Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

Education Committee

March 21, 2017 ·Committee Room 130 ·1:55:27
Video Transcript

Summary

Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 13, 2026

HB2028 Sabin ACT TO PROVIDE GRADUATES OF AN ARKANSAS HIGH SCHOOL EQUAL OPPORTUNITY TO RECEIVE IN-STATE TUITION AND OTHER FINANCIAL ASSISTANCE BENEFITS AT A STA… 1:57

Representative Warwick Sabin introduced House Bill 2028, explaining that it would grant in-state tuition and related financial assistance to students who graduate from an Arkansas high school after attending at least three years there, aiming to remove cost barriers and improve degree attainment in the state. [3:03] [3:18] [3:51] [4:23]

Committee members raised several concerns: Rep. Rick Beck asked whether a student with only one year of Arkansas residency could qualify; Rep. Stephen Meeks queried the bill’s impact on undocumented or illegal-immigrant students; and Rep. Mickey Gates warned that wealthy families who maintain out-of-state residency to avoid taxes might exploit the provision for a tuition break. [4:40] [4:51] [4:56] [5:21] [5:27] [5:42] [6:02] [6:10] [6:33] [7:04] [7:34] [8:06] [8:16] [8:41] [9:11] [9:17]

After brief discussion, the chair called for a vote, the committee voted “no,” and the bill was reported as failed, with the subsequent roll-call recorded. [11:14] [11:23] [11:47] [12:13] [12:19] [12:49] [13:19]

HB1937 Lowery TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF TITLE 6 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING THE BEGINNING AND END OF THE SCHOOL YEAR. 16:29

Chair Representative Bruce Cozart explained that HB 1937 would require schools to begin after Labor Day, give the Department of Education authority to issue waivers and set rules for recapturing lost instructional days, and Tourism Director Joe David Rice testified that the current early start costs the state over $2 million in tax revenue and more than $50 million in tourism dollars. [16:44] [17:18] [17:50] [18:23] [18:55] [19:26] [19:34] [19:38] [19:57] [20:30] [21:01]

Committee members raised numerous operational questions-including whether the 178-day requirement could be met, how the end-of-year date would be handled, impacts on teacher contracts, professional-development days, snow-day make-ups, and athletic schedules-prompting clarifications that contracts would be adjusted, waivers could be used, and the department’s rulemaking would address flexibility. [21:32] [21:49] [21:55] [22:04] [22:36] [23:09] [23:39] [24:13] [24:34] [24:39] [24:46] [25:03] [25:17] [25:39] [25:52] [25:56] [26:23] [26:26] [26:31] [26:37] [26:57] [27:31] [28:03] [28:15] [28:18] [28:37] [28:56] [29:06] [29:09] [29:17]

Representative Stephen Meeks moved to adopt the bill, the motion was seconded, and the committee approved it unanimously with an aye vote. [59:13] [59:33] [59:39] [59:44]

HB1855 Davis TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING SCHOOL CHOICE FOR FOSTER CHILDREN. 1:02:45

Representative Andy Davis introduced HB 1855, explaining that foster children often move out of their school zone and face policy hurdles, so the bill would expand school-choice options for them. [1:03:09] [1:03:42] [1:04:14]

Committee members sought clarification on whether the measure applied only to public schools, noted that the language appeared to limit requests to foster parents or children over 18, and asked about potential impacts on charter schools. [1:04:26] [1:04:32] [1:04:46] [1:05:14] [1:05:18] [1:05:28] [1:05:36] [1:05:39] [1:05:52] [1:06:55] [1:07:01] [1:07:13]

After brief discussion, Rep. Stephen Meeks called for a motion, the committee voted “aye” with no opposition, and the bill was reported passed. [1:07:23] [1:07:31] [1:07:36] [1:07:42] [1:07:50] [1:07:52] [1:08:05] [1:08:07]

HB1781 Lowery TO REQUIRE A SCHOOL DISTRICT TO PAY ONE-HALF (1/2) THE COST OF REMEDIATION FOR A STUDENT WHO RECEIVED A HIGH SCHOOL GRADE OF B OR BETTER IN THE S… 1:08:57

The chair presented HB 1781, outlining the problem of remediation costs and proposing that districts pay one-half of remediation expenses for students who earned a B or better yet were told they were college-ready but still required remediation. [1:09:11] [1:09:44] [1:10:17] [1:10:49] [1:11:21]

Several members raised concerns about the racial impact of the ACT 19 threshold, the variability of college remediation standards, and the potential financial burden on districts, leading to an extensive debate. [1:17:54] [1:18:29] [1:18:46] [1:18:50] [1:19:00] [1:19:31] [1:19:35] [1:19:44] [1:20:06] [1:20:24] [1:20:40] [1:20:57] [1:21:14] [1:21:23] [1:21:48] [1:22:19] [1:22:55] [1:23:32] [1:24:02]

The chair emphasized that the bill would empower students to invoice districts and urged proactive district action, but no motion or vote was taken before the chair later indicated the bill would be pulled. [1:26:25] [1:26:47] [1:27:02] [1:27:19] [1:27:51] [1:27:55] [1:34:11] [1:34:22]

SB26 A. Clark TO INCREASE TEACHERS IN HIGH NEEDS SUBJECT AREAS; AND TO PROVIDE ENHANCED ARKANSAS ACADEMIC CHALLENGE SCHOLARSHIPS FOR TEACHERS WHO AGREE TO TEAC… 1:43:34

Rep. Mickey Gates presented SB 26, proposing a $5,000 annual scholarship for education majors who commit to teach in high-need subject areas, noting that the bill contains no funding mechanism. [1:43:47] [1:44:17]

Executive Director Richard Abernathy explained that the scholarship would be awarded competitively based on department-identified needs and GPA criteria to attract the “best and brightest” teachers. [1:44:29] [1:44:50] [1:45:23]

SB542 Hickey TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING THE ARKANSAS ACADEMIC CHALLENGE SCHOLARSHIP PROGRAM. 1:45:24

Rep. Mickey Gates described SB 542, an amendment to create scholarship incentives for teachers to serve in high-need geographic or subject areas, with a pay-back provision for those who do not fulfill the service requirement. [1:45:34] [1:45:55] [1:46:08]

After questions about overlap with other proposals and clarification that no dollars are attached yet, the chair confirmed the bill would establish a mechanism for future appropriations. [1:48:02] [1:48:27] [1:48:32] [1:48:36] [1:48:44] [1:48:56] [1:49:02] [1:49:09]

The committee moved a motion to do-pass, voted “aye” with no opposition, and the bill was reported passed. [1:50:01] [1:50:08]

SB27 A. Clark TO INCREASE THE NUMBER OF TEACHERS IN A CRITICAL TEACHER SHORTAGE AREA; AND TO ESTABLISH THE TEACHER CANDIDATE LOAN FORGIVENESS PROGRAM. 1:51:01

The committee heard testimony from Rep. Mickey Gates, who explained that the teacher-candidate loan forgiveness program would provide advance payments that convert to loans and become personally liable if the teacher does not serve in a designated high-need area, and he noted that no funding is attached to the bill at this time. [1:51:22] [1:51:50] [1:51:55] [1:52:03] [1:52:11] [1:52:22] [1:52:31]

Rep. Stephen Meeks and Rep. Frances Cavenaugh questioned who would repay the loans and whether the money would come from new or existing state budget appropriations, to which the Speaker clarified that the bill contains no funds and any financing would have to be provided in future legislation. [1:52:03] [1:52:11] [1:52:22] [1:52:31] [1:52:42] [1:52:51] [1:52:55]

After additional public testimony from a high-needs physics teacher, the Chair moved to pass SB27, the motion carried unanimously with no opposition, and the committee recessed pending further action. [1:55:01] [1:55:11]

