A retirement citation was presented for Richard Wilson, Assistant Director of the Bureau of Legislative Research, recognizing his 37-year career, and members expressed personal gratitude for his service.
[16:03][16:35][17:06][17:36][18:14][18:45][18:51][19:32]
Senator Joyce Elliott asked for an update on potential vaping-tax revenues for the next meeting, and Representative Jim Dotson sought a detailed breakdown of the state sales-tax “one-penny” revenue, receiving clarification of its distribution among general revenue, highways, property-tax relief, adequacy, and conservation.
[26:55][27:12][27:44][27:50][27:53][27:59][28:03][28:22][28:50][28:58][29:21]
Senator Linda Chesterfield requested an explanation of “uncollected checks,” which were defined as bank-returned deposits such as closed-account or insufficient-fund items.
[29:33][29:46][29:53][30:03][30:12]
Mr. Wilson also reported a modest decline in July FY 20 collections, confirming the forecast’s accuracy and noting a 1.4 % negative growth rate.
[32:00][32:03][32:06][32:43][32:56]
The committee then adopted the Administrative Rules Subcommittee report, approving all listed emergency and regular rules.
[1:03:43][1:03:49][1:03:53][1:03:58]
Senator Stubblefield inquired about the cost of implementing work-requirements in the Arkansas Works program; officials estimated a one-time $3 million expense that is currently paused and not ongoing.
[1:12:09][1:12:16][1:12:21][1:12:24][1:12:48][1:12:54][1:13:02]
The Review Subcommittee discussed the DHS Optum contract, directing DHS to provide monthly performance reports and to consider a new RFP by October if the contract proves unsatisfactory, a motion that was adopted.
[1:14:55][1:15:00][1:15:36]
Representative Crawford suggested using second- and third-place bidders to expedite procurement; staff noted that special procurement is possible under unique circumstances but would still require proper review.
[1:43:40][1:43:54][1:44:15][1:44:20][1:44:30][1:44:58]
Senator Hendren clarified that the motion seeks detailed assessment data to determine whether to continue with Optum or initiate a new procurement, emphasizing the need to avoid hasty emergency contracts.
[1:53:52][1:53:58][1:54:02][1:54:36][1:55:08]
Senator Jim Hendren warned that if the system is not functional by October, the committee must consider alternative actions, emphasizing the need for proof of performance in the coming months.
[1:55:40]
Representative Mark Lowery raised procedural concerns about whether the Review Subcommittee can order corrective actions for DHS issues, citing egregious incidents such as youth being zip-tied and educators dismissed, and requested a re-evaluation of emergency procurement for juvenile facilities.
[1:56:10][1:56:17][1:56:41][1:57:20]
A corrective-action plan was reportedly issued immediately and the responsible company has responded, prompting Lowery to seek a detailed report on remediation efforts.
[1:57:54][1:58:13]
Representative Jim Wooten reported that the Personnel Subcommittee identified excessive parole officer caseloads and introduced a new Equal Employment Opportunity report template to improve agency compliance; the subcommittee’s report was seconded and adopted unanimously.
[1:59:17][1:59:36][2:00:08][2:00:40][2:00:57][2:01:03]
Senator Joyce Elliott presented the Lottery Oversight Subcommittee’s findings on lottery operations and the Academic Challenge Scholarship Program, moved for adoption of its report, and the report was approved without debate.
[2:01:13][2:01:20][2:01:45][2:02:17][2:02:24][2:02:29]
Senator Jonathan Dismang detailed the Highway Commission Review Subcommittee’s authorization of a consulting contract with Guidehouse under Act 298 of 2019, and the report was similarly adopted.
[2:02:37][2:02:47][2:03:11][2:03:19]
Senator Kim Hammer summarized the Arkansas Health Insurance Marketplace Oversight Subcommittee’s testimony on enrollment numbers, financial status, Medicaid provider reviews, trauma-system improvements, and related programs, and successfully moved to adopt its report.
[2:03:31][2:03:42][2:03:51][2:04:25][2:04:57][2:05:29]
A motion concerning the Department of Parks and Heritage (H-9B) presented by Senator Hester was seconded and adopted, after which the committee adjourned.
[2:06:03][2:06:10]
Members, we'll go ahead and get started with the agenda. Do I hear a motion to approve the last meeting's minutes? Got a motion? Need a second? Got a second. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? The ayes have it. The minutes passed. Representative Sullivan. Yes, Mr. Would I may have a moment of personal privilege, please? Yes, sir. You're going to go down to the table, right? Thank
you, Mr. Chairman. Members, you have before you an interim resolution requesting that the Arkansas Legislative Council remember Wendy Leanne Anderson and her contributions to her local community and the state of Arkansas. It says, whereas Wendy Leanne Anderson, beloved wife, mother, and friend, and member of the Arkansas State University family and Jonesboro community lost her courageous and valiant battle against cancer on Monday, August 19, 2019, in Jonesboro, Arkansas at the age of 49. Of course, she was the wife of
I think you had a couple of comments. Yes. Thank you, Representative Sullivan. And thank you to all of you, especially our Jonesboro delegation, Representative Sullivan, Smith, Ladyman, Tosh, Senator Cooper. Senator Cooper is attending the funeral this morning and could not be here. But thank you, Representative Sullivan, for joining me down here. And on behalf of Coach Anderson and his entire family. Let me say how much he was touched yesterday. Dr. Welch, Brad Phelps, our chief counsel, and I spent the afternoon with Coach and his family, and I shared with him that all 135 members of the General Assembly had signed on to this resolution to honor Wendy, and needless to say, his heart was touched. And he asked that I convey to you how much he appreciates all of your kind words, your thoughts and prayers and phone calls. While we were talking, Senator Cotton called. I delivered a handwritten note from Governor Hutchison, and there have been so many who have reached out to Coach and his family during this very difficult time. And our university is a family, a very close family, and so this has affected us all. And just a quick note about who Coach and Wendy Anderson are. All of you know that my wife Debbie has battled MS for 30 years. And even in the midst of their very valiant struggle, I'm sitting at my desk a couple of weeks ago and I receive a call from Coach. He said, hey, Wendy and I were just talking about you and Debbie and I just wanted to call and tell you we said a prayer for her and we were just thinking about you. My first thought was, you've got a lot more on your plate than to be worried about me and my family. But that tells you a lot about who Blake Anderson is and who his wife Wendy was. And they're both very special to not only our university community, but the Jonesboro community and as evidence this week to the entire state of Arkansas. So thank you all very, very much. Continue to remember Cobra's family in the coming days. Mr.
Thank you all. I'm going to need a motion to adopt the resolution. I have a motion for Senator Hester, a second from Representative Lowry. All those in favor of the resolution say aye. Aye. All those opposed, let the record show unanimously accepted. Committee, if you would stand in a moment of silence for the coach and his wife. Thank you, thank you, thank you. So committee now we have some other important business not on the agenda. We have the retirement of Mr. Richard Wilson, and guys, this is going to hit us hard, and I'm going to recognize Senator Bledsoe for a presentation.
come up here, please. We have a Senate citation for one of our very most favorite people, and it says, Whereas Mr. Richard Wilson, Assistant Director of the Research Division of the Bureau of Legislative Research, is retiring on August the 30th, 2019, after dedicating 37 years to state government. And whereas Richard joined the Bureau in 1997 as an economic forecaster after serving in Governor Tucker's administration and working for Attorney General Steve Clark, he quickly advanced to running the Economic and Tax Policy Office and then was promoted in 2005 to assistant director and whereas he was a catalyst for the creation of the research and policy analysis section prepared numerous physical impact statements for legislation coordinated the redistricting effort for the General Assembly and performed invaluable work on education adequacy and whereas his knowledge of the state's economy and ability to present detailed information in a useful fashion where all could digest and understand it has been a tremendous asset to the Bureau and the state of Arkansas and whereas the members of the Arkansas Senate wish to join Senator Cecile Bledsoe in commending Mr. Richard Wilson for his exemplary leadership and dedicated service and in wishing him well in the years ahead. Now therefore, pursuant to the motion of Senator Cecile Bledsoe, the Arkansas Senate directs this citation to be presented on this 23rd day of August 2019, signed Senator Jim Hendren, President Pro Tem of the Senate, Anne Cornwell, Secretary of the Senate, and Cecile Bledsoe, Senator. Ladies and gentlemen.
