Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

Aging, Children and Youth Committee

March 22, 2017 ·Committee Room 130 ·1:32:20
Video Transcript

Summary

Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 13, 2026

SB132 J. Hutchinson CREATING THE COMMISSION FOR PARENT COUNSEL; CONCERNING DEPENDENCY- NEGLECT REPRESENTATION FOR THE PARENT OF A MINOR CHILD; AND CONCERNING R… 0:37

Representative Hutchinson (Speaker 6) explained that SB 132 would create a separate commission for parent counsel to eliminate conflicts of interest between parent counsel and attorneys ad litem operating in the same agency. [1:04] [1:34]

Committee members asked about funding, and Director Brian Welch clarified that the bill uses existing funding and adds no new appropriations. [2:07] [2:13] [2:32] [2:38]

The chair moved to pass the bill, the motion was adopted without opposition, and the committee voted aye, reporting SB 132 passed. [2:57] [3:01] [3:08]

HB1475 K. Hendren TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE APPOINTMENT OF GUARDIANS AND THE REPORTING REQUIREMENTS FOR GUARDIANS. 3:33

Representative Kim Hendren introduced HB 1475, moved to adopt his amendment, and the amendment was approved unanimously. [3:38] [3:57] [4:09] [4:42]

His daughter Gayla McKenzie presented the bill’s foundation on the Texas Guardianship Bill of Rights, outlining standards for ward rights, visitation, and a process for ward complaints. [8:43] [9:01] [9:36] [10:07] [10:42] [11:18] [11:52]

Committee members flagged a possible conflict with a 2006 House bill and asked about coordination with the Casey Kasem bill; Rep. Hendren expressed willingness to modify the legislation as needed. [13:57] [14:28] [14:35] [14:54] [15:00] [15:12] [15:35]

After no further testimony, the chair moved to pass the amended bill, the motion carried, and HB 1475 was reported out of committee. [17:08] [17:40]

HB1915 Gates TO REQUIRE THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES AND THE DEPARTMENT OF ARKANSAS STATE POLICE TO PROVIDE REPORTS CONCERNING THE NUMBER OF OVERTURNED TRU… 18:13

Representative Gates introduced HB 1915, which would require the Department of Human Services and the Arkansas State Police to report the number of true-finding determinations that are later overturned, aiming to bring Arkansas data in line with neighboring states. [18:14] [18:46] [19:22]

Representative LeAnne Burch asked whether the statistics would improve training and case outcomes, and Speaker 45 confirmed the data would inform training and noted overturn rates of 40-70 % in various districts. [20:13] [20:38] [21:13] [21:47]

The chair moved to adopt the bill as amended, the committee voted aye, and HB 1915 was reported passed. [22:10] [22:19] [22:54]

HB1445 Lowery TO CREATE THE PARENT-CHILD RELATIONSHIP PROTECTION ACT; AND TO PROVIDE FACTORS AND PROCEDURES FOR DETERMINING WHETHER OR NOT A CHANGE OF A CHILD'… 23:25

Representative Gates presented HB 1445, the Parent-Child Relationship Protection Act, which would require custodial parents relocating more than 60 miles to notify the court and give non-custodial parents 30 days to protest, shifting the presumption that the custodial parent acts in the child’s best interest. [23:29] [24:00] [24:30] [25:01]

Committee members, including Rep. LeAnne Burch and staff attorney Donna Gay, raised concerns about added litigation, the burden of filing petitions, and potential conflicts with existing relocation case law, while Gates argued the bill would protect children by ensuring judicial review. [32:34] [32:43] [33:17] [33:47] [34:20] [34:33] [34:52] [35:10] [35:23] [41:10] [41:50] [42:21] [42:54] [43:24] [43:55]

After extensive testimony, the chair called for a vote; the motion to pass did not receive sufficient support and the committee reported that HB 1445 failed to pass. [51:22]

SB40 A. Clark TO AMEND PROVISIONS IN THE JUVENILE CODE CONCERNING THE PLACEMENT OF JUVENILES. 52:09

The committee adopted the amendment to SB 40 after a motion and unanimous voice vote. [52:42]

Representative Gates introduced SB 40, which amends juvenile code §927-355 to clarify placement procedures, specify who may identify relatives, and outline notification and assessment requirements. [53:19] [53:47] [54:36] [55:09] [55:42]

Representative LeAnne Burch questioned the burden on DHS to locate recommended relatives and the criteria for such searches, prompting clarification from Director Martin that the department supports the bill and that recommendations can come from parents or children, with the agency aiming to increase relative placements. [56:12] [56:43] [57:06] [57:11] [57:14] [57:33] [57:47] [58:24] [58:54] [59:44] [59:57] [1:00:31] [1:01:02] [1:01:09] [1:01:20]

After limited debate, the committee moved to pass SB 40 as amended, receiving an affirmative voice vote and reporting the bill as passed. [1:01:48] [1:01:54]

HB1381 Gazaway TO AMEND THE 3058TH TITAN II STRATEGIC MISSILE WING AND THE RESPONSE TO THE 1980 MISSILE EXPLOSION AT DAMASCUS, ARKANSAS. 1:09:16

The committee first adopted the amendment to HB 1381 by voice vote, allowing the amendment to become the bill. [1:12:51] [1:12:56] [1:12:59] [1:13:03]

HB 1381, presented by Speaker 45, seeks to amend the juvenile code to provide judges with guidance for concurrent permanency planning, aiming to prevent case extensions beyond 15 months and to support reunification services alongside adoption goals. [1:13:31] [1:14:02] [1:14:35] [1:15:12]

Representative Stephen Meeks raised concerns about the undefined “time period” for court actions and the continuation of reunification services after an adoption goal is set; staff and stakeholders clarified that “immediately” leaves discretion to the court, that adoption goals precede termination of parental rights, and that reunification services continue until such termination, with the department prepared to file motions to cease services when appropriate. [1:19:05] [1:19:20] [1:19:42] [1:19:46] [1:19:53] [1:19:57] [1:20:00] [1:20:24] [1:20:57] [1:21:33] [1:22:03] [1:22:34] [1:23:09] [1:23:14] [1:23:39] [1:24:13]

After addressing questions, the committee moved the bill to immediate consideration and then passed HB 1381 as amended by unanimous voice votes. [1:18:12] [1:18:43] [1:28:10] [1:28:25]

HR1013 Sorvillo HONORING THE 308TH TITAN II STRATEGIC MISSILE WING AND THE RESPONSE TO THE 1980 MISSILE EXPLOSION AT DAMASCUS, ARKANSAS. 1:28:52

Representative Wing (Speaker 166) presented HR 1013, a resolution honoring the 308th Titan II Strategic Missile Wing and commemorating the 1980 missile explosion in Damascus, noting broad legislative support and endorsement from the Air Force Base. [1:28:53] [1:29:06] [1:29:42]

Representative LeAnne Burch queried the extent of the Air Force Base’s involvement and the historical review process, receiving confirmation that the base’s historians approved the resolution without substantive changes. [1:30:14] [1:30:22] [1:30:37] [1:30:44] [1:30:47] [1:30:51]

The committee moved to adopt the resolution, and after an unopposed voice vote, HR 1013 was reported as passed. [1:31:05] [1:31:21]

