Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House Public Health, Welfare and Labor Committee

March 12, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (6)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
SB426 · 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB426”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1747 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1747”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1142 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1142”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1533 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1533”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1609 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1609”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1636 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1636”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 15, 2026
We need a bigger gavel. All right, welcome to the Health Committee. Members, grab a seat. Yeah. I'm trying
▶ Play
Speaker 3 0:11
to see a quorum. I'm going to look pretty hard.
▶ Play
I see one, yeah. All right, we got, well, I know we have three special orders business, but we have our chair of education is here. Representative Cozart, if you would, let's run your bill first so we can get you back to your committee, respective committee. And you're actually running John Wood's bill, Senate bill. Tell me the number of that if you're good again. 426. 426. It's up toward the top of the agenda members. So we're going to hit First Hill here, Senate Bill 426. Representative Cozart, you're recognized. For your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I have along with me today is Bill Rochelle,
▶ Play
and if we need to ask questions or answer questions, he may have to chime in on this a little bit, if you don't mind, sir. What this is, is it's to create a fair and open competition, the Governmental Construction Act, and it's your fairness in governmental construction contracts. This is a fair bill. What it basically refers back to is, if I can find my notes here, is a proclamation that Governor Huckabee did back in 2005, and it just states that it's a level playing field for union and non-union contractors, and that's basically what this bill is all about. It was passed out of the Senate unanimously, pretty close. I say perclose. I doubt if it went out unanimously, but there was no opposition to it, and there's no opposition here today against us that we know of, and I'd be glad to answer any questions if you need me to. Hi, members. You've heard a brief explanation
▶ Play
of the bill. I'm still trying to pull the bill up myself. Sir, Representative Meeks, if you'll start us with a question. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chair. I mean, it looks like basically what this bill does is it scratches out $20,000 and it puts $50,000 in. No, not the right bill. That's
▶ Play
Senator Hendricks' bill. This should be Senate Bill 426. I've just now got it
▶ Play
pulled up for a representative of me. This is 426. My tablet wasn't behaving very well. And I don't have a question yet, Mr. Chair. Okay. I'm good. Yeah, shut the program down, open it. It's going well. All right, members, any questions on this? Rep. Lundstrom, you're recognized. What
▶ Play
does this change from current law right now? What specific thing are we targeting in this bill? If you
▶ Play
would, first recognize yourself for the record and introduce yourself, and then you're recognized to
▶ Play
Speaker 25 3:31
give testimony. Thank you. Yes, sir. Bill Rochelle, Executive Director for Associated Builders and Contractors of Arkansas. And what this bill does is, like Representative Cozart said, is it codifies an executive order signed by Governor Mike Huckabee, kept in place by Governor Beebe. and basically it just deals with fairness in construction contracts that, you know, either union or non-union contractor can be on construction contracts on state-funded or state-assisted projects.
▶ Play
All right, so we're codifying what was an executive order for the past six, eight years. Past ten years. And we're putting that in statute. Members, any other questions? Seeing or hearing none, is there anybody from the audience would like to speak for or against this bill? Seeing or hearing none, are you closed for your bill, Representative Cozart? Yes, we're closed. We appreciate a good vote. What's the will of the committee? Motion due passed. We have a motion due passed. Representative Wardlaw. Is there any discussion of that motion? Seeing none, all in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Your bill is passed. Thank you, Representative Cozart. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee. All right. Representative Vaught. this also is supposed to be a fairly brief bill that we heard sort of heard the other day as it was and tell us that bill number again thank you
▶ Play
Mr. Chair it's 1609 I can't remember your name and I have Miss Sue Tedford with me at the end of the table also to answer any hard questions I think
▶ Play
there may be an amendment on the tablet. Is that right? It should be engrossed in the bill. It is engrossed. You amended it on the floor. Very good. All right. So you're
▶ Play
introduced to present your bill as amended. Thank you, Mr. Chair. This is just to clarify collaborating physician. By adding physician, practicing physician to line 24, it clarifies who they can practice under. Under the law it is right now, it's a brick and mortar. They have to have brick and mortar. And we're trying to allow where physicians who are semi-retired, who work maybe in an ER or something, can actually have someone collaborate underneath him. This in no way changes any practices that's taken place.
▶ Play
Representative Ferguson, you sort of had an issue whether this was scope of practice or not last time they were here. Has her amendment fixed that for you? Yes, I appreciate the nursing
▶ Play
board and the medical board got together, and I appreciate your cooperation. I'm completely supportive of the bill now. Thank you. members any questions seeing none is there
▶ Play
anyone for the audience speak for or against this bill seeing none are you closed for your bill representing Vaught yes sir and we have motion from representing Wardlaw for due pass is that correct any discussion of the motion all in favor say aye any opposed and your bill is passed thank you seems like there was one other person that said if they were here could run it before i don't see anybody else so we're going to go into our special order of business first up is representative sullivan with the house bill 1747 while they're coming to the table members i'll tell you what's going on here this is going to be a little a little procedural issue there's been a challenge to this bill not on scope of practice but we have a joint rule if I can get right to the part of it that says here about licensure and it's a joint house and senate rule the senate was supposed to have heard this bill yesterday and there was a challenge there and they determined that it is a licensure bill which has to be filed within the first 15 days of the calendar and I'm going to let Representative Sullivan sort of introduce the bill and then I believe we have someone from the medical board that may give us some insight of why this could be or is considered their opinion is considered a licensure bill. Because it's special We've had people come from literally Virginia and Tennessee to speak on this. If I decide it is a licensure bill and Representative Sullivan can then challenge that to the speaker, we're still going to hear the testimony today because they've come a long way. They've spent several nights to be here. We're at least going to hear the testimony so that if the Rules Committee or however this decision comes about, they won't have to come back and we'll be able to vote on the bill. But the point of it is, after we hear a little bit of this, and if I decide that I think that it's a licensure bill, we're still going to hear it, but I won't hear a motion for a vote. I think you understand that's where we're at, Representative Sullivan. Yes, Mr. Speaker, and I appreciate that.
▶ Play
We'll go through it pretty quickly so that they can testify. I know there's a long calendar today. We'll try to move as quickly
▶ Play
as we can. I would like to hear, just for my sake, is it Kevin O'Dwyer, Medical Board Attorney? And if you would set just one of these chairs kind of toward the end, anywhere that you can get a microphone, introduce yourself for the record, and if you would tell this committee and myself how this could be, that we might consider this as a licensure bill.
