House Judiciary Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (13)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
SB79
· 5 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “Without objection, we're going to take up Senate Bill 79, Senator Woods. Senator Woods, I understand we have an amen…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1529
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “Without objection, we're going to move down to House Bill 1529. Representative Beck, you're recognized to present House Bi…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1450
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1450”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1488
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1488”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1505
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1505”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1625
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1625”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1626
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1626”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB204
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “Okay, committee, without objection, I'm going to set Senate Bill 204 for special order on the 19th at 10 a.m.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB261
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB261”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB262
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB262”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB464
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB464”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB529
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB529”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB58
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB58”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 15, 2026
Okay, committee, without objection, I'm going to set Senate Bill 204 for special order on the 19th at 10 a.m.
Without objection, we're going to take up Senate Bill 79, Senator Woods. Senator Woods, I understand we have an amendment that we need to take up first. Good morning, Mr. Chair.
should be on your tablet. Do I have a motion on adopting the amendment?
Okay. We have a motion from Representative Scott to adopt the amendment. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? The amendment is adopted. Senator, you're recognized to present Senate Bill 79 as
Speaker 7
1:50
amended. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Committee members, today you have before you Senate Bill 79, which offers some protection for individuals that are reaching the point of celebrity status or already at celebrity status to where what we're finding in the country is individuals' names, images, signatures, likeliness, their voice, their audio is being used without their permission.
And about 20 other states have a law in place where it gives protection to individuals and citizens that have reached a certain point to where their name or their likeliness is being used for commercial profit without their authorization. So what this bill does is prevents that. We're trying to curb that behavior to make sure if you're going to use someone's name or likeliness for a commercial profit, at least get the person's permission, get their authorization,
Work with that person, work with their family, but don't just go and do something like that without their okay. And the amendment that was recently added was brought to me by the NFL Players Association and the Screen Actors Guild. This is a very serious issue. It's something that I'm trying to help people that need help. Meredith here is actually Coach Frank Broyal's personal family attorney. and then monitor to have another guest here at the end of the table.
I'd also like to introduce himself for the record as well, and I'll
be glad to take questions. Okay, if you would, state your name, and
then you can offer your testimony. My name is Meredith Lowry. I am an intellectual property attorney in northwest Arkansas. I represent Frank Broyles and the family in intellectual property matters. The Broyles family came to me initially because they had had multiple businesses approach them after Frank Broyles retired from the Razorback Foundation,
and most of these businesses wanted his endorsement or to use his name. Some of them even wanted to use his signature on products. And this was very concerning to the family because some of them actually had products already made and without even granting permission yet. And the issue came up more so when people pass, those rights sometimes pass with them. And Arkansas doesn't have any litigation or legislation that supports the rights
that we are working on establishing here with this bill. And so we've worked very hard in crafting this. About half the country has either statutes or litigation that has formed publicity rights, and we've tried to embody that into this bill. Good morning to the members
of the committee. My name is Joe Briggs. I'm public policy counsel at the NFL Players Association,
and I'd also like to recognize Mr. Freddie Scott, who's a citizen of the great state of Arkansas, from the Pine Bluff area, who's a great former football player in the National Football League. We are here to support Senate Bill 79 today with the speakers before me because we believe it's very important for people to have control over what happens with their likeness and image. We understand that there are certain individuals that may oppose this bill in the future, but that's not what we're here to discuss today. What we're here to discuss today is ways that we can strengthen this bill
and give our full support behind it. Not only do we represent Freddie Scott, but we also represent Darren McFadden and Keith Jackson, who I spoke with last night. Both are also in support of this bill and this legislation. They're thankful for the work that you've done to get this through. And we appreciate your giving us an opportunity to speak with you today. We think that not only is this a great first step for the state of Arkansas to get this done, but you should also know that similar bills have been passed or at least being considered from New York all the way down to Alabama, with a bill being introduced just yesterday. So you guys are on the right side of this.
You're taking the lead on it, and we appreciate
your help. Representative Ballinger, you're recognized for
a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Could you help me just, and I'm definitely not an intellectual property attorney, but from what I remember back in law school, you have a property right in your intellectual property under common law. So could you help me understand what this statute would do differently than what's already protected under common law? If I
may. With the common law, those rights in Arkansas have never been discussed.
There is some theory based upon other states and the litigation that's occurred in those states that we could establish those rights. But it's not for certain that those rights would pass to the heirs of someone that has achieved some notoriety. That is a concern. There's also the uncertainty of litigation. And so the statute is to try and settle that and establish those rights on the forefront so litigation would not be as contentious.
Just some follow-up. Can you, and that's something that's interesting about practicing law in Arkansas. There's a lot of things that are unsettled in Arkansas, so I understand that. Could you tell me what the distinction is from this statute from common law, say, that's been developed, you know, through the years in other places, I mean, what would be the, is this consistent with that, or are there things that are different? You know, does this go further than what is established either under federal common law or common law in
other jurisdictions? There's not federal common law on this, to my knowledge.
But in other jurisdictions, there have been decisions where the rights do not pass to the heirs, and that is a particular concern here. When people pass, the family should not see T-shirts or advertisements with their loved one being used to promote products. And that was a definite goal with this legislation.
Representative Scott, you're recognized for a question. Thank
you, Mr. Chair. Senator Woods, can you tell me, I've read in here where it says this bill will protect all citizens. Does that include politicians? For commercial profit, yes.
questions. No one is signed up to speak for or against the bill.
Senator Woods, are you closed for the bill? I am closed with the bill. Was the pleasure of the committee, Representative Scott, we have a motion do pass as amended. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? The bill passes as amended. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee members.
Without objection, we're going to move down to House Bill 1529. Representative Beck, you're recognized to present House Bill 1529. With
the Chair's permission, I'd like to invite Jay Beckett up to assist me.
When I first read this bill, I did a double take. I went back and I flipped back through the bill because I thought I had missed something. You know, I look back because as the law stands today in Arkansas, we make one corporation responsible for another corporation's actions,
even if the second corporation had nothing to do with the other company's business. You know, that's not right or fair. But that's the situation that this bill addresses. Before I explain my bill, I want to take us on a little trip back to 1972. In 1972, you could have bought a gallon of gasoline for 59 cents. You'd get a dozen eggs for 84 cents. Time Magazine had the perfect man of the year. They selected Richard Nixon.
They later had to take that back after a little incident called Watergate. 1972 is also the year that OSHA first adopted its first regulation concerning the use of asbestos. Prior to that, we had no problem with using asbestos in our cars, our public buildings, even in our schools. Now, the reason I'm taking this back to 1972 is because January 1st of 1972 is a very critical date for this bill.
We need to remember that all of the mergers and consolidations and transactions referred to in this bill occurred back prior to 1972 and prior to any OSHA regulations concerning asbestos fibers. Now, I think the best way to explain this bill is to use an example. And I'm going to immediately give everybody on the committee a promotion. You guys are all now CEOs of corporations.
Now, your corporation and my corporation, prior to that magic date in 1972, had some type of a merger or consolidation. And prior to that merger or consolidation, my corporation had something to do with asbestos. It may have been as simple as we shipped asbestos or maybe we used it in a manufacturing process of some type. But because of my actions that I did before your corporation and my corporation merged,
your corporation is now considered a successor corporation. What does that mean for you? What that means is now your corporation has unlimited liabilities for the actions of my corporation. What this bill does is simply sets a value for your corporation's liabilities, asbestos-related liabilities. So let's see how we do that. We do that by taking the fair market value of the transaction back when it was done.
Remember, this was done back prior to 1972. So whatever the fair market value of those assets, the gross total assets that were transferred in that transaction, we take that value first. We then apply an index. That index, an annual index, is equal to the prime rate plus 1%. Now, once we've totaled all that up and we add it to this grand total that we've got, that becomes the amount of asbestos-related liabilities that your corporation is responsible for.
Let me make sure I haven't missed something here. You know, I apologize for the length of this bill, but this bill is actually modeled after a bill that has already been passed and put into law into 22 other states, four of which are neighboring states. And I think I've pretty much covered everything. If my partner doesn't have anything to add, I think we're ready for questions. Representative Whitaker, you're recognized for a question
Thank you, Mr. Chairman Representative, I just have one simple question If we pass this bill, will any Arkansan lose their ability to file an asbestos claim? Absolutely not Thank
you Representative Scott, you're recognized for question.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Beck, can you just give me a thumbnail sketch of
how this would affect a consumer? Let's say someone who just purchased maybe an old elementary school in northwest Arkansas that had asbestos in it or still had the remains maybe of some. Can you give me a day-to-day, just a scenario of what this bill really does. Okay. The important thing to
remember on that is that all of these transactions would have had to have occurred back prior to 1972.
