Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

Judiciary Committee

March 21, 2017 ·Committee Room 130 ·3:04:48
Video Transcript

Summary

Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 13, 2026

HB2103 V. Flowers CONCERNING THE SENTENCES AVAILABLE FOR A CAPITAL OFFENSE. 1:54

Representative Vivian Flowers introduced HB 2103, noting it was brought forward by the Arkansas Coalition to Abolish the Death Penalty and distributed handouts outlining six reasons to repeal capital punishment. [2:14] [2:50] [3:32] [4:04] [4:41]

The committee heard testimony from pollster Ernie Oakley, who presented 2014 survey results showing a decline in death-penalty support and mixed voter reactions to replacing it with life without parole. [7:06] [7:13] [7:24] [7:34] [7:43] [8:19] [8:54] [9:27] [9:59] [10:36] [11:09]

Additional witnesses-including Judith Elaine, who recounted a wrongful-conviction case; Bishop Larry Benefield, who argued the death penalty conflicts with religious and moral values; and Rhonda Brassfield of the Arkansas Coalition, who cited cost, deterrence, racial disparity and innocence concerns-provided further arguments against the death penalty. [12:27] [12:51] [13:26] [13:56] [14:31] [15:01] [15:33] [16:03] [16:29] [16:43] [17:15] [17:45] [18:15] [18:49] [19:05] [19:12] [19:20] [19:51] [20:21] [20:53] [21:26] [22:01]

Committee members asked questions about racial statistics, the bill’s language substituting life imprisonment versus life without parole, and the possibility of amending the bill; Representative Flowers said she would be willing to amend the language, and the chair moved the committee on to consideration of House Bill 2170 without a vote on HB 2103. [22:49] [22:57] [23:03] [23:13] [23:37] [24:04] [24:11] [24:17] [24:42] [25:15] [25:24] [25:27] [25:30] [25:45] [26:18] [26:52] [27:03] [27:26] [27:36] [27:56] [28:13] [28:27] [28:59] [29:32] [30:04] [30:30] [30:35] [30:56] [31:15] [31:27] [31:36] [31:47] [31:53] [32:19]

HB2170 V. Flowers CONCERNING THE IMPOSITION OF THE DEATH PENALTY ON A DEFENDANT WITH A SERIOUS MENTAL ILLNESS. 32:40

Representative Vivian Flowers introduced HB 2170, which would bar the imposition of the death penalty on defendants diagnosed with a serious mental illness, and called law professor Tom Sullivan to testify on the issue. [33:11] [33:28]

Sullivan detailed how forced medication to make death-row inmates competent raises unresolved U.S. Supreme Court questions, described the ethical dilemma for physicians and defense counsel, and argued that the bill would create a pre-trial mental-illness evaluation that automatically substitutes a death sentence with life without parole-points that prompted extensive questions from Representatives Dalby, Petty, Rushing and Gazaway about overlap with Senate Bill 42, the definition of “seriously mentally ill,” and procedural implementation. [33:53] [34:26] [34:57] [35:29] [36:02] [36:33] [37:07] [37:41] [38:16] [38:51] [39:15] [39:26] [39:56] [40:01] [40:13] [40:29] [41:03] [41:08] [41:24] [42:40] [43:00] [43:02] [43:15] [43:45] [44:16] [47:50] [48:15] [48:24] [48:30] [48:50] [48:54] [49:20] [49:51] [1:00:59] [1:01:31] [1:02:07]

Testimony from Prosecuting Attorney Nathan Smith and other opponents warned the measure is overly broad and could effectively abolish the death penalty, while supporters such as former legislator Herb Rule emphasized cost, moral, and victim-family considerations; the committee did not record a vote, leaving the bill pending. [1:06:17] [1:06:37] [1:06:44] [1:07:08] [1:07:39] [1:13:17] [1:13:40] [1:14:10] [1:14:45]

CONCUR IN SENATE AMENDMENT 1:19:47

The committee heard extensive testimony on the merits of life-without-parole versus the death penalty, including cost comparisons, mental-illness considerations, and moral arguments presented by Representatives Petty, House, Dr. Rick Smith, Paul Calvert, Karen DePippa, and Representative Flowers, with several members questioning whether the government’s right to execute should be limited to certain circumstances. [1:20:08] [1:20:17] [1:20:42] [1:21:01] [1:21:13] [1:21:27] [1:21:49] [1:22:22] [1:22:37] [1:22:44] [1:22:48] [1:22:53] [1:23:06] [1:23:09] [1:23:25] [1:23:39] [1:24:00] [1:24:17] [1:24:32] [1:24:47] [1:25:03] [1:25:09] [1:25:13] [1:25:36] [1:25:46] [1:26:08] [1:26:17] [1:26:40] [1:26:54] [1:27:13] [1:27:37] [1:27:43] [1:28:00] [1:28:15] [1:28:49] [1:29:23] [1:29:55] [1:30:29] [1:30:45] [1:30:56] [1:31:02] [1:32:04] [1:32:40] [1:33:11] [1:33:41] [1:34:16] [1:34:41] [1:34:48] [1:35:30] [1:35:48] [1:35:56] [1:36:34] [1:37:06]

A motion to limit further debate to five minutes per side was made by Chair Shepherd and adopted unanimously, establishing a time-constraint for the remaining comments. [1:25:13]

After brief closing remarks, a motion to “do pass” the Senate-amended version of House Bill 2170 was taken; the committee voted aye with no recorded opposition, thereby approving the amendment. [1:38:20] [1:38:34] [1:38:42] [1:39:00] [1:39:13]

SB535 J. Cooper CONCERNING DUAL JUDICIAL DISTRICTS. 1:59:44

The committee adopted the amendment to SB 535 and recognized Senator Cooper and Representative Ladyman to present the bill, which seeks to repeal the 1883 and 2003 statutes that created dual judicial districts in Craighead County,. [2:00:56] [2:01:27] [2:02:01] [2:02:39] [2:02:44] [2:02:49] [2:03:17] [2:03:51] [2:04:27] [2:05:09] [2:05:47] [2:06:26] [2:06:58] [2:07:30] [2:08:06]

Testimony from Craighead County officials-including Assessor Hannah Towle, Circuit Clerk Candace Edwards, and County Clerk Angela Russell-described how the dual-district system creates financial segregation, illegal subsidies, and operational dysfunction, supporting the repeal,,. [2:02:39] [2:02:44] [2:02:49] [2:03:17] [2:05:09] [2:05:47] [2:06:26] [2:06:58] [2:22:02] [2:22:25] [2:22:58] [2:23:28] [2:24:01] [2:24:32] [2:25:04]

After Representative Bob Ballinger moved to limit debate to five minutes per side (adopted) and the committee heard supporting testimony from retired banker E. Ray Hackworth and opposition from mayors and legislators, the committee voted to pass the bill as amended,,,. [2:34:08] [2:34:12] [2:34:35] [2:35:05] [2:35:39] [2:36:10] [2:36:42] [2:37:16] [2:37:49] [2:38:21] [2:39:10] [2:39:24] [2:39:58] [2:40:04] [2:40:31] [2:40:35] [2:41:05] [2:41:39] [2:42:09] [2:42:39] [2:43:09] [2:43:40] [2:44:00] [2:44:13] [2:44:44] [2:47:12] [2:47:27]

HB2113 Henderson CONCERNING THE TESTING OF A FIREARM BY THE STATE CRIME LABORATORY. 2:47:48

The committee adopted an amendment to HB 2113 after Representative Ken Henderson moved for its adoption and the amendment was approved without debate. [2:48:36] [2:48:41] [2:48:59]

Henderson, with input from State Crime Lab Director Kermit Channel, explained that the bill would streamline forensic firearm testing by limiting database entries to weapons that can be scientifically analyzed, improving efficiency for law-enforcement agencies. [2:49:03] [2:49:24] [2:49:32] [2:50:05]

With no members signing up for or against the measure, the committee voted to pass the bill as amended. [2:50:32] [2:50:37] [2:50:46]

SB702 E. Williams CONCERNING THE ASSESSMENT OF AN ADDITIONAL FINE FOR CRIMINAL OFFENSES COMMITTED AGAINST OR IN THE PRESENCE OF A CHILD AND THE ASSESSMENT OF A… 2:51:08

Senator E. Williams introduced SB 702 to increase the fine for offenses committed in the presence of a child to $100 and add a $5 surcharge for high-speed violations, directing the revenue to Child Advocate Centers. [2:51:13] [2:51:47] [2:52:21]

The committee received no testimony for or against the bill and subsequently moved to pass it, which was approved by voice vote. [2:53:30] [2:53:54]

HB1943 C. Douglas TO PROHIBIT THE AWARD OF ALIMONY TO PERSONS CONVICTED OF A DOMESTIC VIOLENCE OFFENSE. 2:54:23

Representative Douglas proposed an amendment to HB 1943 that replaces mandatory language with discretionary language, allowing judges to consider domestic-violence factors when deciding alimony awards. [2:54:35] [2:54:39] [2:55:13]

The committee adopted the amendment after a motion by Representative Dalby, and then approved the bill as amended without further debate. [2:55:19] [2:55:34] [2:55:44] [2:55:56]

HB1817 C. Douglas TO CREATE THE OFFENSE OF POSSESSION OF A FIREARM WHILE UNDER THE INFLUENCE OF ALCOHOL OR A CONTROLLED SUBSTANCE. 2:56:17

An amendment to HB 1817 was offered to require a review of an applicant’s convictions within the past three years before issuing a concealed-carry license, addressing a gap in the existing law. [2:56:48] [2:57:09]

The committee adopted the amendment and subsequently passed the bill as amended by voice vote. [2:57:09] [2:57:20] [2:57:52] [2:57:56]

HB1884 Gazaway TO ADOPT THE UNIFORM UNSWORN FOREIGN DECLARATIONS ACT. 2:58:20

Representative Jimmy Gazaway introduced HB 1884 to adopt the Uniform Unsworn Foreign Declarations Act, and Elisa White, Vice President and General Counsel of the Arkansas Hospital Association, explained that the bill would allow Arkansas courts to use the same 30-year federal procedure for admitting unsworn foreign declarations as state courts. [2:58:24] [2:58:52] [2:58:55] [2:59:28] [2:59:35]

No committee member sought to speak for or against the measure; Chair Matthew J. Shepherd called for a motion to pass, which was adopted unanimously without objection. [2:59:55] [3:00:03]

HB2253 Gazaway REVISED UNIFORM FIDUCIARY ACCESS TO DIGITAL ASSETS ACT. 3:00:32

Representative Jimmy Gazaway presented HB 2253, the Revised Uniform Fiduciary Access to Digital Assets Act, describing its goal of giving fiduciaries authority to manage a person’s digital assets upon death or incapacity, and requested Professor Lynn Foster to testify on the bill’s details. [3:00:38] [3:01:15] [3:01:46]

Professor Foster outlined the act’s key provisions-four types of fiduciaries, extension of fiduciary powers to digital property, and limited access to electronic communications without the owner’s consent-while noting its adoption in 24 states and endorsements from AARP, Facebook, Google, and the National Academy of Elder Law Attorneys. [3:01:46] [3:02:22] [3:02:55]

Representative David Whitaker asked whether recent amendments had addressed earlier opposition from groups such as the Motion Picture Association of America, to which Foster confirmed they had, and no further questions were raised. [3:03:25] [3:03:46]

The chair closed the hearing, moved to pass the bill, and the motion carried unanimously with no opposition. [3:03:55]

