Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

Senate Convenes

January 29, 2019 ·1:00 PM ·1:11:23
Video Transcript

Summary

Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 12, 2026

SJR3 G. Stubblefield APPLYING TO THE UNITED STATES CONGRESS TO CALL A CONVENTION FOR PROPOSING AMENDMENTS PURSUANT TO ARTICLE V OF THE UNITED STATES CONSTITUTI… 19:35

Senator Gary Stubblefield introduced SJR 3, arguing that the nation’s $22 trillion debt and unfunded liabilities constitute an unsustainable fiscal crisis that can only be addressed through an Article V convention of states. [19:58] [20:30] [21:03] [21:37] [22:08] [22:39] [23:13] [23:48] [24:19] [24:51] [25:29] [26:04] [26:35] [27:06] [27:36] [28:07] [28:44] [29:20] [29:54] [30:28] [31:02] [31:34] [32:07] [32:39] [33:11] [33:42] [34:19] [34:50] [35:28] [35:59] [36:33]

Senators Will Bond, Linda Chesterfield, Mark Johnson, Joyce Elliott and others questioned the scope, limits and potential for a “runaway” convention, while Senator Stubblefield reiterated that the application limits amendments to fiscal restraint, term limits and limiting government. [36:48] [37:08] [37:17] [37:42] [38:15] [38:50] [39:02] [39:12] [39:21] [39:49] [39:55]

After debate, the chair called for a vote; the roll call recorded 19 yes, 13 no and two non-voting, and the resolution was adopted. [1:02:13] [1:02:45]

SB71 B. Sample TO CLARIFY THE PROCEDURE FOR THE APPOINTMENT OF MEMBERS OF THE STATE HIGHWAY COMMISSION AS SET OUT IN ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION, AMENDMENT 42. 1:02:47

Senator Bill Sample presented SB 71 to restore the original appointment procedure for the State Highway Commission as set by Amendment 42 of the Arkansas Constitution. [1:03:01] [1:03:27]

A brief question period followed, but no senator offered substantive opposition before the bill was closed. [1:03:49] [1:03:53] [1:04:00] [1:04:06] [1:04:15]

The Senate voted unanimously, recording 34 yeas and 0 nays, and the bill was passed to the House. [1:04:30] [1:05:04] [1:05:13]

SB79 Rapert TO REVISE THE MAXIMUM LOAN LIMITS OF CERTAIN LOANS. 1:05:28

Chair Senator Jason Rapert explained SB 79, which would cap any single lender’s exposure to an individual at 20 % of that borrower’s assets. [1:05:35] [1:05:39] [1:06:07]

No legislators raised objections, and the measure proceeded directly to a vote. [1:06:15] [1:06:19]

The roll call showed 34 yeas and no nays, so the bill was enacted and sent to the House. [1:06:50] [1:06:52]

SB80 Rapert TO CLARIFY THE REMEDIES AND PROCEDURES FOR NONPAYMENT OF RENT ON A SAFE-DEPOSIT BOX. 1:07:00

Senator Rapert described SB 80, which shortens the statutory period for the state to claim property in a safe-deposit box from seven to five years. [1:07:09] [1:07:24]

After a routine question round, the bill was closed without further comment. [1:07:49] [1:07:54]

The Senate recorded 34 affirmative votes and zero negatives, passing the bill to the House. [1:08:01] [1:08:30] [1:08:35]

SB116 B. Ballinger REQUIRING AN INMATE IN THE DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTION TO FIRST EXHAUST ALL AVAILABLE ADMINISTRATIVE REMEDIES AS A CONDITION PRECEDENT TO FILIN… 1:08:49

Senator Ballinger’s SB 116 was presented as a clarification that inmates must exhaust all administrative remedies before filing a civil-rights claim, restoring prior practice. [1:09:06] [1:09:32] [1:09:40]

The proposal faced no organized opposition and moved straight to a vote. [1:09:48] [1:10:09]

The final tally was 32 yeas, 0 nays, and the measure was approved and transmitted to the House. [1:10:26] [1:10:46]