▶ Play
Speaker 51 9:30
Kevin O'Dwyer, I represent the Arkansas State Medical Board. The board has a, there are statutes that allow the medical board to enact rules. that define the practice of medicine in Arkansas. Rule 2.8 specifically deals with how a physician-patient relationship is established, and the board, and I could read the portion of that rule, requiring minimum standards for establishing physician-patient relationship. a physician exhibits gross negligence if he provides and or recommends any form of treatment including prescribing legend drugs without first establishing a proper physician-patient relationship for the purpose of this regulation a proper physician-patient relationship at a minimum requires that one, the physician performs a history and physical examination of the patient adequate to establish a diagnosis and identify underlying conditions to the treatment and it goes on but basically the board has historically and traditionally viewed the performance of a history and physical as an in-person physical exam it has reviewed a number of different models dealing with telemedicine and thus far the problem the board has is that it would be violation of our practice act for a physician to treat let alone prescribe medication to a patient that they have not physically seen. Representative Sullivan would if
▶ Play
your bill would pass would it allow interaction I guess without a patient ever having been physically seen? You know I'm going to let my some of the
▶ Play
witnesses that I have with me explain that if that's okay. That'd be good and again I don't want to have
▶ Play
a long debate in here whether this can be voted on a herd today or not I just want to hear a little bit so I can have some sense of my determination let me just make a real short opening
▶ Play
statement about two or three sentences first of all committee we realize we're breaking new ground and the the key word that was just mentioned I think is historically historically we've always done things in one paradigm and we are offering a new paradigm to the state of Arkansas one that is practiced in I think 40 or so other states. So I think when we talk about 2.8 and the proper relationship, we're certainly saying there are other ways of doing that. And I just ask the committee to keep an open mind that we're offering something new and different and making some historical changes. And let's look at what we're doing based upon that. And with that, I'll let one my witnesses introduce themselves and speak to the speaker's point. Yes, sir. Good morning. It's truly an honor to
▶ Play
Speaker 59 12:36
be here. I'm a physician and not an attorney and prior to taking my position at Teladoc, I have had no legislative experience, so forgive me if I misstep. My name is Dr. Henry DeFillips. I am a board-certified family physician. I've been in the healthcare industry for 30 years. I actually drove six hours from my home in Franklin, Tennessee, right next door where i'm licensed but not in practice as far as the the issue on the table mr o'dwyer and i have had two conversations one was about a year and a half ago the other was about five minutes ago and you'll hear through the testimony that we agree to disagree on a couple of issues um the the um it around the year 2000 or so many of you probably remember the internet prescribing challenges and at that time a lot of the state medical boards enacted the prior in-person visit requirement which mr o'dwyer accurately described as a way to get rid of or eliminate those internet prescribing things where you fill out a questionnaire and a prescription is sent to your house illegal should be illegal glad that's out of business that's bad medicine if you fast forward 15 years not only has technology improved dramatically and changed all of our lives how many people had one of these in 2000 nobody because they didn't exist But the second thing that's happened is a lot of the medical specialty societies have come up with clinical practice guidelines that are done by outstanding experts in the field. I can give you a specific example. The American Urological Association and the Infectious Disease Society of America both have clinical practice guidelines that allow, if the right guardrails are in place in a specific clinical setting, the remote treatment of a urinary tract infection, and even the beginning of antibiotics in certain scenarios, and that's an accepted medical practice. The current medical board rule that dates back to that time frame I talked about doesn't allow that to happen. In Arkansas, there is a huge demand and supply issue for primary care services. The majority of the state is designated as a medically underserved area, and telemedicine is not the practice of medicine. Telemedicine is a tool used in the practice of medicine. Same doctors, same knowledge base, same range of diagnoses and treatments, but sometimes they'll use a stethoscope to get information. Sometimes they'll use a blood pressure cuff to get information. Now they can use a telephone or a video connection in conjunction with a medical record and some high-definition photographs to get information. There's a limited subset of diagnoses, common uncomplicated medical problems, where that's totally appropriate. And the specialty societies will indicate that, and I can provide some of those guidelines to this group if that's of desire. Mr. O'Dwyer and I are going to disagree on a number of things, but the bottom line is you could double or triple the number of primary care physicians in this state and still not even come close to keeping up with the demand for primary care services.
▶ Play
Mr. DePhillips? Yes, sir. I see where your testimony is going, and I get that. And I think it's going to be a great concept. Currently, the way I see it, our licensure law is X. I understand we might think it should not be X, but it is X, as explained. And I think that this bill does, will want to either change or affect the licensure. And so I don't think that I want to hear a motion on it today, but I think it is really good testimony. I think we'll want to continue hearing testimony, but I am going to ask Mr. Speaker to, you know, either confirm me or whatever, but I don't want to take a motion on it today for a vote. But you guys have come a long ways. I think it's a good bill to hear, and I want the committee to hear this bill today. But if the committee is okay with hearing it, moving forward, I will not accept the motions. With the will of this committee, we'll hear this bill. Okay. Very good. good um mr mr o'dwyer thank you for that you're you're fine to go we're not gonna but you know we're gonna hang around but you don't need to be at the table with us but all right uh with that representative sullivan you understand we're i want to hear we want to hear the testimony we think this is this is good information but we're not why i don't think we can take a vote because of the rules i agree mr speaker and i appreciate that thank you all right so would you like We can continue right where we left off. It's fine. It was good testimony. It just wasn't really changing my mind about whether this was licensure or not. Great. Then
▶ Play
I'll proceed to let our expert talk about what the impact that this bill can have on medical care in Arkansas. And, again, I hope we'll consider that there's a paradigm to be protected, and we are offering a new opportunity. This bill offers a new opportunity, and we can change from things looking at what we've done historically and perpetuating that, which perpetuates the problems that we are associated with that, or we can look to change this historically and do medicine in new ways, as many other states are doing. And with that, I'll turn it back to
▶ Play
Speaker 59 17:46
our witness. Thank you, Representative Sullivan, and thank you, Mr. Chairman, for the opportunity to speak today. Yes, sir. I have some specific points I want to make, a little bit of color around them, but I'll try to be very efficient with my comments. First, I'm going to start with the history. So I'm the corporate chief medical officer. I'm a board-certified family physician. I'm the corporate chief medical officer for a company called Teladoc. Teladoc is the nation's oldest, largest, and by any measure, most successful primary care telemedicine company in the U.S. We currently have about 12 million Americans in our program. That's almost 5% of the U.S. population. And we have been in business for 13 years. We've done over 700,000 remote medical consultations for common uncomplicated medical problems, and we cover the liability insurance for all the physicians who work with us, and not once in the history of the company has there ever been a medical liability claim filed against our carrier in the 13-year history of the company. I think that data point alone speaks to the safety of the program when the proper guardrails are in place, which I will certainly get to. From a historical perspective, Mr. O'Dwyer's legal opinion appears to be that our business is not allowed under the rules. Our attorneys have read the rules, including cross-coverage exceptions and other things like that. I am not an attorney, but our attorney's opinion is that our business model is legal under the current rules in the state. We operated here for several years. We discontinued operations in November of 2014 because the medical board began to take action against the licenses of the physicians who are physically in Arkansas, by the way, who were doing telemedicine. And so rather than jeopardize their livelihood, we withdrew the operation from the state in November of 2014. At that time, 70,000 Arkansans lost the primary care telemedicine benefit. Employees of Cargill, Car Mart, and Golden Living were in there. And we also are fortunate that a lot of the Fortune 1000 companies work with us. So Home Depot, Costco, a lot of the nationals that you visit every day, those employees in this state also lost that benefit at that time. So we're at a bit of an impasse. I have attempted on three occasions to meet with the medical board in person and just present what I'm about to present here today and Mr. O'Dwyer on behalf of the medical board has refused that invitation on three occasions. I