As much as we would love to hear exactly all that all over again about our beloved Richard Wilson, I'm going to yield to that. But I will tell you, Richard is going to be a position that's very difficult to fill. He has done an awesome job. in the nine years I've been here you can go to his office and ask him any question and he will answer it exactly the way you ask it. But Richard is awesome and he will be dearly, dearly missed. So Richard with this thank you. Thank you. And with that, we'll recognize Mr. Wilson for the revenue report.
It will. There's plenty of time left. We've got until next Friday. Okay, members. We have three reports today. We'll take them chronologically by production date. The first is June of FY19, the 12th month. of the fiscal year and after 12 months gross collections were 500 million dollars ahead of the year 18. the growth rate there is 7.4 and on a net basis 426.5 million dollars on net available growth rate there is 7.8 percent turning to the graph you can see an explosion in the last few months. This is in addition to, you may recall, the official forecast. The official forecast actually had a surplus already included, and that number was $64.2 million. So finishing with this 231 above forecast plus what was already in the forecast, The final number is $295.4 million. Included in that, there was a restricted reserve that earmarked some of that money. So $47.9 million of that is subject to previous earmarking. And, of course, 25% of that goes to the highway fund. Highways received $73.9 million of that money. so the rest the remainder goes to allotment reserve that amount is 173.6 million dollars turning to the first page of the spreadsheet we finished the year gross receipts growth is two percent and the weighted average income tax is ten point eight percent you can see for the twelve months the two corporate income tax entries. Total $570 million for the year. Last year, $407 million. The three remaining are individual income taxes. This year, $3.6 billion. Last year, $3.36. So quite a bit of growth in the income taxes. I don't know if the Department of Revenue has determined exactly what's going on in my discussion with other states in both of those accounts we're looking at what should be considered one-time money in basically defined as capital gains I should stop there Mr. Chairman and see if we have any questions on that specific report any questions from the committee seeing
thank you the next one is fiscal year 19 annual report we only look at this one every 12 months so i'll i'll go through it and just tell you what's in it top of the page has comparison to gross general revenue collections for the last 10 years shows the increase both in dollars and in percentages 2019 as you can see was the first year to top seven billion dollars the growth rate 7.42% looking at the bottom half of the page we have the gross income tax collections including both individual and corporate combined and the gross sales and use general revenue collections for about 30 years you can see at the bottom of the page again for the first time the income tax collections in excess of four billion dollars growth rate ten point eight percent general revenue sales and use was two point five billion and we break it down by the penny you can see that one penny is worth five hundred and fifty seven million dollars the growth rate there 2%. Turning to pages 2, 3, and 4, all this is line item gross collections for all general revenue and all special revenue inputs. At the bottom of the page 4, 7.2 billion on the general and 2.3 billion on the special. Turning to page 5, it reflects the gross general revenue, special revenue, all the deductions and the net available. This is similar to our monthly front page. Pages 6, 7, and 8 reflect the distributions of those same dollars, all general revenue dollars, all special revenue dollars. You can see the bottom line on page 8 matches those on page 5. Page 9 compares the fiscal year 19 gross deducts and net with fiscal year 18 so you can see where the money was changed. The biggest change is fiscal year 19 the first year without desegregation settlement money. Pages 10 and 11 reflect general revenue distributions comparing FY19 to the previous year. The far right-hand column shows you growth rates and therefore winners and losers for FY19. And finally, Mr. Chairman, page 12 reflects FY19 educational excellence trust fund distribution with the previous year, all growth rates there evenly at 3.4%. With that, I'll be glad to
for the first question. Actually, Mr. Chair, my question is prompted by D1, the revenue from tobacco and whatnot. And I'm going to go through Mr. Wilson to ask this question because I know you've got to go with D&A. During this session, we were looking at a tax on vaping, and we got an estimate, and I would like to have an update, and I know this and D.F.A. can hear this as well, whoever does it, if we were making this report today, an update on what would we be collecting if we were taxing vaping at the same rate that we were taxing cigarettes. and that's just some before you're out of here next Friday you and DFNA if I could have that information that would be great I want to be sure you are
to next month's meeting um actually you know if as soon as they get it if they would just send it out that will be fine but yeah next month's meeting will be fine that probably easier on everybody how about let's do that
you're recognized for a question thank Mr. Chair Richard the on d2 here the sales and use tax collection of you said what the one penny would be I think brings in five point or five hundred fifty seven million percent yes do you have and I know I'm asking off the top of your head so you can get it to me afterwards if you don't know this but of the six and a half percent of state sales tax what the breakdown of where that kind of all goes i know a certain amount of it goes to highways half half a cent and so on but what's the breakdown
on the rest for okay that's not difficult the the 557 million per penny uh you can see in the column just left of that 2.5 billion that's four and a half cents that's the general revenue portion and the other two cents is a half a cent highways half a cent property tax relief, seven-eighths of a cent adequacy, and one-eighth of a cent
question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I guess it's the first time I've noticed in running through this. Could you explain the uncollected checks? Is this something that people don't collect that's due them, or how is that done on page one
on page one of the June you can see we top seven billion dollars but there was about a hundred million dollars worth of mistakes those three lines right under the seven billion gross that ninety two point six million dollars is electronic fund reversal right right above that it says uncollected checks one million nine
was sitting up here looking at the difference in the gaming revenue on the first report. Can you, is that reflective or will be reflective in a year of the $35 million we were told that will be short in the gaming tax due to the amendment that was
accurate. Well, it's going to show up whether it's accurate or not, but $35 million if it's accurate. You can see at the top of page two of the monthly, under racing taxes, we've got the two new accounts reflected. uh so far the coding is not showing those as casinos uh as much as electronic games so that that shift is is in effect but when you look at these numbers it looks like it's
down about 18 million when you look at the june 19 and june 18 numbers you got 82 million to 64 on the dog racing and then you look at the horse racing numbers when you add all that difference up it's roughly that's top of my head rough but well you've
got you've got dog and horse racing uh negative growth for sure you've got a little bit on the electronic games license fees because there there wouldn't be any reason to do that anymore and then the um the privilege fee is is definitely still there at seven percent so uh but that's
the report. Okay, finally, real quickly, July 2019. This is the first month of FY20. In one month, the gross collections are lower by $10 million than the previous July, and on the net, $6.5 million lower than the previous July. negative 1.4 percent is the growth rate. You turn into the graph you can see that the official forecast you can see John Shilna was spot-on for the month and finally turning to the spreadsheet the gross receipts declined growth negative 1.5 the income tax is negative at 3.5 be glad to take questions any questions from the committee seeing
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Going back to July the 18th, 2019, we met, the Executive Subcommittee met and reviewed and approved two emergency rules for the Department of Education, both of which were reported to members of the Legislative Council in accordance with ALC rules. Then yesterday, August the 22nd, 2019, the Executive Subcommittee met and reviewed and approved an emergency rule for the Department of Education concerning educator licensure. The review and approval of that emergency rule will be effective upon adjournment of today's ALC meeting. Then the subcommittee also approved a request from Senator Greg Letting requesting a change to the General Assembly website that would allow a member of the public to generate an email to all members of a legislative committee at once. The subcommittee stated that the capability for the new communication must be in the same format as that used in South Carolina, and that the Bureau IT staff must be able to limit its use by automated emailers. Finally, the subcommittee heard from Director Marty Garrity with a director's report. The report included a request to engage the services of the Mitchell-Williams law firm to provide legal services to the Bureau. The subcommittee voted to approve the request. I move adoption of this report.
a question or discussion. Just a quick discussion concerning the request for website communications, just for the committee to be aware of my concerns as I try to be as open with everything as I can. I feel like this has the potential of being detrimental to the legislature, to committees, not the fact that it's open. We know now that there's at least 135 web contacts. I have two, personal and state, that can be contacted. My cell phone's been public since 2008. Anybody interested can get a hold of a legislator. They can form their own group and their emails. I feel like in the climate that we live in right now, we're opening ourselves up to activists from either side. And I think we are going to desensitize ourselves to paying attention to our emails and probably move backwards while this is intended to do good. The list that we had of all the southern states, South Carolina was the only one that adopted this. So while it sounds good, I would just ask the committee to look at this and see if this is what you really want to do. I would add that I believe I'm correct, and I stated this in committee, that we already have a legislator that's been sued or threatened to be sued for blocking communications. We have federal officials, I've been told, that are sued for blocking communications. So if you simply say, I'm just going to block my committee contacts, you might want to think about that again. That's my statement. Thank
motion. Can I hear a second? I got a second. All those in favor of pulling the button out for separate votes, say aye. Aye. All opposed? Ayes have it. Representative Love, I'm going to recognize you for our question since we took that motion.
