House Public Health, Welfare and Labor Committee
Video
Transcript
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 15, 2026
Bill number again everybody should know it 1292 I think you have two amendments or one amendment is that right two amendments and the two amendments are on the tablet members would you like to I think one amendment is simply adding a sponsor is that right or that's correct would you like to run that one first please certainly as the chair said that first amendment
simply adds I think it's three co-sponsors to the bill. Members, any questions on that? And I hear a
motion. There we go. Thank you, Representative McGee. No discussion on the motion. All in favor, aye. Any opposed? That amendment is adopted. If you would, present your second amendment.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. The second amendment simply adds some language to provide some reassurance to some people who'd had concerns about what might happen. They felt perhaps that the state's hands might be tied in certain situations. We actually thought those concerns were already addressed by the sole source mechanism that's already in place and is actually currently being used since the contract on this particular system expired in February, but
we went ahead and added this language simply to say that if a real-time electronic logbook required by this section is no longer available, then the ACIC shall select another logbook through the procurement process. representative letting who's ACIC that'd be the Arkansas Crime Information Center thank you all right I forgot you don't like
acronyms I would just want to make sure we know who is who your acronym may be different than ours we want accuracy that's all right enough members any questions on the amendment
hearing none what's the will the committee we'll have a due pass on the amendment any discussion hearing none all in favor aye and it posed your amendment is adopted. You're recognized to speak on the
bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair, Madam Vice Chair, members of the committee. Good morning. I honestly believe the discussion around this bill is fairly simple. If we simply focus on the policy, I can't imagine there's anybody here in the room or probably at either end of the Capitol that has not already heard
quite a lot about this bill as there has been quite a lot of chatter. But again, I honestly think it's fairly simple and straightforward. Currently, the state pays about $300,000 a year for a system, a real-time electronic logbook, to monitor the sales of products that contain pseudoephedrine. We do this to help prevent crime. We do have a meth problem here in Arkansas, and while admittedly a lot of the meth is coming in from out of state, we do still have labs here in Arkansas. In fact, the day that I filed an interim study on this issue just about a year ago, police created a home in Maumelle where a married
couple had been cooking meth in their garage. It was just six doors down from a colleague of ours and across the street from a Saline County Sheriff's deputy's home. So we do still have labs here in Arkansas. And so we use this system to monitor those sales. One of the weaknesses of the current system is that it does not share data with our surrounding states. We have 29 border states, and it's very easy for somebody to buy their daily or monthly allotment of pseudoephedrine in that state and then hop across, in Arkansas, and then hop across
to, say, Oklahoma or Missouri to buy more. The corner counties are especially susceptible to that since, as in Benton County, back in my neck of the woods in northwest Arkansas, somebody could easily reach both Missouri and Oklahoma in the same day. And so part of the problem, as I said, with the current system is that we're not getting data from those border states and for me that's really what this issue is all about it's about the data the state is currently paying for a system that does not have access to that data and I really feel that if there's a system out there that does
provide that information the state should use it just to give you an example we know that Benton County in fact is second only to Miller County and the number of Arkansans who hopped across the border to buy pseudo ephedrine in another state last year. There were 1,633 individuals who crossed the border to purchase pseudo ephedrine. In Miller County, there were 2,259. Washington County had just over 1,100 people hop the border to buy pseudo ephedrine. Clinton County, there were 487.
Sebastian County, representative board, there were 534 people who hopped the border to purchase. so as I said that's really what this comes down to for me I think if the state is going to pay to use a system like this we should make sure that we have that data from the surrounding states
members have heard an explanation on the bill Representative Letting I'm sure you've seen we all got the request for proposal
RFP on the desk I believe that was originally supposed to be released in November and then coincidentally 36 hours before this meeting I think
was released after the contract had expired and your bill is calling for communication do you know if the request for proposal that was done 7 years ago required or called for communication between states
I don't believe I don't know Okay, this one does, and I don't know if the previous one or not, but it's on our copy. I'm sure you have a copy. It's highlighted as well. This one does, so I didn't, and I kind of asked you before, but if you felt like this request for proposal would solve the issue you have, which is communication between states, and this does that, but okay. Members, questions? Representative Payton, you recognize for question. Thank you,
Mr. Chair. Representative Letting, probably a real simple question, but if we have a company,
prepared to offer services for free, basically, what we're being told, and they're better services and serve the citizens of state Arkansas better, why is it necessary for us to change the law to accommodate this? Would their bid not be accepted? Well, I'd say the state has had the opportunity to
pursue a solution like that for a number of years now and hasn't. So
your confidence in the bid being accepted on its merit is low, so you feel like we need to change the law to make sure that we go this route?
you, Mr. Chair. Members, any other questions? Seeing none, we have a couple people signed up to speak against this. Representative Vlady, you never introduced
now? Yes, please. Okay. All right. Again, with the chair and the committee's permission, my name is Kevin Kraushaar. Last name is spelled K-R-A-U-S-H-A-A-R for the record.
I'm here on behalf of the Consumer Healthcare Products Association. It's been my privilege to actually be part of the process here working on this issue since the late 90s. And it's always good to be back here. The Consumer Healthcare Products Association, CHPA, if you will, is the national trade association representing the companies that manufacture some of the products, over-the-counter medicines, which are the subject of the electronic tracking system.
CHPA has been working in a number of states on this issue. In fact, working with the company called APRES and NPLEX through the National Association of Drug Diversion Investigators, NADDI, on a national system, what could be a national system, of tracking pseudoephedrine transactions. And that system is in place in now 30 states, including all of the border states surrounding Arkansas, except for Mississippi, which is a pseudoephedrine is on prescription status.
And that is significant because obviously that is a system which other states have come to the conclusion is in their best interest, including the state of Texas. But again, it's a free system available to the state. No RFP is really necessary. In fact, Arkansas is the only state that I'm aware of where an actual RFP process has been put in place. I have had a chance to look, Mr. Chairman, at the RFP. It was presented as Representative Letting indicated. It came out on Thursday.
I'm sorry, on Tuesday of this week. I'm very sure that the company that hosts the NPLEX system in other states will be evaluating it. I don't represent them, and so I can't put words in their mouth. And I haven't, don't, didn't see the 2008 RFP. and I can tell you that obviously technology has changed a great deal and the landscape, political landscape and the legal landscape has changed a great deal since 2008.
