Speaker 89 read a slate of engrossed and grossed bills and resolutions for committee consideration, including Senate Bills 9, 90, 264, 304, 409, 410, 411 and numerous others across the Judiciary, Public Health, Education, and State Agencies committees.
[13:33][14:06][14:37][15:10][15:40][16:23][17:09]
Senators offered informal remarks, with Senator Trent Garner celebrating the Senate’s recent victory over the House and noting an upcoming plaque ceremony, while Senator Jim Hendren welcomed a leadership group from Harding.
[18:17][18:48][19:00][19:04][19:20]
The chair announced a State Agencies meeting on constitutional amendments scheduled for the next morning, and Speaker 89 reported the referral status of several House Bills and a Senate resolution for passage.
[20:11][20:25][20:34]
SR10 Hill COMMENDING THE ARKANSAS CHAPTER OF THE ALZHEIMER'S ASSOCIATION AND PROCLAIMING FEBRUARY 26, 2019, AS ALZHEIMER'S AWARENESS DAY. 22:31
Senator Ricky Hill introduced Senate Resolution 10 commending the Arkansas Chapter of the Alzheimer’s Association and proclaiming February 26, 2019 as Alzheimer’s Awareness Day, providing statistics, personal testimony, and the full text of the resolution before it was read aloud.
[22:49][23:13][23:36][23:43][23:46][24:19][24:49][25:23][25:55]
The Senate voted aye with no opposition, carrying the resolution.
[26:24][26:27]
SB114 #1 J. Sturch TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE APPOINTMENT OF CITY TREASURER IN A CITY OF THE SECOND CLASS AND AN INCORPORATED TOWN. 28:11
Senator John Cooper moved to concur with a House amendment that added a co-sponsor to Senate Bill 114, which amends the law concerning the appointment of city treasurers in second-class cities and incorporated towns.
[28:15][28:28][28:34][28:37][28:46]
After roll call, the Senate approved the amended bill by a unanimous 34-yea vote, and the measure was enrolled.
[29:32][29:50][30:05]
SB147 B. Ballinger TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING ALIMONY SUPPORT. 30:26
Senator Ballinger introduced SB 147, outlining a framework for “restorative” alimony that would give courts discretion, would not affect child-support or property settlements, and would allow a party to petition for a change when circumstances shift.
[30:30][30:52][31:23][31:33][31:44][31:55]
SB218 E. Cheatham TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING DEPOSITS IN THE TEACHER DEFERRED RETIREMENT OPTION PLAN; TO REPEAL CERTAIN PROVISIONS CONCERNING THE TEACHER DEFE… 1:07:31
Senator Eddie Cheatham presented SB 218 to codify and consolidate changes to the Teacher Deferred Retirement Option Plan, stating it would simply organize existing provisions without substantive amendment.
[1:07:45][1:08:15][1:08:27]
SB200 B. Sample TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE ELIGIBILITY OF A MEMBER TO RECEIVE AN INCREASE IN BENEFITS UNDER THE ARKANSAS STATE HIGHWAY EMPLOYEES' RETIREME… 1:09:43
Senator Bill Sample introduced SB 200 to remove the cost-of-living adjustment for health-care offsets in the Arkansas State Highway Employees’ Retirement System, describing it as a sustainability measure.
[1:09:53][1:10:02]
No members sought to speak, the vote was rolled, and the bill passed unanimously, 34 yeas and zero nays.
[1:10:21][1:10:32][1:11:02]
SB201 B. Sample TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE CONTRIBUTIONS OF MEMBERS AND EMPLOYERS UNDER THE ARKANSAS STATE HIGHWAY EMPLOYEES' RETIREMENT SYSTEM; AND TO DE… 1:11:13
Senator Bill Sample presented SB 201 to increase member contribution rates from 6 % to 7 % over two years for the Highway Employees’ Retirement System, again emphasizing system sustainability.
[1:11:23][1:11:37][1:12:04][1:12:08]
The Senate recorded no opposition, rolled the vote, and adopted the bill with 34 yeas and zero nays.
[1:12:39]
SB222 E. Cheatham TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING MEMBER CONTRIBUTIONS UNDER THE ARKANSAS TEACHER RETIREMENT SYSTEM; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY. 1:13:01
Senator Eddie Cheatham introduced SB 222 to codify member-contribution rules for the Arkansas Teacher Retirement System, noting it merely consolidates existing law without effecting change.
[1:13:09][1:13:39][1:13:47][1:13:54][1:14:10]
With no objections, the measure was rolled and passed unanimously, 34 yeas and zero nays.
[1:14:22]
SB315 K. Hammer TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING DRIVER'S LICENSE REINSTATEMENT FEES. 1:14:37
Senator Kim Hammer explained SB 315 would make permanent a system that captures unpaid suspended-driver-license fees through state income-tax returns and directs the proceeds to the state police, citing a two-year pilot that collected over $2.5 million.
[1:14:42][1:15:18][1:15:53][1:16:25]
SB342 J. Cooper TO AMEND THE LAWS CONCERNING THE CONTRACTORS LICENSING BOARD; AND TO AMEND THE LICENSING REQUIREMENTS OF CONTRACTORS. 1:22:03
Senator John Cooper introduced SB 342, a bill emerging from the Governor-appointed red-tape reduction task force and co-chaired with Representative Cozart, outlining four key reforms to the Contractors Licensing Board’s processes.
[1:22:16][1:22:37][1:23:12][1:23:45]
The reforms would (1) shift subcontractors from a licensing to a registration system, (2) require a surety bond for registered subcontractors, (3) elevate certain violations to a Class A misdemeanor on the commercial side and create a criminal violation on the residential side, and (4) add protections for elderly or at-risk individuals.
[1:23:45][1:24:21]
Senator Jason Rapert moved to re-refer Senate Bill 298, concerning funeral-home legislation that had been mistakenly placed under the Insurance Commissioner, back to the Insurance and Commerce Committee for proper consideration.
[1:35:12]
The chair called for objections, none were offered, and the motion carried unanimously.
[1:35:44][1:35:59]
Matched: “…Calendar. Committee on State Agencies to whom was referred Senate Resolution 14 by Central Sample recommend do pass. Calendar. Committee on…”
TO ENCOURAGE THE UNITED STATES CONGRESS AND THE ARKANSAS CONGRESSIONAL DELEGATION TO WORK TO END …
The Senate will come to order. Clerk, please call the roll. Ballinger, Bledsoe, Bond, Caldwell, Cheatham, Chesterfield, Clark, Cooper, Davis, Dismayne, Eades, Elliott, English, Flippo, Flowers, Garner, Hammer, Hendron, Hester, Hickey, Hill, Ingram, Irvin, Blake Johnson, Mark Johnson, Letting, Malick, Pitch, Raper, Rice, Sample, Stubbafield, I invite members, staff, and everyone in the
Wallace. Oh Lord, thank you for this day. Thank you for this blessing. you for our family and our friends. Our Heavenly Father, give us the wisdom to make the right decisions for our state. Please watch over our military. In Jesus' name, amen. I pray for you to declare the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Senator Cooper, you're recognized. Request leave for Senator Sturge. Leave for Senator Sturge. Any other announcements? Senator Hendren.
on the floor. Without objection. And I'd also like to make an introduction. You know, we've got some former military people and many think that the fighters of the Air Force or the helicopters of the Army or the Special Forces are our greatest weapon. weapon, but actually our greatest weapon is up here in the gallery, the military spouses that we have here. So would they stand and be recognized? We've got a whole group of military spouses from Little Rock Air Force Base. Other announcements? Senator Flowers.
Thank you. Members, I'd like for you to welcome again one of my pages from the from my district. He is River Patton, and River is a ninth grade student at Dumas High School. And he's a great student. He plays football as a receiver, so watch out for the bobcats. And then, or bear claws. Bobcats. Bear claws. Bobcats. Bobcats. And he also plays baseball for the high school. Welcome, River. Other announcements. Senator
Malek. Thank you, Mr. President, members. I'm also pleased to have a page for me today. Elijah McCarver is from Chitterster, Arkansas. He attends school. He's a senior at Camden Fairview, is interested in politics, and plans to attend Southern Arkansas University in Business. Welcome, Elijah.
