House Public Health, Welfare and Labor Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (3)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1072
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1072”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1158
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…sit at the end of the table and you are recognized to, for House Bill 1158, I believe is right, I'm sorry, 1159 without glasses, there…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1159
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1159”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 16, 2026
Looks like I'm flying solo today. I want to cover a few almost social things, not quite social, but members on your agendas, you'll see there's a boxed area called scope of practice bills, and you probably heard me mention that on the House 4 yesterday during the announcements, and we have a very strict
House rule. Of course, all House rules are strict, but we have a House rule that to change the scope of practice, first off, an interim study proposal must be done the previous year, and then also these bills must be filed by a certain date, which was yesterday, I believe, by close of business, 430 or 5 or whatever that is, and then they also must set on the calendar in our committee for, I believe, 15 days, is right? So February 11th would be the first day we can hear these scope of practice bills. So they're not deferred. We won't have to have a motion to pull them off
the deferred list or anything, but they are boxed in that box, so they're not deferred, but we can't hear them until February 11th. That's why the little box that's on your calendar and the explanation of scope of practice bills. Anybody who wants to speak for or against the bill needs to kind of sign in and let us know. It makes things a lot more organized. For those of you that are signing in or want to sign in regarding Representative Mayberry's bill, that will not be running today. We had a little
we'll say she might have had a little glitch in amending that and rather than having it amended in here, it was being amended on the House floor so she's going to have to wait until Thursday at the very soonest to be able to run that bill. So we won't be hearing that bill today. We are going to start off, I believe Representative Baltz has a bill that he would like to present and Representative Baltz, we're ready to, we're ready for you to sit at the end of the table and you are recognized to, for House Bill 1158, I believe is right, I'm sorry, 1159 without glasses, there we go. Thank
to me by the state police, it concerns fireworks for importers, distributors, geographers, retailers and shooters of fireworks. Really, just to clean up, if you're a first-time applicant, you have to fill out a form for the state police so they know what you're doing and that you're qualified to do this. And it lets volunteer fire departments, if you approve your volunteer fire departments, you can be a shooter at no cost. So just kind of clean up language for it. I've checked with the fireworks shooters, and they're fine, and the jobbers.
And like I say, the state police brought this to me. So if you have any questions, I'll try to answer them or appreciate a due pass.
Members, any questions? Seeing no questions, what's the will of this committee? Representative Ritchie, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Make a motion to do pass. We have a motion to do pass. Any discussion? all in favor of this motion aye
any opposed congratulations Representative Balch your bill has passed thank you Mr. Chair thank you committee Representative Sullivan are you prepared to present your bill today so if you would go I prefer you go to the end of the table then okay and you're recognized to introduce your bill, which is House Bill 1072, I believe. Is that the right one you're running? Yes, sir.
Okay. You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Just a little bit of history on this bill. The Act 1593 was passed in 2007 by the legislature. It was well-intentioned to study outcomes, and this bill that we're presenting now does not prevent nor detract from the value of outcomes in behavioral health. The bill was actually implemented. It took three years to decide on a tool.
There was a lot of discussion. It was difficult to find the tool that actually tracks outcomes. There are a lot of tools that provide information, but very few in behavioral health that actually track outcomes. And a stakeholder group decided that this was the best bill or the best tool to track outcomes. And that tracking began in 2010. Providers from across the state were called in to do training. The state did a lot of training on that, and the training is ongoing. So we've been
going far five years now, and to date, the state has not provided nor suggested nor implemented any changes based on the outcomes that this tool was projected to do. The tool is basically a therapy tool and a good therapy tool, but it's not a quality outcomes tool. And I could go over more history involved in that, but what this bill does and by the state's own admission in 2014
DHS presented a report to the committee and some of the numbers I think in there and the cost in there I think are low, but it's costing the state probably at least $2 million a year to keep this program running. The cost of businesses is probably $2 to $5 million a year to keep it implemented, and again, the state has made no changes, no programmatic changes based upon any outcome study. In fact, about six or eight months ago, the head statistician for DHS, in a report to
the governor's commission, presented the information that had been collected in the past, I think, year. And at the end of that presentation, the presenter was asked, was this outcomes data? And the presenter said, no, it's not true outcomes data. And no one stood from DHS to stand against that or oppose that. So they are collecting a lot of information. It's just not outcomes information. And it's not being used to drive the program.