Bills discussed (29)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
SR6 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SR6 Hester TO SUSPEND SECTIONS 14.(B)(2) AND 14.(B)(3) OF THE R…”
TO SUSPEND SECTIONS 14.(B)(2) AND 14.(B)(3) OF THE RULES OF THE SENATE OF THE NINETY-SECOND … Hester Sine Die adjournment
SR7 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SR7 Hester TO SUSPEND SECTIONS 14.(B)(2) AND 14.(B)(3) OF THE J…”
TO SUSPEND SECTIONS 14.(B)(2) AND 14.(B)(3) OF THE JOINT RULES OF THE SENATE AND THE … Hester Sine Die adjournment
SB106 Act 106 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ee on City, County, and Local Affairs, to whom was referred Senate Bill 106 by Senator Wallace, recommend do pass. Calendar. Committee…”
CONCERNING THE AWARD OF A SERVICE WEAPON UPON THE RETIREMENT OR DEATH OF AN EMPLOYEE … D. Wallace Notification that SB106 is now Act 106
SB114 Act 234 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…dar. Committee on City, County, Local, to whom was referred Senate Bill 114 by Senator Sturge, recommend do pass as amended number one.…”
TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE APPOINTMENT OF CITY TREASURER IN A CITY OF THE … J. Sturch Notification that SB114 is now Act 234
SB116 Act 444 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB116 B. Ballinger REQUIRING AN INMATE IN THE DEPARTMENT OF CORRE…”
REQUIRING AN INMATE IN THE DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTION TO FIRST EXHAUST ALL AVAILABLE ADMINISTRATIVE REMEDIES … B. Ballinger Notification that SB116 is now Act 444
SB142 Act 108 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ommittee on Insurance and Commerce, to whom was referred to Senate Bill 142 by Senator”
TO ALLOW A FOR-PROFIT CORPORATION TO CONVERT TO A NONPROFIT CORPORATION; AND TO DECLARE AN … Teague Notification that SB142 is now Act 108
SB149 Act 180 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “Judiciary Committee on Engrossed Bills to whom was referred Senate Bill 149 by Senator Rayford, compared the engrossed copy with the or…”
TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS HUMAN LIFE PROTECTION ACT; AND TO ABOLISH ABORTION IN ARKANSAS AND … Rapert Notification that SB149 is now Act 180
SB154 Act 56 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…Calendar. Committee on Joint Budget, to whom is referred to Senate Bill 154 by”
AN ACT FOR THE OFFICE OF THE GOVERNOR - LEGISLATIVE LIAISONS APPROPRIATION FOR THE 2018-2019 … Joint Budget Committee Notification that SB154 is now Act 56
SB155 Act 82 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…Calendar. Committee on Joint Budget, to whom is referred to Senate Bill 155 by Joint Budget, recommend do pass. Calendar. Committee on…”
TO CREATE THE DEVELOPMENT AND ENHANCEMENT FUND; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY. Teague Notification that SB155 is now Act 82
SB159 Act 109 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…e Agencies and Governmental Affairs, to whom is referred to Senate Bill 159 by”
TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING PROVISIONAL BALLOTS; AND TO REMOVE THE REQUIREMENT OF A PROVISIONAL … B. Ballinger Notification that SB159 is now Act 109
SB17 Act 61 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…committee on City, County, Local Affairs, whom was referred Senate Bill 17 by Senator Garner, recommend do pass.”
TO REDUCE THE FEES FOR A LICENSE TO CARRY A CONCEALED HANDGUN; AND TO REDUCE … T. Garner DELIVERED TO GOVERNOR.
SB193 Act 238 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “Senate Bill 193 by Senator Filippo to amend the law concerning the training…”
TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE TRAINING AND INSTRUCTION OF A DEPUTY CORONER. Flippo Notification that SB193 is now Act 238
SB194 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…of a deputy coroner, Senate Bill 193. City, county, local. Senate Bill 194 by Senator Bledsoe to encourage child care facility entrepr…”
TO ENCOURAGE CHILD CARE FACILITY ENTREPRENEURSHIP IN ARKANSAS; AND CONCERNING THE DUTIES OF THE DIVISION … Bledsoe Sine Die adjournment
SB35 Act 51 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…alendar. Committee on Joint Budget, to whom was referred to Senate Bill 35 by Joint Budget, recommend do pass. Calendar. Committee on…”
AN ACT FOR THE OFFICE OF LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR APPROPRIATION FOR THE 2019-2020 FISCAL YEAR. Joint Budget Committee Notification that SB35 is now Act 51
SB37 Act 52 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…alendar. Committee on Joint Budget, to whom was referred to Senate Bill 37 by Joint Budget, recommend do pass. Calendar. Committee on…”
AN ACT FOR THE OFFICE OF THE PROSECUTOR COORDINATOR APPROPRIATION FOR THE 2019-2020 FISCAL YEAR. Joint Budget Committee Notification that SB37 is now Act 52
SB40 Act 53 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…alendar. Committee on Joint Budget, to whom was referred to Senate Bill 40 by Joint Budget, recommend do pass. Calendar. Committee on…”
AN ACT FOR THE OFFICE OF THE GOVERNOR APPROPRIATION FOR THE 2019-2020 FISCAL YEAR. Joint Budget Committee Notification that SB40 is now Act 53
SB42 Act 54 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…Calendar. Committee on Joint Budget, to whom is referred to Senate Bill 42 by Joint Budget, recommend do pass. Calendar. Committee on…”
AN ACT FOR THE WORKERS' COMPENSATION COMMISSION APPROPRIATION FOR THE 2019-2020 FISCAL YEAR. Joint Budget Committee Notification that SB42 is now Act 54
SB54 Act 192 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…dar. Committee on City, County, Local, to whom was referred Senate Bill 54 by Senator English, recommend do pass. Calendar. Committee…”
TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE MAXIMUM AGE LIMIT REQUIRED FOR AN APPLICANT TO BE … J. English Notification that SB54 is now Act 192
SB71 Act 331 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB71 B. Sample TO CLARIFY THE PROCEDURE FOR THE APPOINTMENT OF M…”
TO CLARIFY THE PROCEDURE FOR THE APPOINTMENT OF MEMBERS OF THE STATE HIGHWAY COMMISSION AS … B. Sample Notification that SB71 is now Act 331
SB76 Act 193 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ee on City, County, and Local Affairs, to whom was referred Senate Bill 76 by Senator Wallace, recommend do pass. Calendar. Committee…”
TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING EMERGENCY TEMPORARY LOCATIONS FOR MEETINGS OF A GOVERNING BODY; AND … D. Wallace Notification that SB76 is now Act 193
SB77 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “committee on engrossed bills to whom was referred to Senate Bill 77 by Senator Wallace, compare the engrossed copy with the ori…”
TO AMEND THE LAW TO REDUCE THE ADMINISTRATIVE FEE CHARGED BY THE STATE TO COLLECT … D. Wallace Sine Die adjournment
SB79 Act 62 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB79 Rapert TO REVISE THE MAXIMUM LOAN LIMITS OF CERTAIN LOANS.”
TO REVISE THE MAXIMUM LOAN LIMITS OF CERTAIN LOANS. Rapert Notification that SB79 is now Act 62
SB80 Act 63 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB80 Rapert TO CLARIFY THE REMEDIES AND PROCEDURES FOR NONPAYMEN…”
TO CLARIFY THE REMEDIES AND PROCEDURES FOR NONPAYMENT OF RENT ON A SAFE-DEPOSIT BOX. Rapert Notification that SB80 is now Act 63
SB82 Act 332 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…d tax. Committee on engrossed bills to whom was referred to Senate Bill 82 by Senator Clark, compare the engrossed copy with the origi…”
TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING REPORTS FILED WITH THE COURT BEFORE A HEARING HELD UNDER … A. Clark Notification that SB82 is now Act 332
SB87 Act 927 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…, your committee on engrossed bills to whom was referred to Senate Bill 87 by Senator Clark, compare the engrossed copy with the origi…”
TO DEFINE "IMMINENT HARM" UNDER THE ARKANSAS JUVENILE CODE OF 1989 AND THE CHILD MALTREATMENT … A. Clark Notification that SB87 is now Act 927
SB90 Act 559 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…udiciary. Committee on Engrossed Bills to whom was referred Senate Bill 90 by Senator Clark, compared the engrossed copy with the orig…”
TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING EVIDENCE PRESENTED DURING PROBABLE CAUSE HEARINGS HELD UNDER THE ARKANSAS … A. Clark Notification that SB90 is now Act 559
SB91 Act 317 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…Judiciary Committee on Engrossed Bills to whom was referred Senate Bill 91 by Senator Clark, compared the engrossed copy with the orig…”
TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE RESUMPTION OF SERVICES FOR CERTAIN PARENTS. A. Clark Notification that SB91 is now Act 317
SCR1 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…, we, your committee on enrolled bills to whom was referred Senate Concurrent Resolution 1 by Senator Malik, have carefully compared the enrolled copi…”
TO ADOPT THE JOINT RULES OF THE SENATE AND THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES OF THE … Maloch Approved by the Governor
SJR3 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SJR3 G. Stubblefield APPLYING TO THE UNITED STATES CONGRESS TO C…”
APPLYING TO THE UNITED STATES CONGRESS TO CALL A CONVENTION FOR PROPOSING AMENDMENTS PURSUANT TO … G. Stubblefield Reviewed by the Governor

