Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House Meeting

May 3, 2017 ·House ·2:52:43
Video Transcript

Summary

Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 12, 2026

SB3 J. Dismang (Gillam) TO AMEND ARKANSAS WORKS TO REDUCE INCOME ELIGIBILITY LIMITS AND IMPOSE WORK REQUIREMENTS; TO ALLOW THE FLEXIBILITY TO SELECT WHETHER TO… 12:07

Representative Jeremy Gillam called Rep. Ballinger to present Senate Bill 3, which would amend Arkansas works to reduce income-eligibility limits, impose work requirements, allow the state to choose between “assessment” or “determination” status, and declare an emergency. [12:25] [12:33] [12:45]

After the presentation, Gillam asked whether any member wished to speak for or against the bill, receiving no response before closing debate. [12:57]

The House then voted on the bill and its emergency clause, recording 69 yeas, 21 nays and two members present, and the measure passed. [13:04]

SB1 J. Dismang (Gillam) TO INTEGRATE AND INCORPORATE THE PROVISIONS OF ACTS 2017, NOS. 207, 312, AND 1108 INTO ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION, ARTICLE 19, § 30; AND TO … 13:52

19, §30) and declare an emergency, was presented by Rep. John Maddox, who noted it was the same bill voted on the previous day. [13:58] [14:02]

Rep. Gillam asked if anyone wished to speak against the bill; no member objected and the debate was closed. [14:10] [14:12]

The House approved the bill and its emergency clause with 87 yeas, 1 nay and 3 present, resulting in passage. [14:42]

SB2 J. Dismang (Gillam) TO INTEGRATE AND INCORPORATE THE PROVISIONS OF ACTS OF 2017 INTO ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION, AMENDMENT 98, ALSO KNOWN AS THE "ARKANSAS MEDIC… 14:59

Senate Bill 2, also sponsored by Rep. Gillam, would incorporate the 2017 Acts into the Arkansas Constitution as Amendment 98 (the Medical Marijuana Amendment) and declare an emergency; Rep. Carol Dalby introduced the measure, noting it mirrored a bill passed the day before. [15:07] [15:11] [15:14]

Following the presentation, Gillam again solicited comments for or against the bill, received none, and moved to a vote. [15:18]

The measure and its emergency clause were adopted by a vote of 89 yeas, 1 nay and no members present, passing the legislation. [15:48]

SB4 J. Dismang (Gillam) CONCERNING THE ARKANSAS HEALTH INSURANCE MARKETPLACE; TO STUDY THE FUTURE DIRECTION OF THE ARKANSAS HEALTH INSURANCE MARKETPLACE; AND T… 16:06

The House considered Senate Bill 4, a study of the Arkansas Health Insurance Marketplace with an emergency declaration, presented by Speaker Pitt; after a brief explanation, Rep. Gillam opened the floor for remarks, but the discussion quickly shifted to procedural questions about the Speaker’s authority to convene a caucus. [16:14] [16:19] [16:25]

Representatives Walker, Hendren, and Ballinger questioned Gillam’s implied authority and the need for prior notice, with Gillam asserting his power under House rules but acknowledging no specific citation, while Ballinger raised a point of order that the debate was off-topic. [16:38] [16:49] [17:21] [17:51] [18:17] [18:24] [18:57] [19:12] [19:31] [19:42] [19:50]

Bills to be considered which have been introduced by Joint Budget Committee 20:00

After addressing earlier procedural concerns, the House proceeded to vote on Senate Bill 4; the bill and its emergency clause passed with 84 yeas, 3 nays and 6 present. [20:01] [20:31] [20:48] [20:56]

The session then moved to the yellow budget calendar, and the clerk was instructed to read Senate Bill 5, which would amend Act 1 of 2000 to permit transfers from the Arkansas Healthy Century Trust Fund to long-term reserve funds. [21:10] [21:23]

SB5 TO AMEND INITIATED ACT 1 OF 2000; TO AUTHORIZE THE TRANSFER OF FUNDS FROM THE ARKANSAS HEALTHY CENTURY TRUST FUND TO THE LONG TERM RESERVE FUND; AND TO DEC… 21:29

Rep. Joe Jett introduced SB 5, declared an emergency, and explained that the bill would move the one-time $105 million tobacco-settlement from the Arkansas Healthy Century Trust Fund into the Long-Term Reserve Fund, a step he said could improve the state’s credit rating and save $1.5-$1.8 million in annual interest. [21:35] [21:43] [22:13] [22:48] [23:22] [23:56]

Opposition was voiced by Rep. Kim Hendren, who warned that the transfer would place control in a small council and could be used for non-health purposes, and by Rep. Michelle Gray and Rep. Nelda Speaks, who argued the trust’s health-care restrictions should not be overridden, while supporters such as Rep. Charlie Collins and Rep. Bob Ballinger contended that the reserve would boost bond ratings, provide a safety net for economic downturns, and that additional safeguards could be added later. [24:08] [24:24] [24:27] [25:00] [25:31] [26:03] [26:35] [27:06] [27:37] [28:07] [28:39] [29:12] [29:43] [30:44] [30:51] [31:25] [32:22] [32:56] [33:28] [33:59] [34:30] [35:05] [35:38] [36:08] [36:42] [37:18] [38:08] [38:23] [38:58] [39:31] [40:02] [40:33] [41:04] [41:43] [42:17] [42:56] [43:32] [44:21] [44:34] [45:07] [45:38] [46:09] [46:42] [47:13] [47:19] [47:38] [47:41] [1:01:37] [1:01:53] [1:02:03]

After extensive questioning, the House voted 70 yeas, 24 nays and 4 present, adopting the bill-including its emergency clause. [1:07:45] [1:08:21]

Rep. Jeremy Gillam asserted that, based on Article 5, §12 of the Arkansas Constitution, House Rule 11 and Mason’s Manual, he had the authority to call a caucus meeting on an administrative rule issue and reminded members that any appeal could be made to the full House. [1:09:54] [1:10:26] [1:10:59]

Rep. John W. Walker disputed Gillam’s notice, arguing that formal notice is required for all members, that Rule 11 does not empower the speaker to convene a special session, and that bypassing the governor’s notice violates constitutional and procedural norms. [1:11:30] [1:12:02] [1:12:36] [1:13:06] [1:13:10] [1:13:45] [1:14:22] [1:14:40] [1:14:57]

Rep. Kim Hendren then asked whether the resolution under consideration was intended to impeach Judge Wendell Griffin, prompting Gillam to promise a full explanation when he presented the resolution, after which Gillam recessed the House for ten minutes to investigate parallel proceedings in another building before resuming business and making routine announcements about legislative support staff and upcoming Girls/Boys State events. [1:16:03] [1:16:16] [1:16:35] [1:17:10] [1:17:21] [1:17:44] [1:29:19] [1:29:43]

Roll Call 1:31:48

Representative Jeremy Gillam reported that 94 members were present, establishing a quorum, and announced that the caucus would consider House Resolution 1001, a rule-amending measure previously referred to the Rules Committee. [1:32:18]

He then asked the clerk to read the text of HR 1001, and the chair subsequently read the resolution’s title, introducing the amendment for further consideration. [1:32:51] [1:33:05]

HR1001 Gillam TO AMEND THE RULES OF THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES OF THE NINETY-FIRST GENERAL ASSEMBLY. 1:33:10

Jeremy Gillam introduced HR 1001, a resolution to amend the House Rules by creating a formal impeachment process that requires articles to be filed as a co-sponsored resolution by at least 34 members, assigns investigative responsibility to a committee (which may be an existing or ad-hoc panel), mandates that the committee submit a report-including any minority opinion-and imposes a three-business-day waiting period before the full House may act. [1:33:22] [1:33:58] [1:34:32] [1:35:07] [1:35:39] [1:36:13] [1:36:46] [1:37:20] [1:37:52] [1:38:28] [1:39:00] [1:39:34] [1:40:04] [1:40:38] [1:41:13] [1:41:45] [1:42:17] [1:42:51] [1:43:22] [1:43:59] [1:44:32] [1:45:05] [1:45:37]

Members sought clarification on procedural details: Rep. Meeks confirmed that the full House would retain the final vote even if a committee recommended against impeachment; Rep. Hammer asked how committee members might be disqualified for bias, and Rep. Gillam explained that removal mechanisms are not yet defined and that committee composition would generally follow existing structures unless an extraordinary situation warranted an ad-hoc panel. [1:47:32] [1:47:34] [1:47:46] [1:48:05] [1:48:21] [1:48:55] [1:49:00] [1:49:26] [1:49:53] [1:50:16] [1:50:30] [1:50:46] [1:50:51] [1:50:58] [1:51:08] [1:51:12] [1:51:21] [1:51:41] [1:51:52] [1:52:48] [1:52:53] [1:52:57] [1:53:09] [1:53:28] [1:53:35] [1:53:40] [1:54:02] [1:54:34] [1:54:57] [1:56:17] [1:56:21] [1:56:51] [1:57:32] [1:57:59] [1:58:07] [1:58:40]

Opposition was voiced by Rep. Hendren and Rep. Flowers, who argued the amendment was a reaction to the Judge Griffin case, that existing judicial disciplinary bodies already address such matters, and that it could concentrate excessive power in the speaker’s hands, while supporters such as Rep. Lundstrum, Rep. Dotson, Rep. Brown, and Rep. Gates contended that the current procedure allows a single member to trigger impeachment, creating chaos, and that the resolution would provide necessary ethical standards, a higher-threshold safeguard, and orderly self-policing for the House. [2:08:48] [2:09:22] [2:09:53] [2:10:24] [2:10:54] [2:11:26] [2:11:57] [2:12:27] [2:18:41] [2:18:52] [2:19:23] [2:19:49] [2:20:12] [2:20:26] [2:21:09] [2:21:41] [2:22:11] [2:22:27] [2:22:33] [2:22:54] [2:23:25] [2:24:01] [2:24:36] [2:24:59] [2:25:04] [2:25:06] [2:25:40] [2:26:25] [2:26:46] [2:27:17] [2:27:47] [2:28:19] [2:28:51] [2:33:09] [2:33:43] [2:34:13] [2:34:45] [2:35:16] [2:35:49] [2:36:22] [2:36:53]

The House then voted on the resolution, with Rep. Lanny Fite voting yes, Rep. Warwick Sabin voting no, Rep. Deanne Vaught present, yielding 73 yes, 13 no, and 1 present, and HR 1001 was adopted. [2:42:26] [2:42:57]

Points of Personal Privilege 2:43:50

Representative Jeremy Gillam opened the point of personal privilege by urging members to conduct themselves professionally and with mutual respect, noting how honored he feels to serve alongside his colleagues. [2:44:04] [2:44:37] [2:44:56]

Representative Frances Cavenaugh then requested a point of personal privilege to present a small tractor as a farewell gift for the youngest member, initially mentioning Representative McCollum and then naming Representative Pilking as the intended recipient. [2:45:11] [2:45:33] [2:45:43]

Speaker 218 acknowledged the gesture, congratulated the recipient, and noted the tractor could help navigate flood-water conditions. [2:45:43] [2:46:19]

Later, Gillam presented a collage portrait as a token of appreciation to Representative Eubanks, explained its background, and announced upcoming appointments to the AHIM subcommittee, the Tax Reform Task Force, and the Economic Tax Policy Committee before adjourning the caucus. [2:48:10] [2:48:41] [2:49:31] [2:50:02] [2:50:34] [2:51:09] [2:51:42]