So I am not opposed, and this bill does not oppose outcomes. It just simply says this is not an outcomes tool and the program is not being driven by the information that we're gleaning. As I think everyone knows, if we're not using the information to drive the program changes in favor of quality, to drive program changes and to save money for the state, then we need to go in a different direction. And that's all this bill does.
If the DHS would like to come back and say that they have a new tool or would like to look for a new tool, then they can certainly do that. But at this time, I would appreciate a favorable vote on this so that we can get the state moving in a different direction. I've talked with a number of stakeholders who support this contention. I've also talked with DHS in the last conversation we had, which was a few weeks ago. I'm sorry. They did not oppose this bill. So I would be happy to answer any questions.
We've got a couple questions from members I'd like to ask. First, if I can, it seems to me, Representative Sullivan, don't we need some sort of system of tracking or some sort of accountability? And do you have
any idea for a replacement that would work in your industry? personally no, professionally no but I think the original intent and they brought together a stakeholder group to discuss all the tools and it was difficult it went from 2007 to 2010
trying to find the tool so it's difficult to find the tool that does that but I think that was the right approach was to go to a stakeholder group and try to determine what tool best collected that information I think there also are a number of processes that do track for quality. There's an audit process that value options goes through. All the providers, patients, make sure that every patient has appropriate goals, every patient has appropriate outcomes.
Then they do a retrospective audit to make sure that services are provided that were promised and provide it in an appropriate manner and that patients are meeting those goals and objectives. So I think there are a number of systems in place that make sure the state's money is well spent and that the patients are receiving quality care. As a matter of fact, I think this bill helps focus on quality care.
If we are collecting data, spending time, energy, and resources on information that doesn't drive programmatic changes. I think that's not in the best interest of patients nor the state. So this will allow the state to spend time auditing and authorizing and spend time focused on quality care. So I think the bill actually allows to refocus on quality. You know, the state has, I think if I'm correct in the report, that when the state reported to this body, public health,
I think about six or eight months ago, they generated this report, and they didn't have any suggestions in the report as to how we move forward. That's a long answer to a short question, but basically, no, I don't have a suggested tool at this time. Okay, thank you, Representative Hammer. You're first in line for
questions. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I was curious if you could give us some history about when this tool was originally implemented. You've mentioned stakeholders a couple times.
Were the stakeholders at the table when the tool was originally created, and what was their involvement
back then? And I attended many of those meetings back then. Yes, stakeholders were involved. They surveyed a lot. A number of tools were suggested. A number of tools were reviewed. and stakeholders had a lot of input as to what the tool would be and which tool was selected. Does that answer your question? That's probably all. I do have some other folks in the audience that may have more detailed information than I,
a member of the Governor's Commission and also a former employee for Medicaid that are very familiar with this. If you'd like for me to ask, or maybe they might be interested in coming or you might be interested in hearing from them
in more detail. There are a couple witnesses signed up to speak for this, Representative Hammer. Do you have a follow-up
question? Yes, I do. Perhaps more to the chair. The reason I was asking that question was if there were stakeholders at the beginning of the process,
why was it they went along with this back then, and now we're sitting here several years later, several million dollars later, and we don't have, you know, we've not gotten anything for it. So I'd like just a little history to that if we could. And we may be able to get that from the
next couple witnesses. Would that be, you think, Representative Sullivan would be? Yes, and I can address
that to a point. You know, when this bill was introduced, it was introduced, and I have the cover letter when the bill started,
the governor's wife started the Children's Behavioral Health Care Commission that was made up of representatives in 2007, representatives from the state, representatives from provider associations, and various stakeholders, parents and others. And that commission for a while met monthly. It started meeting quarterly, and this tool was regularly reviewed at those meetings with all stakeholders. And the question came up a number of times asking about outcomes data.
the state sometimes I believe was a little bit slow in coming back without outcomes data and responding specifically to whether it was outcomes data they were collecting or just data that they collect so I think there's been an ongoing process for eight years with considerable stakeholder involvement and to that point DHS has not had a recommendation to change tools, nor had they had a recommendation to utilize the data that gleaned from the
tool, although there have been several suggestions that we quit using the tool or move in a different direction, because of the law, that had to come from, that recommendation had to come from DHS. Okay. Thank you. Representative Love, you're recognized for question. Mr.
