Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House Agriculture, Forestry and Economic Development Committee

February 11, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (2)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1278 · 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…elieve what we've skipped around here just a little bit but House Bill 1278 by Representative Saban. You're recognized to present your…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1214 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1214”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 15, 2026
Okay. Seeing none, is there anybody to speak against the bill? Anybody? Marvin, do you want to speak before
▶ Play
Speaker 3 0:20
the bill? Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm Marvin Childers, president of the Poultry Federation. First, I want to say how much I appreciate Representative Eubanks being willing to continue to meet and to discuss this bill. I say that publicly. He has been, matter of fact, when he filed it, he filed it on one afternoon. He called me that night and said, Would you please read House Bill 1214 and would you visit with me tomorrow about it? And I want to say publicly I appreciate that. We did meet this morning, and I'll be real honest with you, I haven't seen the amendment. but I take Representative Eubanks at his word and what we tried to do in recommending the language in the amendment was to refer primarily to the federal law which does in fact require the two notices that I hope is mentioned in the amendment that is the notice that the grower has the right to terminate the contract within the first three days and then to make certain that the grower understands that he or she might be required during the term of the contract to make additional capital investments. That's been federal law since 2008, and Representative Eubanks was agreeable to the language that I presented to him this morning. I realize that there may have been some miscommunication and that there may be an issue with respect to the bankers, But, Representative Hendren, I want to mention to your point with respect to the material risk. If you'll note, in current Arkansas law, the integrator must, in a separate disclosure statement, set forth all the material risk that a grower might encounter, and that is a separate document. And I think in his amendment, we also added language that that would have to be explained and signed by the grower. So I hope that may help with respect to. Now, it doesn't help the bankers not doing it, but that agreement is between the integrator and the grower. At least it is a disclosure and would be required to be signed by the grower. And with that, Mr. Chairman, I appreciate – I've met with many of you. Representative House, I want to thank you publicly as well for meeting with me yesterday and trying to help us find a solution. I shared that with Representative Eubanks this morning. So with that, Mr. Chairman, I'll be glad to answer any questions. Okay. Representative Hendren, you had a question? Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chairman. Marvin, since – and I appreciate what you just said. What I think you just said is that the company, the integrator, explains to the grower that you may be required to do this during the time, and you're required to sign that document. That's correct. And I think I also heard you just say that you wouldn't have any problem if the financier, the banker, the lender, the guy that's going to give me the money or loan me the money to build those houses, and then is going to require me to pay it back, and if I don't pay it back because I can't afford to put $35,000 in those doors, because there have been some times, and some of you folks may know this, back when this natural gas was so high and poultry was down so low, by the time a grower gets his check, there's nothing left for him at all. That has actually happened, Representative Eubanks. It may have happened to you. Maybe that's why you're out of it, but it did to us, and it happens to folks. And Representative Eubanks said he'd support my bill. Maybe we could perhaps amend this bill. And what would you think about requiring not only the integrator, the company to explain this to the grower, to me, but also the banker that's going to loan me money to explain it to me before he writes the contractor the check for which I'm going to have to pay back over the next 15 years. And like I say, this may be a little bit, you say, well, that's pretty simple. Well, most of us farmers are just pretty simple folks. So if you'd explain it to me, I'd appreciate it.
▶ Play
Speaker 3 4:22
I'm not sure I'm at liberty to speak for the bankers.
