Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House Public Health, Welfare and Labor Committee

February 3, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (2)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
SB96 · 4 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB96”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1072 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1072”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 16, 2026
Okay, and we ask that everyone silence your cell phones and please don't talk from the audience. We have a committee photograph next Tuesday at 10 a.m., if all the committee would make a note of that. Without objection, we're going to take Senator Hendren's Senate Bill 96 first. and I think Representative Link and Representative Farrar you're recognized to present Senate Bill 96
▶ Play
Madam Chair we have an amendment to add to this I think I don't know if members have it yet but it's on their
▶ Play
tablet it's on the tablet I believe okay you're recognized to present
▶ Play
your amendment members the amendment to this bill is no change to the language of the bill at all it's simply House sponsors that we're adding on here. It came from the Senate without House sponsors, and we're putting all the House sponsors. You can see the names there, and I would appreciate a good motion to add this.
▶ Play
Speaker 11 1:15
Any questions about the amendment? Okay,
▶ Play
Speaker 14 1:28
yes, I'm not seeing it. I'm not seeing the sponsors. Ah, thank you.
▶ Play
Speaker 18 1:45
Okay. Well, I went to JMD 130, but I'm not seeing the list of
▶ Play
Speaker 22 1:55
sponsors that he mentioned. She's not seeing a list of sponsors that was
▶ Play
Speaker 24 2:07
mentioned. She's at J&B 130.
▶ Play
Yeah, the amendment's J&B 130. Any questions on the amendment?
▶ Play
Speaker 22 2:15
Mine's not pulling up. She's got J&B 130, but she said it didn't reference us. We have some paper copies.
▶ Play
Speaker 27 2:26
Thank you. I don't want to get a sponsor. Just leave it. Of
▶ Play
Speaker 30 2:35
sponsors? Yeah. Richard. Richard. Want to hear anything? Oh, okay.
▶ Play
I'm on the early list of sponsors. Should I get back of it? I'm on the early list of sponsors. That was about a week ago. I said yes, I'll sponsor anything that kills private options. Should I take my name off of it? I don't know. I don't know
▶ Play
Speaker 18 3:00
how to advise you on that. Thank you. You can
▶ Play
Speaker 38 3:07
vote against something you sponsor. It's done all the time. Wow. To
▶ Play
Speaker 18 3:12
now take your name off, they'd have to go back. Committee. Oh, okay. All right.
▶ Play
okay no questions representative link has moved to add the amendment to senate bill 96 all of those supporting say aye all of those opposed okay the motion passes to add the amendment you're recognized to present the bill thank you madam chair representative Farrar is
▶ Play
going to go over the guts of the bill more so than I am. I'd like to just give a little bit of history of how we got to this in this committee and how we got to this bill, if that's okay. It's not speaking directly on the content of the bill, but I think it is important to know a little bit of the history of where we're at and why this bill is in front of us. Obviously, hospitals started off as free care, the regional hospitals, and then over time we began paying and so on and so forth, but we, as a society, have a moral obligation to take care of the sick and And, of course, through attorneys and so on and so forth, we really can't not take care of the sick. And over the years, we've come up with hospitals who have had a lot of uncompensated care, and there's always been a little bit of federal money and state money to help the hospitals through that time. Medicaid and Medicare has always been part of that. And then as we've come along to the Affordable Care Act, which is a federal mandate upon all the states, then we as a society are obligated to either buy insurance or have Medicaid expanded to cover those who cannot afford the insurance, which is considered to be 138% of the poverty level. Supreme Court ruled that states did not have to expand Medicaid to cover up to 138% of the poverty level. In the state of Arkansas, we felt like in the last General Assembly, and of course there was a vision, but as a majority, which ended up with the vote, the majority of the legislature felt like that we were not going to be able to expand Medicaid in a way that would be good for the hospitals, good for even the people of the state of Arkansas, as our Medicaid system had so many problems. We went to the federal government and asked for a waiver, an 1115 waiver, which is asking Health and Human Services to do something outside the norm, which is a waiver. It waives that opportunity so that we can do something outside the norm, and we presented this idea of using the same amount of Medicaid money as it would cost to expand Medicaid to 138% of the poverty level to purchase instead private insurance for those same people. And it became known as the, and most states know it as the Arkansas option. Here in Arkansas we know it as a private option because it is buying private insurance with the Medicaid money. Obviously a great deal of discord between members and the general public as to whether this was a good idea or not, and many people felt that Medicaid expansion, no matter how we did it, was a bad idea. Speaking, if you will, in favor of that idea, our rural hospitals are still open in many states. They're not, and I think we can credit that toward this