Chair, can we get DHS up here at some point to ask? I'm thinking that's going to happen, yes, sir. Thank you. I'd like that opportunity, please. Representative Lowe. Well, Mr. Chair, I'll hold
my questions into DHS. You'll hold your question from DHS.
Members, any other questions for Representative Sullivan? Representative Fite, you're recognized. Thank
you, Mr. Chair. Representative Sullivan, this may be a question for DHS, but do you know approximately how long it takes to complete
one of these surveys, average time? You know, the survey, it's the same set of questions every time. So a parent comes in, sits down with someone who's going to give them the assessment. It could take, depending on whether the parent speaks English, whether they're educational level,
so it could take anywhere from 35 seconds to 30 minutes. I mean, there are a number of patients or parents who fill this chart out that just come in and check every box and hand it in. And there's no, you know, there were a number of reliability studies done on this tool nationally, but there's never been a reliability study done in Arkansas. And the reliability studies were done in inpatient settings, to my knowledge.
The reliability of this tool in Arkansas, we've never had a validity study. We've never had a reliability study on how it works in the state of Arkansas, and those questions have been asked to the commission. Thank you. Representative Love, you do have a question now? Yes, sir. Thank you, Chair. Okay,
your recognize. And to piggyback, Representative Sullivan, to piggyback off of Representative Feist's question, I want to ask you, is there a cost to administer these surveys?
Well, there's a cost to the business to do that because, yes, we have employees that want to administer. There's an ongoing cost to the state because they do regular trainings. Every therapist in the state has to go through a training internal to learn how to read the IOQ results. So when value options audits, there is a cost to the state. There's a cost to the provider.
There's no reimbursement attached to it.
Okay. I mean, I'm glad that she asked that question, but let me stay on that. Tell me, or could you give me maybe an estimated figure on the annual cost of administering surveys? Because I'm assuming that the providers have the cost or bear the brunt of the cost of administering these surveys. So can you give me maybe just a ballpark figure or estimated cost? Sure. That
figure, the state did a report on that, and they asked providers to send in information.
However, their survey was not validated, and there was no reliability study as to whether the information gleaned from the state's report was accurate. They just asked a number of questions. Based upon their assessment, their assessment was the cost per patient was about $20 per administration, which would run about $80 a year. It's given four times a year. So it's about $80. On the provider side, the business side of that, some of the highest costs were estimated to be about $80 a patient,
with, I think, the norm being somewhere around $40 or $50 per administration. And this is one of the problems that we had in the reliability of the state's method because you not only have to administer it, but you get audited. If there's a problem in the audit, you submit a plan to a corrective action plan. So it involves a number of layers. Okay,
so, I mean, do you have an estimated cost to providers annually? I mean, to all providers annually.
I'm going to guess it's $40, about $40 per patient, $200 if you said $200 per patient. And I think we have someone from Medicaid here, formerly with Medicaid, could tell you how many patients there were, but I'm not exactly sure how many patients there are in the state. I'm going to guess $80,000. Is that a correct answer? I don't know how many patients. Medicaid
or DHS could probably answer that.
We'll ask that question when they hear. Yeah, okay. Representative Love, are you satisfied, or do you have one
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Okay, thank you. Members, no more questions for Representative Sullivan. We're going to call, let's see, Robin Raven-Dren. I hope I got that right. Somewhere close. Yeah, it's close. Okay. Thank you. If you would, introduce yourself for the record, sir, and you're working to us to provide some
Speaker 53
18:49
testimony in favor of this. I'm Robin Ravindran. I work for the state of Arkansas Medicaid Department for 12 years.
Prior to that, I was a state auditor for 20 years. So my background in DHS is about 29 years, and currently I am the executive director for Arkansas Alliance for Health Improvement. We have about 15 members make up of mental health providers as well as other providers. So my testimony here is in favor of this bill because I was in a position to operationalize this rule from an audit standpoint of view.