How many of us can say that we haven't changed computers or upgraded our computers or purchased a new cell phone in that period of time? And so a lot has changed and I applaud the state for taking another evaluation going through the process again on this and again because I don't speak for APRES, the other company. So I'm not sure how to respond to that, and I can't. There are two companies that are in this business, and the state obviously has to pick one or the other. We need to evaluate, I think, two groups that are almost being ignored in this process.
And number one is, what is the need of law enforcement? And it's important to note that there are 278 law enforcement officers that use the NPLEX system, National Precursor Log Exchange, the other system I was talking about. 278 law enforcement officers in this state that are signed up to use the system that is not designated as the system of choice for the state of Arkansas. As Representative Letting said, there are 16,000 transactions in Arkansas border states by residents of Arkansas who went to other states to purchase pseudoephedrine.
Arkansas authorities don't know about those transactions, don't have access to that information unless they use the NPLEX system, and as I said, with 278 law enforcement officials already using the NPLEX system, they can use it and access the system for free. They're already doing that even though the state is spending $300,000 a year on another contract. We can eliminate that process by UCAN by simply approving Representative Letting's bill,
which says that the system has to be free to the state, to law enforcement, and to retailers. And secondarily, it has to be free. The other part of the bill, obviously, that has to be able to communicate across state lines. And that is exactly what the NPLEX system is all about. So you've got the 16,000 transactions by Arkansas citizens going to other places to purchase.
You've got 278 law enforcement officers in this state already using the NPLEX system, even though the other system is in place. NPLEX is a multi-state system. It's the only system that's free to retailers. Walmart, Kroger, Target, CVS, Walgreen are already using the system, and most of those retailers use it on a nationwide basis. I understand you have a lot of smaller, independent, family-owned pharmacists in the state,
pharmacies in the state, and those can also be easily converted. The transition from the current system to NPLEX would be relatively seamless. And again, law enforcement would have access to the data real time. In fact, we have a number of examples where officers are in their squad cars and seeing transactions as they occur within those pharmacies. Everything happens in real time at a moment's notice, and the system, as we're looking at the taxpayers, the system is free to the state, to law enforcement, and to retailers.
Mr. Chairman, we strongly support this bill. We appreciate Representative Letting's work on this. A map clearly shows, obviously, N-Plex, Arkansas being in the middle of a bunch of N-Plex territory. Many of you have seen this map before, but clearly shows that 30 other states, we're going to have Montana on board here very shortly, probably New Mexico by the end of the year. 30 other states have decided to go with the free system. Arkansas is the lone state in the middle
the hole in the donut that has not decided to use that system so again Mr. Chairman we're strongly in support of this bill strongly in support of the system commit to you our continued resources to continue the system and to work with all of you to solve as many of these problems as we can and thank you Mr. Chairman Mr. Chair if I may I did mention
that you should have a map before you unpack it, along with a letter from Prosecuting Attorney Cody Hyland in support of this bill, a letter from the retailers in support of this bill.
Mr. Ronnie Baldwin with the Sheriff's Association had planned to be here this morning to speak in support of the bill. He is ill, but I spoke with him this morning, and he wanted to reaffirm the Sheriff's
Association's support for this bill. all right representative letting you you and i have been fortunate set by each other numerous committees and always enjoy a little bit of debate with you so i want to i want to ask you this question you might maybe that witness was better for this it was mentioned that other
states are not using requests for proposals rfps how are they then deciding who does it i mean How does this process work if they don't put out a request for proposal?
Mr. Chairman, it certainly varies from place to place, but essentially what most states are doing is simply passing pieces of legislation which says that the state shall adapt and be part of the system. An RFP in those areas is not necessary because they're not spending state funds. They're simply becoming part of the system.
Law enforcement right now, any law enforcement officer in the state of Arkansas can get registered and can get a password, a private password, to be able to use the NPLEX system. All that is necessary, all that's been done in the other states has just been enabling legislation to allow that to occur. Okay. So we're
statutorily saying you will belong to the – well, in this case, we're not. I mean, all we're saying is you
Speaker 36
15:14
have to be a free system, so on and so forth, statutorily. That's what this bill does is makes the system free and available.
Okay. And Representative Letting, what happens? I mean, we talked about how technology changes. So if we adopt your piece of legislation, what if something comes along in five years, seven years, whatever that time period is, it costs $100,000 or it costs a million or whatever, but it's so much better than this free system that's available. But we have mandated that we use the free system. I think that's something that a future legislature could address,
but, again, that's one of the reasons we added the language in the amendment this morning
was to say that if, for whatever reason, things do change down the road, ACIC, the... That's fine. You've already described it once. Thanks. ...would have the ability to...its hands are not tied. Right. Right. Okay. All right. Members, any other questions? I'm sorry.
Representative Hammer, I had you first. Now I'll get to you, Representative Boyd. Thank you, sir. Would you
speak, I'm looking at the map, and it says cost $3,000 per year and the savings free.
How are we going to save the $300,000? And that sounds like maybe a simplistic question, but what are we paying the $300,000 for now that we're going to be saving it? It's a contract of the company that currently provides the system. Okay, and is it going to jeopardize any other areas that are covered under that contract? Is that whole $300,000 directly applied against just this one area that's currently covered under the contract,
or is $300,000 a true representation, or is it a portion thereof? To
my knowledge, that is a true representation. It won't affect any other system. Okay, so by what
we're doing, it's not going to jeopardize any other aspect that's currently covered under the contract? Not to my knowledge, no, sir. Okay, and I just want to put this out on the table. not to be offensive or anything, but I'd like to give you a chance to speak about it. It almost would seem that this bill creates an opportunity for a single source
as it is currently available out there now. So how does that not create the appearance of a monopoly? And would you speak to that and just kind of give me some relief on
that, please? I'd say that any company that is in the business of providing these systems is welcome to compete and offer its system to meet those requirements.
And what's the deadline under this bill that they would have to make that secondary proposal or have that prepared to offer by? I don't know
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I have just a few questions, if that's all right.
Let's start with one and then follow up, and we'll probably move on from there. They're all kind of related. All right, let's... But if I
get out of line, just tell me. Fair enough. Representative Blading, I know you already answered this, but remind me. How long was the previous contract in place? Seven years. Seven years. Okay. And when did it expire? February 4th. Okay. So we've had a contract in place which might have kept us from switching companies?