Bills discussed (19)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1475 · 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1475 K. Hendren TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE APPOINTMENT OF G…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB132 · 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB132 J. Hutchinson CREATING THE COMMISSION FOR PARENT COUNSEL; C…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1445 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1445 Lowery TO CREATE THE PARENT-CHILD RELATIONSHIP PROTECTION A…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1915 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1915 Gates TO REQUIRE THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES AND THE D…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2006 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB2006 Capp TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE INITIAL PERIOD FOR WHI…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1381 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1381 Gazaway TO AMEND THE 3058TH TITAN II STRATEGIC MISSILE WING…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1783 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1783 Rushing TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE VISITATION RIGHTS O…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1906 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1906 C. Douglas TO SET A SPECIAL HUNTING AND FISHING LICENSE FEE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1912 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1912 Gates TO REQUIRE VIDEO AND AUDIO RECORDINGS OF IN-PERSON IN…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1913 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1913 Gates TO REQUIRE CHILD MALTREATMENT INVESTIGATORS TO PROVID…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1914 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1914 Gates TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE DISCLOSURE OF INFORMA…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2010 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2010 Sturch TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING NUTRITION PROGRAMS AND S…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2031 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2031 Sturch CONCERNING THE ESTABLISHMENT OF A HUMAN TRAFFICKING…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2058 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2058 Hammer TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING ADOPTION, CHILD PLACEMEN…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2124 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2124 Leding TO ELIMINATE THE ASSET OR RESOURCE TEST FOR LONG-TER…”
Pre-2017 bill
HR1013 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HR1013 Sorvillo HONORING THE 308TH TITAN II STRATEGIC MISSILE WING…”
Pre-2017 bill
HR1025 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HR1025 S. Meeks RECOGNIZING THE CHICKAMAUGA PEOPLE'S UNIQUE HERITA…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB306 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB306 A. Clark CONCERNING A NONCUSTODIAL PARENT'S UNSUPERVISED VI…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB40 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB40 A. Clark TO AMEND PROVISIONS IN THE JUVENILE CODE CONCERNIN…”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 13, 2026
Members, let's go ahead and get started. Representative Tucker, without objection, we're going to move Senate Bill 132 from the deferred list and Representative Hendren, yours will be right after this. This is going to be a short one.
▶ Play
Speaker 6 0:33
This is Senate Bill 132. Thank you, Madam Chair. I appreciate it on Monday you asked me if I was going to run Senate Bill 132 for Senator Hutchinson and my response was not that I'm aware and I have since been made aware. The primary change that this bill makes is to create a commission for parent counsel, and the reason is because within AOC, both attorneys ad litem and parent counsel are operated within the same agency, and so you have parties that can at times be adversarial operating within the same agency, and that agency is essentially run by the judiciary, So you really have both sides of an issue plus the supervisor of the issue, the judges, all kind of operating in the same arena. And so the purpose here is to create a commission for parent counsel, and so that parent counsel will essentially operate separately so there won't be that kind of conflict of interest between those two different areas between attorneys ad litem and parent counsel. And so that's basically the primary thing the bill does. we can go into how the commission would work, if y'all like. But my understanding is that there's no opposition to moving in this direction. And so I'd be glad to take any questions.
▶ Play
Are there any questions by the committee? Representative Kavanaugh? Thank you, Madam Chair. Representative Tucker, where is the funding
▶ Play
for this out of? Is it current funding? Is it new funding? Where is it going to come from? Please introduce yourself to the committee. Good morning, committee.
▶ Play
My name is Brian Welch. I'm the director of the Parent Council Program, and in response to your question, this is current funding. There is no additional funding being added by this bill. Any other
▶ Play
questions? We do not have anyone signed up to speak for or against this bill. Would you like to close for the bill, Representative Tucker? I'm close, Madam
▶ Play
Speaker 6 2:57
Chair, and I move to do pass and appreciate a good
▶ Play
vote. Any discussion of the motion? All in favor, say aye. Aye. Opposed, no. Congratulations, the bill has passed. Thank you, Madam Chair. And now we move to House Bill 1475, Representative Hendren. You're recognized to present your bill. thank
▶ Play
Speaker 45 3:25
you madam chairman uh merely and i had a have had four kids and we had a boy
▶ Play
and then we had another boy on august the 12th 1963 and he turned out so badly that on august the 12th 1965 we replaced him with a daughter and she's here today she's also a lawyer unfortunately but she's here today, and with your, I told her we had a Harvard guy here, she's here today, and with your permission, I'd like to have her join me here at the deal, and talk about this bill as well, after I blubber on about it.
▶ Play
All right, and Representative Hendren, you have an amendment to your bill, is that correct? Yes, ma'am. All right, and so you're presenting your bill as amended, and that amendment is on your tablets, members. It becomes the full bill. It is House Bill 1475. We need a motion first to adopt the amendment. We have a motion. So moved. Any discussion of the amendment? All in favor of adopting the amendment, say aye. Aye. Opposed, no. All right, the amendment is adopted, and you may recognize your daughter to come forward. Welcome to Aging Children Youth Military. Would you please introduce yourself to the committee?
▶ Play
My name is Gayla McKenzie. What I'd like to do, members of the committee and Madam Chairman, is give you a little introduction to this bill. And I've cried about this twice this morning, and I know most of you say, well, that's not your character, but this is a rather unusual bill. And also, members of the committee, I've got a photograph here on my big cell phone that I'd like to, with your permission, to pass around it and let you see it.
▶ Play
but let's do that afterwards we really can't pass around cell
▶ Play
phones in committee okay but what anyway okay this this bill deals with the wards bill of rights which is what it winds up to and let me just begin by telling you a little bit about why I'm bringing this bill my brother died February the 18th last February and he had become a ward of a guardian and at a hearing without his being present and without an attorney being there and it goes on and on and and I I don't know whether you allow voicemails to be played in here or not do you know that no we don't well that's too bad I she's going to be presenting the bill what what bothers me about this why this bill here I don't introduce very many bills and I don't get them passed simply because I asked a lot of questions and that's not a good way to get your own bill passed but that's not what I hired out for anyway this bill needs something needs to be done about this with regards to guardians because my brother was cut off completely from communication to outside he was told he he he contracted pneumonia and I was told my brother my my brother the federal judge that that he'd had pneumonia I could not find that information from the nursing home where he was being held against his will by the way with this guardianship and so then I went to nursing home myself and asked the question I said can I see my brother and they said no you can't visit him now I know you all dealt built with a bill like that before now and said I said then can I at least ask how my brother's doing and they said oh he's doing this is the manager of that nursing home and the head nurse they said oh he's doing fine I said if he's doing fine then why did my brother the federal judge tell me that he had been in the hospital with pneumonia in intensive care oh they said well there was an incident here a while back but he's doing fine now and then on March the 18th february 18th that same brother called me and said julian's dead he died from pneumonia in the hospital and i asked the question the other day about a bill that you've already run out here about visitation rights but this bill and gala can explain it far better than i can of what we've done here but ladies and gentlemen we need to do something about our seniors in this state not just because i'm 79 years old but my brother julian got a raw deal he's in heaven now and he can't speak for himself and I can't play the tape here but this tape that I'm going to play even has something in it from Lauren Ferris from Ecclesia College so the judges ought to listen to what Julian has to have has to say plus the other stuff perhaps at the appropriate time but that's just a rambling introduction here what it is this bill needs to be passed I say I don't have very many of them but this is a good and they're gonna be questioned maybe about funding and I'll make this commitment I told him we get this bill passed I'll get the funding somehow, some way or another, if I have to stand on the streets of Little Rock and beg for it, or if I've got any GIF funding left from my deal, I'll put it on this thing. This needs to be done far more than some other stuff. So with that rambling introduction, I want to ask Gayla to tell you what we're doing here, trying
▶ Play
to do, with the Speaker's permission. Please introduce yourself. My name is Gayla McKenzie. This This bill is fashioned after a bill of rights in Texas that was passed in 2015 and signed into law, and this is very similar to what they passed in Texas. And this basically, it's a blueprint. It sets out some standards and guidelines for both the ward and the guardian. I think we all see, and many states are beginning to recognize there's a lot of, although there's some good guardians out there doing a great job there's some there's some abuse going on with these guardianship sometimes it's they don't understand they think they just have full power so this sets out as you'll see and in these different subdivisions here different rights that the guardian has and and of course it starts off with the with the reference here that of course it's it's that if it's not already in and applied by law or by the court's order then it goes and sets out these different rights for the guardian rights for visitation rights for control of their personal environment you'll see right to be treated with respect to receive communication oftentimes some guardians and we've heard references to this in the past with the casey casein case are cutting off communication with relatives, cutting off communication, intercepting their mail. So this sets forth a number of different standards and rights that the ward has, and it also sets forth an avenue for the ward to have an opportunity to be heard from the court if there's an abuse in the guardianship proceedings. Oftentimes the ward will have assets and can afford to hire an attorney, but of course once you've been declared incompetent by the court how do you go and hire an attorney and that's a real problem for a lot of these wards and then also with the more there's indigent it's difficult for them is that of course they can certainly contact DHS but sometimes they don't know how to do that and the ward is and sometimes the guardian is cutting off people who are trying to help that ward get access to these different services so one of the provisions here of course says that the guardian will receive, excuse me, the ward will receive a list of different areas, different departments that they can reach out to, to have a, to receive help. So it's a number of different provisions that we think address the problems to help get a ward some relief, to provide them with the least restrictive environment. In researching what when the background with the Texas Bill of Rights many cases came up where the wards said you know all of a sudden I became a award the state and I stopped living and I now exist I can't make any decisions and if I and if my guardian gets upset with my son their brother or their sister I can't see them anymore and so this provides a way and you'll see provisions here where that where the guardian can't restrict that access now they can in instances where the guardian believes that will be harmful for their ward but it also gives the ward an opportunity to have that revisited and and to have a voice in that so this we believe is a good law I noticed when I was researching this a number of states have already passed some wards bill of rights others are working their way through the legislature this year to address these problems where overreaching by the guardian and their frustration with the ward, and how do I get out and get help for a guardianship that's too restrictive and has deprived me of basic rights. In closing, I like to say with a felon, they have often a convicted felon has more rights than a ward. And yet, how sad it is that right now we don't have a requirement that a potential ward be represented in court. They have the right, but there's no requirement. And even another issue we have is they can waive that right. They can waive their right to counsel. And how sad that is, the petition saying, we believe this person's incapacitated and can't make decisions for themselves, and yet the court will entertain a waiver of notice or a waiver of counsel by that potential ward. So we're trying to address a number of these items and give the ward here in Arkansas recognize their rights. We're all potential wards someday. And as I read this, I think this is what I would want if I were a ward. So that's the hope. All right,
