Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House Aging, Children and Youth, Legislative and Military Affairs Committee

February 11, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (3)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1115 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1115”
Pre-2017 bill
HR1007 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HR1007”
Pre-2017 bill
SB210 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB210”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 15, 2026
Dean, Representative Lowry, do you recognize to present
▶ Play
your bill? Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you, committee. Appreciate your patience. I know this has been on your agenda for a while. I held it up to have some amendments put on it to satisfy several groups, and it does satisfy me as well. So let me give you, I guess, a little personal background on this. I had really not thought about issues of child custody for some time. The mother of my children, my ex-wife, and I were divorced in 1992. And I have to say, I mean, as painful as divorce is, the thing that was most painful in my situation, because it came as a complete surprise, was going from one night tucking my kids into bed to the next night not being able to do that. So the separation of a parent from a child is a difficult thing to recover from. In the state of Arkansas, we have a unique situation because of case law, because of the Hollinsworth case, where if a custodial parent, the parent that has custody decides that they want to relocate through no fault of the non-custodial parent, the burden of proof is placed on the non-custodial parent, that they have to prove that the move, the relocation, is not in the best interest of the child. That is counter to law in 24 other states where the burden of proof is on the relocating parent. Typically, that is considered a material change in circumstances, and when there is a material change in circumstances, the burden of proof shifts to that party. I have a young lady who's running a little bit late that is actually going to provide testimony of what she went through with this situation, so I'm not going to tell her story, but I did want to spend a few minutes just explaining to you the technical language of it And to tell you also the background of some of the changes that were made, the Attorney General's office came to me mainly just to, you know, their statement was that they want to make sure that they do their best job in advising us so that we don't get sued over legislation that passes. And so they made several suggestions to me. Also, the administrative courts approached me. Their main concern was that in the directing of the judges to consider factors on whether the relocation should be approved or not, the original legislation had the word shall. They asked me to change it to more permissive language may. Of course, my question was, surely there's something in between there, like we strongly implore or, you know, something. But I think the fact that the bill lays out in one case 12 criteria that could be considered and another one 15 criteria, I think that the suggestion is made very strongly to the judges that these factors, all these factors should be considered. The main import of the bill is to shift the burden of proof, to put it on the parent who is actually changing the circumstance. In my circumstance with my kids, and it was painful, my son was three, my daughter was five, so I literally was tucking them into bed every night and not being able to do that. There was a point where my ex-wife was considering marrying someone and moving a state away, And I cannot imagine what it would have been like of trying. I know parents do it. They've somehow, they bite the bullet and they figure out a way to be able to have meaningful time. But for me, meaningful time sometimes was just picking my children up after school and taking them to McDonald's and watching them play on the playground. That would have been impossible if my children were stayed away. In the case of Ms. Verhagen, who will be giving you some testimony hopefully soon, her child has been relocated to the state of Virginia, and she has incurred a significant amount of cost in being able to fly there on a frequent basis to fly her son here. There are some stipulations, and she can tell you the specific stipulations that there have to be some shared cost, but it's still a significant burden. And the burden was put on her to have to prove a negative, to have to prove that the relocation is not in the best interest of the child. And I've taught argumentation and debate, and I can tell you proving a negative is much more difficult than proving a positive, where the relocating parent would have to actually bear that burden of proof. So I want to repeat that there are 24 states, three surrounding states, Louisiana, Texas, and Missouri, that have standards of burden of proof on the relocating parent. Other states have shifting burdens or they have burdens where both parties, but the vast majority of the states have the burden of proof on the relocating parent. So at that point, I'll just go ahead and open up for any questions, and hopefully during
▶ Play
the questions, my witness will arrive. Okay. Thank you, Representative Lowry. Any questions from committee? Vice Chair Harrison.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. i have to be careful how i'm going to wear this but okay coming from a broken home when i was older your situation may be a little different as far as you being an active parent i don't you know i won't say father or mother because each situation is different but do you think it's as far as i look on here being excessive. In our situation, my father left, no money involved. So if our situation was bad, four children, she lost her job, economic changes, do you think 45 days is a little excessive or whatever the amount of time is? For her to have to notify, not to be disrespectful to my father who's not living anymore, 45 days or whatever time to be excessive to notify him that we have to move because economic situations or whatever the situation may be that he has to be notified that we're going
▶ Play
to move. Right. The factors, among the factors that have to be considered is whether the non-custodial parent is an active parent. The judge would take that into consideration. It certainly would build the case for the relocating parent if the non-custodial parent is not active. So those are all a number of factors, but it does still shift the burden. The notification is still something that is in play. You referenced something about 45 days. The only number that's in here is really the distance of moving. One of the things we had to amend is originally we had set 45 miles from the residence of the non-custodial parent. And I looked at that and realized that actually that's unfair because after the divorce or after the separation or whatever, the relocating, the non-custodial parent could have already moved 30 miles away. okay it doesn't trigger relocation until the custodial parent moves and say all they do is move 15 miles the other direction and it it triggers this so we've changed the 45 miles to 60 miles and we've also changed the axis the point of axis to what the primary residence of the child was when custody was awarded so if if the custodial parent wants to move 60 miles from that point, then they would have to petition the court and the burden of proof would be on them that this is in the best interest of the child and then all these factors
▶ Play
could be considered. Mr. Chair, can I have a follow-up? Yes. Do the judges, though, I meant here were the legislative body, but do they
▶ Play
not already have this discretion? No, they do not. Not in terms of burden of proof. The Hollingsworth Law places the burden of proof on the non-custodial parent, and that is by case law. That's not by statute, and I would ask you, and I understand we look at precedent all the time, but that precedent, that case law now is established, and the specifics of that case may not even be similar to Ms. Verhagen's case or any others, but yet that burden of proof is still placed on the non-custodial parent. So now we're statutorily aligning ourselves with 24 other states that say that the burden of proof should be on the parent who is relocating. Thank you. Thank you. Mr. Chair, I mean, I know you probably have a few questions, but would you mind, in terms of my testimony, if I would allow Ms. Verhagen to tell her story before we proceed with other questions?