Bills discussed (72)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB2103 · 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…esent flowers we're going to take up we're going to take up House Bill 2103 first. Representative Flowers, you're recognized to present…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2170 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…ght, without objection, then we're going to move forward to House Bill 2170. Okay. And I guess before we begin consideration of House B…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1041 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1041 B. Smith TO PROTECT THE RIGHTS AND PRIVILEGES GRANTED UNDER…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1055 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1055 Hammer TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF "MARITAL PROPERTY" FOR PU…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1095 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1095 Johnson CONCERNING THE REQUIREMENTS FOR A CONCEALED HANDGUN…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1152 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1152 Watson CONCERNING THE ABILITY OF AN AUXILIARY LAW ENFORCEME…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1173 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1173 Tucker TO AMEND AND MAKE CONSISTENT THE OFFENSES OF SEXUAL…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1177 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1177 Tucker INCREASING THE AVAILABLE SENTENCES FOR CERTAIN SEX O…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1248 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1248 J. Williams TO CREATE AN EXEMPTION UNDER THE FREEDOM OF INF…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1265 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1265 Richey CONCERNING THE POSSESSION AND CARRYING OF A CONCEALE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1268 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1268 Murdock CONCERNING THE USE OF AN IGNITION INTERLOCK DEVICE.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1367 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1367 Watson CONCERNING AN AUXILIARY LAW ENFORCEMENT OR A RETIRED…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1433 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1433 Baltz TO PROHIBIT A REGISTERED SEX OFFENDER FROM LIVING NEA…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1444 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1444 Ballinger TO REVISE CERTAIN EMINENT DOMAIN LAWS THAT ARISE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1629 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1629 Tucker TO PROTECT VICTIMS OF DOMESTIC ABUSE AND STALKING; A…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1630 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1630 Tucker TO PROTECT CHILDREN FROM UNATTENDED LOADED FIREARMS;…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1631 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1631 Tucker CONCERNING A WARRANTLESS ARREST FOR DOMESTIC ABUSE.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1713 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1713 Lowery TO ESTABLISH MURDER IN THE SECOND DEGREE AS A SEVENT…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1747 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1747 D. Whitaker CONCERNING PAROLE ELIGIBILITY OF A PERSON INCAR…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1759 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1759 Dalby TO MAKE LEGISLATIVE CORRECTIONS AND TO REPEAL OBSOLET…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1784 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1784 Eaves CONCERNING THE QUALIFICATIONS TO BE A LAW ENFORCEMENT…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1797 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1797 Leding TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS CIVIL RIGHTS ACT OF 1993.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1798 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1798 Blake AMENDING THE BURDEN OF PROOF REQUIRED DURING THE SENT…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1817 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1817 C. Douglas TO CREATE THE OFFENSE OF POSSESSION OF A FIREARM…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1827 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1827 Della Rosa CONCERNING THE LICENSE FEES FOR A LICENSE TO CAR…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1842 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1842 Johnson A TO ASSESSED IS WHO PERSON FEES CONCERNING AND FIN…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1843 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1843 Petty CONCERNING CRIME VICTIMS REPARATIONS; AND CONCERNING…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1864 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1864 Gates CONCERNING A MEMBER OF THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY AND THE S…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1884 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1884 Gazaway TO ADOPT THE UNIFORM UNSWORN FOREIGN DECLARATIONS A…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1886 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1886 Gazaway TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 16 OF THE AR…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1888 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1888 Ballinger ESTABLISHING AN ENHANCED CERTIFICATION TOCARRY A…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1889 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1889 Ballinger TO CREATE THE OFFENSE OF CARRYING A WEAPON IN A P…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1895 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1895 Gates CONCERNING THE CONCEALED CARRY OF A HANDGUN BY A CONC…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1899 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1899 Bentley CONCERNING THE PROCUREMENT OF A LICENSE TO CARRY A…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1909 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1909 Walker CONCERNING THE TEMPORARY ABATEMENT OF THE REQUIREMEN…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1918 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1918 Walker CONCERNING PAROLE ELIGIBILITY FOR A PERSON SERVING A…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1943 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1943 C. Douglas TO PROHIBIT THE AWARD OF ALIMONY TO PERSONS CONV…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1959 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1959 Ballinger TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING ALIMONY SUPPORT.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1985 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1985 Ballinger CONCERNING FIREARM POSSESSION FOR A NONVIOLENT FE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1994 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1994 Pilkington CONCERNING THE INTENDED PURPOSE OF THE CONCEALED…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2012 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2012 Vaught CONCERNING THE POSTING OF BOND TO RELEASE A PERSON F…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2017 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2017 Brown CONCERNING THE FEE FOR VICTIM IMPACT PANEL ATTENDANCE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2075 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2075 Leding TO PROHIBIT COMMERCIAL SURROGACY ARRANGEMENTS AND TH…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2076 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2076 Dotson TO REDUCE THE FEE FOR A CONCEALED CARRY LICENSE; TO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2080 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2080 Petty CONCERNING SEXUAL ASSAULT MEDICAL LEGAL EXAMINATIONS;…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2083 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2083 Petty TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING CRIMINAL BACKGROUND CHECK…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2088 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2088 Leding TO PROVIDE ENHANCED PENALTIES FOR A CRIMINAL OFFENSE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2112 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2112 Walker CONCERNING A PERSON WHO FAILS TO APPEAR OR FAILS TO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2113 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2113 Henderson CONCERNING THE TESTING OF A FIREARM BY THE STATE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2116 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2116 Holcomb TO PROTECT FREIGHT RAIL EMPLOYEES AND PUBLIC TRANSI…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2118 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2118 Womack CONCERNING THE CIVIL LIABILITY OF AN ENTITY THAT MAI…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2119 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2119 Womack CONCERNING THE CIVIL LIABILITY OF AN INSTITUTION OF…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2121 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2121 Womack CONCERNING A CITIZEN'S RIGHT TO OBSERVE AND RECORD P…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2131 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2131 K. Ferguson CONCERNING A SUSPENDED IMPOSITION OF SENTENCE;…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2168 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2168 Collins CONCERNING THE POSSESSION OF A CONCEALED HANDGUN IN…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2199 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2199 M. Hodges TO CLARIFY THE PURPOSE OF THE MINORITY BUSINESS E…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2202 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2202 Tucker CONCERNING THE NEW BUSINESS RULE AND THE ABILITY OF…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2228 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2228 Blake CONCERNING THE INDEPENDENT INVESTIGATION OF DEATHS IN…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2232 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2232 Ballinger TO CREATE THE GOVERNMENT NONDISCRIMINATION ACT OF…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2234 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2234 Ballinger TO REPEAL DOWER AND COURTESY RIGHTS; AND TO CREAT…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2253 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2253 Gazaway REVISED UNIFORM FIDUCIARY ACCESS TO DIGITAL ASSETS…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2266 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2266 V. Flowers TO ESTABLISH A UNIFORM STANDARD FOR DATA COLLECT…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2270 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2270 V. Flowers CONCERNING BODY CAMERAS FOR LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFI…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB102 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB102 Flippo TO CLARIFY THE LAW CONCERNING THE FINES, FEES, AND C…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB113 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB113 J. Hutchinson TO REMOVE A DRIVER'S LICENSE SUSPENSION OR RE…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB237 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB237 Elliott TO REQUIRE THE PREPARATION OF A RACIAL IMPACT STATE…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB37 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB37 A. Clark PERMITTING A CONCEALED CARRY LICENSEE TO POSSESS A…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB533 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB533 J. Hutchinson TO CREATE THE DYNASTY TRUST ACT.”
Pre-2017 bill
SB535 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB535 J. Cooper CONCERNING DUAL JUDICIAL DISTRICTS.”
Pre-2017 bill
SB550 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB550 T. Garner TO PROTECT ACCESS TO PLACES OF EMPLOYMENT, RIGHTS…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB554 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB554 J. Hutchinson CONCERNING THE AUTHORITY OF A UNITED STATES P…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB702 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB702 E. Williams CONCERNING THE ASSESSMENT OF AN ADDITIONAL FINE…”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 13, 2026
Chairman sees a quorum members a few items a few items before we get started today the speaker has asked me to inform the committee that we likely will will come back for our second committee meeting of the week after session today the plan is that today would be the last time to run house bills and then next week we would take up any senate bills that that head our way so just be aware of that I think I've talked to virtually everybody I think I've talked to all the house members have bills in our committee and and have talked with them about the status of their bills. So hopefully today and primarily I'd like to this morning try and take care of as much business as we can this morning. And we do have three bills on special order and a couple other bills that may take a little bit of time. But I would appreciate it if everybody would try and stay attentive and here in committee as much as possible. I know members have to get out and run their bills and other committees but I anticipate we're gonna we're gonna work for quite a while this morning so with that we're gonna move to the special order of business and after conferring with represent Blake and represent flowers we're going to take up we're going to take up House Bill 2103 first. Representative Flowers, you're recognized to present House Bill 2103. All right, you're recognized to present House Bill 2103. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Members you should have in front of you a copy of a few handouts and this will help us provide you with some of the information we'll be speaking on and I'll try to be as succinct as I can since we have several people who I know want to speak. And I'll just let you know that this bill was brought to me by the Arkansas coalition to abolish the death penalty. And since I am a proponent of that policy and have been a little, well, quite aware of the issues and did some research, I decided to take it on and let me say that while there are several issues and several reasons and actually there are a couple of handouts that I don't see here, so I'll have to thank you. So one of the handouts, six reasons why Arkansas should abolish the death penalty. The death penalty does not deter crime. The death penalty is expensive. Innocent people have been sentenced to death. There have been numerous mistakes with the death penalty in Arkansas. The death penalty is unfair and arbitrary. The death penalty is out of step with our values. For me, the reason that I think that we all have to consider how and why Arkansas cannot and should not impose the death penalty is a reason that doesn't change. And that is that human beings are fallible. To date, 100, since 1972, 157 people who were on death row have been exonerated. And we have no idea how many people have been put to death, because we can't exonerate people who have been put to death. So I would like to ask for your attention, and I won't go into the details because I'm I'm not an expert like some of the people who will testify today to some of these points. And so, Mr. Chair, if we could begin by hearing from some of the folks here, and if I could just call them here to offer some perspective, and then perhaps we can take any questions that the
▶ Play
committee might have. How many individuals
▶ Play
do you have? I have four or five people, and each one of them, we won't go on long, which is why I would prefer if we could do it like this. Each one will be limited to a couple of minutes, if that. And then, like
▶ Play
I said, we can answer questions. Okay. I'm going to give some leeway, and we'll start down this road. Yes. I just ask that each individual keep it pretty short, particularly since this is part of
▶ Play
your presentation. Yes, sir. Okay. Thank you. So, Mr. Oakleaf, who is the founder of Opinion Research Associates, and he's here and is going to speak to a poll that will indicate. Okay. Mr.
▶ Play
Oakleaf. Mr. Oakleaf. Right here. here. If you would have a seat, state
▶ Play
Speaker 34 7:06
your name and then make, make your comments. good morning my name is Ernie Oakley with the company my wife and I founded it's called opinion research associates we do market research which includes political polling and we have done some research. Mr. Oakley, if you would pull the microphone a little closer to
▶ Play
you and make sure that it's turned on there. Thank you, sir. We've done
▶ Play
Speaker 34 7:34
some research on the voter opinion in Arkansas and the death penalty, and I wanted to give you a few of the highlights of that study. In April of 2014, we interviewed by telephone 402 likely voters in Arkansas, randomly selected from registered voter files. Total sample has a margin of error, plus or minus 5 percentage points, at the 95% level of confidence. The first question that we asked in the survey was, Do you generally support or oppose capital punishment, that is, the death penalty, in cases which people are convicted of murder? This is a question that we have asked previously. It was asked in 1992 and again in 2008. In 2014, 67% said that they favored either strongly or somewhat capital punishment. That is a decrease of 10 points from 1992 when it was 77 percent and 2008 when it was 70 percent. We ask people later in the survey, suppose your state senator or representative voted to replace the death penalty with a life sentence without parole. Would this affect your vote the next time the senator or representative runs for office? Does this make you more likely to vote for the senator or rep, less likely, or would it make no difference? We found that 60% of respondents either said it would make them more likely, which was 15%, or that it would make no difference. So 36% said it would make them less likely. So the majority of voters are not likely to punish a legislator for supporting abolition of the death penalty. Critics of the death penalty list reasons. They say the death penalty is flawed. We read a list of problems that people see with the death penalty, and that included there's a risk an innocent person might be sentenced to death, The death penalty is immoral, racially biased, biased against poor people, the death penalty is too costly, and the death penalty causes excess delay in carrying out the punishment. On most of those problems, a majority of respondents said that it was not a serious problem. More people said it was not a serious problem than they said it was a serious problem, except on two of them. One of them, which was alluded to here a moment ago, has to do with the risk that an innocent person might be sentenced to death. 86% of Arkansans believe that that is a serious problem and an innocent person might be sentenced to death. The other issue that was considered a serious problem by respondents was the death penalty causes excess delay in carrying out the punishment. 56% said that that's a problem, which I think both of these issues have to do with fairness of the death penalty. So that is, I think, the primary concern of Arkansas voters with the death penalty. Related to that, we asked people if they were convinced that an offender was suffering from a profound mental illness, such as schizophrenia, at the time of the offense. In that case, 65% of voters said they would be against the death penalty. So in summary, I think what we're finding is while support of the death penalty remains high, the trend is that support is declining, and there are reasons that voters feel should keep the death penalty from being applied in every case. If you have any questions, I'd be happy to entertain
▶ Play
them. All right. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Oakley, for your testimony. Thank you, Mr. Chair. If I could invite Ms. Judith Elaine, and she is a family member of a murder victim.
▶ Play
Ms. Elaine, if you'll state your name for the record,
▶ Play
Speaker 48 12:22
then you may make your comments.
▶ Play
Speaker 49 12:27
Judith Elaine. Chairman Shepard and committee members. Thank you for this opportunity to speak with you First I want to extend My heart felt sympathy to representative petty and representative rushing For the tragic losses of their precious daughters to violence my big brother gene was my hero and the father figure for me he was shot and killed in cold blood the killing happened in a public place the police had the gun with the suspected shooters fingerprints on it they also took eyewitness statements from four people an easy case right wrong. Despite all of this incriminating evidence, the suspect eluded law enforcement for more than 40 years. By the time the suspected shooter was apprehended and returned to the jurisdiction where the shooting occurred, the district attorney said he could no longer make a case. Physical evidence had been destroyed 20 years earlier, and eyewitnesses could not corroborate the statements they had given police 40 years earlier. So after six days of detention, the suspect returned home, and the case was officially closed without anyone being held accountable for my brother's murder. Needless to say, my father, excuse me, my family and I were devastated. The old wound had been ripped open and we were left to mourn all over again four decades later. Even though my brother was murdered, I'm here today to speak against the death penalty. Since it was reinstated in 1976, there have been numerous surveys and investigations into the cost of prosecuting and carrying out the death penalty compared to other serious sentences. Every one of these studies has concluded that it costs millions of dollars more to carry out death sentences. After doing a meta-analysis of cost studies conducted across the country, Dr. Ernest Gross of Creighton University in Nebraska estimated that the death penalty cost states with capital punishment an average of 23.2 million dollars more per year than alternative sentences. His study was published just last August. Closer to home, a report released by the Tennessee controller of the Treasury concluded that capital murder trials are longer and more expensive at every step compared to the murder trials, to other murder trials. In fact, the available data indicated that death trials in Tennessee cost an average of 48 percent more than the average cost of murder trials in which prosecutors seek prison sentences. Given the consistent and overwhelming evidence of the great expense of death sentences. I can't help but think that my family would have been much better served if that money had been spent on crime solving and victim services. Please do away with the death penalty in Arkansas and redirect the savings to more productive purposes. Thank you for your attention and consideration. Thank you for your testimony. Thank you. I would
▶ Play
like to ask Bishop Larry Benefield to join me at the end of the table.
▶ Play
Speaker 57 16:43
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm Larry Benefield, the Bishop of the Episcopal Church in Arkansas, a position I've held for 10 years. Arkansas is a state that needs to eliminate capital punishment. Its practice is inconsistent with our moral and ethical values. This may be an issue on which people of reasonable good faith might disagree, but I have to emphasize my church's consistent opposition to the death penalty for over half a century, a position that's been held for many years as well by the World Council of Churches and the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops. Indeed, we're one of the few predominantly Christian nations left on the face of the earth that still uses capital punishment, and our crime rate is no lower as a result. Other religious nations have been doing better than we. I base my opposition to the death penalty in an understanding that our ideas of justice are too often based on retribution, which is inconsistent with my religious teaching, and I base it on our regard for the sacredness of human life, our commitment to respect the dignity of every human being, our desire to seek and serve Christ in all persons, and our mission to continue Christ's work of reconciliation in the world. We subconsciously encourage death and devalue life when the state is willing to put convicts to death. Even in the face of horrific crimes, we as a civilized society must say that we value human life so much that we will show by example a better way to live. The sad truth is that an execution will not bring back to life the person who was killed in the commission of a crime. It will merely add yet another person to the list of those who've died an unnecessary death. It's better for the conscience of every one of us to commit a convict to life in prison and then to stand beside and sensitively work with the survivors of those who were killed by horrific crimes to help them find meaning in their lives. I want this state to take the moral and ethical high ground and be an example of the best that all our religious heritage tries to instill in us. There are so many things that legislators can do to make our life better. One of the simplest is to eliminate the death penalty and replace it with something that shows our respect for life, even when it's emotionally difficult to do so. Thank
▶ Play
Speaker 58 19:05
you very much. Thank you for your comments. Thank you, Bishop. And
▶ Play
now I would like to call for Rhonda Brassfield, who is the executive director of the Arkansas Coalition
▶ Play
Speaker 62 19:20
to Abolish the Death Penalty. Good morning, and thank you to the chair of this committee, the vice chair, and to all the committee members. Thank you so much for allowing us the opportunity to have this bill heard today. I am the executive director of the Arkansas Coalition to abolish the death penalty. And I just wanted to talk about a few reasons why capital punishment is bad policy for Arkansas. The first reason is that the death penalty does not deter crime. According to FBI crime data, the murder rate is 25% higher in death penalty states than in non-death penalty states. Arkansas's murder rate is 6.1 per 100,000 people as compared to a rate of 4.13 in non-death penalty states. 88% of the country's top criminologists do not believe that the death penalty acts as a deterrent to homicide. The death penalty is expensive. The death penalty is more expensive than the sentence of life without parole. Studies from 12 states and the federal government all show that the death penalty costs taxpayers more than any alternative sentence. A recent North Carolina study found repealing the death penalty would save that state around $11 million a year. Innocent people have been sentenced to death. Since 1976, 156 individuals that were sentenced to death were later found to be totally innocent and set free, the most recent of which was January of this year. During that same time period, the United States carried out over 1,400 executions. That's over one exoneration for every 10 executions that were carried out in this country. There have been numerous mistakes with the death penalty here in Arkansas. At least 25 Arkansans have had their death sentences reduced on appeal. The death penalty is unfair and arbitrary. An estimated 20% of all death row inmates suffer from a serious mental illness. A recent study by the University of Arkansas at Little Rock shows that blacks were over two times more likely than whites to receive the death penalty for a charge of capital murder. Two people with a capital murder charge and an African-American is more than two times more likely to receive the death penalty. Black Arkansans constitute 134 of the 195 executions that have taken place since this state began to take records on the death penalty. The death penalty is out of step with our values. In 2015, only China, Iran, Saudi Arabia, and Pakistan performed more executions than the United States. More people were executed in the U.S. than Iraq, North Korea, Yemen, or Somalia. That puts us in horrible company. And recent events have shed a bad light on the state of Arkansas with our partners around the world. For all of these reasons, I would ask that this committee would consider and pass this bill to replace the death penalty with the sentence of life without the possibility of parole, which equates to death sentence in prison. Thank you so much. We
▶ Play
do have a question. Representative Petty, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you for being here and testifying. I wanted to know, and I'll have a follow-up, if you could read the statistics for me about blacks versus whites.
▶ Play
Speaker 62 23:13
I didn't get that. Yes, ma'am. There is a study. It was commissioned by the University of Arkansas at Little Rock. It was between the Social Work Department and the UALR Bowen School of Law. That study was to study the racial disparity in the criminal justice system. Specifically, they studied capital murder, charging, and sentencing. The statistic that I said for you today is that from the cases that were studied in this particular study, of those that had a capital murder charge, you have two individuals with a capital murder charge, the black individual was more than two times likely to receive the sentence of death, whereas the white person would receive the more lenient sentence of life without parole. Follow-up, and
▶ Play
no disrespect, but how does that explain that there are 16 white males on death row, 17 black males, and one Hispanic? That seems pretty even to me. Yes,
▶ Play
Speaker 62 24:17
ma'am. Well, first, it's not even because the population of African Americans in the state of Arkansas is about 16%, so half and 16%, that's a disparity. But I think that, and I'm sorry if I confuse the committee about the statistic, this is about charging and sentencing. Not everyone that is charged with a capital crime receives the death penalty. So these are people that are charged with a capital crime, And out of those individuals studied, the African American that was charged with a capital crime is more than two times likely to receive the death sentence. So this is not about the people that are on death row, and we can't look at the numbers that are on death row to qualify this particular statistic. This is everyone that we studied that had a capital charge, and all of those people did not end up on death row. All right.
▶ Play
