ALC - Hospital, Medicaid, & Developmental Disabilities Study Subcommittee
November 16, 2026·10:00 AM·Room A, MAC·1:14:03
VideoTranscript7 documents
Summary
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin
Processing date
November 19, 2026
B. Update on Reimbursement Rates Under the Living Choices Assisted Living Waiver Pursuant to Act 213 of 2022, Section 15 [Exhibits B1-B4] 5:32
Speaker 32 presented two monthly letters summarizing the assisted-living waiver cost report and explained that the department has examined several options-maintaining the current reimbursement rate or applying modest increases-which are still pending executive review.
[5:43]
Representative Mary Bentley invited questions, received none, thanked the presenters, and indicated that DHS is expected to issue a recommendation on the rates within the next month.
[6:12]
C. Discussion of Arkansas EARNS Final Report and Potential Legislation [Exhibit C-C2] 6:31
The consultant team, led by Speaker 41 (Mason), presented the final EARNS report and a suite of recommendations-including a July 1 2027 effective date, an integrated “franchise” service-delivery model with shared case management, a statewide cost-allocation framework, and inclusion in the federal benefits-cliff pilot to streamline eligibility, improve career pathways, and reduce administrative waste.
[55:32][56:12][56:48][57:29][59:41][1:00:14][1:00:45][1:01:19][1:01:53][1:02:26][1:02:59][1:03:34][1:04:09][1:04:40][1:05:10][1:05:45]
Committee members raised implementation questions: Rep. David Ray asked for the January report’s org-chart visuals to compare current versus proposed structures, and Rep. Denise Garner queried the fiscal and staffing impacts; Speaker 41 responded that many recommendations are already underway, waivers are in place, and the reforms are expected to be cost-neutral or generate savings over time.
[58:16][58:34][59:05][1:10:16][1:10:40][1:10:55][1:11:12][1:11:43][1:12:18]
A motion to adopt the consultant-group report was made, seconded, and carried unanimously, with Rep. Mary Bentley noting that legislation based on the report will be forthcoming.
[1:12:55][1:13:29]
if everyone will find their seats we're going to start this meeting in about 60 seconds good morning everyone good Monday morning to all of you appreciate everybody coming in for this important meeting today we're excited to have with us today before we get started I know we have some representative elects here so if you guys are sitting next to someone as a representative elect have them press their button we want to let them introduce themselves this morning so callers can get to know who you are. Sure just thank you guys.
County area. Great. Welcome. Okay. Representative Ramis. thank you representative brian armis or elect brian armis um district eight that's a little bit of bentonville a little bit of rogers uh p ridge and bella vista all right welcome okay have one
district 35 and that includes marion arkansas little piece of west memphis all the way up to turrell and all the way over to park and in cross county great welcome glad you guys are here this morning okay we'll get back to our agenda first
thing on our agenda this morning what workers will welcome secretary man and she has someone new she'd like to announce as well this morning to get our update on assisted living waiver Good morning,
Thank you very much for both being here. I thought you guys might want to see that we do have a new Chief of Staff with Gavin, so make sure you introduce yourself to him and get to know him as the
meeting is over. Thank you guys both for being here, and your Secretary Mayan will hear from you. Thank you, Chairman. So this morning you have before you two letters, two monthly letters on the ALF report. And the summation is we've worked through the cost reporting. We had several different options to either stay at the current rate or do some small increases. And that is still under executive review. I'm hoping that DHS will have a recommendation for you in the next month on rates.
Anybody have any questions? Okay, thank you for your report. We'll look forward to seeing you next month. Gavin, welcome. We appreciate you. Okay, next on our doc is to hear from our consultants here with Mason and Cameron to give us our final report. For those that are new here, we have been working on this for nearly two years now, just transforming our workforce and social services together to get a better outcome for our constituents across the entire state. We have worked diligently. really thankful for uh cameron and for mason the hard work they've done they've been great and they will continue working with us as we get our legislation ready and they will be available for when we present the bill in committee so welcome thank you guys for being here this morning and we will begin good morning thank
you everybody let me move the mic up here so you can hear me congratulations to the new uh representatives and senators elected and look forward to working working with all of you. So I first want to thank, seeing Secretary Mann here, we have a slide here but I'll go ahead and do it now. I want to, I really want to. Cameron, I'm
closer. Oh, you still can't hear me? Okay. I always feel like I talk too loud. I'm a little self-conscious of that. So we'll go ahead and get started. The way we've presented this PowerPoint is we have a basic summary of recommendations and then we have some more details so if any of you have questions and want to dig in a little deeper on any particular components we can do that. So I think that that work good so we in in the report just for some context have some basic numbers and why this is important what we're essentially trying to do for those of you who've heard us over the past few months is really look at the different programs that help people become upwardly mobile, and how do we take these different programs and really focus on developing a system approach to delivering workforce training and social services. So in particular, the social services support upward mobility and getting people back to work and careers rather than having them sit on benefits and struggle with affordability and those sorts of issues. You can see here context-wise why this is important is because Arkansas has one of the lowest labor force participation rates in the country, so we obviously want to improve upon labor force participation. I actually believe, in particular, that in the age of artificial intelligence or super intelligence, whichever we're calling it, that keeping people connected to the labor market is going to be critical. We know through the Great Recession time period and other time periods that long spells of unemployment are very bad for people. They have a very hard time ever recovering from that. So we want to keep people and we want to help people who aren't labor force attached become labor force attached. We have a number of prime working-age Arkansas who are unemployed or out of the labor force and we want to try to impact that. And then in terms of youth disconnection, Arkansas has one of the worst youth rates in the country. So what are we trying to do with this? Again as a review, for those of you who have heard me before, we want to help get rid of what we call the silos, or I call them the individual program-by-program approach. Essentially what we have now is individuals in any of your communities that you represent who have to navigate through two, three, four different systems, processes, go to three or four physical locations or connect to virtual systems in order to get all the assistance they need to help them become gainfully employed and enter into careers. We're trying to not have separate