▶ Play
Yes. If you would, identify yourself for the ranch, please. Hi, my name is
▶ Play
Brittany Wyatt. I wrote it all down so I could stay on track. My name is Brittany Wyatt, and I want to thank you all for letting me speak here today as an advocate for children and non-custodial parents' rights. I want to begin by sharing a report with you. As of 2014, according to the American Journal of Sociology, Arkansas ranks as having the second highest divorce rate in the country. In other words, more children in the state of Arkansas come from broken homes than those whose families reside in 48 out of the remaining 50 states nationwide. This is an alarming statistic for the state of Arkansas. In 1996, Hillary Clinton published a book titled It Takes a Village and Other Lessons That Children Teach Us. Throughout her book, Ms. Clinton touches on her vision for raising up good generations of children, and she references how important it is that children be met by both their families and their communities. While the divorce rate has changed since her book, it still remains true that children need more than one parent raising them. Yet, almost 20 years later, Arkansas law still supports and encourages just the opposite, allowing children of divorce to be alienated from one parent by the other. Children oftentimes love both their families on both sides. So why is it okay for laws to allow one parent the ability to keep a child from one side of their family, their friends, their schools that they have attended, churches that they have grown up in, and recreational activities that they love? The law I am referring to is called the Hollingsworth Law, and my family is one of many who have been victimized by this law. My family and I refer to this law as illegal kidnapping, because in so many ways that's exactly what happens to families. Please allow me to share my son's story with you. My son's name is Aaron Matthew Dent. He was born in 2008, and today he is a beautiful six-year-old little boy. He is a normal kid who enjoys everyday things like sports, jumping on his trampoline. He came into this world under better circumstances than I did. I was raised in and out of the state's custody most of my childhood. Just after my 19th birthday, I gave birth to him and was struggling to offer Aaron some of the stability that he deserved. His dad was in a much better situation as he had a career and I was a struggling college student. I remained extremely active in my son's life after his father retained custody of him, behaving much more as the full custodial parent oftentimes than his dad did as he worked long hours. I threw all of my son's birthday parties over the years, enrolled him in every recreational activity he's been involved in, and oftentimes he resided more with me than he did with his father. His dad had legal full custody, but I was the primary physical full custodial parent. Even though my son's dad had full custody, we agreed that I could raise him based on grounds that I would not ask for child support. I wanted to raise my son, so I agreed. We went on this way happily for many years until my son's father remarried. In March of 2013, all of our lives were turned upside down. Aaron's dad picked him up for me on my birthday and announced that in just two days he would be moving him to D.C. with his new wife and his new family a woman that I had not ever met his new bride she had just received citizenship via the justice of the peace ceremony had found a career in Virginia and that's where some of her foreign exchange friends lived I hired an attorney in hopes of having some legal leg to stand on after all Aaron's entire life had been in Arkansas His school was here, his friends were here, his church, his recreational activities, and everyone who knows and loves him. He had nothing in Virginia. My son was distraught about the move. I assured him that everything would be okay. I offered Aaron many years of solid stability in Arkansas. I have no history of drug abuse, nothing on my record more sufficient than a traffic violation, and I've served as a great mom over the years. I knew that the state would see that this was not in the best interest of my son. Yet I watched my son be whisked away, trusting that we would all make the right decision. At the time, I was working as an account executive, and I didn't have any issues in my life that would prevent me from retaining custody. After $20,000 in legal fees, I learned of the Hollinsworth Law. The Hollinsworth Law was enacted in 2003 in Arkansas and has been fought over the years with little success by parents just like myself who are desperate to keep their children in state. This particular law states that in the event of a full custodial parent relocating out of state with a child, the state automatically presumes that it is in the best interest of the child to relocate with their full custodial parent. In my case, Aaron's dad was allowing me to have a day-to-day relationship with my son where I would take him to school and be involved in everything going on in his life prior to his marriage. It was not my son's father's decision to move. This was his wife's choice, her way of alienating me from my child. He followed taking our son with him, leaving me two months of visitation in the summer, a few days during Thanksgiving break, two weeks of Christmas break, and one week of spring break in addition to one weekend a month, the remaining months throughout the year provided I can afford to make the travel accommodations over 1,000 miles across the country. These trips cost me over $1,000 a month between round-trip airfare, car rentals, gas, lodging, food, and facilitating activities to partake in with my child. In addition, I am still responsible for child support, making my average monthly expense an almost impossible financial burden upon myself and my