Bills discussed (58)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB2028 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB2028 Sabin ACT TO PROVIDE GRADUATES OF AN ARKANSAS HIGH SCHOOL E…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1017 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1017 Cozart TO ALLOW THE TEACHER FAIR DISMISSAL ACT OF 1983 TO B…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1020 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1020 Love TO CREATE THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY PROMISE LOTTERY SCHOLAR…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1027 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1027 Eubanks TO PROHIBIT A SCHOOL DISTRICT FROM USING PUBLIC FUN…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1029 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1029 Lowery TO EXCLUDE PRINCIPALS, ASSISTANT PRINCIPALS, AND CEN…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1044 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1044 F. Allen TO ALLOW A STUDENT TO CHOOSE WHICH GRADE IN WHICH…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1408 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1408 C. Douglas CONCERNING WHO MAY SERVE AS A PROCTOR OF A TEST…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1456 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1456 C. Douglas TO ALLOW A SCHOOL DISTRICT TO WAIVE PHYSICAL EDU…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1458 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1458 C. Douglas TO REQUIRE A STUDENT TO PARTICIPATE IN VISUAL AR…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1510 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1510 Gonzales TO CREATE THE DEMOGRAPHIC PREFERENCE DISCLOSURE AC…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1517 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1517 A. Mayberry CONCERNING SCHOOL NURSING AND TO MODIFY THE REQ…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1583 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1583 Dotson TO CREATE RECALL ELECTIONS FOR MEMBERS OF SCHOOL DIS…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1612 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1612 Rushing TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING REQUIRED NOTIFICATIONS…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1671 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1671 Tucker TO GIVE CHARTER SCHOOLS AUTHORITY TO WEIGHT ADMISSIO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1672 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1672 Tucker CONCERNING ADMISSIONS POLICIES OF CHARTER SCHOOLS; A…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1673 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1673 Tucker CONCERNING APPLICATIONS FOR OR AMENDMENTS OF PUBLIC…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1674 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1674 Tucker TO CREATE A COMMUNITY PUBLIC EDUCATION BOARD.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1701 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1701 Love TO ESTABLISH A PILOT PROGRAM TO MAKE GRANTS TO HISTORI…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1738 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1738 C. Douglas CONCERNING ETHICS OF MEMBERS OF A BOARD OF DIREC…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1781 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1781 Lowery TO REQUIRE A SCHOOL DISTRICT TO PAY ONE-HALF (1/2) T…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1791 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1791 Tucker TO ESTABLISH A FOOD PANTRY MATCHING GRANT PROGRAM TO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1811 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1811 Davis TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING P…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1820 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1820 C. Douglas CONCERNING SCHOOL DISTRICT WAIVERS; TO REQUIRE T…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1831 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1831 Leding TO ALLOW AN OPEN-ENROLLMENT PUBLIC CHARTER SCHOOL TO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1855 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1855 Davis TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING S…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1859 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1859 Davis TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING E…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1874 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1874 Lundstrum TO ALLOW CONTRIBUTIONS BY A TAXPAYER TO A TAX-DEF…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1897 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1897 Baltz TO REQUIRE STATE-SUPPORTED INSTITUTIONS OF HIGHER EDU…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1898 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1898 Baltz TO REQUIRE STATE-SUPPORTED INSTITUTIONS OF HIGHER EDU…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1917 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1917 Walker TO LIMIT THE SALARY AMOUNT OF AN ADMINISTRATOR IN A…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1924 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1924 C. Douglas TO ADD THE ALLOWABLE AN ENTRY COLLEGE LEARNING C…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1934 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1934 Lowery PERSONALLY IDENTIFIABLE INFORMATION THAT STUDENTS IS…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1936 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1936 Lowery TO REVISE THE ACADEMIC FACILITIES WEALTH INDEX.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1937 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1937 Lowery TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF TITLE 6 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2052 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2052 Cozart TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2101 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2101 Lemons CONCERNING HOME-SCHOOLED STUDENTS PARTICIPATING IN P…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2117 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2117 Sorvillo TO REQUIRE CAMERAS IN CERTAIN CONTAINED SPECIAL ED…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2125 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2125 Hollowell CONCERNING THE EFFICIENT OPERATION OF CERTAIN STA…”
Pre-2017 bill
HR1044 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HR1044 F. Allen COMMEMORATING THE 60TH ANNIVERSARY OF THE HISTORIC…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB178 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB178 Files TO DELAY THE INCLUSION OF A SCORE ON THE WRITING PORT…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB26 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB26 A. Clark TO INCREASE TEACHERS IN HIGH NEEDS SUBJECT AREAS;…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB27 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB27 A. Clark TO INCREASE THE NUMBER OF TEACHERS IN A CRITICAL T…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB274 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB274 Elliott TO REVISE THE CIRCUMSTANCES UNDER WHICH A PUBLIC SC…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB329 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB329 A. Clark TO RAISE THE PRICE THRESHOLD FOR THE PURCHASE OF C…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB371 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB371 A. Clark TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNIN…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB372 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB372 A. Clark TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE PUBLIC SCHOOL CHOICE AC…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB416 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB416 A. Clark TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNIN…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB441 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB441 J. English TO CREATE A LEGISLATIVE TASK FORCE TO REVIEW TEC…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB442 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB442 J. Hendren TO CLARIFY THAT ALL PUBLIC SCHOOL BUILDINGS ARE…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB443 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB443 T.Garner TO ALLOW A STUDENT TO RECEIVE HIGH SCHOOL GRADUATI…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB518 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB518 B. Johnson TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERN…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB542 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB542 Hickey TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB555 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB555 A. Clark TO MODIFY INCENTIVE BONUSES FOR NATIONAL BOARD FOR…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB562 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB562 J. English TO AMEND OR REPEAL OBSOLETE LAWS CONCERNING PUBL…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB568 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB568 A. Clark CONCERNING THE ECONOMIC SECURITY REPORT PREPARED B…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB570 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB570 L. Chesterfield TO REPEAL THE REQUIREMENT THAT A PUBLIC SCH…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB609 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB609 Elliott TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF TITLE 6 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB773 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB773 D. Wallace TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING IN-STATE TUITION FOR…”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 13, 2026
all right everybody in their seats like call this meeting daughter chair sees a quorum somewhere kind of mixed around but we do have a quorum in here all right thank you everyone from showing up today as we're winding down our session we are winding down our bills even though there's still quite a few on the calendar I'll kind of give you a little update on what's going to happen and how it's going to happen to the best of my knowledge representative Saban you can take the other table I'm When I get through, I'll let you present your bill. Do you need a bill? Today we will be hearing House bills this morning only, and if we do have time before it runs out by noon, we may hear a few Senate bills. I'm not sure. I know I have one that has specifically asked to be heard this morning, if possible. and then this afternoon we will come back after session and work on what we don't finish up this morning and start working on Senate bills. We do have quite a few. We have probably, and I'm just looking, I bet there's 20 Senate bills that came in this morning that will be on the next calendar. So today, House bills this morning, finish up this afternoon, Senate bills will start and then Tuesday will be Senate bills and concurs anything after that will be the call of the chair
▶ Play
Speaker 11 1:50
any questions well I do
▶ Play
have a couple announcements today is youth Education Day. Everybody knew that, right? I'm glad y'all knew. All right, and we have high schools and college students from around the state with us today that'll be in the Capitol and may have some here. I know we have some youth here. We have a lot of kids
▶ Play
Speaker 16 2:24
in the back, not you, Starch. We do have a
▶ Play
lot of kids, and so that does mean, ladies and gentlemen, to be on your best behavior in committee this morning you have children here that are watching and that goes for the audience also please be on your best behavior there are kids that are watching we don't want them all to grow up to be like you maybe we do i don't know so anyway represent saving you are recognized to present and i'm not
▶ Play
Speaker 20 3:01
I appreciate you working me
▶ Play
in this morning, and as all of you may see if you're looking at House Bill 2028, it's a pretty simple and straightforward bill. What it would do is ensure in-state tuition for graduates of Arkansas High School. And you'll see there that, I mean, there are a few qualifications, obviously, to ensure you know, that we're extending in-state tuition to those who attended high school in Arkansas for at least three years and then graduated from high school or received a high school equivalency diploma. And really the purpose behind this bill is just to ensure that, you know, when we make the kind of investments in our young people by educating them at the high school level and what we want to do is make sure that they have the opportunity to continue their education if they meet all of the same qualifications as anybody else. Oftentimes, the difference between in-state and out-of-state tuition is the difference between someone's ability to advance that education, even when they have the qualifications to do so. And we create a choice for students to either, you know, leave the state to continue higher ed or simply to not be able to get that advanced degree. And again, we're trying to improve degree attainment here in Arkansas. really shouldn't be any barriers to someone who's done the work who's met the qualifications and so again the idea here is in-state tuition for anyone who graduates from an Arkansas high school and who's attended that high school for at least three years I'd be glad to take any questions all
▶ Play
right represent Beck you recognized thank you mr. chair so is there a situation now where someone that has been here for one year would not be able to get an in-state tuition?
▶ Play
Sure. I think a lot of times these situations come down to the sort of the residency status of the parents, you know, if the parents have moved in from out of state, haven't changed their residency, if they never had residency in Arkansas, and so the young people suffer. And sometimes you have kids who've, you know, spent basically their entire career in a town or graduated from high school, but because of the status of their parents, it affects their residency, and then they don't get to qualify for in-state tuition. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative
▶ Play
Meek and then Representative Gates. Representative Meek, you recognize. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
▶ Play
Kind of following up on that, is the primary situation that we're looking at here, just for full disclosure to the committee, the kind of the, I don't want to say the dreamer, but the undocumented aliens or illegal aliens, is this the primary focus of the
▶ Play
bill? It's definitely one of the situations that people are facing in Arkansas, for sure. I mean, again, young people who have grown up in an Arkansas town, attended school there for most of their lives, graduated from high school, and, again, just because of the residency status of their parents, basically, and not necessarily by any fault of their own, then can't qualify for in-state tuition like anybody else who attended school
▶ Play
with them. Follow-up. Representative, go ahead. Thank you. Following up on that, when parents come in undocumented, if the child is born in the United States, they're given legal citizenship, so they would be okay. What we're talking about is kids who come across with their parents, say, when they're three or four years old. Is that generally the circumstance we're looking at? I mean, it could be.
▶ Play
I mean, certainly the scenario that you've just described would definitely be among the situations, whether they come in at 1 years old, 4 years old, 10 years old. But, yes, I mean, they're here and they're being educated. They've integrated into the community. They're part of Arkansas and maybe played for the high school football team and, again, basically have all of the same experiences as anybody else and should qualify, again, to go to an in-state school
▶ Play
if they've met all the other qualifications. Thank you. Representative Gates, you recognize. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And I appreciate those concerns that Representative Meeks made. I'm equally concerned about some people that have a lot of economic means have chosen to keep their legal residence outside the state of Arkansas so to avoid state income tax. Would this not allow those same people that have plenty of money to have a separate residence to avoid Arkansas the contribution of paying income tax into the state would that not then turn around and give them a double benefit to allow their child to get at a reduced rate but let's say Texas I know some wealthy people who choose Texas as a residency and they've chosen not to, even though they're here 360 days out of the year, would that not give them, the wealthy, a leg up to get a discounted rate at which obviously they're in a position to not need? Sure, and
▶ Play
that's definitely a scenario that I've thought about too with this, and it's true that that could happen. I would say that two things in response to that. I mean, one, you know, you have a lot of the in-state Arkansas colleges and universities that are already extending that in-state tuition to residents of states that border Arkansas. So, for instance, I mean, we have a lot of folks from Dallas who attend the University of Arkansas, and they pay the in-state tuition rates, for instance. So, I mean, that's happening, whether they're from St. Louis or Louisiana, Mississippi, all of that. But one other thing that I think, you know, that this bill in some way addresses that is that you have to have attended high school in Arkansas for at least three years to qualify for in-state tuition under this bill. And so, again, all things being equal, you know, it's better to, I think, keep people here and have them paying tuition here or, you know, at least removing a barrier for people who wouldn't be able to afford it otherwise so that they can advance their education and be, you know, contribute to the quality of our workforce
▶ Play
in Arkansas. follow up well I and I've got my concerns about giving out-of-state students a tax break because it is the it is on the backs of Arkansas taxpayers that we've built our universities so I think we've we're reinforcing that fact that we're doing that so I've got I've got concerns about it because of that Thank you. Representative Sullivan, did you have a question? No.
▶ Play
Okay. Anyone else? I'm seeing no other questions. I have no one signed up to speak for or against the bill. We have a phone ringing. I'm seeing no other questions.
▶ Play
Would you like to close for your bill? Yes, please. Again, not to be repetitive, but the bill is really tailored to be very simple and straightforward Because when we have young people who, again, have spent at least three years in high school and graduated from high school, that means they were there from at least the beginning of their sophomore year. So they're integrated into the school. They're integrated into the community. They've met all the other qualifications to go to college. And by not having something like this in place, again, we create a situation where either they can't afford to go to college, which means they don't attain the degree, those that we want to have here in Arkansas, that we need to improve, that helps improve the quality of our workforce, that helps us attract more companies to the state, that helps us with existing companies and improving the talent of their workforce. Or they go out of state to advance their education. And so I think what we're trying to do is attract and retain the most talented people to keep them here in Arkansas and to ensure that they have the opportunity to improve their lives, contribute to the economy and contribute to our quality of life. And so that's what this bill does. I think otherwise, again, we're removing that opportunity from, you know, people who are already, you know, part of the fabric of Arkansas. And with that, I'd appreciate a motion, do pass, and a good vote on this bill. What's the
▶ Play
will of the committee? I have a motion, do pass? I have a motion, do pass. All in favor, say aye. Aye. All opposed, no. No. I haven't even called it yet, but it is a no. I'm sorry, but your bill did fail. Do you still want a roll call? Yes. Okay. We have a roll call. While we're getting started on that, before Mark makes a deal, let me make this announcement real quick. I missed this sheet, Arkansas Opportunity to Learn campaign. I believe that's what a lot of the kids are here for today, but they're here to observe the proceedings of the 91st General Assembly and the youth across the state are here. So that's what a lot of them are here, and we are Arkansas Citizens First Congress, and we appreciate you all being here today. Thank you. You ready for me to start? Okay, here
▶ Play
Speaker 56 12:13
comes the roll call. Representative Meeks. Representative Deffenbaugh. Representative Eubanks. Representative Eubanks. Representative Walker. Yes. Representative Lowry, Representative McElroy, Representative McGill, Representative Davis, Representative Davis, Representative De La Rosa, Representative Hodges, Representative Hodges, Representative Beck Representative Sullivan Representative Speaks Representative Gates Representative Vaught Representative Vaught Representative Sturge Representative Kavanaugh Representative Barker Representative Barker Representative
▶ Play
Speaker 20 13:19
Representative Douglas. I'm sorry, your bill has failed. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chair, members of the committee. Thank you. All right, I'm looking for our next step is not in the room. Representative Lemons, you're not here. I don't see you. And Representative Baltz is working on an amendment. Representative Lowry, can you give me a good bill you want to hear? which which one do you want to hear first 1937 everyone All right, are you ready?