have sent paperwork across and he will accurately testify that he has provided the paperwork to the board members. My opinion is that's not the same thing as hearing about it in a conversation like this. So that's sort of the history. Just another quick background on the company. Let me share with you what some of the guardrails are. So in primary care telemedicine, first of all, our model is that we've done business in all 50 states, and I'll get back to that in a moment. We have physicians who are licensed in and physically present in every one of the states. We do agree with the medical board that the care should be local within the state. And all the medical boards beyond Arkansas are of the opinion that the care of the citizens of the state should stay with physicians in the state. Our model accommodates that. So we have Arkansas physicians who work with us, not at the moment, but they did up until November. The second thing is we have a series of evidence-based clinical practice guidelines for the remote treatment of these common uncomplicated medical problems that are based on a review of the world's medical literature. I cited the urinary tract infection example. I have 103 more. I won't bore you with them. But those guidelines form the backbone of the training for the telemedicine program for the physicians as well as for the quality assurance oversight program. Did they diagnose and treat properly within the guidelines? Every physician is at liberty to refer a patient to an in-person visit. There's no financial incentive. If there's anything about the history or the evaluation of the patient that's questionable, the docs are at liberty to refer in person. That happens 4% of the time. I would think it would be higher, but I think our marketing team does a very good job of educating the employees of the companies about what's appropriate and what's not appropriate for a remote telemedicine visit. Let's see, what else? Guardrails. I think that's about it on guardrails. So let's move to patient safety because the most important thing is patient safety. My job as chief medical officer is to be responsible that the highest quality of clinical care happen in that 8 to 11 minute encounter between the physician and the patient. Our physicians have an average of 15 years of experience in bricks and mortar practice. Minimum requirement is five. So we tend to attract physicians who are at the peak of their career or sort of in the second half of their career. They want to augment their practice. They want to leverage themselves. They love the extra stream of income and so our docs seem to be pretty happy doing this patient satisfaction is off as you can imagine off the charts picture yourself as a mom three kids one of them gets sick guess what you don't have to put all three of them in the car take them to the office some things can safely be treated remotely from home I talked about the history and not having a single liability claim so I think the data is pretty clear on patient safety what our business model does is it solves an access issue and Arkansas has an access issue that's at least as big as any other state's access issue mostly in in rural areas where there's not broadband there's not there you know there are several counties in this state that don't even have a primary care physician in the county there are many more that may have one primary care physician in the entire county the alternative is either no care or go to a high cost setting which if is which is the emergency room or an urgent care center if there is one but for the types of things that we treat those settings are so expensive and the medical system just can't afford that cost, specifically the state Medicaid programs, cannot continue to shoulder that burden. So for $40, regardless of the reason for presentation and regardless how long the encounter takes, the persons who are responsible for shouldering the cost of care can provide access to the employees and to the patients or members of the health plan in this way when it's appropriate. So there's a couple of studies that have come out. One is the RAND Corporation in the February edition of Health Affairs of February 2014, so about a year ago, that specifically talked about how behavior, how patients behave with and without a telemedicine benefit. And the bottom line from that study was two major things. First of all, it clearly replaced visiting the emergency room nights and weekends when you did not have an emergency issue. That was 34% of visits in the telemedicine group where telemedicine visits and the same 34% in the comparison group went to the emergency room for sinus infections and the things at a significantly higher cost. The second thing is, and there's actually a line in there, and the RAND Corporation, if you know them well, is a very conservative group. They actually have a phrase in there that said that, and this is adventurous for them, that telemedicine appears to be a safe alternative to access care. That's huge for them to say that. A Harvard Medical School researcher is publishing a very similar design, only instead of following patient behavior, he's following the dollar. I'll save you the data. If you want to see it, I'll share it with you, but I'll cut to the chase. The cut to the chase is that, and they went to our clients. They didn't even work with us on this. Home Depot and Rent-A-Center were the two clients they studied. For every telemedicine consultation on the part of an employee, $727 was the medical cost savings relative to the weighted average cost of all of the other alternatives for care for those exact same patients, for those exact same medical problems. That dollar figure even astounds me, and I'm the chief medical officer of the company. That's an amount of money that no one can afford to ignore. So patient safety, access, and then cost savings. I will tell you that the companies that have used our program, some of which in Arkansas historically have used our program, at the end of the first year, they see a reduction in their emergency room costs for non-emergency visits. If the CEO for Home Depot was sitting here, which I wish he was, he would sing the praises of this. He loves it for his employees at Home Depot. And I guess the last thing I'll share is I took my position as chief medical officer of this company 21 months ago because I really believed in the mission. I'm a family practitioner. I practiced for 10 years in private practice. I made house calls. I delivered babies. I saw people in person. Fast forward several years. I'm quite a bit older now. And I got to tell you that this is a high quality. I would not attach my own personal reputation to this program it's a very mission-based company none of our executives have any interest in cutting corners even at the board and investor level everyone is interested in the highest quality medical care and it's that mission basis that allowed me to take this position I have to tell you that it's a phenomenal solution to a huge and growing problem all of the Medicaid directors in every state that I testify in as soon as they hear this they seek me out and they say work out your issues with the Medical Board or whatever and then come and find me because we have to offer this benefit to our Medicaid population and I do plan to do that here if we're able to operate. Lastly, Mr. O'Dwyer, I don't know if he's gonna speak today or down the road, but you're gonna hear a number of things that are in just pretty, that disagree with what I'm saying so let me just give you a couple of data points. The Medical Board in Arkansas is a member of the Federation of State Medical Boards. All medical boards are members. They actually passed a model regulation that some states are adopting at this point. And in that model regulation, it was agreed to unanimously by the board of the Federation of State Medical Boards. There is actually a provision in there that says a prior in-person visit is not required to establish a physician-patient relationship for the purpose of a telemedicine consult. The second data point that I'll share with you is the AMA, American Medical Association, has a position paper that says the exact same thing. I will be glad to share that with the folks in this room at your request. The third thing I'll share with you is there is no, as a physician, we're outcomes folks. Why do we recommend a beta blocker after a heart attack? Because the data is really clear that the patients who receive it will have a lot longer than the patients who don't. That's the data we look at. There is absolutely no patient-oriented outcomes data that demonstrates that a patient following after a telemedicine consult has a superior outcome if they did have a prior in-person visit with their PCP than if they did not there is no data that supports that contention and lastly 50 percent of the 12 million Americans that use our service don't have a PCP what are they supposed to do they've never had a prior in-person visit because I don't have a doc does that mean we turn them away does that mean we say find an emergency room drive somewhere go without care that's the other option I think I'll stop there our vice president of government affairs Claudia I'm sure I've left some things out, and I'm very grateful for the time, and I hope I
▶ Play
didn't take too long. Members, what I'd like to do is if anybody has any questions right now while it's still fresh, then we'll move on to Ms. Claudia. Representative McGee, you have a question. You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I find that I'm a physician also, so I find this a pretty exciting thing for medicine. Thank you. Whether we do it your way or another way or however, but I I think, as you said, things are changing rapidly, and in our own practices, I mean, we use these to take pictures of people and send them to other doctors. Now, whether the patient can take the picture and send it to me and I can tell anything, I don't know. But I do have some questions that you mentioned a minute ago about states that are beginning to adopt telemedicine rule and regulation. What's the number of those states? I mean, is it on the table in 25 states, or they've already adopted it in how many states?