I believe we've had the flexibility to change systems prior to this time. Okay. But there was a
contract? There was a contract. Okay. Okay. Since in that last seven years, do you know how much pseudo-ephedrine lab busts have decreased? Do you have that information? I don't have that figure in front of me, no. Would you be surprised to hear that they decreased significantly despite not crossing state lines? I would not be, and I would imagine it would
have gone down further had we been able to share data with surrounding states.
Has leads on labs, to your knowledge, ever asked to communicate with the InPlex system?
I believe the companies did have discussions some years back, but I do not have intimate knowledge of those conversations So you
don't know if it's true that they did ask and Inflex basically said we don't want to share data with you I'm probably
not the best one to answer that question I'm going
to let Thank you, Representative Boyd. We're going to move on and we'll come back to you if we need to. Representative Wardlaw you had a question? I thought
you'd like Well, ask that question then. Representative Letting, thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Letting, could you ask your witness
to answer that question that Representative Boyd just asked? Yes. To the representative and to that question, thank you very much for the opportunity. What happened a couple of years ago is that investigations were done as to whether or not the current Leads on Labs system could incorporate and could share data or vice versa with the
NPLEX system. The company in Louisville, Kentucky, APRES, did offer a patch to Leads on Labs and that was turned down. So what Leads on Labs wanted to do was acquire the data that the other company had and that's why that was turned down. They were offered an alternative that is a patch, which, in other words, Arkansas in transaction would have gone to Leeds on Labs in Texas, then gone to Louisville, to Apres, and then back to see whether it was a legitimate
transaction as far as the other states were concerned, would have happened in about three seconds, was my understanding. And that patch, that alternative was rejected by Leeds on Labs. Thank you. Can I get a
follow-up? Thank you. Those 278 law enforcement officers that you talked about earlier in Arkansas, are they able to see this data now that you have available for the other states?
Yes, Representative. Okay. Thank you. Okay. Seeing no other questions from the committee, we have Jay Winters to speak against.
Speaker 72
21:35
Thank you. My name is Jay Winters. I'm director of the Arkansas Crime Information Center. Thank you, Madam Chairman and members.
Let me first of all say that the Arkansas Crime Information's responsibility is to the law enforcement officers and the citizens of the state of Arkansas and to the governor. and not to either one of the companies that service these products. And if I may, let me give you a little history. In 2007, the Arkansas Crime Information Center was given the task by the General Assembly
to create an electronic logbook to monitor pseudo-ephedrine sales. At that time, APRES and Leads on Labs both bid on that project. Leads on Labs, in our opinion, had a better product and was lower cost. We awarded the bid to Leads on Labs.
APRES appealed that. We went back and re-bid it again, and Leads on Labs again won the bid. And so that's the product, and the bid was for seven years. So we've gone on. We started the process in November to get the RFP together for this, and if you want to throw the blame on anybody, I guess you'd throw it on me.
I did not understand what a cumbersome task it is to get an RFP together. And it went back and forth quite a bit. And we were trying to make sure that we covered everything that the law enforcement officers were sure they wanted. And at the same time, we were trying to be sure we covered the information. Because I had been approached by N-Plex and talked to before they considered their product superior.
And so we were trying to be sure we covered everything in our RFP that would be what would be best for law enforcement officers in the state of Arkansas. And so why it ended up taking until Tuesday, I just can't tell you that. I can tell you that we're on the phone back and forth with the folks over in procurement trying to get the RFP together, trying to be sure we did things right.
And I will say I think one of those reasons was because the reason the appeal occurred in 2008 was because there was some wording that caused some problems, and that's why we had to re-bid it. So I guess we were just trying to be sure we had everything covered. Anyway, the RFP is out. The RFP covers everything that is in this bill. My main objection to the bill is I assure you I am not trying to spend states' money.
In fact, I think I probably look like the director of the year if I can do something and save the state $300,000 a year. but at the same time free is not always the best product and that's why for the RFP we have asked for proposals we are going to go over those proposals and so you know that our process is that we are going to have a member of the pharmacy board a member of the Arkansas state police a member of the sheriff's association a member of the chief's association and then my staff member
that oversees the electronic logbook. That five-member panel will review both of these RFPs and make sure they meet all the qualifications in the RFPs. Then we will bring them in for a demo and make sure that they can show us that they do what they say they can do. And while we don't specifically say it's got to be free, one of our grading points is the cost. So I can assure this committee, and I can assure anybody,
if both companies provide the same service, then obviously the free is better. My problem is this says it has to be free. What if tomorrow they decide they don't want to pay this anymore? I understand they've been doing it for a long time and probably will continue to do it. but my two objections to the cost is that it may not always be free and it may not always be the best product. So I think the RFP is the best choice, the simplest choice.
And for those reasons, that's why I would prefer to just let us do the RFP, let us do it that way. We will make sure that we get the best product for the state. I can tell you, you know, when they were up here talking, it sounded like the Crime Information Center has kind of been sitting on our thumbs for the last seven years. We have a product. Law enforcement does like the product.
In fact, I've been the director for three years at the Crime Information Center. When I first came here, the first question I asked the staff there and then went to law enforcement officials and said, somebody's going to ask me why we're paying $300,000 a year for a product when there's another one out there that's free. Explain to me why. And law enforcement was able to convince me at that time they felt like Leeds On Labs was a good product, was the proper product.
They were happy with it. The, I think Representative Boyd may have been the one that mentioned it, but just as a quick example, labs, our labs went from, in 2010 there were 814 labs. In 2012, there were 100 labs. This is from DEA Statistics, Department of Drug Enforcement Administration Statistics.
So I think you can see we've got a good product out there. I'm not saying that N-Plex is better or worse. What I'm saying is we have a process to determine that, and if N-Plex is better, if they are what they have told this committee, I have no question in my mind they will win that bid. But just because it's free, I don't think that's the answer. And I don't think we should bind our state with something like that.
