meat of this really is section four if you just want to skip to that the first four indicators will be academic achievement you know on the test that's what we do right now two will be student growth on the test which is something that the schools have been begging for from my understanding. They want to be measured on growth because they think that's a better measure of what they're actually doing, how have they grown the student. School-level graduation rates or rates. Notice it didn't say district, school-level, because you can have poor graduation rates in certain schools and great graduation rates in others, and the district can end up looking good while the schools are actually not performing, so they can't, under this, they won't be able to hide. for English learner progression or growth in acquiring English. And then the fifth, which will be Part B, will be up to the Department of Education to choose from this menu. And we've left it this flexible because, first of all, we want to align with ESSEB, but in order to turn, and if I misspeak, Director or Commissioner Key can come over here and correct me, um to turn in the fifth indicator to the feds you have to be able to tell them exactly how you're going to measure it and and justify it and all of that and a lot of these things we don't yet know how exactly we can do that so i'm giving them the flexibility on the fifth indicator that they can choose one or more of the following and um everything everybody has thought of that has sent me emails is in here um so you can read through what it is but i there's nothing in here that somebody's come to me and said well did you think about you know how many have advanced degrees or um you know how many uh have advanced placement credit or you know whatever it is it's it's all in here and you can you can read through that but that's that's the gist of it that's what we're trying to do is give direction for the a through f accountability system that aligns with what the Department of Education is going to be doing with ESSA and converting Arkansas to a multi-measure approach from a single-measure approach. I hope I explained that well. Any questions? Because I was not fully expecting to
present this today. Any questions? Representative Walker, you recognize. How does this affect below high school grade students? the sections where the department has some discretion seem to deal with high school students grade 9 and above and I'm concerned about kids reading in grades 1, 2 and 3 because if they don't read by the time they're in grade 3 they're not going to do well thereafter and none of these criteria focus upon early childhood education are requiring any any changes in the way it's delivered that would have been a great suggestion to
throw in as a fifth indicator but I wasn't given that one but what I can say right now all we look at is one test at one time and that's it and what I'm saying here is there is more to education than one test at one time there is a lot more to it so maybe this doesn't encompass every single factor that we can conceive of but it's a heck of a lot more factors than we're including right now and we're trying to to broaden our view of what constitutes a good education in Arkansas and whether it be one test score one time per year on a standardized test we want to start looking at how are you involved in the community are you getting nationally certified teachers all of the other things that we discuss in this committee that we're not considering right now and that's what we've tried to put into this.
Your record followed up. Would you be amenable to adding early childhood education as an indicator? Considering the difficulty we've had in the – Well, there you go. There's preschool. Preschool is different than early childhood. I mean, for me, early childhood is up to grade three or four. I'm concerned that kids, when they get to the fourth grade, that they'd be able to read because that's foundational for
I think that's probably in there. Yeah, I'm going to ask Commissioner Key to come down here. Johnny Key, Department of Education. Representative Walker, we did work with Representative De La Rosa on putting language in there, and you are correct in that those first four indicators, in many respects, are focused on that three through eight which is the requirement of ESSA and then those high school components of the graduation rate and then looking at our English learners population and then student growth but what that fifth indicator allows us to do in the language in here provides that is it expands our ability to reach down into those earlier grades so if you would look in in B when you look at closing the achievement gap or looking at academic growth of student subgroups, we don't limit ourselves in that language to just looking at grades three to eight. We can dip down and look at those indicators that, as you have indicated, of what early childhood components are in their contribution to the success
just say all the answers, add something? I have Mr. Meeks, and I'll come back to you. Thank you. Representative Meeks, you recognize? Back to you, Ripson. Walker, I'm sorry. Thank you.
Well, here's the problem with that approach, Mr. Key. Everybody is aware that in the first three grades or four, the tests don't measure growth so much. I mean, they measure where a student is, and they set forth the needs that those students may have have in order to have growth later on and I'd be more comfortable if you'd be more explicit in in having that as an objective because we know this and you think I think you know girls progress faster than boys so that their rate rate of growth is going to be greater than boys but that doesn't necessarily mean that they are better academically I have more more knowledge I mean more capacity or ability it means that they just lag behind or we lag behind so I'd be more comfortable you seem to be more sensitive than I thought you'd be but I'd be more comfortable if somehow another you could assure us that in your promulgation capacity in working with Representative De La Rosa and sensing no objections to this approach from people here, that you'd find a way to try to address that more explicitly to the end that you apparently agree with me
on? I do agree the importance of that. The reason that the language, we've really tried to balance this language with the ESSA. I mean, I don't know if you all know, last week the Senate voted of the ESSA accountability rules have now been rejected. So the guidance that we had had and been working in up to this point is now removed. So we only have the law itself, and we are awaiting guidance from the U.S. Department of Education. And that's why it was so difficult to get to this. But I will assure you that what we will continue to do is engage in that stakeholder engagement, which is a mandate of ESSA to take into account ideas like what you have just voiced, because it is important. And just so you know, too, we're in the process of developing, or actually it's out there, an RFQ on a K-2 assessment. That is another tool not to be used as a point of, like we do, ACT Aspire, but a tool to measure where students are and to determine their needs in those early grades. So I think we're expanding the ability that we have to accomplish what you're asking for.