doors, eligibility processes, or case workers. In addition, the human services approach really does not focus on work. With issues such as work participation rates, et cetera, the human services approach tends to be more of a compliance approach versus a help people get employed approach. And that's not a criticism of the folks working in human services. It's just the reality of how they have to process the work. So what we want to try to do is impact that by helping ensure that instead of going through an eligibility screening process if you enter a human services program, you really talk about employment and training first. And then what we want to really do too is also help mitigate the inherent inefficiencies in the way programs are done now. We want to get rid of duplicated intake, things like income verification. We're really recommending looking at the physical infrastructure and the footprint of all these different offices and programs across the state and trying to really find where those inefficiencies and where can those savings really help more people get employment and training services. So we had an advisory group that we utilized. Some of you, I see, came to some of the meetings, who I see here today. And we had a number of executive branch officials and other stakeholders. I do want to really thank those who participate in the advisory group. And in particular, Secretary Mann was just here. I also want to thank Secretary McDonald and their teams in human services and in commerce. Because without those individuals and the data they provided and the input they provided, we wouldn't be able to make the recommendations with as much confidence as we can make today. So we really did have a very strong process and people who gave us a lot of input and a lot of information. So our vision for Arkansas Earns, which is what we're recommending we call this effort, is we want to modernize and transform the workforce development and human services system through an integrated administrative and service delivery model that streamlines state and local program administration, improves both the quality of and access to services and supports, Promotes fiscal integrity and resource efficiency for the benefit of Arkansas residents and employers and we don't want to forget the employer side of this either We have a number of goals here We've talked about these before and I won't go through each one of them but essentially we want to really promote upward mobility and increase wages and Greater access to services that promote longer-term employment and labor force attachment Again, I also don't want to lose focus on employers because a lot of times in these discussions we focus on the job seeker or the worker, and frankly, we need an approach where we deal with employers in a much more strategic and efficient way as well because we actually ask our employers. We have six, seven different entities and people asking employers for different things, and we need to have a more efficient approach there. Our design principles around our recommendations were being person-centric, not program-centric. We want to do what's best for people, not what's best for the programs and the government systems that are designed to try to help the folks. We have a work-first approach. We really want to ensure that employment and training discussions occur before eligibility for programs because that is the way that we really meet people and try to figure out what their needs are. We want statewide consistency with regional flexibility. I've mentioned in these meetings before a franchise model. If you think about the way a franchise operates, that's what we're recommending here, that when you walk into or engage with this new system, that you have a top-of-mind experience that you can expect, whether you're a worker or an employer. But yet we also realize that in rural areas of the state versus urban areas, et cetera, that things may be slightly different, so we need to promote the appropriate regional flexibility as well as initiatives in those areas. We want to be results-based and publicly accountable. We want to have transparent outcomes. Frankly, we want to give you as a legislature the ability to track over the next year or two the progress that's being made on this and to have transparency to the public through the legislative process as well. And we realize that bold action requires difficult decisions, which must be made with the best information and data. So here are our recommendations. They really come in three different buckets. And so the foundational change is an organizational shift. Now, one of the design principles we were told early on is there was not an appetite for creating a, quote, unquote, new cabinet level agency. So what we've really done under that foundation is look at what are the relative strengths of the different current state government organizations and how do we reorient the work and build upon those strengths in order to create a system and not have a program-by-program approach. So the Office of Workforce Solutions, which sits in the Department of Commerce, will be the workforce agency and front door for individuals. This is where the employment plan, up front case management, workforce programs, the newly redefined and integrated Arkansas workforce centers, which some may be current human services locations potentially or other locations, but now they will be Arkansas workforce centers and the up front employer relationship. The current Department of Human Services will use the ARI system, which is really a strong eligibility system, and again, eligibility will come second, and we'll talk about that here in a second, but human services will be the centralized eligibility authority, and ARIES will remain the system of record for individuals. So again, we're trying to integrate case management, integrate eligibility in the appropriate places, and then the Department of Shared Administrative Services will be the integration and sort of the, I'll call it the entrepreneurial or innovation layer. They're the ones that own Civiform, Launch, the Hope Hub platform. They will have the data, and they will essentially build the tools that will help the Office of Workforce Solutions in particular be able to do common intake and case management. So our first recommendation under administrative structure, and again, we have three buckets, administrative structure, service delivery integration, and financial integration. So what we're doing here is we're not creating a new cabinet level agency, but what we're establishing is the Office of Workforce Solutions would be the single state workforce agency. And we're recommending consolidating all federal and state employment training and re-employment programs under them as an administrative authority. We want to codify state workforce governance and statute, including the State Workforce Development Board carrying out local workforce board functions. We can talk about this a little bit more, but essentially the Office of Workforce Solutions has received federal waivers that will allow them to be able to better manage and have a consistent customer experience across the state. And it will allow these programs to work more closely together and have a single approach to working with people. We believe that the legislature ought to codify this and show that this is the way forward. We want you to confirm DA, and we're recommending that you confirm human services as the statewide integrated eligibility authority and that ARIES is the integrated eligibility system. We also believe that there should be a statutory requirement that employment and training planning occur before eligibility for work