▶ Play
Yes, Mr. Chairman, with your permission, I would like to have a representative of Arkansas Parks and Tourism join me. That is fine. Just bring
▶ Play
him on down. Anyone on the committee has a bill they want to run, just please let me know. I'm not sure. I didn't really see anybody on our committee that had. I think we pretty well got them all out the other day. So anyway, you're recognized, Representative Lowry. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
▶ Play
This is actually a bill that has not been discussed in the Education Caucus. So for a lot of you, I'm sure this is coming out of left field, which should not be a surprise since it's one of my bills. um but but it is an it's an important uh issue for us to look at and hopefully we can look at it strong enough that we had actually would want to adopt it um the number two industry in the state of arkansas is part is tourism and yet what we have done with having earlier and earlier school starts we have cut dramatically into that that industry and it has a direct loss to to the state of Arkansas in terms of dollars as far as and also local dollars each day in August that we lose because of being in school rather than being able to have the tourism industry thriving each day we lose two hundred thousand seven $793. That's just in state taxes. That's not even in revenue to our businesses. And then we have a daily loss of local taxes of $73,000. The reason that this is an issue that I think we should be taking up now is that other states who have adopted in previous years earlier school starts have actually reversed course. And one example would be the state of Maryland, where the governor actually issued an executive order, didn't even go through the legislative process, issued an executive order mandating that maryland schools would start after labor day so this bill and i know it was originally filed as a shell bill i hope that you've had a chance to see it since the uh the guts of it have been amended in actually specify that uh the school start date would not be until after labor day and uh it gives some provisions there in terms of waivers the department of ed can grant also allows for an extension of the school year but not by much and it mainly the main thing is that it allows the department of education to promulgate rules on how we would be able to look at various breaks through the schedule and be able to rake back days so that we could accomplish this there's not any other month during the year that tourism would be able to regain back what they lose in August. August is one of their peak months, and the numbers are startling of how much is lost the earlier and earlier that we have school starts. But on top of that, we also have other direct costs to public education. It's the hottest time of the year, the highest utility usage there in August while we're having to cool the buildings. There are also issues, and you've seen them in the news, of students experiencing heat exhaustion, those who are involved in two-a-day practices. If you have a later start, the two-a-day practice schedule, according to the Activities Association, would also move later. So you move those football players out of the hottest days of the year in their practices. It also does change somewhat the football calendar itself. We've had some of those early games that are played at Memorial Stadium, where the kids are not used to playing on the reflective heat from AstroTurf, and they are having considerable problems. So all these things, and the thing that makes this difficult, and I recognize this, is it does have a domino effect, that when you move the school start to after Labor Day, there are a lot of other things that are impacted. But the good news of that is that you also impact in terms of being able to regain dollars both for the state, for our economy, but also for our schools. Even if you extended the school year a bit or you took days off of, say, Thanksgiving break, you don't find that same increase in utility costs that you do when you have a school meeting in as early as, I believe, August 19th, maybe even earlier than that. I know charter schools meet earlier than that. So that's a summary of the bill, and I wanted to allow Mr. Rice from Parks and Tourism to give a better explanation of how this would be a benefit to the state in terms of economic dollars, if you'll allow him to introduce himself. If you would, please introduce
▶ Play
yourself and who you're with, and you're allowed
▶ Play
Speaker 80 19:38
to speak. Good morning, Mr. Chairman, members of the committee. I'm Joe David Rice, your tourism director with the Arkansas Department of Parks and Tourism. Representative Lowry's right over the last 20-25 years the school start date has continually crept toward the first of August it's not just here in Arkansas but pretty much across the country and as he pointed out several states are revisiting that issue having determined that actually it's not the best long-term interest of their students and we're asking that you all revisit this as well I know that our industry has trouble hiring people in into August because of the school date starting earlier. We've had to close swimming pools at our state parks on August 1st because all the lifeguards are getting ready to go back to school. The same for some theme parks and Hot Springs. Magic Springs has trouble keeping folks on the payroll. But I hope this is viewed as much more than just a tourism issue because we think that, as Representative Lowry pointed out, it's deleterious to a lot of the students to have to start early. I know I've got some friends in the teaching profession who wants to do some continuing education and they have trouble getting that second semester in because their employers have already gotten them under contract to go back to school. So we think that this makes good sense. In addition, as he pointed out, the tax loss is fairly significant, well over $2 million annually. The loss in total revenue to the tourism division to the tourism industry is well over $50 million. You know, I look around this room and I think everybody at this table turned out pretty good. You all started school after Labor Day and you get out before Memorial Day, and I think we've got a good focus group right here that will attest that this is not a bad idea. And I suspect some of these students in the crowd might sign on as well. That's my brief summary, sir. I'd be happy to answer any questions you might have. Representative Deffenbaugh, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Either one of you, I didn't, I know it's, I think we're, what, at 178 days of school. So have you figured about, would they still end before Memorial Day, or would we take the 178 days into consideration, I guess? That
▶ Play
Speaker 86 21:49
would depend on the approach that is
▶ Play
recommended by the Department of Education. I mean, there have been some conversations about where, and I'll be honest with you, I started out with this legislation of just saying if we could regain a week, if we could just have school start a week later, there's a gain in dollars. And the governor's office had indicated to me interest because of the trend around the country of looking after Labor Day. But when I was looking at that one week of only having to, say, regain five days, I was looking at, you know, ideas like, for instance, I know Representative Douglas has had a bill about how we can make up snow days. We can do that incrementally, I think. We have also, because we've seen a cut in the dollars to professional development, there are some professional development days that could probably be reclaimed. Thanksgiving break, you know, as Joe David said, we all did pretty well with just two days off for Thanksgiving break, you know, but now it's a full week, and I understand the problems there. When I taught at UCA and we had Thursday-Friday breaks, the students decided that that was a Wednesday-Thursday-Friday, and then when you gave them Wednesday-Thursday-Friday, they decided it was time to leave on Tuesday, and it wasn't just the students. Sometimes it was the instructors. Well, that's also been indicated to me as a problem within the public school district that when you only gave Wednesday-Thursday-Friday, one of our larger school districts had difficulty finding enough substitute teachers to cover for the teachers that left on Monday and Tuesday. Well, that's a systemic problem that needs to be solved. That's not something that should be a detriment to trying to adjust the calendar and look at ways that we can adjust this so that it can be, because this has a direct benefit. Those tax dollars have a direct benefit to education. They have a direct benefit to our economy. The fact that the students would be able to keep their jobs longer in the summer has a direct benefit to education. and to our youth. So there are so many different pieces here. Unfortunately, because there are so many different pieces, I know that there are a lot of questions, and there's a lot of different approaches that can be made. I don't know if it would be appropriate if the Department of Ed has any insight into how we could make this happen. Yes, no. But if you want to ask them, maybe they'll come forward reluctantly. Thanks. Thank
▶ Play
Speaker 91 24:34
you. Good. Sounds good to me. All right. Madam Vice Chair,
▶ Play
you're recognized. Thank you. I know from having numerous coaches in my family that football schedules, athletic schedules are set sometimes a couple of years ahead because they flip-flop home venues and whatever. How is this going to affect mainly, I guess, your football schedules if you bump this back? Well, in the bill it says the Department of Education may grant a school district a waiver to begin school on a later date of the department determines. Okay, I thought it said also an early date. um probably the in the promulgation of rules there could be some kind of a waiver in cases like that where there is a contractual obligation um of course a lot of that is going to depend on the activities association because they they have a time frame for which they allow practices before the school start i think they have two weeks from the first day of school or i can't remember what that is but the first game is going to set that oops that practice right and I just wonder if AAA is here to weigh in on that I don't know that of course that's obviously one of the reasons why this doesn't start this would not start until the 2018-2019 school calendar year but that doesn't you know really take care of your objection if you said that they've got contracts two years out that I don't know you know that may give some some difficulty but we certainly knew trying to start it with this next academic year was not possible because calendars have already been announced and I think it's a good idea I'd like to try to help help make it work but thank you may take a couple of years to phase it all in
▶ Play
Speaker 105 26:31
I guess so thank you thank you walker you recognize thank
▶ Play
you mr. chair years ago these schedules have been we're different the school began in September but I recall when school began in July I don't know if you remember that we we went to school in July and July and August and then we were out for two months to pick cotton and do other things that the dominant power structure wanted in some parts of state now so you know it fluctuates but and I guess it's not an issue that we ought to be legislating in my opinion but here's my question is I look at nine months you have a hundred and eighty days the school year we require 180 day school year and bad so that means we end in May if we start in September we take off two days for Thanksgiving, seven for Christmas, one for January, one for February, and then we have spring break of five and by my calculation that's 16 days. 16 from 180 is 164. How do we get 180 days in nine months under your bill? We can't create new days, so how do we get 180 days in there? I don't see it. Now, if you could tell me how that could work. Don't you think,
▶ Play
Speaker 112 28:15
Mr. Larry, our requirement is 178 days, 178 student
▶ Play
days. And there are a number of professional development days uh that where the students are off there as i've mentioned there are five days for thanksgiving break there has been feedback i remember this when we were doing research on the park test that there was concern by school districts that there was maybe too long of a christmas break and that it did affect the testing of the students that they were off for so long that they you know almost had to start over and getting the students prepared so So there are a lot of different approaches that could be taken, and this is the guidance that we would leave with
▶ Play
the Department of Education. Well, maybe it's guidance. Guidance and legislation are two different things. Are you intending this as guidance, or is this a requirement? The requirement
▶ Play
is that we not start until after Labor Day. The guidance would be how do we accomplish that, and that's the rules that would be promulgated by the department. one thing that you might look at are the the snow days that school districts are mandated to put into their schedules that counts for up to five days and with some of the innovative ways we've suggested that they can handle those snow days those may be days that you could recoup that's that's an idea and that's one of the moving pieces that i know uh i think that you had carried some of the legislation even about being able to to recoup snow days in increments uh or you know there another approach would be rather than uh having a complete snow day that you just add 30 minutes to to other school days to be able to claim back that day i mean there's a lot of different approaches um and and i think in you know this day and time you know we've had this calendar has already been mentioned, I mean, for some time, and it has been negatively impacting our economy. It's been negatively impacting, I believe, in many cases, our students, and I think it's time for us to think outside the box and come up with some other solutions, especially since this does seem to be the trend in other states that are also, their economy is centered very much around tourism. We have a few more committee questions. Representative De La Rosa, did you have a question I think you already covered mine I was I was
▶ Play
Speaker 120 30:41
just concerned about snow days being up in northwest Arkansas we tend to take more of them than than the rest of the state does and this could end up having our schools getting out in you know kind of towards the end of June so it sort of negates the the August issue for us because we we would roll into June which would also be a good month for tourism and it would also be hot and so I don't know that it would necessarily benefit us one way or the other so it would just be a shift but that'd be my concern with it is just the the snow day factor because we tend to take more of those I mean three snowflakes fall and we're shut down that's just because we don't we can't handle snow we just we don't have the the ability we got a lot of back roads so we tend to take more than the rest of the
▶ Play
state does I think right representative McGill had a question Thank you, Madam Chair. I do have a question. My understanding is that the standard is 189, 190 days. Under this bill, will teachers lose pay? No, that is not the intent of the bill.
▶ Play
Contracts would be adjusted, and those number of teacher contact days and teacher contract days would still be retained. Got a follow-up? You're recognized. Same question. Will
▶ Play
teachers lose pay? I'm sorry. I thought I answered the question. No,
▶ Play
they would not. Thank you. Representative Meeks. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Lowry, just doing a little bit of quick math, there's 100 days between Memorial Day and Labor Day. take 365 days subtract 100 that leaves 265 days allowable that we would have to get the 178 school days in that difference is 87 days so if we go from labor day to memorial day there would be 87 days that we could have off and still meet the requirement of those 87 days 64 of them roughly would be weekend days which would still leave 23 days for Christmas and New Year's and all that my question then is there are some schools that have experimented with year-round so your bill would allow that the current calendar to fit in how would it affect or would it affect schools that are pilot programs that are maybe looking at year-round well I'm not I'm not familiar with those programs but I would assume
▶ Play
that those programs to operate get waivers from the Department of Education to be able to operate and just much the same way the charter schools do in their earlier school start date they get a
▶ Play
Speaker 134 33:30
waiver from the school calendar all right thank you thank you mr. any other
▶ Play
questions committee represent you banks Rick representative Larry brought up Maryland I graduated high school in Maryland and at that time we did start school after Labor Day but we didn't get out till like the 12th or the 14th of June so I don't and and we didn't have the expanded holiday schedules that we seem to have now we have just two days for Thanksgiving we had I think we got out for Christmas on the 23rd and came back the day after New Year's and we didn't really have a spring break so expanding it into June is not going to really do you any good is it
▶ Play
well it as far as a tourism industry it does uh the their the indication they've given me is that there is no other time during the year that is as valuable as august weeks uh so in terms of i mean even if you moved into june which i i don't think we have to but even if you moved into june you you don't it's not a wash you're still going to gain more in tourism dollars tourism tax dollars in august as opposed to june i think as far as the issue about utility costs august is much hotter than early june so you're going to gain there as as well a good example sir is uh
▶ Play
Speaker 80 34:58
let's let's take uh beaver lake uh in june water's still pretty cold august it's like a bath water so it's the the lake experience is a lot better in august than they are in June so you're saying if
▶ Play
it if it expanded had to expand into the first week or two of June you're better you're still better off than than starting in the middle of August yes sir okay I also had to walk to school in the
▶ Play
Speaker 144 35:24
snow so both ways appeal both ways appeal both ways
▶ Play
yeah all right any other questions committee seeing none I don't have anybody signed up for it as Is there anybody burning out there to speak for or against, seeing none? Would you like to close for your bill? Oh, wait a minute. I'm sorry. I do have one. I have a burning one out here. A burning one. Okay. I'm burning. I'm on fire. You could be. Thank you. And for or against? Would that be against? It's against. Informational. I'd like to end in between that and in between. State your name and who you're with, and you're recognized to be whatever.
▶ Play
Speaker 156 36:14
What? Brenda Robinson, president of the Arkansas Education Association, a sixth-grade teacher. So I did reach out to Representative Larry on last night, and I didn't think you were going to run the bill today. But you didn't either. So there were just some concerns that I had about the student day, 178 days, as well as the teacher's contracted days, which in account we have to have professional development. We have teacher-parent conferences. And I know that he said the State Department would have to promulgate the rules, but I guess it was just a pause for me to what would that really be. And, you know, there's been lots of talk, legislation being passed, legislation that's been proposed that really speaks to making sure that our students have everything they need, all their resources, instructional time, things like that. So I was just wondering how is this going to impact student learning as well and just really wanted to hear, I thought maybe the State Department will weigh on this a little bit today just to see is this doable because I was trying to do the math and I just wasn't sure that I was, I had everything that was doable that could actually and how would this really impact when we really look at what are we about it's about the students and making sure that they have all the time and resources for instruction and just with the bills that are just being passed seem like we're mandating more on students and educators so I wanted to make sure I wanted to talk about that just to see the doability of it and I do know school districts do have an impact on making sure that, like spring break, winter break, some school districts have fall break, so I don't think we've taken into account some school districts, not every school district, because I know it's pretty much being in local control on how they do that, but some school districts have a fall break, like a long break for Thanksgiving, like a week, and then the Christmas break, and then spring break, and then all the other times um that teachers have professional development or school is out and then the mandate on parent teacher conferences so you know how would that impact and would some of those standards have to change in order for um this
▶ Play
to be doable all right um represent kavanaugh do you have a question okay anybody have a question thank you man. Dr. Abernathy wants to get in on this. Come on down. Sorry, Mark, I tried.
▶ Play
Speaker 160 39:07