Seeing no questions, thank you for your comments. Thank
▶ Play
you so much for your consideration. So, are you asking
▶ Play
me to? I was going to ask if you had anybody else or if
▶ Play
that's the. So, for this bill, that is all that I have right now. And I don't know if anyone had any questions for any of the folks who spoke. So before I had any closing remarks or answered any questions myself, I thought I would ask that.
▶ Play
Okay. Representative Dalby has a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Flowers, I was looking at this bill, and it appears that you're substituting life imprisonment for a possibility for a capital murder. and why add that as opposed to just leaving it life imprisonment without parole? Because we're talking about capital murder, so that seems like that's certainly a lesser punishment. No. Can you tell me? If you look on... Do you see where I... If you look on page, it looks like page 3, section 2, about line 18, well, all through there. A person convicted of capital murder shall be punished by, and you've struck out death by lethal injection, and put life imprisonment, or by life imprisonment without parole under the subchapter. My question is, is why add life imprisonment? Why could it not be life imprisonment without parole? It's the same
▶ Play
thing in Arkansas. And let me say this. Can I ask for Ms. Braswell to? I'll allow her to come back and make a brief response. And the only reason that I'm asking her is because, as you know, when we sit down with our staff attorneys and we indicate what we would like and look at model legislation and what it would do, I made that clear. And since I'm not an attorney, I didn't see that, so I would like
▶ Play
Speaker 62 27:36
for her to answer that question. Sure. Ascendance of life and life without parole in the state of Arkansas. This is an oversight. It's supposed to say life without parole, but ascendance of life and ascendance of life without parole is effectively the same thing in Arkansas. Both would require a commutation by the governor for the person to ever be set free.
▶ Play
Any other questions of Representative Flowers? Representative Flowers, do you have any further comments in your presentation? I
▶ Play
would only close with this, and there's plenty of information, and I know that people know the facts, know many of the facts that have been shared here today. Some people, when I filed this bill, ask me, why would you file this bill? It can't get out. And I disagree. I think that when we look at the information and look at all of the reasons why and think about the reasons why we should continue this practice, I don't see where there's even a slight of a balance in the issues. I think that it's not a partisan issue. When we look around the country and look at where there have been moratoriums, it's been Republican governors who have placed moratoriums in their states to end the death penalty and at least take a look at what we're doing and the kind of effect that it's having. And I know from my relationships with many people who I've served with for nearly three years, or beginning this third year, that people come to this body wanting to serve and wanting to make a difference and wanting to do the right thing. And so it's not lost on me, just like I'm sure it's not lost on you, that if there is a way for us to do better, that people want to do better. And so I would just end with the wish and the hope that everyone on this committee think about the things that you have heard today in making your decision. And even if you have some reticence about what you've heard or you feel you need more information, allow for it to get out of committee and for us to have a discussion on the floor. And so with that, I really appreciate your attention and the opportunity to bring this bill to you. And thank you. Representative
▶ Play
Charlene Fite, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Thank you. Representative Flowers, since you said this is not drafted as was your intent with the language with life imprisonment versus life imprisonment without parole, I'm wondering if you would be willing to take down this bill and have the language as you intended it
▶ Play
to be. I would be willing. Well, let me ask you this, because I would. I'm wondering if there is, if parliamentary procedure would allow for, um, there to be an amendment to the bill right now, if, especially something that, in that tiny.
▶ Play
My, my understanding on the House end is that we have to have it in writing in order for the committee to take it up and consider it. I would be
▶ Play
willing to amend it and bring it back for consideration. So are you wanting to
▶ Play
pull down? I'm just trying to figure out timing-wise and make sure we're all clear here. Do you want to pull the bill down at this point and see if you can get an amendment from BLR, or are you wanting to continue forward and see what
▶ Play
happens? I don't like to just see what happens. So why don't I try to get that amendment done, and Mr. Chair, if maybe we could go into the testimony and discussion on the other bill, which is related.
▶ Play
Okay. If we could do that. All right, without objection, then we're going to move forward to House Bill 2170. Okay. And I guess before we begin consideration of House Bill 2170, I would just ask, given the fact that we are here at the end of session and we do have a lot of business to take care of, if there's any duplicative testimony that relates back to what we've already heard, if we could just make reference to that. I already planned for that. We are not going to do that. I figured you
▶ Play
Speaker 47 33:05
counted for that, but just for the benefit of the audience as well. Thank you.
▶ Play
Yes. Okay. If I could ask Tom Sullivan to join me at the table.
▶ Play
Mr. Sullivan, you may have a seat, if you would state your
▶ Play
Speaker 118 33:28
name for the record. Tom Sullivan. I'm professor of law at the Bowen School of Law at UALR. I've taught at UALR since 1988. I've represented capital defendants charged with the death penalty who have been sentenced to death in New Mexico, Texas, and Arkansas. I have represented numerous defendants in Texas who were given the death penalty, and I've represented the post-conviction proceedings. The problem that is posed and addressed by this bill is a significant number of individuals who are in the criminal justice system who suffer from a diagnosed mental illness, and particularly a severe mental illness, which may or may not result in psychotic episodes rendering those people who suffer from this incompetent for execution. Arkansas, like every other jurisdiction, is bound by United States Supreme Court law that limits or precludes the execution of an individual who, because of a mental illness or defect, is unable to understand that they are going to be executed and the reasons for that execution. So the problem becomes for many of those inmates, what does the criminal justice system do with respect to the fact there's an ongoing mental illness and the ongoing mental illness precludes execution. And a lot of those inmates can be treated with psychotic or psychoactive medications that will address the symptoms of psychosis. The problem with that is that the issue of whether or not it's constitutional to impose medication on an ill or mentally ill death row inmate for the purpose of rendering that inmate competent for execution is still unresolved in the U.S. Supreme Court. And as we increase, I suspect, the number of individuals who will be exposed to the death penalty or death penalty prosecution once we resume executions, and I expect that to happen. I believe there's going to be a significant problem in terms of dealing with the mental illness problems of those individuals on death row. I have represented an individual who was psychotic while on death row, who was medicated with Haldol, who was forcibly medicated and then tricked in taking his medication and ultimately was rendered synthetically competent for the purpose of being executed, and that individual was executed. Now, I can tell you the individual was psychotic, had a complete break with reality while he was suffering from these psychotic episodes, and that Haldol was such an effective psychoactive drug that the administration of Haldol redressed those symptoms. So it is possible to use medication to force someone to become competent for execution. The question is whether or not that's a desirable public policy. It puts your medical practitioners who are dealing with mentally ill inmates on death row in the undeniably problematic position of having to medicate individuals knowing that the medication itself will render them competent to be executed. For the lawyer, it's an incredibly horrible situation to be in if you're trying to fight forced medication because basically you're put in a situation of having to say, I will keep my client psychotic in order to keep him alive. And for some inmates, if their symptoms have been redressed, they may actually decide they would rather undergo the execution than continue to stay in a state of psychosis. And when I say psychosis, and I do teach as an adjunct in the psychiatry department at UAMS, I mean severe mental illness, the kind of things that are not pleasant. You would never sign on to be psychotic in order to avoid some of the other bad consequences you might have in your life. You suffer from auditory hallucinations, which cannot be controlled, paranoid delusions. You may believe, as my client did, that there were spiders in his cell that were attacking him. You have this inability to deal with reality. and individuals who are sick often realize that they're sick so we're going to have a continuing problem the states of Louisiana and South Carolina when their supreme courts were confronted the question of can we medicate to make an individual who's mentally ill on death row and not subject to execution can we medicate them forcibly to make them competent to stand trial they ruled in State v. Perry and State v. Singleton that the state constitutions in Louisiana and South Carolina, and these are not what I would call liberal states. They're not Democratic blue states. They ruled that under their state constitutions, it was a violation of personal autonomy and due process to forcibly medicate these individuals. The Arkansas court took the position in Charles Singleton's case that the medication was necessary to treat the mental illness, which is an affirmative response to the problem of mental illness in our system, the duty to treat, to try to make that individual well. But it recognizes the consequence of that would be to render that individual competent for purposes of execution. And in fact, Charles Singleton, who I don't think there was any question about the significance of his mental illness, was in fact executed. And if you're going to treat this person for their mental illness, it seems to me you have an extremely serious ethical problem about whether or not you're rendering them competent to be executed at the same time. I think we'll see an increase in this problem if we increase the numbers of inmates on death row, because mental illness is a significant problem within the criminal population and the population generally in
▶ Play
this society. Representative Petty, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. So you said that they administer Haldol. Is that here in the state
▶ Play
Speaker 118 39:26
of Arkansas? I think you can do that. I think you can still use Haldol in the state of Arkansas. There are better drugs now. This administration occurred in 1995 and before then while my client was ill with the schizophrenia, paranoid type, but I think Haldol is still used in Arkansas. Probably it's a very inexpensive drug. It does have more side effects than the current regime of drugs, which are better for inmates or for individuals who are going to be medicated for psychosis or severe mental illness. so you're saying
▶ Play
that states administer Haldol to make people sane so they can execute them is that what I'm understanding that's the issue that has arisen and the
▶ Play
Speaker 118 40:13
U.S. Supreme Court has never dealt with it arose in Louisiana in state versus Perry it arose in South Carolina in state versus Singleton it arose in this state in state versus Charles Singleton and the question is you have a drug that can render someone competent for purposes of execution. Is it in their interest to take that drug? Well, they're not competent at that point to make that decision. It's going to fall to the lawyer and the psychiatrist who's involved in treatment, and that is an issue that is a continuing problem when you have mentally ill inmates, that they may become psychotic, not understand the reason for the execution. The Supreme Court has ruled that they have to be able understand it. Otherwise, the death penalty cannot be validly imposed. Am I answering your question, Representative? Kind of. Well, go ahead. It's complicated. One
▶ Play
more follow-up. Follow-up. If this is the case, what you're saying, shouldn't we be passing a bill that keeps the Department of Corrections from drugging death row inmates so we can get the truth about their mental status? Does that
▶ Play
Speaker 118 41:24
make sense? We have the diagnosis from the experts who are treating them about their mental status. They're all going to be subject to being evaluated by psychiatrists. These psychiatrists are experienced in this area, and they're not, in my experience, bleeding heart liberals at all. I teach with them. But we do have this problem because mental illness is a fluid concept. You're not necessarily going to be psychotic at all the time when you're mentally ill. and you can be treated, and the institution can treat you, but it's a problem if the purpose for doing that is to make you fit for being executed. I think there's a moral issue there as to whether or not doctors and defense lawyers should be put in the position, frankly, of having to make that decision about mental illness and psychosis are competence and death by execution, and I'm not saying these people haven't committed the crimes. I am not saying they have not been processed through the system fairly. They just happen to suffer from severe mental illnesses, and that's a common problem, frankly, in this society, but particularly within the criminal population. Representative Rushing, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
The question I have, and maybe I'm,
▶ Play
Speaker 134 42:34
I just want to make sure I understand
▶ Play
this right, but what you're saying is if they have this mental illness and it's diagnosed diagnosed and they're in prison. And if we treat them, then they are now capable of knowing what they've done and being subject to the death
▶ Play
Speaker 138 43:00
penalty. Is that correct? If we
▶ Play
treat them successfully, yes. Okay. So I'm looking at the list with schizophrenia, bipolar, major depressive disorder, delusional disorder, post-traumatic stress disorder. Let's just take PTSD, for example. All right. We know that people can be treated for PTSD and they have outrages and outbursts that they may not even know that happened. So this is when they kill people. This is when they have killed the victim. And so therefore, they're just as responsible at that point of no, they may not have known what they've done at that point when they killed that person, but they are supposed to be on their medication. We know that bipolar people don't like to take their medication because it makes them not feel the same. And so how can we say, I mean, this is the person that committed the crime, the person with PTSD, the person with bipolar, because they failed to take their medication. So they need to step up to the responsibility and feel what they're supposed to feel and be who they're supposed to be if we have medication to treat them and let them have the consequences of what they have done for not taking care of themselves to start with. Would you not agree?
▶ Play
Speaker 118 44:16
Our law recognizes that if at the time they did the act, they did not know what they were doing because of the existence of a mental disease or defect, they are entitled to plead insanity, and if the jury that's trying the capital case finds that they were insane under this theory, they are acquitted by reason of mental disease or defect. Alternatively, we also allow under our law the individual who's charged and convicted of the capital crime to plead mental illness as a mitigating circumstance. Not all the individuals who suffer from PTSD have been diagnosed. Not all of them are medicated. And we don't typically impose a requirement in terms of evaluating their culpability that they have taken their medication if it has been prescribed. If the legislature wants to change the laws on insanity, it can do that in that term. But the Supreme Court has moved, the United States Supreme Court has moved to restricting the use of the death penalty for people who suffer from impairment so that no longer can you execute someone who is intellectually disabled, what we used to call mentally retarded, who has problems with adapting their behavior to the requirements of life. We don't execute those people anymore. Approximately 30 years ago, the Supreme Court said it's okay to execute them, but you have to consider whether or not that's a mitigating circumstance. So in the context of what you're asking, if the person is insane at the time of the crime, they are subject to the defense of insanity. If they weren't insane but were mentally ill, that's a factor a jury could consider in deciding whether or not the person, the aggravating circumstances outweigh the mitigation that's been presented. And frankly, someone who has suffered from a severe mental illness, my guess, a lot of times is not going to face a death penalty proceeding at all because the prosecutor recognizes some futility in trying to obtain a death penalty if there's a substantial diagnosis of mental disease or defect. But there is that issue always of whether or not the person voluntarily decided not to take their medication. The problem is mentally ill people probably don't voluntarily act in the same way that people who are mentally healthy act in terms of understanding the need to take their medication. And one of the recurring problems that I understand exists for mental health professionals is people will take their medication, they will feel better because they've taken their medication. The medication often has side effects that are unpleasant and they want to be healthy. And so they will stop taking their meds, or they'll run out of their meds, or they won't show up for a clinical therapy session because they're feeling good. They feel like they're healthy. And like most of us, they want to feel healthy, and therefore they don't take their meds, and they end up decomposing. They may become psychotic and put themselves back in that same situation. It is a difficult and complicated problem in dealing with the mentally ill because it's a fluid situation. made more fluid in a sense by the fact that we have better and better treatment regimens for
▶ Play
people who are mentally ill now. Representative
▶ Play
Dahlbe, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Flowers, earlier this committee passed out Senate Bill 42, and it was passed on the House floor in regard to mental evaluations prior to trial and all of that, And then looking at this particular bill, there looks like there's some conflicts with what we've already passed out in regard to mental evaluations, and how are you going to resolve that? Because it looks like this bill is written is expanding and changing what has already been passed and I believe signed into law. Can you
▶ Play
Speaker 84 48:24
address that for me, please? In what way can
▶ Play
you give me some more idea? Well, there was a comprehensive bill on mental evaluations and criminal trials that completely rewrote how we were doing them and all those kinds of things. And now it appears to me in a reading of your bill that that is now changing some of those things. And my question to you is why are you wanting to change what
▶ Play
we have already addressed this session? I believe that this bill would only change that as it relates to capital punishment, the imposition of capital crime. So if someone is found to be guilty of committing a capital crime versus another kind of crime, I believe that that's where the change would come into play.
▶ Play
Speaker 118 49:20
Representative, if I might interject, I think what this bill may well do would be to complement what's done in Senate Bill 42 in the sense that the evaluation process will be focused on whether or not the individual suffers from mental illness such that that's going to be a determination made during the evaluation. And it would be usable for a number of purposes under this bill for purposes of determining whether the individual was susceptible to a death sentence, but also determining whether the individual was himself maybe competent to even go to trial or was insane at the time of the crime. So I'm not sure that I would understand there's a conflict, but I may
▶ Play
not know Senate Bill 42 that well. Representative
▶ Play
Petty, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. How is this different than what we do now in the competency hearings? Because in the case of my daughter being kidnapped and murdered and her killer on death row, it seems to me that at least like every six months they are taking him for another competency hearing, and they did so as early as last Thursday. Could you please address that? The difference
▶ Play
Speaker 118 50:32
is that for the individual who's been sentenced to death, as I understand it, and who is mentally ill and is being evaluated, it is for the purpose of determining their current state of mental distress. And I think what this bill would do would be to use a single evaluation to determine the parameters of whether or not the death penalty should be imposed at all. You're operating under a regime now, which I believe is consistent with the U.S. Supreme Court decisions, which prevent execution of an incompetent defendant. And the problem, Representative Petty, frankly, is there may be no question that the individual in your daughter's case or any other case committed the crime. There may be no question that at the time they committed the crime they were saying. There is always a question for the mentally ill about how they're doing at the time they come to trial or in some event later than that, such as the execution. And the Supreme Court has said you have to continue to consider whether or not they're competent if there's an issue arising as to competence during that period of time. Uh, there are cases where there are repetitive competency evaluations for people whose cases are delayed and the death and the execution process. Um, this is part of the overall problem with the administration, the death penalty and one reason why people would argue it's a bad policy, although that bill has now been withdrawn. it's just it's a problem because you do have individuals who are impaired and you do have Supreme Court decisions that require states to comply with certain guidelines. The one that we don't have is the Supreme Court decision definitively on whether you can forcibly medicate someone for purpose of executing them and that still has not been decided by the U.S. Supreme Court. Many people think that the Supreme Court has moved in the direction already toward eliminating execution for people who are demonstrably mentally ill. But that decision hasn't come down either, and that's, I suspect, why this bill is here.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. So a perfectly sane person could commit capital murder, go to death row, and then through the years start to hear voices or whatever in their prison cell, and because of that, then we come back with this bill and say, well, now this person is not mentally competent, so we cannot execute. Is this how this reads? So
▶ Play
I'll say with the intent of my bill, and my bill is actually a mirror of a bill that was proposed and drafted by a senator in Indiana. Actually, there were seven proposals in this country, and I believe we might have been the eighth as a result of this legislation, to limit the imposition of capital punishment to exclude those who are mentally ill. And I would add, I guess, that even in your case in particular, something like this would, before the trial, establish whether or not this person is seriously mentally ill or not. And if they were not, then this bill would, if they were in the case of a guilty capital crime, they would serve life in prison. And then victims and families would not have to, or families of those who were victims of those defendants would not have to be subjected to multiple interruptions in the opportunity for closure that this would bring. And that's actually one of the supporting factors that I think people can take into consideration for this bill, as well as the abolishment of the death penalty, is that life without parole provides families more immediate and final resolution that the process in the death penalty does not provide. Representative Rushing, you're recognized for a question. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chair. Okay, I guess
▶ Play
I want to go back to when we were talking about the medication And you said you made a statement that you said that you don't test to see if they're taking their medication at the time that they could that they made the criminal offense. And so if you don't test at the time and then they are diagnosed with this, let's say PTSD and they're diagnosed with PTSD and we know that they've been diagnosed in the in the past. How do we know that it's a side effect, as you said, of the medication? that had caused this feeling of them to stop taking their medication or if they actually were on their medication and they still made this act while being medicated. And also, when we forcibly medicate someone, to forcibly medicate someone for execution, are these people not medicated in prison anyway for their issues or not? I mean, do we not medicate people for their issues that they have in prison already? I believe they are medicated. So we're not forcibly medicating them. Well, no, they can
▶ Play
Speaker 118 56:15
be forcibly medicated while in prison. Yes, if they're a danger to the institution, they are forcibly medicated. And the thrust of this bill is at the outset to determine if there's a mental illness existing in this defendant that would cause these possible problems. And I address more of the problems along down the line. This is a preemptive kind of measure to make sure we don't get in this situation if the individual who's being tried for capital murder suffers from a mental illness, we don't acquit them by reason of insanity unless they are insane as a result of the mental illness, but we simply eliminate the possibility of a death sentence, much as we do with people who are mentally retarded. And that's the case now, and I believe that's been the case historically in Arkansas, that an individual who suffers from a mental defect as opposed to disease is not subject to execution. And you find that out at the get-go. As soon as you have a diagnosis, defense counsel can raise this issue about whether there is existence of a mental illness. If there is, then it would preclude, I believe, the trial with a death penalty option and simply mean that life imprisonment is going to be the option for sentencing if the person was
▶ Play
guilty at the time of the crime. Follow up, Mr. Chair. So you're saying that these people are medicated, whether they're medicated voluntarily or forcibly for their condition, and so they are able to determine why they are there. Is that correct? Because what I just heard was you said that if they're an endangerment, they can be forcibly medicated. I guess maybe I need a definition of forcibly medicated, because what I'm hearing is you're saying that they're medicated for a condition that they've known to have if bipolar PTSD or whatever.
▶ Play
If I could interject real quick, too, because I don't want to get too far into the weeds, into a lot of issues that sort of circumvent the purpose of the bill and what it would do. And so I believe that the professor started out speaking on issues that might be germane to um, the, the state of the, um, defendant or the, the person who is, um, who has, who would be on death row, um, and whether or not they were medicated or sort of the back end issues that we're dealing with right now in the state. What this bill is designed to do is for those who are seriously mentally ill at the time that they commit the crime, not dealing with insanity as a way to justify their act, but to say that as someone who is seriously mentally ill, you will serve life in prison without parole if you are convicted of a capital crime. and that's it. This is not designed in any way to abdicate responsibility from those who commit crimes. As a matter of fact, in keeping with what we have passed with Senate Bill 42 and I believe Senator Hutchinson's bill, which I believe is Senate Bill 136, if we recognize in other aspects of our state law in terms of how we deal with criminals that there should be another standard for people who are seriously mentally ill, this bill sets out to extend that treatment and that consideration in terms of how we deal with people who are convicted of capital crimes. And if I could, Mr. Chair, I have one final expert who could speak to more so to mental illness. Dr. Rick Smith is here. Why don't we do this? We've
▶ Play
got two more questions. currently, and then what I would like to do, I believe Dr. Smith had signed up to speak for the bill. I'd like to bring him up during the public comment time four so that we can hopefully make sure we give everybody as much opportunity to be heard on this issue. Representative Gadsway, you're recognized for a
▶ Play
question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. This question is for Professor Sullivan. With regard to serious mental illness, is this not something that defense counsel already looks for in the early stages, even pre-trial, to test to determine whether or not their client suffers from a serious mental illness so that they can rule out mental disease or defect?
▶ Play
Speaker 118 1:00:59