Thank you, I'd like to introduce my page for the day, and her name is Hannah Malone, and she is a senior at Sylvan Hills High School. She is an honors student looking at going to UCA, is, and her parents are up here too, and I think that's, her parents have helped her a long way, congratulations, do appreciate you being here and look forward to seeing you. Senator Cheatham. Thank you, Mr. President.
I have a page today from Woodlawn High School. Alyssa Kinsey is sitting back in my left. Give her a good round of applause. Alyssa is a senior and she plans to go to South, don't say South Arc. It's not South Arc, is it? Listen, where are you going? South Arc? South Arc, Pine Bluff. It wants to be a radio technician, radiology technician. Thanks.
out of line. They asked me to introduce Senator Chesterfield's page. Joshua Johnson is here, back here in the back. He's a ninth grade student at Parkview High school. He's a football player in the beta club, the debate club, and attends a drama magnet, right? And we're excited to have you here. And Senator Chesterfield has gotten tied up, so I'm introducing you. But we'll get her back there to see you later. Let's give him a big
round of applause. Okay, and I just want to take one quick moment to welcome my own page, Elizabeth Gunderman. She's back in the back of the chamber today. She's a student at Fayetteville High School, wants to run for president someday. I told her she shouldn't sell herself so short, aim a little higher. I just wanted to give her a welcome. Okay. Senator Hammer, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. President. We'd like to ask
you if we could suspend the rules to bring Little Miss Arkansas onto the floor, please, sir. Without objection. You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. President. Distinguished members of the Senate, it gives me great pleasure today. I'd like to take this opportunity to recognize a resident of my district, Amelia Lissoway. This past May, Amelia was named Little Miss Arkansas. She is the daughter of Lauren Lissoway, who joins her today along with her Mimi Jill and her brother Braden. And she attends the Hurricane Creek Elementary School, where she is a second grader. Amelia strongly believes in service to others and has used her time to benefit the community. Amelia's platform is called Spread a Little Joy. And through this, she shows others that even though you are small, you can still make a big difference. Amelia kicked off her platform by preparing her school with positive post-it notes. She has also volunteered reading for both the Civitan and Bryant Preschool Programs and the Saline County Library. Amelia enjoys visiting and dancing for many assisted living facilities throughout Saline County, and she has volunteered her time with Special Olympics. Ms. Lissoway is a hunger hero for the Arkansas Food Bank and spends much of her time volunteering there along with her mother and brother Braden who incidentally tonight will be his last night as a Cub Scout and tomorrow he will move on to the ranks of Boy Scouts. She also led a drive where she was able to collect and distribute 500 night lights to foster children and Amelia is a true asset to Saline County and Arkansas and would like to welcome her to the Senate today and I wish that you would please give her a warm welcome. Mr. President, I'd like to ask possibly if we could recess for a few minutes for folks to get their pictures taken with
Yes sir, will your committee on engrossed bills to move first Senate Bill 9, Senator Garner compare the engrossed copy of the original and find the same correctly engrossed. Judiciary. We are committee on engrossed bills to whom we spurred Senate Bill 90 by Senator Clark compared the engrossed bill with the original and find the same correctly engrossed. Judiciary. We are committee on engrossed bills to whom we spurred Senate Bill 264 by Senator Garner compared the engrossed copy with the original and find the same correctly engrossed. Public Health. Committee on engrossed bills to whom we spurred Senate Bill 304 by Senator Bond compared the engrossed copy with the original and find the same correctly engrossed. Education. Education. We are a committee on gross bills to whom is first sent bill 343 by Senator Sturch compared the engrossed property with the original and fired signed the same correctly in grossed. Education. Committee on gross bills to whom is first sent bill 348 by Senator Eads compared the engrossed property with the original and financed the same correctly in grossed. City, county, local. We are a committee on engrossed bills to whom is deferred Senate Joint Resolution and ble attitude contrary to Ser��'s sent bill 344 and code wrote in coverage of these state agencies. Senate Bill 409 by Senator Flippo to allow for the electronic notification of an invitation of forbid and electronic submission of bids and to require certain entities to accept the electronic submission of bids, Senate Bill 409. State agencies. Senate Bill 410 by Senator Cooper to repeal the Arkansas Barber Law, to abolish the State Board of Barber Examiners, and to amend the law governing the practice of cosmetology, Senate Bill 410. Senate Bill 411 by Senator Stubblefield to prohibit municipal sanctuary policies, Senate Bill 411. City, county, local. Will your committee on joint budget to whom is referred Senate Bill 63 by joint budget recommend due pass? Calendar. Will your committee on joint budget to whom is referred Senate Bill 94 by joint budget recommend due pass? Calendar. Will your committee on joint budget to whom is referred Senate Bill 120 by joint budget committee recommend due pass? Calendar. Committee on Joint Budget to whom was referred Senate Bill 125 by Joint Budget recommended new pass. Calendar. Committee on Ag to whom was referred Senate Bill 283 by Senator Garner recommended new pass as amended number one. Calendar. Committee on Ag to whom was referred House Bill 1146 by Representative Caff recommended new pass. Calendar. Committee on City County Local to whom was referred House Bill 1386 by Representative Johnson recommended new pass. Calendar. Calendar. Committee on Insurance and Commerce to whom was referred to Senate Bill 363 by Senator Cheatham recommended due pass. Calendar. Committee on Insurance and Commerce to whom was referred to Senate Bill 355 by Senator Rayford recommended due pass. Calendar. Committee on Insurance and Commerce to whom was referred to Senate Bill 356 by Senator Rayford recommended due pass. Calendar. Committee on Insurance and Commerce to whom was referred to Senate Bill 357 by Senator Rayford recommended due pass. Calendar. Callender. Committee on Insurance and Commerce to whom is deferred Senate Bill 363 by Senator Rayford, recommend due pass. Calendar. Committee on Insurance and Commerce to whom is deferred Senate Bill 364 by Senator Rayford, recommend due pass. Calendar. Committee on Insurance and Commerce to whom is deferred Senate Bill 365 by Senator Rayford, recommend due pass. Calendar. Committee on Insurance and Commerce to whom is deferred Senate Bill 366 by Senator Rayford, recommend due pass. Calendar. Committee on Insurance and Commerce to whom is deferred Senate Bill 367 by Senator Rayford, recommend due pass. Calendar. Committee on Insurance and Commerce, Committee on Insurance and Commerce, by Senator Rayford. Recommend due pass. Calendar. Committee on Insurance and Commerce to whom is referred Senate Bill 373 by Senator Rayford. Recommend due pass. Calendar. Committee on Insurance and Commerce to whom is referred Senate Bill 380 by Senator Letting. Recommend due pass. Calendar. Committee on Insurance and Commerce to whom is referred Senate Bill 292 by Senator Rayford. Recommend due pass as amended number one. Calendar. Committee on Insurance Commerce to whom is referred Senate Bill 310 by Senator Rayford. Recommend due pass as amended number one. Calendar. Committee on State Agencies to whom was referred Senate Resolution 14 by Central Sample recommend do pass. Calendar. Committee on State Agencies to whom was referred House Bill 1388. And if you could hold on for
that I think is getting ready to leave. Leadership group from Harding on both sides. We wanted to say glad to have them here and please make them feel welcome.
Senator Garner, you recognized. Thank you, Mr. President. I briefly have to bring up the Senate's exhilarating, awesome, unexpected win last night over our House colleagues. You know, we let them get up on us by 16. But I learned when you let your enemy get that glimmer of hope, when they really think they're going to get it and snatch it away from them, like we've done the last three times before this one. I think it's a good day, but I just wanted to bring that up. I know that Senator Henrin said there's going to be a plaque ceremony here in the next couple of weeks, but I just want to appreciate everybody, especially
Senator Johnson, you recognize for a question. Senator Garner, did you notice last night that Senator Irvin and Senator Davis played an excellent game? And did you further notice that none of the female members of the House actually played in the game? Do you think that might have something to do with the outcome?