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Richard Abernathy, Executive Director of AAEA. And our biggest concern is talking about the summer learning loss. When you don't have kids that are attending school from Memorial Day to Labor Day, that's an extended period of time. You could offer summer school, many schools do but that that is an issue you know several years ago we also passed a common spring break bill and at that time there's a lot of concern from hospitality as well thinking that that might cut in on their revenue stream I don't think it's worked out that way so you know this is kind of a local control issue if they want to start school later they can if they want a longer thanksgiving break at which time many people travel uh they can and we just kind of like to
▶ Play
see that left up to local level not seeing any questions yes sir you'd like to speak for again this would be a against okay do we have do we have anybody for first anybody for the bill okay like speak against the bill
▶ Play
Speaker 164 40:18
David Woolley, Superintendent of Schools at ALMA. This may be more of an unintended consequence issue rather than it is against. If you'd like the language in the bill as it reads, page 2, line 11, the school year in any school district shall not extend beyond the Friday before the date observed as Memorial Day. That's hard. That does not leave any flexibility for going beyond that date. The next paragraph says, provided upon approval of the department the week after Memorial Day may be used as a makeup day in any school district which has unavoidably lost more than five days. So we already have a law that says we have to build in five days for snow. We have 178 days required for instruction. So that's 183 days we would have to schedule between Labor Day and Memorial Day according to the language in the law. Well according to my count if you count weekdays starting with the day after labor day going through the friday before memorial day there are 194 you take 183 from 194 that leaves 11 days for thanksgiving for christmas for spring break for professional development for all of those things we need to get done uh during the school year vacations and pd that's almost impossible to make work and representative larry i i don't know whether whether we miscounted or That's almost impossible to make our calendar work. The other thing I would add, our professional educators, as they contribute to the design of our calendar, they are constantly telling us that they get best education out of kids when we have sufficient number of breaks for them to be away from the learning environment during the school year. This is cutting that down. It's going to make it more difficult for us to deliver quality education to children, which is, of course, what we're all about. Those are my comments. Representative Meeks, you recognize
▶ Play
for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, sir, for making that long trip from Alma here today. Based upon the comments that you made, would you be supportive of this concept if we allowed some more flexibility on the back end to allow you to get in what you need to get in in the year? Or I guess that would be my question.
▶ Play
Speaker 164 42:33
I would prefer to leave it alone, quite honestly. but I think the way that the bill is written right now, it's not workable. I think if we're going to mandate not starting after Labor Day, we have to be able to go into June to be able to get our job done. You can't have it both ways. But my preference would be
▶ Play
for us to leave it alone. Rep. Gates, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. In coordination with higher ed and their schedules, would that not make it more in line with higher ed?
▶ Play
Speaker 164 43:06
Right now, I don't have this statistic in front of me, but I believe I'm correct in saying generally higher education in Arkansas begins class one week after we do. In most cases, I believe that's the case. So it's about the same. I don't see that it's really a relevant fact of when we start versus when
▶ Play
they start. My understanding is that higher ed does have some input on this in that teachers who want to take summer school are sometimes prohibited from doing that, especially if they sign up for a summer two. It conflicts with the early school start. So with your permission, we might have – I know Deputy Director Ann Clemmer
▶ Play
Speaker 171 43:53
is here. If I can do
▶ Play
a follow-up also. Or Tara, somebody. Do what? If I can do a follow-up also. What's your follow-up? My follow-up is this. if you have college professors whose children are in in school then there's that week or two weeks that they're having to figure out so if this brought it more in line with higher ed I think it would would it not would it representative Lowry would it not bring it bring some relief to those educators who are in higher ed
▶ Play
well and and that is a considerable factor because when you get into summer school schedules the the higher ed instructors are teaching every day as opposed to during the rest of the term they're teaching their classes on Tuesday Thursday or Monday Wednesday and they have much more flexibility in terms of getting their kids to school picking them up but during the summer with that class meeting every day there there is some conflict.
▶ Play
Representative Meeks, you're recognized. Thank you. One thought I had is, when I grew up, we had the Labor Day start date, and every year parents knew that that was when the kids were going back to school, and I think there's a lot of benefit to a parent knowing, okay, we're going to start every year after Labor Day versus starting at some nebulous dates that changes in August. Could you speak to that logistically? Do you see that being a fact or a benefit or a non-benefit to parents? And that would be to the superintendent. Okay, that's what's
▶ Play
Speaker 164 45:31
on. Right now the present law is we begin, the earliest date we can begin is the Monday of the week that contains August 19th. And you're right, all of us have to look at a calendar to figure out when that is. That was done, you know, for years and years and years. it was August 19th, that was the start date, which sometimes had us starting on a Friday or a Thursday or any day of the week. This was an effort to make that starting date more uniform and make it on a Monday. I don't ever hear that as a complaint from parents or an issue from parents. We don't know when school's going to start. They look at our calendar and they know. Thank you. Thank you,
▶ Play
Speaker 179 46:13
Mr. Chairman. Anyone else? Any other questions?
▶ Play
I'd just like to say I appreciate my superintendent from my district being in here and always giving you know good advice so I appreciate it thank you
▶ Play
all right that was an against I'm gonna go for a four do we have another against all right this is gonna be the last one I'm gonna allow so we got the last one against I think all the departments have hit you
▶ Play
Speaker 184 46:46
after this station name and who you're with you recognize boys watkins arkansas school boards association uh thank you mr chair uh madam vice chair i talked with representative lowry about this and um we do have some concerns based uh on some of the things that have already been presented but one of the things is is we think that the ability of the local community to make decisions about these days that are needed off we don't want to lose that we want local communities to be able to continue to make decisions based upon what's best for them in their communities also I think that anyone in the school business realizes the importance of short breaks throughout the school year those things are good for kids they're good for staff and they allow some parents an opportunity to those that have traveled out of state for holidays things of that nature it allows them to continue to to do that and visit with family and friends whatever they've been accustomed to doing on those holidays and have the travel time to do that and finally there's a lot of things that go on in a public school system believe it or not whenever the kids aren't there you have maintenance schedules that happen throughout periodically throughout the year if you take away those opportunities for maintenance schedules I know for example we used to always finish our gym floor over the Christmas break that allowed us to start into the the to finish the season with a good surface on the floor and that sort of thing so cutting back on this may force districts to cut back on some of their events that they planned during those days off
▶ Play
Speaker 81 48:29
any questions seeing none can i throw
▶ Play
Speaker 187 48:33
can i throw something at you
▶ Play
sure just let me dodge i remember years ago maybe that they were there was a reduction or there was a change in the number of school days for teachers and in and they enacted that reduction and instead of reducing their salary they kept the salary as a way of saying we're going to give you a raise but by taking some of your days off and I'm just kind of throwing that out there as a possible way to give the teachers a little bit of a raise but take some days off of the calendar and I think we've done that before maybe not I may have just dreamed that but well representative that
▶ Play
Speaker 184 49:22
you you may have I may have forgotten it so I'm not saying that did or didn't take place but in reducing the number of instructional days I think would be problematic simply because of what all we're required to do and expected to do during the school year I
▶ Play
just thought with reducing the test days and you know there's some things we've reduced the pd days and i just thought it might be something to throw into the mix so thank you and i'm not being
▶ Play
Speaker 184 49:51
critical when i say this at all but it's not doesn't seem to be our tendency to reduce things here it seems to be our tendency to add uh yeah well
▶ Play
Speaker 92 50:00
maybe it's a new day maybe so
▶ Play
thank you committee i have someone wants to speak for the bill, if you would allow that, because I did say no more, and if Representative
▶ Play
Speaker 194 50:13
Lowry would allow that. Everybody okay? Hey, I
▶ Play
Speaker 193 50:15
love having company down here. All right.
▶ Play
Ms. McNulty wants to speak. I'll let her introduce herself and who she's
▶ Play
Speaker 195 50:25
with, and she's welcome to speak. Hello, I'm Monty McNulty, Executive Director of the Arkansas Hospitality Association. i appreciate the discussion on this issue and and and very much for it i think it's something that the whole state needs to think long and hard about about the tax revenue loss and i know you've heard about that but income loss to businesses the cost of utilities in august i've heard on the news that children can't go on the playground because they might have third degree burns from the equipment out there we're going to school in the wrong month for the south and I think if you'll see what's happening across the country more are looking at going back to a later start date than they were before we have a lost vacation time and a lost travel time for families the point about the teachers. The teachers have basically lost a lot of their summer. There's lost income to students. There are many students that depend on income during the summer months and when they have to leave in the middle or sometimes the beginning of August and can't do that. The loss of employees to the industry. The loss of income for teachers that sometimes work in the summer or even go to school colleges have it would have more time for classes heat again is a problem and it's a dangerous thing football practice is now starting in the first of august and i can't believe that that can be good for our young people there doesn't seem to be a correlation between the start of school and the success of school and i think that that's what we're really all interested we're interested in being successful with school I want to mention the end of school in May and I think a lot of people in this room will admit there are a lot of classrooms that stopped teaching in May I wish we could transfer some of that time to to to make it really worthwhile and give the summer a break there are so many areas of this state that are dependent on hot dry weather and you really can't substitute it from any other time we have lost the most important month in this state we are all for education and all for a new goal and hopefully we can find some kind of solution to this I believe the schools if they're charged with, if they can find a way to make the days work for everybody concerned. And, Mr. Chairman, I appreciate the opportunity to speak. Any questions?
▶ Play
Seeing none, thank you. Thank you. Would you like to close for your bill? Yes, thank you. Thank you. Will you have questions? Oh, okay. Well, before you close, Representative Lowry, we have a couple of questions for you. Okay. Or at least one. You're recognized. um before you close and before
▶ Play
Speaker 120 53:48
we we vote on it um i just want to say that that i tend to support this but i am concerned about the end date so if you would commit that you would look at the wording of the end date to add a little more flexibility to that because that's i think that's the concern everybody's had in the committee is that we're going to end up restricting it so much that they can't fit the number of days in that they need to so if it allows them to go further into june if they need to now i think we should always be working to reduce it but if they need to then then i would be inclined to support this and i'm just going to make a comment i'm going to go right out there on it um i hate the fact that i go back to school shopping in august and it's all fall clothes and i still have a good month month and a half of 100 degree weather so i got to go buy shorts and you know flip flops and all that kind of stuff and then also fall clothes on top of it because back to school shopping actually has nothing to do with when back to school actually occurs because it doesn't occur in the fall anymore it occurs in the summer and I think there's a lot of parents I've always thought that was ridiculous that we're cutting off summer basically a month early so I actually support this but I'm just concerned about the end date
▶ Play
so if you would take that in consideration in your in your closing absolutely I think that that's very good suggestion it probably would just take a small tweak because there is a section that says provided upon approval of the department the week after memorial day maybe uses makeup day and it references uh to contagious disease inclement weather we could probably just add a phrase in there that that they could grant that waiver a lot of it again is going to depend on the promulgation of rules which have come before the alc there'll be a full review uh the rule the the review committee could uh refer this issue back to the joint committees of education so that we We could have input, much like we did on the higher ed funding formula. So there's plenty of opportunity between now and when we would actually be putting this calendar into play to be able to find some creative ways to make this work, and I think it's possible. The one thing I do want to say in closing, I want to apologize to Ms. Robinson with AEA. I did not know that the bill was going to run today. I know we'd been told that only Senate bills, and I'm glad it went the other direction. But I did not think it was going to be run, so I'm glad that she was able to provide testimony. Members, just because something is not perfect doesn't mean it's not good. And this is a good direction for us to take. It's something that will benefit our kids. I think the testimony that you just heard from Ms. McNulty, you know, it's just I've seen it at elementary schools where they've had to keep kids off of the playground in August because it's just too hot. The playground equipment is too hot. It's too hot for the kids. It takes too long for them to be able to cool the kids down so that they can then fully appreciate their instructional day. And so I think that there's a lot of benefits here that go beyond tax dollars, which is that that's an important benefit. When you're talking about $200,000 a day that we're losing and that we can regain easily. So, anyway, for all of these reasons, I just ask that you would give me a – I know one of the members wants to make a motion, so I'm going to let him do
▶ Play
that, but I'd appreciate an upvote on this. Okay. Colleagues, the Education Committee is under new management. That being said, I think we have a few questions. Representative Sturge, you're recognized, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And
▶ Play
Speaker 207 57:22
Representative Lowry, I'm sorry, I didn't mean to ask you this after your closing, but I had the same concern as Representative De La Rosa. If all you could do is change line 12 on page 2 to just say the Friday after the date is Memorial to give them four extra days at the end of the year, I'd be happy with it. I think that would get them closer to that 15 or 16 days of holidays that they already have, and that would
▶ Play
give them some more flexibility. I'd be glad to support you. We can do that, and if you will extend to me the privilege of being able to pass this out and then we can amend
▶ Play
it on the Senate end. I'll extend it. I don't know about the
▶ Play
others. All right, Representative Duffinfall, you are next, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair. In fairness to both sides, Representative Lowry, I'll ask you in a form of a question. Did you know that football can practice all year other than two-week dead period designated by the Arkansas Activity Association? Did you know they could go all year other than the only thing that's affected in your bill would be when the AAA allows them to put on full pads? Okay. I knew that
▶ Play
there was a restriction, and that's a pretty big deal. You're talking about full pads in the middle of August or early August. So thank you for that clarification. Representative Sullivan, did you have a question?
▶ Play
Or Gates? Yes. Thank you. I guess this question goes to the end of the year. If needed, couldn't the department make a unilateral extension if there was some cataclysmic, you know, bad weather that hit the whole state? Could they not in our rules allow that to happen?
▶ Play
Well, the language is currently in the bill that they could extend past Memorial Day if there is an act of God, inclement weather. The discussion we had previous is that we may need to add in there other options for them beyond just acts of God to be able to extend past that. Thank you. Motion at a proper time. Now is
▶ Play
Speaker 217 59:33
the proper time. I make a motion. Do pass. All right, colleagues, you've heard an
▶ Play
explanation of the bill. We've got a motion. Do pass. All in favor, please signify by saying aye. Aye. Any opposed? No. The ayes have it. Representative Lauer, you have passed your bill. Okay, committee, I think next up. Representative Davis. Representative Davis. You have 1855. Is that ready to go? To amend provisions of Arkansas Code concerning school choice. Is there anybody else in the committee that has a bill that's ready to run that's a house
▶ Play
Speaker 56 1:00:20
bill? Okay, last call on house bills. Representative Lowry,
▶ Play
do you have another house bill to run? Because today's kind of the day to get them done. Well, if you want to run it, now's the time. Well, that way we've got to get the House bills out, because if we don't get them out
▶ Play
Speaker 220 1:00:48
today, then that's pretty much going to be it. All right,
▶ Play
so I guess Representative Davis, we'll run his, and then Representative Lowry will come back, too. And colleagues, it'll be House Bill 1855 when he's ready. Yeah, it's your call, Representative Davis. and when you get settled there you're recognized sir and it's house bill 1855 thank you mr
▶ Play
chairman committee i i mean i kind of hate to admit this but this bill was an idea that i had i don't know that i'm as familiar with it as i should be but the bill has been filed for a while and I haven't had any input from anybody really this is yeah house bill one house bill 1855 and I'll tell you I'll tell you generally the idea in the issue that I was getting at when I visited with BLR about this and asked for a bill to be drafted was I had a I had a constituent who's a foster parents and they have birth children and essentially they had birth children in one school in a school district and they brought some foster kids into their home teenagers and they requested to put the foster kids in the same school as their birth kids and this was all in the same district and the district told them that they couldn't do that or they basically wouldn't do it And so I just kind of got to thinking about, and so that family actually had to decide that they could no longer foster teenage kids because they logistically, to keep their jobs and get everybody to school and work on time, they couldn't manage going to multiple schools in the same district. So I got to thinking about that, and I just thought, you know, if there's a population of kids that really needs to be able to have school choice, it's foster kids and it may be that they move to a foster home outside of a particular school zone but they need the consistency of staying in that school it could be that they need to get out of a bad situation in a particular school and so they need to move to a school that maybe their foster family is zoned for or what have you so it seemed like a pretty straightforward idea to me And when I visited with Isaac and the Bureau and asked him to start looking into this, then obviously then we ran into a lot of hoops and hurdles with federal law and existing DSEG settlements and things like that. So that's generally the idea. And so I would say that generally this bill optimizes or allows additional school choice for foster children. um if you ask me a lot of specifics about the language in the bill i'm probably not going to be able to answer it so but that's it in a nutshell okay committee any
▶ Play
Speaker 67 1:04:26
questions representative search thank you mr chair thank you representative i was looking through it and this just pertains to
▶ Play
Speaker 207 1:04:32