▶ Play
Well, I guess I'd need to ask Mr. Chairman, then the sponsor of the bill, Mr. Eubanks, Representative Eubanks, if he had agreed to amend this thing. So not only the company explains this to me as I've signed this contract to grow for 15 years, but the guy that's going to loan me the money explained it to me again. Well,
▶ Play
Representative Hendren, I'll be honest with you, I've gotten more pushback on this bill than I ever imagined that I would get, and I'm really trying to get it passed. I think it's a good bill, but
▶ Play
I think it ought not be a Pelosi bill. We ought to know what's in it,
▶ Play
and we ought to fix it. Like I said, I
▶ Play
will support your bill if you want to do that. Any more questions for Mr. Childers? Okay. Thank you, Marvin. Does anybody else speak against the bill, speak for the bill? Representative Eubanks you recognize to close for your bill I'm close for my bill Motion do pass All in favor signify by saying aye All opposed nay Motion carries Representative Eubanks congratulations on passing your bill Alright next on the agenda I believe what we've skipped around here just a little bit but House Bill 1278 by Representative Saban. You're recognized to present your bill. Representative Saban.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Members of committee, I think we're going to try to run an amendment to the bill first, if that's all right with you. You're recognized for your amendment. Thank you very much. Uh, colleagues, uh, their amendment to this bill, 1278 is a pretty simple and straightforward and it, uh, hold on just a
▶ Play
minute. Have we got that amendment up here on the, excuse me. Okay. Everybody got it. Sorry, representative. Just want to make sure the members have
▶ Play
the amendment to view. No problem. I needed a moment to, uh, clear my throat anyway. Anyway, this amendment actually came from suggestions from the Director of the State Procurement Office, Camber Thompson, who's here in the room with us, and pretty simple and straightforward. And I know we're going to get to the bill, and the bill itself I think is pretty simple and straightforward too. But the amendment simply clarifies in the first change that the combined experience of the owners and senior executive staff can count toward the amount of experience of the bidder or the offeror. And the second change, which I think is actually a good change, will help them administer the intent of this legislation better, just allows the state procurement office to say on the front end whether or not the key personnel of the bidder or offer would or would not be sufficient to meet the experience requirement. And the reason why they'd like to do that on the front end is to save any bidder or offer from having to go through the trouble of putting together a complicated bid package and then find out after the fact that they weren't qualified to get the job. So I think these are good suggestions. Like I said, they came from the State Procurement Office, and I sure would appreciate a
▶ Play
good vote on the amendment. Any questions for Representative Seidman on the amendment? Anybody speak against the amendment? for the amendment. Representative, you wish to close for your amendment? I'm closed, Mr. Chair. Have a motion do pass. All in favor of do pass on the amendment, signify by saying aye. Opposed? Representative Saban, your amendment has passed. You're recognized to present House Bill 1278 as amended. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chair. Members of the committee, this bill basically came about because in my real job, so to speak, I work with a lot of entrepreneurs and start-up businesses, and over the course of the last year or two, some of these entrepreneurs would come to me and say, Warwick, you know, my partner and I, we have a combined, you know, 20 to 40 years of experience in our industry, But we're not allowed to bid on some of these state projects, because a lot of the procurement guidelines will say that the business has to be a certain number of years old, usually about three or four years old at least. And they felt like they were being excluded from the opportunity to bid on these projects that clearly they had the expertise to fulfill. And so I took a look at the law, and as it happens, that's pretty much the case. And so I thought it ought to be possible for the experience of the key personnel in the business to be able to obviously count that experience towards that that's required in these bids. And so the bill itself, again, is pretty straightforward. It basically says that the procurement office can take into account the experience of the owners, the senior executive staff, or in certain cases, the key personnel on the project that's being bid out. Although this exception that we just put in the amendment obviously allows the state procurement office to say in particular instances we're not going to allow that on the front end. But I think it definitely helps to level the playing field. I think it's a common sense change. The good news is I really haven't received much pushback on this. I've talked with some lobbyists who represent some of our bigger companies and those who you might have expected maybe to be against it. And I've not found there to be any opposition. And certainly the state procurement office seems to be on board with it. And so with that, I'd be glad to answer any questions, but that's
▶ Play
the intent of the legislation. Okay, committee, are there any
▶ Play
questions for Representative Seidman? Representative Shepard? Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Sabin, I just had, I think, one or two questions, and I'm trying to pull up the amendment. I'm sorry I had to step out of the room. With regard to a bid that's rejected, number one, the procurement office can still reject any bid it so chooses. Is that correct? I believe that's the case, but, of course, with
▶ Play
Ms. Thompson here, she might be able to be more
▶ Play
expert on it. Okay, and in your bill, if for whatever reason they determine that the experience of the key personnel is insufficient or there's a problem, then under the bill they would have to issue some kind of written finding in that regard. Is that correct? That's correct. Okay. Do they have to do that with regard to any other basis for rejection currently, or would this only would we be creating something that only applies in the instance of rejecting based on the experience of the key personnel that's an excellent question that i honestly don't
▶ Play
know the answer to so i mean if it pleases the committee maybe ms thompson could answer that
▶ Play
question ms thompson do you want to answer that question please come up and state your name Thank you Mr. Chairman
▶ Play
committee my name is Canberra Thompson I'm the director of the office of state procurement and currently on any bid that we would reject a bidder we would put in our file the reason for that rejection so that is something that we do currently Any questions for
▶ Play
Representative House Thank you for coming I disagree with your determination What are my appeal rights?