Bills discussed (6)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
SB2 · 5 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB2 J. Dismang (Gillam) TO INTEGRATE AND INCORPORATE THE PROVIS…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB3 · 5 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB3 J. Dismang (Gillam) TO AMEND ARKANSAS WORKS TO REDUCE INCOM…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB4 · 4 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…gency clause have passed. All right, Mr. Clerk, please read Senate Bill 4. Senate Bill 4 by Representative Gillum concerning”
Pre-2017 bill
SB5 · 4 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “5. Senate Bill 5 by Representative Gilliam to amend initiated Act 1 of 2000…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB1 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB1 J. Dismang (Gillam) TO INTEGRATE AND INCORPORATE THE PROVIS…”
Pre-2017 bill
HR1001 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HR1001 Gillam TO AMEND THE RULES OF THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES O…”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 12, 2026
Unknown speaker 0:00
Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. I don't know if you want to know. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
▶ Play
All right, members, the House will be called into order at this time. As always, I invite you to stand along with our staff, the press, and our guests in the galleries to be led in prayer today by our esteemed colleague, Representative George McGill, and then to remain standing to be led in the Pledge of Allegiance by our other esteemed colleague, Representative Greg Letting.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and thank you for giving me the opportunity to pray. I was doing my daily devotion this morning, and it talked about sitting the work aside. That's the most important thing is your relationship with God. and sometimes in order to have that good relationship we must sit the work aside so with that in mind we're going to sit the work aside for a minute and go to the Master Almighty God we come again once again thanking you for your son Jesus who so willingly came and gave his life so we may live we thank you for this day and certainly this is a day that you've made and we will rejoice and be glad in it Father bless this body and give all of these here, traveling grace as they head home to be with their families, and may they have a wonderful summer. Father, these and all of the things we ask in Jesus' name and for his sakes we pray. Amen.
▶ Play
Amen. All right, members, you know what to do. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 9:55
Thank you.
▶ Play
All right, let's cast it to ballots, Mr. Clerk. With 96 present, the chair sees a quorum. Are there any requests for leave? Representative Jett? Leave for Representative Ritchie, Mr. Speaker. All right. Members, is leave granted for Representative Ritchie? Leave. All right, so noted. All right, Representative Petty? Leave for Representative Ladyman. Is leave granted for Representative Ladyman? Leave. All right, so noted. All right, any other requests for leave? Representative Sullivan, is leave granted for Representative Lanny Fyatt? All right, thank you, so noted. All right, members, Representative Gene Moose. I'm sorry, Representative
▶ Play
Walker, for what purpose? Inquiry. Okay. I was looking away and didn't press my button. Does it reflect that I'm absent?
▶ Play
The clerk will record your presence here. Thank you. All right. Representative Jean moves that we dispense with the reading of the previous day's journal without objection. So ordered. Are there any reports from select committees? Any reports from standing committees? Any unfinished business? Any executive communications? That'll end the morning hour. All right, Mr. Clerk, please read Senate Bill 3.
▶ Play
Senate Bill 3 by Representative Gillum to amend Arkansas works to reduce income eligibility limits and impose work requirements to allow the flexibility to select whether to become an assessment state
▶ Play
or determination state and to declare an emergency. All right, apparently Representative Farrar didn't assign anybody, so Representative Ballinger, would you please come and present Senate Bill 3? Real simple, what
▶ Play
Speaker 30 12:45
we voted on yesterday, same, just mere bill, no differences. Appreciate a good vote. All right, members, you've heard
▶ Play
the presentation of the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? For the bill? Representative Ballinger, signal he's closed for the bill. So the question now before the House will be the passage of Senate Bill 3. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Are you voting on the bill and it's emergency clause? Has everyone voted? All right, let's cast out the ballots. With 69 yeas, 21 nays, and two present, the bill and it's emergency clause have passed. All right, Mr. Clerk, please read Senate
▶ Play
Bill 1. Bill 1 by Representative Gillin to integrate and incorporate the provisions of Acts 2017, numbers 207, 312, and 1108 into Arkansas Constitution, Article 19, Subsection 30, and to declare an emergency. Representative Maddox, you're recognized to present Senate
▶ Play
Bill 1. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Same thing as
▶ Play
the previous bill, this is exactly what we did yesterday, and I'd appreciate a good vote. All right, members, you've
▶ Play
heard a presentation of the bill. Would anyone like speak against the bill for the bill all right represent dramatic signified he's closed for the bill so the question now before the house will be the passage of Senate bill 1 prepare the machine mr. clerk Voting on the bill and it's emergency clause all right everyone voted cast the ballots mr. clerk with 87 yeas 1 nay and 3 present the bill has passed mr. clerk please read Senate bill 2 Senate bill 2 by representative
▶ Play
Gillum to to integrate and incorporate the provisions of Acts 2017 into Arkansas Constitution, Amendment 98, also known as the Arkansas Medical Marijuana Amendment of 2016, and to declare an emergency. Representative Dalby, you're recognized.
▶ Play
Present Senate Bill 2. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Speaker. Colleagues, Senate Bill 2 is the mirror bill to what we passed yesterday, and I would appreciate a good vote.
▶ Play
Members, you've heard an explanation of the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill, for the bill? Representative Dalby signifies she's closed for the bill, so the question now before the House will be the passage of Senate Bill 2. Prepare to the machine, Mr. Clerk. All right, has everyone voted? Let's cast out the ballots with 89 yeas, one nay, and zero present, the bill and its emergency clause have passed. All right, Mr. Clerk, please read Senate Bill 4. Senate Bill 4 by Representative Gillum concerning
▶ Play
the Arkansas Health Insurance Marketplace to study the future direction of the Arkansas Health Insurance Marketplace and to declare an emergency. All right, Representative
▶ Play
Speaker 42 16:14
Pitt, you're recognized to present Senate Bill 4. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Likewise, same bill. We voted on it yesterday. Appreciate a good vote.
▶ Play
All right, members, you've heard an explanation of the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? Representative Walker, for what purpose? Question. Who's
▶ Play
the question? You. Okay, proceed. When we vote on this bill, it will be the last action before us. And at that time, we will go into another session, I'm told. I'd like to know since it's since I understand that you have some planned action and since there's no authority for the speaker to call a special session I should like to know what the authority is for calling a caucus of the house to consider anything on a special session okay and I'd like to know that before we adjourn because if we participate in a caucus representative Walker you allow
▶ Play
me to I'll answer your question then we can't sue you all right the first of all this is not the last item on the agenda we have a budget calendar that we're going there's an item on the budget calendar that we're going to take up next okay at that point we will be adjourning after all the items that are dealt with on the call have been dealt with then we will be at that point adjourning out of the special session. We will be done with all the items that were dealt with in the call that the governor asked us to come with. At that time I have the authority to call a caucus meeting of the house according to our house rules upon any time. I could do it tomorrow, we could do it next week. I'm choosing to do it while everybody's already here and to keep everybody from having to come back down and so at that point uh it is my intention to call us into session as a house caucus but however i should like
▶ Play
Speaker 52 18:17
to know the rule on which you rely
▶ Play
it's the implicit authority of the speaker of the house to note i would still like to know where in these rules that is found it's the implicit authority of Speaker of the House, Representative Walker. You're saying it's inherent authority, but if it's inherent authority, it's got to be written somewhere. And we've done that many times for various other reasons. Doesn't matter. It has to be written. Whether we've done something in the past has to be pursuant to authority. I'm raising the question of the chair now as to where it is. I've answered your question, sir. So you're saying you can do whatever you want to do and you can call us whenever you want to. I'm saying I have the ability to call us into
▶ Play
a House caucus meeting, yes. I'm not saying I have the ability to do anything I want to do at any time. You can't cite an authority for it. Thank you. Representative
▶ Play
Hendron, for what purpose? A question? Yes, sir. With this authority that you say is implied, do you feel in that authority that it implied that you have any responsibility to give us a notice ahead of time of what's going on? The reason I asked that question, I had no idea this was coming up today until I heard from another member of this legislature last night that there was a procedure to do something to impeach Wendell Griffin. And frankly, Mr. Speaker, I know that's not in the bill.
▶ Play
Speaker 9 19:39
I've read it. All right, what's your
▶ Play
point of order? We have a bill that we're in the middle of debating that has been presented, and
▶ Play
this is way off topic. I agree with you wholeheartedly, Representative Ballinger. All right, we'll address questions as far as any further actions we've been called here to do by the governor. And then I will address your question, Representative Hinder, and I'm not gonna ignore it. I will come back in and address that question. All right, all right. And anybody wish to speak against Senate Bill 4? All right, for Senate Bill 4? Representative Pitch, you signify that he is closed for Senate Bill 4. The question now before the body will be the passage of Senate Bill 4. All right, Representative Pitch, or excuse me, Mr. Clerk, pair of
▶ Play
Speaker 64 20:48
the machine. All right, has everyone voted? Voting on
▶ Play
the bill and it's emergency clause. All right, let's cast it to ballots, Mr. Clerk. With 84 yays, three nays, and six present, the bill and its emergency clause have passed. All right, members move to your yellow budget calendar at this time. Clerk please read Senate Bill
▶ Play
5. Senate Bill 5 by Representative Gilliam to amend initiated Act 1 of 2000 to authorize the transfer of funds from the Arkansas Healthy Century Trust Fund to long-term reserve funds and to
▶ Play
declare an emergency. Representative Jett you're recognized to present Senate Bill 5.
▶ Play
Thank You Mr. Speaker. Colleagues this bill has been debated about five hours in in joint budget, I think probably pretty much everybody knows how they're going to vote. Just long story short on this bill, back in 1999, tobacco settlement money put approximately $105 million into a trust fund. This has nothing to do with the $46 million of ongoing revenue streams that goes to the other four entities. This is just the one-time money that goes into the trust fund. What this bill does is it moves that money over into a fund of a long-term reserve fund. Back in 06, I think Senator Malik presented a bill from this chamber and the General Assembly approved it on this and it was set up to be a savings account fund. The government proposes move the tobacco settlement money fund, $105 million, from that trust fund over to the long-term reserve fund. What that will do is potentially raise our credit ratings up to triple A from a double A to save $1.5, $1.82 million of interest. Right now we have about $1.5 billion worth of bonds out there. Those bonds are education bonds, highway bonds, Amendment 82 bonds, and things of that nature. Representative Michelle Gray worked hard on getting a compromise. The compromise is to take the money out of this long-term reserve fund. It takes less than, it takes two-thirds vote from the council or budget to be able to move the money. You have to have less than 3% from the previous year, revenue growth. The money can only be spent on things that are in RSA, so if it's like money on one-time money, so like a few years ago, we put like $20 million of one-time money in UAMS. This money cannot be used for that. It's got to be whatever the money is used for. It's got to be economic revenue growth, Amendment 82, or it's got to be something that's already listed in RSA. So I know that's a very short synopsis on what it took, about five hours to litigate and budget, but that is the bill, and I would appreciate a good vote. All right, members, you've heard a
▶ Play
presentation of the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? Representative Hendren, you're recognized to speak against Senate Bill 5. Boy, I better turn that off. I thought I had. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Speaker. I had not planned to come down here and speak against this bill because we've had plenty of discussion, as the chairman just said, in joint budget. But for fear, if I ask a question, I might be called to a point of order. I thought I would just come down here and maybe see if I get called for a point of order expressing I think the implicit rule is that I can speak up to 30 minutes but who knows what the rules mean so I'm just going to do the best I can till they shut my mic off here in a minute the chairman was correct there's been five hours of debate in joint budget I'd like to ask maybe I don't know whether I can do this or not but I'm going to try how many of you are on joint budget and attended those meetings would you raise your hand And I don't know whether we're being filmed down here today. Somebody tells me we're not this session. And if we're not it doesn't surprise me for some of the stuff that's going on. But I'll tell you what folks, all of you did not raise your hands. You weren't in joint budget and you didn't know what went on in joint budget. And the reason that's important ladies and gentlemen is what you're preparing to do when you vote for this. I'm voting against it by the way. Even though it's sponsored by some dear friends of mine. When you get ready to vote for this bill ladies and gentlemen let me tell you what you're doing. You are taking the responsibility that the people of the state of Arkansas have placed on you in that initiated act to vote what's done with this money. What you're doing when you vote yes for this bill you're going to say I don't want to vote yes or no on that anymore. I want to give a select group of insiders down here which is either the Joint Budget Committee which I'm on now or the Legislative Council which I'm not on now since you start over at the lower end of the seniority. Most of you know that because you are peons too. You are going to take that authority and you are going to give it to one of these two groups in the interim it's a council. And here is the dirty little secret folks that you need to know. And you know we ought to tell our freshmen this when they come down here because you learn it sometimes the hard way. Like the guy that put a dollar in a machine and there was a sign on it that said, you put a dollar in this vending machine you'll learn something you'll never forget. And that was you ain't going to get nothing. You ain't going to get your change or your pop or anything else. What you are fixing to learn here ladies and gentlemen is when you vote to pass this bill, and this is a banker's bill folks. This is by the investment bankers, and that's why we're past it, because you can get more interest because they told you that. Let me tell you something. I didn't come down here to represent the investment bankers. I do. And I love guys like Jim Walton, Sam Walton, and Whit Stevens. But never did they come down here and tell me that if I give my vote away for my constituents then they would give me some money the next election. Never. They never even asked me stuff like that. Folks that's the kind of citizens we need in this state. But when you vote to do this, still no objection point of order yet, but when you vote to do this what you are saying is let the Legislative Council or the Joint Budget who can with one vote, one vote approve to do whatever the executive decides to do with this money, one vote. Now if you don't know what I'm talking about. You fell off a turnip truck yesterday. You don't know what goes on down here. It happened this last session in committees that I was on. It says a two thirds vote. That's what we amended the bill yesterday to do in joint budget that you who weren't there didn't know about this. We asked them to make it two thirds of this body where you still retain the responsibility the citizens of this state gave you with the initiated act that we are amending here. But no with this vote you are giving it away. And then what happens when you go into a legislative council, if they plan it just right, and I'm saying the same they in this member's opinion who's jumped up this deal we're going to look at this deal we're having here in a minute to do what we're going to do with that judge. Whenever we do stuff like that it really bothers me. And so what happens, they plan it just right in the interim session, there's something they want to do with this money $105 million. We've already siphoned off $30 million without any of us knowing it. You didn't know that. I didn't know that. I've been around here a while. And I try to keep my head in what's going on most of the time. Some of you think I keep it somewhere else sometimes. But I try to keep my head in the right place. And I didn't know they had already siphoned off $30 million. But this time they're getting a whole wagon. They're getting a whole bale of hay this time. So let me just conclude with this. And I challenge any of my colleagues to come down here and deny because the chairman of the Bureau yesterday agreed with this in the Joint Budget Committee that what I'm telling you is true. That one person in that legislative council or Joint Budget in the right circumstances could pass this because here's how you do it if you haven't learned yet. All in favor say aye. There's one eye. Without objection we pass it. That's going around the rules. It's done every time it was done this past session. And I'm afraid it's going to be done this next time. So the bottom line is this. You either come down here and represent the 30,000 people that elect you and put you in and take you out. Or you give it to somebody else and let them do it and then go back and say in fact what we ought to ask Pontius Pilate let us borrow your basin here so we can wash our hands. Bad bill. All right, members, Representative Hendren has spoken
▶ Play
against the bill. Would anyone like to speak for the bill? Representative Collins, you're to be recognized
▶ Play