capable individuals now for individuals who are not necessarily work capable so for instance if you are applying for Medicaid only as an example because you need health care access then that would be not done this way you would essentially go through the Medicaid eligibility process separately if work is not what you're applying for we want to assign responsibility for common intake, shared case management, job matching, integrated data to shared services. Establish a transition structure with an effective date of July 1st, 2027, including a transition office, work groups, and defined reporting milestones to you as the Arkansas legislature. That will promote transparency. And we do believe that we should try to align appropriations to this new structure as i mentioned the waivers there were six waivers in particular that office of workforce solutions received and in their waiver package they did an estimate that there could be upwards of six million dollars in savings as a result of a new administrative structure that provides more consistent access and services to people across the state. These waivers expire June 30th, 2028. They can be renewed. The way it works is that at that time, the U.S. Department of Labor will ask Arkansas to submit a new four-year WIOA state plan, and at that time, Arkansas can also seek to extend the waivers, but we believe it's an important signal for you as a state legislature to codify this in-state statute. Can you take a break for just a
second? We've got a couple of people that want to ask some questions. We do have some people that are new here, and so if you could go over and explain to us what did we find in the audit and why did we want to do a single workforce board and why did we seek those waivers, which we've already got now? But what was the need for that? And then I'm going to take a
couple of questions from colleagues before we move on. Okay. So I'll try not to get too complicated here, but essentially the way it works in federal statute under the Workforce Innovation Opportunity Act, under Title I of that act, it defines what's called the one-stop system in states. And it basically says that Congress identified 16 different federal programs that should all come together in a one-stop system in the states. The problem is what the law also did is there are three programs, Workforce Innovation Opportunity Act, Adult, Dislocated Worker, and Youth. Those three programs, and only those three programs, go from the federal government down to the state, and the majority of those dollars go down to, quote-unquote, local workforce boards, local workforce areas managed by local workforce development boards. The other partner programs are identified, unemployment insurance, the Wagner-Pizer Employment Services Program, Vocational Rehabilitation, Temporary Assistance for Needy Families, all these other programs, those dollars do not go down to the local level. They're maintained and deployed at the state level by state employees. So what's essentially occurred is this really dysfunctional arrangement where these local boards with a very, very small portion of the dollars are supposed to create the integrated service delivery structure with all the other programs being operationalized by state and state employees. And so it's a completely dysfunctional mess. And it has been, not only in Arkansas, but in almost every other state. What these waivers do, essentially, is allows the state board to subsume what are defined as local workforce board functions under WIOA and says, okay, state, we're going to allow you now to basically serve as a single state area for all intents and purposes in order to deliver services. So the state can serve as the fiscal agent. The state can serve as the operator of these programs. and the dollars have to still be dedicated to the local area. We owe a Title I dollar still have to be dedicated for services in the local area so that your area, the local area will not lose Title I money. But now we're able to basically, for all intents and purposes, kind of blend all of that in order to then have a consistent one-stop system across the state versus a few dollars going down to these 10 areas and then state running everything else, and then trying to, again, put it all together. So that's kind of as short a version as I can give you for why these waivers are critically important. Thank you. Just one quick thing. Tell us the audit number. What was
the finding of the money that we found, the $15 million that came to the state? How much was actually used to train individuals? I think it's really keyly important that we hear that for those that are new here. Right.
So the report that was issued in January that I was a part of, the Alliance for Opportunity, issued showed that of the 14 to 15 million only about a million of it was being used for training is that what you're asking representative about a million that was being used for training and a lot of that money was being carried over from year to year essentially the short story is and again this is not just arkansas it's just about every other state the wioa title one dollars basically the amount going down to the local areas is enough to pay the staff pay the leases and keep the doors and the lights on and not enough to really serve people with training and the employment services they need because again it's a silo it's a silo approach so what happens is each of these programs has its own delivery its own staffing including title one which is now local and everybody else is here at the state level kind of running their own thing doing their own thing. Again I've mentioned this before but for those of you who are new I come from Utah where in 1996 and 1997 before essentially a prohibition was put into law in 1998 for this approach we did not since 1997 Utah has not had local boards. The state runs quote-unquote the employment centers across the entire state and so no matter what rural town no matter what urban location I go to I have a consistent set of services I can expect and the employees who you meet in those offices do not see themselves like they do in Arkansas as I'm a WIOA worker I'm a Wagner-Pizer employment service worker I'm a TANF worker they don't know what program funds them because they're there to help people and all of the funding for them is blended behind the scenes which are some of the recommendations we still need to talk
right want to start representative Brown you're on just come on okay thank you thank you very much appreciate this report I just had a quick question back under the category of goals I guess it was it's on page seven of the handout that we received they said the advisory groups deliberations to also produced a set of design principles that shape the recommendations and the first one there is person centric not program centric the system should be organized around around what an individual needs, not around which funding stream a worker happens to be paid from. Well, I think you might have just answered that, but I wanted to get some
