House Public Health, Welfare and Labor Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (5)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1116
· 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…Thank you. Thank you. Next up, Representative Lowry. That's House Bill 1116. Representative Lowry, you are recognized to present your b…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1076
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1076”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1172
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1172”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1181
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1181”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HR1005
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HR1005”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 16, 2026
The bill we're going to hear today is Representative Mayberry. While she's coming to the end of the table, I want to remind folks, this committee in particular, I mean, all committees handle bills that get emotional. This committee in particular handles emotional bills, and all I ask for is we will hear whatever testimony we need to hear, however you feel, that's how you feel. We can't stop that, but we don't want people dealing directly into personalities. We want you to talk on the bill. We want you to talk on what the bill does. Let's not get off of scope when we're testifying, and I will appreciate that very much.
I know all these members will. This is nothing personal. This is law, but I know it gets emotional when you're dealing with things that are near and dear to your heart. So just do so. We'll do all testimony with respect, and, again, this committee will appreciate that. Representative Mayberry, you're recognized to present your bill. Members, I
am proud to introduce this legislation to you today. I feel that this is a bill that no matter what side of the abortion debate you are on, you can vote yes on this bill.
If you are pro-life, like myself, you know that this keeps an abortion procedure from coming to our state. Currently, it is not already here, and it is much easier to prevent something than it is to stop it after it gets started. If you are on the other side of the abortion debate, you can feel good about voting for this. The argument has always been to keep it legal and to keep it safe. This bill keeps chemical abortion legal.
It does not change the status quo in Arkansas. This bill also keeps the procedure safer because it guarantees the woman that a doctor is going to be engaged in her care and not in some other state. Let me explain what a webcam abortion is. A woman who wants an abortion, perhaps in rural Arkansas, could go and would be in front of a computer and would talk to a doctor that might be in New York City. That doctor would talk to the woman
and would then hit a button and the door, a drawer would open up. That drawer would contain two doses of medication. the one dose the woman would take right then and that essentially that chemical would kill the baby by FDA protocol the woman would then go home and she would take the remaining dosage of medication and that medication would expel the baby there are complications that can happen from this procedure first of all if an
ectopic pregnancy was not diagnosed ahead of time this could be dangerous for the woman. You need the doctor to examine the woman in person before that procedure takes place. Also, the woman can have lots of bleeding with this. The woman can also get an infection from this and many other complications. That woman is in rural Arkansas. The doctor is in New York City. That woman is not going to be able to get on a plane and fly to New York to that doctor for help.
and I promise you that doctor is not going to fly from New York City down to rural Arkansas to help that woman. So where does that woman go for the medical emergency and to seek help? This is a bill that all of you can feel good about passing today, and with 14 of you on this committee as co-sponsors of this bill, I would appreciate a good vote. Members, you've heard an explanation, Bill. Is
there any questions? Anyone have any questions for Representative Mayberry?
Seeing none, we have, I'm sorry, Representative Love, you do. I didn't see.
And with 14 co-sponsors, I'm pretty sure you'll get a good vote. But what I do want to ask you is how many recorded webcam procedures have we had in Arkansas? None. this procedure
does not currently exist in the state of Arkansas it has not taken place to our knowledge it has not taken place so we are stopping
it before it happens so the status quo Representative Love, the status quo in Arkansas stays the status quo Okay, thank
you Mr. Chairman Seeing no for the questions First to speak against this bill is Ms. Rita Schuyler, Scar, I'm sorry. If you come to the table, introduce yourself for the record.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman, members of the committee. I appreciate the fact, knowing that I may testify before this committee again, that you're encouraging a civil discussion of the bills, which is what the ACLU is interested in. I'm Rita Sklar, Executive Director of the ACLU of Arkansas. We represent 4,000 members in Arkansas but look out for the constitutional rights of all Arkansans.
We believe that it is not in the best interest of the health and safety of patients for lawmakers to instruct doctors in the practice of medicine to prescribe which procedures already approved by the relevant medical, professional, and government regulatory and licensing agencies should be performed on a patient, how and under what circumstances. We believe medical decisions are best made
by medical professionals, and we believe in the sanctity of the relationship between doctor and patient. We believe that government regulation of matters that are in the purview of medical professionals is, in our opinion, too much government. I'll take any questions if there are any. Thank you. Representative Miller, you're
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Ma'am, does your group represent the unborn babies also?
We, like the United States Supreme Court, do not recognize that fetuses have constitutional rights. Period. Evidently. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Yes, sir. Representative
Thank you, Mr. Chair. One of the questions I was wondering about was along the lines of something that you brought up when you talked about concern on the health and safety factor of the woman involved with this process. And I'm just curious that if a physician is out of state and administering this with no immediate attention and something happens as a result, then whose liability does it become to assume the responsibility
of not only that woman's immediate medical needs but also the financial obligations that come along with that? Well,
of course, a woman wouldn't be sitting at home talking to a doctor out of state. she would be in a medical facility with perhaps a physician assistant, nurse, advanced nurse, practitioner, some medical professional other than a doctor. So it's not like, you know, she's sitting in her sewing room talking to somebody,
and I noticed that New York was the most despised state that a doctor could be from. But in any event, that's the true picture is that there would be a medical professional there and medical services available to her should something go wrong, that nobody's going to perform this procedure in the middle of the wilderness where she can't have access to medical
care. Okay, well, let me reframe my question. Who is the person that is legally on the line for what ultimately happens to this woman
under this procedure? Is it the doctor? Well, if there's no doctor
involved, I believe it would be the medical professional from whom she has received the care. But this
would have to come ultimately from a doctor. Is that not correct, or did I misunderstand
that? I can't answer that question. Perhaps the next witness can. It may be that
when Representative Mayberry comes close, maybe she can answer that.
Seeing no further questions, thank you, Ms. Golar. We're going to go to Eric Wewers, who will testify for the bill. Okay, thank you. We'll move to the next against. That would be Ashley Wright. if you would introduce yourself for the record and you're recognized to begin thank you mr chairman good
Speaker 42
9:48
morning members of the committee my name is ashley wright i'm speaking
on behalf of my client planned parenthood of the heartland planned parenthood of the heartland is opposed to house bill 1076 this bill will restrict access to medication abortion which is a safe and legal procedure by banning the use of telemedicine telemedicine is widely used throughout the medical community and is a strategy that is breaking down access barriers to health care, particularly for rural Arkansans. Many areas of medicine use a telehealth delivery system, including mental health and psychiatric services, dermatology, cardiology,
and it is utilized by government systems such as VA hospitals and the Department of Corrections. The American Medical Society has recognized that, quote, the advancement of telemedicine will allow patients to obtain excellence in health care, end quote. The American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists also support advancements through the use of telemedicine, and in particular have identified telemedicine abortion services as a promising strategy to reduce the incidence of second trimester abortion. This bill will have a negative impact on women seeking an abortion in Arkansas.