to speak for the bill. So I realize this is a confusing bill because it seems like there are so many different things in there. So a little bit to Representative Hendren's point, what I'd like to do is spend a few minutes just sharing with you the basis for bond ratings, what the S&P global people do and how they do it. And as chairman of the Insurance and Commerce Committee, I was fortunate when they came in last year in order to assess our current bond status and situation. to be invited to participate in that process. In the written instructions that S&P uses to assess bond ratings, there are multiple categories of things they look at. And Arkansas does very well on many of those categories. So things, for example, like a balanced budget amendment, things like an economic development focus, but there's one particular category that has to do with how well you can protect yourself in the event that there is an economic downdraft and mechanicalistically adjust your spending accordingly. The rating agencies that really only care about one thing when it comes to the state budget, when they're making that assessment, are very focused on can you pay the bond interest? Can you pay the bond principal? That's their priority. That's bucket number one. Bucket number two is everything else. Bucket number two are the things that you and I may care about, which aren't necessarily related to the essential services of government that have to be paid in order to ensure that our bonds are going to be covered. S&P is worried that we're going to frivolously raid whatever money is available rather than pay all of the essential obligations of the state so that they can tell investors with great confidence that Arkansas will, in fact, pay those bonds back. So the current rating we have is a good rating which reflects that so much of how we do things in Arkansas is responsible and conservative and designed to ensure that we can pay our bills. We've had our current rating for 51 years. We've had it through thick and thin. We've had it through good times and bad times. I think part of the reason that we have a rating that is below the rating of 28 other states is because Arkansas was the only state to declare bankruptcy in the Great Depression. So coming out of that, we were at a tremendous disadvantage versus a lot of states. So maintaining the bond rating we've got with a stable assessment is a good thing. This bill was designed to take resources that already exist, they're already sitting in bank accounts, but S&P does not count those as available funds to help us pay for the required spending of the state if for some reason our revenues dropped in a dramatic way. Now, my understanding is the only time in recent memory these triggers would have been tripped were the last, I call it a depression, some people call it the Great Recession, in 2008-2009. So the triggers are not hair triggers, and they're not the type of thing that somebody can, in a willy-nilly fashion, decide to focus on to redirect money from one thing to another. The folks at S&P are going to think through qualitatively and quantitatively how do we assess what Arkansas is doing. They don't have a checklist that goes through item by item by item. If you do exactly this, it's a yes. If you do exactly that, it's a no. Rather, they have a committee of individuals who, in a granular fashion, roll up their sleeves, research our policies and practices, and sit down and listen to people. So when I had the opportunity last year when they were down here to go to dinner with Aaron Burks, who runs the group that manages our debt, They sent two people in from New York, and there were several other folks from the finance office. We talked a lot about the economic development of Arkansas. We talked a lot about the improvement in our unemployment rate. For example, the Arkansas unemployment rate is at a point where the national rate is literally 25% above our rate. And in the last four months, we have had four successive record low unemployment rates since we began measuring unemployment rates in our state back in the 1950s. Those types of things are very, very impressive. On the other hand, since we really don't have any money that is readily available to attack the kind of fund reductions that could trigger concerns in bond repayment, this bill gives us an opportunity to take money that is flowing into the state in a fund with very limited use, the health care arena only. So I would encourage you to vote yes on this. We're not going to take away anybody's authority to do things, but S&P does need more mechanistic confidence that this will work. I encourage a yes vote. All right, members, Representative Collins
▶ Play
has spoken in favor of the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? All right, Representative Gray, you're recognized to
▶ Play
speak against the bill. Thank you, Mr. Speaker, colleagues. As Chairman Jett noted at the beginning, this bill has been debated for some time, and those of us that were able to sit in on some of the joint budget, but not all of it, heard a lot of the issues that have been raised on both sides. I want to say first that I am not one, and I know that the conversation has been around Little Rock and around the state and in this capital once this bill became apparent to all of us that did it somehow coincide with the recent revenue projections or potential cuts to the budget. And I come down here to say I don't subscribe to that theory, that I think that personally I understand the motive to create a long-term fund, reserve fund, in the event of an economic calamity. I think it is probably prudent to set aside money to do something like that. So I do not come down to speak against this because it is a so-called slush fund creation for the governor or it is a, the ulterior motive would be to spend it as soon as we get out of the building and give the authority to put it in the account. I come to you to speak against it for a couple of reasons that I think should be important to all of us. I think Representative Collins did a very good job of explaining bonds and the buckets that bond raters use, but he himself put me in touch with the same gentleman yesterday that he talked to about how they rate bonds. The question is about this trust fund, and today it's a restricted fund. Today it is a fund created by an initiated act of the people that vote to send us down here to set aside this money to only be used for health-related things. The people voted for us to create this fund for health-related things. What does that mean? He's absolutely right. That means we can't use that $100 million, or $103 million as it says today, and collateralize a loan or anything else with that money because it can only be used for healthcare things. So therefore, it's not available to help shore up something if we had an economic calamity. So to a banker, to a bond writer, that would be frozen credit. It's money we could never use. So to create a mechanism where that if we had such a catastrophe that we needed money in the long-term fund, then we'd have to take that health care restriction off this money. And I think that's a prudent discussion that maybe if the state of Arkansas got in such a situation that we needed to pay our bills and pay our teachers and pay our prison guards that we ought to be able to come down in this building and say, the people trust us to take the money they initially set aside for this and help pay the bills of the state. I think that's a prudent motive and a very responsible move by the governor. However, in my conversations with the very people that Representative Collins referenced in his speech for the bill, In my conversations with him, I said, if we take the health care restrictions off this money, but we still require a vote of the entire legislative body to release those funds, will that still improve our bond rating? And he said that would, and it was very careful, and as Representative Collins was, he said anything you do to make this money more accessible would help to improve your rating. So taking the health care restriction off and putting it in a long-term fund would help to improve our rating, regardless of the mechanism for which we could access it. So we heard in joint budget, those of you that were in there, that it would only be liquid and that the bond raters would only accept it as helping our bond rating if the council or budget, the smaller group, could vote on it. That is not inaccurate because always we'd rather have it in our pocket than even having to go to the bank to get it. But even in the bank, it is still available to us. So just taking it to the long-term reserve but still allowing the legislative body to have a vote on it would help to improve our bond rating. So please be aware of that, that we do not have to make it a vote of counsel or a vote of budget, as this bill would suggest, to help improve our credit rating with the bond raters. Secondly, it should not be lost on any of us that, whether it be by seniority or by selection of future speakers, ALC and budget are not necessarily completely representative. As someone with a very low seniority in my class, an ALC spot would be very hard for me to attain had I not had a leadership position. So those of us that won't be on ALC and won't be on budget and not for any ulterior motive but simply just the process, we will not be able to have a say other than just speaking with our colleagues about how money that the people that voted to send us down here asked us to set aside. So I think it's a prudent move. I think the creation of a long-term fund is a very wise thing to do so we can have a credit rating that would encourage economic development and investment from out of state. I do not think it would be in any of our best interests on either side of the aisle to surrender the power that the people that voted for us and sent us down here when we can still accomplish the same thing with a vote of the legislative body. With that, I would respectfully ask you not to vote for this bill.
▶ Play
All right. Members, Representative Gray has spoken against the bill. Would anyone like to speak for the bill? Representative Ballinger, you're recognized to speak for
▶ Play
the bill. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. You know, the question here really is, I think it's fundamental, the state of Arkansas have a long-term reserve fund? You know, almost every state that borders us has one that is typically well-funded. We've got one, we just don't have any money in it. So should we have one? Now, you know, from me, and I've visited with the bill sponsor and other people, I wish that there were more safeguards in this. You know, I wish this bill were better. I wish there was more things that added more protections that make it where more of us were involved in it. Could have those amendments been done and it be a better bill, yeah, it could have. I wish the system would have worked out so we had more of those amendments in there. Now, this is not, we're not amending the Constitution. This is not fixed forever. In 2019, we'll come back, and some of these things that were mentioned, we can make these amendments. Now, the question is, can we trust the governor between now and 2019 not to spend this money? Can we take him at his word to say that he truly is wanting to set this money aside for a long-term reserve to help shore up the economics of the state until we can come back in 2019 and take some of these great ideas that have been presented and incorporate it into this fund to make it even more safe, to make us even more sound. And I think the answer to that from my standpoint is yes. Now I'm sticking my neck out, Governor. You know, you've got to keep your word, you've got to keep this money set aside or I'm going to look look pretty stupid coming down here and speaking for this, but I'd say until 2019 and we can make some of these change, you know, I'm okay, I'm willing to do that. Now, you know, when we elect, you know, Charlie Collins or Tim Griffin as governor, you know, big spenders, maybe we can't trust them, but that's okay, we'll be here by then, right? We'll be able to come back and we'll be able to make those changes in order to protect this money and lock it away, and that's what we're doing. We've got a fund that's designed to do that. You know, sure, it's only ALC that's deciding to do that. I wish it were the whole body that's making that decision. But it is two-thirds of ALC, and I trust you guys. You know, if two-thirds of you are going to say okay, then it's probably going to be okay. It's probably something we really need to spend the money on. Now, maybe future legislators we can't trust. Maybe we're going to elect a bunch of really bad guys that will come in here. But before then, we'll have a chance to address this again. We'll have a chance to fix this and lock it down and make it more of a whole body. I really do believe that there are some things that we can do to make this better. But the question is, are we taking a step in the right direction? or are you okay with status quo? And I'm telling you, status quo is 50 votes plus one can spend the interest off this, and we have. And for good things, I'm sure for good things. However, we continue to spend the money. If we lock this away, this goes in us, builds the fund up, and that fund can grow, and truly we can have something that I think will make us more solvent, help our bond rating, that's great. But I think even better than that, I think it's good economics,
▶ Play
and I'd appreciate a good vote. Representative Walker, for what
▶ Play
purpose? Question. You're recognized for your question, sir. What is the horror or adversity that will befall this House or the state if we follow the regular procedure in addressing our roles as elected representatives of the people of Arkansas? I think we
▶ Play
Speaker 31 47:38
absolutely should represent each one of us. Have 30,000 people back
▶ Play
home, and we ought to represent them. I think one of the ways that we have an opportunity to set before you right now is deciding whether or not we're going to create a fund that's going to make us solvent and keep us solvent as a state and help us to have money when we end up getting hit in the mouth with financial downturn that'll make it where we won't necessarily have to make drastic cuts that hurt our people but we'll actually have some money to tide us over until we get back out of whatever downturn. That's the opportunity that's presented to us. That's what the governor said he's doing. That's what the bill sponsor said he's doing. I'm going to trust him at least until 2019 and we'll put more safeguards. I'll trust you, Governor, for two years. Give us, and then we'll come back
▶ Play
and add whatever it is that we need to add. Follow-up, Mr. Chair? Yes, sir, you're recognized for your follow-up. Have you just given an admission to the fact that the state is on the verge of being broke?
▶ Play
No, not at all. No, I would say that we're actually doing really well as a state financially. You know, we have been blessed to have tax cuts, you know, like $400 million worth of tax cuts over the last few years, and giving that money back to the citizens of Arkansas. And now what we're needing to do is find ways to make government fit within that, and then also put money in the bank in order to be able to, at some time in the future, if we end up with a situation where there's a war in the Middle East or where there is a major economic downturn, which we can't predict, nobody can, that we as a state still can function and continue to function without having the necessity of actually making real cuts to legitimate functions of the state government that hurt our people, the roads, health care, schools, things that we've got to have money to fund. Representative Hammer, for what
▶ Play
purpose? Question, please. You're recognized for your
▶ Play
question. Thank you. In reality, the long-term reserve fund is established. It was established last time, and I think after July 1st, we're going to see money that's going to go into that, depending who you talk to, depends on how much they think that's going to go in there. If we continue to grow economically, would it stand to reason that money that used to go to GIF would actually go into that? So if we start to have some bumper crop years, we could see some significant money put into that long-term reserve fund. Would you disagree with that or where am I wrong in that statement? I would agree 100%. I agree. Now
▶ Play
the question is whether you want to start with $100 million or not. So whether you want to put that money in there that by the way will help the growth because now that interest will be locked away and will stay in the fund rather than the interest being spent by us on neat things but we still end up spending the interest. Follow up
▶ Play
Mr. Speaker. Yes sir you recognize for your follow
▶ Play
up. Thank you. When the tobacco settlement fund was established there were some bonds that were leveraged against that money coming in and with the tobacco settlement money declining and while it may be that we've got 20, 25 years that we can think about depending on money. The reality is that money is going down. By us taking that $100 million away from the Century Fund, are we exposing ourselves to greater liability and being able to meet those bond obligations should we hit an economic downturn and that settlement money goes down? Now, that's a great question. The
▶ Play
answer is no, because of the fact that either the fund is there and it can pay it, or as legislators, we will have the ability to pay it out of this fund if we had to pay it out of this fund, because we're going to pay our bills. So if we ended up in a situation where there were funds that were owed to pay out on a bond, then that's exactly the kind of thing that I think the long-term reserve fund is set there. Rather than default on our bond payment, we make the payment. And so if the economy is such that we don't have the funds and the general revenue, then And we have this fund that we have to, if we have to act on it. Now my recommendation as a state and to you all and for us is let's try to avoid issuing any, you know, going out and getting more bonds and getting more debt as a state. That'd be the best thing for us to do. But if we end up in a situation where
▶ Play
we've got to make those payments, we make those payments with this reserve fund. One last question, Mr. Speaker. Actually, Representative Hammer, we've got two in the queue over here, so I want to move on here. Representative Flowers, for what purpose? Question.
▶ Play
You're recognized for your question, ma'am. Thank you. My question is one about timing and process, and I'm wondering how you can help us to reconcile that if we are fiscally healthy, our economy is healthy, what is the rush or emergency to do this in this way, to overrule the will of the people and move these funds from trust to reserve? What's the emergency? Why do it that way? Why do it now? Well,
▶ Play
part of the premise of your question I would argue with is that we're not overruling the will of the people. We've not eliminated that fund. Now money from that fund is going into a new fund that we can steal. And I would say that the emergency is not necessarily an emergency. I think that you put money back and you save money when you can save money, period. I think that's good fiscal sense. Now in this case, what my guess is, the reason why we're dealing with it right now in a special session, is we just, you know, faced a revenue shortfall, and it's, you know, $70 million that we're needing to make cuts. We were able to make those cuts in ways that I think are reasonable. I support it 100%. I think that's good government for us to pull that money down. However, I think that that illuminates the problem. It's like, what if we couldn't make those cuts? What if all of a sudden those cuts had to come out of our prisons? What if those cuts had to come out of our K-12 education? What if those cuts had to come out of essential services within Medicaid? then what do we do? Then how do we do it? We don't have the funds setting there to do it. And so if we do this, we set up a long-term reserve fund that hopefully will have $250 million in it, not $105 million. Hopefully it'll be really well funded. Then if we're in a situation where we're hitting the mouth with something like that, and we can't make those cuts as smart as what we did, but we actually have to make cuts to essential services, we'll have some of the funds to help bridge that gap until we can replenish those funds.
▶ Play
Follow-up, Mr. Speaker. Yes, ma'am, you're recognized for your follow-up. Thank you. So if we're not overruling the will of the people, why is the
▶ Play
vote requiring two-third and not a simple majority? I mean, what I would say is we're not overruling the will of the
▶ Play
people. What we're doing is transferring funds. We're not eliminating that
▶ Play
Speaker 90 54:22
fund at all. Representative Gray, for what purpose? Question. You're recognized for your question. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Representative Ballinger, it's Representative
▶ Play
Hammer referenced that the long-term fund is already in existence and interest money from other accounts are going into it. But are you aware that in the language of the bill that we have before us now, we've spent a lot of time, including myself from the well, talking about in the event of an economic downturn and the triggers that would have to be in place to be able to use that money. But are you also aware in the bill, and I would assume you are because you're usually pretty thorough, so will you address, that the bill also says or for Amendment 82 projects. So there can be money spent out of this fund, can be spent out of this fund for economic development projects, even without the calamitous economic triggers that we all, including myself, have focused on.
▶ Play
Can you reconcile that? Correct. It's not new language. It's actually in the fund that's already been created. so it's not necessarily in the bill, but the language is there because it's there. So it's either way. So it's 3% growth, or if you have a big Amendment 82 project, they can spend the money. Now, this is the thing is I'll tell you that my recommendation to the bill sponsor, and I was hoping to get something done, is to either eliminate the Amendment 82 projects altogether or make it where we only spend money out of the Amendment 82 projects if we have $250 million in the balance, that we never spend the balance less than $250 million. That would be great amendments. And then also, I think the 3% growth is too high. We ought to reduce that 3% growth. What we're talking about here are some really good changes. I think your idea of bringing it back to the body is a good idea. That's good change. Now, all of that would require actually changes to the fund that already exists. That's not before us. So what is presented before us right now is to fund that fund. There is one change that we're making to that fund, and that is making it a two-thirds threshold, which was something that was negotiated. So we are making it a little harder to spend money out of that long term reserve fund, which I think makes sense that we do that. I would work with you in 2019 to come in and do an amendment to make it even more difficult to spend money out of this because what I want to see is money that's locked down for a real deal emergency. So I think that's a great idea. The question before us now is can we trust the governor and can we trust ALC for the next two years until we can make other substantial changes to this fund? And that's really what I think I'm focused on.