I was the program integrity director for Medicaid. So when we did these reviews, we found the tools that's been used really has no meaning because most beneficiaries, we serve, we meaning DHS, they just fill this out because it's a requirement. There's no true, you cannot assess a true result from those. The only way to do that is to look at the case notes, look at the progress notes,
look at the daily treatment plan. So that would be a good tool to utilize to see an outcome measures, in my opinion. I'm not a clinician. I'm an accountant by trade, so I cannot speak for truly on the clinical side. But from a high-level standpoint of view, this is just another, I call it an unfunded mandate on the provider side that we, my estimation, a couple of weeks ago, I did some calculation based on the information I had.
It'll cost totally about $10 million from the provider side and the DHS side. The DHS side has about $2.8 million, somewhere in that range, but it doesn't add all the audit costs. It doesn't add the other contract costs. I didn't see that. So based on what I saw, So even if you give that amount, on the provider side, it's about $5 million. Someone asked how much did it cost, the provider side. It's about $5 million cost to administer.
And the other part was is to the providers are penalized, which is I'm totally against it for not performing this because there is no payment made for doing this process. But they are penalized. If you didn't do it, we're going to take every services that you provided for that client because you did not do this checklist of 30 questions. So a lot of providers are penalized to pay back all those money they provide,
even though the service were rendered, it was medically necessary, it was already being signed by a physician. So that's why I feel this bill, I support this bill from the Alliance point of view, and I'd be happy to answer any questions.
Representative Hammer, you're first in line to ask a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. So is it your testimony that this is over-duplication of services, or are there other skill sets in place that therapists can use to determine whether or not a child should continue to
receive services, and if so, what is the safety measure in place to make sure therapists just aren't out there cranking up services and trying to
Speaker 53
22:22
keep case managers loaded up? Again, Representative Hammer, I want to qualify myself. I'm not a clinician, but from the experience I have, yes, this is a duplication of effort. We, meaning DHS, currently has checks and balances in place. They have audit tools available.
They continually do those already there to measure these outcomes if it needs to be. And within, I believe, within the next six months, don't quote me on the time frame, there's a new, it's called the DSM clinical tool, should be in place. That will derive the same results, what we are looking here, where it's been really not quite acceptable to most people and not useful. And no other results has been produced based on this data.
All it is is just giving us statistical information saying Provider A has completed these checklists 69% or 70%. It doesn't tell anything, or I have not seen any from those information. How is it turned into clinical? Okay, and I'll go ahead and ask
you, and if you can't answer this, maybe somebody coming down the pike can, and value options as it comes to looking over the shoulder of the therapist
to make sure that they are offering services only to clients that need them. Is that their role, or how does any of that mesh in with what the
Speaker 53
23:54
intent of this bill is? It has no effect on this bill at all. Value options still will continue to do what they do as a quality assurance agency. They will continue to monitor their clinical components. They continue to provide prior authorization of services. Some of these are already prior authorized, by the way, Representative Hammer, by-value option to provide these services.
Not all of those. So that function has no change, none whatsoever, with this bill. All
right. Thank you, Representative Hammer. Members, any other questions for this witness, for this expert, expert or whatever we're calling him at this time. You do? Vice Chair Ferguson, you're recognized. Can
you elaborate a little bit on the DSM tool you were talking about? Because, you know, I think all of us feel like it's important to have long-term and short-term assessments, and certainly as a provider,
Speaker 53
24:49
I can tell you we all have paperwork. And what is a DSM tool? Yeah, what is that tool? I'm going to defer that to Carol Moore. She's a clinician and clinical director for AO, as well as the commission. What is the acronym DSM is the question? Again, my apology. I did
Speaker 53
25:10
what it is if you don't. She will know because Carol Moore is a clinician. She will testify in a few
minutes, so she'll be able to give you that. Okay. Well, thank you for your testimony, and Ms. Carol Moore, you're next to testify for this.
Thank you. And if you would, make sure you're speaking plenty loud into the microphone. Introduce yourself for the record, and
you're recognized to begin. Yes, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, for allowing me to speak, and committee members. My name is Carol Moore. I'm a licensed clinical social worker. I'm a licensed alcohol and drug abuse counselor.