public schools correct yeah they'll have school choice for public school and so was it a public school with your constituent that denied them that's correct yeah thank you and to be fair the
▶ Play
district later changed their policy but you know it's one of those things that may happen very rarely would probably be in the same district if it did happen but to me it was a pretty serious issue. As much difficulty as we have getting foster children into homes it just seemed like one hurdle that shouldn't exist. Representative
▶ Play
McElroy? How would this affect
▶ Play
charter schools? Would it? I don't know to be honest with you.
▶ Play
Thank you Mr. Chair. Committee any other questions? Representative De La Rosa? excuse me
▶ Play
Speaker 233 1:05:36
on just on page one and i'm not trying
▶ Play
Speaker 120 1:05:39
to get ticky with language because you said you're you know you've got the general idea but it says a foster parent or the foster child if the foster child is over 18 years of age and as i've scrolled through this as well it all seems to only apply to children over the age of 18 and if we're talking about public school i mean i would think most 18 year olds would either be in their graduation year or already graduated so unless there's some place further down you know that talks about kids under that age maybe it's a different section I'm not sure but I'm only seeing as I'm scanning through it 18 years or older which doesn't seem like it's gonna yeah
▶ Play
I remember many folks I remember asking about that myself and I don't honestly that was several weeks ago and I don't remember Isaac's explanation for that in the way that was drafted but it I remember that he told me it wasn't what it appears to be I'm trying to read through here and see if I can jog my memory because I didn't see anywhere else where
▶ Play
Speaker 120 1:06:41
you know I thought well maybe that's just that one section and there's another section somewhere that refers to kids under the age of 18 but I don't I don't see it I
▶ Play
don't see it anywhere that that language representative it says that you have to be a foster parent or a child who's
▶ Play
over 18 to make the request it says if the fuck oh yeah that's it
▶ Play
Speaker 120 1:07:13
okay that's talking about who requests the transfer okay all right that's probably not the easiest way to word that but I get it now. I get what you're saying.
▶ Play
Thank you. Colleagues, any other questions? Seeing none, is there anybody in the audience to speak against the bill? For the bill? Representative Davis, would you like to close for your
▶ Play
bill? Yeah, I'd say, what the heck, let's pass it. If
▶ Play
somebody has a problem with it, we'll find out soon enough. That's one of the best closing arguments for a bill I think I've heard
▶ Play
all sessions so we're to that point
▶ Play
so I need a motion from the committee I move do pass okay I've got a motion do pass all in favor please signify by saying aye any opposed all right congratulations representative
▶ Play
Speaker 241 1:08:05
Davis you have passed your bill thank
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:08:07
you mr. chairman thank you committee House Bill 1781 by Representative Lowry. Members, this is House Bill 1781 related to remediation. Any of you who have been around me very long over the last several years, you know that this is something that I've had a great concern about. We have, to hear public policymakers or department heads tell you, they will say, well, we're making inroads on remediation. We went from spending $80 million a year down to $45 million or something like that. Well, that was after they went through and made determinations about what were direct and indirect costs. It was just changing the math. It wasn't really changing the landscape. And so we still continue to have a problem with remediation. We have students who graduate from high schools, in some cases valedictorians, that end up having to be remediated, that they can't make the 19 on certain subject matter tests. And so they are forced to take a remediation course that in many cases they don't even get college credit for. And that was really one of my first concerns was the fact that students were being remediated at four-year universities where it was costing them about two times the cost as if they had gone to a two-year college to get the same remediation. I have been satisfied in recent months that the four-year universities, and I think this is going to happen even more because of the higher ed funding formula change. The four-year universities are incorporating what's called co-requisite models where the students can take a three-hour remediation course, then take a fourth hour, which is basically a lab. If they do meet the remediation score, then they get credit for those three hours. So that's a dramatic improvement. But nevertheless, we still have an issue where our school districts are sending students and they're telling the students that you're college ready, here's your diploma. In many cases, even with a 3.0 average, the student graduates. And if you have never seen the great inflation report, school district by school district, you need to take a look at it. It is scary. It's dramatic. The high percentage of students who received a 3.0 or above and do not meet the remediation schedule. So, this bill allows a student, and I'll tell you it's a different kind of approach, but it allows a student who is told that they are college ready, they earned a B or better in a subject area that they had to be remediated in, they get to the university or college and they find out that they have to take the remediation course, and it is on them, the cost is on them, it's not on higher ed. It's on the student, either through Pell Grant or scholarship or their direct contribution. They have the right then, under this legislation, to invoice their school district for half of the cost. And I say half the cost because there has to be some cost sharing here. Now, the cost sharing concept is not anything new. One of our former colleagues, Representative Ann Clemmer, pointed out to me very pointedly that, you know, Mark, you voted for legislation in 2013 that basically does this. I went, oh, okay. I don't remember that. But I do remember now looking back. And what it did in 2013, and this was Act 1479 of 2013, Department of Ed and the Department of Higher Ed shall jointly study issues concerning the testing and remediation of entering freshmen. And that one of the study elements was to look at cost sharing. cost-sharing. This was in 2013. You want to ask me what happened to this study? Well, you don't have to ask me. You know what the answer is. No study was conducted. There was a great impetus in 2013. I remember Tom Kimbrell was Commissioner of Education, and I remember him very pointedly saying, we believe that K-12 has a responsible, We're responsible in this. We have to step up. Now, in many cases, I think we have done some things that are going to help. The fact that we transitioned from the PARC test to the ACT test, and part of that contract is that every student will be able to take the ACT. Representative Fred Allen brought a bill through here that said students could take that in their 10th grade. Well, that gives you even more time to identify the students who are not meeting those 19 ACT benchmarks. And so the school district and the student and their family have plenty of time to be able to retake the test, to go through study prep. As I have pointed out in here and also in testimony yesterday about the fund balance issue yesterday, School districts have a lot of money that they have in net legal funds that could be used for making sure that these students who they've, not just the students they've told that are 3.0, but all of their students, to directly discuss with them their options of how they can get those ACT scores up, how they can potentially apply for and receive scholarships, but also to save themselves tens of thousands of dollars of not having to go through remediation. The other thing that we know is that if a student has to be remediated in their freshman year, they have a far lower chance of actually moving to completion. So it is in everyone's best interest if we can make sure that those students are remediated beforehand. My hope is that with this legislation, it sends a message to K-12 that there is a way, a more effective way, and a less expensive way for them to make sure that those students do not ever send them an invoice. While the student is on their campus, there are things that they can do to make sure that the student is remediated. But if they have gotten out, if they have been sent out with that 3.0, this empowers the student. The money would be sent to higher ed in the name of the student. It would not be a check that the student could use for new woofers or whatever, tweeters or whatever i hey i've heard it man i'm telling you i taught a class where a kid never bought the textbook because he spent all of his money on new wolfers in his truck uh appell grant money so you know these things happen we're taking that potential out of their hands by sending the money to higher ed in their their name in their account and uh i i hope that a single invoice does not have to be sent. I hope that K-12 school districts will get the message and they will do it on their own dime while they have the student there on campus and make sure that the student is truly college ready. So that is the bill and I await Representative Walker. Eagerly. Representative Deffenbaugh, you were
▶ Play
Speaker 92 1:15:56
on the queue first. How come you're not waiting me? I've been waiting you,
▶ Play
too. Thank you. Okay, here's what I've seen, Representative Lowry. I mean, you're looking at it from a college viewpoint, and I'm looking at it from a high school viewpoint. You know, I've seen out some of these people that I'm, like, teaching algebra, too, exactly the same course as college algebra, sometimes almost exactly the same book, and they can pass the test, they know what they're doing, okay, yet they go to a college and then they, in disregard of their high school grade and or their ACT, the college then wants to give them a test over that entrance or that course they're entering. And so which way are you going to decide who, you know, how are you going to decide what to go on to remediate them? That is a pet peeve of mine. There's no doubt about that. But which way are we going to go? Representative
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:17:06
Deffenbaugh, if they came out of your class and they did well in that and they made a 19 or above on the ACT, they would not have to be remediated. There is no way that the university can say, well, we just weren't satisfied with what you learned in Coach Deffenbaugh's class. We want to do additional testing. If they make the 19, and I'm sure that they would be prepared coming out of your class, they would not have to be remediated. That's for sure. Thanks. Mr. Walker, you
▶ Play
Speaker 249 1:17:41
have a question? Representative Walker. I'm still both. Sorry. That's all right.
▶ Play
Either is fine. Mr. Lowry you hold yourself out as an expert on education can you tell me we understand that when we make recommendations we use the foreseeability concept and one is able to foresee when one is able to make a judgment where he knows the outcome that means he intends the consequence That's the usual principle. You understand that, don't you? I'm following you. What is the racial impact of a 19 score? Representative Walker, that? In the high schools of Arkansas at this time.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:18:29
That, and let me just respectfully say that that is outside the purview of this bill because what we're doing is whatever the rate, no, let me finish. Whatever the racial impact is, we're giving the student a second opportunity to be able to meet the score and
▶ Play
it not all be on them. Here's a concept that I have. When you don't teach children to read in the earlier grades and you then require them to test and they test, as Representative Deffenbaugh says, and they meet what's taught to them and that's the line to the test they take. when you impose upon them a 19 or 20 on the ACT and you know that it's going to fail most black students aren't you intending that outcome you intend the outcome that you prepare for now I'd just like for you to address it I know you and I have some fundamental differences and we come from totally different poles and we have totally different intents But how do you
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:19:35
address that? I'd take offense at that. We don't have totally different intents. But then how do you address it? What I'm trying to do. Well, let me change it. Let
▶ Play
me change it, and I apologize. Let me change it. How do you deal with those black students? 80% of the black students in this state who graduate and Hispanic students don't score 19 or 20 on the ACT, and we know that. Now, I understand you're trying to help the students by making the school districts that haven't taught them, in your opinion, pay part of the remediation costs when they go to college. That's laudable. But isn't it more important to cause these districts to teach these schools and have curriculum, which is a land with the expectations that they have? Representative Walker, I would say that this bill is
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:20:24
giving an extra resource and an extra ability to those students who may have been disenfranchised, as you were saying. If that 19 is an unfair standard, and we're not debating that. This bill does not have anything to do with saying whether it should be 18 or 17, but it's saying that as it is at 19, if it does have a racial impact, we are empowering that student to be able to overcome that
▶ Play
racial impact. represent Cavanaugh you recognize thank you mr. chair representative Lowry since colleges have different remediation requirements in different areas sometimes it's a 21 sometimes it's 19 how does a school be able to prepare if one section is a 19 one section is 17 they don't have any control over what higher ed says is needed for remediation so how do they were you know repair for that if they got different standards for different things
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:21:23
how does Let me just ask just for clarification. How does the school district and the student prepare for that higher standard? Well,
▶ Play
you're saying that they should pay for half the remediation, but if it's not a standard remediation throughout the colleges, there's different ones in different areas, how does a public school prepare for that? Well, the
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:21:43
issue is that it still is remediation, and in many cases it is still courses that the student has to pay for that they're not going to get college credit for. And that is really the large abuse here. And I remember several years back having a conversation with the director of higher ed then, Shane Broadway, and the freshman lottery scholarship dollar amount was $2,000. And I told him, I said, Shane, do you realize that if a student has to be remediated in three different subject areas, for whatever reason, that their lottery scholarship is exhausted if they go to a four-year university? It's exhausted before they ever earn a single college credit. And he said, you know, I've never heard it put that way, but you're exactly right. That's the real tragedy that we're trying to overcome, whether it is a 19 or a 21 standard, the fact that the student has received a B or above, okay? We're not even talking about the 19 ACT. We're talking about that they've been told that they've scored a B or above in that subject matter, and yet they're still not college ready. they're not able to meet whatever the standard is part of the and and the reason why they are invoicing the school district for half the cost is because the student has some responsibility too the student has some responsibility to look at as they are preparing for college what college am i going to and what remediation standard am i trying to live up to and if they know that they're not making that 21 they have other opportunity if it's 21 they have other opportunities to make sure before they ever leave the doors of their high school to be able to retest to take test prep to be able to try and alleviate that that shortfall follow-up please you're recognized thank
▶ Play
you mr chair but for a public school who has no input on what remediation is in a higher ed we're going to say hey because in this area it's a 19 but this area it's a 21 and and that can be a difference I mean in public education you don't know what school the child's going to so I mean we're trying to say if you don't meet this particular mediation in higher ed but you might meet it in this other one well that's what we that's what we have counselors
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:24:02
for and and that's why we have grade inflation reports so that the districts can specifically identify the students that would be covered under this that would that have a 3.0 but at at the point of the testing or the point of the generation of the report they know who those students are and the counselors can then call them in and say listen I remember that kind of counseling you know where they say well I know that you're having your score sent to University of South Carolina but here are the realities of you getting a scholarship from there and it helps having these reports because it there is identifiable information so that they can counsel those students, not necessarily saying that they would counsel them to not go to a school that has a 21 standard, but they would say, listen, there are some things you need to do. If you're going to go to that college, there are some things that you need to do before you graduate, and we can help you with that.
▶ Play
You have a question? Okay, I think I have Mr. Gates in front of you. You recognize Mr. Gates? Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chair. Representative Lowry, a couple of years ago at my restaurant, I had a waitress, kept on screwing up orders. And I thought she probably needed to be relieved of her duties. And I agreed with my manager. I'd come and work one evening. And while I'm in there washing dishes, because that was what I was qualified to do, she came with two styrofoam containers and said, Mr. Gates, one of these is a pint and the other is a half a pint. Which one's a half a pint? Three months later, she was given a diploma saying she was ready for college, and her parents were shocked, and she was shocked that she had to have remedial classes. Each year, the school passed her along from grade to grade to grade, gave her a diploma indicating that she was satisfactory. doesn't this bill encourage schools to better engage parents into the education of their children so that they don't get to college under ready, ill-prepared, and requiring that remedial education? I think it does. I think
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:26:25
it sends an extra message that the district and the students and their family need to be proactive and preemptive, rather than waiting until after the fact and us having to spend an additional, I don't even know what the latest number is, but I think it's around $40 million a year that is being spent at universities and colleges to remediate these students who we were told and the students were told that they were college ready. And those are dollars that the students are having to spend. Thank you. I'm sorry, I'm
▶ Play
preoccupied up here. i think i have mr meeks in line next thank you mr chairman uh the question i have and i definitely agree with your premise that there does need to be some responsibility sharing my concern on this is based upon some of the numbers you you've given about 30 or so of students need remediation or whatnot that that cost to the public school system could be enormous um based upon what you said i don't know if you put any numbers together but 20 30 40 million dollars potentially coming out of the public school system to meet this cost until perhaps they get a better handle on that do you have any concern that that money coming out of those schools would create resource issues with them getting the next group of students ready
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:27:51
well and the bill if you take that 40 million you're talking about the the maximum impact would be half of that would be 20 million but again that That is only in the case of students who, and I don't know what the breakdown would be, but you would have students that maybe did not make a B average or above in their subject area and they would not qualify under this to be able to invoice. The other thing is that we would hope that the school districts then would become very serious about preemptively dealing with this situation so that the students are prepared. They are able to make the 19 or the 21 before they actually leave the high school. You know, I've even advocated for the position that, you know, maybe colleges should adopt or accept students conditionally upon them being remediated. And then that gives the school district the opportunity maybe during the summer to actually work with the student, get them up to that point where they don't have to take a remediation class. And they're able to get, you know, here's the thing. If they don't have to be remediated, the numbers are clear. They will be more successful in getting through and getting a diploma, and that's what our goal should be. Whatever the mechanism is to try and get all parties online, making sure that happens, I think we should move towards that. I believe
▶ Play
Speaker 274 1:29:14
I have Representative Kavanaugh next. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chair. On this bill, would it not be better if it actually applied to the students who took the SMART Corps curriculum, not just in general population, that's actually getting ready to go to college.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:29:31