Medication abortion is only available in the first nine weeks of pregnancy. The vast majority of counties in Arkansas lack an abortion provider, and many women have limited access to private transportation or work and child care responsibilities may make it difficult for them to travel long distances and take time off work. If a woman is unable to get to a provider within those first nine weeks of pregnancy, she would miss the window of eligibility for medication abortion, and she would then only be left with a surgical option. Restricting access to medication abortion could ultimately increase the number of surgical abortions in Arkansas.
Additionally, many women have really personal reasons for preferring a medication abortion, including that it feels less invasive, which is a strong consideration for survivors of sexual abuse. Medication abortion provides a woman with a non-invasive procedure to end a pregnancy, one that she feels is more private and she will be more comfortable and closer to home. She is supported throughout the entire process by a medical professional The evidence-based regimen used for medication abortion is recognized by both the AMA and ACOG as safe and effective
Complications from the regimen are extremely rare and are far more rare than complications associated with pregnancy The adverse event rates for the regimen are much lower than other medications commonly prescribed through the use of telemedicine including psychotropics such as Welbutrin and Xanax A new study released this week in the journal Contraception affirms that medication abortion is highly effective and very safe. Telemedicine is a very promising strategy for delivering health care in a rural state like Arkansas. Telemedicine ensures that Arkansans have access to health care
regardless of their geographic location. Any bill that bans telemedicine sets a dangerous precedent that could jeopardize telemedicine in all avenues of health care. Planned Parenthood works very hard every day to make sure women receive high-quality health care based on research in the field, the latest recommendations from medical associations, new technologies, and feedback from experts, patients, and regulators in order to continually improve practice. We all want to protect women's safety. The bottom line is that laws limiting access to safe and legal abortion
have no basis in medicine, and in fact, these laws go against years of medical research. It is past time that medical decisions be left to a woman and her health care provider. I urge you to not advance this bill. I'll take any questions. Members, any questions? Seeing
none, thank you, Ms. Wright. Thank you. Representative Mayberry, would you like to come close for your bill? And maybe, if you can, answer Representative Hammer's question from earlier.
Thank you. I will address that question by answering it in this way. Again, so you can feel good. Little Rock Family Planning Services that provides chemical abortions here in the state of Arkansas has on their website what their requirements are to have this type of an abortion. And on their website, they say if you live more than 30 minutes drive outside of Little Rock, you must agree to stay in Little Rock, usually at a motel, for at least one night,
and you must have two visits. Why do they ask you to stay close to Little Rock? Because they don't want you getting out into rural Arkansas and having problems. They're the ones saying you need to stay close to the doctor. It also says that surgical abortion is necessary in about 5% of the cases. One in 20 women have to have a surgical abortion. If the doctor is not in Arkansas, who is going to perform that surgical abortion?
I'd also like to answer by telling you that the makers of this medication, Mifeprex, and what they say on their website. And it says, because it is important to have access to appropriate medical care if an emergency develops, the treatment procedure is contradicted if a patient does not have adequate access to medical facilities equipped to provide emergency treatment of incomplete abortion, blood transfusions, emergency resuscitation, during the period from the first visit until discharged by the administering physician.
And I can share many other facts if you want me to, but I think the point is very clear. Representative Hammer, did I answer your question? Yes, ma'am. Thank you very much. Then
Speaker 45
15:35
again, committee, I would appreciate a good vote. Representative Bentley, for
what purpose? I have a question. Chairman? Yes, ma'am. You're recognized. Representative Maybrick, I'd like to
address the one situation that was brought up about the fact that if we ban this telemedicine, that rural Arkansas and women will not be able to get medical abortions.
Can we discuss the fact that doctors all throughout, we have physicians all throughout the state that have a personal relationship with that woman, and she can't receive a medical abortion through her physicians.
you clarify that? That is the status quo. If you want to read the bill, we'll take you straight to the language. This is all we're saying. This is on page 2, line 17, when mifepristone or another drug or chemical regimen is used to induce an abortion.
And the initial administration of the drug or chemical shall occur in the same room and in the physical presence of the physician who prescribed, dispensed, or otherwise provided the drug or chemical to the patient. This does allow chemical abortions, the status quo, to stay that way if the woman is before nine weeks of the pregnancy. Thank you. What's the will of this committee? We have
a due pass. Any discussion on the motion?
Hearing no discussion, all in favor? Aye. Those opposed? No. Congratulations, Representative Mayberry. You passed your bill. Thank you. Thank you. Next up, Representative Lowry. That's House Bill 1116. Representative Lowry, you are recognized to present your bill.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. And if it would be appropriate, I'd like to have my first witness participate with me in my opening statement.
Speaker 64
17:55
and the record, please? Good morning, committee members. I'm Michael Retzer. I'm an owner, a McDonald's owner operator in
Mr. Chairman. Thank you, committee members. House Bill 1116, I have billed as the Youth Employment Act.
What the current law does is it sets standards as well as we should, limitations on how many hours youth can work. Right now the law says anyone under the age of 18 has to, the law pertains to them. And if you looked at the bill, you can see that actually there were some pretty broad parameters. Some that were almost draconian, I mean, or not draconian, but amazing that they could work up to 54 hours.
They could work more than six days in a week. I mean, that's really not restrictive at all. But the problem that has come up is that the compliance cost of documenting, and this is why I have Mr. Retzer here, and he'll testify to that, of what the compliance costs have been. They have been so onerous in many cases that many employers have chosen to not hire 17-year-olds. So all I've really done with this bill, the first thing I did was lower that threshold from 18 to 17
so that these restrictions relate to any child working under the age of 17, so 16 and younger. But at the same time, I went back and I looked at these hours and thought, you know, we really shouldn't have something on the books that says, you know, we think it's okay for children to work up to 54 hours a week. So I've also amended that number to 40 hours in a week, that they would work no more than eight consecutive hours in any one day.
They would be limited to five days of work rather than six. At this point, if it's the will of the chair and it's okay, I would like Mr. Retzer to explain really the need from his perspective of why this bill needs to be passed.
Speaker 64
20:09
Yes, please, we'd like to hear that. Thank you, Representative Lowry. So from my perspective, I own 19 restaurants, and on average we employ 60 employees at each restaurant
and mostly rural South Arkansas. And in the last few years, we've gone away from hiring 17-year-olds. There's only two communities in which I currently hire 17-year-olds. And, you know, when you're managing a lot of part-time and full-time employees, It just becomes too burdensome for a general manager to worry about clocking in, clocking out, working more than eight hours in a 24-hour cycle, and we've just steered clear of it.
You know, it's my belief that parents should control and have the final say on their child, their 17-year-old's work. But, you know, we're being in the food service business, we're a great representation of where many 17-year-olds will come to find employment. And it can be a great experience for them to accelerate their growth into the workforce. And I would like to ask for each of you all's support in this bill.
I think it's something that can help many Arkansas middle-class families to have that 17-year-old saving money for college, saving money to buy a vehicle, or continuing to accelerate their growth into the workforces, which is what we all want. And so with that, I'll entertain any questions. Would this bill open up a whole new workforce
for your industry? I mean, are you having trouble finding people to do the jobs now?
