Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House Insurance and Commerce Committee

February 27, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (3)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
SB181 · 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…right, Representative Lemons, you're recognized to present Senate Bill 181. Representative Lemons, you're recognized. Thank you, sir.…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB182 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB182”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1455 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1455”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 15, 2026
All right, Representative Lemons, you're recognized to present Senate Bill 181. Representative Lemons, you're recognized. Thank you, sir. You have
▶ Play
before you today, in fact, I'm sorry, it's somewhere in my pad here, but it is Senate Bill 181, Regulation of Foundation Repair Contracts. Throughout the state of Arkansas, we have some very unique soil characteristics. It varies from county to county, but more ironically, it varies from lot to lot within a subdivision. Cabot is noted for having what is called expensive clays. Thank you. You'll have one house on one lot that is perfectly fine. The one next to it will have some type of failure within the foundation within a short period of time. A lot of times when, usually when someone does have a foundation problem, they call the foundation company and they'll come out and they'll fix it. And they provide a warranty of anywhere from 5, 10, 20, or even sometimes a lifetime warranty. The problem we're running into is in a lot of cases, there are situations on the bottom of the warranty that says, as an example, from the time someone sells this house they have 5 days to transfer the warranty it's like a size 4 font on a contract that's about 10 pages long. What we would like to do with this bill is to make a warranty truly a warranty. It's the Consumer Protection Act and it will cause the warranty to actually stick with the house that it was intended for. And the way we're doing this is we're taking current owner and making that to define both current owner and future owners of the property. And I'd be glad to answer any questions you may
▶ Play
have. Representative Cozart, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. What is the length of a warranty on those? Do we have a time frame of anybody?
▶ Play
It varies from company to company. Company to company. Yes, there are foundation contracts that fit in the 210 spectrum of a house, and then you've got some that are 510. There's even some lifetime warranties. It depends on the company and whatever the original purchaser of the contract wants. Does the contract that the original owner gets, does it state that it is transferable? It depends on the company. In some cases, like I said a while ago, they'll say that it is transferable. In other cases, it will say you have five days from the date of purchase of this home to transfer it. Okay. Thank you.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Ferguson you're
▶ Play
recognized for a question and you may not know this do you know what the commercial language reads like for repair contracts
▶ Play
again it varies with each company you're talking about like for a commercial building as opposed to
▶ Play
a residential does a contract transfer with a commercial contract on a foundation I'm just curious for personal reasons. I'm not sure. I'm not sure. I guess
▶ Play
it would depend on the contract itself that was purchased. Read the size 4 font at the very bottom. Representative Murdoch, you're
▶ Play
recognized for a question. Thank you, Chairman.
▶ Play
To what Representative Ferguson was discussing, typically in construction, I mean in commercial construction, I'm currently doing a foundation repair project, just completed one, and an architect designs the project and they give you the specification of what you must do within that. So that's how it's defined as what happens. Now, your question was exactly what was the say your question again, Representative Ferguson. I'm sorry. You have a contract commercial. Do you still have that five-day rule for commercial No, no, that's totally different. And that's where I was going with my question to the representative, is this only applies to, as I read it, residential construction. And my concern would be, the remedy would be, I see the payment remedy, the penal is two times the cost, but go back up and make me understand where the problem, who defines the problem, how is the solution defined as how it should be fixed, so that we can make sure that we're addressing maybe where the real problem sometimes occurs, specifically in residential issues where there is not an architect that's usually hired to determine exactly what the problems are. So therefore, in this case, if I'm reading it correctly, the only litmus becomes whether it works or not. Now, if so, if it's not properly designed for a fix, then certainly this would be a problem for anyone to be willing to enter into a contract, a residential contract, such as this. Because I would be scared to just enter into this and say, well, I've got to pay two times whatever it takes to fix this, and I'm just coming here on good faith effort. There's no soil testing being done, no boring testing, no analysis of the concrete, no background. Brown. So can you help me with that a
▶ Play