well if you want to take up the motion that's fine I can hold my question you can go ahead I have a couple number one just in the process of the the educator licensure I guess I'm kind of concerned in regards to why was this an emergency rule when we know that I think we're gonna be looking at these things all the time and so that's that's
Education and I asked this message under the pretense that you know usually when when the executive committee takes up something and it's really, you know, a time-sensitive issue. And so I'm trying to figure out why is it that ADE didn't have this to us in the proper time to go through the
you're recognized to answer his question. Thank you, Courtney Solis Ford, Deputy General Counsel for the department. Representative Love, to answer your question, we were in the process and have been in the process of revising these rules since the act was passed back in May. It was brought to our attention that there were several educators who were eager to look at this process for reinstatement. And at the urging of the sponsoring legislators, we asked that just this particular section be put through the emergency process because the full promulgation process can be quite lengthy. representative loves that you have follow-up
i just think that we need to i'm i'm having that's just something that's going to be stuck in my crowd because i think we need to take this to the full promulgation process instead of trying to fast track
it that's that's what i'm gonna have to sign yeah and if it helps any i I mean, these are in the entire educator licensure rules are currently going through the full promulgation process. Again, just at the request of legislators having just this particular section go ahead and be effective now because there is no process set forth in law, but it will go through the
full promulgation process. Okay, thank you. Mr. Chair, I've got another question now. Yes, sir. It's going to be in regards to something that the legislative or Director Garrity. This Mitchell-Williams contract, can you give me some background on that? Why we needed Mitchell-Williams and different things like that? Because I have some questions in regards to some of the things that Mitchell-Williams does on the lobbying side and then them being able to actually give you all their advice on this side. So can you speak to me on kind of why
are we needing this contract and what's going on here? We've received requests for information which we deem to consider confidential, and they are assisting us in responding to those requests for information.
Shepard, you're recognized for discussion. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I guess in part to respond to Representative Love, I don't know that I can respond directly to your specific question, but related to that, with regard to the retention of Mitchell Williams, to give some background, Mitchell Williams provided legal counsel to BLR for some time, even prior to me becoming speaker. They were retained some time ago, Director Garrity probably could tell us, it's probably been a number of years, to advise BLR in responding to requests that may be made from law enforcement agencies and how to properly respond and advising BLR with regard to that. At some point within maybe the last year, a conflict developed whereby they had individuals that they represented who might be in conflict or have been in positions that conflicted with our position as the legislature and Mitchell Williams. actually they may have asked for a I can't remember if they asked for a waiver or not but we parted ways at that point because of the conflict there have been BLR has had ongoing requests and items that BLR responds to Mitchell Williams no longer has that conflict, Director Garrity mentioned this to me and I suggested that we go ahead and retain Mitchell Williams again because they have familiarity. They had done work for BLR for, I guess, a number of years. And given that there's no conflict at this point, it seemed wise for us to retain them so that they would not take on representation that would conflict with us into the future. Now, as to, so that's, with regard to why they were picked, it was because they had previously advised the legislature and instead of hiring a law firm that we would have to pay money to get up to speed on they already had that familiarity with you know what I I can't answer would be your specific question about with regard to their lobbying efforts or their role as as as lobbyists how does that play into their advice they give BLR I would I don't want to necessarily speculate but I would imagine that they would that they would keep those functions separate which is not necessarily uncommon in a large law firm but I couldn't speak to the specifics of that but just to give some background for your benefit and and the rest of ALC as to why the retention it's it's not necessarily that there's any increase in work to be done it's just simply they no longer had a conflict, and it seems that it's for BLR and everybody else's benefit to have good legal counsel on board.
to the the emergency rules that are part of this and I was going to ask the question of ADE but I might be able to just have a discussion on the motion here for a second with regards to emergency rules versus regular promulgation process. Emergency rules are temporary. They have a defined period of time but the regular APA process administrative procedures act process is quite lengthy and it does take multiple steps in particular for an agency like ADE and these types of rules once we get out of session they have multiple steps that they have to go through before they can get to even the public comment period because there's a state board involved because they've got to get sign off from the governor's office and various things like that you don't just snap their fingers and and have a rule ready for us to approve so in in particular situations like this when they're trying to get something done following a session laws going into effect for the next school year which is upon us sometimes emergency rules can can be a good stopgap for while they're going through the regular process in a permanent rule i hope that clarifies everything for for everybody thank
you i will add to that that yesterday in executive committee i voiced the same concerns the representative love voiced this morning i do believe that the emergency process should be used for an emergency basis we have had this problem all summer and it needs to be reined in to where things are absolutely used for an emergency and so I totally agree with Representative Love's statement and I do agree that school year starts this month they need that rule out for that reason but if they would have started on that rulemaking process when that law was passed we could have almost been there so they it I totally agree Senator Chesterfield thank you mr.
you an answer. Senator Chesterfield, when we initially entered into an engagement contract with Mitchell Williams, we looked at various law firms and settled on Mitchell Williams. We didn't put it out for bid, but we did look
thank you mr. chair regarding the contract with the legal firm have we utilized anybody's services since they excused their self or recuse their self for conflict of interest up till now we have not so there's no one currently providing those services as of to date that's Jill and myself is there anything that's motivating us to do it now that we need to seek
their legal services now I think as we move forward there are times when law enforcement officials have asked that neither Jill nor I be in meetings or in discussions so this just provides as just additional protection for our staff for members to ensure that there is someone at the table representing the interest of the legislature in the Bureau okay and then on
the other on the other issue to the issue that representative love brought up and and whether you need to get the department back up here mr. chair to answer this and I guess I'm failing to see the urgency of why we have to do this if we have the process in place to do it otherwise and whether that can be part of the discussion to the motion or however the chair wants to handle it I guess I need clarity what what's the sense of urgency I don't understand it thank you
we can get miss Courtney back but what what it sounded like yesterday senator and executive committee was is that school year starts in August and in order to ensure that these folks could regain license in this school year we had to go through emergency rule they are pursuing a final rule through the normal rulemaking process I'm sorry mr. chair
I have a point I want to make, Mr. Chairman, regarding the emergency action. We're running into the same thing in the Personnel Compensation Committee, constant requests from the agencies to suspend the rules. And, you know, I think it's the principle of the thing. Why have rules if you're going to be, every meeting, we're being asked to suspend the rules? I wish we could ask the secretaries to instruct their agencies to make every effort not to have to come in and ask for a suspension of a rule or an emergency situation. You know, we've known since last year that school was going to start on August 13th or whenever it started. And then we come in and y'all are faced with an emergency rule of request. I just think if we're going to have rules, we need to pursue them, we need to follow them. Thank you. Thank
you, Representative. I think that message has been sent loud and clear this morning, which I hoped would happen. So, members, we'll take a vote on the original motion on the whole report except the email button. I have a motion and a second. All those in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed? Ayes have it. I will open the floor for discussion on the email button at this point. Senator Irvin,
I'll recognize you first. Thank you, Representative Wardlaw. So I have a question, I suppose, for IT maybe or the Bureau on this issue. And my main question, and I've had this conversation several times with the Bureau, is how are these going to be designated when they come to our inbox? And the reason I'm asking is I have a very difficult time finding emails from my constituents that I serve in my district. and I cannot find their emails. It is a problem that I know I have. I think others probably have this too. But these are constituents that email us, and they are trying to ask for our help to navigate through their issue or with their problem that they're having with state government. And these emails from our constituents are getting lost. And so I want to be able to concentrate on where I'm elected and try to serve those constituents, and it's very difficult to know where people are coming from when they email us. You know, many times I've had people email me, but they're in Senator Pitch's district or they're in Senator Bond's district, and so I try to navigate them to their senator so their senator can help them. So, you know, how is this going to work with all of that? And I would be fine with supporting this, but we're not really addressing a major problem with our emails and our ability to do our work on behalf of our constituents. And until that problem's addressed, I'm not willing to go any further. So if there's somebody from the Bureau or IT that can answer this question, it's got to be solved, in my opinion.