So if something happened today, all right, like someone purchased a building that had asbestos or something like that, this bill does not apply to that. The reliabilities would just fall in place just like they are before we passed this
bill. Did that answer your question? Representative Broadway,
you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Have either of you any idea about how many corporations this would affect in Arkansas
or about how many lawsuits are going on presently that this issue would come into play? We're not sure
Speaker 52
15:49
exactly how many companies it would affect. It might affect, in addition to Crown, maybe one or two other companies because it's a very narrow area. Just a few companies have really been held responsible under successor liability because they purchased a company or merged with a company way back in the day. But Crown's story is so unique because Crown actually purchased a company back in 1964.
Crown purchased the company because that company was in the same business Crown was in. That company purchased or made and manufactured bottle caps, which is Crown's business. That company that Crown purchased in 1964 also had a small insulation division that had asbestos that sold or distributed asbestos, but the company Crown purchased had actually shut down the insulation division that was involved in asbestos six months before Crown bought it. to Crown's purchase. After Crown bought it, 91 days later, Crown sold the asbestos division
or the insulation division that was involved in asbestos to another company, and that other company started that business up again. But Crown never operated that asbestos-related business.
Well, if I may follow up. I understand that. Yes. But I'm really not talking about Crown, per se, and I understand that process. But I'm just wondering about, is this a big problem in Arkansas? Are there a lot of success or liability lawsuits going on?
Speaker 52
17:20
Yes. Crown has been named in almost 5,000 lawsuits during the last
20-plus years that we've represented Crown in its defense of these cases in Arkansas. But the cases are filed typically against numerous other defendants. And then the plaintiffs, the people that are injured by asbestos, they also file claims against these asbestos trusts. This law will not affect any of those claims the plaintiffs have against the numerous other defendants and the trust. Okay. Thank you. Yes,
Thank you, Mr. Chair. My understanding was that this would not affect any ongoing litigation. Is that correct? Well, it would not affect the
Speaker 52
18:06
plaintiff's claims against other defendants, of which there are numerous other defendants that those plaintiffs have sued. But the claims, you know, against Crown, Crown would have immunity under this statute, and that's what happened in the 22 other states where this legislation was passed. Follow-up.
So this would retroactively give immunity to Crown? Well, I'm
Speaker 52
18:32
not sure it would be retroactive as that term is defined, But Crown meets the standard in the bill because since 1964, Crown has paid some $750 million in asbestos-related liabilities and over a billion dollars.
But my question is, if there's an ongoing litigation right now and a claim's already been filed in court, Yes, ma'am. is this act going to result in Crown, one corporation,
being dismissed from every one of those pieces of litigation? That is correct. That
Speaker 52
19:04
is correct. And that's what happened in the other 22 states as well. Representative Ballinger, you're
recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Kind of the way I see this, and you correct me if I'm wrong, but we set statute of limitations all the time for, in fact, about every tort has some statute of limitation. In this case, that's kind of the way I see this, right, is that we're setting a statute of limitation. But in doing so, and something you all haven't mentioned,
is that there actually is still a potential even to get to crown in damages, right, that there is written into this bill. It's capped, but even the ongoing litigation that's going on right now, you can still get to crown by virtue of this bill. So it's kind of a real loose statute of limitations, a statute of limitations that is really long and still enables you to sue up to a certain point,
Speaker 52
20:00
correct? Well, I'm not sure I completely understand the question, But as a practical matter, you know, Crown has been a party to almost 5,000 plaintiffs bringing claims over the last 20 to 25 years.
But in actuality, there are only just a small handful of pending what I would call active claims. So the immunity set forth in the statute would only apply to just those small handful of claims that are currently active and then any future claims that might be brought against many other defendants, including Crown. A
follow-up, but I'm sorry, I kind of asked two questions in that one question. Could you explain, and either you or Representative Beck, the fact that even there is still some liability that could be assessed
under this for previous, for Crown or any other corporation that had done business prior to 1972 up to a certain dollar amount, right? Yes. I mean, the statute is
Speaker 52
20:57
very narrowly written to just exclude certain companies. It's only certain companies would have immunity under this law. And Representative
Beck, you may explain. I hope that you understand my question. Yeah, well,
I think what you're getting at is that as far as would this,
once the amount has been established, that grand total that we talked about with the index and all that, you know, whatever is left of that balance would be
available to plaintiffs. Right, and I guess that would be my question is could you explain what that is?
Explain that index and how all that works. Okay. The index is actually what, and I'm, it actually takes the prime rate for the year plus 1%, and then it multiplies that against what this figure that we came up with,
these total assets at the time of the merger. And it does that for each year. It indexes that forward, totals that all up, and then that's the sum that that corporation, whatever that corporation would be, would be liable for as far as asbestos-related liabilities. That's correct.
Okay, thank you. Okay, I see no further questions. We have one individual signed up to speak against the bill, Russell Winburn.
He'll probably sit there and then if you want to sit over
there or something. Thank you. You'll have a seat. Introduce yourself and who you represent,
and then you may make your statement. Mr. Chair and members of the committee, my name is Russell Winburn. I'm an attorney from Fayetteville, and for the last 27 years, I have represented asbestos victims in cases in Arkansas.
I have some history with this litigation. I want to start off by addressing some of the questions that the committee had relating to the effect of the bill, because I don't want there to be any misunderstanding about what this bill actually does. The formula that's being used by Crown, Cork, and Seal to determine and to cap its liability in these cases completely extinguishes any claim that a plaintiff would have against Crown, Cork, and Seal. In other words, the amount of money that Crown, Cork, and Seal claims to have already paid out in asbestos litigation, and quite frankly, I have no way to verify those numbers because
I haven't seen them, but I would be interested in looking at them. But my understanding is the amount of money that Crown Court Conceal claims to have paid out would be far more than what the value of this company would have been back in 1964. Representative Beck used an example about what this means in terms of extinguishing liability for crown, cork, and seal. Asbestos is an insidious mineral that has a long latency
period between the time that you're exposed to the product and the time that you actually contract disease. My clients, in effect, had a time bomb implanted in their bodies back when they were exposed, and that time bomb was set to go off 30, 40, 50, or 60 years down the road. This is why this litigation still exists today, because there's such a long time period between the time that you're actually exposed to the product and the time that you actually develop disease. So to use another analogy, what Crown Cork and Seal is trying to do here today is sort
of say that, well, if I'm a guy and I plant a bomb in your house and I set that timer to go off 50 years from now, we only want to be responsible for the cost of the bomb. We don't want to be responsible for anything else that happened later on down the line or that our company was actually growing and making money and doing all those things. This is a bad bill for a number of reasons, though, besides that. We don't have a problem.
Crown Court Conceal doesn't have a problem in Arkansas with this. I may have, and I have represented literally thousands of people in Arkansas over the last 27 years in asbestos litigation. I may currently have five claims penned against Crown Court Conceal, all of which and every claim that I can think of within recent memory that we've had with Crown Court Conceal has been resolved amicably, easily, without the need for contentious litigation and really with minimal involvement from Crown Court Conceal's attorneys. Their defense costs, at least in my cases, have been very low.
There aren't very many attorneys in Arkansas that represent as best as victims. You know, I'm one of maybe two or three that does that. So while I can't speak to somebody else's docket, I can tell you that this is just generally not a problem in Arkansas. This is a bill that solves an issue which does not exist here. So the other thing is that Representative Beck and Mr. Beckett have talked about the mergers and acquisitions laws. The mergers and acquisitions laws are very important for businesses.
They provide certainty for businesses. They provide a set of rules that they can go by so that you know, if you buy a company, what the rules are. And businesses like certainty. They don't like it when things are uncertain. And so the law that applies to this particular merger is the law of the state of New York. The law in Arkansas is the same. It's virtually the same in every state in the country. Generally speaking, when you buy a company, you assume that company's liabilities unless those liabilities are expressly excluded.
And that's the rule. Crown, Cork, and Seal knew that when they went and bought this company. They knew that, and they chose New York as the law. So to say that here we are in 2015, and we don't want to abide by those rules anymore, what they're essentially doing is asking you guys, asking the legislature to come in and say, we made a bad deal. We don't like that deal. We want you guys to change the rules. That's a dangerous precedent to set, at least in my estimation.