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 12, 2026
The Senate will come to
▶ Play
Speaker 2 0:09
order. Madam Secretary, please call
▶ Play
Speaker 5 0:16
the roll. Ballinger, Bledsoe, Bond, Caldwell, Cheatham, Chesterfield, Clark, Cooper, Davis, Dismaine, Eads, Elliott, English, Flippo, Flowers, Garner, Hammer, Hendron, Hester, Hickey, Hill, Ingram, Irvin, Blake Johnson, Mark Johnson, Letting, Malik, Pitch, Rapert, Rice, Sample, Stubbefield, Sturge, Teague, Wallace. Everyone, please rise, including those in the gallery. Senator Hendren, will you please lead us in a word of prayer? Members, before
▶ Play
we pray, I just want to give an update. I just talked to
▶ Play
one of our colleagues, Senator Eads. As most of you all know, his wife was having surgery today. Happy to report she came through the surgery wonderfully. She's in recovery now, but would appreciate you keeping Lance and Kim in your prayers. And one other thing is, Jan's got a card out here at the desk. she's going to come around, but if you don't get it, go by her desk and she'll have a card for you to send to Lance and Kim. Let's pray. Lord, we thank you for your many blessings. We thank you for this country where we can come and serve and represent our constituents. God, we just thank you for the many ways that you've blessed us. And we lift up our colleague Lance and his wife Kim and their family, Lord, as they go through this journey, that you'll be with them every step of the way. We thank you for the successful surgery. We just ask that you'll continue to watch over that family. God, we just ask that you'll give us wisdom and courage to do the things that you'd have us to
▶ Play
Speaker 9 1:54
do here as we serve you in the Senate. In Jesus' name we pray. Amen. Amen. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America, and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
▶ Play
Any announcements? Any announcements? Senator Bledsoe has an announcement. Senator
▶ Play
Bledsoe is recognized. Thank you. You'll find on your desk a little notice about the safe haven baby boxes. We're going to amend the safe haven law to include a baby box. There will be one in the old Supreme Court chambers at 1130 tomorrow and then in the Capitol Rotunda at 1. I think you need to see it. It is something new, but it is something that the right to life feels like would keep some of these babies from being left by the side of the road or thrown in the trash. So thank you. I'd love to see you then. It will be at those times, and hopefully we'll all understand what this is about.
▶ Play
Senator Teague, and then Senator Ingram. Members, I
▶ Play
have two pages in the back. I have Katie Webster and Dee Dee. Would you all stand up, girls? They're from down in God's country. Senator Ingram
▶ Play
is recognized. I have two pages in the back, if they might stand. Camille Culp and Mary Kate Jones from Mariana. from Mariana, they're seniors at Lee Academy, and Mary Kate's going to go to the University of Arkansas pre-law, and Camille is going to look at maybe going to Ole Miss, I told her I might have been to both schools, and in pharmacy.
▶ Play
So glad to have you with us today. Senator Wallace, and then Senator
▶ Play
Speaker 25 3:58
Dismane. Senator Wallace. Thank you, Governor. We have our young autometrist up in the upper gallery today. that's 12 of our young doctors from all across the state and they are in the leadership program that we're participating in this week. In addition to that they have a reception tonight at six o'clock at the next level. Lots of
▶ Play
good food. Free eye exams. Senator Desmay is recognized. Request leave for Senator Irvin. Without objection. Any other announcements? Senator Bond. Today, and I think it's the appropriate
▶ Play
time, or you all will tell me if we don't, we have the Little Rock Christian 5A state championship football team here. I would request leave that they could come on the floor briefly, Governor.
▶ Play
Speaker 36 4:56
and then cinder johnson and cinder hammer i don't know if cinder hammer's here
▶ Play
if y'all could come on up we kind of all have a piece of these guys district i think there was supposed to be a joint concurrent resolution filed in the house which they're getting done down there hadn't made it over yet but we just wanted to have them come on the floor have an opportunity for a picture and tell them congratulations for a great accomplishment. Let me say one other point of personal privilege. The athletic director for Little Rock Christians, Johnny Watson, and my family and his family go all the way back to birth, for me at least. And so I'm a big fan of his, and he's a great guy. So thank you all for being here. And let me turn it over to Senator Johnson, Senator Hammer.
▶ Play
johnson's recognized thank you mr president uh we're really proud of these young men i think y'all if you saw the game on aetn you know it was exciting and i still want to ask you guys how long did y'all practice on recovering those onside kicks if y'all don't know they defeated the mighty pulaski county bruins who are clearly a another great team in our community But they did it. They recovered a lot of those onside kicks that they're famous for. And I guess that Mr. Hill's gone off to Fayetteville, hasn't he? He's not with us today. But Justice Hill, their quarterback, who's the son of one of my dear friends and many of your dear friends, Dr. Fitzgerald Hill. And it was a tremendous game. This is a great, great team that we're all proud of, not just for their athletic exploits, but for the way they've conducted themselves. So please help us all welcome the 5A state champion, Christian Ward. Senator Hammer.
▶ Play
On behalf of the Arkansas Senate, we'd like to welcome you here and congratulate you on your great victory. It was not given to you. You earned it. And we'd like to congratulate all the young men and all the young ladies that are represented here today. And also we'd like to congratulate the coaching staff for the exemplary leadership that you provided, taking them from the beginning all the way across the finish line. On behalf of the Arkansas State Senate, we appreciate you very much, and hopefully we'll see some of y'all sitting in our chairs someday. Thank you. Thank you. I think this
▶ Play
is a record on the number of people in this chamber
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 7:54
Thank you. Thank you.
▶ Play
Any other senators wish to be recognized before we move into other business? Any other senators? We've got the
▶ Play
doctor of the day today. We've got Corey Montgomery, who's an orthopedic surgeon. Here he is. We'd like to welcome him to the Arkansas Senate. And then give him a big round of applause, please. Are there any items to be
▶ Play
read across the desk, Madam Secretary? Yes, sir. We, your
▶ Play
Speaker 5 9:51
committee on engrossed bills to whom was referred to Senate Bill 77 by Senator Wallace, compare the engrossed copy with the original and find the same correctly engrossed. Revenue and tax. Committee on engrossed bills to whom was referred to Senate Bill 82 by Senator Clark, compare the engrossed copy with the original and find the same correctly engrossed. Judiciary. We, your committee on engrossed bills to whom was referred to Senate Bill 87 by Senator Clark, compare the engrossed copy with the original and find the same correctly engrossed. Judiciary. Committee on Engrossed Bills to whom was referred Senate Bill 90 by Senator Clark, compared the engrossed copy with the original and find the same correctly engrossed. Judiciary Committee on Engrossed Bills to whom was referred Senate Bill 91 by Senator Clark, compared the engrossed copy with the original and find the same correctly engrossed. Judiciary Committee on Engrossed Bills to whom was referred Senate Bill 149 by Senator Rayford, compared the engrossed copy with the original and find the same correctly engrossed. Public Health Mr. President, we, your committee on enrolled bills to whom was referred Senate Concurrent Resolution 1 by Senator Malik, have carefully compared the enrolled copies with the original and have enrolled at the governor's office at 10.50 a.m. File it. We, your committee on City, County, Local Affairs, whom was referred Senate Bill 17 by Senator Garner, recommend do pass. Calendar. Committee on City, County, Local, to whom was referred Senate Bill 54 by Senator English, recommend do pass. Calendar. Committee on City, County, and Local Affairs, to whom was referred Senate Bill 76 by Senator Wallace, recommend do pass. Calendar. Committee on City, County, and Local Affairs, to whom was referred Senate Bill 106 by Senator Wallace, recommend do pass. Calendar. Committee on City, County, Local, to whom was referred Senate Bill 114 by Senator Sturge, recommend do pass as amended number one. Calendar. Committee on Insurance and Commerce, to whom was referred to Senate Bill 142 by Senator Teague, recommend do pass as amended number 1. Calendar. Committee on Joint Budget, to whom was referred to Senate Bill 35 by Joint Budget, recommend do pass. Calendar. Committee on Joint Budget, to whom was referred to Senate Bill 37 by Joint Budget, recommend do pass. Calendar. Committee on Joint Budget, to whom was referred to Senate Bill 40 by Joint Budget, recommend do pass. Calendar. Committee on Joint Budget, to whom is referred to Senate Bill 42 by Joint Budget, recommend do pass. Calendar. Committee on Joint Budget, to whom is referred to Senate Bill 154 by Joint Budget, recommend do pass. Calendar. Committee on Joint Budget, to whom is referred to Senate Bill 155 by Joint Budget, recommend do pass. Calendar. Committee on State Agencies and Governmental Affairs, to whom is referred to Senate Bill 159 by
▶ Play
Speaker 59 12:42
Senator Ballinger, recommend do pass. Calendar. How about 194, 193 or 194?
▶ Play
Speaker 5 12:48
Senate Bill 193 by Senator Filippo to amend the law concerning the training and instruction of a deputy coroner, Senate Bill 193. City, county, local. Senate Bill 194 by Senator Bledsoe to encourage child care facility entrepreneurship in Arkansas and concerning the duties of the Division of Child Care and Early Childhood Education within the Department of Human Services, Senate Bill 194. Public Health.
▶ Play
Any other announcements before we move to the morning hour? Seeing none, Senator Hester has two Senate
▶ Play
Speaker 5 13:27
resolutions. Senate Resolution 6 by Senator Hester to suspend sections 14B2 and 14B3 of the rules of the Senate of the 92nd General Assembly. Okay,
▶ Play
so members, this is involving the bill filing deadline for retirement bills, so I'm asking for suspension of the rules for the transformation bill that has retirement language in it. The purpose of the bill filing deadline of retirement early is there has to be time for the actuaries to do studies on the amount of dollars that are affected in the system. This does not affect dollars. What this does is if you're currently employed by a career education and you're going to get transferred to another division, all this language ultimately will do is allow you to stay in the current retirement system you're in or move to the new one that you go to. It's protective language for the current state employee, but BLR doesn't have that language finished yet, so we're asking for a suspension of the rules. Now my next option, if the body didn't want to give me the suspension of the rules, is to file a shell bill, which I think we know what shell bills do in retirement. It gets a lot of people, creates a lot of anxiety that it's not necessary, and so I'm wanting to stay away from a shell bill if at all