Mr. Tim Carlock, if you would, I'm going to let you address the Senator's question. If you would like, we can have her repeat it after you introduce yourself for
the record. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Timothy Carlock, Assistant Director for Information Technology Bureau of Legislative Research. I guess readdress the question just so I'm more clear. So my question is, how is
I mean, are these going to come to us individually and is there any way to designate where these people are from, what district they live in, or how can we separate one of these generated emails from this versus a constituent that has a problem? Is there any way for the Bureau to be able to designate those two so that we can figure out or filter emails that are just coming as a cut and paste message versus a constituent that's actually taking the time to email us and trying to find our
problem so there so the short answer is right now there isn't a clear way to designate that in this particular request there is actually going to be a form that they submit to the committee with basically it's all of those email addresses and on that form there are some there will be required fields and I believe district as one of those required fields um the only other thing i would add to that is generally uh constituency services normally routes that information to directly to the membership is my understanding no i mean constituency services we route
the emails to them okay so it's not the other way around we have we do not have staff that's going through our emails for us I mean, we have, you know, like Senator Rice said, I mean, I have two other, I have a personal email and I have my Senate email. But, so a lot of times I have to use a personal email just so I can find a constituent's email to get to them. So we don't have staff that's going through our emails designating one that's just a message on this versus, I mean, we have to do that all ourselves. Senator? Yes.
that point. Okay. I've been instructed by staff that we could add that to this form with the motion this morning if need be or if the committee would see fit to do that. We could add a blank for them to put in their
district number. Okay. I guess that's part of my concern that could be answered by that, but it doesn't address the other concern of trying to be able to find a constituent e-mail versus all the other e-mails that we receive. Do we know of other states that have separate public e-mails, one for just?
Not to my knowledge. Which, again, I'm only, just to be clear, I'm only talking about the emails that I have access to that's publicly available. So we're only talking about those emails. I don't know about personal accounts. Okay. Do you
know if we, I mean, so is there any, I mean, we get a lot of emails that, listen to me in the last question. We get a lot of emails that come from, that are generated, and we're able to unsubscribe from them. but is that legal for us to do or is that in a lawsuit or i mean there's been times where we have gotten harassment and we try to block these people and we have you
assist us with those things absolutely um when we when we think we're being targeted by just direct spamming we shut all of those ports down um it's very it's pretty common in all sectors um and in fact again just approximately we we deny 65 000 65 000 we deny 65 000 unauthenticated emails on a daily 24 hour per basis and we deal with about 4 000 authenticated emails on a on a daily basis so 65 000 a day yes oh my gosh okay and that's not uncommon across the entire nation that's just how email right we have firewalls security we were constantly monitoring that daily but with a lot of adware you run into those types of scenarios where people are trying to punch a bunch of information to a large mass of people right and so once that's triggered we have our our appliances that protect our network immediately reroute all that traffic gotcha okay thank
I'll withdraw my other motion and let me make a motion to move this to House and Senate management for discussion on because there is a lot of discussion on the emailing and the contacting of committees and members and let them do some more work on this before we move it forward that would
be my motion. So Senator just so that everybody's clear on what would happen with this So we would let the House and Senate Management Committees determine whether the prospective chambers would proceed with this motion. So everyone's clear on that. Got a second? All those in favor, say aye. Aye. All opposed? Ayes have it. We'll move on to the Rules Committee Report. Yes, ma'am.
Senator Elliott? Well, I'm good with the motion and everything that happened, but was Senator Rice next in the queue, or did you just go to him for his motion? He was still lit up in the queue. Was he next in the
queue, was my question. Senator, I had three lights on at the time. I couldn't tell you who was next. There were people discussing back and forth, so I can't.
Well, the only reason I'm asking is not a matter of contention or anything like that, but I just wanna be sure, as much as I like that motion, that we follow the cue. When I've been chair and I could actually see who was up next in the cue, that's why I figured we would know. And I just don't wanna establish that precedent, that's all, Mr. Chair, to not follow that cue. although I want to get out of here too, just like
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Administrative Rules Committee, Subcommittee met on July 19. The Subcommittee adopted a report of the Executive Subcommittee concerning its approval of an emergency rule. Senator, can you hold
Let me clarify that it is Senate's Efficiency Committee, not a Senate Rules Committee is my understanding of where this goes to. And I'll be happy to back anything up if I need to if my colleague would like to discuss any more, Mr. Chair.
Thank you, Senator. Senator Eaves, you are now recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. the subcommittee adopted a report of the executive subcommittee concerning its approval of an emergency rule deferred the department of health's rule pertaining to food service establishments to the august meeting referred the facilities rule concerning specifications governing school bus design to the transportation committees and all of the rules were reviewed and approved at that meeting such action being final by the subcommittee pursuant to the motion passed by legislative Council at its June meeting. The Administrative Rules Subcommittee met again on August 21st. The Subcommittee adopted a report of the Executive Subcommittee concerning its approval of emergency rules. The Subcommittee reviewed and filed the quarterly reports that were submitted by the Department of Community Correction, Department of Correction, and Arkansas Parole Board in accordance with Act 1258 of 2015. The Bank Department's rule will be rescheduled to the next month due to the absence of agency personnel at the meeting. Department of Education's rule regarding special education catastrophic Recurrence Fund was referred to the Education Committees. All other rules were reviewed and approved, and I move adoption of
this report. That's a proper motion, do I hear a second? Second. Got a second, any discussion on the motion? Seeing none, all those in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed? Ayes have it, the rules report is adopted. We'll move on to the hospital and Medicaid report, Representative Love. And we'll come back to, is Senator Cheatham at his seat? We'll come back to that report. We'll go to Representative Vaught for Peer.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. The Peer Subcommittee met on Tuesday, August the 20th. The subcommittee approved five items, rainy day transfer to three agencies, the Department of Finance, Administration, Dispersing Officer, Department of Human Services, Division of Children, Child Care, and Early Childhood Education, a restricted reserve transfer to the Arkansas Economic Development Commission, which requires a higher vote threshold than other items that were approved, and a fund transfer for the Arkansas Department of Transportation. The subcommittee reviewed several other items, including cash fund appropriation increase request, budget classification transfer request, miscellaneous federal grant appropriation request, various reports assigned to the subcommittee, including a full accounting of the DF&A on the rainy day fund transfer for a conservation easement in the Buffalo watershed, an emergency rule request including a pay plan request for appropriation that was approved on july 29th for the division of youth services mr. chair representatives from the division are here to answer any questions regarding their emergency request and with that i move for an adoption of the report it's proper motion do i hear a second second
CFO of DYS. So in the peer meeting I asked you numerous times what the amount was that is now projected and what the amount is that was actually spent. When I arrived this morning this paper was on the desk that shows that total projected today is only $25,289.94. Can you tell us why you insisted that $66,000 was the amount that you needed and $100,000 was the initial amount you asked for?