▶ Play
Speaker 59 29:15
that sort of thing so i'm gonna that's an excellent question by the way our platform allows patients to shoot high definition photographs goes on the medical record gets displayed to the doc it's awesome people shoot pictures of their eyes their throats their skin whatever no inappropriate pictures yet by the way um so i'm gonna you're i'm gonna answer your question two ways so those pictures go on the cloud forever you know behind our firewall security wise okay okay um so i'm gonna answer your question two ways number one is um our attorneys looked at the laws and regulations in all 50 states, and our attorney's opinion is that our model is legal. As you know, the regulations are deep. There's exceptions. There's amendments, and so I don't know the legal background. Our attorney's opinion is we're legal in all 50 states, including this state, so we have an agreement. We agree to disagree with the medical board's opinion that our model is illegal. We are currently fully operational in 48 of the 50 states. Idaho is the other one where we're not operational, and they just passed a bicameral bill two days ago that's going to go to the governor that will allow us back in that state. So as of July 1st, if things stay on their current course, Arkansas will be the only state that our company is not able to operate in. That's the real world answer. I'm going to turn it over to our Vice President of Government Affairs to answer how
▶ Play
Speaker 83 30:29
many states have a legislation answer. Thank you, Dr. DePhillips. I'm Claudia Tucker, Vice President of Government Affairs for Teladoc. And that's a great question, and you hear a lot of different answers, but I want to separate truth from fiction here. Currently, 38 states have telemedicine laws on their books. 21 have telemedicine parity, which means that the docs get paid for telemedicine just as they would if it were an in-person visit. Telemedicine proposals that are in the states this year, 2015, there are five of those. Telemedicine regulation and legislation in 2015, there are nine of those. Now, let's talk about, like, interactive audio or audio. Sixteen states currently have interactive audio on their books. Six have audio, which is even more permissive. And 16 states have technology neutral in their definition, which means that they understand technology is moving very quickly. And what we're seeing in the states, whether it be statutes or whether it be regulation, is the statutes and the regulations are here. Technology has surged ahead. Technology is out here. And so what we're seeing now is that synchronization and trying to catch up to technology. And if I may, going back to the licensure and what we were originally here for, yesterday I was prepared to defend scope of practice, and it's kind of been all over the board here. So today we come in, and the challenge is licensure. And I would just say I'm not a doctor, nor am I an attorney, but I am a policy person if licensure is what's before us today, our doctors are licensed. They're licensed just like you are, sir. They're licensed in Arkansas. They are residents of Arkansas. So if our sticking point today is licensure not a different kind of licensure not an additional licensure, but licensure we're there. We are there solid. Thank
▶ Play
you One follow up Thank you, Mr. Chair I understand it's a rapidly evolving field, but I've also read that there have been potential suits by the state of Texas against the corporation. Could you comment on
▶ Play
Speaker 59 32:46
that? I'll be glad to. It's actually the other way around. So the Texas Medical Board took action to attempt to prevent our company from doing business in the state of Texas. All of this information is in the public domain, so anything I say, you can verify or validate. It goes before my time, but I do know the history. So in 2011, we actually filed suit against the Texas Medical Board, and the basis of the suit was that they didn't follow their own policy on how to implement a new rule. I'm going to save you a whole lot of pain and money and legal bills and just cut to the chase. On December 31st of this year, at the appeals court level, the court decided in summary judgment in our favor. And if you're an attorney, you know what summary judgment means. Every aspect was decided our way. Since then, there is a rulemaking process that we're involved with. They have now initiated a process where they do follow, you know, the correct procedure based on the court's input that they're attempting. So Texas is one of the other states, no doubt, where the medical board is just very resistant to allowing telemedicine to happen in the state. Basically, any medical board that says there has to be a prior in-person visit guts the ability of any telemedicine company to make the offering because in a telemedicine world, there's no physical way to allow the telemedicine docs to have a prior in-person visit with the patients who receive care remotely. So basically what the medical board is saying is we don't want telemedicine in the state. When you hear prior in-person visit, that's what you should think of. As I said, there are very few states whose opinion is that way. The last thing I was going to mention is that the Arkansas Medical Board, ultimately through our, you know, we tried to work with them first, and we wound up here. Part of the reason we wound up here is because there was a communication with our attorney that basically said, the Arkansas Medical Board is not going to take up this issue. So if you want to resolve this issue, you need to do it through the legislature. And so that is the reason why we are here in front of you today, because we're instructed by the medical board that they're not going to take it up.
▶ Play
Speaker 83 34:49
Okay. And if I may add one more thing, excuse me. The states that I've named out and the numbers that I've put out as far as having telemedicine laws on the books, obviously that didn't add up to 15. The delta between those are those states that are actually silent on the issue. They haven't even started to address it yet, recognizing that it is an issue. And they are calling people like us to help them develop the policy because they would rather get it right than go back and have to redo it. Thank you. Representative McGee,
▶ Play
I'm going to move on to Representative Wardlaw. I'll come back to you in a moment. Representative Wardlaw, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Out of those 70,000 or 80,000 patients you talked about at these employers in Arkansas, what's the percentage of those that were actual patients of your guys before you pulled out of Arkansas? So all of them
▶ Play
Speaker 59 35:39
were a sponsored-only program, right? So the employer or the health plan buys it, and then the employees and the members get the benefits. So all 70,000 were enrolled and loaded into the platform, and we were ready to receive a call from them any time they got sick. Is your question how many had actually used the service? Yes, sir. Oh, okay. So our utilization ranges. It depends on, you know, the benefit structure. If the co-pay is low, you get more. But our utilization range is as high as 40%. So, you know, guesstimating, I would say probably 20% of them had the opportunity to use the service, so probably about 14,000 I think is a good number. I may be a little bit off, but in order of magnitude, that's going to be utilization. And that's only for
▶ Play
Speaker 83 36:16
Teladoc. We're not speaking for any of the other multiple companies that do this.
▶ Play
So if a company purchases this service, are their employees forced to use this, or are they still allowed to go see a PCP?