▶ Play
Under 1911-244 We have the opportunity to protest During the bid period So prior to the bid opening 72 hours prior If a bidder or offerer Does not agree with our Justification for the experience requirement They have the right to protest that Thank you, Chair
▶ Play
Representative Pitch As I understand this bill and reading it, you already make that determination. What we're doing is strictly changing the threshold you're checking to. We're not asking for other staff to do an additional test. Is that correct? That's correct. Okay, thank you. Representative
▶ Play
Speaker 49 13:25
Jane You're going to have to kind of help me with this
▶ Play
a little bit I see that we're on the bill that says for a certain amount of experience in a certain amount of years help me what is it now is it is it like defined years right now and then we're just going to have a kind of a ambiguous statement of a certain amount I mean help me understand what we're doing
▶ Play
here typically whenever we would bid a commodity or service generally an RFP we may require a bidder to have a certain amount of experience that is typically determined between the procurement office and also the procuring agency depending on what the service is is that a standard year
▶ Play
amount of experience do you mean do you have it like three four five i mean or is it just at y'all's discretion it is at
▶ Play
the discretion of the agency so that's what
▶ Play
we're doing right now yes so somebody could come in with less than a year experience right now
▶ Play
and procure a contract if we do not have a
▶ Play
requirement in the bid that requires more. Okay. Now, what
▶ Play
are we doing with this bill? We're opening up opportunities for others to qualify. Currently, right now, let's say a bidder, we require a company to have five years of experience. Currently, that would actually be the company. With the amendment that was just put through, that would allow the owners or the senior executive staff to have their previous experience to count as company experience. So
▶ Play
if they were with another company and they created their own and they weren't in business for three months, they would qualify? That's correct. Okay.
▶ Play
All right. Thank you. Any other questions? Representative Davis.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Saban, I'll do my best to try to get this in form of a question this so i have a couple concerns about some potential side effects and i just wonder if you've considered these so one of which being have you thought about an instance where key personnel could see that their employer was about to bid something and decide to leave that business, go set up shop across the street, and then bid on the same project, having gained all that experience just immediately previously to the bid opening or to the bid being available. I mean, I don't know how you would address that, but they could potentially be in a dispute over a non-compete agreement or, you know what I'm saying? I mean, have you thought about things like that? I mean, it seems like, I don't know, it just seems like, I mean, I hate to use the word fair, but it seems like you could have some people potentially jump ship from an employer who's done a lot of previous legwork to be prepared for something, to educate for something, to train somebody, and then they can just run across the street, set up LLC, and then go bid and say, will have all this experience that I gained at
▶ Play
so-and-so. Sure. I have considered that. That was part of the discussions I've had with some of these lobbyists who represent the bigger companies, because that was sort of the worst-case scenario concern, I think, that would come up. I mean, again, the direct answer to your question is I think we all, in our conversations, kind of decided that the likelihood of that is just so slim based on a lot of different sort of things that would go into that happening. And that concern is, I mean, almost no different than what happens in, you know, the private sector or in any other scenario where, you know, a few people could leave a company and start their own business based on intelligence or taking clients with them, whether they're, you know, work for a stockbroker or et cetera. So, you know, weighing all of the different factors, you know, I think that most of their concerns were mitigated, understanding that, you know, in the private sector, things like that do happen, regardless of whether you're talking about state bids or not. And it's better to err on the side of, again, leveling the playing field and allowing people with legitimate businesses who, again, have a lot of experience yet are artificially barred from, you know, really bidding for business based on the experience they have simply because of the age of their company. It does a lot to impair and inhibit the development of new startup businesses in Arkansas, which supposedly we're all for.