Yes, I'll do my best. The $66,000 was an adjustment on the calculations we had. It's not just the $25,000. We ended up needing an additional $16,000 to pay out those extra for the leave time for the employees who were no longer ours that were transitioning over to a vendor and had some annual leave left over that we need to pay out. Then the extra $25,000 is for some extra help positions that we still have. So, total, that would be $41,000, I believe, roughly $41,000, including some other payroll. This is our basic calculations today. We expect to have to use all but about $21,000 of the $66,000. Okay. Any further questions
hospital Subcommittee representative love you're recognized to give that report. Thank you. Mr. Chair apologize I just had to step out and take a phone call the ALC Hospital and Medicaid subcommittee met Thursday July the 18th 2019 in committee room B Of the multi agencies complex the subcommittee heard the following testimony regarding rural hospitals Kim Patterson, Chancellor for UAMS, discussed the UAMS mission of addressing critical health care needs of the state and improving health care outcomes statewide. He stated that there are 105 critical access hospitals, 39 counties with only one hospital and 28 counties with no hospital. He reminded the members of the recent closure of the Dequeen Hospital, which was the first hospital closure in Arkansas since Arkansas's version of Medicaid expansion through the Affordable Care Act was enacted. He did note that Navigant Healthcare had identified 17 other rural hospitals in Arkansas currently at a high level of financial risk. He mentioned that the rural populations have high numbers of elderly, obesity, tobacco users and people with chronic disease. Dr. Patterson also mentioned that two-thirds of the land mass in Arkansas is depopulating and moving to urban areas. He stressed the need for more health care professionals of all types in the state. Dr. Patterson stated the struggle of rural hospitals is impacted greatly by the payer environment of various forms of reimbursement, such as private insurance, Medicare, and Medicaid. Philip Gilmore, Ph.D., president of the Arkansas Rural Health Partnership and CEO of the Ashley County Medical Center in CrossFit, Arkansas, spoke about the importance of a hospital to a rural community. He stated that rural communities need hospitals for economic growth and that the health status of the community declines when there isn't a hospital. He studied that his hospital has shown a profit in the last 9 of 10 years, and that the hospital receives a quarter of a cent sales tax from the county to buy equipment and maintain its buildings. Bo Ryle, President and CEO of Arkansas Hospital Association, emphasized the economic impact of hospitals on communities, and that 22 hospitals are among the top three employers in their counties. He said hospitals are extremely grateful for the Medicaid expansion because it had reduced the uninsured rate and the uncompensated care for hospitals. He noted that some of the financial challenges of hospitals is their reliance on public payers such as Medicaid Medicare Medicaid which only reimburse approximately 78% of the cost of care compared to commercial insurance and self-pay which reimburse the full cost of care mr. Rao noted that many rural hospitals rely mostly on Medicare Medicaid for reimbursement as a result they are hit hardest financially this is our report mr. chair and I move for adoption there's a proper motion I hear
DHS in general? The Medicaid Arkansas Works Division. I see Mr. Link coming forward. If you would introduce yourself for the committee, and you're recognized
far as implementing? Implementing those work requirements. We did not, I don't believe we associated any cost implementing the work requirements. There was some, and I'm speaking a little bit out of my turn here, Senator Stubblefield. No one from actually Medicaid or our finances here. We did credit some of our programming expenses to it. I want to say about $3 million would be the total cost of implementing the work
costs still being? Everything is on pause. There was no ongoing cost. That approximate $3 million, and I'm somewhere fairly close on that number, so media please don't quote me on that, but I'm somewhere close on that number. I'm flying with my pants here, Senator Stubblefield, but everything was put on pause. Those costs are not ongoing. That was a setup cost to get it started, but there's not an ongoing cost for the implementation. Okay.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Yes, sir. Thank you, Senator. Seeing no further questions. All those in favor of the report, say aye. Aye. All opposed. Ayes have it. Report's adopted. We'll move on to the policymaking report. Senator Chesterfield, you're recognized
to give that report. Thank you, Mr. Chair. The policymaking subcommittee met on Wednesday, August 21st, and heard from Senator Dishmang concerning a consultant services contract with Guidehouse LLP for use by the Highway Commission Review and Advisory Committee. Senator Dishmang provided information concerning updates to Guidehouse's proposal in compliance with the request of the Highway Subcommittee, and representatives of Guidehouse were present at the meeting. A copy of the contract is attached to this report. The contract maximum cost is $722,463.19. The policymaking subcommittee recommends approval of the contract. I move for the adoption of the report.
being here thank you Mr. Chair thank you all those in favor say aye all opposed ayes have it we'll move on to the review subcommittee representative Davis thank
you Mr. Chairman members committee met in July and all those actions were considered final August meeting was held earlier this week. Review subcommittee reviewed a Office of State Procurement Administrative Rule, methods of finance, grants, and contracts. No items were held. After discussion on the DHS contract with Optum, a motion was made to review the contract now and for DHS to provide a monthly report to the review subcommittee on the status of the contract and ongoing assessments. That report shall include real data in order for the subcommittee to make a determination by October whether the contract should continue or if DHS should initiate a new RFP and procurement for independent assessments. That motion was made by Senator Hendren and it was adopted. Mr. Chairman, I move adoption of this report. All right,
to mental affairs at DHS Thank you madam chair is Is October soon enough for an RFP in the events what's reported in September and October doesn't show that the problems dealing with the Optum contract are
correcting themselves? Senator Hammer, it takes a minimum of eight months to get an RFP off the ground. That's kind of what we talked about in the review committee is a minimum that we could do this to get to write an RFP, get it out there, receive the bids and go through the process of selecting a vendor would be
eight months. All right, and then I'd like to ask you a question on the Milligan contract. It's item number six that was sent out of the committee. Can you answer a question about the Milligan contract? Let's see what it is now. All right. In the contract with the Milligan report, does the agency look at litigation that's ongoing with Milligan or that has recently either ongoing or that was recently concluded as part of the terms whether to continue the contract with them because they have some hefty litigation that's going on in the past and do you does that factor into whether their contract should be continued I don't know we do
have somebody from procurement here Mary Catherine might I don't know if she'll know off the just on the fly but she might have an idea on that I don't know
the day I'd like you to I'd like you to get me the information that shows that if they have ongoing litigation in other states or they have been found to be in default because of the litigation going on is that a disqualifier for a contract here in the state of Arkansas as we've seen it be the case with other contractors that they've been disqualified from being awarded contracts because of issues in other states I'd like to have that please.
recognize for a question. Yeah. Kelly, several months ago, you and I met with representatives from Optum, and they had said during that meeting that they underbid the contract do you remember those comments well I do remember talking with him yes sir okay so they they said we underbid and we had numerous deliverables that they admitted in that conversation that they had not only underbid but didn't have the ability to deliver what they had promised and in that conversation we said that there would be some penalties our discussion of penalties for that under bid and the failure to do that have we followed through and have we recouped any of the the money that we spent when they admitted they overbid and they admitted they didn't deliver
plan and the letters? Yes, sir. We do have a corrective action plan with Optum on their timeliness. We have specific penalties for underperformance on that, on the timeliness of assessments, because we do consider that to be a critical performance standard. There is also, in the contract itself, several penalties, including caps, the corrective action plan, terminations, performance reports and monetary penalties. I would be happy to send you the list of all of the criteria that we have and all of the matching damages where you can see.
May I have a follow-up? I have all of that. That's why I'm asking the question to get it on the record. What I'm asking though, have we actually recouped any of the money? The penalties are listed and they're pretty clear and they admitted they defaulted. Have Have we actually recouped any money? Not that I'm
for a question. Madam Chairman, I've got a question that's really not germane, but I think it's a timely topic if I would be permitted to ask the DHS about this. All right. I'd like to know one from your department. First, let me ask a question. Do you all have authority over the Louisville Youth Retention Center? It was in the headlines Sunday. Obviously,
Department of Human Services does, Representative Wooten. Neither one of us work in that division, but we can maybe try to help you or get you an answer.
I just find it that no one has mentioned that contract with that contractor. I mean, is that not an important issue when there's an accusation made relative to the treatment of youth in a center
That's fine, Madam Chairman. I just think that's an area that we need to address, particularly since it's a new contractor and they've already had a problem down there. Thank you, Madam
question. Thank you, Madam Chair. I think on the opt-in contract, I think one of the things that concerns me and everybody with the RFP process, the procurement process, is for vendors to kind of game the system and low bid in order to win the contract and then to come back and need more money or we put forth more money on that. I'm worried about that happening. I'm worried about it setting a precedent for the procurement process for vendors because if they can game our system by winning that contract by being a low bid and then underperforming and we have a corrective action plan in place but yet we're going to be giving them $16 million more. Can you alleviate my concern in any form or fashion and that that's not happening? Because it seems very clearly to me that that will set a precedence. Yes, ma'am. We
can talk about this. We talked about this in the review committee, Senator Irvin, and what the additional $16 million added onto this contract, there's two things going on with this review. There's $16 million added to the contract, and there's also some performance indicators being added. That money is not a request, if you will, from Optum. It's not an increase of their rates. In reality, it was an underestimate on DHS's side of how many assessments would be performed. A couple reasons for that. There's a lot more people, as you know, qualifying and and for the past and being assessed for the past and what we anticipated we thought there'd be about 35,000 going in closer to 45,000 we also assessed a great number of people for behavioral health to get them qualified or not qualified whether it's tier 0 tier 1 or whatever just because you're assessed obviously doesn't mean you qualify but had a number of people early on in but you know being assessed for behavioral health well so if you remember for the aging group um a judge held up the assessments that we were doing for aging and if you remember that whole deal that was about a year ago and that pushed 2,000 people into the optimum assessments instead of the assessments that we were doing before that and then as we have gone through the aging we have changed our tool and we changed the assessments trying to be more accurate you know because we've heard all the stories and we we want the people need care to get care so it's now a longer process than it was and so we've added money to that because the assessments take a significantly longer than what our RFP said they would so this is not often coming back and saying we're increasing our price after we bid X amount this is us making adjustments where in our RFP we underestimated the number and how long
it would take okay and final follow-up question would be on who is sending them for assessment is that that we how did we underestimate that from 35,000 to now what 45,000 how does that so so in most cases providers you know are
seeing a client and they'll say we believe this person would be tier two we think it's very possibly be tier two and belong in a pass and they're the ones that recommend in the course that it does go through and to at least some degree and of course Paula Stone's here can hopefully run up here and correct me when I'm wrong but not if but when but there's also a prior authorization process that some go through to see if they need an assessment or not so it's not just an open gate there is there is a gate to that process
well I hope so because when we had these discussions about the past it It was very clear that not everybody needed to be in it. Amen. Yes, ma'am. All right.
Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you, ma'am. There it is. Thank you, Madam Chair. I think I pretty much made it clear in committee how disappointed I truly am in this whole optimum debacle that we've got going on. and that I don't like these doomsday scenarios coming to us saying that if we start an RFP over, the sky is going to fall. But I do believe that we, as representatives, have a job to make sure that our constituents are protected and that we are taking the RFPs from not necessarily the lowest bid but the ones that can truly do the job. And this time, I think we failed our constituents by having somebody come in who did not have the tools needed to perform the services in which they were bidding for. With that said, though, I wanted to go on record thanking Senator Hendren for making a motion in which for the next couple months we will get hard evidence from y'all saying what the numbers truly are. And if you don't perform, if they are not performing, then we can start a new RFP if we need to. But I think they've got a job to do, and if they can't do it, I don't think we can keep them here. And that's what I
a question. Thank you, Madam Chair. And Representative Vaught said some of what I had wanted to say. I find it frustrating that often we come to review and we are told we're over a barrel, we have to renew this contract, we have no choice because it's going to be eight months until we can get someone else. Can we not have some kind of a backup plan for when we start seeing problems like we did back in June with this contract, hey, we may need to make a change here. Can we not start looking and get the B team ready to go, except in this case I would not call them the B team. I would call someone else an A team, ready to go because this looks like it's not going to work out and not have to come in here every time and be told we're over-barreled. We have no choice. We have
to renew this contract. Ma'am, the RFP process is long and it is complicated. And I understand that that's frustrating. It is hard to set up a B team in that regard because it takes a lot of people, a lot of approvals, a lot of back-and-forth and evaluations, demonstrations of products. It's a very time-intensive process. On this particular Optum contract, we're still within what the total projected cost is for all of this. I went back and looked at the original contract with the total projected cost at 86 957 548 578 54 and we're still at that total projected cost my concern was not the
and i i do believe that um paul stone and others at the departments are working very hard to get that fixed i appreciate the ability to come in here once a month as you've requested to give the evidence and to hold us accountable. I think that is an excellent idea. Have you
recognized for a question. Thank you. As much as you, when you describe the process and we're asking you how can we, when we find problems such as these, make this a lot shorter process so we could pivot to something better for our constituents and for the state taxpayers, then you say that this process is so arguous and you've went through such a process to select these people. What it does in fairness is it shines a light on you and DHS in general and your ability to evaluate properly over this long process that you described and then submit to us someone that's not capable of doing the job. We expect you to be able to give us guidance and directorship as when we have bad players, people that are not performing to this level. It's been so long, and this optimum, as Representative Vaughn called it, debacle, has been such a debacle. And I don't know how long we have to sit here and just rub your back and be nice and say, okay, we're going to wait, we're going to wait, we're going to wait. We have to, I mean, we're demanding that something happens with this. Our citizens, our constituents are suffering so much. Our providers are suffering. Everybody is suffering from this. And Representative Sullivan had a meeting he just put on record where they admitted. Now, how many of us can be in a contract and we admit we didn't do this and we're not performing? and you still say to me that you can't tell this body where you've taken the money back. Where does that happen? Can you please provide or have someone provide for us a detailed accounting of what is going to happen based on their performance that has already occurred? Can you please give us an accounting for that? They noted that it happened, they admitted it happened, but to your knowledge, nothing has been removed, no money has been taken back from them. I can tell you that I
was not privy to that conversation, I was not at that meeting, so I apologize, I'm not able to give you any information on that. We do have the cap and I can, do you have the information on the specific performance syndicators and all the damages that are available under that? I've seen all of that information.
Okay. So you're asking for the specifics of... I'm talking... The side of it whereby we have acted as an agency with someone that we have under contract that is woefully underperforming, and we have measures in the contract for this, from timeliness to performance, et cetera, and we have measures. What have we done? We have
started that process, Senator Murdoch. We have sent a corrective action plan. We have sent, I don't know if it's these or fines, and then letters come back. So it is a negotiation process, so I'm telling you, we've not
received a check. But this has happened for so many months, my friend. This didn't just start. This has been going on. You have heard testimony after testimony. And then, according to Representative Sullivan, an acknowledgement. So what letter are they sending? They've acknowledged. We underbid it. We're not performing. You were in that meeting, according to what's on record now. Thank you,
Chair. All right. Thank you. Ladies and gentlemen, we had several still on the queue. Just if you would keep your remarks succinct, and if it's already been said, you might want to not say it again. All right. Senator Hammer. You're recognized. Thank you, Madam
Chair. So what y'all testified today is we're about $10,000 over the lifetime of the contract as you make improvements to the processes and corrective actions are followed and implemented. Could we see that those numbers might actually go the other direction so that we would stay within the money that was originally allotted in the contract in the first place?
Well, yes, we would expect, of course, there'll be reassessments, and that's the process we're into now. Everyone has to be assessed yearly, so we're into reassessments, and we're still seeing a number, a higher number than we probably anticipated of applicants to the past, I guess you could say, new people to the past being assessed. With the aging, that should slow down, because we'll have gone through the original process and then the reassessments, and we don't see as high of a number coming in
as new. Okay, and last question is, is there a clause in the contract that if they failed to meet critical deliverables, the contract would be terminated? And are they at that point now, and if they are, did you have an exit strategy in the event that this happened prior to the contract being completed
for the original time allotted? Every contract can be ended with 30 days, or for cause, and Mary Catherine can get into all the complications of that. So I think what kind of you're asking, the same thing Representative Fite was asking, is there a plan A or C, or a plan B, or whatever, and that's not something that's not really doable, if you will, in this process, in the procurement process we use. May we take that up
I sat here and listened to this information and felt very frustrated not knowing the best thing to say and the best thing to ask on behalf of my constituents. And I don't want to repeat what has already been said. I'd like to preface my question by saying that a lot of the concerns and a lot of the things that we're hearing, I remember expressing and hearing when this contract was approved and a lot of complaints about the assessments and the rate at which we were doing this in terms of time and money and who was actually doing the assessments. So I'm super frustrated. And I'm also hearing about the complexity and the time frame with regard to the procurement process, which was mentioned even when there was at the front of this process, that we've already gone through this, we have this sort of in front of us to do and move forward. So my question is this, understanding all that and understanding that there are processes in place for there to be corrective action. At what point would we say, like where do we draw the line? And when I say we, I mean as legislators but also you as being in the executive role of this. And I think that they should know this too because I know that whether you're a child or a caregiver or administrator or whatever, if there are supposed to be consequences and there are supposed to be repercussions to a bad act or non-performance or whatever, you know, if my parents said, I'm going to whoop your butt if you do this again, if my butt didn't get whooped, I learned I could do it again and nothing's going to happen. Now, that's not what happened with my parents. They were serious. So my question is, at what point, where is our line where we say, forget corrective action, we've given you a chance, we've imposed these fines or these penalties, but for the sake of our people, we're not moving forward and we're going to start this over and we're going to find someone to do the work in the meantime. What does that look like?
so there is such thing and mary catherine can obviously go into this much deeper than that there is such thing as emergency procurement there and that's where we end up sometimes in a sole source or whatever that may be there is that process we've used that process in less in the last year on a major contract when when transportation was got so not going so well we came in and changed our transportation vendor with this situation and again we not that you don't deserve the conversation you totally do this whole committee does we talked a lot about this in the review committee itself a number of a number part of this was trying to get a whole new operation off the ground you have to be given good direction along with performing well And as I said then, some of our direction, we may not have anticipated some of the issues and numbers that came up. We may not have had our tool in the right place, especially when we get to the aging population. Perhaps our tool wasn't written right. When it is solely the vendor that is failing, then we're at that point, and that's the point that we're at now. That's why we've written a corrective action plan. That's why we're levying these and using the performance indicators is because we feel that DHS has got ourselves in that position where the decisions have been made and things are more fine-tuned to where we can start holding the vendor themselves more accountable.