▶ Play
Representative Hendren, for what purpose? A question and perhaps a follow-up? All right, let's
▶ Play
start with the first question, and then we'll go from there. Again, at least half of our members were not in the joint budget hearings regularly, as perhaps you and I were. Correct. I've noticed a couple of times, Representative Ballinger, You've referred to the governor's responsibility about spending this money, and you're sure he won't do it, and he won't do something else. And I look up on the door, and I see a name up there that I recognize a little bit, and I'm not going to bear his responsibility. I bear my responsibility, as I'm sure you do. My question, this was raised in joint budget, as you may recall. We've changed the rules here a while back, maybe this last year, as I'm sure you know, because you're on, I guess, state agencies, isn't it, and maybe revenue and tax. We changed the rules that said of the surplus we have each year, we'll take, is it 50% of that or something, and put it into highway funds to match the federal highway match. Now, for you members that weren't here, you probably ought to listen to this stuff. So what happens? Now we're projecting no surplus at all this year. The question joint budget was this, and that's what I'm going to ask you to answer to the body here in a minute because a lot of us didn't hear this. What happens if we, now I noticed a paper today says we're a little bit better off, but we're still behind the forecast. Now what happens was asking the budget committee the other day, if we come to the end of this fiscal session or this fiscal year, and we have no money to match the federal highway match, the question was, should we take some of this money with the two-thirds vote of the governor's agreement or recommendation of the administration and the two-thirds of the council's approval to use that, whatever it is, to match it to build the roads and the highways to replace the flooded-out roads and highways in Pocahontas and northwest Arkansas. Now, based on what you just said, would you criticize the governor? If we passed this bill today, which you say you support, would you criticize the governor if he chose to take $50 million of this to match those federal highway funds under the situation? I think
▶ Play
you have a couple different questions there. One is the match for the Federal Highway Fund, so we're going to come from surplus. We took care of that all in RSA, so that's taken care of as it is. The funds were found, we've got that. Now, if in this emergency situation up in Pocahontas, which actually hit close to home, we had a couple folks die just a few miles in my district. You know, if we were in a situation where we needed these funds in order to replenish roads because the feds don't have it or whatever, then, yeah, I would probably support that. I wouldn't hold that against him if we had to have it in order to help people in an emergency situation. So that would be an escape hatch? Well, the answer is no. There's actually federal funds that come through the disaster release because we declared ourselves a – I mean, we're getting kind of off the topic here a little bit, but I think that we're going to have some federal money that doesn't require a match. But if we need some additional funds to go to some of these hard-hit areas, then I would say that's exactly what this fund should be for. Now, I wish it wasn't $100 million we were putting in. I wish it was $200 million. Then the $50 million wouldn't hit as hard. So if it's ever going to be the $250 million, so we can help the folks in Pocahontas, so we can help the folks in Madison County, so we can help the folks in South Arkansas, wherever it is, when they are hit in the mouth with a disaster, we're going to have to have a fund to do it. By the way, the fund where the money sits now, you're not allowed to do that. It's not dedicated to that. It's not dedicated to an emergency in general, but what we'd be doing here is actually setting funds aside for exactly what you just pointed out, an emergency when folks, our citizens, got hit in the mouth real hard and we needed the money. And I hope that we don't have to spend this money, but if we did, I'd say that it's probably a good time for us
▶ Play
to break down and spend it. Just one follow-up, and then I'll sit down and shut up. You just said that all these needs have been met with the Revenue Stabilization Act and the funding. would you would would you agree that this member and perhaps others might disagree with your assessment of that particular situation at this point and they could be correct
▶ Play
I would say that I would be utterly confident that you can disagree with me representative Hendrick see another question I appreciate a good
▶ Play
vote all right members representative Ballinger has spoken for the bill would anyone like speak against the bill representative Deborah Ferguson you're recognize to
▶ Play
speak against the bill. Thank You Mr. Speaker and thank you colleagues. This is very simple. I mean we can listen to all this discussion but if you vote yes for this you are voting to subvert the vote of the people of Arkansas who voted that the tobacco of settlement trust fund should be used for health care and not be rated to use by the legislature when they meet shortfalls I remember represented
▶ Play
to Ferguson has spoken against the bill would anyone like to speak for the bill against the bill all right represented Jett you're recognized to close for your bill thank
▶ Play
you mr. speaker colleagues I know the debate was going to be long It was long in joint budget as well, so Sterling wasn't disappointed today. A lot of the questions was asked was the same questions I asked going through this when we first started this process. I just want to touch on just a couple quick things about the threshold. The threshold of two-thirds come from the Initiated Act. There's nothing shady, nothing going on there. The Initiated Act caused two-thirds of the vote. At the time, the original bill and the sponsors put together, it was a simple majority. Michelle Grez I told you put together a compromise package to raise it up to two-thirds for the level and that was just because initiated that was a two thirds vote second thing I'd like to discuss talk about was in budget testifying that DFA Duncan buried himself testified that there's no strategies in place about robbing the money going forward I personally talked to the governor's staff the governor and different folks and I'm not personally heard rumors nor have been involved in anything about talking this money subverting this money to different for different things highways or any other any other things we all know we got problems in the state that needs to be addressed but I can assure you myself I've never been involved in any discussions whatsoever with the governor governor's staff and we all heard Duncan Barrett governor's budget director DFA say that he's not been involved in those discussions either and does not know any of those things. One thing I do like to address also is I just want to remind this body that the council is the governing body when we're not in session. I mean, we're here three months in a regular session every two years. The council is what governs this general assembly for the majority of the time that we're elected. The council routinely pushes out, votes out for multi-million dollar contracts. You know, there's different things that we voted on coming out of council that was, you know, I can't give specifics off the top of my head, but there have been times that we voted for over $100 million contracts coming out of council. For somebody to say that you said on council that you don't really matter, I mean, I don't know where, I can't even defend that. I can't even begin to defend that, saying that, you know, if you're on council, you don't matter. I mean, council is what governs this General Assembly when we're not here, out of the three months, out of 24 months. That's what takes place. That's what governs. We're elected to do this. So we routinely in council pass budgets or pass monies coming out of council for routinely millions and millions of dollars, if not hundreds of millions of dollars. Another thing that was put back into the compromise package, if you will, from Representative Gray, was if this money is taken out in the bill, it's defined in the language of the bill, this money has to replace in the next fiscal year. That gives a backstop to saying, okay guys, if you guys take this money out, you guys know that you're going to have to find money to replace, so if the full $100 million comes out and there's no discussion about this money coming out, the whole purpose of this money is going in is to have a long-term savings plan that can potentially save the taxpayers $2 million a year. That's the whole impetus of this whole bill. But if that money comes out, $100 million, that means under this compromise package, that means that we've got to put $100 million back in the following year. That's a pretty heavy lift, so I think that would probably cause people to give pause and stop and say, hey, wait a minute, we're going to pull money out. That means we've got to put $100 million back into the back of the year or the next fiscal year. I think that's pretty serious. This is a savings account. And one last thing, Representative Hammer, your questions, you were spot on, sir. I can't even remember. I just put my notes saying that the question you asked, I just want to say yes to whatever you was asking was, was yes. So I sat there and I listened. I've had about six hours of this now and it's starting to run together, but the question you was asking was, it was a yes,
▶ Play
whatever that was. And I just appreciate a good vote. Thank you very much. all right members we have four pairs on the desk before we commence with the voting Richard excuse me rep representative Richard Womack votes yes representative John Payton votes no this was witnessed by representative Coleman representative Womack is the present member are there any procedural objections to this pair? All right. Representative Lanny Fyatt votes yes. Representative Charlotte Douglas votes no. This is witnessed by Representative Boyd. Representative Douglas is the present member. Are there any procedural objections to this pair? All right. Representative Jack Ladyman votes yes. Representative Brant Smith votes no. This was witnessed by Representative Boyd. Representative Smith is the present member. Are there any procedural objections to this pair? All right, Representative Farrar votes yes. Representative Milton Nix votes no. This was witnessed by Representative Boyd. Representative Nix is the present member. Are there any procedural objections to this pair? All right, please do not vote any of these voting machines that were involved in the pairs. All right, prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. All right, you're voting on the bill and it's emergency clause as everyone voted. All right, let's cast the ballots, Mr. Clerk. All right, with 70 yays, 24 nays, and four present, the bill and its emergency clause is passed. Okay, members. We're going to check and make sure that the Senate has no further business that we're going to have to take up. And while we're doing that, I do want to go back and address a couple of the questions that were raised earlier and before we conclude our business in the special session and move forward. Representative Hendren, if I remember correctly and if I'm not remembering the question correctly, feel free to ask it again. You'd ask the question before us, the notification. Okay, on Monday, I was able to meet with Representative Whitaker and Representative McGill as well when I first got here on Monday and informed them of and even showed them a draft of what I was looking at, told them why we were doing it, kept it filled in the background. I then went at the invitation of the Majority Leader to the Republican caucus meeting that was held, I believe, at 1130 on Monday and informed them at that point. I've mentioned every day along the way that this, that we would convene a House caucus meeting. I mentioned it Monday afternoon and I mentioned it yesterday that we would be convening a House caucus meeting to take care of an administrative rule issue. So I apologize if you didn't get the message. I thought that I had done a capable job of that, but if I did not, my apologies. And then to Representative Walker's question earlier, Article 5, Section 12 of the Arkansas Constitution, Rule 11 in the House, and then Mason's Manual has an entire Chapter 52 concerning the issues of the presiding officer and their duties. And so it was from those areas there that we derived the implicit nature of the presiding officer to be able to call to order a house caucus meeting for purposes. And I'll read in the Constitution, it says, each house shall have the power to determine the rules of its proceedings and to punish its members and other persons in contempt and disorderly behavior and its presence, and it goes on. It's from that section 12, along with, like I said, Rule 11, and then Chapter 52 in Mason's that we derive that. So if you feel like that that is an error and would like to challenge at the appropriate time the rule of the chair that the presiding officer has that capability, you have that ability to, and the full body here would take up that vote and make that determination as to whether or not my ruling would be sustained or overturned. I'll recognize you, Mr. Walker, for a follow-up question. Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
▶ Play
Several things. While you may speak to some members giving them notice, I think notice has to be formal so that all of us can have equal access to it. And I would say that I had no notice. and I'm sure that there are some others here who had no notice of what you had in your mind nor was there any writing which reflected it. Second, with respect to each house being able to set its own rules, that contemplates that rules will be set and then when they are set, they become capable of being enforced but they are only set after agreement by a majority vote rule 11 in the Constitution does not authorize the speaker of the house this speaker or any other speaker to call a special session of the legislature and if you would tell me read the read the language to us all show where it gives the speaker the same power as the governor. To do that, it's common that the only person who can, in any of the states, call a special session is the governor. Now, if you can tell me otherwise, you can say I have implicit authority, which you did before, and now you rely on Rule 11. I say Rule 11, and it doesn't give you implicit or explicit authority. Now,
▶ Play
it was Article 5, Section 12 of the Constitution. Rule 11 of our House rules conducting the presiding officer was what I was referring to there, not Rule 11 of the Constitution. Now, I will say this, Representative Walker, and I was very deliberate yesterday in the Rules Committee meetings and would do so again today. This is not a part of the special session. If you look at the red calendar, the timing of this coinciding after we are done with a special session, yes, it is timed while we are all here, but it is not a part of the special session. However, in the House rule, had I so chose to go that route, but I did not, under the resolutions subsection on page 41, rule 49, it does state that resolutions can be introduced in an extraordinary session, lack of germaneness notwithstanding, and 51 votes shall be required to adopt a house resolution all right so there are references to that like I said if you if you disagree with my ruling on that you have the ability to appeal it the entire body would be the ones that would decide whether or not to sustain my ruling or overturn me but we're not at that point just
▶ Play
yet I've just been trying to explain where we're coming from and why we're position and for you personally. What this would amount to is your calling a special session of the legislature. We all happen to be here, but not four people aren't here. That means four people, at least they didn't sign in as being here, that means four people didn't get notice. That means 120,000 people cannot have their voice even considered because they did not get adequate notice. Even the governor gives notice for a special session. We have never had a special session where the governor was not required and did not follow the process of giving adequate notice to all the people. And then he also sets forth the nature of the call before, along with the notice. And there was no notice and there was no nature of the call. And I think it is surreptitious and disrespectful to the body, even though I know you have your votes to do pretty much anything you want to, to go ahead and circumvent our rules and to circumvent the Constitution of this state.
▶ Play
Your opinion is well noted, sir. All right, members, while we are investigating on the matter of the Senate having conducted their business, we are going, I'm going to just take us into recess for 10 minutes. Let's find out what's going on in another building real fast, and then we'll come back before we complete our business with a special session. Representative Hendren,
▶ Play
for what purpose? Just a follow-up question on your answer to my question. I appreciate that, but when the notice was given to the Republican caucus, and of course, I was driving in from Northwest Arkansas, and I wasn't part of that caucus that day. When you gave notice, what I heard last night from another member of this legislature is that the purpose of this impeachment thing I guess we're going to be looking at that I guess is on the I guess is I guess there's a copy of it here I think I read it on the web this morning it does not specify but I have heard that that targeted is is that judge that went and laid down out in front of the penitentiary down there Wendell Griffin and and objected and I guess my question is was that announced is that the purpose of this and And since you're the sponsor, is that the purpose of this resolution, to impeach, to bring the possible 34 members of this body can bring charges, which the Senate would then consider about impeaching Wendell Griffin? Is that the purpose? No, I'm going to explain everything when I present the
▶ Play
resolution. I assure you I'm going to go try to be as exhaustive as possible to answer questions and everything. And a follow-up, what about the four members who aren't going to be here this afternoon or when
▶ Play
that session happens? Well, to be honest with you, sir, no matter when we dealt with this, there's always a chance that
▶ Play
people wouldn't be here that day. I mean, that's going to be constant no matter what. We had days in the session when we had people that weren't here, but we didn't stop conducting business just because a few members had to ask, they asked for leave because they couldn't be here. Same principle would apply to that. So, all right, as I said, we're going to go for 10 minutes while we find out where things are at on the other end of the building. So the house will be in recess for 10 minutes. Thank you.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 1:18:33
Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
▶ Play
Speaker 8 1:24:03
Thank you.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 1:24:33
Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. BEEP! Thank you.
▶ Play
Speaker 138 1:29:03
all right members I'm going to call us back
▶ Play
into order and we're going to have a couple of announcements here and then we'll finish our business so at this time I'm going to I'm going to recognize Representative Vought for her announcement.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. On your desk, you should have a manila envelope. That's what BLR put together for you. If you'll remember last session, it comes with the slide presentation and all of that. So y'all make sure y'all thank them for that. That takes a lot of work and a lot of effort. So please take a moment and email them and tell them thank you for that. Also, Girls State and Boys State will be meeting in the House chamber back-to-back days Thursday and Friday, June the 1st and the 2nd. We ask that before you leave today that you clear your desk and remove any valuables in your desk before you
▶ Play
leave. Thank you. All right, members, we've gotten word the Senate has finished up their business, and so there being no further business necessary to come before the first extraordinary session of the 91st General Assembly, the House of Representatives is hereby adjourned, Sonny All right, members, if I could get your attention here. I'm going to call to order a House Caucus meeting for the 91st General Assembly. All right, we're going to do the normal procedure for roll call at this point, so I'm going to ask the clerk to prepare the machine. Please note your presence by hitting your yellow present button. All right, let's cast the ballots, Mr. Clerk. 94 present the chair sees a quorum all right members as we've kind of already discussed a little bit the reason for this caucus meeting at this time is going to be to take up one item of business which is house resolution 1001 which was addressed in the Rules Committee yesterday afternoon, so I will be doing that presentation. But before I do that I'm going to ask the clerk to please read House Resolution 1001. House