Yes. The defense counsel, particularly in a capital case, would be concerned if there's any indication that the client suffers from a severe mental illness for a couple of reasons. One, whether or not that individual is competent to proceed with trial, whether or not they understand what the trial is going to be about and can assist their counsel. Second, in developing any kind of insanity defense, meaning at the time of the crime, the severe mental illness compromise their ability to understand basically right from wrong or conform their behavior to the requirements of law. But third, also whether or not there exists serious mental illness that could be used as a mitigating circumstance in a death penalty proceeding and a jury could rely on that to decide not to impose death. What this bill does is, in a sense, it preempts that much as we have with respect to mental retardation and simply says, if you've got evidence of this at the time, and there's a finding of this by the trial court based on expert testimony, you preclude the death sentence option to avoid the consequences of that and impose a life sentence without parole, basically under our capital sentencing statute. But yes, counsel is always going to be looking for this. This simply creates a procedure whereby if there is evidence of that mental illness, counsel can take that to the court and say, in this case, death should be ruled out as an option for sentencing because my client suffers from a severe mental illness. And as a result of that, it's recognized already in our law that's a mitigating circumstance that may warrant a life sentence. Follow
▶ Play
up. So basically all of these factors that you've discussed, whether a person suffers from bipolar disorder, post-traumatic stress disorder, these are things that can already be argued to a jury for the jury to decide not to impose the death penalty. And frequently is argued to a jury. Everything from how they were treated in the second grade is argued to a jury to not impose the death
▶ Play
Speaker 118 1:03:05
penalty. Right. Our law recognizes any mitigating circumstance can be considered by a juror.
▶ Play
Right. Okay. And if defense counsel didn't argue this, that would be grounds for rule 37 hearing. Yes. For ineffective assistance if
▶ Play
Council doesn't pursue that. Okay. All right. All right. That's all the questions I see at this point. Representative Flowers, would you like to finish up
▶ Play
your presentation of the bill? Yes. I had actually one more person who, as a former legislator, and he is here today. Can I engage him? Who is
▶ Play
that? Mr. Herb Rule. I believe he's going to be first up to speak for the bill. Okay.
▶ Play
Speaker 172 1:03:49
So we'll just take his testimony up with the
▶ Play
public comment. So before we have those speak for and against, I would ask the committee to take a look at the handout, which lists on the third page considerations for limiting the death penalty prohibiting application to defendants with serious mental illness. And it sort of lists some of the things that were already discussed in terms of the Supreme Court banning execution for mentally retarded legislation limiting execution of individuals with mental illness and highlights that Connecticut is already a state that does that, and there are several states that are being proposed this year. And as I mentioned, and I want to keep pointing out, that this is not a Republican or Democratic issue out of the eight states, including us, who would be proposing these measures to exempt defendants with serious mental illness. Only two of us are Democrats. And then the other point that I found that I thought was worth mentioning is, you know, a lot of times people discount the impact of PTSD. I was one of those who did until I experienced it from a life experience. and I think it's lost on a lot of people the impact that that has on those who serve our country in war. And I was shocked to learn that an estimated 300 veterans, many suffering from combat-related mental illness health disorders, are on death rows across America. And so when we think about these mental illnesses and these conditions that affect people and affect their behavior, and we're making the decision in other areas of criminal law about how we should treat them, how we should house them, how we should sentence them in all areas. I'm just proposing this bill in saying that if they're too sick to treat in other ways or to house with general populations, then might they not be too sick to execute? And with that, I appreciate your consideration and your thoughts and invite you to move forward with those wishing to speak for and
▶ Play
against the bill. All right. Thank you, Representative. Going to the list, signed up to speak against the bill is Bob McMahon and the Prosecuting Attorneys Association. and I've asked that they kind of consolidate their comments if possible.
▶ Play
Speaker 176 1:06:37
Mr. Chairman, I'll defer to the electeds
▶ Play
on this issue. Okay. Good morning. My name is Nathan Smith. I'm the prosecuting attorney in Benton County, and so I'll just talk a little bit about the last bill that we talked about and defer comments on the other one since it was pulled. First of all, I would point out that this bill is far too broad in its current form. We already have a mechanism that deals with criminal competency in the state of Arkansas, as was pointed out earlier as well. Specifically, when you think about things like post-traumatic stress disorder, if you prosecute cases and deal with mental health experts, most people who are going to be confined to jail facing a capital murder trial, that in and of itself creates post-traumatic stress disorder, as I'm sure would be being confined in prison. So I think the point here is we need to make sure that we have a functioning justice system in this state. The purpose of this bill, I think, though, I'm sure well-intentioned by Representative Flowers, would be simply to eliminate the death penalty in Arkansas. I don't think anyone could ever receive the death penalty if this law were passed, simply because of the breadth of the bill itself. So the Prosecuting Attorney's Association opposes this bill. Thank you very
▶ Play
much. Oh, I think we had a question here. Oh, I'm sorry. Representative Petty,
▶ Play
you recognize for a question. Thank you for being here, Mr. Smith. Could you briefly sum up to the committee and everyone that's listening, the last two cases in Benton County that what these people did that you helped sentence to death? Yes, ma'am. So the last two cases of Benton County,
▶ Play
one case involved was against a man named Zach Holly who kidnapped a little girl in Bentonville named Jersey Bridgeman. She was six years old. He took her out of her bed. He took her to an abandoned home near where she lived. They were neighbors. He knew her. Stripped her for clothes. He raped her. And he strangled her with her pajama pants. And they found her in the closet of that house. She was six. She has you know, uh, sisters and a mom and, um, you know, grandparents and all that. It was a horrible, uh, situation for, for that family. Uh, the other case, uh, that we had, uh, was of a little boy named Isaiah Torres, who was also six years old. Uh, he was, uh, the son of a man named Mauricio Torres. So Mr. Rosenzweig's in the room, he represented him. Um, Mr. Torres, uh, was proven at trial to be a serial child rapist, a serial child abuser, and he abused Mauricio Torres for at least, or Isaiah Torres, his six-year-old son, for at least a couple of years before his death. The final act of abuse, he raped his son with a stick, and his son died of internal injuries as a result of that. And those are horrible and ugly facts, and no one likes to think about them, and they're hard to even say. I can say that I hope I never, ever again have the misfortune to prosecute a death penalty case because the simple fact that they exist means that some horrific crime has occurred. But I do think there are some cases for which the death penalty is the appropriate punishment, and certainly the violent rape and murder of children I think are some of those in my opinion. So for all of those reasons, I would say
▶ Play
that we would oppose the bill. you recognize for a follow-up thank you um in regards to mr torres um it is my understanding that he is sane um yet um and can you explain what his
▶ Play
job was Mr. Torres was an occupational therapy assistant. He worked in that type of medical field job. He was an occupational therapy assistant. I don't think he was an occupational therapist, but he was an OTA. Worked in nursing homes, retirement centers, things like that. And certainly I don't recall specifically there being a lot of questions about mental health when it came in Mr. Torres' case, but certainly Mr. Holly's case. You know, there were hearings and it was contested in terms of his, you know, mental culpability and responsibility both at the time of the crime when he ultimately confessed to committing the crime and things like that. So these are things that are constantly and continually litigated in these cases. All right. I see no further questions.
▶ Play
Thank you for your testimony. Thank you very much.
▶ Play
Speaker 184 1:11:30
Going back to the. Okay. Scott Ellings, prosecutor from the 2nd Judicial District. A couple of other things we want to point out is that this bill is retroactive. It would apply to those who are sitting on death row now that there are some circumstances that I think that we don't anticipate. I mean, folks that are on death row have gone through trials, have been litigated. There are extensive mental evaluations. And I want to point out again that Senate Bill 42 is very extensive. It's now Act 472. The governor signed it, and you passed it. It's very extensive. It's a two-part mental evaluation issue. I think that it addresses many of these concerns. And certainly, one of the things in this bill that I noticed is that it requires a judge to appoint two professionals as opposed to agreeing to one professional or some professional that's not employed by the state hospital. So there are other concerns about this bill. I respect Representative Flowers and her efforts, but I think that this is an effort to abolish the death penalty in another way, to prevent it from happening. And the state has thus far determined that that's a proper sanction and in appropriate cases all right thank you thank you for your testimony i'm going to go
▶ Play
back to the list for those speaking for the bill i believe first up is herb rule you're recognized to be with state
▶ Play
Speaker 190 1:13:17
your name and yes thank you mr chairman ladies and gentlemen thank you for your service my name is herb rule i'm an attorney and uh served in the United States Marine Corps and had the great privilege of serving in the House of Representatives in 66 and 68 sessions. I appreciate your fine work. And what I wanted to do is to just briefly mention to you the fact that the death penalty doesn't work. You know, we're going to get eight people killed in April because we can't get the drugs to last. What kind of sense does that make? And it costs so much more to execute these people than it does to give them life without parole. It makes no sense. Financially, it makes no sense in terms of decreasing the crime rate at all. And prosecuting attorneys will sometimes talk to you and say, Well, you know, if you take away the death penalty, we won't have anything to negotiate when we come to trial before the trial with the defendant's counsel. They can negotiate the difference between life without parole and life with parole, possibly, to do that. So that's not really a very sound objection to this bill that would bring us back into the center and say life is valuable and that we are having a good sense to keep the dangerous people that commit these horrible crimes in jail for life without parole. So this is a message that I wanted to share with you about the status of primarily House Bill 2103, but it also runs through the other bills that are on for special order business to get. So if there's anything else anybody has on their mind or wants to ask, I'm... Representative
▶ Play
Petty, you're recognized for a question. Sorry. You mentioned the eight that the state is going to execute in April. Would you tell this committee if you know what those eight men did and if they are mentally
▶ Play
Speaker 190 1:15:40
competent? I do not know, Representative Petty. I have read about them and about their crimes, but I have not read their case files at all. I suspect that Governor Hutchinson read them. Representative Ballinger, you're recognized for a question. What
▶ Play
would your opinion be? Thank you, Mr. Chair. What would your opinion be as the appropriate punishment for a man who rapes a six-year-old to death? What? Life without parole? Let
▶ Play
Speaker 199 1:16:16
me, excuse me. Do you think justice is served in that situation? Yes, I do.
▶ Play
Speaker 190 1:16:20
Okay. I'm looking at Leviticus, number one, that says, hey, you must not exact vengeance. Love your neighbor as yourself. And then I did a little song or poem that may be relevant to your question, but shoot them, shock them, poke them with a needle. Murder is here to stay. Lock them up so they can't get away. We're going to move on to the next question. every day. Representative
▶ Play
Maddox, you recognize for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Rule, I have to take issue with something you said. I think you said it makes no sense, that it definitely makes no sense. I just have to take issue with, you know, there are arguments certainly on both sides, but don't you think we need to give deference to the victims' families in this matter? I've always thought that we need to allow them to have a say. And don't you think that that makes sense to at least consider what they want when they're the ones who have suffered the loss. Would you not agree with that? Well, I think certainly that's a great consideration, absolutely.
▶ Play
Speaker 190 1:17:25
And what I hear in the time that I've been involved in learning more about the death penalty and its use is that there are many families who don't want to choose the death penalty. We heard that today. But I don't know that we could safely make it a matter of choice for the victim's families rather than the prosecutor. There may be divisions within the family, as you may have experienced or learned about, that would affect that. But certainly that's a question. And that can go on, you know, depending on the question of life without parole or life imprisonment with parole. Representative Rushing, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
I wasn't going to have a question until you decided to start quoting Bible verses, and I just want to know if you know what Exodus 21-24 says. Yeah. Yeah. An eye for an eye. Thou shalt not kill. No, eye for eye, tooth for tooth, hand for hand, foot for foot. So what's good for the goose is what's good for the gander. Yeah, and
▶ Play
Speaker 190 1:18:40
vengeance, you know. So we can believe in both of them, right? But thank you so very much.
▶ Play
Representative Petty, did you have a question? if i may this is a question that i've been holding off to try to uh behave myself but i have been forced to ask it and i wrote this question down and i think that you would be the appropriate person for me to ask and i have to preface this by saying this is just going to take one second for me to read my question because I was a little bit upset when I did a lot of studying on this. And I am going to talk about my personal case. And so I want this committee to know that my daughter, Andy, who was a 12-year-old girl, was a sweet little girl, broke no rules, loved animals, wanted to be a teacher. She loved life. The man who kidnapped, raped and strangled her to death and left her in the elements for three days while he came back to help our family search for her and lead police in a different direction was a predatory monster. And Mr. Chairman, I'm going to quote something that he said to her before he strangled her, and it is not the most appropriate language for, okay.
▶ Play
Why don't we take a second, and maybe you and I could talk about what that question is going to be. Well, I can
▶ Play
ask the question, and I would behave myself. Okay, if you would ask the question. Thank you. Would you or would you not agree that people who commit grave crimes are most vulnerable of all, our little children, our police officers, women, and sometimes even men, but the most vulnerable, I think about Isaiah Torres, and I think about Jersey Bridgman, and I think about how those children died, and you sit at the end of the table and quote Bible verses and say that they don't deserve grave punishment. Well, what about those crime victims? What about those families? Do they not deserve grave punishment for grave crimes? I agree that
▶ Play
Speaker 190 1:21:01
they do deserve grave punishment, and I think, with all due respect to your point of view, that life without parole is the gravest and is graver than a quick release through execution, even though we have good reason to believe that execution isn't a quick release anymore with the problems that we've had with our drugs. Representative House, you
▶ Play
recognize for a question? Thank you, Counselor. I appreciate your comment. I do recognize the difference between opinion and fact, so I take your comments in that regard. But one of the dear ladies spoke this a while ago, and then you repeated it as a fact, and I question whether it is, and that is it costs more money to deal with a death case than it does life without parole. Now, I say that, and this is an honest question. We pay the attorney general and her staff a lot of money, whether they're working on cigarette cases or death penalty cases. Those are sunk costs in every case, even life. And I've been down there where we house the life without parole, and I'm sure you have, too. Those are sunk costs. What additional cost is there that amounts to anything between a death case and a life without parole case? Well, there's the cost
▶ Play
Speaker 190 1:22:37
of housing the prisoners while they're there. No, I just said I've been down. They're all housed in
▶ Play
the same kind of build, and they're there. And the major
▶ Play
Speaker 190 1:22:48
portion of the cost, as I understand it from the studies in North Carolina and Tennessee and elsewhere, the major portion of the cost occurs during the investigation and the trial and the appeal phases of the process. Those are
▶ Play
sunk costs. No, they're not sunk
▶ Play
Speaker 190 1:23:09
costs. No, they're much more. I'm sorry I wouldn't agree with you, but they are not sunk costs because these calculations and the investigations that they've done show the difference between what happens in a case where there's just life without parole versus a case where the death penalty is done. I think those are reasonable cases. We don't have one. We've asked for one in Arkansas. You recognize for a follow-up? All right, we
▶ Play
pay that officer to stand there or go out and investigate that. He is a sunk cost. Now, just to follow up on something, we have chief police from the Secretary of State's security police standing here in our room. And he is armed. I'm sorry. That's all right. You see our police chief there, and he is an armed individual. You would agree that the government has the right to arm him, and he may use his weapon if circumstances present.
▶ Play
Speaker 190 1:24:17
Agreed? Well, I suppose so, yeah. He's a police officer.
▶ Play
I'm sorry. Okay, yes. So the government does have a right under appropriate circumstances to take the life of another human being. Well, yes, I agree. So what we're arguing about is what point in time the government ceases or declines to exercise that right, isn't it?
▶ Play
Speaker 190 1:24:47
That's exactly right. It is a political decision for first this committee and the General Assembly to determine what the state wants to do about the ultimate punishment for first-degree murder.
▶ Play
Speaker 228 1:25:03
Thank you, Counselor. It's been a pleasure to see you again. Very good to see you, sir.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Representative Ballinger, you're recognized. Thank
▶ Play
you. I have a motion to limit debate to five minutes per side. Okay. That's a proper motion. Is there any discussion? The motion is to limit debate to five minutes per side. All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? The motion passes, and staff will record the time, And I'd remind Representative Flowers that her closing will be included in that five-minute time period.
▶ Play
Speaker 233 1:25:36
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Rushing, you're recognized.
▶ Play
Oh, he's left the table. Mr. Rule, you had one more question. I just have one more question, sorry. And this is kind of a follow-up on Representative House's dealing with costs of the death penalty and housing the prisoner, and I know that you referenced North Carolina and several other states, and I just want to know if you know what the cost of living is in those states and how it compares to Arkansas, and how can we relatively compare all of those when the cost of living is different
▶ Play
Speaker 190 1:26:17
in each one of those states? Well, there are going to be variations, I think, in terms of what prosecuting attorneys and police and prison officials are paid from state to state. But what the indications are is that the cost is substantially more than operating with life without parole. And, you know, they're rigorous scholarly studies. You can look at them and you can say, well, maybe this, maybe that. But I'd say that they're accepted across the board by most people. Good
▶ Play
question. All right. I see no further questions. Thank you for your comments. Going back to the list, signed up to speak against the bill. I believe we have some additional prosecutors.
▶ Play
Speaker 235 1:27:13
Mr. Chairman, Bob McMahon with the Prosecuting Attorney's Association. And this may not be the appropriate time. I just wanted to clarify, are we now back to addressing House Bill 2103 as the last witness did, or are we back on 2170? This is 2170. Okay, well, I just wanted to reserve the right then to make sure we have the opportunity to be heard on 2103 because we hadn't had that yet, but I have nothing further to add with this particular legislation. All right, thank you. Going back
▶ Play
to the list, sign up to speak for the bill. It's Dr. Rick Smith. Doctor, if you'd have a seat, state your name and who
▶ Play
Speaker 238 1:28:00
you represent, and you may make your statement. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. My name is Rick Smith, and I am a lifelong Arkansan. I work at UAMS. I'm a professor of psychiatry, medicine, and public health, but I'm officially on leave today, so I'm here as a private citizen rather than as a representative of UAMS. I briefly agree with Professor Sullivan, my colleague, who testified earlier. I would try to clear up a few minor points, well, not minor points, a few quick points. One is the issue of not guilty by reason of insanity. Uh, that's determined, um, uh, prior to conviction. Uh, Representative Flowers' bill, uh, deals with, uh, uh, that determination that's made. But, uh, our illnesses that she listed are really lifelong illnesses. Uh, these are, uh, rarely ever cured. We have medicine that helps these illnesses, and we can restore someone to sanity, but that doesn't mean that we can cure the illness. So they still have many symptoms, even when they're sane. As Professor Sullivan said, my colleagues who do that work are certainly not what I would consider bleeding-heart liberals and are pretty tough on their calls when they make those. The last thing that I would add, well, related to that, people can move in and out of sanity. Somebody could be sane at the time they committed the crime, they could be sane at the time of trial, or they could be sane or insane when they're in prison. I certainly think that there are people who are a danger to society by the acts that they have committed, demonstrated by the acts that they have committed. They need to be incarcerated for life without parole because they have committed heinous crimes. I don't believe that they should be put to death because I think there are overwhelming reasons. Usually, in this case, their mental illness, they would prevent that. So due to the time constraints, I'll ask if there are any questions for me or comments. Representative Petty, you're
▶ Play
recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. You just said that they move in and out of sanity. If that's
▶ Play
Speaker 238 1:30:56
the case, how would we ever know? Well, physicians like myself can determine that. There are tests that we use in our profession about whether they're sane at a given time or not, and forensic psychiatrists who Professor Sullivan deals with do this work on a daily basis. there must be seven or eight of them that are active here in Arkansas who work here. So it's an issue we make all the time when we admit somebody to the hospital or commit somebody to the hospital, regardless of whether they're a criminal or not.
▶ Play
All right, I see no further questions. Thank you for your comments. Going back to the list, to speak against the bill, Paul Calvert. Mr. Calvert, you can have a seat. State your name and make your comments, please. My name is Paul Calvert.
▶ Play
You all know me from here. I've been here several times. and um i think the argument about mental insanity being a reason not to put someone to death is not sometimes i think it could be valid but i think after if you've actually determined the person has committed murder i think you've you've gone beyond the point where that's a valid determination anymore um i think the concept of murder itself requires a minimum level of mental competency because murder has a major element of intent. In my opinion, a two-year-old is incapable of committing murder because two-year-olds are mentally incapable of having the requisite intent. So if a two-year-old kills a person, his offense should most likely be considered an act of negligence on the part of a child's guardian or simply an accident. On the other hand, I believe the most 14-year-olds are mentally capable of committing murder because they are generally fully capable of having the requisite intent. I think we would even make that same distinction between cases of animals that kill a person accidentally like a large horse that accidentally steps on a small child versus a horse that aggressively kicks or bites a person, which results in their death. In the Bible, the owner of an animal could even be put to death if they knew the animal was aggressive. That's in Exodus 21, 28, the following verses. Generally, I believe the death penalty should be the only punishment for actual cases of murder not prison and genesis 9 verse 5 and 6 and for your life blood i will require reckoning from every beast i will require it and from man from his fellow man i will require a reckoning for the life of man whoever sheds the blood of man by man shall his blood be shed for god made the man made man in his own image i i think that the death penalty is appropriate for murder cases I don't think that mental incompetency is a proper reason not to put someone to death if we can actually establish that they did indeed commit murder. And I think it does require some level of mental competency to establish that someone is capable of committing murder. But if that's been established, I think the death penalty is always appropriate, generally speaking.
▶ Play
All right, I see no questions. Thank you for your comments. Thank you. Going back to the list, and I'll let Representative Flowers know we have 52 seconds left on the four side. Signed up to speak for the bill is Karen
▶ Play
Speaker 249 1:34:41
DePippa. I'm Karen DePippa, representing the Catholic Diocese of Little Rock. Our church supports the sanctity of life. This is with all due respect to victims and victims' families, of which I am one. And we support within the sanctity of life, though most vulnerable, and those we would consider persons with mental illness, we support this bill. Thank you. All right, no one else has signed
▶ Play
up to speak against the bill. representative flowers i'm gonna give you the option here we've got 30 seconds left you i can either call on uh the additional individuals from the public although it's going to be a very brief comment or you could use those 30 seconds to
▶ Play
close i'm sure that my colleagues are really anxious to see if i can meet the challenge of closing in 30 seconds and um and i think i'd like to do that and do my best.
▶ Play
Speaker 252 1:35:48
You're recognized. Don't start yet. Regardless of our conclusions,
▶ Play
Christians must make sure that Christian values, justice, humanity, and grace motivate us rather than vengeance or hate. And whether Christians choose to support or oppose capital punishment, We are all called to make sure that it is carried out justly and does not target innocent people. I think that this bill addresses a concern and an issue that we have addressed in other pieces of legislation, and it just extends our moral focus and our concern for the seriously mentally ill to how we treat people and capital punishment. This is not a bill to abolish the death penalty. That's a different bill. And I will just close with making this point. Because the death penalty is so arbitrary, subject to discretion, and not evenly applied so that everyone who is sentenced to capital punishment with or without a mental illness gets capital punishment, gets the death penalty, is why we need this bill. And I would ask for your full consideration of everything you've heard today. On the side of four. Okay. I'll let you have more
▶ Play
than 30 seconds, but I was reading a note here from Representative House. Representative House, did you have a question of the sponsor? Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Lyers,
▶ Play
thank you so much. It takes a lot of courage to bring a bill like this. Early on, there was talk about you pulling your bill down. Would you like for this committee to vote on your bill now, and if it passes, then you can come back with your amendments, the corrections that we talked about, or would
▶ Play
you rather go? That was another bill. Okay. That was a different bill, and I already pulled it down. Okay. But I thank you. I mean, can it be raised and we voted? Sure. But, Mr. Chair, would we be right now dealing, though?
▶ Play
Speaker 172 1:38:11
We're on House Bill 2170. 2170. Right. Okay. All right. So we're ready for a vote on that one. Then there's not a correction that needs to be
▶ Play
made. Okay. Thank you, Mr. Chair. All right. But what's the will of the committee? Representative Whitaker? Motion to pass. Okay, we have a motion to do pass. Is there any discussion? Representative Rushing, you're recognized. I'll make it
▶ Play
brief. I wrote it down. I just want to remind everyone at this table that there are two mothers at this table that will never see their child again here on earth. I would ask that this committee to consider the fact that life imprisonment, even for a mental illness would allow that murderer to have visitors and talk to their loved ones, something that these two parents of the victims will never be able to do again, ever. Any further
▶ Play
discussion? All right. The motion before us is do pass. All in favor say aye. Those opposed? No. The no's have it. All right, we're going to move back up to House Bill 1798, Representative Blake. Thank you,
