House Public Health, Welfare And Labor Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (15)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
SB1010
· 6 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB1010”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1384
· 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1384”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1968
· 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1968”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB1039
· 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB1039”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1190
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1190”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1871
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “Ward. Okay. 1482, members. And then next we'll do House Bill 1871, and then we're going to concur on amendments, and then I t…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB2210
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB2210”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB1171
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…u passed your bill. Thank you. All right. Senator Caldwell, SB 1171.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB442
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB442”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB916
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB916”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1182
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…mmittee and Mr. Chairman. All right. Now we've got Wardlaw, House Bill 1182.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1183
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1183”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1482
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1482”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB850
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB850”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB888
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB888”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 16, 2026
Crisscross applesauce. Yeah. All right. I'll let everybody get settled and settled in. I know there's going to be members coming in and out. Now, as always, we've got about 20 people here that all have non-controversial bills that they want to run first. And to the extent that that's possible, I'd like to do that because we do have here's the point. Here's the game plan. I would like to do as many bills as we can, which I think that may be about six or seven, and I think most of them are non-controversial.
I'd like to get those out just because of time. You know, if something's non-controversial, I want to keep it going through the process so it can get the round-trip ticket and become a law if that's the desire of the legislature. Since we're in the last – almost at the end here, that's important. So I'm going to try to rattle through some of these non-controversial bills. If we get bogged down and somebody lied to me and told me something was not controversial, it is, we might give it a few minutes and then move on because we do have two. Here's the main, the big rocks for the day.
You've got two special orders, Representative Hammers, House Bill 1190, and then also SB 1010 by Senator Hutchinson. Those are the two special orders. We also have three what amount to unemployment bills in varying different ways. We'll heal those next. Lunch is already planning on being delivered. We'll work until 1.20. If we have to, I hope we can get it all done. So with that being said, that's kind of a game plan.
Some of these non-contro firsts. Hopefully we can get that done in about 15, 20 minutes. Move on to the two special orders. Then hit the unemployment stuff. And if we have to come back after session, we'll come back after session. But the hope is to be done by 1-20. Any questions from the committee? Representative Harris, I respect your assertiveness. I guess you're going first. Yeah. All right. Well, since you're there, we'll do it. Representative Harris, Senator Woods, you'll be recognized. You tell us the bill, please.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee members. This is Senate Bill 916. by Senator John Woods, and this is to ensure that vulnerable citizens receive medication for life-altering illnesses and to create the Continuity of Care Act of 2013. This amendment has been engrossed but has been shrunk to amend by various people. But what this bill basically does, and I have with me, and this has been endorsed by the
the Multiple Sclerosis Yes, the National Multiple Sclerosis Society and I have here with me Julie Cawthorn and so if she could just state her name. Yes, ma'am, if you'll say your name for the record you'll
quickly, my name is Julie Cawthorn I am from Little Rock and I chair the Government Relations Committee for the National MS Society Arkansas Chapter and I just want to briefly point out I live with MS as the beginning steps and
I just wanted to briefly point out really the guts of this bill and the importance of it and this would protect an insurance enrollee's prescription drug benefits by requiring written notice of changes to an enrollee's financial responsibility for a prescription drug and requiring this notification to occur 60 days prior to the increase in price becoming effective. Typically these types of medications are in the specialty tier levels and sadly we are
finding that people with MS, Parkinson's, AIDS, rheumatoid arthritis, etc., your disease modifying treatments can, the copay could be $200 and then within the life of the contract It could jump to $900, for instance. And this is just to protect the ability to continue our medications as ordered so that we can continue to live as productive life as possible.
Okay, thank you for your testimony, ma'am. Senator Woods, you have
Speaker 15
4:22
something to add? There's no opposition to this bill, and we've worked with all interested parties, and it's just a 60-day notification bill, basically, is what it is. Okay. So I appreciate your vote, and I'm closed.
All right. Thank you for the testimony. Representative Love, you're recognized for a motion. All right. Members, you've heard testimony of the bill. Any questions? Is there anybody in the audience that would like to speak for or against the bill? If not, Representative Love, you're recognized for a motion. Any discussion on the motion?
All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? One down. Thank you. Next, we're going to do Senator Irvin. this is Senate Bill 1039 members thank
you Mr. Chair and if Jody Ann Tritt is in the committee room
I'll have her come and speak on this bill with me Senate Bill 1039 is What it is is it creates an advisory committee and you can look through the bill and you can see who's listed on that advisory committee. What this is and the purpose that we came up with this is because any changes to the health payment improvement initiative and how that proceeds I think is extremely important and it's very, very important I think as we learned through the town hall meetings and
the different meetings that occurred all throughout the state, and I hosted really one of the first ones with Dr. Allison coming up and speaking to physicians all across the state, that it's important to have the input of those folks that are out working in the private sector as well as in all the areas of our state to have their input as we progress through that program, and so that's what this achieves, and it's important that long-term care is
also included only when those issues that deal with long-term care, then it will be a part of their perspective and purvey, and then on medical episodes of care or how those are directed, how those are put together, and also I think there may be, happen to be some retooling as we move and adjust, and that's appropriate, and what it does is it gives the legislature a level of comfort to know that there have been eyes from professionals that this deals with this every day in their practice and in their life and with their patients, that that input is collected and gathered and reported to the legislature.
And for me, I feel that this is a good tool to be used to gather that input so that we just have some more knowledge as we proceed down this path with this program. And I worked with a lot of different folks on this. And before I filed the bill, I handed it to Dr. Allison and looked at – so they were able to have their input on it, which I very much appreciated. And we worked together on this, and I'll let Jody Ann Tripp with the Hospital Association also discuss the bill. Thank you. If you'll say your name
for the record, please, you will be recognized.
Sure. I'm Jody Ann Tripp with the Arkansas Hospital Association, and actually Senator Irvin did an excellent job. So I can answer any questions that
anyone might have. Okay. Thank you. Representative Love. you recognize for question
thank you mr. chairman I'm looking at the purpose of the board and I think that's on page five and as of right now we're we're working on passing the a bill to to have a non a nonprofit exchange now tell me
how this works with the nonprofit exchange because what we're saying is this this board is going to advise DHS so so kind of talk to me about
about that sure and I don't have as much expertise on how the exchange works especially in where you are with the amendments of the bill right now so I can speak to the one that's available to the public I may or may not know the amendments that you all have seen so basically what this board does that Senator Irvin has sponsored sets up an opportunity for when episodes of care are created under the payment
improvement initiative that providers have input on what those episodes look like as target prices are created so it wouldn't necessarily play into the exchange as far as what the qualified health plans are in those types of things these are particular individual episodes of care with quality metrics payment those kinds of things that we're going through already through the payment improvement initiative okay it sounds good thank you thank you members any other questions
seeing none thank you for the presentation is anybody in the audience that
would like to speak for against all right we've got a motion do pass from representative perry any discussion on the motion all in favor say aye opposed pastor bill next we've got uh we're going to do sb-442 representative fight is running that and then sb-1171 by senator caldwell you're on deck. So Representative Fayette, you're recognized to present. Thank you,
Mr. Chair. Thank you, members. This is an amendment to Senate Bill 442, which was the establishing
an interpreter advisory board for individuals who are deaf or hard of hearing. And what this amendment will do is add me as a co-sponsor. Also, Representative Ferguson had expressed a concern about the fee established for the board, and so we clarified that in this amendment, and we are saying before a rule is promulgated under this subchapter, the proposed rule shall be presented to the Legislative Council, just to make it very clear about the fee schedule.
Okay, and members, just to be clear, we have already adopted the amendment, and it is engrossed in the bill. This is just a straight-up due pass, so the amendment's engrossed in the bill. you're probably playing catch up and looking at that but you've heard an explanation does anybody have any questions does anybody need a little bit are you trying to read top to bottom left to right alright no questions is there anybody in the audience that would like to speak
for or against the bill okay members you've heard the presentation you've got a motion to pass Any discussion on the motion? Everybody okay? I'm seeing a lot of perplexed looks. All right. We've got a motion. Do pass. All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Congratulations. You passed your bill. Thank you. All right. Senator Caldwell, SB 1171.
And then next we're going to do representative award laws. What's the number? 1482. So we're on 1171. Next is 1482. Senator Caldwell, you're recognized. Thank
you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, committee. What this bill does is bring transmitting a prescription into the modern-day era. Presently, a doctor or dentist can transmit a prescription either by writing it, calling it in, or faxing it in,
And this basically legalized using the Internet to transmit a prescription. And it just brings our laws up to date. Thank you, Senator
Caldwell. Members, you've heard an explanation of the bill. Is your tablet messing up, Representative Love? All right. We've got Juanita up there. All right, members, you've heard an explanation on the bill. Any questions?
All right. Is there anybody in the audience that would like to speak for or against the bill? Seeing none, you want to close for your bill, Senator Caldwell? I'm closed. All right. Representative Wilkins, motion do pass. Any discussion on the motion? All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Congratulations. You passed your bill. Thank you, committee and Mr. Chairman. All right. Now we've got Wardlaw, House Bill 1182.
Where did he go? Ferguson. Oh, okay. Right. Representative Ferguson, you're going to present 1482. I'm sorry, not 1182.
Ward. Okay. 1482, members. And then next we'll do House Bill 1871, and then we're going to concur on amendments, and then I think we might be to the special orders. So we're doing good.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. This is 1482. Does the
members have this amendment on their tablets? There's some copies up there that may need to pass out. We'll pass out a hard copy. Okay. You want to start explaining it while they're passing out? Yes, sir. I can try. What this amendment does, committee, is it sets up a Delta project for a real intense home patient managed care. And it takes the most expensive Medicaid patients in these poorest counties,
and it makes sure these guys are going to the doctor, make sure these guys are being compliant, taking their meds. And they work with the home health, with the doctors. This amendment is completely optional. If you turn to the last page, I believe it's page 4, go to page 3, and it starts on KI. Okay. All right.
Hang on. What's the issue, members? Yeah, case manager. Okay. Y'all want to adopt the amendment first? Oh, the wrong amendment.
Okay. Oh, now I understand. Yeah. Man, y'all are aggressive today. But thanks for reading the amendment. All right, here it comes. and just while it's going I mean I it should go without saying but I know it's crowded in here and I'm sorry to the members to the audience and people here to watch I wish we had a bigger room
but this is this is what they decided we needed 100 years ago when they built this place so I wish there were more seats I know it's uncomfortable we're trying to make it as expeditious as possible everybody have the new the appropriate amendment okay everybody good moving forward while you're reading we need to adopt the amendment first so representative ward law you want to explain your or explain the amendment first or are you
done explaining the amendment i can explain it some more the biggest hurdle we had to jump with this project was making sure that we we were very much optional so I wanted to get to that point before we adopted if you don't mind well that okay that'd be fine if you go to page three on the amendment look down on k1 at the bottom it says this section does not require a physician to participate in this pilot program created on this subsection if you go to the next page number two so the physician has the right to refuse a contract under this pilot program
created under this section are the the right to terminate it says terminate the contract without any penalty so we'll make sure we make that very clear I think there were some misconceptions about this pilot program a few weeks ago and we've worked very hard this week to try to get everybody on board I think we've got everybody on board we're waiting on DHS to give us their feelings because we just got all this back from the Medical Society so we may have to make a few minor changes in the Senate, and we agreed to do that.
So I'll take any questions anybody has.
All right. Representative Hammer, you're recognized for a
I'm looking at it would be B2. It says the pilot program shall encompass a minimum of 5,000 recipients.
Yes, sir. Okay. That is continuing. It is depending on the doctor's contracting with whatever vendor DHS contracts with for this pilot program. So if they don't get 5,000, that's not a killer. They just want 5,000. I'm just curious. This is in the Delta? Yes, sir. If we have reports that
show that physicians are not currently able to meet the needs or not there to meet the needs, how do you expect to fulfill this given the history of the reports
that have been presented to us previously? I'd be curious to hear
your thoughts on that. Maybe I should go back and explain the program a little bit. It's not managed care, Diff misspoke a little bit. I had a feeling I might correct him about that. It's case management, and I think this will be a real cost savings to Medicaid, and it will be a real convenience for patients and helpful to physicians.
What they do, they only take the very sickest populations, those who typically spend more than $35,000 a year in Medicaid dollars, and because physicians are so busy, they have trouble triaging and managing these people and keeping them out of the ER and just so these people they'll hire RENs to come help manage these cases and I would think in 40 Delta counties they won't have any trouble meeting the 5,000 threshold. With the assistance of RENs
who they're going to hire in order to achieve this and
carry this forward? Right there there are several companies out there that will compete on this that the one company that Jeff and I met with I think said they would hire 100 R.E.N., so I would think any competing company would do a similar thing, so it
will be, you know, it will go out for a bid. Would you explain on page 1 what the phrase Medicaid primary care case
management, who qualifies to bear that title? Yes, that is physicians now. That's the definition under Medicaid.
Is that definition limited only to physicians, or according to the federal mandate of Medicaid, does it expand to include anybody else?
like a management fee. Right, they pay $3. I think that's the definition that kind of...
$3 per member per month that they pay to physicians to have patients on what they call their panel.
Right, I think that's just the definition section. And this bill retains that $3 per member per month fee. Right. No, that's already in
existence. It's a way to incentivize taking Medicaid patients despite the low reimbursement rates. Yeah, this says they
cannot lower that per member per month fee. Right. All
right. Thank you. Okay. Representative Overby, you're recognized for a question. I was just going to
Okay. Members, any other questions? Representative Meeks, you're recognized.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. My question is on page 3, and line F. It says, Department shall require that the contracting vendor's savings in comparison to a risk-adjusted Arkansas fee-for-service benchmark, and I'm guessing, based on what was said, that this is not going to bump up against the episodes of care. Right. Physicians
will, this will be a fee-for-service program, and it's laid out in here.
The savings will be shared between DHS and the company who administers the program and the physician. Well, has there been
any talk about putting any of these chronic conditions within the episodes of care that might be a better way to save money than
what this would for comparison? I think most of them are already in the 13 that we've learned about over the last two years. But I'm sure the ones that they find through this could certainly be added. I mean, we won't leave that up to DHS.
One of the primary things they manage are high-risk pregnancies. I mean, that's one of the big savings that they find for the program. Just wanting to
make sure that we, you know, do the best that we can to take care
of patients. Oh, sure. Absolutely. You know that's my concern with
that. Okay. All right. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you. Representative
Mayberry, last question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I noticed the beginning date on the pilot program. Is there a specific end date at which point in time that the entire program would be evaluated to see if we need to continue on an ongoing basis?
It's a two-year program. It's going to begin on January 1 of 14 and end on December 31st of 16. And the reason we've done it like that is because of the session of 15, if this program doesn't realize any real savings, we can obviously let it end and go away. If it does show us some great savings, we can obviously put it in as a permanent program. At that point in time, after
that evaluation is done, would we have to come back with new legislation in order to do more? In order to continue it, we would. Okay. Thank you.
Yes, sir. All right, members. You've heard a presentation on the bill. Is there anybody in the audience that would like to speak for or against? Seeing none. Yeah, or a better way to say it, maybe, not like to, but will speak for or against. Seeing none, what's the pleasure of the committee? As amended. Any discussion on the motion? And then I'll say it's worth noting that this is one of several what I consider good quality reform-minded pieces of legislation
that hopefully will help address cost issues in our remaining Medicaid program moving forward. So, thank you for running the bill. Seeing no other discussion, we've got a motion to do pass. All in favor, say aye. Any opposed? Congratulations. You passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman of the Committee. Okay. Now, we're going to concur on three amendments, and we're going to go to the special orders. You've got the First Amendment. It's House Bill 1384. Representative Miller asked me to do this for him today. If there's just some strong objection, I'll just tell you I'll wait.
