May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 12, 2026
SR9 G. Stubblefield CONGRATULATING THE PARIS HIGH SCHOOL VOLLEYBALL TEAM FOR AN OUTSTANDING RECORD 9:33
Senator Gary Stubblefield presented Senate Resolution 9 honoring the Paris High School Girls Volleyball Team, detailing its four-year state-championship run, seven consecutive state-final appearances, multiple district and conference titles, and a 3.68 GPA average.
[9:33][9:42][9:48][10:22][10:52][11:28]
The Senate moved to adopt the resolution, with all members voting aye and no opposition, resulting in its passage.
[12:10][12:22]
SCR2 Hester COMMENDING GUATEMALA FOR RELOCATING THE GUATEMALAN EMBASSY IN ISRAEL TO JERUSALEM. 16:18
Senator Bart Hester introduced Senate Concurrent Resolution 2 praising Guatemala for relocating its embassy in Israel to Jerusalem, noting the significance compared with U.S. efforts.
[16:23][16:55]
During discussion Senator Keith Ingram asked about the logistics of delivering the commendation, which the chair said was being worked on.
[17:00][17:07]
The Senate unanimously approved the concurrent resolution, with all members voting aye and the measure transmitted to the House.
[17:11]
Senator Wallace offered Amendment 2 to Senate Bill 76, inserting an emergency clause, and the amendment was adopted by voice vote.
[18:00]
SB148 #1 Hester TO MODIFY THE SMALL BUSINESS ENTITY TAX PASS THROUGH ACT; AND TO PROVIDE FOR A TEMPORARY LIEN AT THE TIME A CHARGING APPLICATION IS FILED. 18:25
Senator Bart Hester introduced Amendment 1 to Senate Bill 148 to refine language about individual member interests in the Small Business Entity Tax Pass-Through Act, explaining it would prevent unintended effects on entire LLCs.
[18:27][18:32]
The amendment was approved by unanimous voice vote and sent to engrossing.
[18:41]
Senator Trent Garner sought to suspend the rules to place Senate Bill 176, amending regulation of pyramid promotional schemes, at the end of the calendar after a one-word amendment was offered.
[18:49][18:53]
SB176 #1 T. Garner TO AMEND THE REGULATION OF PYRAMIDING DEVICES AND TO REGULATE THE PYRAMID PROMOTIONAL SCHEMES. 18:58
After brief discussion, the amendment was adopted by voice vote and the motion to suspend the rules was carried unanimously, allowing the bill to be scheduled for consideration later that day.
[19:19][19:34][19:39][19:46][19:56][20:05]
HB1124 #1 Vaught Maloch TO AMEND THE LAWS CONCERNING VETERINARY MEDICINE; AND TO ESTABLISH A VETERINARY TECHNOLOGIST CERTIFICATION AND A VETERINARY TECHNICIAN … 20:35
Senator Bruce Maloch explained Amendment 1 to House Bill 1124, which clarifies that veterinarians must retain supervisory control over veterinary technicians and technologists even when not physically present.
[20:38][20:46][21:13]
Following questions, the Senate voted aye with no opposition, adopting the amendment and sending the bill to engrossing.
[21:19][21:22][21:26][21:38]
HB1125 #1 Evans Irvin TO PROHIBIT AN INSURER FROM REQUIRING PAYMENT FOR HEALTHCARE SERVICES THROUGH GIFT CARDS, CREDIT CARDS, OR VIRTUAL CREDIT CARDS. 21:43
Senator Missy Irvin presented an amendment to House Bill 1125 that would bar insurers from requiring payment for health services through gift cards, credit cards, or virtual cards, adding herself as a Senate sponsor.
[21:46][21:52]
The amendment was adopted unanimously, and the chair subsequently moved to refer the bill back to committee for a missed amendment, which was also approved.
[22:00][22:10]
SB160 B. Ballinger TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING SAMPLE BALLOTS; AND TO ALLOW VOLUMINOUS NUMBERS OF SAMPLE BALLOTS TO BE MADE AVAILABLE TO THE PUBLIC BY OTHER ME… 22:27
Senator Jim Ballinger offered an amendment to Senate Bill 160 to modernize the sample-ballot statute by permitting bound books or electronic tablets instead of only wall postings, citing recent school-election issues.
[22:38][22:43][23:15][23:27]
After a brief question period, the Senate rolled a voice vote, recording 34 yeas and no nays, and the bill was passed and transmitted to the House.
[23:33][23:54][24:05]
SB167 L. Eads TO DESIGNATE STATE HIGHWAY 549, ALSO KNOWN AS FUTURE I-49, IN NORTHWEST ARKANSAS AS A SCENIC HIGHWAY. 24:23
Senator Lance Eads introduced Senate Bill 167 to designate State Highway 549 (Future I-49) in Northwest Arkansas as a scenic highway, noting it would aid tourism without altering signage or billboard regulations.
[24:26][25:01][25:07]
The Senate unanimously approved the designation by voice vote, recording 34 yeas and no nays, and the bill was sent to the House.
[25:14][25:32][25:44]
SB196 K. Ingram TO ADOPT FEDERAL INTERNAL REVENUE CODE PROVISIONS CONCERNING OPPORTUNITY ZONES; AND TO PROVIDE STATE TAX INCENTIVES RELATED TO INVESTMENTS IN O… 26:32
Senator Keith Ingram introduced Senate Bill 196, adopting federal opportunity-zone provisions and providing state capital-gains tax incentives to spur investment in Arkansas’s 85 designated zones, outlining the tax benefits and urging a favorable vote.
[26:32][26:35][26:48][27:06][27:40][28:11]
SB211 J. Dismang Hendren TO CREATE THE TAX COMPETITIVENESS AND RELIEF ACT OF 2019; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY 31:58
Senator Jim Hendren presented Senate Bill 211, the Tax Competitiveness and Relief Act of 2019, noting it was the same tax-cut measure debated previously and requesting a vote.
[32:02][32:06][32:09]
Following a roll call that recorded both ayes and nays among members, the Senate concluded the vote with no further objections and proceeded to pass the measure.
[32:41][33:11][33:49][34:10][34:32][35:29]
SB225 M. Pitsch TO AMEND THE LAWS CONCERNING THE ARKANSAS ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT COUNCIL AND THE ARKANSAS ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT COMMISSION. 35:42
Senator Mathew Pitsch presented Senate Bill 225 to revise the Arkansas Economic Development Council and Commission, granting authority over foreign-trade zones, enhancing minority- and women-owned business programs, shifting energy oversight to ADEQ, and simplifying job-creation reporting requirements.
[35:44][35:51][36:01][36:35]
Following a brief question period, the Senate unanimously approved the bill by voice vote, recording 34 ayes and no nays, and transmitted it to the House.
[36:46][37:01][37:04][37:16][37:41][37:46][38:05]
SB170 Hester CONCERNING COUNTY AND MUNICIPAL REGULATION OF RESIDENTIAL BUILDING DESIGN ELEMENTS. 38:13
Senator Bart Hester introduced SB 170, explaining that it would bar counties and municipalities from imposing residential design standards-except for safety, historic districts, mobile homes and limited overlay districts-and noted that he was still negotiating final language with the Municipal League.
[38:16][38:20][38:50][39:24][39:57]
Senators questioned whether private covenants would remain enforceable and expressed frustration that amendment language had been delayed repeatedly, with the bill’s timeline slipping from 24 hours to several days.
[40:32][40:54][41:00][41:14][41:39]
Senator Joyce Elliott voiced ambivalence, warning that the measure could amount to state usurpation of local zoning authority and asked if waiting for finalized language was prudent, while Senator Keith Ingram strongly opposed, arguing the bill would strip cities of zoning power, hand unchecked control to developers, and urged holding the legislation until concerns were resolved.