I'm currently a second-term appointee to the Governor's Commission on Children's Behavioral Health, and I'm also the vice president of the Behavioral Health Providers Association. And if you would, speak up a little louder
in that mic, pull it a little closer, or do something. I apologize. I'm a little nervous. Can you tell? If we get it close, that'll help us. And what is it you have to tell this committee? If you
might start off with telling us what DSM is. The DSM is the Diagnostic Statistical Measurement tool that is established throughout all mental health providers
that is utilized to determine a diagnosis for a particular client on an individualized basis. Do you have any
President Ferguson, did you want to ask her? Well, I guess my question would be, would this be something that could replace what they're doing now? I mean, I understand. I think everybody agrees the tool that they're presently using is costly and not very effective. Is this something that would replace that possibly?
The DSM-5, well, we are currently utilizing DSM-4 in transition to DSM-5. That is a national established tool. That is not an outcomes measure. Outcomes measures are very clearly needed and required and mandated by many of our funding sources for all providers and are definitely something that is needed to ensure quality of care, quality of services that an organization is providing. The current outcome, Y-O-Q, excuse me, the current tool that is being utilized by the state is not a bad tool for individualized care.
It's something that many providers may choose to continue to utilize. It measures one person's progress or decline, but it is based on a seven-day time period or less. It's a tool that is completed by parents, children if they're of a certain age, or legal guardians if the parents are not in the picture. It is a 60-question questionnaire that in the part of the state that I come from personally,
we have a high level of people who are illiterate, are unable to read the tool, who do speak other languages, such as Spanish, the tool itself is hard for them to complete. It has also been made very clear in our commission meetings that the tool itself, although costly to the state as well as to the providers within the state, it is not a measure of outcomes, and that has been clearly stated to myself in a commission meeting.
Yeah, thank you. I guess, you know, I'm just wondering if we drop this. We do have to have quality outcome measures. What tool, do you have a tool that
your group suggests? At this point, there is not a set tool that is suggested. There's been one that's been recently discussed in our last commission meeting that's utilized for the system of care, which is also a part of DBHS, One of their programs that we all participate in as providers, a very simple tool.
The organization that I personally am employed by has a very clear-cut and well – what is the word I'm looking for? Very clear-cut set of outcome measures that do guide exactly whether or not we are providing adequate and appropriate services to the clients that we serve, both adults and children. Representative Love, you're recognized for a
Carol, is that? Yes. Carol, you just stated that most of your funders have an outcome measurement tool. No, I'm sorry. Let
me clarify what I said. They require that we as providers, whether it's the state contracts, accrediting agencies, they require that we produce outcome measures. Okay, so most of your funders don't
have a tool that you all use for outcome measures. That's correct, sir.
Okay. All right. I just want to clarify that. Thank
Fyke. You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Would you agree that the tool currently being used, the one that we're looking at in this bill, is totally subjective? Absolutely. Filled out by a parent, filled out by an older child, not compared to anything, really. It's just totally this
person's opinion? Absolutely, and in regards to compared to, it is only compared to the previous YOQ that has been filled out.
Thank you. Representative Hammer, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Carol, how long have you
been practicing, please? I have been a licensed social worker in the state
of Arkansas since 1984. for. So you were practicing before this tool was put into place is that correct? Yes sir. Okay and have you ever received since this tool has gone into place any feedback or can you give us a insight as to how this tool has benefited you as a therapist having been around as long as you have?
What I have received outside of the commission meeting is a report quarterly on the percentage that we have completed, what our compliance rate is for my particular agency. We have received some information in the commission meetings regarding some statistical information, but no information whatsoever in regards to outcomes and any effect on policies, procedures, or services that we provide.
So you as an individual therapist, how are you directly impacted by this tool being in place in the first place to hold you to a standard or accountable for the cases that you oversee?
This particular tool holds us to no accountability or standard. The only impact that it has, and I do provide some direct services at this point in time, but my position currently is a statewide clinical supervisor over our offices.
It has a major impact on our staff in regards to the amount of time that it takes to apply. The accuracy of the reports that are obtained from that may or may not be actual true information. It is used to note whether or not somebody appears at any one time to be having an increase in a symptom or a behavior. All right, Representative Hammers, I
get you where you need it.