▶ Play
thank you. Are there questions by committee members? is there anyone in the audience who wished oh excuse me we do have some representative birch you're recognized and i'm going to apologize ahead of time because i didn't
▶ Play
look up the specifics but on the conflicts report which i started actually paying attention to way too late in the session it says that there was a potential conflict with um 2006 house bill 2006 on one of the paragraphs, and that's also in this committee. I don't know if Representative Kapp is going to present it. If there is a conflict, are you willing to, Representative Hendren, at least look at resolving that conflict if that one also gets out of committee today? And I don't know whether it will. I don't know what the specific conflict is, but I know there's a paragraph that's potentially in conflict with the other guardianship bill. Absolutely.
▶ Play
Our main concern is to get some help into the courts and to the ward, just to make this thing work better for the people of Arkansas. So we're open to whatever modification or amendments that need to be made to make this thing work. So absolutely. I think that
▶ Play
was my question as well. With the bill that we heard recently that was called the Casey Kasem bill, was how these two would dovetail. And I don't know if you've had an opportunity, either of you, to look at that and see there were a lot of overlaps with this bill.
▶ Play
I'll respond first to that. On the floor, when that bill came up, because I'm not a member of this committee and I hadn't heard about it, but as Representative Beck was presenting that bill, you may recall I asked these dumb questions. I stood at that time and asked him, because that bill talks a lot about the Department of DHS and other things, and my specific question was, and it was primarily related back to my burden on this thing, was this also apply to individual guardianships. And my understanding is that it does. So hopefully that will complement what we're trying to do here. But Gaila may have something more to say about the ward's opportunity. In our particular case, the ward, the prospective ward, which was my brother, wasn't present at the hearing. He didn't have an attorney there. He thought he was gonna have, he had told me, but he didn't have one. And I have on the tape here where the guardian insisted and wanted me to promise not to be there. Well, I was listening to that deal when they talked about that, and then I heard the song on her radio station, said he's not heavy, he's my brother. And when I listened to that song and liked music, I went to the hearing. And the judge allowed Gayla and me to speak in Julian's behalf at that hearing, even though his table was empty. There was no lawyer. He was not there at the hearing. But at the other hearing was the proposed prospective guardian with two attorneys hired by the ward's money, and then two people representing the nursing home and the facility that will be collecting the $7,000 or $8,000 or $10,000 a month. But the judge did allow us to make a statement, but then he said this, and I think this is what Gayla and Texas and others have tried to do here. The judge said, you realize I'm going to let this hearing proceed, which he did, and we know the rest of the story. He said, I'm going to let the hearing proceed, but he said this. He said, you know, this can be revisited. The problem is how do you do it? How do you do it?
▶ Play
I don't think we had anyone in the audience signed up to speak for or against the bill. What are the wishes of the committee? Is there any discussion of the motion? All in favor say aye. Opposed, no. Congratulations. The bill has passed. Madam Chairman, I want to say anything. Excuse me. It has passed as amended. Okay. Could I just say that the Office of the Courts, we've talked to Donna this morning,
▶ Play
and we've told her, as we told the members here, whatever needs to be done to make this bill workable, we're amenable to doing that at whatever point it needs to be done. Thank
▶ Play
you. All right. Thank you. And Representative Gates, I believe you have a bill to present to us this morning. House Bill 1915 is the one you had told me you would be running is that correct? That is correct.
▶ Play
Speaker 45 18:14
And you're recognized. Thank you Madam Chair and has amendment been put is that engrossed or is there an amendment to it? I think it 1915 in 1915 I think it had it's engrossed okay good this has to do the amendment was I don't know if Misha is here it was actually Misha's amendment asked me to put in there this just this goes to A similar report that we've asked for during the interim, but this is requiring the states to give us a report as to when people are found, I have to get the wording right, when true findings are found, this gives a report of how many are overturned. one of the things that we found that our true findings were double that of our surrounding states, but when you redact the amount that are overturned when it finally gets in front of a judge, it puts us more in line with our surrounding states, and so this kind of gives us a report to what our real numbers are because if you look at the initial report, it looks like Arkansans are twice as bad at maltreatment and everything else, and this just makes some public statements that after we get a judge finally looking at these cases, that we're in line with other states.
▶ Play
And that's all this basic does. Representative Birch, you're recognized for a question. Thank
▶ Play
you, Madam Chair. You know it wouldn't be right
▶ Play
Speaker 48 20:07
if I just didn't ask you a question, right? I do. I was already aiming
▶ Play
right at you. Thank you. Well, then this one's going to be a little bit of a soft touch. Make it easy, would you? Would you agree with me that the statistics that may be gathered after this is implemented will help even in the training of the investigators and potentially have more ability to put the administrative judge's findings better to work for the people of Arkansas?
▶ Play
Speaker 45 20:38
Absolutely. In fact, one of the things that we found after getting some of those reports back was that some of our actual best trainings doesn't come at the front end. It actually comes at the end, or it comes after the initial training, and that has to do with federal funding. And so I think that's a great point. But, yes, that gives us some real springboard of what numbers that we're really dealing with. And one of the things also that I originally had in there and took out, and I thought it was reasonable, is that if, I know in my district, I think statewide we have around 40% that are overturned. In my district, it's 70%. 70% are overturned. I mean, you can almost flip a coin and get a better odds. And what I took out was the report will not show individual reports. But the individual reports will be available to us as legislators so that we can get some real numbers. And that will also, if the department has the real numbers of the overturn rate individually, then I think that we'll see the overall number come down. Any other
▶ Play
questions by the committee? I don't think we have anyone in the audience to overlook anyone who wishes to speak for or against this bill. All right, would you like to close for your bill? I'm closed. I appreciate it. I make a
▶ Play
Speaker 45 22:10
motion for D. Bass. Ask for a good vote. Any discussion of the motion?
▶ Play
As amended, thank you. As amended. As amended. Oh, it's already engrossed, so we don't have to do that. All right, we're good. All in favor, say aye. Opposed, no. Congratulations, the bill has passed. Representative Lowry, I believe you have a bill for us today. And what is your bill number, Representative Lowry? 1445. Representative Lowry, you're recognized to present House Bill 1445. Good morning, members.
▶ Play
I've been before you on this bill previously and
▶ Play
Speaker 45 23:02
over the last weeks have chatted to some of you personally about it and also just gathered feedback about some of the misconceptions that may be out there about this legislation. And let me just first say the background of this is trying to, you know, we hear so many times that one of the problems that we have with children who are not doing well in school or end up being incarcerated or whatever is the lack of a full family influence. And so the impact of this bill or the goal of this bill is to make sure where it is desired and where it is possible that a child has no encumbrances to relationships with both parents and also with extended family. That would include grandparents. We've heard legislation from Representative Rushing about grandparents' rights and making sure that nothing separates that and nothing upsets that we currently have in Arkansas law that says if a custodial parent chooses to relocate no matter where 60 miles 200 miles a thousand miles they have an absolute right to be able to do that. They have little to no requirement upon them to even let the non-custodial parent know other than that the non-custodial parent's visitation rights will be influenced. They have no requirement to notify the courts. And really all this legislation does is says that if you are going to relocate outside of 60 miles, which potentially could cause separation from the child and the non-custodial parent, then you have to notify the court that you're going to do that. And that is within all kinds of guidelines when it comes to custody arrangements, because you are changing the material circumstances of the situation. Not the non-custodial parent, they're not changing the material circumstances, the custodial parent is doing that by making this move. And so it requires then that notification. The non-custodial parent is then notified, and then they have 30 days to file a protest. I want to focus on that. I think part of the blowback that we get from judges on this is that they think that this is going to create a groundswell of new custody cases. And I don't believe that that's the case because the parent, the non-custodial parent, has 30 days to respond. And if they find that the 61-mile move is not unduly burdensome, then they may not challenge it. But they should have the right to be able to challenge it, especially if it's a situation like 1,000 miles. And I've given you an anecdotal example of where that happened to one mother who, for whatever the reason, was the non-custodial parent. And all the expense came on her then to have to travel to see the child or during extended break, spring break, Christmas break, summer break, all the expense was on the non-custodial parent to have the child flown back. The other thing that it also does, beyond notice, is it also removes this presumption that the custodial parent is acting in the best interest of the child. That's not necessarily the case in a move where they are moving away from extended family. They're moving away from the non-custodial parent. They're moving away from maybe even both sets of grandparents. They're moving away from the school that the child has become acclimated to. We cannot presume that that custodial parent is acting in their best interest because their best interest, or they may not be acting in the best interest of the child. They may be acting in their best interest, they probably are. I know it's been referenced that this bill would somehow handcuff a custodial parent from being able to pursue an employment opportunity or an educational opportunity. And those are criteria that have to be taken into consideration. But they need to be taken into consideration by someone who is looking out for the best interest of the child. We've decided in many cases, in most cases, that the best person to do that is the judge who has jurisdiction over that case, who retains jurisdiction over that case so we're all we're doing here is saying then there's a there's an even playing field for the judge to take into consideration everything including the employment situation that may be a benefit especially if it is an increase in pay that would be a benefit so that be in the plus column but the judge would also look at the fact that maybe Maybe the child is being removed from a daily input from grandparents, from friends, from siblings, from all kinds of extended family. That would be in the negative column. And I think we have to put those who we elect or place in positions of these types of authority, these decision-making authority, we have to give them that responsibility. Now it's been brought up to me. One piece of feedback that I received from a member was, well, can't we just go ahead and maybe pass a law that says, that requires some notification in the original custodial agreement that the two parties would go back to court if there is a change, if there is a relocation? I think that's a reasonable statement to make, but as I referenced the last time in in an analysis by Mr. Patrick Lewis, who's a family law attorney, he says even a written agreement as part of a divorce decree or a settlement agreement that says both parents agree to stay within a certain geographic distance is void under current Arkansas law. So even trying to preemptively acknowledge this, if you've never been through divorce, especially with children involved, um you can't you cannot know um how difficult it is to try and anticipate every possible scenario to be able to look five years ten years down the line because frankly all you're concerned about is that one day you were tucking your kids into bed every night and then because of a judge's order having to wait every other weekend. I've been there. All I was concerned about is what can I do to be present in my child's life now. I didn't have the foresight to look ahead five years or ten years. There's other conditions that are also there where you just don't want to do anything that would anger your ex-spouse because you're in the process of negotiation. Of course attorneys have told me well that's the that's that's why we're here we're here so that you're not the bad guy well a lot of times you give up a lot of ground that you maybe shouldn't so what would what I'm asking that you do with this legislation and I understand understand you're going to hear from the judicial count judicial counsel that you the judges they don't like it they don't they don't like it this change. They may even say they don't like the legislature telling them what they have to do. Well, you know how I feel, and a lot of you feel about how we feel about the judicial branch telling us what we can do or what we can't do. So, you know, that's a fight for another day. But it shouldn't get in the way of talking about seriously what is in the best interest of children. That's what this is about. One parent should not be able to make that decision without having it be reviewed by somebody who is in an impartial place to make the judgment, to do the plus column, the minus column, to make a look at all the different characteristics and criteria of the situation and then make a determination whether it is in the best interest of the child. So I'm asking you today to vote for this legislation, to give it a due pass so that we can protect the interest of that child, so we can at least give the judge an opportunity to maybe appoint an ad litem who could also do that balancing act and not put it all in the hands of one parent who may or may not because of pressures that are on them acting in the best interest of the child. So I stand open for questions. to Birch for a question madam chair yes