The precedent that you're setting is the next time a company comes along, doesn't like the deal that they've made, and it could be something completely different from asbestos, doesn't like the deal that they've made. They're going to come in, and you guys are going to be charged with listening to facts in an abbreviated setting like we have here today and trying to decide whether or not it's right or wrong for that particular company to be able to change the law, essentially. That's bad for business, and it's not a position I think that this committee wants to put itself in.
Finally, this bill doesn't benefit any Arkansas citizen. As far as I know, Crown Court Conceal doesn't employ anybody in Arkansas. They have no jobs at stake here. There's no money that's going to be. The only person that's going to save any money is Crown Court Conceal, and the only person that's going to be affected are my clients who are victims of asbestos disease. So all this does is really hurt victims. It's a specialty bill. It's a bailout bill. And with that, I would be happy to answer any questions that anybody may have.
Representative Ballinger, you're recognized for a
question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Just a couple questions. First off, one thing is the issue of the certainty. In this case, we have a corporation that purchased another corporation who actually, in this case, this corporation. Now, I do understand they're a successor corporation, but the corporation itself never did any work in asbestos, correct? That's not true. No, the corporation, the Crown Court Conceal, and I know that this law affects more than that,
but Crown Court Conceal never actually did any
work in asbestos. Crown Court Conceal purchased Mundette Corporation in November of 1963. Mundette Corporation was merged into Crown Court Conceal, and Crown Court Conceal, during the time that they owned this particular company, did sell and contract to sell asbestos-containing products. Okay. I mean, I guess that's a question of
a fact that's different than the testimony that we've heard so far.
But, you know, we set statute of limitations all the time. And one reason why we do that is so that people can have some sort of certainty that there's not going to be some claim that's popped up that's happened years ago. And I do understand the nature of asbestos, and that's one reason why, you know, we're setting a very narrow kind of unusual creative statute of limitations here but to me that certainty is something that that is is pro-business and in fact you know you talked about other states and how other states engage in it well 20 other states now have the same law so
i think almost half the states have the same provision to me that seems like that's that we're probably moving the direction of more certainty and not less certainty with this bill I mean, how would you
explain that? Well, I think there's an important distinction between a statute of limitations and a change in the mergers and acquisitions law. The statute of limitations in most states as it relates to asbestos claims runs from the date that the plaintiff knew or should have known that they had an injury resulting from a negligent act. And that's important in an asbestos case, as I explained earlier, Representative,
because it's so long between the time they're exposed those in the time that they actually understand that they've been hurt. So the statute of limitations is unaffected by this bill. What's affected by the bill is, and what you're doing is creating an exception within the mergers and acquisitions law, saying that a particular company, we're going to give them an exception to the longstanding rule that when you buy a company, you accept their liabilities absent an express agreement otherwise. And so that's the problem with the uncertainty in the mergers and acquisitions law.
Crown Court Concealed has been successful in telling people in other states that this is a very narrowly tailored and constructed bill, that it only applies to us. Actually, I agree with that as the bill is written. I think the danger in this is creating an exception at all. And that the next time you're going to be hearing from somebody else saying, what about this bill you passed for Crown Court Concealed, we want the same kind of treatment. And it'll be a completely different set of facts. that's the uncertainty that I'm really talking about.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Welcome, Mr. Winburn. Always nice to have a Northwest Arkansas attorney here. Thank you. I don't mean to just really be ugly to you, but I've got a question for you if I may ask, please. Please don't be ugly. First of all, my heartfelt sympathy does go out to anyone that has experienced an asbestos encounter, and I really do pray for those folks both now and any in the
future that may come along. However, I'd like to know from you, can you tell me exactly how much money is currently available for the victims you represent in established trust funds today? Well,
that's sort of a trick question, and I'll tell you why. The
companies that have established Those trusts have established it according to provisions of the bankruptcy laws. So they have been created through bankruptcy. So there are bankruptcy trusts available. Anybody that watches late night television can tell you, at least according to the attorneys
that advertise for these things, that there's $18 billion in those trusts. The problem with that is that those trusts are designed, there are multiple trusts, and you can't just go in and make a claim against all of them. You have to be able to establish that you were exposed or worked with a product that that trust is responsible for, number one. Number two, those trusts don't, they pay anywhere from maybe a nickel to a dime on the dollar in terms of what the actual value of a person's case is. And the reason for that is because those trusts are, and the trustees that run them, are responsible
for maintaining those trusts for future victims. And I'll give you an example. There's a company named Johns Manville who for many years was the leading manufacturer of asbestos in the United States. John's Manville filed for bankruptcy in 1982, emerged from bankruptcy in 1990, and established a 524G trust in order for these claims to be handled. They went on about their way. They have no further liability for asbestos related problems. The only recourse somebody has against John's Manville now is to file a claim against this
trust. In this process, Johns Manville values a mesothelioma claim at between $200,000 and $500,000. But they pay 10 cents on the dollar. And so there's maybe a big pile of money out there, and people that advertise like to point that number out to get people to pick up the phone and call. But the fact of the matter is that most of that money and the true value of their claim, a victim's claim against that company, is never realized through a bankruptcy trust.
Thank you. Representative Drown, you're recognized for
a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Going back to the question that was just asked by Representative Scott, in these trusts, you're saying a dime, 10 cents on the dollars paid out to the victims. How much, because I'm starting to see a big picture here in regards to these trusts, how much would a person who oversees one of those trusts be compensated for
meaning they're overseeing a trust the victims are getting a nickel to a dime on the dollar so somebody has to be making money somewhere I mean it seems to me like that's a very minimal amount for someone who's suffering from from a disease or cancer or something from related to an industry they had worked in so my question is somebody's making money somewhere so exactly how much would Could a typical trust, a person overseeing that trust, be compensated in a year's time?
You know, I don't know the answer to that question, but the gist of your question is fair. The reason why these victims are undercompensated through the trust is because the trust themselves have been underfunded. And that's the bottom line. There's simply not enough money. Periodically, the trustees who run these trusts are required to go in and conduct, you know, financial calculations to determine how much money we have to pay out on claims. and that would include the future claims. So they're required to estimate how many claims are going to be filed in the future and how do we maintain this trust over time in order to compensate these people as best we can.
Initially, the Johns Manville Trust was paying out someplace around 75 cents on the dollar, maybe even closer to a dollar. Again, it's gone down over the years. But I don't know the compensation system for the actual trustees. I don't think that they're overly compensated, and that's really not where the money is going to. The problem arises in the fact that the trusts were underfunded from the
beginning. All right, I see no further questions. I believe that's the only individual we had signed up to speak for against the bill.
Representative Beck, are you closed for your bill? With
Speaker 52
36:34
the Chair's permission. Thank you, Mr. Chairman and members of the committee. I'd just like to respond briefly to a couple of Mr. Winburn's points,
if I may. Hold on just a second. Actually, I'm going to let you go ahead and speak on this. Technically, closing for the bill could only come from the representative. I'm going to let you go ahead and speak to that, and then I'll let Representative Beck close.
Speaker 52
36:56
Thank you, sir. First of all, Crown, Cork, and Seal has never sold asbestos-containing products. In fact, that's one of the conditions of the bill is that the bill doesn't apply to companies that after the merger sold some asbestos-containing products or, you know, continued in that business. Crown has never done that. Crown manufactures bottle caps and other kinds of closures, the ones you might find on spray paint cans and those types of things. Crown has never been involved in an asbestos-related business.
With regard to Mr. Winburn's comment about asbestos being a time bomb, Crown very much agrees that asbestos is a bad product and victims of asbestos need to be compensated. Crown's saying, as a matter of public policy, let's have the wrongdoers compensate victims, not companies like Crown that just by virtue of owning a company that had a defunct insulation Division for 91 days don't make Crown have to spend, you know, billions of dollars to
defend these claims and pay interest surcharges. With regard to Mr. Winburn's argument about, you know, Crown should have known that it was assuming this liability, that's the whole argument, and that's why the year 1972 in this bill is important, because 1972 is when the federal government said to everyone out in the world, we're issuing these regulations because asbestos, we now know it's bad. Crown didn't know in 1963 and 1964 that asbestos had any potential liability attached to it.
That's why this successor liability, the quirk in the law, has worked such a hardship and such an unfairness on Crown. And this law, lastly, is not any kind of a bailout. What this law does is correct just a fundamental unfairness that has worked against Crown It's kept Crown from being competitive, and that affects people in Arkansas because we want companies in our country, and Crown's the largest manufacturer in the U.S., of bottle caps and those types of closures.