family. Still Aaron's father works long hours Six days a week So my son really isn't being raised by any family at all As of now In what world is this a feasible way To nurture a parent and child relationship Most of my time with Aaron Is spent in hotel rooms Eating at diners And otherwise I'm left watching my son grow up Via a telephone screen The choice to move was not mine And it wasn't my son's Yet we are the ones suffering the most This move was orchestrated by a new wife who didn't want me in the picture And all at the expense of my child Arkansas law has let this happen This law has affected more than just my relationship with my son It has affected my ability to be cognitively sound enough To meet with decision makers in what was my career as an account executive For the first time in my life, I now suffer from insomnia The consequences of this law have added additional stress and turmoil and my everyday relationships with the people who are closest to me. I have experienced depression due to the loss of the most important person in my life. In a weird way, it has felt like a death in my family, but a death that has no closure. I am suffering in a way, if I am suffering in such a way as an adult, I can only imagine what it would do to a six-year-old. This situation has created overwhelming signs of separation anxiety in my child, who now ask me questions like, if you love me, then why do you keep giving me back? Aaron's inability to understand why this is happening is unimaginable to me. Anytime my son is disciplined by me now, the only thing he can take away from this is a seed that's been planted in his mind that he is somehow unloved by me, which is the farthest thing from the truth. This law has allowed Aaron's removal from his entire support system with loved ones on both sides of his family, all who reside in the state of Arkansas. And that has actively taken his voice away from him. So that's where my voice comes in. I understand that you can't keep a parent from moving out of state. I understand that there are things in life that change. People remarry, careers change, and we are a mobile society. What I don't understand is why there is not some kind of protection for the children to encourage the parent and child relationship to further go on. This in and of itself should have some kind of financial responsibility upon the parent who decided to relocate. Like I said earlier, Arkansas has the second highest divorce rate in the nation. This is a tragedy for Arkansas children, as divorce alone is traumatic enough in and of itself. One parent should not be put in a position that is so superior to the other parent that they could control and destroy their lives, even their relationship with their own child. the interruption of their education that they may be receiving the ending of recreational activities that they enjoy or the cancellation of spiritual lifestyles that the child has been raised up from birth it's time for people to start passing laws that are with the times in order to protect our children from parental alienation that may cause instability in
▶ Play
a child's life thank you Okay. Thank you. Questions? Representative S. Smith.
▶ Play
Representative Scott, I'm sorry. I'm so easy to forget. Thank you, Mr. Chair. First of all, let me begin by saying your story breaks my heart, and I'm so sorry, as I know every member on this committee is, for what you and your son both have experienced. I am truly sorry. My first question is going to go, if I may have two questions, please, Mr. Chair, is to go to Representative Lowry. I'd like for us to go to page 4, line 14, and let me make sure I have this good no actually page four line 12 I'm sorry item number four the child's views about the proposed relocation taking into consideration the age and maturity of the child can you expound on that just a little bit for me because the thing that I'm concerned about is that we might have children who go into court or as my husband insists those children go into his chambers they are never put on the witness stand and those children can decide if mother gets to move or if daddy gets to move and I don't think in any way that's the intent of this bill but I'd like to know your opinion of that. I would
▶ Play
agree with you that you don't want to place the child in a situation where they're having to choose. I think that's one reason why it's very important that we did change the language in the previous page where it says that the court may consider all relevant factors when determining rather than shall. This just gives a list of the factors that could be considered if it is age appropriate to talk to the child and to be able to get their feedback. What
▶ Play
is deemed as age appropriate? Well, as it
▶ Play
said, it really does not use that word. It says taking into consideration the age and maturity of the child. So that would be, again, a determination that the judge would make of whether the child is mature enough to be able to speak to issues like the difficulty of being able to be with both parents, not necessarily asking them to choose or suggesting that they choose, but just to talk to them about
▶ Play
the effect of the relocation on them. I have another question, if I may, quickly. Quickly. I do agree it takes a village to raise a child, and I consider the village being grandmothers, granddaddies, aunts, uncles, and that's the way I define a village. My question to you, however, is does this bill anywhere in it, and if it is, I have missed it, does it talk about who encounters the expenses? because I'm thinking that if a custodial parent moves a child 700 miles away, then it should be their expense for the non-custodial parent to get him or her there to see that child because they were the one who moved. Can you tell me how this addresses that, please? This bill does not address that.