little bit? I'll do my best. Let me kind of put this in the form of an example and maybe I can hopefully answer most if not all the questions. Let's say that a couple by the name of Bob and Sue Brown build a house. Six months into the house they start having a foundation failure and what I mean by foundation failure not to point to any one company but so you'll all know you've seen the O'Sham commercial where Snowlin Ryan's sitting on the couch with the family, and the crack in the wall is you could almost put your fist through it. Now, that is a full-blown foundation failure. The superficial cracks that you get in your brick, those are not foundation failures. What happens is Mr. and Mrs. Brown, they build this house. They have the problem. They have it fixed. They sell it to the next person. The next person needs to know that this repair had been done, and it should be disclosed in the closing documents that the repair was done. However, a lot of the foundation companies are putting a limitation on their contract. I mean, we all know that insurance companies actually make their money by finding a way to not pay a claim. And it's the same thing with any part of our industry. Now, as far as what you were talking about, who determines if it's a failure or not, what I have seen in the past, I've been around residential construction for 30 years. When someone does have an issue, they typically will contact a professional engineer, or more importantly, a professional geotechnical engineer, and they will come out and they'll look and they'll say, you have a problem or you don't have a problem. This is either real or it's superficial. It is then their responsibility to go to the contractor, and if the warranty has expired on the original construction, to then go and hire someone like Oshams or somebody like that to go and do the repair. So I'm unaware of any place or time in the past where someone has just filed a frivolous claim because they had a small crack in their brick. Typically, it is a failure, and they do have to get experts to come out and attest to it. So
▶ Play
my real concern would be if I build a house, and I've been doing it for a long time, If I build a house, according to the specifications as presented, the owner determines a lot of this, and I build it. He or she chose not to employ an architect or designer. They may buy stock plans. Stock plans don't deal with soil conditions. I enter into a contract, and I build that for them. It's their risk that they're taking to build on this particular soil. So soil conditions have so much to do with what you're talking about. Now, many times in residential construction, geotechs are not involved because they cost money, and people sometimes are trying to save money. In most commercial situations, the architect, as a part of his design team, he's going to have a geotech to make sure that that soil is suitable for the foundation. Because the foundation cracks at some point in time does not mean that the foundation contractor or the contractor who built that house was negligent at all. So I think that this bill would very possibly, unless there is some integrity put into it to make sure that the design originally has been properly presented and done and adhered to after it's been presented, then you can give that responsibility to the contractor or whomever for the culpability. But I think jumping to a conclusion because of failure, when the failure can come from other mitigating circumstances, that is not the fault of specifically the foundation contractor or the general contractor. It depends on how much responsibility and how it was designed. So I definitely understand this is a good consumer protection thought of what we're trying to do. I've seen, I've fixed, I've been a part of the oceans and the power lifts and all of those. I've dealt with all of them, you know, churches and residences. I've dealt with all of this. So that foundation is very important, and I think it's unfair if we put the responsibility on the foundation contractor or general contractor simply because three years later, six months later, it fails.
▶ Play
It may be someone else's responsibility. If I could, just a couple of points. I'm glad you brought them up because I'd forgotten to mention this. First, let's talk about concrete. Two things about concrete. It's going to get hard. It's going to crack. I don't care how good you are, concrete is going to crack. There's a big difference between a superficial crack and an outright failure. I think we agree with that. Totally. I think, though, that we may be talking apples and oranges. This pertains to most houses, of course, are not going to fail. This does not go back on the original contractor. What this is for is if the house fails and if a foundation company is brought out in year 5, 10, 15 of the house and makes the repair, we're just wanting their repair to be warranted, not the original construction,
▶ Play
just the repair. Representative Lemons, if I could ask a question, and just to make sure I understand, this is very limited in its scope. and its foundation repair contracts. This does not specify any changes to the contracts whatsoever. It merely gives the homeowner a venue to enforce existing contracts and future contracts. So a power lifter, whoever it might be, when they're writing their contracts, needs to deliver whatever they put in there and agree to. So let's just extend Representative Murdoch's example for a moment. Let's say that the original failure was due to poor match between the foundation design and the soil. PowerLift comes out and says, well, your foundation is cracked because this design is bad for this soil type. In order for me to fix it, I can't do my normal 1x fix, which costs 1x dollars. Because of all these things, I need to do these extra, and it's going to cost you 2x or 3x. But when I do that, I will now give you this warranty or whatever is part of the contract. So this would enable people to deal with exactly the kind of problems that he correctly points out.
