Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

Revenue and Taxation Committee

March 30, 2017 ·Committee Room 151 ·1:14:32
Video Transcript

Summary

Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 12, 2026

SB9 A. Clark TO ENCOURAGE CHARITABLE GIVING AND ELIMINATE PERVERSE AND ABSURD TAXES AND DISINCENTIVES ON CHARITABLE GIVING; AND TO EXEMPT CERTAIN WITHDRAWALS O… 0:11

Senator Alan Clark introduced SB 9, arguing that charitable donors currently pay sales tax on donated goods-such as Habitat for Humanity shipments and food-bank donations-and that eliminating this tax would aid disaster relief and local charities (). [0:34] [1:04] [1:41] [2:13]

Committee members, including Chair Rep. Joe Jett and DFA Representative Dan M. Douglas, examined the fiscal impact, with DFA presenting a statement that estimated roughly $62.8 million in donations and a $1 million sales-tax loss, while noting data limitations for many retailers (,,). [3:53] [4:27] [5:05] [5:39] [7:05] [7:17] [7:48] [8:25] [8:51] [9:21] [9:28]

After a series of questions about tracking donations and budget offsets and Senator Clark’s closing remarks, the committee reported that no motion was made to advance the bill, so SB 9 did not move forward (). [17:55] [18:25]

SB688 TO AMEND THE INCOME TAX CREDIT FOR WASTE REDUCTION, REUSE, OR RECYCLING EQUIPMENT; AND TO DECLARE EN EMERGENCY 20:11

Rep. Monte Hodges introduced SB 688, outlining that it would tie tax credits for waste-reduction equipment to large steel-project investments, requiring at least $1 billion in capital, 500 jobs at $75 k salary, and that credits would be paid only after those thresholds are met (). [20:42] [21:17] [21:49] [22:24] [22:55] [23:28]

Committee members discussed the bill’s cost-benefit, with Rep. Kim Hendren raising concerns about past bond costs and Rep. Aaron Pilkington explaining that the legislation includes safeguards and AEDC involvement to protect the state’s finances (). [23:41] [23:45] [24:01] [24:33] [25:05] [25:34] [25:39] [25:54] [26:04] [26:10]

After public opposition from David Ray questioning the bill’s vetting and fiscal impact, Rep. Hodges moved a due-pass, which was adopted unanimously, so SB 688 was approved by the committee (). [29:11] [29:30] [30:01] [30:19]

SB729 TO AMEND THE CARRY FORWARD PROVISION RELATING TO THE INCOME TAX CREDIT ALLOWED FOR WATER IMPOUNDMENTS. 31:04

Chair Rep. Joe Jett presented SB 729, noting it would extend the carry-forward period for a $9,000 water-impoundment tax credit from nine to fifteen years to aid farmers (). [31:06] [31:37] [32:09]

With no opposition or questions, the committee moved and adopted a motion to pass the bill, approving it unanimously (). [32:40]

SB140 TO PROVIDE FOR THE COLLECTION OF SALES AND USE TAX RATHER THAN USE TAX ON SALES BY CERTAIN REMOTE SELLERS. 35:06

Representative Murdoch (speaking for Representative Gray) presented amendment 374 to SB 140, adding a $100 million line item for the Highway Department and emphasizing that it is a compromise, not a new tax. [36:50] [37:10] [37:41] [38:12] [38:24]

The Department of Finance Administration, represented by Dan M. Douglas, objected that the added $100 million is not budgeted, arguing that spending before the online sales-tax collections are known would be administratively improper. [39:18] [39:49] [40:16] [41:24] [41:29] [42:00]

Committee members, including Representatives Gray, Flowers, and Hendren, questioned the revenue projections and collection feasibility, with Douglas noting limited data on out-of-state retailer compliance and uncertainty about the anticipated $150 million-plus revenue. [44:10] [44:44] [45:00] [45:05] [45:17] [45:53] [46:06] [46:11] [46:30] [47:02] [47:33] [48:05] [48:35] [49:11]

A motion to adopt the amendment as amended was taken; after roll-call the amendment failed 10-yes, 6-no, 2-abstentions, with both the chair and co-chair voting no. [57:58] [58:18] [58:48] [59:19] [1:00:00] [1:00:08] [1:00:16] [1:00:26] [1:00:37]

SB450 Hester TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE SALE AND REDEMPTION OF TAX-DELINQUENT PROPERTY. 1:11:31

Representative Charlie Collins introduced SB 450, describing it as a cleanup of property-registration and tax-delinquent-property procedures, noting Attorney General approval and no known opposition. [1:12:22] [1:12:26] [1:12:49]

Collins moved to pass the bill, and after a voice vote the committee approved SB 450 unanimously. [1:13:06] [1:13:09]