Speaker 64
21:54
Like I said, so in South Arkansas, there's two robust communities where industry in Stuttgart and in Sheridan, for example, the industry is very strong in those communities. And so there's high-paying jobs. And so those communities, we've gone to hiring 17-year-olds because we need them. When you've got the type of business we've got, you need to cover all shifts. and it's a great benefit in those communities to having the 17-year-olds be available and be productive for us.
So certainly in those communities, which is what we've done, but everywhere else we steer clear just because of the burdensome that Representative Lowry laid out in his testimony. Representative Payton, you're
recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Lowry, agriculture being the largest industry in Arkansas, My question is, how does your bill affect farming operation? It may be incorporated, but it's basically a family farm during planting and harvest. You know, a lot of times an eight-hour day just doesn't get it done.
How does your bill affect where a 16-year-old or a 17-year-old would be employed on the family farm trying to get the things done during harvest or planting? Well, first, the
17-year-old would not be affected because they would be treated like any other laborer, adult laborer. The restrictions would come in when you're talking about 16 years and younger. And I think that these tightened restrictions, I think, are necessary because we are talking about a younger workforce.
So it would be tightening the current restrictions, limiting them by one day a week, and limiting them to eight hours a day. But it
ask you this. If they're going to school five days a week, Saturday they need to work 10 or 12 hours, they would not be allowed to do
Speaker 77
23:50
that under this bill? I believe that that is correct. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Would it
only be considered work if they're being paid by, whether it's a corporation or whatever?
In other words, you may be talking about representing Payton like a family farm. Is that kind of where
you're going? Well, of course, that's true. Family farms a lot of times pay their children, you know, and like our family business, I detailed cars. You know, I got paid something for doing that. Right. So, you know, in most cases when a family business is incorporated, they do try to compensate their children in one way or another for the hard work they do. Right. Right. Thank you.
Jeff, Jeff. Jeff. Vice Chair Ferguson, you're recognized Reading this, now they can work 10 hours on a Saturday Is that what I'm reading? And you're just reducing that by two hours? Right So it would really just change the farm work by two hours
Yeah, and I would say that originally I did not touch any of those issues of 54 hours or 10 hours
in a day or anything and I may have overreacted to some criticism that I got through the Arkansas Times blog of wanting to return us to the days of Charles Dickens I mean they were just painting me in the most awful way and I started looking at it and went well you know that is a little extreme I had not thought of the example that Representative Payton brings up where you are talking about weekend work but I think that the very fact that we are lowering this age and you're talking about
16 year old and younger we probably do need to have some reasonable standards and a 10 hour work day is pretty extreme and I appreciate the clarification by the chairman that if it's a family farm they probably would be able to work around that Representative
Payton Thank you again Mr. Chair I mean I grew up in rural Arkansas we you cut and bale hay and there's a thunderstorm coming and you know would I be in violation of the law if if the
family is loading hay and and trying to get it off the field before the rain comes because we have to put in a 10 or 12 hour day I mean this is you know I think when you cut the hours like you're doing you're just putting good people in violation of a law unnecessarily. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Would it, Mr. Faulkner, can you shed any light on this? Would you please, would you come to the end table, introduce yourself, Daniel Faulkner with Department of Labor, and maybe we can get clarification on
Speaker 86
26:41
this. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Daniel Faulkner, Attorney, Arkansas Department of Labor. Generally speaking, anybody employed for money, in essence, would be covered by this law. There are some exceptions for short-season crops, agriculture, and like Representative Lowry, I didn't dig too deep on that because I didn't anticipate that question. I'd be happy to get with you after committee and dig through the details of that, but we are neutral in the bill. We're happy with the pleasure of committee. So what
if you, say, owned a pharmacy and you had a 16-year-old
daughter that you want to be. Wait, wait, wait. Whoa. I'm sorry. Out
of order. I apologize. Go ahead. Rep. Sohammer, you're recognized for a question. Does this, how would this scenario work if you had a, if you had a, if you had a teenage child that worked at one place and then maybe they maxed out on their hours and they wanted to work or say they work two separate jobs, is this per employer
or is it total number of hours regardless of however many employers they work for? Rep. Hammer, it's
you could actually be working two separate jobs, working the maximum number of hours allowed underneath this? Correct. We look at those records by employer. So
Speaker 86
28:09
I frankly never had that come up, but we would enforce it by employer. Okay. All right, thank you. Representative Boyd, your recommendation for a question.
My apologies, Mr. Spence. So let's say you owned a small business, you have children, one of them is 16, so in a summertime that child could not legally work or be paid more than 40 hours in any week. Generally there's an exception
Speaker 86
28:38
for a business owned or controlled by the parent, so generally those hours limits don't apply for those types of situations. Representative Ritchie you
Mr. Farmer I'm going to get this right since there's a lot of farmers who hire high school kids for the summer and different things did you say there was an exemption for agriculture there are some exemptions for agriculture
Speaker 86
29:04
but I hate to play the lawyer game but it's a little fact specific some are for certain types of crops some are for a certain number of days per year and I'd like to know the exact scenario before i'd answer that i'm happy to do that i just don't want to give a general statement that may not be accurate yeah follow up with that yes
during the summer a lot of farmers work at least six days a week um and they they employ high school kids and they go out there and work and they're maybe crop consultants people out inspecting the crops all kinds of different things going on so do you think that would fall under the exemption or they would they those those kids would have to only do five days a week well it's sort of couched in terms of
Speaker 86
29:54
seasonal crop and man days i'm not trying to be in a difficult here i just
don't have enough facts to answer the question and i'd be happy to get with anybody on the agricultural issue anytime to discuss this thank you i apologize for sure representative
miller Do you have a question, sir? Yes, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Lowry, I think that your bill is warranted, and I think we've got a good idea here. But I am kind of like being from rural Arkansas, and like I said, we have a family business.
We are incorporated, and my son works for me. I work for our family business, all that kind of stuff. very familiar with this, would you be willing to hold off on this until we can maybe get with the gentleman from the Department of Labor and see if we can work through some of this stuff? Sure. That is fine. And
I do apologize that the only thing that's really brought on concern has been the changing of hours and days.
I just felt like that that was the right thing to do when you're talking about 16-year-olds, 15-year-olds, 14-year-olds. But I did not anticipate seasonal work and things like that. So before, I guess, I close or pull the bill down, I would point out that the Arkansas Hospitality Association, they're here ready to testify that they're in favor of it. As you've already heard, the Department of Labor has no concerns with it.
But we can look at these hours. but I do appreciate the thoughtful consideration and certainly am willing to bring it back. I think that would be a good
idea, Representative Lowry. I think it's a good bill, but obviously a different industry with concerns, and we'd like to hear it again. Okay. All right. Well, thank you very much, committee. Thank you. Is there any other non-committee members in here wanting to run a bill before we move to committee members? Seeing none. Next up is, who's next?
Rep. Hamm, are you ready to run your bill, sir? 1172? That's what we've got. Yes, sir. Would you
like to go to the end of the table? You're recognized. I present your bill, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. This is House Bill 1172. This language in this bill actually mirrors what is referred to in the House as House Rule 72.