▶ Play
Is that a fair assessment? That is very fair, yes. If I may continue, and I appreciate that,
▶ Play
Chairman, because that is a good analogy. You can
▶ Play
have one follow-up, and then we'll go to the next questioner. Okay, so to clear up what I was saying, and I think what your intent of your bill is, So we had that situation, the pre-construction, for my current project that I just completed that involved exactly what you're talking about or what we're talking about. It was not residential, it was commercial. And the conversation was such that the foundation company was reluctant or would not put in their warranty that they could warrant that this would be good forever, if you will, because of that original soil in this particular area with several buildings because of the original soil. So, yes, there would be a conversation, but I think that we would get less than and then maybe we would run into the problem of our residential homeowners not even being able to enter into an agreement because the agreement would put such severe consequence on the foundation repair company if there was a future failure because no one, if you've been around this, no one can really ensure when they were not a part of that original geotech design and what happened with the soil conditions, nobody can really ensure that. What they can do is come in, do a repair with their method of how they repair, and that's what they can ensure that what they've done. But I just want to be careful. We may be close to the same thing, but I just want to be very clear from a real standpoint of what happens. So we don't want to put too much in it that even prevents us from getting any repair from our failures. But telling them that they've got to come back and pay two times, that's going to be tough for homeowners to find someone to do this under these type conditions. That's tough on a business is what I'm saying. Thank you.
▶ Play
If I could answer, please. Representative Murdoch, I agree with everything you've said. In fact, to go one step further, I would hope that the foundation company, before they would go out there, or the repair company, before they went out there to work on a building that was 5, 10 years old, I would hope that they would do their due diligence. being a good business to ensure that they could in fact tell the people that I can or I cannot fix it. So therefore I think it goes back to the foundation repair company. They've got to do their job. Now let's talk again about, you brought up the fact about the penalty. Granted, that is a stiff penalty. But you've got to keep in mind this bill is set for residential. The biggest investment that 99.99% of the people are going to do out there is their home. That is their investment, their future. That's their retirement. I personally do not see an issue with it being twice as much. Typically, on a boilerplate home that runs somewhere between 1,500 to 1,600 square feet, what I've seen is the repair on these foundations runs anywhere from about $15,000 to $25,000. Yes, that's a lot of money. However, the peace of mind that the homeowner needs, I think it's good. It's their investment. It's
▶ Play
their life. Thank you. Representative Lemons, the penalty only happens if they go to court. This law is just designed to get them to comply with the contract, and there's $100 a day kicker if they're not complying. But if they're complying with the contract, there's no penalty beyond complying with the contract and then paying the $100 a day. And then if they can't get compliance and they go to court, this sets forth what the judge could rule. Is that a fair assessment? Yes, sir. Representative Cozart, you're recognized for
▶ Play
a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm going to echo what Representative Murdoch said, but I'm not going to say it. But I am a residential builder and commercial builder, and I have built quite a few homes in a lot of places that sometimes the soil is not the greatest. And the foundation that you put under that house is what you have to adapt to that soil, whether you have an engineer look at it. You do what you have to do to make that household up. I also do a lot of consulting work, and I have had a lot of people call me in and ask me what they can do because they have issues with their homes. A lot of this, that foreground is the contractor, as we know, but when you bring in these people, there's no way you can hold them to what they're having to do for very long. I mean, I can't see a contract with a foundation repair person lasting very long because they still have to deal with that same soil condition that somebody built a house on a very bad piece of ground. And it's really not their fault if it fails again because it's just a bad piece of ground. It's going to fail the first time. It's probably going to fail the second time. And their conditions that they're working under are not as ideal as the original contractor had. So I really have a problem with this because I think we're putting too much burden on them, and I would ask you if you agree, but
▶ Play
you probably won't. Can I say maybe? You know, a couple of things I want to make sure we understand. I mentioned the word lifetime contract a while ago. Not all contracts are a lifetime. You know, when you build a house, under most circumstances, you have what's called a 210 warranty. If people want to buy a bigger warranty, they can. The contract could be for one year, two years, five years. That's between the homeowner that is wanting the repair done to the house and the repair company. In no way does this law state it has to be a certain period of time. It's just that if you have a warranty, we want it to go with the homeowner. This is nothing more than keeping a foundation company from denying liability because person A sold their house after the repair to person B. we want the warranty where there's one year one day or a hundred million years we wanted to go with with the present or future homeowner and that's it that's all we're trying to do is just keep the warranty attached to what is supposed to be attached and that would be the home and again this is a
▶ Play
repair project it's not an initial construction
▶ Play
Speaker 38 19:15
project representative Sevilla you recognize for question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Lemon, you interested me in your earlier statement when you were talking about a time period. Does that go back to the code originally? You said there's how many days in transferring? No. No. There's
▶ Play
not a code. I'm sorry. Go ahead
▶ Play
Speaker 38 19:33
and finish. No. Well, I'm interested in what you said earlier about a period of time. It depends on the
▶ Play
company. The foundation repair company, they will have, some of them will have a transfer down at the bottom. It says that if you sell this house, this warranty has to be transferred within X number of days. And then they have a little clause down there that will say something like, we will charge you a $200 processing fee to transfer this warranty from A to B. What we're trying to do is to get away from that. Let the warranty stay with the house. If person A builds the house and they have a five-year warranty, or they fix their house, they've got a five-year warranty, two years into it, they sell it, that next three years should go with the next property and the next owner. And that's
▶ Play
Speaker 38 20:26
the only thing this bill is about. That's it. Let me ask you this. Were you serious when you were talking about four-point type in this agreement that when this transfer is being made, It's so small that the average person can't. Again,
▶ Play
it goes back to the insurance company. If they have a printer that will print a type 4 font, I'm sure
▶ Play
Speaker 38 20:46
they'll use it. Then why haven't you addressed that? That should be addressed in this bill. Well, I mean, I. No, I understand you didn't write the bill, but I would say to you. And a lot of them don't have it at all.