expansion. Of course, the other side will say, well, it's costing a lot of money. Okay, agreed. But this is why we've come to this point, which I believe this bill is a good idea to bring forward to end the private option, end the debate of whether private option is a good idea or not and move on to overall Medicaid reform. We've always talked about medical reform in the United States and in the state of Arkansas as to how do we go about it. And this bill presents good ideas to form a task force and gives that task force ideas on how we can reform Medicaid in the state of Arkansas moving forward. Put this argument behind us, put private option argument behind us, move forward, and I believe this bill does a good job and Representative Farrar, I believe, can explain the guts of it a whole lot better than I can. Well, I hope so. What I'll do
▶ Play
I want to go over the bill section by section. So we'll start SB 96. Now everybody is not going to be happy with this bill because it is a compromise bill. So the first two pages of the bill were a lot of whereases and whatnots. It's just a short history of the bill, of the law. So section one is the title, Arkansas Health Care Reform Act of 2015. Section two. Section 2 is where we create the task force that reforms Arkansas Medicaid system. It's a legislative task force with eight senators, eight representatives, and the Surgeon General will be on the task force as a non-voting member. This section also gives the rules and the purpose of the task force, like developing an alternative method of developing health care for the state of Arkansas. It identifies resources of funding to keep the Arkansas taxpayers from paying more taxes. It develops an Arkansas plan that gives us the maximum flexibility by limiting the federal government's rule. It decreases health care costs by promoting healthy behaviors and personal responsibility. It increases the employment of able-bodied recipients. Section 3, it allows DHS to apply for the necessary waivers to accomplish this plan. It also states that the private option and Medicaid expansion will end December 31, 2016. It also states that Arkansas will apply for block grants or block waivers to pay for this new program. The block grant will allow Arkansas to design a program that fits Arkansans in Arkansas. DHS will submit the waivers to implement this plan before July 1, 2016. Okay, Section 4, this section right here, it stops ARKIDSB from being put onto the private option. That was one of the plans two years ago was to put this population on. The section also states it stops the independent savings accounts program below 100% of federal poverty level. This is a $3 million savings to the state of Arkansas. section 5 and 6 short what it says it states the medicaid expansion that was created by the social security act 1902 ends december 31st of 2016. section 7 is just the emergency clause and like representative link said this is a medicaid reform bill this is what we in the legislature and the state of arkansas has been pushing for for years we want to reform the medicaid system so we can form a different health plan for Arkansas that works for us. So I feel that's just what this bill does. I'm in total support of this bill to reform the Medicaid system. I'm looking for questions. Members,
▶ Play
do you have questions? Representative Hammer. Thank you for the explanation of
▶ Play
the bill, Well, and I was wondering if you could tell me if the task force comes back with a recommendation or when they come back with a recommendation, then that will have to come in the form of a special session in order to be able to approve that. Is that correct, or how is that process going to work? Well,
▶ Play
I think it depends on the timing of the bill. We have a fiscal session. If we have an answer before the fiscal session, we could actually do it then. If not, I think
▶ Play
a special session probably would be in order. Okay, and what was the rhyme or reason of the end date? And just to make sure, is the end date 12-31-16 so that if the task force doesn't come up with a recommendation that's agreed upon by the legislative body, then the private option would end 12-31-16 regardless? I don't think that
▶ Play
was an intent, but the private option does end 12-31-16. Even if
▶ Play
the task force doesn't come forward with a recommendation that's approved on by
▶ Play
the legislative body? Yes, the private option ends that period anyway, but Medicaid
▶ Play
expansion would continue. Okay, and I'm just curious on the task force, why was the administrative branch not given any voting power in the decision that would be presented before us as a legislative body? It's strictly a legislative committee. I'm just curious what the reasoning went into, why just legislators only? I believe the executive branch
▶ Play
wanted the Surgeon General on the task force. But he's non-voting, correct? Yes, that's true. Okay. All
▶ Play
Speaker 59 11:45
right. All right. Thank you, Madam Chair. Representative Womack, you're recognized.
▶ Play
Speaker 64 12:02
Thank you. Thank you, Madam Chair. Hey, Representative Ferraro, I know how hard you've worked on this, and we agree 99% of the time. And you presented this in the spirit of a compromise bill, and I agree 100% with that. I'm curious, though, on behalf of my constituents, would the sponsors of this bill be willing to consider moving that end date for the expansion population from 12 to 31 back any at all as an assurance to my constituents that the private option is dead and there's no intent to carry this program further.