Crown, in 2000, almost had to declare bankruptcy because of these massive asbestos-related liabilities. Rather than declaring bankruptcy, Crown sold divisions, And as a result, its number of employees in the U.S. went from 12,000 to 4,000. Crown pays these huge interest surcharges every year, which keeps it being competitive with, you know, other manufacturers of bottle caps in the U.S. and those around the world. Crown just lost a huge Coca-Cola contract, which Crown had been a customer of Coke's for many, many years,
because Crown's cost structure, because of these asbestos liabilities, doesn't allow Crown to be competitive with other manufacturers. That's why this bill is important as a matter of good public policy to allow Crown to be competitive with others that don't have the same asbestos liability as a Crown does. Representative Beck. And since I
allowed Mr. Beckett to speak on that, Mr. Winburn, do you have any response? And then I'm going to let Representative Beck close on them. Just very briefly, if the committee is interested, I do have memorandum from the contracting division.
of Mundette that from 1963, December of 1963, which indicates that those contracting divisions were ongoing, that they were selling contracts, that they were installing asbestos, and that they were being encouraged to do so by Crown's leadership. I would be happy to provide that to the members of the committee. One final comment. With regard to the magic date, I think Representative Beck referred to it as 1972. Anybody with a computer can go and find out that the knowledge relating to asbestos and disease goes back a long, long way.
It goes back into the beginning of the 20th century. There were medical articles going up through 1960 that firmly established the relationship between cancers and asbestos exposure. These were published in very widely distributed medical journals of the American Medical Association, the British Occupational Health Journal, all of those things. To say that we were unaware of the hazards of asbestos in 1960 simply because OSHA didn't act on that knowledge until 1972 is no excuse.
The knowledge was there. They had reason to know. And quite frankly, many of the companies, and I'm not saying that Crown did this, but many of the companies actively concealed that knowledge. So the magic
date doesn't make sense either. Okay, thank you. Representative Beck, you're recognized to
close for the bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. The magic date that I refer to doesn't talk about the knowledge of what a corporation may or may not have. I refer to the magic date strictly because that's the date, that's the line, the timeline,
the line on the timeline that says that these mergers are consolidations occurred before that date. That was, and I apologize if there was any confusion around that. In closing, you know, I'd just like to say my heart goes out to anyone who's been harmed by asbestos. You know, companies, and the companies, you know, who dealt and used asbestos, you know, they should have reliability for what they've done. And I would support that. But this bill's not about that. It's not about that at all, all right?
You know, I've always been told that two wrongs don't make a right, all right? It was wrong for other corporations other than Crown to not take all the precautions that they may have known about as far as asbestos is concerned. But it's also wrong to make one company pay for another company's mishandling of something, and that's what this bill is all about. So, as I mentioned earlier, two wrongs do not make a right. I do move, do pass, and I appreciate a good vote.
Thank you. Okay, we have a motion, do pass. Is there any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? No. The ayes have it. Bill passes. Representative Lemons, you're recognized to present House Bill 1488.
Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee. I do appreciate you changing the agenda just a bit to bring me back up. As a lot of you, I'm sure, are starting to experience, we have to be in multiple places at the same time here in the last couple of weeks. What I'm presenting to you today is House Bill 1488. This is commonly referred to as the shall-certify legislation. Since the passage of the National Firearms Act in 1934, an applicant for an National Fire Association or Administration National Fire Act tax stamp
has been required to obtain the signature of a chief law enforcement officer, either a police chief or sheriff in his or her local jurisdiction, on the tax stamp application. This is to certify that the chief law enforcement officer has no knowledge that the applicant is prohibited from owning the item or no reason to believe the applicant is likely to use this item illegally. Unfortunately, many of the chief law enforcement officers simply refuse on the basis of either personal beliefs or political pressure to review, much less sign these forms. House Bill 1488 will require that the chief law enforcement officer in the state to review and either approve or disapprove the application needed for submission to the ATF within 15 days of receipt.
If the Chief Law Enforcement Officer finds that they cannot certify the application, the applicant shall receive a written notice as to the reason for the denial. Since 2005, eight states have passed a shall-certified law, including our neighbors to the East Tennessee and their neighbors to the West Oklahoma. Six of the eight states have adopted shall-certified laws within the past year. At present, there are approximately ten states, including Arkansas, in the process of approving a shall-certified law. Currently, an applicant living in a jurisdiction in which no CLEO or Chief Law Enforcement Officer will certify an ATF application
can bypass the signature requirement by using a trust, corporation, or LLC. The typical cost to prepare this trust or other legal entity ranges from $200 to $500. No Chief Law Enforcement Officer signature is required on the application filed by the legal entity. Unfortunately for the gun owners living in such jurisdictions, the ATF recently proposed a rule change proposed Rule 41P, which would eliminate the use of this alternative. Depending on the implementation of Rule 41P, a chief law enforcement officer may require
either that one representative of the legal entity obtain a chief law enforcement officer certification or that every person registered within that entity obtain the same. This change in policy would effectively eliminate the transfer of NFA items in those jurisdictions where no chief law enforcement officer will certify an application, thereby preventing entire segments of the gun-owning population from owning NFA items. In conclusion, the ideal situation would be to amend the NFA to eliminate the CLIO certification requirement.
However, that does not seem likely at the present time. In the meantime, the most expeditious solution to enact the shell-certified law at the state level. House Bill 1488 does nothing to enhance or lessen any gun laws. House Bill 1488 does simplify requirements to the CLEO to do their job in a timely manner. House Bill 1488 does bring conclusion, either approval or denial, to an application as opposed to the CLEO literally sitting on the application for an extended period of time.
House Bill 1488 does provide an applicant to appeal the CLEO's decision in a court of law. Last but certainly not least, House Bill 1488 does give an applicant their due process as allowed by our Constitution. I would like to thank Mr. Todd Rather, Executive Director of the National Firearms Act Freedom Alliance, for his input in creating this much-needed bill, and I'd appreciate a good vote. Representative Copeland, you're recognized for
a question. Representative Lemons, thank you for being here, and you and I have discussed this bill.
Can you give us a real-world example? I appreciate the presentation. Kind of lengthy, wasn't it? Oh, no, I don't know about that. But anyway, it made a lot more sense when you told me in plain English. So could you tell them what you told me? Sure. Because I think it's a good bill, but if you don't mind.
Thank you. When someone wants to make a modification to a firearm, They have to obtain approval from the ATF to do such.
There is a form that they must send in to ATF. From the time you send in your form to the time you get permission back or denial back, it could be anywhere from four to eight months. What we're trying to do is to, we can't do anything about that on a federal level. It still takes that period of time. But to even make that application, you have to take it to the chief law enforcement officer to sign off on it. A lot of your CLEOs, Chief Law Enforcement Officers, are literally sitting on these applications for weeks, maybe months,
because for whatever reason, they just don't want to be involved. And they are required by ATF to do their job. And it's not an overwhelming case, but it is happening from time to time. So what this bill will do will put a 15-day moratorium on them being able to make a decision. We're not asking them to approve or deny. Just give them 15 days
to let people have their due process. Yes. So the federal law stays the same, still has to go through that process.
What type of modifications are we talking about? Well, the
most common modification would be if you wanted what is called a short-barreled rifle or a short-barreled shotgun. If the barrel is less than 16 inches in length, you do have to get permission from the ATF to be able to make that modification. That's the biggest example, or the most commonly used. It's all coming back to me
Representative Whitaker, you recognize for a question? Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Under the National Firearms Act, does this also include converting a weapon to fully automatic and the use of silencers?
Yes, it would. That is part of the ATF application if you are so inclined to request that, but not
always. Representative House, you recognize for a question?
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Lemons, if the sheriff or the police chief is under the obligation to provide the letter now
and if they don't do it, you take them to court. I'm reading your bill. This says if they don't do it, then 15 days you
take them to court. Have I missed something? Well, not really. Right now there is no definitive time. Unless one really wants to push the issue, there's no definitive time as to how quick the CLEO has to respond to the request. This bill gives them 15 days. If they receive a denial, if the applicant so chooses, they can appeal this to district court,
and then the judge would have the final decision. So the import of the bill is to set a time limit. But you've got 15 days, and then you can go to court, and there's
no 30 or 60 or 90? No, sir. And there's no penalty other than the judge telling the sheriff if they're wrong, you need to sign this application.
Okay. Thank you, Mr. Chair. All right. I see no further questions. No one has signed up to speak for or against the bill. Representative Lemons, are you closed for your bill? Yes, sir.
