Senator Bart Hester moved to place Senate Bill 576 on the amendment calendar so it could be engrossed and run on Monday, and the motion was carried without objection.
[26:49][26:55][27:07]
SCR5 B. Davis TO CELEBRATE AND RECOGNIZE WORLD DOWN SYNDROME DAY IN THE STATE OF ARKANSAS. 28:03
SR22 Hammer TO RECOGNIZE MR. AL HUNT FOR HIS EFFORTS IN ADVOCATING FOR RESPECTFUL LANGUAGE ON BEHALF OF HIMSELF AND OTHERS WITH INTELLECTUAL AND DEVELOPMENTAL … 38:33
Senator Kim Hammer asked to suspend the rules to present SR 22 honoring Mr. Al Hunt for advocating respectful language for people with disabilities; the suspension was approved without objection and the resolution was adopted by voice vote.
[38:46][38:51][39:19][39:52][40:26][40:57][41:08]
SB4 #1 T. Garner TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS LEGISLATIVE STUDY ON VETERANS AFFAIRS. 44:58
An amendment to Senate Bill 4 (creating the Arkansas Legislative Study on Veterans Affairs) was adopted without objection, and the underlying bill was then rolled and passed unanimously, 35-0.
[45:51][46:19][46:22][46:39][46:42][46:53]
SB250 #1 A. Clark TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING EDUCATIONAL NEGLECT; AND TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING REPORTS OF EDUCATIONAL NEGLECT MADE TO THE CHILD ABUSE HOTLI… 48:20
Senator Alan Clark’s amendment to Senate Bill 250 (amending the law on educational neglect) was adopted without objection, and the bill itself was rolled and passed unanimously, 35-0.
[48:42][49:10][49:26][49:42]
SB252 #1 K. Hammer TO MANDATE INSURANCE COVERAGE FOR TREATMENT OF PEDIATRIC AUTOIMMUNE NEUROPSYCHIATRIC DISORDERS ASSOCIATED WITH STREPTOCOCCAL INFECTION AND P… 50:30
Senator Kim Hammer presented an amendment to Senate Bill 252 requiring insurance coverage for PANS/PANDAS treatment; the amendment was adopted without objection.
[50:44][51:17][52:15][52:49][53:06][53:19]
SB318 #1 B. Davis TO PROHIBIT UNLAWFUL FEMALE GENITAL MUTILATION OF A MINOR; TO CREATE AWARENESS PROGRAMS CONCERNING AND STATISTICAL TRACKING OF UNLAWFUL FEMAL… 53:47
Senate Bill 318, introduced by Senator Breanne Davis to prohibit unlawful female genital mutilation of minors and create related programs, was rolled and passed unanimously, 35-0.
[53:50][54:21][54:59]
SB291 #1 Rapert TO ALLOW FOR AFFILIATE TRANSFER BETWEEN INSURERS. 55:18
Senator Jason Rapert’s amendment to Senate Bill 291 (allowing affiliate transfers between insurers) was adopted without objection.
[55:25][55:28][55:30]
SB457 #2 B. Ballinger TO REGULATE THE ADMINISTRATION OF REAL PROPERTY OF THE STATE AND POLITICAL SUBDIVISIONS OF THE STATE. 55:41
Senator Bill Ballinger’s amendment to Senate Bill 514 (regulating state real-property administration) was adopted without objection.
[56:00][56:09][56:30]
SB573 #1 G. Leding CONCERNING PROGRAMS AVAILABLE TO MINORS IN A STATE CORRECTIONAL FACILITY; CONCERNING PAROLE DISCHARGE FOR OFFENDERS WHO ARE MINORS; AND CONC… 56:30
Senator Greg Leding’s amendment to Senate Bill 573 (programs for minors in correctional facilities) was adopted without objection.
[56:35][56:46]
SB514 #1 J. Dismang TO REGULATE TELECOMMUNICATIONS SERVICE PROVIDERS AND THIRD-PARTY SPOOFING PROVIDERS. 56:58
Senator Jim Dismang’s amendment to Senate Bill 574 (regulating telecommunications and spoofing providers) was adopted without objection.
[57:07]
SJR15 #3 A. Clark THE ARKANSAS TERM LIMITS AMENDMENT. 57:19
Senator Alan Clark’s amendment to Senate Joint Resolution 15 (Arkansas term-limits amendment) was adopted without objection.
[57:38]
HB1564 #1 M. Gray Rapert TO ESTABLISH THE PUBLIC SAFETY ACT OF 2019; TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS PUBLIC SAFETY COMMUNICATIONS ACT OF 1985; AND TO DEVELOP A NEXT GENE… 58:37
Senator Bart Hester’s amendment to Senate Bill 576 (tax-law reform) was adopted without objection.
[58:42][58:48]
Senator Jason Rapert sought personal privilege to move HB 1564 to the end of the calendar; the amendment to the bill was adopted without objection.
[58:42][58:48][58:56][59:19]
SB2 T. Garner TO CREATE THE DOWN SYNDROME DISCRIMINATION BY ABORTION PROHIBITION ACT. 1:00:01
SB396 Rapert TO AMEND THE STATUTES CONCERNING THE BOOKS AND RECORDS REQUIREMENTS UNDER THE ARKANSAS INSURANCE CODE; AND TO MODIFY THE TRADE PRACTICES ACT UNDER… 1:13:56
Senator Jason Rapert’s SB 396, amending insurance-code record-keeping requirements, was rolled and passed unanimously, 35-0.
[1:14:09][1:14:23][1:14:46]
SB401 B. Johnson CONCERNING APPLICATIONS BY THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY TO THE UNITED STATES CONGRESS UNDER THE PROVISIONS OF UNITED STATES CONSTITUTION, ARTICLE V. 1:15:11
Senator Johnson introduced SB 401, proposing a 15-year aggregation period for Article 5 convention calls that would begin after April 1 2019 and could be revisited by future legislatures.
[1:15:19][1:15:51]
After discussion the Senate voted 24 yeas to 5 nays and the bill was reported to the House.
[1:22:13]
SB487 Elliott TO CONDUCT AN ASSESSMENT AND AUDIT OF THE CULTURE AND CLIMATE OF THE DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTION. 1:22:32
Senator Joyce Elliott presented SB 487, directing the hiring of a consultant to conduct a comprehensive assessment and audit of the Arkansas Department of Corrections to improve accountability.
[1:22:45][1:23:22][1:23:53][1:23:58][1:24:27][1:24:57]
Senator Ballinger spoke in favor, noting the bill would empower the Penal and Corrections subcommittee and could yield cost-saving recommendations.
[1:23:58][1:24:27][1:24:57]
The Senate rolled the vote and adopted the measure unanimously, 35 yeas to 0 nays.
[1:25:30][1:26:01]
SB492 T. Garner TO PROMOTE HOSPITALITY AND TOURISM; TO ESTABLISH AREAS OF A CITY OR TOWN THAT HIGHLIGHT RESTAURANT, ENTERTAINMENT, AND HOSPITALITY OPTIONS; TO … 1:26:06
Senator Trent Garner introduced SB 492, authorizing cities and towns to create temporary or permanent entertainment districts that would permit regulated alcohol sales and related activities.
[1:26:26][1:26:36][1:27:07][1:27:40][1:28:11]
Senators discussed examples such as the Murphy Art District and raised concerns about youth access, while the Chair fielded questions before moving to a roll call.
[1:28:20][1:28:43][1:28:56][1:29:13]
The roll call produced 23 yeas and 8 nays, passing the bill to the House.
[1:30:02][1:30:33]
SB524 B. Ballinger TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING ELECTRONIC VOTING EQUIPMENT; AND TO AUTHORIZE THE STATE BOARD OF ELECTION COMMISSIONERS TO PERFORM POST ELECTION… 1:30:43
Senator Blake Ballinger offered SB 524, which would permit the State Board of Election Commissioners to conduct random post-election audits of electronic voting equipment in three counties each year and to investigate any suspected violations.
[1:31:05][1:31:38][1:32:09]
The Chair explained the bill’s development with the Secretary of State’s office and County Clerk’s Association and asked for a vote.
[1:31:38][1:32:09]
The Senate approved the measure by a vote of 34 yeas to 1 nay.
[1:32:09]
SB527 Bledsoe TO REQUIRE A HEALTHCARE PAYOR TO DISCLOSE ON A MEMBER IDENTIFICATION CARD WHETHER A HEALTH BENEFIT PLAN IS INSURED OR SELF-FUNDED; AND TO DECLARE… 1:32:43
Senator Cecile Bledsoe presented SB 527, requiring health-care payors to disclose on member ID cards whether a plan is insured or self-insured so that providers and patients can determine which legal regime applies.
[1:33:12][1:33:48][1:34:20][1:34:54]
The Chair noted there was no known opposition and opened the floor for questions before moving to a roll call.
[1:34:58][1:35:36]
The bill passed unanimously with 35 yeas and 0 nays.
[1:35:36]
SB544 Irvin TO ESTABLISH PREJUDGMENT AND POST-JUDGMENT INTEREST RATES. 1:36:06
SB547 B. Johnson TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE DIVISION OF PROPERTY IN AN ACTION FOR DIVORCE. 1:43:28
Senator Blake Johnson moved SB 547 to add an additional exception to the definition of marital property, allowing property improved with marital funds to be considered in divorce proceedings.
[1:43:44][1:44:17][1:44:27][1:44:35][1:44:51][1:45:22]
The Chair fielded a brief question period before proceeding to a roll call.
[1:45:52][1:46:22]
The Senate adopted the amendment by a vote of 25 yeas to 4 nays.
[1:46:22]
SB551 J. English TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING RESTRICTIVE COVENANTS; AND TO AUTHORIZE THE TERMINATION OF CERTAIN RESTRICTIVE COVENANTS. 1:47:13
SB557 Teague TO DESIGNATE WASHINGTON, ARKANSAS, AS THE BIRTHPLACE OF THE BOWIE KNIFE, ARKANSAS HERITAGE SITE. 1:55:40
Senators Jimmy Hickey and Jim Teague introduced SB 557 to designate Washington, Arkansas as the birthplace of the Bowie Knife and create an Arkansas Heritage Site.
[1:56:12][1:56:15][1:56:27][1:56:47][1:56:55]
The Senate unanimously approved the designation, 35 yeas to 0 nays.
[1:56:55]
SB561 J. Hendren TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS TAX REFORM ACT OF 2019; AND TO REFORM THE SALES TAX, INCOME TAX, PROPERTY TAX, AND FRANCHISE TAX LAWS OF THE STATE. 1:57:30
The Chair opened the floor for questions, received none, and moved to a roll-call vote.
[2:04:08][2:04:15]
The bill was adopted with 32 yeas and 1 nay and sent to the House.
[2:04:25][2:05:05]
SB562 D. Wallace TO AMEND THE LAW REGARDING A DISTILLER OR MANUFACTURER PERMIT; TO AUTHORIZE OFF PREMISES SALES OF VINOUS LIQUOR; TO AUTHORIZE ONPREMISES SALES… 2:05:32
Senator D. Wallace introduced SB 562 to permit off-premises and on-premises sales of wine and to authorize wine-tasting events, noting that the measure would not affect the River Valley small-farm exemption.
[2:05:40][2:06:15]
Senator Mark Johnson asked whether the bill would also cover distilleries such as Rocktown Distillery, and the chair clarified that the legislation is limited to wine and does not change existing distilling rights.
[2:06:41][2:06:48][2:07:18][2:07:25][2:07:32]
After a brief question period, the committee rolled the vote and recorded 31 yeas and 3 nays, passing the bill and ordering it transmitted to the House.
[2:07:42][2:07:56][2:08:24][2:08:27]
SB563 Maloch TO AUTHORIZE THE ARKANSAS AGRICULTURE DEPARTMENT TO PROMULGATE RULES REGARDING LABELING OF AGRICULTURAL PRODUCTS AND TO RECEIVE AND INVESTIGATE CO… 2:09:02
Senator Malik presented SB 563, which would empower the Arkansas Agriculture Department to adopt labeling rules for agricultural products and to impose civil penalties, describing it as permissive legislation that fills gaps if federal action is insufficient.
[2:09:36][2:10:00]
Senator Trent Garner sought clarification that the bill would allow the department to allocate penalty revenues to a fund, and the chair confirmed this aligns with a companion bill previously considered.
[2:10:13][2:10:23][2:10:35]
The committee rolled the vote, approving the measure by a 33-yea, 2-nay margin and directing it to the House.
[2:10:48][2:11:22]
SB565 Rapert CONCERNING THE PUBLIC POLICY OF THE STATE OF ARKANSAS UNDER THE INSURANCE LAWS OF THIS STATE. 2:11:38
Senator Jason Rapert explained SB 565, stating that it would prevent the American Law Institute’s Restatements of Insurance Law from superseding Arkansas public policy when conflicts arise.
[2:11:47][2:11:54][2:12:27]
No members requested further discussion, and the chair proceeded to roll the vote, which passed overwhelmingly with 34 yeas and 1 nay, to be sent to the House.
[2:12:34][2:12:49][2:13:05][2:13:17]
SB571 J. Hendren TO CREATE AN EARNED INCOME TAX CREDIT, AN INCREASED STANDARD DEDUCTION, AND AN INDIVIDUAL INCOME TAX REDUCTION; AND TO PROVIDE FUNDING FOR INC… 2:13:36
SB586 G. Leding TO ALLOW A MANUFACTURER TO SPONSOR AND PROVIDE ADVERTISING MATERIALS TO A NONPROFIT ORGANIZATION HOLDING A LARGE ATTENDANCE FACILITY PERMIT. 2:49:55
Senator Greg Leding introduced SB 586 to amend the ABC law so manufacturers may sponsor signage and advertising materials at large-attendance nonprofit venues, stating there was no opposition.
[2:50:01][2:50:20]
The committee rolled the vote, recording 29 yeas and 4 nays, and the bill was approved for transmission to the House.
[2:50:52][2:51:32]
HB1251 Eubanks Wallace TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF "PRACTICE OF OPTOMETRY"; AND TO MODERNIZE THE PRACTICE OF OPTOMETRY. 2:51:50
Chair Representative Fred Allen introduced HB1251, noting that it would modernize Arkansas’s optometry statutes by adding a section that authorizes optometrists-who meet additional credentialing requirements and must report laser procedures to the Board of Optometry and the Department of Health-to perform five specific, minimally invasive procedures that have been routine in other states for years.
[2:52:07][2:52:37][2:53:14][2:53:46][2:54:19][2:54:51][2:55:27][2:56:01][2:56:36]
After debate the committee voted 25 yays to 8 nays, carrying the bill out of committee.
[3:20:47][3:21:17]
HB1564 Gray Rapert TO ESTABLISH THE PUBLIC SAFETY ACT OF 2019; TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS PUBLIC SAFETY COMMUNICATIONS ACT OF 1985; AND TO DEVELOP A NEXT GENERATION… 3:22:38
Senator Jason Rapert presented HB1564, explaining that the bill revises the Arkansas Public Safety Communications Act, reduces the projected revenue from $38 million to $24 million, eliminates the controversial high-cost fund, and provides for a two-thirds-vote mechanism to adjust the number of PSAPs while funding next-generation 9-1-1 equipment and the AWIN program, with updated fees for cellular, VoIP and prepaid calls.
[3:22:39][3:22:52][3:23:23][3:23:54][3:24:26][3:24:57]
The committee then approved the measure by a vote of 29 yays to 3 nays, sending it back to the House.
[3:25:32][3:26:04]
Matched: “…rules. Any questions? Without objection, motion's carried. Senate resolution 22 by Senator Hammer to recognize the Mr. Al Hunt for his effo…”
TO RECOGNIZE MR. AL HUNT FOR HIS EFFORTS IN ADVOCATING FOR RESPECTFUL LANGUAGE ON BEHALF …
I know, I know, you're waiting on Ann. Senate will come to order. Clerk, please call the roll. Ballinger, Bledsoe, Bond, Caldwell, Cheatham, Chesterfield, Clark, Cooper, Davis, Dismang, Eades, Elliott, English, Flippo, Flowers, Garner, Hammer, Hendron, Hester, Hickey, Hill, Ingram, Irvin Blake Johnson, Mark Johnson, Letting, Mallett Pitch, Rayford Rice, Sample Stebbifield, Sturge, Teague Wallace Everyone in the gallery please rise, everyone on the floor please rise and please join me in a word of prayer Dear Heavenly Father, thank you for the opportunity to live in this country, thank you for all of our many blessings, help us Lord to look for you look to you for guidance as we work here today help us do your will and help us focus on the things that matter to many arkansans around the state lord forgive us of our sins and help us live for you in jesus name amen i pledge allegiance to the flag of the united states of america and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. And I want to mention I have a new microphone and so it should have, it should fix some of the problems we had previously. Announcement, Senator Garner. Thank you, Mr. President. I have two pages
in the back today. First we have Zach Gwynn. He's 17. He's from Rising. He goes to Woodline High School and his favorite movie is the Lion King. Let's give him a big round of applause. Next, I have Maggie Harrell. Maggie's 16th and 11th grade. She's from Hampton and goes to Hampton High School. Her favorite movie is Scooby-Doo, and she's a cheerleader. Let's give her a big round of
applause. Thank you, Governor. Members, I'd like to introduce a page actually for Senator Teague. Senator Teague is out of the chamber right now, but Emily Bunch. Emily's in the back. She is a 10th grader. She's from Little Rock and attends Little Rock Christian Academy, very active in volunteer groups in her community. She loves playing the piano and singing. She's also involved in FBLA, and Emily is the daughter of Rachel Bunch. So let's welcome Emily. Senator Leving. Thank you, Mr. President.
colleagues. I also wanted to give a quick welcome to my two pages of the day. We've got brothers Grant and Taylor Harris back here, both 14, 8th graders at Lingle Middle School in Rogers, both into track and cross country. I just wanted to make sure we gave them a warm welcome. Thank you.