▶ Play
Are you talking about moving it back to 15 to this year? Any day. Just
▶ Play
Speaker 64 12:48
in the spirit of compromise, show my constituents that this is truly a compromise bill. To help you with
▶ Play
your constituents, If you read the conditions and the terms of the waiver, if we end the program before the demonstration ends, we have an appeal process that we have to go through. Now, do we want to gamble on the length of the appeal process? Because in the waiver, in the terms and conditions, it says we will have to continue to furnish insurance for this population until the appeal process is over. Is that two more years? Is that six months? Is it 30 days? I don't know that. I don't know the gamble. But if we change the date before the private option actually terminates, So we have to do that. Representative Womack,
▶ Play
can I also add a little bit to that? Sure. Thank you. The end of 2015 is when this task force will, hopefully they may come up with a great idea before the end of 2015, but by the end of 2015 they have to make a recommendation to the governor and to this body. At that point in time we try to either accept or whatever the recommendation would go forward with applying for waivers, whether the 1115s, 1332s, or maybe there's a new waiver invented by them. We don't know. But if we go forward with application of waivers, that will take some time. And then to implement whatever law that uses those waivers will take some time. So even if we move that two or three months, we're still gambling with the idea of beyond what Rep. Farrar said, which is an excellent point. We're still also gambling with the idea of do we have time to get the waivers back from D.C.? Do we have time to implement them and give the executive branch, give the agencies time to work forward on whatever this solution is? So this is, I mean, we would really be pushing and pushing hard to get anything earlier than the end of 2016. I really believe that is the best date we can come up with, the safest date we can come up with to have Medicaid reform. I mean, we're talking about a major overhaul, and it's going to take
▶ Play
Speaker 64 14:47
time to do it. Yeah, I appreciate that. I just, I'm not sure that we couldn't give a couple weeks just so that we're able to, a month, whatever. I'm honestly just throwing that out there as a trying to find a compromise that makes every, you know, I know that it's impossible to make everybody happy, but so
▶ Play
that's the spirit that I'm bringing this request, not. And Rep. Sherwin Womack, I don't know that moving it forward even two months would save any money because the programs are in place, that being the ARCSA option, private options are in place. And currently with federal government paying 100%, I don't know that it would save any money if we did move it a month or two months. I don't know that it would be a monetary advantage to us even if we did see a
▶ Play
way to do it. Representative Fite, you're recognized. Thank you, Madam Chair. And I, too,
▶ Play
appreciate your hard work on this. I know you've given it a lot of time and thought and talked with a lot of people. A concern that my constituents have, and I'm speaking for them, I'm their representative, they've been contacting me and saying that there's a heavy push now on television, on social media, get enrolled now, get enrolled now. What if we suddenly have 400,000 Arkansans signed up for this? Then would we be told there's no possible way that this
▶ Play
can be wound back? Well, the Optimus study that we did two years ago said the maximum of three years would be 250,000 enrollees through the Optimus study. In meetings with DHS, I asked that question. I said, how many do you expect in the next two years? They said they never expected over 270,000 people to be enrolled on the program anyway. I also asked DHS, and they assured me they would not actively pursue enrollment of this population because they know it's ending. So if that helps you out with your constituents. May
▶ Play
Speaker 79 16:43
I follow up? Pardon? May I follow up?
▶ Play
Oh, sure. This was Little Rock Media last night.
▶ Play
Representative, I see that John Seelig came in the room, head of DHS. Would you like for him to come to the end of the table and see us? Yeah. I know I want to
▶ Play
ask a question. Thank you, Madam Chair. I'm Director of Human Services, John Selig. I'll ask you to repeat your question and make sure I give you an answer
▶ Play
to this response. And thank you so much for being with us, and I appreciate your good work as well. My constituents are very concerned that there is suddenly a media push to enroll as many people as possible as quickly as possible. And I realize that that's perhaps beyond your control, but this is still an area of concern to the people who are contacting me, my constituents. I saw this on Little Rock Media last night on television. Get enrolled now, get enrolled now. And I was asking, what if we suddenly have 400,000 people? I know your projection was for 250, but you have no control over how many people might come to our state and sign up. Is that correct? Well, we
▶ Play
don't have control over it, though. I think both the Optima study that was referenced and a couple of other studies from other national organizations all came in right at about 250 in terms of the total that would even be eligible. So I can't see how it would go much above that. Obviously, I mean, people could come apply, but if they're not eligible, if their income is too high, they don't qualify for some other reason, say their age, they can't just show up and get on the program. So I'm pretty comfortable that, in fact, very comfortable that that's a good number. In fact, I doubt we'll hit that number, but I think that's a good range, kind of the top of the range. And we just, as Representative Farrar said, we don't do any outreach. We don't do any media. I haven't seen that media, so I'm not sure what it is. They're suggesting people get enrolled in. The open enrollment period above 138 is closed, I believe. We don't handle that side of it. And, again, we don't do any outreach, and I'm not sure who would be unless it may just be some
▶ Play
insurance companies encouraging people to get on
▶ Play