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:33:05
Resolution 1001 by Representative Gillum to amend the rules of the House of the representatives of the 91st General Assembly.
▶ Play
Speaker Gilliam, you're recognized to explain the resolution.
▶ Play
All right. Members, I'm going to try not to be just overly long in this, but I want to make sure that I cover all the ground and answer questions and stuff, too. So I'm going to start with why I'm presenting this resolution before you to change our House rules. And to do that, I must go back in time about four years ago to when I was House Management Chair. We had a couple of instances with elected officials that occurred during that time frame that Speaker Carter had a couple of different instances had begun the process of trying to figure out what would happen if we needed to as a body go down the road of impeachment. The subsequent resignations by those two individuals kind of negated the urgency for that process. And so they were, for all practical purposes, dropped. Now, I take responsibility for not pressing forward and getting those things done at the time it should have been done this is a process we should have had in through our rules in the eventual case that something would happen should have been done a while ago and so i take responsibility from having that position that i didn't press forward with speaker carter and we had members that had asked about it we just didn't ever proceed with it also even though it was kind of an out of sight out of mind thing two years ago when we were here, or at least over the last two years, the previous biennium. Should have done it then, but it was kind of one of those things that was out of sight, out of mind. Nothing was going on at the time, and so I'm here before you today because it's something that needs to be addressed and in our rules, okay? Recent conversations from our colleagues to the other end of the building had brought to light that we did have a deficiency within our house rules to do that. I kind of take this, the timing and everything, it's going to be kind of a Warshak test for most everybody else. You're going to kind of imprint on it, you know, what you want to on the timing of it and everything. And all I can say is that, you know, I was a victim of, as I said, just not getting it done earlier. I didn't want us to continue without having something in place. I'm not bringing this before you today, asking you to take any actions or do anything. I'm just simply asking you to join with me and just getting the framework into the rules. This may not be used for a decade. It may be used, you know, 10 months from now. It might be used a year. I'm not setting a timetable on when this would actually be used, but I do think it's important that it get into the rules and that we have that in place, since right now we have nothing in place at all. Now, from my perspective, when you begin work on things. You have to do research. Those of you who have spent time with me know that I'm methodical and patient in my processes, and I know it frustrates a lot of folks that I take my time on those things. When the conversation came back up about three weeks ago or so, close to three weeks ago, about possible impeachment of an elected official, and it highlighted and reminded a lot of us that we didn't have this done, we began a process of actually researching, calling, being very deliberate to make sure that if we were going to put anything in place, that it was done so with a lot of thoughtfulness in place. And so we have been contacting other states. We have been in contact with Alabama and talked to their officials. They've just gone through this process with their governor. They had a similar type of situation to the fact that they had the reference from their Constitution. They didn't have anything formed up or anything at all, and then that need arose. And they were saying they wished they had taken care of it long before so that they didn't have to have that all in the process with the impeachment. So we have looked at their framework. We've looked at what they put into place from Illinois. We've looked at what the U.S. Congress has as far as their procedures and have brought Well before you end this resolution, what we feel like is a good framework for the Arkansas House representatives to use in the eventuality or in the case that there was a need to bring forth impeachment articles against an elected official. Now it also reminded me of something that I had meant to do with the rules that we adopted back in January, and that was include the references and the things necessary to address if we had an issue within our own body. And that was an oversight on my part in the addition of the rules back at the beginning of our biennial back in January. So if you're looking at the resolution, when you start out on the first page, that's what you see first is the things that would, the citations back to the Constitution, the code that would govern us. And if there was an unfortunate situation in which one of our body needed to have an issue addressed, then that's what you see in the first section. And then you move on from that into 112 and the subsequent subsections of that, and that's where you see the framework for what we would use if we had to proceed down a road of impeachment proceedings. So under the Arkansas Constitution, we have the sole power of impeachment. What I'm proposing in this resolution here would be that the articles of impeachment would be filed in the form of a House resolution which would be co-sponsored by at least 34 members. Now, the reason that we went with that number would be because it's just over one-third of the body, but it's two-thirds of the number of members that would be necessary to take a vote, an affirmative vote, pass out that article, and send it to the Senate to further the process. So that wasn't just by happenstance, they didn't just pull that number out of the air. Alabama's 21, Illinois was a little different too, but we strongly felt like that if you're going to go down this road, this is a serious issue, and if you're going to go down that road you needed more than just one or two members being able to file a resolution that would take you down that road and then so that's why you've got that number there. At that time the speaker would refer that resolution to committee. Now that would be basically left to the speaker based on the case that was being brought before and if the articles were. There's a high likelihood that Judiciary would be the one that would typically be what would hear most things, but in the eventuality that it might, or in the situation in which it might wind up being a constitutional officer, maybe state agencies is the right committee, so we don't spell it out and make it go to one all the time. It would be kind of on a case-by-case basis, depending on what was there. And for those purposes there, once it was assigned there, that committee would be tasked with investigating the allegations that were asserted in the Articles of Impeachment. To make that recommendation to the House of Representatives as to whether a cause exists to impeach the official that is subject of that. Now as you read through this you'll notice that we don't spell out the committee rules. That also we left flexibility in there to be done by case by case basis because you don't know which official that you might be addressing and those are all going to be different. I answered a question yesterday in committee from Representative House as to the length and breadth of the investigations. Those are going to vary. If you were talking, if we were in a situation like Alabama had found themselves in, then you're talking about hiring special counsel to conduct the investigation and to actually prosecute the case in front of the House of Representatives. That could be a long process. I think theirs took weeks and months in their investigative process here recently, but if you were dealing with something else that was a fairly known quantity, maybe at a county clerk level, I think maybe it was the example that was used, and there were a lot of known facts and everything was really pretty obvious, then that might be a week-long process or two days if there's already guilt or something that's been prescribed or admitted to. There's flexibility in there. The committees that are going to be assigned that resolution would be able to adopt their own committee rules for that case and that purpose and allow them that flexibility and to be able to move forward in the matters that would be appropriate with that. So also through this, though, there's a couple of more unique facets that would come about from this that I want to make sure I touch on that I think are important. The committee would then send a report to the full body if they chose to proceed. We'll use the example of an affirmative vote from the committee in our scenario here. If two or more members of that committee chose to do so, they could send the minority opinion report to the body as well. I think that's important so that everyone would hear both sides of the argument. And as was pointed out today in the debate of some of the other items that we had in the special session earlier, that not everyone gets to attend all the meetings. So this would be a way to make sure that the minority opinion or dissenting opinion, to borrow some judicial terms there, would be presented and read in front of the whole body as to why, you know, it wasn't necessary to proceed with impeachment proceedings based on the positive or affirmative committee report at the time. Now in reality, the committee easily could send a report back that says, look, the investigation yielded that it is not necessary for us to move forward, and that no action needs to be taken. And in that case, the opposite of that would occur, and you would have the minority opinion would be, no, you do need to move forward with it. So, but that's a little unique. We don't normally have that in a process when we get a due pass recommendation from a committee. We don't have a secondary report that says why we shouldn't pass a bill. We usually leave that to the floor when people coming down and saying why the committee was wrong for passing it out. So that's in here as well. It would be a majority of the membership of the committee to be able to pass it forward. The same would apply for us as a full body. Here would be 51 members as well to be able to send the articles down to the Senate to further that process. So it's fairly straightforward. There's a three-day, three business day threshold in here as well from the time that the committee issued their report. So you could not have a situation to where they issued a report on a Friday afternoon and we came in on a Monday to begin proceedings. It's going to be three business days, and that scenario, my interpretation of it would be Thursday of the following week if somebody, if they issued the report on a Friday. The point is to be deliberate and not rush through the process, and so that's why that three-day margin is in there as well. So as I said, members, it's fairly straightforward, self-explanatory. I will say that part of the reason that I wanted to do this while we were here was because we were already here. It's not that I'm necessarily always cheap, but we were already here, and I felt like we could go ahead and take this item up while we were here. I could have called everybody back in two weeks from now or three weeks from now, but it would have possibly been a hassle on a numerous amount of schedules and would have cost us a lot more money. There was no illicit or nefarious motive to it other than I thought that it was efficient. And as I came in on Monday and met with members about this issue, I approached this purely as an administrative function that needed to have been done. It was highlighted that it hadn't been done. And so that's why we're doing it in the manner that we're doing it. And so, once again, you know, I'll be happy to answer any questions if there's some ground that I did not cover on this.
▶ Play
Representative Stephen Meeks, for what purpose? Question, please. You're
▶ Play
recognized for a question. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I appreciate the work that you've put into this. And just clarification, when the committee makes its recommendation, you know, normally if a bill goes to a committee, if the committee says do pass, it comes back to the House. If the committee says no, the bill dies. But in this case, regardless of which way the committee rules, that will come back to the full body, and the full body will have a decision even if the committee says no on impeachment.
▶ Play
Is that correct? They're going to issue their report, and if we were in a situation where they said we do not need to move forward, then the full report would be issued to the House, but no further action would move forward at that point. because the committee chose and deemed that no action was needed through their investigation. But the report would come before the House, and we very well could meet and proceed by having the reports read. But I would find it extremely unlikely that the committee would go through the investigative process, Issue A, you do not need to move forward, and that this body would need to then go around that committee. We don't do that on anything else. I don't know why we
▶ Play
would do that on this. So, follow-up. You're recognized for a follow-up. So, if the committee, if 10 members of the 100-member body basically said no. Well, it would be 20. Right. Well, there's 20 members on the committee, but all it takes is 10 to say no in order for the resolution. So theoretically, 10 members of the committee, if it worked out right, could say no. The other than 90 members could be in support of impeachment. And I want to make sure that we're not saying that those 10 members who just happen to be on that committee are going to stop something that the rest of the body thinks needs to go forward. So ultimately, could the body, if that committee said no, I want to make sure that they can make that recommendation to the full House, but I want to make sure that the full house has the final say, yes or no, and not the committee. Does that make sense? It does. Hang on one
▶ Play
second. Let me refresh my memory on the exact wording of this here. I don't want to speak out of turn, Representative Meek, so I apologize for, I just want to make sure that I'm reading this correctly and then I cite to you back appropriately. Yeah, and I
▶ Play
read through it, and my, what I took away from is that the full body would make that final decision, but I just want to make sure that we have that clear that even if the committee says no, that the full body would still have a chance to vote either away.
▶ Play
Well I can see how based on the wording here you could read that and I think that also following the normal procedures of the fact that a bill could be pulled out of committee that you'd be you'd be correct in
▶ Play
that assertion. Okay I just want to make sure that that's the we've got that.
▶ Play
Thank you sir. Representative Murdock for what purpose? Question. Do you recognize for
▶ Play
a question to try to clarify where representative meeks went in what you gave him so that is an act and we can pull something from committee in that that can happen but in this particular case you have a committee for a reason to handle the issue that committee that recommendation is made to the body then obviously the bodies and I think I'm just trying to make sure I understand but you just see it.
▶ Play
Okay. This would function. The committee would submit to the House of Representatives, along with its recommendation of the resolution, the report regarding the findings and conclusions. So basically, to break it down, we're the grand jury, and so they're doing the investigative process on behalf of the body. So they're going to send that report and their findings to the body to be able to take action and be able to move forward. Now, from all likelihood, it would function in a normal committee mindset to where if they passed it out, it comes and you move forward. And that was the way in our conversations with the folks in Alabama, that they had envisioned their system being able to function as well. And so, but it's, if the report was that you don't need to move forward, but you had 60 members that disagreed with the report because you have the minority or the dissenting opinion report that would be issued as well. That's where they had that component in. That's why you have that function because it
▶ Play
is an extraordinary situation. Representative Gates, for what purpose? Question. You
▶ Play
recognize her question? With the ambiguity that currently exists without this, then every rule becomes a challenge and then a simple majority on every single point of order would be the rule of the day without this resolution. Is that correct? Yes, sir, that's absolutely correct. Since
▶ Play
we have nothing in place at all, one of you could stand up today and make a motion to impeach somebody. You can impeach the governor, if you're mad at him about the special session or anything. And we have nothing in place to govern and guide how we're going to do. That's why I'm presenting this, so that we have some administrative guidelines here on how this would actually
▶ Play
function. REPRESENTATIVE HAMMER, FOR WHAT PURPOSE? QUESTION, PLEASE. YOU'RE RECOGNIZED FOR
▶ Play
A QUESTION. WITH REGARDS TO WHAT REPRESENTATIVE MEAKS STATED A WHILE AGO, I'M LOOKING AT PAGE 2, LINE 25. AND AS I READ LINES 25 THROUGH 29, IT SAYS THE COMMITTEE SHALL SUBMIT TO THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES. THAT'S NOT AN OPTION. THE COMMITTEE WILL HEAR, THE EVIDENCE WILL HEAR AND MAKE A DETERMINANT AND WITHIN THE COMMITTEE make a recommendation but regardless of whatever that recommendation is or is not by the way that reads I'm interpreting that the full house will have the ultimate decision as to whether to accept the recommendation of the committee or go against the recommendation of the committee regardless of what I bring forward am I correct in that interpretation that's I agree with you sir that's that's my interpretation of it as well follow up Mr. Speaker you recognize because Because there's been questions, even as of today, comments have been made on the House 4 in the previous session about committees and about, you know, inside groups and all that kind of rhetoric, can you or are you at liberty or would you speak as to the selection of the committee that's going to hear such matters as this and qualifications or because it's involving impeachment, will it all be attorneys or are you comfortable speaking to that place?
▶ Play
happy to speak with what we, our research and what we have determined is, is that, you know, you're going to go to one of the existing committees you've got, unless it's in an extra, absolutely extraordinary situation, you might have to go with an ad hoc committee to deal with something that would be extraordinary. But outside of that, what you're looking at here is judiciary, state agency rules, and you're going to be dealing with a committee that is a preexisting committee already. I mean, it's, like I said, it would only be in a massively extraordinary situation would you have to go a different direction. So if it was, like, say, the governor, attorney general, something of that nature, you could go judiciary or state agency. You know, it would be dependent on the case and everything and the makeup of those bodies. But in our conversations with folks at NCSL and in Alabama, uh judiciary was the predominant thought process because uh they're they're just kind of set up that way and so i i my thought going into this uh you know here in arkansas if we ever got to that mode uh where we were doing an impeachment proceeding would be that judiciary uh you know nine out of ten times
▶ Play
Speaker 171 1:56:21
would be the appropriate venue representative civillo for what purpose Thank you Mr. Speaker. As you had mentioned, Representative Gillum, that this is a very serious issue. Has it in the studies that you have performed, passing this from one chamber at a 51% vote, as serious as this is, another, as you would say, maybe a stop gap at the Senate level, if I'm correct, that is a two-third vote. Yes. But once again, I think that the 51 votes here in the House to pass it would maybe limit some of our oversight on such a serious message and pass it to another chamber. And so I guess my question, is it pretty normal to see one chamber pass it out at 51 or a majority in comparison to having a higher threshold?
▶ Play
Yes, we're following the model that pretty much everybody else uses. And again, I remind you that the role of the House of Representatives is that kind of more of a grand jury. Our job is not to convict. our job is to analyze the evidence to see if it warrants the trial in the Senate and so that's why our threshold is where it's at and that the function and the way that we approach