I think so. Senator Bond. I have another announcement. I have the doctors of the day today, Dr. Lori Barber and Dr. Jeffrey Barber. Dr. Lori Barber is an ophthalmologist in private practice, and Dr. Jeffrey Barber is an otolaryngologist. How about that? Did I get that wrong? ENT doctor, excuse me. ENT doctor in private practice here in Little Rock, and our nurse Brenda is here. Of course, we want to give them all a round
of applause. Thank you for being here. oh senator caldwell thank you very much members if you would listen up state agencies will meet tomorrow at 8 30 to hear constitutional amendments tomorrow at 8 30 to hear constitutional amendments
constitutional amendments Will your Committee on State Agencies to whom was referred House Bill 1388 by Representative Gonzales, recommended to pass? Calendar. Committee on State Agencies to whom was referred House Bill 1430 by Representative Dodson, recommended to pass? Calendar. Committee on State Agencies to whom was referred House Bill 1181 by Representative Wardlaw, recommended to pass as amended number one. Calendar. Committee on State Agencies to whom was referred House Bill 1277 by Representative Hawks, do pass as amended number one. Calendar. Mr. President, we, your committee on enrolled bills to whom was referred to Senate Bill 141 by Senator English, Senate Bill 161 by Senator Letting, Senate Bill 181 by Senator English, Senate Bill 202 by Senator Ingram. Compared the enrolled copies with the original and found correctly enrolled and at 9.55 a.m. delivered to the governor for his approval. Violet. Dear Mr. President, this is to inform you that on February 26, 2019, I approve the following measures from the regular session of the 92nd General Assembly. Senate Bill 49, Act 191, Senate Bill 54, Act 192, Senate Bill 76, Act 193, Senate Bill 81, Act 194, Senate Bill 98, Act 195, Senate Bill 123, Act 196, Senate Bill 134, Act 197, Senate Bill 150, Act 198, Senate Bill 160, Act 199, Senate Bill 188, Act 200, Senate Bill 196, Act 201, Senate Bill 225, Act 202, Senate Bill 226, Act 203, Senate Bill 228, Act 204. Sincerely, Asa Hutchison, Governor. Okay. All right.
Senate Resolution 10 with Senator Hill, commending the Arkansas Chapter of the Alzheimer's Association and proclaiming February 26, 2019 an Alzheimer's anniversary.
Granted. We're going to welcome the Alzheimer's Association here today on the floor before we present this resolution. This resolution is very special to me, I just want you all to be aware of that. My mother was diagnosed with Alzheimer's for 10 years before she passed away two years ago. So this is a very dear organization in my heart and has all my support. And I want everyone to please give us full awareness for Alzheimer's today. With that, we
neuro brain disorder tragically robbed individuals of their memories and leads to progressive mental and physical impairments. Whereas, there are no known treatments to prevent, cure, or even delay the onset or slow the progression of Alzheimer's disease. And whereas, an estimated 60,000 Arkansans have Alzheimer's disease and currently 177,000 Arkansans are designated caregivers. And whereas, Alzheimer's disease is the sixth leading cause of death in the United States. And as of 2015, Arkansas had the fourth highest Alzheimer's mortality rate in the country. And whereas, according to the Alzheimer's Association 2018 Alzheimer's Disease Facts and Figures Report, the direct cost to the American Society of Caring for those with Alzheimer's is valued at $259 billion. More than 15 million caregivers provided under 18 billion hours of unpaid care for those with Alzheimer's and other dementias in 2016. And in Arkansas, nearly 177,000 family members and friends care for people with Alzheimer's and other dementias, providing 201 million hours of unpaid care, and the annual value of this caring totaling $2,545 million. And whereas the mission of Alzheimer's Association is to eliminate Alzheimer's disease and other dementias through the advancement of research and promotion of the brain health and the enhanced care and support for all individuals and Alzheimer's disease and their families and caregivers and whereas the efforts of Alzheimer's Association to raise funds and promote awareness to fight Alzheimer's disease and other dementias help improve the quality of human life for those living with Alzheimer's disease and their caregivers and whereas February 26 2019 would be appropriate day to establish Alzheimer's Awareness Day in Arkansas in recognition of these individuals, families, friends, and caregivers dealing with Alzheimer's, disease, and researchers who are seeking a cure and cause. Now, therefore, be it resolved by the 92nd General Assembly of the state of Arkansas that the Senate commends the Arkansas chapter of the Alzheimer's Association for their outstanding work in fighting this terrible disease and advocating for those living with this disease and proclaims February the 26th, 2019 as Alzheimer's Awareness Day. Thank you. All in
in an incorporated town. Thank you, Mr. President. This bill allows a, it's an ordinance that shall be passed before the filing period begins for an election for the office of city treasurer, but no later than February preceding the beginning of the early filing period. It allows the appointment of the city treasurer.
the roll. Any objection to rolling the vote? All right. See no. Roll the vote, please. Ballinger, Bledsoe, Bond, Caldwell, Cheatham, Chesterfield, Clark, Cooper, Davis, Dismayne, Eads, Elliott, English, Flippo, Flowers, Garner, Hammer, Hendron, Hester, Hickey, Hill, Ingram, Irving, Blake Johnson, Mark Johnson, Letting, Malik, Pitch, Raper, Rice, Sample, Stubbefield, Sturge Teague Wallace. Does anyone wish to change their vote? Seeing none, cast
Thank you, Mr. President. Okay, this is the bill that we handled last Thursday. And since then, I've had a chance to visit with several people. You know, I absolutely understand how there could have been a lot of confusion surrounding this bill. This is not something we deal with every day. And there were a lot of questions, which hopefully I've had a chance to answer most of those. I don't want to belabor the point. but essentially what this bill does is kind of provide the framework of the structure to move to a restorative alimony we kind of already set up it within the code that we're going to go this direction this provides the framework to do it this is a piece of legislation I've worked with the Judicial Council on they have no problems with it because we've actually in the legislation put in language that provided a mechanism for their for them to practice some discretion this doesn't affect child support doesn't affect all that separate code section. This only is alimony, and even if somebody would like to have permanent alimony and there's good reasons for it, it just requires the judge to make findings set in. And having said that, I would be willing to answer any questions, but I don't want to stretch anything out any longer than
I have to. Senator Vaughn, you recognize for a question? Senator Vaughn, you and I have bounced this back and forth in committee and before, but just to make clear for everybody, the bill allows anybody with an alimony award to petition the court for a change if we
pass it into law. Yeah, correct. And so, and just like any other change of circumstance, they could do that. So, this doesn't, this doesn't negate any order that's out there. It just, you know, they have the ability to go back and petition. And if there's not a, not a, if the circumcision hadn't changed, the court would just have to make a findings to uphold the alimony that, that
you. And, um, Mr. Chair, and thank you, Senator Ballinger. If it's not changing anything, why do we have 20% of the net income of the payer? And if you get to be 62 years old, when you may be getting richer than ever before, why would the percent be reduced to 10%? Because
you may not be, and your income may be dropping substantially. But even if it isn't, then that's the idea of creating the flexibility for the court to make specific findings and to set it at whatever percentage that would be justified, as long as they can justify it through the order. All right. Seeing other questions, I do appreciate a good vote. Thank you. Does anyone want
Chair. Ladies and gentlemen of the House, I don't pretend to know everything there is to know about law, but I know what feels right and what feels wrong to me. And I know that the majority of individuals who receive child support are women, and I know that there are women who have put their whole careers on hold for guys to get an education. And they work within the home, which I think is one of the most noble callings that a woman can have, is to be a housewife, to raise those children, to make sure that there is comfort for the individual who is the primary breadwinner. I know that. I know, too, that if it were my niece or my daughters, that if they have done that, then to even suggest that what they have put in is only worth 20 percent because somebody decides they want to graze in another pasture, then there's a problem. There's a problem. I ask you to think about it. most of you are parents in this room. Think about that. Think about your daughter having put her life on hold. She's 50 some odd years old. There is no rehabilitation for that. And yet you're saying to her, primarily to her, and I know it sometimes the guys too, but you're saying to them, you're only worth 20% of the millions that perhaps your husband made. And if that individual gets to be 62, guess what? He only has to give you 10%. There's something fundamentally wrong with that. And if y'all see fit to pass it, because this is a male-dominated body, I wouldn't be surprised, but I would ask that you think about it when it comes to your daughters. I want you to think about it if it comes to your sons who may not be the principal breadwinner, but have been that sustainer in that family. To talk about reducing the amount of money instead of a 50-50 thing that marriage is supposed to be about, it's now an 80-20 thing. And at a certain age, it becomes a 90-10 thing. There's something wrong with that. I don't care how logical it sounds. It is fundamentally wrong. And I would ask that you vote no. Senator Flowers, you're recognized to speak against the bill.