clarity on that. Yes. Yeah, what happens now, essentially, is that depending on what door I walk through typically depends on what my experience is going to be. So, for instance, one of the things we've showed is in the state of Arkansas, The only office that is physically present in every county in Arkansas is a human services office. So for some of your most vulnerable rural population, poorest people, their only option we're giving them is go apply for public benefits. They don't even get access to the workforce. They don't even get approached or asked about it. And so that's what happens. And so you have Arkansas workforce centers in certain parts of the state. You have community colleges in certain parts of the state. So you have these different doors that people can go through, and often depending on what door you go through locks you into what approach or what services you're going to receive. And so to tell you the truth, in many cases for people, unfortunately, it's luck of the draw on where did I enter first, depending on what my experience is going to be. Now further, not only is that a silo sort of fragmented approach, but then your experience within programs can be different. So I have Arkansas workforce centers that are WIOA Title I funded, and I may go to Pine Bluff, and my experience may be completely different than what it is at Little Rock. So there's not even within the programs a consistent approach to providing services to people. So, again, if you think about – I always think about it from a franchise. If I went, if McDonald's operated this way, if I went to a McDonald's down the street here, I may get offered a burger. They may not even have French fries at that particular location, so I can't even get them. But if I go, you know, three miles away, there may be French fries but no burgers or no Big Macs available. And that's really what we see
key part of that standard operating procedure is when you walk through that door, somebody meets you and talks to you about your situation and what is your employment goal. They may be in crisis, so there may be some immediate crisis intervention, but it's about the long-term plan of what are you trying to do with your life, and then let's figure out which of the programs and which, not just programs, but really services. The issue is what services do we want people to access regardless of what program is funding that service? And what service is it that's going to help people be upwardly mobile versus locked into I'm stuck on a financial assistance program and those sorts of things and nobody's helping me off of that or
transitioning off of that? I know that the various programs have to do reporting, so if you've got the money blended, is that going to complicate the reporting process, or are we going to change the reporting process? I mean, what's going to happen with all
that? That's a great question. So, yes. The challenge is, obviously, each federal program has slightly different reporting requirements, And this is really where the Shared Services Center can be very helpful and come in, which is how do we look across the different reporting structures and how do we look across the different definitions within those reporting structures and in what way do we have now an integrated set of data that then we can much more easily do our reporting, see what items are in common across reports. So an example that the state's working on right now, for instance, is the Perkins program that goes to education and WIOA. And how do you have common set of metrics? And I know the federal government, actually Department of Education, Department of Labor at the federal level are looking at this too. How do we make Perkins and WIOA reporting more consistent because those are kind of similar programs and similar goals in those programs? And so part of this will be to look at how do we have more integrated reporting. And again, this is where the shared services center approach, think becomes really helpful because they can kind of bring all this together and figure out what's the best way to report to the different federal entities. Thank you. Thank
you. Senator Petty. Thank you, Madam Chair. So, and you may be going to cover this in your report. If so, just tell me to be patient. But some of the conversations that we have around these local workforce boards is how can we ensure that the local voice which is you know feet on the ground locally and and ear to the ground locally doesn't get lost in some you know bureaucratic board at the state capitol uh and and eventually get lost to some uh statewide board as opposed to the local boards who are uh supposedly more in tune with the local uh needs yes yeah so i can mention that i'll
talk about that in two ways number one is if you look at the local boards right now really they're local boards over the wioa title one programs and again i'll tell you what we did in utah and then this is one of the things that could be discussed in the arkansas earns legislation um in utah what we did is instead of having boards as creatures of the federal government, we created advisory boards in state statute. So they were creatures now of the state, not of the federal government. The advantage to that was, ironically, is that then you have boards that have a voice, not just over a particular funding stream, which is what the local boards essentially are now, but now you have boards that are looking at the totality of the entire picture. They're looking at all of the programs and services that are coming to that area and then having input into what does that look like for the totality of our region. And so one of the options that the legislature could consider is do we want a similar kind of advisory board structure as part of the Office of Workforce Solutions? And so that's one way to ensure you have local voice. As I mentioned, too, that even with the waivers, the local areas will still have their quote-unquote Title I allotments, so it's not like the state will be able to shift money away from the area you may be concerned about and send it over to Little Rock or something like that. So those dollars will still have to be expended for the benefit of people in those communities. But in terms of the board piece, that's really some options that I would recommend is looking at, you know, do we want to have some kind of state structure under the Office of Workforce Solutions, working obviously with the Department of Commerce on what that might look like in state statute, just to provide an advisory voice up to the state board and to the state officials. Okay, Representative Crawford. Thank
you, Madam Chair. Thank you for being here. I hope you weren't stuck in an airport. No, I actually had a great flight. Thank you. You may have said this, but if so, I missed it. Okay. When we do away with the local boards, logistically, how will that work? We will have one brick-and-mortar place where all the people go in, or
we will still have different doors for people to go in? No, actually, there will be different doors. So don't think local board is like a corporate board for a corporation. The local board is supposed to just provide oversight over the quote-unquote local workforce system or local workforce area. It doesn't actually provide the services. The local board itself doesn't. So what we're recommending here is that we look at the totality of the footprint of all these different programs, including human services, what's currently Arkansas Workforce Centers, the community colleges, frankly, And where do people access services and then have a discussion about what does our physical footprint and how do we bring programs together? So whether I walk through what's now a human services door or an Arkansas Workforce Center door, a community college door, I'm walking into a consolidated or an integrated workforce system door. That's what we're trying to do. So the local boards don't necessarily impact what the service delivery or what the doors look like or what even the
of employees, just boards. No, that's correct. My understanding, yes, that will be the employee piece of this is not part of our recommendations, but my understanding is that that's what the legislature working with the executive branch can figure out is what does that look like for people who are currently employed by a local workforce area.