That particular rule, if you're not familiar with it, establishes some requirements that if you are going to run a bill that deals in the area of scope of practice or other things that are listed on this bill, that that same expectation would be placed whenever an item is going to be brought before rules and regs. So what we're doing with this bill is saying that in the rules and regs that you'd have to have a study
that would be presented before action could be determined by rules and regs when it comes to areas dealing with such a scope of practice and some of the other areas that are mentioned in there. The intent of the bill is, and the reason the bill is being presented, is to make sure that when things come up in the interim, dealing with areas such as scope of practice, that the committee members on rules and regs have ample amount of time to be aware of those items that are coming up, and that there's a study for the basis for need for consideration.
Part of this is brought to you from the fact that it also brings agencies to a greater standard of accountability that before coming, before rules and regs, that they would have to have study or information that's made and mailed to the committee so the committee can make better choices and more informed decisions instead of having to deal with something that just pops up at the last minute and comes through rules and regs. I'm going to be glad to answer any questions. Representative Hammer, I like the concept here.
I like the idea. Rules and regs during the interim is a joint committee. And in the House, we use the House rules to determine if something is changing the scope of practice or not. So how would, if there's a question about whether a rule changed the scope of practice, what body would that be referred to to answer that question if it's a scope
of practice or not? Well, as far, and I question the attorney as far as, you know, is this something that could be adopted by rules and regs itself and just handled by the committee?
The reason that I'm presenting it to you as legislation is because there are agencies that bring issues before rules and regs, and also because that House rule applies only to the House side, this would make it applicable to any issue relating to this topic or these topics that's brought before there. And, again, I agree with that
concept, but the question is, we'll say that the ABC commission, whatever, I didn't mean to bring up alcohol, that wasn't it, just whatever.
You've got to be so careful with acronyms. So a certain commission or board brings forward a rule that you and five other members of the rules and regs or whoever determines that this is scope of practice, but others five or six may disagree it's not scope of practice what body determines whether that's scope of practice well i think the question i think the
answer to the question would be that it would be rules and regs that would determine that it is an issue that is considered scope and practice and it
could be a vote by the rules and regs committee itself with
a simple majority determining whether it's a scope of practice or not
and then at that point that it did then a study would have to be done or a study would have to be put forth for it to be brought back to the rules and regs before a decision could be made that way you don't have somebody just coming in at the last minute and saying here's the rules and regs we want to put in without any study going into it and it creates for greater transparency that all members are made aware of it and basically it slows the process down a little bit to make sure that
all the members are well-informed. Representative Branscombe, as the Chair of Council, I think you may have some
input on this. Well, as I understand it, under the new Amendment 1 that was passed in November, this is going to pretty well take care of your problem, I think. With the passage of Amendment 1 that currently is, as we understand it, and we're now working on the rules of it, the guts of the bill.
Before something like you're talking about can be passed, it's going to have to become before this committee, the council before a major change in a committee could be done anyway. Well, and what I would be
willing to do is want to get the idea out there first of all today. What I'd be willing to do is pull it down because, as in a couple of the other amendments, I'd want to maybe reserve the right to bring this bill back up in the event that as we progress along and people learn more about Amendment 1 and other amendments,
we make sure that that may be the intent and the idea right now, but that may not turn out to be the case, and before the session's over, I'd want to be able to bring this back
up before the committee. I think it's a great idea, Representative Hammer. Maybe you could put it into the package of bills that Representative Branscombe is working on and how the council and rules and regs will carry forward. I think it's a great idea, but a couple details. Maybe if you were to Representative Branscombe, you'd be willing to work on that, I'm sure, right? he says absolutely and if we've got to come back before this body
that'd be great but I think it's a great concept I'm just not sure it's there if you're happy with that members any other questions or comments before he leaves in the table everybody's happy with it thank you next up is does it represent Boyd I believe you have a resolution to present if you go to the end of the table Sorry, members, that is H.R. 1005 is what Representative Boyd is presenting, and you are recognized, sir.
Mr. Chair, committee members, House Resolution 1005 really does two things. First, it isolates some facts surrounding prescription drug abuse in the state. And then second, it encourages certain bodies, such as the pharmacy board, the medical board, ACHI, to work together. If you have any questions, I'm happy to answer them. Members, any questions?
Representative Sullivan, you're recognized for a question. Are they not working together now? I think they are working together now. I think that a resolution from this body helps solidify
House side of the legislature. Thank you. I've been in that position before. I appreciate
that. Okay. Representative Ward-Wall, I think you have a motion. Is that right? Motion do pass. Any discussion on the motion?
All those in favor? Any opposed? That's pretty good for this committee, 50%. We're like good goalies, aren't we? It's a rough committee. Welcome to our committee, Representative Copeland. Are you ready to present your bill? I am. He's adding me signs. All right. Representative Copeland is going to present House Bill 1181. He has an amendment. And he has an amendment that he would like to add on in this committee. And is it going to be paper copies for that, Phil?
Okay. Phil is going to hand out paper copies of the amendment that we must first consider before we consider the bill itself. If you give us just a moment, Representative Copeland, we'll hand out copies of that and you'll be recognized to present your amendment, not the bill, sir, just the amendment.
I believe everybody has a copy of that. Representative Copeland, tell us about the amendment, please. Thank
you, Mr. Chairman. I started to use that opening line that I've heard a lot in my first few days.
This is just a little bill that doesn't do much, but I thought that probably wouldn't be appropriate, so I'm not going to use it. But what the amendment actually does is just simply adds some co-sponsors. Then also there was a future date used there within the Social Security Act, and it just makes it a past date rather than a future date. It was the only two things. So the date was strictly a technicality, and then added the co-sponsors was basically the element of the amendment.
Members, any question about the amendment? Seeing none, what's the will of the committee? Representative Bentley, you would move to adopt the amendment into this bill. Okay. That motion is made. All those in favor? Any opposed? Okay, members, now we're going to hear about the bill itself with this amendment adopted. And you'll
recognize Representative Copeland. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. This bill is to repeal the private option.
It is, I think the two key elements of the bill is one is to cap enrollment. We have said repeatedly, a lot of people at least have, that we want, And I think the administration, we want to wrap this up. And so this bill ends the private option effective December 31, 2015. Caps it as of July 1st of 2015. Also, another, I believe, key important part of this bill is that there is a notification section.
And so we immediately, within 90 days of the passage of the bill, We would notify everybody that is presently on the private option that this program is ending. And then anybody that were to sign up, if we were to get a waiver to continue covering people during the interim, because it does have that provision as well, they would also get a notification. That's very important in that when you give notification, other states have proven that you start having a falling off rate of about 5% a year.
so within a year you'd have about a 60% reduction in the people in the program. And if I may, Mr. Chairman, just from my angle as far as a representative, I'm also a pastor, and I have a nonprofit that I started four years ago. Our congregation is about 300 people. Half of those are on the private option. Half of those are on Medicaid. So this is not a light thing for me. probably 95 to 98 percent of the people that are in our non-profit that we see about 400 people a
year they're almost all on the private option are on within the Medicaid expansion population so this is I'm very excited about Senator Hendren's bill because I believe Senator Hendren's bill the cornerstone of that bill is that it has a task force I believe that's the part that is the most understood cornerstone of that is the task force. There is another bill that's going to be coming up that has some real good accountability factors, and I believe mine adds the notification and also
adds the freezing, or yes, the freezing aspect. So I believe those three things, that three-prong approach, and I'm very excited about the task force because I believe there are going to be some great reforms come out of this, and we're going to be able to reform our whole program, and that's my hope to help everybody that I serve in every capacity that I hold to make our state a great environment to have insurance and to be able to help them with their overall health care. Members, you've heard
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I want to call you Pastor Copeland, but Representative Copeland, let me ask you, Does the governor support
this bill? He hasn't talked to me about it. I don't know. To be honest with you, I don't know, Representative. Okay. I know he represents us ending the private option, so I would assume he does.