Yes, sir. Are there any other questions? Seeing none, I have no one signed up for or against the bill. Yes, sir. oh wait well i do have a i have a four real quick let me get her in there sorry i didn't see her back there we have a motion and we'll hold that motion until after this i apologize to anybody that wanted to speak for
anything with this it's just we have struggled so hard we don't have on the list so um so they well i don't think anybody was expecting me to run it right this minute so
you recognize to make a statement Good morning. Tracy Ann Nelson with the Arkansas Education Association. I wanted to acknowledge the opportunity to be a part of adding information into this bill. We talked to Representative De La Rosa, and we appreciate that our recommendations were incorporated. So we were extremely active on defining some of the language in ESSA, so to come and see it here is really valuable to us. We really truly honor the fact that there are multiple measures for success for students and the fact that Arkansas had tests already in place and the improvements to tests will allow families, legislators will allow everybody to evaluate the success of students through the multiple measures using tests also. Thank you.
all right we have we have a motion of do pass from representative walker as amended all in favor say aye any opposed no congratulations you passed your bill representative sabin i believe i believe you're going to run 1666 is that correct that is correct i appreciate you working with us on time today thank you you're recognized to
present your bill Thank you. It's nice to be back in the Education Committee. I'm almost serious about that. Hopefully they'll be good to you today. Yeah, I hope so. Well, as you can see in this bill, Mr. Chair and members of the committee, this bill is designed to require our institutions of higher education in this state to provide education and awareness materials regarding suicide and mental health. And, you know, I think there have been some other legislation, pieces of legislation that have been introduced in this session that have sort of underscored the problem we have with suicide here in Arkansas. We unfortunately, our rate is much higher than average. We have fewer resources to deal with it. And college is a particularly stressful time for young people. Obviously, you know, it's the first time many of them are away from home. are confronted with new people, new situations, and obviously there's a real need to at least let them know what resources are available when they're struggling, sometimes away from loved ones with that issue. I was going to have some people come testify with me on this bill who reside in Texas, and the reason why is because my bill is actually modeled on legislation that was adopted in Texas, and I've reached out to some of the people who are involved, including the director of counseling at the University of Texas at Austin, as well as an attorney named Mark Walker, whose son actually committed suicide in college, and he became an activist on this issue and was involved in passing the Texas legislation. Obviously with the schedule that we all know is very erratic here, it was difficult to get them to come, and so Mr. Walker wrote a three-page letter, which I'm not going to read in its entirety, but I do want to read just portions of it so you understand kind of, you know, what inspired the legislation that I'm bringing. So like I said, I'll be very quick and efficient, because I know you all want to eat lunch. He says, My name is Mark Walker. I live in El Paso, Texas, and I'm still the very proud father of Lee Middleton Hooper Walker, who took his own life on May 22, 2014, at the all-too-tender age of 19. Lee had just completed his first year as an honors student in the Jackson School of Geosciences and in the Plan II Honors Program at the University of Texas at Austin. Like many other high-achieving students, Lee set great expectations for himself and took a permanent solution to a temporary problem when, for the first time, he had had an academic disappointment. Since that terrible day, we have searched our memories and those of Lee's friends and instructors for the signs of depression that we missed during those several months that he was away from home. Although we believed ourselves up-to-date on many issues, apparently we were woefully unprepared to understand and deal with what we now know is a very common affliction among young college-age Texans, depression. As we tried to come to grips with this loss, we learned so much more shocking information about the scope and seriousness of depression among college students. Suicide is the second leading cause of death for college-age youth in this nation, and studies show that up to a third of students, particularly new students, suffer from depression to the extent it warrants professional assistance. Every year we lose twice as many people to suicide as to homicide, and yet suicide is considered among the most preventable deaths. We know from experience that even raising awareness of depression and mental health issues can save young lives. So I'm going to skip over this next part and just kind of cut to the end. Texas SB 1624, which is the bill that I modeled mine after, did not require the hiring of any new staff or faculty, or need the adoption of any expensive curricula or programs. Instead the professionals who were able to, sorry, instead the professionals were able to meet and produce quality materials for widespread use. My wife and I created a fund through the UT system to help fund the effort, and I understand that the total production cost did not exceed $10,000. Representative Sabin's HB 1666 takes Texas SB 1624 as a template and greatly improves upon it for better and more effective application without any greater cost. I am keenly aware of legislative concerns about mandates and costs and pledge to the Arkansas legislature and the state of Arkansas to raise the necessary funds for creation of the programming and video, which I would anticipate could be accomplished along the lines of the cost of the Texas effort. My mother's parents, who were from Pea Ridge, Arkansas, would be proud of your efforts. And so I'm going to stop there with his letter, but I wanted to let you know that I have reached out, obviously, to other colleges and universities across the state. I've talked with Maria Markham, the Director of Higher Education. There's no opposition to this bill. I think everyone sees the need, and in many times I've actually received some enthusiastic response from our higher ed institutions who want this opportunity to provide this kind of information to students during new student orientation and other opportunities. So with that, I'd be glad to take
any questions. Committee, are there any questions? Seeing no questions from the committee, and we don't have anybody signed up for or against, we have a motion on the table for do pass. All those in favor, please say aye. All those against, no. Congratulations, you've passed your bill. Thank you, Madam Chair and members of the committee. Mr. Lowry, you're welcome to the end of the table, and he's going to present 1740, and he has an amendment. You're welcome to go ahead and start on your