their plan. Okay. Representative Miller, you're recognized. Thank you, Madam Chair. I appreciate it. Representative Farrar, number one, you know I love you. My question, and I'm speaking like Representative Fite for my question. I'm not sure that's... Oh, yeah, I'm getting back on the bill here. I apologize. Is there a... I think that we have a... There's a general lack of trust in our government right now and in what's coming out. Is there a place, and I've read this bill, and I know that the expansion ends, I know Medicaid expansion ends, I know the waiver goes away. Is there a place in this bill that you can clearly point us to that says the enabling legislation that allowed DHS to enter into this agreement with the federal government where it is repealed? Representative, thanks for your
▶ Play
Speaker 57 20:14
question, and I love you too, buddy. Thank you. I would
▶ Play
go to Section 5. I'd point you to Section 5 and 6, and I can read it to you if you want me to. It says the eligibility enrollment and participation in Medicaid for the current Medicaid expansion population under a health care independence program authorized under 2077-2004 at whatever sequence, including the current Medicaid expansion population in the eligibility category created by, here it is, Section 1902A10A8 of the Social Security Act, 42 U.S.C. that's the act that gave us what you're asking we're repealing that act and it says that in sections 5 and 6 thank you very much I'm going to let everyone
▶ Play
who's not asked a question go first and then I'll come back to those of you who have signed up for a second question
▶ Play
Speaker 64 21:14
Representative Love, you're recognized thank you Madam Chair I
▶ Play
Speaker 103 21:20
guess this is a question Mr. Seedling
▶ Play
are you still at the end of the
▶ Play
Speaker 64 21:27
table I am I was just leaning back because I had a little heartburn about this legislation myself but for the opposite reasons that have been expressed with the block grant piece that you all put in here I mean talk to me a little bit about the legislation before the block grant piece was not put in here. Is that correct? Prior to this bill. Yes,
▶ Play
sir. If this helps, I mean, I really see this bill as having two significant pieces that complement each other. One is the question of what happens after the private option ends, and the other is we need to reform the larger health care system, and those two fit together. So the block grant is on the let's reform the larger health care system side. So there was nothing about a block grant, for example, in the bill that was passed
▶ Play
Speaker 64 22:22
two years ago for the Health Care Independence Act. Okay. So, yeah, and that's where I'm having a little heartburn. Tell me this. You all added this piece. Joe, Representative Farrar, you all added this piece. Is that as a cost-control mechanism? Is that? Well,
▶ Play
with a block grant program, It gives Arkansas the chance and the opportunity to have their own health care system without the rules of the Fed, federal regulations. We can go in and develop a program that fits us. That's what the block grant was.
▶ Play
Speaker 64 22:54
Okay. But is it also not a mechanism to control cost? Yes, it is. It will control cost. So then that also means that only a finite number of people can be on the program. Is that correct?
▶ Play
No, that is not true. If we could insure everybody for a certain cost, we'd insure everybody or give everybody health care for a certain
▶ Play
Speaker 114 23:21
cost. Okay, wait a minute. Well, I mean, I'm giving
▶ Play
my opinion. I think the private option was expensive. It was too expensive for the state of Arkansas. What if we develop a plan with a block grant system that insures this same population or gives them health care for the same population less expensive? but what I'm saying
▶ Play
Speaker 64 23:43
is that if there's a fixed amount in that block grant that means there's a fixed amount of people that can go on to the
▶ Play
program is that not correct thank you the block grant is designed on the bigger part of the Medicaid system the 90% you know the 90% the private option yes but the whole system, all of Medicaid. We'll fix the whole Medicaid system with a block grant, not just the insurance part. Does that make sense? Medicaid is not just the health care portion. I got you. Okay. We're looking at the whole
▶ Play
Medicaid system, all of it. Okay. Representative Lundstrom, you
▶ Play
have a question? Yes. You're recognized. Thank you. How much is this going to cost If we keep this going for the next two years and it's open enrollment, you say it's, we're at $218,000 right now. If it goes to $250,000 or $300,000, I mean, it's open enrollment. Anybody can sign up, so there's no control over blocking enrollment. So it can just keep going up and up and up. How much is this costing right
▶ Play
now? Well, to the state of Arkansas, it's none. It's zero. I know. Our match doesn't come in until the
▶ Play
16th. Right. The 5% match. Our match, though, is going to be how much? Well, this
▶ Play
ends the match. This bill ends the match. The 5% match that grows to 10, this would stop that. There would be no Arkansas money. No
▶ Play
Arkansas money in it. It's federal money, which we all still get to pay for, but still no Arkansas
▶ Play
money. If I can just add a little bit. In fiscal year 2017, the second year of this coming biennium, we would have half a year in which we would owe 5% match, but that, I mean, in the governor's budget, that match is largely, if not completely, taken care of by the premium taxes, the premium fees, premiums that come in as a result of the private option. And so, in a sense, it pays for itself for that six-month period. And then, as Representative Farrar says, then the program goes away. There is no match unless this body and the governor decide to do
▶ Play
something else. I'll have a follow-up question
▶ Play
in a minute. Let me digest that. Okay. Representative
▶ Play
Sullivan, you're recognized. Mr. Selig, you came before this committee a couple of weeks ago and showed us the improvement plan that the state was involved in now, and I appreciate the fact that we're looking at total improvement. I think that's a great idea. But you assured us that the track that we were going on was leading us to where we want to go. Now we come up with this task force, and the task force is going to essentially do away or has the potential to do away with that or amend it or change it. Has your mind changed on what we're currently doing and whether that current system that you projected, I think, is a $2 million savings by 2020.
