Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House State Agencies and Govt'l Affairs

February 11, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (1)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1113 · 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1113”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 15, 2026
I have some reminders for those who are here to testify for and against and members of the audience. First of all, although I don't see any signs today, signs are not permitted in this committee room. If you have a sign, it needs to be outside this room. Generally, we do not allow applause or audience participation in the discussion beyond providing testimony. A few pointers for those of you who are testifying or in the audience. Please show respect for the legislative process and for others who are testifying on the issue, even if you disagree with their opinions. Properly and respectfully address committee members as representative. The chairman should be addressed as Mr. Chairman. After the chairman has recognized you, please clearly state your name and the organization, if any, that you represent. Always address your remarks to the chairman or to the member of the committee who has asked you a question. Keep your remarks focused on the bill that is being discussed Keep your remarks brief and to the point Discussing your support or opposition to the bill Please do not repeat testimony that has already been given Avoid references to individuals, groups, or other matters That are not being discussed in the proposed bill Please observe decorum at all times any pictures, printed material or other props presented during your testimony must be approved by the chair in advance of your testimony. Thank you for taking the time to be here today and to be a part of your government. With that I'm going to step down from the chair and Representative Womack take the chair and I'll go to the end of the table to present House Bill 1113. All right, Representative Bell, you're
▶ Play
recognized to present House Bill 1113. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chair, members of the committee. On your desks, you have in front of you one of the things that we're here to talk about today. You've got a copy of this official Secretary of State's notification of the combined holiday. And it has sparked a discussion around the nation and in the state. You also have a picture of my family. And there's a reason that that's significant to me because over the last several weeks, I've heard a lot of people say, well, you don't know anything about Robert E. Lee. You don't know anything about Southern heritage. You don't know anything about Southern history. That photo is of my family in front of Lee Chapel on the grounds of Washington Lee University at my daughter's graduation. I'm a son of the South. My great-grandparents came to Arkansas back around 1900. They homesteaded farms near Mina and in northwest Howard County. six generations of my family have now lived worked and raised families in this state i love arkansas i love our history i love our heritage i love the people who make this state what it is out of the bios the rivers the mountains the hills the fields the wildlife and all the wonderful beautiful scenery and recreational opportunities that we have the state's home it's home to three million people back in 2009 when I first decided to run for the legislature I did it because I I wanted to do my part to help make this state an even better place for that seventh generation of my family to live, work, and raise their family. That's why I'm at the end of the table presenting this bill today. The most common question I've heard since I filed this bill is, why are you doing this? Many of you have probably heard the same question with regard to this bill. I've heard that question from black friends Who can't understand why a white conservative Republican from MENA With virtually no black constituents is running this bill One thing I'm sure of, I didn't do it for the votes I've heard from white nationalists Secessionists, historians Civil war reenactors, civil rights activists And many, many others who have given me a wide variety of opinions, ranging from strong support to thinly veiled threats of violence. Mr. Chair, with your permission, I'd like to play a phone message that's an example of one of those threats. Yeah, go ahead. Give me just a moment to get it located here.
▶ Play
Speaker 7 5:32
Let me see if I can get this thing.
▶ Play
Speaker 9 5:46
Is that, you able to hear that? with Arkansas League of the South is calling to let you know that we're not going to stand by while you participate in the ethnic and cultural praising of our people by the removal of our heroes. Robert Lee is a godly man, a southern man who should be venerated. It is a cowardly traitorous move for you to try to remove his holiday and replace it with only Martin Luther King Jr. Day. There will be consequences for this. We will expose you for the traitor you are. You can call me back at 417-294-0306 if you'd like to talk about it.