Center pitch. Thank you, Governor. We have a judge from Fort Smith, Ms. Shannon Blatt, and one of her mentees, Lauren McKinney, who's a senior at Southside High School. And for those of you in Conway, I don't know if Senator Raper's here, but she plans to be a UCA bearer next year. Please welcome them here. Any
other announcements? Any other announcements? Are there any items to be read across the desk, Madam Secretary? Yes, sir. We are committeha on engrossed bills to whom was deferred entste Erphilm 3.90.19 by Senator Ballinger compared cái engrossed copy with the Richelon find and same correctly engrossed. Judiciary. Commithe on engrossed bills to whom was deferred Senate Bill 463 by Senator Mark Johnson. Compare the engrossed copy with Richelon find and same correctly engrossed. State Ages. Committe bills to whom is first sent bill 481 by Senator Clark. Compare the engrossed copy with Richelon find and same correctly engrossed. City county local. Engrossed bills to whom was referred Senate Bill 512 by Senator Bledsoe compared to the engrossed copy of the original and found the same correctly engrossed. Insurance Commerce. For your Committee on Agri, to whom was referred Senate Bill 397 by Senator Wallace, recommend do pass as amended number two. Cowder. Committee on Education, to whom was referred Senate Bill 392 by Senator Ballinger, recommend do pass. Cowder. Committee on Education, to whom was referred Senate Bill 528 by Senator Dismane. onge Gary Lange . County on Education for Senate Bill 539, of Senator Sterc, recommend do pass. County on Education for Senate Bill 349, of Senator Clark, as amended No. 1. County on Education for Refer House Bill 1409, by Representative Delarosa, recommend do pass. County on Education for House Bill 1569, Representative Dotson, recommend do pass. Committee on Education, to whom was referred House Bill 1600 by Representative Hodges, recommended due pass. Calendar. Committee on Education, to whom was referred House Bill 1508 by Representative Davis, recommended due pass as amended number one. Calendar. Committee on Joint Budget, to whom was referred Senate Bill 103 by Joint Budget, recommended due pass. Calendar. Committee on Joint Budget, to whom was referred Senate Bill 74 by Joint Budget, recommended due pass as amended number one. Calendar. Committee on Judiciary, to whom was referred Senate Bill 511 by Senator Hill, recommend do pass. Calder. Committee on Judiciary, to whom was referred House Bill 1411 by Representative Birch, recommend do pass as amended number two. Calder. Committee on Revenue and Tax, to whom was referred Senate Bill 462 by Senator Bond, recommend do pass. Calder. Committee on Revenue and Tax, to whom was first, Senate Bill 560 by Senator Blake Johnson, recommend do pass. Calendar. Committee on Revenue and Tax, to whom was first, Senate Bill 576 by Senator Hester, recommend do pass as amended number one. Calendar. Committee on Revenue and Tax, to whom was first, Senate Bill 581 by Senator Jonathan Dismang, recommend do pass. Calendar. Committee on Revenue and Tax, whom is first sent bill 582 by Senator Blake Johnson, recommend do pass. Calendar. Committee on Revenue and Tax, whom is first sent bill 584 by Senator Dismay, recommend do pass as amended number one. Calendar. Committee on Revenue and Tax, whom is first sent bill 203 by Senator Teague, recommend do pass to concur in House Amendment number one. Calendar. Calendar Committee on Revenue and Tax, who was referred to Senate Bill 453 by Senator Eades, recommend do pass to concurrent House Amendment No. 1. Calendar Committee on Revenue and Tax, who was referred House Bill 1713 by Representative Fortner, recommend do pass. Calendar Committee on State Agencies, who was referred to Senate Bill 258 by Senator Bond, recommend do pass as amended No. 3. Calendar Committee on State Agencies, who was referred to House Bill 1420 by Representative Ford, Recommended due pass. Calendar. Committee on State Agencies to whom is referred House Bill 1444 by Representative Vaux. Recommended due pass. Calendar. Committee on Transportation and Technology to whom is referred Senate Bill 479 by Senator Sample. Recommended due pass as amended number two. Calendar. Committee on Transportation and Technology to whom is referred to Senate Bill 575 by Senator Filippo. Recommended due pass as amended number one. Calendar. Committee on Transportation and Technology, to whom was for Senate Bill 589, by Senator English, recommend do pass. Calendar. Committee on Transportation and Technology, to whom was for Senate Bill 594, by Senator Wallace, recommend do pass. Calendar. Committee on Transportation and Technology, to whom was for Senate Bill 596, by Senator Hammer, recommend do pass. Calendar. Dear Mr. President, this is to inform you that on March 20, 2019, I approve the following measures of the regular session for the 92nd General Assembly, Senate Bill 266, Act 519, Senate Bill 292, Act 520, Senate Bill 310, Act 521, Senate Bill 341, Act 522, Senate Bill 384, Act 523, Senate Bill 494, Act 524, Senate Bill 495, Act 525. Sincerely, Asa Hutchison, Governor. Follow it. For your Committee on Enrolled Bills, two moves refer to the following, Senate Bill 445 by Senator Garner, Senate Bill 162 by Joint Budget, compare the enrolled copies with the original, find the same correctly enrolled, and at 10.50 a.m. today, delivered to the Governor for his approval. Followed. Senate Bill 611 by Senator Letting, to clarify the law concerning information reported by paid canvassers, Senate Bill 611. Thank you. State agencies. Any other announcements before we move on to the business agenda? Senator Sturge is recognized. Thank you, Mr.
President. I won't take much time. I just wanted to introduce my page, Mr. Cole Weaver. Cole is a student at Southside Charter High School in the 9th grade, 15 years old. He's probably one of the most rail-rounded kids I know. Not only does he play football and basketball and soccer, but he's also a member of our choir, went to Allstate and the American Choral Directors Association, a national honor. So I'm very glad to have Ms. Cole Weaver.
Senator English. Thank you. I'd like to introduce my page, Blakely Baker from Sherwood-Silvan Hills High School. And she is on the Sherwood Mayor's Youth Council, the Band, and National Honor Society and Beta Club. Please welcome her. Where are you? Senator Bond,
Dr. Anna Kendrick, Pinnacle View Internal Medicine is here back with us. She's right in my district and we're happy to have her here. And Brenda Hewitt, our nurse, who's always here, thank you very much. Let's give them a round
recognized for an announcement. Thank you. Senator Chesterfield is not here, but she wanted me to remind you that Monday is AKA Day. So I think that means, guys, please go somewhere and find a pink or green tie and show up with the proper colors.
You know how Senator Chesterfield gets about these colors. A.K.A. Day on Monday. Thank you. Senator Hester, do you have an announcement? I was told you do. Maybe you don't. My son's up here. There's no objection. He'll continue to eat popcorn. No objection. Senator Hester. Thank you. Members, I'm
going to ask that I can put a bill that I just got out of committee on the amendment calendar just so I can get the amendment engrossed and add it on so I can run it Monday. It's Senate Bill. I suspend the rules for Senate Bill 576 just to put it on the amendment calendar so I can run
it Monday. Any questions? Any objections? Motion's carried without objection. What's that? It'll be put at the bottom of this Senate amendment calendar. Yep. Senator, do you have an announcement? I want to pull a bill back. Okay. He wants to pull a bill. Okay. Senator Davis is recognized. Senate Concurrent Resolution 5 by Senator Davis and Representative Evans to celebrate and recognize World Down Syndrome Day in the state of Arkansas. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, Governor. Senator Davis is recognized. Next the floor. Thank you. I have a
resolution today to celebrate and recognize World Down Syndrome Day in the state of Arkansas. Down syndrome is a naturally occurring chromosomal arrangement that has always been part of the human condition. It exists in all regions across the globe. Because of this, it's imperative that we remember the inherent dignity, worth, and valuable contributions of persons with intellectual disabilities and the importance of each person's individual autonomy and independence. World Down Syndrome Day encourages people from all over the world to choose their own activities and events to help raise awareness of what Down Syndrome is, what it means to have Down Syndrome, and how people with Down Syndrome play a vital role in our communities. So the date of World Down Syndrome Day is the 21st day of the third month and it's selected to signify the uniqueness of the triplication of the 21st chromosome, which causes Down syndrome. So, whereas this year marks the 14th anniversary of World Down Syndrome Day, which supports individuals with Down syndrome and those who advocate for them, now therefore be it resolved by the Senate of the 92nd General Assembly of the state of Arkansas, the House of Representatives concurring therewithin, that the Senate celebrates and recognizes March 21st, 2019, as World Down Syndrome Day in the state of Arkansas. Today I have members of Gigi's Playhouse, Board of Directors here with us. Gigi's Playhouse is a national non-profit whose purpose is to change the way the world views Down Syndrome and send a global message of acceptance for all. Gigi's is the only network of Down Syndrome Achievement Centers with 41 locations nationwide and one opening here in Little Rock soon. Gigi's has a lifelong commitment through their programs to support families in developing high expectations for their son or daughter with Down syndrome. They offer therapeutic, educational, career development, and global acceptance programs with over 200,000 program participation hours to date. Today, we are asking people to take the Generation G Pledge. The pledge is a conscious decision to be better every day, to be accepting, be generous, be kind. Let's challenge the status quo by stepping out of our comfort zones and become narrative shifters. Let's shift the narrative in regards to the way we speak about those who are differently abled. Let's be generous, kind, accepting, and recognize the limitless potential of those who have Down syndrome. While receiving a prenatal Down syndrome diagnosis for my daughter, while it was one of the scariest times in my life, what Everly has shown our family over the last seven months is that while she has Down syndrome, there is absolutely nothing down about it. Amen. Thank you. Thank you. For those who haven't yet taken the pledge, I'd like to, if it's okay, take five minutes to let us all take the pledge. And if we can come to the front and take a group picture, I would really appreciate that. Take as much time as you need. Thank you.
You've heard the resolution. All those in favor of the resolution, say aye. Aye. Let's make sure y'all are saying it loud. Opposed? The resolution is adopted. Okay. Before we go to Senator Hammer, some of you may know Canaan Sandy, who is the number one Razorback fan. He has Down syndrome. He, as you may have heard, had a stroke. He was still having some problems. He's in the heart hospital, and he is having surgery. They found a hole in his heart, and he's having surgery tomorrow. So if you'll keep Ginger, his mom, and Kanan in your thoughts and prayers. I wanted to mention that. Senator Hammer. Senator Hammer is recognized. Thank you, sir. Members,
I would like for a very special but brief suspension of the rules so I can present a resolution. I worked with Senator Davis on this. This all came together very quickly. It was supposed to happen Monday, but if you give me some latitude, a very brief resolution, please. I'd like to ask
to suspend the rules for the purpose of it. You've heard a motion to suspend the rules. Any questions? Without objection, motion's carried. Senate resolution 22 by Senator Hammer to recognize the Mr. Al Hunt for his efforts in advocating for respectful language on behalf of himself and others with intellectual and developmental disabilities. Senators recognize. Thank you. Mr. Governor, may I suspend the rules for
Mr. Hunt to be on the floor, please. Without objection. Thank you. Let me explain before I read this brief resolution why this is happening today. We had it scheduled to happen for Monday, but as a result of the day being changed to today and I worked with Senator Davis just to respect her efforts for today but this dovetails into what we are recognizing today I'd like to read to you just a brief resolution recognizing Mr. Al Hunt he is joined by his father Dr. James Hunt and his mother Miss Deanne Hunt which incidentally Dr. Hunt is a pediatric specialist and he is going to be our doctor of the day for Monday and so just to give you a little background there and here's the resolution it says whereas approximately 31% of adult Arkansans have some type of disability whereas individuals with disabilities should be treated with respect in all aspects of government including the language of the laws intended to govern them and whereas language used to describe individuals with disabilities has evolved over time a certain descriptive words have become outdated and whereas Mr. L. Hunt born in Little Rock in 2003 with the diagnosis of Down syndrome has advocated on behalf of himself and his peers for for the removal of the outdated and language from the Arkansas Code in order to ensure the Arkansas Code reflects the most current correct and respectful language in referencing individuals with disabilities of all kinds and now therefore be resolved by the Senate 92nd General Assembly of the State of Arkansas. The reason this is is because there's a piece of legislation that Representative Ladyman and Senator Irvin and I have worked together on along with David Ivers and DHS is going to be coming up next week that's going to talk about changing the terminology and bring it updated. And Mr. Hunt, Al Hunt, along with probably hundreds and thousands of others are going to help in the presentation of this bill as far as work that's gone into it. And because of what we've done today with Senator Davis's blessing, Al is here today just to be recognized for his efforts and appreciate his parents. And with that, Mr. President, I'd like to ask for the resolution to be adopted favorably, please, sir. Okay. You've heard the resolution. All
Senator Garner, Senate bills to concur in-house amendment. We got a tall order today, so. Amendment 1 to Senate Bill 4. Senator Clark wishes to be recognized. I have a carefully guarded secret.
I have a carefully guarded secret, and I have known for being able to keep a secret, and also it is always a great joy to share a secret. Forty or so years ago, on this day, in South Arkansas, a sweet little baby girl was born. So everybody wish happy birthday to Senator Joyce Elliott.
Did he say 30 years ago, Senator Ellinger? She was saying 20. 20 years ago. He forgot Willisville. He forgot. But I want to say to him really quickly, the sweet little girl part really threw me off. Senator Garner, Senator Garner, Senate Bill 4, Amendment 1, we will vote on the amendment and then we will vote to concur. My bill of amendment, they
Any questions on the amendment, amendment is adopted, any objection? It's adopted without objection, Senator, now we'll deal with the underlying bill. To create the Arkansas Legislative Study on Veterans Affairs. It changes from a task force to
questions on the underlying bill? Anyone wish to speak on it? Senator Close, any objection to rolling the vote? Please roll the vote. Mallinger, Bledsoe, Bond, Caldwell, Cheatham, Chesterfield, Clark, Cooper, Davis, Dismang, Mange, Eades, Elliott, English, Flippo, Flowers, Garner, Hammer, Hendron, Hester, Hickey, Hill, Ingram, Irvin, Blake Johnson, Mark Johnson, Letting, Malik, Pitch, Rapert, Rice, Sample, Stubbefield, Sturge, Teague, Wallace. Anyone wish to change their vote? Seeing none, cast up the ballot. 35 ayes, 0 nays. The bill is passed. Transmit to the House. Senator Hendron is
recognized. Members, a couple things. I have one introduction. Please welcome Judge Tom Smith up in this gallery here from Benton County. We don't get our judges down here from Northwest Arkansas, so good to have them. Also, as you can probably tell, the sound system is working a lot better. They spent two or three hours up here last night from SLIC and the guys upstairs, so make sure you tell them that you appreciate their hard work. Thank you. And then I got one one other thing to do is Senator Blake Johnson's out of the out of the chamber. So I'm going to refer his bill back to committee. Actually, he's actually okay for it and asked me to do this. So I'd make a motion that we send Senate Bill
534 back to transportation for purpose of amendment. Any question? Any objection? Motion is carried without objection. Senator Clark. Amendment 1, Senate Bill 250. senator alan clark is recognized on the amendment and once the amendment's adopted then we'll move to the underlying
sp 250 my bill my amendment any questions no it's not my my bill house it's house amendment to add a sponsor No, it's not your bill, it's not your bill. It is my bill. Okay. Any questions? Any objection? Members adopted without objection. Underlying bill, Senator. Senate Bill 250 by Senator Clark to amend the law concerning educational neglect and to amend the law concerning reports of educational neglect made to the child abuse hotline.
This is a great bill in interest of time that everyone had agreed to. I believe you all voted for it, and anyone who did not vote for it the first time meant
to. And I'd appreciate a good vote. Any questions? Anyone wish to speak? Senators closed. Any objection to rolling the vote? Please roll it. Allinger, Bledsoe, Bond, Caldwell, Cheatham, Chesterfield, Clark, Cooper, Davis, Dismayne, Eades, Elliott, English, Flippo, Flowers, Garner, Hammer, Hendron, Hester, Hickey, Hill, Ingram, Irvin, Blake Johnson, Mark Johnson, Ludding, Malick, Pitch, Rapert, Rice, Sample, Stubbefield, Sturge, Teague, Wallace. Anyone wish to... My screen is screwed up. Anyone wish to change their vote? Seeing none, cast up the ballot. 35 yeas, zero days. The bill is passed. Transmit to the House. Senator Davis is out of the chamber. Is anyone running that for her? We will pass over Senator Davis. Senate bill is a Senate amendment. Senator Hammer. Amendment 1, Senate Bill 252. Senator is recognized. Thank you, Governor.