▶ Play
it representative Dodson for what purpose question you recognize for a question thank you mr. speaker my question is
▶ Play
without a rule in place currently and I think you touched on this briefly that any member could make a motion right now today however without any rules in place the speaker at their discretion can choose to hear that motion or not hear that motion so this actually establishes the process where one individual can't block the process and one individual can't start the process will have a system and process in place with this rule established that's clearly defined is that correct that's absolutely correct yes sir follow up mr SPEAKER. YOU RECOGNIZED. THANK YOU. AND THEN TO TOUCH ON JUST AS A FOLLOW-UP MOSTLY TO WHAT REPRESENTATIVE MEAKS HAD STARTED. I HAD THAT SAME LINE OF THOUGHT PROCESS YESTERDAY AND WENT THROUGH AND ASKED VARIOUS FOLKS WHO HAD HELPED DRAFT THIS LEGISLATION. AND AS WE UNDERSTOOD ON AT THE END OF PAGE TWO LEADING INTO LINE ONE OF PAGE THREE OF THE the draft it basically says that the committee shall produce a report so it's not like a regular committee where it can be tabled or killed in a committee but the speaker shall call for the consideration of that report whatever it is good or bad within three day or three days after it's not subjective so the house the full body will consider it once the articles have started that process has started the the committee itself can't block it is that an accurate statement yes sir i believe it is thank you
▶ Play
representative allen for what purpose question you recognize for
▶ Play
a question uh it's my understanding that down through the years that we never had an impeachment process in this body is
▶ Play
that correct that's correct we've not had any uh set structure as to how it would occur and and it's actually well there's been one case but it was back predating our current Constitution
▶ Play
you recognize for a follow-up earlier one of my colleagues mentioned the judge that's Griffin so my My question is, is this the reason why we're in such a haste to put something in place to start the impeachment process with the judge? And I think we have to be very careful that we don't go down that slippery slope, because it could be the judge today and one of
▶ Play
us tomorrow. Representative Allen, I'll say this, we do not and I would not propose that we do something in our house rules because of one individual or citizen of the state of Arkansas. This is in place because we needed administrative guidelines as to how something would occur. This could be for the judge who had the DUI issues that was in the news. This could be for a whole myriad of elected officials down through the next several years. I don't know what the future holds on any of that. As I stated earlier, you know, over the last three weeks the conversations from our colleagues on the Senate end brought up the fact that there was at least a possibility. Well, in that scenario, I felt that it was prudent and responsible for us to make sure that we had guidelines if an event was to happen, and especially given the fact that right now, with no guidelines at all, you could stand up and make a motion to impeach the governor, and we would have no process, we would have nothing to be able to move forward with whatsoever. And so I felt like the prudent thing for us to do, and I don't, I do not believe that this is in haste, us putting in administrative procedures of this nature, the flexibility that's built in, the protections that are built in. This is not something I believe you do very quickly. The process in and of itself would be very methodical, very drawn out unless it was a clear cut open and shut case as was referenced yesterday in the Rules Committee by Representative House. You're going to investigate, you're going to go through things. There's no haste in that. This is simply whether or not you want to have policies and procedures in the House rules for an occurrence to go down the road where impeachment articles were filed. That's the question I'm asking you here today, is whether or not you want to put procedures in place, and then from there, the body would move on any decision to be made from there. In case you haven't heard. We're going to move
▶ Play
on. You can get back in the queue, Representative Allen. Thank you, partner. You've already had your follow-up. you're going to have to get back in the queue. Representative Hendren, for what purpose?
▶ Play
An inquiry of the chair or of the sponsor? My question is, one of the things that happens here frequently in the legislature is a motion for immediate consideration. And when that happens, that stops the debate, no more talks, and so forth. So before, and I want my question to the speaker, the sponsor, and the speaker in the chair, Is there going to be an opportunity for members of this body to speak for and against this amendment, this House Rules Change resolution, before someone makes that motion and it's accepted and it's voted for? Yes, I'll answer that question. There will be an opportunity for
▶ Play
speeches for and against the resolution. Thank you. Members, I will say this, you know, if you don't want to proceed with putting in these procedures or you don't like these procedures, vote no. If you think these are prudent and responsible and appropriate, vote yes. This is not meant to be a massive, huge, complicated issue here. I'm presenting this and I came in Monday and met with folks and presented it and showed it to them. I'm viewing this as a necessary administrative function. If you agree with me, then vote yes. If you don't think that we need any procedures in place and you want to go with just somebody pop up and raise your hand and vote and make a motion to impeach somebody, that's kind of all I'm trying to do here,
▶ Play
folks. Representative Hammer, for what purpose? Please. You're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Either for you, Representative Gillum, or maybe the parliamentarian, because this deals with such a sensitive nature and because, based on your comments a while ago, you stated this would go to an existing committee, you cited judiciary, that has 20 members on it. What is the process in the event you determine that one of the members of the committee that is going to, or several of the members that it is going to, has shown actions either through social media, previous comments, positions taken, that you feel that they would be disqualified from serving on that committee because of the sensitive nature of this? What is the process to make sure that the 20 committee members are pure in their intent of hearing that evidence and making an unbiased decision? I'll answer that, and I'll be perfectly honest
▶ Play
with you. It was a question that I had and I've had for two and a half weeks, and it's one that I've asked folks all the way from Professor Brill to other folks in the research on this. And there's not an absolute, at least at this point, I'm not comfortable in telling you that there's an absolute definitive answer as to whether or not that anyone has the authority to remove them from that process. Because this is a, it's a political exercise by its definition and the process, but it has some judicial undertones. And so we're still researching that. And so I can't definitively tell you right now what that would be. And some of that would almost have to rely on being the case-by-case basis of what actually occurred and whether or not somebody's comments on social media. And I think a lot of that is probably more appropriate for the Senate to decide than it would even be our side based on a lot of the conversations I've had. There doesn't seem to be a lot of, I don't want to put words in people's mouths, but there doesn't seem to be a lot of opinion or precedent that would guide our part of the process as to where that would happen. There seems to be more opinion and thought as to what would happen on the Senate side during their trial than on our side. But it's something that we are still very much, I'm looking into, I want to get those answers, but I just don't have that part yet. I know that in the Alabama situation, when that was cited and the governor had made appeals there, the courts ruled that the House had jurisdiction over that process, and those members were allowed to stay and proceed. Follow-up, Mr.
▶ Play
Speaker. I'm recognized for a follow-up. Thank you. In reality, without the passage of this resolution gives you coverage as far as getting down into the weeds on those specific issues. So in the event that this situation occurred, then you could have the authority bestowed by this body on you to go forward and start getting those things worked out. Is that a fair statement? Yes, sir, it
▶ Play
is. Thank you. Representative Rye, for what purpose? Questions. You recognize for a question?
▶ Play
Yes, sir. Mr. Speaker, this situation and procedure that we are going through or fixing to go through, would this need to go through both bodies for what we're doing, or is this just among ourselves?
▶ Play
No, sir. This is just for the House. All right, members, I don't want to just exhaust this forever. I'm going to yield the well here and allow for those that want to speak on the bill to come forward. So I hope I've answered everybody's questions. If I've not, I'll try to address them in my
▶ Play
closing. Thank you. Speaker Gillen has explained the resolution. Would anyone like to speak against the resolution? Representative Hendren, you recognize
▶ Play
to speak against the resolution. A week ago, last Tuesday night, I was at a Republican committee meeting in Bentonville, Arkansas. And I attend those regularly and have ever since I changed parties 20 or 30 years ago. I won't say how I got changed, but I got changed. And a couple of my colleagues on this floor today were in that same meeting that night. And they can either verify for you or retract what I'm about to tell you, because this is what happened. And frankly, ladies and gentlemen, when I come down here and speak to this well, it's not what just Kim Hendren believes. It's what I believe my constituents believe. I don't agree with all of them. They don't agree with me, obviously. The big discussion last week ago, Tuesday night, was how we select committees in this body. We just passed our rules changed at the beginning of this body that allows the speaker, the current speaker, or whoever the next speaker may be, unless we change it, to appoint every committee, every chairman, and every chairman and vice chairman serve at their pleasure. Now, there were some other discussions in that Republican committee meeting in Bentonville the other night, but this was the main thing. And I'm telling you, folks, the people up there don't like that. They don't agree with it. And there are higher officials in the Republican Party that don't agree with it either, that called me the next day and said keep up the fight, keep up the discussion. So that's one of the reasons I'm down here today keeping up the discussion. And I might say with what's going on here I'm at my own risk. I told somebody as I walked out a while ago after we finished this last debate, I said my office this year is down in the basement. I'm expecting it now to be moved down under the new Arkansas Broadway Bridge. Because I know how things work down here. and gentlemen. And if you don't you will learn it if you stay here a while. And I want to say several things about that. And I challenge you. You've got lawyers in this body. There's some up in the lobby. There are probably people watching on this television. Lawyers. And I see one Democrat lawyer right out there that I think a lot of Whitaker. Now I've ruined him and me both. But this body, and you need to check all you freshman need to understand this. They keep talking about stuff down here about rules and about we can't do this and can't do that. Ladies and gentlemen, colleagues let me tell you this. This body can do anything they want to do at any time they want to do when they are in session that does not violate the Constitution of the State of Arkansas. I don't care what that rule book says or anything else or what the Speaker says or what Kim Kim says, or what anybody else says. You can, somebody says, you can stand up and make a motion. Ladies and gentlemen, you can stand up and make a motion to overrule the Speaker to do whatever you do, or to move Kim's seat outside, I guess. And if you get 51 votes you can do it. Now as you all continue to serve in this body you need to understand that. That doesn't mean I recommend you do it every day. But you need to understand the ultimate power of the Arkansas Constitution and as a matter of fact the U.S. Constitution resides with the people. Don't ever forget that. So any time we had that happen the other day over in the budget committee. And the chairman, the bureau legislator agreed that. Charlotte Douglas had the Speaker, well he's not even here. Yeah he's probably back there talking in the corner. The Speaker says I'm not going to consider that deal right now whatever she wanted to do. And I asked the question. I I said, is it not appropriate that any member of this budget committee could make a motion to overrule the ruling of the Speaker? The answer is yes, yes, yes, yes. And ladies and gentlemen, if you ever forget that and you ever let it go away, you're losing something in this legislative process and in our government and the state of Arkansas and the United States of America. You've heard of the nuclear option in the U.S. Senate. It was just exercised. That's what that's talking about. It's true there and it's true here. Now let me talk about this deal specifically. You say why am I concerned about it? Based on what this is if the Speaker now or the Speaker in the future does not like what I say down here they could ask that I be impeached or you based on this bill. Now why do I say that? Some of you are shaking. Let me tell you how it works is the current Speaker based on the new rules and most of the old rules appoints every committee and every chairman and every vice chairman and they serve it their pleasure. Now if I am Speaker and you do something I don't like then I come to 34 members is all I've got to do it, 34 members. And frankly the Speaker makes over 100 appointments, way over 100 in this body every year, every session. Over 100, probably 150. Many of them paid jobs and so forth. Members if you don't know about that you need to find out about it. It wouldn't hurt to know who is appointed by whom, by what, by for, for what reason. But when there is that kind of power and say I'm Speaker and that guy is sitting back on the corner I didn't like what he did. I just didn't preach that guy. And I go to you, well he's done some bad things. Well you need to, I heard we mentioned a while ago we mentioned Speaker Carter. I heard that when he was Speaker and the chairman of these committees some of them served at his pleasure. Now that was the two years I was back home trying to make an honest living. I heard he went to a committee one day that said that they weren't doing what he wanted and he threatened to remove the chairman and vice chairman of that committee. And a lot of this stuff I hear ladies and gentlemen is the truth when you get out and find it out. that. That's why I said that about Griffin last night. The reason I said that about Griffin that's what I've heard. That's what I've told other people. It came from a fairly credible source. I'm not in favor of trying to impeach Wendell Griffin. I don't agree with what he did. But I'm not going to vote for this deal anyhow. But we changed the rules to allow the Speaker of this body now appoint everybody. That's tremendous power. Now the Speaker comes and says let's change the rules, let's add a rule that not only says that then if I can find 34 members of this body that agree with me perhaps me or agree with you about somebody one of you needs to go home if I can get 34 of a member there are going to be charges brought. And then I'm going to assign them to committee as Speaker that I choose. And I might say just a word about that again. When the Speaker whoever he or she may be makes an assignment of a committee from that chair up there. Any member of this body has the right and in my opinion the responsibility if you don't agree to stand to your feet and say Mr. Chair I challenge the ruling of the chair and the assignment of that bill. And if 51 of us ladies and gentlemen agree to change it we can change it right then and now I don't. And isn't that the way it ought to be? I think we are 100 equals in here ladies and gentlemen. I believe we all are. We ought to have our say, we ought to come down here and say and then vote our, and then go back home which we will and be responsible to the voters. So we can do that any time we want to. Talk about it if something comes up tomorrow. Somebody about mentioned about well what if we had to impeach the governor. I've got to be careful I'm on soft ground here again today. But if he's done something or she's done something that bad you can stand up here today and say I I think we ought to do that I make that motion and I make a motion right then we set the rules in place to do that. We can do it. And that's the way it ought to be done and it's been done that way for years. Not everything we've done in the past is right. Question about assigning to committees. So many problems with this. But ladies and gentlemen I believe we already have the authority with 51 of of us, 51 of us equal 100's. If somebody does something that egregious or whatever it might be, if it includes, if it's one of us we have the right to come to this body and make the emotion to take the appropriate action. And to set whatever rules at that time we choose to set. And frankly we ought to do that. And if we don't do it the people that are going to vote us in or out next March or February or May whenever we are going to have that primary now ought to take the steps to replace us. So let's just be accountable to the people. I just hate to see, I've been, let me finish with this. I've been passing out a Scripture verses, some fun of you here today. It really got on my case here about two weeks ago. Let me tell you what it is. Now you can either remember it, write it down, and I'll give you the test. But here it is. Most people would say 2 Chronicles 26.16. Well that's not the way we say things today in politics when we are We're quoting scripture. So here's what it is. Two Chronicles 26, 16. Go read it and see what it means to you and to me as you consider how you're going to vote. So folks, the power rests with us, with you. Let's keep it there. Representative
▶ Play
Hendren has spoken against the resolution. Would anyone like to speak for the resolution? Representative Lundstrom, you're recognized to speak for the resolution.
▶ Play
Colleagues, I'd like to speak for this resolution. First of all, we have to have standards and ethics. What Speaker Gillum has done is put this before us to put it in our rules, whether it's for this judicial issue or if we have a House member that requires this type of sanction. He has done the information and brought it to us so that we can add it to our rules. Yes, our rules can change. That is our job, to be ethical and to have standards. And now we can go back home and say we do have standards, even to remove one of our own members, which may happen someday. That's part of this process. Our body needs to police itself, and we need to hold ourselves accountable. This starts that process, and I applaud him for bringing it to us. I would ask for a good vote. Representative
▶ Play
Lundtram has spoken in favor of the resolution. Would anyone like to speak against the resolution? Representative Flowers, you recognize to speak against the resolution. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Speaker. Colleagues, I sat here and listened, and I didn't ask any questions. I just sort of wrote notes. So, I'm going to approach this in three parts. First of all, how or why we're even discussing this. There has been commentary, and I believe Mr. Speaker talked about, the process that began four years ago. Since four years, there have been two legislative sessions, two fiscal sessions, at least three special sessions, And there has been no move or conversation to address that in this time. So, and with all due respect, I find it disingenuous to say that this is an extension of that inquiry and that process that began four years ago. On April 17th, we got an email in this body that came from the Speaker's office saying that in response, I quote, in response to inquiries from the membership, I have begun looking into the matter of impeachment proceedings. that we got that email the very same day that Judge Griffin issued his order and that he also exercised speech that many of us may not have agreed with. But that happened the same day. So let's start by first acknowledging that this is not about a process that began a while ago and we want to be responsible, this is about Judge Griffin. This is about creating a process to address that. That's what this is about. Secondly. What's your point of order?
▶ Play
Not speaking to the resolution. Representative Flowers, try to stick to the resolution, please, as close as
▶ Play
Speaker 202 2:22:27
you can. Mr. Speaker, I'm trying to
▶ Play