▶ Play
Okay. Second question, if you don't mind, Mr. Chair, similar topic. So have you considered instead of a one-for-one, let's say, for one year's experience at company X, i leave company x set up company y i have one for one experience understanding that sure the you know key personnel understand probably have the primary experience you're looking for but you would then be dealing with a perhaps an entity that in and of itself you know has not completed a project that they could be bidding on there could be a lack of support staff there could be a lack of you know just organizational structure you know you could have a you could have an entity that consisted of just key personnel who have no support staff did you considered you know some other ratio of experience to be considered as opposed to just one for one well I
▶ Play
think for the purposes of this legislation you know I was really trying to just attack the one term really the experience term I think there are a lot of other factors that that the Office of Procurement and the state agencies take into account when they do these bids. And again, I'm sure Ms. Thompson could probably address those. But this was strictly meant not to, again, even micromanage or tell people what to do, but just to say when you've got this factor and you're calling it experience, right now the state is only talking about experience in the context of the age of the actual business. And that seems very limiting, and it seems ultimately unfair. I think that a lot of the factors you're talking about could be addressed in either other legislation or other rule making, or if I had to guess, and again, Miss Thompson could address this. I mean, it's maybe even addressed already based on what they have in place now. But it's this, really, this whole bill amounts to how we talk about the word experience. And that's really all I'm trying to do with the bill. Again, maybe, I don't know whether you'd like Ms. Thompson to address your question.
▶ Play
Yeah, Ms. Thompson, if you don't mind, would you address that? How would you address those other factors in
▶ Play
the procurement process? Especially in a request for proposal or request for qualification, there is an evaluation of the proposal that's received, so they will receive a certain number of points based on the personnel that may be working on the project, so we may ask for resumes, who they are, what they've done. So we would actually be able to take into account, Do they have any support staff, or would it just be maybe the two owners of the company trying to handle the whole project? So that would be taken into account
▶ Play
Speaker 26 20:50
in their total evaluation. Okay. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Representative Shepard, I think you had a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. with regard to our current bidding process what percentage of bids involve an experience requirement is it all of them is it only some of them and if it's only some of them what is the what's the basis for making a determination as to what experience is necessary
▶ Play
I would say most of our RFPs and RFQs will have some sort of experience requirement in them. So I would
▶ Play
say over 75%. And then I guess a follow-up to that is, piggybacking on my first question, is what's the basis for the experience requirement? Is it, I mean, I can imagine there's a number of factors that would be involved. One, can they do the job? Two, is it a company that has the financial wherewithal? to make good on its promises moving forward. There may be others, but could you share what considerations go into that experience determination? We also
▶ Play
look at, and the agency will look at, what type of service we're trying to bid out or require. Sometimes there are not a lot of companies in a space that can even provide certain services depending on just the breadth of the service that needs to be provided. there just aren't a lot out there we also take into account in our technical evaluations a lot of the concerns that you had so we'll look at their financial stability through usually a done in Bradstreet report we'll get their done in Bradstreet score and that will actually be scored as well so a lot of these things we do take into account in their technical evaluation but when we look at just saying on the front end they need to have five years of a company experience that the company has been in business, a lot of times that can be from an agency, an arbitrary number that they feel comfortable with. So this would actually help our agencies branch out a little bit farther to allow others that may have the experience to get into the marketplace and at least try and bid on the project. Okay. Representative
▶ Play
Beck, I think you had a question.
▶ Play
And you may have addressed it harshly. The question I have are, do you have any concerns related to, you know, the experience of the business would represent their experience with the type of project that they're bidding out, whereas the experience of the individual would not be all-inclusive in terms of the, It gets back to Representative Davis's point of the support staff and everything. Would there, what would be, I guess the question would be, what would be the assurance that we're not bidding someone or we're not allowing someone in that couldn't support the project from a support type standpoint? I think those
▶ Play
are addressed in that technical evaluation because we ask many different questions of any bidder that proposes a bid package so we won't just ask you know how many years have you been in business we'll ask specific questions about different projects that they've worked on we'll ask their financial stability we'll ask about the key personnel that will be working on the project and we and depending on the service various other questions in order to get a good feel for can the business do the project or are Are they still just too new, and then it's reflected in their evaluation and how they score?