But this is concurrence on an amendment that he had for this bill. requiring the criminal background checks for this is amendments one and three yeah on house bill 1384 it was it the amendment simply changed it to mirror the same requirements as the department of health and dhs now there was just some so okay you with senator urban yeah you want to present it i think they're pretty simple amendments They are simple amendments
Members, I carried this For Representative Miller over on the Senate Side so I can speak to the amendment The state police came to us And we removed The section that said that they Needed to take fingerprints for a state criminal Background check because they don't collect fingerprints So that's basically what the amendment Does is just make sure that it's consistent With their policies and procedures on Carrying out state criminal background check Okay, members, you've heard an explanation
of the amendment. Any questions? If not, what's the pleasure of the – does anybody like to speak for or against the amendment?
What's the pleasure of the committee? Motion to concur on the amendment. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? All right. Thank you, Senator Irvin. I'm actually not sure about House Bill 1968. Are you going to run that one also, Senator Irvin? No, okay. I thought maybe you were – okay. I thought you were staying there maybe for that. Representative Malone, House Bill 2210, you want to explain your amendment?
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Committee, this amendment makes the bill even better. I
appreciate a good vote. All amendments do. All right. Thank you for the explanation. Especially when they come from the other end. Yeah. You've heard an explanation, members. Any questions on the amendment? Okay. What's the pleasure of the committee? Motion to concur. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Any opposed? Congratulations. You passed your amendment.
And I actually, yeah, you wanted to run the House bill, the ambulatory surgery centers. I'm trying to get back to my agenda to look at the number. I believe the amendment just added me as a sponsor. Yeah, I looked at it. Okay. Members, this is the last concurrence, and my tablet is frozen up, and so I can't get back to the number. 1968. 1968. House Bill 1968. That's the amendment. You've heard of the presentation. Any discussion?
What's the pleasure of the committee? Motion to concur. all in favor say aye any opposed congratulations on your amendment that was the first quarter thank you very much we made some progress now what I want to do is start with the special orders I'm going to wait
okay representative hammer you are officially first on the list you want to go first okay then we'll do sb 1010 by senator hutchinson senator hutchinson are you you're running that one representative hammer you're you're our special order for the day okay um all right senator hutchinson representative hammer if y'all want to join us at the end of the table they're running 1010 members if y'all join us at the end of the table
you'll be recognized to present sb 1010 and if you're here to speak on the bill from as a member of the audience i think the sign up sheet's right over here behind this camera so you can come sign up to give testimony. The amendment is engrossed in the bill, members.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Just some quick set the stage for Senate Bill 1010. First of all, Senate Bill 1010 will require all used, that being referred to as second-hand mattresses that are sold commercially within the state to bear a label that states the mattress has been used. Secondly, Senate Bill 1010 changes current Arkansas Department of Health regulation that states unlawful sale of bedding is finable from $25 to $250 in up to 30 days in jail to a Class A misdemeanor.
it also requires that the labels shall also comply with rules adopted by the department requiring label dimension format informational content wording letter size material means of placement and fixing the bedding and other relevant factors simply put use mattresses or mattresses that have been slept on mattresses that have been damaged or discolored in the storage and shipping process and have not been sold to a consumer and are not to be considered
used and can be sold as a new mattress. Surrounding states that have already adopted legislation to address this issue is Missouri, Oklahoma, Texas, Louisiana, and Tennessee. They've already enacted laws such as Senate Bill 1010 to prohibit the fraudulent sale of used vetting. This has caused Arkansas in Mississippi to become the dumping grounds, and if we as a state don't take some action on this, we're going to continue to be the recipient of mattresses.
And I guess probably to summarize it before we take questions in an appropriate time, I'd like to invite two guests to come to the end of the table that are able to speak to the validity of why we need this law. Basically, once a mattress has left the store of origination, it should be considered used. by partening by joining up that's a hard word to say this morning by joining up with other states around us that have already passed
this kind of legislation what we're going to do is as a state protect our citizens so that they're not purchasing something under the false pretense that it's a scratching dent when in reality it's a used mattress and I guess the most visual illustration I can use of why we need to do this if any of y'all like the ocean 11 series of movies. Remember that one particular movie where that guy goes in and he's supposed to be inspecting the motels? And, you know, they've kind of set this guy up and he gets in the bed
and to the, you know, to the eye, it appears that the mattress is okay. It looks good. Everything looks fine to the naked eye. He puts on those special glasses and he flips his glasses down. And if you remember the movie, I won't go into the great scene of what he saw, but what we're doing through the passage of this bill is helping protect the citizens and this is a bill that's designed to protect the citizens from buying something under the pretense that it's just a little scratch and dent situation. It is designed
to protect those citizens from such an event and with that I'll be glad to answer any questions or turn the mic over to Senator Hutchinson who may want to
add some things to it. Senator Hutchinson, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'll be very brief. just represent hammer did a great job of describing the bill just want to give a little context what happens if you a lot of these mattress companies will sell their mattress with a two-year warranty or and so if the warranty is exercised
and the mattress is returned to them they'll sell it lump them together and sell them in bulk into some distributor New Jersey or wherever who then goes and will bleach the mattress and try to remove all the stains and shake it up and fluff it back up and repackage it as new. And then as Representative Hammers said, because we don't have any laws prohibiting it, they've been shipping a lot to Arkansas. They can still sell used mattresses.
If there's a market for used mattresses and we don't want to interfere with that market, We just want not to be fraud, where you can't sell a used mattress and claim that it's new and repackage it to where you're deceiving the consumer. I've got a good friend who is worried about some of the, will it interfere with damaged, and we don't think it does at all.
This is only if it's been slept in and if it is used. It does not impact NICs and damages that occur in transportation. So with that, we'll take any questions. Okay, members,
you've heard an explanation of the bill. Representative Mayberry, you've got a question.
I did, and I've lost where I was in here, but it was identifying cellar. Oh, I guess page 2, line 19, it identified the cellar,
and talks about, you know, the labeling and such as that, but says dispose of bedding in any commercial manner at the wholesale, retail, or other level of trade. That's not including folks who are selling something at a yard sale or something like that. Is that right? That is obviously used. They don't have
to go label that. Yeah, if it's, I mean, as long as I didn't find it's used and normally used, then they're fine. It's the repackaging of it is new. that if you're going to repackage it and put the wrappers around it,
you've got to put a label on that if you're just selling it out of here. Or there's some furniture stores in Saline County who donate it to, you know, different charities and stuff, but they're obviously used. They're not being repackaged. Okay. Mr.
Chair, may I add to that? Yes, sir. If I go to Goodwill, I go to Helping Hands, I go to a flea market, I go to a garage sale. I go there with the expectation that I'm going to buy something used.
But if I walk into an established furniture store that is in the business and recognized by the state as being in that business, what I don't want to have happen is walk in and under the pretense that I'm buying something new, find out that it was a mattress that was returned, repackaged, rewrapped, and sent back out to a store and sold under the pretense of being new. And that's the heartbeat of this bill, that we just want fair labeling so that if a consumer walks into, say, I'm just going to grab a store,
Furtison Furniture in Benton, and they are going to buy a mattress, that that mattress is indeed new, unless it's otherwise labeled as being a recycled mattress. Okay. Representative Love,
you're recognized for a question. Thank you,
Mr. Chair. Mr. Representative Hammer, let me ask you something, because I'm familiar with some companies that refurbish mattresses. So if a mattress is stripped, say it's been slept on, they strip it down to the frame,
they put the material back on, they package it up, would this bill, and they sell it as new, would
this bill prohibit that? Yes, I think it would. I mean, a mattress, it's like a, I'll use an airplane, Senator Hendren's left, but an airplane, they can go through a refurbishing and redo the engine, and it can be as good as new. But if you try to sell that airplane as a new airplane when it's not,
that would not only be a civil, you can have a civil suit filed against you, you for fraud, but probably theft by deception. And if it's been slept on, I think it's used, even if you strip it down and redo it. Now, you can do that and sell them as refurbished and go through the process and tell people what all was done, but you've got to be truthful in what you're selling. That's not a new mattress. You can still sell it, but you're
going to have to tell people what happened and what has been done to because that that's not a new mattress. Thank
you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Representative Link. Gentleman, either one, we talk about the other states, states around us have the law. How's our law comparing to that and how's our fine system compared to their fines? Well, we have no law. Okay. How's this bill compared to their laws, and how is this bill's fine system compared to their laws?
Well, we may need to ask somebody more expertise than at least me. I know we took laws from other states and modeled it after it, so I suspect it's very, very similar. And the penalty is the lowest criminal penalty you can give in Class A misdemeanor. So it's not a significant penalty. You recognize? okay do it do
you feel comfortable with the penalty then or do you think it
should be higher I mean I think I got a feel comfortable that because you put well I think we ought to see how it plays out and if there's still abuse then we can come back later and raise a penalty but I'm I'm typically want to move slow and not you know so I think it's a good first step and then we Hopefully it addresses the problem and we don't ever have to worry about it again. But if it doesn't, then we can always come back and, like we've done on a lot of other issues,
come back subsequently and raise the penalty. Thank you. Thank you. Representative Harris. Thank you,
Mr. Chair. Senator Hutchison or Representative Hammer, I appreciate this as being a consumer protection type bill. but as you know big companies I feel like do this all the time not just on bedding but on different products you get home and you realize it's been opened and probably used before I mean do you feel like as you're doing this I know
bedding is important but sometimes if it's damaged or used why in particular I mean if we do it for bedding which is important will we go down an avenue start doing it for other companies why this in particular if you know if it does affect damaged products and companies have a right to resell I mean why are we going
down this well I think for two reasons first it's we're one of
the few states you haven't so we become a dumping ground as represent hammer said and so it's a serious problem the second reason it's a health issue no other product are you laying your head down and putting your kids in that bed and there have been examples where there's bed bugs that are being sold as new mattresses you can imagine what kind of stuff is left on a mattress that's been slept in for a year and a half and we're putting our little kids in those beds and it's I think that's why it's before the Public Health Committee not
judiciary is because it is a health issue. Can
I follow up on that, too, Representative Harris? One thing to keep in mind also is that a lot of these mattresses are coming from the far corners of the nation, and the reason that they're sending them here is because we are an easy target without this bill being in place. So as far as whatever diseases, such as was mentioned, bed bugs, which have been at epidemic proportion you know in the northeast this is a bill that would would help prevent that
and to the point that was made a while ago and also to tie it into years you know part of the issue is this if you're going to be a good honest fair businessman you're going to do what's right when somebody walks in and you have that kind of reputation that people trust you would say to them hey this mattress has been stripped down to the frame and rebuilt back up and this is what I'm telling you, and this is everything I know about it, then the consumer can make a decision on the basis of that.
It's not right to present it under the pretense that it's something that it's not, and so this bill will help identify at what stage that mattress, you know, has either been repackaged, torn down, or whatever. End of the day, it comes down to whether you're going to be a fair, honest businessman or not. Nobody can make a law that will make them do that, but we can present a law that will help hold them accountable if they're going to
deceive the public sometimes I ask the question the wrong way and then I get a brilliant answer especially when you're a lawyer and we can not you but from
Senator Hutchison but um sorry because you can give me the worst scenarios but I guess my point was over regulation when you start regulating one company then you're going to start regulating all companies that was my point of the question had nothing to do with bed bugs necessarily because that's an awful situation i would not want bed bugs in my house so i wasn't necessarily talking about that but i was talking about regulating one group of people and then we're going to start regulating more groups of people like other companies that was the point of the
question so that's what i wanted you to
talk about that address that if you first of all we regulate I mean, this industry already, and for health reasons, we regulate restaurants, bars, hair salons, I mean, you name it. We have health regulations in all sorts of industries. You wouldn't think you'd have to, on the same basis, regulate mattress sales, but it turns out you do, which is kind of gross, but it's happening.
So I think there's a longstanding and accepted principle, even among very conservative people such as you and me, that if we're talking about the safety of our citizens, that regulation is appropriate. If we don't regulate, what you're going to open up businesses to is lawsuits because it's fraud. And there's a – I mean, you could get – I think this is a much cheaper way to address a problem, and this is hard for me to say as a lawyer but then filing a bunch of lawsuits and having
fraud suits filed all over some of whom probably aren't doing anything wrong it just you know they may it may have been nicked up they didn't know themselves that it was used I mean if a furniture store owner doesn't know that it's used the bill allows you to go after the person who does know it's the wholesaler it's whoever is so this is going to be addressed one way or the other and I think this is probably the best way to do it as opposed to a bunch of litigation thank you
representative Harris and I am glad we
got dirty mattresses and bedbugs out of the way before lunch represented Malone and then Overby thank you mr. chairman
who's monitoring or checking who who's gonna be in charge of that regulating checking the dirty mattresses Department of Health will be I
don't know checking I guess they'd have so yeah there'd be if reports were you report to the Department of Health and they'd come out and inspect okay
well then if they're not checking can you I
thought I read in here something about a grading system can you explain
need some help because it says bedding inspection so And that's why I
just wasn't sure who's doing the inspecting. It would be the Department of Health. They currently have.
Do they have mattress inspectors? They currently have it. Yeah, it's currently part of their regulation.
It is a Department of Health regulation. So they currently are doing this right now. There's just no teeth to it. And so they may inspect and find there would be a problem, but nobody's going to stop because it's slap on the wrist and just move on. But, yes, there's not any new bureaucracy having to be created or any new positions or anything. But
the grading scale, the Department of Health just came up with the grading scale that's mentioned?
Yeah. Let me, if you don't mind, get Randy Lamb maybe come and help answer that because you've exhausted my knowledge on the issue actually it's our other question this is where we get
really bogged down if we're not careful so represent him alone if you'll hold your questioning I assume mr. Lamb signed up to speak on the bill all right Randy okay hold it yeah okay thank you okay thank you representative over be you know there's been a lot of things when
since i've been in here that we've discussed this first time we've discussed bed bugs i've never seen one i don't want to see one but uh i think this is one of the better bills we've had so i want
to do pass at the proper time okay uh representative mayberry okay representative butch wilkins
you know i too support this legislation i i hope i've never bought a mattress and it was used and
it turned i thought it was new and it was used but but how do we i'm sure somebody knows who's doing this now so how do we how do we actually enforce this with store inspections or or on an individual how do we how do we get to that well I suspect well and I'll tell
you what I've when I filed this bill I've actually had a few people come up to me one of them is a good friend he said you know what he goes that happened to me he said I went in thought I was buying a brand
new mattress got a real good discount on it so I was like boy I'm a lucky guy I got 500 you know $2,000 mattress I got for $500 and took it home and three weeks later it collapsed and he goes I went back and said they said there's no warranty and so I think probably most of it would be reports from consumers to the health department then they'd go inspect and see if it was a you know ongoing problem if it was just something was wrong with that particular mattress but I think it
be mostly by consumer reports
on consumer consumer reports consumer complaints to to police this for lack of a better word but these mattresses what you're saying is that these mattresses are used but are actually actually labeled as new mattresses or yes let's
go out there repackaged as new mattresses we need to go after
them folks thank you thank you I think that was the last question so seeing no other questions we'll we'll move on to speak for against then we'll let representative and Senator Hutchinson close first first people signed up to speak against the bill of Jonathan McElwain if you'll join us at the end of the table say your
name for the record you'll be recognized to present or speak against the bill are
sorry it's not on there we go thank you my name is Jonathan McIlwain. I own a furniture business in Russellville called Good Deal Charlie. I'm a second generation owner of this store. We currently employ 15 people. I've just grown the business
from Russellville and I have a few locations across the state. And what this bill does is it just redefines what a used mattress is. It is already against the law to sell something used as new. So what this is doing, it's just going and wrapping up damaged product. You know, mattresses are shipped in plastic, right? So, I mean, when those things are slid across a semi, on and off a dock,
they're ripped, they're torn. You know, if plastic is, they get dirty. And that is the overwhelming majority of what we're talking about here. And the opposition, the creators of this bill, are casting a big blanket over all of these things and trying to categorize and stamp them as used in order to slander the business. What it is is that, you know, they get mad that I sell the same type product that they do at a much lower rate
Now, you know, what happens is that, you know, I sell them and they say, well, hey, that guy's selling you Well, no, it's a damaged mattress that has sometimes been, you know, is sold in bulk by a manufacturer that supplies these high-end retailers that want to sell these things. It's supplied by them. This is a, if they think it's a problem, it's a market problem, they should contact manufacturers and say, hey, stop putting these mattresses on the market that can be sold for less.