▶ Play
that this bill specifically just deals with the issue of burden of proof. I certainly understand what you're saying, that that shared expense consideration has to be put in place or has to be in place, but I think that that's good language for another bill. Okay, thank you. Representative Meeks, you recognize? Thank you, Mr. Chair,
▶ Play
and Representative Scott I'd already touched on one of the ones with the children. Right now, I'm kind of conflicted. I don't know whether I'm for or against this bill, honestly, so I appreciate the testimony that was given. You said 24 other states have this law, which means that right now a majority of states don't have this law or maybe have something else involved. Could you speak to that? Well, the
▶ Play
other states, the other 26 states, have either a presumption in favor of the relocation or a shifting burden between the two or no presumption at all. This is the largest group, the 24 states, that have the presumption in the favor of the burden of proof on the relocating parent. The others are split between three or four different characteristics. okay so when you say split between the
▶ Play
other characteristics so kind of a compromise between what your bill is doing and what we currently have in law
▶ Play
a mix the 24 states is the plurality of the states that have the burden of proof on the relocating parent the remaining states are split between shifting burden which would be it's where it starts with the relocating parent and And then the burden of proof shifts to the non-relocating parent. In some cases, the presumption is in favor of the relocating parent. So the burden of proof is against the non-relocating. But this is the vast plurality of states' positions on relocation. And I have a follow-up
▶ Play
question, too. Okay. What we're going to do is one question and then one follow-up, okay?
▶ Play
Okay. My question, because apparently you have a 45-day window. As far as, I guess, a 45 or 60-day, whatever window it was, there are times when a parent gets a job and they may have to start two weeks later or three weeks later. Is that going to keep them potentially from getting a job? I mean, is there something in the law that will allow them to go to the job? I mean, so could you kind of speak to that? Because, you know, today's mobile society, once you get a job offer, you know, a lot of times you don't have two or three months. You have to take the job within a
▶ Play
couple weeks. Well, that's certainly a factor in terms of the stability of that family. But we are still talking about uprooting a child and taking them away from one of their parents. And I want to focus on the fact that we're talking about, in many cases, taking the child away from an active parent. The courts are able to rule that if the non-custodial parent is not active, then that makes it a much easier decision. So I understand what you're talking about being a mobile society. We've already prefaced that or referenced that, but there still should be, I believe, an extra protection for maintaining. There are a lot of things that underscore an effective parent-child relationship other than just monetary. I mean, sometimes that physical presence, that ability to be able to see them on a daily basis is a critical element, too, and it needs to be equally considered.
▶ Play
Okay, thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Representative Johnson, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. A couple questions. One, could you explain to me what this bill would do in her circumstance of how it would change? Well, unfortunately, it would not do
▶ Play
anything in her current circumstance. Well, no, I'm talking about if it was in place
▶ Play
before her circumstance occurred. Do you want to speak to
▶ Play
that? the way that the law currently is he left the state without any permission from the state he literally told me one day and had him out of state the next day I had no idea that there was going to be a move and the state didn't have any idea there was going to be a move he took him out of state and then came back and I had petitioned the courts for a change of custody back to me and he got away with it So there was nothing in place to keep
▶ Play
him from doing that There's no notification law at all?
▶ Play
He was supposed to give 30 days But once he's got the kid
▶ Play
out of state, the bill's been wrong Okay, so there's already a 30-day
▶ Play
notification He's supposed to petition the courts for 30 days Okay For permission Now my
▶ Play
question's for you You could add more to that if you wish Well,
▶ Play
the notification is in place but still the burden of proof fell on her, even if he had followed proper procedure and given the 30 days notice, she would have had to have come forward and show that this relocation is not in the best interest of the child, not in the best interest, which is proving a negative, rather than having him have to. I mean, he created the material change in circumstances. So to me and the reasoning behind this bill is that if you're the one that changes, I mean, she's just walking along having a great relationship with her child, and then all of a sudden she's put in a position where she's got to provide proof, even though she did
▶ Play
Speaker 76 28:34
not change the material circumstances. Okay. Then I have a
▶ Play
question for you. If I struggle with we have parents that are not involved that are deadbeat parents, and I struggle that this could put an undue burden on some single parents that they have to go through a process when nobody even cares, but they still are put in a position they're going to have to do things. I'm struggling with this bill pretty hard. And what process does a parent of deadbeat dad or mom have to go through to comply with this law? Well,
▶ Play
the process that's spelled out in this bill does not put any undue requirements on a parent if the non-custodial parent is non-active, if they're, as you say, the deadbeat parent. They just have to go through the notification process. They have to prove that this is in the best interest of the child. If the deadbeat parent is not even active, then there's no conflicting testimony, and it's really something that the judge is easily able to make a determination. But they still have to go through a process. Not
▶ Play
the deadbeat parent. No, but the custodial parent that's doing their best, working on minimum wage or whatever they're doing to get by, has to have a process they have to
▶ Play
go through anyway. But they already have to go through the process of the notification. All this does is just put on them the burden of proof, which in that case, where you have no conflicting or no negating information, it's not that difficult a burden for them.