▶ Play
Speaker 59 36:30
Oh, no, this is just, and that's a very good question. And the answer is no, they're not forced at all. Basically, the way that the benefit is positioned, and our marketing materials are really clear, is if you're sick, go to your PCP. We really work hard to maintain that existing relationship. We send a copy of the record back to the PCP, et cetera, et cetera. And so the marketing material says, if you're sick, go to your PCP. If you can't get to your PCP timely for one of these common uncomplicated medical problems, Teladoc is another option. It's a tool in your toolbox. It's one of the rest of the choices that you can make. And so people choose to use it. Other people choose not to use it. What's interesting is about 40 percent of all of our consults are repeat users. So it seems to be when people try it the first time, they like it and they tend to use it or their family members tend to use it again. But it's not mandatory. Thank you. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chair. Yes, sir. Representative McGee, we're back to you, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair. So tell me how this works from a patient standpoint. The individual, are you contracting with companies to provide the services? or insurance companies, or do you contract with individuals? Do you have individuals? If I'm an individual and I want to be a member of Teladoc, can I pay you a fee and access your
▶ Play
Speaker 59 37:49
physicians? We are a sponsored-only program, not a direct-to-consumer program. There are other companies that are offering direct-to-consumer. The market isn't there yet. The consumers aren't looking for this on their own. So our clients that we sell to are employers, health plans, and hospital systems, and I named some of the employers in the state who have purchased our service. And then the employees or the members of the health plan or the employees of the hospital system then get access to the benefit. So it's a sponsored-only program. The way it actually works is there's two parts to the process. One is the consult request process, and then the other is the actual interaction between the physician and the patient. And if it's okay, I'll take one moment to describe that. So the consult request process, we give consumers a choice. You need to meet consumers where they are to get the kind of utilization that we see. So you can literally make a phone call and speak to a live person, and they'll collect all the information. Or you can go online, and we have apps in the App Store, and you can use any device and fill out the information. The information is really important. You're required to fill out an electronic health record before your first consult. There has to be an established medical record in our program that's shared between the physician and the patient before any medical care can happen. We need to know your past history, medications, medical problems, surgeries, allergies, all the things that are important to know. That's required. Patients can't get to a doc without it. The doc can't get to the patient without having reviewed it. By the way, that medical record is where all the high-definition photographs go when people shoot their pink eye or shoot the back of their throat or shoot a mole and send it in to us with a camera. So the first is the consult request. We have four different specialties of board-certified U.S. family physicians, excuse me, U.S.-based physicians, family physicians like myself, pediatricians, internal medicine docs, and emergency room docs. We currently don't offer mid-levels. There's no regulatory reason why we can't, but there are plenty of docs interested in doing this, and we have a full network at this point. And so then the physician reviews the information, and then again, it's patient choice. Do you want a video consult, or do you want to talk to the doc on the phone? 95% of consumers who, and everybody's got a smartphone, select the phone. I have no idea why that is, but that's what they pick. I guess think about the last 10 phone calls each of you made, how many were video calls? That's sort of the example, I guess, that I would use. And then once they establish the connection with the physician, eight to 11 minutes of real-time interaction, all the questions get answered to the satisfaction of the doc. If the doc has any concerns, either about the record, the picture, or what he's hearing or seeing on the phone or the video, fully at liberty to refer the patient to an inpatient setting. That happens part of the time, and it's fine with us when it does. And I think that's why the program is safe and then you get a physician who's licensed my predecessor was a multi-state license fan so there are still a leftover few docs who have multiple licenses that work with us I'm moving to a model where we use 100% docs were licensed in state which is required by law but also physically present in the state which is not required but we are going the extra mile to make sure that happens so right now we're running about 70% of all consults our docs that are physically in the state and we'll drive that to a hundred over time. Once the consult is done, we use SureScripts for e-prescribing. It's the largest e-prescribed company in the world, or excuse me, in the United States. Scratch that from the record. We allow no DEA-controlled substances through the program, no lifestyle drugs, diet pills, Viagra-type pills through the program. So we have a 98% generic prescribing rate. So like generic antibiotics, allergy meds, and inhalers are our top three classes of drugs. Our overall prescribing rate is at or below the bricks and mortar average, so we don't have overprescribing. We follow CDC guidelines for antimicrobials, so we don't have antibacterial resistance or overuse. Our quality assurance program monitors 10% of all the consults that are done. We did 300,000 last year, 50,000 in December, another 50,000 in January, so clearly the market demand for this service is getting really big really fast, but that's, sorry, a little more long-winded probably than you wanted, but that's what the consult looks like from the patient standpoint. So could
▶ Play
I follow up with So the patient, he calls someone first to get, he doesn't get to the telemedicine doctor until he goes through someone else? That is correct. We
▶ Play
Speaker 59 42:03
use what's called a store and forward program. So we create the medical records, store the data like the photographs and any lab information that gets forwarded to the doctor.
▶ Play
And patients, at that point, does that person that's doing that, do they have any decision-making process as to whether or not that person is sent to the doc, or are they just getting the information and then it goes to the doc? They fill out the information, it goes
▶ Play
Speaker 59 42:24
to the doc, and every patient who requests a visit with a doctor gets a visit with a doctor. We don't have any filter on that at all. If they want a visit, they get it. Okay. So, all right.
▶ Play
But that's probably all I have right now while I'm thinking about it, Mr. Chair. I hope you
▶ Play
Speaker 59 42:45
get the feeling it's a pretty robust program. So I
▶ Play
Speaker 88 42:48
do have another question, Mr. Chair. All right.
▶ Play
Did you have a question, Representative Maysler? I do, Mr. Chair, but it may be somebody else has to actually answer that because I'm wondering, couldn't we now, via our own regulations, allow this to happen or do we actually need a law to make it happen? And the reason why I asked is because I had considered doing something with telemedicine, and I told, well, if we just get with the board, that we could potentially do it through rules or regulations based on the current statutes that we already have. Again, that may be a question that you won't be able to answer, but maybe somebody
▶ Play
Speaker 59 43:20
else can answer that for me. I'll start, and obviously my vice president, there's a lot of smart people around me, thank God. So the answer to your question is, yes, the medical board could alter their rules to allow this model in the state. The medical board here has chosen not to do that, and they seem to have their heels pretty dug in that they're going to continue to choose not to do that. That's my observation. Mr. O'Dwyer may have a different opinion, certainly entitled to it. But we're here because the board has basically said we don't plan to change it. You need to fix it with legislation, and we'll do whatever the legislature tells us is basically the message that we got. Claudia, do you have an additional?
▶ Play
Speaker 83 43:56
The only thing I would add to that is we go nationally and talk in different states and boards of medicine, and I really enjoy that work. It's kind of mission work for me. And some of them are very receptive and they want to move forward. Others, you know, call it what you will, whether it be territorial or a fear of market share loss, call it what you will, are less willing to work. All
▶ Play
right. Representative McGee, are you done? you need one more let's do one more yes sir okay thank you mr. chair for your indulgence i just find this pretty fascinating topic so so the patient kind of it's it who pays the 40 bucks
▶ Play
Speaker 59 44:38
we actually um uh the the answer is it's a combination between the patient and the sponsor so i'll give you a couple of examples in a medicaid program the medicaid program pays the whole 40 because the patient co-pay is always zero that's usually by law in the state home depot That CEO, I told you, is a fan. He basically picks up, Home Depot picks up 35 of the 40, and the co-pay for the employees is 5 because they want to incentivize use. It keeps people at work. It gets people healthy faster. It gets access. So, and then there are some companies where the patient using the service pays the whole 40. It's individual. By the way, we work with several large insurance companies, and all of them reimburse for this type of a telemedicine program. All of the insurance companies we work with, including Aetna, several of the large
▶ Play
Speaker 105 45:20
blue plans. They reimburse? Yes, sir. So, one more, Mr. Chair. I'll stay as long as you'd like. Just one more. Let's do one more. That'd
▶ Play
be fine. So, the practicing physicians that you have in these programs, the family practice doctors, the pediatricians, internal medicine, ER docs that do this, how do they negotiate rates with you? Are they working for your company, or do they get paid a certain percentage of the fees?