Thank you. What's the pleasure of the committee? Representative Copeland, you recognize? The motion do pass. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? The bill passes. Thank you. Mr. Chair, do you want to
go and hit my other bill while I'm here? Yeah, we'll go down to,
without objection, we'll go down to House Bill 1626. Okay, and
if I could, I would like to request
Ms. Lindsey Bailey from Arkansas Association of Counties to join me. Representative Lemons, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Okay, this is House Bill 1626. I'm going to give a little brief history as to why I feel like this bill is important. On September the 13th, 2011, at 4.45 p.m., a man entered a courthouse armed with two guns and a rifle. The man was there to confront a district judge who had previously ruled in a divorce and custody case where the man was a party. When the man discovered that the judge was not in his office, he fired approximately 70 shots in the courthouse.
Fortunately, the local police was the first to respond to the emergency call, and the assailant was fatally shot to end this terrible situation. This occurred in our own Crawford County Courthouse in Van Buren, Arkansas. At the time of this incident, no one in the courthouse was armed or able to protect themselves. In fact, by law, no one in the courthouse was allowed to be armed. House Bill 1626 would provide some remedies to the situation in the event that this horrible tragedy ever occurs again.
House Bill 626 would allow countywide elected officials to conceal carry into their offices. Those offices include the county judge, county clerk, circuit clerk, county treasurer, county collector, coroner, and assessor. At present, district judges and prosecuting attorneys are allowed to conceal carry of their respective offices. Like most counties, Lono County Courthouse, which is where I'm from, does not house its sheriff's department in the courthouse. Our sheriff's department is approximately two and a half miles away and separated by the courthouse by Interstate 30 and numerous traffic lights.
Like most counties, Lono County does not presently have the resources to maintain a sheriff's deputy in the courthouse during normal operating hours. The only person with a handgun in our courthouse on a regular basis would be our court bailiff, and he's only there when court is in session. In our specific courthouse, the district court is located on the third floor. This court is where a divorce and custody hearing occurred. I believe most, if not all, prosecutors and sheriffs would agree that the greatest threat to a violent act in a courthouse
would be a product of a divorce and custody hearing, the same as what we had in Crawford County. Another real danger is found in the employees coming and going to the courthouse. In our courthouse, the employee parking is dimly lit at best. It has been rumored that one of our Central Arkansas courthouse parking lots just received a $50,000 upgrade to provide adequate lighting. Unfortunately, most counties cannot expend funds to do the same. House Bill 1626 ties with the courthouse security plans required in the Courthouse Security Act of 2007.
It allows the allowed use for countywide elected officials to conceal carry would be up to the local control as dictated by each county security plan. Also, the county security plan will dictate whether supplemental training is required above the concealed carry. House Bill 1626 gives people the opportunity to protect themselves. And if the chairman would allow me to, I'd like to turn it over to Ms. Bailey. You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee.
I'm basically just here today to say that we helped Representative Lemons in the drafting of this bill we fully support this bill and the local control that it gives to the county judge and the circuit judge as chairs of the courthouse security committee and I would entertain any questions you might have for us
I have a question And you were saying it gave local control.
Describe to me how it actually provides local
control. Sure. As Representative Lemons mentioned, back in 2007, there was a law put in place by the General Assembly that created courthouse security plans. The AOC supervises that, and each county reports their courthouse security plan. to the Arkansas Administrative Courts. This would allow the courthouse security team to put protections in place where they could,
if they so choose, require active shooter training if someone wanted to carry who was covered by this bill. It would just allow them to see who could carry and what kind of training they needed to
have to do so. And if I could add, just the sheer decision, the pure decision as to whether to allow these full-time county elected officials the right to conceal carry in the courthouse would be up to the individual courthouse security group.
If I may add one more thing onto that. As you all know, there's a great difference between our courthouses across the state in security. Some have full-time law enforcement officers, metal detectors. Those courthouses may choose not to participate in this, while others with minimal security, who this bill is really intended to protect, would be allowed to do so. Okay, I see no further questions.
It does not appear that anybody else has signed up to speak for or against the bill. Representative Lemons, you're recognized to close for your bill.
it, and I'd appreciate a good vote. What's the pleasure of the committee? Representative Ballinger, we have a motion due pass. Any discussion? All in favor, say aye. Any opposed? Bill passes. Thank you.
have one other, but that one was just filed yesterday, so I'd prefer to pass over and take it up at a later date.
Thank you. Thank you. Without objection, we're going to take up Senate Bill 261. Senator Hutchinson, you're recognized. Yes. And I understand we have an amendment.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. This amendment is to address the concerns of this committee last time I presented this bill. I'll appreciate adopting the amendment, then I'll explain the bill as amended.
All right, committee, I think the amendment's been handed out.
I guess we need to entertain a motion to adopt that. Representative House makes a motion we adopt the amendment. Any discussion? All those in favor signify by saying aye. Aye. Any opposed, no. Senator Hutchinson, you're prepared to discuss Senate Bill 261 as amended. Thank you,
Mr. Chairman. and this is my second attempt with this non-controversial bill I bring to y'all.
This bill, if y'all recall, there's an issue with police being called out for what typically is a suicide attempt or there's no crime being committed, but police are needed, and they will confiscate the weapon of the person who's threatening suicide or going through a mental break. And currently for that person who's committed no crime to retrieve their property,
they have to petition the court and it's a pain and the court, the judges don't like it and certainly the citizens whose property has been confiscated doesn't like it. So this bill sets up a mechanism by which there will be a 72-hour pause, kind of if there's additional issues that need to be addressed by family members, they can do that. But upon 72 hours, no charges have been filed. The person can go directly to the city or whomever the law enforcement agency is that confiscated that
and retrieve their lawful property. The concern that was raised last time I presented this bill was if a minor goes, because the bill said that upon proof of ownership and identification that they can receive their property back, the issue is what about a minor? And so the amendment addresses that and says that if it's a minor, the parent or legal guardian of the owner must come and present evidence of ownership
and obviously identification. With that, I'll take any questions. Very good, Senator.
Any questions from committee? Seeing none, I don't believe we've got anyone signed up in the audience to speak for or against. We already did. Yeah. Would you like to close for your bill, Senator? I'm closed. As
I will say, Representative Love, who's not just enjoying my company,
he's carrying this in the house. Y'all are quite the pair. Representative Bennett? Okay. You're closed, Senator? Closed. I believe we would entertain your motion as amended, correct? Yes. Motion's been made to do pass Senate Bill 261 as amended. Hearing no further discussion, all those in favor, signify by saying aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? Congratulations, Senator. Your bill passes.
Where are we going next? We'll go back with the committee's indulgence. We'll go back to the agenda, regular agenda, Senate Bill 58, anyone here to present that? Senator Woods? Senate Bill 262,
anyone here to present that? Representative Benner, are you going to present Senate Bill
262? Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'd like to ask Diana Tyler from the Department of Community Corrections to join me. All right.
You are recognized, Representative. Let me make sure we can get this. Senate Bill 262. Yeah. All right. Very well. Proceed.
Very simply, what this bill does is allow the Department of Community Corrections to refuse someone who has been sentenced to community corrections. Where this would become important is, for example, if the offender that was sentenced had had problems in the jail while they were holding him, if there were sexual offenses involved, if there was some sort of offense that does not make them a candidate for appropriate treatment in community corrections, it would allow the community corrections department to go back to the judge
and ask that they be resentenced to the Department of Corrections. Does that cover
it? Pretty much. All right, very well. Any questions from committee? Representative House, you're recognized. I appreciate what you're trying to do, but
what I'm hearing is that if you don't like the judge's sentence, you just don't have to obey it. And if you don't mind, I'm
going to let Ms. Tyler answer. Donna Tyler with community correction.
Speaker 181
1:06:25
That's not exactly it. We house different kinds of offenders in our five community correction centers. Some of them are sentenced from the courts that are judicially transferred from the Department of Correction, and their crimes have to fit a target group of offenses that are outlined in statute. What is at issue here is something called primarily probation plus. These are folks who have been placed on probation by the courts, but as a condition of that probation, they have to do some time with us.
Usually it's about 90 days, okay? If someone who has been judicially transferred acts up in our center, we can transfer them on to ADC where they have more secure facilities because we're very minimum security. If you are a probation plus, though, and you've acted up in the county jail, you have assaulted officers and other inmates or you've committed a sexual act, There's nothing we can do with you.
We can't send you to ADC. We have to house you for the duration of however long the court says. And what this bill does is say, look, if you've done those things, if you've hurt people in the county jail and you're getting probation plus, you can't come to us because if you're going to act like that, there's really nothing our services can do to help you. You're going to spend all of your time in a very small ad seg because we can't let you out on that minimum security with the other inmates.