amendment. Your amendment to your bill. Thank you, members. This is a bill that specifies a process for a homeschool student being able to re-enroll, if they so choose, the public schools. and the amendments are language that's been provided in consultation with Department of Ed and other stakeholders to alleviate any concerns they may have about it. So I'd appreciate a good vote on the amendment. Committee, are
there any questions? We have a motion on the table. Do pass. A motion to adopt the amendment. Committee, all in favor, say aye. Opposed, no. congratulations you may proceed with your bill thank thank
you members you know I think that this is a no-nonsense bill I know that I have very few of those that you know little old bill this does do something though you know we we all I get a lot of you know heat about the fact that you know we're trying to make it easier for students to get out of the public schools this is actually a bill that makes it easier for someone to get back into the public schools homeschool students it wants to re-enroll in public schools this spells out the process it puts out the down the recommendation or excuse me the requirements of what they would have to produce to be able to re-enroll they would have a have to have a transcript listing all courses taken in semester grades from the home school a score from a norm referenced assessment test taken during the past academic year a portfolio listing indicators of the home school students academic process or progress curricula that might have been used in the home school tests taken and lessons completed by the home school student and other indicators so they would have to submit some type of a score in terms of being able to justify their grade placement with if they chose to re-enroll and so This really just cleans up something that's really not been detailed and not been codified, allowing the homeschool student to come back. If there's any fiscal impact, it is that we're making it easy for a homeschool student to be able to be accepted back into a public school district, and the public school district would then be able to receive the foundation funding for
that student. Question. It is a little higher bar than you would see from public school because of the portfolio. You know, you're not accepting the transcript as a true indicator like you would for a student moving from public school to public school. Could you just ease the concerns that the homeschool community would have about that?
well all i all i could really say to that is that the the homeschool advocates uh are presenting this bill i mean it's their bill i'm just here before you so it's something that's all the language has all been agreed upon uh by family council and and their stakeholder groups that work with homeschoolers uh it's a necessary process we certainly don't want to just accept at face value someone comes in and says well i've been homeschooling for uh my child for 10 10 years and they should be put in at the 11th grade status i mean there's going to have to be some type of at least you know the difference would be public private schools you at least would have a clear transcript and all of that that may not be apparent apparently available with homeschool so the portfolio just kind of substitutes for some of those things that may not be available for a private school student wanting to re-enroll. Right. Thank you.
I have a question. I may have missed this. I had to go make a phone call, but the nationally recognized norm test, does the homeschool students take that? They do
not as a requirement, but it would be required in this case for them to produce that they've scored at least at the 30th percentile on a nationally recognized norm-referenced assessment. So they would have to, before they
could come in and re-enroll, they would at least have to take that test? Yes. Okay. That was my question. That was the only thing. I just didn't want them to miss out on that. All right. Any other questions? Seeing none, does anyone like to speak against the bill or the bill? I have a motion to do pass as amended from Representative McElroy. All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? No. You have passed your bill. Congratulations. Madam Chair, we have one more bill we're going to run real quick. It is a quick one. She promises. This is the last one. 1457. I'm not going to
on it do i have a motion to pass it was engrossed this is 1457 guys i heard about this idea at a conference kentucky is doing this already it allows a school to apply for a plan for an alternative education to replace a snow day in other words they can have a plan in place that if they miss a snow day that they do not have to make that up at the end of school they can make it up while the kids are at home by going online and having lessons posted or they can send folders home with the students and they can say day one is the blue folder day two that you miss is the green folder if you go online with Kentucky and look at the school applications to participate the program you'll see some incredibly innovative ways that they have come up to make sure the academics are there to replace the the time that they miss at school there's also ways to make the teachers accountable for the times that they miss and ways to make sure that all personnel are not just having a free day so it's up to the department to approve their plan it's not just a given and and so that's you know our assurance that they're not just getting a free day off mr meeks hey mr chairman a quick question um on these these snow days of course teachers are a contractor for so many days that they have to to work a year let's say there's three snow days we take advantage of that uh will those three days uh be allotted towards their contract days or even though we've got the kids taken care of will the teachers still be required to come make those three days up at the end of the year there i've read numerous plans and plans are all different one of the plans makes the teachers be available by email or phone during those hours that they would have been at school so if the kids are doing their work that they've been assigned through the the you know the school website or packets that they took home sometimes they call blizzard bags so there's different ways to make sure that the teachers are accountable for that time so it's a planned level decision the school needs to have a PD day to put forth the plan and then they would submit that to the Department of Ed and see if it meets accreditation okay all right thank you
I'd just like to tell you that some of the the schools like St. Paul and some of those up there that miss 20 days of school this is going to help them to get the academics in before you know June when it's zero of zero use to make up those days. Good. All right. Thank you. Motion
Aye. Any opposed, no. Congratulations, Pastor Bill. What's for lunch? I have a motion to adjourn, but right before I do that, I will tell you, we do not meet this afternoon.