Okay. You're good, Representative Lundstrom. I'm very good. Well, we still have a witness from DHS. Oh, Rep. Bragg, I'm sorry. I missed that. You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Just one point of clarification. You're saying this
tool is not effective, but did you say you were required to have some type
of assessment? We are required by all funders and as providers for our own benefit
and it's important that we have outcome measures that we can utilize to ensure quality care, quality procedures, quality policy, quality everything. And the bottom line is how it impacts the clients that we serve. I mean, is that a state requirement? It is required in state contracts. It's required in our national accreditation that is required by DBHS. So there's a requirement, but this tool
is not effective, but you said there's no other tool available?
Do other states have? At this point in time, individual providers utilize their own outcome measures. This particular instrument has provided no guidance, no outcomes. So if we didn't have
this particular instrument, would you be in violation of a statute, or do you have to have
something in place? I believe that the bill that Representative Sullivan is presenting is the statute that we are looking to, that we are in agreement with changing.
Okay. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you. I believe we'll bring Mr. Charlie Green to the table, if you would, sir. and y'all would both introduce yourself for the record and tell us the other side
Speaker 89
35:36
of this yes sir my name is charlie green i'm the interim director for the division of behavioral health i brought with me miss paula stone and she can tell you her credentials i'm assistant director
for the Division of Behavioral Health and I'm also a licensed clinician. I'm a licensed clinical social worker. We'll be
happy to answer any questions. Representative Hammer has already risen his hand so let's
hear your question, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Green, this is my summation of things and you tell me where I'm wrong or give you open mic to respond. It seems like we've got a a tool in place that is
not producing what it was originally expected to produce and we've been rocking along for several years that there should have been plenty of time for it to produce the results that it was originally intended to do and it's not there and it's time to pull the plug on it we don't have any other tool in place but I don't see why we need to keep cranking out approximately two million dollars and also the financial expense to the providers from this point
forward. That's my observation. Can you shoot holes in it or tell me where I'm wrong
Speaker 89
36:54
in that? Well, I'm going to let Ms. Stone talk about the effectiveness of the tool here in just a second. I do want to state that we feel like there is another part of the statute that does mandate that we report outcomes data. We also feel like outcomes data is very important when we're providing services to these children, and we need to have a tool to do that.
Now, as part of some ongoing efforts that are part of the payment improvement effort overall for the department, we have looked at making some significant changes to how behavioral health care is provided to children and adults. And as part of that, we will very likely end up with a new outcomes tool. That being said, because we do feel like we're mandated to use to have outcomes data and report that,
we'll need to keep using what we have until such time as we can change the policy. The use of the IOQ is actually in the RS, the Rehabilitative Services for Persons with Mental Illness Policy within the Medicaid Manual. Okay, can I ask you something on what you just...
Hang on, Rep. Sever-Handler. Yes, sir. Mr. Green, did you... So what you're
saying is somewhere in this statute, in this bill that's in front of us,
it does require that we have outcomes
Speaker 89
38:32
data? No, sir. It's not in the bill. It's in 20... I had it right in front of me. You're taking my question. It's in
Speaker 89
38:46
for you. He just did it a lot faster than you would, though. Thank you. I'm here for you, honey. 20-47-5-10. We believe mandates that we provide outcomes data,
or we report on outcomes data, which means we need to
collect it. And obviously we don't have that statute in front of us. Can you read something from that?
Speaker 89
39:15
You bet. at the end of the statute the house committee on aging children and youth legislative and military affairs and the senate senate interim committee on children and youth okay i had to go back one before we have to submit a report to that those groups and the report shall include but not be
limited to and there's four things listed one of the last of which is outcome data
for the system of care. So if we remove this from the statute, you have no way of reporting data as you're required
Speaker 89
39:52
to this committee then? If we stopped using the YOQ, we would not currently have a way to report the data because that's what we're using. We don't feel like, our council doesn't feel like the bill actually mandates that we stop using the YOQ.