Bills discussed (45)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
SB688 · 4 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB688 TO AMEND THE INCOME TAX CREDIT FOR WASTE REDUCTION, REUSE,…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB729 · 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…mittee and chairman. Thank you. Members, we'll move down to Senate Bill 729. Is Senator Cheatham in the room by any chance? Okay, I'm g…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB9 · 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…ng. Mr. Chair, DFA has issued a fiscal impact statement for Senate Bill 9 of 2017. We also did a similar fiscal impact in 2015 when a…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1028 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1028 Lemons TO EXEMPT CERTAIN BUSES, COACHES, AND OTHER MOTOR VE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1037 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1037 Wardlaw TO REPEAL THE REQUIREMENT THAT CERTAIN RETAILERS PR…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1227 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1227 Farrer TO REDUCE INCOME TAX RATES IN CERTAIN CIRCUMSTANCES;…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1252 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1252 Rye TO AMEND THE INCOME TAX DEDUCTION ALLOWED FOR MEDICAL A…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1253 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1253 Wardlaw TO REPEAL THE REQUIREMENT THAT CERTAIN RETAILERS PR…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1263 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1263 Jett TO CREATE A SALES AND USE TAX EXEMPTION FOR PARTS FOR…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1395 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1395 Leding TO CREATE AN INCOME TAX CREDIT FOR TAXPAYERS THAT EM…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1396 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1396 Leding TO EXEMPT FROM THE INDIVIDUAL INCOME TAX EDUCATION S…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1397 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1397 Leding TO EQUALIZE THE SALES TAX TREATMENT OF DUES AND MEMB…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1399 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1399 Ballinger HONOR ARKANSAS VETERANS ACT OF 2017.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1409 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1409 House TO CREATE AN EXEMPTION FROM THE INCOME TAX FOR SERVIC…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1412 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1412 Ballinger TO PROVIDE FOR A PARTIAL PROPERTY TAX EXEMPTION F…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1449 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1449 Dotson TO AMEND THE ANNUAL FRANCHISE TAX FOR CORPORATIONS T…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1512 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1512 Davis TO REDUCE THE INCOME TAX RATES APPLICABLE TO INDIVIDU…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1531 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1531 G. Hodges TO CREATE AN INCOME TAX CREDIT FOR EDUCATIONAL LO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1535 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1535 K. Hendren TO AMEND THE DISTRIBUTION AND USE OF SALES AND U…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1565 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1565 Jett TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE ISSUANCE AND EXPIRATIO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1582 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1582 Dotson TO EXEMPT CERTAIN ELECTION EQUIPMENT FROM SALES AND…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1647 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1647 C. Douglas TO EXCLUDE MANUFACTURER REBATES ON MOTOR VEHICLE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1684 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1684 Jett TO EXTEND THE STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS FOR DETERMINING T…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1693 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1693 Rye TO AMEND THE DISTRIBUTION AND USE OF SALES AND USE TAX…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1788 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1788 Dotson TO PHASE IN AN EXTENSION OF THE NET OPERATING LOSS C…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1789 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1789 Dotson TO AMEND LAWS CONCERNING THE CORPORATE FRANCHISE TAX…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1790 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1790 Dotson TO AMEND THE INCOME TAX PROVISIONS CONCERNING THE AP…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1795 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1795 Gates TO EXEMPT CERTAIN DONATED ITEMS FROM SALES AND USE TA…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1796 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1796 Gates TO AMEND THE TIME LIMITATIONS FOR TAX ASSESSMENTS, CO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1824 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1824 J. Williams TO ALLOW A PROPERTY TAX EXEMPTION FOR DISABLED…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1845 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1845 Richey TO CREATE AN INCOME TAX EXEMPTION FOR TEACHERS EMPLO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1850 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1850 Leding TO CREATE THE STRONG FAMILIES ACT; AND TO CREATE AN…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1853 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1853 Ladyman TO AMEND THE DEADLINE FOR ASSESSING TANGIBLE PERSON…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1911 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1911 Bragg TO CLARIFY THE APPLICATION OF THE INCOME TAX CREDIT F…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1965 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1965 Jett TO REPEAL PROVISIONS REGARDING THE USE OF SALES AND US…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2062 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2062 Hammer TO EASE THE BURDEN ON TAXPAYERS; TO OFFSET EXCESS RE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2066 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2066 Hammer TO PROVIDE FOR A PARTIAL REBATE OF DISTILLATE SPECIA…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2068 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2068 Hammer TO RETURN EXCESS FEDERAL GRANT FUNDS TO THE UNITED S…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2100 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2100 Jett TO AMEND AND MODERNIZE THE LAW CONCERNING THE APPORTIO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2256 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2256 V. Flowers TO ALLOW AN INCOME TAX INCENTIVE FOR CERTAIN FIT…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2276 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2276 Gonzales TO REQUIRE THE DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE AND ADMINISTR…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB120 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB120 J. English TO AMEND ARKANSAS TAX LAW CONCERNING INCOME TAX,…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB140 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB140 TO PROVIDE FOR THE COLLECTION OF SALES AND USE TAX RATHER T…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB450 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB450 Hester TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE SALE AND REDEMPTION…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB663 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB663 Files TO CLARIFY THAT AN ACCOMMODATIONS INTERMEDIARY IS REQ…”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 12, 2026
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, members of the committee. Senator Alan Clark, SB 9 is designed to fix a gross inequity in the tax system. No one is called on more to help with local projects from volunteer fire departments to schools, to charities than your local retailers, largely because they're so visible. Right now, to use my business as an example, if I clean out a warehouse from our lumber company, building material company, and ship the obsolete and old merchandise to the landfill, I pay zero tax. But if I send it to Habitat for Humanity, then the state of Arkansas expects me to pay sales tax on retail value, or supposed retail value. That is not a good tax policy. If you were here in 2013, there's a good chance you were co-sponsor of this bill. This is my third session to have it, because over half the legislature were co-sponsors. I have waited patiently to be told that we had offsetting revenues that we could use to get this done, because every legislator I have talked to agreed it needed to be done. If you go back to your districts and ask your Main Street retailers what they think about this bill, the first thing they're going to do is they're going to express shock that they're expected to pay sales tax on donations. The way they find out is if they happen to be audited, and if they have been very benevolent and given a lot, they scream because they get handed a big tax bill. Same is true for those who give to the food banks. If we have big disasters here, in fact, folks were surprised. When I first presented this bill four years ago, They just had major tornadoes in Mississippi. And Tyson had shipped in large, many truckloads of chicken and water. And Mississippi thanked them by sending them a tax bill for the sales tax on that. And I hate it that Arkansas falls in that same category. That's not the way to repay people who are trying to help you in a disaster. And that's the bill in summary.
▶ Play
And I'd be glad to take any questions. Thank you, Senator. Just the first question, just kind of point of question, but no offense to you, sir. We're looking at the fiscal impact of 2018 state sales tax loss, $1 million. Has this been, have you worked out with the governor's office where the money's coming from? Or is this in the budget, the governor's budget? Or is this outside of the budget? or where are we with
▶ Play
the money part of it? This was outside the budget, and I have completely relied on Senator Files as to whether we had found offsetting revenues to take care of this or not. And if he had not thought so, I wouldn't have run out of committee and down to this end. Thank you. I've got a
▶ Play
lot of respect for Senator Files. Can DFA go down to the end of the table and let's hear how the governor's side of this want to work out, please?
▶ Play
Good morning, Senator. Good morning. Good morning, Mr. Chair. Chair Paul Gehring, Assistant Revenue Commissioner, Department of Finance and Administration. Mr. Good morning. Mr. Chair, DFA has issued a fiscal impact statement for Senate Bill 9 of 2017. We also did a similar fiscal impact in 2015 when a substantially similar bill was filed. Just to explain how we get to our numbers, we have a number of publicly available sources of information to determine our fiscal impact. In 2015, we had a number of food banks that make publicly available information out there to list the amount of donated food items that they receive. And under Arkansas law, these items, if they would be subject to sales tax at the time of purchase by that organization, then they would also, if they were donated, they would also be subject to sales tax as a withdrawal from stock that's paid by the retailer. In 2017, when we generated our fiscal impact statement, we had additional information from one more food bank. So that's how we had additional money that we had to incorporate into our fiscal impact statement for the 2017 version of the bill. Uh, just to give you also some information that of our fiscal impact statement, approximately 90% of our, uh, of our cost of this bill is attributed to those specific food banks that provide the publicly available information that we can incorporate into our impact statement. If there is another, uh, retailer or some other type of company that makes donations to a party that would be eligible under this bill that would ordinarily be subject to tax as a withdrawal from stock. DFA does not receive that information, and it is not provided to us when a retailer reports withdrawals from stock or their taxable sales on their return. They do not indicate to us which one of these would otherwise qualify as an exempt donation from sales tax. So I'd be happy to answer any questions about the fiscal impact statement, if the committee should have
▶ Play
any. Is there any way, Paul, that you can get Senator Clark's bill in a good place where this thing could be implemented going forward? Have you tried to sit down and work out some type of mechanism or something
▶ Play
to make this work? And we certainly have met with Mr. Clark. I'm sorry, Senator Clark was early on in the session. We met with Senator Clark to talk about this bill to talk about the impact statement. Of course, DFA, we try to stay, steer clear of the policy determinations that are made by the General Assembly for granting exemptions from tax. So, you know, we certainly, we will do everything we can to implement the bill as it's introduced and passed by the General Assembly. I think the issue for DFA speaking regarding this bill is the impact on the
▶ Play
state budget. Thank you, sir. Members, any questions? Representative Bragg, you're
▶ Play