Rep. Les Warren presented SB Warren, proposing to expand the Arkansas School for Mathematics, Sciences and the Arts to include 10th-grade students, change board meeting frequency, repeal the campus-transition language, and permit up to five international students per class with a $35,000 tuition.
[20:24][20:59][21:33][22:03]
Rep. Stephen Meeks asked about recruitment costs and confirmed the program would begin with Chinese students, using existing partnerships and a nominal fee covered by tuition.
[23:15][23:43][24:20]
Rep. John W. Walker objected, arguing that the $35,000 tuition for a private school diverts resources, raises concerns about limited minority representation and elitism, and questioned the benefit to Arkansas students.
[24:53][25:26][25:57][26:29][27:00]
After discussion, the committee moved to a motion to pass the bill as amended, which was approved unanimously.
[31:58][32:03][32:27]
HB1917 Walker TO LIMIT THE SALARY AMOUNT OF AN ADMINISTRATOR IN A PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT.
REGULAR AGENDA Number Subtitle Sponsor
HB1457 C. Douglas AND DISTRICT PUBLIC SCHOOL OPEN-ENROLLMENT AN TO PUBLIC A ALLOW CHARTER SCHOOL TO DEVELOP A PLAN FOR THE USE OF AN ALTERNATIVE METHOD OF INSTRUCTION TO BE USED ON DAYS WHEN SCHOOL IS CANCELLED.
2:27:15 - 1:39:15
Representative Stephen Meeks explained that HB1457 would let charter schools develop alternative instructional plans for snow days-such as online lessons or take-home folders-so missed days could be made up without extending the school year.
[2:27:17][2:27:47][2:28:23]
He responded to the chair’s query about teachers’ contracted days, noting that many plans require teachers to be reachable by email or phone during the cancelled-day period and that accountability provisions are built into the proposals.
[2:28:30][2:28:55][2:29:00][2:29:29]
Following a brief clarification that the bill specifies a limit on the number of make-up days, the chair moved to pass the measure, the motion was seconded, and the committee voted “aye” with no opposition.
[2:29:43][2:29:48][2:29:52][2:29:56][2:29:59][2:30:07][2:30:17]
The committee adopted HB1457, recording a unanimous “aye” vote and passing the bill.
[2:30:17]
HB1575 Lowery TO LIMIT THE AMOUNT OF FUND BALANCES A SCHOOL DISTRICT MAY MAINTAIN.
1:39:15 - 37:10
Speaker 223 introduced HB 1575, noting that Arkansas school districts held a $790 million net legal fund balance and proposing a 20 % cap with a five-year phase-in to compel spending on priorities such as pre-K, tutoring and teacher bonuses.
[1:39:19][1:39:54][1:40:28][1:41:10][1:41:43][1:42:14][1:42:45]
HB1576 C. Douglas TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ACADEMIC FACILITIES PARTNERSHIP PROGRAM CONCERNING APPROVED BUT UNFUNDED NEW CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS.
37:10 - 2:03:20285 segments42 speakers
Rep. Stephen Meeks introduced HB 1576, proposing that if an approved academic facilities partnership project is rescinded or otherwise unfunded, its reserved $10 million allocation be offered to the next approved but unfunded project below the line.
[37:15][37:45]
The committee did not advance a motion or vote on the amendment during this meeting.
[37:15][37:45]
HB1583 Dotson TO CREATE RECALL ELECTIONS FOR MEMBERS OF SCHOOL DISTRICT BOARDS OF DIRECTORS; AND TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING SCHOOL DISTRICT BOARDS OF DIRECTORS.
HB1608 Della Rosa THE BY ACCOUNTABILITY OF STATE DEVELOPED CONCERNING SYSTEM THE ARKANSAS UNDER THE EVERY STUDENT SUCCEEDS ACT.
2:03:20 - 51:21
Speaker 68 introduced HB 1608, stating its purpose to align Arkansas’s accountability system with the federal ESSA by shifting from a single-measure to a multi-measure framework that includes four core indicators-academic achievement, student growth, graduation rates, and English-learner progress-and a flexible fifth indicator chosen by the Department of Education.
[2:03:35][2:04:06][2:04:37][2:05:07][2:05:39][2:06:11][2:06:45][2:07:15][2:07:24]
Representative John W. Walker asked whether early-childhood outcomes could be incorporated, leading the sponsor to explain that while the bill’s language focuses on grades 3-8, the flexible fifth indicator can be used to address earlier grades and that the department will continue stakeholder engagement to refine the metrics.