This amendment was heard in the committee the other day in insurance, and what the amendment does is that we have an oncoming disease in our society that's being recognized nationwide as well as worldwide that is called PANS or PANDAS. And unfortunately, there's some disagreement among the medical field as to the methodology of diagnosis to arrive at the determination that a treatment known as IVIG would be required in order to treat this. And so as a result of ongoing effort of which there was an interim study dealing with this, As a result of that, UAMS, in partnership with Children's Hospital, has formed a clinic that is specifically going to be dealing with the PAND and PANDAS, working with national organizations. They've been recognized as far as being one of the diagnostic clinics that would be able to receive those that have this and be able to treat them. So what the amendment does, which is basically the guts of the bill, what the amendment does is it requires for an interdisciplinary panel to be established, and then it also would allow for a PAN and PANDAS Arkansas council to be established, and all of this is driving toward the purpose of coming up with that methodology of diagnosis so that once they get the ICD-9 code in place, then insurance companies would have the pathway clear for insurance companies. and state agencies that offer insurance plans to be able to pay for the treatment of it. There are some dates in there as to when it's supposed to be achieved by and before that mandate is actually passed on it will have to come back before the General Assembly either at a special session on the call if the governor would allow or during the next general session once this is done and if you have any constituents of which there are some that are in the gallery today who are dealing with this disease we are going to be one of the states that will be on the cutting edge of helping make sure that our residents that have this disease have a pathway forward to get treatment working in conjunction with the insurance companies covering the cost of it I'll be glad to answer any questions any
questions anyone wish to speak All those in favor of the amendment, say aye. Aye. Opposed? Aye. Senator Gerson, we, you have, you have a, Senator Hammer, you have one more, later, you can come back. Later. Senator Irvin is recognized to handle Senator Davis' bill. Amendment 1 to Senate Bill 118. Senator Davis' amendment for her bill. Any questions, any objections? Amendment's adopted without objection. Now we need to vote. Now we need to vote on Senator Irvin. We're going to now vote on the underlying bill. Senate Bill 318 by Senator Davis to prohibit unlawful female genital mutilation of a minor to create awareness programs concerning and statistical tracking of unlawful female genital mutilation and declare an emergency. Any questions? Anyone wish to speak on this? Any objection to rolling the vote? Please roll. Is Senator closed? Yes, I'd appreciate a good vote. Please roll the vote, Madam Secretary. Ballinger, Bledsoe, Bond, Caldwell, Cheatham, Chesterfield, Clark, Cooper, Davis, Dismayne, Eades, Elliot, English, Flippo, Flowers, Garner, Hammer, Hendron, Hester, Hickey, Hill, Ingram, Irvin, Blake Johnson, Mark Johnson, Letting, Malik, Pitch, Rayford, Rice, Sample, Stubbefield, Sturge, Teague, Wallace. Anyone wish to change their vote? Seeing none, cast up the ballot. 35 yeas, 0 nays. The bill is passed. Transmit to the House. Senator Raper. Enroll it. Senator Raper.
I think. Amendment 1 to Senate Bill 291. Any questions on the amendment? Any objection? Amendments adopted without objection. Senator Engrossing, Senator Ballinger. Senator Ballinger is recognized.
my amendment. Any questions? Any objection to the amendment? Amendments adopted without objection, Senator Grossing. Senator Dismayne, who will pass over his briefly. Senator Letting. Thank you, Mr. President. Amendment 1 to Senate Bill 514. My bill, my amendment. Very quickly,
this is part of a juvenile justice reform package by Senator Irvin, myself, and others. And in the gallery today, we have Laura Berry and Dustin Vickers, the two Arkansans that were freed by Act 539 from Senator Irvin and Representative Petty in 2017. Just
wanted to give them some acknowledgement. Thank you. Any questions? Any objections? Amendment is adopted without objection. Senator Grossing. Senator Dismayne. Amendment 1 to Senate Bill 514. My bill, my amendment. Any questions? Any questions? Any objections? Amendments adopted without objection. Senator Engrossing. Senator Hammer. Amendment 1 to Senate Bill 574. Senator Hammer. Thank you. My bill, my amendment. Appreciate it. Any questions? Any objections? Amendments adopted without objection. Senator Engrossing. Senator Alan Clark. Amendment 3 to Senate Joint Resolution 15. Senator Clark. my bill my amendment any questions any objection amendment is adopted without objection senator grossing moving to house bills with senate senate hester amendment one to senate bill 576 my bill my amendment okay any questions any objection amendments adopted without objection Senator Grosick Senator Ballinger amendment 2 to House Bill 1341 My bill, my amendment. Any questions? Any objection? Amendment's adopted without objection. Senator Ingrossing. Senator Ballinger, again. Amendment 1 to House Bill 1395. Same thing, my bill, my amendment. Any questions? Any objection? Amendment's adopted without objection. Senator Ingrossing. Senator Raper. Amendment 1 to House Bill 1564. My bill, my amendment,
Any questions? Any objection? Amendment's adopted without objection. Senator Engrossing, Senator Rappers, recognize your personal privilege. Yes, and actually, personal privilege, I want
to make a motion. Members, it's on this bill on 1564. We've heard this. Actually, I tried to get this engrossed before we heard it in committee. I just wanted to ask, with your consent, if we could take this up at the end of the House calendar, at the very end today so I could go ahead and vote it and get this off our desks. Without any objection, any questions?
Without objection. Thank you. Senator Irvin, do you want to handle the amendment for Senator Davis? Yes. Please. Thank you. Amendment 1 to House Bill 1631. Senator Irvin. This is her bill, her amendment. any questions any objection that was adopted without objection sender engrossing senator dismay senator dismay we will wait till he comes back on that unless someone wants to handle that for him senate bills for third reading senator garner Senate Bill 2 by Senator Garner to create the Down Syndrome Discrimination by Abortion Prohibition Act Senator Garner is recognized Thank you, Mr. President I think it's an appropriate bill to bring today as we recognize those that
were made different You know, one of the most powerful testimonies I heard was given by a man named Frank Stevens at the U.S. House of Representatives. Mr. Stevens has Down syndrome. He's an advocate for the rights of those who were with Down syndrome. Mr. Stevens said to the panel of lawmakers this statement, I'm a man with Down syndrome and my life is worth living. The reason Mr. Stephen has to state that obvious fact that those with Down syndrome deserve life is because there's an epidemic across the world for those who are Down syndrome. Facts don't lie about this, Minus. The United States from 1955 to 2011, 67% of those with Down syndrome never saw their first birthday. The mortality rate in France is 77%, and in Denmark it's nearly 98%. By far the worst place in the world to be made with Down syndrome is Iceland. We know every child with Down syndrome, nearly every single one of them, isn't born. And what's this mass genocide against those who are made differently? It's abortion. This is an epidemic for many communities, especially for the Down syndrome. I brought this bill because I wanted to make sure that those who have this diagnosis, those who could live this full in fulfillment of life, those we see who every single day bring joy to not only their family but to members of their community and this state have a chance to live a person sent me this card whenever I first put this bill out there and I love what the front of it says I never knew I wanted a child with Down Syndrome until I had one and in this letter she talks about the joy that she has every single day for her son who's in his 40s now. She says there's hardships, but she says she wouldn't trade it for anything. What this bill does is if there is an exemption, either for threat of life to the mother, rape or incest, or some other exemption, that once you have the diagnosis of a Down syndrome test, which happens for about 10 to 13 weeks of pregnancy, the child cannot be aborted for that reason it places extra protections on the civil side for the woman and this will sit with the doctor with that I will take
any questions from the members of the committee any questions on the bill anyone wish to speak against for otherwise Senator Close Madam Secretary please call the roll Ballinger. Aye. Bledsoe. Aye. Bond. Bond. Caldwell. Aye. Cheatham. Aye. Chesterfield. Aye. Chesterfield. Clark. Clark. Cooper. Davis. Dismang. Eads. Elliot. English. English. Flippo. Flowers. Flowers. Garner. Yes. Hammer. Aye. Hendren. Aye. Hester. Aye. Hickey. Aye. Hill. Yes. Ingram. Ingram. Irvin. Aye. Blake Johnson. Blake Johnson. Mark Johnson. Aye. Letting. Letting. Malik. Pitch Rapert Rapert Rice Sample Stubbafil Stubbafil Sturch Teague Wallace Aye Anyone who wish to vote Senator Dismayne is aye or change their vote Senator Rapert is aye Senator Dismayne is aye. Anyone else? Senator Teague is aye. Okay. Anybody else over here? And anyone over here? Senator Blake Johnson is aye. Senator Clark is aye. Senator English is aye. Anyone else? Anyone else? Cast up the ballot. 29 nays, two nays. The bill is passed. Transmit to the House. Senator Garner. No, he's going to pass over. He's passing over now. Senator Garner, Freckenhouse. Need to be read. One second. The bill that Senator Dalby's, it has Senator Dismay running it here. We're passing over that. Senator Garner, SB6, Madam Secretary. Just one second, Senator Garner. Yes, sir. actually Senate Bill 6 by Senator Garner to designate the shotgun as the official state firearm I'll run it colleagues this is a bill that shows
our symbol and our pride in making an official state gun I couldn't get real specific like other states did I didn't want to name a certain gun a Glock or whatever but I think the shotgun is a universal gun that most Arkansans have if they have guns It's used in a variety of different ways. It can be used primarily for killing those ducks over there in the Delta, which I try to do every year. I'm not very good at it, but I try very hard. I think it's a great pride, and I think it'll bring tourism, it'll bring hunting opportunities, and it'll bring some other opportunities to the state
Senator Garner? Senator Flowers is recognized. Senator Garner, you testified in committee that there are other states that have official firearms how many states did you actually find had on a news article i read i think it was
and said that i was incorrect about that okay and in terms of uh the delta and duck hunting You know, Arkansas is known all over the world as the duck hunting capital of the world, even known for duck calling. So do you really think we need a shotgun to draw our tourists here for duck hunting? Oh, yes, ma'am. I think when you
know, Prairie Wing over there or you go to our many different facilities here, they can have a big sign that says buy shotgun to Arkansas, it's our state gun, so I think it'll drive it here, I mean how do you quantify that or find the numbers that's impossible, but I think the symbolism behind it is important, I think it'll show that you know, this is a gun that we use in many different aspects and it's a great representation of our state Has the duck hunting industry asked you
I know people who duck hunt who love the idea. I know, but nobody from the industry, the duck hunters of Arkansas, they haven't asked you for it, have they? People who duck hunt in Arkansas haven't. But that organization has not, has it?
I'm not going to divulge private citizens' information. Yeah, because you don't have it. Thank you. Now, point of personal privilege. Senator, I would advise a senator not to argue with the senator presenting the bill. Ask your question. Take the answer. If you don't like it, move on. Senator, point of personal privilege
you're recognized. Thank you. I was just told that I made story and basically that I lied here. I want for the record to show I did not I do not lie to my colleagues on purpose. I say stuff that's wrong sometimes, but I want that to be very clear for the people watching. I did not
Three to four if you had the old super black eagle. Any other questions? Anyone wish to speak on it? Senator Flowers recognized to speak against the bill. Senator Hickey, one moment. Senator Hickey, I thought you were just standing there, Senator Hickey. Senator Hickey's recognized. Okay you've heard will you come to the well and make
immediate consideration on this bill thank you. You've heard the motion all those in favor say aye. Opposed? Ayes have it. Motions carried. Madam Secretary, please call the roll. Ballinger? Aye. Bledsoe? Bledsoe? Bond? Aye. Caldwell? Aye. Cheatham? Cheatham?
Davis, Dismayne, Eads, Elliot, Elliot, Flippo? Aye. Flowers? Garner? Yes. Hammer? Hammer? Hendren? Hester? Aye. Hickey? No. Hill? Ingram? Aye. Blake Johnson. Aye. Mark Johnson. Aye. Letting. Aye. Mallett. Yes. Pitch. Yes. Raypert. Yes. Rice. Aye. Sample. Aye. Stubbafil. Stubbafil. Sturge. Aye. Teague. Aye. Wallace. Aye. Anyone who did not vote wish to vote. Anyone who did vote wish to change their vote. We're going to go on this side first. Senator Cheatham. Anybody else over here? Vote or change the vote. Senator Hammer is aye. Senator Cheatham is aye. Anyone else? Anyone else? Cast up the ballot. 20, you got it. 29 yays, one nay. The bill is passed. Transmit to the House. Senator Rafer. Oh, Senator Hammer. Let me recognize Senator Hammer real quick with Senator Rafer. He has a couple of quick announcements. Quick announcement. Members, a while ago, when I was presenting the amendment on the Panda-Pandas, we had the gallery packed with parents and children. I'm not
sure that they're still here. If you're part of the Panda-Pandas group, I just wanted to have them stand. I think they were actually some asked to leave because they had so many up there and just wanted to recognize that they were
in the gallery. Thank you very much. Senator Raper. Senate Bill 396 by Senator Rayford to amend the statutes concerning the books and records requirement under the Arkansas Insurance Code, and to modify the Trade Practices Act under the Arkansas Insurance Code. Senator Rayford is recognized on the bill. Thank you.
Members, this simply clarifies that insurance companies for complaints and market conduct information should keep the records for the current year and the next five years supported by the Insurance Department. Had no
complaints. Appreciate a good vote. Any questions on the bill? Anyone wish to speak at all? Any objection to rolling the vote? Please roll the vote, Madam Secretary. Ballinger, Bledsoe, Bond, Caldwell, Cheatham, Chesterfield, Clark, Cooper, Davis, Dismain, Eades, Elliott, English, Flippo, Flowers, Garner, Hammer, Hendron, Hester, Hickey, Hill, Ingram, Irvin, Blake Johnson, Mark Johnson, Letting, Malik, Pitch, Rapert, Rice, Sample, Stubblefield, Sturge, Teague, Wallace. Anyone wish to change their vote? Seeing none, cast up the ballot. 35 yeas, 0 nays. The bill is passed. Transmit the bill to the House. Senator Blake Johnson. Senate Bill 401 by Senator Johnson. Concerning applications by the General Assembly to the United States Congress and with provisions of the United States Constitution, Article 5. Senator Johnson is recognized on the bill. Thank you, Governor. Thank you, colleagues. This bill just would put an aggregation period of 15 years for Article 5 calls to convention after the adoption, after April 1st, 2019. So it would not affect the one that we did in this session, but it would set a sunset for them and they could be readdressed by following legislature at a later time. I'd appreciate a good vote. Any questions? Anyone wish to speak? Senator Raper is recognized to speak. Do you have a question? We
actually have a question. Okay. Senator Riper is recognized. Senator Johnson, could you tell me if there's any other state that actually has in place a time limit, and how did you come to this? If there was another state that was a guideline, could
you just give me a little background on that? Well, there was some conversation and emails about a seven-year period that when it goes to Congress that it would go away, and it's not accurate. I had our staff research that, and there was some committee on the federal level of a seven-year aggregation period for states to adopt. That would have been their recommendation, so this is twice that and approximately the same as our term limits at this time, so I thought that was a good time. But did you
idea. Okay. Appreciate it. As you know, I've been a great supporter of the ability of the states to be able to make their voice heard this way. So I was just looking for guidance
on, is there any other state? This is from here on going out, and that would be the policy for the state to do that 15-year period. And the next legislature could readdress that if they so choose. So I'd appreciate it. Any other questions? Senator Stubblefield, you just stretching, or you had a question? Yep. Senator Stubblefield, you have a question? I guess it's a question.
15 years or longer? I don't care for the open-ended contract, and I like this time frame, and it can be readdressed by the legislature in the future. And it does not touch your bill, so, or your act, or your call, so. Any other questions? Senator Mark Johnson, Ferndale. Senator Blake Johnson, are you
familiar with the 27th Amendment? to the U.S. Constitution? You just let it roll. I hadn't got anything to do with it here. Well, you know, it was proposed by the Congress, like all the amendments were. Do you know about how long it took to ratify that one? From when it was presented to the last state to get it into the Constitution
this bill is on. Yes, sir. I understand. Would this in any way limit would this limit such an Article 5 convention from putting a limitation on the number of years the states had to consider it such as was done on the so-called Equal Rights Amendment? On the
but it would, as Senator Stubblefield asked you about, it would limit if we were, say, near a almost a 14 and a half years and a couple of the stakes were about to meet and consider it. It could cause us to kind of fall back to the end of the line, so to speak. There's
there's many what ifs, but the legislature at that time can readdress it if that body so chooses. OK, thank you, Senator. Any other questions for the senator? Anyone wish to speak? Senator is
Caldwell, Cheatham, Chesterfield, Chesterfield, Clark, Clark, Cooper, Cooper, Davis, Davis, Dismang, Eads, Elliot, English, Flippo, Flowers, Flowers, Garner, Hammer, Hendron, Hester, Hickey, Hill, Ingram, Irvin, Irvin, Blake Johnson, Mark Johnson, Letting, Letting, Mallet, Pitch, Raypert, Rice, Sample, Aye. Stubbafil? No. Sturge? Aye. Teague? Teague? Wallace? Aye. Anyone wish to vote or change their vote? Senator Cooper is aye. Anybody else over here? Senator Hill is aye. Senator Letting is aye. Anybody else over here? Cast up the ballot, 24 yeas, 5 nays, the bill is passed. Transmit to the House. Senator Elliott. Senate Bill 487 by Senator Elliott to conduct an assessment and audit of the culture and climate of the Department of Correction. Senator Elliott, whose birthday it apparently is, is recognized.
Thank you. First day of spring. Always a spring chicken, y'all. I'm just telling everybody that. Members, this bill is like some of the other bills we've done where, for some of our agencies, if we needed to understand better what's happening with them, we'd create a bill to hire a consultant, as we are through BLR, as we have with some other bills. But this one has to do with the Arkansas Department of Correction. And this is intended as a way of helping to help us be more accountable to our constituencies. So, because there are issues for which I can't account, so what the bill proposes to do. And I've worked with folks at UA Little Rock who understands how to create this kind of bill so that we can look at systems, not just one part of something, but to evaluate the entire system. And of course, and I've worked with Marty Garrity and Jill Thayer to create the study here, and we have the funding to do it, just as we are doing the bill to study what's happening with our highway department. It's the exact same process, and so I would
ask you for a good vote, and I'll answer questions if anybody has any questions. Any questions for Senator Elliott? Anyone wish to speak against, in favor? Senator Ballinger is going to speak in favor of the bill. Senator Ballinger is recognized. Thank you, Mr. President. I just wanted to say that all this is empowering the legislature, and in particular whoever is chairing the Penal and Corrections subcommittee, and take a look, basically, to get more information. So I'm a co-sponsor on this piece of legislation. I think the information could be great and valuable. It could be a situation where you find ways to save money, and frankly, probably we'll find ways to do things better. So I appreciate Senator Elliott's effort on this bill. Anyone else wish to speak on this bill? Is the senator closed?