recognized, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair. How much tax revenue have we collected from companies that might have made these charitable donations and paid tax?
▶ Play
In our fiscal impact statement, we have these food banks. In 2017, we had five food banks that were Arkansas-based food banks that we obtained the publicly available information. And the amount of the donations was $62.8 million in donations. So our fiscal impact incorporates those types of donations that were accountable and we have the actual data to incorporate. The problem for DFA is all the other retailers or businesses that would have to pay tax as a withdrawal from stock on their inventory, we just do not have that information. But we did incorporate 10 percent of our fiscal impact for those types of retailers or other types of businesses that would have to pay tax. As just an estimate, we certainly think our fiscal impact statement is conservative. But we just don't have that type of information unless those businesses decided to provide that information to us, and we just don't have it.
▶ Play
Okay. Thank you. Welcome, sir. Representative Douglas, you're
▶ Play
recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Well, just trying to think through this, say I was a large corporation and I wanted to donate $100,000 worth of goods to a food bank, then I would be responsible for the sales tax on that, which would be roughly city, county, state, local sales tax, about $10,000 roughly, but then I would also get to write off the $100,000. And if my tax bracket was in a typical corporate tax bracket, say 25%, would that be? So you'd get a $25,000 tax savings and pay 10 back on sales tax. Am I looking at that right to where there's still a net gain for company? It would be correct, Representative Douglas, that if the charitable donation qualified as a proper charitable donation, that it could be claimed as a deduction on the taxpayer's income tax return. If it was a food item that is subject to the reduced sales tax on food and food ingredients, you would have probably a lesser amount of tax that would be remitted. But if there is an item that's donated that's subject to the regular sales tax rate, a non-food item, Certainly, it could be in that neighborhood of amount of tax that would be reported as a withdrawal from stock from that company. Okay.
▶ Play
Thank you, sir. Representative Johnson, you're recognized, sir. Representative Johnson. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair. I'm going to go back to Representative Brank's question is, how much did we actually collect in dollars in this? I know what you're saying we should have collected. When you report this on your sales tax, does this show up as a line item by itself? I mean, can you track how much of this was actually collected, or did I just take a truckload over there and drop it off and not say anything?
▶ Play
It would not be as a line item on the return as to what items were donated to a charitable organization or a nonprofit, and that was paid as a withdrawal from stock. the taxpayer does not provide that information on their sales tax report. So you're
▶ Play
not even sure if we did or did not collect
▶ Play
any tax on it? Well, for purposes of the items, the specific food bank items that had the actual data, we're certainly assuming that the sales tax was collected at the time of the sale of the item to the organization that made the donation, or if it was a retailer that has a sales tax permit, that they would have donated the items as a withdrawal from stock and pay the tax on their own return. Okay, thank
▶ Play
you. Members, any other questions? Anybody in the audience want to speak against the bill, for the bill? Senator Clark,
▶ Play
you want to close for your bill, sir? Yes, thank you. To, I would like to respond to the idea that Representative Douglas presented. When you've, there's no special tax credit for donations. You give $100,000, that's $100,000 off your income. And the fact that you didn't have to pay tax on your, on income that you no longer had is not any kind of break. And then you had to pay sales tax on top of that. The, you have to use their numbers. They do the best job that they can. I quit arguing with the EFA a couple years ago. But here are the facts. we talked to a large poultry producer in Arkansas, and they said this would have zero tax impact on them. Now, what that means is that their donations now, they're paying no sales tax on. Now, let me tell you one of the ways you can do that is if, unlike Mississippi, if you ship it in from out of state, we don't charge you a tax. And so for a large corporation, you can do some work in the computer and show that it's shipped from Tulsa rather than Little Rock, and you no longer owe any tax. For the local retailer, this really just helps people who want to be honest to be honest. For the local retailer, the volunteer fire department comes in and says, I'd like to have some prizes for our Halloween bill. and you can simply say, go take it off the shelf. I'm going to look the other way. And when you report it as being shoplifted or just shrinkage, you don't have to lie and say it was shoplifted. You just, when you inventory, it's not there anymore. You don't pay any tax on it. If you ever write it down, when they come audit you, and if you've given thousands of dollars, it's real painful. And I ask you to take care of your retailers in your district that have no idea that this is coming someday. And all that they're doing is just trying to help every school, every group, every fire department, and then other things like natural disasters. Everybody comes along, they're trying to help, and they have no idea that the state of Arkansas is going to hand them a tax bill. This is certainly something we need to fix, and you'll have to decide whether the revenue's there or not.
▶ Play
And I thank you for your time. Thank you, sir. Members, you heard the
▶ Play
testimony, less of which is the committee. Representative Hendren. Mr. Chairman, I guess before we get a motion on this thing, I'd just like to make an inquiry or ask if I can make a motion to do this. In a committee I was part of last night's state agencies, that committee passed out a bill incorrect. In fact, I would just suggest anybody in this room go look at the archives in the House of Representatives. It was called out, and then it failed by at least two to one. And I just, I really have heartburn of how we're doing things these last few days. So can I make a motion or should I make a motion that from this point forward in this session, all committee votes are done by roll call? Hold on just a second. We'll check the roll book on that. And while you're looking for that, Mr. Chairman, if I could, let me just explain why I'd make that motion.
▶ Play
Speaker 38 15:31
Stand by, sir, I think the real book's going to say this is going to be on a bill-by-bill
▶ Play
basis, but we're going to call upstairs and get a check on that to make sure,
▶ Play
okay? While they're doing that, could I just express a minute while I make that motion?
▶ Play
Well, I think we all pretty much understand, but if you think you- I think we all pretty much understand. Well, you know, you don't know the
▶ Play
rest of the story, and the rest of the story is after that happened last night, I was in an elevator with a gentleman who had said he had committed not to ask for a roll call, but after he saw what happened with that roll call, it angered him so much that he himself called for a roll call. And those kind of tactics, I don't think, serve the people of the state of Arkansas. And that's why I'm making this motion. I appreciate it, sir. Just stand
▶ Play
by. If it's in the rule books, and if we can do that, then we'll accept your motion. but if it's not, the way I understand the rule book right
▶ Play
now, it's just going to be on a bill-by-bill basis. But the rule says, I understand, Mr. Chairman, the House with 51 votes can change whatever their rule they want to change if it does not violate the U.S. or the state constitution. Is that
▶ Play
correct? I think so, sir, but we're not on the House floor right now, and I can't get 51 votes for this meeting.
▶ Play
Speaker 47 17:22
I guess we will be at 1.30, won't we? Thank you.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 17:25
Thank you.
▶ Play
Mr. Hendren, it's been determined what we're going to do moving forward. This is going to be on a bill by bill basis. If members want to roll call, it just takes two members to roll call. And that's why we're going to operate the rest of this committee. So that being said, do we have a motion on the table for Senator Clark's bill for SB 9? Thank you. Senator Clark, for lack of motion, sir, this bill does not advance. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you. You're welcome, sir. Representative Hodges, you're going to present Senate Bill 688. Are you ready to go, sir? Members, this is going to be Senate Bill 688.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Speaker, Mr. Chair and the committee. With your permission, I'd like to have Mr. DePep up here and Julie Mullenix and I don't know if George Hopkins, if he wants to be up here or not. Yeah, I'll just bring everybody you want up there and let, when everybody
▶ Play
gets comfortable on the end of the table. In your
▶ Play
famous words, I need people up here that are smarter than I am. There you go, buddy. I feel your pain.
▶ Play
Just everybody recognize yourself and you guys get ready.
▶ Play
Mike Preston also. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chair. Joel DePippa, Senior Counsel, Department of Finance and Administration. George Hopkins,
▶ Play
Speaker 60 19:40
Executive Director, Arkansas Teacher Retirement System. Julie Mullinex with
▶ Play
Speaker 62 19:47
Mullinex and Associates. Mike Preston, Executive Director
▶ Play
Speaker 64 19:51
of Arkansas Economic Development Commission. Thank you, guys. Appreciate
▶ Play
everybody being here. Representative Hodges, get ready. Just go ahead,
▶ Play
sir. Okay. Thank you, Mr. Chair. You have before you SB 688, an act to amend certain tax incentives to amend the income tax credit for waste reduction, reuse, or recycling equipment, and to clarify the distribution of income tax credit for waste reduction, reuse, or recycling equipment. And if you guys can recall back in the 89th General Assembly, we did a lot of work to get Amendment 82 enacted or get it passed to attract a super project to the state of Arkansas, which was Big River Steel, which is in South Mississippi County, which is in my district. Almost three years ago, there was 1,300 acres of farmland, which has now been developed into a $1.3 billion steel mill. And I think everybody here at the table, they've been in Mississippi County and toured the facility. I've seen Mike Preston there, and I know George Hopkins, he probably knows more about the facility than the CEO of the company, and I'll have visited the site and seen what has taken place in Mississippi County. They currently have a little bit over 400 jobs, and also this is a good economic development piece of legislation. And all the parties that you see here at the table have worked very extremely hard in getting this piece of legislation drafted and put together and all. That's the reason we're just now bringing it to you guys. So this bill provides a mechanism for Arkansas economic development to ensure a positive cost benefit to the state in the evaluation of potential future steel projects that meet other eligibility criteria for the respective project described in the legislation, including steel mill expansion projects that have a capital investment of at least $1 billion, provide at least 500 jobs with an average salary of $75,000 per year, and steel specialty product manufacturing facilities that have a capital investment of at least $200 million and provide at least 150 jobs and an average salary of $75,000 a year. The legislation includes appropriation, appropriate callbacks to be determined by Arkansas economic development and agreement between the taxpayer and the state. During any single year that the jobs and salary numbers are not met, the cost benefit analysis will assist in determining the level of the callbacks required under the agreement. You know, and the good thing about this bill is that, you know, most tax credits, they're given up front. You know, we taxed ourselves in Mississippi County, and we give a business those dollars up front that are coming to our area. But with this piece of legislation, the tax credit will not be given until the project, the total capital investment is made. And the jobs have to be in place. So now I'm done, so we can open up for any questions that the committee may have. Members, any questions? Yes,
▶ Play
sir, Representative Hendren. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chairman. We've been talking about some other millage issues and bond issues in this session. And when we were doing that, I had some staff here getting me some information about bond issues. issued in this state up before this time. One of them they had, I think it dealt with this one, and I'm going to go by memory because I don't have the paper here, but I think it's close, was that Big River Steel, as I understand, was a $125 million bond issue or whatever that we borrowed. And I said, well, what does it cost us before we get that paid off? Hey guys, we've got people talking. I said, what does it cost us before the taxpayers pay off that $125 million bond issue? Now these may or not, but this is my recall. I think it's close in DFA, I guess, whoever's here. I was told, as I recall, that by the time we get that $125 million paid back, whoever will pay $182 million. That's $57 million more than what we actually put into that facility or whatever that project. And then I did a math with the old-fashioned math type thing we used to do before new math came in, and I think that's 46 percent more we spent on that deal than the revenue, than what we got out of the investment. Is that true, and is what we're going to do with this bill going to help mitigate some of that 46 percent cost of a deal? We dealt with a deal the other day on usury in Arkansas and, you know, these lenders that come in here and charge 200 percent, 46 percent. But is that figure wrong? And does this bill here do anything to help us get more bang for the buck rather than costing