▶ Play
Speaker 100 45:50
do you do that different in different states i'm happy to be transparent
▶ Play
Speaker 59 45:54
no it's uniform across the entire the entire united states so of the forty dollars if it's a telephone with um image assisted consult that reimburses 23 if it's a video consult reimburses 28 we pay the extra on the video because i want to make sure they have the equipment and they're comfortable with it we want to incentivize the use as best we can those numbers may sound low but i have to tell you that there is zero overhead associated with this program. You can do it from your car. We provide the medical liability insurance. It is pure profit. So when I was in practice, I charged $55 for an office visit, which seems to be the going rate. My overhead was 55 to 60%. The net of that is $23. So it literally winds up being the same for the docs. And we have no problem recruiting docs. They volunteer. We don't force or compel. All we do is give them the opportunity. And about 20% of docs are interested, about 80% or not. And I think the challenge we have at the medical board level is the 80% making sure that the 20% can't do what they want to do. I have no problem with the 80% who don't have interest, but I would hope that the 20% who do and know how to do it safely would
▶ Play
have the opportunity to do it. Thank you so much for your comments, and thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chair, for being very diligent with my questions. Yes, sir. Representative Loeb, do you have a question? Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Sullivan, I'm going to ask you a couple of questions. Number one, do you consider
▶ Play
this a type of like a free market bill? Thank you for asking a question to me. Mr. Love. I appreciate it. It absolutely is. You know, I heard, I learned some new information today. You know, again, Arkansas ranks at 48th. Folks, it's time to get off the ranking of 48th. It's time to move away from there. And you've also heard in the last few days, professional organizations tell us how high quality their physicians were. And we heard that in the arguments the last few days. We have high-quality folks, high-quality folks, high-quality folks. Yet we hear that that same association is now challenging the professionalism of those very same doctors. And it has to make me wonder why. If they're refusing the face-to-face meetings and the discussion seems to be a big part of this, whether it's face-to-face, yet it's happening all over the nation and there's no evidence that this is being done poorly. And again, I just kind of have to question the motives of why that is happening. I can't wait for my company to explore this. We're in several locations and I hope we can do that. I think it is a free market issue. Thank you. Did I answer your question? Yes,
▶ Play
sir. Follow up. Now, based on some of the information that the gentleman gave. I did look up the statement from AMA in regards to telemedicine. And the one thing, the next question I'm going to ask you is this, is that are you just trying to promote choice, you know, options to patients, whether they want to go to brick and mortar or they want to go to telemedicine or whatever? Are you just trying to kind of give more options, more choices? Yes, sir. You've hit the nail
▶ Play
Speaker 59 48:59
on the head. It's all about just giving another option to folks who may have a challenge accessing care. Again, we recommend they go see their own PCP first every time. The bottom line is there are some logistics. Business travel, Shell Oil Company is a client. If somebody's on a platform in the Gulf for eight months, it's kind of tough to go see their PCP. So we just want to be able to create another option that's accessible, you know, patient safety
▶ Play
first, but that's accessible and affordable after patient safety is addressed. You know, I think in final close-up to that, we're going to have to start trusting the consumer. The consumer right now has one choice, and that's to enter the door through a brick-and-mortar doctor's office. And we as a legislature are going to have to start trusting the consumer that they're smart enough to make a wise choice both medically and financially.
▶ Play
Speaker 83 49:48
And, sir, I want to add, and this is on behalf of the clients in Arkansas who have reached out to me over the last several days, and I know that they've sent e-mails and faxes to some of you all here, but the car marts and the car gills and the golden livings and then i could go on and on and on and they've called me they emailed me and they said claudia where's our voice you know how can we get our voice heard and so the last thing i want to say is please listen to those employers who are using this as a tool to not only improve quality of health care for their employees but also to reduce costs and sir it is a free market and i urge this group to not fall for a ploy that will continue to remove this benefit to the people of Arkansas. Thank you. I'll
▶ Play
make one closing remark, Mr. Speaker, and then I'll wrap it up, I think. I was, again, learned some new information. I was very disappointed to hear that a face-to-face meeting has been denied. You as a legislator, if you had your constituents calling you, asking for a face-to-face meeting, and you had refused a face-to-face meeting, I don't know that you'd be elected again and I would encourage us as a legislature to at least encourage our medical society and folks to give this some real thought it's a big deal and it gives our constituents and the people that you represent they deserve that thank you Mr. Speaker members I
▶ Play
still have other questions but we're an hour into this we're not going to hear a vote today Dr. McGee, no, I don't think so
▶ Play
Speaker 126 51:24
No question I mean, we've heard a lot
▶ Play
of testimony about how people worked or didn't work with other people and I'd maybe like to hear the medical board five minute response I was actually going to invite Mr. O'Dwyer up here to respond just so we can have a little bit of balance Mr. O'Dwyer, if you could do this in about five minutes or so, that would be wonderful If it takes you 10, we'll probably be able to do it. I'll try to do it as quickly as
▶ Play
Speaker 51 51:53
I can. That's great. First off, I would like to dispel this notion that the Arkansas Medical Board is some rogue dinosaur agency that sticks its head in the sand and doesn't listen to not only Teladoc but other telemedicine companies because that's about as far from the truth as you can get. I have met with Dr. DePhillips about a year and a half ago and other representatives of Teladoc. in my office for about an hour, took in all their information they had. I took all that information and supplied it to the medical board. All of it was reviewed by every member of the medical board. Every piece of paper that they've provided me has been forwarded to the medical board. Nothing has been withheld. We have received information from various telemedicine companies. You know, about five years ago, it was about twice a year. Now it's, you know, I deal with telemedicine, feels like, almost daily. Every piece of paper that's sent to me is forwarded to the medical board, and all 14 members of the medical board review it. At some point, after we've had several companies present to the board, the board determined that they really weren't doing anything in their face-to-face explanation, but just rereading all the information that they had already provided us. And it was taking up, you know, as much as an hour of the board's time. We only meet two days every other month. So the decision was made to please just forward us the information. If we have questions concerning it, we'll respond back. So the idea that the board refuses to work with companies is totally not true. I have requested from other companies and Teladoc on numerous occasions, please forward me whatever information you have. I'll be happy to supply it to the board. i think what the problem the board has had with all of these models including the federation of state medical board model i was at an attorney workshop in november it's a federation of state medical board attorney workshop in november there were about 30 states represented the question was asked have you have uh have you reviewed the federation of state medical board model everybody raised their hand. Next question, how many states in here actually agree with that model? Not one hand was raised. Arkansas is not out on an island by itself. I have spoken with a number of board attorneys over the last few weeks and months concerning telemedicine, and Arkansas is right in line with everybody I have spoken to. This is not something the board takes lightly. I think you'd have to be, I think you would have to be a dinosaur to believe that technology isn't catching up with us. And I think Dr. Phillips mentioned 15 years ago, no one had a cell phone that took pictures. The board understands it's coming. We are constantly looking at models, constantly studying. We've had people from UAMS come to the board, speak to us about models that they felt would work. And the board is looking at this. And I agree with Representative Meeks, the current board rule allows the board to determine what model works and what doesn't. Representatives here today from Teladoc, they just haven't presented a model that the board felt was good, safe practice for the patients of Arkansas. That was known to them a year and a half ago when I first met with them. They continued to work in Arkansas, knowing the board's position. I'd be happy to entertain any questions. Members, we're going to allow
▶ Play
just a couple questions. Again, I don't want to get hung up into a major contest. I know we have another telemedicine bill coming down the pike a little later, too, so we'll have other debate and chances to talk about this. Representative Meeks, I'm going to recognize you
▶ Play
for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. My question is simply this. Teladoc operates in 48 out of 50 states. So I'm having a hard time believing that whatever model that they're presenting to you is not going to work in Arkansas. Apparently, I mean, something was used before, and now it's not being used for whatever reason. So I'm having a hard time figuring out why the board is not doing what they're supposed to do and allow these to operate here in the state of Arkansas. So can you speak on that? 48 out of 15 states, it would be 49 apparently in July, and Arkansas would be the only one that's left out. Those numbers are not the numbers
▶ Play
Speaker 51 56:35
that I know. I don't know where they get those numbers. But they're operating in
▶ Play
49 out of 50 states? Well, and I think
▶ Play
Speaker 51 56:42
you have to put a comma legally. They were operating in Arkansas, too. Thank you, Mr. Chair. All right, Representative Love.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I guess let me try to say this is there a model that is acceptable right now for the Arkansas Medical Board in which the Arkansas, or is it the Federation of State Medical Boards is there a model that can be used that I guess Teladoc is not using, I'm trying to wrap my head around that Well, I can only speak to their model.