▶ Play
you're recognized for your question thank you madam chair as I read this representative Lowry if I were the custodial parent and the the court the original court hearing for the divorce and they approved the custody arrangement was in Monticello Arkansas and I wanted to move with the children to Little Rock Arkansas which is outside that 60 miles, and I was still able to fulfill every requirement of the original visitation order. As I read this, were it to pass into law as written now, I would still have to file a petition giving all this disclosure of very specific information about where I'm going to have my children to include that street address in Little Rock for public record. even though I could still fulfill all those requirements in the original order I would have to do that plus have based on the second provision a second custodial hearing another custodial hearing just because I wanted to move from Monticello to Little Rock where the job opportunities were better am I reading this wrong? well
▶ Play
Speaker 45 33:47
what is there is that you do have to file that petition, but it may not culminate in a hearing if the non-custodial parent feels like you are doing everything possible to make sure that visitation is allowed. And so in that case, and I think this is where the judicial hysteria comes from, is this attitude that we're going to be overrun by new custodial cases. That's not the case. Parents, non-custodial parents may not object to a move that's 61 miles or maybe 100 miles if, as you say in your scenario, that the custodial parent has done everything they can to make sure that visitation rights are fully upheld. You're recognized. Thank you,
▶ Play
Madam Chair. If I put into the scenario that there was a pretty contentious litigation of that divorce and anything that other spouse could do to make my life miserable, and that might be part of the reason I'm moving from Monticello to Little Rock, would be in play. and all they have to do is file a response. They only have to have an attorney to do that to cause me to have to do this additional litigation and get into court. Is there some protection for me from basically continuing that custodial fight that I just went through with that original divorce? Completely hypothetical, by the way. I understand,
▶ Play
Speaker 45 35:10
and that's why my response is going to be that in this case we're letting the perfect be the enemy of the good. But we cannot just look at an isolated incident, especially if it's a hypothetical, and say that this is not something that we should do to protect the interest of the child. And I understand what you're saying. You're right. There are some custodial battles that are just endless. They continue. But they're going to be endless whether this law is in place or not. There's going to be other things to spit and fight about. This is just one where we're making sure that while the spitting and the fighting is going on, that somebody impartial is involved in the middle of it to make sure that the right thing is done.
▶ Play
Representative Walker. Thank you, Madam Chair. Mr. Larner, we spent a lot of time on this the last time, and it seems as if the same arguments that were presented then are the ones that are being presented again. Can you tell me any new argument that you have that
▶ Play
Speaker 64 36:23
we haven't already heard and rejected the
▶ Play
Speaker 45 36:27
first day? Well, I felt like, and I know I'm certainly at a great disadvantage because now there's so few members able to be here because we're in those last weeks, so the chances of me even getting a due pass are very remote. But I felt like there were some issues of clarification that are needed that maybe I just really didn't touch on last time, and that was that this legislation does not automatically serve as a predictor that every case is going to end up being re-adjudicated because in many of the, in some cases, the 60 miles, you know, if you're moving 60 to 75 miles or 80 miles, that may not be something that triggers a non-custodial parent object. And I think that was just something that I really was not clear on, is saying that I, and I'm not privy to the conversations that the Judicial Council have and the judges have, but I do know that a lot of their concern is having an overflow of new cases or re-adjudicated cases coming back to them, and they're already concerned about case flow. I don't think it's a realistic concern just because of
▶ Play
this bill. Representative Walker. I think that what is pretty evident here is the pain of divorce. And you can't overcome that pain by establishing a law to put a burden, put great burdens upon the prevailing parent in terms of the custody award. award. Both parties are obliged to get on with their lives. The custodial party is usually the female. The man is usually in a position to go and do whatever he wants. He can go 200 miles away. He can go to another country. He doesn't have to give any report. He has no burden of proof, nothing. What is being proposed is really not only unfair but unequal. And I hate to just simply ask that you, for the sake of time today, just withdraw it, please. Well, and I will, for the sake of time,
▶ Play
Speaker 45 39:03
not belabor this, but I would say also if we're talking about equity and fairness, you have to consider that the non-custodial parent is more than likely the one that is also paying child support. So they already have a great financial burden on them. Now you're putting on top of that, not by any creation of their own, nothing that they did to create the material circumstances. Now you're placing on them another additional financial burden in terms of the extra travel, the ability to have the child be able to be transported, to be with them for extended breaks. I think also some of the comments are made they're not supported by evidence we can't just automatically say the vast majority of custodial parents are female that presumption that is changing somewhat and I think that's a good thing because there's no evidence that says and I know I probably risk alienating you by saying this but I'm sure you agree there's nothing that says that gender is a predictor of which parent is going to be able to be more supportive in a custodial situation. But even if that evidence exists, we do know that the best thing for a child is the influence of both parents, and that's what I'm trying to preserve. So if the committee is willing, I'm willing to go ahead and put this to a vote without any further closing, but I know that you probably have to hear from the against. Is there
▶ Play
anyone in the audience who wishes to speak for the bill, against the bill? Please introduce yourself to the committee.
▶ Play
Thank you, Madam Chair and committee. My name is Donna Gay. I'm a staff attorney at the Administrative Office of the Courts. I work with domestic relations and probate matters primarily. I'm here today just to represent a decision that Judicial Council took that Representative Lowry alluded to, and that is that Judicial Council voted to oppose the bill. they took that official position and I'm here to tell you that I would like to give you one little bit of background information about the Hollinsworth case which the Supreme Court of Arkansas decided in 2003 there was a most domestic relations cases as you probably know go to the court of appeals but sometimes the court of appeals has 12 members who sit in three member panels and what sometimes happens and what happened in this case about relocation is that different panels decided these relocation cases in different ways and a conflict developed in Arkansas so that it was difficult for attorneys and litigants to even know what they were dealing with. It depended on which panel they got. So when that happens, the Supreme Court will often take a case to resolve a conflict in the Court of Appeals, and that's what they did with Hollingsworth, and that's been the law since 2003. So one thing that the decision did was it gave some guidance to attorneys and to litigants about what was going to happen when they had a relocation decision and they came up with this presumption that a custodial parent could relocate with the child or with the children. Now, absolutely the non-custodial parent has the opportunity to rebut that presumption and when the presumption is rebutted that's when the court the courts always always Arkansas courts always look at best interests of the child in custody cases in cases involving children that's the that's the hallmark of any one of these cases so there'll never be a case involving a child where the court doesn't look at best interests of the children and when I got feedback from the judges about the bill itself not one ever expressed the concern that there would be too many cases I just I just didn't hear that concern so thank you. Thank
▶ Play
you for your testimony is there anyone in the audience who wishes to speak for the bill. Oh,
▶ Play
Speaker 39 44:13
I'm sorry. You have a question for this witness. Sorry. Didn't see your hand. Thank
▶ Play
Speaker 45 44:19
you, Madam Chair. Ms. Gay. Yes, sir. Having sat in Garland County in a number of custody hearings, oftentimes a judge seems to could have gone one way or the other. Both parents were qualified and a judge one little bit could have swayed the judge to go the other it wasn't dad abuses mom or is rude on the kids it just you both they were both equally qualified to be custodial parents would it not in those cases where just a slight difference could cause a judge to have more information to say well if you're going to leave all the grandparents all the cousins and go pursue a job in Las Vegas that may be uprooting that child from because of the difficulty that divorce I think we always see brings turmoil to a child that moving that removing that child from all their family and everyone else uprooting them and moving them to las vegas that that judge may at that point have said i'm not going to give you custody because that would be the deciding factor would you not agree that that might give a judge one more thing to say instead of going this way i'm going to go that
▶ Play
way you mean if there were the opposite presumption representative gates i i
▶ Play
Speaker 45 45:53
what i'm for clarity at the initial custody where the judge is awarding custody and could have gone one parent or the other had that judge known that this parent that he is fixing to give custody to three months later was going to take the children, leave their community, leave both sets of grandparents, leave all the cousins and go to Las Vegas where they knew absolutely nobody and those children have to go to new schools, leave all their family leave all their grandparents that that judge may have said, I'm not going to give you custody, I'm going to give custody
▶ Play
over here. Yes, sir. I think anything can happen in a custody case. They're hard cases. But this doesn't preclude the judge making the decision even at the point of relocation. It's just that it puts the burden of overcoming a presumption on the non-custodial parent. And that's one thing that this bill would do. It just flips that presumption. A follow-up,
▶ Play
Speaker 45 47:03
if I may. Yes. Then if without this, let's say I was divorcing my wife, I got custody of my kids, and then I uproot and leave to go to Las Vegas. then we've got then it's too late at that point because i've already moved i've already taken the kids i've already uprooted them uh does that not even bring more conflict to it than telling the judge judge we you know if if i'm wanting to move so far away that i actually have to notify the judge that gave me custody that there could be some material reasons that you might want to have to reconsider the decision you made in the best interest of
▶ Play
the child? Well Because I've already moved. Right. I guess it all comes down to there has to be a point at which the custodial parent has custody of the child, so that decision has been made for whatever reason, whatever the weighing was the judge did initially. So I think the presumption is with that custodial parent because he or she is the custodial parent. All right, thank you. Thank you. Seeing no other questions, thank you
▶ Play
for your testimony. Was there anyone in the audience who wished to speak for the bill? Representative Lowry, are you closed for your bill? Just say a few more words.
▶ Play
Speaker 45 48:49