I want to get full-tilt price out of this thing, and when the damaged product gets on the market, then, you know, they're undercutting me, you know, at a discount. Keith, did you have something to say? My name is Keith Emus. The
Speaker 177
51:22
process this goes through, the manufacturer makes a mattress. It's put on a truck, shipped to a distributor. In process, the bag can tear open. It can rub against the wood. It can leave a stain on the mattress. It can rip a hem. It can do several different things.
the distributor obviously will not accept that as new and sell it with a warranty. So it goes back to the manufacturer, who then sells it at auction to people like Jonathan. Jonathan buys that mattress at a fraction of what it would cost retail and then sells it to people who are not in a high-end mattress business or in the market to buy a high-end mattress at a greatly reduced cost. He's selling a mattress that is new, that's never been slept on, that's never been used by anyone. It does not come with a warranty. It's not advertised as coming with a warranty.
he's selling it as it is with the full understanding among his clients or customers that that's what it is and he's selling a $1,500 mattress for $300 now if you're buying a $300 mattress in a discount furniture store you're not going to go into a high-end furniture store and buy a $1,500 mattress but it is our belief that this is an attempt to regulate the industry and do away with this because they're trying to force this component of the market out both manufacturers of new low-end mattresses and the high-end mattresses at least
the distributors of those mattresses so I
go back to your story I feel like they're targeting me amongst others Senator Hutchinson a month before he proposed this legislation wrote me a letter threatening you know whatever he could to to come after me like he was talking about with with legislation and then they are with with with the law or civil suit and now he's just trying to legislate this thing. It's more of a market issue. What's going to happen is if I can't sell these
beds at this price point, I'm going to have to carry a lower quality mattress to a consumer that can only afford to pay so much that they're going to complain about the quality of the bed and not be able to buy good quality. I'm going to have less sales and people are going to lose jobs over this is really what it
Speaker 177
53:44
thousands upon thousands of these mattresses get sold
in Arkansas every year. We are completely unaware of a single health complaint from that. Right. But the bedbugs argument is completely spurious. That doesn't exist in Arkansas, and it doesn't exist in this market in Arkansas. That is not an accurate representation of where we are as far as public health
goes. All right. Thank you for the testimony. We'll take questions. I have, to me, the basic question, I think you said something early that this bill redefines what is used and what is not. I'm trying to glance through it, but do you have some concerns about the specific language
in the bill? Just the damaged mattresses is what it does. I mean, Senator Hutchinson just talked about how it would qualify those as used, and you'd have to put this big, ugly, used sticker on the mattresses. Who's not going to run for the hills when you see that? I mean, it's going to kill the business. But
you're saying that damage would count as used in this bill? Yes,
because they're sold in bulk, and the overwhelming majority of what's sold by the manufacturer in bulk
is a damaged thing that they're going
Speaker 177
54:53
to have to label. There's a separate component as well. If something sits on a showroom floor and is never sold and goes back to the manufacturer, that would be declared used too, which is akin to someone trying on clothes in Dillard's than putting them back without buying them and requiring Dillard's to say that's used clothing. That's what
this bill does. Members, any questions? Vice Chair Murdoch, you're recognized for a question.
Speaker 194
55:19
Okay. Currently, or as the bill states, do I understand you to say that the legislation would require you to put a stamp that says used? Yes, sir. And it says what it has. Okay. But right now, how is someone, a consumer that walks in the door, how are they to know that it is used versus – how is that distinction right
now? Well, it's not. They just – they're going to categorize it, and then the burden is going to be put on someone along the line, and eventually the retailer, I'm sure, if a distributor or the manufacturer that's putting these on the market –
Speaker 194
55:55
Hold on a second. I don't want you to testify. I want you to answer this question. Don't give me nothing. I want to know right now, if I walk into your store and you have a mattress, how do I know it's a new versus used? I'm just asking for a distinction. If I go to a car dealership, they let me know it's a used car. I know it's a used car by labeling. I'm just asking how is the consumer to know? It is
Speaker 177
56:15
currently state law that if you sell a used mattress, you have to say that it is used. How do you say
We, you know, we're talking about what Senator Hutchinson referred to as a scratch and dent mattress, a name brand mattress. That's what the bill is focusing on. Well, how is it law that a
used mattress has to be identified as used now, like on a label? Yes, that's been
a label, on the mattress? I think that's kind of the fundamental
So you're saying this is about redefining what used is. Okay. Maybe we can ask the health department what the law is now in a little bit. Representative Hammer, you're recognized for a question. And just for the record, as a member
of this committee, even though I am sponsoring the bill on the House side, I'm able to ask questions. Is that correct, Mr. Chair? I'm sorry. Say that again. And I just, for the record, I just want to make sure that as a member of this committee, even though I'm sponsoring the bill, as a member of the House, I am able to ask questions.
Yeah. Okay. Yes, you're recognized. For the record. First of all, have I ever written you a letter, either one of y'all? No, sir. I'm the sponsor on the House side, so I just wanted you to know that, and I wanted it public. I've never received nor have I ever written you a letter, number one. Yes, sir. Number two, do you think, and I'm asking this question on the basis of a comment that you just made a minute ago, Do you think the person who is spending $300 is any less deserving of full disclosure than the person who is spending $1,500 on
a mattress? No, I do not, but there's, you know, there's the burden of proof would lay on me to determine what's what,
and the overwhelming majority is simply damaged, and this would slander all
of those mattresses. Okay, and to that point then, speaking of full disclosure, how do you, if I walked in your store today as a consumer, or whether I have $300 in my pocket or $1,500 in my pocket. And by the way, does your store carry both brand spanking new mattresses shipped straight from the factory and mattresses that have been
recycled? Does your store offer both? I don't sell anything from a manufacturer straight from the manufacturer.
Okay, so you don't get any $1,500 mattresses straight from the factory? No, sir. You know, we're a discounter. Okay, all right. Then if I was to walk into your store today and I was to say, I want to buy a new mattress, what would you say to me and what proof would there be on the mattress that would verify what you tell me? There's no
labeling on them right now when they come in.
And there's no way for a distributor or me to know, but, I mean, simply you can tell by looking at it what it is. So it's left
up to me to the consumer and my ability to interpret my knowledge that if you don't tell me that this is a mattress that has this kind of history, I'm looking at it in a wrapper that, for all I know, could have been rewrapped in your store because it was damaged in shipment, as you are saying. and I, as the consumer, am supposed to take it for granted
that that mattress is a new mattress that
I'm buying for $300. Well, they don't come with a Carfax report, you know. That was
Speaker 177
59:58
remanufactured. They're not advertised as brand-new from the factory with a warranty. That's what that is. okay i'm going to just i'm
going to break my own rule and i want instead of asking five
questions all around i'd like to get a little bit of clarification from the department of health real quick uh i saw robert i saw a variety of people over there mr breck if you just real quick i just want to get some clarification Yes. We'll say your name for the record. Robert Breck with the Health Department. Could you just tell us what the law is now in terms of identifying used mattresses versus damaged?
There has been a law in the book since 1927 that deals with the issue of bedding whether it's new or used. Any product now, the way it's defined under the law, if any material in that product has been used or if the item is used, then the label must have it, there must be a label attached to it, a certain size, a certain font, a certain size that states that it has been manufactured with used materials.
The original intent of that law, based on the way it's written, it had to do with infectious diseases. Any bedding that's been exposed to any type of infectious or contagious diseases must be destroyed. Okay, so the law
is that it does have to be identified as used? That's correct. Do you have, and what about like refurbished, damaged, that seems to be the part of what we're talking about. Is there a
law regarding that? No, I think that is the main difference between this law and the law that's existing.
This law would be codified very close to the existing law, actually. But it does seem to appear that the difference between the two laws would include factory returned or returned items, as he has suggested. So bottom
line is we are adding to the definition of used and including factory returned or something similar to that that would classify mattresses used. That is correct. Okay. I think that – does everybody – that sums it up for me. Okay. All right.
Now, thank you. Thank you, Mr. Brack. Okay. Now, questions. There's a few more. Representative Love, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Gentlemen, tell me this, because, I mean, you almost had me with your argument, but this is a distinction. You said you purchased mattresses that have all been bundled up. You purchased them from some sort of outlet or whatever. Is there a possibility that you could have a damaged mattress that's never been slept on
in with a mattress that has been slept on but been refurbished, sanitized, or whatever? Is that? Could, I mean, is, I mean, now tell me, is that a possibility? If he postures 100 mattresses, could some have been slept on and re-sanitized and they've been packaged with damaged mattresses that have been sent back. That would
Speaker 177
1:03:22
be against the law already in Arkansas. So, I mean, if someone sells that, that's on them.
Okay. If you sell it as new, I mean, but to be sold as damaged, so that's what I buy from a distributor who buys from the manufacturers is a lot of damaged mattresses, yes. And damaged mattresses don't necessarily
mean slept-on mattresses. They're just mattresses that may have gone through. It's a cosmetic issue. I've seen
Speaker 177
1:03:53
these mattresses. It's a place where the side rubbed against wood in transit or where a stitch came undone.
I'm familiar with that because I've worked in the furniture business, so I understand that can happen. But what I'm asking is, is there a potential for you to purchase mattresses that have been used with mattresses that
have been damaged? I don't knowingly purchase them, no. I mean, could they slip through? Is it possible? Potentially. But, I mean, then they would have to all be labeled by this bill that way. And, you know, they're not. It's a very small minority.
I mean, out of 100, maybe two, maybe three. So what I propose is that these retailers approach the manufacturers who are letting these damaged mattresses back on the market You know, they call them, tell them, hey, stop letting these on the market. We'll suck up the cost, which is going to be, you know, raise our cost 5%, and all of this stuff goes away. And we're not
Speaker 177
1:04:58
in favor of selling used mattresses as new.
That is not our position. We just believe this redefines the definition of used mattress to include many, many things that are not. We're not here to defend selling used mattresses as new. But a remanufactured mattress that's been rejected from a distributor is not used, and this bill says
that it is. Okay, tell me what a remanufactured mattress is. Tell me what a remanufactured mattress
is. I think what you described earlier could be that, you know, or, you know, something that's been taken out and out of package and repackaged.
Speaker 177
1:05:36
I chose my wording wrong. What I meant to say was that a mattress that was rejected from a distributor and was sent back to the manufacturer is not used. And this bill defines that as a used mattress. So
a defective mattress, is that what you're saying?
Speaker 177
1:05:50
Not necessarily defective, but cosmetically flawed. It doesn't mean it's a bad mattress. It just means that it has something wrong with it in such a way that you wouldn't pay full retail price for it. Okay, thank you, Mr.
Chairman. Could you tell my tablet is messed up?
Do you know what section and what page the redefinition is that you're referencing? I don't have the bill in front of me. Okay. I'll try to find him. Representative Ward-Law, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
I can tell you if you go to page 2, line 25, it says, All bed manufactured, sanitized, or sold by the seller within the state shall bear a clear label that states this. and i think that's where they're talking about but what i don't understand is if you're saying
that there's two or three in a hundred that could get thrown in there that and you don't know what two or three that is how is my the consumer supposed to know what two or three that is and if i lay my kids on
that at night i'd really like to know that well if if it's obvious that you know something has been returned or something that there's damage on it i mean you just call we just would call it
out which is extremely rare but if you're you're saying that that there's regulation already out there and if i recall right the regulation
the only penalty in is that you have to destroy that mattress it says it has to be labeled used if it is used but you said a while ago that there's two or three per hundred that probably are used yeah that's that's they're not labeled used so you're already breaking that
regulation right i don't think that i am because you know you knowingly have to do it and if we know something if there's any kind of
evidence we call it out okay thank you mr thank you uh representative
harris last question thank you mr chair now would you agree that when
i ordered an air mattress through the mail and it came fedexed and the box was ripped open and they came and set it up and it had a black mark on the side and it came directly from the distributor was that used if you if
you would say i refuse this mattress it goes back to the distributor and the manufacturer gets it back that's you know that's
what because that's what happened and i complained but we kept it um but i have a question i i can honestly say i was not lobbied on this
bill i heard about this bill because i'm running three bills this morning and so i've got a do that but i heard about it five minutes before i walked in here through a text but so i don't even know what the name of your store is and it may have been mentioned this morning but when people walk into your store and i have heard that it's in russellville through your testimony do they know by the title of your you know by the your store name do they know what they're going into that the mattresses are going to be cheaper and what they're getting the name
of my store is good deal charlie so we try to tell them right up front that we're trying to give them a bargain i like that name yeah thank you and when they come in we say hey look at this this thing was damaged here and there and you know we get excited about it because we get to sell somebody a great product that they otherwise wouldn't be able to afford okay
i didn't mean to make this into an infomercial there you go but honestly so they know what it's no surprise just like when I go to a store I know what I'm going to get into so it's not a surprise and that I guess that's my point and this bill just may be
overreaching and it's not that I'm against Senator Hutchison and what he's trying to do it's just this bill may not be necessary now honestly thought when I came in here with this whole crowd of people we were going to be talking about Bart Hester's building and you know but I'm just surprised so I don't chance thank you don't worry okay I
don't see any other questions from committee members, so thank you for your testimony. Thank you for your time. All right. We have several or three people signed up to speak for, one more against, but the next
to speak for is Mr. Randy
Speaker 246
1:10:07
Land. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you, members of the committee. I'm Randy Land. I'm the executive director of the Arkansas Home Furnishings Association. We have over 500 members, and 20-something are here today. I think the one thing that's been confusing this morning is this bill is not addressing scratch and dent.
This bill is only addressing mattresses that have been slept on. If a mattress gets scratched and dent in the back of a truck or coming off at a dealer, that mattress is still new. Everything in it is still new. This is only if a mattress has been slept on, except mattresses that claim they were show floor samples from like other states. Because we don't know that that mattress was a floor sample.
You just have to state it on a tag that the health department will decide what size and what color that this mattress is not new, that it is a used mattress. It's a fair issue. We're not trying to put someone out of business because their mattress, they may have some scratch and dents because this bill is not dealing with that. This bill is only dealing with mattresses that have been slept on or the thousands of mattresses that claim to be floor samples from other states.