Very quick follow-up, Madam Chair. Are you saying that now that we're at a place where everybody's clear about the tools, the job to be done, the numbers, and more importantly this is the corrective action plan are you saying that if this vendor does not perform on any level that they continue to fail on any level of that plan that we will be prepared to cut this contract and move toward finding a new contractor and entering into that phase where we use
emergency services and and that's pretty well what Senator Hendren's motion during the review committee was about is we will be monitoring this contract as we have been but perhaps even more so reporting to the to the review committee I guess to this committee or both and and making you know holding I won't say more accountable because we have been holding accountable but that's that's what this is all about is reviewing and reviewing to you and and getting to that point by I think the end of October I think is what
the motion was well I heard that I just want to be real clear so I know what the process is yes ma'am we're we're very clear so if because I'm really concerned about what your recommendation would be since you're sort of the oversight before it gets to us you're working with them the contract is with you so there's this plan everything is in place we're doing what we're supposed to do in terms of determining where that line is drawn but for DHS is it such that if they don't perform at this point at any juncture with regard to the corrective action plan DHS will be prepared to cut the court and say to the legislature we've done all we can and we're prepared to write
a new contract I mean that's kind of yes or no. As DHS, I mean, we care very much as you do. I mean, we're all kind of here in this about taking care of the folks in the state of Arkansas that need taking care of. The entire point of this contract is to determine who needs what services. If this contractor is not able to determine the need of our beneficiaries in the state of Arkansas as to what services they need, then yes, we need to find someone else. But we've got to get them to that point. And I believe when this all comes together, we're going to be okay. If we're not, if it's all on the contractor, we'll find another contractor. We're not
you. Representative Richie, you're recognized for a question. Hi, Madam Chair. Cindy Crawford. I'm in Representative Ritchie's place. I just have a question. When vendors fill out the RFP, you have more than one and they're scored. so my question is instead of redoing the whole rfp process can you go back to those who didn't score as high maybe the second and third and then it would be quicker to get a
new vendor as far as competitive procurement goes with the rfp you would be starting over there is A POSSIBILITY WHERE YOU COULD GO INTO A SPECIAL PROCUREMENT IF THERE WERE UNIQUE CIRCUMSTANCES TO THE STATE, WHICH I BELIEVE EVERYONE HAS SPOKEN ABOUT, UNIQUE CIRCUMSTANCES. WE CAN TAKE A LOOK AT THOSE SECOND AND THIRD SCORERS AT THAT POINT, BUT THAT WOULD BE THE question of moving to the new contract is is how we determine who would be the best to come in on short
question thank you madam chair mr. link does it make sense at this point to just go ahead with an emergency procurement and move on no ma'am it doesn't okay so what's what is it that white white why doesn't it is optimum is optimum going to be able to do this in the end is that what you're saying we believe so yes ma'am and you believe that because they're going to hire
some more people or something a lot well again we've so each each part of this if you will this bucket there's really four different buckets of people that's being assessed and we started off with behavioral health, and this started off very rocky. We're getting a lot of emails, a lot of concerns there. There's a number of issues that we overcame, and as often as our partner, we overcame those, and it became more smooth. I said the other day it's going well, and a number of emails came in explaining I wouldn't say it's going well. Okay. So I'm not saying it's going well, but it's going so much better. And we still have a few points to work out, but it's not to the point that it was. it's not where oh my gosh this is this is horrible dd was a little smoother kicking off we still had some issues to overcome there then personal care and now we're at the aging and and with aging just as i do i mean we we want to help every type of beneficiary out there that has trouble we wanted properly determine their care but when we mess up or when when we are concerned that the elderly are not getting the care that they need and we're concerned that a company is badly determined that we get very upset as we should and that's where we're at now we're getting over the bumps in the in the aging population the elderly population i i feel that optum will work with us and we will overcome those bumps just like we have the other three populations it's just we feel very strongly to get over that quickly and that's why we're here because
we all care about the aging Well, I want to be sure I understand, because when I first started listening to this conversation, I was under the understanding that they had underbid, but apparently that's not the case. They didn't underbid. We just didn't assess. We didn't think the RFP was underrated. Yes, ma'am. I'm sorry. Don't mean to
interrupt. No, that's okay. Go ahead. The $16 million is not being added because they underbid or asking more money, as I explained a moment ago. That was how the RFP was written, and then the number of assessments are much higher than
we anticipated. Okay, so with all of that, and just, I think, lastly, what I'm trying to make sure I understand, is if it's going to work out, is it going to work out because, it's not because Optum does not have the capacity to do the work, but it's because of the bumps in the road is that what you're saying
to me yes ma'am there's so many factors that go into to properly putting together an assessment program and one of the first factors of that is the the tool and then the platform so the tool is how to explain it's a set of questions and the weight that each question carries to determine what type of care that an individual may need and that has to sit on an i.t platform and operate properly there then you have to get get the assessors, and in most cases nurses, trained and hired, and then in the correct places geographically in the state to be able to see people in the number of days. There's just
a lot to it. And part of that timeline that Representative Vaught referred to, the motion from Senator Hendren, I was not in that meeting, so maybe I missed this. Was there an established timeline that we will know just how things are going to work, or is that something you're working on? deciding that time. I think that, and I don't
want to speak exactly to what the motion said. I'll leave that up to your chair. But we're going to be, we'll say, enhanced monitoring, which I would say we're pretty close to that anyway, and reporting back to the committees. And I think the committee, I think the motion said the committee will determine by the end of October if there will be a motion to send us back out for RFP.
And that's paraphrasing. Okay, thank you. Thanks, Madam Chair. All right, Representative Gardner, and I do want to say this, Representative, before you start, looking at the time and everything, if you are not, if you're an alternate, you certainly get your turn. But if you're not on the committee, you're going to have to wait until everyone else has asked their question. So, all right, with that, you're recognized.
not on. Okay. There you go. Thank you. I am representing Representative Whitaker today. But my question is that we make sure or asking if we're making sure that within the corrective action, we have steps that are ensuring those who are performing the assessments are properly
trained. Well, that would be definitely part of the contract, and I don't know the language in there, the performance indicators, whatever, but having properly trained personnel on the ground is definitely part of the contract. Then that's not what we've, that's not what our, I don't believe we've assessed any damages on
We're still talking to Optum about it. All right. Have you finished, Representative Gardner? Yes. All right. Representative Murdoch, recognize. And by the way, the review meeting is not at the end of October.
want to wait and not say anything, but the more you testify to the confidence that you have in Optum, and then you just stated that the only performance or only issue you've had with them so far is timeliness. But let me explain something to you. And these members have, we've been in various meetings, public health, et cetera, where it's been more than timeliness. It is the people that they have put before the patients and the evaluations. They have come back with some results that just makes no sense. So we certainly think we have a capacity issue of, the Optum has a capacity issue in the people that they're putting in the field. and it's not just with these pastors, it's school-based community. Anywhere that Optum is working, I get complaints. Everywhere they're working, it is not just showing up, but it's who shows up, and then when they finally show up, which is an issue, the job that they do. We have heard, you have heard testimony, I know Kelly has been here, from members whereby some of the evaluations or assessments have been done are just ludicrous. It is abysmal what they're doing. So please, when you say, Kelly, that you believe that Optum is ready to do this, Senator Elliot just asked you a question. Why can't we just move forward, pivot to something better? You say, I think that they're ready to do this. Just don't put yourself in that. Trust me. We're out here in the field with them. They are not performing. and though we all want them to and I know there's a process please understand that it's more than time it is. It is capacity of optimum to perform this.