▶ Play
Thank you. That's one example. They've all been thinly veiled. You know, these folks, some of them have experience at making threats. They walk the line very, very closely. My mother passed away back in 2007. Throughout my life, she taught me the importance of taking a stand and often reminded me of why she chose to name me after the biblical prophet Nathan. You all know me as Nate, but until the day she died, my mother never one time called me Nate, always Nathan. Those of you familiar with that Bible story know that the prophet Nathan confronted King David about his adulterous affair and the murder of his lover's husband at great risk to his own life. My mother often reminded me of this, and she encouraged me to never shy away from taking on tough issues when action is needed. Arkansas has come a very long way since the days of government sanctioned slavery. We've come a very long way since the days of segregated schools and whites-only drinking fountains. Every morning as I walk into this building, I walk past the monument out here to Little Rock Nine. Every time I do that, I think of the courage it took for nine young people to walk into that school in the face of racial bullying and hatred. Many of us have experienced some of that over the last few weeks with regard to this bill. Despite those great advances that have happened in our society, racial division still exists in America and it exists in Arkansas and in many of our own communities. You see, there are people who make money and who gain power by inciting
▶ Play
and encouraging racial division. Representative Bell, could you please try and narrow it to the subject matter of the
▶ Play
bill a little bit, please? I'm going straight there, Mr. Chair, but this is important to
▶ Play
preface the purpose for the bill. Let's get there
▶ Play
as soon as possible, please. Those people who profit from racial division seek out opportunities to incite division along those lines. There are people in this room with us today who engage in those activities. Mr. Chair, with your permission, I think staff has an additional handout that I'd like to have distributed. Yes, appropriate. While that handout's going out, I'd like to go directly to that question why am I running this bill as I've worked through the answers to that question I come up with four key points it is important that those who seek to encourage racial division are deprived of a tool of that annual opportunity to exploit General Lee as if he were pro-slavery or racist. It's important that we honor Martin Luther King Jr. without the racists, the nationalists, et cetera, having the opportunity to make the kind of comments that we've all heard. I've heard on numerous occasions, and I'm confident that most of you have, people in our own communities say, I'm not celebrating a holiday for that. We'll not use that word here. I'm celebrating Robert E. Lee Day. This bill is important to improve the image of our state and perceptions about our state around the nation and around the world. The fact that we're one of three states that continue to celebrate a combined holiday is regularly used as proof that we're somehow backward, racist, etc. You're going to hear some testimony, I think later today, from economic development professionals that this has an effect on our ability to recruit businesses to locate here in our state. It's important that we, as a state, stop celebrating a Memorial Day that we have to Jefferson Davis, who indeed did fight to preserve slavery. That's contained in this bill. So what exactly does this bill do? You know, over the last few weeks, one of the things I've found interesting is I've been contacted by a number of people, and I've asked them the question, have you read the bill? Well, I've read excerpts. Well, have you read the bill? Well, no. Well, the bill is a very simple and straightforward bill. So what does it do? The bill ends the dual celebration of Martin Luther King Day and Robert E. Lee Day. It ends the June 3rd celebration of Jefferson Davis Day and creates a new state memorial day celebrating Patrick Cleburne, Robert E. Lee, and Southern Heritage. That day will be on November 30th if this bill is enacted. November 30th is the day that General Cleburne died in battle, and I believe it's fitting that we should honor both these great Confederate generals at that time. That day is currently celebrated by at least one Arkansas city to honor General Cleaver and there's some associated economic activity with that. With that, Mr. Chair, with your permission, I'd like to ask Mr. Grant Tennille to join
▶ Play
Speaker 21 12:50
me at the table. Yeah, go
▶ Play
Speaker 24 12:52
ahead. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, thank you, Representative Bell. Very quickly and briefly, I think it's important to understand that we're doing business in a global economy, in a world where things are smaller than they used to be. And who we are as a people and the environment that we create here is constantly speaking to the world about what the economic opportunities in this state are and should be. I am not here to debate the merits of a Robert E. Lee holiday. I am only here to say that the world looks at the kind of environment that you create And businesses look at the kind of environment that you create. And it's time for us to acknowledge that there are people on the planet who see the dual observance of this holiday as a tremendous slight. I'm not arguing whether that's right, wrong, or indifferent. I'm just telling you it's true. Okay. Thank you for your insight. Can I ask
▶ Play
a question real quick? Yes, sir. And this is kind of just to get us back to the bill. Since you're at the end of the table, how many companies have we run off in Arkansas because of observance of this bill that you've come in contact with in your capacity?