▶ Play
Speaker 54 1:39:35
committee. Thank you, Mr. Chair. House Bill 1798. Representative Blake, you're
▶ Play
recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair and committee. This bill addresses one question. Is the state sentencing people to death and executing innocent people? A study from 2014 believed that the figure is one in every 25, so about 4% of the people sentenced to death are innocent. The study, a rate of false convictions of criminal defendants who are sentenced to death was released in 2014 in the proceedings of National Academy of Sciences, because a surprising number of innocent people are sentenced to death. The author, Samuel Gross, says that it tells you that a lot of them haven't been exonerated and some of them, no doubt, have been executed. Since 1973, 156 people have been released from death rolls throughout the country due to evidence of their wrongful convictions. convictions. In 2003 alone, 10 wrongfully convicted people were released from death row. Some of those cases, North Carolina, Henry McCollum and Leon Brown, the two brothers were 19 and 15. Both men contacted the North Carolina Innocence Commission, which discovered DNA that implicated another person. men were freed in 2014. In Alabama, Daniel Wade Moore was acquitted in 2009. Moore was found guilty for murder and sexual assault. In 2002, he was sentenced to death by the judge, overruling the jury's original consensus. However, he was acquitted in 2009 when 256 pages of withheld was finally revealed. In Texas, Anthony Graves. Graves was convicted in 1994 of assisting Robert Carter in multiple murders in 1992. There was no physical evidence linking Graves to the crimes, and his conviction relied on Carter's testimony that Graves, with his accomplice, that Graves was his accomplice, a claim Carter later recanted. In 2006, it was found that prosecutors elicited false statements and withheld testimony that could have influenced the jurors. A special prosecutor hired to re-examine the case said, we found not one piece of credible that links Anthony Graves to the commission of this capital murder. He's an innocent man. In Florida in 2012, Self Penelver was arrested in 1994 for brutal murders of three individuals. There was nothing physical linking him to the murder. The police had a poor quality video in which the murderer's face could not be seen. He remained in custody until 2012 when the jury, at his most recent trial, acquitted him of all charges. So, if the death penalty remains the law because the courts deem it constitutional, and our legislator continues to believe that it is a necessary tool for punishment and the deterrence of crime, The question is, what steps can be taken to reduce the risk of innocent capital defendants that will face death by the state? I believe that one way to address this question is to raise the regular standard and burden of proof for a death sentence. This bill, 1798, proposes that before the government may deprive a defendant of life, it must prove the defendant's guilt by a standard more rigorous than beyond a reasonable doubt. If a jury finds the defendant guilty beyond a reasonable doubt, it may not proceed to the penalty and sentencing phase unless it also certifies that it has found the defendant guilty beyond all doubts. If the jury cannot certify this effect, the judge assumes responsibility for sentencing that defendant to life without parole. I am not advocating that the burden of proof should be altered at guilt. At the guilt phase of a criminal trial, I have only directed my exclusive efforts at the penalty. penalty and sentencing phase. It's a simple premise. Because there's a fundamental difference between incarceration and execution by the state, there should be a distinction between the standards of proof. I believe that the jury must reevaluate the correctness of its guilty verdict before it may determine whether the death penalty should be imposed. Should the jury decline to find that the defendant guilty by any possible doubt, the defendant will not go free. Rather, the judge will assume responsibility for the sentencing other than death. Should the jury find that the defendant is guilty beyond any doubt, the penalty phase will proceed unaltered. I believe this bill can reduce the risk that innocent persons will be sentenced to death. Now, if you look at the bill, there's two sentences added. On page one, line 31, number four, the defendant is guilty of each element of the underlying offense beyond any doubt, and that is for death. that after the guilty phase going into the sentencing phase that the jury must prove beyond any doubt that the jury must decide that beyond any doubt the defendant is guilty of all charges. If the jury doesn't, then the sentencing goes back to the judge with life without parole. And I'm open for any questions.
▶ Play
Representative Fite, you're recognized for a
▶ Play
question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative, do any other states have this, or would Arkansas be the first state
▶ Play
Speaker 265 1:46:22
to do this? To my knowledge,
▶ Play
Speaker 267 1:46:26
we would be the first. Follow-up? Is there a
▶ Play
reason why other states do not have this? Because they haven't done it yet. We could be the first. We are the first in a lot of good stuff, like the private option, which many more states will be doing now. But just because we're the first doesn't mean, just because we have the potential to be the first doesn't mean we're we're wrong follow-up or
▶ Play
that we're right time will tell all right I see no further questions going to the list we have the prosecuting attorneys association sign up to speak against the bill and for the benefit of the public and all those who have signed up. Again, we're speaking to House Bill 1798. You're recognized.
▶ Play
Speaker 235 1:47:34
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Bob McMahon, representing the Arkansas Prosecuting Eternity Association. The Arkansas prosecutors are opposed to this piece of legislation. We believe that it creates an unreasonable, impossible standard that probably cannot be met. We're not aware of any other state that has this. As Representative Blake said, I tried to do a brief survey. I've up until now had about half the state's reply and no one that has responded has such a standard. The Supreme Court has held that due process forbids convicting an individual of a crime unless the government approves each element beyond a reasonable doubt. The standard must be met by the prosecutor. It means basically that there's no other logical explanation that can be derived from the facts of the case. Again, it's the highest standard or proof that exists. We're prepared to meet that And
▶ Play
Speaker 269 1:48:19
we oppose this piece of legislation, providing an unreasonable standard of any doubt.
▶ Play
Thank you. All right. I see no questions. Going back
▶ Play
Speaker 270 1:48:32
to the list. All right, going back to
▶ Play
the list, Herb Ruhl has signed up to speak against the bill. Or for the bill, I'm sorry. Okay. Okay. Judith Elaine, sign up to speak for the bill. Ms. Elaine, if you would have a seat, state your name, and then you may
▶ Play
Speaker 49 1:49:21
make your comments. Judith Elaine. And you've already heard the bulk of my comments. And I would just say that if we can't completely do away with the death penalty, at least we can raise the standard by which we apply it. All right. Thank you
▶ Play
for your comments. Signed up to speak against the bill. Is Paul Calvert. All right, he's for the bill. Okay. Well, let me move on down to Mike Godfrey.
▶ Play
Good morning, committee members. Mike Godfrey with the Arkansas Sheriff's Association. I just want to speak to one point on the bill, and that is beyond any doubt. I've had quite a bit of experience in jury trials in both the guilt and innocent phase and the sentencing phase. And beyond any doubt is a standard that I think is going to be almost impossible to meet. Even if you have a case where you have DNA, there's a small, small, minute percentage that could be in question. Uh, if you have a confession that an attorney recants in court, uh, even if, even if the person says they, they did it, the, the confession could be questioned. If you, if you say beyond any doubt, uh, those things could create a doubt. And I think it's a standard. It's going to be very hard to prove. All right. So no
▶ Play
questions. Thank you for your comments. Sign up to speak for the bill. Karen DePippa.
▶ Play
Speaker 249 1:51:07
Karen DePippa, and I'm representing Catholic Diocese of Little Rock. We support any bill that would assist creating innocence for an accused if they are so innocent. So we are in support of this bill. We do support the sanctity of life, and we do recognize that this is not an easy issue, and just appreciate the support of the bill. All right. Thank you
▶ Play
for your comments. Is there anybody else from the Prosecutor's Association, or Bob, were your comments collective? Okay. All right. Thank you. No one else has signed up to speak against the bill. Paul Calvert signed up to speak for the bill. Mr. Calvert, you're recognized.
▶ Play
Thank you, committee. My name is Paul Calvert. I've spoken with Representative Blake about this somewhat, and I think his intent is not to fully change the idea of making it fully without a doubt, but I think his idea is probably similar to mine in that we're trying to fix some of the problems of false convictions. And I think the standard should be changed. I think there's a problem right now. And so I understand the concerns of the prosecutors with the idea of beyond a doubt, because I think that is perhaps an impossible standard. But I think to change the standard, I think, is a very worthy goal. But to the goal, I think we already have something similar to this in the U.S. Constitution and the Arkansas Constitution as well. The U.S. Constitution Article 3, Section 3 requires a minimum of two witnesses for treason. Arkansas Constitution Article 2, Section 14 also requires two witnesses for cases of treason. A two-witness standard is also consistent with biblical justice, Deuteronomy 17, verse 6. At the mouth of two witnesses, or three witnesses, shall he that is worthy of death be put to death. At the mouth of one witness, he shall not be put to death. I think it would be reasonable to establish this same high standard for murder cases here in Arkansas and like many of the people that I have contact with some of them will be opposed to the death penalty altogether and one of their arguments is that we're convicting innocent people and while I don't oppose the death penalty I'm actually very much in favor of it. But I do agree with the problem of convicting innocent people. And I think part of that's the plea bargaining system. I think part of it's maybe the lack of a standard to actually identify what qualifies as beyond a reasonable doubt. Biblically, that would have been a minimum of two witnesses, among other things, I think. And you can see in the U.S. and Arkansas Constitution required two witnesses. I think that it's a worthy study. I think it's a worthy goal to look into. And even if you don't pass it, I think it's something worthy to further study and look into. And I appreciate Representative Blake for bringing this up. All
▶ Play
right. Thank you for your comments. No one else has signed up to speak for or against the bill. Representative
▶ Play
Blake, would you like to close for the bill? I sure would. Thank you. We've heard about raising the standards, being absolutely sure. If a jury of our peers is going to sentence someone to death, then I think the standards should be raised. Death is a difference than incarceration. I said that earlier. It's something that we should be sure that jury members know, going into the sentencing phase, that if we are going to terminate this person's life, then we should have a higher burden of proof. And we should be sure that we're not executing innocent people. My father, he used to get us up, my brothers and I, every Saturday morning. And we would do housework. We would put up sheetrock. We would do crown molding. We would do things. And when I got old enough to work the saw, the angular saw, he would say to me, one rule, measure twice and cut once, and if we're going to be cutting someone's life short, we should be absolutely sure that that person is guilty, beyond any doubt, of the crime that we're executing them for. I
▶ Play
Speaker 282 1:56:57
would move a do pass, and I would like a favorable vote. All right, we
▶ Play
have a motion do pass. Is there any discussion? Representative
▶ Play
Whitaker. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I first want to apologize right up front to my friend and colleague, Representative Blake, that we didn't have an opportunity to discuss this bill before today. But it also behooves me to at least do what damage control I can by not having you surprised when the roll is called or if there is a voice vote. But as an officer of the court, I'm going to be voting against this bill. The folks who say that it presents an impossible burden, I believe them to be correct. If we want to abolish the death penalty, and I am a proponent of abolition, let's do that. But let's not do it this way. The truth is, and there are many late-night theoretical discussions that law students and lawyers have had over the generations about should there be a higher burden. And to be honest with you, at the end of the day, we always come back to the same conclusion that beyond a reasonable doubt is the only standard anybody can agree on. The truth of the matter is you have exposed the flaw there. When the death penalty is an option, we can never be sure enough. We simply cannot know. The dozens and dozen scores by now hundreds of cases where many years later we see vindication of people we were absolutely certain were guilty is our best argument against the death penalty. And for those of you who quote scripture, it's not scripture, but I'm reminded of something a wise man once said. An eye for an eye, and pretty soon the whole world is
▶ Play
blind. Any other discussion? All right, the motion before us is do pass. All in favor say aye. Any opposed? No. The no's have it. All right, committee. Thank you, committee. Without objection, we've got another bill here that I believe quite a few people are here in the room to speak for or against, and I'm going to move down to it. Without objection, we're going to go to Senate Bill 535, Senator Cooper. And there should be an amendment loading on the screen. All right, the amendment's there. And also for the benefit of the committee, we're going to check on adjusting the temperature here in the room. Bill 535.
▶ Play
Mr. Chair, if it's permittable, I'd like to ask some of the Craighead County elected officials, a couple of those, to join me at the table, if it's okay. I'll allow it.
▶ Play
Speaker 259 2:00:53
And in the meantime, can we
▶ Play
get a motion to go ahead and adopt the amendment? Okay. Representative Dalby moves adoption. Is there any discussion? All in favor, say aye. Any opposed? The amendment's adopted. Senator Cooper and Representative Ladyman are recognized to present Senate Bill 535 as amended.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Today I bring you in the committee what I believe is one of the most important bills that we will have, especially this year as it pertains to Crackhead County. What this bill is is a repeal bill that goes back and repeals legislation that was put in place all the way back to 1883. There was some additional legislation that was put in place about 2003. There was some other legislation that was put in place that didn't do a whole lot except change the boundary designation. So that's what the amendment really does is make sure that those statutes and those boundaries are properly defined in the bill. This bill is critically important to Craighead County. Before I go ahead, I'd like to say with me is I'd like to get these folks to identify themselves, please, for the committee's information.
▶ Play
Speaker 308 2:02:39
My name is Hannah Towle. I'm the Craighead County Assessor. Thank
▶ Play
you all for having us today. And
▶ Play
I am Candace Edwards, Craighead County Circuit Clerk. Thank you. What this bill or what this legislation did in 1883 was basically take 10 counties in the state and divide them in dual judicial districts. That was in the days of primitive travel and communications. And the counties that were done that way mostly had a situation of high water and creeks and river crossings. things like that was difficult, so they divided the county into two districts. That may have made sense in those days, but it doesn't make any sense today. Part of the stipulation that was done in those days was those districts were required to maintain revenues and costs, expenses separate from each other. One district could not subsidize the other. Each district had to keep separately its own funds and expenses and operate as an independent county within the other county. Actually what it was was two counties or two districts within a county supervised by the elected officials of the county. So they were maintaining supervision over two districts that legislation that was put in place back then was mandates upon the county and on the other counties that are also involved in this. However, this legislation just deals with Craighead County. In 2003, there were additional legislation there, in addition to the 1883 legislation, added to the confusion in Craighead County when some unbelievable statutes concerning an election was placed on the books. And that called for a deputy sheriff and a court clerk as a deputy to be put on the ballot. The strange thing about that is that was a non-binding ballot. It really did not legally do anything, but it led to some assumptions in the county that somebody had been elected to something. Uh, that was strictly a straw poll, um, basically telling the county sheriff, uh, that this region, uh, desired to have that person appointed, and the same thing applied to the circuit clerk. Uh, it's also required that these candidates, and, uh, remember these people have not been elected to anything on the ballot yet, but yet the statute said that these people would be required to live in the district or live in Lake City and also have an office there. So what we have on the books is a statute that says a candidate that hasn't been elected to anything is required to have an office in that location. That's just part of the strange things about a lot of this legislation that was passed back then. Um, this, um, this legislation has led to some very complicated issues in the county over the years, um, and it has, uh, created some conflict within county government, and I think today we could say that what we really have in Crackhead County is, for the most part dysfunctional county government. It's led to some belief in especially the Lake City area, the individuals that work there, that they are basically equal with the countywide elected people who are their superiors and their situations now, which these people with me can tell you about concerning insubordination, outright refusal to perform the policies that they've been instructed to do. And it's just led to a lot of difficulty with them being able to legally perform their functions. And that's really what they're asking to do is to clear these shackles and to return Craighead County to a county structure like 65 other counties in this state exist in right now. So what we're asking is Craighead County to be made whole again and the local county officials to be able to do their job like like a whole county system should work. This is morphed over the years to where we have a a situation, I guess you could describe it in the proverbial language as this is the tail that's wagging the dog in county government. What's come to the point in this is that because of these statutes and because of the dual county dual district system within that structure, people actually believe that they are relatively equal with the people of their superiors. There's been situations in the office there where employees over there in that office have gotten very lax about the preservation and protection of public sensitive public information where they typed passwords and IDs to the terminals and they all shared it there's not a single one of us that let our business operate like that and yet here in Craighead County we have that is a routine way of doing business in this location in section 19 and if you look at the bill itself there's not one word in there that actually does any new establishes any new language it's all getting rid of the old language in the old statutes that go back to that 1883 law. In section 19, this, it talks about each district is required to operate on two separate sets of books. These are financial records. These are the expenses and the revenues of the districts. They are required to keep track of their own revenues and be responsible for their own expenses. Under this structure, it is unlawful for either one of them to subsidize the expenses of the other. That's very clearly laid out in there that one of these districts cannot subsidize or cross the boundary there concerning helping prop up the other from the revenues from either one. Now, it's ironic, the day that I filed this bill, the Supreme Court in Arkansas made a ruling concerning Blytheville. If you know anything about that, you understand that's also a divided county. And over there, the idea was to take a countywide bond issue and build a courthouse at Blytheville. Well, the districts over there are divided between Blytheville and Osceola. And what the Supreme Court said in that striking down that countywide bond issue was it referred to that that would be an illegal extraction of tax money from the Oceola district, and that was strictly illegal, and that's the reason that was cast, that Supreme Court rule as it did last year the the city of or the district of Lake City had three hundred and thirty two thousand dollars in revenue salaries itself just in Lake City came to two hundred and eighty thousand dollars that only leaves fifty thousand dollars for the totality of everything else utilities fuel other people's salaries that's not involved in that insurance and my calculation is it very likely that the Eastern District is being subsidized probably would not surprised me a million dollars a year and you know when you have this kind of situation it's it's very hard to for people that live in in an area to to understand sometimes the the reasons that it's necessary for us to follow the law. But basically the situation we have here is a likeness of somebody putting their hand in somebody else's pocket and extracting money from there and say, well, that's the way it is. You can't take revenues from somebody else illegally, and it worked right, and basically that's what a lot of the language is that people want to justify this. Well, it's been working this way for 100 years. It's okay. Well, if you're extracting money from your neighbor it's not working over all right you know a bank robber could say the same thing it's working until they get caught or till they're forced to stop or the repercussions set in but what it is right now there's an extraction of funds out of the out of the county government from one district to the other and the people that are funding the Lake City operation it looks like about one-third of their costs are coming from their own district. The West District is funding two-thirds of the operation in the other district. Recently with the frustration that's been building in this, and this goes back for quite some time in the quorum court meetings over the last two years this has been discussed regularly over and over and over again and some time ago some of the elected county officials came to me and asked what we can do about this and ask for help and there's several things that was being looked at at the time one of those was something you will probably hear about later. It will probably be described to you as a memorandum of understanding. And I was on a conference call when that was explored one time, and I also explored that possibility with BLR, and some other people here in the capital also ran some questions by legislative audit. And as we explored that more and more, it became very evident that there is no satisfactory endgame to this on any other avenue, except to get rid of the problem that's causing all of this issue, and that's the legislation that's in place. So it became apparent to me the only way out, and the only satisfactory way out of this is just get rid of the, just repeal the archaic legislation that's in place. So work with Jimmy Hickey, Senator Jimmy Hickey, who you all know is the chair of legislative audit and see if he had any ideas on this and he came to essentially the same opinion I did and you'll see he's a co-sponsor of this bill. I think basically what we have here, and there'll be people that will oppose this, but basically it's fear that they've had this facility for a long time, and it provides some functions over there, and the argument that you're going to hear is that the reason I filed this bill is to close that facility down. That was not the reason I filed this bill, and that's not the reason that these officials here are supporting this. And I will tell you that besides the ones here that support this is also the county collector and the county clerk as well, and I have letters of support with that. and also the mayor of Jonesboro. So I would also like to tell you that we have very talented local officials. It's not their fault that we're in this situation, but they are in a situation where they cannot perform their jobs and do it legally. We need to help them. They're asking for our help. and this district lies within my Senate district this county lies within my Senate district and I'm not asking somebody else to come in and do something I'm not willing to do and I might pay a political price for it I don't know about that we'll deal with that when the time comes but we need to help these people that need help doing their job and eliminating these unbelievably archaic laws that are shackling them in this way. This also is something that is creating a confrontation within the county. It's creating a divisive atmosphere within the county. And somewhere down the line, Craighead County is going to suffer economically with this going on. We need to set the county at one again so that the county can operate as one and function, cooperation across the county. And I will call your attention to this. Right now, you cannot shift these funds, say, from the side of the county that Jonesboro is contained in over to the other side of the county. Strictly illegal to do that. If my bill passes, they can legally do that. they can apply the funds wherever they will because there will not be a prohibition at that time against transferring it across that district line. So this is vital to the future of Craighead County, and I would ask you to not get engrossed in the emotional appeal that this side of the county, their facility is going to be shut down. These people have never said that, and I've never said that. That's not part of this bill. What we do have right now is, within a few employees in certain places, a cavalier attitude toward handling personnel or personal information, tax information, and sensitive information. It should not be handled in the way that it is. We should not be subjecting to these elected officials, people that work for them that are openly insubordinate. There was a bank account that existed over at Lake City, and I guess still exists. It has several parts to it. The collector that was recently elected there discovered that everybody over there was on the signature card and yet the county collector was not on the signature card and somebody asked me recently what did they did he ask for them to be asked to be put on that you think about that when does the boss ask a subordinate to allow to be put on a signature card of a bank account that they're responsible for. Concerning this bill, people talk about state mandates. People talk about government close to the people. What this archaic legislation contains is mandates. What we're doing is removing those mandates and allowing these officials to do their job that they were elected to do and giving them the freedom to do that that the other 65 counties in this state enjoy. And with that, I'll let them give you some information that they might want to give you. For
▶ Play
the benefit of the committee and given the amount of time and the amount of work We have to work through for the two ladies at the end of the table. Would you have anything that would be in addition to what Senator Cooper has
▶ Play
already laid out? Yes, sir. If you don't mind, I would like to. I have four pages, but I'll only bring up one topic. Okay, thank you. That's acceptable. I appreciate y'all taking the time to listen to this. Senator Cooper touched on the insubordination. I want to bring this up to kind of let y'all know. So I'll give you one instance where we had a new elect of our deputy circuit clerk in the Lake City District in November. I reached out to her and set up interviews for a new employee for the position that was going to be available there. We talked through it. We decided that we were going to set up interviews, that her and my chief deputy would do the interviews, and then they would recommend two or three people to me to do final interviews, and then we would decide who we were going to hire. At that point in time, they did three interviews. I emailed her to let her know that I had set up three more interviews. At that point in time, she emailed me back with, I'm sorry, but Judge Hill and Tony Thomas, and this is her wording, so excuse my grammar. I'm sorry, but Judge Hill and Tony Thomas was here meeting with us yesterday, and I have already offered the position to someone else. At that point in time, she had gone behind my back, went to our county judge. At that point in time, the county judge gave her permission to hire somebody. I do understand that Act 61 does state that he does have final say in who the deputy clerk is out there, but it is upon my suggestion, and it was not for the elected deputy circuit clerk's position. It was for another position. At that point in time, I contacted Rainwater Holton Sexton, who is our attorney. At that point in time, they gave me a letter to send to the person that she had offered the job to to let them know that I was the hiring official in this capacity and that I was still doing the interview process and that I would make that decision. That's just one instance of where when I've asked her to do something, work with her, In addition to her predecessor, if they did not like the answer that I gave, they went to the county judge who at that point in time inevitably would go against what I would say. I do also want to point out one instance that one of the arguments is going to be that this is a local issue. And I have to say that I agree with him. This is a local issue. But unfortunately, there is a state law that has set how we're going to do business there. At every turn that I have taken in the past two years and three months that I have tried to bring my office into state statute, our county judge and our quorum court have stood on this law stating that I do not have control of that office. My desire is not to close that office. My desire is to bring it into compliance and to make it follow everything that is demanded out of the circuit clerk's office. And right now, we are not doing that. So I appreciate your consideration