[2:07:46][2:08:02][2:08:16][2:08:54][2:09:03][2:09:27][2:09:30][2:09:36][2:10:01]
The sponsor noted that recent Senate action removed prior ESSA guidance, leaving the bill to rely on the law itself and pending federal guidance, and affirmed ongoing development of tools such as a K-2 assessment to support early-grade measurement.
[2:12:25][2:12:44][2:13:17][2:13:47][2:14:11][2:14:21][2:14:26][2:14:51][2:15:21]
HB1610 Tucker TO PROVIDE ARKANSAS BETTER CHANCE PROGRAMS LOCATED WITHIN A SCHOOL DISTRICT FUNDING EQUAL TO THE FOUNDATION FUNDING AMOUNT FOR EACH EARLY GRADUATE OF THE PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT.
HB1611 Tucker CONCERNING THE BASIC LANGUAGE OF INSTRUCTION IN PUBLIC SCHOOLS.
51:21 - 2:15:54257 segments38 speakers
The committee considered HB 1621, a school-board election-timing bill introduced by Representative Lowry, hearing testimony from Representative Walker about potential loss of minority representation, Chair Boyd emphasizing local control and the existence of a diversity office, and multiple stakeholders-including the Arkansas School Boards Association, county clerks, and business groups-who discussed turnout, cost, and partisanship concerns.
[51:37][52:09][52:39][53:17][53:32][53:48][54:21][54:32][54:55][55:27][55:54][56:00][56:16][56:30][56:34]
After the discussion, the committee moved to immediate consideration, and a motion to pass the bill was approved unanimously with all members voting aye and no opposition, thereby reporting the bill out of committee.
[56:39]
HB1666 Sabin TO REQUIRE INSTITUTIONS OF HIGHER EDUCATION TO PROVIDE INFORMATION ON MENTAL HEALTH AND SUICIDE PREVENTION SERVICES TO ENTERING STUDENTS.
2:15:54 - 24:33:5146 segments8 speakers
Representative Mark Walker presented HB 1666, citing Texas SB 1624 as a model and arguing that a modest, under-$10,000 program to provide suicide-prevention and mental-health information to incoming college students is both cost-effective and has broad institutional support.
[2:16:25][2:16:55][2:17:26][2:18:02][2:18:33][2:19:05][2:19:37][2:20:10][2:20:45]
After no questions were raised, the committee moved a do-pass motion which was approved, enacting the bill.
[2:20:51]
HB1671 Tucker TO GIVE CHARTER SCHOOLS AUTHORITY TO WEIGHT ADMISSION LOTTERIES AT THEIR DISCRETION.
HB1672 CONCERNING ADMISSIONS POLICIES OF CHARTER SCHOOLS; AND TO ALIGN CHARTER SCHOOL ADMISSIONS REQUIREMENTS FOR A STUDENT WHO HAS BEEN EXPELLED FROM ANOTHER SCHOOL DISTRICT WITH ADMISSIONS REQUIREMENTS FOR SCHOOL DISTRICTS.
HB1673 Tucker CONCERNING APPLICATIONS FOR OR AMENDMENTS OF PUBLIC CHARTERS UNDER THE ARKANSAS QUALITY CHARTER SCHOOLS ACT OF 2013.
HB1674 Tucker TO CREATE A COMMUNITY PUBLIC EDUCATION BOARD.
Speaker 266 explained that HB 1621 mirrors the fund-balance cap of HB 1575, retaining the 20 % limit but allowing local boards, with state board approval, to exceed it for special circumstances and noting the need to address confusion over fund-balance definitions.
[1:57:57][1:58:28][1:59:03][1:59:13][1:59:36][2:00:11]
After brief comments, the chair called for a do-pass motion, which passed unanimously, enacting the bill as amended.
[2:01:17][2:01:39]
HB1701 Love O ESTABLISH A PILOT PROGRAM TO MAKE GRANTS TO HISTORICALLY BLACK COLLEGES AND UNIVERSITIES TO PROVIDE EDUCATIONAL PROGRAMS TO OFFENDERS WHO ARE RECENTLY RELEASED OR SOON-TO-BE RELEASED FROM INCARCERATION.
SB26 A. Clark TO INCREASE TEACHERS IN HIGH NEEDS SUBJECT AREAS; AND TO PROVIDE ENHANCED ARKANSAS ACADEMIC CHALLENGE SCHOLARSHIPS FOR TEACHERS WHO AGREE TO TEACH IN THE HIGH NEEDS SUBJECT AREAS.
SB27 A. Clark TO INCREASE THE NUMBER OF TEACHERS IN A CRITICAL TEACHER SHORTAGE AREA; AND TO ESTABLISH THE TEACHER CANDIDATE LOAN FORGIVENESS PROGRAM.