▶ Play
Has your mind changed on that? No, it hasn't at all. I think what we're doing now is working, but that doesn't mean we can't do more, be more aggressive, work in some areas that we're not even working in now. And that's what the governor's, from my discussion with him, that's what he wants us to do, is not kind of stick with what we have but see if there's more we need to do. And there may be some things we're doing now that we want to do differently
▶ Play
that we can do even better. So if you were projecting a several million dollar increase, you think we can do better than that? In terms of savings?
▶ Play
Yes. Billions, actually. Our projection is that we'll save close to $3 billion by 2020 on the path that we're on. But, yes, I think there's more we can do. I'd be
▶ Play
interested in seeing the data for the last couple of years on what the savings are now that cause us to project that. I'm also Representative Selig on these we talked about gambling on the the appeal process there was a gamble there is there not also a gamble on the block grant I mean we seem to be resting a lot on the fact that we're going to get a
▶ Play
block grant is there not a gamble there the idea one of the ideas is look for a block grant This legislation does not say we go get one. But we did have a conversation with HHS, and the idea of a block grant was thrown out there, and they like that flexibility for Arkansas, and Arkansas likes that flexibility. A block grant's the most flexible thing that we can do that gives Mr. Seelig and the other folks opportunities to really look for ways to save Arkansas money and provide better health care than ever before. So that's why we keep hearing that block grant thrown around, but it's simply in here as an idea. It's not in here as we will go get a block grant. So, no, we're not gambling on that. We're just throwing that out there as one of the better ideas we think that could come out of
▶ Play
the task force. And I agree 100%. I think it's a great idea. But if we're talking about gambling, there seems to be a lot predicated on the block grant. And without some assurances from the federal government that we're going to get one, we might need to, as we talk about that block grant, mention or indicate that it's not a given, that we're still hoping it's
▶ Play
not a solution. Thank you, Madam Chair. Sure.
▶ Play
Representative Payton, you're recognized. Thank you, Madam Chair. Representative Farrar, some of my questions got asked and answered already, but one key question I have, we can only appropriate money through June 30th of 2016. By law, we can't appropriate any money that would continue through December 31st of 2016. So would you be willing to amend your bill to put those end dates in line with our fiscal year? And also, open enrollment for most insurance plans are September, October, November. So that would allow the population an opportunity to get in the open enrollment where December 31st end date is going to be passed the open enrollment. So my question is, would you be willing to amend your bill to change those end dates to June 30th of 2016?
▶ Play
Thank you for the question. No, because it doesn't change the end date of the program
▶ Play
at all. Okay, could I follow up, Madam Chair? Thank you. And we've heard a lot about, you know, if we do nothing, then the program continues through December 31st of 2016, at which point it's been argued it becomes expansion, traditional expansion, the way the federal government prescribed it in the first place. The proponents of what we call the private option wanted to involve private insurance as a means that they thought it would lower the cost. Have we proven that it lowered the cost in the past two years, or has it been more expensive
▶ Play
to purchase the private insurance? According to the GAO report, it was more
▶ Play
expensive to put private insurance. So the private insurance has been more expensive. Would the block grant allow the task force and DHS to use that money to purchase insurance instead of traditional means of paying the suppliers? Is that one of the reasons we're pursuing a block grant, so we can continue purchasing
▶ Play
insurance? I think the task force will come up with every way. I'm not going to speak for the task force. Whether they're going to purchase insurance or do we pay fee for service. I think they'll let the task force work and see what they come up with. And if the block grant saves us money, that's the way to
▶ Play
go. And one final short question. It will be real short. I almost forgot it. It's escaping me real quick. Hold on. But the block grant, will it be within the authority of the task force and DHS to do this, or will it require legislative action? You don't answer that
▶ Play
question. The task force is going to be asked to make a recommendation. The task force has no authority to do anything, any more than most subcommittees have authority to do anything without the overall committee approval and generally the overall general assembly approval. So the agency, the governor, nor that task force can do anything without this body coming forward as a whole and saying this is the direction we want to go and then we can go and apply for those permits or those waivers or the WAC grant or whatever this task force comes up with. But the task force will make a recommendation, and it will be up to this body as a whole, the 135 members, to decide how we move forward.
▶ Play
And we were under the impression that it would be within our privilege to end these programs, and the DHS negotiated a waiver that has provisions in it that y'all are arguing prevent us from ending this program because of provisions that were negotiated in the waiver that were not approved by the General Assembly and not within what we were being told two years ago. Is that not still going to be an opportunity that DHS negotiating for these waivers can do things that we don't approve of without legislation?