[42:11][42:43][42:46][42:51][43:20][43:30][50:43][51:16][51:50][52:21][52:58][53:29][54:01]
Supporters such as Senator Trent Garner and Senator Alan Clark argued the bill protects individual property rights and should proceed, and after disclosures of potential conflicts the committee voted 23 yeas, 11 nays, and one abstention, passing SB 170 to the House.
[54:32][55:03][55:40][56:11][56:44][57:16][57:56][58:29][58:51][1:16:09][1:16:28]
including those in the gallery. Senator Rapert is going to lead us in a word of prayer. If we can find him. Senator Hendren you want Senator Hendren is going to lead us in a word of prayer Let's pray. Lord we thank you
for your many blessings we thank you for the ability to serve here in the Senate God we just ask that you'll give us wisdom that you'll help us to make the decisions that are best for the people that we serve Lord we just thank you for those that are serving us in foreign lands we thank you for those that are away from their families we ask for their safety and God we just ask that you'll guide and direct all that we do today that it will bring honor and glory to you. In Jesus' name, amen. To the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for
Senator Hendren is recognized. Leave for Senator Dismayne without objection. Anyone else? Madam Secretary, are there any items to be read across the desk? Yes, sir. We hear a committee on
engrossed bills to whom was referred to Senate Bill 150 by Senator Davies compared the engrossed copy with the original and find the same correctly engrossed. Insurance Commerce. We hear a committee on engrossed bills to whom was referred to Senate Bill 197 by Senator Ballinger, compare the engrossed copy with the original and find the same correctly engrossed. City, county, local. Will your committee on engrossed bills, who was first sent by 144 by Senator Ballinger, compare the engrossed copy with the original
an announcement, please. Thank you, Governor. Members, I'd like for you all to help me welcome the Pleasant Valley Mennonite School. If you all would stand up. They're from Southern Lafayette County. Now, I will have to give you all another little story real quick. They think that Senator Malek is their senator because he was originally their representative, so they always call him and he always takes care of them and does a great job, but we are glad to have you here today. Thank you.
Senator Elliott is recognized. Thank you, Governor. I'd like to ask leave for Sarah Strickland, who is right over here, to have permission to be on the floor today, and I'll tell you who she is if you give me leave. Thank you. But I do want you to meet, if all of you would direct your attention, right over to Sarah because you're going to be seeing her around here. She is Sarah Strickland, and she's a graduate of Indiana University with a degree in arts administration. She is going to volunteer her time to the Arts Caucus to help us think about and give us expertise on some of the things we can do, and she's volunteering to do that. So I'm so excited that she's from Little Rock and has chosen to do this for us as volunteer work, a brand new graduate. So will you please welcome Sarah Strickland. You'll be seeing her around.
Yes, sir. Will your Committee on Education to whom is first Senate Bill 135 by Senator Hammer recommend do pass? Calendar. Committee on Education to whom is first Senate Bill 199 by Senator Davis recommend do pass. Calendar. Committee on Education to whom is first Senate Bill 225 by Senator Hickey recommend do pass. Is that
your Committee on Education to whom is first Senate Bill 156 by Senator Ballinger recommend do pass as amended number 3. Calendar. Will your Committee on Judiciary to whom is first Senate Bill 152 by Senator Irving recommend do pass. Calendar. Committee on Judiciary to whom was first Senate Bill 183 by Senator Clark recommend do pass. Calendar. Committee on Judiciary to whom was first Senate Bill 207 by Senator Irving recommend do pass. Calendar. Committee on Judiciary to whom was first Senate Bill 227 by Senator Pitch recommend do pass. Calendar. Committee on Public Health to whom was first Senate Bill 149 by Senator Rapert recommend do pass. Calendar. Committee on Public Health to whom was first Senate Bill 168 by Senator Bledsoe recommend do pass. do pass. Calendar. Committee on Public Health, who was for House Bill 1013 by Representative Boyd, recommend do pass. Calendar. Committee on Public Health, who was for House Bill 1225 by Representative Bentley, recommend do pass. Calendar. Committee on Public Health, who was for House Bill 1317 by Representative Boyd, recommend do pass. Calendar. Dear Mr. President, this is to inform you that on February 6, 2019, I approve the following approve the following measures from the regular session of the 92nd General Assembly. Senate Bill 17, Act 61, Senate Bill 79, Act 62, Senate Bill 80, Act 63. Follow. Will your Committee on Enrolled Bills, to whom was referred Joint Budget Bills 20, 41, 43, 46, 47, 51, 58, 59, 65, 73, 92, 95, recommend, and also Senate Bill 155 by Senator Teague, compare the enrolled copies with the original and have delivered to the governor at 10.05 a.m. File it. Senate Bill 268 by Senator Blake Johnson and Senator Garner. To amend the law concerning the deposit and distribution of fees to the Department of Arkansas State Police Fund, Senate Bill 268. Transportation. Senate Bill 269 by Senator Bledsoe. To update references to the accreditation organization related to physician assistance, Senate Bill 269. Public Health. Senate Bill 270 by Senator Bledsoe, to extend the registration deadline for a surgical technologist, Senate Bill 270. Public Health. Senate Bill 271 by Senator Bledsoe, to update references to an accreditation organization related to occupational therapy, Senate Bill 271. Public Health. Senate Bill 272 by Senator Bledsoe, to repeal an obsolete law regarding the recording of a certificate before practicing medicine, Senate Bill 272. Public Health. Symbol 273 by Senator Bledsoe. To clarify that an expert witness acting on behalf of a board or any profession or occupation classified under the laws of the state of Arkansas as a profession of the healing arts has immunity and declare an emergency. Symbol 273. Public Health Senate Bill 274 by Senator Bledsoe To aid fellowship as a method for a foreign graduate to obtain a license to practice medicine and declare an emergency Senate Bill 274 Public Health Senate Bill 275 by Senator Bledsoe To clarify a law regarding out-of-state physicians who practice patient care services initiated in this state through the use of any medium Senate Bill 275 Public Health Senate Bill 276 by Senator Garner, to amend Arkansas law concerning the dates of general primary election and preferential primary election, and to amend the time period for filing as a candidate for a primary election, Senate Bill 276.
Res. 9. Senate Resolution 9 by Senator Stubblefield congratulating the Paris High School Volleyball Team for an outstanding record. Senator Stubblefield. Senator Stubblefield. Thank
Okay. okay whereas the parents high school volleyball team finished the season by winning their fourth consecutive state 3a final whereas the volleyball team has been to the state final seven seasons in a row whereas overall the team has brought home seven district tournament titles, five conference titles in the last nine years, whereas the team recently won the Lady Eagles Invitational Tournament for the first time in the program history, whereas the team's average GPA at the end of the fall 2018 semester was 3.68. the team has been ably led and inspired by excellent head coaches Jordan Devine and whereas the motto for the team is C-A-N-I, which means constant and never-ending improvement, a motto that has encouraged the team along with the support of their families, friends, and community through all their challenges and successes and is a tribute to their talent, hard work, and leadership. Now therefore, it be it resolved by the Senate of the 92nd General Assembly of the State of Arkansas that the Senate congratulates the Parris High School volleyball team, head coach Jordan Devine, for an excellent record, be it further resolved that upon adoption of this resolution, copies shall be sent to the Parris High School volleyball team by the Secretary of State.
Thank y'all. Senator Hester. Senate Concurrent Resolution 2 by Senator Hester. We're committing Guatemala for relocating the Guatemalan Embassy to Israel in Jerusalem.