We can't. So what it would do is just have the court say, okay, I've got to do something else with you. And more than likely, it's going to be ADC because of the way you have acted.
May I follow up, Mr. Chair? Absolutely. What I'm thinking about is the poor sheriff that has got a prisoner. He's been told to deliver her to you, and now you're telling the sheriff we're not taking him, her.
Speaker 181
1:08:28
Well, it wouldn't be our regular judicial transfers. This is because the system takes care of that through the target offenses and our ability to move them to ADC. It's those probation pluses, and this doesn't come up that often, but when it does, it's a problem for us. And then, I mean, they're in the county jail. instead of coming to us, then they would go to ADC. And both of us are backed up. You're going to wait either way. And you're right as far as a county sheriff. Yes.
Speaker 181
1:09:02
Yes. Representative Bennett brought up a good point. These are events that happened after sentencing. In other words, you got probation plus, you're in the county jail, and then you do something awful. Okay, very well.
Any other committee members with questions? Very well. I do not see anyone signed up to speak for or against from the audience.
Having no further questions, Representative Bennett, would you like to close
for your bill? I'm closed. I'd appreciate a good vote
and do pass, please. All right. That is a proper motion. Motion has been made to do pass Senate Bill 262. Hearing no further discussion. All those in favor signify by saying aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? Congratulations. Your bill passes. All right. Back to the agenda. House Bill 1505.
Representative Gray. You recognize. Thank you, Mr. Chair. i'm all about second amendment rights but i'm getting tired of gun bills today i don't know about you guys um well i know this this actually um this started this bill started with with personal experience actually and what this bill allows allows concealed carry permit holders to do
is actually carry their concealed weapon on uh publicly owned and maintained parking lots we'd be legal to carry for instance um on in the capital only on the parking lots not in the buildings or on the grounds um so we'd be legal when i drop my child off at daycare when we meet with our higher ed uh uh people we'd be legal on higher ed the the gun would have to stay in the vehicle and that way too when we're driving just driving through we're illegal right now when we
just drive through a k-12 school when we drive through their parking lot we are currently illegal if we're carrying a weapon um and that's essentially all this does it does not open it up to any private businesses it's just state owned and maintained parking lots so i'll entertain any questions all right i've got a
question for you i want to make sure because we've had this bill various times this doesn't if i've got joe's construction company this has nothing to do with affecting my
property rights as a private as a private business owner anything correct
no this is not and the bill was actually written i'll just i'll tell you how this all came the bill was actually written and it said publicly accessible is the way it was first written um and that's yeah and i actually took that to mean that a bakery or any other privately owned business i'm not in the i do not want to legislate for privately owned businesses this is just for state property let me ask you one
further and this this has come up i think in several districts what if uh let's use let's pick
on them i hope they're not in here but dhs has an office in a strip mall that also has private businesses is that going to cause any sort
of contention or problem no only if the parking lot were maintained were owned and maintained by the
state of Arkansas okay all right very well uh questions from committee I believe I always make this mistake but it's not Captain Tosh it's Representative Tosh recognize Representative Tosh thank you
Mr. Chair representative make sure I understand I think I'm corrected about this what you're trying to do
is simply anyone that has uh can legally carry a firearm under any other statute you just want want to make sure that they're not in violation of the law because they're traveling from point a to point b and when they get to point b if instead of being in violation they can leave their weapon in the vehicle and still be in compliance with current law is that correct that's correct and i don't
think that a lot of people that have concealed handgun permits actually understand that when they are dropping their children off at school and they drive through that parking lot that they're actually illegal you know if you go and most people now know about
high red because the signs are posted everywhere. Or even people if you have concealed carry and you're driving through a parking lot here at the Capitol, you're technically illegal. So I'm just trying to clear. Essentially, this to me is a cleanup bill that should have been
done a long time ago. Go ahead, Representative Todd. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Just a quick follow-up Representative. What this does, this prevents them from being in violation. In other words, if this law doesn't pass, then what are they supposed
to do with their firearm even though they're legal carrying it to this point once they get there if this law doesn't pass then it becomes illegal that's so what are they supposed to I guess this clears up and takes away any doubt what they're supposed to do with their firearm when they're in a place that they have the legal right to be
there correct that's correct and I actually when I do have a concealed carry permit and at times when I do carry I have to be very mindful if I'm going to pick my daughter up at school that I'll actually I'm overly worried that somebody will
catch me doing something so I'll actually take my weapon to my mother's house which is two blocks away I'll drop it off and go pick up my daughter and then go get my weapon again so but and I'm one of the few people that's actually mindful of that so yes this would uh to answer your question this would make it legal
for what most people already do and don't realize that they're breaking the law today all right i believe uh representative tosh you're you're good all right representative
drawn withdrew representative broadway recognized thank you mr chair uh representative gray i need
to i think understand how this bill interfaces with um representative collins bill about guns on college campuses, to me this says that if there is a ball game that has 60,000 individuals attending, that anybody that has a concealed carry license can bring their gun on campus and leave it in a parking lot. And I just need to understand if that is true. That is true. That is correct. That would be true with a high school sporting event.
Okay. All right. That's what I need. That is true. Thank you. Representative Bennett, did you have a question? I wasn't sure. Okay. Any further questions from committee? All right. Seeing no one has signed up to speak for or against, Representative Gray. You're closed. What's the pleasure of the committee? Representative Tosh makes a motion to do pass. Hearing no further discussion, all those in favor of House Bill 1505 signify by saying aye. Aye. Any opposed, nay?
No. All right. Congratulations, Representative Gray. Your bill passes. Thank you, Mr. Chair and colleagues. Going back to our agenda, House Bill 1506. Anyone here to run that bill? Representative Beck, House Bill 1530. House Bill 1532 is a fantastic bill, but it is being amended. House Bill 1538, Representative Ballinger. do you want us to put that on deferred right now
ok we've done that ok 1543 is on members own house bill 1544 I don't see representative Sullivan I don't believe he's going to run that today house bill 1570 no house bill 1571 let's see we did have we done Senate Bill 57 72 is Senator Hutchinson
still with us he is not we'll pass over that House Bill 13 do very much well they never do now this bill was brought to me by those interested in the dependency neglect cases in Arkansas and it really does just clean up some language in the dependency neglect code. I'll just go through section by section and tell you what each particular change is. In section one of the bill, right now in all juvenile cases,
notice is given to all the parties and we change that in dependency neglect cases. Because that's a situation where, as you may be aware, where a child's welfare is at issue and And the court needs to intervene in a family situation to make sure the child is being taken care of properly. In that instance, the court appoints an attorney ad litem, and everybody's interested in the welfare of the child. But the attorney ad litem is the only person in the proceeding whose sole concern is the welfare of the child. And so this basically amends the notification procedure.
So when anything happens in the court case, the child is served through their attorney ad litem. as opposed to being served in another way that the person that could be subjecting the child to harm could intervene with the notice about what's happening in the court case. So it's just a way to make sure that the attorney who's been appointed to look out for the welfare of the child is notified of all court proceedings in the case. In the second section, when a dependency neglect case arises, a court enters an order for all sorts of purposes.
Right now, it's not included in the statute that the court should determine what the most appropriate goal of the dependency neglect case is for the juvenile. So this just adds a section to say the court may, but it's not shall. It's may or an order determining the most appropriate goal of the case. In the third section, right now in dependency neglect cases, The statute reads that a court may impose sanctions against a certain list of parties in violation of the order.
And it lists parents, the juvenile and custodian, and this basically just cleans that up. And allows the court to enter sanctions against any party to the proceeding that's in violation of the court order. Whether it's the Department of Human Services, which is not currently included in the list, or anybody else that's a party to the case. It just gives the court the authority to enter sanctions against anyone who violates the court order. which is the case for all other cases. In section four, it just cleans up the language where it refers to, this is for children who are born out of wedlock and
it changes the language from an illegitimate juvenile to a juvenile for whom paternity has not been established. That's just more appropriate language in 2015 for our statutes. In Section 5, this deals with health care for children that are in dependency neglect proceedings, decisions that cannot be made without the approval of the court. As you can see in Section A, the custodian or parent or guardian cannot consent to the removal of bodily organs
unless the procedure is necessary to save the life of the juvenile. And subsection D, the parent, custodian, or guardian cannot consent to the amputation of any body part. And this just adds that same language in unless the procedure is necessary in an emergency to save the life of the juvenile. And then in the last section, this deals with the termination of reunification services. And this just changes language to make it consistent with everywhere else in the code. The current language is, if one of the following grounds exists,
the circuit court has determined that the parent has subjected the child to aggravated circumstances. But of course, it can not only just be the parent, it could also be a guardian or custodian. And it just adds that language in as it is in several other provisions of the code. So this is all pretty straightforward stuff just designed to clean up the language in the dependency neglect code. And I'd be glad to entertain any questions. All right. I see no questions from the committee. We do have a few people who have signed up.