I would think he'd be thrilled, but I can't speak
Chairman. Representative Hammer, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Copeland, if I just want to, my interpretation is that this is going to end the private option effective December 31, 2015. That's the hard date. Is that correct? Correct. Okay. And I think we've heard others express that their intent is to end it December of 16.
Am I correct on that? Yes, sir, Representative Hammer. Okay. And is it your idea that with the task force, if that bill survives and gets through, the task force, do you expect that it will have its recommendations completed by December of 15? Or what happens if they don't have the recommendations completed by then and it carries over into the 15 to 16-year time frame? What happens to folks in between?
Well, I would say I think we need to end it sooner than later just because of the – I think we're all sitting here and very much concerned as I am, and I know that you are and some of you even more than me, about the 210,000 people, which is – I've heard 230, but I know it's over 200,000, which is above our largest estimate that it was ever going to be, by the way. And so if we wait, that's going to be 300,000. It could be $350. It could be $295.
And so I think the angst just goes up, not down. And so while I'm very open, Representative Hammer, if the task force said, hey, you know, we just can't get it done by then, you know, that's something that I think we should look at. But I do think just because of the continued enrollment, it needs to end sooner rather than later. All right. Thank you.
Thank you, Mr. Hammer, Representative Hammer. Is Mr. Curtis in here from the governor's office? I didn't think about that one. There you are.
Could you go to the end of the table for me, sir? I go
sir. I will. Representative Sullivan, you recognize for a question? Yes, understanding Mr. Cope and Representative Copeland, and understanding the value of collaboration, would you be willing to collaborate with the governor's office or the task force to discuss and open some discussions about changing that date,
for example, pending a task force recommendation if that's prolonged or pending other circumstance that the governor or his staff may be concerned about? Would you be willing to enter into those conversations with them? I wouldn't just be willing. and I'd
be thrilled because when I heard the governor talk about making the reforms and looking at the whole pile, I was so excited and very excited about what he has planned. So absolutely. Great. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Payton, you're
recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Representative Copeland, during the past 24 months and all the doors you knocked on and during the campaign and in consideration of the November election results, do you feel you have a mandate from the voters in your district to present this type of legislation?
You know, that's a pretty heady stuff, mandate, but I appreciate the question, Representative Payton. I can tell you unequivocally of the 3,000 doors I knocked on, I got two questions,
and one of those two questions was, are you for or against the private option ending? And I had it on my little handbill, and when I would say, yes, I'm far in it, and then I would try to say, you know, but I want to help people. Because of my background, they just slammed the door. They heard what they wanted to hear. And so, yes, I think it's overwhelming the citizens of the state. And we talk about the 210,000, and there's no one that lives that every single day anymore. There's people here equally as much as me.
But I live it every day. It's my business. And I have to stand in front of those people this Sunday, in fact, and I did last night. But, you know, I want to really help them going forward and help our state. I just don't think we're on a sustainable path. If I
could follow up. Yes, sir. Okay, thank you. Assuming we're going
But go ahead and try. Well, I may miss the mark again. I guess I was just going to try to simplify the question. And do you feel a responsibility to introduce this legislation based on your communication with people back home?
Yes, sir. I believe that we are concentrating on the 210,000, and I think we may have lost sight of the 2.7 million that are on the other side of the fence. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Bentley, you're recognized. Thank you,
Chairman. And my question is that as well to you, Donnie. We have been the past couple weeks heard numerous examples here of how the private option has helped those $200,000 that we're talking about. And so you and I want to talk a little bit about the other $2 million that we haven't discussed a little bit. So in orientation, we had the opportunity as legislators to go and hear the National Guard.
And the Major General there spoke to us and said that the national debt was his greatest concern. It wasn't ISIS, but his greatest concern for our nation was our national debt. because his folks there, the National Guard, 63% of their funding for their training was being cut because of the sequester. And so can you tell us, Donnie, what the cost to the American taxpayer has been
for the private option this year? Do you know that? It's approaching $1.6 billion. That's with a B. And then another $80 million of cost overrun in the state.
And so, I mean, everybody says it's a disaster. And, you know, I had a reporter ask me yesterday, he said, why are you doing this? And he said, and I asked him a question. I said, I know you're the reporter, but can I ask you a question? Do you believe right now SB 96, could you tell me definitively that it ends the private option and rolls back the expanded population? He said no. I said, do you think my bill does that? He said yes. I said, that's why I'm running it. Thank you.
Could I have a follow-up, Chairman, please, on one follow-up?
Yes, ma'am. Okay. I'm an employer, a small business owner, and I have a lot of 27-year-olds that work for me. And when I write their paycheck out, I kind of have to quince every time I print that check because I see that they maybe make $450, and 105 of that goes to taxes every week. So every week my employees lose one day of pay just to pay for taxes. And we have 20-year-olds that are single, they don't have families, and so their insurance rates have just really skyrocketed. And I'm sure that when I was out on the campaign trail, I had... I'm
There is. I'm getting there, and I appreciate your leanings with me because we've been pretty lenient hearing some private option pros. I just want to get a little bit of cons out there as we're on the campaign trail heard, and I appreciate it. Chair, my question's coming. Can you give us an estimate? I know that you talk on insurance rates, where you have seen insurance rates. I know teachers' insurance rates have skyrocketed, my insurance rates have skyrocketed. Can you tell us anything on insurance rate for the rest of that 2.5 million out there in the state that are not
on the private option? Yes, and I think they're being pushed, and personally, my insurance went up,
And most everybody I talk to, their insurance has gone up from as little as 18% up to 40%. So I think we're getting shoved in every direction. I don't think anybody probably would disagree with that. Is that in the bill
somewhere? I mean, seriously, folks, let's talk about the bill. We can, you know, this body has debated private option and all the things. But at this point in time, we're not dealing with statistics. We're not dealing with the bill. And that's our job. We need to do that. We need to debate the merits of this bill. And I understand that you feel some of that is.
Let me ask a question, then we'll get back into our list of, looks like, five more people. Explain to me the freeze. How does the freeze work in
your bill? What does it do? How does it work? It caps enrollment or freezes enrollment. At
does it stop enrollment? At the amount that it's enrolled presently at the passage of
that point in time. From my understanding, in fact, the bill actually has a provision to negotiate with the federal government
to extend the insurance to the end date. And all this is doing is capping enrollment so that we're not talking about 300,000 people now instead of 200,000 people. All right. Representative
Speaker 155
54:32
I have, on the date that this ends, what happens to 215,000 Arkansans and what happens to our community hospitals that are so dependent upon the reimbursement for this?