▶ Play
us 46 percent? Representative Hendren, I don't have the exact numbers from Act 896 of 2013 on the top of my head, but that sounds like an appropriate ballpark from those discussions four years ago in the General Assembly. The bond issue did have provisions for the repayment schedule, which would include carrying some of that interest you've described. This bill- Excuse me.
▶ Play
Excuse me. Hey, guys, if you guys want to take a conversation around the corner or outside or something, I would certainly appreciate it. Thank
▶ Play
you. This bill has a number of provisions in it to ensure that there is a full positive cost benefit to the state under this particular program. This is modeled after both the 2013 and 2015 recycling tax credit legislation, if you recall that, but includes the ability for AEDC to be at the table with the taxpayer in determining the total possible amount, as well as those annual repayments that model the 2015 legislation we've discussed. This ensures that the state is going to be protected and that your concern is going to be in the capable hands of Mr. Preston and his team.
▶ Play
Thank you, sir. Members, any more questions? Anybody in audience want to speak against the bill? Mr. David Ray, are you in the room, sir? If you can find a chair down there someplace, just sit down and recognize yourself. And once
▶ Play
Speaker 73 27:03
you get yourself recognized, feel free to proceed, sir. All right, thank you, Mr. Chairman and members of the committee. I'm here today to speak against this bill, Senate Bill 688. Part of, first of all, the first point that I would make is that a bill of this magnitude really ought to require more thorough vetting than it has currently received. This bill was until very recently a shell bill on the Senate end. And then was run through committee yesterday morning and passed through the Senate floor yesterday afternoon and they rolled the vote. So I don't believe that this bill has received very thorough vetting from the members. The second point that I would make is that waste reduction and recycling is already the second biggest tax credit in Arkansas. And it will be the largest tax credit in Arkansas once the InvestARC credit has been fully phased out. The third point that I would make is I would like for members of this committee to consider the opportunity cost of creating more and larger tax credits within our tax code. At a price tag of $11 million a year, for example, you could reduce the corporate income tax rate by a tenth of a percent with simply $7 million a year. So that's something that would benefit all entities that pay the corporate income tax rate, rather than just one particular industry or one particular company. And with that, I would encourage the members of this committee to please vote
▶ Play
no on this bill. Thank you. Thank you, sir. Any questions for Mr. Ray? Mr. Ray, appreciate your testimony. Anybody in the audience want to speak for the
▶ Play
bill, against the bill, for the bill? If not, Representative Hodges, do you want to close for your bill, sir? Yes, I'd like to close for the bill. Like I said earlier, this is a good economic development bill. It passed in the Senate, 33 yeas, one nay, and one absent, was absent yesterday. And if Senator Hickey voted for it, it's a good bill. I saw him walking in and he tends to vet and critique very closely. And as a matter of fact, he and I worked on the recycling tax credit issue during a session prior. And he's very thorough, so it's a good bill, it's a good bill for the state of Arkansas. It's a good bill for Mississippi County, and I'd appreciate it. I'd offer a due pass on this bill.
▶ Play
Thank you, sir. Members, we heard testimony. Do we have any, do we have a motion? I'm sorry, I beg your pardon to hear you. I have a motion from Representative Hodges, due pass. Any debate? All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? No.
▶ Play
Congratulations, you passed your bill, sir. Thank you, illustrious
▶ Play
committee and chairman. Thank you. Members, we'll move down to Senate Bill 729. Is Senator Cheatham in the room by any chance? Okay, I'm going to run this bill. Ben, are you going to come? Members, we're going to do Senate Bill 729. Representative Jett, you are recognized to run your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Members, this bill comes to us from the Senate and Senator Cheatham's bill. In just the interest of fair disclosure, this is the agriculture bill. It talks about water impoundments for the farms. In just the interest of fair disclosure, I am a farmer, but I do not. participate in this program, nor do I have water reservoirs. So basically what this is, is farmers have the ability to, it's a conservational type program. Farmers have the ability to go on the back side of, say, an 80 acre field, put a 20 acre pond, and they recapture that water. And then they pump that water back up to the top side of the field. And it's a conservational type program. Over the years, I think, if my memory serves me right, I think it's a $9 tax credit. Is that correct? Okay. Yeah, it's up to, I'm sorry, $9,000 tax credit on a project. And that used to carry for a maximum of nine years. And actually what we're asking for is just carry the carry loss forward to 15 years. It's the only thing we're asking for. It's in a depressed farm economy right now, and we think this has helped, this would be good for agriculture and all up and down the delta. With that being said, I will entertain any questions. Thank you. Do you want to recognize your guest there so we can maybe have some questions for him? Yeah, I mean, this is being noble. You know, usually I say I've got somebody to the right of me who's really smart. This will be the exception to the rule. All right, thank you. Appreciate it, John. Do you have any questions for the committee? Seeing none. Is there anybody in the audience want to speak for or against the bill? Seeing none. Are you closed for your bill? I'm closed, and I appreciate a good vote, members. Any questions? Okay. Okay, we have a, do you give yourself a motion? Yeah, I can do that to make a motion do pass. We have a motion do pass, and you debate on the motion. Seeing none, all in favor say aye. Aye. All against, no. Thank you, committee. Ayes have it, congratulations, pass your bill. Representative Johnson, you have any problems, IT problems? That don't surprise me. Is Senator Fowles in the room?
▶ Play
Speaker 93 33:47
Are you wanting to run your bill 140? Members, we're going to roll down to
▶ Play
Senate Bill 140. Representative Collins. Mr. Collins had a motion for expungement for this bill. I recommend
▶ Play
that we expunge the vote by which SB 140 failed.
▶ Play
Thank you, sir. That is a proper motion. Any debate? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no. Ayes have it. Senator Fowles, you're field, yes, sir. Mr. Murdoch, I'm sorry, everybody hold tight. Representative Murdoch has an amendment. Representative Murdoch, can you go down to the end of the table and present your amendment, sir? Do we have the amendments passed out, staff? Bear with us, community, we're going to pass the amendment out. And also, members, you can look on your tablets. This amendment should be on the tablets by now. Representative Murdoch, just give us just a moment, sir, and we'll let you get going. Yes, sir. I'm sorry, this could be amendment 374 in your tablets, amendment 374 in the tablets. Representative Murdoch, is there a reason why DFA would want to see a copy of this amendment also? I've not read the amendment. Does DFA have a copy of the
▶ Play
Speaker 109 35:57
amendment? We can make sure they get a copy. It's pretty much the same as the previous amendment, just adding one additional item. Okay.
▶ Play
Staff, if you don't care, make sure that the folks at DFA has a copy of that as well. Everybody, members, you guys good with amendment, reading it? Everybody got a copy?
▶ Play
Speaker 109 36:50
DFA got a copy? Representative Murdock, go ahead, buddy. Thank you, Chairman. Thank you, Committee. We won't prolong this. This amendment just adds one item to the amendment that was presented by Representative Gray last time we ran this bill. It just adds a line item that sends $100 million to the Highway Department per the highway distribution law that we currently use. So, again, just trying to – the big picture here is trying to find a way in this process that we utilize for addressing the needs of the state in us coming together on a compromise. That's what this is. It's a compromise. And this is my seventh year down here, my fourth term. So you come to realize that nobody gets to everything that they want the way that they want it. And I think this is an opportunity for us to show the constituency that we represent, that we can come together to make something work together. Not perfect. It's not what everybody wants. But it's something that we've come together and made happen and addresses some of the real dire needs of people out there on those roads. which you're on those roads, is a very, very dire need. This doesn't address everything, but it certainly gives us an opportunity. It's new revenue. It's coming into the state. It's not a new tax. Hopefully we won't debate that today. But it is an opportunity to show that we've come together to make something happen to the good for our people. Let's do that. So please help me in passing this amendment, adding
▶ Play
this amendment to this bill. Thank you. I'll take questions. Thank you, Representative Murdoch. So basically, it's the same amendment that we've seen three times before with the added of $100 million going to the highway on code 277201. Yeah, just a small addition, just a small difference. Smaller difference. Yeah, just a small. I understand. You sound like my wife. Members, you got any questions? DFA, you want to go to the
▶ Play
Speaker 38 39:00
end of the table and help us pontificate on this? Mr. Chair, Paul
▶ Play
Goering, Assistant Revenue Commissioner, Department of Finance Administration. DFA has had an opportunity to take a look at this amendment. We do see that change. It appears to us there's an additional $100 million that would be spent on highways. These funds, the $25 million that was a prior portion of the amendment, as well as the additional $100 million, are certainly not accounted for in the state's budget. We don't think that this type of amendment to this bill is proper. We would, until the state has been able to establish the collections of these online retail sales taxes from these out-of-state retailers, we are not going to know the amount of collections that the state will receive until they're actually businesses that have been signed up and those taxes are actually being collected. So we think it'd be very difficult for the state to comply with the requirements of this amendment, for one, administratively, but also spending the money in this fashion before the money is collected, we would be
▶ Play
opposed. Representative Gray, you're recognized, sir.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Paul, just the facts, if you don't mind. This bill is contingent, or this amendment, it's contingent upon the collection of the revenue. And if I recall discussion in the amendment in the past, there is some set aside. So the capture of current online income that the state's receiving doesn't get lost in this new amendment. So I don't understand, and I can certainly be educated on it, but I don't understand the dynamic that you're describing in which the state could not satisfy this. Because it's not putting a burden on the state to find money to fund this amendment. It's only saying when we collect this money, this is how it will be directed. So, what am I missing? Well,
▶ Play
I think that the difficulty is that for one, until the monies are actually, the retailers have actually signed on to collect tax upon purchases to Arkansas residents, we're not going to know what that revenue actually is. So setting the cutoff of $195 million, and then turning around and then spending the money, and before the monies are actually known and collected, could be problematic. You're recognized for follow-up, sir.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. And Paul, I certainly can understand spending money, some of farmers, so I can definitely understand spending money before you get it, and not having it. But my question is still, this amendment is set up that you would only fund it if you collected it. So I'm still confused. If internet sales tax collection does not hit this number, I don't understand. I don't think this amendment is obligating the state to pay over what it collects. Am I
▶ Play
missing something? And possibly Representative Gray and other, by way of explanation, in the event that you do have perhaps a downturn in the economy and possibly income taxes suffer or another type of state tax suffers, you have already, but sales taxes increase, you would have the situation that those revenues that are being collected from the online sales tax in excess of the $195 million provided for in the bill have already been
▶ Play