▶ Play
Speaker 24 14:41
I think that the question is, how many calls haven't we gotten? How many projects? So we don't have
▶ Play
a definitive answer? We do not have
▶ Play
Speaker 24 14:51
a, I mean, no one has ever come to me and said we will not put a project there because you have a dual observance of
▶ Play
this holiday. Okay, thank you. And in the interest of time, can we somehow get right back to the bill on this, please? I feel like we're
▶ Play
Speaker 24 15:10
waiting off pretty big here. Okay. Thank you. You should approve this bill because it sends the right message around the globe that Arkansas is a place where all kinds of people and all kinds of businesses are welcome and sought. Okay. I mean, are we saying that Arkansas is
▶ Play
not the kind of place without this bill? I think that it provides
▶ Play
Speaker 24 15:32
problems for us, yes, absolutely. Okay. But do you have any specific
▶ Play
examples that you could lend? Okay, thank you. Back to you, Mr. Bell. Mr. Chair, just if I
▶ Play
might follow up on that just a little bit. I think as I've made clear in my presentation and Mr. Tennille did, the key point is there is a perception. I don't believe that Arkansas is backward or racist or any of those other things, and I'm confident Mr. Tennille doesn't. What we do know from conversations that we've had with people outside of this state and in other countries is that that perception exists. And when that perception exists, there are people who just won't talk to you.
▶ Play
Okay. Are you finished with your testimony and ready for questions? Glad to take your questions. All right. Are there any questions by committee members? Representative
▶ Play
Miller, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Tennell, Representative Bell. Let's say hypothetically that this bill passes. Do you have any kind of way of gauging what the immediate or, say, over a five-year time span, what the economic growth impact will be on the state of Arkansas? As a direct result
▶ Play
Speaker 24 17:02
of this bill, there's no way to gauge that. Okay, thank you. Mr. Chair, I
▶ Play
would echo that. we're dealing in an area of subjective things that can't be measured objectively. And I think as Mr. Tennille has already stated, we're in a situation where it's a question of the phone just simply doesn't ring. People just simply don't contact you because of the perception. So you can't measure what doesn't happen. It's like proving innocence beyond a reasonable doubt. It's very difficult to do. Thank you. Representative Armstrong,
▶ Play
you're recognized for questions. Thank you, Mr. Chair
▶ Play
and Representative Bell. Thank you. And it is my hope that we can keep the comments as we move forward on soundly just the premise of this bill, Representative Bell. I want to go on record because I've sat in the hot seat with you over the last seven days to make it known that I will be voting for your bill today out of committee. But wouldn't you agree is my question that as we think about the young people that are in our classrooms that may or may not have even known about a Dr. King and Robert E. Lee day and as we look around this room today it's primarily adults we were sent here in my opinion and I hope that you would agree is my question to ensure that those working-class and middle-class families had an opportunity to see their day and we've done that with the tax cut we were also sent here to look whether you were up or down about it as it relates to health care insurance whatever you want to call it that those 200 plus thousand people mr. to know you're talking about industry I think we've got a bright future ahead of us that they were protected so my question representative Bell today and forevermore as it relates to the whole premise of why you're trying to get this policy in place. Wouldn't you agree that our state's far beyond the days in which we have to hammer home such an issue of racial separation and that we should be looking towards a day where economic growth, grooming young people to be able to take the reins of society by the horns and make certain that our state continues to grow, ensuring that if they want to serve and have an opportunity to come to the state capitol, that they can do it under the pretenses of not feeling objectified by a situation such as the one we're faced with today. Wouldn't you agree that our state's on a much better path than where we've been in the past, and we need to move in a much more positive
▶ Play
direction going forward? I absolutely agree. That's exactly why I'm running this bill. I want signs like this right here to no longer be on the doors of our state capitol. Representative Tosh, you're recognized
▶ Play
for a question. Representative Bell I've heard a lot of testimony from the other day and I appreciate the attitude everyone has had concerning this bill and the manner in which they've conducted themselves and I'm very appreciative of that and I'm sure the rest of the committee is also but something that concerns me is do you know how many legal holidays we now celebrate in
▶ Play
the state of Arkansas? There are I believe seven major holidays and there are nine or ten
▶ Play
memorial days? Totally. If I stand to be corrected, but counting the federal days, I believe it's 11 days. Of course, there's always a possibility of a governor's proclamation day. And at the current, we already celebrate 11 days. It's my understanding this bill then would create another holiday. Is that correct? Actually, we're
▶ Play
removing one memorial day and substituting another memorial day. We're not adding anything to the calendar. We're not adding another holiday? No, sir. What will November the 30th be? It will be a Memorial Day, just as currently the Jefferson Davis Memorial Day is that is being removed by this bill.