Yes. You know, and this is not, I am not going to get into lawyer bashing. Representative Walker can accuse me of a lot of things, but I've never bashed lawyers, have I? But we do have a system, we have a judicial system where it's not like an individual, a non-custodial parent can go to Walden Books or Books a Million and pick up a, you know, filing custody orders, dummies, you know, for dummies. You know, you have to hire an attorney, and the non-custodial parent is already at a disadvantage because they are paying the child support. They're paying all the expenses of, in many cases, even though it may only be the one parent, and they could probably get by with a one-bedroom house. They're having to pay rent or pay for a three-bedroom house to be able to accommodate children who are going to be with them every other weekend. So they have these extra expenses. And then to be able to contest this move, whether it's Las Vegas or whether it's 100 miles away, They can't just go down and fill out a simple form. They have to pay a retainer, which is usually going to be $2,000 or more, just to get that judge to a point where they will listen to the instances that Representative Gates is talking about. I agree that the judges probably would act in the best interest of the child in looking at all the factors, but you have to get to that point first. And because there is the presumption that the custodial parent knows what they're doing and they're doing it in the best interest of the child, that judge is never going to get to hear that. They're not going to be able to assert their influence over the case, which is what we empower them to do from the beginning, and nothing severs that influence that they have until the child turns 18. So this is a material change of circumstance. It is something that I think should automatically trigger. It shouldn't have to put into play the non-custodial parent actually going through the paperwork process. It should automatically trigger the judge saying, you know what? I want another look at this. This is my responsibility. This is on me. This is what I'm paid to do. This is what I swore an oath to do. I want another shot at it. So for those reasons, I ask that you would give
▶ Play
a due pass. okay we have a motion to pass is there any discussion of the motion all in favor say aye aye opposed no the noes haven't the bill has failed is anyone here to present house bill 2006 for representative cap How about House Bill 2124 by Representative Letting? Representative Gates, are you going to be presenting Senate Bill 40? All right, you recognize to present Senate Bill 40. There is an amendment. It should be on your tablets, members. Yes, it is. Amendment to Senate Bill 40. I'll give you just a moment to look through that amendment. All right, do we have any questions about this amendment? A motion to adopt? All right, all in favor of adopting the amendment, say aye. Opposed, no. The amendment is adopted. And Representative Gates, you are recognized to present your
▶ Play
Speaker 45 53:19
bill. Thank you, Madam Chair. SB40 deals solely with 927-355, which is a provision in the juvenile code pertaining to placement of juveniles, which have been removed by DCFS and are being placed outside the home. As it stands, the provision is simply worded and provides limited direction for circuit courts to make placement decisions for children. For example, it makes reference to placement with relatives, but it fails to provide specifics as to, one, who is allowed to identify placement options for the children, two, who has the burden, if any, to locate any appropriate persons with whom the children can be placed to avoid foster care, And three, it fails to provide any mechanism through which relatives, non-custodial parents, and additional cases of people such as fictitious kin can be notified that a child that they know has been placed in state custody, how those persons can take placement of the child, what financial options are available if placement is taken, and the obligations of the court and the department to the parent after the child is placed with those individuals. and technically out of foster care. Although the department is working internally to expand its utilization of relatives and fictitious kid to avoid having to place children in foster care, and they're doing a yeoman's job at making those changes. An expansion of the code was necessary to clarify the existing obligations of the department and to provide practitioners with guidance so they can adequately assist their clients in obtaining familiar placement for the client's children, something that has not readily been available to practitioners previously. Specifically, the bill created a section that provides the detailed assessment the department must undertake to locate certain individuals related to or known to the child, assesses those individuals primarily and if the preliminary checks are positive to provide detailed written notice to those individuals about becoming a resource for those children. And lastly, it also relieves the Department of Further Assessment obligations if preliminary background checks come back unfavorable. And I'll entertain any easy questions. Are there any questions?
▶ Play
Representative Birch? Can we just make her first every single time, please? Thank you.
▶ Play
Thank you, Madam Chair. Because I know you worked very hard with some folks to get this one really close, I probably have fewer questions on it than I might have on some others. But my first question involves down on line 35, page 1, where it says recommended relatives of the juvenile. I'm sorry. You're not on the mic. I'm so sorry. I think I'm loud enough, but sorry. All right, so when DHS takes custody of a juvenile or the court determines that they shall be removed, the department shall conduct an immediate assessment to locate noncustodial parent or recommended relatives who's making the recommendation on recommended relatives and who has the burden for determining that recommendation well once we've taken
▶ Play
Speaker 45 57:06
once we've for instance if we've taken a hold on a
▶ Play
child right and then because once that hold is taken then this burden is on DHS to immediately conduct this search which can be exhaustive and should be exhausted but how do they know who to search because what I'm concerned about is that if the mom from whom the children are removed doesn't want anybody else to have them she's not going to say where the other
▶ Play
Speaker 45 57:33
father is or where right and and understandably but sometimes uh mom may have the child and has taken them from the child and the father's been looking for them you know because of whatever the dynamics are that's going on sometimes the child spends a lot of time already at grandma's house and if they would ask the child who do you normally stay with who you know those are people that uh i know in my family uh our kids didn't just spend the night anywhere they were either at grandma's house or aunt janna's house if they asked my kids if something happened to us you know is there somebody that we could call well my kids would say call my nana or call aunt janna and that would give them a source, and then they could establish whether or not those people are, if they're kin, or if they have those relationships with those kids, because a lot of times, as you know, those kids are going through trauma, and we're trying to keep the trauma down, so if they can be placed with somebody that they already have those established relationships, it keeps them out of the system. We already don't, I forgot what the number of beds that we have, 0.7 beds for every need, it will reduce that need and it actually will keep the trauma down for the child did I answer your question no not really
▶ Play
you recognize for follow up my bigger concern is that this creates a pretty unreasonable burden on the deployment because grandparents come in and say check this person this person this person and at some point the workers are having to take care of the child also where does it stop the recommended so that's part but let me go on If I might, perhaps we
▶ Play
could ask for Director Martin to come forward. She might be able to help us with some of these concerns.
▶ Play
Speaker 45 59:25
Actually, somebody with a brain. That would be. And I appreciate the assumption that I worked really hard on this. Senator Clark has worked very, very hard in it, and I'm carrying some of
▶ Play
the water for the senator. Director Martin, I think we all know you at this
▶ Play
Speaker 100 59:44
point, but if you would, for the record, introduce yourself. Yes, ma'am. Mr. Martin, Director of Division of Children and Family Services. Representative Birch, I agree with your concern, but we have a duty to find these relatives, and I think the answer to your question on recommended relatives is it could be recommended by the parent, it could be recommended by the child, and we've seen our workers have actually, as we've started to push for relative placement, and our numbers continue to increase, we're at 27%, whereas two years ago we were in the low teens. 27 placement with relatives it actually lessens the burden on the workers if they're able to find that relative immediately and never have to place the child in a foster home so I agree with you that we don't need to um to be looking at 20 different relatives but I don't think that this law requires us to to be doing an assessment on everyone if we if we have identified one relative then we go and we move forward with that relative and then you know it just says an assessment so we can move forward with the one relative and then we also need to be looking at relatives throughout the case which the law does require and we haven't done a good job of that historically as you're aware in 928-108 we already had a duty to notify relatives this just kind of this is in a separate section and is some additional layers and guidance on how to find those relatives or fictive kin. And
▶ Play
if I might ask, Director Martin, is your department in agreement with this bill? Yes, ma'am, we
▶ Play
Speaker 102 1:01:20
are. We support this bill. All right, thank you. Were there
▶ Play
other questions by committee members? All right, thank you. We don't have anyone signed up to speak for or against this bill. Is there anyone in the audience who wishes to speak for? You're nodding. Did you want to? Oh, okay. Anyone who wishes to speak against the bill? Representative Gates, would you like to close for
▶ Play
Speaker 45 1:01:48
the bill? I make a motion do pass. Ask for
▶ Play
a good vote. Thank you. As amended. As amended. Yes. Okay. Any discussion of the motion? All in favor, say aye. Aye. Opposed, no. Congratulations, the bill has passed. Did you have anything else for us today, Representative Gates?
▶ Play
Speaker 105 1:02:14
Well, there's another one of Clark's, and I'm saying Hammer, it's Representative Hammer tied up. To my understanding, I
▶ Play
was just told that they're going to try to make a couple of
▶ Play
Speaker 110 1:02:25
amendments to that bill. On 306? On 306, yes, sir. All right,
▶ Play
I see Representative Gassaway in the room. Did you want to present your bill today, Representative Gassaway?
▶ Play
I'm sorry, I can't hear you at all. All
▶ Play
right, we'll take just a little break. If you'll just stay close around and give him a couple of minutes to get prepared. I would, without objection, like to move this from the deferred list. This is House Bill 1381. Move it from the deferred list to the active list. We'll take it up in just a few moments.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 1:03:22
Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
▶ Play
Representative Gassaway, are you going to run that today or did you want to wait until next week? We need to get a decision on this, you're going to run it now, all right, we're ready. and we have an amendment we'll pass that out to members oh excuse me it's already on your tablet members are you seeing that amendment on your tablets House bill 1381 well I'm not pulling it up Some of us are having trouble pulling up the amendment.
▶ Play
Speaker 116 1:09:58
Thank you. for copies to
▶ Play
you?
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 1:10:58
Thank you. Thank you.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:11:58
All right, Representative Cazzoa, you are recognized.
▶ Play
Thank you, Madam Chair, members.
▶ Play
Speaker 45 1:12:28
Today, I have House Bill 1381.
▶ Play
Oh, excuse me. We need
▶ Play
Speaker 45 1:12:34
to adopt the amendment first. That's correct, which has now been amended, and the amendment is now the bill. So in explaining the amendment, I will basically be explaining the bill to you. This amendment came about.
▶ Play
We need a motion first to adopt the amendment. Okay, sorry. Representative Birch
▶ Play
makes that motion. All in favor, say aye. Aye. Opposed, no. All right,
▶ Play
Speaker 45 1:13:03
now we're ready. Thank you, Madam Chair. So the amendment is basically the bill, and when I originally filed this bill, there were some concerns that were expressed to me by Representative Birch and others, and I think including Madam Chair, about how this would affect permanency planning in DHS cases involving juveniles who were dependent-neglected, and the concern was that it would draw the cases out beyond 15 months, which could significantly impact federal funding, and that it may also create a playing field that would be not in the best interest of children. And so what I did is I called a meeting, and I brought all the stakeholders involved together, which includes DHS, the attorney ad litem, parent counsel, the administrative office of the courts. And we had a meeting, and this amendment is an agreed-upon, compromised amendment that we believe furthers the goals of helping parents who are actively trying to be involved in their children's life and who want to reunite with their children after the children have been removed from the home, by providing some language to judges in the statute that will encourage concurrent planning or concurrent goals. So in the event that the case is moving toward adoption or termination of parental rights, this amendment in the statute will give judges guidance to hopefully, which I don't think is occurring now as much as we would like it to, have a concurrent goal and allow reunification services to continue and hopefully allow those parents who do actually care and are actually trying to be involved in their children's life a path to see that happen. Most of what's contained in the amendment is currently the law in other places, but this just simply puts it in one statute so that when the judges are at the permanency planning hearing, and I think most judges around the state do a great job of doing this. Others may not be as thoughtful as others, but this will give them a framework to consider as they make those decisions at the permanency planning hearing. And I realize that that's kind of a convoluted and complicated explanation. We do have Jerry Shoram here with DHS and all the stakeholders here,