Senator? To Jerusalem. Thank you, Governor. Well, you know, this is real simple just as it reads. We're committing Guatemala for relocating the Guatemalan Embassy in Israel to Jerusalem. And as we know, our previous past five presidents have committed to move the U.S. Embassy to Jerusalem, and they haven't done it because of the political pressure, and it's a very difficult thing to do. But the U.S. did it. Guatemala is the only country that has followed, and just out of respect for them and understanding the political pressures that they face doing the right thing, I wanted to say thank you. Happy to answer any questions.
working on that plan currently. Any other questions? If anyone wish to speak on it. All those in favor say aye. Opposed? Ayes have it. Senate Concurrent Resolution 2 is passed. Transmit to the House.
running behind on my job. We have a Doctor of the Day, Dr. Tracy Baltz back here, ophthalmologist in Little Rock. Give him a big round of applause. And then our nurse, Brenda Hewitt, Linda Hewitt, of course, so say
thank you again to her. Thank you. We're going to move from, do you have an announcement? Okay, move from the morning hour to the business agendas. Senator Wallace, an amendment to SB 76 with an emergency clause. Thank you, Senator. Amendment 2 to Senate Bill 76. My amendment, my bill. Any questions for Senator Wallace? All those in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? Ayes have it. Amendments adopted. Emergency clause adopted. Send
Bill 148, Amendment 1. Thank you, Governor. This is an amendment brought by some local attorneys that helped clarify some language that I thought was appropriate, basically identifying a member's interest and not just the member so you don't affect an entire LLC. Appreciate a good vote. Any
questions? All those in favor say aye. Opposed? Ayes have it. Amendments adopted. Send to engrossing. Senator Garner. Amendment 1 to Senate Bill 176. Thank you,
one word to the thing. If it's the will of the body, I'd like to make a motion to suspend the rules to put this at the end of the calendar so it'd be heard today. Substantially the same bill we heard in committee that's been out for a week or two now. I would like to do that. So a motion to suspend the rules to put this at the end of the calendar today.
Got to adopt the amendment first. Got you. Yeah, we're going to do the amendment first, and then we'll do the motion. So any questions on the amendment? All those in favor say aye. Opposed? Amendment's adopted. Senator Engrossing. Okay, now the senator has a motion to suspend the rules.
day as amended. Okay. You've heard the motion. Senator Teague has a question for Senator Garner on the motion. Senator Garner, what's our urgency? Senator Teague, I
just wanted to get it done today and just be done with it. I mean, we can wait until tomorrow if you want to, but it's substantially the same bill. I don't think there'll be any
issue hearing it today. I appreciate it. Thank you. Yes, sir. Any other questions? You've heard the motion. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? Aye. Aye as have it. Amendment. The motion is carried. Bill will be moved to the calendar for
Senator Malek. Thank you, Mr. President. Members, when this bill was presented in the House, there were some questions and an agreed upon amendment with the House sponsor, and so it's my amendment with the agreement of the House sponsor, and I'd be happy to answer any questions, and then we'll have the bill
Malik. Senator Malik, what is the amendment? Okay, it clarified, of course this is the veterinary technician and technologist bill, it clarified the oversight requirements of the veterinarian to the technologist. In what way? There was some concern on indirect supervision that the veterinarian still had control and responsibility even if they weren't personally present. It was just clarifying that. Is it still a supervisory requirement? Excuse
questions for Senator Malek on the amendment? All those in favor of the amendment say aye. Opposed? Ayes have it. Amendments adopted. Send to engrossing. Senator Irvin.
sponsor. All those in favor say aye. Opposed? Ayes have it. Amendment's adopted. Senator Engrossing. Senator Ballard. I'm sorry. Go ahead. I need to make
Senator Ballinger, SB 160. Senate Bill 160 by Senator Ballinger to amend the law concerning sample ballots and to allow voluminous numbers of sample ballots to be made available to the public by any means. Senator Ballinger. Thank
you, Mr. President. This is really a fairly simple bill. So what happened is we have a law dealing with sample ballots that basically says you've got to post sample ballots on the wall at the polling place. And that was fine, but then what happened when we moved the school elections, which to me was a good idea, but what it does is produce some other problems like many, many, many ballot faces. So now all of a sudden you've got to post a whole bunch of them. This doesn't change that. You can still do that. Or what you can do is you can actually put together a bound book, or you can put together a bound book and use it on tablet or technology. And so this is something that was brought to me by the board election commissioners, just kind of a clean up to sort of fix something that we changed last time. And
the vote. Anyone wish to speak on it? The senator has closed. Any objection to rolling the vote? Please roll the vote, Madam Secretary. Malinger, Bledsoe, Bond, Caldwell, Cheatham, Chesterfield, Clark, Cooper, Dismane, Davis, Eves, Elliott, English, Flippo, Flowers, Garner, Hammer, Hendron, Hester, Hickey, Hill, Ingram, Irvin, Blake Johnson, Mark Johnson, Letting, Malik, Pitch, Rayford, Rice, Sample, Stubblefield, Sturge, Teague, Wallace. Anyone wish to change their vote?
a Scenic Highway. Senator Eads is recognized. Thank you, Governor. And this bill is actually shorter than the title that she just read. But what this does is actually takes the new section of highway that's being completed in Northwest Arkansas from the 71549 interchange there in Bentonville to the Missouri state line and make it a scenic highway so that they can change the shielding and the maps for the benefit of tourism. And it doesn't change anything, any requirements as far as signage or still allows for billboards or anything like that. And I would appreciate a
building design elements. Senator Hester. I just told a few members that I would push this to the in the calendar today, and as negotiations shockingly have picked up pace since we said we're going to vote today. So I'm going to give a few more minutes. We're working on
it. OK. Senator Ingram. Senate Bill 196 by Senator Ingram to adopt federal Internal Revenue Code provisions concerning Opportunity Zones and to provide state tax incentives related to investments and Opportunity Zones. Senator
Ingram is recognized. Thank you, Governor. This is, in my opinion, the best thing that came out of the Federal Tax Act of last year. Senator Tim Scott from South Carolina included in this legislation what is called an Opportunity Zone. The governor has selected, they're based on census tracts, it is to help low and moderate income and make it attractive tracts, make it attractive to investment. This came through the tax task force, Senator Rapert was on it with me and Senator Hendren as you all know chaired it, I think Senator Pitch was on it. And this is part of the package, Senator Irvin, she was very much a part of it, would have We've gotten through a lot quicker if she hadn't been – no, I'm just kidding. But this was part of the tax package to come through, and in simplest form, this mirrors the federal law, Arkansas tax mirrors the federal law. If you locate in an opportunity zone, there are 85 of them in our state, and you hold it – your investment 10 years, you don't have any capital gains. It works a percentage up from five that's basically, I think, somewhere, I can't remember whether it's 50 percent, but at the end of the day, it makes it very attractive for businesses to locate in a census area like this. So I would ask you to vote for it.
a question. Thank you, Senator Ingram. I think I'm on now. Thank you, Senator Ingram. You may recall many years ago when you were mayor of West Memphis and I was assisting one of the industries there, I came to you and we got the designation for them as an enterprise-owned business, and I think that company grew pretty well. So I'm grateful to see us have an opportunity, no pun intended, to do this again. The state incentive is also a capital gains tax break. There's no other state incentive. It just mirrors exactly what the federal law is. But it doesn't preclude them from taking advantage of any of the other Arkansas tax breaks for expanding an industry. No, it's just another tool in the tool
you. Thank you, Senator Johnson. Any other questions? The senator has closed. Is there any good? Senator Raper wants to speak for the bill. Yes, I'm very
appreciative of the senator for bringing this bill. And I did want to make mention, if you have not known it, Congressman French Hill actually has been a huge proponent and put an article in the paper. And I want to make sure the body recognizes that he's been doing his best to make sure the legislature addresses this as well. And it's a great bill. It's going to mean a lot to the state of Arkansas. And thank you, Senator Ingram. Does anyone else wish to speak on the bill?