Sir, I believe, let me put it this way, I believe that we can work through these problems if we don't by middle October whenever the committee is, then we I think we're ready to pull the plug and start over. I believe that we can work through this and get it done, but but I'm not laying my word on anything other than myself. Appreciate
Chairman. This is more of an explanation because there's been several references to the motion, and since I made it, I just want to clarify that to me the real question here is when is the appropriate time to make a decision because this is a big decision affecting tens of thousands of Arkansans, and we always have to be careful that the cure is not worse than the illness, and if we make the decision at the wrong time or with the wrong information what are going to be the results of that so the after a lot of discussion the review committee said we need this is serious enough that it deserves further attention at least but are we at the point where we're prepared to throw the entire system into upheaval because we don't have a contractor at the end of august i think all of us agreed that that was probably not the best solution and the best decision point so when did it make sense if it's an eighth month procurement process and on a contract for multi-million dollars I don't think I think the way you get more problems is to do an emergency procurement process where we don't do the due diligence that's necessary to make sure that we don't have the mistakes in the RFP that we had in the last one so what did the motion do the motion said we need more data and I appreciate the amendment that representative void made to the motion to say bring us facts and figures how many assessments have we done and how many what percentage of that is an error and is that percentage going down or is it going up are we fixing the problem or not and if the answer to that question is no then we still have time to begin the process to give us an alternative at a time that doesn't though the system into upheaval. So I think that DHS and Optima's got the picture that we're not kidding around on this, that in October, if the system's not worked, that's an appropriate time to make a decision. So again, I don't think anybody here is ignoring the problems or saying that they don't exist or just taking Representative Link's word that it's gonna work out. We're saying you need to prove it to us in the next couple months, or we have to take some other steps. So that's the purpose of the motion, and
Thank you. Thank you, Madam Chairman. And I appreciate Senator Hendren's clarification of the motion. The issue that I'm going to raise is tangential, but since DHS is there, the review process is something that we take very seriously. And I'm extremely concerned on a tangential point about the issue that Representative Wooten raised about DYS and about the Louisville Center. And my question is, can the review committee, and this may be a question of process, can the committee order a corrective action, or is that completely up to the agency that oversees it? because this is something, it may not be the tens of thousands, but when we look at some of the egregious activities that have been found out by the ombudsman, it makes it really laughable that one of the other vendors was eliminated for actions in another state that pale in comparison to youth being zip-tied and educators being dismissed. So again, my question is about process, and if the review subcommittee can entertain at their next meeting a similar motion to what Senator Hendren just discussed, I would hope that they would do that in terms of re-evaluating the potential of an emergency procurement related to oversight of our juvenile facilities.
All right. Madam Chair, if I could say that, yes, a corrective action plan did go out immediately. And the company has responded. I think we've responded back. There's communication. It happened immediately. So if that helps any. Okay. Well,
I'm sure review and full ALC would like a report back of what is being done to correct those egregious actions. Yes, sir. Thank you. All right. Thank you. Thank you, Madam Chair.
All right, ladies and gentlemen. There are no other questions on the queue, and we do have a motion. We need a second. All right. And the motion is to adopt the report. All those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed. the motion passes all right representative wouldn't you are recognized to give you a report you're gonna have to press your button there you
did is it it's not it's not showing there it is came on thank you madam chairman the personnel subcommittee of legislative council met tuesday august the 20th 2019 and reviewed the items listed in the report these included communications and reports including a report of provisional position continuation and parole probation officers caseloads reports from community correction and i'd just like to make the point that a lot of the parole officers or most of the parole officers are trying to oversee better than a hundred uh cases that's that's that's too high of a number. It probably needs to be addressed. The committee also reviewed several action items, including a new Equal Employment Opportunity Report template. And here again, this is a result of, for some reason, some agencies have not been submitting the reports. and so we're going back in now that we have transformation and we have 15 basically agency secretaries and making them aware of the report to be submitted each month and hopefully there will be full compliance to that. Based on that and based on those comments, I'd be happy to answer any questions and move to adopt the report at the appropriate time. That's a proper motion.
Do I have a second? Second. Any questions or discussion from the membership? Seeing none, all those in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed? Ayes have it. Lottery oversight be Senator Elliott. You're recognized.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. The Lottery Oversight Subcommittee met Thursday, August 22, 2019, in Big Mac B. The subcommittee heard testimony regarding the following items. One, activities and operations of the Office of the Arkansas Lottery, with testimony from Mr. Bishop Woosley, Director, Department of Finance and Administration, Office of the Arkansas Lottery. and two, update on the Academic Challenge Scholarship Program with testimony from Mr. Nick Fuller from ADHE. The subcommittee reviewed the following reports as are mandated, Workforce Challenge Student Status, Academic Challenge Student Status, Arkansas Department of Higher Ed Grants Fund and Net Proceeds Trust Fund, and the Academic Challenge Scholarship Program Administration Financial Report. All of those with testimony from Mr. Nick Fuller of ADHE. That's my report, Mr. Chair. I move forward for adoption.
That's a proper motion. Do I have a second? I got a second. Any discussion or questions on the report? Seeing none, all those in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed? Ayes have it. The report adopted. senator dismayne you're recognized to do the highway commission review
thank you mr chairman the ark or the highway commission review and advisory subcommittee met on august 1st the subcommittee was presented a proposal by godhouse to study the arkansas department of transportation as required by act 298 of 2019 the subcommittee authorized blr to enter into the contract with Guidehouse for provision of consulting services. The subcommittee also authorized the chairs to approve the final form of the contract to be presented to the policymaking subcommittee which has already been approved and I move for adoption of the report. That's a proper motion. Do I have a second? I have a second. Any
questions or discussion on the report? Seeing none, all those in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed. Ayes have it. Report adopted. We'll move on to the Arkansas Health and Insurance Marketplace. Senator Hammer. Thank
you, Mr. Chair. The Arkansas Health Insurance Marketplace Oversight Subcommittee met jointly with the House and Senate Public Health Welfare and Labor Committee on Monday, August 19th, 2019. Subcommittee heard testimony regarding the following. Alan Kerr, State Insurance Commissioner, 54,963 people are covered under the health insurance plans purchased through the marketplace as of August 1st, 2019. AHIM has a balance of $4.3 million, which should pay for marketplace operations over the next seven to eight years. Proposed rules are out of public comment on multiple employer welfare benefit plans, and then they may choose from four providers. Preliminary rate changes range from 0.51 to 2.89 for the year 20. Janet Mann, Dawn Steele, Kelly Link, Department of Human Services discussed the process of enrolling Medicaid providers, systematically reviewing Medicaid provider rates and status of the Medicaid trust fund. Arthur Boyette, Director of Disability Determination for Social Security Administration, discussed the federal and safe partnership and operation of the agency. Laura Hsu, Stephanie Williams, James Bledsoe, Greg Brown, Department of Health, gave an update on the trauma system, considerable improvement in the coordination of transportation and care between hospitals, a dramatic increase in mortality rates of the patients involved. Matt Gilmore, Public Health Programs Policy Coordinator, Health Department, former director, Tobacco Settlement Commission, presented a brief review of the Tobacco Settlement Commission annual report in 2018. and Maurice Rigsby, Vice Chancellor of Institutional Relationships for UAMS, gave a brief update on the activities of the Arkansas Pan-Pandas Advisory Council Act 878 of 2019 and the study of Pan and Pandas funded through the Pace Foundation in Arizona who has been invited to Arkansas to present before the committees or who will be. And with that, Mr. Chair, I'll make a motion to approve the report.
That's a proper motion. Do I have a second? I have a second. Any questions or discussion on the report? Seeing none, all those in favor say aye. All opposed. Ayes have it. Reports adopted. Members, if you look through the rest of the agenda under H, all those items are here for your pleasure. There's only one that needs a motion on H-9B. I have a motion from Senator Hester. Do I have a second? I have a second. Any discussion on the motion? It's the Department of Parks and Heritage. Seeing no discussion, all those in favor say aye. All opposed, ayes have it. The committee will adopt a report. All other reports will be reviewed and seeing no other business on our agenda we stand adjourned.