you, Madam Chair, and thank you again for being here. I wanted to go back to this idea of kind of putting the workforce placement first. Could you explain to me what kind of safeguards you envision? I'm concerned that when you talk about a large percentage of recipients were all you know being of the right age to be in the workforce that we're discounting those recipients who may be disabled may be caring for a disabled family member may you know may have children at home and no access to child care and I'm concerned that doing this this first we're going to look about and see what kinds of jobs you may be qualified for or what types of training you may be qualified for, we're going to delay access to benefits that may be necessary to keep their kids from going hungry to ensure that they have care. So how are you envisioning that this will not become another barrier, another administrative burden on families that are already
struggling? Yeah, that's a great question. So number one is, and I've pulled in the slide, the different programs that we're looking to be consolidating in Office of Workforce Solutions include the child care assistance that goes to parents. It includes employment and training services through the SNAP program. It includes the work portion of the TANF program. So the good news is now, I think, where under this scenario, again, and we're modeling this after successful practices we're seeing in other states like Utah and now even Louisiana who's implementing this, which is I don't want to come across that, hey, I have to sit here and go through a bureaucratic employment and training process before I can even talk about what assistance I get. It actually can happen very quickly. But the issue is that we talk to you exactly and find out what is that situation right now. If the situation is that, hey, I have a disabled child at home, I need services for that disabled child, you'll be immediately referred to the appropriate person to be able to discuss that. So essentially, think of it as a triage, up front triage, where as part of that triage, we're sort of an upward mobility first triage system versus eligibility, what program can we get you on triage. That's kind of the difference. So, again, everybody's circumstances, as you've mentioned, can be clearly different and varied. But what we're trying to do, again, is have a consistent triage, too, no matter where you go, I get access. Because right now what you have is people, let's say I have that disabled child, I have to figure out, wait, do I go to an Arkansas workforce? No, sorry, wrong place. Do I go over to voc rehab? Oh, that may have been the wrong place. Oh, no, I've got to go into a human. So what we're trying to do is create this consistent triage across the state so we get people to
the right place immediately as well. How long do you envision that process taking? And, for example, say I'm a mom in a rural area and I've got maybe I'm a single mom or I've got a disabled child. But in any case, I don't have access to child care. There are no child care providers in the area. How long is this assessment going to take? I mean, am I going to be referred to someone else who's also going to assess me? And also, I mean, who determines whether or not my need is enough to qualify for benefits? And
is there an appeal process for that? So again, we're trying to have an integrated case management approach and an integrated eligibility approach. So the goal of both of those is I only have to tell my story one time. Again, right now is I'm having to tell my story three and four and five times to get to the services you're talking about potentially. So what you do is you have that upfront sort of assignment to a case, the appropriate caseworker. You have that integrated eligibility screen that then gets you to the right partner, both on the public side, but also part of this, let's not forget, is we're talking about integrating in even the 1033 and community-based providers, et cetera, to try to have a network of public-slash-community providers, depending on what services people need, that then have that integrated case management, that integrated eligibility component to it. In terms of, you know, how long is this going to, I'm not sure if you mean how long is the transition to this vision or how long is it going to take to
get services? Sorry, I was traveling this weekend, too, and it was not nearly as nice as your experience, so I'm probably not being clear. How long would it take? I mean, are we talking about a process that's going to take longer and require that same mom that I used as an example to jump through a lot more hurdles or wait longer in order to access benefits? Or are we talking about something that will be faster?
It will be something that should be faster because, again, instead of having to figure out where do I go for this and get handed off, And a lot of times I will call it soft handoffs, where I may get a referral to some, I may come in one door, get a referral, and then that's one of the issues we've found through these different studies is nobody often follows up on these referrals. I may refer you, representative, to Cameron over here who's going to help you with child care, and then I'm like, okay, done, and I don't know if you ever made that connection to Cameron or not. So the goal here is that we have, again, an integrated case management process that shows what services does that person need, who did they get referred to. We follow up on those referrals. We make sure they get the help they need, and we don't have them jump through a bunch of hoops. I think the evidence is pretty clear that it streamlines the process. Now, for an issue such as a rural area that may not have a child care provider, that's a little bit of a nuanced and different issue. This doesn't really address something like the number of child care providers we have in the state. What it does do, though, is it better understands what child care providers we have and who do I need to, and it utilizes child care in a way that supports that work goal for those individuals who are trying to get back in the workforce. Did you want to say, yeah, go ahead, Cameron. Thank you. Representative
sure, Cameron, go ahead, Cameron. - Thank you, I just wanted to go ahead and make a quick point here as well. You said something about changing their eligibility or whether or not it would be eligible. What's really important is that we're working on integrating things that exist. Eligibility exists for these programs at the federal level because they're federal programs. So we are not in any way impacting an eligibility finding. That's still determined by the federal program. We're just trying to, nor are we trying to change existence of programs at the state or the federal level this is really just working to integrate the existing resources and services that we have so that way people can find what they're eligible for more easily and access it
more quickly so Cameron on that note let's go even a little bit deeper currently it's very difficult a woman like Mason was saying we get a soft hand up right now we have to go four or five different doors and we're trying to eliminate this and make it much more person-centric and not not case Managers of programs but case managers of people so people actually get the help they need that's correct. Okay, great. Thanks All right, representative
and it we are up Thank you. I'm gonna have a question. Um, you mentioned voc rehab earlier I see this mentioned on page 11 But it doesn't say anything about the services or staff or the agency how it would change under What you're proposing can you elaborate on that?
Yes? Yes. Well, the good news is vocation rehabilitation is already part of the Office of Workforce Solutions. So the vocation rehabilitation program doesn't get moved or anything at this point. And so a lot of that will be continuing on the improvements in the work that the Office of Workforce Solutions is already doing. And voc rehab is already, unlike a lot of other states, actually already integrated more fully into the workforce stream, so to speak. so that's why we don't spend a lot of time on it because it's
a follow-up. So some of that WIOA, WIOA? WIOA, W-I-O-A. So, and I think I might have asked this in another meeting, is some of that money dedicated towards
the workforce for rehab, voc rehab? So, yeah, so there's different titles of WIOA, And Title IV is the Vocational Rehabilitation Program. So you have the Rehabilitation Act of 1973, and that was incorporated into WIOA Title IV. So that's the connection. And then voc rehab is, the law identifies what are called six core programs. It's the three Title I, adult, discay, worker, youth. It's Wagner-Peyser Employment Service, adult education literacy, which is Title II of WIOA, and voc rehabilitation, which is Title IV. So those are the six core programs under WIOA. Thank you.