Speaker 194
1:11:42
Vice Chair Murdock, you recognize for a question. Thank you, Chairman. All right, so you changed the whole argument. Sorry I didn't get here earlier. Yeah, well, the two gentlemen spoke against it before you testified that this was different than what you're reading. And I guess getting deep into the bill, we'll find out what this actually is. But you're saying this is not – you actually sell as new the dented, scraped, or, you know, in shipment, some of the bumps and bruises that goes on with shipment.
That's still being presented as new in your store, whomever store you represent. Yes,
Speaker 246
1:12:18
sir. And I represent, like I said, 500 members. And the majority is by far as for this bill. So it – Let me – I'm sorry. To finish my question. So not for
Speaker 194
1:12:28
you to speak for him, those that just spoke, because now I want to get lined up with what the problem is with the bill because they just spoke as though this bill is redefining something. In your opinion, what does this bill do that's different from the bill that we currently have on the books from 1927, I guess?
Speaker 246
1:12:47
Well, because our state does not have a bill with any teeth, and they were right, But this has become the dumping ground on all these mattresses that has been sent back to either manufacturers or have been sent back and redone, and so we've become the dumping ground because we don't have any teeth in what we have in the statute that the health department is having to work with. I mean, it's like a $25 fine or something like that. It's a very small fine.
This would make it a misdemeanor. We're basically taking on what all the other states around us have already done except Mississippi.
Speaker 194
1:13:28
Did that answer your question? Not really. You're saying to do what? I mean, you're putting teeth in what? In clarifying the difference between selling a new mattress
Speaker 246
1:13:38
and a used mattress. If he's got a new mattress for sale, I mean, he doesn't have to,
Speaker 194
1:13:47
you know, it comes with those labels on it. So obviously there's an allegation or there's something here that says that this legislation was necessary because of what's happening with Good Charlie or the previous testimony.
I mean, what are we trying to miss? What's happening out there that brought this on? Something is going on that we're trying to, at least 20 of us or maybe 19 of us didn't know this was coming. So we're trying to get an understanding of what we're really fighting, what we're really hearing. that they're against people just testify that they're not doing what you just said. They're saying that they're selling the same thing you're selling based on their
testimony. Rip, may I speak to the question? Please. I think the difference is, and if Robert could come back up to the microphone, he can clarify what I'm about to say, and maybe Senator Hutchinson can clarify.
The difference is now that it is a regulation. It is not a law. This would make it a law. And I think that is the defining difference because if the Department of Health, and I wish Robert would sit at the table and he can straighten me out if I'm wrong, if they go in and pull an inspection, which is their right to do, what they can do is just order that those materials, those beds, be destroyed. This is going to assess some penalties, but it will also bring a misdemeanor factor into it, and we'll actually take it from being a regulation to being a law.
and I'm either fixing to get really embarrassed or get really supported
Brett, you're recognized. There is a current statute on the books. There is a penalty provision in that statute, and it states it's a minimum fine of $25, the gentleman was correct, but it does go up to a $250 fine and 30 to 90 days in jail.
That is absolutely correct. Under the current law, it would have to be used, which would be slept on. And it would have to be sanitized. If it was used, it would have to be marked as such. And if it had been subjected to any contagious or infectious disease, it would have to be destroyed. It could not be resold. But there is a current penalty in the law that's been there since 1927, I think. Okay.
Thank you, Mr. Breck. And, members, I've got a new tablet, and I think the whole heart of this thing is, if I'm summing it up for everybody, is page 2, line 13. And, Mr. Lane, you just tell me. I'm going to just read it, and then you tell me your interpretation, which is secondhand material means any fabric, filling material, or other material or article of vetting that has been previously used for any other purpose, including without limitation floor samples from any source
other than the seller's own business and factory return materials or bedding and then the industrial waste stuff is easy to understand but I think that is the point of floor samples it doesn't say from any other state floor samples from any source other than the seller's own business and factory return materials or bedding and just give me your interpretation of that because I think that's the whole meat of what we're talking
Speaker 246
1:17:05
about That is true, Mr. Chairman. If it's secondhand, it states it right there if it's basically ever been slept on or used as such.
If it's a floor sample from someone within their store that they know that mattress has never been in a home and someone slept on overnight, it's no problem. I just didn't want to get scratch and dent stuff mixed up with our intent of here today. Did that answer
your question? And I was really – I don't want to wade in. It's just my point is, I guess would be – I can't get a good tablet up here.
But I just think no matter how you feel, I think the concern is that the floor samples or then – I forget the language now because it's gone away, but it's the factory return part. What is – in industry practice, define that for me. I mean, help me understand what a
factory return would be. All right. Let me try to bring some clarification. Again, this bill, and I'm going to read, this bill only addresses slept on mattresses
and floor models from out of state that you can't, if you didn't do that, everybody would claim it's a floor model. So the language, new material is defined as any fabric, filling material, other material or article abetting that has not been previously used in the manufacturing, distributing, and retailing process or for which a legal title has not been transferred by a manufacturer, distributor, or retailer to a final purchaser. So if
you've got... I think my point was on the secondhand material definition.
Well, I understand, but that says if you've got, if it's a legitimate title and it's never been purchased by somebody else and it gets dented or scratched, it's not used. That's new. And secondhand, what's the question? It says factory return
materials. I just want to give me an industry definition of that because I don't know, and I think
mean, if it's been returned from a user who slept on it
or returned by a user, period. I guess you won't know for sure if it's slept on, but if somebody bought it, walked out of the store,
Speaker 194
1:19:43
Vice Chair Murdoch. Representative Hutchinson. Thank you, Chair. Can you help me, please, with why you think I kind of want to refer to this letter that I hear about because I think that will clear up something for us to see exactly what you're trying to deal with here, if that letter is true. I appreciate it.
And, yeah, I was contacted by a client who's a furniture store, said, hey, this is happening in Arkansas. It's illegal. It's not being enforced. What is this? Selling used mattresses as new. So I've sent a letter out, a cease and desist letter out like I do a lot saying, if you are. I didn't know for sure, because I said, if you are selling used mattresses without identifying them,
you are in violation, da-da-da, and ask you to cease and desist from that activity. I guess Mr. McElwain got one of those letters. I sent them out to several people. We could have brought lawsuits, but I don't think that's necessary or appropriate if we can just get legislation to enforce the law. The current law is not working.
We are a dumping ground, and you can have testimony from all sorts of people who will tell you that, Arkansas and Mississippi. So, again, I'm not trying to be overly burdensome and trying to lock somebody away in prison for, you know, 10 years for doing this, But we need a criminal violation, and this provides a criminal violation. The softest one you can provide, but it's still a criminal violation.
There has to be in any criminal, not any criminal violation, but in almost all criminal violations, there has to be what's called mens rea, or criminal intent. You have to have knowingly done it. So if Mr. McElwain doesn't know that it's used, then he's not criminally liable. But the people who sell to him and who do know are. And this allows us to go after them who are selling it to him and get them from doing that and using Arkansas as a dumping ground to sell their used mattresses.
So, again, it gives us more teeth. Whatever we've got now is not working. And honestly, I know this doesn't help the bill. y'all don't, but in the Senate committee it took 20 seconds. I understand that, but
Speaker 194
1:22:27
so you've cleared it up for me, so really the previous testimony was that they're not selling slept on mattresses, so therefore they would not be in violation. So if they're not doing
that, this only puts some teeth into the law so that you can penalize those that go afoul of the law, so this just gives us some teeth, so that makes it simpler to some degree. Thank you. Thank you. Okay. All
right, we're going to get back to questions for Mr. Land. I kind of distracted us there. And then I think after this, we're going to limit debate, members. So be thinking about a number. Representative Meeks, you're recognized for a question for Mr.
Land. Thank you. My concern is that we already have the statute on, you know,
against selling used mattresses that already has a penalty and everything of that nature. Are we trying to do something here where we're just adding a law instead of just doing what we can to enforce the current law? Do you not think that taking more measures to enforce the current law would help to curb the selling of these used mattresses since we already have the statute already in place?
Speaker 246
1:23:44
Representative Meeks, that's a great question. But if you're selling a mattress, I'm going to throw a figure out there. Believe it or not, there's a lot of $3,000 mattresses now. And you're selling a mattress set for $3,000, and your neighbors just sold one for $500 and whoever that is. Wouldn't you take a risk to try to do that for a while if you were getting away with it for a $25 fine? Because that's basically what it is.
So we're trying – we've got to put some teeth in it to make it where it's – I mean, make this justifiable or liable, whatever. It's just a good ethical deal. Well,
I guess a follow-up question then is, you know, if that is the case, then why are we – like I said, we've got how many pages? Five, six pages here. why not just look at that one area that deals with the fine and either up the fine or up the penalty
instead of having to go through, you know, six pages worth of potentially changing a definition and that's where I was kind of concerned about, you know, is this a change in the definition, is it not? Some people think it is, some people think it isn't. And so I know sometimes we need a little bit more clarity, but it seems to me like if you were worried about that we could just change the section that has the fine instead of writing this whole six-page bill that could cause more confusion or about the definition and everything of that nature. You know, when we're talking about lawyers here and, I'm sorry, President Company, whatever.
Speaker 246
1:25:18
And because you said that, we try to learn from mistakes, and we basically took what Oklahoma and Missouri's bill is now, and that's what you're looking at. So this is very
similar legislation to Missouri and Oklahoma? Almost identical, yes, sir. Okay. And I know this may be a question for Mr. Burke. With this, if this law passes, what happens to the old statue? Are there any conflicts? Because I don't see where it takes out any of the old law whatsoever. Is there going to be some confusion about what penalty to apply, since there's going to be two different penalties potentially?
Well, it is potentially there. The current law is actually codified in the same chapter. It's in Title 20, Chapter 27, which is the miscellaneous public health. But it's under subsection 201 through 207 or 8. And so it's in the same chapter. It is odd to have two laws that would be in the same chapter. Now, the way the courts would normally interpret that is the latest expression of the legislature would be what is meant to the current law.
So any conflicts between the two, the later act would prevail. But it does not repeal the current law, and I don't know why they didn't do that, but for whatever reason, it's – I don't – Senator Hutchinson, could you address why the
current law wasn't repealed or maybe why you guys just didn't look at the current law and just maybe tweak it a little bit in order to get what you wanted to do? Well, as to the first question, legislative
staff drafted it, and I don't know why they didn't repeal it.
But I don't think there's a conflict either, and I think Ms. Breck's right that they'll look at the last one as – but I don't think there's a conflict. I mean, it's up to $250. This is $250 fine. The Department of Health can do. So the fine is if they would do $250, I mean, there's no conflict. What this adds, though, is a criminal penalty that does not exist in current law, And I think that is a misdemeanor.
I mean, it's not a – I'm going to go on your record. You're not going to – but it is at least a little bit of teeth that we don't have now that I think is needed. And quite frankly, you could up the fine. You could double it to $500, and it doesn't even begin to touch the amount of money they're making off selling these. So if one out of 3,000 they sell, okay, I'll pay a $500 fine. Whoops, I didn't know. And then they continue to sell 2,999 more.
The fine isn't an impediment, at least not much of one. What you need is some criminal, and it's the most minimum. I don't think they're, you know, to be equated with thieves, but there needs to be some criminal violation, so we've done that in this law, as has all the states and the surrounding areas. Okay. Is that good, Representative
Meeks? Yeah, thank you. All right. I don't have any other questions down. Nope. Okay. We're going to go longer.
Representative Womack, you're recognized for a question. Real short. Would you consider – it looks like this might be an easy way to resolve this conflict. Would you just consider removing factory return materials or bedding on page 2, line 16? And I think that would address the opposition's concerns. What's that? Would you consider on page 2, line 16, just removing the words factory return materials or bedding? It looks like that would completely resolve the... I think that would get it.
This is factory return... Can I ask a question, Representative Olmack, and this might clarify. I almost asked earlier, but I just wanted to – is there a difference in just industry terms in a factory return and consumer return? When I read factory return, what I assumed it meant was like a retailer sent it back to the wholesaler or to the manufacturer because of a damaged problem, not a consumer buying one and then returning it. I would say that in layman's terms is a consumer return, not a factory return.
Am I misunderstanding that? And I think that might be the hard question.
Speaker 246
1:29:39
Thank you, Mr. Chair. That's great. Appreciate it. Mr. Chairman, to keep from making a mistake, can I have a factory guy here? Yes. Todd Gerties, would you mind responding to that question? Will you come here and respond
to that question? And I think the easiest way to ask it is, does factory return mean a damaged product that was never purchased by a consumer? That might be the easiest way to ask it.
Speaker 288
1:30:07
that would be a hard way of answering that I'm Todd Gerdes I'm a manufacturers representative I've been a manufacturers representative for 35 years and there are several mattress manufacturer representatives here in the room today who will tell you that for the most part there are not very many scratch and dents sent to distributors it's about 2% of all the beds sold from manufacturers are scratching them. The other 98 percent are returns from consumers. Could you get a little
closer to your mic? I'm sorry. And then, and I guess, again, I think if I'm paraphrasing Representative Womack and apparently Representative Love's question is, in the wording of the bill on page two, whatever line, 13, I think, could you just describe factory return materials or betting for us and what that
Speaker 288
1:31:00
would encompass? Sure. A factory return would be something that It was sent back to the mattress factory, whichever mattress factory it was. And then instead of sent to a landfill, it was sent to a distributor.
But does a mattress that a consumer purchases and then return, would that be included in the factory return definition? Could be. It could be, or is it always? I mean, I think the concern is, are you also including the things, that like a damaged mattress that is returned because it was damaged in shipment or whatever reason that the definition might also include a lot of mattresses that weren't actually purchased and therefore used by a consumer. And
Speaker 288
1:31:42
like I was saying, in most cases, if it's a scratch and dent, it consumes about
2% of our returns. I understand, but
the definition includes both. Right. Okay. All right. Representative Womack, did you have any other questions? Okay, Representative Love,
you're recognized for a question. Mr. Chairman, I think you touched the essence of my question. Mr. Lamb. Mr. Lamb. Randy.
Can you ask the gentleman to sit back down because I do want to. All right, so the question is probably not going to change, but I just want to hear it. Could a factory return mattress also be a new mattress that has never been slept on? Yes, about 2% of them are. Okay. I mean, I don't care about the percentage. I'm just asking. Is that a factory return mattress could be a mattress that has never been slept on?
Correct. Okay, thank you. Mr. Chair, can I, and I'm willing to amend it to get that, but before I do, I've got a constituent of mine here who likes to address this because he says there's something we're
missing. And it's as much as my fault as anybody, but I just want to stop and keep going with the procedure. If he wants to sign up to testify, I think that would be the better way to do it. Okay, instead of just playing ping-pong here. All right. I don't have anybody else for a question for Mr. Land.
So did you have anything else to add on that, what we were talking about, the definition, sir? Okay. All right. Then no other questions. Now we have several more people signed up to speak for and against. Representative
Wardlaw, you're recognized for motion. I'll make a motion
limit debate five minutes each side. Everybody like five minutes? Okay. All right. We've got a motion to limit debate to five minutes each side. Any discussion on the motion? All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? All right. Debate is limited. So for members of the audience, what that means, you've got five minutes to speak for, five minutes to speak against, keeping in mind that the closing of the sponsor of the bill will also be deducted from the closing or from the four side.