I am, except I just want to give a little levity. So as you know, our constituents are always wanting us to work together. they say is Democrats and Republicans. So if this does not float their boats, I don't know what will. Because on this field right here in the Senate, we've got, just listen to these names and know what's possible. Elliott, Dismay, Bond, Letting, Ballinger, Garner, and Hickey. Is that not a beautiful thing? I'll ask you for a good vote. On
that note, is there any objection to rolling the vote? Please roll the vote. Ballinger, Bledsoe, Bond, Caldwell, Cheatham, Chesterfield, Clark, Cooper, Davis, Dismayne, Eves, Elliott, English, Flippo, Flowers, Garner, Hammer, Hendron, Hester, Hickey, Hill, Ingram, Irvin, Blake Johnson, Mark Johnson, Ludding, Malik, Pitch, Rayford, Rice, Sample, Stubbefield, Teague Wallace. Anyone wish to change their vote? Seeing none, cast up the ballot. 35 yeas, 0 nays. The bill is passed. Transmit the bill to the House. Senator Garner. Senate bill 492 by Senator Garner to promote hospitality and tourism to establish areas of a city or town that highlight restaurant, entertainment, and hospitality options to establish temporary or permanently designated entertainment districts. Senator Garner is recognized. Thank you. Before we get started, I got to say this is
two bills in a row that me and Senator Elliott are co-sponsors together. So I'm sure I'm losing a membership somewhere to something. This is a good bipartisan bill. What this does is for years, you know, there's been an attempt in Arkansas to give the cities and places the freedom to be able to set up these entertainment districts where people could have alcohol in a very restricted way, very regulated, in a very set area where they carry alcohol out. This could be a permanent thing, or it could be a temporary. You know, there's plenty of places across the United States that have entertainment districts, and they're wildly successful, in my opinion, or they have it set up permanently. Typically, they have certain hours when you can actually drink to have regulations on if children are going to be able to come there or not. That all will be done by the local government there, the city council, to do that. Or it could be temporary. I'll give you an example in my area. We have the Murphy Art District, which has the music fest every year. It's a big festival. We have great acts come down there. We had Toby Keith. We had Brad Paisley. We almost had Carnie B. She had to cancel at the last minute. If you know who she is, she's very popular. But during that three-day, four-day period, they could do a temporary entertainment district to allow alcohol in places they typically would not want it. And people are concerned with kids being accessed to this and the problem that we have with families. What I'll say is the people who brought this, in El Dorado and Pine Bluff, they care deeply about the experiences that families have. In El Dorado, we have a splash pad slash playground that they built on an acre, open to everybody. They have puppet shows and rock climbing things for kids all the time for free. They care deeply about the experiences family had in protecting our children. They want to have the ability in other areas to have this option available to them when it's more of an adult entertainment where they can use this legal product. With that, I'll
take any questions from the chamber. Any questions for the senator? Anyone wish to speak? Is the senator closed? I'm closed. Is there any objection to rolling the vote? There is an objection to rolling the vote, so please call the roll. Ballinger? Aye. Bledsoe? Bledsoe? Bond? Aye.
Cooper. Davis. Davis. Dismang. Eads. Elliot. Aye. English? Aye. Flippo? Aye. Flowers? Flowers? Garner? Yes. Hammer? Yes. Hammer? Hammer? No. Hendron? Aye. Hester? No. Hickey? Hickey? Hill? Yes. Ingram? Aye. Irvin? Aye. Blake Johnson? Aye. Blake Johnson. Aye. Mark Johnson. Aye. Mark Johnson. Aye. Letting. Aye. Mallet. Aye. Pitch. Aye. Rayford. Aye. Rice. Aye. Rice. Sample. Aye. Stubbafil. Aye. Sturge. Aye. Teague. Aye. Wallace. Aye. Anyone wish to vote or change their vote? Senator Hickey is aye. Senator Bledsoe is no. No. Senator Cheatham is aye. Senator Raper is no. Anybody else want to vote or change their vote? cast up the ballot 23 yays 8 nays bill passes transmit to the house Senator Ballinger send bill 524 by Senator Ballinger to amend the law concerning electronic voting equipment and to authorize the state board of election commissioners to perform post-election audits of votes tabulated electronically. Senator Ballinger. Thank you, Mr. President. This bill is one that the Election Commission brought to me, or the Board of Election Commissioners. And essentially what it is, is there are several states, and in fact there's probably going to be an effort from the federal level to require some audits of elections. And so essentially what this does, this provides for a random audit of three of the counties that's selected by lot every year randomly. And then if there is actually some evidence that there is an election law violation, it gives them the authority to go in and conduct the audit. It is agreed upon bill. It's actually been worked through the Secretary of State's office, County Clerk's Office, or County Clerk's Association, and been working all session long. So we're just now bringing it to you. Happy to answer any questions. I appreciate a good vote. Any questions for the senator? Anyone wish to speak? Senator has walked away and therefore closed. Any objection to rolling the vote? Please roll the vote, Madam Secretary. Ballinger, Bledsoe, Bond, Caldwell, Cheatham, Chesterfield, Clark, Cooper, Davis, Dismayne, Eades, Elliott, English, Flippo, Flowers, Garner, Hammer, Hendron, Hester, Hickey, Hill, Ingram, Irvin, Blake Johnson, Mark Johnson, Letting, Malik, Pitch, Raper, Rice, Sample, Stubbefield, Sturge, Teague, Wallace. Anyone wish to change their vote? Cast up the ballot. 34 yays, one nay. The bill passes, transmit to the House. Senator Bledsoe, SB 527, has an emergency clause. Send Bill 527 by Senator Bledsoe to require a health care payer to disclose on a member identification card whether a health benefit plan is insured or self-insured, self-funded, and declare an emergency. Senator Bledsoe is recognized. Thank you,
Mr. President, and ladies and gentlemen of the Senate. On Senate Bill 527, the definitions start on page 1, line 33, to line 18 on page 2. The body of the bill is two lines and a word, and then the emergency clause comes after that. And in those two lines, what we're trying to do is we are saying, well, we're trying to clear up some confusion. This bill requires insurance companies to disclose on the ID card, and everyone that has insurance gets an ID card, whether they are insured or self-insured, whether it's a self-funded plan. Right now, when a patient comes into a clinic or hospital, they present their ID showing the health benefit plan that they are in. But the patient doesn't usually know whether the plan is insured or self-insured. And the physician or hospital can't tell from looking at the card. This makes a difference, and it also makes a difference in which law applies. If it's an insured plan, then Arkansas insurance laws apply, including prior authorization, prompt pay law, any willing provider. But if it's a self-funded plan, then federal ERISA laws apply. This bill just requires the insurance companies to make clear on the member ID card what kind of plan the patient is in. This bill will get rid of a lot of confusion. Arkansas Works is already on the ID card for them. EBD is okay with this. Blue Cross Blue Shield
is okay with this. And there is no known opposition to this bill. And I'd be glad to answer some questions. Any questions? Anyone wish to speak? Senator closed. Any objection to rolling the vote? Please roll the vote, Madam Secretary. Balinger, Bledsoe, Bond, Caldwell, Cheatham, Chesterfield, Clark, Cooper, Davis, Dismayne, Eades, Elliot, English, Flippo, Flowers, Garner, Hammer, Hendron, Hester, Hickey, Hill, Ingram, Irvin. Bless you. Irvin, Blake Johnson, Mark Johnson, Leting, Malik, Pitch, Rapert, Rice, Sample, Stubblefield, Sturch, Teague, Wallace. Anyone wish to change their vote? Seeing none, cast up the ballot. 35 yea, 0 nays. The bill is passed, transmitted to the House. Senator Irvin. Senate Bill 554 by Senator Irvin to establish pre-judgment and post-judgment interest rates. Senator Urban is recognizing the bill. Thank you. Members,
this bill ties our interest rate on judgments to the federal rate. It adds to for a total of 5%. And this brings Arkansas in line with many other states to create a more equitable situation where the plaintiff is compensated, but at a rate that reflects the reality of
the situation. Any questions? Senator Malik has a question. He's recognized. Thank you, Mr. President. Senator, do you know what the current prime lending rate is that a bank would charge to
at 3%. And so 2% above that's 5%, yet the Wall Street prime or New York bank prime is 5.5%. So I guess what your bill does is actually gives a – 10% was too much in the current rate environment. But 2% above the primary credit rate gives a better rate than even the current prime lending rate for the bank's best customers. And I just didn't know if that's what you intended. I
you. Thank you. Any other questions? Senator Ballinger has a question. Thank you, Mr. President. Was this, in that rate in particular, was this negotiated with the Traveler Association? I believe it was, yeah. Thank you. Any other questions? Senator Hickey and then Senator Cooper.
I assume you have a question, Senator Hickey. I guess that's what it's going to be. Okay, Senator Hickey and then Senator Cooper. I'm going to be kind of like Senator Malik. What we're doing here is we're allowing somebody that has a judgment, that's not paying their stuff, to have a rate that is better than what some of your preferred customers could come down and even get. So it doesn't really compute to me, to be honest, Senator, why we would allow something like that to happen because we've got our individuals out here that couldn't get their money. they've pursued this thing through the courts they've got a judgment and now they're going to have to try to get this restitution and come back when they could be reinvesting their money elsewhere if these people had have just done the right way so I guess my question to you was is I just want to make a hundred percent sure that
we understood all that before bringing this bill yes sir thank you ma'am the current rate is ten percent which is one of the highest in the country and so this will bring us in line with other states Alaska, Georgia, Iowa, Nebraska, South Carolina, Texas, Washington, Utah, Arizona, Wisconsin are the other states that have rates that are consistent with what we're bringing. Thank you, ma'am. Senator
in committee. This was discussed at length, and I don't know if you were aware of the details of what what we discussed in there, but this does give somebody that has their money tied up in that and gives them actually a 2% more than what other states, some of the other states are doing. But yet, that's way above what the going rate is today. So the people has their money tied up in a judgment still has their compensation for not being able to get their money at the right time or at that time.
Senator Cooper, for your help. Senator Jason Rafer. All right. Senator, based on what I'm seeing in the bill, you're actually creating a better situation than what currently was in statute. It actually said 10%. So it's striking 10%, correct? That's correct. So it was actually, we had codified a very high interest rate compared to what's available. So from what I see, is this absolutely creating a better situation for people out here? I believe so. And I think the bill also does have something that's important to a lot of us, and that is that if the rates were to float upward, it does cap it under Amendment 89 at the usury rate, correct? It
Thank you. Yes. Any other questions? Anyone wish to speak on the bill in any way? Senators, closed? I am. I'd appreciate a good vote. Senator Ballinger, you want to speak for the bill? Okay, well, she just closed. I think we're good. I assume there's an objection to rolling the vote. Please call the roll, Madam Secretary. Ballinger?
Davis. Aye. Dismang. Aye. Eades. Aye. Elliott. Aye. English. Aye. Flippo. Aye. Flowers. Aye. Garner. Garner. Garner. Aye. Hammer. Aye. Hendren. Aye. Hedron Hester Hickey Hill Ingram Irvin Blake Johnson Mark Johnson Letting Mallet No. Pitch. Aye. Rayford. Aye. Rice. Aye. Rice. Sample. Sample. Stubbafil. Stubbafil. Sturge. Aye. Teague. Teague. Wallace. Aye. Senator Clark is. Senator Clark is aye. Senator Bond is no. Senator Ingram is not voting. Senator Hammer is aye. Senator Garner is aye. Senator Cheatham is indeed present. Senator Cheatham is present. Anybody else over here? Anybody else? Over on this side. make sure it reflects your desire cast up the ballot 23 a's three days the bill passes transmit to the house senator Blake Johnson Senate bill 547 by Senator Blake Johnson to amend the law concerning the division of property and an action for divorce senator Johnson's recognized members this this just adds another exception into purpose purposes of section the marital property means all property acquired by either spouse subsequent to the marriage except this adds a number eight and properties that possibly have been improved or the usefulness have been improved by the the marital funds so that's that that consideration would be given in that the property separation in a divorce so that's all it does any questions anyone wish to speak on the bill senators closed any objection rolling the vote we do have an objection madam
Would any members like to change their vote or cast their vote? Senator Elliott is a no. Senator Clark is an aye. Senator Rice is an aye. Senator Clark is an aye. Senator Rice is an aye. Senator Stubblefield is an aye. Anybody else? Senator Hickey is an aye. All right. All right, seeing no more, please cast up the ballot. The vote of 25 yeas, 4 nays. The bill passes. Transmit to the House. Senator English.
restrictive covenants. Thank you. it's basically this bill does just that it moves to change a restrictive covenant that goes back to 1947 on a piece of property that is presently a church has been a church for a number of years and but in the covenants it says it has to be either a church or a residential housing and the people who own it, the Baptist Association, do not have the resources anymore to maintain the facility, and they can't sell it with this restrictive covenant. All right, members, are there any questions?
mic, please? I'm sorry. I thought it came on our mic. No, it's North Hills and Bucane Boulevard. Okay, I know where it is, and it's the situation I'm aware of, and I thank you for carrying this
bill. Thank you. All right, thank you. Are there any other questions? Senator? Okay. Any other questions? Thank you. Anyone wish to speak for or against the bill? Senator Clark, you're recognized to speak against the bill.
know that Senator English is not too surprised because she knows my reservations in committee the uh I think that this bill uh presents some really grave problems uh we're dealing with covenant restrictions first of all let me say I think there's a much better way to do what they want to do through notification they could and central bond could probably present this better than I can but they could change the notification process but to publication and then a declaratory judgment I think when nobody shows up but I have property and covenant restrictions that are 30 years old or not old and to be able just to change them because one piece of property because people are not happy with what's going on with it it's not that I'm not sympathetic but covenant restrictions are very important when when you need property to your heirs and and everybody understands here's what you can and can't do with this property and for somebody to be able to come back later and said well we're not happy with these rules so we just want to change it uh you know like i said i'm sympathetic with with these folks uh but there's another thing here i mean this and this one piece of property comes back to that this piece of property was supposed to be a church it was for a church uh it was deeded to be five acres to be to always be a church or to or for single family dwellings they say they can't sell it well the fact is they can't sell it for market value that there's nobody that that can pay for that has the money to pay for an expensive church doesn't mean that there's somebody that won't pay below market value and that's what happens when you put restrictions on a property uh is sometimes it raises the value sometimes it lowers the value but for us just to come back willy-nilly in the state legislature uh because of one problem and change uh and start down this slope of change and covenant restrictions for everybody, I think is extremely dangerous. So while I am very sympathetic to the folks involved, I think this is a very bad law. Thank
This is referred to a lot of times, especially as things get older, when it gets 30, 40, 50 years old. You see it a lot of times in farms and stuff on deeds where Grandpa wants his farm to continue on with his heirs, well, two generations later, those kids no longer involved in farming. And for them to receive part of that property and stuff, that they must continue farming with that property. And they're no longer involved in it. And so we call that governing from the grave, or ruling from the grave, or controlling from the grave, because Grandpa's already passed on. I think that's kind of what we're seeing here in this case is someone years ago had a good intention for this. Well, times change, property changes, the environment changes. When you go looking at 30, 40, 50 years down the road, things are not the same. I don't look the same as I did 30 years ago. And so surrounding properties do not look the same. I think this is a good deal. Appreciate a
Thank you, Madam President. I just want to say as an old title guy, you know, I appreciate the fact that this creates a mechanism to clear up title that would be really difficult to clear otherwise. And this only comes in effect if the people who are benefited from it are people who are not discernible. So if it's got to be 200 more potential individuals, this is extremely narrow. In fact, I said in committee, if it was broader, it'd probably be a little more helpful. This is extremely narrow, probably about as narrow as you can make it to fit for this one situation. But if other people are situated like this, it provides a mechanism. Only when there's 200 or more potential people who would be benefited, that means, you know, it's got to have a lot of errors down the road and the individuals unidentifiable. So I think it's not nearly as broad as what it could be.
Thank you. Thank you. Are there any other members I want to speak for or against the bill? Seeing none, Senator English, you recognize to close for the bill. I'm close for my bill. Thank you. Close for the bill. Is there an objection to rolling
change their vote. Senator Bledsoe is an aye. Senator Hammer is an aye. Senator Dismang is an aye. Cheatham is an aye. Any other members wish to change their vote? Seeing none, please cast out sample as a no. Anyone else? All right, seeing none, please cast up the ballot. It's too late. I'm sorry. With 25 yeas, 5 nays, the bill passes. Transmit to the House. Sorry, I already called casting ballots. We're going to pass over Senator Teague's bill. Oh, you've got it. Senator Hickey, he is recognized to present Senate Bill 557 for Senator Teague. Senator
Well, I'm going to call it the Bowie Knife. Senator Garner and I have been having a debate on that, and it is Bowie. But anyway, I'm running this for Senator Teague. Basically, it does what the title says. What has transpired, members, is there's actually a college in Texarkana, Texas that has been operating this school up there. They are moving, and we're going to transfer this over to the University of Arkansas Community College at Hope Texarkana, which is on the Arkansas side, of course, and they're going to actually run that school up there. So that's what this bill
the bill? Seeing none, he's closed for his bill. Please, no objection. Please roll the vote. Ballinger, Bledsoe, Bond, Caldwell, Cheatham, Chesterfield, Clark, Cooper, Davis, Dismayne, Eades, Elliot, English, Flippo, Flowers, Garner, Hammer, Hendron, Hester, Hickey, Hill, Ingram, Irvin, Blake Johnson, Mark Johnson, Leading, Malik, Pitch, Rayford, Rice, Sample, Stubbafield, Sturge, Teague, Wallace. Any members wish to change their vote?
