Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House Judiciary Committee

February 3, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (4)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1117 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…ked that we pass over House Bill 1114 And that brings us to House Bill 1117, Representative Lowry You're recognized to present House Bi…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1114 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ar Agenda, Representative Lowry Has asked that we pass over House Bill 1114 And that brings us to House Bill 1117, Representative Lowry…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1197 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…s. Thank you, thank you committee Moving on down the agenda House Bill 1197, Representative Letting I understand is not going to run th…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1208 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…etting I understand is not going to run that today likewise House Bill 1208 Representative Gonzalez is not going to run that as well, s…”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 16, 2026
for the benefit of the committee members over the past couple weeks as we've had meetings I've generally announced them from the floor after we conclude our business upstairs for the day but from this point forward if it's Tuesday or Thursday just plan on being here and because we're going to this our agenda will start filling up if there is a reason to cancel a meeting then We'll do our best to let you know in advance But from this point forward Just plan on being here Tuesdays and Thursdays At 10 o'clock Going to our regular Agenda, Representative Lowry Has asked that we pass over House Bill 1114 And that brings us to House Bill 1117, Representative Lowry You're recognized to present House Bill 1117 Thank you Mr. Chairman and thank you committee for bearing with
▶ Play
me again on this bill. The first thing I want to do is I want to apologize to the committee for not being adequately prepared last time. I will blame that on the flu or hubris maybe because I thought that the subject area of this bill was so important that frankly it would fly through. But there were some very good questions raised. I'm not going to belabor the testimony I gave last week, but I am going to try and address some of the questions that were raised and explain why I've chosen to not make any changes. One of the issues that was raised is why age 65? Why this arbitrary age? How do we know that just because someone is 65, they are vulnerable to crime being committed to them? Well, it's not an automatic, but that is typically the definition of a senior citizen or an elder person would be 65 or older. The prosecuting attorney still has the discretion of whether to file under this enhanced penalty. I considered looking at some type of a test that would maybe have to be, you'd have to go through the process of determining whether the victim actually is more vulnerable because of their age. And frankly, I decided against that because that makes them the victim all over again. For them to have to, I mean, in many cases they're already embarrassed, especially if it's a financial fraud, they're embarrassed either for anyone to know, but sometimes they're family members. They're many times on the precipice of losing their independence, and then here comes a situation where they get defrauded. And so for them to have to basically prove that they are especially vulnerable I think would be just piling on. So the prosecutor still has the discretion in terms of interviewing the victim and finding out whether their age actually was the reason that they were targeted. The other issue that was brought up was whether it unfairly or wrongly took away discretion from the judge in terms of ordering that the enhanced penalty be served consecutively or concurrently and the bill actually says consecutively again I chose not to change this because it undermines the enhanced penalty if you are able to order that concurrently along with the other felony penalty the bottom line here is that this this enhanced penalty is intended to be a deterrent is intended to be an extra protection for those who, in many cases, are least able to protect themselves. I know some of these things are redundant from what I've said the other day. So rather than repeating a lot of those statements, I've brought out some troops in support. I know that Mr. Sanderson with AARP is ready to provide some testimony at the appropriate time, Mr. Chairman. Okay, let's see. Mr. Sanderson has signed up
▶ Play
to speak for the bill. I'll go ahead and call Mr. Sanderson to the end of the table. If you would, take a seat, state your name and who you represent, and then you may make your statement with regard to this bill.
▶ Play
Speaker 8 4:25
Thank you. I'm Herb Sanderson with AARP Arkansas. I appreciate the opportunity to come and speak today. This is an important issue for us. One in 20 older individuals are subject to financial exploitation in this country. The state of Utah did a study. Utah has slightly less population in Arkansas and found that losses were, just for the financial exploitation, were $52 million. In addition to the financial exploitation that happens when somebody is defrauded or taken advantage of, it has an effect on their senior's physical and emotional health. I'll just give you a quick example of somebody that I knew for a long time. Her husband passed away recently, I think it was eight days after the funeral, she received a call from somebody purporting to be with an insurance company, said that her husband had a life insurance policy, but the policy was lapsing, and if she would just give a little information, that policy could be reinstated. Well, about five minutes into the call, when they were asking for social security, bank numbers, etc. She wised up and hung up the phone. It was obviously a scam, and what these people were doing is they take the obituaries, and that's their sales leads that they use to take advantage of people. But it is a huge problem, and we think this bill would go a long way to correcting the exploitation that's taken place out there, and we appreciate a good vote on the bill. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Sanderson. We have one other
▶ Play
individual who signed up to speak on the bill. Jeff Rosenzweig signed up to speak against the bill. If you would, take a seat, state your name, who you represent, and then you may make your statement. Jeff Rosenzweig, Arkansas Association
▶ Play
Speaker 11 6:33