▶ Play
possible. Be happy to answer any questions. Any questions for
▶ Play
Senator Hester? Senator Flowers. Senator Hester, how do you know it has no impact?
▶ Play
Well I guess that's fair. We're not dealing with contributions coming in or leaving the retirement systems. So I guess it could technically have some impact where an individual or an employee decides to go to. But as far as contribution rates or what's being given out, it doesn't affect those. Which if you read the Senate rule, it actually is very specific on why we have the bill filing deadline.
▶ Play
Does that answer your question, Senator Flowers? Well, we're taking your word, and I don't guess you're claiming to be an expert
▶ Play
on fiscal impact. I am not an expert on
▶ Play
fiscal impact. So it goes back. I don't know. I mean, how do we know? That's the whole purpose, trying
▶ Play
to find something out. Well, if it would make you feel better, I'm happy to have somebody from BLR come address this. But we've talked about this. I went to the Retirement Committee yesterday, made the announcement to the Retirement Committee that I'd be here. I didn't have any... I had some questions, but no further concerns that we were going to be violating that rule suspension. Well,
▶ Play
did that committee recommend that you do this today? I did not ask them for a vote
▶ Play
or any type of action because this is a Senate rule, but just because it involved retirement, I went to the committee and made the announcement.
▶ Play
Seems like the committee should have a position on it. I wonder what that is, if the governor would allow the chair to say whether they have a position or not. Well, their next meeting
▶ Play
is Monday, and the bill filing deadline is Friday. They can just tell us here today. Does anyone on the Retirement Committee have an
▶ Play
opinion? Any Senator on the Retirement Committee wish to speak?
▶ Play
Speaker 82 17:13
Senator Cheatham. Not willing to speak on that particular piece, but
▶ Play
Speaker 83 17:18
Senator Hester just maybe helped me a little bit. I think I know, but in the transformation bill, career education is being moved. Is that correct? That's correct. It's being divided up. Divided up. And some of those personnel will have a choice of staying in teacher retirement or moving to April. Is that correct? That's correct. And it's going
▶ Play
to allow that employee to choose whether to stay or go with a new... So
▶ Play
Speaker 83 17:43
at least to help those people that are being moved not really want to affect anything else other than their choice.
▶ Play
That's correct. This is just language protecting the current employee. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Goodman. Thank you,
▶ Play
Senator Garner. Thank you, Mr. President. And we'll still
▶ Play
have a discussion on these actual bills and what they do. This is just suspending the Senate rules to allow us to get to that point where we're going to have a discussion. We're trying to do everything on the board to make sure we move forward. Is
▶ Play
that correct? That's correct. Thank you. Senator, any follow-up, Senator Flowers? None. Okay. Anyone else have any questions? Anyone else wish to speak on this? All those in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? Ayes have it. The resolution is adopted. Senator Hester, you have
▶ Play
Speaker 5 18:33
another one. Senate Resolution 7 by Senator Hester to suspend Sections 14B2 and 14B3 of the Joint Rules of the Senate and House of Representatives of the 92nd General Assembly. Senator Hester. The
▶ Play
same thing, just different parts of the code that we're, or different Senate rule that we have to suspend for the same purpose.
▶ Play
Any questions on this one? Anyone wish to speak? All those in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? Ayes have it. Resolution is adopted. Moving to the business agenda. Senator Stubblefield, SJR 3. MS. Senate
▶ Play
Speaker 5 19:12
Joint Resolution III by Senator Stubblefield, applying to the United States Congress to call a convention of proposing amendments pursuant to Article V of the United States Constitution. SEN. SEN.
▶ Play
SEN. SEN. STUBBLEFIELD. SEN. SEN. SEN. SEN. SEN. SEN. SEN. SEN. SEN. SEN. SEN. SEN. SEN. SEN. SEN. SEN. Joe, almost 70% of the people in Arkansas favor an Article 5 convention. You know, when I woke up this morning, I thought about something that happened, and Senator Bonds brought something up about President Clinton the other day in the committee meeting, and I thought about, you know, I remember in 1999 when Senator, President Clinton's Secretary of Labor, Robert Reich, he came out one morning and he wrote an op-ed, and And in that op-ed he said this, he said, there is no need for the American people to worry about the interruption of the work of Congress because of the impeachment proceedings, because everyone knows that the Federal Reserve controls the monetary system, the economic system. And they also know that the IMF controls foreign policy. And they also know that the President of the United States has the power to declare war. None of those are constitutional. But he also added, and let me finish that up, he said the dirty little secret is out that both houses of Congress have become totally irrelevant. You can look that op-ed up. That's the same sentiment that's prevalent today, but it's been prevalent for many decades before he made that statement. This Article 5 is not a Democrat. It's not a Republican issue. This is an American issue. Ladies and gentlemen, let me tell you something. We are faced with a debt. In fact, some of you may have got the email yesterday from the CBO, the Congressional Budget Office and the Government Accountability Office. In that email it said we are in unchartered waters. In other words, we owe $22 trillion in debt, with another $120 trillion in unfunded liabilities from Social Security, Medicaid, Medicare, pension funds, student loans. That doesn't even take into account the personal debt owned by Americans. We are in unchartered waters. And some say, well, you know, this could go on. We really don't worry, and most Americans really don't have a clue because most of us really don't understand how much $22 trillion in debt is. And that same attitude prevailed among those who had never experienced an economic earthquake like those who lived in the Great Depression did, my mother and dad, many of your moms and dads, and certainly our grandparents who lived through the Great Depression. And they realized that the Great Depression didn't just happened overnight. In fact, it was a culmination of more than two decades of economic abuse. The promise of prosperity built on debt had tempted a lot of conservative, normally conservative Americans to risk all that they own. And guess what? They lost. And now we We have 85 years, 85 years of economic abuse with no side and end, I mean no ended side. What do you think? Does anybody in this chamber today really believe that Congress is going to wake up in the morning all of a sudden and say, we've got to cut our spending? Do you really believe that? Do you really believe that anything is going to change in Washington, D.C.? You know, Senator Flowers was talking this morning, a city, county, local, and I've worked with most of you for six years, some of you eight years, and there's one thing about state legislatures that I have become aware of. We may not agree on a lot of different things, whether we're Republicans or Democrats, but Most of the time, we agree on how to, I mean, we don't agree on how to get there, but we agree on most things. We just don't agree on the avenue of how to get to that place. But we get along and we work together. We even like each other, Senator Cheatham. That's not so in Washington, D.C. Let me tell you something. They give these speeches in Washington, D.C. and talk about the interest of the American people. But you know what it's really about in Washington, DC? It's about maintaining power. It's about buying committee chairmanships and buying leadership positions for millions of dollars. You don't have to watch the news very long to realize that Washington, DC cares very little about the American people. I will agree, there are a few up there, there are some good people in Washington, DC who have fought hard, but they are basically pushed aside because they don't go along with the flow. You know that as well as I know that. Congress has been known, Congress has known this all along. They've known the kind of financial condition this country's in and what we're facing economically. They know this and they know it's not sustainable. Senator Ingram and I talked about this a couple of months ago. We agree the economic path we're on is not sustainable. We cannot continue to owe this kind of money. Just yesterday the CBO said in eight years on the current path we'll owe $30 trillion. $30 trillion. Now most of you understand how government, The budget process works in Washington. Mandatory spending, discretionary spending. Back in the 60s, mandatory spending, the social programs, made up 35% of the budget. The discretionary spending, the military, education, infrastructure, that made up 75% of the budget. And we all know that today, those have flipped, they're just the opposite. And with $22 trillion in debt in five years, just the interest, if there's no increase in interest. And by the way, 10 years ago, the bid to cover ratio on our U.S. debt, Senator Hickey, we talked about this, was 3.8. Today it's 1.8. If it drops to 1.1, we can no longer borrow any money. Now, what do you think happens then? We have a Congress that's known this all along, and yet they refuse to address the problem. And yet, why should they? No incentive to, as long as they can keep getting reelected and maintain power in Washington. You and I have witnessed the greatest generational theft in this country's history. You and I, some of us that are older, may not experience it, but I can assure you, your Your children and your grandchildren and their children will experience it. Washington, their consensus is it's better to sink the nation with debt than to rock the boat to reform. We have surrendered control of our finances to a group of people that are so ignorant in basic economics, they don't even know how to run the country. Most of us grew up, our mom and dad, I run a business. My dad told me when I was a boy, you cannot continue to spend more than you take in. We all operate under that. That is a very simple economic fact. You cannot continue to spend more than you take. Why don't they do that in Washington? Our