Well, I think, to be fair, you still have to include the entire student population that has chosen to go on to college. It may have been a decision they made after they opted out of SMART Corps, but they still, again, they still have been given a B or better in that subject matter, whether it was SMART Corps or not. there's been some indication through the grade that they they made the grade that they are ready for college material but i i would say that that is probably a a great advantage uh the students would be better prepared if they took smart core and again that's another thing where the school district can be much more proactive in going to the student and saying listen we you know we want you to be prepared why don't
▶ Play
you sign up for the smart core curriculum Rep. Deffbaugh, you're recognized. Okay, Representative, I've got one quick question for you. How are you going to handle private schoolers that have to do the same thing or charter school people or homeschoolers? How does that apply to them?
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:30:34
This only applies to the public school students.
▶ Play
Okay. All right, seeing no more questions. We've ate up a bunch of time here today. I have four and against coming. I have no one signed up for. No surprise. Representative, I mean, I'm sorry, Commissioner Key, you're recognized to speak against the bill first.
▶ Play
Speaker 278 1:31:06
so when i caught representative lowry outside and before the meeting started and he said yeah i know y'all don't like this bill but uh i'm going to try it anyway so and i appreciate the conversation that and it is a good conversation it's been one that we have engaged in in this state for a number of years and we have yet to find a solution because oftentimes we look for magic bullets and there are no magic bullets to this. The real solution to our issue of remediation is to back up the process and make sure we are engaging these students in effective instruction throughout the continuum of their education. Some technical points that I wanted to make the committee aware. First of all, I think Representative Kavanaugh mentioned the issue of SmartCore. in last year's graduating class we had 69 percent of our graduating seniors that graduated smart core and it's about 31 percent that did not so smart core is our default college and career ready curriculum so this this bill does not as has been addressed does not distinguish between students who graduate in the smart core curriculum which we say that should signify that they are ready to move on to college versus those who do not. The other thing that I would point out is that, you know, we have, we do have students that graduate, and they won't necessarily have had math in their fourth year. If you start earning credits in eighth grade, you can fulfill all of your credits before you get to your senior year, and if you look on page two, where it discusses the students that are enrolled in an institution of higher education within two years of graduating high school. So theoretically, you could have three years of a student not have had math in that three-year period of time of any kind. So, I mean, we don't disagree with the premise that there needs to be some action and focus on reducing and not just reducing but eliminating the notion of remediation. we we don't agree that this is the way to do it on the back end we are working and maybe our agencies the department of ed department of higher ed department of career ed working to together as well as these departments have worked in a number of years to look at that continuum of education to make sure that everything is aligned because that's one of the things that we have noticed in the past is lack of alignment between pre-k k-12 higher ed and then the career options so just to let you know that this is something we are tackling and we continue to be open to conversations about how we can attack this even more effectively mr chairman mr chairman let me
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:34:11
make a comment i know that you have other members that want to run bills i've wanted the conversation to be started, and it needs to be, and I think we've got a commitment from the Department of Ed that that's going to take place, and I know you probably have several against speakers. I'm going to go ahead and pull this bill down, because I think the conversation has been started, and I will just let everyone know that if there's any way the Joint Performance Review can also look at this issue, we're going to do that in the interim. Speaking. Pardon? Go
▶ Play
Speaker 134 1:34:40
ahead. So with your permission, I'm going to pull this bill down. I thank you. I believe the whole committee loves you more. I'm going
▶ Play
to let Representative Allen run to the end of the table and run a resolution real quick that I have a bill that I'm going to run, and then we'll continue on and try to get out of here by 12. We'll try to get out of here as quick as possible. Representative Allen, you're recognized to run your
▶ Play
resolution. Thank you, Mr. Chairman and members. How much time do I
▶ Play
Speaker 282 1:35:17
have, Mr. Chairman? 1024, is that correct? Yes, 1044.
▶ Play
As soon as you can do it, the better. Okay. This resolution, 10 years ago we had the commemoration of Central High School integration started, and we did a resolution. And all I did was I took the same resolution that we had before, amended it from 50, and put 60 in there. That's the thrust of the resolution. I'm sorry. we're still working on problems up here. I
▶ Play
have motions of do pass. All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Congratulations. You passed the resolution. All right, Madam Chair, you're on for a minute. I'm going to run a bill. Okay. All right, committee, we're going to run
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:36:01
20-52. 52 for Chairman Cozart. Okay, Mr. Chair, you're recognized. Thank you, Madam Chair and committee.
▶ Play
Committee, this is the act of provisions of the Arkansas Code concerning the schools of innovation and other purposes. Basically what this does, this documentation is the understanding and implementation of the research-based practices of professional learning communities. We brought the funding bill for this earlier, and this is some of the language for that bill and how it will be processed and reported and the budget of it and all those things on that so it's really simple bill you you can look at it as a one-pager so basically this does start the rules and how this is going to work on our PLC any questions I'd be glad to take them representative starts you recognized I said a motion at proper time committee
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:37:07
Are there any other questions? Is there anyone that wants to speak for or against? I'm closed. Representative Walker, you're recognized? I just want
▶ Play
to motion as a prop. We've got you motioned. I'll yield to my
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:37:29
senior colleague. I'm assuming that motion is a due pass. Thank you, Representative Walker. We've heard his motion. Committee, all those in favor, say aye. All those opposed? Roll call. Congratulations. You passed your bill. I was going
▶ Play
to say it was good to be in education because public health was not kind a while ago. Uh-oh. Thank you. Thank you. I don't Representative Baltz has not made it back yet. I'm trying to make sure we got all our House bills out of the way. Is there anyone in the room? Representative Davis, you're good or not? You don't want to run? Not right now? Okay. All right. Okay. Give me just a second, committee. We're going to still try to get out of here as quick as possible. I'm trying not to move on to Senate bills until we actually get what House bills I said we were going to try to run this morning. We may run some House bills after session today. we're not going to recess we will recess we will not gavel out and come back this afternoon but let me get straight on that I want to make sure before I do so just take a deep breath and hold on any of our committee running senate bills for anyone this afternoon you'll have one this afternoon
▶ Play
Speaker 276 1:39:33
oh you have an amendment on 555 okay yes sir let me get let me get to
▶ Play
that Senate bill what? Oh, 26. Okay. That's Clark. Okay. Okay. Let me see what, uh, let me see what representative Andy Davis. No, I just, I think we're waiting on representative Douglas to figure out what she's doing, but I was
▶ Play
Speaker 103 1:40:15
going to say, we'll get that. This bill, they don't have the fiscal impact on it, but they can explain it. All right,
▶ Play
Representative Douglas, you still in the room? Still in there? How controversial is that, Bill? All right, I'm going to ask the audience something real quick. Senate Bill 26, Representative Clark, is there any one that's going to? Okay. You ready? I'm sorry. Okay, never mind. Representative Douglas is back. Is it going to run a Senate bill? Yes, sir. Oh, okay. Well, then we are going to move to Senate bills. I'm sorry. I kept you waiting. No, I don't want to before I'll represent it. Well, I don't have anyone. I was going to. I thought you had a rep bill. I'm sorry. All right, you go right ahead, and I'll run 26. That's Hickey's bill. Senate Bill 542. Clean-up bill.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:41:37
Is that correct? Got a motion? Yes, committee. Actually, what this does is put into code the practices that they have been using for the scholarship. It deals with being able to pay the scholarship in the summer. It's just things that they were doing already, but the code did not match the practice. So Senator Hickey went in and made all those things, you know, consistent, and it will be a good bill to help kids. What's the date on the very top of
▶ Play
that bill? The grossment date? 316. So it's been engrossed. It's probably different than the one that's possibly on your screen. So it has been engrossed last Thursday. Okay. I think both amendments have been engrossed into that, I believe. Okay.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:42:29
I believe so. Okay. Are you ready for questions? I am. I'd like to ask for a
▶ Play
due pass. Not yet. At the proper time. All right. Any questions? Now you can ask. I'd ask for a due pass. I have a due pass motion. All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? Congratulations, you passed your bill. Thank you, committee. Representative Gates, you're recognized to Senate Bill 26.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. If I could, have Richard Abernathy join me. Members, SB 26, first of all, I can, right now, there's no known opposition to this. What this does, and there's no funding for this, this just puts a mechanism in place. this is for education majors who agreed to teach for five years in high needs geographic areas and high needs subject areas they would receive an extra 5,000 year scholarship in their junior year and their senior year and this is a tool to help combat teachers the upcoming shortage in teachers. It also helps recruit teachers in subject areas where we really need them and if they're looking at going one direction or another direction that $5,000 could help pull them into those subject areas. Again there's no funding mechanism for this it just puts it into place and with that I would let Mr. Abernathy address this. Thank you Mr.
▶ Play
Speaker 160 1:44:29
Chair. Richard Abernathy Executive Director of AAEA and I think Robson Gates did a really good job and this is just a enhanced lottery scholarship bill and what we're trying to do is make incentivize prospective teachers who want to teach in high needs subject areas as identified by the department so whatever those needs are identified by the department then these students will be eligible for enhanced scholarship now it is beyond just the the standard because we realized that we may not need 4,000 people signing up for one subject area so it would be earmarked by the department how many in each subject area we need and also it'd be a competitive basis because we want to try to track the the best to go in those areas and so you see there's a grade point average in this particular piece of legislation and but if there's not enough money then that grade point average go up because it is we want a competitive basis we're trying to find a way that the best and the brightest can enter the field of education and help get that
▶ Play
paid for and I'd also like to add this sometimes it's not the classes sometimes it's a the geographic area you're talking about uh you know some of our rural schools have a hard time attracting somebody outside that geographic area to come in and teach and so this may be an incentive for them to say you know what when I graduate I'm willing to come and I'm willing to go serve in those areas and so I think we need to encourage that with scholarship money. It's one way to attract it, and there are needs that we have, and this is one of those things that we can do to push educators in that direction. And there's also a payback mechanism that if
▶ Play
Speaker 318 1:46:08
they don't do what they say and teach in these high-needs
▶ Play
Speaker 160 1:46:11
subject areas, then, in fact, they will be obligated to pay those dollars back. We'll entertain any questions. Mr. Deffenbaugh, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
I had, I'm not sure not arguing this bill, but I need to ask this question. I'd heard Senator Clark talk about SB 555 with the National Board Certification and really quoting some figures along this line. So is this scholarship on top of what he may propose, if you know what I'm talking about, or is it uh is it on top of it or is it uh in lieu i mean is it is it uh is it one or the other
▶ Play
Speaker 160 1:47:00
that's what i'm trying to get at this is actually um those students who have not earned their baccalaureate degree yet trying to get them interested in in high needs uh high demand subject areas to teach so it really doesn't have anything to do with the national board like what you're referring to but we're just trying our teaching pools is going down as you know our number of teachers who number of people who are entering the teaching professions going down so we're just trying to attract more personnel one and then trying to get them to declare that they want to teach whether it's in the stem field or special ed or whatever other field the department says is the high needs at that time but which has changed over the years and I
▶ Play
think center Clark is also going to come and present the the other bill himself and I think that'd be a great question to ask him when he presents the other one Okay.
▶ Play
All right. Thank y'all. Representative Sturge, you're recognized. Thank
▶ Play
Speaker 207 1:47:59
you, Mr. Chair. And Representative Gates, I guess this goes to you. I was looking through it, and I know you said at the beginning there are no funds obligated yet as far as appropriation, but if we amend, I mean, from the way I read it, if we amend the academic challenge scholarship, does that not obligate us to pay for it? You're not supposed to ask me the hard questions. sorry i was just reading it that way and i'm thinking well maybe it does obligate us if
▶ Play
Speaker 174 1:48:27
we're changing the code that currently exists my understanding that it doesn't but i will we would love for that
▶ Play
Speaker 160 1:48:32
to happen but unfortunately it does not uh that the in that's by the attorneys that that wrote this and so there's there are no dollars attached to this right now but that's not to say that we won't come back and ask for some some dollars to
▶ Play
help fund this because we can appropriate but then you still have to fund it right so you can have appropriate you can have the the measure that puts it in place you can have the appropriation and still not have the funding so the
▶ Play
Speaker 207 1:48:56
funding is not there for sure i understand i just i worry about that like i said the wording of it made it sound
▶ Play
like we were already obligating ourselves it puts it into place so that if funding becomes available this would be the mechanism for which those funds to be dispensed we still we still would choose
▶ Play
whether to fund it any other questions you don't have to get my attention we're still working on stuff anyone the audience speak for against select clothes you
▶ Play
know a lot of times Once we come up with ideas that do require funding and it kind of obligates us, I think this puts us in a position to see what kind of response is out there for people to start saying, hey, that's an area I'm willing to go serve in, I'm willing to go take those classes and maybe change my major to go in that area where it is truly needed. And with that, I'll close and ask for a good vote, and I'd make
▶ Play
a motion for do pass. I have a motion to do pass. Everyone in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no. Congratulations, you passed your
▶ Play
bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Do we have time for SB 27? I'll give you five minutes. We can do that. Can we do that in three minutes? You said five. Well, I was actually
▶ Play
Speaker 160 1:50:30
going to bargain back. And you've already used about 15 seconds. So with that, I'd like to give it to Mr. Abernathy. This is a very similar bill other than a scholarship bill. This is actually a loan forgiveness program. It is designed for, again, teachers going into high-need subject areas as well as geographical areas in the state as identified through the department. And so it sets it up there. Again, there's a payback mechanism in this bill that if ADHD would actually be the one setting up the rules and regs on it, But if the student does not participate in either the high-need subject area or the geographical location, then they would, in fact, pay this loan back. They would be eligible for a loan for their junior and senior year if they're in good standards with the university. There is no grade point requirement on this particular deal other than they'll sign a MOU through the Department of Higher Ed that they agree to teaching these subjects in geographical regions.
▶ Play
You know, members, for so long we've seen people take advantage, and then when it comes down to actually serving and going and doing, they're not there, and they've given the benefit. And, you know, the trend for us is to tie the actual completion of what they've contracted to do. If it's not, it converts into a loan, and then they owe us that money back. And so there is not an incentive. We're not paying them on the front end with no strings for completion, and I think this is a good measure for
▶ Play
Speaker 274 1:51:55
us to do that. any other well you guys know burning questions
▶ Play
represent meeks is first thank you mr chairman my my burning question is this who would repay the loans is it the local school districts repaying that loan the
▶ Play
department of who's repaying the loan the individual student that that got the money if he doesn't if he doesn't go it let's say he agreed to go to uh wherever if he ends up not going and serving in that area that he agreed to or she then that become converts to a loan and then she they're personally liable for that as a loan okay so they get the money beforehand from
▶ Play
the department of higher ed and then okay that's converted to a loan basically representative kavanaugh thank
▶ Play
you mr. chair just to clarify this money's coming from the department is it new money or is it existing money is it coming out of their budget where is this money coming from there
▶ Play
Speaker 332 1:52:51
there is no funds attached to this bill either there's another bill that has
▶ Play
no money for it not at this point but this this puts it into place basically so that in the next couple of as we go through this process that we can start
▶ Play
Speaker 160 1:53:08
this ball rolling we're hoping that you find it attractive enough that come in 2019 that we can come up with some dollars to help fund these two programs
▶ Play
i think reps in de la rosa do you have a question okay Any other questions from the committee? Anyone in the audience? A gentleman who'd like to speak for or a guest?
▶ Play
The question was, if I can, is it and or? One is a high-needs geographic area or a subject area, and it's or. It's or, okay. It's or. All right,
▶ Play
Speaker 326 1:53:42
got that. All right, thank you. If you'd come to the end of the table, you're welcome to
▶ Play
speak for it. Set him up right there. Would you like to
▶ Play
turn that mic on for him? Right there's good. Turn that mic on. We're going to have to hurry. We're losing him quick.
▶ Play
Hello. My name is Jason Bailey, and I teach physics. I teach in a high-needs area. I'm also currently trying to get my master's in gifted and talented education. Just as kind of an idea. Stay close to that mic. So we can hear you good. When I graduated from UCA with my teaching degree in BSc in biology, I graduated with three other people that were in my field. There were over 200 English teachers. There were over 150 pre-K teachers. To get a degree in a science, you have to basically get the bachelors that would be associated with that science degree, and that's tough. One of the major reasons why I became a science teacher was because of one of the grants that was supplied from the ADE that provided me the ability to do that, and so this is good.
▶ Play
Thank you for that. Thank you. Appreciate it. Any other questions? Anybody else want to speak against it? Any questions from committee on anything? I have a motion. I will move. Well, actually, Eubanks gave a motion for you. left, but he's not here now. So I got to take a new one. So go ahead. All right. We have motion to do pass. All in favor, say aye. Any opposed? No. Congratulations. All right. We are going to recess till after session.
▶ Play