▶ Play
and a positive vote. Mr. Chair, I'd like to add one thing to this. If you go back and look at the law concerning the authority, concerning who can hire in that case, the county judge has the authority to hire county officials except the other elected county officials and their staff. Thank you. Again, my
▶ Play
Speaker 308 2:25:31
name is Hannah Towel. I'm the Craighead County Assessor. I will keep my testimony very brief. First and foremost, I believe that I was elected to follow the law in addition to representing the people of Craighead County. And so when some of our questions came up about the issues that have arisen, my first reaction was to call and get legal counsel. Of course, AAC is one of our resources. And so in one of the instances where I called and asked for assistance, the person on the other end of the line misunderstood me and thought that I said that I was from Crittenden County. So I received an answer, and then a couple of hours later, I called back to clarify something that was said, and at that time, I again stated that I was from Craighead County, and she caught at that time. And at that point, she said that she had to retract her original answer, that she could not give me an answer, that it is essentially too goosey of a situation for her to be able to give me an answer because of the legislation that is in place currently. And so it just seems incredibly strange or unfair, I guess you could say, that most counties can get an answer for their questions, yet we cannot. And so I just ask that you make it so that if I have legal questions that we can get answers without these in place. So I would greatly appreciate your consideration for this bill. Thank
▶ Play
you. Okay. All right. Thank you. We're going to go to the public comment. Let's see. Speaking against the bill is Bud Moxley. Yeah. All right. We're going to move on down. And speaking against the bill is Senator Wallace. REY PARRELANY WALLACEVILLE SPEAKER gratis Mr. Chairman,
▶ Play
Speaker 311 2:28:00
members, it's good to be back with the House. with the house you hear that you hear that noise that's the government saying I'm the government and I'm here to help you all those folks that you see behind you on that side over there they're from the Eastern District we call that Buffalo Island they don't usually come out to Little Rock they trust us to make the laws of the state. They trust their county judge. They trust their quorum court to handle the county issues. They trust their mayors and their city council to handle the local issues. In fact, I think almost all, if not all, of the mayors are over there today. Half those folks akin to me and the rest of them are my friends. Six words. Local issue, local control, local government. We're not here to legislate passwords on a computer. We are not here to legislate in subordination. Those issues are best solved at the local level. Those issues may be out there, but that's why we have mayors. That's why we have a quorum court. That's why we have a county judge. These folks from Buffalo Island came here because they're very worried. They've had a courthouse that has been in existence over 130 years. Their great-grandfathers, their grandmothers, their parents have all gone there it's a way of the life it's worked for 130 years insubordination passwords are not a reason for us at the state level to get involved I would ask remember those six words local control local issue local government should be handling this thank you any questions
▶ Play
from the committee all right thank you Representative Kat. Let's go through the, actually, go ahead and ask a question.
▶ Play
Senator Cooper, the purpose of my question is for clarification. I'm neutral on this issue as it pertains to your county, but recently, for, you know, also the benefit of my colleagues here. We had passed House Bill 1743 in regards to dual districts in the House, and this morning that went in front of the city, county, local, and the Senate side. But my bill pertained to the identical sections in your bill as it is to revenue. Is that correct? Section 19, 20, and 21.
▶ Play
One of the differences, there's a couple of differences in the two bills. Probably the primary difference is that yours dealt only with finance. Yours did not deal with the dissolving of the district. It's the two district issues itself. I think that's a critical difference. And also mine is limited to Craighead where yours deals with the other nine, I guess it is, counties across the state.
▶ Play
Thank you. I just wanted to clear that up for my
▶ Play
colleagues so they understood the distinction between the two. I think it's critical for Craighead that we carry this forward because of the overlapping of the 2003 legislation also, which dealt with the election over there. And that produced a situation that has morphed into people that doing their jobs feel like they're equal with the elected county officials. And I think I prefer, you know, without getting into a comparison between the two bills. And I think for the most part, here's a good bill. But for Craighead County, I think it's essential to pass this. I would say that if both bills pass, there's no conflict, and it won't do Craighead any damage. I do see a little bit of damage to Craighead if mine doesn't pass and yours does because of the election situation and the financial situation there. If one of them passes and the other one doesn't, you get into things, but the bills are not in conflict. If both of them pass, one will enhance the other, actually, is the way the situation will be as I see it.
▶ Play
Thank you. All right. Speaking for the bill is E. Ray Hackworth. Good morning, Major. Hold on just a second. Representative Ballinger, you're recognized.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I have a motion to limit debate at
▶ Play
five minutes per side. Okay, that's a proper motion. Is there any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion passes. We'll have five minutes each side and the four side that will include the closing of the bill. Mr. Hackworth, you're recognized. Speak for the bill. Thank
▶ Play
Speaker 321 2:34:30
you. Good morning, Mr. Chairman and members of the House Committee of Judicial Affairs. My name is E. Ray Hackworth. I'm a retired banker and resident of Jonesboro, Craighead County, Arkansas. I'm here today to ask that you vote in favor of Senate Bill 535 as presented by Senator Cooper. This Senate bill will repeal the Legislative Act of 667 of 2003 and Act 61 of 1883. The Legislative Act of 667 of 2003 has created a non-binding voting program in the Eastern District of Craighead County, whereas the clerks and the deputy sheriff assume they are elected officials when they are not. Act 667 also created other problems relating to the proper record keeping, proper control of county money, and the flow of work being and being able to reconcile who did what work in the Lake City office pertaining to the county tax assessor, tax collector, county clerk and the circuit slash chancery clerk offices, which are maintained in Jonesboro. A request of clarification of the segregation of duties of personnel in the Lake City office from the Bureau of Legislative Research was conducted on November the 18th, 2015, and they stated, it appears that the person or persons acting in conflict of the law as a solution violates, or as the solution is, violates the common law prohibiting the performing of dual office holder responsibilities in the county. Our system is broken in Craighead County because some people do not understand, nor do they want to understand, the difference between a county seat and a judicial district. There are 10 counties in the state that have judicial districts, Jonesboro being one of them. Logan County being one of them. There is a difference between the judicial district and the county seat. Each county has their own respective and identified county seats. In Craighead County, it is Jonesboro. To change the county seat in the state of Arkansas in any of our counties, it requires a vote of the qualified voters within that county. That That has never been done in any of the 75 counties in the state of Arkansas, and there's never been a vote conducted in Craighead County. Senator Cooper's bill repeals Act 667 of 2003 and the Uncodified Act 61 of 1883, which established the dual judicial district lines in Craighead County and in the other nine counties in the state of Arkansas. Senate Bill 535 puts Craighead County back as it was originally in 1874 as a whole county. This current bizarre system of non-cooperative culture within our county was created by the legislative that Senator Cooper's bill is attempting to repeal. In 2015, after the legislative audit of Craighead County, our clerk, Candace Edwards, asked that the Lake City issue be addressed. Representative Sullivan applauded Ms. Edwards for her disclosure and was very supportive of her efforts to correct the bizarre situation in Lake City. Yet today, Sullivan is leading the opposition to keep the Lake City issues in place and keep turmoil within our county. As a landowner and a taxpayer in Craighead County, I ask for your assistance and vote to affirm Senate Bill 535 today and reverse Act 667 of 2003 and Act 61 of 1883 and restore Craighead County in a whole and put it in compliance with the state constitution of 1874. Thank you very much for this opportunity to speak with you. All right. Thank you for your comments.
▶ Play
Going back to the list, speaking against the bill, John Milligan. Just a reminder, we have five minutes on each side. We're down to about a minute left on the fore side and five minutes on the against side. State your name, and then you may make your comments.
▶ Play
Speaker 325 2:39:10
Yes, sir. Thank you all for hearing me. I am John Milligan. I am the mayor of Lake City. I'm here today with the mayor of Black Oak, Carraway, Monette, Bay, and Brooklyn. They all, like myself, oppose this bill. The last quorum court meeting, it was February 27th. The elected officials that Mr. Cooper's talking about was, we was told then that, like he said, the MOU was, we was told then that that would handle the situation. They said that they was working on them. So we go back to the people that we serve and say, here, this is how they're handling it. Two days later, you turn on the news and this bill is being presented or going to be filed and all the people that we serve are blown away because that's not what we're telling them. And we feel that this is over the top, that it can be handled on a local level. I appreciate
▶ Play
your time. Thank you for your comments. Going back to the side to speak for the bill. Okay, it appears that all those who were speaking for the bill have already had their opportunity. Speaking against the bill is Representative Dan Sullivan. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chair, and thank you, committee folks, I'm not leading the charge, I'm representing my people. You know, you heard about the people in Jonesboro. I've got a lot of stuff here about what the people of Craighead County, Eastern District, all over the county are like. They fix people's roofs, which is a huge story in here. They have hundreds of thousands of dollars they've raised for their local community. This is a community that works together. They have one of the small elementary schools there has a 91% efficiency level. These are schools and communities that do things together. So what happened? Folks, they haven't had any problems there for years. It goes 100 or more years. I'm going to address a couple of these specifically. I have paperwork. BLR said this could be addressed. The issues could be addressed by deputizing the people. I've got the paperwork here. I met with the local legislative audit. I have the paperwork here that says they're operating well within their scope going back to 1999 when they started doing this. and there's nothing in here that indicates there are significant problems in the Craighead County Court operations other than what's going on in every other county. And this latest issue is in the Jonesboro Sun today about the Eastern District picking the pockets. Folks, that really saddens me that we are, it's gotten to the point that we're coming down here to bring to you issues like this. And Representative Kapp's bill, 1743, resolves the financial issue. Yes, that was significant. In fact, Craighead County didn't follow it. We weren't doing that. But if they were, and if it were against the law, that is resolved. And I hope we can all get together and support that bill. You know, harmony and unity are family. Unity is singing the same song. Harmony is the blending of different instruments and voices to make the song pleasant to hear. You actually can't have harmony with people who are like you. You can have uniformity, but not harmony. Harmony is embracing the differences to bring together a sweet song. And tension is required. You know, a guitar has four different strings, or five, I don't know what kind of guitar you play. But every one of them has a different level of tension. And when you don't tune the guitar, it sounds terrible. But it's only the tension in the strings that brings about the harmony. You know, we do this all the time in legislative sessions. We have bills people disagree on. We say take it back to committee. We even expunge the vote occasionally to get things right. And that's all we ask you to do here. You know, this is a local issue. Discord can produce harmony. I'm sorry, differences can produce harmony or discord. Our goal should be to produce harmony. And I ask that you let this go back to our local area and let us solve this. Thank you, Chair, and thank you, Committee.
▶ Play
I'll answer any questions. Thank you. All right, seeing no questions, thank you, Representative Sullivan. Okay, and we have, again, no one else has signed up to speak for the bill. Against the bill,
▶ Play
Speaker 332 2:44:00
Ed Hill. And you've got about a minute. Thank you, Mr. Chairman and Committee. I appreciate this time. First, I would like to say that the Lake City Courthouse has been very functional for lots of years. To my knowledge, there's never been a legislative audit to come back bad about anything at Lake City Courthouse. Lake City Courthouse has provided a very good service for many years, and we hope to continue that. We're here to provide a service for the public, and that's why we're here as public servants. And we're here to provide a service to them, not at our convenience, but to the taxpayers' convenience. That's why we're in public service office, to serve the public, and that's what we've done in Lake City. You know, sometimes government like this is kind of, is the reason kind of people are skeptical of government because it appears here that we're trying to fix something that's not broken. I appreciate this committee taking time. Mr. Chair, committee, thank you, and I'd ask for a no vote on this.
▶ Play
Thank you. Thank you for your comments. All right, we have 30 seconds left. Speaking against the bill is Mary Lynn Williams.
▶ Play
Speaker 333 2:45:15
Thank you, gentlemen and ladies for allowing me to speak. I have nothing new to add to what has been said here for those who want to take this back to our communities in our county in Jonesboro and work it out. as reasonable people can. I simply come saying this as a citizen of Jonesboro, a member of the, a citizen of the western half of the county. I have had the privilege and the honor of living in both districts of the county, and I have been pleased with the functionality of the government in both districts, and I see no reason for this to. Time is up. Thank
▶ Play
you. Thank you. All right. We have one minute, 56 seconds to be exact for Senator Cooper, Representative Ladyman, to close for the bill.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. It's ironic that they bring up the idea of bringing government back close to the people because that's exactly what my bill does. It repeals the mandates which prevent that from happening. There is no doubt that this has had problems. Court and court meetings have been in turmoil for a long time over this issue. This goes back two or three years that I'm aware of. There's been multiple articles written about this in the Jonesboro Sun. And I would just ask you for the sake of good government in Jonesboro and the future of Craighead County and economic development to do bring this back to local control, which this is exactly what this will do. It will put local government back in the hands of those that were elected to do it. That's all they're asking is to be able to do their job legally and to do it and to do the job they were elected to do. Thank you for
▶ Play
your consideration. All right. Thank you, Senator Cooper. What's the pleasure of the committee? Representative Smith? Motion do pass as amended. Okay. Motion do pass as amended. Is there any discussion? All in favor, say aye. Those opposed? No. The no's have it. All right, members, if you can hang in there with me for a few more minutes. Hopefully we can knock out a few more bills here. Without objection, let's go to House Bill 2113. Representative Henderson, and I believe there's an amendment here. And I'm looking around the room. We've got Representative Walker is here. Senator Williams is here. Representative Douglas. All
▶ Play
right. Thank you, Mr. Chair. If I could, I'd like to call Kermit Channel from the State Crime Lab to the desk.
▶ Play
Speaker 300 2:48:27
All right, do I have a motion to
▶ Play
Speaker 303 2:48:36
adopt the amendment? Representative Dalby? Yeah, absolutely. All right, we have
▶ Play
a motion to adopt the amendment. Is there any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? All right. It's adopted. You recognize, present the bill as
▶ Play
amended. Thank you on that amendment. We looked at getting that engrossed, and we just ran out of time. But anyway, House Bill 2113 deals with the forensic testing of firearms at the state crime lab. And I'm going to let Director Kermit Channel kind of give us an overview of what this consists of. And basically what
▶ Play
Speaker 338 2:49:24
this does, really, it's a process to make it more efficient for law enforcement and also for the crime lab. Because what this bill really addresses is our ballistic database, our firearms database. And right now, with the way the current law is, basically any weapon is submitted to us for entry. However, scientifically, most weapons can't be entered. And so this just makes it a little clearer that basically doesn't say that all weapons have to be submitted. and we make that determination based on the science. So, again, it's really an efficiency measure for law enforcement. They don't have to submit those shotguns to us for us to, yeah, okay, we've shot it. Here it's back. And for us to only enter in long guns and things that actually make, you know, sound science to try to get connections in this database. All right. Any questions?
▶ Play
Speaker 339 2:50:16
All right. Does not appear anybody to sign up
▶ Play
to speak for or against the bill. Representative Henderson, would you like to close for your bill?
▶ Play
Yes, Mr. Chair. This just to make our sheriff's departments in state crime a little bit more efficient. Appreciate a good vote. All
▶ Play
right. What's the pleasure of the committee? Representative Whitaker? All right. We have a motion to do pass as amended. Any discussion? All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion passes. Thank you, committee. Thank you, Mr. Chair. All right. Senator Williams, I guess, is here.
▶ Play
Speaker 342 2:51:13
Okay. Senate Bill 702. Yes, sir. All right. You're recognized. Thank you so very much. I hope I've treated everybody the same way that comes to state agencies to do our best. This is a relatively simple bill. Don't laugh. It's a relatively simple bill. Some of you have signed on. And two years ago, we introduced this bill, and we had a $25 fine if certain crimes were committed in the presence of a child. And in doing that, we went two years, and we collected $200. So it was kind of disheartening for the Child Advocate Centers. So we've stepped that up a little bit to $100. And if you are driving a car and you're exceeding the speed limit by 20 miles an hour, if you're driving 90 miles an hour down the interstate and you've got a child in the back, there's a $5 extra charge for endangering that child. Every penny of this will go to Child Advocate Centers. I'll tell you real briefly what a Child Advocate Center does. A Child Advocate Center in the state of Arkansas sees about 5,000 kids a year. I'll give you a quick example. in Lowen Oak County. They see about 20 kids a month that gets a forensic interview. What that means is it's $1,000 examination for every child, 20 of them a month. Most of that is at least a third or half of that is through raising funds locally. Now, I've supported this organization for many, many years. I've sat on the state board. I've started domestic abuse shelters. I'm involved in them today. Most of this work is hard work to do volunteer work and raise funds. We have helped in the past with GIF. As you know, GIF money is probably a thing of the past. So this is an effort to give them a steady stream of income so they can continue serving the children. They not only serve the child when they're there, they offer future help, And I'll be brief, Representative Sheffer. They also offer counseling for the family and the victim if the family's not offending for as long as they need to at no charge. So it's a great organization. It's one that I'd hope that this committee would support me and I'd take any questions.
▶ Play
Any questions from the committee? No one has signed up to speak for or against the bill. Would you like to close for your bill? I'm closed for it. I know time is short. What's the pleasure of the committee? Representative Ballinger. We have a motion to do pass. Is there any discussion? All in favor
▶ Play
Speaker 342 2:53:54
say aye. Aye. Any opposed? The motion passes. Thank you
▶ Play
very much, committee. Members, we've got, I'd like to see if we can knock out two to three more bills here real quick and then that hopefully will leave us some time. I guess we should start doing like rules and passing the hat for lunch but we haven't done that. So Representative Douglas you have two bills that came back. You recognize and present House Bill 1943 and I understand there's an amendment. Yes, sir.
▶ Play
Speaker 347 2:54:35
I have an amendment to offer. And I realized when I passed this out of committee that it was kind of a weak little, yeah. And so I came back to the committee members and, um, got some help. I'm on, uh, 1943 and that's the one on the alimony. What I did was I made this permissive. I took out the shall and just put in May, and that allows the judge discretion in the cases. It just adds domestic violence as one of the things that they need to consider. That's the body of the amendment. We
▶ Play
move a motion to adopt the amendment. Representative Dalby moves adoption. Is there any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? The amendment's adopted. You recognize to present the
▶ Play
Speaker 347 2:55:34
bill as amended or as? Yes, and I would, I think the amendment changes it to, you know, where judges and the lawyers were much more happy with it. And I would ask for a favorable vote from the committee. I appreciate them working with me and allow me to bring it back. All right. What's
▶ Play
the pleasure of the committee? Representative Tucker. Okay. We have a motion. Do pass as amended? Is there any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion passes. You recognize to present House Bill 1817. Thank you.
▶ Play
Speaker 347 2:56:12
And the same thing kind of went with this bill as well. We realized when I presented it that the information I put in the bill about the blood evidence had recently been changed by Representative Gassaway's bill and by federal law. So we went back and amended it to comply with federal law in his bill. And then we realized that the last section of the bill did not provide a look back in order for the state police to look at a person's record going back to make sure that they had not had convictions in the last three years in order to give them their concealed carry license. So they asked for that language to be added to the bill, and I did so. And I would ask for a favorable vote on the amendment. Is
▶ Play
there a motion to adopt the amendment? Representative Tucker moves adoption. Is there any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Yeah. The amendment's adopted.
▶ Play
Speaker 347 2:57:20
You recognize, present the bill as amended. Thank you. And I would, again, just feel like this is a public safety bill. I think it's good for us to make the public to feel like we're doing all that we can do to make them safe with the new laws that we've got with open carry, concealed carry. And I think it was a little bit of a hole in the law, and I think we've done some good work here to make the law better. So I just appreciate a good vote as amended. What's
▶ Play
the pleasure of the committee? Representative Nix moves do pass as amended. Is there any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? The motion is adopted. Thank you very much, committee. Members, final two bills I'd like to take up before we break. Representative Gassaway has two proposed uniform laws, and we have a witness who's here, I believe. So Representative Gassaway, you're recognized. Without objection, you're recognized to present House Bill 1884. And just for the benefit, this is the Uniform Unsworn Foreign Declarations Act. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, members. House Bill 2253 is a bill to adopt the revised uniform for 1884. Oh, we're starting with 1884. 1884 is a bill to adopt the Uniform Unsworn Foreign Declarations Act. And here with me today I have Elisa White, who is the Vice President and General Counsel of the Arkansas Hospital Association. She's also a Uniform Law Commissioner and has been since 2009. And with the Chairman's permission, I'd ask that Ms. White be allowed to explain the bill.
▶ Play
You recognize. Thank you very much. Essentially, what this does is it gives a process that's been done in federal court for 30 years and provides clarity that the same process can be followed in state court for admitting unsworn declarations from a foreign country. And I'll answer any questions, but that's it. Any questions from the committee?
▶ Play
All right. I'm seeing no questions, and no one has signed up to speak for or against the bill. Representative Gatsby, would you like to close for the bill? I'm closed for the bill, and we'll make a motion to do pass. Okay, we have a motion to do pass. Is there any discussion? All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion passes. Without objection, we're going to
▶ Play
move to House Bill 2253. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Now, House Bill 2253 is a bill to adopt the revised Uniform Fiduciary Access to Digital Assets Act, and this is a very important bill in the day and age in which we live. What this bill will do is it will help in the event that a person dies or loses capacity to manage his or her own affairs so that a fiduciary who receives legal authority can manage and distribute the person's property in an appropriate manner. And so what this bill will do is it will provide a framework in which a person can, through basically power of attorney or some fiduciary form, designate how their social media and other digital assets will be managed in the event of their death or in the event of their incapacity. And I have with me here for this particular bill, Professor Lynn Foster. Professor Foster was my property professor back in 2003 at the UALR Law School. She has been teaching at the Bowen School of Law since 1986, and she's authored several books and law review articles on Arkansas law, and with the chair's permission, I'd ask that she be allowed to present this bill.
▶ Play
You're recognized. Thank you. Committee members, thank you for your time today. We appreciate it. very, very briefly, under this bill, there are four types of fiduciaries, personal representatives, trustees, guardians of the estate, and agents under a power of attorney. This act extends the traditional powers of fiduciaries to manage tangible property to include management of people's digital assets as well. The act allows fiduciaries to manage digital properties such as computer files, web domains, virtual currency, but restricts a fiduciary's access to electronic communications such as e-mails, text messages, and social media accounts unless the original user consents in an instrument like a will, trust, power of attorney, or other record. That very, very briefly is what this act does. It has already been enacted in 24 states, and it has been introduced this year in 18, which is amazing for a uniform law, and that just points out the need for this law. We've been hearing a lot of pressure from the probate section of the Arkansas Bar Association to enact this law this year because it really will assist with the administration of estates. IT HAS BEEN ENDORSED BY THE AARP, FACEBOOK, GOOGLE, AND THE NATIONAL ACADEMY OF ELDER LAW ATTORNEYS. REPRESENTATIVE WITTECER, YOU RECOGNIZED.
▶ Play
THANK YOU, MR. CHAIR. THANK YOU. I WAS JUST CURIOUS. I KNOW IN PREVIOUS ITERATIONS THIS BILL HAD BEEN OPPOSED BY SOME OF THE GROUPS YOU MENTIONED AND ALSO THE MOTION PICTURE ASSOCIATION OF AMERICA. The amendments that you all have offered, has that won them over, so to speak? Absolutely, and
▶ Play
everybody is now in line. Thank you. Any further questions?
▶ Play
All right, no one has signed up to speak for or against the bill. Representative Gassaway, would you like to close for your bill? I'm closed for the bill. We'll make a motion do pass. All right, we have a motion do pass. Is there any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion passes. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you. Members, thank you for your work and patience today. I understand that we may very well come back into committee later this afternoon after session. So just be on the lookout for an announcement to that effect.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 3:04:40
Okay, without objection, we're adjourned.
▶ Play