favor of the bill. And I will be quick and succinct. But, yes, I had the opportunity to serve on the task force, the tax reform task force, as a member of that body. And I just want to say, as a whole, this is an excellent bill. I'm so thankful that Senator Ingram has pursued this bill and is bringing it to us. But we did so much work on that task force, and I'm just really proud of the work that we did. And I just want to note, there were two young ladies. One was from the Tax Foundation and one was from ITEP. And those two young women who were economists did an extraordinary job with us on that task force. And so I just wanted to make a mention of them and their expertise that they provided us. And so I'm for this bill, and I just appreciate the work that the task force did
Bill 211 by Sen. Disming and Sen. Hendron to create the Tax Competitiveness and Relief Act of 2019 and declare an emergency. Senator Hendron has the floor. Thank you, Mr. President.
Disming yesterday, he didn't come back, so I'm running this for him today. But you all know what the bill is, the same bill we debated at length yesterday. It's the tax reform, tax cut bill, Senate Bill 211. Again, the same one that we passed or that we
voted on yesterday. I'd appreciate a good vote. Any questions? Anyone wish to speak on the bill? Any objection to rolling the vote? It's always worth a try. Madam Secretary, please call the roll and note that there is a pair of votes at the desk.
or anyone wish to change the vote on my right first anybody ever vote I don't know if anybody else would change their vote or vote or do not vote. We good? We good. My secretary says it's about 20 in the age, five days ago it happened. Won't you talk about this? Who's lunch? Who's, uh, Senator Johnson? Who's lunch? All the Americans have found? No opposed? No opposed. Thank you.
Economic Development Commission. Senator Pitch. Thank you, Governor. Senate Bill 225 is another AEDC bill. It's an act to enable the laws of the Economic Development Council. It's kind of their forming legislation. It has three major parts. It defines the existing role, which is in place, but it defines it of how they are over the foreign trade zones. It also incorporates changes to programs which are active to them, which are minority-owned and women-owned businesses, as well as a key thing that changed is energy was put under or AEDC, and the reality of it is it needs to be an ADEQ, so this deals with that. And finally, it deletes the requirement that we've asked companies to give how many jobs at what hourly rate, which is a competitive disadvantage for a company moving to Arkansas. Now it just has to give the number of jobs.
Seeing none, cast up the ballot. Thirty-four yays, zero and nays. The bill is passed. Transmit to the House. We are... Are you ready, Senator Hester? Okay. Senator Hester. Senator 170. Senate Bill
170 by Senator Hester. Concerning county municipal regulation of residential building design elements. Senator Hester. Thank you, Governor. I think, as
we all know, this is a bill that I've been negotiating on hard with the Municipal League and continuing to work hard on. We have yet to come to terms. Well, I've agreed to their terms, but we can't seem to get language. I don't know if Senator Bond knows how that works sometimes. Parties can agree, but the language seems to be very difficult to come by. They're telling me I'll have it sometime Friday, and if that comes about, I'm happy to amend on the, do as I said, and amend on the House, but we thought we'd have it in 24 hours, then 48, and so now on and on and on we go. We've seen, I think you've probably experienced this in some of your bills, but this is a simple bill that says that cities can't create design standards for housing. To date, I have not had one city that's provided a design standard that they currently do. North Little Rock does have one, but it was voluntarily put on by the property owner in conjunction with the city. These are typical POA things that determine if you should have vinyl or brick on your home, or the pitchness of your roof, or where a window should go. It excludes all safety concerns. So if you have a city that is concerned about safety, we excluded safety. We excluded mobile homes. We excluded downtown corridors. We excluded historical districts. We put some language here that we feel takes care of overlay districts. That's one of the concerns Municipal League. They want to clarify that language and I'm happy to clarify that language on, but again I think there's probably some questions. I'd be happy to answer those and I don't believe to date we know of a city that is currently doing this. This came up because in Northwest Arkansas we we have some subdivisions going up that have affordable workforce housing in there. There were some city planners that didn't like the looks of houses with vinyl on them. I've lived in houses with vinyl on them and quite proud of them. And anyway, we don't believe that it's a city's role to determine what the product outside of standard safety concerns how it should be made of. But I'm happy to answer any questions. any questions
Senator Cheatham I'm not used to using this high dollar mic Mr. Esmer, I think I understand what you're trying to do but just clarify one thing if I'm a builder and I'll buy a large track I can still have covenants on my subdivision is that correct?
Well, I don't think I've ever burned you before. Flippo might be the only one that disagrees with that in here. But no, hey, I will tell you, we have continued to work, but I feel like, you know, 24 hours went to 48, went to 72, went to Friday afternoon, and at some point, again, I think we've sat down and agreed on the terms, but we've got to get language rather than just sit here and try to kill a bill.
Thank you. Senator, I've been down this road before where it's taken a long time to get something done, and I've never been quite successful at convincing people I will fix it on the other end. So I don't know what that's about, but I have all kinds of sympathy for wanting to get it done, and I'm ambivalent about this. I'm not, I'm just ambivalent, that's all, about the bill itself and about our constantly wanting to fix something on the other end, because if we were a few days out, I would be all about that. But I'm just concerned that we are making this a standard thing so early in the session. So are you just totally against waiting until we can actually see the language? Because I'm caught between what I see as a kind of
to spend. Senator Elliott has the floor. Please listen. Kind of a common system and what my city wants us to do. And a lot of that has to do with usurpation or intruding up on local rights. So how do you, we try not to do that. So in this case, are you ever concerned that we're going to go too far with usurping the rights at the local level? That's probably a bad question to ask you, but think about it as somebody else, maybe, than yourself. Just talk to me about that, I guess. Okay, I'll go through that with the three parts
that I picked up on. One, I don't feel like this is a state forcing our will on the city. I feel like the state is giving the power back to the, or what the Constitution says and the powers in the individual property owners. So I'm not, I'm not, it's not, it's not we're pulling power up, it's we're pushing it down to the individual property owner, which I believe is in the Constitution. And the state of Arkansas has the strongest property rights in the country. We talk about moving it to the other end. I don't believe that these amendments are necessary. I am perfectly fine with this bill. Now, however, I have I've told them municipally, I'm happy to alleviate some concerns of many mayors. I'm happy to add their amendments because I don't think they're bad either. But I want them to provide me those amendments. I don't want to sit around day after day after day when we all have got plenty to do. I'm sorry, I turned it off.
Does this square at all then, how would you differentiate what you just said for property rights and our doing the same thing that maybe the gender identity LGBT people wanted to have their individual rights recognized, why not do, following your logic, would we not do that? Because I'm thinking about establishing precedence here.
Well, I hadn't thought through that question there. I mean, you know, the reality is I'm talking about an individual's property rights. The bill from the other ordinance I think that you're talking about from Fayetteville, again, was to allow people peaceful enjoyment without having to have the city, in that case, putting an
I'm saying also, what I'm asking you about, if we were to go with this, would it follow that we should also go with the people I just mentioned to you and their individual's civil rights? What was the question? Well, if this means we are devolving the rights down to the individual so they can enjoy their rights as individual property folks, so the other, we're talking gender, ID, LGBT, or whatever, doesn't it follow then that we should do the same thing and pass a law that says those people should have their individual rights respected as well because we're going to devolve it down to the local level so
they should have it. Okay, that's a fair question. I think civil rights are very different than property rights. You know, I think property rights are, I'm very happy to be dealt with on an individual level, like the Constitution protects, and civil rights, I just think that should be uniform throughout the state so that individuals and businesses can have a uniform process and not dealing with an undue burden. But they're not uniform.