▶ Play
if anybody would like to hear from them. yes would you please bring them to the end of the table sure we have several questions by members it might just expedite things if they're here would
▶ Play
Speaker 127 1:16:05
you please introduce yourselves to the committee Gerald Sherham deputy counsel for
▶ Play
Speaker 128 1:16:11
the Department of Human Services Renee Robinette, Attorney Ad Litem
▶ Play
Speaker 130 1:16:17
Program Director. Connie Hickman, Director of Court Services,
▶ Play
Speaker 132 1:16:20
and I represent the judges. Laura Calhoun, one of the Assistant
▶ Play
Directors for Parent Council. All right, and members, if you want to direct your questions to a specific person, or if you just want anyone to take your question, let us know. Representative Kavanaugh. Thank
▶ Play
you, Madam Chair. Mine's a real quick question, and I think Representative Gassaway can answer this. This is not going to extend or put any extra time on this placement process. No, it will not.
▶ Play
Representative Walker. We have to have a motion on the floor first. We have a motion due pass from Representative Blay. All right. I think we did have several questions, members, that we would like to get cleared up. Representative Meeks had a question. You don't? I do.
▶ Play
You do? Yes. Well, since Representative Birch is not asking questions. That's fine.
▶ Play
Speaker 93 1:17:36
Go ahead. I finally had questions. You
▶ Play
can cut me off. That's
▶ Play
Speaker 141 1:17:48
fine. Okay. That's what I
▶ Play
want to hear. Do you have any more questions? Okay, we had
▶ Play
Speaker 143 1:17:57
a motion for immediate consideration,
▶ Play
we had a motion due pass, so we have to take, I really had, we had several questions that members were wanting to ask here. Who had the motion due pass? You are making that motion do pass. All right. As amended. All in favor, say aye. The motion was for immediate consideration. Yes. How many vote for immediate consideration? Say aye. Opposed? No. The no's have it. All right. Representative Meeks, you're recognized with your questions. Thank you,
▶ Play
Madam Chair. I appreciate it. My question is, my question is, when it mentions following the orders of the court in time period immediately proceeding. Is there a definition of time period? Are we talking about days, weeks? I know that weeks and months were struck from that, but the court's not going to see that. All it's going to see is time period. So if you could expound on how the court will interpret time period, I would appreciate it. I would never presume to
▶ Play
Speaker 154 1:19:42
guess how a judge is going to... Would you pull your mic towards you
▶ Play
a little bit? If you would lift it up, the people in the sound booth say we're killing their ears when we're dragging these mics. So if you could pick it up and lift it
▶ Play
Speaker 153 1:19:57
towards you. Thank you. I would never presume to guess how
▶ Play
Speaker 154 1:20:00
a court is going to interpret the statute. The issue of months and weeks came up in the original draft of this bill, and we raised some concerns about that language. It was existing language, because when you're talking about months, it could be six months, nine months, 12 months, and we had some concerns about applying that in these cases and having cases unnecessarily extended. So I think that the Department of Human Services came up with the compromise on striking the months and weeks and doing immediately, so that we would expect the court would use reasonable judgment to determine whether information is immediate enough for the court to still consider that. We think the factors that are listed out also help to give the court and the parties some direction on what kinds of things the court should be looking at on whether or not to extend the goal of reunification or to go ahead and change the goal to some other goal for the child.
▶ Play
Follow-up, Madam Chair? Yes, you're recognized. All right, and then on page two, at least on my paper copy here, where it says section two here, it says, If the court sets a goal of adoption, reunification service shall be continued to be provided unless the court determines that reunification service is no longer needed, terminates parental rights, or otherwise finalizes a permanency plan. And I've been around the foster care system now for a couple of years, and that kind of confuses me a little bit that we would set a goal of adoption, but then continue reunification services. so could you somebody at the end of the table explain how that would actually work if you're if you're setting a goal of adoption then rights should already be terminated or something else should be happening there i'm not sure why we would continue with unification services that to me might cause confusion or cause problems with the child if they're you know i'm adoptable but my mom may you know i may still be reunifying so could you please kind of expound on that yes Yes, thank you for the question.
▶ Play
Speaker 127 1:22:03
I think in practice, I mean, when you change the goal to adoption, the termination of parental rights hasn't happened yet. The goal is adoption following the termination of parental rights. So when you change the goal, you are now setting the goal to be adoption following the termination of parental rights. And in practice, all across the state, the reunification services will continue. And indeed, there's only one mechanism to stop reunification services under the juvenile code absent adoption happening and that is a motion for no reunification services. So what this does is it tightens up the language in the juvenile code to make it clear that up to the termination, that parent still has a chance to reunify with their parents and we are not pulling the rug out from underneath them before their termination of parental rights hearing. The other pieces are the court finalizes the termination of parental rights or another permanency plan for the juvenile and the court at any time and the department is willing to take on the burden of filing those motions for no reunification services if we're going to go for something other than adoption as the case unfolds, but under this language we're confident that we're going to meet the needs of the parents and
▶ Play
the child going forward. My question would be the same as Representative Meeks. This does not make sense to me. If I were the parent seeking to adopt a child and I would tell that my adoption is moving forward, but at the same time, we're seeking reunification services, at that point, I would probably withdraw from being an adoptive parent, because I would find that very, very confusing. Can you help me with that?
▶ Play
Speaker 154 1:23:39
Madam Chair, currently under the law, if you change the goal to adoption, as Mr. Sharon pointed out, you have not terminated parental rights. so the parent still has up until that termination to continue to show that they have demonstrated progress or that there are not grounds to terminate their parental rights so they still have that right to to have those reunification services and the adoptive family is told that we're still working towards that goal of tpr termination of parental rights but that has not happened yet there are cases that we have a legal risk adoption that we can start a legal risk placement much earlier in the case. And concurrent planning is something that has been part of the federal construct for a long time. Actually, under the CFSR, the review, when Arkansas was looked at with the concurrent planning, we were not doing a good job. We should be looking at adoption, looking at these other placements much earlier in the cases. So I think the concurrent planning language actually helps us to comply with federal law. it helps us have good practice we need to be open with our foster parents about the status of the case if we're not at termination yet we should not be assuring foster parents that they are going to be able to adopt that only happens once parental rights are terminated but they know that this is a possibility and as Mr. Sharon pointed out in those cases where you have egregious fact patterns where you really have murdering of a child aggravated circumstances those other types of really egregious abuse of a child we can ask for no reunification services earlier in the case we don't have to wait till this permanency planning point
▶ Play
representative birch i thought i was going to get away without asking questions but that actually kind of raises one as i read this though the court can make that determination not to continue without even the motion for no reunification services at that pregnancy planning hearing the way this is written the court can say it's not in the best interest of the child to continue having those reunification services, which often are simply just visitation with the children. Or the court can say that that's not a reunification service, that that's for the child, for them to continue to see the parent. So this doesn't stop the court from making a decision, does it, that no contact with the parent should happen? I mean, this doesn't require those services to continue, or I'm reading it incorrectly. I don't think it
▶ Play
Speaker 127 1:26:13
does bind the court in any way in terms of finding what's in the best interest of that child if no further contact needs to be had with that parent or what have you. I think the purpose of that section where it says unless the court determines that services no longer need to be provided pursuant to this chapter specifically talks to 927.365 which is the no reunification services section but there's nothing in here that limits a court's ability to cut off contact at all, and that is firmly within the court's discretion to protect that child as the court determines to be appropriate, which is, of course, the current law as it is now. All right.
▶ Play
Thank you. We were consulting a little bit back here. Were there other questions by committee members? I do have one additional question. Is this language agreed upon by all people sitting at the end of this table? All right. Thank you. I don't see anyone in the audience signed up to speak for or against this bill. Have I overlooked anyone? They're all at the table. Well, we do have a few people in the audience. Would you like to close for
▶ Play
Speaker 45 1:27:34
your bill, Representative Gassaway? I think this bill is a bill that addresses all the concerns of all the parties that you see here. It helps make the process a little more clear and gives some guidance on how this process should operate for judges who, and again, I think I'm not criticizing the judges at all. I think they do a great job, but it gives more guidance and more clarification for them on the process to follow in these permanency situations. So with that, I'm close for the bill. I would appreciate a good vote. And Representative Blake,
▶ Play
you're recognized for your motion. You've asked. As amended. As amended. This is the proper time. The time is now. Is there any discussion of the motion? All in favor, say aye. Aye. Opposed, no. Congratulations. The bill has passed. Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you, Commissioner. The final item on our agenda today, without objection, we will move Representative Sorvillo's House Resolution 1013 to the active calendar. Representative Sorvillo, you are recognized. And Representative Sorvillo, in the interest of time, would you make
▶ Play
Speaker 166 1:28:53
it as brief as possible, please? Yes, ma'am. Basically, for some of y'all, you went around in 1980 when this missile explosion happened in Damascus, Arkansas. So one of the things about this bill is I hope that we can look at the history. I think a lot of people were not aware of it and go through the historical event that occurred. but what I want to say to you is that we have 50 co-sponsors we could have had more just time the time element so I think that we that we've shown great support so what we need to do is ask you to support this and let it get to the floor I have I have spoken to the Rock Air Force Base and they they want to come to the signing when the governor signs this so we do have support it's gone all the way to Washington, D.C., and all the way back, and I've got an okay. So once again, that's as brief as that can be. Thank you.
▶ Play
All right, with any questions, anyone in the audience to speak? Oh, Representative Birch, did you have a question? Oh, my
▶ Play
gosh. All right. Only because I've been – thank you, Madam Chair. Only because I've watched the iterations of this one. And truly when you say it's been to the Air Force Base and the Pentagon, could you describe what exactly that means? Well,
▶ Play
Speaker 166 1:30:22
what they wanted to do is look at the historical accuracy of this. And so that is basically, they had their historian look at it and came back with the approval so it met
▶ Play
their criteria. That's right. And were there any changes that were made that you were uncomfortable with following
▶ Play
Speaker 169 1:30:44
it going up the chain of command
▶ Play
Speaker 166 1:30:47
and down no actually we had amended it and so with that amendment that is what was sent to them so you're not going to move to my role next time I mean yeah but no they were actually very very supportive of it all right and do
▶ Play
we have anyone the audience to speak for or or against this resolution? Seeing none, Representative Wing, you're recognized for your motion. Can we have a motion due pass? All in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed, no. Members, to my knowledge, this concludes everything that I know of on our agenda. Senate Bill 306. Whose is that? That was, that was.
▶ Play
Oh, didn't we do that today? No. No.
▶ Play
Yeah, we've got some amendments on it. So sorry, guys.
▶ Play
Okay, sorry, I spoke too soon.
▶ Play
We're done for today. Today. Today. But be watching your announcements to see if we will be
▶ Play
meeting Monday or if we will be meeting Wednesday. but it looks like we will only be meeting one more time and probably very briefly at that. So I appreciate all the good work for this committee this week clearing our calendar. And with that, we are adjourned.
▶ Play