Hendren. Senate Bill 561 by Senator Hendren. to create the Arkansas Tax Reform Act of 2019 and reform the sales tax, income tax, property tax, and franchise tax laws of the state. Senator Hendren, you're recognized. Thank you, Madam
Governor. Members, this is really taking the task force's final report and the recommendations that came out of that that were not too controversial, putting them all into one bill. There's about six or seven things here that I'll go with fairly quickly. if you have questions I'll be glad to answer them but we did go through it all in in the committee if you look on the front page the title really shows all the different measures that have been taken in order to reform our tax code on page two it shows the goal there on line 20 which is to modernize simplify and ensure fairness to all taxpayers so as we went through the tax code we compared it with other states we look for inefficiencies and this is an effort to correct some of those things so one of the first things that happens and begins on page three and takes a whole lot of the pages of this bill is transferring the franchise tax from the Secretary of State's office, the collection and administration of that, to the Department of Finance Administration. There have been issues with that. Most other states do DF&A and they have a far better ability to collect and track that. There will still be a certification process with the Secretary of State's and most of page, starting in page three, and if you look on page four you see it just lines out Secretary of State and puts in DF&A and again throughout most of the code it puts the responsibility of the management of that tax collection at Department of Finance Administration. You have to make some laws, changes to the law on page 7 regarding DF&A's ability to disclose information about taxpayers so that they could disclose to the Secretary of State whether or not somebody has paid. If you look on page 7, line 19, they have to provide proof of payment so the Secretary of State knows whether or not their franchise is in good standing page 8 is again more of the disclosure language line 13 and 14 are just some grammar cleanup and then starting in line 8 or I'm sorry on page 9 more disclosure that gives them the ability to disclose and also to take action against one that fails to pay their franchise tax so that's we come back to that at the end of the bill but almost all entirely through the bill is really just to transfer the franchise tax collection to Department of Finance Administration from the Secretary of State's office and both of those agencies are okay with that and aware of it. Starting on page nine there were several inconsistencies we found in the way counties assessed and collected property tax which as you know is a huge component of how we fund our school districts and as you also know the state has to make up the difference for equalization and that's why it's so important that the counties do it in a standard way so what this does is it gives the assessment coordination department the ACD starting on page 9 the charge of developing some guidelines and standards that will be used by all the counties to try to standardize how they make determination about what's taxable and what's not it will prescribe forms necessary page 10 monitor the county's compliance and then the thing that it does at the end on page 10 is it allows for them to report back to council or to the General Assembly if we're in session any counties that are not in compliance and then make a recommendation just a recommendation about whether or not there should be a potential withholding of some funds until a county begins to comply and that that was again agreed to by the counties. On page 10 we start the third issue which is this is the first one that really has a fiscal impact. DFNA estimates that what we're going to ask them to do here every two years is going to have a cost of about 800,000 so 400,000 a year and that is to create a report basically going through a methodical review of all of the exemptions discounts credits and deductions relating to state income tax and state sales and use tax one of the things we found when we again compared our tax code with us we're one of the few states that doesn't have a periodic review of these of these exemptions and that's why they piled up for so many years and in fact it hurts our scoring by agencies who rank our tax code if we do not have a process to periodically review these. So we started out with once a year but because of the expense it was changed to once every two years. If you see on bottom page 10 it requires the director to basically make a decision and a recommendation about whether that particular policy exemption credit deduction is worth continuing and that's the analysis that begins on page 11. The other one this is a result of a task force recommendation from Senator Elliott we we noticed that one of her constituents noticed that why is it that we give a tax exemption to billboard advertising but not to billboards that are on transit buses so we looked at that it's about a $50,000 cost so again that's the other one that has a cost to exempt public transit buses just like we do billboards that's at the bottom of page 11. ATVs we talked about a long time everyone was convinced that the agricultural exemption was legitimate but also that there was a lot of abuse in it through working with Farm Bureau we came up with a way that really first we talked about a rebate program that we discovered it to be almost as expensive to manage and administrate that as it would potential savings so we went to a disclosure process and that's what begins on the top page 10 where they have to get a form when they get that exemption that they realize that they're claiming this is for agricultural use and that they're subject to audit to confirm that that's what it's really being used for. Again, the idea being there that you don't get the agricultural exemption for an ATV that you're just taking a four-wheeling. Okay, bottom page 12 and the rest of that, there's several more pages of going back to the franchise tax and how that's transferred to the Department of Finance Administration. One of the things that we saw on the bottom page 14 is there was a lot of trouble with Secretary of State's office, the business will go out of business, notify of dissolution and the franchise tax will continue to be assessed for three or four or five years to where it got to be very expensive for some of these companies. So this gives the taxpayer the ability to demonstrate that they've really been out of business, they're not going to be continued to have taxes and penalties once they were out of business and again that was just something that we found had been a problem in the past. There's some exceptions or there's some ways that DF&A can deal with those who fail to pay beginning on page 16 similar to what they had the Secretary of State's office and then the last part there on like 18 and 19 just allows them to adopt rules and regs to implement this so again two items have fiscal impact most of these are just cut and paste out of the task force's recommendation we looked at for the last couple years I'd be happy to answer any questions are there any
questions on the bill. Any questions? Seeing none, anyone wish to speak for or against the bill? Seeing none, you have closed for your bill. Madam Secretary, any objection
Any members wish to change their vote? Malik is not voting. Hickey is a no. Anybody else want to change their votes? Seeing none, please cast off the ballot. The vote of 32 yeas, 1 nay. The bill passes. Please transmit
to the House. Senator Wallace. Senate Bill 562 by Senator Wallace to amend the law regarding a distiller or manufacturer permit to authorize off-premise sales of venuous liquor, to authorize on-premise sales of venuous liquor by the drink, and to authorize a venuous liquor tasting event. Senator Wallace. Thank you, Madam President. This bill is going to allow us to have wine tasting events in the state of Arkansas. The intent is to be more inclusive and to allow for a permit where you can, if you manufacture, distill, import, transport, store, and you can sell the wine. The exception to this is the area over in the center, Stubblefields area, which is called the River Valley, and they're known as small farms. They have their own rules over there, and this will not affect them at all. What this simply does is allow us to do wine tasting, very similar to what you see now with beer tasting in the Rocktown Distillery over here in Little Rock, Arkansas. And I will take any questions you have. Are there any
questions for Senator Wallace? Senator Johnson? Yes, sir. Senator Wallace, in Little Rock we have at least one distillery. And when I see venous liquor, I think brandy, I think a distilled wine. Does this just mean wine, or does this mean like a, and I'll say their name, Rocktown Distillery has a distillery here in Little Rock, and they make whiskey. They make moonshine. They make what they call, it's kind of a bourbon. It's slightly different from others. Would this allow their events and things like that as well?
have the right to distill, and they can actually do their own tasting of their beverage already. Okay. Thank you, Senator. Thank you, Madam Chair. Any other questions?
All right. Seeing none, anyone wish to speak for or against the bill? Seeing none, you've closed for your bill. All right. Madam Secretary, is there an objection to rolling the vote? No objection. Please roll the vote.
change their vote? Raper is a no. Teague is a no. And Malik is a no. Raper. There we go. Anybody else wish to? Sturge is not voting. Anybody else wish to change their vote? Seeing none, please cast up the ballot. With a vote of 31 yeas. three nays. The bill passes. Please transmit to the House. Senator Malik. Senate Bill 563
by Senator Malik to authorize the Arkansas Agriculture Department to promulgate rules regarding labeling of agricultural products and to receive and investigate complaints and to authorize a civil penalty. Senator Malik, you're recognized. Thank you, Madam Chair. Members, this is really a companion bill to the bill that Representative Hillman had that I handled a few days ago on proper labeling of agricultural products, calling meat, meat, calling rice, rice. This is simply some permissive language that allows the Agriculture Department to develop rules and regs to implement that. It's permissive because now we know that the federal government, USDA and FDA is working on some of this, and if they fix it at the national level, which is preferable, then they wouldn't have to do that, but it does allow for it if it's needed. I'd be happy to answer any questions. Anyone else? Anyone have any questions? Senator Garner, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Madam Chairwoman.
So this, similar to the other one, will allow the board to find people and then put that in a fund they can use for their own reason as well, right? So they're basically getting to determine what can be labeled X, Y, and Z based off the other law that you passed when they promulgate these rules. Is
that correct? It's the same penalty, possibility, and fund that was in the bill of Representative Hillman's. Okay. Is that the one? Okay. Thank you. Any other questions? I appreciate
a good vote. Anyone wish to speak for or against the bill? Seeing none, he has closed for his bill. Is there an objection to rolling the vote? No objection to rolling the vote.
Senator Ballinger is a no. Anyone else wish to change your vote? Seeing none, please cast up the ballot. With a vote of 33 yays, 2 nays, the bill passes. Please transmit to the House. Senator
laws of this state. Thank you, Madam President. Members, Senate Bill 565 is very straightforward if you've read the bill. The American Law Institute annually restates new insurance laws. They basically put out a statement about insurance law. This bill simply says that if something in the restatement is in conflict with Arkansas law, that it does not represent Arkansas public policy. This handles an issue that we've had before where we've discussed what's called an unconstitutional delegation of authority. This just means that a restatement that's issued by that national body does not automatically become law here if it's in conflict with the public policy of the state of Arkansas. That would give us an opportunity to address it before anything would happen. Appreciate a
good vote. Happy to entertain questions. Are there any questions for Senator Rapert? Seeing none, anyone wish to speak for or against the bill? I see none. You've
closed for your bill. Any objection to rolling the vote? No objection. Thank you. Please roll the vote. Ballinger, Bledsoe, Bond, Caldwell, Cheatham, Chesterfield, Clark, Cooper, Davis, Dismayne, Eades, Elliott, English, Flippo, Flowers, Garner, Hammer, Hendron, Hester, Hickey, Hill, Ingram, Irvin, Blake Johnson, Mark Johnson, Letting, Mallett, Pitch, Raper, Rice, Sample, Stubblefield, Sturge, Teague, Wallace. Anybody wish to change their vote? Seeing none, please
571 by Senator Hendren, to create an earned income tax credit, an increased standard deduction, and an individual income tax reduction, and to provide funding for income tax reductions through new taxes on cigarettes and e-cigarettes. Senator Hendren, you're recognized. Thank you, Madam Chairman. Members, Senate Bill 571, I'm
going to go through it, and then I'll explain a little bit about why I think most of you all are familiar with this. So if you got the bill, it starts on page two where it creates an EITC trust fund. Before I go through this bill, I think let me just tell you a little bit of the fundamentals of it. Senator Stubblefield was down here yesterday with the bill and he said one of the things that's frustrating around here is many times on pieces of legislation you end up arguing about the things that are said that are not true more than the facts of the bill. So let me kind of clear up a couple things that are out there. The first thing is that this is a tax increase bill. Every dime that is collected in new taxes is returned to the taxpayers, period. The whole purpose of this trust fund is to make sure that there is a place to collect the revenue so that it can then be redistributed in a responsible way back to the taxpayers now some will say well then that's just a shifting of chairs on the deck and you know what I say to that yes it is the reason is is because the ship is lifting listing very far to one side and sometimes you need to rearrange the deck chairs or you're going to capsize and why do I say that I say that because right now our Medicaid program which those of us that that served on the Health Care Reform Task Force know how much it's costing us, illnesses related directly to smoking are costing us $795 million every year in the state of Arkansas. That's a pretty big highway program right there, just because of smoking-related illnesses. You know how much tobacco money is bringing in? 230. So what does that mean? That means everybody else is paying a half a billion dollars in taxes to compensate for the costs of healthcare directly related to the use of tobacco. So what that means to me is it's time to rearrange some deck chairs. It's time to take the ship and stop it from listing so far towards tobacco. We are one of the most unhealthy states. We have higher rates of tobacco use to the national average. What's going on in our schools with vaping is astounding and somewhat terrifying when you talk to the administrators. Read what happened with the FDA folks meeting with Juul and Altria yesterday, what their comments are about their takeaway from that meeting. What they said basically was they're being dishonest. The industry is being dishonest when they say they're not trying to stop this marketing to kids. So I would argue that it's time to start rearranging the deck chairs. But that is different than saying we're raising tobacco so that we can grow government. It's just not happening. So what is happening? If there is this $500 million disparity, the question is when we begin to rearrange it, where do we put the relief? What this bill does is it says we're going to make low-income earners, medium and low-income families a priority when we start trying to rebalance the tax level. And I think especially in light of what we've done here in this session, it's appropriate. I've supported the drop in the top rate. It was the third part of an overall tax plan to make Arkansas more competitive. That doesn't change the fact that we took $100 million to drop the top rate, that those making less than $50,000 aren't going to see a dime. We've increased the gasoline taxes. It was necessary to help us build roads. But you know who percentage-wise that's going to hurt the most? Those making less than $50,000 a year. We're probably going to put the Internet tax on. Again, we need to do it. Every other state's going to do it. And if we don't, we're going to lose our Main Street businesses. But who's that going to hurt percentage-wise the most? Low and medium-income families. So the starting point of this piece of legislation is it's time to start putting some of the burden where it needs to be, which is on those that are driving up the cost. So it does that by saying we're going to raise the taxes on tobacco, we're going to start taxing vaping, just like we do tobacco, and we're going to take that revenue and we're going to responsibly give it to low and middle income, let them keep more of their money. We're one of the more aggressive states. That's one of the things we learned in our tax reform. We have such low property tax, such high sales tax. Again, who does that more impact? Low and medium income families. So we could have taken this $100 million and we could have dropped the top rates some more. We could have done a capital gains tax. We could have done lots of things. But what this bill does, it says we're going to balance the load a little bit, starting by taking the load off of low and middle income families. So how does it do it? It does it with three different ways. the first one is I want to I want to talk about is on the bottom page two it does a trans standard traditional tax table change just like the three tax cuts that we've done in the last three sessions but it does it on the lowest table this only applies to those making less than twenty two thousand two hundred dollars and what it does is right now their income from forty five hundred dollars to eighty eight hundred and ninety nine dollars is taxed at two percent and that doesn't seem like a whole lot, but if you're making less than $22,000, it matters. So we take that rate and we drop it to 0%. That one change is only going to help people making less than $22,200, and it's going to have a cost to the budget of $16.7 million. If you go to page two, we increased the standard deduction from $2,200 to $3,300. That is the most broad-based tax reform piece, and there's three things. This one is more broad-based, because anybody who claims a standard deduction is going to see an $1,100 increase in their standard deduction, which is going to be $50 to $75, depending on what tax bracket you're in. That one change, which percentage-wise, again, helps low- and middle-income families the most, it has a price tag on the budget of $41.7 million. And then finally, the one that seems to be the most controversial is we're going to begin the process of an earned income tax credit program with a cost of the budget of $38.3 million. That begins on page three. That credit will begin to accrue in calendar year 2021 and be dispensed in calendar year 2022. And the reason that it is delayed a year is, as I said, the way this program works, because here's one of the biggest arguments that people use about sin taxes or taxing a revenue source that is declining is, oh my gosh, you're going to cut the taxes, then the usage is going to drop, and now you're going to have a budget crisis. And I will tell you, we had legislators from some states come and explain to us that they had done that very thing, and it's not a great strategy, and we listened. And this bill doesn't do that. What this bill does is says, we're going to wait and collect a year's worth of proceeds, put it in a trust fund. DF&A is going to determine do we really have the 38 million dollars necessary to fund a 5% EITC. The fiscal impact says they will and the fiscal impact says they'll have almost twice that the first year that we disperse it. And if it's more they can increase that EITC above five. If we have a dramatic downturn in smoking or a dramatic downturn in our economy they can reduce it. So there is almost a 50% cushion for us not to get our budget into a program, into a pinch but it also makes sure that that dot those dollars don't find their way into general revenue but in fact they go back to the taxpayers that's the whole concept of this so that's the three methods rate change standard deduction increase and EITC and I'll talk a little bit of have the practical impact on those in just a minute how is it paid for if you look on page four it says it's paid for with a new special excise tax of 20% upon all retail receipts or proceeds derived from the sale of cigarettes. So depending on what the price of cigarettes is, that 20% can run anywhere from 80 cents to $1.20. The pack of cigarettes are all over the place. We've got, we just have a wide range. That is how it is, how it is done. If you go over to page number five, you're going to see the first thing that happens is there is a transfer of the first fiscal year of $55 million to general revenue, and that is to pay for