Michael Moats with the attorney ad litem program. If you'd have a seat at the end of the table, introduce yourself, who you represent, and then you may offer your testimony. Yes, thank you. My name is Michael Moats. I'm an attorney ad litem with the attorney ad litem program. I currently represent kids in Crawford and Sebastian counties. Thank you to the chair and to the committee for allowing me to speak today.
Basically, Representative Tucker covered everything that I wanted to cover. I think that these are good cleanup amendments to the current legislation. The only thing that I'll add to what he said was in Section 1, we view it as our job as attorney ad litems to represent the best interests of children. And you're talking about young kids currently under
Speaker 207
1:22:24
the rule could be handed some pleadings that contain matters of a very sensitive nature from child rape to severe abuse. You know, we view it as our job to filter those pleadings.
And currently, you know, if this bill were to pass and we were served under Rule 5 as is the civil procedure rules at this point, you know, we filter that information and give that to the child in an age-appropriate manner. Other than that, I don't have any comments in addition to what Representative Tucker has already stated today. Thank you for your testimony. We have one other on the list, Janet Bledsoe, to speak for the bill. Thank you. Okay.
Thank you. Representative Tucker, you want to close for your bill? I'm close. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm close. Representative Howes, for what purpose? Go ahead and ask your question. Representative Tucker, in the case of a juvenile being served through their ad litem, the parent is also served as well. Is that correct? Yes, sir. Yes, thank you. I didn't see that it didn't say that, but I want to make sure. Thank you. Yes, sir. Are you close for your bill? Yes, Mr. Chairman, I'm close.
All right. What's the pleasure of the committee? Representative Whitaker? Motion do pass. Move a motion do pass. Any discussion?
All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? The bill passes. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Hodges, I believe you're here to present a bill.
Is that correct? Which bill are you here on? Okay, without objection, we're going to take up Senate Bill 464. Thank you, Mr. Chair and committee. This is a great – Judiciary is a great committee to be on. I served on my first term, my first time being at this end of the table,
but it's not my first time being in front of Representative Shepard, but I'm glad to be here. I'm presenting to you guys today Senate Bill 464, a bill that was brought to myself and Senator Burnett from the Department of
Speaker 215
1:24:59
Child Support. And if you don't mind, with the permission of the chair, I'd like to bring up Barbara Morris-Williams.
She's the field operation manager for the department. If you would, just go ahead and have a seat and introduce yourself. My name is Barbara Morris-Williams. I'm with the Office of Child Support Enforcement. I'm the Field Operations Manager. What we're doing, Senate Bill 464, there's two parts to it. In Section 1, it's pretty much a nomenclature change. It updates the name of the Aid to Families with Dependent Children, AFDC, public assistant program to add its current title, Transitional Employment Assistant, which is referred to as T.
Speaker 217
1:25:48
This program, and this section of the, let me get my notes here, this section
Speaker 215
1:25:59
already exists in law. Current law contains only the former name of the program, and the Office of Child Support would like to, they have cases in which parents may have received assistance under both titles. So they're trying to just bring this in line and add this to the current law, since the name is under T as well.
And Section 2 provides consistency with the current federal approach regarding what may be deemed to be adequate medical coverage in child support cases. Previously, the definition of ability to provide health care was linked only to employers or group of coverage. This change to existing law allows the inclusion of other insurance options, including private individual policies or Medicaid coverage. This section of the bill provides, allow greater flexibility in how families who are the subject of orders for child support provide health care coverage for their family.
Did you want to add to that? Any questions? Representative House, you recognize for question? Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Hodges, Medicaid eligibility may be sufficient coverage. I understand that. And a lot of times Medicaid coverage is established based on the family income of the custodial parent,
if I'm correct, and you can correct me if I'm wrong. But the non-custodial parents' income
will not be counted for purposes of that Medicaid eligibility, if I'm correct. That's my understanding. So basically, we'll say dad can be making a ton of money and afford health insurance for the child, but when we take out this Medicaid provision, that throws the child perhaps solely on the mercy of the state for coverage.
Do you see my dichotomy there? Generally, in that situation, if the noncustodial parent is able and capable of providing medical insurance through employer or through purchasing a private policy, then in those situations, the court would normally order that that parent be responsible for providing the insurance. This bill would simply give the court and the parents more flexibility in determining what their situation is.
Any other questions? No one has signed up to speak for or against the bill. Representative Hodges, would you like to close for your bill? Just appreciate a due pass. Thank you. What's the pleasure of the committee? Representative Scott? Can we have a motion due pass? Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? The bill passes.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee. Thank you.
Thank you.
Unknown speaker
1:30:28
Okay, I had to step out to present a bill. I just want to make sure that I'm caught up here. What number is that? Okay, Representative Vines, without objection, we're going to let Representative Vines present Senate Bill 529. Okay, Mr. Chair, let me pull it up just quickly so I don't speak out of turn.
Okay, yeah, here we go. Yes, sir, Mr. Chairman, thank you, committee. This is Senate Bill 529. It comes to us from Senator Burnett and others. What this does is it extends that judgment lien. Currently, I believe it's three years, and this would continue it in force for up to
10 years. All this does is simply allow you not to have to go renew that after three years to make it similar to, I believe, and correct me if I'm wrong, the duration of other judgments.
So it's just, I guess, as we've had a lot today, clean up language, clean up bill. I'd be happy to answer any questions you might have. Any questions? Okay. I see no questions. No one has signed up to speak for or against the bill. Are you closed for your bill? Absolutely. What's the pleasure of the committee? Representative Scott? Motion to pass. We have a motion to pass. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Any opposed? The bill passes. Thank you, Mr. Chair and committee.
All right. As I was saying, I just want to make sure that I'm caught up. We've set Senate Bill 204 for
special order on March 19th. House Bill 1456, Representative Bain, we're going to pass over that today. House Bill 1490, Representative Ballinger, pass over. Senate Bill 58. Okay, Senate Bill 58. Senator Woods, I think he wants to take that up Thursday.
House Bill 1506, Representative Meeks. And likewise, House Bill 1530, we'll pass over both of those. House Bill 1532, Representative Vines, we're going to pass over that, correct? Okay, it's members' own. 1538 House Bill 1543 is on member's own House Bill 1544
Representative Sullivan is not here and then we're going to pass over House Bill 1570 and 1571 Senate Bill 57 Pass over Senate Bill 57 We've already taken up Senate Bill 261 Senate Bill 472 We're going to pass over We're going to pass over House Bill 1322 I am going to Without objection We're going to set House Bill 1203 Representative Hammersville
For special order Thursday at 10 a.m. And Likewise Otherwise, we're going to take House Bill 1240, Representative Tosh, off the deferred agenda and set it for special order Thursday at 10 a.m. All right. House Bill 1598
Representative Douglas House Bill 1599 Representative Douglas I don't see her Senate Bill 152 Senator Hutchinson House Bill 1624 Representative Meeks is not here. House Bill 1626, we already took that up. House Bill 1631, Representative Douglas is not here. House Bill 1371 and House Bill 1374, Representative Wright is not here.
House Bill 1400, we're going to pass over. House Bill 1403, okay, it's being amended. House Bill 1203, I've just set for special order. House Bill 1441, Representative Bain, pass over. Okay, we'll pass over that.
House Bill 1450, Representative Copeland. Representative Copeland, you're recognized to present House Bill 1450.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman and committee. This bill is an attempt to help with prison overcrowding. Also, let me give you just a quick, I know we've been here quite a while, so I'll try to make this very quick and do the bill justice. And again, I know we have some people from corrections here, so they can, no pun intended, correct me if I'm wrong here.