Thank you. Representative Garner. Madam Chair. Thank you all for being here. Hi again. Most of my questions I think you answered with Representative Hudson, but I do want to know how we're going to integrate child care when the funding is coming now to education and not to DHS. Who is responsible for pulling that information in and making sure that CCDF funds are where they need to be? - Yes,
great question. What we're recommending is that the Department of Education continue to administer the CCDF on behalf of the state of Arkansas and that it, that providers, et cetera, they'll still have that. What we're recommending is the portion of the CCDF that's used to help working parents, that that portion be moved through the appropriations process to the Office of Workforce Solutions to provide those services for. And we also think that this helps focus those portion of the CCDF on ensuring that it is assisting working parents and that they're able to better get access to those services so that they can actually enter the workforce hopefully again be upwardly mobile and have careers and yeah go ahead Cameron has we also have
some specific recommendations broken out about the CCDF near the bottom of page 11 of the report and so because the CCDF doesn't a number of different things one of the things we're recommending is that the Office of Workforce Services take responsibility for operating the child care participant enrollment while DHS is still responsible for determining eligibility because again that would be part of their eligibility authority however the Department of Education would maintain the child care provider provider eligibility determination right so it's the recipient eligibility falls within the Aries and the individual database but the provider eligibility still stays with
you. I'll check that out. Thank you. Thank you, Senator Irvin. Thank you. Have you walked through the system, the software system that Division of Workforce Services has? Have
system they use that they currently have i've been over to division of workforce services and have you looked at their technology system that they use for exactly what we're talking about have you walked through that system with them i mean we've the case management the intake system i mean we've yes so i have
not personally sat down at a computer and gone through it with them but we have been working with robert McGoo with shared services as well as Cody and others around what systems do they currently have and what are they migrating to and the sort of the the Arkansas launch is what they're migrating toward now and away from I believe their current system which I don't off the top of my head know what the name of it
is okay so so but I guess my question though is you're trying to figure out a way to integrate all of the current existing technology software intake systems into one correct that's correct and that's actually being worked on now by shared services right and then and then training so that's that would be step one so i'm looking at i think what would be really helpful i love your presentation thank you lots of good information but sometimes i think it helps us wrap our heads around this if we can actually see like who who has what and where it's going to go in in a in a picture graph so to speak okay with current existing software systems and where they're housed and then where where they're going to go to okay i think that would be helpful for the legislature to see and then the second i also think it would be really helpful uh the funding the waivers understanding that and where that is in a in a way that we can look at it and say okay we're going to they're still going to be in charge but we're going to do overall training for these specific areas and entities and then a map of where those entities exist so what I love I mean I do I do see that you want to utilize the college the two-year colleges and you've identified those I think it'd be really helpful for the legislature to see where those are on the map in the state of Arkansas where current we all know that each county has a DHS office physically where it's you know in that county I know there's more than one in certain counties and then workforce centers and where those located and then college career college career colleges that are located in this area I think a map of that would be really really nice to be able to see and then to say we're trying to train everybody to where we're all working in unison or how I mean I think I hear you and I understand the goal I appreciate the goal I went and worked through with DWS and looked at their software system and and the case management software system that they have and they were trying to get there I felt like but they were just kind of all on their own what you're saying is really bringing in DHS, Department of Ed, and everybody else, braid the funding, but making sure that we have a good system that can do a soft handover for all of that. So just something I think would be helpful to see, and I think it would help make sense, I guess, more so. Okay. So let me mention a couple things,
Senator Urban. on the map of the locations we actually had a map in our january report okay so we can pull that for you and make sure you have that in terms of the software and all that my recommendation was let us work with shared services and with robert and see i think he probably already has some documentation that you're like you're asking and let me see what he has and uh we can provide that to the committee and to all of and get that out to
all of you yeah because we'll follow up with robert on that yeah i think it would be helpful to see what is currently happening and how that's being worked and then where the holes are where the gaps are that need to be filled in to kind of complete the idea complete the project um and to see timeline of implementation just organizing the project in such a way that this is identified as what's already existing what's already being worked towards and where the holes are that we need to fill in the gaps. I personally think that that would be helpful. - Absolutely, I think we can do that
for you. - Okay, thank you. - We'll work on that for you. And if, by the way, Representative Bentley knows this, if we provide you with something, you say that's not exactly what I want or that's not enough, just let us know and we'll get it until you get what's helpful, so yeah. - Thank you. Representative Brown.
Thank you, Madam Chair. I'm going to try to phrase this as a question so that I am within the guidelines here. But what I want to say is I tend to get off in the weeds with things. That's how my brain works. And so I've sort of been following a family. A constituent reached out to me a couple years ago and I've sort of gotten to where I'm tracking and assisting where I can but what I've noticed is a lot of times these with this family and probably with many others they're trying to pull their lives together they don't have they may not have transportation they may not have money for running here there and everywhere and I want to say that i truly support the concept of this program i don't know how we work out all the details that's not my job but um you know when somebody has to go go here to go get a birth certificate and run there to get a social security card and run here and run there and oh you should have done this by such and such a date they don't have the ability to do that so it would be really nice if we could pull this stuff together under one roof or you know if we tell people you've got to go here there and everywhere maybe provide that transportation to get to some of these locations i don't want to go overboard with this but um you know it's just insane what that hoops i see people jumping through, trying to take care of basic needs and to comply, the acrobatics they go through to comply with all the different requirements. So wouldn't you agree? Yes. Well,
I'll take it a slight step forward. I think it's a total shame that we ask the most vulnerable people in our society to have to do this to improve their lives. Um, and so that's why I'm so passionate about this particular issue. And, um, I feel very blessed that I had an opportunity early in my career to participate in what we did in Utah in the 1990s that you've all heard about. And all I can tell you is that every single person that I know that has actually gone out to Utah to see how it works comes back to me and says, Mason, you haven't advocated hard enough for this because they see the contrast in the way it's being done in their states versus the way it could be done and what a best practice looks like. And so I 100% believe, and let me also state, this is not about making quote unquote eligibility easier so we can get more people on public assistance and sitting on the government. That is not what this is about. This is about how do you more efficiently and effectively connect people to the services that they need in order to address what you're talking about with that family, what they need in order to improve their lives. And the way, you know, there's really sort of one way that individuals get out of poverty, and that is they need to find a way to earn more money. The way you earn more money is you provide skills and education and the supports around those services so that people then have the skills, competencies, and ability to perform well in jobs. And I would say, I use the word careers very intentionally too, because I don't think this is just about, let's have a, find a person, a job, and then again, sort of say, well, Good job. We did our thing. We're done. But how do we help people, no matter where they are, improve on their life circumstances through upward mobility, which means not just a job, but how do I have a career? How do I move? How do I do something that I enjoy doing and passionate about and that can help earn enough money that I can be self-sufficient, my family can be self-sufficient? So that's my personal morals and goals around this and why I feel so strongly about advocating for this with all of you. And I 100% believe that if the legislature moves forward on the recommendations that we're giving you, that you will come back in two and three years and say, we're really glad we did that, because you will see a difference in the lives of your constituents.