So five minutes, and I'll just tell you where we've got. We've got one signed up to speak against. It's Carlton Saffa, and then we've got Dustin Ferguson, Sylvester Smith, John Paul Wells, and Curtis Ferguson to sign up for. And he would like Curtis to go first. We'll start with the only other person against, which is Carlton Saffa. Mr. Saffa, if you'll join us at the end of the table, say your name for the record. You're recognized to speak against the bill.
Speaker 299
1:34:50
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I don't know what qualifications I have to speak to you all other than the fact that I'm a consumer and someone who's followed politics pretty closely for the last few years. I've never spoken on behalf or against a bill. But I was inspired to put my name on the list a few minutes ago, actually by some remarks from Representative Harris and then later some remarks by Representative Meeks. I don't want to get into the weeds of health department code and regulation. I'm not a doctor. I'm not a lawyer. I don't understand them.
But I do understand that this bill opens a Pandora's box of further regulation. Representative Meeks, you did a great job, I think, of pointing out that this is duplicative. There are already laws on the books that could address this. In fact, it reminds me a lot of the gun debate that we have. Let's enforce the laws that we have rather than add additional laws. I think the health department indicated this would be a rarity where we would have a law that duplicates another law. And Senator Hutchinson himself acknowledged that the folks in legislative drafting may have made an error in even writing this bill.
So why don't we eliminate the other law? Why do we create the law? I joked to someone in the back a minute ago. I was looking around for my friend Dean Elliott because I'm curious. Will Dillard's have a bill next session to put T.J. Maxx out of business? Is that the idea now? Do the mainline dealers want to put the discounters out of business? Is Steinmart next? And how about Savers? I don't know the history of Hank's Fine Furniture, but as I understand it, they began in much the same way as a freight company selling Denton Scratch items.
I guess what I would say to you all is this. After I leave here, I have to return a sport coat. It's one that I ordered two weeks ago, and it's too big. I lost a little bit of weight, thank God. is that a used sport coat? I don't know. But I wore it for about 15 minutes at home trying to figure out if it fit or not. I tried it on with a few shirts. Now, does Joseph A. Bank have to label that as used? And I mean this in all seriousness, guys. What's the difference between a mattress and a sport coat? Another thing I would say to you, it's interesting that the proponents
of this bill have not provided one instance where this is really a problem. In fact, I think the only example they gave us from oceans 11 they went to a Hollywood movie to provide you where this is really a problem I've sat in committee and listened to victims talk about problems before where are the victims in here today this is as governor Beebe said about another bill something it's something in search of a problem the folks who are here today against this bill me and and folks who sell the product I think we have an interesting
viewpoint. I don't like the bill, not because I care about mattresses, but because I don't think that we should be able to put folks out of business legislatively. And I think that's what's occurring. Again, this is a Pandora's box about returned items and used items. Is the coat I'm taking back this afternoon going to have to be labeled as used? Does it have to have a big sticker on it? They de-tagged it when I took it out of the store. I guess they can put the tags back on. And finally, I'd address, I guess, the idea of bed bugs, because I think that's a big buzzword that someone had introduced into this debate. I think it's really tainted the debate.
Everyone in this room, unless you're a local legislator, is sleeping on a mattress today that's either in the Capitol Hill apartments or in a motel room. And I promise you, you're far more likely to face bedbugs at the Clarion Inn or wherever it is you're staying tonight than on a mattress that's in a bag that's sold from a manufacturer. So before we get in a tizzy about bed bugs, you might check your pillow tonight. I guess all I have to say, guys, is don't get into the weeds about health department regulation. We've heard from the health department themselves
that this is duplicative. Representative Misha did a great job of pointing that out. Representative Harris does a great job of pointing out that this may be an overreach and an overregulation. But if you do this, if you address mattresses with legislation, what's to keep Dean from coming next week or next session to protect used suits? What's to keep someone from outlawing outlets stores. My wife loves outlet stores. And a lot of the stuff in those outlet stores and outlet malls comes in as a return or an exchange. Now, there are items that are clearly damaged, but there are items that aren't. And in fact, I've bought some of those items before.
Polo shirt for $20. There's got to be something different about that. So anyway, I'm rambling, guys, but I just wanted to talk to you about the overarching idea here. And that is this is a free market issue. And you are legislatively addressing a problem for which there is already a law on the books, and which opens a Pandora's box a huge problem. So I would encourage a good vote and would really appreciate one just as a consumer. And in my mind, a good vote would be no. Thank you very much.
Thank you. Next on the list, that's the end of the against. Next on the list, I think you said the sponsor request of Mr. Curtis Ferguson to go first.
So, again, we're at five minutes against, keeping in mind to reserve a little bit of balance for the close. My name is Curtis. Sorry, five minutes, four. Yeah,
Speaker 302
1:39:52
I won't take five minutes. Curtis Ferguson, I'm a retailer. And I have sat through fantasy here today. I mean, I know Goldilocks and the Three Bears, but this business about all this stuff being set back, scratch and dent, and big truckloads of scratch and dent, that is fantasy.
In fact, there should be some Pinocchio awards handed out because here's the deal on the mattress. You have major manufacturers who give extremely long warranties. Customers take advantage of those warranties. They take the mattress back. We give them a new one. We ship it back to Sealy, Serta, Simmons, whoever. They sell it to these jobbers, and they put a nice plastic package around it and sell it in truckload lots. And then you add Sleepy's, which is the biggest sleep store on the East Coast, and Macy's,
handle their own warranties and I have in my hand truck load offers from these and some and most of them say and these are very clean these mattresses are look very clean these are used mattresses that have been shipped back to manufacturers who are jobbing them out into that it's an epidemic now this is not scratching dent that is a that is bull Thank you. This is used, used, used, and it's not a sport coat deal where you put it on for 15 minutes.
People spend a third of their life in a bed, and they, hey, Chris, how you doing? They blow their breath on it, and then, you know, yeah, this is a great new mattress, and this little spot on here, oh, that was a roof leak or the trailer truck. Hey, this scratch on the side or whatever, these are used mattresses. It's an epidemic that's going on. The bed bug is not a fantasy. Here is a national bedding magazine that says the bed bug epidemic starts in Chicago,
goes to Cleveland, Columbus, Philadelphia, where all those Macy's and Sleepy's stores are that's shipping them in here by the truckload. If you don't believe the bed bugs are real, go over to Lowe's, Home Depot, and Walmart. Look at that full shelf of bed bug poison. It's here, and they're shipping it in. Now, listen, this is a simple deal. You're either for the consumer or not. You're either, you stand in the gate for the consumer. These guys are peddling those used bids and calling them new.
It's going on all over the state. It's a fraud. And I can tell you it needs to stop. And it's just, it's a black and white issue. It's a good bill. It really addresses past that retailer. I don't want to go out and file a lawsuit on a fellow retailer. But I can tell you this. If this bill passes, we'll send a message to Seeley, Serta, Simmons, and Macy's, and Sleepy's that they have to tag this used before they give it to that jobber to send it in here. Then the guy says he's only getting three out of 100 that's used.
have a big yellow tag on it. Okay. This is a real good bill. Thank you. All right. Man, I thought Medicaid was going to be the most passionate issue of the day. it's like I mean all right two minutes left we've got it was Dustin Ferguson and Curtis Ferguson together so we can scratch Dustin off the list okay John
Paul Wells is the last person to speak for so sir if you'll speak for we've got two minutes left and you know how it works so we'll leave Senator Hutchinson request about
Speaker 305
1:43:37
30 seconds thank you very much mr. chairman I've been in the southern mattresses for 58 years now and I can't remember the last time I sent back and I know I have some time but I can't remember the last time I sent back a stretch and dent if you see them if you see a mattress it's that much discounted it's been in somebody's house and somebody's sleep don't it some of
these mattresses have up to 10 year warranties I may have been somebody's house nine and a half years now that's what maybe a little stretch but you know a lot of them three four or five years been slept on and they sent them back to the factory they repackaged them and sell them you see these guys set up in parking lots selling mattresses you're more than likely buying a used mattress if it doesn't have a warranty with it you're buying a used mattress that's been slept in somebody's house for a
Chairman. Thank you, Mr. Wells. All right. We've got about one minute left. Senator Hutchinson, Representative Hammer,
you're recognized to close. Well, I'll just briefly try to cut through all the debate. This bill addresses used mattresses, not didn't scratch. If somebody doesn't know that it's used, then they're certainly not violating the misdemeanor because that's got to have criminal intent. And if you didn't know, you're not going to be convicted of that.
But if you do know, and as Mr. Ferguson said, it's usually the guys over in New Jersey or in Chicago who are doing this as a racket. We've got to be able to have some way to enforce the laws. And I agree. We're not adding new laws. We're enforcing our existing laws. The current enforcement mechanism is not working, and we need to strengthen it. And that's all this bill does. And I'll let Representative Hammer use up the remainder of time if he likes.
That would be easy. I don't think there is any. So, sorry, Representative Hammer. All right, members, you've heard debate and testimony on the bill. What's the pleasure of Representative Wardlaw? Y'all want to say at the same time, Overby and Wardlaw both requested to make the motion. So, all right. Motion. Motion do pass. Any discussion on the motion, members? Okay. All in favor, say aye.
Aye. Any opposed? Chair rules the ayes have it. Okay. All right. Congratulations. You passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair and committee. Okay, everybody, everybody that was here for the mattress bill, if you could slip on out
and let everybody sit down in a used chair. We're going to do House Bill 1190 next. Okay, if everybody kind of expedited here, we need to get started.
So if you're talking, please go outside or stop talking. We need to get started. We're going to do $11.90 next. Good job. We're going to do $11.90 next. Members, now that the bed bug discussion is over, I'm going to tell you that there's sandwiches back here. And I always say it, I know it's rude to eat in front of people, so I'm sorry for the audience, but we go right into session this afternoon, and we're probably going to be in session for a real long time, probably until supper time, so we don't get much of a break.
And so I'm sorry to eat in front of you, but there's no other way to do it. Why don't we do it like this? We're going to start 1190, and just casually, who's ever hungriest can start it, grab a sandwich one or two at a time, try to do it quietly, and we'll just do that as we're hearing testimony from Representative Hammer. So all that being said, if everybody gets settled one last time, Representative Hammer, you're recognized to present House Bill 1190.
Thank you, Mr. Chair, and it is not my intent to call any witnesses. I'll just share that up on the front. I just wanted to – and would you please clarify, for the record, we did get the amendment passed in the last meeting. And – The amendment is – attached
or engrossed? It's not engrossed. It's not engrossed. The amendment is attached to the bill, I guess, in the form of a paper clip. You have a hard copy in front of you. Okay. All right. So there you go.
Go ahead. Okay. Basically, what I wanted to say with regards to the amendment as it is attached to the bill is, first of all, that it is amended not to change, but to bring a greater level of assurance to some of the issues that were expressed in the committee the other day. Secondly, we affirmed, and we did double-check with Jay Bradford's office with regards to one of the issues.
and if they're here, they can speak to it, that passage of this bill will not interfere should, in the event the private option go through, it should not be a hindrance to that. Also, the amendment reinstates that it does not expand the scope of practice, and the most important thing is it keeps the final authority with the legislative body. The Board of Nursing is the governing body that is responsible to discipline nurses who step outside the scope of practice just as the medical board is charged
with the responsibility to discipline their doctors. So as far as confusing the terminology that's in any portion of the bill to imply that the nurse practitioners are being given greater authority beyond their scope of practice is not accurate. Reports show or have shown that we are not keeping up with meeting the needs of the Medicaid population. That's part of the reason why we're going through the debate that we are on health care. And I would only have to point to your attention as recently as an hour ago that we passed a piece of legislation.
And you may remember, and if you have your handbooks that we gave to you, and I pulled out the copy, one of the things that was stated in that bill a while ago was the phrase Medicaid primary care case manager. And if you were to look into Section 9 of your book and you were to look at the part that was tabbed for you, the exact terminology that was in the bill that was passed a while ago was referenced in print as it conforms to the Medicare and the private insurance guidelines and the Medicaid guidelines that a nurse practitioner is able to operate in the function of a PCCM as referenced in that bill a while ago.
And as far as why we need to pass this bill, I would only point to you the law that was passed out of this committee a while ago, referred out of this committee a while ago, that in the very back section of the law that we passed out of here, it says this section does not require a physician to participate in the pilot program created under this section. It goes on to say, a physician has the right to refuse the contract under the pilot program created under the section or to terminate the contract at any time without penalty.
House Bill 1190 does not expand scope of practice. It does not remove the collaborative arrangement that is required. It still requires a legislative session or legislative body to be involved in the process of any changing of scope of practice. And we, by virtue of need or by law, are about to inherit a caseload of individuals that are going to comply to the Medicaid guidelines of the 138 percent. And the only question I would ask you before you take the vote is this. An hour ago, we passed a bill that allowed doctors not to be involved in the process by law.
Why would we not pass a bill that would allow nurses to be involved in the process to the level of their scope of practice? why would we not do that now and allow them to share the responsibility? I'm not asking doctors to be nurses, and I'm not asking nurses to be doctors. I'm just asking to let them operate within the function of their capability and draw your attention to what we voted out of here an hour ago and ask that you give this bill the same consideration with the due pass. Mr. Chairman, I do not intend to call any witnesses on my half.
We debated this thing well. That's what I'm speaking to. I will be glad to take questions or answers the chair directs okay thank you representative
hammer members let's let's roll through it fast I know y'all know we got a lot of bills to get to representative board law first question thank you mr. chair representative
hammer these nurse practitioners have the same exact level of education that these doctors that you're referring to while ago have no sir and
I did not imply that what I wanted to draw attention to was
that as far as the terminology that was in the bill an hour ago and the terminology that's allowed under the present law as to what capacity they can operate, that there is common ground and that there is that ability, that they are recognized as being able to be authorized for payment to their
level. Does your bill not give them equal representation under Medicaid, though? It
gives them the opportunity to be reimbursed up to the standards and guidelines of which Medicaid says that they can be reimbursed.
Okay, but is that equal? No, because some things a doctor
cannot do. Okay, thank you. Thank you. Representative Ferguson. Since Representative Hammer is choosing to use my own bill against me, I think I deserve the right to reply. Perhaps I didn't find it necessary to go at length to explain the program that Representative Wardlaw, and I want to do, the primary care case manager in our program is still the physician.
The nurses that will be hired under this plan really don't even treat patients. They go into homes and make sure people are taking their medications. They do more administrative functions to control the cost of care. We're in no way making. I'm sorry. Representative Malone. Point of
trying to do, that should have been explained during her bill, and Representative Hammer is presenting his bill, and it's question time only.
would just ask that we keep it to question. Well, I will ask it as a question. Representative Ferguson, let me just say, that's a point. Representative Hammer, don't bring up that bill. Representative Ferguson won't have to talk about
no correlation is what I'm trying to say. okay all right representative meeks you recognize for a question thank you representative hammer
do you know if after these changes if the medical
society or any of the other groups that oppose it or have they changed their stance at all that you're aware of
to my position to my knowledge a raise where they were the other day and the reason I introduced the amendments was bring a greater level of security to the committee and also to address their concerns without compromising the original intent of the bill oh well I'd like to say thank you for at least being open to that and doing
that wouldn't you agree yes I would thank you thank you mr. thank you representative love motion of the proper time okay representative link
represent hammer part of what you change and we talked about this amendment a bit on Tuesday today's Thursday yeah is one of my big concerns my concern has been procedurally which is getting over to the rules and regs part of it and so tell me how right now that a the scope of practice if you will of nurse practitioners determined and how it will be determined if this bill passes is there change in house determined how is it determined now as far as how as I've
stated in previous testimony I think was is also made reaffirmed in previous testimony scope of practice is determined ultimately by the legislative body the nurse the nursing board oversees the nurses and if they if a nurse steps outside of the scope of practice it's their responsibility to discipline them to the appropriate measure much as is in pharmacy board or any of the other boards and ultimately and I stated it for emphasis in the bill And it says whether service or cost is within the scope and licensure of an advanced nurse
practitioner shall be interpreted by the Arkansas State Board of Nursing according to the rules reviewed by the Legislative Council. Ultimately, it's got to clear by us. So the Nursing
Board can or cannot change the scope of practice?