state does it. Most other states do it. Not true in D.C. 65% of all state budgets are controlled by Washington. We have nothing to say about it. 65% of all state budgets were controlled by Washington. Yet they continued to pass laws restricting the rights and freedoms of the majority of Americans while they exempt themselves in the process. I doubt many of you know, and I can assure you that most voters don't know, that Congress has exempted itself from civil rights, from anti-discriminatory laws. They've even exempted themselves from our retirement program, our school system, and even the normal daycare systems. They don't follow the same guidelines that we do. I'm going to read to you something and see if you recognize these words. We know through painful experience that freedom is never voluntarily given by the oppressor. It must be demanded by the oppressed. You know who said that? You know who said it, Senator Chesterfield? Dr. Martin Luther King said that. You know who he said it to? He was speaking to those who criticized his civil rights protests. They wanted him to wait for a better time for his movement to fight for racial equality in the United States. They argued that one day the culture would accept equal rights of African Americans. But Martin Luther King knew that wait almost always meant never. He knew that those in power would never willingly see their authority, and it was up to the African American community and their supporters to fight for their rights as American citizens. And thank God he did. Well, that same principle that Martin Luther King believed in is the same principle that the vast majority of Americans believe in today. That the overreach and the abuse that's been perpetuated by the federal government will never end until we the people demand our freedom. There's only one way to do that. It was provided for us in the Constitution. It's called Article 5 and it was the second clause in Article 5. Two days before the Constitutional Convention ended. Just two days. A guy by the name of Colonel George Mason stood up and he said, gentlemen, we've made a mistake. We have given, we have given Congress the ability to propose amendments, but we haven't given that same power to the people and then he asked this question do you believe that any government that becomes tyrannical would even propose amendments to restrain its own tyranny now we know this to be true because all you have to do is read madison's notes james madison was a very good note taker and he wrote that down and he wrote the words nincom two little words those words meant no comment, no debate. In other words, all those men that were assembled there, they found that that proposition was so obvious that the states would even have to restrain the federal government. They didn't even debate the issue. They never brought it up. And so they unanimously adopted the second clause of Article 5, giving the people, and by the way, Now, if I remember correctly, in the Constitution it says that the powers delegated to the federal government were to be few and defiant. Those to the states would be numerous and indefinite. You know what's happened? We have drifted so far from the original intent of the Founding Fathers, from the moorings of our Constitution, that we have flipped roles. Now the states have no power. The federal government has all the power. They merely use us as regional agencies to funnel our own tax dollars back to us through individual mandates, sometimes through unfunded mandates. And if you think that's going to get better, we can't even represent the people in our own state the way we want to represent them for fear of breaking a federal regulation or a federal rule. They unanimously adopt this second clause of Article V. Seventy-five percent of all Americans say the federal government is too big, too powerful, too involved in our lives. For so many years, we've trusted Washington, D.C. with our financial security. They have betrayed the trust, they've jeopardized the future of our children and our grandchildren. You and I have witnessed, and I've told you before, the greatest generation of theft in American history. Every U.S. congressman and every U.S. senator understands the cost of refusing to confront the exploding national debt. Like I said, we may not feel the results right now, but I can assure you someday our children and our grandchildren and their children, they will feel these results. And yet this coming crisis is one of Congress's own making, having promised far more benefits than they ever made provisions for the American people to pay for. And the founders knew. They knew the depravity of man, they knew the sinfulness of man, and they knew what power does. It's very addictive. And so they gave us a way to get out of this mess and to rein ourselves back in. Let me conclude by saying this. Our founding fathers, I believe, were men of faith. They had to be. They risked their lives, their families' lives, their fortunes, all for freedom. And for 180 years, we were a nation of faith. America was a nation of faith. That's not true any longer. We've become a nation of fear because we expect, we've traded in our independence for security, for promises from the government. I know because I spent a lot of time with my granddad who worked till he was 90 year old. He wouldn't take his social security because he didn't want have anything to do with the government until finally one of his eight daughters, his youngest one, no boys, talked him in and convinced him that that was his money. So he finally went down and took it and gave it to his girls. We don't have that independence, that faith anymore because we're so afraid that the federal government is going to mess up and we're not going to get our checks, and we have to rely on them for everything. We've become a nation of dependence, not independence. And that faith was taken from us, starting back in the 1960s, when nine robe judges began to take us down a path of removing the very foundation of our faith, which is God Himself. They took God from our education system. You see, the real threat to our Constitution today is not posed by a Convention of States. A Convention of States is merely a meeting where you propose amendments. You have gotten emails and letters calling in a con-con? A constitutional convention is for the purpose of writing a constitution. We already have a constitution. This method is simply to restore the constitution to its original meaning, not rewrite the constitution. It's basically that simple. So the threat today is not a convention of states, but rather an out-of-control federal government. And her founders telegraphed that message to us, showing us that there's a way back inside the fence of the Constitution. So with that said, members, I would take any
▶ Play
questions. Thank you, Senator. Members, are there any questions? You heard a presentation of the bill. Any
▶ Play
questions? Senator Vaughn, you're recognized, sir. Well, I hadn't planned on questions, but you mentioned at the beginning our exchange that we had in the committee. And so setting aside, I think our agreement on the exploding debt, the constitutional question I have in reviewing Article 5 is there's nothing that limits the convention that I see in the Constitution once the convention is called, and that's my concern. I know there was a response from that in the committee. I just wanted to give you an opportunity to
▶ Play
give that here. Yes. And add one other comment. And let me make it clear that there are three subject matters that are included in the application from 38 states. In those three subject matters, nothing can be brought up outside of the scope of physical restraints, limiting government, and term limits. Any amendment brought up outside of those subject matter, it will be called out of order. It won't even be considered. They have to aggregate. The 34 state, and I know a little bit about aggregating because I'm a farmer. When you dump a load of gravel and you run over it and it becomes flat, those gravel aggregate. And it's the same way with these applications. They have to line up with these three subjects. If not, anything brought up outside the scope of these three subjects will not even be considered. In fact, that delegate, thanks to your amendment, but it would happen anyway, Senator Hickey, could be brought home and in Indiana even charged with a felony. So all these emails you've been getting talking about a runaway convention, and by the way, even if there's an amendment offered, it takes 38 states to ratify that amendment. Only 13 could block any amendment. 13 states it's the founders someone said why has this never happened i'll tell you why it's never happened it is a very difficult process and the founders set a very high bar because they did not want the constitution amended all the time it's a very high bar things have to get really bad which they are. Well, then, just to follow
▶ Play
up on, I think that's where we have a legitimate disagreement. I don't see in the Constitution where it can be limited. Folks on your side, you see that it can, so I just wanted to point
▶ Play
that out. Well, Senator Vaughn, I would say that my example of Robert Reich, those are not in the Constitution either. We fought three wars. We fought Vietnam, Korea, and Iraq without Congress authorizing war. Under the Constitution, only Congress can authorize war. And yet we fought free, not even was the Constitution amended to allow that to happen. So we've been outside, we have circumvented and ignored the Constitution for many, many years.
▶ Play
Right, well, and I hesitate to go further, but with regards to what I mentioned, with regards to Bill Clinton was the last president to run a balanced budget at the federal level was a guy from Arkansas. We were agreeing that since 2015-2016, we're up 77% on our deficit. That was where we were agreeing, the exploding deficit, which is a problem of nonpartisan. Right. Is there
▶ Play
anyone that would like to speak for or against the bill? Senator Chesterfield, you recognize to speak against the bill?