Senator Chesterfield, I appreciate what you've said and agree with it, but the question for me, and I just want to get your take on it. If somebody wants to go to court, they think they have a reason to go to court to petition the court for a better settlement, would you surmise that that responsibility would fall on the person least able to hire attorney or attorneys to go to court? Indeed,
and that is what's so difficult about all of this, is because if you have committed your life to working within the home and you have become dependent upon that person, they want you to now rehabilitate yourself. But in the meantime, not only do you have to rehabilitate yourself, you've got to find some money for an attorney. And so the primary breadwinner is very unlikely to give you the money to fight whatever he or she wants to do in that instance. That also puts the individual at a distinct disadvantage. There's something wrong with this. I don't think it's in the best interest of the people of this state, the majority of whom are women. I just think it's a bad bill. Thank you. Senator
Garner, you recognize for a question. Thank you, Mr. President. So I appreciate what you said, but it seems like you only are looking at one side of this issue. What would you say to those men or women who are the primary breadwinners, but then their situation in life changes as things move forward? Or you can agree as time goes forward, you can make more money or less money. You can have other situations that happen to you. Why do you think the court shouldn't be able to address those specific situations and make a difference? The court already can. If
there is a material change in what you have, you have the right to petition the court for a change. I have no problem with that. I'm from a family of three boys, so I don't want my brothers treated unfairly either. But I don't want us to put a percentage on what women primarily are
worth. But under this current law, the change we're going to do, that's still applicable. They can still get that change in whatever it was before. They're just trying to put a... Is there a question that you want to ask me? Or do you want to just argue the case? Yes, ma'am. That was literally a question. That was a preliminary question? Under the current law, and even under these changes, they can still go to court and have it changed back. Is that
correct? I don't think that under the current law, we would be dealing with the statistics that are in this bill. That is where my difficulty is. I don't think that we ought to be talking about people being, whether it be you, if you're not the primary breadwinner, or anybody else, being reduced to a percentage. I'd appreciate a no vote. Is
Against the bill? Senator Flowers. Senator Flowers. Thank you. Members, I'm against this bill. I'm going to try to be succinct in why I am against the bill and urge you to vote no for this bill. I'm an attorney. I've been practicing now for more than 34 years. I practiced first in Texas for nine years and then came home to Arkansas in 1991. And I've been practicing here since. I primarily have a practice in domestic relations, family law. I deal with everything from juvenile delinquency, dependency neglect, custody, child support, divorces. And in those divorces, oftentimes there's an issue about alimony, and alimony, you know, goes both ways these days. Palimony, you can call it palimony if it's for a male. But in my practice, I'll tell you, there is nothing wrong with the Arkansas law as it stands now as it relates to alimony. It doesn't, as Senator Chesterfield said, have those percentages in there. It's left to the discretion of the judges, circuit court judges that deal with divorce cases in Arkansas, to decide. Normally, when people are in the court and they are petitioning the court for alimony, there's an affidavit of financial means that's filed. That's a document that's used, that's set up by the Supreme Court. It's a form, and it gives the persons, both parties, information, financial information. It sets forth their income, whether that be from a job, whether it's self-employment, or if they are employed by someone. It also gives other income that they might have access to. One might put on their income from dividends that are paid based on investments. Other things, they might have interest in another business. They might have two incomes from employment. They may have a lot of different types of income. And And all of that is reported on that affidavit of financial means. And then beyond the income, there is a section that calls for the monthly expenses of the parties. Those monthly expenses are itemized. They go from everything from your rent or your mortgage to your utilities to what you You pay monthly average for food, for cleaning, for grooming, for charitable donations, things that ordinarily happen in a marriage and with people, what they contribute to. And their expenses are important. Expenses kind of show that there is a custom of living, a standard that the parties have taken up on themselves. And then it goes into debts. What are the parties' debts? What do they owe overall? And then it says, what are you paying toward that debt each month? So you figure out, you got your income, you got the expenses broken down, and you have your debt, other debt, like your car note, bigger debts. You might have some loans. We were talking about student loans the other day. Might be student loans that are mentioned as a debt. and that debt is, if it's repaid on a monthly basis or on whatever basis it's repaid, that's reported on that affidavit of financial means as well. Generally, in these divorce proceedings, the courts will, the judges will ask, what do the parties want in terms of a pretrial list or inventory? What do you want? Based on the things that you have, the parties have acquired during the marriage, what is it that you'd be willing to keep? One party would keep and the other party would like to give to the other person. And then there's the issue of separate property versus marital property. So a spouse that has come into the marriage with certain property that they had before, I don't know how it could have been acquired, could have been by a gift, could have been by heirship, anything like that. And then you have also separate property that is acquired during the marriage by gift, devise, or descent as well. And that's not generally available to that other spouse, that separate property of that individual. But the thing that gets me is, and what the law is now, the courts have a balancing test. And you can even go online and see Arkansas on our judiciary page, there is a bench book. And judges use this bench book to give them some basic understanding if it's, have it right at your fingertips of how this proceeding is supposed to work. And in that bench book, there is actually a balancing test. There is literally in writing the parameters that the judges use to balance these kinds of decisions about alimony. Now, Senator Chesterfield mentioned about the breadwinner versus the one that works at home. But also consider this. that one that works at home, or they may have a job which is a lesser paying job than that other party that's being asked for alimony. And the reason being, it could be because the spouse that has the greater income was helped and supported for years and years to get that other spouse, that breadwinner's career off the ground. Now, I've represented individuals who have been in that circumstance where they supported all their life. They gave up their desire to move on and be the best in their field at the top. I've had teachers that have been willing to give up their move upward. They've given up opportunities to get master's and doctorate degrees and pursue their own fields of interest. to help that spouse get his or her doctorate degree. And most of the time, I have to admit, it's been the male that the female has supported and helped to get that greater degree and that large income and salary that has been used to support the family for years and years. Now, the court can look at all of that right now and they make what is in the best interest and it's based on certain things, these things that I'm talking about, the number of years of the marriage, the kinds of things that one party contributed to the marriage as opposed to the other. And when that woman comes in and she's been that supporter of that spouse all these years, and all of a sudden he found something younger and a little quicker and runs out and she's left, can't support herself and can't keep up with the standard that she's become accustomed to. That's the whole measure, and that's what alimony is about, being able to put that party that's in the lower income position, give them the standard that they're used to, and they're entitled to that. You should want that. I can't imagine why this bill is being brought. Except that I had one email sent twice over the weekend from some man who said he was stuck with all this alimony. And he talked about his wife, said she was a drunkard and all this kind of stuff. Well, he gave a name, he said, where he lived. And And so I thought, you know, now we have Court Connect, and you can go online now and find anybody's case that you want to see. Well, I didn't see this man's case. So I don't know who he is or what he was talking about or whether he was, was it fake? And I tend to believe it was fake. But this is wrong. And this part at the end of that bill that says that this act itself operates as a material change of circumstance, that is other language for retroactivity. Retroactivity. This is a retroactive bill. And Mr. Senator Ballinger says, well, they can. Well, yeah, they can, because it's retroactive. But you consider, and I was sitting here the other day, and over the weekend, I mean, you think about, I thought about some of the clients that I've had and some of the women that have struggled and helped to keep the family together, to support that spouse, to help him rise in his career, only to be left, it's wrong. And those are orders and decrees that are in place right now. You don't know how far back they go. But a judge would not have put that order in place but for some evidence that, number one, she considered the custom of living and the ability to pay that alimony by that party that's charged to pay. So, you know, another thing in this bill is a three-year cutoff unless you have some determination that rehabilitation or restoration hasn't occurred and you've got to go back within six months of the three years to ask the court for an extension. You know, when people break up in marriages and stuff, all kinds of things happen. Your insurance, health insurance, you might be held on to the insurance for a few months, then you got to go to COBRA. COBRA costs a lot of money. There's a lot of things that you need to consider when you're talking about striking down all of the orders of alimony in the state of Arkansas. Now, I don't know where the heck this bill came from. He said from another state and other states are getting. We are Arkansas. We're not another state. We're not Texas. We're not Arizona. We're not California. We are Arkansas. Arkansas used to be in the court system about equity, and it still is. But we don't have chancery courts anymore. We have circuit courts. But the rules of equity still apply. And that's what the judges in the divorce courts apply, equity. It's all about equity and fairness, fairness to the parties that are before the court. You vote for this bill? Everybody is going to rush. Everybody that's ordered to pay alimony will rush to that courthouse, alleging the material change of circumstance that this bill says it is automatically, and get all these orders terminated. I mean I don't understand this at all I think it's a mean bill I think it's