Because I'm not saying this just to be taking up time, I promise you. I'm trying to get this sense of, and I hear all the grumbling because I'm talking about something we probably don't like to talk about. But if we want to respect, and I have some sympathy for this, We want to respect the individual's rights as a property owner. Does it follow that we should want to respect the individual's rights as they're having civil rights as an individual?
I would say that the individual property owner can have whatever, as long as they're dealing with people according to civil rights, they can have whatever rules they want on their property at their home, whether they're considered gross to you or the next person or appropriate
my thing. No, not in this case. Thank you. Okay. Senator Chesterfield, then Senator Pitch, then Senator Stubblefield. Senator Chesterfield, are you passing over? Okay. Senator Pitch.
Senator Hester, I want to congratulate you on working on a tough bill. I'm probably going to have to answer this comment with a don't you think question. But Monday morning you were negotiating with a state agency or an organization in good faith. And we thought we had a deal there. They were going to be the five agreed upon amendments. And you gave a time frame, which seemed fair at the time to me. And I started sharing that with my mayors back home. And they were okay with those amendments too. But we've yet to hear the other side say those are okay. And at some level, if we're going to do business as a government, what we say we're going to do has to be what we do. And I guess, again, I'm going to have to answer this with a don't you think, and you may want to weigh in further because you've had to live it this week. But that's a source of frustration for me when we get a tough bill that we decide is a good amendment base, and then one team tries to make it last longer, in my impression. We're clear to Wednesday, and that was supposed to be done on a Tuesday. So don't you think that we need to
do better? We can do better. Senator Stubblefield and then Senator Garner. You have a question still? Nope. Are you okay? Senator Garner. Nope. Senator Garner, then Senator Irvin. Thank you,
Mr. President. Senator Hester, the prior bill that Senator, or law that Senator Elliott talked about, wasn't that about the property-owning of business owners not having individual civil rights dreamed up by different cities through ordinances and actually did an overall protection by the state, that the property owners and the business owners can make that determination. Very similar in principle, in theory, to what this bill does, where cities and municipalities can't come by and make determinations on people's property if they're able to build it as they see fit. I agree. Thank you. Senator Irvin.
Senator Hester, I see that you filed the bill on January the 25th. Is that correct? That's correct. So it's been sitting out there. Is that correct? It has. And so not just that you've been able to have conversations since Monday, but that the bill has been in the public view since January 25th. Is that correct? That's correct.
me a little notice Do you want me to go ahead and do that? Let's any other questions for Senator Hester. Anyone wish to speak against Senator Ingram wishes to speak against the bill. Senator Bond will get your disclosure after all the speaking right before we take the vote.
Senator Ingram. Thank you Governor. We can talk a lot about this bill and what it does or what it doesn't do. The main thing that it does is you're usurping the rights from local government. Now I can look around this room and I would join you in standing up and raising cane if the federal government tried to mandate what we're trying to do to city and local government. This is not our role. I've been a mayor, so I'm a strong proponent of local government. The next thing that's going to come in front of us is whether it's right to have zoning laws in the city. That's the purview of the city. This is the purview of the city. Now, as far as the question about how long this bill's been on the calendar, This thing has been a rush job since day one in committee. In fact, in committee, this bill was tried to be put on the calendar without public notice. Am I correct, Senator Stubblefield? It was tried to be put on the calendar without public notice so we could have public input. That was on Monday. I know that the sponsor is trying to work with the league in working this out but the end result of what we're doing here and I can give you examples of what's going to happen a home builder could come in and build a hundred houses just alike just exactly alike and destroy a community over the years because at some point those houses might go down in value and the city doesn't have any way to deal with them other than to try to catch it on the front end. That's the role of cities. That's what they try to do. Now, as a mayor, I never liked, I never had a developer that, you know, patted me on the back and said, oh, these are great rules. But we had rules to go by. And sort of, I guess, the city had the rules to go by, and the role of the developer was trying to figure a way out to build their project as cheap as they possibly could. But we can't allow every local issue, and as Senator Hester has said, this hadn't even come up in cities. I've talked about it as a preventative measure, but we are going to usurp the power. As I told the lawyer that spoke in front of the committee about this, you know, at home, if we pass something that the builders and the community finds offensive they get beat the mayor gets beat the councilman get beat that's the role of government but for us to take that away and continually and this is down a slippery slope again think about your local zoning ordinances what is to keep somebody from coming to the legislature and trying to circumvent that so to keep home rule which i think is sacred just like I think state government rule is sacred. Everybody's got a role in this thing. This is not our role. Now the mayor of what mayor in northwest Arkansas had sent me and talked about as this is written now it could affect projects in North Little Rock. It would have affected projects in Conway and Hendricks that was done. There was a couple other cities They cited specific projects that have already been completed in the state that are assets to their community, but this will prohibit that. So I ask you, at the very least, the sponsor to hold this until they get it worked out, and if that's not agreeable, then to vote against this. Thank you very much. Anyone else wish to speak on the bill?
Senator Garner wants to speak in favor of the bill. Thank you, Mr. President. ironic that this talk of this local government seems to forget the most important person in this whole process, the individual. The greatest form of local government is the individual's right to make decisions what they do on their property. That's a keystone principle we hold in America. The only thing Senator Hester's bill is allowing that individual to make determinations on how they want to do their property. When that poor person who wants to put something that might be a little bit cheaper, but is safe and effective, can be overrun by a local government, that's wrong. And I think us taking proactive steps to protect that individual right, the ability of people to do that, is a necessary step to making this state better. Thank you. Anyone
I had really hoped that the amendments would get written for this bill. I think that the cities had some concern, and I think they will get written. I think once this bill gets passed out of here, I think they'll get written really quickly. I commend Senator Hester on bringing this, I like local control, and I think that a developer ought to be able to do what they want to, but this is not private property. This is government, and just like the Bill of Rights protects our freedom of religion as an individual, it protects our freedom of speech as an individual. What is happening, and I don't think usually it's on purpose, but I'm afraid sometimes it may be, is backdoor discrimination, and sometimes it's just outright discrimination. As I have shared many times, you know, both my parents, neither one had indoor plumbing before they left home. When, you know, I sell flooring, when you move from carpet to vinyl, which is what we installed 80s and early 90s, to ceramic tile and hardwood, costs go up. And when costs go up, each time you talk to bankers or real estate agents, each time cost goes up, you eliminate a certain number of people from the market. When you say you have to have brick instead of vinyl, you eliminate a certain number of people from the market. When you say you have to have this many square foot it. In the home, you eliminate so many people from the market. That's okay when you develop a piece of property the way you want to do it and put the covenants in there, and you can still do that. But what you won't be able to do under this bill, unless it's a historic district and these other things where cities need to be able to have some flexibility, what you won't be able to do is price poor people out of your community and oftentimes those poor people are minorities more often if you look if you look at the scale but again I'm not I'm not concerned about color because I come from poor white people and and one of the things that as we have studied water we have what I have learned is if you want services I've always lived out in the county But if you want services, if you want water, if you want sewer, et cetera, you're going to have to build in the city most of the time. And so you're eliminating a group of people if you allow these things to happen unless there's a compelling reason. And all the compelling reasons that I've looked at with the mayors and with the city planners seem to be covered. And they certainly would be covered with these amendments that he's trying to get written. So I would like to see them get them written. I would like to see them in there, but I would like to see us move forward, and I
Senator Flowers is recognized. Thank you, Governor. I've considered this bill quite a bit since Senator Hester brought it to the committee. We weren't really expecting it that day, like Senator Ingram said, but we heard him presented and a contractor from Northwest Arkansas who was also an attorney who has a business, and it's a fairly large business, and he's engaged in building houses and also influencing individuals that he sells the houses and builds the houses for to accept designs that are less costly. The thing that I'm concerned about, number one, I think we've been talking about ethics and stuff, but I didn't hear Senator Hester mention that he's a contractor and there might be some need to disclose that to you as a body. He did mention that in the committee, but I think it's important to mention it here on this floor. The other thing that concerns me, it leads from that, you know, when we start thinking about, when I started thinking about a developer having the ability to influence a person who is of less means, and I would argue against what Senator Clark just said. I don't think most poor people in Arkansas are minorities. Minority population is not that great in Arkansas. So I would suggest to you that it's not. More whites are poor in Arkansas than minorities. But So, be that as it may, when you consider, when I consider a developer being able to influence people of less means to build a house or make a design in some kind of fashion that's going to be cheap and that's all they're concerned about, Well, you still don't know what the back-end cost is. You don't know about the ethics of that developer. And as an attorney, I've seen a lot of mortgages and of people that were of less means and they had greater mortgages than somebody of greater means. So that's not a seller to me. But then I thought, well, if it ever got to be an issue, because it's not an issue in Arkansas. At this point in time, an individual can design a residence to their liking. The design is all up to them. They are, they're not limited at all at this point. There's no need for this bill. And so when you think about putting a bill in place that would say to a city that if something comes up, If property values start declining, or if other things about design come to the forefront and something's wrong, it's out of low control. You got the developer that's really running that residential area. And that troubles me to think that we're going to have an exclusive group of entrepreneurs building and designing houses for people who are not of great means, probably not very educated either. And so, consider that. They're easily scammed. Not to say that Senator Hester, I don't guess, would scam anybody. I don't, I've known you since been here, you haven't scammed me.