and pledged to other spending. Let me follow up on that. Paul, say for example, the collections come in at $110 million. Will this not force the state to spend $125 million under this proposal? I'm sorry, Mr. Chair, could you repeat that? Well, if the collections, this arbitrary number, it's coming in at $110 million, will this not force the state to spend $125? So I know we're spending more money than what we're actually collecting, since we don't know exactly what the amount's going to be. Is
▶ Play
that a fair assessment? Well, this is the, I would have to take a look at this again, but it appears to be that these $125 million is, you would have to reach the threshold of $195 million before you start making the collections, and then over after you meet that threshold, it's spent in this fashion. Okay. Representative Flowers, you recognize, ma'am.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. As I listened to Representative Gray's questions and Paul's answers, it made me think about how we have a process whereby we budget hundreds of millions of dollars, billions of dollars recession and earmark costs for agencies and programs, and then we anticipate income through a number of sources. And so it seems to me that that's essentially what we do. We have not collected those taxes yet, and we're budgeting based upon what we anticipate the expenditures and the income is going
▶ Play
Speaker 129 45:00
to be. Wouldn't you agree? I think that the
▶ Play
main issue that we would just like to bring to bear on that specific point is the online collections of sales taxes. To determine that those are from companies that have no physical presence with the state of Arkansas is very difficult of a challenge. We have 75,000, 70,000 sales tax accounts in the state of Arkansas. of those we have about 16,000 of those are out of state companies or at least that they have an address on their account that's indicated to be an out of state company. So and not just be if a company is registered with an out of state address doesn't specifically mean that they have no physical presence in the state of Arkansas. So you may have a company that at the time that this this bill was passed had no physical presence but and then but registers for sales tax and then after that they may change their business model and that they do have a physical presence so they wouldn't be able to be counted in this bill because they no longer should be included as an online retailer
▶ Play
Speaker 113 46:06
that's no longer physically present in the
▶ Play
state of Arkansas. You have a follow-up, ma'am? Yes, Mr. Chair. I guess, so I would ask, based on this assessment, I think that in the whole time we have met this session, that this room has never been more full. I've never received more calls than on this bill, anticipating around $150 million in revenue for this. from my cities, from retailers, and I understand, I was also told that we're one of the only states that has not done this. So based upon that, would we have any reason at this point, definitive, factual reasons to believe that we won't collect revenue according to those estimates and according to the way that it is collected in most other states and according to the interest that we see here? Do we have any reason to believe that
▶ Play
we won't collect? Representative Flowers, there are sources of information that are easily quantifiable, such as the revenues that we collect through the streamlined sales tax agreement. We certainly have clear data from those of those retailers that have signed on to become hold a sales tax account in the state of Arkansas. And we're projected to collect around $15 million from those. The estimates that you mentioned of the excess of $100, $150 million, those are not figures that have come from DFA, and we certainly can't provide those types of numbers to anybody. Certainly, it's anticipated, as we put in our fiscal impact statement, that increased compliance through Senate Bill 140, it's anticipated that revenue may certainly increase as a result of greater collections of sales tax. But certainly there are a host of factors that can market behavior that could certainly is dependent upon whether or not somebody goes to a brick and mortar store or chooses to buy the item online if both retailers are collecting the tax. So certainly, and all of the, as you mentioned, the other states that are working through their legislation, a lot of that legislation is relatively new in quantifying the effects of those legislative actions. For example, in Colorado, their law was finally upheld in December, which is the House Bill 1388. We certainly can't for a law that's just recently been upheld by the Supreme Court failing to grant cert to quantify the impact of what these laws are going to do. We're not going to, we can't say that at this point that we have the type of information to say with any degree of certitude that we are going to collect those types of amounts of
▶ Play
money. Thank you. Members, any other questions? Representative Hendren.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. You mentioned a few minutes ago that I guess the DFA you're talking about has had no discussions or at least I understood you to say no discussions about how much money might be or where it could be used. And the reason I ask this question, I'm going to ask you to either confirm or deny that I got calls because I had been one that thinks this money ought to be used for specific things such as Douglass's roads, instead of just putting it in general funds. And I had two powerful lobby groups call me. I didn't call them. They called me. And I said, why not? And they said, because we need this money to go into education for facilities and stuff like that. Now, that came from two sources, from two people, two groups that pretty well know what they're doing with lobbying. And what bothers me then, I read the paper last week, and one of the school districts in one of our wealthier parts of the state, is going to build a $20 million high school, raise their millage to the highest in the state of Arkansas, and still only be able to generate less than half of that $20 million to build that high school. And the other $10 million will come out of these facilities funds that a bunch of us fought through with Lakeview. So my question to you is this. Has DFA or anybody in that administration discussed the possibility of this money from this hundred, whatever it is, $35 million, $150 million, going into, like these lobbyists have claimed, going into education facilities. Have those discussions ever been held that you're aware of? Well, certainly, Mr.
▶ Play
Hendren, these Senate Bill 140 and House Bill 1388, as they've worked through, there have been a lot of questions and a lot of discussions, and I'm not, you know, specifically aware of, I'm aware of all the other bills that have been out there that have been filed that such as, you know, transferring the money over to for purposes of reducing sales tax and income taxes, as well as spending the money on the highway department for road maintenance and construction. But that's the extent of the discussions that I've had on the bills that have been filed.
▶ Play
One specific follow-up. Yes, sir. Specifically, my question is, has there been any discussions in your group that you're aware of about taking part or all that hundred and six, whatever million it is, and
▶ Play
putting it into education for facilities? Absolutely not, Representative Hendren. That would run afoul of exactly what I was just talking about. We're trying at all costs to avoid discussions of spending money before it's actually being collected. Representative Douglas, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. So general revenue is made up, correct me on this if I'm wrong, mainly of individual income tax, corporate income tax, and sales tax, correct? Correct. Would it not be cleaner, since this is sales tax that could be on blue jeans or bubble gum or whatever you buy off the Internet, And should, by all means, go into general revenue, wouldn't it be cleaner to fund highways to transfer a user item sales tax, like the sales tax on new cars or used cars or something like that that is related to the roads than something that is totally unrelated to the roads, in your opinion? Representative Douglas, I'd have to avoid any type of policy commentary on the proper method to fund highways, but certainly I'm aware of the discussions that have been spoken with the Good Roads Foundation and the other organizations that have discussed options for finding appropriate revenue for highways. But that would be a cleaner, more easily identifiable way to segregate the funds, would it not? I can agree that the amount of revenues that are collected on some of those items that you have mentioned, such as the sales of new and used vehicles, that's certainly a very clear and identifiable source of revenues. When it comes to other items such as car parts and things like that that are sold by a general retailer, it's much more difficult to identify those sources of revenue because those aren't broken out on a taxpayer's monthly sales tax report. Okay, thank you.
▶ Play
Thank you. Member, any other questions? Representative Murdoch, you want to, I'm sorry, anybody want to speak against the amendment? Yes, sir, Representative Fowles. I'm sorry, Senator Fowles. Sorry, no problem. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chair. Another motion. That's a promotion. I would just ask the committee for a vote on the clean bill, as I have in the past. I know I'm wearing out my welcome down here, and I will be very brief when I give explanation of the bill and get back to it. But like a clean bill, I think this challenges the constitutionality of it, as we've talked about in the past, of distributing revenues. And the court's looking at this just from one thing to another. But if it doesn't pass, it doesn't pass. But I would like to ask the committee to vote on a clean bill. I
▶ Play
appreciate it, Mr. Chair. You're welcome, sir. Anybody in the audience want to speak against the bill, for the bill, amendment? I'm sorry. Representative Murdock,
▶ Play
Speaker 109 54:52
you want to close for your amendment, sir? Yes, sir. Just real quick, a couple of points. Paul, you focused a lot of the conversation on collections and what will happen with funds. And obviously, it was spoken to by members pretty articulately that how we do business down here a lot of times is based upon the come, based upon the receiving of revenue, be it tax revenue, expect it, or it shows up or not shows up. We're experiencing some of that now. So a lot of our plans that we make are based on anticipated revenues from various sources. Again, that has been articulated. So this bill does not bring anything, the state, into any peril without the receipt of the funds. So the revenue is the trigger. The revenue don't make it, then we're not obligated. So that addresses that. But we spent a lot of time on that for some reason. Then you talked about some of the legal concerns of what can happen with this type of collection and some of those comments, well, SB 140 clean is subject to the same thing. This is just simply an amendment to the same type of collection. This is an amendment. This is a distribution amendment. It's not an amendment to how we're going to do the collection. That's a clean SB 140. So in a sense, you're speaking or you're casting doubt on the bill itself. I hadn't seen you speak to SB 140 without the amendment in such a manner. So that's a concern that you're speaking to those concerns as we talk about amendments and distribution of the money. But the bill itself is still basically the same, the gut of the bill, in terms of how it will be handled. So that was another concern. Obviously, whenever we're dealing with money coming in, money going out, we make priorities. In each session, we come, and in fiscal sessions, we change based upon the needs of the state. This is a situation that has arisen that we need to address. It's been here. It's been present. I don't think there is a member in this body and in this committee that will not submit to the need that we have currently with our highways and the other things that are in this amendment. The administration have committed to a lot of these things, not my amendment. The administration is not a part of my amendment, but they have committed to a lot of these things inside of the amendment in terms of for the good of the people. I asked the committee if they would please support me in helping move forward in showing the state of Arkansas that we can come together and compromise. We're not going to do anything that would be considered Washington-style politics. We're not going to do those type of things to one another. We're going to come together, do what's good for the state of Arkansas, and move forward so we can go home. Thank you. Thank you, sir. Do you want to make your motion? Move, do pass the amendment, can you do pass the
▶ Play
amendment? Okay, members, we have a motion on the table to adopt amendment to Senate Bill 140. Any debate? All in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed say no. No. Call the roll, Ms. Eden. You could have did it from there, Chairman, and just say it. I understand, but I've got Representative Douglas up there screaming in my ear. Okay. That's the problem. Representative Warren. Representative Watson. No. Representative Gray. Yes. Representative Flowers. Yes.
▶ Play
Speaker 146 58:48
MS. Representative Johnson. MR. Yes. MS. Representative Ferguson. MR. Yes. MS. Representative Eves. MR. No. MS. Representative Hendren. MR. Yes. MS. Representative Douglas. MR. No. MS. Representative Hodges. MR. Yes. MS. Representative Saban. MR. Yes. Yes. Representative Dotson. Representative Dotson. Representative Bolts. Yes. Representative Murdoch. Yes. Representative Collins.
▶ Play
Speaker 155 1:00:00
No. Representative Letting.