That's, again, that's in policy. We'd have to bring that, go through the usual process of change in policy. Representative
Hammer, are you asking us for a follow-up? How long has the YLQ been
in place, Charlie? We'll let Paula take a crack at that one. So as Representative Sullivan testified, it started in 2007. We began the search for the instrument. Once the instrument was chosen, we started working
towards implementing that instrument. That began in 2009 where we ran pilots in certain areas of the state and it became part of the policy and all providers began using the wild cue in July of 2010 Okay, my question then
is this. This thing has been around a long time and what I just heard said and correct me if I'm wrong in my interpretation is that it's a violation of statute if we don't have something that is supposed to be producing the outcome. My understanding is
this is not producing the outcome, so is not somebody in violation of the statute that they haven't been producing what the statute requires? And if so, who is that person or who is it that hasn't done their job that we don't
have what is required in statute? So we do have an outcomes report for both 2012 and 2013. And those reports were done. So one of the things we had to do is
we know that a tool is not valid to collect state-level aggregate data until we have it fully implemented. And so we needed to wait on all the providers to have the children that they were currently seeing, and we're talking about upwards of 50,000 children entered into the system, and then you had to also wait for a comparison. So you have the instrument that says that ask the parent or the child how their symptoms are, where they are with their
symptoms, and then you have to have the comparison. So there again, you had the administration of the instrument and then the comparison administration of the instrument to be able to come up with those outcome reports. So we have two years of outcome reports, both state-level aggregate data as well as working with the providers on their provider-level data.
We've been doing this since 2007. Is that right? We began the
Speaker 8
42:44
There we go. Thank you. Mr. Ward, while you're recognized for a question. It'll be as quick as I can get it out, Mr. Chairman. Thank you. Ms. Paula, did DHS give a report to the commission, and in that report did they admit that this tool
doesn't work effectively? We did not. I was not present at a commission meeting where someone from the state said that the tool did not work. Do you know what they said to the commission? We presented data to the commission regarding the outcomes measures,
So we did a state-level aggregate comparison of the children overall. And for those that received two instruments within that year, what happened with their symptoms? Did they get better? Did they get worse? Did they stay the same? Or did they actually recover? So we had that level of data that came to the state, to
so that's a big broad question it works or it doesn't work obviously it's a pretty simple yes or no it's a it's a valid tool and I think it gives our state as well as particularly gives the providers valuable information now that information is taken again from the parents or from the child, and at the time of intake, and then every 90 days, they're asked to answer the
questions. And so you're using that as a comparison. It's as helpful as a clinician or as a provider wants it to be. So it can be a very helpful tool if it's used appropriately in determining exactly if your services are working. So you're providing treatment, and so what you're asking that parent is based on the treatment that was provided did that child get better or did that child get worse so then the provider is able to then determine if they need to continue treating in that same way
all right i don't see any other questions here's my thoughts for a moment a couple questions for you is there any way is there something else is there another tool that we can use to report this to report to the committee that you're supposed to report to that would fulfill the need of
Speaker 89
45:18
the statute? We're working on developing another tool. We've actually, as Carol mentioned,
we've got one we're using with our system of care, which is a smaller population. It is not mandated that we use it for everyone, but we're working with stakeholders right now to try to figure out what is the best tool. Right now, it's mandated they use the YOQ And, again, hopefully we can have something worked out by the time we'd want to change that
policy. All right. We've got, you know, I mean, you guys know what you're doing and I don't, but I get to ask questions because I sat here for a moment. We've got 49 other states.
Is someone else doing something better than us that we can copy?
As with this, the committee that chose the YLQ, there are a number of instruments that can be utilized, and other states are using some of the instruments that were on that list. So the committee started out, the work group that looked at this instrument and chose this instrument started out with 70 different instruments. They narrowed it down to five, and then they chose this one. So there were a number of other instruments on that top five list that other states are also utilizing.
Okay. Let me ask this as a sort of possible compromise to get us maybe out of a little bit of a, I don't think it's exactly a rock and hard place, but it's a little bit of a difficult situation considering that we have to report would it be possible and I'm kind of referring to you too Representative Sullivan so I want you to pay attention for a little bit here sorry could we put some sort of timing in your bill would you consider some sort of amendment that says
this goes away by the end of 2015 and by that time we will have another something in place to where we will have some sort of reporting system Is
that somewhat agreeable to everybody? Yes, I'm agreeable to that. May I make a comment about the testimony? I don't think the comments that were made, this is a therapeutic tool. It's not an outcomes tool. You notice even in the comments today, the comments were specific to a patient improvement.