Okay. Representative Ray. Thank you, Madam Chair. So similar to Senator Irvin's question about a map, I flipped through the materials here. I'm looking for, do you guys have any sort of org chart that shows where all of these functions currently fall versus how you would propose arranging them in the future.
I think, Representative Bentley and Senator English, I think maybe one of the things we should do is provide a copy of the January report again to everybody because that is in the January report as well. So the reason we don't contain a lot of these visuals in this report is because we were sort of trying to build off the report that was issued in January, which you will see in that report we had kind of a current state as well as a potential future state org charts around this. So it does, that addresses that.
here. Is that where we ended? Yeah, okay. um i'm just gonna we'll start we'll go back to sort of our transition dates we're recommending the report um the waivers were approved in august we are recommending an effective date for this of july 127 with a transition um office um that again in in program year 2026 they'll have to report on the waivers and that june 30th of 2028 is when the waivers expire so that's just some of the transition date so we'll move into recommendation two which is I think in many cases the most important part of this discussion which is integrated service delivery again we want to help the state of Arkansas create I'll call it a franchise model of service delivery where no matter where I am in the state I can have it a consistent expectation so what we want to try to do is have consistent service delivery across the state while allowing for regional innovation tailoring we've already talked about trying to consolidate physical and virtual infrastructure I've already mentioned the footprint of the different offices and again we've already just spent a bunch of time also talking about a single workforce intake process for work capable customers regardless of which door they entered that they can have an academic and career development plan that is a shared case record they tell their story one time everybody who needs to has access to that case management system no matter which agency you work in. And let me give you an example about shared case management. Another constituent group is veterans. So there are different work type employment services provided by Veterans Affairs and those sorts of organizations, too, at the state and community levels. So if an individual comes to a workforce center and they're a veteran, then that would then trigger the ability of different veterans specific services and people within the case management world to be able to see that one case. And so the veteran wouldn't have to go to a work center, go to a veteran center, go somewhere else to be able to tell their story three or four times and get the services that individual may get. So that's another kind of constituent example around that. We've already mentioned consolidating the eligibility functions into DHS and, again, having integrated eligibility. One interesting thing that's occurred through the advisory group is once we started having conversations about the capability of the ARIES eligibility system, it immediately triggered some new thoughts around, oh, we could have our WIOA programs in ARIES eligibility, et cetera, and we're not doing things separately. Again, that gets to some of Senator Irvin's mapping question. The integrated case management on a shared platform and then separating that from eligibility determination. Establishing a regional point of contact for employers. That's another thing that OWS is already starting to work on is how do we ensure that employers have a single point of contact or at least how do we bring the different services to employers in a more meaningful way so that we're not calling them with six different people reaching out. And again, this gets to the question around performance reporting, having a common performance and accountability framework built on outcomes rather than inputs and a defined reporting relationship to the legislature for appropriate oversight. Just as an example right now in terms of ready-made integration, Six counties have been identified that have co-location opportunities for DHS and workforce connections. They're already having conversations around that. There are 26 Arkansas workforce centers statewide and nine mobile workforce centers. And then currently the TANF grant is paying for the Career Pathways Program, which is a relationship between DHS and the community colleges. We're recommending that that relationship be OWS with the community colleges. And those career pathway campuses are at 22 community colleges and two universities. And then under financial management, there is a potential opportunity that Arkansas could request a statewide cost allocation model. Now, this gets really into the weeds, but this is in many ways the secret sauce behind all of this. Because right now, again, in terms of inefficiency, the way it's happening is you've got each local workforce area trying to negotiate each year its own cost allocation model and infrastructure funding agreement. And so that looks different. I've always said I think we spend more time negotiating MOUs and cost arrangements than we do serving people. I think if you almost looked at people's time, it almost literally is probably that. What we're saying now is, no, we bring that to the state level and have a single cost allocation model. And this is the secret that allows people to see themselves as service providers versus program representatives. In the absence of an approved cost-wide state allocation model, we do believe that try to bring that negotiation to the state level. This is where the state board acting on behalf of the local boards can do this, working with the different programs, and that we braid those federal funds to the extent permitted and then seek federal waivers where available. I already mentioned the MOU and infrastructure. We get rid of that whole negotiation process at the local level and work on a state consistent basis. And then we also are recommending inclusion in the federal benefits cliff pilot and approval of an alternative cost allocation model. There's a benefits cliff pilot being discussed and worked on potentially. And then, again, we recommend that any of these administrative savings, they be dedicated to direct participant services. And again, one of the shames of this, I think getting back to the earlier comments and the earlier question is, is that these built-in inefficiencies are what keep people from getting access to the skills development and training they need to be economically viable through work and careers. And so we really want to ensure that the supportive services for child care, transportation, and those sorts of things help people get into the labor force and don't keep people from entering the labor force. We already have currently sort of three cost allocation systems or methodologies in the state, each working independently, and what we're recommending across these programs is that we have one statewide model. So that is the overview of our recommendations. Again, we have a bunch of slides that have more specific details. Those are contained within the report that I believe you all have. So if we need to go to any of those slides or you want to talk further or have questions, I can do that. But this is the overview of our recommendations.