▶ Play
Speaker 48 1:00:08
Representative Letting. Thank you.
▶ Play
I'm sorry, Representative Murdoch, your bill amendment has failed to 10-6. What were the last two votes?
▶ Play
Speaker 109 1:00:26
I didn't hear the co-chair and chair. It's 10-6-2. No, on the roll call. What was the co-chair and the chair's votes on the roll
▶ Play
call? The co-chair was no, and I didn't vote. But I would be a no if you want me on record, sir. Thank you. You're welcome. Thank you, committee.
▶ Play
Speaker 160 1:00:46
Senator Fowles, are you ready to proceed,
▶ Play
sir? I think so. Am I recognized, Mr. Chair? Yes, sir. Thank you. Members, I appreciate your indulgence throughout this session. This is a tough bill and has the opportunity to probably have the most impact of anything we do down here for all of our local businesses and for cities and counties as well, as well as the state. I don't know if you saw yesterday, but Amazon has agreed to collect taxes in all 50 states that everyone that has a sales tax, they're going to collect in now. So I think the constitutionality probably has been addressed with that as well. Our job as legislators is to come down here and distribute, to make policy decisions and then to distribute on the backside as well. This gives us an opportunity, as you all know, to levelize the playing field for our local mom-and-pop businesses and to continue to do what's right by the people of Arkansas and not reward out-of-state sellers. I'd be happy to take any questions, and I appreciate a good vote.
▶ Play
Thanks, Sheriff. Senator Gray, you recognize. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Senator Files, thank you for your good-natured approach. I know this has been as tiring on you as everyone. My question would be, with the income tax reductions we've seen over the last three general assemblies, Now this one and the two previous, and this is going to be a method of sales tax collection that many will see as a new tax to them, because it's a new collection method. I have some real concern that this will be disproportionately felt by the members of our constituency that as most sales regressive taxes are on the lower income parts of our community versus the cuts to income tax. It seems that we're finding a new method to collect sales tax for makeup for gaps that we've created by reductions in income tax.
▶ Play
Can you speak to that at all, please? Sure, I'll try. I think the task force is going to look at the methods of which we tax and try to make us more competitive, and I think that that will be their main charge. As you know, and all of us around this table know as policy makers, this is not a new tax. And although we get the emails that talk about a new tax, the taxes are currently due. So while I do share your concern that it's perceived that way at times, I wouldn't have picked it up if it was a new tax. I don't think anybody at this table would have either. And looking forward on the income tax side, we don't know what the revenues will be. Let's say that they're $100 million, and there has been strong push from the governor's office to continue to cut income taxes to make us more competitive. But there are also other things that probably need to be addressed in terms of exemptions, in terms of other methods of taxation, and just how we tax as a whole. So I hope that this will give us a platform to do more, whether that be income tax reform or some other tax reform. And I appreciate your kind comments. I've enjoyed working through this process, and I think that, as Representative Murdoch said, this is our opportunity to come together and not just go, hey, I didn't get my way, so I'm leaving. I'm not going to vote on this, or I'm not going to be a part of the discussion, because all of us have a voice and all of us represent the same kinds of people. Mr. Gray, you have a follow-up,
▶ Play
sir? Yes, Mr. Chair, and Senator Faust, thank you for that answer. I just would wrap up with wouldn't you agree that a sales tax in general is going to be harder on those with less disposable income, or what would be commonly referred to as the working people in Arkansas. Wouldn't you agree that usually a sales tax is harder on that group of people? I think you have a point
▶ Play
to be made there, and also the fact that taxes are already due to me is a bit of a wash, but that is a fair point. Thank you, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Hendren, you recognize her? Just a question to Senator Fowles or maybe the chair or the staff. It seems like I recognize this number here, this Senate bill. What is it, 140? Could you tell me, Senator Fowles, or could the staff tell me how many times this session we voted in this committee on this bill? I can tell you. How many? You voted three times and expunged the vote three times. How many more do you think it might take? Today's it.
▶ Play
One way or the other, today's it. Members, any other questions?
▶ Play
Representative Armstrong, you recognize, sir. Not a question. May I be indulged for a comment? Maybe. What's your
▶ Play
Speaker 165 1:05:47
comment, sir? I just have to go on record and say, Mr. Chair and Senator Faust, thank you. If today is it and we are to get to the space and place where we are operating from where the center once used to hold this place together, it would be my challenge to those like Representative Collins, who has agreed to continue to go to the mat with us, our chairman, Mr. Jett, you, Senator Faust, and other members to take charge of what we have to do as legislators to ensure that the constituents we represent properly get their just due, and it's not overladen or overbared by what lobbyists or special interest groups have hammered us on and traded some of our information, unfortunately, for the greater good of their efforts. And that's not what we're here for. So, Mr. Chairman, with that, I thank you for being patient with us. Mr. Fowles, thank you for your patience as well. That's kind of you, sir.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Armstrong. Members, any other questions? Do you not just want to speak against the bill? Yes, sir. Please come to
▶ Play
the end of the table and recognize yourself. One more time, I just briefly would like to ask you all to
▶ Play
Speaker 167 1:07:01
vote this down. It's been killed three times and I just hope you all would not snatch defeat Out of the jaws of victory, I think passing this would be a defeat against the Arkansas people. Please
▶ Play
kill it. Thank you, sir. Anybody want to speak for the bill? Mr. Gary Fletcher, union audience. Recognize yourself, sir, and who you're with, and
▶ Play
Speaker 169 1:07:28
proceed. My name is Gary Fletcher, I'm the mayor of the city of Jacksonville. I'd like to address a couple of things real quickly. Senator Gray was talking about, is this not tax on the poor? I tell you, a greater burden than tax on the people is to lose their jobs in retail, because retail generally employs those kind of people. I'm sorry.
▶ Play
Hit your button again. I just shut you down. Keep that in mind. If you go too long, I'll do it again. I'm not a Baptist preacher. I understand. I also want to say, I hear this idea of
▶ Play
Speaker 169 1:07:59
a new tax and all that stuff. And I wrote down something when I heard that, and I'm going to read off my card because I didn't have no paper right there. But I said it's not a new tax because in the barter system, retail sales is as old as businesses sell. And we've always had sales tax on retail sales up until this modern age of Internet sales that nobody even dreamed of maybe 10, 20 years ago. But I want to tell you right now, Representative Bob Johnson, I expect him to support me in this thing because I'm the one that's got to sit down and figure out how to, last November, how was I going to cut $1.6 million on my budget when cities live on sales tax. And, you know, Municipal League has a saying on their building in concrete that strong cities make a strong state. We all applaud economic development, but I'll tell you something just as important as economic development is economic stability. And if you open a door and make a door real big on the front of a building to try to drive industries and jobs into your state, but you don't do anything to shut the back door where you're losing your retail jobs. Folks, right now, it's even getting into the malls. We're seeing national change. Just pick up the business magazines, read the newspapers of how many national chains are shutting down and closing stores and malls. I'm talking about Main Street. When you're talking about trying to bring an industry in your town, they're not coming to listen to a politician like me telling them about how great the town is. All they've got to do is drive down one street in any city, and it's called Main Street. And when they've got empty buildings there, they know right there, Why would they come and invest millions of dollars in a city and the town is run down with empty buildings? And when I think of empty buildings and empty Main Street, I think of Detroit. We've all seen those commercials. I don't want our cities or our cities and our state having that. I want to see our city growing and be progressive. It's the most fair thing to level that playing field. The Internet salespeople are not going to be the ones that employ your local people. They're not going to be the ones that come out here and sponsor your local Little League baseball teams. We've got to take care of each other. And you're going to go back, and I hope that you talk to your mayors and your county judges. 65% of my budget is sales tax. And I'm blessed to have the Little Rock Air Force Base out there. I provide fire protection out there. I'm called out there for police. I'm having a hard time buying police cars last year. I am dreading November sitting down and trying to put a budget together. I am begging you. Of all the things you've done, I've seen the shell bills and the hundreds of bills y'all got filed. There's not a bill y'all going to pass. that's going to have the greatest impact and greatest positive impact, hopefully, if you pass this, on the cities and the counties and the state, then there's one bill right here for the next past sessions and the future sessions, as far as I'm concerned. Thank you, sir. Thank you. Anybody not even want to speak
▶ Play
against the bill? For the bill, Senator Fowles, you want to close for your bill? Appreciate a good vote. Thank you. Do we have a motion? We have a motion from Representative Douglas. You want to make your motion, sir? Motion do pass. As amended. Yes. Any debate? All in favor say aye. Any opposed? No. Ayes have it. Congratulations, sir. You passed your bill. Thank you, members. I appreciate your indulgence.
▶ Play
I promise that I will work with you on this moving forward. Thank you. Well, once again, that was really fun.
▶ Play
We got one more bill, members, so everybody just please don't leave. We're going to take a look at Senate Bill 450. It's Senator Hester's bill, and Representative
▶ Play
Speaker 173 1:11:36
Collins is going to run the bill. Senate Bill 450. Are the land commissioner
▶ Play
Speaker 104 1:11:47
folks here? Thank you, sir. Thank you.
▶ Play
Mr. Collins, you get ready, sir. You're ready to go, buddy.
▶ Play
Speaker 35 1:12:08
Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. Excuse
▶ Play
me, just a second. Hey, everybody standing in the county hallways, take your conversations outside, please. Thank you very much. I'm sorry, Representative Collins. Thank you very much, Mr.
▶ Play
Chair. I've got someone from the land commissioner's office that's going to help me. Although, this is a bill that cleans up our property registration and other tax approaches. It's coming with AG office approval. There's no known opposition. Senator Hester assures me this bill is good in every way, and there's no problems at all. If there are no questions, I'm closed. Senator Hendren, that was Senate Bill 450.
▶ Play
And Representative Collins, that gave me really good comfort knowing that Senator Hester assured us, so it made me feel good. Any questions? Anybody in the United States want to speak against the bill, for the bill? Representative Collins, you want to close for
▶ Play
your bill, sir? I'm closed, sir, and I move do pass on Senate Bill 450. Any debate, members?
▶ Play
All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? Congratulations, sir, you passed your bill. Thank you very much, Mr. Chair and Committee. Members, hang on just a second, we'll do a little bit of housekeeping. Hey, members, here's what we're going to do going forward. I know we got a lot of members left the room, but we got some Senate House bills coming back to us. We got to get concurred, so either we're going to do one or two things. We're going to come back this afternoon, immediately call of the chair. It's going to be on the agenda, or we're going to come in at 10 o'clock tomorrow morning and We're working around state agencies as well. I know Representative Collins at least has his own bill coming back. We've got to concur and we've got to work through. So everybody pay attention to what's going
▶ Play
on when we're there. Yes, Representative Hendrick. Just a question. I see the Senate's meeting at 9 or 10 o'clock this morning. Do you know if the House plans to meet tomorrow afternoon or not? I do not, sir. We are not? No, I don't know
▶ Play
yet, sir. That's the stuff that we're working through right now. Everything's kind of getting balled up. So just kind of pay attention to the text and to the notes and check the House website. We'll get this kind of cleared away, but we got two or three bills, we got to get cleaned up before we get out of here. With that, members, I appreciate your patience. I know it's been a long trying day and this meeting is adjourned.
▶ Play