SB337 Hester TO REPEAL THE ACADEMIC FACILITIES EXTRAORDINARY CIRCUMSTANCES PROGRAM.
HB1738 C. Douglas CONCERNING ETHICS OF MEMBERS OF A BOARD OF DIRECTORS OF A PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT; AND TO CREATE THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS ETHICS REVIEW BOARD.
HB1740 Lowery THE RE-ENROLLMENT OF HOME-SCHOOLED A OR ENROLLMENT CONCERNING STUDENT IN A PUBLIC SCHOOL.
2:22:47 - 2:48
Speaker 223 outlined HB 1740, creating a statutory process for homeschooled students to return to public schools that requires a transcript, a norm-referenced assessment score at the 30th percentile, and a portfolio of coursework to verify placement.
[2:22:52][2:23:25][2:24:02][2:24:13][2:24:36][2:25:07][2:25:33][2:25:38][2:25:51]
Following brief clarification questions, the chair called for a do-pass motion, which passed unanimously, adopting the bill as amended.
[2:26:09][2:26:41]
HB1762 Brown TO ALLOW AN EMPLOYER TO MAKE A MATCHING CONTRIBUTION TO AN EMPLOYEE'S TAX-DEFERRED TUITION SAVINGS PROGRAM AS AN EMPLOYEE BENEFIT.
2:48 - 37:55123 segments17 speakers
Rep. Sarah Capp introduced HB 1762, explaining that it would let Arkansas employers match up to $500 of an employee’s contribution to a 529 college-savings plan and deduct the amount from corporate income taxes (not a credit).
[3:29][3:44][4:16][4:52]
Rep. John W. Walker and other members raised fiscal-impact concerns, estimating that combined employee and employer deductions could cost the state roughly $12 million in lost revenue and noted that no fiscal impact statement had been provided.
[7:55][8:22][8:54][9:19][9:29][11:12][11:43][12:15][12:38][12:44]
Testimony from Speaker 68 and Rep. Frances Cavenaugh clarified that the bill is intended to encourage even modest monthly contributions (as low as $10) and that the employer deduction would work similarly to the employee deduction.
[13:00][13:31][14:04][14:31][14:34][14:48][15:03][15:11]
The committee moved to a motion to pass the bill as amended, voted “aye” with no opposition, and reported HB 1762 passed.
[16:52][16:54][17:16]
HB1791 Tucker TO ESTABLISH A FOOD PANTRY MATCHING GRANT PROGRAM TO BE ADMINISTERED BY THE DEPARTMENT OF HIGHER EDUCATION.
HB1811 Davis TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING PREKINDERGARTEN PROGRAMS.
HB1820 Dotson CONCERNING SCHOOL DISTRICT WAIVERS; TO REQUIRE THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION TO GRANT A SCHOOL DISTRICT WAIVER PETITION IF AN OPEN-ENROLLMENT PUBLIC CHARTER SCHOOL DRAWING STUDENTS FROM THE SCHOOL DISTRICT WAS GRANTED A WAIVER.
HB1834 K. Hendren TO PROHIBIT A PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT OR OPEN-ENROLLMENT PUBLIC CHARTER SCHOOL FROM INCLUDING IN ITS CURRICULUM OR COURSE MATERIALS FOR A
MATERIAL OTHER AUTHORED OR BY ANY OF PROGRAM STUDY OR BOOKS CONCERNING HOWARD ZINN.
HB1855 Davis TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING SCHOOL CHOICE FOR FOSTER CHILDREN.
HB1856. F. Allen TO ESTABLISH THE ARKANSAS EARLY LITERACY ASSESSMENT PROCUREMENT ACT.
SB329 A. Clark TO RAISE THE PRICE THRESHOLD FOR THE PURCHASE OF COMMODITIES THAT SCHOOL DISTRICTS MUST PROCURE BY SOLICITING BIDS; AND TO PROVIDE FOR ANNUAL ADJUSTMENTS IN THE PURCHASE PRICE THRESHOLD BASED ON INFLATION.
HB1874 Lundstrum TO ALLOW CONTRIBUTIONS BY A TAXPAYER TO A TAX-DEFERRED TUITION SAVINGS PROGRAM ESTABLISHED IN ANOTHER STATE TO BE DEDUCTED FROM AN ARKANSAS TAXPAYER'S INCOME TAX.
HB1897 Baltz TO REQUIRE STATE-SUPPORTED INSTITUTIONS OF HIGHER EDUCATION TO OFFER TO THEIR STUDENTS A PANIC BUTTON ALERT SYSTEM.
HB1898 Baltz TO REQUIRE STATE-SUPPORTED INSTITUTIONS OF HIGHER EDUCATION TO OFFER STATE EMPLOYEES AND THEIR DEPENDENTS A REDUCED TUITION RATE.
HB1907 C. Douglas TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING THE ACADEMIC FACILITIES PARTNERSHIP PROGRAM.
37:55 - 41:3918 segments4 speakers
Rep. Stephen Meeks explained HB 1907, which would allow unspent funds from the academic facilities partnership program to be reallocated to the next approved but unfunded project, with each project having a right of refusal.