want to take a question and I and I can I should have probably asked this to the sponsor of the bill but can you give me I'm trying to understand rehabilitative alimony and my concern with that is how is that determined if if this recipient needs to be rehabilitated. And does the judge make that determination? My concern is I don't want the spouse that is on the side of paying the alimony to somehow use this negatively against the other person because I know how divorces can be really messy. And so my concern is I don't want that to be used against a spouse if they're not, I mean, is that, because they have a drinking problem, because they have a gambling problem? I mean, who determines whether they have those problems and if they need
you can answer that. Oh, I can tell you about my experience. Yeah, that's fine. Because I've had judges that will order alimony for short periods of time, as short as six months. And then I've had judges to order alimony for up to five years. And generally what they're looking at is the circumstance that the party who does not have that greater income is faced with. Okay. So one case that I handled was I represented the male and he was ordered to pay for that short period of time because his wife had been suffering from some illnesses, some medical procedures and all. And so the judge considered that. She was not working then. And they weren't married that long. It's a lot of issues that the court considers. It's factors that are considered. And some of them are the length of the marriage, the health of the parties, deals with your station in life, what you're accustomed to, your standard of living. If you're in a house, and you're fighting over the house, and the house is ordered sold, that's marital property, so it can be ordered sold, so the wife doesn't have the money to pay for the house, maybe the husband might want to buy the house at a public sale, maybe not. Maybe it's so contentious that everything is just ordered sold. They can't agree on anything. One doesn't want the other to have anything, so they don't want them to have the house. And in that instance, for the party that doesn't have the greater income, where are they going to go? What kind of residence are they going to be able to live in? Will it be close to anything that they've been accustomed to for years and years? You're talking decades, some of these marriages. So
under this bill, so my mother is the person you're talking about as far as, you know, she didn't go to college. She didn't get a college degree because she was supporting the family while my dad was getting his medical degree. And so, I mean, under this bill, you interpret that
she would be reduced to? Three years. Okay. And then go and find something that can pay your bills. Okay. Thank you for the question. And that's not right because your mom also has insurance needs. If she's elderly, she might need supplemental insurance to Medicare. There are so many instances. Some people might even have a car that was purchased that they still have a note on. How are you going to pay for a place to live and a car note, too? and then some parties some parents still help their adult children so I mean it's all things all these things that are considered by the court and that is the law right now and the support is based it's not just a number thrown out or that somebody says I want it's based on the ability to pay that too so that That person who's paying that alimony, I don't know where this comes from that they're at such a disadvantage. If you've got a bad decision, appeal it. That's what our law provides for. Thank you. I'll take any other
Thank you, Senator. I voted for this bill the other day and it failed, and I might be on the wrong side again this time, but I understood at the time, and I appreciate it because Senator Ballinger did. I did ask him a question and he confirmed it, but I was under the impression that this only referred to this rehabilitative alimony, which is, I assume, to help someone It's after divorce to, like, prepare for a new job or whatever. But you've convinced me that it goes to the, and I don't know the legal term, Senator, but normal, regular alimony.
Yes. We're talking about replacing what our law is now. And I, you know, the Senator said that the Judicial Council is for this bill. Judicial Council didn't come into our committee and say that. And I don't know one judge that would be for this bill. I don't. Senator Flowers. And the only judges that were in the committee were some juvenile court judges. They don't deal with divorces and alimony. Yes, ma'am.
Senator Flowers, you and I have been friends a long time. And, you know, I respect your legal opinion on things. And as I certainly respect Senator Ballinger's. But I have a problem with this bill, as you seem to, that you've helped point out to me. I want to thank you for that, because while we may need to make some substantial changes in the law on this, I'm a little reticent to go forward with it where
we are right now. So thank you for pointing that out to me. I don't see the need for substantial changes. I think the law in Arkansas is good law, and we should be the standard for the other states. Senator Hammer,
you're recognized for a question. Thank you. Senator Flowers, I respect the fact you're an attorney. I appreciate your 34 years of service as far as representing. I'd be curious to hear from you. And when the sponsor comes back into the well, whether this bill passes or fail, do you currently have any clients that you're representing that are going to be advantaged by how the outcome of this bill is determined by our vote?
No. As a matter of fact, I mean, we've got a contractor's bill coming up here in a little bit. And due to a derelict contractor, I don't even have an office now. So, you know, no new clients. But I can tell you that I am concerned about those clients that are, have been awarded alimony orders. and the effect of this bill on them. Because I'm telling you, you're going to see a rush to the courthouse if this bill passes, just because of that last line in that bill, this act is a material change of circumstance. Anything else? I see no other questions. I really do. I mean, you know, I don't come up here a whole lot. I mean, I can come on any bill I want, but, you know, this has been my life, trying to help somebody, help people. And I've seen how some people have been just abused by their spouse. We don't need this bill. Vote no. Thank you. Would I like to speak for
President. Look, if the bill did what Senator Flowers says it did, I would be against it. I would vote against it. I appreciate your question, Senator Irvin. Your question is right on. I would also, it would be dead wrong for that judge to not take into account your mom's years and years and years of service. I've got five girls, five little girls, who I love greatly, who someday are going to be married, and I would not want anything to happen where the system itself, especially the system I set up, would abuse them. And I'm confident it won't. The reason why judicial counsel is okay with it and has contacted some of you all to let you know. I mean, they didn't come out to promote the bill, but they promoted the process that we came together, we worked together, and all a judge has to do is make findings. That's it. Anytime that you think in your head there's a reason why it should be permanent alimony, they put it on paper. That's all they have to do. Anytime that you think that it should be above the 20%, you think in your head there's a reason, that's fine. The court just has to put it in paper. It provides broad flexibility like they have now. Everything Senator Flyer said about the way the process works, it still works that way. All the information is still provided. All the information is balanced. All of it. The question is, so it's the judge's job to go out there and carry out justice, right? To implement the law or say how the law should be implemented. That's their job. It's our job to set policy. And what we're doing by this is saying, okay, alimony should be restorative. And that's the direction that we should go. Unless, unless there are extenuating circumstances. Unless the woman has taken care of the man for a long time for him to have a big income. This doesn't deal with property settlement, so if they have a lot of property, that'd still be divided the same way. This doesn't deal with child support. That would still be set up the same way. This only deals with alimony, and it only deals with alimony that we set basically a framework, a policy saying we're going to go this direction, unless they're extenuating circumstances, and I would appreciate a good vote. Thank you.
like to vote or change their votes. Eads is aye. Senator Hill is no. Davis is no. Anybody else? Madam Clerk, please cast up the ballot. With 12 yeas, 16 nays, the
bill has failed. Senator Johnson. Mr. President, having voted on the prevailing side, I hereby give notice of reconsideration on Senate Bill 147. All in favor say aye. Before we
move on to the next item, Senator Dismang wants to request leave for a couple of guests without objection. Senator Sample. Somebody want to find Senator Sample? We will move on. We'll pass over Senate Bill 200, Senate Bill 201. We'll move on to Senate Bill
218. Senator Cheatham. Senate Bill 218 by Senator Cheatham to amend the law concerning deposits in the Teacher Deferred Retirement Option Plan to repeal certain provisions concerning the Teacher Deferred Retirement Option Plan and declare an emergency. Senator Cheatham, you're recognized.