▶ Play
They don't have a transfer. I'm just saying that it's hard to find.
▶ Play
I got you. Okay, thank you. Representative Lemon, do you think that the sponsor of this bill would be willing to amend out the what I'm going to call punitive damage aspect of the court case so that rather than twice the amount of the repair damage, et cetera, et cetera, that it basically said if there was a good faith dispute between a homeowner and a repair contractor about whether or not the repair contractor was liable for the failure, whether it's the soil, it's a different aspect of the house, whatever the reason is, there could very well, it sounds like, very clearly be good faith disputes. The incentive of punitive damages creates a potentially unlevel playing field. So, and what I'm sensing from some folks is that, you know, that creates a burden on companies to make contracts, which, you know, in my sense is an amendment like that may make this feel a lot more balanced. I'm not sure that that works for other people, but do you think that's a possibility? Yes. All right. Next question, Representative Murdoch, you're recognized. Well, I
▶ Play
think what you summarized is where I was going, and I appreciate that, Chairman. I think that's where we need to go. I understand the intent of the bill. I think there's a great intent here. I just think we need to get clarity on the punitive damages and also even on defining the problem, defining who's the culpability and responsibility of the issue. So those two things I think are very important, defining responsibility and the punitive damages and how we should do that. I do agree that it's something that needs
▶ Play
to happen. Thank you. Representative Talley, you're going to
▶ Play
ask for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. That was kind of some of my same question is, I think the intent on this Representative Lemons is really good, but my concern is who makes that determination of what I think is failure, and me and my wife thinks failure, may not be what you and your contractor think is failure. I don't see in this who makes that determination. Do we have to sue before that determination is made? That's where I think the main concern is on this is that, I mean, I may think a hairline crack is a failure where that's typical standard concrete after a few years. So that's where I see the problem and appreciate some thoughts on
▶ Play
that. Be glad to address an amendment. So, Representative Lemons, let me ask the question this way. Obviously, you're representing the bill here and we're going to follow through the way you would like, but one thought could be that we could, in this discussion at this point, you could reconnect with the bill's sponsor in the Senate, Senator Williams, and see what his thoughts are on the two suggestions that we've kind of heard here and see what his thoughts are. And then my sense is there are at least two or three people on this committee who you could bounce those thoughts by, and my hypothesis is if they were comfortable, this would fly through with that amendment. Does that sound like a plan that's amenable to you? Yes, sir. I'd be glad to
▶ Play
do that. And being this is my first time to do this, I don't know what the exact verbiage is I need to say,
▶ Play
but what you just said sounds good. Okay. Well, first of all, I think you did an outstanding job with the bill. It's not at all anything about that. It's just the content of the bill, and that's exactly what the purpose of these hearings are for. So with that, what I would love to do is allow us to just pass over this bill today. we'll leave it on our agenda and then next week when we come back if you want to present an amendment we can go ahead and put that on and again I think you know some of the folks in this committee that know this business and if you run the amendment and get their alignment my hypothesis is it'll fly through
▶ Play
the committee so this is not the proper time for
▶ Play
Speaker 18 25:09
me to ask for a clincher we can clinch a pass over
▶ Play
the bill today if you'd like Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chairman. Committee members, I appreciate your time. Thank you very much, Representative Lemons. The next bill on our agenda is Senate Bill 182. Representative Farrar, you recognize to present the
▶ Play