Agenda

SPECIAL ORDER OF BUSINESS- TUESDAY, MARCH 21, 2017- 10:00 A.M

HB1798 Blake AMENDING THE BURDEN OF PROOF REQUIRED DURING THE SENTENCING PHASE OF A TRIAL WHEN THE STATE SEEKS THE DEATH PENALTY.

1:39:30 - 1:54

HB2103 V. Flowers CONCERNING THE SENTENCES AVAILABLE FOR A CAPITAL OFFENSE.

1:54 - 32:40 86 segments 11 speakers

Representative Vivian Flowers introduced HB 2103, noting it was brought forward by the Arkansas Coalition to Abolish the Death Penalty and distributed handouts outlining six reasons to repeal capital punishment. [2:14] [2:50] [3:32] [4:04] [4:41]

The committee heard testimony from pollster Ernie Oakley, who presented 2014 survey results showing a decline in death-penalty support and mixed voter reactions to replacing it with life without parole. [7:06] [7:13] [7:24] [7:34] [7:43] [8:19] [8:54] [9:27] [9:59] [10:36] [11:09]

Additional witnesses-including Judith Elaine, who recounted a wrongful-conviction case; Bishop Larry Benefield, who argued the death penalty conflicts with religious and moral values; and Rhonda Brassfield of the Arkansas Coalition, who cited cost, deterrence, racial disparity and innocence concerns-provided further arguments against the death penalty. [12:27] [12:51] [13:26] [13:56] [14:31] [15:01] [15:33] [16:03] [16:29] [16:43] [17:15] [17:45] [18:15] [18:49] [19:05] [19:12] [19:20] [19:51] [20:21] [20:53] [21:26] [22:01]

Committee members asked questions about racial statistics, the bill’s language substituting life imprisonment versus life without parole, and the possibility of amending the bill; Representative Flowers said she would be willing to amend the language, and the chair moved the committee on to consideration of House Bill 2170 without a vote on HB 2103. [22:49] [22:57] [23:03] [23:13] [23:37] [24:04] [24:11] [24:17] [24:42] [25:15] [25:24] [25:27] [25:30] [25:45] [26:18] [26:52] [27:03] [27:26] [27:36] [27:56] [28:13] [28:27] [28:59] [29:32] [30:04] [30:30] [30:35] [30:56] [31:15] [31:27] [31:36] [31:47] [31:53] [32:19]

HB2170 V. Flowers CONCERNING THE IMPOSITION OF THE DEATH PENALTY ON A DEFENDANT WITH A SERIOUS MENTAL ILLNESS.

32:40 - 1:19:47 136 segments 19 speakers

Representative Vivian Flowers introduced HB 2170, which would bar the imposition of the death penalty on defendants diagnosed with a serious mental illness, and called law professor Tom Sullivan to testify on the issue. [33:11] [33:28]

Sullivan detailed how forced medication to make death-row inmates competent raises unresolved U.S. Supreme Court questions, described the ethical dilemma for physicians and defense counsel, and argued that the bill would create a pre-trial mental-illness evaluation that automatically substitutes a death sentence with life without parole-points that prompted extensive questions from Representatives Dalby, Petty, Rushing and Gazaway about overlap with Senate Bill 42, the definition of “seriously mentally ill,” and procedural implementation. [33:53] [34:26] [34:57] [35:29] [36:02] [36:33] [37:07] [37:41] [38:16] [38:51] [39:15] [39:26] [39:56] [40:01] [40:13] [40:29] [41:03] [41:08] [41:24] [42:40] [43:00] [43:02] [43:15] [43:45] [44:16] [47:50] [48:15] [48:24] [48:30] [48:50] [48:54] [49:20] [49:51] [1:00:59] [1:01:31] [1:02:07]

Testimony from Prosecuting Attorney Nathan Smith and other opponents warned the measure is overly broad and could effectively abolish the death penalty, while supporters such as former legislator Herb Rule emphasized cost, moral, and victim-family considerations; the committee did not record a vote, leaving the bill pending. [1:06:17] [1:06:37] [1:06:44] [1:07:08] [1:07:39] [1:13:17] [1:13:40] [1:14:10] [1:14:45]

CONCUR IN SENATE AMENDMENT

1:19:47 - 2:54:23 254 segments 43 speakers

The committee heard extensive testimony on the merits of life-without-parole versus the death penalty, including cost comparisons, mental-illness considerations, and moral arguments presented by Representatives Petty, House, Dr. Rick Smith, Paul Calvert, Karen DePippa, and Representative Flowers, with several members questioning whether the government’s right to execute should be limited to certain circumstances. [1:20:08] [1:20:17] [1:20:42] [1:21:01] [1:21:13] [1:21:27] [1:21:49] [1:22:22] [1:22:37] [1:22:44] [1:22:48] [1:22:53] [1:23:06] [1:23:09] [1:23:25] [1:23:39] [1:24:00] [1:24:17] [1:24:32] [1:24:47] [1:25:03] [1:25:09] [1:25:13] [1:25:36] [1:25:46] [1:26:08] [1:26:17] [1:26:40] [1:26:54] [1:27:13] [1:27:37] [1:27:43] [1:28:00] [1:28:15] [1:28:49] [1:29:23] [1:29:55] [1:30:29] [1:30:45] [1:30:56] [1:31:02] [1:32:04] [1:32:40] [1:33:11] [1:33:41] [1:34:16] [1:34:41] [1:34:48] [1:35:30] [1:35:48] [1:35:56] [1:36:34] [1:37:06]

A motion to limit further debate to five minutes per side was made by Chair Shepherd and adopted unanimously, establishing a time-constraint for the remaining comments. [1:25:13]

After brief closing remarks, a motion to “do pass” the Senate-amended version of House Bill 2170 was taken; the committee voted aye with no recorded opposition, thereby approving the amendment. [1:38:20] [1:38:34] [1:38:42] [1:39:00] [1:39:13]

HB1041 B. Smith TO PROTECT THE RIGHTS AND PRIVILEGES GRANTED UNDER THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION AND THE UNITED STATES CONSTITUTION; AND TO DECLARE AMERICAN LAWS FOR AMERICAN COURTS.

HB1367 Watson CONCERNING AN AUXILIARY LAW ENFORCEMENT OR A RETIRED LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER CARRYING A CONCEALED HANDGUN; AND CONCERNING RETIRED LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICERS.

RE-REFERRED TO COMMITTEE

HB1943 C. Douglas TO PROHIBIT THE AWARD OF ALIMONY TO PERSONS CONVICTED OF A DOMESTIC VIOLENCE OFFENSE.

2:54:23 - 2:56:17 9 segments 2 speakers

Representative Douglas proposed an amendment to HB 1943 that replaces mandatory language with discretionary language, allowing judges to consider domestic-violence factors when deciding alimony awards. [2:54:35] [2:54:39] [2:55:13]

The committee adopted the amendment after a motion by Representative Dalby, and then approved the bill as amended without further debate. [2:55:19] [2:55:34] [2:55:44] [2:55:56]

HB1817 C. Douglas TO CREATE THE OFFENSE OF POSSESSION OF A FIREARM WHILE UNDER THE INFLUENCE OF ALCOHOL OR A CONTROLLED SUBSTANCE.

2:56:17 - 2:58:20 5 segments 2 speakers

An amendment to HB 1817 was offered to require a review of an applicant’s convictions within the past three years before issuing a concealed-carry license, addressing a gap in the existing law. [2:56:48] [2:57:09]

The committee adopted the amendment and subsequently passed the bill as amended by voice vote. [2:57:09] [2:57:20] [2:57:52] [2:57:56]

REGULAR AGENDA

HB1629 Tucker TO PROTECT VICTIMS OF DOMESTIC ABUSE AND STALKING; AND PROHIBITING A PERSON CONVICTED OF MISDEMEANOR DOMESTIC BATTERING OR STALKING FROM POSSESSING A FIREARM.