So if there is a problem with that funding, we cut ourselves out of anything. And, again, you only meet every two years. So I'd be happy to answer any questions. Mr. Winters,
you've been here three years. Do you know or has this proposal been changed on the two issues that you might have heard me ask earlier about accepting transactions from other states and being able to send Arkansas transactions. Do you know if that was in the proposal seven years ago? Was that a requirement? It was not. Okay, but it is going to be in this one. It
Speaker 72
29:27
that, you know, there's always two sides of the story and somewhere in the middle is kind of the end. I was a part of the conversations two years ago when Representative Malone was going to run a bill that required states to share the information. And the email that I got said that we are prohibited by state law
in all 26 in-plex states from releasing the data from the in-plex system except for specifically legislated data feeds performed in batches batches once each day to six states or by court order. This is not a matter of choice. It is simply and irrefutably the law in all inplex states. Now, one of our specific things is, and I don't know who made this law, and it doesn't really matter in the other states, but I can assure you law enforcement didn't make the law. It does not help anybody for that law,
for that information to be held so I contacted Tennessee which is an n-plex state but they required that that information belongs to the state of Tennessee not to n-plex and we are currently sharing information with the state of Tennessee and they are they're working leads on labs will share now I I suspect we can argue back and forth about who will share with who,
but I know that we can and do share with the state of Tennessee. So the capability is there. We cannot make other states share, but the capability is there, and we are currently doing that with the state of Tennessee now. We have some questions if
you'd like to take those. Representative Sullivan, you're first in the queue, sir. I
think there's an amendment proposed to the bill does that
address some of your questions or concerns not
Speaker 72
31:48
but I'll promise you whoever's got the bid if I jump up and say I think we ought to change it the room will fill up again I guess maybe I
need to be a little bit more specific. I thought to address the question of if funding goes away, that the system would revert back to the current system.
So to the question of this is a we're putting the state at risk based upon a funding stream that's not secured, then if that secured funding stream goes away, I thought the amendment then allowed for the system to revert back to current standard. true but it does not give us the
Speaker 72
32:26
option if we find if there is a better system out there and there may not be but if there is a better system out there that might cost maybe not cost three hundred thousand i don't i don't have any idea what the bids are going to be right now although
implexus says their bids is going to be zero so i'm kind of counting on that now but But if there is a better system out there that costs a little bit, that's certainly something we'd like the option to look at anyway. It may not be feasible, but I think it's something we should be able to look at. This bill would stop us from doing that. Okay. Thank you, Mr.
Chair. Representative Love, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Sir, what is your name at the end of the table again? Jay Winters. Mr. Winters. All right. Mr. Winters, I've heard some ancillary talk about this bill, but can you tell me what's the difference? Can you articulate what's the difference between leads on lab and the Implex product? And I mean, the pros and cons, because that's what I'm trying to get familiar with. What makes one product better or worse? But just can you articulate the differences between the products so that I have a better understanding?
Speaker 72
33:46
Well, honestly, sir, at this point, I can't tell you that because that's what we're wanting with our request for proposal is to see what they can both do. On paper, it appears that both of them can do the same thing. Again, the argument would be that Leeds-On Labs cannot share across state line. And again, they do
Speaker 70
34:11
have the ability, but it is not being done by state law or for whatever purpose.
Speaker 72
34:21
But to answer your question, I think from a law enforcement standpoint, they are certainly interested in being able to share across state lines.
Speaker 70
34:32
But so I think without question the evidence would show that N-Plex has all the surrounding states so they're sharing with each other so there certainly shouldn't be a problem there.
Now, is that not a benefit to law enforcement that a product is sharing across state lines versus, I guess, waiting on the option to share across state lines?
Certainly. Okay. Well, then I guess I'm baffled by your testimony because you're saying that you're testifying against Inplex. however you just stated that it would be a benefit so no no sir no sir I apologize if I
this this doesn't specify in place he's not testifying as a company's just as tying against this well here the statue
well mr. chairman I guess this is what I'm saying I hear
inplex and I hear leads on laughs so those are the
only two right right right right and then that's all the two companies that we know of I mean that's come to the table but this really doesn't specify who gets the bid
it It just says they have to be free. Okay. I will take that from the chair. But, I mean, I guess what I was saying is that that's all I'm hearing. So I'm just, the assumption is it's going
to be IMPLEX. And that's a fair, too, but also I don't want this committee to be making, we're not here to decide what company gets this bid. We're just here to decide how we go about asking for the bid.
Payton. You're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Winters, I'll try to get to the point, but I think we're seeing the benefits of a competitive bid process and the RFP process. And so your testimony is that this legislation would lock us into guidelines
that you feel would restrict your ability in other areas to require certain things. And one of my biggest questions is about the database itself. I mean, we're collecting data on Arkansans and personal information and where that's housed and who owns it and who controls it. You mentioned something about Tennessee, and they were able to negotiate with N-Plex a concession about their database.
Correct. So do you feel like if this legislation passes, you'd have less leverage to negotiate some of those
Speaker 72
37:16
concerns? Certainly, because one of our qualifications in our request for proposal is that the data collected belongs to the state of Arkansas, not to NPLEX or any other group. If I
could have one short follow-up. Yes, sir. Thank you. I asked this to Representative Letting,
whether or not he had any confidence that the ACIC would accept the lowest bid. Right now, do you feel that you are completely open-minded to compare the two companies and consider their bids and their response to your RFP? Yes, sir. Very much so. Okay. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Yes,
sir. Representative Sullivan, we're back to you for another question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. You mentioned in your testimony that you were unaware
how long it took to put the RFP together.
Yes, sir. And that's why it's late. But we knew seven years ago when
the deadline was due. That's correct. Yes, sir. Thank you. Members, any further questions? I'm going to go with
Representative Womack first and Representative Hammer after that. Hey, thank you. I may have missed this, and if I did, I apologize. Mr. Winters, would you mind telling me why you believe it's important for Arkansas to
Speaker 72
38:44
if things were to change later on, we would want the same option that was testified earlier.
If, for instance, something happened and our surrounding states chose to go with another route, we want to be able to share that information back and forth because it is important to have that. Thank you.
Representative Hammer, you say you have a question for Representative Letting? Okay. Appropriate time. Any further questions for Mr. Winters? Seeing none, thank you, Mr. Winters, for your testimony. And next up is Captain Joe Baker,
who also will be speaking against this bill. If you would, make sure that green light is on. Pull the mic up close, introduce yourself. You're recognized
Speaker 106
39:36
for testimony. Good morning. Captain Baker from the West Memphis Police Department, West Memphis, Arkansas. And yes, sir, and you want to speak against this bill? Yes, sir. We just, law enforcement on our side of
Speaker 108
39:51
the state, the agencies I've spoken with,
and I know the detectives at my department, we feel it's important for ACIC to be able to at least have the option to choose the best provider for this service without being locked into only only one you know option for the service provider it's I think it kind of limits what law enforcement can have access to if there's no you know if there's no options other than the one option now which would be in Plex we've used leads
on labs for seven years now and my detectives have had great success with it. I personally had great success with it. I was assigned to the Narcotics Division for eight years and it's been a good product for us during that time. We are able to see Tennessee's data. They do share data with us. Being a border state we do have lots of our residents going across into Tennessee and we can
track and monitor their purchases you know over in the Memphis area so just those are a couple of our our concerns and issues we saw
on the bill members any questions for Captain Baker all right seeing none thank you for the testimony, sir. Thank you. Representative Letting, you want to close for a bill. Generally, we don't do
questions during closing, but we do have a question for you if you'd like to
accept one. I will do my best, Mr. Chair. Representative Hammer, you're recognized. Thank you. Representative Letting, on the bill on page two, I think it is, and it's at the top, Line 1C, it says the real-time electronic law book shall be able to communicate in real-time with similar systems operated in other states and similar systems containing information from more than one state.