Thank you, Mr. President. I don't think this will be quite as exciting, but it's very important to a lot of people. Senate Bill 218, dealing with teacher retirement. This bill particularly deals with deferred retirement option plans, and over the years a lot of changes have been made to that piece of teacher retirement. What the board decided to do was to try to codify all the changes into one place. So it would be very, you could look at it and see where everything is. And I would take questions, supported by the teacher board. I see
Ballinger, Bledsoe, Bond, Caldwell, Cheatham, Chesterfield, Clark, Cooper, Davis, Dismang, Elliott, English, Flippo, Flowers, Garner, Hammer, Hendron, Hester, Hickey, Hill, Ingram, Irvin, Blake Johnson, Mark Johnson, Letting, Malik, Pitch, Rapert, Rice, Sample, Stubbefield, Sturge, Teague, Wallace. Is there any senator who would like to change
200. Senator Sample, you're recognized. Senate Bill 200 by Senator Sample. To amend the law concerning the eligibility of a member to receive an increase in benefits under the
Arkansas State Highway Employees Retirement System. Thank you, members. Senate Bill 200 is for the R-DOT, it's ASHA Retirement System. All of the retirement systems are trying to make themselves more sustainable. This one is just to take and remove the COLA for health care offset, and so that's all it does. We're just making the system better. Any questions?
Sample, you're recognized to present Senate Bill 201. Senate Bill 201 by Senator Sample to amend the law concerning the contributions of members and employees under the Arkansas State Highway Employees Retirement
system and declare an emergency member senate bill 201 it it's the same thing i mean the system is trying to make itself sustainable and and this is how serious they are the employees have agreed to increase their contribution rate from six to seven percent over a period two years and so six and a half to seven. And the system has agreed that they will take and raise their contribution rate. And so this is only to take and make this system more sustainable. And I'd appreciate a good vote. Any questions?
Is there any, Senator, that would like to change their vote? Seeing none, with 34 yeas, 0 nays. As the bill has passed, as has the emergency clause. Transmit to the House. Senator Cheatham, I apologize. I didn't realize I left you up there in the middle of two bills. You're recognized
to present Senate Bill 222. Senate Bill 222 by Senator Cheatham to amend the law concerning member contributions under the Arkansas Teacher Retirement System and to declare an emergency. Thank you, Mr. President.
Again, it's another bill that's brought by the Teacher Retirement Board. This one deals with contributory and non-contributory services, and the change that's been made over the year. I think Senator Chesterfield decided in 1937 is when some of this stuff started, but we've been there a while, but it just codifies everything in one place in the code, and actually shows some historical as you go along in that code, and it just makes it easier to see what's going on. It doesn't change anything. Senator Chesterfield and I are just like we were yesterday if we pass this
the bill, against the bill, any objection to rolling the vote, please roll the vote. Ballinger, Bledsoe, Bond, Caldwell, Cheatham, Chesterfield, Clark, Cooper, Davis, Dismang, Eads, Elliott, English, Flippo, Flowers, Garner, Hammer, Hendron, Hester, Hickey, Hill, Ingram Irvin, Blake Johnson Mark Johnson, Letting Malik, Pitch, Rapert Rice, Sample Stubbefield, Sturge, Teague Wallace Is there any senator who would like to change their votes? Seeing none with 34
Last time when I was in the House, I ran a bill that would amend the law concerning the driver's license reinstatement fees. And I put a sunset clause on it because the data had never been tracked and it had never been evaluated before as far as the amount of fees that were out there under suspended driver's license. DFA, Department of Motor Vehicle, was not set up to calculate and to track the information. And so I worked with them, and as a result, they were able to put the systems in place to determine the amount of suspended driver's license fees that were out there. And as a result of that, the amount that they could best calculate came up to be around $50-plus million that's sitting out there. And so what this bill does is what the last bill did, excuse me, that I intentionally put the sunset clause, because I wasn't sure it was going to actually benefit or hurt, and neither did they. But as a result, we found out that it's actually helped because what this bill does is allow for DFA to capture from those that have suspended driver's license fee their state income tax return to settle that amount that's owed to DFA. And that amount is redirected to the state police to help. This involves suspended driver's license fees that have failure to appear, failure to pay, and this one picks up the DWI as well. And so this is directly sent to the state police. With regards to how much it helped last time, if you want a rough ballpark figure, it was $2,508,064.42 that was able to be captured and sent back as a result to the state police by doing this piece of legislation. And so this does not have the Sunset Clause on it. We've had two years to make sure it was a good process, and now I'm bringing it back for permanent placement through this bill. and I would appreciate a
good vote and be glad to answer any questions. Senator Flowers and then Senator Chesterfield. So, Senator Hammer, I'm still having trouble hearing in here, but, okay, so there was a two-year model run on this? Is that what you're saying?
Yes, ma'am. When I was with Representative last time, I ran this bill, and I intentionally put the Sunset Clause in it So we would have to go through this process now because DFA, Department of Motor Vehicle, couldn't determine exactly at the
time how much was out there, what it would amount to in the processes. Okay. Well, my question is, now, generally, child support arrearages are intercepted. So, I'm really concerned with, is there a priority in your bill that for child support arrearages, that has priority? And all that money is supposed to be taken. That's federal and state law.
Yes, ma'am. All this did was add them to the list so that their portion could be collected, but it did not take the place of, nor does this bill put them ahead of the other. This is just capturing whatever's left over after those other things that are already in place have already been collected themselves. So it just added them to the list of things, but it doesn't take place, nor does it move
them ahead of the other things you're concerned about. So if there is still an arrearage of child support, even after an interception, DF&A gets nothing for these fees that you're talking about.
Yes, ma'am, and I would maybe use this illustration. Say somebody owes $2,000 in child support and the other things that are ahead of the state police on this list and say those other things accumulate to $1,500, that other $500 would be able to be taken by the system in order to pay for those suspended driver's license fees. So everybody in front of them would be taken care of, and then if there's anything left over. If it's $2,500 the person owes, they get nothing. This just established it so they can get in the pecking order because it was about, I think without looking at my cheat sheet, I think it was about $54 million-plus that's sitting out there in suspended driver's license fees and other fees that aren't being collected. Senator Chesterfield. Thank you,
Mr. Chair, and thank you, Senator, for taking my question. Yes, ma'am. Some couples that are in this predicament file jointly. So, how does one differentiate between those filing singly and those who are filing jointly? Or does the partner who has not had the DWI, who happens to file jointly with her husband or his wife, and they don't know about this, they're stuck anyway, is that right?
I would, I'm going to give you what I think is the right answer, okay? I think the right answer is that if they file jointly, that is going to be taken, whether the husband will say, you know, has DWI's suspended driver's license, and the, you know, the wife, and they're married, and they file jointly, that money's going to be taken from both of theirs. And
I'm sure they'll have a come-to-Jesus talk. Is there any way that prior to filing, so an individual will have enough since then to file singularly, would you tell me, is there a way that they can be notified as to that outstanding fee owed by one of the spouses? I'm glad you asked that question
because yes. Me too. I thank you for asking that question because, yes, DFA sends a letter out in November notifying them that when they file their income tax the next time around, this is going to be deducted because that allows them to go to the court and make it right beforehand. So thank you for the question because it jogged my memory that, yes, they are notified through the normal legal processes.
are you closed for your bill? Closed for the bill. Appreciate a good vote. Right. Any objection to rolling the vote? Seeing none, Madam Clerk, please roll the vote. Ballinger, Bledsoe, Bond, Caldwell, Cheatham, Chesterfield, Clark, Cooper, Davis, Dismang, Eades, Elliott, English, Flippo, Flowers, Garner, Hammer, Hendron, Hester, Hickey, Hill, Ingram, Irvin, Blake Johnson, Mark Johnson, Letting, Malik, Pitch, Rapert, Rice, Sample, Stubbefield, Starch, Teague, Wallace. Would any senator like to change their vote? Seeing
requirements of contractors. You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair, Mr. President. This is a bill that came out of the red tape reduction task force effort from the last year. As you know, we've been involved in a co-chaired with Representative Cozart, an effort to examine red tape reduction in Arkansas and concerning licensing. And this bill was one of the bills that came out of that. This is an agreed to bill the contractors themselves came came to us and said this is what we'd like to do and modifications we'd like to do in our process one of the things that I did early on in that was encourage them to look inwardly into their boards and to see what they could do to reduce red tape and make some common sense changes within and bring things to us that they would suggest to be done rather than us trying to impose changes from our standpoint on them. So they came several months ago to me and said that they had some changes that they would like to make to this process. And this bill that they brought to us, these changes that they brought to us consists of four things. One is it changes the registration process from the licensing process to a registration process for subcontractors. Number two, it provides a surety bond for that process of those people that will not be licensed, but they will be registered. They will be under a surety bond as well. Number three, it modifies the commercial side, changes an unclassified misdemeanor to a Class A misdemeanor for violations. On the commercial side, or on the residential side, it produces a criminal violation on that side. And number four, there's also a section in there that they added concerning elderly or at-risk populations if they were abused or neglected or taken advantage of. So that's the four things that this bill does, and I appreciate a good vote. Try to answer any questions if you have
Senator Cooper, I'm just reading as quick as I can this bill. At the beginning of the bill, it says there was a group, a commission or something, or many states.