▶ Play
The waivers, whatever waivers we would apply for would come from the General
▶ Play
Assembly. Okay. Thank you, Madam Chair. I would just personally like for Mr. Selig to explain, for new members particularly, that the GAO or the Governmental Accountability Office report, there's been a lot made of that, that the government's spending more on our program than it should be if we'd expanded Medicaid. So you might explain how it's phased over a three-year plan and why that report is a little
▶ Play
misleading. Thank you, Madam Chair. Representative Payton, the waiver for three years actually has an evaluation component where it will be evaluated for this very question of cost-effectiveness for CMS to look at and see whether it was cost-effective. The GAO, when they did their comparison and said that it would be more expensive doing what we're doing, they assumed that when we added 250,000 adults to the Medicaid program, we would not have had any issue with access and other finding providers to serve them, and so we wouldn't have had to increase rates. We don't think that's a reasonable conclusion. We think if we added 250,000 adults, we would have had to raise rates across the Medicaid program to get them served. And so that's where we disagree with the GAO, and they've had kind of a longstanding disagreement. It doesn't have anything to do with this, longstanding disagreement with HHS over how you do those calculations. But the waiver itself, it looks like, based on what we worked out with HHS, the agreement we struck with them, it looks like it is going to be cost effective. And then, you know, people, you'll never know for sure what it would have cost to serve them in
▶ Play
Medicaid because we don't have them in Medicaid. and to add to network access for patients which you probably wouldn't have had in Medicaid just for my own comment which I shouldn't be allowed to do okay representative Hammer you're recognized
▶ Play
thank you ma'am chair there's one thing I wanted to try to throw in this make sure I'm right on one thing the federal court is still sitting out there with the possibility that they could strike down the Affordable Care Act.
▶ Play
Is that right, or have I missed that major event? I think
▶ Play
a portion of it, yes. OK. If in the event something happens at the federal level that the ACA goes away between now and next year, will there be a benefit to the task force being in place here in the state of Arkansas that we can be progressively working toward a solution in the event that all of a sudden that goes away? I mean, that's an element totally out of our control. I understand that. But if it totally goes away and all of a sudden the funding's cut off that we're counting on to pay the private option with right now or anything else we do, what are the mechanisms in place to make sure we're working toward a way to respond
▶ Play
to that? Well, my goal on the task force is to fix a totally different health care system for Arkansas. using block grant and not worrying about the federal match that's my goal okay can we let
▶ Play
me ask you 275 seems to be the number that nobody believes will go above so why can't we cap at 275 just to give a comfort level to some that maybe are struggling with this one of
▶ Play
the specific questions of the secretary was whether the state could place a cap on, and she was very clear that we could not have a cap in this program, that it's an eligibility-based program. You're either eligible or you're not, and that there's just not the possibility of telling people, sorry, you didn't get in under a particular time frame or under a particular number limit. So CMS has made it clear that we can't have a cap like that.
▶ Play
Kind of like I've got to do at work if I don't get in on time, but we're giving somebody else a special. okay but but the they said we can't do it but it would only be a problem if we did do it if we set it at 275 so I mean if we if we put in their cap of 275 what what could they do immediately that would threaten anything we have while we're working on moving toward what this task force is supposed to bring his recommendation?
▶ Play
I am not an attorney, but I think if we tried to put something in that was contrary to what they felt like the law and the policy was, they could stop
▶ Play
the program now. Okay, and did GOA, Government Office of Accountability, did they ever respond to the disagreement between our interpretation of the numbers and their interpretation of the numbers? Did we ever ask them to explain that and did we ever get a response back or did we even ask for it? I'm not aware that
▶ Play
we asked for anything or that we got anything extra from them.
▶ Play
Okay. And then final question to Representative Farrar. We keep hearing about this task force and we see you're supposed to be on it. Has that task force been established yet and those names have not yet been published or at what point do you expect that'll happen? They have not been published
▶ Play
and I think after the law passes or if it passes then the task force will be set up then. Okay. Thank you.
▶ Play
Thank you, Madam Chair. Representative Fye, you're recognized. Thank you. Part of my question was answered, but the other part was not. Back to the task force. Most of us as legislators are not experts in insurance or in health care. Will the task force be bringing in those experts?
▶ Play
Yeah, they would bring in experts to come in and testify on the Medicaid system. health care, hospitals, providers, all of it. Representative Miller, you're
▶ Play
recognized. Thank you, Madam Chair. My first question is for Mr. Selig. You said earlier, and just clarify for me if I'm wrong, that the original estimates that we've gone with as far as the population that would be eligible for the expansion is $250,000 to $275,000. Is that correct? Yes, there are $250,000. I think there was
▶ Play
one estimate that could be as high as $275,000, but we think $250,000 is a better number.
▶ Play
So are you willing to go on record right now as saying that you expect only about 30,000 to 40,000 more folks to sign up in the next year and a half to two years?