I just need interpretation on that and make sure, am I reading it right? It sounds like what's going to be required is that the system that we would go to, all it would have to do is be able to communicate with one state. And I'm wondering if that was the intent or if the requirement should be that it at least has to be maybe all states touching our borders because it seems like all anybody would have to do is say, well, we can communicate with Louisiana and we fulfill the obligation. Is that the intent of that, or can you explain that?
That's certainly not the intent. And as I said, the competing system communicates with, I believe, 30 other states. So that's certainly not the intent. That's not what we're
trying to do there. But the way it's written, would that be a minimum requirement that whoever gets the bid would just have to be able to communicate with one other state, and they would have fulfilled the requirements that's covered under this law? I don't read it that way. Okay. All right. Thank you.
Representative McGee, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Lane,
Speaker 113
43:12
just one short question. I've sat and listened to this testimony about a free system and putting in a statute to be free. Who pays for it if it's free? Somebody pays for it. I mean, I don't know. I don't quite understand. Somewhere down the line that that process has to be paid for. That would
be true. Industry currently pays for it because they have a responsibility, and acknowledge that responsibility of making sure that their product is not used
Speaker 113
43:41
in ways that it's not intended to be used. The pharmaceutical industry then is who funds the whatever it is, the Netplex program? Correct. Okay. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
And your bill would not require that Netplex get this. It would be anyone who offers this
for free. Again, yes, absolutely correct. And to address some of the data concerns, some of the other systems that are out there, the system is talking to other states. So data sharing is really kind of a moot point. Okay. And I really feel that this is a simple issue.
I think a lot of politics and personalities have come into play. I really think it's a very simple decision. It's just about making sure that the state is using the best tool available to make sure that it's protecting its citizens. And to address some of Director Winner's concerns, the amendment that we adopted at the very beginning of the meeting was to make sure that in the event things do go south, ACIC would have the flexibility to find another system. Representative
Letting, would you accept one more question? And I'll cut it off after one more if that's okay? Why not?
Okay. Representative Lundstrom? I understand the word free, but ultimately this is going to be passed on to the consumer one way or another. This will be worked into the price of the cost of the
drug, correct? I wouldn't want to speak for the pharmaceutical companies, how
they... Well, it's not a charity. They're offering a good product. But
again, they're doing so to make sure that their product is used the way they
intend it to be used. Okay. All right, Representative Letting, are you officially closed for this? I would say that if this bill
really falls in line with the requirements of the RFP, I'm just not sure why there would be opposition, but
I would appreciate a good vote. Thank you. Members, you've heard an explanation. What's the will of this committee? Representative Sullivan, you make a motion do pass. As amended, as amended twice. okay we have a motion do pass as amended twice do we have any discussion of the motion seeing no discussion of the motion all in favor say aye all opposed
say no chair rules nose have it thank you representative letting now we have two hands
Speaker 120
46:11
the roll mr. price okay representative Sullivan representative Henderson
Representative Boyd, Representative Bentley, Representative Lundstrom, Representative Payton? No. Representative Fite? No. Representative Bragg? Yes. Representative Womack? Yes. Representative
Representative Miller? Yes. Representative McGee? No. Representative Ritchie? Yes. Representative Overby? Yes. Representative Meeks? Yes. Representative Branscombe? Yes. Representative Hammer? Yes. Representative Wardlaw?
Representative Love? Yes. Vice Chair Ferguson? Chair Link? No. Oh, not voting. Okay. 1, 2,
Representative Letting, your bill has passed 12 VAs, 7 nays, and 1 non-voting. And also, congratulations, the first one I missed on voice call yet. Thank you, Mr. Chair, Madam
Chair, and committee. Yes, sir. All right, Representative
Baltz in here. I think you're next up, aren't you? Representative Valetti, you did not want to run any of your other bills today, right? Okay. But you're going to leave them active. We're not putting them deferred yet. Okay. Very good.
And also, I took him out of order over you, Representative Miller. You had no intention of running your bill today. Would you like to move that to deferred? We will move that to deferred. Thank you for that. That does make you up next, Representative Balch, you're recognized to introduce your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair and committee. Do you have an amendment? We do have an amendment, yes. There is an amendment on the tablet, members. That's House Bill 1133.
members I'm trying to make sure we're all looking at the right thing here we do have one amendment
so that okay so I see that that that'd be in our tablets can say MGF 111 I think is what we push to see that amendment yeah that's right it should say from an accredited college university approved by the Department of Health under the everybody got that okay you like to explain your amendment represent balls it's basically just
what it says to have this licensure you have to be accredited from have to go to an
accredited college or university approved by the Department of Health.
All right. The other amendment is engrossed in the bill. I just got that explanation. This is the only amendment that we're looking at today. Members, any questions on the amendment? Seeing none, will the committee as do pass? And all those in favor, aye? Any opposed? All right. Well, no, no. The amendment is... I'm sorry. We accepted the amendment. I said do pass. We accepted the amendment, and I'll get this straight here in a minute.
All right, Representative Balch, you are
recognized. Introduce your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair and Committee. I'd like to introduce Mr. Kelly and Mr. Cantrell here with me also today to help me with this bill. This is a licensure of a community paramedic bill. What it does basically is helps folks that kind of fall through the cracks that are not on home health and need a little bit of assistance, to put it kind of in a nutshell.
It's a licensure-type situation where they can be a community paramedic rather than just a regular paramedic or something like that. And I'll take any questions or whatever you'd like. Representative Hammer, you're recognized for a question.
Baltz or any of your witnesses sitting down there, can you tell me about the additional training that's going to be required for this additional licensure, please?