bill. Yeah, really. I don't know if I want to or not. This is another Eddie, Senator Williams bill. maybe it's not as complicated. What this bill does is tries to keep the teacher and public employees' premium costs down. What's happening now is the teacher and public employees aren't signing up for the insurance when they first get there. They'll get on their wives or their husband's or their spouse's insurance. But when these teachers or public employees get ready to retire, they try to get back onto the system. So what happens is that makes an older pool, premium costs go up, where as we get older, we get sicker, most of us, some of us. So what this bill does is tries to make the employees sign up early, okay, but then instead of, then when they get ready to retire, it goes by when they signed up. So what it says in the bill is if the if you sign up in the first three years you're employed to the to the inch and the public insurance or teacher insurance when you retire then there's no penalty if you sign up between four and i believe 13 let me look at my notes i believe it's 13 years then um you have a five percent penalty on your premium cost uh from 14 to 23 years it would add a 10 premium cost cost, then after the 23rd year to be a 15% premium cost to the retired employee for their premium cost. What this does, it just keeps the cost down for the ones that are coming in and the ones that didn't get into the system early or later on, it gives a little penalty for doing that. If a retiree that has been into the program continuously, nothing changes. The retiree would still stay at the same premium cost. This program would start December 31st of this year. So anything before that doesn't count, but after that, this way it goes. So
▶ Play
I'll take some questions. So Representative Farrar, if I was to play back what I'm hearing, what I'm hearing is this insurance fund is currently in a situation where we're having much higher overall insurance rate increases on the entire pool of people. Within that, there are some individuals based on factors that are a much higher percentage of the cost of the pool, and yet not all those factors are being accurately reflected in the way the costs are allocated. And so what this bill is doing is for one of those groups of demographics, it is effectively allocating the existing cost in a more accurate way to those that are driving the cost. Is that kind of a fair assessment of what this is going to help us do for our insurance? I wish I would have said it just like you did. Representative Murdoch, you're going to ask for a question.
▶ Play
Thank you, Chairman, and thank you, Representative Farr. So it seems like we're attempting a little bit to be actuarial scientists to try to stave off some of the costs that come with people joining the program later. Let's take this example. If someone is on insurance with their spouse through these years and is more affordable for their family and their situation, and then there's a life change and there's a situation where they now need to exercise this insurance, what you're saying is at these various levels, then they'll be penalized as such. Would it not be, and it may be in here somewhere in the weeds, would you not consider that if that person or those persons were insured already, so they are insurable, so they're not really a penalty, if you will, type, What you're trying to avoid here is maybe older, sicker people or the cost from an actual cost standpoint. But if I'm on my wife's insurance and I'm not sick, I'm healthy, I've been insured, and there's just a life change and I come over to now exercise this insurance, I don't know that it's fair that I'm penalized for that. Well, I think it does say that in
▶ Play
Speaker 57 30:11
the – I got this bill yesterday. Sure. So I think it says that and
▶ Play
it gives a time. If you lose your – just like the situation you said, you have 31 days to get onto the program. Then it goes back to the regular cost. Okay. There is no penalty. There's no penalty. Right. It's just a transfer from another. Yes. And I'll give you – if I can find it, I'll give it to you. Participation. Yeah, right. Page 2, line 11, I think that's what that is. Applies participation in the program within 31 days of returning to the active employment. The employee is in a position that is eligible to participate in the program. That's the way I read that.
▶ Play
Speaker 61 30:55
Okay, well, if you go above that, I think that's referencing a retiree who has a break in enrollment in
▶ Play
the program may be considered to be continuously enrolled if it meets these particular. I'm not... Let's all
▶ Play
go to B1 or BI. It says the retirement shall be continuously enrolled in the program if actively enrolled in the position that is eligible to participate in the program. And I think what you're saying is an eligibility to participate.
▶ Play
Well, not eligibility to participate in the program, but transferring from another program Right. where they were eligible in. So they were insurable and they were under an insurance, but because of life change, they're coming over to this
▶ Play
insurance. So I think that's slightly different. Again, I got this yesterday, so I'm just like you on this. Go to Section 3 on page 3. See if that's an active and priori is described in subdivision.
▶ Play
See if that answers your question. I think that's what that answers. Okay, on the subdivision A5 section, which would be, but it references that subsection, that's the way the premium would be charged. Where's A5? What does A5 say? That's what we just went over. So that's our initial? Yes. With no penalty, basically. Right. Okay. That's why I read it. That's the way I read it. That's the way I think I read it, too. If
▶ Play
anyone else in the community sees this, please help us.