Agenda

HB1583 Dotson TO CREATE RECALL ELECTIONS FOR MEMBERS OF SCHOOL DISTRICT BOARDS OF DIRECTORS; AND TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING SCHOOL DISTRICT BOARDS OF DIRECTORS.

HB1610Tucker TO PROVIDE ARKANSAS BETTER CHANCE PROGRAMS LOCATED WITHIN A SCHOOL DISTRICT FUNDING EQUAL TO THE FOUNDATION FUNDING AMOUNT FOR EACH EARLY GRADUATE OF THE PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT.

HB1671 Tucker TO GIVE CHARTER SCHOOLS AUTHORITY TO WEIGHT ADMISSION LOTTERIES AT THEIR DISCRETION.

HB1672 Tucker CONCERNING ADMISSIONS POLICIES OF CHARTER SCHOOLS; AND TO ALIGN CHARTER SCHOOL ADMISSIONS REQUIREMENTS FOR A STUDENT WHO HAS BEEN EXPELLED FROM ANOTHER SCHOOL DISTRICT WITH ADMISSIONS REQUIREMENTS FOR SCHOOL DISTRICTS.

HB1673 Tucker CONCERNING APPLICATIONS FOR OR AMENDMENTS OF PUBLIC CHARTERS UNDER THE ARKANSAS QUALITY CHARTER SCHOOLS ACT OF 2013.

HB1674 Tucker TO CREATE A COMMUNITY PUBLIC EDUCATION BOARD.

HB1701 Love TO ESTABLISH A PILOT PROGRAM TO MAKE GRANTS TO HISTORICALLY BLACK COLLEGES AND UNIVERSITIES TO PROVIDE EDUCATIONAL PROGRAMS TO OFFENDERS WHO ARE RECENTLY RELEASED OR SOON-TO-BE RELEASED FROM INCARCERATION.

SB26 A. Clark TO INCREASE TEACHERS IN HIGH NEEDS SUBJECT AREAS; AND TO PROVIDE ENHANCED ARKANSAS ACADEMIC CHALLENGE SCHOLARSHIPS FOR TEACHERS WHO AGREE TO TEACH IN THE HIGH NEEDS SUBJECT AREAS.

1:43:34 - 1:51:01 31 segments 7 speakers

Rep. Mickey Gates presented SB 26, proposing a $5,000 annual scholarship for education majors who commit to teach in high-need subject areas, noting that the bill contains no funding mechanism. [1:43:47] [1:44:17]

Executive Director Richard Abernathy explained that the scholarship would be awarded competitively based on department-identified needs and GPA criteria to attract the “best and brightest” teachers. [1:44:29] [1:44:50] [1:45:23]

SB27 A. Clark TO INCREASE THE NUMBER OF TEACHERS IN A CRITICAL TEACHER SHORTAGE AREA; AND TO ESTABLISH THE TEACHER CANDIDATE LOAN FORGIVENESS PROGRAM.

1:51:01 - 1:08:57

The committee heard testimony from Rep. Mickey Gates, who explained that the teacher-candidate loan forgiveness program would provide advance payments that convert to loans and become personally liable if the teacher does not serve in a designated high-need area, and he noted that no funding is attached to the bill at this time. [1:51:22] [1:51:50] [1:51:55] [1:52:03] [1:52:11] [1:52:22] [1:52:31]

Rep. Stephen Meeks and Rep. Frances Cavenaugh questioned who would repay the loans and whether the money would come from new or existing state budget appropriations, to which the Speaker clarified that the bill contains no funds and any financing would have to be provided in future legislation. [1:52:03] [1:52:11] [1:52:22] [1:52:31] [1:52:42] [1:52:51] [1:52:55]

After additional public testimony from a high-needs physics teacher, the Chair moved to pass SB27, the motion carried unanimously with no opposition, and the committee recessed pending further action. [1:55:01] [1:55:11]

HB1738 C. Douglas CONCERNING ETHICS OF MEMBERS OF A BOARD OF DIRECTORS OF A PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT; AND TO CREATE THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS ETHICS REVIEW BOARD.

HB1781 Lowery TO REQUIRE A SCHOOL DISTRICT TO PAY ONE-HALF (1/2) THE COST OF REMEDIATION FOR A STUDENT WHO RECEIVED A HIGH SCHOOL GRADE OF B OR BETTER IN THE SUBJECT IN WHICH THE STUDENT REQUIRES REMEDIATION; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES.

1:08:57 - 1:02:45

The chair presented HB 1781, outlining the problem of remediation costs and proposing that districts pay one-half of remediation expenses for students who earned a B or better yet were told they were college-ready but still required remediation. [1:09:11] [1:09:44] [1:10:17] [1:10:49] [1:11:21]

Several members raised concerns about the racial impact of the ACT 19 threshold, the variability of college remediation standards, and the potential financial burden on districts, leading to an extensive debate. [1:17:54] [1:18:29] [1:18:46] [1:18:50] [1:19:00] [1:19:31] [1:19:35] [1:19:44] [1:20:06] [1:20:24] [1:20:40] [1:20:57] [1:21:14] [1:21:23] [1:21:48] [1:22:19] [1:22:55] [1:23:32] [1:24:02]

The chair emphasized that the bill would empower students to invoice districts and urged proactive district action, but no motion or vote was taken before the chair later indicated the bill would be pulled. [1:26:25] [1:26:47] [1:27:02] [1:27:19] [1:27:51] [1:27:55] [1:34:11] [1:34:22]

HB1791 Tucker TO ESTABLISH A FOOD PANTRY MATCHING GRANT PROGRAM TO BE ADMINISTERED BY THE DEPARTMENT OF HIGHER EDUCATION.

HB1811 Davis TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING PREKINDERGARTEN PROGRAMS.

MATERIAL OTHER AUTHORED OR BY ANY OF PROGRAM STUDY OR BOOKS CONCERNING HOWARD ZINN.

HB1855 Davis TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING SCHOOL CHOICE FOR FOSTER CHILDREN.

1:02:45 - 16:29

Representative Andy Davis introduced HB 1855, explaining that foster children often move out of their school zone and face policy hurdles, so the bill would expand school-choice options for them. [1:03:09] [1:03:42] [1:04:14]

Committee members sought clarification on whether the measure applied only to public schools, noted that the language appeared to limit requests to foster parents or children over 18, and asked about potential impacts on charter schools. [1:04:26] [1:04:32] [1:04:46] [1:05:14] [1:05:18] [1:05:28] [1:05:36] [1:05:39] [1:05:52] [1:06:55] [1:07:01] [1:07:13]

After brief discussion, Rep. Stephen Meeks called for a motion, the committee voted “aye” with no opposition, and the bill was reported passed. [1:07:23] [1:07:31] [1:07:36] [1:07:42] [1:07:50] [1:07:52] [1:08:05] [1:08:07]

SB329 A. Clark TO RAISE THE PRICE THRESHOLD FOR THE PURCHASE OF COMMODITIES THAT SCHOOL DISTRICTS MUST PROCURE BY SOLICITING BIDS; AND TO PROVIDE FOR ANNUAL ADJUSTMENTS IN THE PURCHASE PRICE THRESHOLD BASED ON INFLATION.

HB1874 Lundstrum TO ALLOW CONTRIBUTIONS BY A TAXPAYER TO A TAX-DEFERRED TUITION SAVINGS PROGRAM ESTABLISHED IN ANOTHER STATE TO BE DEDUCTED FROM AN ARKANSAS TAXPAYER'S INCOME TAX.

HB1897 Baltz TO REQUIRE STATE-SUPPORTED INSTITUTIONS OF HIGHER EDUCATION TO OFFER TO THEIR STUDENTS A PANIC BUTTON ALERT SYSTEM.