Yes, sir. Hello, Mr. Chairman, members of the committee. Thank you. My name is Ken Kelly. I am a government affairs chair for the Arkansas Ambulance Association and a 30-year paramedic here in the state of Arkansas. This bill primarily is a scope of practice change, which takes existing paramedics that have received more than 1,200 hours from accredited institutions in the state, expands their knowledge into some more, I guess, as Representative Ball said, gap-filling assessments. We go out.
Typically, emergency medical services respond as part of the public safety net for emergencies, and we're, in the past, have primarily been a treat-and-transport type of health care model. We now see the role that paramedics can play in seeing routine patients, providing assessments and monitoring of critical health conditions, and we're able to better integrate those patients into our existing health care systems. The additional training that's required for a community paramedic is specified in the bill as a 300-hour course.
This is based on a national standard curriculum. There are many states that operate community paramedic programs or mobile integrated health care systems that take paramedics with that existing public safety knowledge and they expand their knowledge to include mental and social health services, health care monitoring, and integration. A lot of times what we see on the 911 responses are it's not that people do not need help, it's just they don't know the appropriate help that they need. So community paramedics that are already responding to many of these patients
will receive additional education that will help integrate them to the appropriate levels of health care without creating a duplication of services. The 300-hour course would be offered as amended today through our accredited programs in the state. Currently, all emergency medical services programs at the advanced level, and that would include advanced EMT and paramedic, must be offered through an accredited program in the state. We have 16 accredited programs, most of those offered through our community college and university systems.
this would also be a requirement that they would go through an accredited program. Accreditation following the national standard curriculum would be expected in any rules and regs that we would promulgate with regards to community paramedicine. Follow up, please. Yes, sir.
As one who's worked as a medic on the ambulance before, specifically here in Little Rock, and listening to the medics in the area where I work, One of the things I hear them talk about is they don't have enough time to do what they're doing now
and the demands that are on the ambulance services now, so I'm just wondering how adding this extra layer on them is going to impact their workload and the shifts that they're required to work, and is that going to create a demand on ambulance services to have to increase staff and equipment? Could you address that, please? Yes, in many
ways we feel that from the public safety standpoint, this will actually relieve some of the stressors for those EMTs and paramedics that are responding as part of the 911 system or the emergency response system.
Many of the calls that they respond to now at wee hours of the morning in inclement weather are for just patients that need an assessment, need some, I guess, hand-holding, some guidance about the appropriate health care. And as they access the health care system today, usually that results in a 911 emergency response, a trip to the emergency room, and often they beat us out of the emergency room before we can complete our paperwork, only to find out that they needed to better integrate with a primary care physician or an urgent care center or home health services or hospice services.
So in many ways, what we're doing today with a traditional 911 response system would be relieved by a community paramedic filling that role for that particular type of response. So some systems are looking at this for a 911 reduction model, and the stressors that we have on the public safety system. So I think it will be very dependent in the community, how they set up their community paramedic program, but that is one of the benefits of having community paramedics versus doing that same service with the higher-priced, overtaxed 911 system now.
Thank you, Representative Hammer. I want to, and Mr. Kelly's doing a great job of addressing this, but sometimes he knows more than we know kind of I want to talk briefly because this kind of came from a program in my area in Baxter County and what's happening is so many people go home maybe after a minor surgery that Medicaid paid for and they're at home by themselves, they get scared two days later, they're not sure what's happening, their body feels a little weird or something and the only
thing they know to do is call 911 and so once that ambulance comes there, picks them up and takes them to the hospital that hospital now had a readmittance and in the those in the medicaid world and mr seal who could address this better but although i'm not going to ask him to end the table but he and i have talked about this numerous times in the medicaid world that's once you have a readmittance that means that you are not going to get paid you i mean you're it's going to ding you for a lot of dollars so mountain home figured out if they send their ambulance drivers around just as a follow-up when they're not on emergency calls or not getting themselves out of the area
The ambulance drivers go and they knock on the door of Joe or whoever got out of surgery a few days earlier and said, hey, how are you feeling today? Are you taking your medicine? Do you understand your medicine? Let's check your blood pressure. Let's see if everything's okay. And they knocked down I forget how many million dollars they saved in the first year of the program by not having the readmittances. And that's what this is all about is making it to where the scope of practice would change so that these ambulance drivers can do that. they did it under a pilot program but normally ambulance drivers
cannot go out and check your blood pressure and so on and so forth and so that's really what this is that's the basics in the layman's term that I can explain it as to what we're trying to do or what Representative Ball is trying to do with this bill
okay so Representative Sullivan Representative Love you're recognized for a question Thank you Mr. Chair and at the basic look of the bill I don't have any problems with it however I am concerned with one of your amendments The last amendment that you made stated you deleted line 9. We're on page 3.
You deleted line 9, and then you replaced it with from an accredited college or university approved by the Department of Health. Why was that change
necessary? Being that this level of education has not been offered in the state, or at least it's not offered broadly, I think UAMS has a pilot community paramedic education program. In our normal EMS rules and regulations, all advanced training currently for EMTs and paramedics must be completed by an accredited institution.
Normally that is handled through rules and regs, but in visiting with some of our key stakeholders, because this does create an integration with home health, hospice, mental health services, They wanted some assurances that the community paramedic program being the highest tier of education would be from an accredited institution. So we agree with the amendment that we can engross it into the bill. It's just to assure quality education, meeting the national standard curriculum.
Follow up, Mr. Chair. Yes, sir. So are we putting in a law that just say a freestanding institute could not come along and set up and offer accredited training? I mean, if we make this statutory, then what we're saying is that just say, for instance, if there's another agency in the state that offers some sort of training like this, that they could not come in because they're not part of the U of A system or the UCA system because you're saying that you're relegating it to an accredited college program.