▶ Play
Yes, sir. I'm not sure that there'd be anything to hold me to, but that is certainly my expectation, that we wouldn't see more than that. I mean, we will see some people come off and on. As people's income goes up, they'll move into the private market with subsidies, and if someone loses their job, they may move down to the private option temporarily, So there won't be necessarily fixed people, but I certainly don't expect the number to
▶ Play
go above 250,000 at any given time. Okay, thank you. Madam Chair, if I have one more for my esteemed colleagues at the end of the table, even you, Representative Lee. We're talking about the task force and the ideas, and I'm happy to go on record and say I fully support a lot of what I'm hearing here. about Medicaid reform. I think it's great. What concerns me, number one, has any other state ever been awarded this block grant opportunity for Medicaid? Has that happened before? I don't
▶ Play
know that a large block grant, and I'm kind of looking at Mr. Sealy to kind of back me up here, I don't think a large block grant has ever been awarded as we hope that we may go for. And, again, that's why this is not in the legislation saying we will ask for it or we will get it. But I don't believe a large block grant. Is your knowledge, Mr. Sealy? Yeah,
▶ Play
and part of it depends on your definition of block grant because people think of that differently. But there are some states, such as Rhode Island, who got what they considered to be a block grant, gave them considerable flexibility in how they used their Medicaid funding. Oregon got, I think, what some of them would almost consider a block grant, where they were told, okay, you won't spend any more than this amount of money, and they got considerable flexibility in return. So I think depending on how you define it, there is some precedent for it. I think, as Representative Link pointed out, we may want even more flexibility depending on how we design
▶ Play
it. Thank you. And one other question is, and we're talking about a lot of this because I think this is key to folks making up their mind about how they feel about passing this legislation. And what are, do we have any ideas? I know the block grant's the big idea, and I like it. Do we have any other ideas? Let's say that we don't get, I don't want to be guilty of voting. I know many others don't want to be guilty of voting on hopes and dreams. What are some other ideas that are floating around if the block grant idea falls through?
▶ Play
There's three options, Representative Miller, that this task force ultimately will have. Do absolutely nothing. In other words, just let the Medicaid expansion die and we do nothing. Number two would be continue some sort of program, whether it's anything similar to private option or whatever, but some sort of hybrid expansion sort of like we have now. I'm not saying it will be a private purchase or whatever, but some sort of hybrid expansion. And you look to other states that are not doing block grants, But they're asking for a lot of permissions, whether that be permission to demand that someone is either trying to get a job or working or they're putting some demands in there of personal responsibility for your own health and so on and so forth as to being eligible. So that's sort of a hybrid. And then the ultimate is just Medicaid expansion. That's the three things that really this task force ultimately can do. And then I hope that there's a lot of innovative ideas coming out of this group and then the experts that are called in that can really move us in a unique direction because no one else, no other 49 states have solved this problem yet. And I'm hoping that this task force can be the group that finally does. Representative Ferraro, you have? No, you said
▶ Play
well. Representative Sullivan, did you have a follow-up question? You are next on the list.
▶ Play
Mr. Selig, you said we were going to save millions with
▶ Play
that being the first year. So you're now speaking of
▶ Play
the payment improvement effort or something else? You mentioned when I asked about savings, you said this could potentially save billions. I'm wondering what time frame
▶ Play
that is. So just so I'm clear for the committee, we currently have a payment improvement initiative underway that I would argue is saving hundreds of millions of dollars now. Then there's the potential savings from doing additional reforms. Those reforms probably wouldn't start. I mean, we might do some things, but largely wouldn't start probably until 2016 or later. Depending on what you do, I think there's the potential to
▶ Play
save significantly more money. I didn't hear an answer. I'm sorry. If we're going to save billions, how
▶ Play
long does that take? Our estimate on the current payment improvement effort is that by 2020, we would have saved the state and federal government over $3 billion, and that that savings is happening now, if I can, Madam Chair, just in the three years since we've had this initiative underway, the five years prior to that, our average growth rate was close to 7% a year in Medicaid spending. Our average growth rate in the last three years has been between 2% and 3%. That difference has saved about $900 million already, and we believe that a large part of that is due to the transformation we're making in the health care system. It's always hard to pinpoint exactly what's causing what, and some of it may be due to the economy, but we think it's having a significant impact, and even if all $900 million isn't due to that, it's still a big
▶ Play
number. I'd like to sit down with you privately and see that, and I'd appreciate that. Just real quickly, on page four, I think it's, I don't have the line, line 20, it talks about recommended alternatives that give us some ideas, and I appreciate that and think that's a, I understand that's where we're going. and I support that. It also talks about limited exposure for the state financially. And then we talked about just a few minutes ago, Mr. Selig, you said you were not an attorney about stopping it now. I would think that's one of the bigger questions that people in our state have is getting a legal opinion that says we can't stop that now. Do we have an attorney here that can answer that question? and give us some clarity to that?