[38:19][38:54][39:00]
During Q&A, members asked whether emergency situations could change the priority list; Meeks clarified that once the list is set, projects cannot move up and must use their own budgets for emergencies.
[39:00][39:26][39:41][39:54]
The committee proceeded to a due-pass motion, voted “aye” with no opposition, and reported the bill passed.
[40:09][40:18]
HB1924 C. Douglas AS AN THE ADD LEARNING CLASSIC TEST TO ENTRY ALLOWABLE COLLEGE EXAMINATION FOR THE PURPOSE OF RECEIVING SCHOLARSHIPS.
C. Douglas TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING PUBLIC SCHOOL HB1925 C. Douglas TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING PUBLIC SCHOOL ACADEMIC FACILITY REVIEW CONFERENCES.
41:39 - 50:2138 segments10 speakers
Rep. Stephen Meeks introduced HB 1925 to increase the review-conference period for academic facilities partnership applications from 20 to 75 days, giving districts more time to correct deficiencies.
[41:39][42:14][42:50][43:23][43:33][43:56][44:30]
Director Brad Montgomery testified that the current workload requires the extended timeframe, noting 144 conferences for 260 applications and that a 75-day window would address the backlog.
[43:26][43:31][43:33][43:56]
A brief clarification debate occurred over whether the period should be 75 or 90 days, with Meeks confirming 75 days as the final figure.
[44:58][45:01][45:11][45:26][45:33]
HB1934 Lowery TO ENSURE THAT PERSONALLY IDENTIFIABLE INFORMATION OF STUDENTS IS PROTECTED.
HB1936 Lowery TO REVISE THE ACADEMIC FACILITIES WEALTH INDEX.
HB2207 Boyd TO ABOLISH THE ALLOCATION OF ENROLLMENT POSITIONS AT THE UNIVERSITY OF ARKANSAS COLLEGE OF MEDICINE BASED ON CONGRESSIONAL DISTRICT AND ARKANSAS RESIDENCY.
50:21 - 1:31:00128 segments26 speakers
The chair, Representative Justin Boyd, explained that HB 2207 would repeal the statutory allocation of enrollment slots by congressional district and allow the UAMS College of Medicine admissions board to admit students based on qualifications rather than geography.
[50:25][50:42][50:50][51:00][51:10]
Representative John W. Walker questioned why the existing system, originally intended to boost minority enrollment, was being removed and asked for justification, while Boyd could not provide a specific reason but cited anecdotal district-shopping by applicants.
[50:42][50:50][51:00][51:10][51:13]
HB2243 Davis TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING SCHOLARSHIP PROGRAMS.
1:31:00 - 2:30:31181 segments23 speakers
Representative Davis’s HB 2243, which amends scholarship program provisions, was presented by Speaker 226 who outlined changes to scholarship amounts and eligibility, and Deputy Director Tara Smith clarified the new 2.5 GPA requirement for non-traditional students with college credit.
[1:31:30][1:32:06][1:32:13][1:32:20][1:32:39][1:32:42][1:32:45][1:32:49][1:33:16][1:33:52]
Representative Walker questioned the reduction of standards, and after brief discussion the chair noted no further speakers and moved to vote, resulting in a motion to pass the bill as amended that was adopted unanimously.
[1:35:58][1:36:04][1:36:10]
SB274 Elliott TO REVISE THE CIRCUMSTANCES UNDER WHICH A PUBLIC SCHOOL OR PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT THAT HAS BEEN TAKEN OVER BY THE STATE FOR BEING IN ACADEMIC DISTRESS CAN BE RETURNED TO LOCAL CONTROL; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
SB371 A. Clark CONCERNING CODE ARKANSAS SCHOOL PUBLIC AMEND TO THE OF PROVISIONSINTER-DISTRICT STUDENT TRANSFERS.
SB372 A. Clark OF THE PUBLIC SCHOOL TO CHOICE AMEND OF PROVISIONS OF TO ACT 2015; AND DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
SB416 A. Clark TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING THE OPERATION AND FUNDING OF PUBLIC CHARTER SCHOOLS. FUNDING OF PUBLIC CHARTER SCHOOLS.
SB518 B. Johnson TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING SPECIAL EDUCATION.
SB531B. Sample TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING THE ARKANSAS SCHOOL FOR MATHEMATICS, SCIENCES, AND THE ARTS.
SB562 J. English TO AMEND OR REPEAL OBSOLETE LAWS CONCERNING PUBLIC EDUCATION
SB568 A. Clark CONCERNING THE ECONOMIC SECURITY REPORT PREPARED BY THE DEPARTMENT OF WORKFORCE SERVICES.
SB570 L. Chesterfield TO REPEAL THE REQUIREMENT THAT A PUBLIC SCHOOL OR SCHOOL DISTRICT PROVIDE A DUTY-FREE LUNCH PERIOD FOR FULL-TIME NONEXEMPT CLASSIFIED EMPLOYEES.