do that, and I will. I would also like to point out that in terms of timing, this body has a very definitive role that is specific to the House of Representatives that is afforded us by the Constitution. Since 1874, this body has had the power to impeach. I don't believe we've ever utilized it. And in that time, this body has never seen fit to set up a special set of rules to address something that could happen in any manner of ways to any manner of elected officials. The second thing I would like to point out is that there already is a process in place because we have the separation of powers. There is a code that's defined by judicial canons, and the Judicial Discipline and Disability Commission exercises this role in addressing judges. So to say that we have to use our authority and define special rules and then pretend like it's not about that, I think, does a disservice to the body and does a disservice to the rules. I'll end by saying this. We know what this is really about. And I want to come up here and say, let's address that. If this is really about impeaching Judge Griffin, then let's be courageous as a body. Let's be honest as a body and say that that's what we're doing and then address it appropriately. not come down here and file a resolution the day before it's to be addressed without any opportunity for any of us to be a part of the discussion or process for what this is really supposed to do. and finally
▶ Play
Speaker 203 2:24:59
I'll point out that as we
▶ Play
have always had this power to impeach there have been numerous occasions and accounts including last year there was a judge and I won't mention the name There was a judge whose misconduct involved sexual material and inappropriate sexual relationships with people that he then used to influence his decisions on the bench. i don't believe anyone in here including mr speaker with all due respect in the year that there was an investigation of this judge before he resigned in january there was no move to set up special rules for impeachment please take that into consideration thank you and i've asked for a no
▶ Play
vote representative flowers has spoken against the resolution would anyone like to speak for the resolution representative Dodson you're recognized to speak for the
▶ Play
Speaker 205 2:26:23
resolution thank you mr.
▶ Play
speaker this want to address a couple of things that's been mentioned in the for and against with regards to this resolution I've personally had multiple conversations throughout the years that we lacked a rule on impeachment proceedings. This is a constitutional responsibility that's designated to the House of Representatives without a process set up in place to address it. I had this conversation with Speaker Carter four years ago, with the parliamentarian, with multiple ones over a couple of sessions and several years. So to say that this is a brand new discussion is simply not true. Now as far as the resolution that we have before us, and this is what we're voting on, we're not voting on any articles of impeachment. No resolution for articles of impeachment have been drafted or are before us. Hopefully, this is something that we're setting up a process for that it'll take 100 years for us to utilize. And in 100 plus years, we haven't had the need for it. However, it is something that we have had the need to have a rule in place. And this, because it's a serious thing, because impeachment is an incredibly serious question to even consider, we need to have rules in place for this process and this procedure. Currently, without a rule in place, one member can make the motion and the speaker combined can accept that motion. And at that point in time, the rule-making process begins on how to define it in the midst of a heated argument and debate where there's already a motion and articles on the table that should be being considered. That is not the time to create the rule and the process for an impeachment procedure. this is the time to actually look at it, deliberate it, and I think this is a reasonable measure. It takes it out of the hands of basically two members, one who makes the motion and whoever the speaker happens to be at that point in time, whether they accept that motion to begin the process. It puts in the hand of a third of the body, which is a fairly high threshold to make a motion to get something started. Not only that, but they have to put their names out there whether or not it goes anywhere or not to get that that process started. I think that's a reasonable request and I would hope that this body would would consider it and vote to pass it. I'll try to answer questions I guess. Representative Howells for
▶ Play
what purpose? You are recognized for a question. Representative Dotson, a couple of years ago, Lieutenant Governor Mark Dahr was suspected because he was entitled to a presumption of innocence, of misusing public funds and credit cards. Did we not at that time begin an impeachment investigation before he decided it was better or more prudent to resign?
▶ Play
Absolutely. I remember it quite clearly. Republican, wasn't he? I believe so. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Speaker, Chairman. Representative Flowers, for what purpose? Question. Do you recognize for a question? And so I guess to piggyback off of that question and to refer back to your involvement and your awareness of these discussions dating back at least four years, can you express why it's so important now, but in those four years, in two sessions, in particular you or others who were involved in that conversation did not bring forth a rule or a bill of
▶ Play
this magnitude. Well obviously it didn't rise to the urgency level to actually have articles or a process in place before we were going to potentially hear anything. At that point several years ago there was bit of urgency at that moment in time and then urgency fell away and the business of a session as all of us are inclined to do during a session have multiple things to focus on at this point in time this is the only thing and before us this is what the purpose of this caucus has been called for for us to consider this one resolution and rules before you we can pass them or we We cannot adopt the rules or deal with it when there's actually a potential heated situation,
▶ Play
which right now we're not in the midst of. Follow-up. You're recognized for a follow-up. I believe that our colleague mentioned that there was a heated situation and that the process had begun without these rules. So my question, it would be, do you believe that had Dahr not resigned, that the House would not have been able to appropriately, faithfully, and fairly utilize its constitutional power to impeach at that time?
▶ Play
I certainly would hope so. However, it would have been in a very heated situation in the midst of a lot more challenge to set up fair, impartial rules for us to actually go through a process that was laid out and everyone knows what the rules are before we begin with that i appreciate a good vote representative dodson has spoken
▶ Play
in favor of the resolution would anyone like to speak against the resolution for the resolution representative brown you recognize to speak for the resolution Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
▶ Play
I'll be very brief. As Representative Gillum, our Representative Hendren, and Representative Dotson have all pointed out, there is no, currently one person could stand up in this body and make a motion to impeach, and it would take 51 votes to pass that. To me, that's like, you know, being in a third world country. And I think that perhaps there is a situation that people are considering addressing, but when you realize that we don't really have any orderly process in place and that this is something we've needed to do for quite some time, I applaud Mr. Gillum's resolution and I believe we do need a process. We need an orderly process and we don't need a chaotic process like in some third world country. So I would appreciate a good vote. Thank you.
▶ Play
Representative Brown has spoken in favor of the resolution. Would anyone like to speak against the resolution? Speaker Gillen, would you like to close for your resolution? Representative, you're recognized to speak for the resolution.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. You know, there is a difference between the caucus of the House and in session because in session has to do with the other end, but this is House business. And every time we talk about that, I have to go through the mental gymnastics of why this is different than regular session. So I think this is the appropriate time. The separation of powers, it seems, never gets brought up when a judicial branch interferes in an executive branch or a legislative branch. this is a checks and balances there are checks and balances it is we the legislature who determines what the laws of Arkansas is going to be we've been given the duties and the responsibilities of of looking when people overstep their bounds and the the responsibility of impeachment does begin here it doesn't start at the other end they can cry all they want down there but they can't start the process it requires one member of a hundred currently I was one of those people that called the speaker and said I found the actions of Judge Griffin to be inappropriate and I was one of those that called and there were numerous calls by that time and I was told at that time just hold on because the process needs to be defined part of me I will be voting for this part of me likes the ambiguity, because when there's ambiguity, then we get to just kind of make up the rules as we go. Generally, when you're looking at serious matters, you don't want to make up the rules as you go. And I think this resolution goes to define so that we do not have chaos, and it removes the ability of one person, as myself would have made that motion to impeach. it takes it out of the hands of one person and it requires at least 33 other people to sign off on it we are able to present bills that we didn't get anybody to sign off we don't even have to have a senate sponsor when we introduce a bill this requires 34 people you have to convince 33 other people that you have at least a somewhat valid case before you can even get it to a place to get it to the speaker. I think this is a reasonable measure. It does raise the bar more than the one person and I think it would be a good way to start so that we remove chaos. I appreciate a good vote.
▶ Play
Representative Gates has spoken in favor of the resolution. Speaker Gillum, you Do you recognize the close for the
▶ Play
resolution? Thank you, Mr. Chair. Members, I'll try to be brief in my closing, but I do want to address a couple of points that was made. Representative Flowers mentioned a few things that I need to kind of probably touch on here. One, the email that was sent out was done on Monday afternoon, not on Friday, when Judge Griffin joined in the protest. I called Representative Michael John Gray on Saturday afternoon, who was still in his capacity at the time as the minority leader, and told him that I was getting phone calls about it and that we were going to look into it, that we were going to be deliberate about it. We weren't going to rush into things. And I think, as I pointed out before, you know me, and you know I don't go into those kind of things and rushing. So it wasn't done the same day. And I'm not trying to say that we're not having this conversation because of the actions of Judge Griffin. What I'm trying to say is this needs to be done irregardless of anybody else's actions. And that, yes, there are members who have talked about impeaching him. I'm not trying to say that that has not come up. What I'm trying to say is that we need to deal with this and get this handled. I think some of the comments that were made about doing this so it's not in all of the process of everything else. And so, and I've said before at the beginning of this, I take ownership for not completing the process before, as in reference with the lieutenant governor and the treasurer. And so, you know, I should have gone ahead and pushed to carry that out. But once the resignations took place, the immediate situation had resolved itself, and therefore, you know, at that time it just kind of died down and it just didn't pick back up. And I could have pressed. I didn't do it, and I take ownership of that. But I feel like that now because of some of the conversations that have taken place that if this is imminent and it might happen, we'd be prudent to get something into place. And that's why I bring this before you now. I want to point out something else I didn't bring up all ago that I think ought to underscore something here, okay? In the situation that occurred with Alabama, okay, and their governor, now he did resign, so they didn't go all the way through the process, but they'd spent a few hundred thousand dollars on the process by the time they got to the resignation, okay? I felt like that we probably didn't need to be spending a few hundred thousand dollars because one person stood up and made a motion to take us down that road. And so that's another part of the reason that I bring it before you now to be dealt with. I can't do anything about the optics or who writes a letter or a media availability. You know, and I'm probably not going to be, if you are convinced that I am doing this for nefarious purposes, I'm probably not going to be able to convince you about that. You probably predetermined that, and there's probably nothing I can do about that. I just ask that you look at what's actually in front of you and decide whether or not you think it's prudent for us to have these things in place or if you want to leave it like it is to where one person could stand up and make the motion and then I as the speaker would have to then determine whether or not we proceeded with that. I'm personally much more comfortable if at least a third of the body had to sign on and decide they wanted to move forward than I would be just me and one other person, as Representative Dotson pointed out earlier making that call. And so, and as some of you pointed out, you know, in your lack of faith in some of these processes and stuff, I would assume that that would probably be a good thing for you too under most circumstances. But if an impeachment is imminent, it will happen under this system that we've got now. or it would happen with this. That's why I'm saying just look at what's in front of you, decide whether or not these are the processes that you feel should be in place, and then vote yes. If you think that you're better off with the one person being able to make a motion and then go down the road that would exist now with ambiguity and potential chaos, vote no. To me, it's a simple choice. But I'm asking you to join with me, vote yes, let's put these things in place, and then if something comes down the road, six weeks, six months, six years, we've at least done our job and we've got something in place and we'll know how the process will go forward.
▶ Play
So, thank you very much. The question before the House is passage of House Resolution 1001. We have a pair on the desk. Representative Lanny Fite votes yes. Rep. Warwick Sabin votes no. Witnessed by Rep. Deanne Vaught. Rep. Sabin is the present member. Are there any procedural objections to this pair? Please do not vote either of these two voting machines. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. has everyone voted cast out the ballot mr. clerk with 73 days 13 days and one present the resolution is passed
▶ Play
Okay, members, as we had, I had hoped to have had you out of here a long time before now, but there are a couple of points of personal privilege that have been asked to be dealt with before we leave, and then I'll handle one little organizational item here before we leave as well. So I believe Representative Kavanaugh has asked for a point of personal privilege here. Members, I will say this while she's coming to the well here. We deal with some things from time to time that are tough subjects, but as I've commented numerous times, how important it is that we deal with it in a professional manner, but also one in which our affection for each other, our respect for each other carries through. And so as we leave here, I'd like for us to remember that we like each other, that it's a privilege to serve in this chamber, that it is a privilege to serve with each other. And as I stated yesterday, I am very, very honored to be serving with you down here in the House of Representatives. Representative
▶ Play
Kavanaugh. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Can I ask Representative Botts, Representative Sturge, and Representative Gray to come down? We've asked for this point of personal privilege because we were at an event about a month ago in Sharp County, and we were just talking and, you know, how things happen in events and certain things come up that you can buy, and this beautiful little tractor came up. and the first thing I thought of is we need to give this as a going away present so they can ride it home after their first session for the youngest member of the house well
▶ Play
Speaker 218 2:45:33
we know that is Representative McCollum but his legs are too big to ride this so we got this for Pilking Representative Pilking so that he can ride it home on his way home today maybe if he's got any water and help him get through the flood water So there you go. Congratulations.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 2:46:19
Thank you.
▶ Play
Mr. Speaker, you're recognized. All right. I would ask my fellow assistant pro-tems, I know we represent a fight still in the hospital, but I'm going to ask if Representatives Bragg, McGill, and Gray would come down here for a second with me and join me at the well. Members, I have, as you know, kind of done a few little things different this go-around, and one of the things I was extremely grateful for was the four assistant pro tems and their friendship and their leadership in this chamber as we, and they helped me throughout the session, took a lot of things off of my shoulders, and also Representative Eubanks, who I've had the great fortune to have as my pro-tem now for two sessions and two general sessions. He's my friend, and so I wanted to do something special for him, And we had talked a few different times along the way just about what a great job he was doing in his session. And so we've got something we want to present to you today. If you would come make your way down here. We felt that it encapsulated the experience that it is to serve with Representative Eubanks. And it's a gift for him to have on his wall. But we have here a picture. and it's going to be tough to see but this picture here we've got what we hope are the best possible stares that he's given at people during this session and then we even caught that rare and elusive smile in one picture as well and so we want to present this to you as a token of our affection and appreciation for a job well done so thank you He had noted that the Secretary of State's office had done a collage like that similar that they had down in the basement during the session, and he had noted that he wasn't in any of those pictures at all, and we found out it was because I couldn't find one of him smiling, and that was kind of their threshold there. So we went about doing one for ourselves. And so the members, as we kind of close out our official functions for this week, I do want to thank you again for your support. I want to thank you also for your generosity at the end of the session for the gift to me and my family. I just very much appreciate it, and again, it has been an honor to serve with you for the first of the special sessions that we might have throughout the next year and a half or so. So at this time, I'm going to come back to my chair. Thank you. Okay, just kind of as an organizational note so everybody can know how this is all going to go out. Because of the AHIM bill that was passed and its necessity to create a subcommittee of legislative council, we're going to have to populate that committee. And so hopefully by maybe the end of the day or at some point here tomorrow or so, So we're going to get all the council assignments public, but we need to address that one, and I want to get that done before we send the rest of all the council assignments out. But we are going to be doing that very, very quickly because we do have council meetings beginning here in just a couple of weeks, and so we're going to have to move very quickly. That's why that's not being done today. And then we'll also be making the Tax Reform Task Force appointments known. I'm going to hold off on that right now, and we'll be making all that very public here, hopefully by the end of the day or tomorrow as well. And we'll for sure get it done by then this week, and then proceed with a few other appointments to the Economic Tax Policy Committee and a couple other things that we've got to handle as well. But due to the lateness and the hour and everything, I know everybody's ready to get out of here. So at that time, I'm going to adjourn us out of this caucus, seeing no other business to be done. Thank you, members. Representative Branscombe has an announcement as soon as I adjourn us from the caucus. So, members, thank you again.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:52:14
Caucus is adjourned. Representative Branscombe, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. ALC Executive Committee will meet in 10 minutes at 12 o'clock concerning rules on marijuana. And
▶ Play
Big Mac B. All right. Everybody have a safe afternoon. Thank you.
▶ Play