▶ Play
Just so I'm clear, we can stop it now. It should be the impact
▶ Play
of stopping it now. I think the statement you made is if we stop it, the feds can stop it now. Could stop it now was your comment. And I think the follow-up to that was follow along that line. I think people in the state need some clarity. If we chose to stop it now, could the feds, the federal government, come in and end it immediately? I think that's an important question for this committee to consider as we look at various end dates, what the possibilities are, what our exposure is, and what the impact is. I think,
▶ Play
Representative Sullivan, that I was referring to if we kept it now, as opposed to, I mean, if we stop it, it stops. The federal government wouldn't need to come in and stop it. So I think I was referring to if we kept it now, I think they might then stop it because they wouldn't agree to those terms. But, again, I'd take an attorney to
▶ Play
say for sure. Right. And under the terms and conditions of the waiver, if you stopped it now, we're still looking at a one-year, almost a one-year wind-out. Okay. So the dates would be the same. Okay. Thank
▶ Play
you. Thank you, Madam Chair. Representative Lundstrom, did
▶ Play
you have a follow-up question or was it answered? No, I had a follow-up. Other states have gotten Medicare enrollment. This is Medicare. It's not private option. It says right here, transform the Arkansas Medicare program or Medicaid program with innovative and cost-effective solutions. Other states, such as Arizona, Tennessee, Maine, Colorado, and North Carolina, have all frozen enrollment. I want to know if that's on the table, because if it's not, this is just folded all in and
▶ Play
one big, huge expansion. Those states ended enrollment before the Affordable Care Act. They stopped enrollment on their Medicaid system that they had already. Correct. But based
▶ Play
on that, why can't we do the same thing? Because
▶ Play
we're under federal rule because we expanded Medicaid. Because
▶ Play
we expanded Medicaid. So now we're stuck cleaning up that huge mess. There's a bill coming. I know it's the federal feds getting paid for it.
▶ Play
We're going to fix that. That's what the task force is going to
▶ Play
do. We're going to fix the Medicaid system of Arkansas. Representative Bentley, you're recognized. Representative Farrar, I just have one clear-up question. You stated earlier that if we don't pass this bill and that we continue on and we stop the private, that the Medicaid expansion is going to continue. Okay. I wanted that clarified from you. Yes. Okay. Okay. Okay. Seeing no further questions, and there's no one from the audience to sign up to speak for or against, Representative Lincoln, Ferrara, do you want to close for the bill?
▶ Play
I mean, we can talk about different ideas of how to clean up Medicaid all day long, but that's ultimately what this task force is going to be about. It's going to be about the leadership of the House and Senate, choosing the right members, choosing a good balance of people. I know that every person that will be put on task force whoever they are and I seriously have no idea who it is I don't think our leaders know yet will have the best interest of Arkansas in mind just as we all do in here but we're all going to have different ideas on how to go about it I hope that this body will give us a chance to form that task force and to look for the best ideas for Arkansas to go forward and have the healthiest Arkansas that we can possibly have and if you're closed I would make a motion to do pass Madam Chair As amended Yes ma'am Do
▶ Play
pass as amended Okay the motion before the committee Is do pass as amended All in favor say aye Aye All in favor Oh all opposed say no No The motion passes
▶ Play
Thank you Madam Chair and committee Representative Sullivan, are you ready to present your bill, sir? Members, House Bill 1072 that Representative Sullivan presented last week, and he went back kind of to the drawing board, and we really appreciate him doing that and fixing a little tweak and if you would like to
▶ Play
present your bill now. Yes, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair. We have met with DHS to amend the bill. They suggested language for the amendment. Basically, the amendment lets them do what they already had authority to do, but they're comfortable with this. I also have an email from the Deputy Director of DHS that they are in agreement with the amendment and the bill, so I'd appreciate a good vote.
▶ Play
Thank you. And, members, this amendment is engrossed into this bill now. And we have a question, and we have a motion. We do have a couple people signed up to speak in favor of it, but I don't know that we have a motion do pass. Any questions before I accept that motion? Any questions on this bill? We have a motion do pass. Any comments about the motion itself? I'll second that motion. Okay. No, we don't need a second, then good. Let's move on. No, ma'am. We appreciate your enthusiasm, but we're good. Okay. All right. Seeing no comments about the motion, all those in favor, ayes? Aye. Any opposed? Aye. Congratulations, and thank you for working on that and getting it right for this committee, sir. Your bill is passed. Let's see, I believe Representative Letting, is he in here? I believe he left. I'm seeing no one else to present any bills. Any members here to present a bill? Seeing none, we're adjourned.
▶ Play

Agenda

SB96

0:38 - 51:49 212 segments 24 speakers

HB1072

51:49 - 53:33 5 segments 2 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Deborah Ferguson Chair Unverified
19 segments
Representative Mary Bentley Unverified
32 segments
Speaker 11
1 segment
Speaker 14
1 segment
Speaker 18
3 segments
Speaker 22
2 segments
Speaker 24
1 segment
Speaker 27
1 segment
Speaker 30
1 segment
Representative Robin Lundstrum Unverified
11 segments
Speaker 38
1 segment
Representative Joe Farrer Unverified
40 segments
Representative Kim Hammer Unverified
16 segments
Speaker 59
1 segment
Speaker 64
11 segments
Representative Lanny Fite Unverified
6 segments
Speaker 79
1 segment
Chair Unverified
31 segments
Representative Josh Miller Unverified
11 segments
Speaker 57
1 segment
Speaker 103
1 segment
Speaker 114
1 segment
Representative Dan Sullivan Unverified
16 segments
Representative John Payton Unverified
10 segments