I guess that's my kind of stuck with me is that we're saying it has to be a two- or four-year institution, a college institution, when it could be that someone from out of state could come and offer the same training absent a two- or four-year college. And I guess that's my big, my whole thing about that. Well, I'm not familiar with the Department
of Higher Education rules and regs as far as accreditation for the institutions,
but the program being a national standard curriculum would be offered through an accredited institution. Most of those are community colleges or universities as we know them today, but I don't think I'm versed enough to answer the question about a freestanding entity that would offer accredited education. Representative Love,
and I hate talking too much from the chair but I've been involved with Representative Vaults heavily on this and the conversation happened yesterday with some of the higher ed
people that they said, look, this thing would allow anybody to hang a shingle and start teaching this and we're concerned about that which we wanted to, I think Mr. Kelly would say, we wanted to leave it open that's why that was originally written the way it was so that we could get this training easily But even at UAMS, which is probably arguably the most expensive place you could go, this training is going to be about $1,200. So it's not going to be cost prohibitive even at the most expensive place. But there was concern about just hanging a shingle, and all of a sudden we've got a whole plethora of ambulance drivers
that may not be trained as to accredited like we want. And that's why Representative Ball has agreed to make that amendment just to ease that. I think in two years, Representative Ball, because this is a pilot program, we're going to see this legislation open back up and we're also going to see that we can promulgate more rules but it's kind of one of those things where let's be careful to start with and not screw things up because it is a pilot program it was I was fortunate to go to Atlanta this year and on a health
seminar and they were talking about this very pilot program on a national basis it's a pretty big deal it's a good deal so we want to be careful not open it up too much Representative Love. I'm sorry I'm talking too much from the chair, but I've kind of been
Mr. Chair. Thank you, Mr. Walts. Representative Fite, you're recognized
for a question. Yes, thank you, Mr. Chair. My question is it sounds wonderful, but why is an ambulance driver going out to check on people? Why is it not a CNA or something from the hospital?
I'm going to defer that question to Mr. Cantrell, who has a functioning community paramedic program, and I think he can give you some background on the types of patients and how they get referrals to their system. Thank
you, Mr. Chair, for letting us speak. We actually... I'm sorry, if you would introduce your full name and what you do for us. My
Speaker 151
1:03:06
name is Gerald Cantrell. I'm an RN paramedic from Baxter Regional Medical Center in Mountain Home, the pilot program that Mr. Link was speaking of.
We actually had a unique experience. We're a hospital-based ambulance service in Mountain Home. We had a unique experience of realizing two years ago that our hospital was fitting in that mold of a lot of other facilities in the state of Arkansas where they were seeing significant penalties because of some CMS rules and regulations related to readmissions primarily. We started actually looking at patients that we were seeing, Mr. Kelly mentioned, patients that were high-end users of 911 services.
Also, those same patients were coming to the emergency room by ambulance, utilizing the ambulance regularly. um medicare cms actually had four criteria four classifications of patients that were challenging hospitals to help prevent them from coming back to the hospital a lot of those patients have congestive heart failure a lot of them have chronic obstructive pulmonary disease breathing problems, pneumonia, and also acute heart problems. So what we identified from our standpoint was we
had a unique opportunity in the hospital to visit with those patients, knowing that our paramedics were at a skill level where they understood chronic disease management, probably a little bit better than maybe just an aide or an orderly or somebody that would go out and visit those individuals. In a lot of instances when we visit those patients in their home they're having what we would consider critical events occurring that's going to that would require them to come back to
the hospital in a real short period of time if we weren't able to help manage their health in the home. In a lot of those instances patients are requiring breathing treatments, they're requiring other levels of skill sets that our paramedics already have. So we visit those individuals, we look at their medicines, and we say, what can we do to help you manage your health in your home for an extended period of time? Usually that extended period of time is 30 days or greater. Most of our patients are enrolled in the program for about 90 days.
And we visit those patients regularly over that period of time, helping them not only improve their health, but we begin the process of really start helping them deal with issues related to their medications, issues related to maybe diet and things of that nature. So we really start extending ourselves beyond the simple, let me take your blood pressure, let me listen to your chest and see what your lungs are doing, and let me do some other things.
We really nail down and work with those patients to really help them identify triggers that might create problems for them. A pneumonia patient is an example. If they start having fever and start having issues that are maybe going to put them on that track going back to the emergency room if somebody doesn't help them manage that, we really start helping them identify triggers in their health that are going to create problems and we really direct them on how not only to manage those things, but we have direct contact
with their physicians. We reach out to their physicians and say, hey, this patient's having some issues. Can I get them back into your office in the next day or so before they go back to the emergency room so we believe there's some problems going on? So that's the advantage that we saw that we had to begin with was our paramedics were already trained at a pretty high skill level. We took and provided them another 300 or 400 hours of training to get past that issue of concern
about chronic disease management, and then we started working with those patients to deal with their health in a much different way than maybe they've ever had an opportunity. So I think that's where the program went from the beginning, and we want to, and we've been able to continue to grow that day after day after day to improve those patients' health. We've seen about 300 and probably 80 patients so far have a high success rate in helping them keep at home rather than coming back to the hospital, and that's where we see value in the program regularly, so.
Baltz? Yes, so I just want to kind of stress that we are not trying to knock home health out of anything or any of those other entities that provide care for these folks. These are the ones that don't qualify for those type situations, and these are the ones that are kind of like we said falling through the cracks that we'd like to try to help. Representative Sullivan,
you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
You talked about the recoupments that hospitals were
facing for readmits. So I'm assuming that the payment for this service now, when we administer that, does that fall within the episodic calculation when they're paying for that? Is that how it's reimbursed by the hospital? Yes, it's my understanding
that that is one of the components of the episodic care penalties that are currently imposed by CMS. There will be a variety of funding mechanisms for community paramedic programs.
Some communities that already subsidize their 911 and EMS system may subsidize community paramedics. There are opportunities to work with hospitals and health care systems that are facing the episodic care and penalty issues. There are other programs around the state that will partner with health plans to monitor just their patient population, may just be beneficiaries of a certain health plan. And then there are certainly grant and demonstration project funds that are available from the federal government that can also help manage some of these programs.
But the biggest thing that we have seen in most of the states with regards to hospitals is the episodic care, and they've expanded that list. Gerald mentioned the four major. That's now been expanded to six diagnoses that fall into that with the possibility of going as high as maybe 11 types of patients.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Yes, sir. Representative Hammer, you're recognized for
your question. Thank you. So when the community paramedic goes out to see the patient, there is an extra charge for that, or is it absorbed by the hospital?
Speaker 151
1:09:59
Currently, because of the structure of EMS in Arkansas and also other legislation, the service we provide actually is an extension through the hospital. It's a free service that we're offering to our residents. We do not bill for that service. From a hospital's perspective, the benefits that are gained through the readmission avoidance and also some of those issues where we have repeat visitors or repeat callers calling 911,
as we're able to manage those individuals and redirect those, there's an indirect cost savings to the hospital for that. So right now the service we provide is free. the hospital benefits from the readmission avoidance and some of those penalties on the backside so there
already is a cost savings to the hospital that that whether they receive a additional payment for this or not the hospital's realizing a cost savings by doing this currently that's correct sir okay um what if you're not a hospital-based ambulance service that you you know
like MEMS or some of the other ambulance services around the state that don't have that direct connection, what's the benefit to them and what's the disadvantage to them?