Senator English, did you want to say? So I guess I'm thinking to myself as we're having this big discussion that right now the state is looking at work requirements for Medicaid and for SNAP and identifying those people who are not in the system right now or are not working. So from my standpoint, this looks to me like the opportunity for us to help people move forward in their lives. It's not enough just to say you don't have a job. It's how are we going to help them to be able to move forward with a job, with a career, and have that kind of a system, which we don't have right now. Right now we just say people have to have a job. But we need to have a system so that people can have an opportunity to take advantage of some of the many things that we've got going on here in the state for employment and training and education. Lots and lots of things that people have never had an
Senator English, can I mention something? One thing, and I believe I mentioned this at our last meeting, is that for those of you who are tracking the work requirements issue, I always like to remind people that work requirements are not an outcome. They're an output. It tells me what is somebody doing in order to receive a particular benefit. So if I fall under the Medicaid work requirement, it means in order to receive that Medicaid benefit, I have to do certain activities. It doesn't tell you, it's not an outcome. It doesn't tell you that, hey, that person got employment and got a level of earnings where they may not need Medicaid anymore. And so I always want to say that one of my frustrations with the whole work requirements issue is it's sort of a narrow, focused kind of look at what is happening with that individual in their life. And so part of what we're trying to do here, to Senator English's point, is create a systems approach where, yes, you may be subject to that work requirement, but we're not going to just end there and say, oh, you met the work requirement. We're going to work with you to see what can we do and what supports and activities can you get so that maybe you get employer-sponsored health insurance and don't need Medicaid anymore, or you don't need food assistance because you're now earning enough money that you were able to transition off of that SNAP benefit. So I think it's important to distinguish the notion of work requirements versus outcomes and people having a better life as a result of the services they received.
Thanks, Mason. I think to reiterate that myself, we have so much hit and miss across the state depending on where people live. I think the most thing I'm excited about is that no matter where our constituents live across the state, we're going to have the same opportunities, the same ability for them to get connected with the great things that are happening, which most people have no idea about you know i know even where i live in perry county few few know what's going on up the road tomorrow to one of the two-year college their abilities they could really make a much better living but they don't know and they're not connected and there's uh this will give an ability for all of our constituents across the state to know what's going on and to be connected in an efficient manner in the 21st century on an online platform that's going to be
so much better representative garner thank you thank you madam chair um i've just got a quick question about logistics in the discussions either in stakeholder group or in here and maybe this is for for DHS but have we talked about the fiscal impact what's what is going to cost and also more even than money just that the time and personnel with everything that's going on in but DHS right now with Medicaid and snap and all that is this is this something we can do at the same time or is it something that we need extra personnel for or have those discussions been yeah I probably can't
speak I wouldn't want to speak for the executive branch obviously but one of the things we really tried to no that's a great question because one of the things we really tried to do through the advisory group process is work collaboratively with the executive branch to say you know how can we sort of stretch here and be bold but at the same time be realistic about what can get done I think the good news about our recommendations is a number of these are already being worked on currently when we talked about some of the systems issues and such some of those things are already underway in terms of the dhs portion of it yes they're having to work on some of those things but we talked about those things in the context of doing this meaningful reform as well and so So my guess is, and our goal was that there would not be a negative fiscal impact to this. In fact, I think over time you'd see cost savings, actually. Yeah, over time. Yeah. So, again, not speaking for the executive branch, what we tried to do as consultants is work with the executive branch through the advisory group process to have something that could transition and be done. So, for instance, the waivers have already been received. Cody and his office, it's already working. Cody and Eddie and those folks are already working on implementation of these things already. And so I think that this legislation really helps bolster their ability to continue to work on the things they want to work on anyway and gives them license to say, yes, let's be bold and kind of move to that next level as we work together. Great. Thank you. I just wanted to
oh okay you're fine no problem okay with that we're at this point we have any motions from any of our committee members on this report that we've just received from okay represent a bit another report we second all right we have a motion to approve and a second on that all those in favor of accepting this report from our consolidation group here consultant group here i any nays all right thank you all so much i am excited we are continuing to work on legislation that you all will be seeing soon to be a part of so please reach out to myself or senator ervin if you and senator english if you have any concerns or questions, things that you want answered, Mason and Cameron are very available to us to answer any questions that we may have. So please reach out to me or to staff if any questions you may have, concerns as we work through this, and we'll have some legislation ready for you guys to see soon. And with that, we're adjourned. Thank you.
B. Update on Reimbursement Rates Under the Living Choices Assisted Living Waiver Pursuant to Act 213 of 2022, Section 15 [Exhibits B1-B4]
5:32 - 6:313 segments2 speakers
Speaker 32 presented two monthly letters summarizing the assisted-living waiver cost report and explained that the department has examined several options-maintaining the current reimbursement rate or applying modest increases-which are still pending executive review.
[5:43]
Representative Mary Bentley invited questions, received none, thanked the presenters, and indicated that DHS is expected to issue a recommendation on the rates within the next month.
[6:12]
C. Discussion of Arkansas EARNS Final Report and Potential Legislation [Exhibit C-C2]
6:31 - 1:13:50177 segments19 speakers1 document
The consultant team, led by Speaker 41 (Mason), presented the final EARNS report and a suite of recommendations-including a July 1 2027 effective date, an integrated “franchise” service-delivery model with shared case management, a statewide cost-allocation framework, and inclusion in the federal benefits-cliff pilot to streamline eligibility, improve career pathways, and reduce administrative waste.
[55:32][56:12][56:48][57:29][59:41][1:00:14][1:00:45][1:01:19][1:01:53][1:02:26][1:02:59][1:03:34][1:04:09][1:04:40][1:05:10][1:05:45]
Committee members raised implementation questions: Rep. David Ray asked for the January report’s org-chart visuals to compare current versus proposed structures, and Rep. Denise Garner queried the fiscal and staffing impacts; Speaker 41 responded that many recommendations are already underway, waivers are in place, and the reforms are expected to be cost-neutral or generate savings over time.
[58:16][58:34][59:05][1:10:16][1:10:40][1:10:55][1:11:12][1:11:43][1:12:18]
A motion to adopt the consultant-group report was made, seconded, and carried unanimously, with Rep. Mary Bentley noting that legislation based on the report will be forthcoming.
[1:12:55][1:13:29]