▶ Play
It is a net even. Okay. Well, it was my understanding that November the 30th would be proclaimed as another holiday. You're telling me, though. That is incorrect. So Robert E. Lee's birthday then would not be celebrated as
▶ Play
a recognized holiday? Robert E. Lee's birthday is not currently celebrated on his birthday. It is celebrated jointly with the Martin Luther King federal and state holiday on the third Monday in January, which this year happened to be on Robert E. Lee's birthday.
▶ Play
My concern was, and I think you've answered my question, is that we continue to create other holidays. the impact, the physical impact that that has on the state, you know, because you know services are shut down on those days around the state. And so, but you've answered my question. Representative Tosh, you haven't served with me that long, but I
▶ Play
think anyone who's been with me for very long at all would know that that would be the last thing I'd be doing. Okay. All
▶ Play
right. Just want to make sure. Thank you.
▶ Play
Representative Douglas, you're recognized for a question. Yes. You know, my parents taught me a long time ago that you cannot respect one man by disrespecting another. And in this process, I see a little of that going on. What I would offer up is not the amendment and the change that you would put in to have a Claiborne-Lee Memorial Day in November, but just to simply do as we did for Martin Luther King and round down. Take the birthdays and round to the next Monday. You've got Martin Luther King on the third Monday. Just take Robert E. Lee and put him on the fourth Monday. The process is the same for both men, and, you know, we can go on, And I think that would be a way to respect both of them by using the same process, you know, to declare, you know, their Memorial Day. And then that way they do stay separate, but they're both respected. Would you consent to looking at that as a possibility? Representative Douglas, if I have your commitment
▶ Play
that you will help me pass the bill, if we do that, I would certainly, I'm always open to that. What I would encourage you to do is I have had this bill out for three weeks. I just thought of it, if that's where you're going. I am certainly going there because I have asked for a special order of business to have this bill heard today because there are people who wanted to be here to testify on this bill. Well, I apologize
▶ Play
for not following your bill that closely, but I was thinking about kids that are coming to school that are hungry, kids that are coming to school without shoes on. And, you know, I thought that took precedence over watching your bill, but I apologize for not being as attentive as
▶ Play
I should have been. Well, I also serve on the education committee. But as we go forward, I would suggest, if you would like to entertain that amendment, I'm open to amending to move the day as long as it's not on the joint celebration day. This is the last opportunity that this bill will have to be heard. and if I have your commitment that you will support the bill with a change that will keep the holidays separate and provide another day of celebration I am open to that and if you will vote for the bill I will work with you to amend the bill to get that type of date and we'll certainly amend it on the Senate end
▶ Play
I would like some feedback from people that are in the room before I just go off on my own idea but if we could do that and it would respect both men, then that would, I think, be a good solution. So I would commit to working with you with some feedback from people in
▶ Play
the room. Representative Douglas, I do want to say that it's certainly the furthest thing from my mind to in any way insinuate that Robert E. Lee was anything less than a man of character and integrity and honor. He was a southern gentleman who clearly abhorred slavery. He opposed secessionism. He was a fine southern gentleman. One of the reasons I'm running this bill goes directly to what you prefaced in your statement there, and I want to go back to that for just a moment. It is critical for General Lee to have the respect that he actually deserves, that he not be used as a tool of racial division. And we go, every year when we have this holiday, I hear the statements like I heard, like I mentioned to you all, in my own hometown. So he's saying
▶ Play
every seventh year you hear the argument. Every year when we have the joint celebration, the
▶ Play
holiday. Because it doesn't fall together, but every seventh year, right? I apologize. You're welcome to some follow-ups,
▶ Play
but we have a procedure we've been asked to follow this time. I'm way out
▶ Play
of line. I apologize, Mr. Chair. Thank you.