HB1630 Tucker TO PROTECT CHILDREN FROM UNATTENDED LOADED FIREARMS; AND TO CREATE THE OFFENSE OF NEGLIGENTLY ALLOWING ACCESS TO A FIREARM BY A CHILD.

HB1268 Murdock CONCERNING THE USE OF AN IGNITION INTERLOCK DEVICE.

HB1784 Eaves CONCERNING THE QUALIFICATIONS TO BE A LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER.

HB1842 Johnson A TO ASSESSED IS WHO PERSON FEES CONCERNING AND FINES THE

HB1884 Gazaway TO ADOPT THE UNIFORM UNSWORN FOREIGN DECLARATIONS ACT.

2:58:20 - 3:00:32 8 segments 3 speakers

Representative Jimmy Gazaway introduced HB 1884 to adopt the Uniform Unsworn Foreign Declarations Act, and Elisa White, Vice President and General Counsel of the Arkansas Hospital Association, explained that the bill would allow Arkansas courts to use the same 30-year federal procedure for admitting unsworn foreign declarations as state courts. [2:58:24] [2:58:52] [2:58:55] [2:59:28] [2:59:35]

No committee member sought to speak for or against the measure; Chair Matthew J. Shepherd called for a motion to pass, which was adopted unanimously without objection. [2:59:55] [3:00:03]

HB1886 Gazaway TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 16 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE.

HB1889 Ballinger TO CREATE THE OFFENSE OF CARRYING A WEAPON IN A PROHIBITED PLACE; AND CONCERNING THE POSSESSION OF A HANDGUN.

HB1895 Gates CONCERNING THE CONCEALED CARRY OF A HANDGUN BY A CONCEALED CARRY LICENSEE INSIDE A COURTHOUSE.

HB1899 Bentley CONCERNING THE PROCUREMENT OF A LICENSE TO CARRY A CONCEALED HANDGUN BY A VICTIM OF DOMESTIC ABUSE.

HB1909 Walker CONCERNING THE TEMPORARY ABATEMENT OF THE REQUIREMENT OF A PERSON TO PAY COURT-ORDERED CIVIL PENALTIES, COSTS, FEES, FINES, OR RESTITUTION WHILE THAT PERSON IS INCARCERATED OR CONFINED TO A HOSPITAL.

HB1918 Walker CONCERNING PAROLE ELIGIBILITY FOR A PERSON SERVING A LIFE SENTENCE OR A SENTENCE IN EXCESS OF FORTY-FIVE YEARS.

HB2017 Brown CONCERNING THE FEE FOR VICTIM IMPACT PANEL ATTENDANCE.

HB2075 Leding TO PROHIBIT COMMERCIAL SURROGACY ARRANGEMENTS AND THE ENFORCEMENT OF SURROGACY ARRANGEMENTS.

HB2076 Dotson TO REDUCE THE FEE FOR A CONCEALED CARRY LICENSE; TO CREATE A LIFETIME CONCEALED CARRY LICENSE; AND CONCERNING THE FEES FOR A LICENSE TO CARRY A CONCEALED HANDGUN.

HB2083 Petty TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING CRIMINAL BACKGROUND CHECKS FOR A LONG- TERM CARE EMPLOYEE TO CLARIFY THAT EXPUNGED, PARDONED, OR OTHERWISE SEALED OFFENSES WILL NOT DISQUALIFY AN INDIVIDUAL FROM EMPLOYMENT IN A LONG-TERM CARE FACILITY.

HB2112 Walker CONCERNING A PERSON WHO FAILS TO APPEAR OR FAILS TO PAY A FINE; CONCERNING THE OFFENSE OF FAILURE TO APPEAR; AND CONCERNING COSTS, FINES, AND FEES ASSESSED TO A PERSON WHO IS INCARCERATED OR IN A HOSPITAL OR INPATIENT FACILITY.

HB2118 Womack CONCERNING THE CIVIL LIABILITY OF AN ENTITY THAT MAINTAINS A POLICY THAT PROHIBITS THE CARRYING OF A HANDGUN ON ITS PROPERTY.

HB2119 Womack CONCERNING THE CIVIL LIABILITY OF AN INSTITUTION OF HIGHER EDUCATION THAT MAINTAINS A POLICY THAT PROHIBITS THE CARRYING OF A HANDGUN ON ITS PROPERTY AND THE LIABILITY OF THE INSTITUTION'S GOVERNING BODY.

HB2199 M. Hodges TO CLARIFY THE PURPOSE OF THE MINORITY BUSINESS ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT ACT; AND TO AMEND THE REPORTING REQUIREMENTS AND PROVIDE FOR PENALTIES UNDER THE MINORITY BUSINESS ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT ACT.

HB2253 Gazaway REVISED UNIFORM FIDUCIARY ACCESS TO DIGITAL ASSETS ACT.

3:00:32 - 2:47:48

Representative Jimmy Gazaway presented HB 2253, the Revised Uniform Fiduciary Access to Digital Assets Act, describing its goal of giving fiduciaries authority to manage a person’s digital assets upon death or incapacity, and requested Professor Lynn Foster to testify on the bill’s details. [3:00:38] [3:01:15] [3:01:46]

Professor Foster outlined the act’s key provisions-four types of fiduciaries, extension of fiduciary powers to digital property, and limited access to electronic communications without the owner’s consent-while noting its adoption in 24 states and endorsements from AARP, Facebook, Google, and the National Academy of Elder Law Attorneys. [3:01:46] [3:02:22] [3:02:55]

Representative David Whitaker asked whether recent amendments had addressed earlier opposition from groups such as the Motion Picture Association of America, to which Foster confirmed they had, and no further questions were raised. [3:03:25] [3:03:46]

The chair closed the hearing, moved to pass the bill, and the motion carried unanimously with no opposition. [3:03:55]

HB2228 Blake CONCERNING THE INDEPENDENT INVESTIGATION OF DEATHS INVOLVING A POLICE OFFICER.

HB2012 Vaught CONCERNING THE POSTING OF BOND TO RELEASE A PERSON FROM JAIL; AND CONCERNING THE POSTING OF BOND BY A MINOR TO RELEASE A PERSON FROM JAIL.

HB1994 Pilkington CONCERNING THE INTENDED PURPOSE OF THE CONCEALED HANDGUN LICENSING PROGRAM.

SB550 T. Garner TO PROTECT ACCESS TO PLACES OF EMPLOYMENT, RIGHTS OF WAY, PRIVATE REAL PROPERTY, AND PUBLIC INFRASTRUCTURE.

HB2088 Leding TO PROVIDE ENHANCED PENALTIES FOR A CRIMINAL OFFENSE COMMITTED BECAUSE OF THE VICTIM'S RACE, COLOR, RELIGION, ETHNICITY, ANCESTRY, NATIONAL ORIGIN, SEXUAL ORIENTATION, GENDER IDENTITY, OR DISABILITY.

HB1827 Della Rosa CONCERNING THE LICENSE FEES FOR A LICENSE TO CARRY A CONCEALED HANDGUN.

HB1888 Ballinger ESTABLISHING AN ENHANCED CERTIFICATION TOCARRY A HANDGUN; AND CONCERNING THE POSSESSION OF A HANDGUN.

HB1444 Ballinger TO REVISE CERTAIN EMINENT DOMAIN LAWS THAT ARISE OUT OF PROPERTY RIGHTS SECURED UNDER THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION, ARTICLE 2, § 22.

HB1959 Ballinger TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING ALIMONY SUPPORT.

HB2113 Henderson CONCERNING THE TESTING OF A FIREARM BY THE STATE CRIME LABORATORY.

2:47:48 - 2:51:08 14 segments 6 speakers

The committee adopted an amendment to HB 2113 after Representative Ken Henderson moved for its adoption and the amendment was approved without debate. [2:48:36] [2:48:41] [2:48:59]

Henderson, with input from State Crime Lab Director Kermit Channel, explained that the bill would streamline forensic firearm testing by limiting database entries to weapons that can be scientifically analyzed, improving efficiency for law-enforcement agencies. [2:49:03] [2:49:24] [2:49:32] [2:50:05]

With no members signing up for or against the measure, the committee voted to pass the bill as amended. [2:50:32] [2:50:37] [2:50:46]

HB2116 Holcomb TO PROTECT FREIGHT RAIL EMPLOYEES AND PUBLIC TRANSIT EMPLOYEES BY ENHANCING THE PENALTIES OF CERTAIN CRIMINAL OFFENSES.

HB2202 Tucker CONCERNING THE NEW BUSINESS RULE AND THE ABILITY OF A BUSINESS TO RECOVER LOST PROFITS IN LITIGATION.

SB37 A. Clark PERMITTING A CONCEALED CARRY LICENSEE TO POSSESS A CONCEALED HANDGUN IN HIS OR HER EMPLOYER'S PARKING LOT.

HB2131 K. Ferguson CONCERNING A SUSPENDED IMPOSITION OF SENTENCE; CONCERNING A CRIMINAL CONVICTION; AND CONCERNING SUSPENDING AN IMPOSITION OF SENTENCE WHEN A PERSON OWES RESTITUTION,

HB2266 V. Flowers TO ESTABLISH A UNIFORM STANDARD FOR DATA COLLECTION AMONG LAW ENFORCEMENT AGENCIES.

HB2270 V. Flowers CONCERNING BODY CAMERAS FOR LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICERS; AND TO ESTABLISH INCENTIVES FOR THE USE OF BODY CAMERAS AND BODY CAMERA DATA STORAGE.

SB237 Elliott TO REQUIRE THE PREPARATION OF A RACIAL IMPACT STATEMENT FOR CERTAIN BILLS FILED WITH THE SENATE AND HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES.

HB1843 Petty CONCERNING CRIME VICTIMS REPARATIONS; AND CONCERNING THE CRIME VICTIMS REPARATIONS REVOLVING FUND.

HB2080 Petty CONCERNING SEXUAL ASSAULT MEDICAL LEGAL EXAMINATIONS; AND CONCERNING THE COLLECTION AND TESTING OF DNA DURING A CRIMINAL INVESTIGATION.

SB702 E. Williams CONCERNING THE ASSESSMENT OF AN ADDITIONAL FINE FOR CRIMINAL OFFENSES COMMITTED AGAINST OR IN THE PRESENCE OF A CHILD AND THE ASSESSMENT OF AN ADDITIONAL FINE FOR TRAFFIC VIOLATIONS COMMITTED IN THE PRESENCE OF A CHILD.

2:51:08 - 1:59:44

Senator E. Williams introduced SB 702 to increase the fine for offenses committed in the presence of a child to $100 and add a $5 surcharge for high-speed violations, directing the revenue to Child Advocate Centers. [2:51:13] [2:51:47] [2:52:21]

The committee received no testimony for or against the bill and subsequently moved to pass it, which was approved by voice vote. [2:53:30] [2:53:54]

SB535 J. Cooper CONCERNING DUAL JUDICIAL DISTRICTS.

1:59:44 - -15:43

The committee adopted the amendment to SB 535 and recognized Senator Cooper and Representative Ladyman to present the bill, which seeks to repeal the 1883 and 2003 statutes that created dual judicial districts in Craighead County,. [2:00:56] [2:01:27] [2:02:01] [2:02:39] [2:02:44] [2:02:49] [2:03:17] [2:03:51] [2:04:27] [2:05:09] [2:05:47] [2:06:26] [2:06:58] [2:07:30] [2:08:06]

Testimony from Craighead County officials-including Assessor Hannah Towle, Circuit Clerk Candace Edwards, and County Clerk Angela Russell-described how the dual-district system creates financial segregation, illegal subsidies, and operational dysfunction, supporting the repeal,,. [2:02:39] [2:02:44] [2:02:49] [2:03:17] [2:05:09] [2:05:47] [2:06:26] [2:06:58] [2:22:02] [2:22:25] [2:22:58] [2:23:28] [2:24:01] [2:24:32] [2:25:04]

After Representative Bob Ballinger moved to limit debate to five minutes per side (adopted) and the committee heard supporting testimony from retired banker E. Ray Hackworth and opposition from mayors and legislators, the committee voted to pass the bill as amended,,,. [2:34:08] [2:34:12] [2:34:35] [2:35:05] [2:35:39] [2:36:10] [2:36:42] [2:37:16] [2:37:49] [2:38:21] [2:39:10] [2:39:24] [2:39:58] [2:40:04] [2:40:31] [2:40:35] [2:41:05] [2:41:39] [2:42:09] [2:42:39] [2:43:09] [2:43:40] [2:44:00] [2:44:13] [2:44:44] [2:47:12] [2:47:27]

SB533 J. Hutchinson TO CREATE THE DYNASTY TRUST ACT.

SB554 J. Hutchinson CONCERNING THE AUTHORITY OF A UNITED STATES POSTAL INSPECTOR TO MAKE AN ARREST IN THE STATE.

DEFERRED BILLS

HB1095 Johnson CONCERNING THE REQUIREMENTS FOR A CONCEALED HANDGUN LICENSE FOR A CURRENT OR FORMER MEMBER OF THE UNITED STATES ARMED FORCES.

HB1265 Richey CONCERNING THE POSSESSION AND CARRYING OF A CONCEALED OR UNCONCEALED HANDGUN; TO ESTABLISH A LICENSE TO CARRY AN UNCONCEALED HANDGUN; AND TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS.

HB1152 Watson CONCERNING THE ABILITY OF AN AUXILIARY LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER TO CARRY A CONCEALED HANDGUN AND TO BE EXEMPTED FROM THE LICENSING REQUIREMENTS TO CARRY A CONCEALED HANDGUN.

HB1177 Tucker INCREASING THE AVAILABLE SENTENCES FOR CERTAIN SEX OFFENSES WHEN COMMITTED AGAINST A FAMILY OR HOUSEHOLD MEMBER.

HB1248 J. Williams TO CREATE AN EXEMPTION UNDER THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT OF 1967 CONCERNING CERTAIN LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIVE RECORDS.

HB1433 Baltz TO PROHIBIT A REGISTERED SEX OFFENDER FROM LIVING NEAR A FACILITY WHERE A PERSON WITH A MEDICALLY DIAGNOSED MENTAL DISABILITY OR PHYSICAL DISABILITY RESIDES.

HB1759 Dalby TO MAKE LEGISLATIVE CORRECTIONS AND TO REPEAL OBSOLETE LAWS CONTAINED IN TITLE 27 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE.

HB1631 Tucker CONCERNING A WARRANTLESS ARREST FOR DOMESTIC ABUSE.

HB1173 Tucker TO AMEND AND MAKE CONSISTENT THE OFFENSES OF SEXUAL INDECENCY WITH A CHILD AND SEXUAL ASSAULT IN THE FOURTH DEGREE.

HB1055 Hammer TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF "MARITAL PROPERTY" FOR PURPOSES OF DIVISION OF PROPERTY IN AN ACTION FOR DIVORCE.

HB1747 D. Whitaker CONCERNING PAROLE ELIGIBILITY OF A PERSON INCARCERATED IN THE DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTION.

HB1985 Ballinger CONCERNING FIREARM POSSESSION FOR A NONVIOLENT FEDERAL FELONY OFFENDER.

HB1713 Lowery TO ESTABLISH MURDER IN THE SECOND DEGREE AS A SEVENTY-PERCENT CRIME.

HB1797 Leding TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS CIVIL RIGHTS ACT OF 1993.

HB2232 Ballinger TO CREATE THE GOVERNMENT NONDISCRIMINATION ACT OF 2017; AND CONCERNING RELIGIOUS LIBERTY.

SB113 J. Hutchinson TO REMOVE A DRIVER'S LICENSE SUSPENSION OR REVOCATION AS AN AVAILABLE PENALTY FOR OFFENSES NOT RELATED TO DRIVING A MOTOR VEHICLE.

SB102 Flippo TO CLARIFY THE LAW CONCERNING THE FINES, FEES, AND COSTS THAT MAY BE ASSESSED FOR A VIOLATION OF THE MANDATORY SEAT BELT USE LAW.

HB2121 Womack CONCERNING A CITIZEN'S RIGHT TO OBSERVE AND RECORD PUBLIC EVENTS.

HB2168 Collins CONCERNING THE POSSESSION OF A CONCEALED HANDGUN IN A PUBLIC UNIVERSITY, PUBLIC COLLEGE, OR COMMUNITY COLLEGE BUILDING; AND CONCERNING CONCEALED HANDGUNS.

HB2234 Ballinger TO REPEAL DOWER AND COURTESY RIGHTS; AND TO CREATE THE SURVIVING SPOUSE MARITAL SHARE.

-15:43 - 3:04:47 511 segments 64 speakers

HB1864 Gates CONCERNING A MEMBER OF THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY AND THE SCOPE OF WHERE A MEMBER OF THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY MAY CARRY AND POSSESS A CONCEALED HANDGUN.

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Matthew J. Shepherd Chair Unverified
94 segments
Representative Vivian Flowers Unverified
46 segments
Speaker 34
11 segments
Speaker 48
1 segment
Speaker 49
10 segments
Speaker 57
5 segments
Speaker 58
1 segment
Speaker 62
12 segments
Representative Rebecca Petty Unverified
21 segments
Representative Carol Dalby Unverified
7 segments
Representative Charlene Fite Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 47
1 segment
Speaker 118
38 segments
Speaker 134
1 segment
Representative Laurie Rushing Unverified
15 segments
Speaker 138
1 segment
Speaker 84
1 segment
Representative Jimmy Gazaway Unverified
10 segments
Speaker 172
2 segments
Speaker 176
1 segment
Nathan Smith Unverified
9 segments
Speaker 184
3 segments
Speaker 190
22 segments
Representative Bob Ballinger Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 199
1 segment
Representative John Maddox Unverified
2 segments
Representative Douglas House Chair Unverified
11 segments
Speaker 228
1 segment
Speaker 233
1 segment
Speaker 235
3 segments
Speaker 238
8 segments
Paul Calvert Unverified
10 segments
Speaker 249
4 segments
Speaker 252
1 segment
Speaker 54
1 segment
Representative Charles Blake Unverified
18 segments
Representative Lanny Fite Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 265
1 segment
Speaker 267
1 segment
Speaker 269
1 segment
Speaker 270
1 segment
Mike Godfrey Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 282
1 segment
Representative David Whitaker Unverified
6 segments
Representative Jack Ladyman Unverified
44 segments
Speaker 259
1 segment
Speaker 308
5 segments
Angela Russell Unverified
8 segments
Speaker 311
5 segments
Representative Sarah Capp Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 321
9 segments
Speaker 325
3 segments
Representative Dan Sullivan Unverified
7 segments
Speaker 332
3 segments
Speaker 333
2 segments
Representative Ken Henderson Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 300
1 segment
Speaker 303
1 segment
Speaker 338
3 segments
Speaker 339
1 segment
Speaker 342
5 segments
Speaker 347
10 segments
Elisa White Unverified
1 segment
Lynn Foster Unverified
4 segments