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Jane. In your opinion, we pass this bill with this strength in the Office of Procurement's ability to get better bids? Yes. Unequivocally,
▶ Play
you believe that? I believe it will. I believe it will open competition
▶ Play
up greatly. Okay. Thank you. Representative Bakes. And that was a perfect segue into my question. Do you believe that this could potentially lead to savings for the state by having this additional competition? Yes, I believe that it can. Okay. And following that, I think most of us in this room are used to dealing with millions of dollars. And I think some of us may have the fear that we're going to be giving multimillion-dollar contracts to two guys in a corner office who are just starting off. So could you please maybe give us an idea of, you know, what size contracts we're talking about here? Give us a vision of who you see, the size of companies, the type of projects, what are the dollar values of these projects? Can you kind of
▶ Play
go into that a little bit? Our RFPs and RFQs can be several hundred thousand dollars to many millions of dollars, you know, $20, $30 million contracts. So there will be some of the very, very large contracts, maybe the $30 million plus that this may not be for at the beginning. But they may be able, some of these companies may be able to get some of the smaller contracts, get that experience, gain the experience, and then over time they'll be able to then compete for some of the $20, $30 million contracts. Okay, so you see so primarily you envision that most
▶ Play
of these startup companies are going to be going after those smaller projects And then that creates the ability for them to work up from there. I think they will. Okay. All right. Thank you. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Any other questions from the committee? Okay, saying none Thank you for your testimony ma'am. Thank you chairman. Thank you committee Is there anyone speak against the bill? Bill, for the bill, Representative Saban, would you like
▶ Play
to close? Yes, sir. I just wanted to briefly reiterate, because, I mean, the questioning actually was excellent, and I thought that it kind of brought out a lot of important points here. But, you know, the bill, like I said during my initial testimony, and I apologize, I must be coming down with a cold. It's really narrowly tailored for this definition of experience, And I don't know if you all have ever taken a look at some of these RFPs, RFQs, and bid packages, but they're pretty intense. They're pretty complicated. They are very bureaucratic, no value statement meant there. But I think there are a lot of these tests that are, all of these issues that you brought up, they're kind of addressed through the process. And this is not so much to say, hey, let these two guys in their garage throw out a shingle and bid for a $10 million project. It's more like, let's not restrict the ability of people who have decades of experience and who have a lot of expertise to bring and who, by any other measure, ought to be able to at least have a shot at some of the state business, not to deny them that opportunity. so narrowly defining the definition of experience just to the age of the company. So that's all this is. It's not to, you know, make it a free-for-all. It's just to offer the state the opportunity to take advantage of the free market and competition and the best abilities of all of our citizens to promote entrepreneurship and start up business development in the state of Arkansas, which, again, I think we're all for. So with that, I'm closed, and I
▶ Play
appreciate the opportunity. Thank you. Okay. Members, Representative Saban has explained his bill. What is the pleasure of the committee? Have a motion due pass? All in favor, say aye. Aye. As amended, as amended, thank you, Representative Shepard. All opposed? Motion passes. Representative Saban, congratulations on passing your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair
▶ Play
Speaker 64 29:11
and members of the committee. As amended.
▶ Play
Now, Representative Saban, are you going to buy us lunch? Okay, members, I've got a bill on there. we're going to pass over. It's getting an amendment on it. And I think that concludes our business for today. So we will, unless there's any other business, we will stand adjourned. Thank you.
▶ Play

Agenda

HB1214

0:25 - 5:54 16 segments 4 speakers

HB1278

5:54 - 29:49 85 segments 13 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Dan M. Douglas Chair Unverified
17 segments
Speaker 3
7 segments
Representative Kim Hendren Unverified
6 segments
Representative Jon S. Eubanks Unverified
23 segments
Representative Matthew J. Shepherd Unverified
7 segments
Canberra Thompson Unverified
18 segments
Representative Douglas House Unverified
1 segment
Representative Mathew W. Pitsch Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 49
1 segment
Representative Lane Jean Unverified
8 segments
Representative Andy Davis Unverified
6 segments
Speaker 26
1 segment
Representative Rick Beck Unverified
2 segments
Representative Stephen Meeks Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 64
1 segment