SB773 D. Wallace TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING IN-STATE TUITION FOR VETERANS, MILITARY PERSONNEL, AND DEPENDENTS.
HB2028 Sabin ACT TO PROVIDE GRADUATES OF AN ARKANSAS HIGH SCHOOL EQUAL OPPORTUNITY TO RECEIVE IN-STATE TUITION AND OTHER FINANCIAL ASSISTANCE BENEFITS AT A STATE-SUPPORTED INSTITUTION OF HIGHER EDUCATION.
HB2125 Hollowell CONCERNING THE EFFICIENT OPERATION OF CERTAIN STATE AGENCIES; TO SPECIFY THE PROCESS FOR A POSSIBLE MERGER OF CROWLEY'S RIDGE TECHNICAL INSTITUTE TO EAST ARKANSAS COMMUNITY COLLEGE; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HR1044 F.Allen COMMEMORATING THE 60TH ANNIVERSARY OF THE HISTORIC INTEGRATION OF LITTLE ROCK CENTRAL HIGH SCHOOL.
SB178 Files TO DELAY THE INCLUSION OF A SCORE ON THE WRITING PORTION OF THE ACT ASPIRE ASSESSMENT IN A DETERMINATION OF THE ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE OF A STUDENT, PUBLIC SCHOOL, OR PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT.
HB1612 Rushing TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING REQUIRED NOTIFICATIONS TO A PROSECUTING AUTHORITY REGARDING A STUDENT'S UNEXCUSED ABSENCES.
HB1781 Lowery TO REQUIRE A SCHOOL DISTRICT TO PAY ONE-HALF (1/2) THE COST OF REMEDIATION FOR A STUDENT WHO RECEIVED A HIGH SCHOOL GRADE OF B OR BETTER IN THE SUBJECT IN WHICH THE STUDENT REQUIRES REMEDIATION; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES.
HB1859 Davis TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING EFFECTIVE STUDENT DISCIPLINE.
HB1937 Lowery TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF TITLE 6 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING THE BEGINNING AND END OF THE SCHOOL YEAR.
HB2052 Cozart TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING SCHOOLS OF INNOVATION.
HB2101 Lemons CONCERNING HOME-SCHOOLED STUDENTS PARTICIPATING IN PUBLIC GRADUATION CEREMONIES.
HB2117 Sorvillo TO REQUIRE CAMERAS IN CERTAIN CONTAINED SPECIAL EDUCATION CLASSROOMS UPON REQUEST.
HB1017 Cozart TO ALLOW THE TEACHER FAIR DISMISSAL ACT OF 1983 TO BE WAIVED IF A PUBLIC SCHOOL OR PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT IS UNDER STATE AUTHORITY AFTER BEING CLASSIFIED AS BEING IN DISTRESS.
HB1027 Eubanks TO PROHIBIT A SCHOOL DISTRICT FROM USING PUBLIC FUNDS TO PAY A TEACHER'S OR CLASSIFIED EMPLOYEE'S MEMBERSHIP DUES IN A PROFESSIONAL ORGANIZATION.
HB1029 Lowery TO EXCLUDE PRINCIPALS, ASSISTANT PRINCIPALS, AND CENTRAL OFFICE EMPLOYEES WITH A MULTIYEAR EMPLOYMENT CONTRACT FROM THE DEFINITION OF "TEACHER" UNDER THE TEACHER FAIR DISMISSAL ACT OF 1983.
HB1044 F. Allen TO ALLOW A STUDENT TO CHOOSE WHICH GRADE IN WHICH TO TAKE THE COLLEGE AND CAREER READINESS ASSESSMENT.
HB1408 C. Douglas CONCERNING WHO MAY SERVE AS A PROCTOR OF A TEST OR ASSESSMENT ADMINISTERED UNDER THE ARKANSAS COMPREHENSIVE TESTING, ASSESSMENT, AND ACCOUNTABILITY PROGRAM ACT.
HB1456 C. Douglas TO ALLOW A SCHOOL DISTRICT TO WAIVE PHYSICAL EDUCATION REQUIREMENTS FOR A STUDENT WHO PROVIDES PROOF OF PHYSICAL ACTIVITY; AND TO EXEMPT A STUDENT WITH A PHYSICAL EDUCATION WAIVER FROM PHYSICAL EDUCATION GRADUATION REQUIREMENTS.
HB1458 C. Douglas TO REQUIRE A STUDENT TO PARTICIPATE IN VISUAL ARTS OR PERFORMING ARTS IN EITHER GRADE SEVEN OR GRADE EIGHT.
HB1510 Gonzales TO CREATE THE DEMOGRAPHIC PREFERENCE DISCLOSURE ACT.
HB1831 Leding TO ALLOW AN OPEN-ENROLLMENT PUBLIC CHARTER SCHOOL TO USE A WEIGHTED LOTTERY IN IT ADMISSIONS PROCESS BASED ON CERTAIN STUDENT CHARACTERISTICS.