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair, ladies and gentlemen of the Senate. One of those three things troubles me greatly, that's limiting government. What does that mean? For me, it meant throughout history that I would be limited in those opportunities that were granted to me or that were denied to me because of my race or my ethnicity. I am concerned about having a constitutional convention for the first time since 1787. And why? Because we have 27 amendments to the Constitution that have held through time. And now we're talking about doing to the Constitution what we ought to do in the electoral process. And that's sending home people who continue to expand the deficit. We have a simple solution. It doesn't take a constitutional convention. It takes the will to vote against people who have no respect for the economic stability of this state and this nation. That's not something that we need a constitutional convention for. I'm also very, very much concerned about, as we talk about limiting government, there is talk about freedom of religion. The Constitution says there can be no establishment of religion, and yet that's very much a part of the conversation. And if we go down that road, what happens to the plethora of individuals who have religions other than our own? I'm concerned also about who will represent each of the states as we talk about this Constitutional Convention. When we had the Constitutional Convention of 1787, there were but, what, 13 states. All of the individuals who put this together were white, and they were male, and they were moneyed. Will we again put together a convention that is white and male and money? Or how will we do, or what will we do about making sure that this Constitutional Convention reflects the diversity that really is America what will we do about the 13th the 14th and the 15th amendment which many people claim was legislative over overreach when they were added to the Constitution they're very near and dear to me there is still one of the things that the president of the United States States said he wanted was to look at the 14th Amendment. And that 14th Amendment is what gave me citizenship rights. And so I am concerned, because it is very difficult. It is very difficult to change the Constitution. And it's difficult for a reason. Because it has held for this country over the years Only 27 times has it been changed. There have been 33 proposed amendments. Only 27 have been accepted. The first 10 of which are the Bill of Rights about which I care so much. And I fear, I fear that as we go down this road willy-nilly, that we are putting together a convention that may not look like me, may not care about me, may not recognize the diversity that is America, unlike the lack of diversity during that time. And in spite of that lack of diversity, those individuals put together a document that has lasted through time and has ultimately made me a citizen in this country. I would say leave things alone. Thank you Senator. Any questions
▶ Play
for Senator Chesterfield? Seeing none, is there someone that would like to speak for the bill? Senator Johnson, recognized to speak for the bill.
▶ Play
Thank you Mr. President. I rise on this issue with some reluctance to even speak my very first real speech in the well about this. It's a little bit of background. I want you all to know that when I was born, my dad was a member of this body. My parents became engaged in the parking lot over here on the west side of the Capitol. When I was 10 years old, I was a page sitting right down here in the front. When I was 18 years old, I was the reading clerk standing there where Ann usually stands. I have so much respect for this body, and I take everything we do here seriously. I appreciate each and every one of you's colleagues and friends. We don't do a lot of things here that are trivial, but this one sets a new bar. We're charged with something that could, as Senator Stubblefield said, affect our children and our great-grandchildren. Our lieutenant governor used a term once that I heard, and it was about our federal budget. He said it is unsustainable, and I can't even begin to enumerate the fiscal issues that Senator Stubblefield covered so carefully, but I want to talk about our responsibilities and a sobering moment I had about our republic. A few years ago, my wife had a reason to travel to Maryland for a business meeting, and she said, when we get through, I want to go visit as many of the president's homes in Virginia that we can. And of course, like many of you, I'd already been to Mount Vernon and to Monticello and even Ashlawn, which is Monroe's home. But newly open to the public was Montpelier, who was James Madison's home. And I visited Montpelier, and there's a room there that you get to go on a tour. And it's tiny. It's about the size of our conference room over here on the east side of the Senate chamber. And this is the room, they told us, where James Madison read the books of the ages of Hammurabi and the Greeks and the Romans and tried to fashion what he thought our republic should be and the work that he did result is the United States Constitution and President Madison is known as the father of the Constitution and the story that senator stubblefield mentioned about uh uh george mason colonel mason and how he brought in at the at the last minute it's like wait a minute folks we got one last little protection we have to put in here and i think that's something we should stop and think about now this whole process reminds me of some of y'all heard the story about the the dam that broke somewhere and the old fellow was sitting on his porch and the sheriff came up and said joe the the uh the dam's broke it's going to flood you've got to leave he says no sheriff the lord will protect me and he he came back soon in in a in a boat and the floodwaters were up about to the fellow's porch and he said uh sheriff he said i'm not worried the lord will protect me. So the sheriff took one last try. He brought a helicopter and he flew over. Then Joe was up on the roof of the house and he says, Joe, you're going to die. Please get in our helicopter and let us take you to safety. He says, no, no, the Lord will take care of me. So of course the floodwaters rose and Joe drowned and he's at the pearly gates and he meets the Lord and he says, Lord, I thought you would take care of me. He says, well, I sent a car, a boat, and a helicopter. What more did you want? And that's kind of how I feel about Article 5. Everybody wants these solutions. And I think if James Madison and other founding fathers were here, we'd say, well, we need you we need some guidance on how we can can get our republic back on track and they're going to say well I sent you article five here it is we haven't used it and the reason we haven't used it I think is that when things got to be critical mass in our society I think in my own case some of you my generation you remember that there was a saying if you're old enough to fight You're old enough to die in Vietnam. You're old enough to vote. And that's when we got the 18-year-old vote. And there was some rumblings about a convention of states at that time. Congress got in gear and got it passed. Sometimes we have to initiate things. We have to knock things off dead center. But remember, Article 5 is not a dead letter. It was put in the Constitution for a reason by some very brilliant people. I believe divinely ordained people. I believe that truly they did the Lord's work when they came up with that. And that's why, while we're one of the youngest nations in the world, we are the oldest constitutional republic. So I urge your support of this resolution and let's move forward to one more step toward making things better in America. Thank you, Mr. President. I'll take questions for any.
▶ Play
Any questions for Senator Johnson? Seeing none, I do have... I had a hand up over here. Do you want to speak for or against the bill, sir? For the bill? Recognized to speak against the bill, Senator Elliott?
▶ Play
Thank you. Recognized? Carry on. I shan't be long at this discussion, I hope, I have gotten lots of letters about this issue, and I got information that I read and appreciated just as I was coming in. So one of the things I try to hold myself accountable to is making sure I respect at least both sides of an issue. And you know, many times there are more than just both sides. And I respect the fact that people feel very strongly about this, that this is something we ought to do, but I would suggest to you that we have so many blind spots, and it's nobody's fault, but we just don't see them. And with all due respect, a case in point, Senator Johnson, is the privilege that you had to be here and to run around because your dad was in this chamber and have that opportunity and not think there was anything untoward about it, and there's not. But it gave you a faith and it gave you a comfort because the Constitution was written for certain people in this country. Even those folks who, as you say, were doing God's work, they were not doing God's work for everybody. and so that's part of what informs me this time around if we were to do this in this atmosphere and just think about where we are now in this atmosphere where we are so divided and we're divided in ways that none of us can be proud of I don't believe and while I respect the fact that we think we ought to have it it does give me great pause that we were to have it in this environment that's not exactly the way it was when the forefathers were doing God's work for some people but I fear that's what a constitutional convention could end up being in this environment that we find ourselves now And the last thing I want to say about this is I think we have become so lazy about our democracy that we look for shortcuts. And this is one of them. If the people in Washington are not doing what we want them to do, why in the world do we keep sending them back? To me, that's just lazy democracy. Just like term limits. That's just lazy democracy. So if we want to change it, we have a channel for changing it. Rather than asking us to have a convention, why don't we get serious about doing what we need to do to elect the people who would be responsible? They go to Washington, they are not responsible, what do we do? We send them right back. And then we look for another way out. I suggest to you, as our founding fathers would have suggested, and as Jefferson certainly taught us, that our democracy depends on our participation. It depends on our participation, not workarounds. As I respectfully suggest to you, that's probably what this is. I'm just as uncomfortable today with thinking about some kind of rewrite in the Constitution because what Senator Bond called to our attention, we don't know what might happen at this convention. I think it's a dangerous thing to do just for that reason. But even more so, I think it's even more dangerous if we keep looking for workarounds and being lazy about our democracy and not doing what we should do to hold people accountable. So I would ask you, with due respect, to vote no.
▶ Play
Any questions for Senator Elliott? Seeing none, Senator Clark, would you still like to speak for the bill, sir? You're recognized. Speak for the bill.
▶ Play
Speaker 144 55:32
Three quotes. The only thing to fear is fear itself.
▶ Play