HB1898 Baltz TO REQUIRE STATE-SUPPORTED INSTITUTIONS OF HIGHER EDUCATION TO OFFER STATE EMPLOYEES AND THEIR DEPENDENTS A REDUCED TUITION RATE.

HB1917 Walker TO LIMIT THE SALARY AMOUNT OF AN ADMINISTRATOR IN A PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT.

HB1924 C. Douglas TO ADD THE ALLOWABLE AN ENTRY COLLEGE LEARNING CLASSIC AS TEST EXAMINATION FOR THE PURPOSE OF RECEIVING SCHOLARSHIPS.

HB1934 Lowery PERSONALLY IDENTIFIABLE INFORMATION THAT STUDENTS IS OF ENSURE TO PROTECTED.

HB1936 Lowery TO REVISE THE ACADEMIC FACILITIES WEALTH INDEX.

HB1937 Lowery TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF TITLE 6 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING THE BEGINNING AND END OF THE SCHOOL YEAR.

16:29 - 1:57

Chair Representative Bruce Cozart explained that HB 1937 would require schools to begin after Labor Day, give the Department of Education authority to issue waivers and set rules for recapturing lost instructional days, and Tourism Director Joe David Rice testified that the current early start costs the state over $2 million in tax revenue and more than $50 million in tourism dollars. [16:44] [17:18] [17:50] [18:23] [18:55] [19:26] [19:34] [19:38] [19:57] [20:30] [21:01]

Committee members raised numerous operational questions-including whether the 178-day requirement could be met, how the end-of-year date would be handled, impacts on teacher contracts, professional-development days, snow-day make-ups, and athletic schedules-prompting clarifications that contracts would be adjusted, waivers could be used, and the department’s rulemaking would address flexibility. [21:32] [21:49] [21:55] [22:04] [22:36] [23:09] [23:39] [24:13] [24:34] [24:39] [24:46] [25:03] [25:17] [25:39] [25:52] [25:56] [26:23] [26:26] [26:31] [26:37] [26:57] [27:31] [28:03] [28:15] [28:18] [28:37] [28:56] [29:06] [29:09] [29:17]

Representative Stephen Meeks moved to adopt the bill, the motion was seconded, and the committee approved it unanimously with an aye vote. [59:13] [59:33] [59:39] [59:44]

SB274 Elliott TO REVISE THE CIRCUMSTANCES UNDER WHICH A PUBLIC SCHOOL OR PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT THAT HAS BEEN TAKEN OVER BY THE STATE FOR BEING IN ACADEMIC DISTRESS CAN BE RETURNED TO LOCAL CONTROL; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

SB371 A. Clark TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING PUBLIC SCHOOL INTER-DISTRICT STUDENT TRANSFERS.

SB372 A. Clark TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE PUBLIC SCHOOL CHOICE ACT OF 2015; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

SB416 A. Clark TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING THE OPERATION AND FUNDING OF PUBLIC CHARTER SCHOOLS.

SB518 B. Johnson TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING SPECIAL EDUCATION.

SB562 J. English TO AMEND OR REPEAL OBSOLETE LAWS CONCERNING PUBLIC EDUCATION.

SB568 A. Clark CONCERNING THE ECONOMIC SECURITY REPORT PREPARED BY THE DEPARTMENT OF WORKFORCE SERVICES.

SB570 L. Chesterfield TO REPEAL THE REQUIREMENT THAT A PUBLIC SCHOOL OR SCHOOL DISTRICT PROVIDE A DUTY-FREE LUNCH PERIOD FOR FULL-TIME NONEXEMPT CLASSIFIED EMPLOYEES.

SB773 D. Wallace TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING IN-STATE TUITION FOR VETERANS, MILITARY PERSONNEL, AND DEPENDENTS.

HB2028 Sabin ACT TO PROVIDE GRADUATES OF AN ARKANSAS HIGH SCHOOL EQUAL OPPORTUNITY TO RECEIVE IN-STATE TUITION AND OTHER FINANCIAL ASSISTANCE BENEFITS AT A STATE-SUPPORTED INSTITUTION OF HIGHER EDUCATION.

1:57 - 2:24:33 381 segments 54 speakers

Representative Warwick Sabin introduced House Bill 2028, explaining that it would grant in-state tuition and related financial assistance to students who graduate from an Arkansas high school after attending at least three years there, aiming to remove cost barriers and improve degree attainment in the state. [3:03] [3:18] [3:51] [4:23]

Committee members raised several concerns: Rep. Rick Beck asked whether a student with only one year of Arkansas residency could qualify; Rep. Stephen Meeks queried the bill’s impact on undocumented or illegal-immigrant students; and Rep. Mickey Gates warned that wealthy families who maintain out-of-state residency to avoid taxes might exploit the provision for a tuition break. [4:40] [4:51] [4:56] [5:21] [5:27] [5:42] [6:02] [6:10] [6:33] [7:04] [7:34] [8:06] [8:16] [8:41] [9:11] [9:17]

After brief discussion, the chair called for a vote, the committee voted “no,” and the bill was reported as failed, with the subsequent roll-call recorded. [11:14] [11:23] [11:47] [12:13] [12:19] [12:49] [13:19]

HB2052 Cozart TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING SCHOOLS OF INNOVATION.

HB2101 Lemons CONCERNING HOME-SCHOOLED STUDENTS PARTICIPATING IN PUBLIC SCHOOL GRADUATION CEREMONIES.

Page 2 of 4

2:24:33 - 1:45:24

HB2117 Sorvillo TO REQUIRE CAMERAS IN CERTAIN CONTAINED SPECIAL EDUCATION CLASSROOMS UPON REQUEST.

HB2125 Hollowell CONCERNING THE EFFICIENT OPERATION OF CERTAIN STATE AGENCIES; TO SPECIFY THE PROCESS FOR A POSSIBLE MERGER OF CROWLEY'S RIDGE TECHNICAL INSTITUTE TO EAST ARKANSAS COMMUNITY COLLEGE; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

HR1044 F. Allen COMMEMORATING THE 60TH ANNIVERSARY OF THE HISTORIC INTEGRATION OF LITTLE ROCK CENTRAL HIGH SCHOOL.

SB443 T.Garner TO ALLOW A STUDENT TO RECEIVE HIGH SCHOOL GRADUATION CREDIT FOR COMPLETING BASIC TRAINING IN THE MILITARY BEFORE GRADUATING FROM HIGH SCHOOL.

SB609 Elliott TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF TITLE 6 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING DISCIPLINE OF STUDENTS IN PUBLIC SCHOOLS.

SB441 J. English TO CREATE A LEGISLATIVE TASK FORCE TO REVIEW TECHNICAL AND WORKFORCE EDUCATION PROGRAMS AND RECOMMEND WAYS TO ALIGN THE PROGRAMS TO PRODUCE AN EFFICIENT, TECHNOLOGICALLY ADVANCED TECHNICAL AND WORKFORCE EDUCATION SYSTEM.

SB442 J. Hendren TO CLARIFY THAT ALL PUBLIC SCHOOL BUILDINGS ARE EXEMPT FROM TAXATION.

SB542 Hickey TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING THE ARKANSAS ACADEMIC CHALLENGE SCHOLARSHIP PROGRAM.

1:45:24 - 1:55:28 47 segments 13 speakers

Rep. Mickey Gates described SB 542, an amendment to create scholarship incentives for teachers to serve in high-need geographic or subject areas, with a pay-back provision for those who do not fulfill the service requirement. [1:45:34] [1:45:55] [1:46:08]

After questions about overlap with other proposals and clarification that no dollars are attached yet, the chair confirmed the bill would establish a mechanism for future appropriations. [1:48:02] [1:48:27] [1:48:32] [1:48:36] [1:48:44] [1:48:56] [1:49:02] [1:49:09]

The committee moved a motion to do-pass, voted “aye” with no opposition, and the bill was reported passed. [1:50:01] [1:50:08]

SB555 A. Clark TO MODIFY INCENTIVE BONUSES FOR NATIONAL BOARD FOR PROFESSIONAL TEACHING STANDARDS CERTIFICATION.

SB178 Files TO DELAY THE INCLUSION OF A SCORE ON THE WRITING PORTION OF THE ACT ASPIRE ASSESSMENT IN A DETERMINATION OF THE ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE OF A STUDENT, PUBLIC SCHOOL, OR PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT.

HB1612 Rushing TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING REQUIRED NOTIFICATIONS TO A PROSECUTING AUTHORITY REGARDING A STUDENT'S UNEXCUSED ABSENCES.

HB1517 A. Mayberry CONCERNING SCHOOL NURSING AND TO MODIFY THE REQUIREMENTS FOR A SCHOOL NURSE.

HB1820 C. Douglas CONCERNING SCHOOL DISTRICT WAIVERS; TO REQUIRE THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCTATION TO GRANT A SCHOOL DISTRICT WAIVER PETITION IF AN OPEN-ENROLLMENT PUBLIC CHARTER SCHOOL DRAWING STUDENTS FROM THE SCHOOL DISTRICT WAS GRANTED A WAIVER.

HB1859 Davis TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING EFFECTIVE STUDENT DISCIPLINE.

HB1017 Cozart TO ALLOW THE TEACHER FAIR DISMISSAL ACT OF 1983 TO BE WAIVED IF A PUBLIC SCHOOL OR PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT IS UNDER STATE AUTHORITY AFTER BEING CLASSIFIED AS BEING IN DISTRESS.

HB1020 Love TO CREATE THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY PROMISE LOTTERY SCHOLARSHIP PROGRAM; TO PROVIDE FUNDS TO EVERY CHILD BORN IN ARKANSAS TO BE USED FOR COLLEGE TUITION.

HB1027 Eubanks TO PROHIBIT A SCHOOL DISTRICT FROM USING PUBLIC FUNDS TO PAY A TEACHER'S OR CLASSIFIED EMPLOYEE'S MEMBERSHIP DUES IN A PROFESSIONAL ORGANIZATION.

HB1029 Lowery TO EXCLUDE PRINCIPALS, ASSISTANT PRINCIPALS, AND CENTRAL OFFICE EMPLOYEES WITH A MULTIYEAR EMPLOYMENT CONTRACT FROM THE DEFINITION OF "TEACHER" UNDER THE TEACHER FAIR DISMISSAL ACT OF 1983.

HB1044 F. Allen TO ALLOW A STUDENT TO CHOOSE WHICH GRADE IN WHICH TO TAKE THE COLLEGE AND CAREER READINESS ASSESSMENT.

HB1408 C. Douglas CONCERNING WHO MAY SERVE AS A PROCTOR OF A TEST OR ASSESSMENT ADMINISTERED UNDER THE ARKANSAS COMPREHENSIVE TESTING, ASSESSMENT, AND ACCOUNTABILITY PROGRAM ACT.

HB1456 C. Douglas TO ALLOW A SCHOOL DISTRICT TO WAIVE PHYSICAL EDUCATION REQUIREMENTS. FOR A STUDENT WHO PROVIDES PROOF OF PHYSICAL ACTIVITY; AND TO EXEMPT A STUDENT WITH A PHYSICAL EDUCATION WAIVER FROM PHYSICAL EDUCATION GRADUATION REQUIREMENTS.

HB1458 C. Douglas TO REQUIRE A STUDENT TO PARTICIPATE IN VISUAL ARTS OR PERFORMING ARTS IN EITHER GRADE SEVEN OR GRADE EIGHT.

HB1510 Gonzales TO CREATE THE DEMOGRAPHIC PREFERENCE DISCLOSURE ACT.

HB1831 Leding TO ALLOW AN OPEN-ENROLLMENT PUBLIC CHARTER SCHOOL TO USE A WEIGHTED LOTTERY IN ITS ADMISSIONS PROCESS BASED ON CERTAIN STUDENT CHARACTERISTICS.

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Bruce Cozart Chair Unverified
49 segments
Speaker 11
1 segment
Speaker 16
1 segment
Speaker 20
2 segments
Representative Warwick Sabin Unverified
16 segments
Representative Rick Beck Unverified
1 segment
Representative Stephen Meeks Unverified
26 segments
Representative Mickey Gates Unverified
31 segments
Speaker 56
4 segments
Chair Unverified
105 segments
Speaker 80
5 segments
Representative Gary Deffenbaugh Unverified
8 segments
Speaker 86
1 segment
Speaker 91
1 segment
Speaker 105
1 segment
Representative John W. Walker Unverified
14 segments
Speaker 112
1 segment
Speaker 120
10 segments
Representative George B. McGill Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 134
2 segments
Representative Jon S. Eubanks Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 144
1 segment
Speaker 156
5 segments
Speaker 160
14 segments
Speaker 164
8 segments
Speaker 171
1 segment
Speaker 179
1 segment
Speaker 184
6 segments
Speaker 81
1 segment
Speaker 187
1 segment
Speaker 92
2 segments
Speaker 194
1 segment
Speaker 193
1 segment
Speaker 195
6 segments
Speaker 207
6 segments
Speaker 217
1 segment
Speaker 220
1 segment
Representative Andy Davis Unverified
13 segments
Speaker 67
1 segment
Representative Mark D. McElroy Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 233
1 segment
Speaker 241
1 segment
Speaker 249
1 segment
Representative Frances Cavenaugh Unverified
6 segments
Speaker 274
2 segments
Speaker 278
6 segments
Representative Fred Allen Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 282
1 segment
Speaker 276
2 segments
Speaker 103
1 segment
Speaker 318
1 segment
Speaker 174
1 segment
Speaker 332
1 segment
Speaker 326
1 segment
Jason Bailey Unverified
2 segments