Considering all that happened with the ACA and decreasing Medicare reimbursements, what are we going to do? Are we just cutting them off? In this
country, we don't ever turn anybody away. We never have. And that does put a burden on our hospitals, and I've talked to some of those folks and heard from those folks as well that we're going to be visiting with some people Friday on the same subject, Representative. But I believe, you know, my thought on it is we were losing money. The hospitals were losing money before this started.
They're still losing money. And so I think the task force is going to really help us in that area. But we've done this for previous to this year. We've taken care of that population. And what most studies have proven with a lot of the states that have rolled back Medicaid and rolled pre-Obamacare, those people just go out and get a J-O-B. Okay. That's
I think we have. There has been a task force doing some work, but the actual mandated task force, I would assume that's true, yes, sir. Does your bill put in place a task force? No, Senator Hendricks does that. Well, what we're talking about is
your bill. Senator Hendricks' bill is not passed. It's not even come to this committee yet. But you're assuming that there's going to be a task force, so therefore you're kind of determining the votes of all these people in the House of Representatives as if there's going to be a task force. If your bill has a task force, then let's talk about it.
But I don't think we can talk about something we think might happen or you think might happen because we've got 99 other people that's going to make a vote on that. So for you to assume there's going to be a task
force, I don't think it's fair testimony to this committee. Well, no, I think that was your question, Mr. Chairman, that I have a task force in my bill. And I said, no, I don't. But we do have 100 legislators that I think can handle that job pretty well, quite honestly. And I think the citizens of the state are paying them. And we've got 2.7 million people in the state that probably make up a pretty good task force and have a lot of great ideas as well.
So you're assuming that we're going to form a task force, but your bill doesn't actually form a task force. Is that, I'm asking. So the governor may change
his mind and we may not have a task force. You're right. But I think if the governor gets his way, we'll have a task force. Okay, what happens if we
don't? What if we do? What happens if we don't have a task force? You're referring to a
task force. I'll tell you what I'll do. I'll put together a task force, and I won't be on it,
and we'll put some really smart people on it from insurance and health care. Would you like to amend your
so we're going to move on. I don't trust the governor to go through with that task force. I believe he's got the support to do
that, Mr. Chairman. Representative Bragg, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. With the end date of December 15, are there any legal contracts or obligations that would be affected that might extend beyond that time that would be affected by that end date?
I'm not aware of any. Maybe you are. No, I'm not. That's why I'm asking. Yes, sir. Okay. Thank
you, Mr. Chair. Professor Hamer, you're going to ask for a question. I have a question, but also I'd like to ask Representative Copeland, but I'd like to ask the chair a question, please. Yes, sir. The content of the bill, does it automatically hit any of the triggers that are in the original language?
If this freeze, the content of this bill puts this cap, or if this freeze, it immediately ends the federal waiver.
so through passage of this bill it would automatically trip one of the triggers that's in the original language it ends
the federal waiver as soon as this thing passes and becomes law yes sir okay we can have somebody from the bureau
testify to that but that's completely my understanding well would you mind having somebody in the room to come from the bureau or we will find somebody yes sir Okay, well, my question then is if that happens,
then we have everybody that's covered under the private option at that moment becomes uncovered, effective at that moment. 120, it's got
Speaker 163
59:13
a. It's not until 2000. I just want to clarify that if we vote this through, the unintended consequences
is it's going to trip one of those triggers. And we're going to find somebody that can help us
with that, Representative Hammer. I can give you my opinion in the fact that I've sat in front of the Health and Human Services Secretary
who looked at us and said, if you cap or freeze this thing, it stops the waiver immediately. We will not do that. But that's her words. It's not in the bill. It's not fact. It's fact, but it's not written down. And since I've kind of rapped about the task force that's been not in the bill, but it's been supposed, then I would like to have someone tell us that as well. So you have a question
for Representative Copeland? If I may. Yes, sir. Representative Copeland, the task force, there is a bill out there that if it makes it through and becomes law,
there will be a task force that will help us systematically approach how to handle the private option population in the event it goes away. Would you be willing to consider modifying your bill or holding until we see what happens with that task force, which I think is going to happen fairly quickly, and then tie your bill into that task force?
I'd rather leave my bill the way it is, Representative Hammer, and I really appreciate your sentiment there. I have full confidence that that's going to pass, that task force provision. If my bill were to pass and we got into a negotiation about an amendment to add a task force, if that bill didn't pass, I'm not only open to that, I'm excited about doing that. I would like to mention the chairman mentioned the Secretary Burwell's contention,
told them unequivocally that that would trip the trigger if we were to cap it, and he has no reason not to believe that, and I believe the chairman. But I also would contend that we also, the secretary said in the letter that our governor read to us, Secretary Burwell thanked us for agreeing to continue the expanded population through, quote, 2016. and when I asked that question does that mean we're going to keep the 210,000
people on through 2016 I was told that was just Secretary Burwell being political so I don't know if maybe her saying you cap it that may have also been political so I think it's fair to say either one of them could have been political just commentary Okay then let me if I may one
last question. Yes sir one follow up thank you Representative Hammer did
I think you did, but let me ask you, how did you come up with December 31, 2015?
What made you pick that particular date?
Thank you for asking that. I think there's a couple of things. One, I think from everything I can read in Senator Hendren's bill, SB 96 rather, I did not see any notification aspect in there for those 210,000 people. And I think it's only fair, right, and the humane thing to do to give those people, one, I wanted to give them, to answer your question, almost a year to make other plans.
Then I wanted them to be notified, and I didn't see that notification in SB 96. And I don't think it's right. If we're really going to end this, whether it be 2015 or 2016, these people need to be made aware of that. They need to have the ability to
make other plans. Is the intent of your bill to drive a date that if the task force does or does not get formulated to have a hard date and in a backdoor way force the task force that is possibly going to be coming into place
to move on an expedited timetable? No, sir. I
would like for them to have all the time that they need, and I believe 11 months is a lot of time. I'm not trying to push anybody or try to, you know, force them to make quick decisions. No, sir. I would like for them to have all the time they need, and I believe 11 months is a lot of time. All right. Thank you. Thank you. Representative
is really more of a point of information because we would have two competing bills.
The assumption is if both of them pass, they have two different dates. Which one would take precedence? Because, I mean, we've had this before where you've had two competing bills potentially pass. Do we know which one would take precedence? Okay,
the general rule, and so maybe clarification we need on that. General rule is the last bill that passes is the newest law that supersedes the next one. So then that's the general rule of thumb, Representative Meeks.