▶ Play
Thank you. Thank you. Representative Talley, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Was this vetted before the task force on teacher
▶ Play
insurance that's working on developing the overall plan? I asked Representative Gossage that he's on the task force, and he said no, but EBD, Senator Williams, I asked Senator Williams, he said EBD is behind this bill.
▶ Play
Representative Vines you're recognized for a question
▶ Play
in the interest of time I think Representative Murdoch touched on it mine again dealt with after year three if you lose your job you get divorced or God forbid your spouse dies does section three take care of that and allows you to come into that program within 31 days? Yes
▶ Play
Speaker 71 33:33
okay Representative Seville, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Speaker 38 33:36
Thank you, Mr. Chair. It states up here in the heading, it says life and health insurance. I don't read the health insurance part of this. It doesn't define term or whole life. I guess what my question is, and I want to make sure I understand this. If someone leaves our employment and becomes retired, they have a policy that is in effect. For some reason, as there's a life change, they choose to come over back into the state program. If they do that in three years, within three, go ahead. Now, what it is is they're
▶ Play
trying to bring a younger group into the pool. A younger group? A younger group. Okay. Right. So when the new employees come on, if they enroll into the program within the first three years, then when they retire and they continue that program,
▶ Play
Speaker 38 34:47
there is no penalty. I got you. Okay. I understand what you're saying now. Now, will the premium, the current premium, be based on, I guess, the group? It would not be because, you know, age determines premium, health conditions and so forth. I believe health conditions would not be unless there's preexisting terms. But so would someone come in basically at a certain age? If you're retired, you'd be older. Their premium would be? Representative Seville, this is
▶ Play
the health insurance. It's not life insurance. This is actually our health insurance. And as you recall from our sheets, we don't have age as part of the definition. That's my point. The big pool
▶ Play
Speaker 38 35:29
doesn't go back. Right. So that would be so it's not an individual. It would still fall within the group. And now let me ask you that the percent, if they did not sign up in the first three years, if the group rate was X dollars, would they have a kind of a surtax there adding 3% or 5% or 10%? When they rejoin the group, if your premium is $100, the next person comes in, they're retired, okay? They didn't sign up in the first three years. They're retired. If they didn't continue the program, if they didn't
▶ Play
join in, let's say they didn't join in, they joined in year four, then they retired. Right. They would have a 5% increase in their premiums. Okay. 5% increase. Okay, thank you.
▶ Play
I don't see any other questions from the committee. Is there anyone in the audience that would like to speak against the bill? For the bill. Representative Farrar, would you like to close for your bill? Motion do pass. We have a motion on the table. Any discussion? No discussion. All in favor? Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative Farrar. You've passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. The next bill on our list is HB1455 Representative Boyd you recognize present your bill Mr. Chair thank you I'm asking two people from
▶ Play
the appraisers board to join me if that's okay That's okay sir Okay I'm going to be as quick as I
▶ Play
can. We have session at 10 o'clock, so we're going to end this meeting at 9.58. Well, I
▶ Play
hope that this bill doesn't take that long. Me too. Okay. So basically, this bill is clean-up language for the appraiser board. The appraiser board has been working with the governor's office to clean up the language. This is what makes sense based on the current environment. To my knowledge, there's no opposition to this bill. I hope So we're available if there are any questions. The committee have
▶ Play
any questions? I don't see any questions. Is there anyone in the audience that would like to speak against the bill, for the bill?
▶ Play
Representative Boyd, are you closed for your bill? I just ask that someone on the
▶ Play
committee give me a due pass recommendation. Representative Love, you're recognized for a motion. Motion due pass. We have a due pass motion on the table. Any discussion? Seeing none, all in favor? Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative Boyd. You passed your bill. At this point, I'm going to adjourn the meeting without objection so that we can get ready for session.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 38:32
Thank you very much, committee.
▶ Play

Agenda

SB181

0:22 - 26:22 84 segments 9 speakers

SB182

26:22 - 37:11 37 segments 10 speakers

HB1455

37:11 - 38:33 6 segments 2 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Charlie Collins Chair Unverified
32 segments
Representative Tim Lemons Unverified
29 segments
Representative Bruce Cozart Unverified
6 segments
Chair Unverified
2 segments
Representative Reginald Murdock Unverified
23 segments
Speaker 38
11 segments
Representative Brent Talley Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 18
1 segment
Representative Joe Farrer Unverified
13 segments
Speaker 57
1 segment
Speaker 61
1 segment
Representative John T. Vines Chair Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 71
1 segment
Representative Justin Boyd Chair Unverified
3 segments