To my understanding, it was never the intent, and that was proven in the debate, rather lengthy debate in the rules, that it is not the intent of this bill, nor does this bill give authority to change scope of
practice and and right now the nursing board cannot
change to my knowledge no they cannot legally okay okay thank you
and if anybody's in the room and wants to it's the chair's discretion I just want to be honest open
and transparent chairs discretion okay thank you members any other questions represent a branch can be recognized for a
Speaker 327
1:58:11
question or are you surrendering thank you mr. chair representative hammer has a I appreciate the intent of this bill and and I'm not all that against it but I have a son that will be entering med school this this fall and he's going to
be facing another seven years of intense studies so if this bill were to pass would would he not be better off just to go for the nurse practitioner of two years and be done with it?
I'm sure we've all received the emails that have been sent out by the nursing staff at the Med Center. I hope at their own interest level and nothing beyond that. But I would say this. This bill doesn't change anything. A doctor can only do what a doctor can do. A nurse practitioner can only do what a nurse practitioner can do. In fact, the way I see the beauty of this
in my way of looking down the road that we're in all potential practicality is going to be taking on a large Medicaid population, which is already underserved, that this would open it up so that at the level, kind of like I used the other day, to the ceiling level that nurse practitioners are able to function within, that they would be able to be involved in the process to help meet the needs of the Medicaid population to that ceiling
level. But there's always going to be people that go above that ceiling level. And doctors, and I'm not a doctor, but this is just from talking to doctors, being around the medical field to the level that I have, that there are always the time slots for the doctors are competed for. I had somebody the other day tell me I can't get into my doctor until Friday. In my way of thinking, this should help address that issue by allowing the worst-case scenarios to be seen by the doctors
who have been trained to that level and should only see those patients in that case and in that
Speaker 327
2:00:06
scenario. One follow-up. And I don't disagree with you, but we all know we've seen the studies and hear the reports that we're facing, this country's facing a major doctor shortage. Do you think this bill would in any way contribute to a doctor shortage in the future? I mean, in saying that there are going to be few less going into the doctor profession and more going to the nurse practitioner
because it is going to be such a shorter time frame and less expense? I don't know if you meant to. Would it help create
this, would it make a problem even worse? Well, I don't know if you meant to, but you may have just made my case by saying there's a severe doctor shortage, number one. Number two, no, I do not. You know, doctors are driven to be doctors because they want to be doctors. Nurses are driven to be nurses because they want to be nurses. Pharmacists are driven to be pharmacists because they want to be pharmacists. And the motive of what's driving me to this is not because of any other reason
other than it opens up the opportunity for the Medicaid population to be seen at an entry point level to the ability of the nurse practitioner without going above that and reserving more time for the doctors to have the ability to meet the worst-case needs and scenarios. All right. Thank you, Mr. Chair. It's like
y'all are doing it on purpose, you know, catching me in between a bite. I don't have anybody else signed up or any other questions.
So seeing no other questions, thank you for the presentation, Representative Hammer. Thank you. We do have a lot of people sign up to speak against the bill. Only one. Okay, good. Mr. David Roten with the Arkansas Medical Society. Mr. Roten, if you'll join us at the end of the table, you'll be recognized to speak
against the bill. David Roten with the Arkansas Medical Society, and again, I apologize for my voice.
As much as we would love to do it, we still cannot support Representative Hammer's bill. The language that has been added really doesn't make any changes. The first language that deals with the PCP issue is basically repeating what current federal law says now, which defers to the state. under current law Arkansas Medicaid program could have chosen when they established the PCP program several years ago to allow nurse practitioners and physicians assistants to service PCPs they chose not to they chose not to for
very good reasons now that's been a while but this bill doesn't change that it just simply references what the federal law says there this issue is not about the quality of care provided by advanced practice nurses we're not here to contest that it is the role that an advanced practice nurse and other physician extenders should play in the health care system I couldn't agree more with what representative hammer just said and that is that we need to let
advanced practice nurses and physician assistants take care of a lot of patients that don't have problems that need to be seen by a physician but we believe strongly that that physician needs to be there for when they do need to see the physician and what this bill does it takes the physician completely out of the mix because it allows an advanced practice nurse independently in an office by him or herself with no physician supervision no physician
involvement whatsoever to be the primary care provider for that patient none of the other payers in Arkansas do that and that was mentioned last week that they do Blue Cross Medicare none of those programs have a primary care case management program in Arkansas furthermore this is the Blue Cross Blue Shield coverage policy for advanced practice nurses in it it's very clear
services provided by ANPs are limited to those patients presenting problems of low to moderate severity in the medical decision-making has to be the same they do not pay for advanced practice nurses to see patients in a hospital a PCP the physician managing the care of a patient needs to be able to see patients in the hospital they need to be able to admit patients to a hospital Arkansas rules and regulations do not allow advanced practice nurses to admit or discharge
patients to a hospital furthermore the Blue Cross policy says that APN should be participating as a team member in the provision of medical and health care interacting with physicians and by the way just in case those of you that wonder Blue Cross pays APNs 75% of what they pay physicians that is their current rule the Medicare coverage policy for nurse practitioners is very
similar it says they should work with one or more physicians to deliver health care services within the scope of their practice then we move to the scope of practice issue itself and this is where the real problem is the provision in the current bill sounds great but here's the problem this is the nursing board rules and regulations for advanced practice nurses chapter 4 section 1 scope of practice in accordance with the scope of practice
defined by the appropriate national certifying body the nursing board's own rules have deferred their authority to these national certifying bodies for which you have no control or authority over and that is the crux of the problem with the scope of practice of APNs it's not about the disciplinary process this bill doesn't deal with disciplining an advanced practice nurse the bill the
part of the bill that deals with scope of practice is that Medicaid needs to know what is in the scope of practice of an advanced practice nurse in order to know what to pay them for past efforts working with the nursing board have been woefully unacceptable and unsuccessfully trying to do that we come over here year after year fighting this battle and the battle happens because the statute on advanced practice nurses doesn't even say anything about scope of practice
the nursing board rules defer to national certifying bodies ladies and gentlemen the only way I know that we're ever going to resolve this issue is for this committee send a message to the nursing board and the medical board. You guys get together and come up with some guidelines on what is within the scope of practice or what's not of advanced practice nurses and bring them back to you during the next legislative session so that you can deal with it once and for all.
Again, we'll stand behind the testimony the other day about the difference between a primary care physician and an advanced practice nurse this bill elevates the advanced practice nurse to the same level as your local family doctor and we just do not think that's right they need to be working with doctors in a team environment and that way everybody gets the best
quality care thank you thank you Mr. Roden members representative Ferguson you're recognized for a
question well I think someone from Medicaid might be here
that might clarify some of this what APNs can do in the list Is there someone here? I thought it was someone from Medicaid. Representative Ferguson, let me go. Let me make
sure here, and we'll do that before we close, okay? Okay. All right. Is there anybody else to speak for against the bill? Representative Bluff, you had a question? Sure, I did. No, no, no, no, no. Thank you, Mr. Chair. You had a question? Yes. Okay, yeah. For Mr. Roten? Yes. Okay, yeah. Mr. Roten, come back, please.
Yes, sir. Mr. Roden, I listened to your testimony, and you were saying that the doctors and the nurses should have gotten together and, you know, worked out the scope of practice. And I know that Representative Hammer has been working on this bill for a while. Did you try to take the time to amend this bill with the same? We offered
some amendments before the first round of testimony, and they were rejected.
Okay, all right That's all I need to know. Thank you Okay members any other questions? All right. Thank you There's nobody else on to speak for against representative Ferguson. You wanted Medicaid to join us here If y'all want to join us say your name for the record
Speaker 337
2:09:14
we recognize Make a statement if you wish or answer a question Thank you, mr. Chair I'm Brett Hopkins with the Department of Human Services with me is Marilyn Strickland And if you would restate
your question whichever one of us can best answer it Well, I think maybe a part of this, the reason for this bill is that you might clarify that how we've been told that Medicaid's not worked with the APNs in the past on their request for a list of services.
Can you, is that true? And can
you kind of clarify that? Yes, Representative Ferguson, I can address that. We worked back in the fall of 2011. The nurses, the APN, sent us quite an extensive list to look at and to determine which ones, you know, we would be able to cover. We actually sent those to our quality improvement organization, Arkansas Foundation for Medical Care, had them to review and had to, because simply because they have the specialties to do that,
be it advanced practice nurses, to determine which of those codes were appropriate for them to deliver, or they were qualified to deliver. We actually got a list, I think, of about either 115 to 155 codes. We sat down with the representatives from the Nursing Association as late as October of 2011. We were ready to promulgate those codes, actually begin them through the APA process, and they indicated to me and my staff
that they first wanted to get agreement with their association members, and unfortunately, we did not hear back from them. We actually had a computer service request report ready to put those in the system and have those ready for payment, I believe, it was in June 2012, to get it through the APA process. So we have always been open to working with the advanced practice nurses but they've been
unwilling to agree to Elias to say well they never
came back to us in fact at that point I was working Linda Tyler
representative Tyler so was working with him and she kept calling wanting to know had I heard back well I had not representative love you recognize for question
thank you mr. chairman mr. Strickland did you did I hear you correctly say that you have an agreed upon list that you all are ready to input, but you haven't heard back from the nurses? Yes, sir, you do. You did hear that. Do
interested in looking at that list. Sure. Thank you. No problem. Oh,
certainly. Okay. How about Mr. Price, and he'll send it to the committee. Excellent. All right. Okay. Any other questions? I will ask, is there anybody here from – were you referencing the nursing board? If we're going to continue to go back and forth and ping-pong, we might as well get both sides. So is anybody here that would like to speak about the testimony that was just given? Okay. Then thank you for the testimony, Ms. Strickland.
If you'll join us at the end of the table, you
are recognized to tell us that everything they just said is wrong. Good morning, my name is Dr. Darlene Byrd, I am an advanced practice nurse and I have been working with Marilyn Strickland honestly since 2004 in regards to the CPT codes. The latest meetings that she represented basically stopped when Jean Gessau left and the
The change in administration pretty well stopped the negotiations. The codes that she mentioned, the Arkansas Nursing Association presented her with a list of codes, and it was more than just about 150. It was several hundred codes that we feel like are within our scope of practice and codes that has at one time been vetted by the Arkansas Board of Nursing.
The codes that they came back with was a very limited set of codes that still does not recognize our full scope of practice, which we feel is mandated by federal Medicaid rules and regs. The major problem that we have with the process is that they have gone to Blue Cross, they have gone to AFMC, they have gone to everybody besides the Board of Nursing who has the expertise in determining, excuse me, wrong word,
in interpreting our scope of practice as set forth by the Legislative Council. They, in this last round, they never contacted the Board of Nursing from the information that I have received from Sue Tefford, the executive director. Thank you. Okay, thank you. Now, members,
we've heard, and whatever the outcome here, I think we can all agree if I'm rarely labeled a peacemaker, but I'll be happy to facilitate
whatever meetings we need to make happen, so maybe the next legislative session we don't have to be here going through all this again. um representative hammer you want to close for your bill i'm gonna
close make it real short and sweet what you just heard was that there's a list that's been prepared okay it was acknowledged there was a list that's been prepared so then it begs the question what is stopping that effort from moving forward change of administration whatever reason you want to make whatever reason
you want to use you have an opportunity to move this forward and i'll be honest with you i probably lost a few doctor friends over this I probably gained a few nursing friends over this that's irrelevant that doesn't really matter what matters is that through this method and through this means everything that we've been talking about through this session about helping control cost and provide accessible access to medical treatment and let me just bring your thought attention to this how long has this problem been working on and we were asked a minute
ago two more years and we can get this we've been waiting two more years for how
many years appreciate a good vote thank you representative hammer members you've heard testimony for the bill and against the bill what's the pleasure of the committee representative love makes a motion do pass any discussion on the motion all in favor say aye all opposed all right yeah let's just roll call
Speaker 353
2:16:13
Representative Word, Representative Word, Representative Butch Wilkins, Representative Butch Wilkins, Representative Perry, Representative Malone, Representative Hank Wilkins, representative lading representative love representative link
representative harris representative harris representative wardlaw representative hammer Representative Branscombe, Representative Meeks, Representative Mayberry, Representative Mayberry.
Representative Overby, Representative Ritchie, Representative Womack, Representative Ferguson, Vice-Chair Murdoch, Vice-Chair Murdoch, Chair Burroughs.
Sorry, Representative Hammer, you failed to pass your bill. May I say one thing of a positive nature? Yes. If nothing else, as was mentioned a while ago, this should push to good communications between the two parties, and I look forward to working in the future to make it a better health care system. Thank you. Thank
you. It does seem like we've been playing counselor today for about two hours. Representative Love, you have a question? Yes, I have a question
I would share. Chair, is it possible that we could send this bill to interim study?
Yeah, if you want to – we could have sponged the vote, sent it to a withdrawal calendar. No, I mean, the
He can still do that. All right, you can do that without any action from us, so I think that's a good idea. Thank you. Okay, well, the next wave can exit, and we're going to go – we've got about an hour left, and I do thank you all for being patient and being here. I know everybody's time is valuable. We have three bills that I would like to hear as much as I would like to do what's possible on.
It's SB 50, SB 875, SB 38. We're going to start with SB 850. I think that's Senator Hendren. Senator Hendren, you're recognized. Thank
you, Mr. Chairman and members of the committee. I start to say this is not a very controversial bill, but you never know around here, but hopefully it's not. This bill is, I think, good for our economy.
It's good for our businesses. It's not going to cause anything to cause any jeopardy to the benefits that we're paying out. So let me just tell you what Senate Bill 850 does. Right now, employers have been saddled with some additional taxes because the recession led the state to have to borrow several hundred million dollars from the federal government. Well, to pay the interest on that loan, the employers were hit with additional taxes. Those taxes have not been credited. They're unemployment accounts like their traditional unemployment taxes are. So this bill takes care of that so that they get credit for those taxes that they're paying in.
That's what the first part of the bill does there on page 1, and it also says it on the top of page 2 there. The next thing it does is it puts in place a reduction of that tax depending on the level of the fund. So nothing would happen until January 2014, and then if you look on the last page there, if the fund balance is less than one-half of a percent of the total payrolls, then instead of it being 0.7, it would be down two-tenths of a percent to 0.5 percent. And it does the same thing if the fund balance continues to improve or does not improve.