those two tax cuts that take effect immediately. Beginning in July 2020, you can see that increases to $83.7 million. And you know, this is one of the most interesting parts of this bill, because I did not realize this until we started doing the fiscal impact. As I started talking to DF&A, we had $55 million in there every year, but one of the things they said is, look, if you put a 20% tax on cigarettes, you know what's going to happen. People are going to smoke less. That's what's happened in other states. And so what they do in this bill is they project instead of 140 million packs of cigarettes every year, which is what they're projecting in Arkansas now, this bill is based and this fiscal impact is based on that dropping to 120 million. The other thing that the fiscal impact takes into account, which I had not thought about is the piece of legislation that we passed yesterday, Senator Dismay and Representative Davis' bill that increases the age to 21. Because as you increase the age, less is going to be bought, and that's going to have an impact because of the sales tax and the excise taxes on it now of general revenue. So we had to account for a decline in smoking, which is also going to, on the plus side, what we did not account for is eventually there'll be a decline in health care costs. So that's why it goes up to 83.7 million in July starting in 2020 and then the future years to make it a revenue neutral with regard to the tax cuts and the decline in use. So the cigarette tax is really the big ticket item it pays for about 90% but there is a new tax on e-cigarettes and that begins the bottom page 5. E-cigarettes mean a vapor or e-liquid product as it defined. Basically if you look on the bottom page five, it says it will be taxed at the same time as taxes on tobacco products or the same rate under the Arkansas Tobacco Products Tax Act of 1977. Now let me say one more thing that's out there. I got a text right before I came out here that there's still a lot of confusion. I don't know whether it's intentional or unintentional. I really think most of it's unintentional because when I read the legislation I understand where they get this idea. This is not an inventory tax. This is a tax at the wholesale level. So no user, no shop is going to have to have somebody show up September 1st and say I'm assessing you a tax on all the stuff in your inventory. That's not how a wholesale tax works. I've confirmed this with DF&A and I've confirmed it with the Alcohol Tobacco Control Board. It will not, you will not have your inventory taxed. That will be clear through rules and regs and if we need to clarify it more in the legislation, we will. DF&A's fiscal impact is not based on that. It is based on any other sales tax audit, like I've been through, and anybody that has a business has been through. They show up and they look for invoices to determine how much you bought, and that's what your sales tax audit is based on. So there is no tax on the inventory. So finally, let me kind of say what the impact of this bill is going to be. And I use this example in committee, and I've kind of worked on the numbers a little bit more. So this money is focused towards low-income families. So let's look at a low-income family. A single mom with two kids, works all year for $9.15 an hour, has a gross income of $19,030. The reason I chose that example is because those of you who have problem with the EITC, this is the worst case scenario. What I mean by worst case? Maximum credit. Maximum refundability. The single mom with two kids, she's going to be able to take advantage of the maximum value of this earned income tax credit. But what is going to be the effect of this bill? Right now, she's paying sales tax, she's paying property tax that's booked into her rent, she's paying gas tax that just got increased. Currently, under the current law today, if Senate Bill 571 does not pass, she will have $340 in state income tax due. Okay? Under this bill, those two things that I talked about in this bill are going to kick in. The first one, the rate reduction and the standard deduction increase is going to save her $125 of that $340. So now she has, like I said, that is going to happen immediately. The second half, once the EITC were to kick in, again, she would be eligible for the maximum amount, which would be $291. So what does that mean to her? That means she's going to get, I know this is terrifying to some, but she's going to get a check for $77, dollars. The maximum credit that a single mom with who's going to get is a check for $77. So what has happened to her from the beginning to end of this bill? She's gone from a tax burden of $340 to a check of $77 because of the new tobacco taxes coming there. That's a $420 change in her life situation. That doesn't sound like a whole lot to many, but to somebody who's making $300, $400 a week, that's a whole lot. So now, and here's the thing, I don't think many of us who just say EITC bad have ever stopped to think about it. So why do we say this is about families? Let's look at that same lady or make it a guy who doesn't have any kids. So just a single filer with no kids. They're going to utilize the exact same deduction, but instead of this $291 credit, they're going to get a $27 credit. So instead of a $77 check, they're going to owe $152. They're still going to see a tax reduction, but not nearly as much as somebody who has children. So the EITC really targets the money. There's two criterias to make this thing get to where you have a positive number. You have to be working. And if you have kids, you're one of the few who's going to be subject to maybe getting a refund. And to those who have such trouble with this, I would just ask this question. What if she quits her job? What's going to be the cost then? I can promise you it's going to be more than $77 to the taxpayer if she doesn't work. That's the whole concept in this program. Now the question comes up is, yeah, but you're completely taking all that back if she decides to smoke. So let's just look at it if she decides to smoke. Let's say she smokes a pack a day. Again, the range of this tax, depending on what the retail price could be, from $80 to $1.20. So let's split the difference and say it's $1. A pack a day, that's $365. So it's a $55 increase if she's a mom with two kids. She's still getting a tax decrease. Now, if she has no kids, because she doesn't get much of an EITC, it is about a $200 increase. When you factor the tax cuts with what she's paying for additional tax in cigarettes. So that brings the question, is that fair that those who smoke pay a little bit more so those who don't can get to not have to carry such a heavy load? And then finally let me just say this. Let me just end with this. We've talked about vaping a lot this session. We just passed a bill to fund NCI, but if we don't pass this. There will be no tax on vaping other than the regular sales taxes on everything else when we go home this session. We've gotten more text on vaping probably than almost anything else this session because of this bill and realized vaping is about a seven million dollar impact compared to the hundred and forty billion dollar impact of cigarettes. And you've gotten emails just like I have telling you how how can we do this vaping is a medicine it's a smoking cessation product it's uh it's it's healthy here's uh what was in the news yesterday i told you about that meeting departing departing food and drug administration commit commissioner scott goldia expressed frustration tuesday yesterday over a meeting he had with tobacco and e-cigarette giants altria and jewel last week, saying he believed Altria had been misleading about the motivations behind its business decisions on e-cigarettes. We had a full-page ad here last week about how we're going to fix youth vaping in schools. It's going up 48% by most accounts. Every time I've been to a forum since this session began, school administrators and principals have showed up and said this is a crisis that is beginning in our schools. We are allowing companies to sell flavored nicotine products that are addicting, chemically addicting kids, and we're not charging them any tax like we do snuff or cigarettes or scola. This bill begins the process of correcting that so that, again, I don't care. If people want to choose to smoke or vape, I do care about kids in particular. But adults, this absolutely does not infringe on your right to do that at all. But what it does do is begin to say you can't continue to ask low and middle income families to pay high taxes to cover the health care catastrophes that we know are going to result. So that's why the bill is aired here. I know it's a controversial bill, and it's probably
why we're here, I think. So I'll be happy to answer any questions. Senator Garner. Thank you, Mr. President. So when we ran this on Monday, we got the fiscal impact that morning, even though over the weekend, many people had asked about it. At that meeting, you gave us a draft of a new fiscal impact, because the original one had this as being a net negative. As of right now, the new fiscal impact hasn't been updated on our system. I don't have it. If somebody here has, I'd love to see what the actual numbers are going to be. I have a draft that says the numbers may be one thing or another. It's going to be revenue neutral. Senator, is there a real fiscal impact that we can
think those filed bills and had them amended, especially with large fiscal impacts, are familiar with the fact that every time you amend one of these, DF&A has to go and adjust their fiscal impact. And what they do is they basically amend their fiscal impact to match their amendment. At the committee, I had the fiscal impact and I had the amendment to what it is going to do what the new table and the new chart is going to be and I have a copy of it right here and anybody wants to see it but let me just go beyond that as I said in committee the fiscal impact of the tax cuts was in the newspaper Thursday after our press conference that those numbers did not change the only thing that took us a little while to nail down was what's going to change with regard to the revenue because of the smoking change and because of the vaping change. And it is a big number, so it was important to be right. And so DF&A worked Saturday and Sunday, and we came in early Monday morning, and we finalized it, got a table presented to make sure that the right side of the equation was correct, because that required us to adjust the amount of transfer to general revenue. So yeah, the fiscal impact is available, and the final amended version that will be posted on the website, I don't know when DF&A will finally get it posted. so the there's not
of the committee thank you any other questions any any questions anyone wish to speak uh on the bill senator garner is going to speak against the bill thank you I'm not going to dive into numbers I wish we had accurate ones I wish the public had accurate ones to look
at what I want to think about is real poor people that this is supposed to help. Real people in our district. Those numbers, as Senator Henry said, this will do for that working mom, it's going to be $692 extra a year for her. Every paycheck she gets, if she's a smoker, will be decreased. Let me tell you how real poor people work. They don't wait to the end of the year to do their dividends or to save a little bit then when we get this tax return back. They live week by week by paycheck by paycheck. That disposable income, the stuff they spend their kids on, is this money that we're taking from them every single week. And at the end of the year, you give them more money. Maybe, I don't know, it's $200 less, $200 more. We don't know. when that mom doesn't have that extra money because she has this habit that's going to affect her real people small business owners you know how many vape shops are going to shut down immediately after this comes into law there's a part in the section page 6 16 through 18 wholesale will be taxed immediately the guys and committees were saying 40 000 30 000 100 000 dollars tax burden the day this passes. These aren't the wealthy people who can afford to write a $100,000 check to the state of Arkansas. You know what they're going to do? They're going to fire employees. They're going to shut their shops down. They're going to be hurt. Gas stationers, I live 20 minutes from the Louisiana border. Do you understand how different a carton of cigarettes will be after this. In Louisiana, it's going to be $1.08. Ours is going to be $2.40 after this passes. Every carton, I'll save $10 to $12 to $13, driving 20 minutes away. Who do you think that's going to affect? Missouri, there's this .17 cents per pack. Where do you think those people will go? $22 plus per carton will be driven across state lines. that's the real impact of this bill. That's the real thing. If you want to stop smoking, let's do it. If you think we're paying too much cost on Medicaid since we expanded it to everybody, let's reform Medicaid when it comes to smoking. Let's get people who do this bad habit to have to pay for it themselves rather than this smoking thing that goes against every person in the state of Arkansas. I wish we could say we were robbing Peter and pay Paul, but we're offering Peter, Paul, and all the rest of the disciples to pay him at the end of the year. Senator Hendren said something when he started his speech a while ago, and I want you to listen to the word he said, because it's important. It slipped up on him. Redistribution. This is redistributing wealth from all to a few. This is a bad policy. This will hurt the people we're claiming that we care about. And at the end of the year, when they get that check, okay, good. They'll pay off their credit cards they had to run up while they had to have less income. They'll do more with it. Let's get a bill that we can address. Let's work with the vaping shops and the other ones to decrease the amount of kids' usage. I heard the shop owners. They are stringent on not giving to kids. The only thing you're going to do is hurt state government, hurt the people we represent. This is
a bad bill. Thank you. Anyone else want to speak? Senator Ballinger, anybody for the bill, on the bill? Senator Ballinger, speak against the bill. Thank you, Mr. President. You know, the thing that I would want to address is the issue of the vaping. You know, that's a new thing. You know, the fact that it's growing in schools is probably because it didn't exist just a few years ago. So it's a brand new thing. it is something we ought to be careful about. We ought to pay attention to because we don't know what the health effects could be. But one thing that I'm almost 100% positive, in fact I'm 100% positive, that the effects of a cheeseburger on our cost of Medicaid is more than the effects of vaping at this point. The effects of soda pop on our Medicaid is, as a person who can represent the obese crowd, different versions of obesity. I can tell you that obesity is probably, you know, second, if not the most number one cause of health problems in the state of Arkansas. We are one of the fattest. So why aren't we taxing cheeseburger, potato chips? Why aren't we doing those things? I mean, at some point, I just had a bag of cashews, just had a good conversation with Senator Johnson about whether they're good for you or not good for you. They got a lot of fat. Maybe we need to do a sliding scale and now tax cashews as well. At some point, it's just not really our business, right? Government is terrible, terrible at making the decision about what we're going to do to try to make things healthier. And I think Senator Hedgen acknowledged that when you're taxing vices, It makes it where, you know, it's unstable, where you've got to figure out, you know, how you, I mean, down the road, what's going to happen with this tax cut, but also this, you know, earned income tax credit that we're providing here. I'm, you know, I usually wouldn't, I mean, obviously, not the Senate pro tem, I wouldn't want to speak against this bill. I don't think that that's effective. but in this case I feel like we just need to slow down we're doing stuff that we really shouldn't be doing that we told people back home we wouldn't be doing and I really think that this impacts rural Arkansas worse than it impacts anywhere else I appreciate no vote anyone else want to speak Senator Senator closed I'm sorry Senator Urban do you wish to speak Senator Irving speak for the bell.
Members, when you, I was driving down the road and I heard on the radio and it was a K-8 news and on their page, I believe it was K-8, they had just an alert about the crisis and the epidemic of vaping with our teenagers. I have been contacted by so many mothers in my district that are really concerned about it. This is a tube of lipstick. A flash drive basically is what vapes look like. And they are vaping in classrooms. Some teenagers are vaping up to four pods a day. One pod is equivalent to a whole pack of cigarettes. and so you can imagine the nicotine and what that's doing to our students and to our kids and our teenagers. There's been a 21% increase in the usage of it because it's cool. It's cool and it looks like a flash drive and it's got nicotine in it and they're getting high off the nicotine and they're not paying attention in school and they're passing it around. I had one mom that said, hey, her child said, if you tell on me, I'll get beat up by my friends. And that was in Timbo High School. So I am incredibly concerned about this growing epidemic. I am not sticking my head in the sand. I don't think any of us should stick our head in the sand. I think when this is happening with our teenagers, and we've got to address that. and we have no idea what the public health concern is going to be and so you know that's the part of the bill that I'm very supportive of because I think we have to address it thank you anyone else wish to speak on the bill
ready to get spring break and there's not a better way to start it than a good debate let me just close with a couple things I always hear the cheeseburger cheeseburger argument talk to the healthcare professionals it's it's ludicrous to compare the amount of healthcare costs associated with cheeseburgers compared to what lung cancer and nicotine and addictive products due to our due to our our state it's just it's let me tell you what what's not ludicrous though 22.3% of Arkansas adults smoke so I talked to Senator Garner's point about this tax, the fact is 78% aren't going to get anything except tax relief and low income. The 22% who choose to continue to smoke, that's right, they're going to pay higher taxes because they're breaking our health care system. 6,000 deaths per year in Arkansas due to smoking-related illnesses. Now, the purpose of this bill is not to change behavior, but other states that have done this, including my neighbor 10 miles from my house in Oklahoma raised at a dollar a pack have seen a decline in smoking. The CDC says there's 1.5 million more e-cigarette vapors in 2018 versus 2017. This is an epidemic, and we can either acknowledge it or we can ignore it. This was shocking to me. 27% of high school kids now use tobacco products, and it's growing every day. We need to do something. And I think it's time to start doing something both with fiscal policy and with health care policy. Senator Garner mentioned reforming health care reform, you know, Medicaid. I'm so proud of the work that the health care reform task force did, saving over $835 million out of the traditional Medicaid and the expanded Medicaid program because of the reforms that we came together in place, put together in a special session. We can reform it, but the biggest way that you decline use, particularly for teens and for kids is by increasing the cost. And it's only fair, again, because the cost that is borne, being asked to be borne by the rest of the taxpayers. So I think it's a fair bill, it's a reasonable bill, and I would ask for a good
vote. Senator is closed. Madam Secretary, please call the roll. We have a pair at the desk. Senator Elliott yes. Senator Dismayne no. Ballinger? No. Bledsoe? Bond, Caldwell, Cheatham, Chesterfield, Clark, Cooper, Davis, Davis, Dismayne, no, Eads, Elliot. Elliot is yes. English. Flippo. Flowers. Garner. Hammer. Hendron. Hester. Hickey. Hill. Ingram Irvin Blake Johnson Mark Johnson Letting Malik Pitch Raper Rice Sample Stubbeville Stubblefield Sturge Sturge Teague Teague Wallace Anyone wish to vote or change their vote? Senator Clark is no Senator Stubblefield is aye Senator Ingram is aye Senator Rice is no Anyone else? cast up the ballot? Sound the ballot. I have five hands. One, two, three, four, five. Sound the ballot. 18 yays, 14 nays. The bill did not pass. But the bill passed. Now we have requests to sound the ballot. I would ask that you, they are looking for you in your chair, but I would ask that when they call your name, if you would indicate that you're here that will help them it'll make it a little she's only going to call the eyes Bledsoe, Bond, Cheatham, Cooper, Eads, Elliott was paired, Flowers, Hendron, Hester, Ingram, Irvin Blake Johnson Letting Mallett Pitch Rapert Steverfield Wallace All present, the bill passes and the final was same as before transmit to the house 18 yays, 14 nays The bill passes, transmit to the House Senator Letting Senator Letting is recognized Senate Bill 586 by Senator Letting to allow a manufacturer to sponsor and provide advertising materials to a non-profit organization holding a large attendance facility permit. Senator Lighting is recognized. Thank you, Mr. President. Colleagues, this one's much simpler.