▶ Play
You're welcome to go with one more follow-up if you feel that way.
▶ Play
If I could clear that up for just a moment, the holidays are currently celebrated jointly every year. Once every seven years, it falls on either Dr. King's birthday or Robert E. Lee's birthday. The rest of the time, it's on neither one of them's birthday. But the perception, again, coming back to it, As someone who is a student of Southern heritage, I am in no way attempting to insinuate that General Lee was anything other than someone who I personally regard as somewhat of a hero. We're dealing with a situation here where perceptions are very different, and there are people who deliberately take advantage of that opportunity to make General Lee out to be something other than what he was. And it is my belief and one of the reasons that I'm running this bill that creating some space between those two days gives us the opportunity to have an honest discussion about the men, both General Claiborne and General Lee, and the man, Martin Luther King, who I think both of those men contributed greatly to American history and contributed positively.
▶ Play
Representative Tosh, you're recognized for a question. I just want to remind, I'm hearing conversations about maybe possibility of creating another holiday, and I just want to caution the committee to remember that any time we create another holiday to be celebrated, that approximately it costs the state of Arkansas approximately $320,000 just in monetary terms to be able to celebrate that holiday, not counting the loss of services that take place on those particular days. So just as a word of caution, as a committee, let's keep that in mind, the impact that will have on the state to be able to, when we start talking about creating another
▶ Play
holiday. Representative Tosh, let me make one thing absolutely clear to you. If this bill becomes about creating a new holiday, I will actively oppose this bill. All right, next question, please. Representative Drown, you're
▶ Play
recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Are these your handouts? Yes.
▶ Play
I keep hearing today, just to go back a little bit on myself, my family's lineage in military service goes all the way back to the Civil War to include every major war and conflict since then. I keep hearing that this is not a racial issue, but I'm going to go ahead and read these. Is this okay if I read what these say? The first one. Yeah, I think so. The USA's Magic Negro, a.k.a. Barry Obama. That would be President Barack Obama, my Commander-in-Chief, currently.
▶ Play
Mr. Chair, could I get a copy of
▶ Play
the handout because I don't have them with me? The second one. We care nothing for, can't read, can't read, or universal rights. We loathe equality, democracy, and other pathologies. Fought for democracy. Steve likes U.S. flag official flag of the KKK of the soda head sorry, fought under the battle flag America secede or die don't agree with it secede, leagueofthesouth.com don't agree with it I fought for 3,000 Americans that were killed on September 11th of 2001 didn't ask what the race was this has been turned into racial issue based on these documents and I will be voting no today and for any day after this. That's all I've got
▶ Play
to say. Mr. Chair, would you please keep questions from the members to questions and not statements? I would very much appreciate that. Yeah I will
▶ Play
try but in all honesty I feel like you were given a lot of latitude in your opening statement and you put these out so I felt like it was appropriate
▶ Play
in this instance to... And I would like the opportunity to rebut but in the interest of order we do have a procedure all right I provided these because these are from the Facebook pages of people who testified against this bill the last time that this bill was presented the gentleman the phone call that you heard threatening
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 31:03
consequences is a
▶ Play

Agenda

HB1113

2:37 - 31:07 96 segments 11 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Nate Bell Unverified
46 segments
Representative Richard Womack Chair Unverified
15 segments
Speaker 7
1 segment
Speaker 9
2 segments
Speaker 21
1 segment
Speaker 24
10 segments
Representative Josh Miller Unverified
2 segments
Representative Eddie L. Armstrong Unverified
5 segments
Representative Dwight Tosh Unverified
9 segments
Representative Dan M. Douglas Unverified
7 segments
Representative R. Trevor Drown Unverified
3 segments