▶ Play
Speaker 79 30:13
And you're changing it from 30 days to 45? I believe that's correct. All right. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Please assist us in following the rules that the Speaker has asked us to go by, and that is one question and then a follow-up. I know these things get very engaging. Thank you. Representative Bart, you're recognized. I have a question for her and a
▶ Play
follow-up for him, if I may. You recognize. Thank you, Mr. Chair. My question is, did you have a chance to prove the negative for your child? That's my first question for you. No, I didn't. And why were you not given that chance? The Hollinsworth Law prevented that. But I thought, never mind, that's not how it reads. Did you have a follow-up question? Yes. My question is for Representative Lowry. This deadbeat parent that you keep talking about, what is considered an active parent? What do you consider an active parent? Someone who goes to a ballgame once a week, someone who picks up a child once a week from school, or every two weeks or every three weeks, what do you consider a deadbeat
▶ Play
parent? Well, let me first point out, I did not initially use the reference deadbeat parent. I'm referencing what the courts would talk about, an active parent. And that would be a determination that's made by the judge. We can't stipulate to that. And I would tell you that one of the reasons amendments were made was because judges are always concerned about being told by the legislative branch what they have to do. So that's why the language was changed to May. Since those changes have been made, the Arkansas Judicial Council has taken no position, neither for or against this bill. They're neutral on it. But all of those decisions about active parent, as one of the factors, would be up to the judge to
▶ Play
determine. Okay. Thank you. Representative Petty, you're
▶ Play
recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I don't believe that the non-custodial parent should have to prove when the custodial parent moves. Do you know what I'm saying? They should not have to prove that. And also, just to clarify for the rest of the committee members, I know you touched on the Hollingsworth case, and I have read on that quite a bit. Could you just, in a brief explanation, let the committee know sort of what happened in that case? I am going
▶ Play
to defer to Brittany because I know she's really been absorbed with that. I'm not that familiar with the specifics of Hollinsworth.
▶ Play
Ms. Hollinsworth and Mr. Hollinsworth were married, and they had, I think, two or three children. And when they divorced, Ms. Hollinsworth remarried, and she married someone who was in the Army. and his base was in Tennessee. And so when she remarried, she petitioned the courts to take the children to Tennessee. And the courts found that it was in the best interest of the child to stay with the father in Arkansas because that's where the children had always lived. That's where they went to school. All their activities were here, and they switched custody from her to him. She took it to the appellate court. the appellate court decided that you can't put a blanket around the state or a mobile society and that the custody should be given back to her. And then that's where Hollinsworthworth
▶ Play
was established. Okay. Thank you. Representative Brown, you're recognized.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. My question is
▶ Play
for Brittany. I apologize. I forgot your last name. But is notification that the parent is moving and taking the child with him or her, is that currently required by Arkansas law, whether they are the custodial parent? I mean, I guess the custodial parent. I mean, he was considered the custodial parent, but you were, in actuality, the custodial parent. And at this point, my comment is it's unfortunate that you weren't able to get that changed before this occurred, but hindsight's 20-20. So was he required to give you notification that he was going to be leaving the state, and if so, how much notification? He was required
▶ Play
to give the courts 30 days notice I found out the day before he moved And the courts found out after he had already moved
▶ Play
So he was at that point in time in violation of Arkansas law Yes If you may, if I may, just one more So, but at that point in time he was no longer in Arkansas So there was nothing Arkansas law could do about it Exactly, yes Thank
▶ Play
you Representative Richman, you're recognized. My question was just asked and answered. Okay.
▶ Play
Representative Petty. So he just up and left. And go ahead. He just left. Why did that not constitute parental kidnapping? Because he already had full custody.
▶ Play
Speaker 104 36:00
And didn't ask, I mean,
▶ Play
he asked the courts. He went through the proper channels. He just did not tell you. No,
▶ Play
I petitioned the courts for a change of custody after he had moved. And the court said that a relocation is not a material change of circumstance.
▶ Play
Okay. Representative Johnson. Representative Larry, question for you. What is DHS's standpoint on
▶ Play
this? I have not been approached by DHS with any concerns. As I've mentioned, the AG's office came to me to help make suggestions on some cleanup and also the administrative courts, and those changes have been made. But other than that, there's been no other opposition. And even in those cases, there was not opposition. There was just suggestions that changes would be made. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair. Representative Vaughn. So, Representative Lowry, maybe instead of this law, we need a law where it is considered parental kidnapping if you don't follow the correct channels of the law that's already in
▶ Play
place. Would you not agree? Well, that probably is something that should. The real problem is that, you know, Brittany explained that she did petition the courts, And even in light of that information that the custodial parent had violated the law, the judge said, ruled in his favor because of the Hollingsworth law, because of the precedent. So that's why this law has changed, is in the case of that, you shouldn't be able to let someone get away with criminality, which there was in this case. So really there was just, there was a double victimization of Brittany and her situation. The law, the existing law, was violated, and yet his right to do that was upheld by current case law. So we're at least fixing part of
▶ Play
that. Representative Meeks, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And, again, this piggybacks off the last question. If the Hollingsworth law is in place and we pass this law and he violates this law, then would they still not ignore it because of the Hollingsworth president, which has been done by
▶ Play
the Supreme Court? Well, in Brittany's specific case, and it's really to her credit that she's here testifying because, you know, as she has told me, she's testifying to help other parents. There's nothing that can help her situation. Even with this change of burden of proof, that case cannot be revisited. So I really appreciate her coming forward. I know it's very painful for her, but she doesn't want any other parent who has, especially as an active parent, to have to go through this kind of situation again. A follow-up, Mr. Chair? But, again,
▶ Play
I guess my question is I understand in her case it won't help, but in future cases would it still not be the same thing if somebody was to just up and move, even if we pass this law, if they move it to the other state, then I mean Arkansas would have no jurisdiction correct or would they if we pass this law would they now be able to do some kind of extradition type thing well even in Brittany's
▶ Play
situation she was able to petition the court the child had been moved with the custodial parent to another state but the court still held if I understand they still held some jurisdiction over the custodial situation, and they ruled against her because of the case law, because of the Hollingsworth Law. If the burden of proof were different, if we could roll back time, the burden of proof were different, then that act of parental kidnapping would have been overturned. The burden of proof would have been at least on him then to have to prove that this was in the best interest of the child. But really, as it stood, it was a non-starter. The burden was put on Brittany. Representative Scott. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Brittany Sweetheart, did you appeal the court's decision? And if you did not, why not? I did appeal the
▶ Play
court's decision. Unfortunately, I was not allowed to admit much evidence of the parental alienation that had happened once the stepmom came into place in the initial trial. So when it went to the appellate court, there wasn't really much ground because I hadn't had that admitted in the first trial. But, yes, I did appeal it. Thank you.