Agenda

REGULAR AGENDA Subtitle Sponsor Number

HB1783 Rushing TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE VISITATION RIGHTS OF GRANDPARENTS AND GREAT-GRANDPARENTS.

HB1906 C. Douglas TO SET A SPECIAL HUNTING AND FISHING LICENSE FEE FOR ACTIVE MILITARY MEMBERS HOME ON LEAVE IN ARKANSAS.

HB1912 Gates TO REQUIRE VIDEO AND AUDIO RECORDINGS OF IN-PERSON INTERACTIONS AND VERBAL COMMUNICATIONS THAT OCCUR DURING INVESTIGATIONS PERFORMED UNDER THE ARKANSAS JUVENILE CODE OF 1989 AND THE CHILD MALTREATMENT ACT.

HB1913 Gates TO REQUIRE CHILD MALTREATMENT INVESTIGATORS TO PROVIDE CERTAIN NOTICES TO ALLEGED OFFENDERS.

HB1914 Gates TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE DISCLOSURE OF INFORMATION RELATING TO OF NEED A SERVICES FAMILY IN PROCEEDING DEPENDENCY-NEGLECT A OR PROCEEDING.

HB1915 Gates TO REQUIRE THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES AND THE DEPARTMENT OF ARKANSAS STATE POLICE TO PROVIDE REPORTS CONCERNING THE NUMBER OF OVERTURNED TRUE FINDING DETERMINATIONS.

18:13 - 52:09 87 segments 8 speakers

Representative Gates introduced HB 1915, which would require the Department of Human Services and the Arkansas State Police to report the number of true-finding determinations that are later overturned, aiming to bring Arkansas data in line with neighboring states. [18:14] [18:46] [19:22]

Representative LeAnne Burch asked whether the statistics would improve training and case outcomes, and Speaker 45 confirmed the data would inform training and noted overturn rates of 40-70 % in various districts. [20:13] [20:38] [21:13] [21:47]

The chair moved to adopt the bill as amended, the committee voted aye, and HB 1915 was reported passed. [22:10] [22:19] [22:54]

HB2006 Capp TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE INITIAL PERIOD FOR WHICH A TEMPORARY GUARDIAN IS APPOINTED FOR AN INCAPACITATED PERSON; AND TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING FULL MERIT HEARINGS HELD AFTER THE ENTRY OF EMERGENCY TEMPORARY GUARDIANSHIP ORDERS.