But if I'm not mistaken, I believe it was in the 50s
that good time, the good time program or type of reward system, good time, was introduced. In the 90s, rightfully so, our late 80s, there was a great emphasis put on much harsher sentences. That good time, notorious good time program was never adjusted for this establishment of harsher sentences,
which I'm for, by the way. What this bill attempts to do is to pull out the most well-behaved of inmates, which are known as Class 1, so that is the cream of the crop as far as behavior-wise, and add some additional good time for that behavior. and just want to give you just very quickly and again I'll try to make this as quick as possible
but this is class one only I want to make sure that everyone understands that secondly there is presently a rule that because already and and some of this I'm learning but already there's a one-for-one program in prison where if you get served and again I can be corrected on this by some of our people that are here, but the way I understand it, one-for-one works where
if you get a 30-year sentence, pretty much that sentence is reduced to 15 years as far as actual time served. Then on top of that is the good time. Now, the good time section states that, and I believe that's 12-29-202-D2, states that with your one-for-one and then with your good time, you could not exceed 50%. And that's kept intact.
What this good time is for, again, for class one only, it would, and just trying to figure it up, if an inmate did everything that is included in here, it would reduce their sentence by probably two, two-and-a-half years at the max, maybe three at the very most additional. But I think there's something much more important that this does here. I believe that, again, this is for Class I only, not for Class II, not Class III.
Also, Class I would have to be Class I for six months before they could get this additional good time. And also there is provisions made in here that if there's a sexual-related disciplinary violation, if there's a possession of illegal substance or contraband, smuggling or trading contraband, green money, or an attempted escape, then they lose all that good time
that they have accumulated under this provision. And so just estimating with some of the numbers that I've heard, there's 18,000 inmates. If 1% were to, and I figured roughly two, but if 1% were to take advantage of this program or this law, it could save the state about $4 million. If 2%, it would save us about $8 million.
And, again, these are inmates that are on their very best behavior. Again, we have looked at it. I am a strong proponent of the death penalty. I'm a strong proponent of you do the crime, you do the time. And so this good time is already there. What I'm doing is enhancing the good time for the class one inmates. And hopefully these people. And I think one of the main things, and I'll close with this, that this does is, I believe, build some morale for some people that maybe are seven or eight years out.
And if you'll look very quickly, if you'll look at, I believe it's on page two, there are times that have given, there's a lot of leeway given to leadership as far as how they adjust this. But it's things like not using infirmary for, you know, just to be using it, not abusing the infirmary, completing vocational programs, and getting their GED, et cetera, et cetera. I would say this.
We really need to do one or two things if we put people into these programs and then trying to get them to get vocation, to get these things. but I believe there needs to be some sense and find the balance between justice and then also giving them opportunity a little daylight is what this does and again it just adjusts the good time notorious good time that was established many many years ago and with that I'm happy to answer any questions
I don't see any questions I don't believe anybody has signed up to speak for or against the bill. I do have a question. Is there anybody from the Department of Corrections here? I guess I might have a question or two for the department. No one wants to answer mine.
I'm still due on the job, so I'm hearing somebody who might know something. Okay, sounds good. Thank
you, and if each of you would just state your name so that we can have that for the record. I'm Kathy Fry. I'm the public information officer for ADC. I'm Mike Carraway. I'm the assistant director at Arkansas Department of Correction.
Okay. Does ADC have an official position on this bill? No. No. And I guess with regard to some of the other things that have been proposed this session that are being worked on, does this bill have any negative consequence as to the application of some of those things, particularly with what the governor is proposing? I don't think so, no. We can't think of anything, no.
my head, I don't know the answer to that. Well, do you have a, I mean, is it roughly half of them? Less than half? More than half? Probably about 30% maybe. Is that too high? More? 40? 50? So approaching 50% are Class 1, and who determines that classification? That's determined at the units, based on their behavior and all that, by the Wardens and Classification Committee.
eligible for Class I status? None that
a Class I status could apply to someone who's convicted of murder? Yes. A rapist?
Yes. A drug offense? Yes. I mean, the crime has no bearing. I guess it might be taken into
account, but there's no crime that's precluded from being classified as a Class 1
or having a person identify as a Class 1 inmate. That's correct, and
they actually get their class based on their behavior. They're the worst-behaved ones you'll find that are a Class 4, and if they go over a period of time and they behave and there's no disciplinaries and they're carrying out their job assignments and all that, They move up when they go before the classification committee each time, move up in class until they get up to be a 1B or a 1C. Does their conviction or past criminal history have a bearing on their classification?
When they originally arrive at the Department of Corrections, they come in as a Class 2 inmate, which on calculating their good time
and all that, when they come in as Class 2, they get 20 days good time for every 30 days served. Now, when they move to a Class I, they get 30 days for every 30 days served. If they go down and they commit a disciplinary and get moved to a Class III, they get 10 days good time for every 30 days served. And if they continue down the
level to a Class IV, they don't get any good time.
Okay, and as I understand this bill, the various classifications, there's already good time awarded for time served. This bill, in particular, would award blocks of good time, whether it's 90 days or 180 days, based on the completion of certain programs or obtaining a GED or other specific programs. Is that correct, Representative Copeland, just to make sure that I'm on the same page? Yes, sir. Okay. Any questions from the committee? Representative Ballinger, do you have a question?
Thank you, Mr. Chair. And you may have
got to the answer that I'm looking for, but essentially what I wanted to make sure is that this is something that you all could carry out, that the functioning of this would fit into the systems that we have now. I mean, I assume that's correct. That's correct. I mean, right now they get good time based on several different factors out there, different programs. They get some good time. But what the law does is evidently when you get down to the end of the sentence, like you said,
But if an inmate had, say, a 30-year sentence and
they had to serve a half before parole, they would have to serve 15 years. Well, the most good time that they could have to accomplish that would be seven and a half years. They'll still have to serve seven and a half years
of their sentence based on the statute. Thank you. Representative Bennett, you're recognized for a question. I just have two questions, if I might.
One, there's a section, I believe it's, let's see, it's which section of this? This is on page 2, line 17, about not abusing infirmary privileges. Do you think that this might create a situation where people will avoid going to the infirmary if they truly are sick no and if I might the follow-up the other question is so
if I'm understanding what you're saying correctly even if we implement this they still cannot have their sentence reduced by more than 50 percent which is in another statutory provision is that right this could actually end up providing more good time on the books for the inmate than they're going to be able to ever use, but that's not necessarily a bad thing.
Okay. See no further questions. No one has signed up to speak for or against the bill. Representative Copeland, are you closed for your bill? Thank you. I did want to mention that I had
just ran this by some people in different areas, so it wasn't just kind of a solo act.
And it felt like the biggest part of this, and the director mentioned a little bit about that there is a chance that they actually could build more good time than they could actually use. But I believe morale is a huge factor for
our prison inmates, but more importantly probably for our guards and everybody there. But, you know, we constantly are talking about trying to create ways to release the log jam. And I said, and I know you've heard me say this multiple times, and I'll close,
but I feel like this is important. I almost brought him with me today, but I didn't do that. But I recently hired a guy that I've known for some time, and he spent 20 years in prison. He's probably one of the best employees I've ever had. I've had other employees that were inmates, and it didn't end so well. My best friend's daughter was murdered and dumped in the bayou.
And so I find myself in between two straights in that I feel very strongly in punishment. I feel very strongly in that people need to serve their time. But this is something we already have. This is adding a little bit for those people that are doing the right things, trying their best to do their very best. And I don't pretend that this is easy. I don't pretend that it's something that is easy finding that balance,
but I'm hoping this is something that finds that balance, and I appreciate a good vote, and I do make a motion for do pass. Okay, we have a motion, do pass. Any discussion? All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? No. The ayes have it. You've passed your bill. Members, we're going to come back after session this afternoon
and take up a few more bills, and so with that, we will be adjourned.
Agenda
SB79
HB1529
HB1488
HB1626
SB261
SB58
SB262
HB1505
HB1625
SB464
SB529
HB1450
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Matthew J. Shepherd Chair
Unverified
Speaker 7
Meredith Lowry
Unverified
Joe Briggs
Unverified
Representative Bob Ballinger
Unverified
Representative Sue Scott
Unverified
Representative Rick Beck
Unverified
Representative David Whitaker Chair
Unverified
Representative Mary Broadaway
Unverified
Speaker 52
Speaker 61
Representative Camille Bennett
Unverified
Russell Winburn
Unverified
Chair
Unverified
Representative R. Trevor Drown
Unverified
Representative Tim Lemons
Unverified
Representative Donnie Copeland
Unverified
Representative Douglas House
Unverified
Lindsay Bailey
Unverified
Speaker 147
Senator Jeremy Hutchinson
Unverified
Representative John T. Vines
Unverified
Speaker 181
Speaker 130
Speaker 185
Representative Michelle Gray
Unverified
Representative Dwight Tosh
Unverified
Michael Moats
Unverified
Speaker 207
Speaker 215
Speaker 217
Barbara Williams
Unverified
Speaker 243