Insanity, doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results. That's what we're doing currently with the federal government and our budget. And most importantly, is this one. When the people find that they can vote themselves money, that will herald the end of the republic. Benjamin Franklin. The people have discovered that they can vote themselves money. Our Constitution, one of the reasons it's so great, is that we didn't set up a democracy, we set up a republic. A democracy, any group of us that has a majority can vote to do anything. But because of the Constitution and the Bill of Rights, you can't keep me from practicing my religion if it's all of you against me. You can't keep me from speaking if it's all of you against me. Can't keep me from having a firearm if it's all of you against me. And we could go on down. And in this great Constitution, we have Article 5, and we have a way to fix things if things aren't being fixed. And we have what I think is an irrational fear, after studying it, of a runaway convention because it takes 34 states to agree completely on what we're going to have a constitutional convention about and what they can look at, and that's all that they can look at. And regardless of what they do, it then takes 38 state legislatures or conventions to pass whatever they do. But here's the most important thing, why I ran a little over six years ago, is I told everyone back then I had a 22-year-old and a 26-year-old that we're not going to have the same opportunities that I had had. Dad taught economics along with history and English, and six years ago no nation had been as far in debt as we were and recovered from it. No nation has ever been this far in debt and not suffered grave financial calamity. If there, I don't know that this will work. It seems to be a plausible answer. But I know what we're doing is not working and is headed for calamity. Just like I couldn't see Mount St. Helens erupting, but yet it did, it did, and as every other nation that has had this happen couldn't see that it was coming, Venezuela couldn't see what was coming, it's there, it's coming here, and this is something that I can do to stop it, and so of course I'm voting yes.
▶ Play
Thank you. Thank you. Senators, anyone wants to speak for or against the bill? Seeing none, are you close for your bill, Senator? You're recognized to close for SJR 3. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
▶ Play
Colleagues, Senator Clark mentioned Mount St. Helens. There was an individual by the name of Harry Truman living on Mount St. Helens, not the president. He was warned just a couple of weeks before it erupted that he needed to get off the mountain because there was a lot of activity going on underneath. He said, I've lived here 60 years, and it's never blown. Guess where Mr. Truman is today? He's 40 feet below volcanic ash on the side of Mount St. Hillens. Senator Elliott, I fear a lot of things, too. I also fear George Soros and 250 other groups. I fear our country is turning to socialism to replace the Constitutional Republic. That's what I fear. Whenever George Soros and 250 other groups have adamantly fought this initiative from day one, it tells me a whole lot about Article 5. It tells me they are afraid of losing their power, their control over Washington, D.C., and it tells me they are afraid of the American people. That is who the founders were concerned with more than anything else. They gave all of the states complete sovereignty, and they said your powers are to be numerous and the federal governments are to be few. That
▶ Play
is no longer the case. Mr. President, I'll close. Thank you very much. Any objection to rolling the vote?
▶ Play
Speaker 2 1:00:45
You got to try. Madam Secretary, would you
▶ Play
Speaker 5 1:00:51
please call the roll? Ballinger. Aye. Bledsoe. Aye. Bond. No. Caldwell. Aye. Cheatham. No. Chesterfield. No. Clark. Aye. Cooper. Aye. Davis. Aye. Dismang. Dismang. Eads. Eads. Elliot. No. English. No. Flippo. Yes. Flowers. No. Garner. Yes. Hammer. Yes. Hendron. Hendron. Hester. Yes. Hickey. Aye. Hill. Yes. Ingram. No. Irvin. Blake Johnson Blake Johnson Mark Johnson Letting Mallet Pitch Rapert Rice Sample Stubbafil Sturge Teague Wallace Members, is there anyone that would like to change their vote? Hendren is
▶ Play
aye. Anyone else that would like to change their vote? Blake Johnson, aye. Last call. Anyone wants to change their vote? Cast up the ballot. A vote of 19 yes, 13 against, two non-voting. The resolution passes. Members, I want to recognize if Senator Sample is ready for the presentation of SB-71.
▶ Play
Speaker 5 1:02:45
Senate Bill 71 by Senator Sample, to clarify the procedure for the appointment of members Members of the State Highway Commission is set
▶ Play
out in Arkansas Constitution, Amendment 42.
▶ Play
Senator, you're recognized for presentation of your bill. Thank you, Mr. President. Members, this bill is just bringing the procedure back to the way that the Mack Blackwell Amendment was passed. Somehow it got off track in about 1979, but this ensures that every congressional district will have one highway commissioner representing them, and there will be one highway commissioner that will be at large. I want to make sure that everybody knows that this is just giving everyone representation on the highway commission. That's all it does. That's all I intend it is.
▶ Play
Speaker 161 1:03:49
I'll take questions. Members, any questions
▶ Play
for Senator Sample? Senator Ingram, you're recognized for questions, sir.
▶ Play
If you would, Senator, please rise and turn on the button. It was on. This one was on.
▶ Play
Speaker 163 1:04:06
So this would keep every commissioner being appointed from Northwest Arkansas. Any other questions for
▶ Play
Senator Sample? Seeing no questions, is there anyone that would like to speak for or against the bill? Seeing none, Senator Sample, are you closed for the bill? Closed. All right. Any objection?
▶ Play
Speaker 5 1:04:30
Roll the vote. Madam Secretary, roll the vote. Ballinger, Bledsoe, Bond, Caldwell, Cheatham, Chesterfield, Clark, Cooper, Davis, Dismang, Eades, Elliott, English, Flippo, Flowers, Garner, Hammer, Hendron, Hester, Hickey, Hill, Ingram, Irvin, Blake Johnson, Mark Johnson, Letting, Malik, Pitch, Raifert, Rice, Sample, Stubberfield, Sturge, Teague, Wallace. Anyone wish to change their vote? Seeing none, cast
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:05:13
up the ballot, 34 yeas, 0 nays. The bill is passed, transmitted to the House. Senator Raifert has two bills, SB 79, SB 80. Senate Bill 79
▶ Play
Speaker 5 1:05:27
by Senator Raifert to revise the maximum loan limits of certain loans. Senator Rafer. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. President. Members, Senate Bill 79 is actually plain and simple. This is, both of these bills actually are department bills and what this states in here to go ahead and answer, foretell a question that might come, is this 20% basically means that no banking institution can loan out more than 20% to one individual. It does not have anything to do with interest rates which if you look at it is not relatively clear when you just look at that. But it does refer to the fact that they are limited on that amount. I'd be happy to
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:06:07
take any questions. Any questions for Senator Raypert? Anyone wish to speak against or for Senators close? Any objection on rolling the
▶ Play
Speaker 5 1:06:19
vote? Seeing none, please roll the vote. Madam Secretary. Ballinger, Bledsoe, Bond, Caldwell, Cheatham, Chesterfield, Clark, Cooper, Davis, Dismang, Eades, Elliot, English, Flippo, Flowers, Garner, Hammer, Hendron, Hester, Hickey, Hill, Ingram, Irvin, Blake Johnson, Mark Johnson, Letting, Malik, Pitch, Rapert, Rice, Sample, Stubbefield, Sturge, Teague, Wallace. Anyone wish to change
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:06:52
their vote? Seeing none, cast up the ballot. 34 Or yay, zero, nays, the bill is passed, transmit to the House. Senator Rayford.
▶ Play
Speaker 5 1:07:00
Senate Bill 80 by Senator Rayford to clarify the remedies and procedures for nonpayment of rent on a safe deposit box. Thank you. Members, this
▶ Play
is another agreed-to bill. A few years ago, many of you that are here remember that we had a change in the amount of time before property would have sheeted to the states. And that it was actually determined that the Bank Department looked at some of their codes, and there was a reference here in their codes that had not been changed. And so what this simply does is change from seven years back to five years, and that's where you see that it strikes prior to seven and inserts before the period of time established by Section 1828-203. That sets it at five years related to property that's in a safe deposit box that would then a sheet to the state. I'd be happy to take any questions.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:07:49
Any questions? Anyone wish to speak on it, against it, for it? Senator closed. Yes, sir. Any objection to rolling the
▶ Play
Speaker 5 1:08:01
vote? Thank you. Seeing none. Madam Secretary, please roll the vote. Ballinger, Bledsoe, Bond, Caldwell, Cheatham, Chesterfield, Clark, Cooper, Davis, Dismang, Eades, Elliott, English, Flippo, Flowers, Garner, Hammer, Hendron, Hester, Hickey, Hill, Ingram, Irvin, Blake Johnson, Mark Johnson, Letting, Malik, Pitch, Raypert, Rice, Sample, Stubberfield, Starch, Teague, Wallace. Anyone wish to change their
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:08:35
vote? Seeing none, cast out the ballot. 34 yeas, 0 nays. The bill is passed. Transmit to the House. Senator Ballinger. Senate
▶ Play
Speaker 5 1:08:46
Bill 116 by Senator Ballinger, requiring an inmate in the Department of Correction to first exhaust all available administrative remedies as condition proceeding to filing a claim under the Arkansas Civil Rights Act of 1993 or any other state law. Thank you, Mr. President.
▶ Play
Speaker 173 1:09:06
This bill is really a pretty simple bill. There's no no organized opposition to it at all. So Department of Corrections have for years required that an inmate to exhaust all administrative remedies before they actually bring a claim. The court has looked at it and said we didn't ever actually draft that into the code section. And so they wanted to have something, some clarity before we do that. So this basically just puts us back to the way we've always done things. Basically, an inmate has to try to go through the local procedures before they
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:09:40
actually file a claim in court. So I appreciate a good vote.
▶ Play
Speaker 5 1:09:48
Any questions? They don't wish to speak. Any objection to rolling the vote? Please roll the vote. Ballinger, Bledsoe, Bond, Caldwell, Cheatham, Chesterfield, Clark, Cooper, Davis, Dismang, Eads, Elliott, English, Flippo, Flowers, Garner, Hammer, Hendron, Hester, Hickey, Hill, Ingram, Irvin, Blake Johnson, Mark Johnson, Letting, Malik, Pitch, Rappert, Rice, Sample, Stebbelfield, Sturge, Teague, Wallace. Anyone wish to vote or change their vote? Senator Chesterfield.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:10:26
Senator Chesterfield present. Anyone else? Seeing none, cast up the ballot. 32 yays, 0 nays. The bill is passed. Transmit to the House. Senator Teague is recognized.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. President. I'd like to send House Bill 1052 back to budget, please. Without objection. Thank you. No budget tomorrow while I'm here. We'll beat Thursday at 9. No budget. Bail
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:11:06
bondsman any other announcements any other announcements any other announcements and so Senate will be adjourned until 1 o'clock tomorrow subject to the clearing of the desk
▶ Play