There's no opposition to this bill. It just amends ABC law to allow manufacturers to sponsor signage in large audience venues. Think of Murphy, venues that are operated by nonprofits. So
think of Murphy Arts District down in El Dorado, The Amp, up in Rogers. Like I said, there is no known opposition to this bill, and I'd appreciate a good vote. Any questions? Anyone wish to speak on the bell? Any objection to rolling the vote? Please roll the vote. Blake Johnson, Mark Johnson, Letting, Malik, Pitch, Raypert, Rice, Sample, Stubbefield, Sturge, Teague, Wallace. Anyone wish to change their vote? Senator Raypert is no. Senator Malik is no. Senator Teague is no. Anyone else? Senator Flippo is not voting. Senator Stubblefield is no. Anyone else? Senator Sturge not voting. Anyone else? Cast up the ballot. 29 yays, four nays. The bill passes transmit to the House. Senator Wallace, House Bills for third reading of passage. House Bill 1251 by Representative Eubanks and Senator Wallace to amend the definition of practice of optometry and to modernize the practice of optometry. Senator Wallace is recognized. Thank you, Governor. remember this when this bill passes and it goes into effect the patient the Arkansan still has the option he can go to an optometrist or he can go to an ophthalmatist nothing changes on that what this bill does do is it narrowly allows the doctors of optometry to perform minor procedures that are routinely done in an office that they're educated to do and it's not going to broaden the scope of practice that they're already treating. Now the laws govern the practice of optometry have not updated in more than 20 years. Science has improved, technology has improved in those 20 years. It's going to add a section to our code which lists the specific procedures that optometrists will be allowed to perform. And it requires that the optometrists that do this be credited or have credentials to be able to do this. It requires optometrists who perform authorized laser procedures to report the outcome of those procedures to not only the Board of Optometry, but also to the Department of Health. This bill lists five minimal, non-invasive procedures. These procedures can be done in your doctor's office without general enthese... I can't say the whole word today. Entheseous. And contrary to what you may have heard, these are procedures that our optometrists are trained to do. Why is it needed? Well, rural Arkansas. It's going to allow more cure for people in rural Arkansas. Doctors of optometry serve patients all over our state. We currently have practices in 80% of the counties. Whereas with ophthalmathy, those full practices are only about 30%. in. It's going to allow laser technology to treat conditions that our autometrists are already doing. They're already using these tools every day. It's going to cut down on waiting periods. Quite often our patients, our fellow citizens are having to wait months to be able to get in to see an eye surgeon. This bill will allow them to go to the autometrist, the person they've been going to, the person they trust, and get the same procedure done. We talk a lot about education of the autometrist. They go through a four-year medical school. They have over 5,000 hours of experience focusing strictly on eye health care. They follow the clinical guidelines from the American Ophthalmology Society and American Optometry Association, just as others do. Optometrists are doctors. They're not just, they're being laid out like they're a 32-hour technician, temp laborer. They've gone through 5,000 hours of training. They're doctors of eye care. They're taught how to examine their eye, how to look for cancer. You know, the key point is these five procedures we're talking about. The patient can walk in. He can set his keys down, sit in his doctor's chair. and at the end of the procedure when he gets up he can pick up his keys and walk outside 18 states already have a higher scope of practice than arkansas four states are currently doing the procedures we're talking about over 70 000 cases have been done of the procedures we're talking about out. There's no documentation that shows that our optometrist cannot do these procedures. No reported incidents. Again, when this is all said and done, the patient is going to have the option of where he wants to go he can go see his optometrist who may only be 15 minutes away or he may choose to go see somebody that may be two hours away but it's going to be left to Arkansans for their choice and with that I'll take questions any questions for the senator any at all anyone wish to speak on this bill against it for Senator Bledsoe wishes to speak against bill. Senator Bledsoe is recognized. And then I'll go to Senator Hill for the bill. Senator Bledsoe.
Thank you, Mr. President. Ladies and gentlemen, I rise to speak against the bill, not because I don't care and love those optometrists that are from my own area, my own home, home, and not because I don't respect and revere the Senator bringing the bill, but I have a true concern about the quality of medicine that we may be lowering by passing this. And let me explain. As you know, I have not, I think this is my second time in 10 years to speak against a bill. I think it's a very serious thing, but I am so concerned that we get it right. Octometrists are doctors of optometry, not doctors of medicine. They contribute an invaluable service to patients. There's no doubt about it, but training certified, Their training certifies them in eye refraction and fitting of glasses and contact lenses. Unfortunately, Medicare considers this a routine test and therefore does not approve the test, making it a non-approved service except under certain circumstances. Many commercial insurances have followed suit and considers the test a non-covered service. Well, what does that mean? It means that it's a problem for the optometrists. They're not getting paid for that. And I have wondered, that's their bread and butter, and now they're not getting paid for it. And I have had to wonder, is this part of what we're doing here? Optometry training consists of a four-year curriculum that is varying degrees that allows students to observe ophthalmologists performing eye surgery. How many of those hours that we just heard about have they had in actually operating on the lid and on the eye? A true residency program in any surgical discipline requires hands-on performing. in incremental fashions under the direct care of a trained surgeon, an ophthalmologist who has gone to medical school, who has done, and let me back up. An optometrist goes to college for four years. He goes to optometry school for four years. A medical student goes to medical school, goes to college for four years, goes to medical school four years, and then does a four-year residency program to be able to operate on the eye. Optometry school does not require this hands-on approach because their optometric teachers are not trained to do that, ladies and gentlemen. Who is going to train the students if the teacher is not trained to do them? And let me repeat, optometrist instructors don't have that kind of training. Only ophthalmologists can do this. ophthalmology residents have performed an enormous amount of eye surgical procedures all under the supervision of trained physicians. The main lesson learned in a residency program is not only your skill, but your decision making and treatment and knowing your limitations. To state that you can learn, and I understood what the senator said, But to state that you can learn in a weekend course is an affront to medicine, but most of all, an affront to patient care. He has mentioned the hours. How many hours did they have in surgical care, in the care of the eye? If you damage that eyelid and it doesn't close properly, then you have to wear a patch. you have to have moisture in that eye it's a very serious thing the public frequently assumes that if the legislature approves a new subgroup of persons to perform surgery then it must be okay many members of the general public do not know the difference between a doctor of optometry and a doctor of medicine with specialty training in ophthalmology, they don't know the difference. How many of us know the difference? There's a big difference in the training that goes into a person that has the responsibility of operating on the eye. He talks about lasers. He talks about what they're doing now. If they are doing some of this now, then they are not doing it under the law. The bill is not about increasing accessibility to eye care. It's not about that. Affordability, no. Nor patient choice. It's about economics. The discussion has turned into a turf war between two groups, both of whom perform an essential service. But to me, this is a patient care issue that is setting precedence, and this is only the start. If education and training do not matter, then why do we have medical school? Why do we ask our young people to go an extra four years and sometimes an extra six years to do the things that others are wanting to do without the education and the training. But let me just tell you what I think will happen. If this passes, I believe that in an outpatient or office setting with no appropriate accountability, the initial happening will be the overusage of acquired equipment like a laser. In other words, using it unnecessarily, such as treating inconsequential skin lesions where even though the patient was unhurt, it was not needed. There was no need to have it done. Another thing is clinical judgment cannot be learned in an abbreviated course. Misdiagnosis, delayed diagnoses, and unnecessary surgery and procedures done will hurt and not help a patient. I believe that will happen. Another thing is learning how to perform a procedure is important, but it's only part of training. This whole bill implies that it is minor surgery and can easily be learned. But let me tell you what Dr. Gilbert Campbell, Campbell, who was the former chair and professor of surgery at UAMS, preached to his surgical residents. I know that he did it. I've heard too many residents say that when you got around Dr. Campbell and he stressed the surgical disciplines and holding up a standard of Excellence, he said, there is no such thing as minor surgery. There are only
you do not take any surgical procedure lightly since terrible outcomes can occur during the simplest of procedures. Well, what about responsibility? we as legislators are facing an awesome responsibility in what we're voting on today to vote affirmatively is diluting training for patient care and basically saying that we know more than the professionals how can we trust our physicians and other health care providers for our health needs, but distrust them when it comes to advising us on the importance of training. If this bill passes, it will mark the largest setback in medical care since I have been in the Senate. The message we send to the citizens of Arkansas, it's loud and it's very clear. Education does not matter in health care, nor does training. Please, by voting against this bill, let us say today that as much as we respect and like our optometrists, we would rather they wait to bring this bill back when they can show us that their new curriculum in their college of optometry and their new residency program that trains them to do the surgery, which may be given by an ophthalmologist, that this will cause them to be better and better trained. And we can look at this bill again in two years, and if they can show that they have had the training under those that actually do surgery on the eye, no matter how minor it is. And if it's your eye, it is not minor. And I would say it's not minor to the people in Arkansas. And I would ask that you would vote this down. Thank you. Senator
Hill is recognized in favor of the bill, and then Senator Hammer is going to speak on the bill. okay thank you governor it shouldn't take very long what i have to do what i want
to talk about is a real life experience you know this is what i consider the fear factor bill the what if bill i've heard more what else and it might happen it's whatever with what i'm going to tell you about is a real to life fact my dad is 88 years old he cannot drive i am only 20 25 miles from Little Rock where we have lots of ophthalmologists. Okay. What the fact is that we face is I'm an only child. He can't drive. He had a minor iris surgery, which is one of these. I had to take him to five different doctor appointments. The first time when he was diagnosed by the optometrist. Second time we had to drive to Little Rock to ophthalmologist for the checkup. Had to go back for the minor surgery which is a third time had to go back for a follow-up after that surgery then I had to go back and take him back to his ophthalmologist that is five times how many people can take off five different times to take an 88 year old person to the doctor that was money out of my pocket to do that for him I had to have it done with a minor surgery I love my dad love my family this would make it a lot better. I could have done
this in two trips. Thank you, sir. Senator Hammer is going to speak on the bill, and then Senator Bond against the bill. And I've got Senator Irvin down against the bill. Anybody else? Okay, Senator
Hammer. Thank you, Governor. Members, I'll let you make up your own mind. We'll not try to influence you, but I did want to bring out one thing that was addressed in public health, and we had Marty and Jill come down to address the point. You have a handout that was given to you on your desk today, and in that handout, it challenges the constitutionality of us as a committee being able to do that because of the separation of powers issue. Marty reassured us that it is okay that we're doing what we're doing. That's the one thing I want you to know, because when we get stuff handed out to us, we need to be, you know, hundred percent accurate about what's handed out to us but the other thing I want you to know is this that was brought out in the committee before they can do anything before they can do anything that we would choose if you choose to vote for this it will have to run through the rules and regs process and we will have the final stop as far as what is expected in order for them to meet the level that gives the comfort in order to feel like the optimal that the optometrists are able to perform this so that's just one bit of information came out the public health meeting want to make sure you knew that this will have to go through
bill. Thank you members and Senator Bledsoe did a very good job I think outlining a lot of my issues as well against the bill. I do want to say though that there is real life issues and this is real life stories and in public health we had a real life patient that was damaged due to an optometrist doing laser surgery on her eyes. Her testimony was very real It was very powerful. She traveled to Louisiana and had laser surgery performed on her eyes, and now she is, I believe, cannot see or is legally blind with that definition. These are high-powered lasers. This is not something to be taken lightly. When you talk about minor procedures, no, these are not minor procedures. And the reason why you have a hand on your desk is because there are CPT codes. CPT codes classify these as either minor surgeries or major surgeries. These, according to the CPT codes that you have to code, are major surgeries. Let me explain to you why that is. Many times if somebody presents, as a patient presents to a physician about something that's dealing with their eyes, and there were pictures that were given to us on what these lesions are, these pimples of the eye you might refer to, or lesions. These are very serious issues. The only two procedures by law right now that an optometrist can do by law is to remove an eyelash and remove a foreign body. That's like me and you taking some tweezers and removing a splinter, right that's very very different than taking a scalpel to the tissue that's around your eye most doctors won't do that they'll send that to dermatology to even plastics because i'm not going to mess around with this tissue around your eye it's incredibly incredibly sensitive and so a lot of times those are referred and sometimes they're referred out to even plastic surgery because of where they are located. There is a conflict, and Dr. Westfall, the Dean of College of the Medicine at UAMS, who is also a graduate of West Point and was at Harvard, testified against the bill. He is the Dean of College of Medicine at UAMS. He showed pictures of the scalpel surgeries that we're talking about. That requires fine-tuning of your hands. That does require follow-up, Senator Hill from the ophthalmologist. We want to make sure that there's no infection that's going on with that surgery. We want to make sure that if there's an injection, that we're safely giving that injection. This is not, these are not procedures that can be utilized with topical anesthesia. These are injectable anesthesia procedures. That's very serious. And when you're talking about injecting near your eye, it is very sensitive and they could get into your eyeball. And so it requires a lot of training. It requires a lot of skill and a lot of experience. So no, these are not minimally invasive. They are not non-invasive. They're very invasive. And these are major surgeries. And so 32 hours versus thousands and thousands and thousands hours is the difference in what we're talking about here. And at the end of the day, I have to ask myself this question. I have two eyes, you have two eyes, but would I sit my child in that chair for the first procedure? And the answer to that is no. So if I will not sit my child in that chair for the first procedure, I'm not going to vote for any other citizen of the state of Arkansas to sit in that chair either. And with that, I would ask you to thoughtfully and seriously consider your vote on this
to speak in favor, then Senator Bond. So I'll just be brief. I sat in and listed the testimony from the lady that had had surgery that went bad, and what she testified to, that procedure is not permissible within the law that we're passing. It's that simple. She had a bad experience, not to do with
quickly, I know everybody's ready to vote. As Charles Barkley, I think, infamously said, the only minor surgery is when it happens on somebody else. And there is, Senator Hammer brought out the legal opinion that had come up, and I think the first part of that legal opinion that says there's a conflict between the bill and the existing statute is correct. I kind of agree. The second part I don't agree with, but I think there is a conflict in the bill and existing law as to what can be done. And let me say this, this has been brought up before. We should be, in my opinion, in this body, one, embracing these folks who have spent their lives getting a tremendous amount of education, many of them taking out loans uh becoming medical doctors it's a big deal if anything what we should be doing is trying to train more of those people and incentivizing them to rural arkansas as best we can and i think there's a lot of people in this body that want to do that we shouldn't be offering something less to rural arkansans in the name of access in my opinion all right and this is a safety issue. Let's trust in our doctors who are trained as medical doctors to do these procedures and put patient safety above these scope of practice battles. Anybody else want to speak?
Senator, are you closed? Wish to close? Thank you, Governor. First thing I want to do is for everybody to hear me say ophthalmology, so you know I can say it. Our students of optometry today are trained in these procedures. We have students that are worried about coming to Arkansas because they're not going to be allowed to, under our current law, allowed to do the procedures that they are trained in. It's not for them a 32-hour continuing ed course. They are trained in this course. We have 430 optometrists. I'm sorry, optometrists, and we have approximately 115 optometrists, and I got that word goofed up again, but our folks, our people out there have more optometrists available to them, and at the end of the day, here's what's really important, that citizen of Arkansas is going to have his choice or her choice of where they want to go. We're not forcing them to do anything. We're giving them more options, and more options is good for Arkansas. And I'm closed. Senator, it's closed. Madam Secretary, please call the roll. We have a pair at the desk. Senator
Ballinger? Ballinger? Bledsoe? Bond? Caldwell? Cheatham. Chesterfield. Clark. Cooper. Davis. Dismayne. Eads. Elliot. No. English. Aye. Flippo. Aye. Flowers. Aye. Garner. Aye. Hammer. Aye. Hendren. Hendren. Hester. Aye. Hickey. Yes. Hill. Yes. Ingram. Aye. Irvin. Aye. Blake Johnson. Aye. Mark Johnson. Aye. Letting? Mallet? Mallet? Pitch? No. Riper? Aye. Rice? Aye. Sample? No. Stevifil? Stevifil? Sturge? Aye. Teague? No. Wallace? Aye. Anyone who didn't vote wish to vote? Aye. Anyone wish to change their vote? Anyone over here? Senator Stubblefield is aye. Anybody else over here? Over here, Senator Malik is aye. Senator Cheatham is aye. Anybody else over here? Senator Disman is no. Okay. Cast up the ballot. 25 yays, 8 nays. The bill is passed. Return of the House. Senator... Do we have five hands? We do not. We do not. Senator Stubblefield, we're going to pass up. Senator Henry is
recognizing. Members, I know it's ready to start spring break. What I'd like to do is stop the House bills right here, except Senator Rayford asked to have his move because it's got to go back to House Concur, the 9-1-1 bill. What's the... So I'd like to move that we consider House Bill 1564, and then we'll adjourn. That's going to make for a fairly long day Monday, and I don't think we have any budget bills.
You've heard the motion to suspend the calendar and immediately consider House Bill 1564? Yep. Heard the motion. Any objection? Any question? Motion passed without objection. Senator Clark is recognized. Senate Judiciary is still meeting 15
there. We will have announcements after we finish. Senator Rayford. We are committing on engrossed bills to whom was deferred House Bill 1564 by Representative Gray, compared to the engrossed copy of the original, and find the same correctly engrossed. Senator Jason Rayford. Thank you, members. members, you should have, it may not be prominent for you, but
on your desks is actually information of the breakdown of all the revenue for this bill. As you know, this bill actually came out early, early on in the session. It has been amended to include some different provisions to make the bill better. We did not have anybody appear in committee that actually spoke against the bill. The bottom line is this is the Arkansas Public Safety Act. It actually passed out of the House community unanimously with 81 votes on the floor. This bill went from originally at about a 38 million dollar revenue bill down to about 24 million dollars that will be raised now that has been amended. The main thing is the high cost fund which is the most contentious part of the bill has been amended out of the bill. This still has the provision to take the PSAPs from 127 down to 77 we amended the bill and committee to satisfy request in the house that simply gives the option by two-thirds vote that the new board that is put together to handle this situation could lower or raise the amount of PSAPs if they have to by two-thirds vote so that simply gives them the ability if there was a situation that they needed to return to because some sort of isolation that they could. That would be used rarely, of course, with two-thirds. This bill is going to allow for upgrades to accommodate 9-1-1 equipment for us to have next generation 9-1-1. This is also going to fund AWIN. And this actually, the bottom line on this is it takes it from 65 cents to $1.30 on the cell phones, VoIP, and non-traditional phones. It does not change landlines, and it takes the prepaids to 10% of their transaction. Happy to answer any questions if you have
more on the bill. Senator Rappert, Madam Secretary, please proceed with the reading, third reading. House Bill 1564 by Representative Gray, an act to establish the Public Safety Act of 2019 to amend the Arkansas Public Safety Communications Act of 1985 to develop a next generation 9-11 system. Any questions for Senator Jason Raper? Any questions at all? It may be your last chance before spring break to get a question in. Thank you, members. Appreciate a good vote. Anyone wish to speak? Anyone object to rolling the vote? Madam Secretary, roll the vote. Ballinger, Bledsoe, Bond, Caldwell, Cheatham, Chesterfield, Clark, Cooper, Davis, Dismang, Eads, Elliot, English, Flippo, Flowers, Garner, Hammer, Hendron, Hester, Hickey, Hill, Ingram, Irvin, Blake Johnson, Mark Johnson, Letting, Mallet, Pitch, Rayford, Rice, Sample, Stubfield, Sturge, Teague, Wallace. Does anyone wish to vote or change their vote, Senator Garner? It's a no. Senator Hester is no. Senator Dismayne is no. Senator Teague is not voting. Anyone else over here? We've got you, Senator Wallace. We've got to get you some glasses back there. Senator Flippo, not voting. Anyone else? Anyone else? Cast up the ballot. 29 yays, 3 nays. The bill is passed. Return the bill to the House from whence it came. Announcements. Sorry for hitting you. Senator Sample. Senator Sample has an announcement. I'm sure it's important.