of Criminal Defense Lawyers, and I spoke against this bill last time. I'm not going to speak on the policy issues again that's that's a matter for you to determine but the bill has some draftsmanship issues which I spoke on before and which I would have hoped representative Lowry would have tried to fix but apparently decided not to those problems of course are still there one is the mismatch of 60 to 65 in certain statutes the question of whether the defendant has to have knowledge of some sort that the person was over 60, was 65 or over. You have some possible chaotic issues by changing the relevant culpable mental states as opposed to the underlying offense. And you may have, therefore, some double jeopardy issues. Then you have some issues that one of the representatives pointed out, what happens if the defendant is himself 65 or over? In other words, you have two guys who get drunk and start pushing each other or if you're going to apply it to a hot check case or that type of thing. And I don't think it's an answer merely to say that, well, the prosecutor has discretion because what you'll end up there with is chaotic and inconsistent interpretations and inconsistent application from place to place. And I'm happy to work with whoever to try to fix these dressmanship problems if, in fact, you're all on board with a particular policy. But I think passing this bill as currently written will cause more problems than it solves.
▶ Play
Representative Copeland, you're recognized for a
▶ Play
question. Can you recommend what the adjustments you would make in the bill? You've pointed out the problems. What are your
▶ Play
Speaker 11 8:29
solutions? Well, I would first decide what the magic age is going to be. In the battery statutes, for instance, it's 60. In other words, either raise that to 65 or lower this to 60, but at least have consistency in the interpretation. of. Have a consistent issue as to whether or not the defendant has to have knowledge of the age of the victim in the case. Some of the statutes do, some don't. Of course, you have an enhancement. The question is which is going to apply. Then you have the issue of what the relevant culpable mental state is. There are essentially four culpable mental states in the law, purposefully, knowingly, recklessly, and negligently. This requires purposely some of the statutes that are going to, that it would appear to enhance have different mental states, and so you have the question of consistency of the mental states. So those are some of the things I would fix. That's
▶ Play
great information, Counselor. One other thing, aren't those, you mentioned battery versus this, a lot of this seems to be more civil and especially the financial stuff, but wouldn't we have a lot of the same discrepancies protecting children with those same issues that you talked about and what we're talking about here is protecting an age that is vulnerable and you have some of those same in in the code but it seemed to work really well taking care of our children with
▶ Play
Speaker 11 10:14
is that an accurate statement yeah yes well it's a little bit different situation here because children by definition are not met by definition are not mentally developed physically developed enough obviously a person essentially knows or can reasonably guess the age of the person with whom he's doing can and can figure up pretty quickly that he's dealing with someone under the age of 12. That would not be the case in this type of situation. You have, whereas by definition, every child is incapable of things, you have very different capabilities of people who would fit within this range of 65 or over, some are obviously very vulnerable, then you have others who are not and who are clearly still at the top of their games. And so I think that would be the distinction. Representative Bennett, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Do you have a recommendation as to what mental state you would choose? Would you continue with
▶ Play
Speaker 11 11:34
purposefully or would you reduce it to knowingly? Well, I would reduce it to knowingly in conjunction with a specific requirement that the defendant know that he was dealing with an elderly person. That's how I think how I would do with it. In terms of reaching consistency and sensibility of application.
▶ Play
Go ahead. And just for the benefit of people that are not attorneys here, how difficult would you think it would be to
▶ Play
Speaker 11 12:16
prove the purposeful standard? You know, there's really not a whole lot of error between purposeful and knowingly in the way they're applied, you know, in the law. I don't think there's really that much different purpose essentially is akin to intent and knowingly means you know it's going to happen and it's practically certain that something is going to happen. So there's really not, in the practical sense, there's really not that much difference. Thank you for your statements. Representative Lowry, do you want to
▶ Play
close for your bill? Yes, thank you.
▶ Play
Well, as you just heard, there's not much error between purposely and knowingly. I think, I mean, having been a debate coach, I understand the philosophy of something dying from a thousand cuts. I don't think any of these cuts are significant to what we're trying to carry out, though. What we're trying to do is give an extra area of protection to our senior citizens, to those who are vulnerable. My concern in hearing some of the testimony is that, you know, if you give discretion, then you're criticized. If you don't give discretion, then you're criticized. I think we should trust our prosecuting attorneys to be able to utilize that discretion, to have this available tool in their toolbox, to be able to protect those who are vulnerable. again the issue that was raised is that there's really not that much difference between purposely and knowingly and I think to to slow down this process to change words that really are not going to have little import really would be detrimental to the impact of what we're trying to do here with this bill so I appreciate your forbearance to allow me to come back again and hope that you will recommend do pass. Thank you, Representative
▶ Play
Speaker 33 14:21
Lowry. What's the pleasure of the committee? I recommend
▶ Play
do pass. Representative Petty, you're recognized for a motion. Thank you. I recommend do pass. Okay, we have a motion do pass. Is there any discussion on the motion? All those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? No. No. Ayes have it. Representative Lowry, congratulations you've passed your bill out of committee with a recommendation of due pass. Thank you, thank you committee Moving on down the agenda House Bill 1197, Representative Letting I understand is not going to run that today likewise House Bill 1208 Representative Gonzalez is not going to run that as well, so if without objection Seeing no further business, we are adjourned.
▶ Play

Agenda

HB1117

1:17 - 15:20 36 segments 7 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Matthew J. Shepherd Chair Unverified
8 segments
Representative Mark Lowery Unverified
10 segments
Speaker 8
4 segments
Speaker 11
12 segments
Representative Donnie Copeland Unverified
3 segments
Representative Camille Bennett Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 33
1 segment