Instead of it being 0.8, which is what it would be without this bill, it would take it down to 0.6. So the purpose of the – and let me just say, Department of Workforce Services has said this will not make it to where we can't pay back the $200 million plus we owe to the federal government by the end of 2014. But what this will do is those triggers are met, and as this fund begins to recover, it will remove some of the burden that we've placed on employers because of this recession. It's not going to – they're still going to be able to meet their obligations, but instead of rapidly building up a trust fund,
what it's going to do is remove some of that interest tax that has been being applied to employers. So I believe and I think many of us believe that we should not take more from the employers than is necessary to keep this fund solvent, and this does that. It removes the burden that we put on them because of the recession, keeps the fund solvent, but it makes it possible for us, again, to allow employers who have paid literally billions over the last five years in unemployment insurance to have a little bit of relief from that
so they can invest in making new jobs and hiring more people and buying new equipment. So I think it's a good jobs creation bill and gives our employers some relief that they've earned. So I'll be happy to answer any questions.
Thank you, Senator Hendren. Members, any questions? Representative Link, you're recognized. Let's go back to the part where the very
first part of the explanation says it's going to credit the employers for paying that, I guess, the stabilization tax. Correct. What's happening now?
It's going into the general fund, but unlike all the rest of the 7% or whatever it is they pay that's credited to their account, then you take the amount that is charged to their account for claims and you use that to determine their experience ratio. They're not getting any credit for that. It's just going into the general account, and it's not being credited to their account. They're paying the tax, but unlike the rest of the taxes they're paying, they're not getting credit for it specifically
by firm or by company okay thanks thank you members any other questions okay seeing none
we have one person sounded to speak against mr. Alan Hughes you'll say your name for
the record you're recognized thank you mr. chairman my name is Alan Hughes I'm president of the Arkansas state FLCO. We're here opposing Senate Bill 850 today because our advisory committee is appointed by the governor. I've mentioned several cases here before go over this made up of business, labor, and the general public. The concern is about the trust fund. There's only two eighty two million dollars in that trust
fund right now. We still owe 217 million to the federal government and a point six is one number but twenty four million dollars what you'd be taken out going towards the trust fund we still owe that debt I've always heard about skin in the game last session they took sixty million dollars away from unemployed workers by cutting a week's benefit and reducing their index there's no increase anymore to keep up the cost of living if we're gonna have skin in the game I think we ought to keep this fund like it is what he's talking about
not passing this bill let that fund built up watch we've encouraged them over the years we've stated time after time we'd have had 500 million in there what we thought would be right we wouldn't been paying this debt back but what happens if the economy makes a quick turnaround we're right back to borrowing money again also there's a trigger when it goes up to 169 million there's stabilization tax drops again so if you're taking out 24 million now it goes down another point two you're taking another 24 million out I think
We ought to keep everybody paying this and make sure we secure that fund. I appreciate the
vote against this bill. Thank you, members. Any questions for Mr. Hughes? Seeing none, thank you for your testimony. We have two people signed up to speak for. First is Mr. Gordon Gondek. If you'll join us at the end of the table, you'll
recognize to speak for the bill. No, thank you. My name is Gordon Gondek. I'm with Dixie Restaurants, and I'm speaking on behalf of Muntean McNulty and the Hospitality Association.
850, the Senator's bill here. Could you get us a little closer to the mic, please? I beg your pardon. It gives some much-needed relief to the business people in Arkansas. I know Mr. Hughes talked about we have to build up the safety net. We have to build up the safety net, surely, but we're not asking for a huge chunk of money. In the last five years, and I got these numbers from DWS, in the last five years, Arkansas employers, who are the only people that fund unemployment, it's not like Social Security that employees pay into it.
Arkansas employers paid $1.876 billion, that's billion with a B, for Arkansas unemployment benefits, and that averages out to $375 million a year. What we're asking for in this $24 million here is 6.4% of what we would normally pay in the average of the last five years. that allows us
to take care of our business allows us to hire some more people but it does not it's not going to stop the fund from getting paid the government's $360 million that we borrowed from them that's still going to be paid off by the end of 2014 even with this money this small relief that we're asking for Okay, thank you Thank you for your testimony. Members, any questions?
Seeing none, thank you for your testimony. Next, the last person to sign up to speak is Mr. Sylvester Smith. She'll join us at the end of the table. Say your name. You're recognized to present
or speak for the bill. My name is Sylvester Smith, and I'm a contract lobbyist and business consultant. I'm here today representing the National Federation of Independent Business. As always, Mr. Chairman, members of the committee, I will try to be brief. I represent about 4,000 small business owners, and as Gordon just said, Gordon's one of my members, all of the money in this fund is paid by business owners, and what we're asking
is for you to allow us use of our money and enable us to invest in our business, and I certainly understand Mr. Hughes' concern. It's a legitimate concern. Arkansans have suffered through tough times during the recession, and this fund is important. and it needs to be there for our Kansans in the darkest hours and periods of unemployment. And if we're wrong and if the economy does take a nosedive and the fund balance goes down, then we will be back here in two years, head in hand, saying we're going to have to pay more.
And we believe that it should be you should seek our guidance here and allow us to invest our funds back into our businesses. Thank you, and I'll take any questions anybody may have.
Representative Meeks, you're recognized for a question. And it's my
understanding right now that if the fund balance stays below a certain amount per year, that businesses already have to pay in additional taxes. I have gotten contacted from a lot of businesses that in January had to pay, I think, like 6% or 8% or something else like that above what they actually normally pay.
So it would seem to me that there is already a trigger in place that if that fund balance does go down and below, So then businesses know that they're going to actually have to pay.
Wouldn't you agree with that? Yes, sir. That's correct. But what happened is two years ago, and someone else can correct me if I'm wrong, because there had been this historic period of negative balances, we agreed to raise those premiums for everybody across the board in addition to that mechanism that you're talking about. And if there is another historic negative trend,
then we would have to come back to the table and do this again. At the end of the day, no one pays into this fund but us. So as the fund goes, so do our premiums. And to Representative Link's point, the reason why it's so important that we get these funds attributed to our individual accounts is your premium expense is determined based upon your history. And if you have a negative history based upon having too many people ending up on the benefit from your company, then your premiums go up. So what's happening is we're paying more in premiums, but we're not getting the financial benefit of the math working out in our favor when a certain number of our employees come and have to receive the benefit.
Okay. Members, any other questions? Okay. Thank you for your testimony. Thank you for your time. Senator
Hendren, would you like to close for your bill? Yeah, briefly. I just want to thank you for your time. I think, again, you've heard the facts. This is the employer's tax that they pay, and they're asking since they came up here and allowed the taxes to be raised to meet the need of this recession, that they'd be allowed now to remove that so that they can continue to make this economy grow. I look at this a lot like my wife is chairman of a missions account in our church,
and our philosophy has always been the money doesn't do any good sitting in the bank. It needs to be out doing what it's intended to do. And I think that's the same thing as there are, as Representative Meeks mentioned, there are provisions in the current law in addition to this that's going to stop it from going insolvent. And if we get to a position where the economy falls off a cliff again, we all know we'll be borrowing from the federal government again, this tax will go back on. But in the meantime, let's give employers every opportunity to get this thing going and create some more jobs.
That's the best solution for unemployment is to create more jobs. So
I'd appreciate a good vote. okay thank you for the testimony members you've heard a presentation on the bill what's the pleasure of the committee got a motion do pass any discussion on the motion if not
Speaker 353
2:31:08
all in favor say aye any opposed ayes have it call the roll representative word representative word representative butch wilkins representative
butch wilkins representative perry representative perry representative malone representative wilkin hank wilkins representative letting representative love representative link representative harris representative harris representative wardlaw representative wardlaw
Representative Hammer Representative Branscombe Representative Meeks Representative Mayberry Representative Overby Representative Ritchie Representative Womack, Representative Ferguson, Representative Ferguson, Vice
Chair Murdoch, Chair Burris. Sorry you failed to pass your bill. Members, I think we've got a few more bills to go. For those of you that aren't catching on to body language, I'll just feel you, I think what's going to happen is we're not going to run SB 875, and I don't think Senator Hutchinson is here to run SB 38.
So if you're here for those and you're tired of your seat, you can probably go ahead and go. We'll give it a little bit to do that, but we do have a couple more bills to run. I'm talking, yeah, I think pretty much everybody can go. I mean, if you want to stay, you can. I think the rest of the bills are non-controversial. Whatever your number was, Vice Chair Murdoch. All right, 1183. Members, we're going to do HB 1183.
back no no I didn't hear yet
I didn't hear you so I didn't put anything
Speaker 194
2:34:28
I'm here to run bill house bill 1183 and I have miss Douglas at the end of the table she'll explain to bill we'll say your name ma'am you're recognized I'm Lisa Douglas I'm the
Speaker 378
2:34:46
president of the Arkansas State Board of Massage Therapy and I'm also a practicing and I'm also practicing a massage therapist HB 1183 is an improvement to the current current laws that we have and it also helps out with protection of the public current therapist and massage therapist students we have also included safeguards that will help our arkansas I'm sorry real
quick tell me what bill number that is again HB 1183 1183 is this
okay yes all right then it's actually on the deferred list members with the motion to suspend the rules we could pull it off the deferred motion to suspend the rules pull off the off deferred any discussion on the motion all in favor say aye any opposed okay now the bills on the active calendar and you can continue presenting okay thank you I was
Speaker 378
2:35:53
just gonna say that no right now what we have is good set of rules but HB 1183 it helps with stop safeguards and put everything in place for the human trafficking and we know that that's a big problem and we have also implemented a few things that rules for clarification and I will answer any questions anyone has. Okay Representative Meeks you're recognized for a question. This
for me because I think it's a great
bill, especially since it addresses the human trafficking thing, but also too, and folks know that I've been railing on fees this go around, and I do notice that it looks like there's an increase in a fee on page 5, line 32, and I think there might have been one other someplace else or something like that. If you could kind of explain now why you believe the fee increase is necessary.
I think there may have been an application fee or something else of that nature. What the increase in the fee is going
Speaker 378
2:37:03
to be used for, if you would just go over that for me, please. Yes, sir. The application fee has always been in place, so that hasn't changed. The only thing that has changed is it's $75 a year, that is annually, and that is for massage therapy clinics. We now have an inspector. We just recently got them this past year. We haven't had an inspector before this, even though our law has required one.
But what the $75 will do, an inspector will come out, and they will be given a certificate saying that they are Arkansas State Road and passed, and it will just be insurance for any kind of students that are going to the clinics or any kind of clients that are going to clinics. And it's nothing more than, let's say, if you were the FDA approved. That means it's just a quality saying that you have your checks and balances and that they have gone through the necessary legal procedures.
And you said that you've added a health inspector. Was that a change in the law, or is that something that y'all are having to do because it's been in law and you just now are able to, I
Speaker 378
2:38:07
guess, have the resources to do it? Yes, sir. We now have an inspector because it was always in the law that we were supposed to have inspections for the schools and everything else, but we haven't had that position available until recently. It was done by, usually it was done by a board
member. Okay, and so this fee is going to help pay
Speaker 378
2:38:26
that inspector? Yes, and also to actually give them the printing and everything supplies,
like if somebody needs an extra copy of their clinic inspection and for travel for reimbursement for that employee. Okay, thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Members, any
other questions? Seeing none, is there anybody in the audience that would like to speak for or against the bill? All right. Representative Murdoch, you've got to close for your bill. Okay. He's closed and with the motion, do pass. Any discussion on the motion? All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed?
Ayes have it. Pass your bill. Thank you. Representative Ward? Thank you. You'll join us at the end of the table. You're recognized to present House bill 1871
Speaker 386
2:39:35
You're recognized Thanks, Mr. Chair. House Bill 1871 is an agreed upon bill between the Division of Age and Adult Services and DHS is more or less dealing with the funding formula for that for the 8 AAA agency on aging that operate as nonprofit organizations throughout the state to run the services to the elderly person under the old American Act. As you may know that the current formula that is currently in place has been in place for
the last 31 years. The only thing that this particular bill does is more or less align the demographics and everything with the day's demographics of the State of Arkansas. We believe that currently the formula that is in place at all is outdated due to the last census count for the 2010 census, we know that the 50-40-10 funding formula that is currently being used by the Department is simply need to be changed.
This particular bill also brings in shareholders and bring in a group of people so that we can discuss, so the discussion can be made on how the funding formula should be enacted. And we are hoping that with these shareholders and these persons that will be appointed to actually to look at the current funding formula to more or less bring it in line with the demographics of the state of Arkansas, we'll be able to do so by 2014 and have a funding formula in place
that will meet those particular demographics and those particular criteria set out by the Old American Act. As stated, these are Title III funds that comes to the Department through the Federal Government that are more less there to administer services to those persons that are age 60 and older. I'm here to ask any questions. Thank you.
Representative Ward, you're going to not like me for this, but I just realized when you started talking exactly
what this bill was, and I might have some questions, too, but I'll recognize Representative Malone first.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. You say that it's an agreed-upon bill, but I do have an email from my area agency director who has some major concerns about this, and I notice that it's been amended. Was
Speaker 386
2:42:08
that an amendment? Yes, yes. We did some amendment. The 5A, which consists of the eight area agency directors and all, they did get together
to actually require or request some amendments and all. the Division of Aid and Adult Services along with DHS we did amend the bill to make it meet to their specification so so they are now yeah they are agreeing upon there's
you okay Representative Meeks you recognize for a question thank
you Mr. Chair it's I mean basically it says those shall take into consideration the following factors
without limitation, do we need to actually add that to law in order for anything to change? I mean, because it doesn't mandate that they have the following factors. It uses they shall consider it. I don't know that it really puts any teeth to it to get them to do the right thing. Well,
Speaker 386
2:43:08
that was one of my concerns as well. But I think that the only way that we was going to more or less get this agreed upon by the division agent and also the Department of Human Services were to more or less put
it in that term because of the fact that the federal government was making it mandatory for the Department of Human Services to actually to define certain terms such as rule and other terms and all in order to make sure that those particular formulas are matched with those those persons that are more or less in need, especially those persons that they consider frail and at risk. And that's our reason why the language is as such. And hopefully the shareholders upon their meetings and all will
be able to look at what the Department of Aging or the Federal Department of Aging is going to recommend, and we already have those particular numbers in place. I think that at the upcoming May shareholders meeting that we We will be able to discuss those terms and make sure that those particular terms and
Speaker 396
2:44:12
all meet with all the specifications that are set out by the federal government. Okay. You know,
I mean, I agree with you. If there's funding that needs to go to a certain area and all of that, then we definitely need
to get it there. But I'm just concerned that, you know, because it's not mandating them to actually do something that, you know, we're not really doing anything with this bill. Well, you know,
Speaker 386
2:44:38
like I said, again, I'm totally with you on that, but I think that since the funding formula that has been in place for the last 31 years, they have had several discussion on it. And they, when you talk about splitting up monies and splitting up funds, a lot of the people and everything don't want to give up even though that they know that it's the right thing to do.
So by actually compromising with the Division of Age and Adult Services and Area Agencies and also the Department of Human Services, this is the only way that we can more or less get this particular bill agreed upon. All right. Well, I appreciate it. And, you
know, as we move the process forward, you know, let's as a legislature, I guess, make sure that we're following up on this and make sure that, you know, whatever we can do to help get the funding where it needs to go, we need to do
Speaker 386
2:45:29
that. Well, I'm hoping that during the interim and all,
through administrative rules that those particular funding formula that will be recommended by the shareholder would come through administrative rules and they will be promulgated at that point in time so we will have a public hearing to let people know exactly what the formula would be looking like and what the recommendations are okay thank you thank you mr. chair all right Representative Overby, were
you going to ask a question? You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
Mr. Chair, sorry. On 36, it starts, line 36, first page, B, and then it goes on down to, and on the next page, one and two, it says the distribution of the older individuals in the state who have the greatest economic need and social need with particular consideration of the low-income minority older individuals.