▶ Play
Representative Brown had a question. Representative Brown, did you go
▶ Play
ahead? Yes, thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. We discussed this, I've read this, and now I'm getting really confused. So back to the bill, what you're asking for is that the relocating custodial parent notify the court and make the case for why this is in the best interest of the child. That's
▶ Play
what you're asking for. Changing the burden of proof to the parent who's making the material change in
▶ Play
Speaker 93 41:36
circumstances through the relocation. Thank you.
▶ Play
Representative Petty. So basically, right now, the non-custodial parent is being punished. A custodial parent wants to move. They just take the kid, they move, and the non-custodial parent has no say in it.
▶ Play
Is that correct? Well, the non-custodial parent bears the burden. I mean, you've already heard Brittany said she spent $20,000. I mean, you talk about an active parent. That certainly would be a threshold, I think, to spend that kind of money to fight for your child. But really she was not granted much opportunity to be able to argue because there was a presumption. Because of Hollingsworth, there was a presumption that the relocating parent, that it's a non-starter, that that's the way it should be. So we're changing that so that now there's actually, there has to be an arbiter of fact. There has to be consideration of numerous factors of whether that relocation is in the best interest of the child, and that burden would be on the relocating
▶ Play
parent. Just a quick follow-up. I just want to say I don't think that's fair on the non-custodial
▶ Play
parent. Representative Harris, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Just to bring it back, Ms. Brittany's case is special, and so let's bring that back. And I have, my heart goes out to her, but I want to be clear, Representative Lowry, that in your case too, but that's a special case, but we're talking about custodial parents. and let's be clear, if you would agree with this, that the custodial parent has been granted through testimony and through the court case has been granted custody for a reason. Is that correct?
▶ Play
That is correct, but that decision to grant custody does not unilaterally give them the right to move across the country. There still is a process that they have to go through, and the process has been overly burdened against the non-custodial parent in terms of the burden of proof can
▶ Play
I have a follow up Mr. Chair yes but you would agree that they broke the law that is there when they moved just out of state without
▶ Play
notifying the court yes in that case but in any other case say someone goes through all the proper hoops they give the notification they say to the non-custodial parent, and let me preface this by saying that, you know, fortunately in a lot of situations, these kinds of decisions are worked out in the custodial agreement, okay? Some of these things are proactively worked out of whether there's going to be relocation, you know, what are we going to do to accommodate that, but say in the case of someone who follows all the rules, they give the 30-day notification, they go to court, it still remains that when they go to court, with everything having been done properly, the judge then turns to the non-custodial parent who did not even initiate the action and says, okay, now you have to prove why this shouldn't happen. And that's an unfair burden. The burden should be on the initiating agent here, the custodial parent. You're exactly right. There's a reason why they were given custody, but that custody does not automatically give them the right to uproot the child
▶ Play
and separate them from the other parent. Representative Gage, you recognize? Representative Lowry, I agree that it's harder for a non-custodial parent to prove that it would be against the interest of the child than it would be for the custodial parent to prove that it is in the best interest of the child to prove. If this were changed, would it also cause, give the judges when they're granting custodial parents to ask that question about relocating? If I grant custody, are you planning on moving? Would that become a determining factor maybe in granting custody? I don't
▶ Play
think that that would be an automatic question that would be asked to determine custody. Maybe if it is raised by the non-custodial parent in terms of opposing or maybe asking for joint custody, for instance. In the 2013 session, I was able to pass legislation that now makes the policy of the state of Arkansas all to favor joint custody, but that has not been the case previously. So that could be a question that could be asked if there was a petition for joint custody. Do either one of you plan on relocating? But it doesn't, this bill itself does not automatically make that a line of inquiry. Thank you. Representative Petty?
▶ Play
Sorry. I just feel like it seems like the non-custodial parents are being victimized and almost criminalized, every one of them do not get the custody just because they're bad and they're non-custodial. They end up being non-custodial. That doesn't necessarily mean that they're the bad parent. Things happen, and sometimes they just agree, okay, you're going to be the custodial parent, you're going to be the non-custodial parent. So it's bothersome to me that the non-custodial parent seems to be victimized here. And I just don't think that's right. That's
▶ Play
all. Thank you. Question. Representative Vulture recognized. This
▶ Play
bill really has nothing to do with who is given parental rights and who is not given parental rights. Am I right? It has to do with relocation of a child. Am I correct?