So the point is, assuming this bill passes, but then Senator Hendren's bill passes last, then really this bill will... Of course, I don't know if it matters
which one passes or which one that the governor signs last. That's when it becomes law. I don't know. As I've said before, I'm in over my head when I start talking about that stuff. And we're not going to be able to get anybody from the Bureau over here anytime soon. Representative Hammer, we do have some other folks in the room that might be able to testify a little bit.
upon the waiver and how it would work, if that would be okay with you, or would you rather have somebody I mean, we're not going to be
able to get anybody from the Bureau. Today. Today. I might like to make a recommendation to the Chair that if the decision this committee is going to make would in any way, shape, or form trip one of those triggers, I guess it would be when this becomes law that that trigger would be tripped, that we might want a delayed decision and have somebody here that could be considered
an expert in that. But just a friendly question. There's a
person in this room that knows that law and that waiver more inside than anyone else. He's just not from the Bureau. That's why I'm asking
you. What kind of expertise do you want? I recognize the chair's ability to discern expert witnesses, so I'll defer to you, sir. Then when we're done with
questions here, we will call him forward. Representative Sullivan, you're recognized.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Copeland, it seems that there's some concern based upon not only when the triggers are, but your law presumes that there is another commission. And given the fact that there are some presumptions made upon wind timelines, Is it your pleasure that we continue to move forward or that we might be able to wait until we have some of those answers with allowing you to bring this back up when some of those presumed responses are available to you?
No, sir. I would like to go ahead and proceed, and I appreciate that. And I would like to get from, you know, even if whatever happens here today, I'd love to get that information about tripping the trigger, and I respect the others in the room, but I'd love to get that from a nonpartisan, noninvested source that the chairman referenced, BLR. So I'd love to get that in writing, if I may. Thank you,
Mr. Copeland. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Professor Ferguson, you're recognized. Yes.
I think we, I agree with the governor. We need to look at total health care spending and do the fiscally and responsible thing and the compassionate thing to do. So I guess my question for you, if we're looking at Medicaid, the private option has actually shored up Medicaid to the tune of $55 million and has brought in $1.5 billion in revenue for those programs. So what would you do with all those senior citizens in a Medicaid program
that has become unsustainable? Well, previous to
the private option, yes, Medicaid had its own problems, and the governor is addressing that. But I don't remember hearing the level of angst and problems and budget concerns that we had before the private option. It was only after it. And so the private option does not affect those 65 and older. In fact, the only way it actually does affect them
because we're robbing Medicare to pay for Medicaid. And so to your point, Vice Chairman, is that I believe this will actually help our senior citizens and quit robbing from them to pay for the private option because I believe that's what's happening presently. Well, I
mean, you're talking about Medicare, which is the federal program which we don't control. Correct. We will still have all of those bad effects from the ACA.
And we will also, and you weren't here, but we were having serious debt problems in Medicaid. And that will be exacerbated if you immediately end this without some fiscally responsible way to move to a different health care system. Absolutely.
And I trust the task force, and again, that's with confidence that that's going to pass. And I've got confidence in you guys that that's going to pass. And so I believe those things are going to be addressed, and that's what the governor was referring to. in his address.
And just to Representative Bentley's thing, and the insurance things are also, they're not going away. Those are federal issues with the ACA. That's not anything that we control as state legislators. You're going to still, my insurance premiums doubled, you're still going to have those problems whether or not we continue the private option or not. And the ACA
is the Affordable Care Act, just for those listening. Rep. McGee, you're recognized for a question.
Motion, Mr. Chair. Rep. McGee, I'd rather hear the rest of the witnesses. Most in the proper time. Thank you. Fair enough. Yes, sir. Seeing no other questions, I'd like to, if at all possible, is there another question? I'm sorry. Rep. Blundstrom, I'm sorry. I didn't
see you. You're recognized. That's okay. I understand other states have implemented a freeze on their spending, and I went through and just did some quick research and found Colorado, North Carolina, Maine, Arizona, and Tennessee
have all done freezes where spending has dropped. Why is Arkansas any different? Why can't we do that as well? I'm not understanding. You're talking about a spending freeze, not an enrollment freeze. But if it's a spending freeze, we are limiting enrollment. We're saying there's only
so much money. Right, that you're spending on the number of people that's coming or that can be
coming in. An enrollment freeze is different. No, this is enrollment freezes. I'm sorry, I misspoke. Enrollment freezes have occurred in Colorado, North Carolina, Maine, Arizona, and Tennessee. I'm
Why not Arkansas? Why can't we control our own destiny as well?
Absolutely, and it's been pointed out in every state that has done this, that it's rolled back expansion, that it's healthier. People go back to work. They will rise to the level of expectation. And, you know, we said before we pass this, we don't pass this, the sky is going to fall. Now we're saying if we rescind it, the sky is going to fall. And it's just like it's been with tax cuts. You know, we said before if we make a tax cut, we're going to go in the tank,
and that didn't happen, and it won't this time when we cut taxes. And I believe this is just going to enhance, not put us in a negative situation, but it's going to put us in a more competitive situation as a state.
Okay, seeing no further questions, Mr. Seelig, would you like to tell us something about this waiver and maybe clarify some of the things I probably messed up? What we're looking for is what will happen to the existing waiver if this bill passes,
and I'm sure you've read this, and what will happen to our existing waivers?
Yes, sir, and I haven't had a chance to visit with Representative Copeland, but just reading the bill. As you pointed out, HHS has made it clear that we can't cap enrollment. It's really the Medicaid expansion around the country is kind of, it's an on or off switch. And if you have it, if you're eligible, eligible people can get it. You can't say only if you got in by a certain time. So if this bill passed, it says that, as I read it, July 1, those eligibility categories are
eliminated. So we would need to start notifying people really as soon as it passed to give them enough warning that their coverage will stop July 1. It gives us the ability to ask for a temporary category, working with the federal government, but they have been clear to us that they would not do that, particularly since it says it would only be available to people who had been on the program. In other words, for new people who were eligible, they couldn't apply. And the federal government has been very clear that you can't do that. So effectively, as I read the bill and talking with our attorneys, July 1, the private option would end, and
we need to start notifying people, probably the latest April 1, that their coverage was going to
end. Any questions for, lots of questions for Mr. Stigley. Representative Hammer, I see your
hand up first, so your question. Thank you. Mr. Stigley, make sure I interpret this correctly. So if this bill passes, it would trip one of the triggers that would, in essence, end coverage July 1st, even though the bill has an end date of December 31st, 2015.
By virtue of the fact it tripped one of the original triggers, everything stops July 31st. Is that correct or not? Yes, sir, with the
exception that it's not a trigger in the health care independence program in the law that was passed two years ago, but it is one of the requirements of the federal government, so our waiver would stop. In other words, the triggers in the law that was passed said that if the federal match rate increases or if the feds kind of change the rules on us, there were different triggers in there. This is not one of those triggers. This is simply one of the requirements at the federal level
as to how the program works. And this law, as I read it, this bill, says that the program will stop July 1 unless we got the federal government to agree to a temporary coverage group. And it's just clear to me that they will not agree to that based on everything I've understood and based on our conversation with the Secretary last
Thank you, Mr. Chair. We were told over and over two years ago that the reason we were doing this was to give Arkansas more control,
that Arkansas would have control of this program rather than the federal government. But now I am hearing Arkansas has very little control, that the federal government indeed has all the control. Would you agree? No, but there are some basic
requirements in the law that we can't get around. I think we do have a lot more control. In fact, what we have done with the private option, there are about 12 states that are now either doing what we're doing, some version of it, or looking at it. And I think it's because Arkansas has taken an approach where we have more control.