That refers to the task force that I chaired that was appointed by the governor. We studied that situation with boards and licensing for the last year. There are several states that are involved in that effort to reduce red tape.
Well, my question is, what kinds of problems did you all address? I mean, for instance, okay, you're saying now the contractor can be licensed or registered. They can register. The subcontractor
bond? Yes, they have to be, they have to put up a bond. They have to register. It's a two-step process. They register and put up the bond, which covers violations if they have any, the financial side of that. There's also a part of that where that is an option, actually. They can submit a financial statement if they choose to do that, but this is one option where maybe there's a project that they don't have time to actually go back and do a financial statement. They can do a bonding quicker than they can do a financial
statement. But they have the option of either one. So presently under our law, does that subcontractor have to be licensed? Does the subcontractor have to be licensed
They do? Yeah. So, I mean, can you give some, I'm just trying to understand because, I mean, I've seen some real terrible contractors. and at the local level, generally a contractor is going to go to the city, ask for a permit and the city has different little ordinances and the ordinance might say you got to have a bond but there's nobody checking and they also have to say how much the project is worth. What is the amount of the project? And there's no way, how do you know that unless you just have to depend on that
person? Sister Flowers, all of that process is outside what this bill does. This bill does the four things that I've enumerated here. All of that process is handled under different statutes. but in your
bond or how much are their assets supposed to be work uh there's a formula there i believe it's uh 10 times uh their net worth there's a multiple there that's that the
uh contractors board uh recommended that that be and it's it's pretty significant and my last question is does the contracting board have enough staff to maybe determine whether what that person who is registering are their licensing is really truthful yeah thank you sister flat senator flowers
I believe they do they didn't express to me that they had any concerns about that. They administer that now and they didn't indicate to me that that would be a significant difference in manpower. If they did, they didn't raise that issue. Thank you. Any
are you closed for your bill? I appreciate a good vote. I'm closed. Thank you. Any objection to rolling the vote? please roll the vote. Ballinger, Bledsoe, Bond, Caldwell, Cheatham, Chesterfield, Clark, Cooper, Davis, Dismayne, Eades, Elliott, English, Flippo, Flowers, Garner, Hammer, Kendron, Hester, Hickey, Hill, Ingram, Irvin, Blake Johnson, Mark Mark Johnson, Letting, Malik, Pitch, Rapert, Rice, Sample, Stubbefield, Sturge, Teague, Wallace. Any senators would like to change their vote? Seeing none, please cast
of the Senate, there are some lovely ladies in red and white who are with us. I'd ask them to stand and I'd ask the Senate to welcome the ladies of Delta Sigma Theta sorority to the chamber. They come from around the state of Arkansas, they are the largest black female sorority in the country and they do a remarkable job of public service and so we welcome you and please come again. Thank you. Senator Dismay. Thanks Senator.
Just real quick I want to go back over because I was out of the chamber and I think we caught them as they were walking out and they've come back in. But we have a group from Harding University here today. I think they're in both chambers so I want to give them a welcome. And then just to kind of put it out there, they're also being led by Lori Klein who is one of our ethics commissioners. So anyway, let's welcome them to the chamber. Thank you all.
Senator Pitch. Thank you, Mr. President. For those of you who are on the Arts Council or would like to, tomorrow at 8 o'clock in room 151, we're having our second meeting, and Senator Elliott asked me to remind you all. Thank
there items on the desk? Yes, sir. Senate Bill 412 by joint budget, an act for the Department of Education, Educational Television Division, Capital Improvement Appropriation, Senate Bill 412. Joint budget. Senate Bill 413 by joint budget, an act for the Department of Education, Arkansas School for the Deaf, Capital Improvement Appropriation, Senate Bill 413. Joint budget. Senate Bill 414 by Joint Budget, an Act for the Department of Education, Arkansas School for the Blind, Capital Improvement and Appropriations, Senate Bill 414 Joint Budget Senate Bill 415 by Joint Budget, an Act for the Department of Education, Capital Improvement and Appropriations, Senate Bill 415 Joint Budget Senate bill 416 by joint budget, an act for comment . Senate bill 416. . Senate bill 417 by joint budget, an act for the institution of high education capital improvement appropriations. Senate bill 417. Benriorisk terra��, 19. Senate bill 418 by joint budget, an act for state crime laboratory capital improvement appropriations. Senate bill 418, 418. Straight budget. Joint Budget, an act for the State Military Department, Capital Improvement Appropriations. Senate Bill 419. Turn Budget. Senate Bill 420 by Joint Budget, an act for the Arkansas Geographic Information System Office, Capital Improvement Fund, Senate Bill 420. Turn Budget. Senate Bill 421 by Joint Budget, an act for the Arkansas Agricultural Department, Capital Improvement Appropriations. Senate Bill 421. Turn Budget. Senate Bill 422 by Joint Budget, an act for the Department of Human Services, Division of County Operations, Capital Improvement Appropriations, Senate Bill 422. Joint Budget. Senate Bill 423 by Joint Budget, an act for the Department of Health, Capital Improvement Appropriations, Senate Bill 423. Joint Budget. Senate Bill 424 by Joint Budget, an act for the Department of Finance Administration, Management Services Division, Capital Improvement Appropriations, Senate Bill 424. Joint Budget. Synbal 425 by Joint Budget, an act for the Department of Finance Administration monday. Dispersing office, huh. Capital improvement appropriation is a secret for 25. Joint Budge. Single 426 by Joint Budget, an act for the Department of Finance Administration building authority capital division capital improvement appropriation. Synbal 426. Joint Budge. Original 427 by Joint Budget, an act for the Department of Human Services, division of youth services, capital improvement appropriation. Senate 427. Joint Budget. Senate 429 by joint budget, an act for the Arkansas Economic Development Commission, capital improvement projects, grants and programs, appropriations. Senate 429. Court Budget. Senate 430 by joint budget, an act for the Secretary of State capital improvement appropriations, Senate 430. Joint Budget. Senate Bill 431, by joint budget, an act for the Department of Finance Administration, Alcohol, Beverage, Control, Enforcement Division, Supplemental Appropriation, Senate Bill 431. Turned budget. Senate Bill 432, by joint budget, an act for the Arkansas State University BB Supplemental Appropriation, Senate Bill 432. Turned budget. Senate Bill 433, by joint budget, an act for the Department of Finance Administration, Building Authority Division, Supplemental Appropriations, Senate Bill 433. Joint budget. You ready? You want to do it right now?