▶ Play
Speaker 51 57:27
The model that they propose, the board does not believe is safe practice. The model that the Federation of State Medical Boards proposed last year, as I said, there are 30 states at this meeting. Nobody thought that was a safe practice either. The board has looked at several things like cross-coverage or on-call type situations where telemedicine would be appropriate. There's telemedicine occurring in Arkansas now, just not the way that Teladoc or other telemedicine companies would like. It would fall more into an on-call or cross-coverage type situation. Teleradiology is being used, been used for years in this state within the regulations of the medical board. Okay, can
▶ Play
you kind of tell me the difference between what Teladoc uses and what you say is
▶ Play
Speaker 51 58:25
acceptable right now? Well, the model that they propose is someone calls up or gets on a live feed and tells the doctor what's going on, and then he starts prescribing medication. And that cross-coverage is there's already been a person that has seen the patient or an on-call, there's already been a patient that's been seen by a physician. And that's the part where most of these telemedicine models fall short is that the in-person visit by a physician, the physical exam by
▶ Play
Speaker 140 58:59
the physician. I guess that defeats the purpose of
▶ Play
the telemedicine model because, I mean, you're saying, now I understand exactly what Dr. Phillips was saying. You're saying that you have to be in person. I guess it defeats the purpose of the telemedicine model. So, I mean, wouldn't you agree? The models we've seen so far, you
▶ Play
are correct. All right. Representative Hammer, I'm going to recognize you because for some odd reason you've not asked a question yet. He wasn't in here for a long time. I wasn't in here. He hasn't been here. Well, that explains a lot. I'm going to give you a question and your obligatory follow-up, and then we're going to end this and move on to some other issues.
▶ Play
I'm glad my reputation precedes me, Mr. Speaker. I'm glad to hear that face-to-face is still a valuable aspect of what's considered frontline quality care but to me everybody in this room's got an opinion and we're all trying to prove that our opinion is right so what I'd like to hear from any of y'all at the end of the table to me it's about litigation and it's about consumer complaints and it's about people feeling that they have been fraudulently treated so I'd like to hear from Teladoc and also from the other gentleman I'm sorry about complaints statewide in 48 states that they are operating as far as litigation and an ongoing suits because of poor medical practice thank you for the question I'll start and Kevin
▶ Play
Speaker 59 1:00:27
I'll pass it over to you so one of the things that I didn't speak about thanks for asking the question is is we have a very it's the mo I've been in a number of different companies a number of different industries we have the most aggressive quality assurance oversight program I have ever seen every every ten percent of all charts right back to chart one if a doc does one consult in a month that chart gets pulled for a quality review we've got data analytics and the member complaints is actually an input into the physician oversight program so when a patient has a complaint about the service which by the way happens a very very low percentage of the time and with regard to to prescribing, the number one complaint that we get won't surprise you. It's, I signed up for that telemedicine service, I paid my $40, and that darn doc did not give me the antibiotic for my annual sinus infection that I already know that I needed. So we follow CDC guidelines. If it's viral, we don't give an antibiotic. That's our number one complaint. Back to your point, our overall satisfaction rate is north of 95% with the service. First of all, we have a 20% survey response rate, which is triple the industry average. There's something called a net promoter score that consumer-facing companies get. We are actually ahead of every other health company and up there with Southwest Airlines. I've never seen anything like that with a health-related company before. And in the 95% satisfaction, most people report that. It's usually, you know, it's a five-point program, and they group together good and excellent, and that's 95%. Most of the time, 80% of that is good, and 20% is excellent. In our world, it's the other way around. 80% are excellent, and 20% of that 95% are good. Lastly, I don't know if any of you use Uber, but I'll give you the analogy, is after an Uber ride, you get to rate the driver. I don't know how many of you are aware of this, but the driver also gets to rate you as a passenger. And if you get bad ratings, you get thrown out of the program. Don't know if you knew that. We do the exact same thing. We have physicians rate the patients, and if they're rude or curse or whatever, and the patients all rate the physicians. And our overall complaint rate is low. Last data point, and I promise to turn it over to my colleague Kevin, is Mr. O'Dwyer advised me that I guess the reason we were able to operate here for a while before they chose to intervene is because they only intervene when there's a complaint. We were here for years before they intervened. I'm assuming that means that there was never a complaint in the entire time we were here up until this past fall. But I won't answer for Mr. O'Dwyer.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:02:53
Yes, sir, Mr. O'Dwyer. Why don't you go ahead and respond
▶ Play
Speaker 51 1:02:56
to that same question. We've had one complaint we've investigated for prescribing from an Ohio doctor to a patient here in Arkansas. We started our investigation, wrote the doctor, and then he surrendered his license. That was the extent of that investigation. May I ask a follow-up? In brick and mortar,
▶ Play
how many complaints do you handle in a year? How many suspensions have there been in a year's time?
▶ Play
Speaker 51 1:03:26
We investigate a number of complaints each or every other month. I don't know the number of complaints, but it's large. Some of those complaints the board decides to take action on, whether we begin an investigation or ultimately bring charges and have a hearing. I don't have the numbers in front of you. On average, we probably have three or four to five hearings every other month.
▶ Play
And that's on in-state brick-and-mortar? Correct. Okay. One last question, if I may. I'd just like to know how many customers Teladoc is currently serving in the state of Arkansas, and thank you for the tolerance. Up
▶ Play
Speaker 59 1:04:09
until November of 2014, it was north of 70,000, and today it is zero. All right, members. What you've
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:04:17
heard is a fair amount of debate. just over an hour's worth. Mr. Phillips, I'm going to recognize you briefly. Thank you so much, Mr. Chairman.