That will very much be determined by the local policies that are set up that establish the community paramedic program. And, again, I'll just reference you to the current, I guess, models around the nation that we see, and that is partnering through health plans, grant and demonstration project funding, as well as some internal cost mechanisms.
If they're reducing the amount of burden on the 911 side, they may shift some of those budget dollars to fund the community paramedic positions. But it will very much vary. Nearly every ambulance service, save the few volunteer services that we may still have that do not bill, most of your current ambulance services are funded through fee for transport. That model, under some of the Affordable Care Act incentives, is rapidly moving to a pay-for-performance model. So the days of fee-for-service probably are getting numbered in many respects.
So the community paramedic programs, likewise, may be funded by communities and systems through a pay-for-performance mechanism. So there will be a
cost. Either way, there's going to be a cost for this program, either in a pro-run charge or the areas that are going to choose to implement this are going to have to absorb that cost while the hospitals receive a savings through decreased visits to the ER. Is that a fair statement? That is a fair statement, and whether they
would share in any of those savings and benefits to fund the program would very much be a local decision.
Okay. Representative Hammer? I've got one other question. That was four. Yes, sir. But the chairman
really wants this bill to go through, I know. There is no one
Speaker 96
1:13:14
That's A and B. I can tell he's a former medic because he's going through a branch protocol. Did you
say this is currently being done in the state now?
We have the one pilot project that was a cooperative between UAMS providing the community paramedic education program and Baxter Regional Medical Center stood up their demonstration project, I guess, close to 18 months ago, maybe two years ago. And this is relatively new in the state. It's been going on in all of our neighboring states and across the country. The concept of community paramedicine dates back to 1990s when we first saw some of the, particularly the rural wilderness states that were using community paramedics to expand vital health services in underserved areas.
Then in the late 90s, early 2000s, we saw it come to the major metropolitan centers that their 911 systems were overtaxed. So over the past two decades, I think we have seen a blending of many different types of models that now have locked into the valuable services that we can provide to the citizens of Arkansas based on our diverse health care services available. We have underserved areas, we have metropolitan areas, and we have day-to-day areas that we think the paramedics that we currently have on the streets will be of a benefit to the citizens of Arkansas.
Without this bill, then, are you going to have to stop that because you'll be operating outside your scope of practice if this bill does not go through, and therefore that, and I don't know how that model program got set up to operate and it not be functioning outside the law of scope of practice currently that you got that exception. So without this law, is it going to stop all of that because currently it sounds like operating outside of scope of practice without this bill going through? Well,
currently because they're not charging a fee for service
and they are still operating within the limited protocols of an existing paramedic. They are operating within the scope of practice. Now, if they were to want to expand that scope of practice to provide some other services, that's why we need this legislation that's enabling legislation for community paramedics. So now they are calling themselves a community paramedic program, and they are putting the pieces in place, but they are using existing scope of practice paramedics, licensed paramedics to perform some limited services, but they would like to see
an expansion of those services with some additional protocol.
I remember seeing no further questions. We have no one signed up to speak for or against this, which is attributed to the good work of Representative Balz of solving all those problems. Representative Womack, you
Mr. Chair. I'm still not exactly clear I think you may have just confused me a little bit without the pilot program
you can still do the bulk of this and stay within your scope of
practice we can do the scope of practice for a paramedic right now is basically assessment and then course certain protocols for treating and transporting the chronic diseases for example a congestive heart failure patient we have protocol in place as a paramedic that would allow us to do certain assessments and certain basic interventions but to manage that patient for an extended period of
time and that would be on a per transport or per response basis the community paramedic program would give additional protocols or skill sets that the paramedic could manage that same patient for an extended period of time instead of it being a per-call 9-1-1 type response basis. So it would expand the ability to care for that population for a longer period of time. Okay, thank you.
Seeing no further questions, Representative Overby, you're recognized.
Motion do pass as amended. All right, we have a motion for Representative Overby. Do pass as amended. Do we have any discussion on that motion? Seeing none, all in favor say aye Aye Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative Waltz Your bill is passed Thank you, Mr. Chair and committee A little bit of calendar management I don't think we have anyone else to hear today I don't see anyone else in the room A little bit of calendar management Let me get back here for a second Representative Fite, do you want to move your bill to deferred?
It is to amend various sections of the law regarding hearing instrument dispensers All right, we'll move 1343 to deferred. Representative Ferguson, you're going to hear your bill next week, I guess, 1162. We'll find out from some others if they'll move to deferred. Representative McGee, what about your 1120? You want to leave that active or deferred? We'll leave that active. Representative Boyd, active or deferred? Active. Active, both of them? Both of them.
Okay. Representative Fite, that's a brand-new bill there. Okay, we're going to set a special order of business without objection, special order of business next Tuesday for 1067. That's Representative Collins' bill on water quality. He's got witnesses coming from northwest Arkansas, so we would like to set that for next Tuesday without objection. We'll do that. Okay. And you just moved yours to active, Representative Meeks, or you just filed that. Okay. I think that's all the calendar management we have. And you will notice there are a couple bills that came off of deferred to active,
and that was Representative Murdoch and Representative Collins. Seeing no further business, we're adjourned.
Agenda
HB1292
HB1133
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Chair
Unverified
Representative Kim Hammer
Unverified
Representative John Payton
Unverified
Speaker 23
Speaker 29
Kevin Kraushaar
Unverified
Speaker 36
Representative Justin Boyd
Unverified
Representative Jeff Wardlaw
Unverified
Jay Winters
Unverified
Speaker 72
Speaker 70
Representative Dan Sullivan
Unverified
Frederick Love
Unverified
Representative Richard Womack
Unverified
Speaker 106
Speaker 108
Speaker 113
Representative Robin Lundstrum
Unverified
Speaker 119
Speaker 120
Speaker 127
Speaker 18
Representative Scott Baltz Chair
Unverified
Ken Kelly
Unverified
Speaker 114
Representative Lanny Fite
Unverified
Gerald Cantrell
Unverified
Speaker 151
Speaker 96
Speaker 13