Mr. President, I need to make a re-referral of a bill. And for the members that are still here, I actually talked with Senator Irvin. She's the chairman of public health. Yesterday, we had a bill referred. And it was forgotten that all of the funeral home bills now are under the insurance commissioner. And so Senate Bill 298 got referred. And I talked to Steve. He said, I just forgot about that situation, so I've talked with Senator Irvin. If there's no objections, we'll re-refer Bill Senate 298 to Insurance and Commerce for consideration there.
objection, so moved. Senate Bill 433, by Joint Budget and Act for the Department of Finance Administration, Building Authority Division Supplemental Appropriations, Senate Bill 433. Joint Budget. Senate Bill 434 by Joint Budget, an act for the SAU Tech Supplemental Appropriations, Senate Bill 434. Joint Budget. Senate Bill 435 by Joint Budget, an act for the University of Arkansas Fayetteville Supplemental Appropriations, Senate Bill 435. Joint Budget. Senate Bill 436 by Joint Budget, an act for the University of Central Arkansas Supplemental Appropriations, Senate Bill 436. Joint Budget. Senate Bill 437 by joint budget, an act for the Arkansas Minority Health Commission for the Minority Health Initiative of the Targeted State Needs Program Supplemental Appropriations. Senate Bill 437. Senate Bill 438 by joint budget, an act for the Department of Veterans Affairs Supplemental Appropriations. Senate Bill 438. Senate Bill 439 by joint budget, an act for the Department of Parks and Tourism Supplemental Appropriations. Joint Budget. Senate Bill 440 by Joint Budget, an act to amend Arkansas Constitution, Amendment 98, and to ban use of medical marijuana in food and drink, except in certain circumstances. Senate Bill 440. Agriculture. Senate Bill 441 by Senator Bledsoe, an act to amend Arkansas Constitution, Amendment 98, and to add restrictions regarding advertising and the use of certain symbols. Senate Bill 441. Agriculture. Senate Bill 442 by Senator Malick, an act for the Southern Arkansas University Veterinary Technology Program Appropriation for the 2019-2020 fiscal year, Senate Bill 442. Joint Budget. Senate Bill 443 by Senator Davis to require diaper changing accommodations in certain buildings, Senate Bill 443. Public Health. Senate Bill 444 by Joint Budget, an act for the Arkansas Geological Survey Capital Improvement Appropriation, Senate Bill 444. Joint Budget. Senate Bill 445 by Senator Garner to provide for a March primary election on years in which the Office of President of the United States will be voted on and to amend the time for the General Assembly to meet in fiscal session, Senate Bill 445. State agencies. Senate Bill 446 by Senator Letting concerning step therapy requirements for certain prescription drugs to treat metastasis cancer, Senate Bill 446. Insurance Commerce. to increase the homestead property tax credit to maintain funding for current property tax relief to provide for the use of the excess funds in the property tax relief trust fund to declare an emergency to Senate Bill 447. Revenue and tax. Any more
announcements to come before the body? You? No? I'm seeing none. Thank you. The Senate stands adjourned, subject to the clearing of the desk until 1 p.m. tomorrow.
Speaker 89 read a slate of engrossed and grossed bills and resolutions for committee consideration, including Senate Bills 9, 90, 264, 304, 409, 410, 411 and numerous others across the Judiciary, Public Health, Education, and State Agencies committees.
[13:33][14:06][14:37][15:10][15:40][16:23][17:09]
Senators offered informal remarks, with Senator Trent Garner celebrating the Senate’s recent victory over the House and noting an upcoming plaque ceremony, while Senator Jim Hendren welcomed a leadership group from Harding.
[18:17][18:48][19:00][19:04][19:20]
The chair announced a State Agencies meeting on constitutional amendments scheduled for the next morning, and Speaker 89 reported the referral status of several House Bills and a Senate resolution for passage.
[20:11][20:25][20:34]
SR10 Hill COMMENDING THE ARKANSAS CHAPTER OF THE ALZHEIMER'S ASSOCIATION AND PROCLAIMING FEBRUARY 26, 2019, AS ALZHEIMER'S AWARENESS DAY.
22:31 - 28:1116 segments7 speakers
Senator Ricky Hill introduced Senate Resolution 10 commending the Arkansas Chapter of the Alzheimer’s Association and proclaiming February 26, 2019 as Alzheimer’s Awareness Day, providing statistics, personal testimony, and the full text of the resolution before it was read aloud.
[22:49][23:13][23:36][23:43][23:46][24:19][24:49][25:23][25:55]
The Senate voted aye with no opposition, carrying the resolution.
[26:24][26:27]
SB114 #1 J. Sturch TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE APPOINTMENT OF CITY TREASURER IN A CITY OF THE SECOND CLASS AND AN INCORPORATED TOWN.
28:11 - 30:2610 segments4 speakers
Senator John Cooper moved to concur with a House amendment that added a co-sponsor to Senate Bill 114, which amends the law concerning the appointment of city treasurers in second-class cities and incorporated towns.
[28:15][28:28][28:34][28:37][28:46]
After roll call, the Senate approved the amended bill by a unanimous 34-yea vote, and the measure was enrolled.
[29:32][29:50][30:05]
SB147 B. Ballinger TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING ALIMONY SUPPORT.
30:26 - 1:09:43105 segments15 speakers
Senator Ballinger introduced SB 147, outlining a framework for “restorative” alimony that would give courts discretion, would not affect child-support or property settlements, and would allow a party to petition for a change when circumstances shift.
[30:30][30:52][31:23][31:33][31:44][31:55]
SB200 B. Sample TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE ELIGIBILITY OF A MEMBER TO RECEIVE AN INCREASE IN BENEFITS UNDER THE ARKANSAS STATE HIGHWAY EMPLOYEES' RETIREMENT SYSTEM.
1:09:43 - 1:11:136 segments3 speakers
Senator Bill Sample introduced SB 200 to remove the cost-of-living adjustment for health-care offsets in the Arkansas State Highway Employees’ Retirement System, describing it as a sustainability measure.
[1:09:53][1:10:02]
No members sought to speak, the vote was rolled, and the bill passed unanimously, 34 yeas and zero nays.
[1:10:21][1:10:32][1:11:02]
SB201 B. Sample TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE CONTRIBUTIONS OF MEMBERS AND EMPLOYERS UNDER THE ARKANSAS STATE HIGHWAY EMPLOYEES' RETIREMENT SYSTEM; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
1:11:13 - 1:07:31
Senator Bill Sample presented SB 201 to increase member contribution rates from 6 % to 7 % over two years for the Highway Employees’ Retirement System, again emphasizing system sustainability.
[1:11:23][1:11:37][1:12:04][1:12:08]
The Senate recorded no opposition, rolled the vote, and adopted the bill with 34 yeas and zero nays.
[1:12:39]
SB218 E. Cheatham TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING DEPOSITS IN THE TEACHER DEFERRED RETIREMENT OPTION PLAN; TO REPEAL CERTAIN PROVISIONS CONCERNING THE TEACHER DEFERRED RETIREMENT OPTION PLAN; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
1:07:31 - 1:13:0120 segments5 speakers
Senator Eddie Cheatham presented SB 218 to codify and consolidate changes to the Teacher Deferred Retirement Option Plan, stating it would simply organize existing provisions without substantive amendment.
[1:07:45][1:08:15][1:08:27]
SB222 E. Cheatham TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING MEMBER CONTRIBUTIONS UNDER THE ARKANSAS TEACHER RETIREMENT SYSTEM; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
1:13:01 - 1:14:377 segments3 speakers
Senator Eddie Cheatham introduced SB 222 to codify member-contribution rules for the Arkansas Teacher Retirement System, noting it merely consolidates existing law without effecting change.
[1:13:09][1:13:39][1:13:47][1:13:54][1:14:10]
With no objections, the measure was rolled and passed unanimously, 34 yeas and zero nays.
[1:14:22]
SB315 K. Hammer TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING DRIVER'S LICENSE REINSTATEMENT FEES.
1:14:37 - 1:22:0323 segments5 speakers
Senator Kim Hammer explained SB 315 would make permanent a system that captures unpaid suspended-driver-license fees through state income-tax returns and directs the proceeds to the state police, citing a two-year pilot that collected over $2.5 million.
[1:14:42][1:15:18][1:15:53][1:16:25]
SB342 J. Cooper TO AMEND THE LAWS CONCERNING THE CONTRACTORS LICENSING BOARD; AND TO AMEND THE LICENSING REQUIREMENTS OF CONTRACTORS.
1:22:03 - 1:30:1833 segments7 speakers
Senator John Cooper introduced SB 342, a bill emerging from the Governor-appointed red-tape reduction task force and co-chaired with Representative Cozart, outlining four key reforms to the Contractors Licensing Board’s processes.
[1:22:16][1:22:37][1:23:12][1:23:45]
The reforms would (1) shift subcontractors from a licensing to a registration system, (2) require a surety bond for registered subcontractors, (3) elevate certain violations to a Class A misdemeanor on the commercial side and create a criminal violation on the residential side, and (4) add protections for elderly or at-risk individuals.
[1:23:45][1:24:21]
Senator Jason Rapert moved to re-refer Senate Bill 298, concerning funeral-home legislation that had been mistakenly placed under the Insurance Commissioner, back to the Insurance and Commerce Committee for proper consideration.
[1:35:12]
The chair called for objections, none were offered, and the motion carried unanimously.
[1:35:44][1:35:59]