Agenda

REGULAR AGENDA

SB450 Hester TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE SALE AND REDEMPTION OF TAX-DELINQUENT PROPERTY.

1:11:31 - 0:11

Representative Charlie Collins introduced SB 450, describing it as a cleanup of property-registration and tax-delinquent-property procedures, noting Attorney General approval and no known opposition. [1:12:22] [1:12:26] [1:12:49]

Collins moved to pass the bill, and after a voice vote the committee approved SB 450 unanimously. [1:13:06] [1:13:09]

SB663 Files TO CLARIFY THAT AN ACCOMMODATIONS INTERMEDIARY IS REQUIRED TO COLLECT AND REMIT THE SALES TAX AND TOURISM TAX DUE ON ARRANGEMENTS THE ACCOMMODATIONS INTERMEDIARY MAKES FOR THE SALE OR USE OF AN ACCOMMODATION.

SB9 A. Clark TO ENCOURAGE CHARITABLE GIVING AND ELIMINATE PERVERSE AND ABSURD TAXES AND DISINCENTIVES ON CHARITABLE GIVING; AND TO EXEMPT CERTAIN WITHDRAWALS OF STOCK FROM THE SALE AND USE TAX

0:11 - 20:11 65 segments 14 speakers

Senator Alan Clark introduced SB 9, arguing that charitable donors currently pay sales tax on donated goods-such as Habitat for Humanity shipments and food-bank donations-and that eliminating this tax would aid disaster relief and local charities (). [0:34] [1:04] [1:41] [2:13]

Committee members, including Chair Rep. Joe Jett and DFA Representative Dan M. Douglas, examined the fiscal impact, with DFA presenting a statement that estimated roughly $62.8 million in donations and a $1 million sales-tax loss, while noting data limitations for many retailers (,,). [3:53] [4:27] [5:05] [5:39] [7:05] [7:17] [7:48] [8:25] [8:51] [9:21] [9:28]

After a series of questions about tracking donations and budget offsets and Senator Clark’s closing remarks, the committee reported that no motion was made to advance the bill, so SB 9 did not move forward (). [17:55] [18:25]

SB688 TO AMEND THE INCOME TAX CREDIT FOR WASTE REDUCTION, REUSE, OR RECYCLING EQUIPMENT; AND TO DECLARE EN EMERGENCY

20:11 - 31:04 30 segments 6 speakers

Rep. Monte Hodges introduced SB 688, outlining that it would tie tax credits for waste-reduction equipment to large steel-project investments, requiring at least $1 billion in capital, 500 jobs at $75 k salary, and that credits would be paid only after those thresholds are met (). [20:42] [21:17] [21:49] [22:24] [22:55] [23:28]

Committee members discussed the bill’s cost-benefit, with Rep. Kim Hendren raising concerns about past bond costs and Rep. Aaron Pilkington explaining that the legislation includes safeguards and AEDC involvement to protect the state’s finances (). [23:41] [23:45] [24:01] [24:33] [25:05] [25:34] [25:39] [25:54] [26:04] [26:10]

After public opposition from David Ray questioning the bill’s vetting and fiscal impact, Rep. Hodges moved a due-pass, which was adopted unanimously, so SB 688 was approved by the committee (). [29:11] [29:30] [30:01] [30:19]

SB729 TO AMEND THE CARRY FORWARD PROVISION RELATING TO THE INCOME TAX CREDIT ALLOWED FOR WATER IMPOUNDMENTS.

31:04 - 35:06 13 segments 4 speakers

Chair Rep. Joe Jett presented SB 729, noting it would extend the carry-forward period for a $9,000 water-impoundment tax credit from nine to fifteen years to aid farmers (). [31:06] [31:37] [32:09]

With no opposition or questions, the committee moved and adopted a motion to pass the bill, approving it unanimously (). [32:40]

SB140 TO PROVIDE FOR THE COLLECTION OF SALES AND USE TAX RATHER THAN USE TAX ON SALES BY CERTAIN REMOTE SELLERS.

35:06 - 1:14:30 125 segments 24 speakers

Representative Murdoch (speaking for Representative Gray) presented amendment 374 to SB 140, adding a $100 million line item for the Highway Department and emphasizing that it is a compromise, not a new tax. [36:50] [37:10] [37:41] [38:12] [38:24]

The Department of Finance Administration, represented by Dan M. Douglas, objected that the added $100 million is not budgeted, arguing that spending before the online sales-tax collections are known would be administratively improper. [39:18] [39:49] [40:16] [41:24] [41:29] [42:00]

Committee members, including Representatives Gray, Flowers, and Hendren, questioned the revenue projections and collection feasibility, with Douglas noting limited data on out-of-state retailer compliance and uncertainty about the anticipated $150 million-plus revenue. [44:10] [44:44] [45:00] [45:05] [45:17] [45:53] [46:06] [46:11] [46:30] [47:02] [47:33] [48:05] [48:35] [49:11]

A motion to adopt the amendment as amended was taken; after roll-call the amendment failed 10-yes, 6-no, 2-abstentions, with both the chair and co-chair voting no. [57:58] [58:18] [58:48] [59:19] [1:00:00] [1:00:08] [1:00:16] [1:00:26] [1:00:37]

DEFERRED BILLS

HB1028 Lemons TO EXEMPT CERTAIN BUSES, COACHES, AND OTHER MOTOR VEHICLES FROM SALES AND USE TAXES.

HB1252 Rye TO AMEND THE INCOME TAX DEDUCTION ALLOWED FOR MEDICAL AND DENTAL EXPENSES; AND TO REMOVE THE THRESHOLD FOR CLAIMING AN INCOME TAX DEDUCTION FOR MEDICAL AND DENTAL EXPENSES.

HB1263 Jett TO CREATE A SALES AND USE TAX EXEMPTION FOR PARTS FOR AND REPAIR OF AGRICULTURAL EQUIPMENT AND MACHINERY.