Agenda

Wednesday, May 3, 2017 9:00 AM

7:58 - 8:06 2 segments 2 speakers

House is Called to Order

8:06 - 8:44 1 segment 1 speaker

Prayer and Pledge

8:44 - 9:35 2 segments 2 speakers

Attendance

9:35 - 11:55 5 segments 2 speakers

End of Morning Hour

11:55 - 12:04 1 segment 1 speaker

REGULAR SENATE BILLS

12:04 - 12:07

SB3 J. Dismang (Gillam) TO AMEND ARKANSAS WORKS TO REDUCE INCOME ELIGIBILITY LIMITS AND IMPOSE WORK REQUIREMENTS; TO ALLOW THE FLEXIBILITY TO SELECT WHETHER TO BECOME AN "ASSESSMENT STATE" OR A "DETERMINATION STATE"; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

12:07 - 13:52 7 segments 3 speakers

Representative Jeremy Gillam called Rep. Ballinger to present Senate Bill 3, which would amend Arkansas works to reduce income-eligibility limits, impose work requirements, allow the state to choose between “assessment” or “determination” status, and declare an emergency. [12:25] [12:33] [12:45]

After the presentation, Gillam asked whether any member wished to speak for or against the bill, receiving no response before closing debate. [12:57]

The House then voted on the bill and its emergency clause, recording 69 yeas, 21 nays and two members present, and the measure passed. [13:04]

SB1 J. Dismang (Gillam) TO INTEGRATE AND INCORPORATE THE PROVISIONS OF ACTS 2017, NOS. 207, 312, AND 1108 INTO ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION, ARTICLE 19, § 30; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

13:52 - 14:59 6 segments 3 speakers

19, §30) and declare an emergency, was presented by Rep. John Maddox, who noted it was the same bill voted on the previous day. [13:58] [14:02]

Rep. Gillam asked if anyone wished to speak against the bill; no member objected and the debate was closed. [14:10] [14:12]

The House approved the bill and its emergency clause with 87 yeas, 1 nay and 3 present, resulting in passage. [14:42]

SB2 J. Dismang (Gillam) TO INTEGRATE AND INCORPORATE THE PROVISIONS OF ACTS OF 2017 INTO ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION, AMENDMENT 98, ALSO KNOWN AS THE "ARKANSAS MEDICAL MARIJUANA AMENDMENT OF 2016"; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

14:59 - 16:06 6 segments 3 speakers

Senate Bill 2, also sponsored by Rep. Gillam, would incorporate the 2017 Acts into the Arkansas Constitution as Amendment 98 (the Medical Marijuana Amendment) and declare an emergency; Rep. Carol Dalby introduced the measure, noting it mirrored a bill passed the day before. [15:07] [15:11] [15:14]

Following the presentation, Gillam again solicited comments for or against the bill, received none, and moved to a vote. [15:18]

The measure and its emergency clause were adopted by a vote of 89 yeas, 1 nay and no members present, passing the legislation. [15:48]

SB4 J. Dismang (Gillam) CONCERNING THE ARKANSAS HEALTH INSURANCE MARKETPLACE; TO STUDY THE FUTURE DIRECTION OF THE ARKANSAS HEALTH INSURANCE MARKETPLACE; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

16:06 - 19:50 15 segments 7 speakers

The House considered Senate Bill 4, a study of the Arkansas Health Insurance Marketplace with an emergency declaration, presented by Speaker Pitt; after a brief explanation, Rep. Gillam opened the floor for remarks, but the discussion quickly shifted to procedural questions about the Speaker’s authority to convene a caucus. [16:14] [16:19] [16:25]

Representatives Walker, Hendren, and Ballinger questioned Gillam’s implied authority and the need for prior notice, with Gillam asserting his power under House rules but acknowledging no specific citation, while Ballinger raised a point of order that the debate was off-topic. [16:38] [16:49] [17:21] [17:51] [18:17] [18:24] [18:57] [19:12] [19:31] [19:42] [19:50]

Budget Calendar of the Arkansas House of Representatives 91st General Assembly First Extraordinary Session

19:50 - 20:00

Bills to be considered which have been introduced by Joint Budget Committee

20:00 - 21:29 6 segments 3 speakers

After addressing earlier procedural concerns, the House proceeded to vote on Senate Bill 4; the bill and its emergency clause passed with 84 yeas, 3 nays and 6 present. [20:01] [20:31] [20:48] [20:56]

The session then moved to the yellow budget calendar, and the clerk was instructed to read Senate Bill 5, which would amend Act 1 of 2000 to permit transfers from the Arkansas Healthy Century Trust Fund to long-term reserve funds. [21:10] [21:23]

SB5 TO AMEND INITIATED ACT 1 OF 2000; TO AUTHORIZE THE TRANSFER OF FUNDS FROM THE ARKANSAS HEALTHY CENTURY TRUST FUND TO THE LONG TERM RESERVE FUND; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

21:29 - 1:29:43 164 segments 15 speakers

Rep. Joe Jett introduced SB 5, declared an emergency, and explained that the bill would move the one-time $105 million tobacco-settlement from the Arkansas Healthy Century Trust Fund into the Long-Term Reserve Fund, a step he said could improve the state’s credit rating and save $1.5-$1.8 million in annual interest. [21:35] [21:43] [22:13] [22:48] [23:22] [23:56]

Opposition was voiced by Rep. Kim Hendren, who warned that the transfer would place control in a small council and could be used for non-health purposes, and by Rep. Michelle Gray and Rep. Nelda Speaks, who argued the trust’s health-care restrictions should not be overridden, while supporters such as Rep. Charlie Collins and Rep. Bob Ballinger contended that the reserve would boost bond ratings, provide a safety net for economic downturns, and that additional safeguards could be added later. [24:08] [24:24] [24:27] [25:00] [25:31] [26:03] [26:35] [27:06] [27:37] [28:07] [28:39] [29:12] [29:43] [30:44] [30:51] [31:25] [32:22] [32:56] [33:28] [33:59] [34:30] [35:05] [35:38] [36:08] [36:42] [37:18] [38:08] [38:23] [38:58] [39:31] [40:02] [40:33] [41:04] [41:43] [42:17] [42:56] [43:32] [44:21] [44:34] [45:07] [45:38] [46:09] [46:42] [47:13] [47:19] [47:38] [47:41] [1:01:37] [1:01:53] [1:02:03]

After extensive questioning, the House voted 70 yeas, 24 nays and 4 present, adopting the bill-including its emergency clause. [1:07:45] [1:08:21]

Rep. Jeremy Gillam asserted that, based on Article 5, §12 of the Arkansas Constitution, House Rule 11 and Mason’s Manual, he had the authority to call a caucus meeting on an administrative rule issue and reminded members that any appeal could be made to the full House. [1:09:54] [1:10:26] [1:10:59]

Rep. John W. Walker disputed Gillam’s notice, arguing that formal notice is required for all members, that Rule 11 does not empower the speaker to convene a special session, and that bypassing the governor’s notice violates constitutional and procedural norms. [1:11:30] [1:12:02] [1:12:36] [1:13:06] [1:13:10] [1:13:45] [1:14:22] [1:14:40] [1:14:57]

Rep. Kim Hendren then asked whether the resolution under consideration was intended to impeach Judge Wendell Griffin, prompting Gillam to promise a full explanation when he presented the resolution, after which Gillam recessed the House for ten minutes to investigate parallel proceedings in another building before resuming business and making routine announcements about legislative support staff and upcoming Girls/Boys State events. [1:16:03] [1:16:16] [1:16:35] [1:17:10] [1:17:21] [1:17:44] [1:29:19] [1:29:43]

Call Back to Order

1:29:43 - 1:29:49

Announcements

1:29:49 - 1:31:31 4 segments 2 speakers

Arkansas House of Representatives 91st General Assembly Caucus of the House

1:31:31 - 1:31:48

Roll Call

1:31:48 - 1:33:07 3 segments 2 speakers

Representative Jeremy Gillam reported that 94 members were present, establishing a quorum, and announced that the caucus would consider House Resolution 1001, a rule-amending measure previously referred to the Rules Committee. [1:32:18]

He then asked the clerk to read the text of HR 1001, and the chair subsequently read the resolution’s title, introducing the amendment for further consideration. [1:32:51] [1:33:05]

RESOLUTIONS

1:33:07 - 1:33:10

HR1001 Gillam TO AMEND THE RULES OF THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES OF THE NINETY-FIRST GENERAL ASSEMBLY.

1:33:10 - 2:43:50 177 segments 17 speakers

Jeremy Gillam introduced HR 1001, a resolution to amend the House Rules by creating a formal impeachment process that requires articles to be filed as a co-sponsored resolution by at least 34 members, assigns investigative responsibility to a committee (which may be an existing or ad-hoc panel), mandates that the committee submit a report-including any minority opinion-and imposes a three-business-day waiting period before the full House may act. [1:33:22] [1:33:58] [1:34:32] [1:35:07] [1:35:39] [1:36:13] [1:36:46] [1:37:20] [1:37:52] [1:38:28] [1:39:00] [1:39:34] [1:40:04] [1:40:38] [1:41:13] [1:41:45] [1:42:17] [1:42:51] [1:43:22] [1:43:59] [1:44:32] [1:45:05] [1:45:37]

Members sought clarification on procedural details: Rep. Meeks confirmed that the full House would retain the final vote even if a committee recommended against impeachment; Rep. Hammer asked how committee members might be disqualified for bias, and Rep. Gillam explained that removal mechanisms are not yet defined and that committee composition would generally follow existing structures unless an extraordinary situation warranted an ad-hoc panel. [1:47:32] [1:47:34] [1:47:46] [1:48:05] [1:48:21] [1:48:55] [1:49:00] [1:49:26] [1:49:53] [1:50:16] [1:50:30] [1:50:46] [1:50:51] [1:50:58] [1:51:08] [1:51:12] [1:51:21] [1:51:41] [1:51:52] [1:52:48] [1:52:53] [1:52:57] [1:53:09] [1:53:28] [1:53:35] [1:53:40] [1:54:02] [1:54:34] [1:54:57] [1:56:17] [1:56:21] [1:56:51] [1:57:32] [1:57:59] [1:58:07] [1:58:40]

Opposition was voiced by Rep. Hendren and Rep. Flowers, who argued the amendment was a reaction to the Judge Griffin case, that existing judicial disciplinary bodies already address such matters, and that it could concentrate excessive power in the speaker’s hands, while supporters such as Rep. Lundstrum, Rep. Dotson, Rep. Brown, and Rep. Gates contended that the current procedure allows a single member to trigger impeachment, creating chaos, and that the resolution would provide necessary ethical standards, a higher-threshold safeguard, and orderly self-policing for the House. [2:08:48] [2:09:22] [2:09:53] [2:10:24] [2:10:54] [2:11:26] [2:11:57] [2:12:27] [2:18:41] [2:18:52] [2:19:23] [2:19:49] [2:20:12] [2:20:26] [2:21:09] [2:21:41] [2:22:11] [2:22:27] [2:22:33] [2:22:54] [2:23:25] [2:24:01] [2:24:36] [2:24:59] [2:25:04] [2:25:06] [2:25:40] [2:26:25] [2:26:46] [2:27:17] [2:27:47] [2:28:19] [2:28:51] [2:33:09] [2:33:43] [2:34:13] [2:34:45] [2:35:16] [2:35:49] [2:36:22] [2:36:53]

The House then voted on the resolution, with Rep. Lanny Fite voting yes, Rep. Warwick Sabin voting no, Rep. Deanne Vaught present, yielding 73 yes, 13 no, and 1 present, and HR 1001 was adopted. [2:42:26] [2:42:57]

Points of Personal Privilege

2:43:50 - 2:52:35 18 segments 4 speakers

Representative Jeremy Gillam opened the point of personal privilege by urging members to conduct themselves professionally and with mutual respect, noting how honored he feels to serve alongside his colleagues. [2:44:04] [2:44:37] [2:44:56]

Representative Frances Cavenaugh then requested a point of personal privilege to present a small tractor as a farewell gift for the youngest member, initially mentioning Representative McCollum and then naming Representative Pilking as the intended recipient. [2:45:11] [2:45:33] [2:45:43]

Speaker 218 acknowledged the gesture, congratulated the recipient, and noted the tractor could help navigate flood-water conditions. [2:45:43] [2:46:19]

Later, Gillam presented a collage portrait as a token of appreciation to Representative Eubanks, explained its background, and announced upcoming appointments to the AHIM subcommittee, the Tax Reform Task Force, and the Economic Tax Policy Committee before adjourning the caucus. [2:48:10] [2:48:41] [2:49:31] [2:50:02] [2:50:34] [2:51:09] [2:51:42]

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Jeremy Gillam Unverified
144 segments
Representative George B. McGill Unverified
3 segments
Representative John W. Walker Unverified
12 segments
Chair Unverified
7 segments
Speaker 30
1 segment
Representative John Maddox Unverified
1 segment
Representative Carol Dalby Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 42
2 segments
Speaker 52
1 segment
Representative Kim Hendren Unverified
46 segments
Speaker 9
1 segment
Representative Bob Ballinger Unverified
27 segments
Speaker 64
1 segment
Representative Joe Jett Unverified
14 segments
Representative Charlie Collins Unverified
13 segments
Representative Michelle Gray Unverified
13 segments
Speaker 31
1 segment
Representative Kim Hammer Unverified
11 segments
Representative Vivian Flowers Unverified
18 segments
Speaker 90
1 segment
Representative Nelda Speaks Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 8
1 segment
Speaker 138
1 segment
Representative DeAnn Vaught Unverified
2 segments
Representative Jon S. Eubanks Unverified
23 segments
Representative Stephen Meeks Unverified
6 segments
Representative Fred Allen Unverified
5 segments
Representative Mickey Gates Unverified
7 segments
Speaker 171
2 segments
Representative Jim Dotson Unverified
14 segments
Representative Johnny Rye Unverified
1 segment
Representative Robin Lundstrum Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 202
1 segment
Speaker 203
1 segment
Speaker 205
1 segment
Representative Steve Hollowell Unverified
1 segment
Representative Karilyn Brown Unverified
3 segments
Representative Frances Cavenaugh Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 218
2 segments