▶ Play
That is correct. Okay, thank you. Okay. Thank you. Is there anyone in the audience that would like to speak for this bill? Anyone would like to speak against this bill? Yes, Representative Vaught, you're reckoning to speak against the bill. Even though
▶ Play
I totally sympathize with you. Excuse me, Representative Paul, would you go to the end of the table? Sorry. Thank you. Sorry. You're fine. Even though I totally sympathize with you, and I do, because I've had friends that have been in this case before, I still think it's the wrong law because this is not about a parental custody thing. It's about the moving of a child, which I totally understand, and I think the law was totally violated by what happened to her. And I think if we had a law where it was set as a kidnapping law, if they go across the lines or don't follow the procedures, I think that's more of the law that I think that you're looking for than this law, if that makes sense. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair. Are there any questions? Is there anyone to speak for? Representative Richman, you're recognized to speak for, if you would. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
I'm sorry. Okay. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I appreciate this. I decided to speak for this because I've seen this situation happen several times. It happened years ago in Virginia with some best friends, and in this case, again, it was the wife in that particular situation, left devastated. She did not materially have the resources to fight it, and so her children disappeared almost completely out of her life because of a relocation. The thing about this bill is that it doesn't tip the scales to one custodian, the custodian or the other parent this simply balances the field that they're playing on and still allows the judges to have input all it does is basically if i'm going to leave and i intend to take the children then it is up to me to prove that that is the right thing to do and that's a balancing act because i think that too often that the parents with the children automatically gain favor because they are the custodians and the judge will weigh in more heavily in their favor than otherwise. To me, this simply balances the field, and I think it is a good effort and a good bill. Thank
▶ Play
you. Thank you. Is there anyone to speak against? Four. Any questions? Representative Smith, you want to speak for the bill? Yes.
▶ Play
You're recognized. I do agree. I mean, I totally agree. But first, you have to have the key. Thank you, Chairman Gill. I, too, am going to vote in favor of this bill. And I concur with my colleague, Richmond. The reason I'm going to vote yes is because I think this bill being in place will actually slow down some of the quick maneuvering and give the children the chance to, if things don't go the way the non-custodial parent wants them to go, at least it slows it down enough for there to be some goodbyes said. And, you know, at the end of the day, it's all about the kids anyway. The judge may approve the move, or he or she may say, you know, we really need to slow this down and look at more facts. But it does put a little bit of distance between a departure date and the decision and gives the parents, both parents, an opportunity to prove beyond a shadow of a doubt why things need to happen the way they do. So I would encourage a good vote for this bill.
▶ Play
Thank you. Thank you. Is there anyone else that would like to speak against the bill? For the bill? Representative Lowry, you
▶ Play
recognize the close for your bill? Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you, members. I want to emphasize that I understand that we can't make decisions because of anecdotal situations, even as painful as they are to hear. But I think it gives a face to the issue that we're dealing with. I mean, we deal with a lot of, you know, hard language and numbers and all this, but, you know, sometimes we just have to see the faces, and we have to understand that these are real relationships that are affected. this bill does nothing does nothing to change the issue of custody awarding and i'm referencing this to to representative vaut's issue custody is is awarded for a number of reasons sometimes custody is awarded because one parent has more resources they're able to hire a better attorney or maybe they are the better parent, the better provider, and I am not negating that in any way, but what happens after that custody arrangement has taken place, it's been sealed in law, at some point in the future, if there is a change, you know, the judges don't, they don't do a periodic review of custody. They've made a decision. They don't call you in every year or two and see if something has changed. But what they do have is if there is a material change in circumstances, which relocation would be that, then that gives an opportunity to revisit the issue of what is in the best interest of the child. Not necessarily to revisit the custodial arrangement, but just to revisit the family dynamic. And it's still a family. Even if there's divorce, it's still a family. And I think the state of Arkansas We have a responsibility to do everything that we can to maintain family dynamics. And I believe that this law does that. It forces the person who is actually initiating this change in circumstances to have to prove that it's in the best interest of the child rather than putting that burden on a non-castiliar parent who through no fault of their own, they've done nothing. They've just been a nurturing, loving parent, and then one day they're thrown this curve. And then they have to be the one that steps up and proves that it's not in the best interest. So having said all that, thank you so much for your careful inquiry into this. It is a sensitive area, and so I have not specifically spoken to anyone about making the due pass recommendation, but I hope that somebody will do that so that you will be able to vote this
▶ Play
out. Thank you. Representative Lowry has closed for his bill. What is the wishes of the
▶ Play
committee? Can I make a motion at a
▶ Play
proper time, sir? Representative Petty, you recognize for motion? To do pass. Representative Petty has motion to do pass. All in favor say aye. Aye.
▶ Play
All opposed? No. Roll call, please, Mr.
▶ Play
Chairman. We have to have two. Let's see hands. Okay. Okay. Mr. Kirk, call the roll. Representative Meeks.