HB2124 Leding TO ELIMINATE THE ASSET OR RESOURCE TEST FOR LONG-TERM CARE MEDICAID WITHIN THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM FOR VETERANS.

HR1025 S. Meeks RECOGNIZING THE CHICKAMAUGA PEOPLE'S UNIQUE HERITAGE AND IMPORTANT CONTRIBUTIO0NS TO THE STATE OF ARKANSAS.

HB2058 Hammer TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING ADOPTION, CHILD PLACEMENT AND CUSTODY, AND THE RIGHTS OF GRANDPARENTS.

SB40 A. Clark TO AMEND PROVISIONS IN THE JUVENILE CODE CONCERNING THE PLACEMENT OF JUVENILES.

52:09 - 23:25

The committee adopted the amendment to SB 40 after a motion and unanimous voice vote. [52:42]

Representative Gates introduced SB 40, which amends juvenile code §927-355 to clarify placement procedures, specify who may identify relatives, and outline notification and assessment requirements. [53:19] [53:47] [54:36] [55:09] [55:42]

Representative LeAnne Burch questioned the burden on DHS to locate recommended relatives and the criteria for such searches, prompting clarification from Director Martin that the department supports the bill and that recommendations can come from parents or children, with the agency aiming to increase relative placements. [56:12] [56:43] [57:06] [57:11] [57:14] [57:33] [57:47] [58:24] [58:54] [59:44] [59:57] [1:00:31] [1:01:02] [1:01:09] [1:01:20]

After limited debate, the committee moved to pass SB 40 as amended, receiving an affirmative voice vote and reporting the bill as passed. [1:01:48] [1:01:54]

SB306 A. Clark CONCERNING A NONCUSTODIAL PARENT'S UNSUPERVISED VISITATION WITH HIS OR HER CHILD; TO AMEND DEFINITIONS UNDER THE ARKANSAS JUVENILE CODE OF 1989; AND TO AMEND THE LAW ON PROBABLE CAUSE HEARINGS AND THE TERMINATION OF PARENTAL RIGHTS.

HB1445 Lowery TO CREATE THE PARENT-CHILD RELATIONSHIP PROTECTION ACT; AND TO PROVIDE FACTORS AND PROCEDURES FOR DETERMINING WHETHER OR NOT A CHANGE OF A CHILD'S PRINCIPAL PLACE OF RESIDENCE IS IN THE BEST INTEREST OF THE CHILD.

23:25 - 1:28:52 183 segments 24 speakers

Representative Gates presented HB 1445, the Parent-Child Relationship Protection Act, which would require custodial parents relocating more than 60 miles to notify the court and give non-custodial parents 30 days to protest, shifting the presumption that the custodial parent acts in the child’s best interest. [23:29] [24:00] [24:30] [25:01]

Committee members, including Rep. LeAnne Burch and staff attorney Donna Gay, raised concerns about added litigation, the burden of filing petitions, and potential conflicts with existing relocation case law, while Gates argued the bill would protect children by ensuring judicial review. [32:34] [32:43] [33:17] [33:47] [34:20] [34:33] [34:52] [35:10] [35:23] [41:10] [41:50] [42:21] [42:54] [43:24] [43:55]

After extensive testimony, the chair called for a vote; the motion to pass did not receive sufficient support and the committee reported that HB 1445 failed to pass. [51:22]

HR1013 Sorvillo HONORING THE 308TH TITAN II STRATEGIC MISSILE WING AND THE RESPONSE TO THE 1980 MISSILE EXPLOSION AT DAMASCUS, ARKANSAS.

1:28:52 - 1:09:16

Representative Wing (Speaker 166) presented HR 1013, a resolution honoring the 308th Titan II Strategic Missile Wing and commemorating the 1980 missile explosion in Damascus, noting broad legislative support and endorsement from the Air Force Base. [1:28:53] [1:29:06] [1:29:42]

Representative LeAnne Burch queried the extent of the Air Force Base’s involvement and the historical review process, receiving confirmation that the base’s historians approved the resolution without substantive changes. [1:30:14] [1:30:22] [1:30:37] [1:30:44] [1:30:47] [1:30:51]

The committee moved to adopt the resolution, and after an unopposed voice vote, HR 1013 was reported as passed. [1:31:05] [1:31:21]

HB1381 Gazaway TO AMEND THE 3058TH TITAN II STRATEGIC MISSILE WING AND THE RESPONSE TO THE 1980 MISSILE EXPLOSION AT DAMASCUS, ARKANSAS.

1:09:16 - 3:33

The committee first adopted the amendment to HB 1381 by voice vote, allowing the amendment to become the bill. [1:12:51] [1:12:56] [1:12:59] [1:13:03]

HB 1381, presented by Speaker 45, seeks to amend the juvenile code to provide judges with guidance for concurrent permanency planning, aiming to prevent case extensions beyond 15 months and to support reunification services alongside adoption goals. [1:13:31] [1:14:02] [1:14:35] [1:15:12]

Representative Stephen Meeks raised concerns about the undefined “time period” for court actions and the continuation of reunification services after an adoption goal is set; staff and stakeholders clarified that “immediately” leaves discretion to the court, that adoption goals precede termination of parental rights, and that reunification services continue until such termination, with the department prepared to file motions to cease services when appropriate. [1:19:05] [1:19:20] [1:19:42] [1:19:46] [1:19:53] [1:19:57] [1:20:00] [1:20:24] [1:20:57] [1:21:33] [1:22:03] [1:22:34] [1:23:09] [1:23:14] [1:23:39] [1:24:13]

After addressing questions, the committee moved the bill to immediate consideration and then passed HB 1381 as amended by unanimous voice votes. [1:18:12] [1:18:43] [1:28:10] [1:28:25]

SCMR1 K. Ingram IN RESPECTFUL MEMORY OF CORRECTIONAL CORPORAL BARBARA ESTER.

HB1475 K. Hendren TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE APPOINTMENT OF GUARDIANS AND THE REPORTING REQUIREMENTS FOR GUARDIANS.

3:33 - 0:37

Representative Kim Hendren introduced HB 1475, moved to adopt his amendment, and the amendment was approved unanimously. [3:38] [3:57] [4:09] [4:42]

His daughter Gayla McKenzie presented the bill’s foundation on the Texas Guardianship Bill of Rights, outlining standards for ward rights, visitation, and a process for ward complaints. [8:43] [9:01] [9:36] [10:07] [10:42] [11:18] [11:52]

Committee members flagged a possible conflict with a 2006 House bill and asked about coordination with the Casey Kasem bill; Rep. Hendren expressed willingness to modify the legislation as needed. [13:57] [14:28] [14:35] [14:54] [15:00] [15:12] [15:35]

After no further testimony, the chair moved to pass the amended bill, the motion carried, and HB 1475 was reported out of committee. [17:08] [17:40]

SB132 J. Hutchinson CREATING THE COMMISSION FOR PARENT COUNSEL; CONCERNING DEPENDENCY- NEGLECT REPRESENTATION FOR THE PARENT OF A MINOR CHILD; AND CONCERNING REPRESENTATION IN THE JUVENILE DIVISION OF CIRCUIT COURT.

0:37 - 1:32:19 265 segments 32 speakers

Representative Hutchinson (Speaker 6) explained that SB 132 would create a separate commission for parent counsel to eliminate conflicts of interest between parent counsel and attorneys ad litem operating in the same agency. [1:04] [1:34]

Committee members asked about funding, and Director Brian Welch clarified that the bill uses existing funding and adds no new appropriations. [2:07] [2:13] [2:32] [2:38]

The chair moved to pass the bill, the motion was adopted without opposition, and the committee voted aye, reporting SB 132 passed. [2:57] [3:01] [3:08]

HB2010 Sturch TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING NUTRITION PROGRAMS AND SERVICES FUNDED BY AND PROVIDED IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE OLDER AMERICANS ACT OF 1965.

HB2031 Sturch CONCERNING THE ESTABLISHMENT OF A HUMAN TRAFFICKING HOTLINE; AND CONCERNING HUMAN TRAFFICKING.

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Charlene Fite Chair Unverified
62 segments
Speaker 6
4 segments
Representative Frances Cavenaugh Unverified
2 segments
Brian Welch Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 45
72 segments
Representative Kim Hendren Unverified
16 segments
Gayla Mckenzie Unverified
10 segments
Representative LeAnne Burch Unverified
23 segments
Speaker 48
1 segment
Representative John W. Walker Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 64
1 segment
Donna Gay Unverified
11 segments
Speaker 39
1 segment
Speaker 100
4 segments
Speaker 102
1 segment
Speaker 105
1 segment
Representative Stephen Meeks Unverified
9 segments
Speaker 110
1 segment
Speaker 116
1 segment
Chair Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 127
6 segments
Speaker 128
1 segment
Speaker 130
1 segment
Speaker 132
1 segment
Speaker 93
1 segment
Speaker 141
1 segment
Speaker 143
1 segment
Speaker 154
7 segments
Speaker 153
1 segment
Speaker 166
6 segments
Speaker 169
1 segment
Representative Carlton Wing Unverified
1 segment