Agenda

Call to Order

0:04 - 0:53 4 segments 3 speakers

Prayer

0:53 - 1:53 3 segments 1 speaker

Pledge of Allegiance

1:53 - 2:13 2 segments 2 speakers

Announcements

2:13 - 9:59 27 segments 10 speakers

Bills to be read

9:59 - 13:34 9 segments 3 speakers

SR6 Hester TO SUSPEND SECTIONS 14.(B)(2) AND 14.(B)(3) OF THE RULES OF THE SENATE OF THE NINETY-SECOND GENERAL ASSEMBLY.

13:34 - 18:34 26 segments 7 speakers

SR7 Hester TO SUSPEND SECTIONS 14.(B)(2) AND 14.(B)(3) OF THE JOINT RULES OF THE SENATE AND THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES OF THE NINETY-SECOND GENERAL ASSEMBLY.

18:34 - 19:35 4 segments 4 speakers

SJR3 G. Stubblefield APPLYING TO THE UNITED STATES CONGRESS TO CALL A CONVENTION FOR PROPOSING AMENDMENTS PURSUANT TO ARTICLE V OF THE UNITED STATES CONSTITUTION.

19:35 - 1:02:47 93 segments 10 speakers

Senator Gary Stubblefield introduced SJR 3, arguing that the nation’s $22 trillion debt and unfunded liabilities constitute an unsustainable fiscal crisis that can only be addressed through an Article V convention of states. [19:58] [20:30] [21:03] [21:37] [22:08] [22:39] [23:13] [23:48] [24:19] [24:51] [25:29] [26:04] [26:35] [27:06] [27:36] [28:07] [28:44] [29:20] [29:54] [30:28] [31:02] [31:34] [32:07] [32:39] [33:11] [33:42] [34:19] [34:50] [35:28] [35:59] [36:33]

Senators Will Bond, Linda Chesterfield, Mark Johnson, Joyce Elliott and others questioned the scope, limits and potential for a “runaway” convention, while Senator Stubblefield reiterated that the application limits amendments to fiscal restraint, term limits and limiting government. [36:48] [37:08] [37:17] [37:42] [38:15] [38:50] [39:02] [39:12] [39:21] [39:49] [39:55]

After debate, the chair called for a vote; the roll call recorded 19 yes, 13 no and two non-voting, and the resolution was adopted. [1:02:13] [1:02:45]

SB71 B. Sample TO CLARIFY THE PROCEDURE FOR THE APPOINTMENT OF MEMBERS OF THE STATE HIGHWAY COMMISSION AS SET OUT IN ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION, AMENDMENT 42.

1:02:47 - 1:05:28 12 segments 7 speakers

Senator Bill Sample presented SB 71 to restore the original appointment procedure for the State Highway Commission as set by Amendment 42 of the Arkansas Constitution. [1:03:01] [1:03:27]

A brief question period followed, but no senator offered substantive opposition before the bill was closed. [1:03:49] [1:03:53] [1:04:00] [1:04:06] [1:04:15]

The Senate voted unanimously, recording 34 yeas and 0 nays, and the bill was passed to the House. [1:04:30] [1:05:04] [1:05:13]

SB79 Rapert TO REVISE THE MAXIMUM LOAN LIMITS OF CERTAIN LOANS.

1:05:28 - 1:07:00 8 segments 3 speakers

Chair Senator Jason Rapert explained SB 79, which would cap any single lender’s exposure to an individual at 20 % of that borrower’s assets. [1:05:35] [1:05:39] [1:06:07]

No legislators raised objections, and the measure proceeded directly to a vote. [1:06:15] [1:06:19]

The roll call showed 34 yeas and no nays, so the bill was enacted and sent to the House. [1:06:50] [1:06:52]

SB80 Rapert TO CLARIFY THE REMEDIES AND PROCEDURES FOR NONPAYMENT OF RENT ON A SAFE-DEPOSIT BOX.

1:07:00 - 1:08:49 8 segments 3 speakers

Senator Rapert described SB 80, which shortens the statutory period for the state to claim property in a safe-deposit box from seven to five years. [1:07:09] [1:07:24]

After a routine question round, the bill was closed without further comment. [1:07:49] [1:07:54]

The Senate recorded 34 affirmative votes and zero negatives, passing the bill to the House. [1:08:01] [1:08:30] [1:08:35]

SB116 B. Ballinger REQUIRING AN INMATE IN THE DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTION TO FIRST EXHAUST ALL AVAILABLE ADMINISTRATIVE REMEDIES AS A CONDITION PRECEDENT TO FILING A CLAIM UNDER THE ARKANSAS CIVIL RIGHTS ACT OF 1993 OR ANY OTHER STATE LAW.

1:08:49 - 1:10:53 8 segments 4 speakers

Senator Ballinger’s SB 116 was presented as a clarification that inmates must exhaust all administrative remedies before filing a civil-rights claim, restoring prior practice. [1:09:06] [1:09:32] [1:09:40]

The proposal faced no organized opposition and moved straight to a vote. [1:09:48] [1:10:09]

The final tally was 32 yeas, 0 nays, and the measure was approved and transmitted to the House. [1:10:26] [1:10:46]

Announcement

1:10:53 - 1:11:21 2 segments 1 speaker

Adjourned

1:11:21 - 1:21:21

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Chair Unverified
27 segments
Speaker 2
2 segments
Speaker 5
28 segments
Senator Jim Hendren Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 9
1 segment
Senator Cecile Bledsoe Unverified
2 segments
Senator Larry Teague Unverified
3 segments
Senator Keith Ingram Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 25
2 segments
Senator Will Bond Unverified
11 segments
Speaker 36
1 segment
Senator Mark Johnson Chair Unverified
14 segments
Senator Kim Hammer Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 59
1 segment
Senator Bart Hester Unverified
12 segments
Senator Stephanie Flowers Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 82
1 segment
Speaker 83
2 segments
Senator Trent Garner Unverified
1 segment
Senator Gary Stubblefield Unverified
41 segments
Senator Jason Rapert Chair Unverified
16 segments
Senator Linda Chesterfield Unverified
8 segments
Senator Joyce Elliott Unverified
8 segments
Speaker 144
1 segment
Senator Alan Clark Unverified
6 segments
Senator Bill Sample Chair Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 161
1 segment
Speaker 163
1 segment
Speaker 173
2 segments