HB1227 Farrer TO REDUCE INCOME TAX RATES IN CERTAIN CIRCUMSTANCES; AND TO REDUCE INCOME TAX RATES BASED ON THE GROWTH OF INCOME TAX COLLECTIONS.

HB1399 Ballinger HONOR ARKANSAS VETERANS ACT OF 2017.

HB1409 House TO CREATE AN EXEMPTION FROM THE INCOME TAX FOR SERVICE PAY AND ALLOWANCES OF FOREIGN SERVICE PERSONNEL.

SB120 J. English TO AMEND ARKANSAS TAX LAW CONCERNING INCOME TAX, SALES AND USE TAXES, AND THE SOFT DRINK TAX; AND TO SUPPLEMENT THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM TRUST FUND TO OFFSET DECREASED DEPOSITS FROM TAX REVENUES

HB1037 Wardlaw TO REPEAL THE REQUIREMENT THAT CERTAIN RETAILERS PREPAY SALES TAXES.

HB1253 Wardlaw TO REPEAL THE REQUIREMENT THAT CERTAIN RETAILERS PREPAY SALES TAXES.

HB1412 Ballinger TO PROVIDE FOR A PARTIAL PROPERTY TAX EXEMPTION FOR DISABLED VETERANS IN PROPORTION TO THE EXTENT OF THE DISABILITY OF THE VETERAN.

HB1395 Leding TO CREATE AN INCOME TAX CREDIT FOR TAXPAYERS THAT EMPLOY A RECENTLY RETURNED VETERAN.

HB1396 Leding TO EXEMPT FROM THE INDIVIDUAL INCOME TAX EDUCATION SCHOLARSHIPS, AWARDS, AND GRANTS FROM NONPROFIT VOLUNTEER SERVICE ORGANIZATIONS.

HB1397 Leding TO EQUALIZE THE SALES TAX TREATMENT OF DUES AND MEMBERSHIP FEES FOR CERTAIN CLUBS AND FACILITIES; AND TO LEVY A SALES TAX ON DUES AND MEMBERSHIP FEES TO CERTAIN FACILITIES AND CLUBS.

HB1449 Dotson TO AMEND THE ANNUAL FRANCHISE TAX FOR CORPORATIONS THAT ARE IN THE PROCESS OF LIQUIDATION.

HB1531 G. Hodges TO CREATE AN INCOME TAX CREDIT FOR EDUCATIONAL LOAN PAYMENTS FOR QUALIFIED INDIVIDUALS AND EMPLOYERS OF QUALIFIED INDIVIDUALS.

HB1512 Davis TO REDUCE THE INCOME TAX RATES APPLICABLE TO INDIVIDUALS, TRUSTS, AND ESTATES USING REVENUES DERIVED FROM SALES AND USE TAX FROM SELLERS THAT DO NOT HAVE A PHYSICAL PRESENCE IN THE STATE; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

HB1684 Jett TO EXTEND THE STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS FOR DETERMINING THE CORRECT AMOUNT OF TAX DUE IN RELATION TO CERTAIN AMENDED RETURNS OR VERIFIED CLAIMS FOR CREDIT OR REFUND.

HB1790 Dotson TO AMEND THE INCOME TAX PROVISIONS CONCERNING THE APPORTIONMENT OF BUSINESS INCOME; AND TO REPEAL THE THROWBACK RULE.

HB1693 Rye TO AMEND THE DISTRIBUTION AND USE OF SALES AND USE TAX REVENUES.

HB1788 Dotson TO PHASE IN AN EXTENSION OF THE NET OPERATING LOSS CARRY-FORWARD PERIOD FOR CALCULATING ARKANSAS INCOME TAX; AND TO MAKE TECHNICAL CHANGES.

HB1789 Dotson TO AMEND LAWS CONCERNING THE CORPORATE FRANCHISE TAX; TO REPEAL THE ARKANSAS CORPORATE FRANCHISE TAX ACT OF 1979; TO MAKE CONFORMING CHANGES.

HB1845 Richey TO CREATE AN INCOME TAX EXEMPTION FOR TEACHERS EMPLOYED IN CRITICAL TEACHER SHORTAGE AREAS.

HB1850 Leding TO CREATE THE STRONG FAMILIES ACT; AND TO CREATE AN INCOME TAX CREDIT FOR EMPLOYERS THAT PROVIDE PAID FAMILY AND MEDICAL LEAVE FOR CERTAIN EMPLOYEES.

HB1582 Dotson TO EXEMPT CERTAIN ELECTION EQUIPMENT FROM SALES AND USE TAXES; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

HB1824 J. Williams TO ALLOW A PROPERTY TAX EXEMPTION FOR DISABLED VETERANS WITH A ONE HUNDRED PERCENT (100%) TOTAL DISABILITY THAT MAY NOT BE PERMANENT; AND TO CLARIFY THE REQUIREMENTS FOR ESTABLISHING ELIGIBILITY FOR THE EXEMPTION.

HB1535 K. Hendren TO AMEND THE DISTRIBUTION AND USE OF SALES AND USE TAX REVENUES.

HB2100 Jett TO AMEND AND MODERNIZE THE LAW CONCERNING THE APPORTIONMENT OF INCOME DERIVED FROM MULTISTATE OPERATIONS; TO CHANGE THE METHOD FOR SOURCING OF RECEIPTS FOR SERVICES AND INTANGIBLES.

HB2066 Hammer TO PROVIDE FOR A PARTIAL REBATE OF DISTILLATE SPECIAL FUEL TAXES IN CERTAIN CIRCUMSTANCES; AND TO CREATE THE DISTILLATE SPECIAL FUEL TAX REFUND FUND.

HB2068 Hammer TO RETURN EXCESS FEDERAL GRANT FUNDS TO THE UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT; AND TO ENCOURAGE RELIEF OF THE NATIONAL DEBT OF THE UNITED STATES.

HB2062 Hammer TO EASE THE BURDEN ON TAXPAYERS; TO OFFSET EXCESS REVENUES AVAILABLE TO THE STATE; AND TO AMEND THE USE AND DISTRIBUTION OF CERTAIN REVENUES.

HB1647 C. Douglas TO EXCLUDE MANUFACTURER REBATES ON MOTOR VEHICLES FROM THE DEFINITIONS USED FOR PURPOSES OF DETERMINING SALES AND USE TAXES.

HB1965 Jett TO REPEAL PROVISIONS REGARDING THE USE OF SALES AND USE TAX REVENUES FROM REMOTE SELLERS; TO DEPOSIT SALES AND USE TAX REVENUES FROM REMOTE SELLERS INTO A FUND TO BE USED BY THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

HB1565 Jett TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE ISSUANCE AND EXPIRATION OF GROSS RECEIPTS TAX PERMITS AND THE COLLECTION OF UNPAID TAXES UPON DISCONTINUATION OF BUSINESS.

HB2276 Gonzales TO REQUIRE THE DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE AND ADMINISTRATION TO REPORT THE REVENUE IMPACT OF EACH TAX AND EACH TAX CREDIT, DEDUCTION, AND EXEMPTION.

HB1795 Gates TO EXEMPT CERTAIN DONATED ITEMS FROM SALES AND USE TAXES.

HB1796 Gates TO AMEND THE TIME LIMITATIONS FOR TAX ASSESSMENTS, COLLECTIONS, REFUNDS, AND PROSECUTION; AND TO LIMIT THE TIME AVAILABLE FOR A TAX AUDIT.

HB2256 V. Flowers TO ALLOW AN INCOME TAX INCENTIVE FOR CERTAIN FITNESS AND NUTRITION EXPENSES.

HB1853 Ladyman TO AMEND THE DEADLINE FOR ASSESSING TANGIBLE PERSONAL PROPERTY.

HB1911 Bragg TO CLARIFY THE APPLICATION OF THE INCOME TAX CREDIT FOR WASTE REDUCTION, REUSE, OR RECYCLING EQUIPMENT USED FOR WOOD AND WOOD FIBER.

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Senator Alan Clark Unverified
12 segments
Representative Joe Jett Chair Unverified
65 segments
Representative Dan M. Douglas Chair Unverified
39 segments
Representative Ken Bragg Chair Unverified
1 segment
Representative Bob Johnson Unverified
2 segments
Representative Kim Hendren Chair Unverified
30 segments
Speaker 38
2 segments
Speaker 47
1 segment
Representative Monte Hodges Unverified
13 segments
Representative Aaron Pilkington Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 60
1 segment
Speaker 62
1 segment
Speaker 64
1 segment
Speaker 73
5 segments
Speaker 93
1 segment
Representative Charlie Collins Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 109
13 segments
Representative Michelle Gray Unverified
8 segments
Representative Vivian Flowers Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 129
1 segment
Speaker 113
1 segment
Speaker 146
2 segments
Speaker 155
1 segment
Speaker 48
1 segment
Speaker 160
1 segment
Representative Eddie L. Armstrong Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 165
2 segments
Paul Calvert Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 167
2 segments
Speaker 169
8 segments
Speaker 173
1 segment
Speaker 104
1 segment
Speaker 35
1 segment