need to protect people sometimes people need to be protected from themselves and I would rather an elected body be in the business of looking out for that citizen locally as as opposed to a developer just doing willy-nilly whatever they want to do. And for that reason, I just, I'm having trouble with this bill because I think we do need the benefit of local control when the circumstances call for it. And at this point, there is no issue. Even the issue that he says this stemmed from in Springdale, I think it was, they tried to put legislation locally before the people, before the governing body, and it didn't work. It was voted down or it was pushed back or something. It was not passed. So that's there for Springdale to do. And they did it. And I'd like to have the same kind of system for other parts of the state, particularly in my district, where I do have a lot of people that are not great means. but at some point you know when it comes to standards and when you're talking about property value because I was thinking about that more than anything I didn't bring it up in the committee but as I thought about your bill you know I don't think that the Fair Housing Act wanted to take things away from local control that wasn't the design for that Fair Housing Act that was to protect people from being discriminated against, redlining, building in certain areas, building anything. But you just don't put up anything. It's not safe and you've accepted out the safety and prevention codes and that kind of thing. But at the same time, if you have a subdivision that has already been started and all of a sudden you've got other houses coming up and the design is something that is so far away from the design of those houses that are already there, is that going to influence and have an effect on property values? And people do, I mean, I'm for bringing everybody's property value up, especially in poor neighborhoods. I think, you know, those values are attached or you know connected to our school they pay taxes for our local schools so those things are important and I hope you all consider that and municipal league is against it and I've got a lot of emails and maybe you all have too from a lot of the mayors and stuff and I don't generally listen and think a lot of what's going on in other districts. I'll try to help somebody when they can, but at this point, there is nothing to be fixed. There's nothing to be fixed. And when we move forward with a bill like this, we take away the possibility of being able to fix things locally if something does happen, if a problem does arise. So that's my reason for voting against. But I think Senator Hester needs to at least acknowledge to the body that you are a contractor and you develop houses such as what you are contemplating in this bill. All right. Members, is
realized this morning, my dad is Bond Consulting Engineers. I don't have any interest in that business. My dad still works 10 hours a day, but he does do business with, I think, some of the folks interested in the passage of the bill. So I just wanted to disclose that under our new rules. Family has defined as parent even though I don't have a financial interest I want to point
for the bill disclosure you recognize sir just gonna let the body know that my wife is involved with residential development and in residential building Senator Clark,
don't know how many times we're supposed to do this. I did this in committee. I sell building materials, so actually more expensive building materials will, on that side of it, if the bill fails. But Rosh Coleman builders who testified for the bill, So I'm pretty sure it's a customer of ours, not a big customer, but a
the bill my disclosure is that I have done consulting work for an organization that serves six counties to try to develop low-income housing opportunities and that is not what I primarily do they I'm not working for them right now but I didn't want to make that disclosure because I have worked for them in the last year a lot of what you do when you're trying to help people at that the lower end and the or this organization is primarily looking at first-time homebuyers and I can tell you that you all heard the saying you know a billion here billion there and pretty soon you're talking real money and as Senator Clark talked about you know you you upgrade this you have a little nicer paneling a little nicer siding and it really makes a big difference not in the quality of the house but in the cost of the house and I can tell you when we're looking at a first-time homebuyer that goes through classes to one to get their financial house in order so they can qualify for a mortgage and second to meet the to build a house that meets their needs but they can afford you're getting into some some kind of narrow, narrow margins there where, you know, if you bump it up to, you know, another $2,000 from a $100,000 house to $102,000 house, it might not work. Well, we can talk about this. Well, it's health and safety. I'm all for health and safety. I don't think we need to have someone go into a house and throw a light switch on and water starts coming out of the faucets. I want, you know, qualified electricians and plumbers doing the things that relate to the safety of a home. But when you get down to the aesthetic things, the design, things that people think, well, I wish it were that way on your house. And that's really what we come down to is if you're an individual, you need to make those choices and not government. And I say that, I did that quote from the Constitution to point out that our framers of our state Constitution said that property rights are the highest sanction of all our rights. And I believe in local control, and I think that our cities and counties should enforce the health and safety and the rules for everybody. But when you go beyond that, there needs to be a very compelling reason. I don't think that this is a compelling reason. I intend to support the bill. I hope that the Municipal League comes forth with what they had said they were going to do. I'm confident they do. I have confidence in them, but I think it's important to let them know that, you know, please come forth and do that, and I will vote for Bill.
Yeah. So, you know, I don't know of anything that I have going on right now that benefits me financially, but I have, I practice real estate, a lot of real estate. I have represented people who build houses, people who sell houses, buy houses, and all that. So in the spirit of disclosure, just in case, there's some point I'll have a client of this little thing. So anyway, that's that.