▶ Play
Speaker 156 56:32
No. Representative Scott. No. Representative Fight. Representative Feit. Representative Bradaway. Representative Bradaway. Representative Petty. Representative Tucker. Representative Tucker. Representative Rushing. Representative Rushing. Representative Sullivan. Representative Sullivan. Representative Johnson. Representative Flowers. Representative Flowers.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 57:36
Representative Mayberry Yes Representative Gates Yes Representative Brown Yes Representative Vaught No Representative Richmond Yes Representative Wallace
▶ Play
Speaker 156 58:07
Yes Representative Sturge No Representative Smith Yes Are
▶ Play
Speaker 165 58:24
you No Representative Harris No And Representative McGill.
▶ Play
Okay. Your bill has failed. with seven A's and and six nays.
▶ Play
Thank you, committing, for your patience. And seven not voting. Thank you. Representative
▶ Play
Love, you're recognized to present your bill. I'm not voting for
▶ Play
Speaker 171 59:32
this guy. It's better to call a roll call than I'm not.
▶ Play
You're recognized, Representative Love. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Committee. This bill will be quick. Well, actually, it's not a bill. It's a resolution. And basically, it's just a resolution to recognize black history by the Arkansas House of Representatives. I did have a big speech, but I'm thinking that you are going to need some more time to run some more bills. So I will keep my speech, and I would just ask for a good vote on this. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank
▶ Play
you for committing. Okay. Thank you. Any questions from committee? Yes. Representative Johnson, you recognized? Motion at proper time,
▶ Play
sir. Okay. Any other questions? Representative Brown, question? Can I
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:00:34
make a comment? Yes, you may. Mr. Love, I read the proclamation, and I loved the title of it. And I believe that February is federally recognized as Black History Month. Correct. But when I read the text of the proclamation, much of it made me sad. that I felt that this proclamation could have been done in a much more celebratory and positive way. Now, I'm going to vote for it because I believe in recognizing Black History Month, but it broke my heart the way it was worded. And having grown up and attended segregated schools and having watched Dr. Martin Luther King on TV, I think he would have liked a much more upbeat proclamation. Those are my comments. Is there anyone
▶ Play
that would like to speak in favor? In opposition, Representative Love, you want to close for your bill?
▶ Play
I'm closing. I would just tell Representative Brown
▶ Play
that your comments are duly noted. thank you mr. chair okay thank you what is the
▶ Play
Speaker 180 1:02:16
wishes of the committee
▶ Play
Speaker 181 1:02:20
represented Johnson you recognize do pass all in favor vote aye opposed Rep. Love, you have passed your bill.
▶ Play
At this time, we'll hear Senate Bill 210. Representative Nix is going to present this bill. You're
▶ Play
Speaker 183 1:02:46
recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Speaker 184 1:02:52
Thank you, committee. We have Bill 210 that we're presenting, Senate Bill, and it's basically an organizational efficiency bill, And I have Ms. Sherry Middleton, director, and I'd like for her to come and explain the bill.
▶ Play
Ms. Middleton, would you come to the end of the table and state your name and
▶ Play
Speaker 186 1:03:22
position for the records, please? Thank you. I'm Sherry Middleton, DHS Division of Community Service and Nonprofit Support Director. You're recognized. Basically, we have two advisory entities. One has been in our legislation since we were legislated as a division. And then 20 years ago, when they did the AmeriCorps program, someone before me created an advisory commission. So we are looking at the efficiency of putting those two together. And because of some vacancies on both groups, we wouldn't be displacing anyone. So it's just more efficient and cost effective. Okay. Thank you. Are
▶ Play
there any questions from committee? Yes. Thank you. Representative Wallace, you recognize.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Will this save us money?
▶ Play
Yes, sir. Great. Thank you. Representative Meeks, a motion at the proper time. Are there any more questions? Anyone to speak for or against? Representative Meeks, you recognize? There's been a motion to do pass. All in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? You've passed your bill. Thank
▶ Play
Speaker 193 1:04:55
you very much. Thank you committee. I
▶ Play
see no other business before the committee. Thank you very much.
▶ Play

Agenda

HB1115

1:19 - 1:00:06 184 segments 22 speakers

HR1007

1:00:06 - 1:02:50 13 segments 7 speakers

SB210

1:02:50 - 1:05:06 11 segments 5 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative George B. McGill Chair Unverified
34 segments
Representative Mark Lowery Unverified
62 segments
Representative Justin T. Harris Chair Unverified
7 segments
Brittany Wyatt Unverified
27 segments
Representative Sue Scott Unverified
7 segments
Representative Stephen Meeks Unverified
8 segments
Representative Bob Johnson Unverified
12 segments
Speaker 76
1 segment
Speaker 79
1 segment
Representative DeAnn Vaught Chair Unverified
7 segments
Representative Rebecca Petty Unverified
9 segments
Representative Karilyn Brown Unverified
1 segment
Chair Unverified
9 segments
Representative Marcus E. Richmond Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 104
1 segment
Speaker 93
1 segment
Representative Mickey Gates Unverified
2 segments
Representative Brandt Smith Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 156
3 segments
Speaker 165
1 segment
Speaker 171
1 segment
Frederick Love Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 180
1 segment
Speaker 181
1 segment
Speaker 183
1 segment
Speaker 184
1 segment
Speaker 186
2 segments
Representative Dave Wallace Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 193
1 segment