And we agree there are a number of, you know, we look at goals and objectives for every patient. And a while ago when I think Ms. Moore was talking about current outcomes, you know, we have goals and objectives. Those goals and objectives, if they're not met, then when we have an audit, you have a problem with the audit because you're not writing appropriate goals, you're not doing measurable objectives. So there are a number of ways to collect data, but yes, sir, Mr. Chair, if we could sit down and talk about this, I'd be willing to look at a date specific.
Yes, Representative Hammer, we've got all sorts of things going on in the committee right now. Question to the
Chair. Yes, sir. Please. This bill doesn't have an emergency clause, so could you educate me that if this bill passes as is, Is there not already a hard date that would be established by sometime middle of this year? So why would, am I wrong or right in my thinking that
there? You're right in your thinking that there would be a time given by that, but we don't have anything that says that the DHS or anyone else has to replace this tool with another one,
other than they have to report. Representative, why do you have
some input? If I could clarify, who's the gentleman at the end of the table from DHS right now? Mr. Green. Charlie Green. Mr. Green, I thought in your testimony you said that you
Speaker 89
49:11
all were looking at a new tool. Well, yeah, we're looking at doing some pretty significant transformation of the whole system, of which a new tool would probably be part of.
Okay, so let me ask you this then. Is this the most effective or is this the best tool that is out there? Because, I mean, I guess it's kind of apparent that this tool, that providers are against this tool. Did they recommend another tool, and did you all take a look at those tools? So the
providers gave us lots of feedback on the issues with this tool, and I think that the differences between tools, One of the issues that they told us about this tool, again, as testimony has been provided previously,
is because this tool is completed by the parent or by the youth that is given the tool. Other tools have been developed that use the clinician as the person who's assessing that child and using a different tool. So there are different tools that are used in different ways. Here's what I think.
I'm going to ask Representative Sullivan, you have every right to ask us to proceed forward and give you a vote today. I don't know what the will of the committee is right now, and it may be very positive, and you have something going on, Representative Love, or do you want me to finish here real quick? I don't really want to sit here and try to fix this bill in committee. Although we don't have a whole lot going on, I don't want to do that. I would like it if you all could fix this and bring it back in a week. If you really want to proceed forward and you really feel hard about it, Representative Sullivan, you are a member of this committee and you can make a motion to do pass.
That's up to you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm willing to work with DHS if we can bring this back in a week to the table. I appreciate your consideration of that. We've been talking about this for eight years. Yes, sir. And if we can solve it in a week, I'll be excited. I think the will of this committee has probably
moved this forward, so I think there's a great deal of pressure to solve this in a week, although we may not have the best. It sounds like there may not be the best solution in the world out there anyway, but we're going to get something going on, I would say, in a week, sir.
And I appreciate it. You know, my interest here is the taxpayer. The taxpayer has paid tens of millions of dollars for this program since 2008, and there has not been one suggestion of programmatic change nor one suggestion to improve care based upon the data that's collected. And so my interest here, again, is what taxpayers are doing. There's been a lot of talk about providers, and I know I am one, and there was some misleading information.
My business is not one of the leading providers in the state of this service. That information was not accurate. but my interest as a taxpayer and this is very in line with what the governor asked us to do to improve quality to reduce cost to the state and reduce cost to business and if we can work that out in a week and come back here I'm very willing to do that thank you
Mr. Chair members if it's alright with this it sounds like the sponsor of this bill
would like to come back in a week or so and I think it might be a good idea to where we have an amendment on here that gives us certain dates and fixes our issue with the other statute that requires some reporting. So thank you, Representative Sullivan, and thank you, all experts who have testified. We'll get this resolved, and we'll see everybody in another week. Representative Hammer, you have a bill on this committee. Are you ready? No? Okay. Is there anyone else, any other representatives or senators here that would like to present a bill?
So, saying none, we will see everybody on Thursday.
Agenda
HB1159
HB1072
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Chair
Unverified
Speaker 8
Representative Scott Baltz
Unverified
Representative Chris Richey
Unverified
Representative Kim Hammer
Unverified
Representative Fredrick J. Love
Unverified
Representative Lanny Fite
Unverified
Speaker 53
Representative Deborah Ferguson
Unverified
Carol Moore
Unverified
Representative Ken Bragg
Unverified
Speaker 89
Paula Stone
Unverified
Speaker 15