But there are some just basic requirements about income levels and eligibility that we can't – they're in the law. That's the way the federal government interprets it. And those things we don't – so we don't have total control. I would agree with that. But we do have more control than we would have
otherwise. Representative Bragg, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Selig, same question I asked a while ago. So if this were to end even earlier in July, are there any other contractual obligations or commitments that would be affected or have some legal implications for that?
Well, I'm not an attorney. I don't think there are any that we would have. I think there is a question about, for clients who have coverage through the private sector, whether they would have, I don't know that they would have any cause of action. They might try to have with private insurance companies, but I'm not aware of anything in particular that's a certainty at this point. We think, as we have talked about before, we think we can shut this program down with enough lead time, and that's why I'm saying, but we would need to start informing people a few months early.
Representative Sullivan, you're recognized for question. Yes, Bob. When, if we form the task force, The task force, in order to change the plan substantially and do what this bill does, ends enrollment. So what assurances do we have if we can't change the fundamentals that that's going to happen? Well, what assurance do we have? That we can wind that. I mean, we're talking about in the task force at the end of 2016,
this is going to wind down that expanded population. It's going to shrink or go away. If one of the fundamentals now are, I think you referred to them as basic components. If one of the basic components now is that we're not allowed to violate that part or change that, what assurances do we have that we can violate it in 2017? Well, you wouldn't be violating
it in 2017. It's kind of if you have the program, you have to meet these certain requirements.
But you don't have to have the program. A state can stop having Medicaid expansion at any time. And, in fact, the health care independence program, what we're working under now, the private option, it has a sunset of December 31st of 2016, so it will stop unless there's action by this committee. And one of the clauses that was put in Senator Hendren's bill to ensure that those people didn't somehow just kind of move to a regular Medicaid expansion program, I mean, there is now language in there that specifically says if the private option stops, we can't move those people into regular Medicaid.
So it will stop, by my understanding, unless this body and the governor choose to continue either it or something else in some way. So I feel completely sure that this program will stop if
no action is taken. Short follow-up. Yes, sir. So when the Secretary says that she's confident that we'll meet that expanded population's needs going forward, you're confident going forward to the Secretary ends at December 31st of 2016?
Right. I mean, what I took from the Secretary and from the Governor's comments was he wants to find some way to serve this population. But that doesn't necessarily mean with the private option. I took her letter to say I appreciate the fact that you do want to try to serve this population in some way. No more than that. I mean, she didn't say that you will continue Medicaid expansion. He didn't say that. I think what was said was we need to find some way to serve these clients. I have full confidence in our governor.
Chair. Mr. Seelig, earlier there was some discussion in regards to, you know, the budget and the Medicaid budget. Can you speak to that in regards to how this bill would affect the budget if
passed? Yes, sir. The Medicaid budget, when we passed the health care independence program, what we have in place now,
and the Affordable Care Act went in place, we have seen about, I believe it's about 90,000 people who were on the traditional Medicaid program where we pay 30% of the cost, shift over either into the private option or onto the exchange. And that is saving us about $55 million a year. If you assume that if you got rid of the private option and wanted to restore those Medicaid categories for women with breast and cervical cancer, for pregnant women, for people with tuberculosis.
If you were to restore those categories, we think it would cost about $55 million to put those back in place. And you all may remember, those of you who were here, you cut about $35 million in state funding that was going to different programs for indigent care, to mental health centers, community health centers, UAMS. If you assume that if those clients no longer have health insurance coverage, you're going to need to restore some of those indigent care funds, that's another $35 million. So the impact on the state budget this year of having this program in place is about $90 million.
So I think the governor and you all would have to look at, if you're going to restore those programs, finding the $90 million to do so. Hi,
Member Sino for the questions. what's will this committee what you have a motion
could I ask a procedural question real sure by passing this out of this committee we basically give the other 80 members of the house the ability to weigh in on this issue it
doesn't become law until after it goes through several more steps is that correct I'm I hopefully
you know that yes it's going to move out of this committee. If it moves out of this committee, it goes to the House floor where it has to receive 51 votes. Then we go to a Senate committee. We don't have to go to the Senate floor. I'd like to make a motion. And then the government will have to sign it. I'm going to make a motion. Do pass. Thank you. Members will have a motion. Do pass. Is there any discussion on that motion? Without discussion on that motion, yes. Let me just say, I think
the role of committees is to vet these things and to, you know, you want to take things that have been vetted to the house and I think it's responsible public health members don't just pass the buck it's your responsibility to vote how you think is right and not just pass it on to the house I'm sorry and we do
need to have a due pass as amended because this was amended in this committee so I will take that as due pass thank you Mr. Chair I amend my motion
yes sir the only discussion I want to have on this is y'all With my thought on this, and obviously Representative Copeland's not willing to work on this or amend it, my thought on this is I'm not sure why we're not adding the task force as an amendment to this rather than assuming another bill is going to pass, and then we don't know what the order of them is going to be and which one passes first and what becomes law. So it's possible that we would not have a task force in that. With that said, all in favor? Aye.
Those opposed? No. Those have it. Can I ask for a roll call? You cannot, but our members can. How many hands do I see? I see two, three. If we have enough, Mr. Price, call the roll, please. Representative Love. No. Representative Wardlaw. Representative Hammer.
Speaker 197
1:23:18
Yes. Representative Branscombe. Representative Meeks. Representative Meeks. Representative Overby. No. Representative Ritchie. Representative Ritchie. Representative McGee. No. Representative Miller.
Yes. Representative Womack. Yes. Representative Bragg. No. Representative Fite. Yes. Representative Payton. Yes. Representative Lundstrom. Yes. Representative Bentley, Representative Boyd, Representative Henderson, Representative
to pass anything out of the committee we have eight yeses 10 noes two not voting this bill fails seeing nothing else before this committee we're adjourned thank you chairman
Agenda
HB1076
HB1116
HB1172
HR1005
HB1181
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Chair
Unverified
Representative Julie Mayberry
Unverified
Speaker 12
Representative Fredrick J. Love
Unverified
Rita Sklar
Unverified
Representative Josh Miller
Unverified
Representative Kim Hammer
Unverified
Speaker 42
Speaker 45
Representative Mary Bentley
Unverified
Speaker 35
Representative Mark Lowery
Unverified
Speaker 64
Speaker 61
Representative John Payton
Unverified
Speaker 77
Representative Deborah Ferguson
Unverified
Speaker 86
Representative Justin Boyd
Unverified
Representative Chris Richey
Unverified
Speaker 99
Representative David L. Branscum
Unverified
Speaker 123
Representative Dan Sullivan
Unverified
Representative Donnie Copeland
Unverified
Speaker 155
Speaker 156
Representative Ken Bragg Chair
Unverified
Speaker 163
Representative Robin Lundstrum
Unverified
Speaker 177
Representative Charlene Fite
Unverified
Speaker 197
Speaker 211