All right, members. Any more disclosures? Anybody else? All right. Senator Hester, you ready to close for your bill? I am. All right. Thank you, members. Senator Flowers, thank you
for that. I did disclose in committee, and I am a residential contractor. Anyway, being a part-time legislature is a beautiful thing, right? We all have other jobs, and we're going to have conflicts constantly. I think it's very appropriate that we come down here and talk about those conflicts. That way everybody knows it. But what we don't want is a full-time legislature. We want people going home and working in the community and understanding these issues. But I think what we can all agree on is that the city plays some role when we build a house or on your property. And so we agree that the safety codes, right, fire codes, safety, as a body, we would easily agree that the city plays a role in that. I think the question here is where is that line drawn? And this bill's determination, the intent of this bill is to draw that line and define it on what a city's role is or isn't. We all agree they have a role somewhere and a line somewhere. Where to draw the line, this does that, and I'd appreciate a
All right, members, anybody wish to vote or change your vote? Senator Rapert, no. Senator Hickey, no. Senator Hill, yes. Senator Letty, no. Senator Elliott, no. Senator Clark, yes. Senator Cheatham, no. Senator Stubblefield, yes. Anybody else, members? All right, seeing none, Madam Secretary. cast a ballot. All right. By a vote of 23 yeas, 11 nays, one non-voting. Senator Hester, your bill passes. Transfer to the House. All right. I believe we've got Senator Garner. We tack on yours at the end of the... We
are committee on engrossed bills to whom is first sent by 176 by Senator Garner. Compare the engrossed copy with the original and find the same correctly engrossed. Calendar. Calendar. Symbol 176 by Senator Garner to amend the regulation of pyramiding devices and regulate the pyramid promotional schemes. All right, pass over. Yeah, I'll explain it to everybody. Okay, you're recognized, Senator.
change. We could get it done today. I wasn't trying to sneak anything by anybody or do anything nefarious. I just, everybody, I know some members would like to read it in more detail. Obviously, it wasn't on the calendar for the day, so I'm going to pass over until tomorrow and put it on the calendar.
were recognized. Okay, members, a couple important announcements. The first one is Senator Cheatham, are you still there? Senator Pitch, if you all will look at your microphones, One of the things you'll notice is that they're going straight up instead of 45 degrees back. And I've already briefed you all on this once. You've got to have it tilted 45 degrees back so that the audio can carry it. There you go. And you're on now. You
it's like this, you can't hear me talk. Well, that's not what the sound technicians tell you. So the official instructions are leave it 45 degrees cocked to the back, and we'll check with them if there's a problem on them. Second thing is, you all know after we adjourn here we're going to take a five-minute recess and then come back for a committee of the whole to hear our discussion and presentation of nominations for potential replacements in Statuary Hall. That is something that's defined for a legislative responsibility. You do? It's hadn't been done in over a hundred years. We've got nine to consider, potentially. And so we're going to ask members to do a presentation of no more than five minutes, there's also a question and answer. If anybody else wants to weigh in on those, we'll give an opportunity to do that, but we obviously don't want to be here until 5 o'clock this evening. One other announcement, members, before you take off. I do have a budget calendar. Okay, and there is a budget calendar, so don't take off. There's a deal at UAMS, Arkansas Senate Day, 3.30 to 5. They'd like to give a tour to members, so if you can get out there after we finish the other items on the agenda, I'm sure Dr. Patterson would
love to have you come out and see the facilities. Senator Ingram, question? Since I'm not going to be here for our discussion, I would like to submit to the body that they're obviously the History Commission or somebody that might have something to bring to the table besides the 35 of us in selecting who should be the statute. So since I'm not going to be here, my suggestion was to get maybe some outside people from the university or the History Commission or somebody that has maybe a grander perspective than we do. I can't imagine
anybody with a grander perspective than the 35 members of this body. But certainly this bill will go back to State Agencies Committee. Let me also comment that all we're talking about here is a feeling of the will of the body. It has to go through the legislative process. State agencies may want to ask them for input. And also, of course, I talked to the Speaker this morning. The Arkansas House may have something to say about it as well. So this is the beginning of a process that really Senator Hester started two
Mr. President. Senator Henry, what's kind of the procedural part of this work? So we have nine different names. Are we doing a ranking system? How should we keep up
our... I can go over that now or after the recess. Okay, we'll do the recess. Before we start, I'll go back and explain the process and how we're going to do it, because it's not very complicated, but we'll go through it here as soon as we take about a five-minute recess and after the budget calendar and
your budget calendar real fast. You're recognized. Members, just an observation. My hearing aid batteries died about the time of that last debate started, so best things happen to me today. So, members, we have Senate Bill 132, ASUBB, Senate Bill 133, South Arkansas Community College, Senate Bill 137, Department of Ed, Division of Public School Academic Facilities, House Bill 1065, Arkansas State Board of Chiropractic Examiners 1077 Arkansas State Board of Public Accountancy 1080 Arkansas Court of Appeals 1081 State Board of Election Commissioners 1084 Martin Luther King Jr. Commission 1085 Disabled Veteran Services Office 1086 Arkansas Veterans Child Welfare Service Office 1087 Arkansas Spinal Court Commission 1088 Department of Ed Arkansas School for the Deaf 1095 Health Services Permanent Agency, 1099 Department of Labor, 1111 Arkansas Crime Information Center, 1123 Department of Ed Arkansas School for the Blind, 1138 Arkansas Legislative Audit, 1148 Arkansas Natural Resources Commission, 1157 State Securities Department, 1159 Arkansas Public Employees Retirement System Appropriation, and 1160 Department of Information Systems appropriation. I'd answer any questions. Mr. President, if there is none, I'd move that we roll the vote and batch it. All right, members, any objections
Johnson, you have an announcement? Yes. Senate Transportation will be meeting jointly with House Transportation and Technology about the broadband USDA and about bringing broadband into your local community. So please be there, even if you're not
but please be there if you're in transportation. 3 o'clock in Big Mac. There you go. Ableime. Calendar. Ingrossed. Calendar. Calendar. engrossed copy with the original and find the same correctly engrossed. Calendar. Calendar. Will your committee on engrossed best whom is for House Bill 1124 by Representative Vaught compare the engrossed copy with the original and find the
Irvin, you recognized. Members, we are not having a public health committee meeting this afternoon so that is on there just as a placeholder but there is going to be a tour of UAMS and it will leave at 3.30 it will be from 3.30 to 5 and so invite you all the senators if you want to come and go on that tour to be downstairs at 3.30 to load onto the buses they're going to take us over and I also need to re-refer house bill 1125 to back to the committee for the purpose of amendment. Without objection? So moved.
Senator Hickey, you are recognized, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Just want to remind everybody, Texarkana is going to be having a legislative reception tonight, 5 to 7, and Next Level Event. I tried to invite all of you, but I want to ask you, if you can make it, we'd like to have you there. Thank
you. I just wanted to let everyone know that the Judiciary Committee will be meeting 15 minutes upon adjournment of the Committee of the Whole because this is the fourth week of the session and we are not caught up. All right, members, any more announcements?
SR9 G. Stubblefield CONGRATULATING THE PARIS HIGH SCHOOL VOLLEYBALL TEAM FOR AN OUTSTANDING RECORD
9:33 - 16:1816 segments5 speakers
Senator Gary Stubblefield presented Senate Resolution 9 honoring the Paris High School Girls Volleyball Team, detailing its four-year state-championship run, seven consecutive state-final appearances, multiple district and conference titles, and a 3.68 GPA average.
[9:33][9:42][9:48][10:22][10:52][11:28]
The Senate moved to adopt the resolution, with all members voting aye and no opposition, resulting in its passage.
[12:10][12:22]
SCR2 Hester COMMENDING GUATEMALA FOR RELOCATING THE GUATEMALAN EMBASSY IN ISRAEL TO JERUSALEM.
16:18 - 18:059 segments7 speakers
Senator Bart Hester introduced Senate Concurrent Resolution 2 praising Guatemala for relocating its embassy in Israel to Jerusalem, noting the significance compared with U.S. efforts.
[16:23][16:55]
During discussion Senator Keith Ingram asked about the logistics of delivering the commendation, which the chair said was being worked on.
[17:00][17:07]
The Senate unanimously approved the concurrent resolution, with all members voting aye and the measure transmitted to the House.