It is. Please pay attention. The retirement committee will meet at 9 o'clock. Monday morning in Big Mac 8, and come expecting a pretty long meeting because we're going to deal with House Bill 1173. Thank
Senator Clark. I want to let you know, I've showed it to several of you, but I have got the proofs of the new Senate coin for you to see. As many of you as possible would like to look at them so we can go ahead and get them ordered. Some of you expressed disappointment that my face was not on the back. Who was that? We can, I can name names, but
there's still Mount Rushmore, Senator Bledsoe. Thank you, Mr. President. The executive committee of ALC will meet on Monday at 1230 in room 205. Thank you. Senator
Hendren is recognized. Oh, sorry. 1 o'clock Monday. 1 o'clock. Anyone else? Anyone else? Anyone else? Senate is adjourned until 1 o'clock Monday, subject to the clearing of the desk.
Senator Bart Hester moved to place Senate Bill 576 on the amendment calendar so it could be engrossed and run on Monday, and the motion was carried without objection.
[26:49][26:55][27:07]
SR22 Hammer TO RECOGNIZE MR. AL HUNT FOR HIS EFFORTS IN ADVOCATING FOR RESPECTFUL LANGUAGE ON BEHALF OF HIMSELF AND OTHERS WITH INTELLECTUAL AND DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILITIES.
38:33 - 44:5815 segments2 speakers
Senator Kim Hammer asked to suspend the rules to present SR 22 honoring Mr. Al Hunt for advocating respectful language for people with disabilities; the suspension was approved without objection and the resolution was adopted by voice vote.
[38:46][38:51][39:19][39:52][40:26][40:57][41:08]
SB4 #1 T. Garner TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS LEGISLATIVE STUDY ON VETERANS AFFAIRS.
44:58 - 48:2012 segments4 speakers
An amendment to Senate Bill 4 (creating the Arkansas Legislative Study on Veterans Affairs) was adopted without objection, and the underlying bill was then rolled and passed unanimously, 35-0.
[45:51][46:19][46:22][46:39][46:42][46:53]
SB250 #1 A. Clark TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING EDUCATIONAL NEGLECT; AND TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING REPORTS OF EDUCATIONAL NEGLECT MADE TO THE CHILD ABUSE HOTLINE.
48:20 - 53:4713 segments3 speakers
Senator Alan Clark’s amendment to Senate Bill 250 (amending the law on educational neglect) was adopted without objection, and the bill itself was rolled and passed unanimously, 35-0.
[48:42][49:10][49:26][49:42]
SB318 #1 B. Davis TO PROHIBIT UNLAWFUL FEMALE GENITAL MUTILATION OF A MINOR; TO CREATE AWARENESS PROGRAMS CONCERNING AND STATISTICAL TRACKING OF UNLAWFUL FEMALE GENITAL MUTILATION; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
53:47 - 50:30
Senate Bill 318, introduced by Senator Breanne Davis to prohibit unlawful female genital mutilation of minors and create related programs, was rolled and passed unanimously, 35-0.
[53:50][54:21][54:59]
SB252 #1 K. Hammer TO MANDATE INSURANCE COVERAGE FOR TREATMENT OF PEDIATRIC AUTOIMMUNE NEUROPSYCHIATRIC DISORDERS ASSOCIATED WITH STREPTOCOCCAL INFECTION AND PEDIATRIC ACUTE-ONSET NEUROPSYCHIATRIC SYNDROME.
50:30 - 55:189 segments2 speakers
Senator Kim Hammer presented an amendment to Senate Bill 252 requiring insurance coverage for PANS/PANDAS treatment; the amendment was adopted without objection.
[50:44][51:17][52:15][52:49][53:06][53:19]
SB291 #1 Rapert TO ALLOW FOR AFFILIATE TRANSFER BETWEEN INSURERS.
55:18 - 55:413 segments2 speakers
Senator Jason Rapert’s amendment to Senate Bill 291 (allowing affiliate transfers between insurers) was adopted without objection.
[55:25][55:28][55:30]
SB457 #2 B. Ballinger TO REGULATE THE ADMINISTRATION OF REAL PROPERTY OF THE STATE AND POLITICAL SUBDIVISIONS OF THE STATE.
55:41 - 56:585 segments3 speakers
Senator Bill Ballinger’s amendment to Senate Bill 514 (regulating state real-property administration) was adopted without objection.
[56:00][56:09][56:30]
SB573 #1 G. Leding CONCERNING PROGRAMS AVAILABLE TO MINORS IN A STATE CORRECTIONAL FACILITY; CONCERNING PAROLE DISCHARGE FOR OFFENDERS WHO ARE MINORS; AND CONCERNING THE REINSTATEMENT OF CERTAIN RIGHTS FOR MINORS WHO ARE OFFENDERS.
56:30 - 57:083 segments2 speakers
Senator Greg Leding’s amendment to Senate Bill 573 (programs for minors in correctional facilities) was adopted without objection.
[56:35][56:46]
SB574 #1 K. Hammer TO REQUIRE A CANDIDATE FOR AN ELECTED OFFICE TO FILE A SWORN STATEMENT CONCERNING THE CANDIDATE'S TAX PAYMENT STATUS AND CRIMINAL HISTORY; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
SB576 Hester TO REFORM THE TAX LAWS CONCERNING THE LEVY AND COLLECTION OF SALES AND USE TAX, THE APPORTIONMENT AND ALLOCATION OF INCOME FOR TAX PURPOSES, CORPORATE INCOME TAX RATES, AND NET OPERATING LOSSES; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1564 #1 M. Gray Rapert TO ESTABLISH THE PUBLIC SAFETY ACT OF 2019; TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS PUBLIC SAFETY COMMUNICATIONS ACT OF 1985; AND TO DEVELOP A NEXT GENERATION 911 SYSTEM.
58:37 - 59:324 segments2 speakers
Senator Bart Hester’s amendment to Senate Bill 576 (tax-law reform) was adopted without objection.
[58:42][58:48]
Senator Jason Rapert sought personal privilege to move HB 1564 to the end of the calendar; the amendment to the bill was adopted without objection.
[58:42][58:48][58:56][59:19]
SB396 Rapert TO AMEND THE STATUTES CONCERNING THE BOOKS AND RECORDS REQUIREMENTS UNDER THE ARKANSAS INSURANCE CODE; AND TO MODIFY THE TRADE PRACTICES ACT UNDER THE ARKANSAS INSURANCE CODE.
1:13:56 - 1:15:113 segments2 speakers
Senator Jason Rapert’s SB 396, amending insurance-code record-keeping requirements, was rolled and passed unanimously, 35-0.
[1:14:09][1:14:23][1:14:46]
SB401 B. Johnson CONCERNING APPLICATIONS BY THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY TO THE UNITED STATES CONGRESS UNDER THE PROVISIONS OF UNITED STATES CONSTITUTION, ARTICLE V.
1:15:11 - 1:22:3229 segments6 speakers
Senator Johnson introduced SB 401, proposing a 15-year aggregation period for Article 5 convention calls that would begin after April 1 2019 and could be revisited by future legislatures.
[1:15:19][1:15:51]
SB487 Elliott TO CONDUCT AN ASSESSMENT AND AUDIT OF THE CULTURE AND CLIMATE OF THE DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTION.
1:22:32 - 1:26:069 segments2 speakers
Senator Joyce Elliott presented SB 487, directing the hiring of a consultant to conduct a comprehensive assessment and audit of the Arkansas Department of Corrections to improve accountability.
[1:22:45][1:23:22][1:23:53][1:23:58][1:24:27][1:24:57]
Senator Ballinger spoke in favor, noting the bill would empower the Penal and Corrections subcommittee and could yield cost-saving recommendations.
[1:23:58][1:24:27][1:24:57]
The Senate rolled the vote and adopted the measure unanimously, 35 yeas to 0 nays.
[1:25:30][1:26:01]
SB492 T. Garner TO PROMOTE HOSPITALITY AND TOURISM; TO ESTABLISH AREAS OF A CITY OR TOWN THAT HIGHLIGHT RESTAURANT, ENTERTAINMENT, AND HOSPITALITY OPTIONS; TO ESTABLISH TEMPORARY OR PERMANENTLY DESIGNATED ENTERTAINMENT DISTRICTS.
1:26:06 - 1:30:4311 segments3 speakers
Senator Trent Garner introduced SB 492, authorizing cities and towns to create temporary or permanent entertainment districts that would permit regulated alcohol sales and related activities.
[1:26:26][1:26:36][1:27:07][1:27:40][1:28:11]
Senators discussed examples such as the Murphy Art District and raised concerns about youth access, while the Chair fielded questions before moving to a roll call.
[1:28:20][1:28:43][1:28:56][1:29:13]
The roll call produced 23 yeas and 8 nays, passing the bill to the House.
[1:30:02][1:30:33]
SB524 B. Ballinger TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING ELECTRONIC VOTING EQUIPMENT; AND TO AUTHORIZE THE STATE BOARD OF ELECTION COMMISSIONERS TO PERFORM POST ELECTION AUDITS OF VOTES TABULATED ELECTRONICALLY.
1:30:43 - 1:32:434 segments1 speaker
Senator Blake Ballinger offered SB 524, which would permit the State Board of Election Commissioners to conduct random post-election audits of electronic voting equipment in three counties each year and to investigate any suspected violations.
[1:31:05][1:31:38][1:32:09]
The Chair explained the bill’s development with the Secretary of State’s office and County Clerk’s Association and asked for a vote.
[1:31:38][1:32:09]
The Senate approved the measure by a vote of 34 yeas to 1 nay.
[1:32:09]
SB527 Bledsoe TO REQUIRE A HEALTHCARE PAYOR TO DISCLOSE ON A MEMBER IDENTIFICATION CARD WHETHER A HEALTH BENEFIT PLAN IS INSURED OR SELF-FUNDED; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
1:32:43 - 1:36:067 segments2 speakers
Senator Cecile Bledsoe presented SB 527, requiring health-care payors to disclose on member ID cards whether a plan is insured or self-insured so that providers and patients can determine which legal regime applies.
[1:33:12][1:33:48][1:34:20][1:34:54]
The Chair noted there was no known opposition and opened the floor for questions before moving to a roll call.
[1:34:58][1:35:36]
The bill passed unanimously with 35 yeas and 0 nays.
[1:35:36]
SB547 B. Johnson TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE DIVISION OF PROPERTY IN AN ACTION FOR DIVORCE.
1:43:28 - 1:47:139 segments4 speakers
Senator Blake Johnson moved SB 547 to add an additional exception to the definition of marital property, allowing property improved with marital funds to be considered in divorce proceedings.
[1:43:44][1:44:17][1:44:27][1:44:35][1:44:51][1:45:22]
The Chair fielded a brief question period before proceeding to a roll call.
[1:45:52][1:46:22]
The Senate adopted the amendment by a vote of 25 yeas to 4 nays.
[1:46:22]
SB557 Teague TO DESIGNATE WASHINGTON, ARKANSAS, AS THE BIRTHPLACE OF THE BOWIE KNIFE, ARKANSAS HERITAGE SITE.
1:55:40 - 1:57:308 segments4 speakers
Senators Jimmy Hickey and Jim Teague introduced SB 557 to designate Washington, Arkansas as the birthplace of the Bowie Knife and create an Arkansas Heritage Site.
[1:56:12][1:56:15][1:56:27][1:56:47][1:56:55]
SB561 J. Hendren TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS TAX REFORM ACT OF 2019; AND TO REFORM THE SALES TAX, INCOME TAX, PROPERTY TAX, AND FRANCHISE TAX LAWS OF THE STATE.
SB562 D. Wallace TO AMEND THE LAW REGARDING A DISTILLER OR MANUFACTURER PERMIT; TO AUTHORIZE OFF PREMISES SALES OF VINOUS LIQUOR; TO AUTHORIZE ONPREMISES SALES OF VINOUS LIQUOR BY THE DRINK; AND TO AUTHORIZE A VINOUS LIQUOR TASTING EVENT.
2:05:32 - 2:09:0212 segments3 speakers
Senator D. Wallace introduced SB 562 to permit off-premises and on-premises sales of wine and to authorize wine-tasting events, noting that the measure would not affect the River Valley small-farm exemption.
[2:05:40][2:06:15]
Senator Mark Johnson asked whether the bill would also cover distilleries such as Rocktown Distillery, and the chair clarified that the legislation is limited to wine and does not change existing distilling rights.
[2:06:41][2:06:48][2:07:18][2:07:25][2:07:32]
After a brief question period, the committee rolled the vote and recorded 31 yeas and 3 nays, passing the bill and ordering it transmitted to the House.
[2:07:42][2:07:56][2:08:24][2:08:27]
SB563 Maloch TO AUTHORIZE THE ARKANSAS AGRICULTURE DEPARTMENT TO PROMULGATE RULES REGARDING LABELING OF AGRICULTURAL PRODUCTS AND TO RECEIVE AND INVESTIGATE COMPLAINTS; AND TO AUTHORIZE A CIVIL PENALTY.
2:09:02 - 2:11:388 segments3 speakers
Senator Malik presented SB 563, which would empower the Arkansas Agriculture Department to adopt labeling rules for agricultural products and to impose civil penalties, describing it as permissive legislation that fills gaps if federal action is insufficient.
[2:09:36][2:10:00]
Senator Trent Garner sought clarification that the bill would allow the department to allocate penalty revenues to a fund, and the chair confirmed this aligns with a companion bill previously considered.
[2:10:13][2:10:23][2:10:35]
The committee rolled the vote, approving the measure by a 33-yea, 2-nay margin and directing it to the House.
[2:10:48][2:11:22]
SB565 Rapert CONCERNING THE PUBLIC POLICY OF THE STATE OF ARKANSAS UNDER THE INSURANCE LAWS OF THIS STATE.
2:11:38 - 2:13:368 segments3 speakers
Senator Jason Rapert explained SB 565, stating that it would prevent the American Law Institute’s Restatements of Insurance Law from superseding Arkansas public policy when conflicts arise.
[2:11:47][2:11:54][2:12:27]
No members requested further discussion, and the chair proceeded to roll the vote, which passed overwhelmingly with 34 yeas and 1 nay, to be sent to the House.
[2:12:34][2:12:49][2:13:05][2:13:17]
SB571 J. Hendren TO CREATE AN EARNED INCOME TAX CREDIT, AN INCREASED STANDARD DEDUCTION, AND AN INDIVIDUAL INCOME TAX REDUCTION; AND TO PROVIDE FUNDING FOR INCOME TAX REDUCTIONS THROUGH NEW TAXES ON CIGARETTES AND E-CIGARETTES.
SB586 G. Leding TO ALLOW A MANUFACTURER TO SPONSOR AND PROVIDE ADVERTISING MATERIALS TO A NONPROFIT ORGANIZATION HOLDING A LARGE ATTENDANCE FACILITY PERMIT.
2:49:55 - 2:51:504 segments2 speakers
Senator Greg Leding introduced SB 586 to amend the ABC law so manufacturers may sponsor signage and advertising materials at large-attendance nonprofit venues, stating there was no opposition.
[2:50:01][2:50:20]
The committee rolled the vote, recording 29 yeas and 4 nays, and the bill was approved for transmission to the House.
[2:50:52][2:51:32]
HB1251 Eubanks Wallace TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF "PRACTICE OF OPTOMETRY"; AND TO MODERNIZE THE PRACTICE OF OPTOMETRY.
2:51:50 - 3:22:3873 segments10 speakers
Chair Representative Fred Allen introduced HB1251, noting that it would modernize Arkansas’s optometry statutes by adding a section that authorizes optometrists-who meet additional credentialing requirements and must report laser procedures to the Board of Optometry and the Department of Health-to perform five specific, minimally invasive procedures that have been routine in other states for years.
[2:52:07][2:52:37][2:53:14][2:53:46][2:54:19][2:54:51][2:55:27][2:56:01][2:56:36]
HB1564 Gray Rapert TO ESTABLISH THE PUBLIC SAFETY ACT OF 2019; TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS PUBLIC SAFETY COMMUNICATIONS ACT OF 1985; AND TO DEVELOP A NEXT GENERATION 911 SYSTEM.
3:22:38 - 3:26:278 segments2 speakers
Senator Jason Rapert presented HB1564, explaining that the bill revises the Arkansas Public Safety Communications Act, reduces the projected revenue from $38 million to $24 million, eliminates the controversial high-cost fund, and provides for a two-thirds-vote mechanism to adjust the number of PSAPs while funding next-generation 9-1-1 equipment and the AWIN program, with updated fees for cellular, VoIP and prepaid calls.
[3:22:39][3:22:52][3:23:23][3:23:54][3:24:26][3:24:57]
The committee then approved the measure by a vote of 29 yays to 3 nays, sending it back to the House.
[3:25:32][3:26:04]