Why is the minority in there, the word minority, I don't mean them, but the word minority in there because an older person is an older person. Representative Overby, that is
Speaker 386
2:46:49
a federal mandate. That's a part of the federal mandate. the State Division agent have to follow the federal rules in order to implement that because of the fact that those are Title III funds that are handed down directly from the federal government. Thank you.
Representative Love, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Ward, I think I'm going to follow up on the same on page one, line 32. About taking into consideration, I think I'm in the same mind as Representative Meeks in it. I believe this, even though we shall take into consideration, I think that does take the teeth out of it.
And so I'm going to ask you this. Are you saying that DHS was going to
Speaker 386
2:47:45
oppose your bill without this language? Well, I think that the Division of Aging and Adult Services that actually operate the eight area agencies, DHS was not going to oppose it. It was the eight area agencies. As Representative Malone stated earlier, that she had received emails from her AAA directors in her area with opposition because of the fact that, I'd like to say again, the current
funding formula that had been in place for more than 31 years, it just simply gives more priorities to those person at age 60 years of old age we had left out a lot of the federal mandate from the Division of Aging and all that should have been in there that had been omitted and by more or less having 50% of the funding formula for just those person at a 60 in all not those that are dealing with minorities or frail or at risk you know that is what the Division of Aging
was a little bit more concerned about but by actually following the federal mandate you know we had to put those terms and those terminology had to go back in there so doing that and all the area agencies the eight area agency had to agree upon the fact that they were not following federal guideline by actually allowing the current fault that funding
formula to stay intact okay Follow-up, Mr. Chairman? Now, the areas on aging now, is that?
Speaker 386
2:49:18
Those are non-profit organizations that receive those funds to operate services for those persons that are 60 and older. And so you're saying
that the providers came out against the bill. Is that what you're saying? Well,
Speaker 386
2:49:34
I'm saying that the recipient of the funds came out against the bill. The person that was actually receiving those funds for various services that they were rendering to elderly persons.
And to make it, I'd say that there is, I'd say, you know, again, this particular funding formula has been intact for more than 31 years. We know that it's outdated because we know that the demographics of the state of Arkansas has changed tremendously in 30 years but again like all other organizations and all I know that people just they just don't want to give up funding especially if they don't have to or not forced to in a lot of cases
okay mr. Ward how actually does
this change the fund or how actually would this change the
Speaker 386
2:50:29
funding formula it would change the formula it would change it based on the current demographics in the state of Arkansas for an example you have a 50 40 10 when I say 10 you're saying 10% of those funds are set aside for minorities we all know that well according to the state definition of minority and it is running right close like 16 to 17 percent we have like 16 17 percent minority as
definition by term that should be in a part of this bill not 10 percent so we know that the funding formula is off because if you just simply start looking at the definitions of those areas that is currently being funded in the way that they're being funded that it just simply doesn't match okay all right okay thank you okay members
any other questions is there anybody in the audience that would
like to speak for or against okay representative Wilkins make makes a motion to Hank Wilkins makes a motion to do pass representative Ward I'm just gonna be honest I'm gonna for lack of a better word cut you some slack you sit up here and been nice and respectful session don't say too much that that's the exception on this committee so I including myself I'm gonna just say like I'm going to hear vote. I'm a little bit concerned, and I'm just holding the right to maybe oppose this bill on the floor.
Not that that's just – I'm just telling you that from my own personal – I don't want you to feel like I let it out and then I trick bag you on the floor or something. But I need to get some answers. But given the time sensitivity of this session and add a little bit of deference to you, we'll just have a vote here,
Speaker 386
2:52:18
and we'll see how it goes. Okay. Well, you know, if there is any question or any concerns, I think that, you know, I can make sure that I set up a meeting with the Department of Human Services and the Division of Aid and Adult Services, and I think that any clarity that you may need or desire, I think that they'll be willing to get it to you.
Okay, fair enough. So, members, you have a motion to do pass. All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? The ayes have it. We've got one more bill. Representative Ferguson is going to present SB 888. That would be our last bill for the day, members. And I will say, once she's getting down there, we're probably going to have to do at least a meeting next week, maybe Monday. We might do it earlier. It's a possibility for tomorrow, but I doubt that. I'd say most likely Monday.
So be aware of that. Representative Ferguson, you're recognized.
I'm going to ask Lynn Davis from the Health Department to join me as well. Okay. Since we have such a short time frame, You don't want to see my 62-page PowerPoint on mammography? No. Okay. No, thank you. This is actually something that a group of radiologists, I might say it passed the Senate 32 to 0. It's Senator Bledsoe's bill.
And Dana Greer, who is a radiologist in Fayetteville, actually brought the problem to everyone's attention and the health department's attention initially. And the bill is really about access to mammography. Reimbursement for commercial health insurance is primarily driven by what we call CPT codes, which is they're established by the American Medical Association, which are provider codes. And most insurers pay based on what Medicare pays.
The problem is there are two codes for mammography. There's a code for film mammography, and there's never been a CPT code developed for digital mammography. It's a temporary code. Because some insurance companies continue to pay on the film code and not the digital code, the reimbursement is unfair in causing mammography to become less available throughout the state. We're asking that all the insurance companies base their digital mammography on the same Medicare RVU.
Mammography is the primary imaging tool that radiologists use to detect breast cancer. Mammography is a highly regulated imaging test in which much time is spent fulfilling the requirements for the Mammography Quality Standards Act. For instance, when you have a mammography machine, you have to pay a physicist to come in the office every year, and they do sample images, and then they have a group of radiologists, which Dana Greer is a part of, that review the films to make sure the quality of the films or the digital images is appropriate.
In the early 2000s, mammography began moving from a film media to a digital media. This required a complete overhaul of the way mammography is done. We moved from looking at an x-ray film on a light box to viewing digital images on a computer. It was felt that this change would allow for improved detection of breast cancer and remote interpretation and transfer of images that could allow for improved access to this life-saving test.
What that means now, because it's a computer image, it's a much better image than a film image because just like a digital camera image, you can change the contrast, you can zoom and blow up, and they even have what they call a CAD, computer reading program, that identifies opacities to help the radiologist pick up breast cancers because breast cancer on a film is really just opacities that you see. Unfortunately, due to the stringent regulation of mammography, the development of this new equipment is very costly.
A digital mammogram machine still costs approximately four times what a film machine does. They're about $300,000 to $400,000 usually. A film machine you can get for $60,000 or $70,000 now. Radiologists have no doubt that digital mammography is superior to film in detecting breast cancers. Almost all new purchases of digital equipment in the state have been digital in the last year. Even in Arkansas, who lags behind the rest of the country, 75% of facilities are digital mammography.
88% are nationwide. Doctors have seen significant improvement in the digital imaging. In 2000, Congress recognized that digital mammography was more expensive to perform than film. They passed legislation that required Medicare to pay 50% more for digital mammography than film. Since that time, most private insurers have followed the similar reimbursement. The RVU, our relative value unit, used for the guide reimbursement are 4.11 for digital mammography compared to 2.39 for FEM.
Almost all private insurers pay more for digital mammography than FEM, on average 1.4 to 1.5 times more. The problem that we have encountered in the Arkansas center, it centers around Arkansas insurers, Blue Cross Blue Shield. I'll just say who it is because they're, what, 75% or 80% of the market. Some reimbursement for digital mammography at the same rate as FEM. They pay less for each mammogram than the majority. Let me say this. They pay less for each mammogram than the majority of our private payers.
They pay less than Medicare and just almost the same as Medicaid, as our state breast care program. Since Arkansas Blue Cross Blue Shield has such a large percentage of covered lives in Arkansas, the lack of appropriate reimbursement for this procedure threatens the life-saving tool for women across Arkansas because of the low reimbursement people can't afford to when their machines die, in other words, and aren't serviceable anymore, they can't
afford to move to digital mammography, and I think Lynn Davis has some statistics for you about mammography in the
Speaker 410
2:58:54
state. I'm Lynn Davis. I work for the Arkansas Department of Health in the mammography program, and I have worked here in that capacity for the last eight years. since 2005 I know of we have lost access to some of the care for mammography in Arkansas we only have
48 out of the 75 counties that have permanent mammography facilities now and access to care to me is a problem okay thank you for the presentation uh representative meeks you're
recognized for questions thank you and first of all let me say
you know i agree you know we definitely have to improve access to health care my first question to you is this is there any other i guess
procedures that we actually have put into state statute i don't know but i'll tell you
I mean, it's sort of a catch-22 for this procedure. The American Medical Association, it started in 2000 to make it a permanent code, and because of 9-11, that got sort of delayed. So the dilemma is that the digital code is a temporary code. Insurance pays on a CPT code.
So what Blue Cross says, well, we'll start paying the digital rate when the American Medical Association creates a code. But every other insurer pays us way more than the 1.5 of our Medicare. It's just Blue Cross. We've tried to deal with them, and they're saying, well, get us a code, and then we'll pay you. But the problem is the American College of Radiology doesn't want them to create a code because nationwide, almost everybody pays more than the 1.5, and they think their rates will go down. So Arkansas is stuck with this dilemma that is not resolvable
Blue Cross and the Shield. Yes. Do you think that mandating? No, I don't like to mandate. I'll just say it right off. And we've worked for years to – but, you know, what do you do if we can't get a code from the AMA and they won't pay? All of their rates as an insurance company are based on Medicare, all their other procedure codes. It's just this one code that falls way below their own formula for paying.
Right. Well, I mean, I guess since you kind of asked me, I think there are other ways to put pressure on a company besides mandating them through government services. I mean, there's, you know, rioting. There's protest. I mean, there's all kinds of other ways that we in America have the freedoms that we have in order to actually do this. And, you know, I can
understand the dilemma that you're in. we've gone through this for several years I promise you we have extended every other avenue and we even delayed bringing legislation until
the last hour trying to deal with them alright thank you Mr. Chair okay Representative Meeks thank you for the question any other questions Representative Hammer you're
recognized for a question Representative Ferguson I've got a
question out there, so I'm going to try to ask you to help me get to it. Are you saying that Blue Cross Blue Shield has refused to come to the table? And in this particular area, which is very sensitive, I acknowledge that,
that they are not willing to come in line with what other Blue Cross Blue Shield agencies in other parts of the country are? Am I misinterpreting that? No, you're not. and I'm particularly
aware of it. The way West Memphis is a unique situation. If you have Blue Cross Blue Shield, even if it's not Arkansas, if you have Illinois or Mississippi, whatever, if you're an Arkansas doctor, you file it to Arkansas Blue Cross Blue Shield. So they pay the Arkansas rate.
We're sort of in a unique situation and why I realize really the disparity and Dana Greer, too, is in northwest Arkansas Fayetteville. they require because we're part of the Memphis market we're a contiguous county to Tennessee we have to file ours to Tennessee Tennessee pays us $50 more per mammogram than Arkansas Blue Cross Tennessee yeah and that's the dilemma that you know the rest of the country doesn't want the ACR to make it a permanent
code because everybody else is doing what they should do They're being, you know, and like I said, it's really the low reimbursement is really keeping us from continuing to have mammography all over the state. I'm just curious what reasons
have they given, and maybe if somebody from Blue Cross Blue Shields in the room, they can come defend or speak for themselves, but what reasons have you been given for this not to happen up to this point? They just
said, you know, bring us a code and we'll look at it like we do everything else.
But we're not going to get a code. That's not going
to happen. Well, that's not uncommon in other areas of bills and laws we have to deal with that that has occurred. But it just strikes me as funny that they're resorting to this kind of – I would be happy for them to come and
let you ask them that question. We've asked it repeatedly. Okay. Thank you.
Thank you, members. Any other questions? okay is there anybody in the audience that would like to speak for against the
bill seeing none what's the pleasure of the committee motion do pass any discussion on
the motion okay just for my own peace of mind this is the most ridiculous thing if we do it that we have to do it I appreciate representative Ferguson kind of giving me a heads up I think she saw that I would probably resent be resentful toward this bill and I am it's a ridiculous thing I have to I think somewhere in the United States there's at least two or three people floating around on large yachts by money
They're making off of whatever is going on here, and I don't appreciate I don't like it at all But if we got to do this to help the people in the state of Arkansas will do it But I think it's
a horrible whatever whatever's going on. I don't like it Thank you well, and since you breached the subject I just say to represent and makes his point I I agree with free market I also believe that there's also the second component of that which is fair and 85 percent market share isn't fair. So it's a very heavily regulated environment so that we're not dealing with something that's free and fair on its own.
This is one of the most regulated industries outside of probably insurance and liquor are the two most heavily regulated industries in the state. Representative Hammer. To the motion, and
Chair can rule me out of order, I'm just wondering what kind of precedent we're about to set. We're in a very awkward position. We're about to set a precedent over a very sensitive subject, especially given the magnitude of everything that we're dealing with during this session and all the avenues that are trying to be explored in order to curtail cost and all the subjects that have been discussed in this meeting prior to.
And quite honestly, I feel like we're being held hostage, not by the representative, but by the fact that we're having to have this discussion. but it is going to set a precedent just
for the record you just summarized my session making decisions I wouldn't normally make because of the bad policy decisions of other people I agree yes to the positive side do you think that what we're
about, I don't know if I can ask the chair
question we may be in our precedent that we're about to set based on how we're going to vote send a shot across the bow that there better be a real cooperative spirit regardless of how this thing shakes out down the road that we're not above coming back and doing this if this is what it takes in order to get people to the table.
Wouldn't you agree? I think that's a good point for discussion. Okay members, any other discussion? If not, all in favor of do pass
say aye. Any opposed? The ayes have it. Thank you Mr. Chairman. Thank you committee. Okay, members, that's all our business for today. Like I said, we may have a meeting Friday or Monday, so I'll announce and notify as needed.
Agenda
SB916
SB1039
SB442
SB1171
HB1482
HB1384
HB2210
HB1968
SB1010
HB1190
SB850
HB1183
HB1871
SB888
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative John Burris Chair
Unverified
Senator Jon Woods
Unverified
Julie Cawthorn
Unverified
Speaker 15
Representative Fredrick J. Love
Unverified
Representative Charlene Fite
Unverified
Senator Ronald Caldwell
Unverified
Representative Deborah Ferguson
Unverified
Representative Jeff Wardlaw Chair
Unverified
Chair
Unverified
Representative Kim Hammer
Unverified
Speaker 82
Representative Betty Overbey
Unverified
Representative Stephen Meeks
Unverified
Representative Andy Mayberry
Unverified
Representative Stephanie Malone Chair
Unverified
Senator Jeremy Hutchinson
Unverified
Representative Kelley Linck
Unverified
Speaker 153
Representative Butch Wilkins
Unverified
Speaker 168
Speaker 172
Speaker 177
Speaker 182
Speaker 194
Speaker 179
Speaker 199
Robert Breck
Unverified
Speaker 246
Speaker 206
Speaker 263
Speaker 268
Representative Richard Womack Chair
Unverified
Speaker 288
Speaker 299
Speaker 302
Speaker 304
Speaker 305
Speaker 308
Speaker 105
Speaker 319
Speaker 327
Speaker 337
Speaker 99
Darlene Byrd
Unverified
Speaker 353
Speaker 238
Senator Jim Hendren
Unverified
Gordon Gondek
Unverified
Sylvester Smith
Unverified
Speaker 267
Speaker 358
Speaker 378
Speaker 386
Speaker 388
Speaker 396
Speaker 410
Speaker 95