[17:11]
Senator Wallace offered Amendment 2 to Senate Bill 76, inserting an emergency clause, and the amendment was adopted by voice vote.
[18:00]
SB148 #1 Hester TO MODIFY THE SMALL BUSINESS ENTITY TAX PASS THROUGH ACT; AND TO PROVIDE FOR A TEMPORARY LIEN AT THE TIME A CHARGING APPLICATION IS FILED.
18:25 - 18:585 segments4 speakers
Senator Bart Hester introduced Amendment 1 to Senate Bill 148 to refine language about individual member interests in the Small Business Entity Tax Pass-Through Act, explaining it would prevent unintended effects on entire LLCs.
[18:27][18:32]
The amendment was approved by unanimous voice vote and sent to engrossing.
[18:41]
Senator Trent Garner sought to suspend the rules to place Senate Bill 176, amending regulation of pyramid promotional schemes, at the end of the calendar after a one-word amendment was offered.
[18:49][18:53]
SB176 #1 T. Garner TO AMEND THE REGULATION OF PYRAMIDING DEVICES AND TO REGULATE THE PYRAMID PROMOTIONAL SCHEMES.
18:58 - 20:359 segments4 speakers
After brief discussion, the amendment was adopted by voice vote and the motion to suspend the rules was carried unanimously, allowing the bill to be scheduled for consideration later that day.
[19:19][19:34][19:39][19:46][19:56][20:05]
HB1124 #1 Vaught Maloch TO AMEND THE LAWS CONCERNING VETERINARY MEDICINE; AND TO ESTABLISH A VETERINARY TECHNOLOGIST CERTIFICATION AND A VETERINARY TECHNICIAN SPECIALIST CERTIFICATION.
20:35 - 21:437 segments5 speakers
Senator Bruce Maloch explained Amendment 1 to House Bill 1124, which clarifies that veterinarians must retain supervisory control over veterinary technicians and technologists even when not physically present.
[20:38][20:46][21:13]
Following questions, the Senate voted aye with no opposition, adopting the amendment and sending the bill to engrossing.
[21:19][21:22][21:26][21:38]
HB1125 #1 Evans Irvin TO PROHIBIT AN INSURER FROM REQUIRING PAYMENT FOR HEALTHCARE SERVICES THROUGH GIFT CARDS, CREDIT CARDS, OR VIRTUAL CREDIT CARDS.
21:43 - 22:275 segments3 speakers
Senator Missy Irvin presented an amendment to House Bill 1125 that would bar insurers from requiring payment for health services through gift cards, credit cards, or virtual cards, adding herself as a Senate sponsor.
[21:46][21:52]
The amendment was adopted unanimously, and the chair subsequently moved to refer the bill back to committee for a missed amendment, which was also approved.
[22:00][22:10]
SB160 B. Ballinger TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING SAMPLE BALLOTS; AND TO ALLOW VOLUMINOUS NUMBERS OF SAMPLE BALLOTS TO BE MADE AVAILABLE TO THE PUBLIC BY OTHER MEANS.
22:27 - 24:238 segments3 speakers
Senator Jim Ballinger offered an amendment to Senate Bill 160 to modernize the sample-ballot statute by permitting bound books or electronic tablets instead of only wall postings, citing recent school-election issues.
[22:38][22:43][23:15][23:27]
After a brief question period, the Senate rolled a voice vote, recording 34 yeas and no nays, and the bill was passed and transmitted to the House.
[23:33][23:54][24:05]
SB167 L. Eads TO DESIGNATE STATE HIGHWAY 549, ALSO KNOWN AS FUTURE I-49, IN NORTHWEST ARKANSAS AS A SCENIC HIGHWAY.
24:23 - 38:1351 segments14 speakers
Senator Lance Eads introduced Senate Bill 167 to designate State Highway 549 (Future I-49) in Northwest Arkansas as a scenic highway, noting it would aid tourism without altering signage or billboard regulations.
[24:26][25:01][25:07]
The Senate unanimously approved the designation by voice vote, recording 34 yeas and no nays, and the bill was sent to the House.
[25:14][25:32][25:44]
SB170 Hester CONCERNING COUNTY AND MUNICIPAL REGULATION OF RESIDENTIAL BUILDING DESIGN ELEMENTS.
38:13 - 26:32
Senator Bart Hester introduced SB 170, explaining that it would bar counties and municipalities from imposing residential design standards-except for safety, historic districts, mobile homes and limited overlay districts-and noted that he was still negotiating final language with the Municipal League.
[38:16][38:20][38:50][39:24][39:57]
Senators questioned whether private covenants would remain enforceable and expressed frustration that amendment language had been delayed repeatedly, with the bill’s timeline slipping from 24 hours to several days.
[40:32][40:54][41:00][41:14][41:39]
Senator Joyce Elliott voiced ambivalence, warning that the measure could amount to state usurpation of local zoning authority and asked if waiting for finalized language was prudent, while Senator Keith Ingram strongly opposed, arguing the bill would strip cities of zoning power, hand unchecked control to developers, and urged holding the legislation until concerns were resolved.
[42:11][42:43][42:46][42:51][43:20][43:30][50:43][51:16][51:50][52:21][52:58][53:29][54:01]
Supporters such as Senator Trent Garner and Senator Alan Clark argued the bill protects individual property rights and should proceed, and after disclosures of potential conflicts the committee voted 23 yeas, 11 nays, and one abstention, passing SB 170 to the House.
[54:32][55:03][55:40][56:11][56:44][57:16][57:56][58:29][58:51][1:16:09][1:16:28]
SB196 K. Ingram TO ADOPT FEDERAL INTERNAL REVENUE CODE PROVISIONS CONCERNING OPPORTUNITY ZONES; AND TO PROVIDE STATE TAX INCENTIVES RELATED TO INVESTMENTS IN OPPORTUNITY ZONES.
26:32 - 31:5821 segments6 speakers
Senator Keith Ingram introduced Senate Bill 196, adopting federal opportunity-zone provisions and providing state capital-gains tax incentives to spur investment in Arkansas’s 85 designated zones, outlining the tax benefits and urging a favorable vote.
[26:32][26:35][26:48][27:06][27:40][28:11]
SB211 J. Dismang Hendren TO CREATE THE TAX COMPETITIVENESS AND RELIEF ACT OF 2019; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY
31:58 - 35:4211 segments6 speakers
Senator Jim Hendren presented Senate Bill 211, the Tax Competitiveness and Relief Act of 2019, noting it was the same tax-cut measure debated previously and requesting a vote.
[32:02][32:06][32:09]
Following a roll call that recorded both ayes and nays among members, the Senate concluded the vote with no further objections and proceeded to pass the measure.
[32:41][33:11][33:49][34:10][34:32][35:29]
SB220 B. Sample TO REPEAL OBSOLETE PROVISIONS OF TITLE 24; TO AMEND CERTAIN PROVISIONS OF TITLE 24 RELATING TO RETIREMENT BENEFITS; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
SB225 M. Pitsch TO AMEND THE LAWS CONCERNING THE ARKANSAS ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT COUNCIL AND THE ARKANSAS ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT COMMISSION.
35:42 - 1:16:48121 segments25 speakers
Senator Mathew Pitsch presented Senate Bill 225 to revise the Arkansas Economic Development Council and Commission, granting authority over foreign-trade zones, enhancing minority- and women-owned business programs, shifting energy oversight to ADEQ, and simplifying job-creation reporting requirements.
[35:44][35:51][36:01][36:35]
Following a brief question period, the Senate unanimously approved the bill by voice vote, recording 34 ayes and no nays, and transmitted it to the House.
[36:46][37:01][37:04][37:16][37:41][37:46][38:05]