▶ Play
I appreciate it. And thank you, committee members, for listening to this debate. And as introduction, you are Bill Phillips. I am Bill Phillips and represent Teladoc. Yes, sir. Just a couple of points. The ten most diagnosed procedures that we encounter are sinus infection, ear infection, urinary tract infection, skin rash. These are just very minor. If someone calls and is enlisted in our system, they've gone through the protocol, and they are now one of our patients, and they've got a stomach ache, a terrible stomach ache. We don't say, okay, well, we think it's this or that. We say you need to get to the emergency room or you need to call your primary care doctor. This is something that we don't. If you've got three sinus infections in six months, we say we would like for you to go to your primary care doctor and take care of that. It may be something more than just a sinus infection. So the safety is there. one thing that you need to know and understand on this under the protocol that we are now operating on or not operating under in Arkansas because the medical board it says you first have to have a primary care doctor encounter a face to face we have 70,000 plus folks or we did have in November there are 4 or 5 other companies doing business in Arkansas and I would guess that they probably with us would represent $150,000. Now, if you put a financial picture to that, $150,000 folks, the CPT pricing for an office visit is $131. Before you can engage in telemedicine in Arkansas, you have sucked $19.6 million out of the state. Totally unnecessary. The protocol that we have is safe. It's secure. It lets the patient and the doctor, after that exam or the medical records and the transport of information, there's folks doing telemedicine all the time just like this. If I pick up my phone call on Dr. John Smith and say, I've got this sinus infection, can you send me? Yeah, I'll send you a Z-Pak down at Kroger. That's telemedicine. It is not dangerous. It's time has come. I wish Kevin had said another question that I asked this national state boards of medicine. He said 30 of them said that they have regulations against it. A fine question would have been, well, are you enforcing that? Are you making them leave your state? No, none of them. The answer would have been none of them, because 48, well, 49 now, Idaho just passed through the Senate committee yesterday, a House bill, that will go to the governor probably at the end of the week. 49 states, we are operating. I don't care what the others say they've got on the books, what their regulations are. They are staying silent on it because they know that they have not caught up with technology that's available. All right. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:07:54
Phillips. Thank y'all. Well, I'm not going to accept any motions, so I'm not going to even look for one, but appreciate y'all coming. Representative Sullivan, you and I will, I'm sure, visit with the Speaker, and we'll
▶ Play
move here procedurally. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and just to be clear, there is an amendment on abortion that specifically says chemical abortions that addresses the issue that we talked about. It's not allowed. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:08:20
Speaker. Representative Douglas, good to see you here. Why don't you hop down there and freshen us up with a different subject and don't hurt yourself in the process. I almost made a real show. House Bill 1142, second special order. I see it has numerous amendments. I believe they're all engrossed. Mr. Price says they're all engrossed. So 1142, as you read it, is how she will present it.
▶ Play
Speaker 157 1:08:49
you'll give me just a minute to grab all my files I've got one more to grab committee I thank you today and thank you Mr. Chair for allowing us to have a special order of business to talk about this very important issue we have experts from out of town and I appreciate you accommodating them in this way. This is a bill on the field of surgical technology. Most of us will be affected by an operation at some time in our lives or someone we know of is going to be in the operating room. I think we would all agree some of the most vital personnel in the OR are the people responsible for making sure that the patient area is sterile. Infection is a problem for patients sometimes. We also want good personnel in there making sure that the right instruments are there and often there are hundreds or even there's I think a thousand instruments for a total hip that the surgical technologists have to learn and memorize. Making sure that those instruments are there, set up in the right way, and that those instruments are still there and accounted for once the patient is sewn back up. Very important. And the people that do these jobs, a sterile field, counting the instruments, laying those instruments out, are the surgical technologists. They're essentially the surgeon's co-pilot. in the operating room. That's a great description. I think that many Arkansans would be surprised to learn that there's currently, and this is very important, no minimum state certification required for technologists to work in the OR. This bill, HB 1142, addresses that. The surgical techs in my district brought this bill to me because they are conscientious professionals who desire to establish a standard for patient care. We want that to be consistent across the state. I first got to know them through my medical academy in Van Buren High School where they volunteered to work with my students who were going into the medical fields. HB 1142 would set minimum requirements for the people responsible for setting up in maintaining the sterile field in our operating rooms. The state medical board would certify technologists, that would be the procedure, who met minimum requirements from the National Board of Surgical Technology. We are not creating a new license. We are simply asking that the licensed be called for when they are employed. The other option is they can be successfully completed one of the surgical technology training programs or in the military. So we will accept that from the military. As we develop this bill, we began by bringing all of the stakeholders to the table months ago. We listened to their concerns and suggestions. We amended, amended, and amended this bill to answer every concern that was brought to us except for one. Don't run the bill. We talked to the medical board, the nurses, physicians, surgeons, and the hospitals. We met with each group individually then after meeting in a group setting to go over amendments, and several times we would come back to the table and revise our amendments with definitions or deletions to make the bill better, and we appreciated the input. This process has taken several months, and that's why we are so late coming to the table in the session because of this process. One of the things that we've got in our bill is that there's a grandfather clause, So those that are working now will be grandfathered in. They don't have to go back to school. They've proven themselves. There are also exemptions for students currently enrolled in a surgical tech training program or nursing medical program that can still practice as surgical techs. Some raise concerns that perhaps health care facilities in rural areas won't be able to find certified techs or that it would be a hindrance to hiring. In other words, we would limit the pool of people available for this job by requiring a license. We were sensitive to that, and we have included a broad exemption to address that as well. We've stated that if a facility is unable to employ a qualified surgical technologist after a thorough effort, they simply have to document that they made that effort and then hire and the hire has two years to comply I recognize the frustration some of you have with certifications or licensing requirements and the aversion that many of us have to perceived mandates and not to pick on any one profession but let's think about the various occupations that we do require certification and licensure from across the state. You know, there are hundreds, and, you know, out there, you know, your massage therapist, your dog groomers, your nail technicians, all of those recognize that they need a minimum degree of education in order to give us the right care that we need in those professions. It only makes sense that the people serving in these critical roles, working side-by-side with surgeons in our operating rooms, would have minimum requirements to meet as well. I've given you an overview from 20,000 feet up. I have experts here that can give you data on why this is needed and how this will increase patient care. I'd be glad to take your questions, and I would welcome my expert to the table with me, Kathy Spark. Kathy, if you would like
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:16:33
to come. Members, for an explanation of the bill, Representative Meeks, you're recognized for your
▶ Play
first question. Thank you. Representative Douglas, I appreciate you presenting this bill, and of course, you know, we obviously want to have the safest hospitals and to be able to do things correct. But in your statement, you said that the people who are currently doing it now are being grandfathered in because they've proven themselves. If they've proven themselves, then to me, we don't really have an issue. And I would ask you, why would we even need this bill if the people doing it have already proven themselves? I'm
▶ Play
Speaker 157 1:17:14
going to let Ms. Bartman speak to that. That is a clause that, you know, it is a good question. And I'm going to let her tell about those situations in the other states that
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:17:35
have accepted this. Ms. Sparkman, you need to introduce yourself for the
▶ Play
record and you're recognized to give testimony. Mr. Chairman, members of the committee, my name is Catherine Sparkman. I'm the Director of Government and Public Affairs for the National Association of Surgical Technologists, which is headquartered in Denver, Colorado. It's a group of 40,000 members. represent the interests of 55,000 certified surgical technologists nationwide. Briefly, in my past, I am a recovering attorney. I was a, for 30 years prior to entering public policy on behalf of medical personnel in the operating room, I was a medical malpractice defense attorney. I represented hospitals, enterprise liability, which means I represented the interests of the staff and employees of hospital systems both in Dallas, Texas and in Denver, Colorado. I will make an effort to explain the exemptions and exceptions to the law and I'll start with the grandfather clause with a distinction between policy and politics in in crafting this bill it was important that we did not take anyone out of a current job but we expected over time that as the workforce turned over and progressed that surgical technologists would continue to to seek certification and that hospitals would continue to insist that their surgical personnel were appropriately independently competent and certified. An example is perhaps the state of Texas where we passed a similar certification law providing for grandfathering of currently practicing surgical technologists. An interesting thing happened in Texas. That bill was passed in 2008. At that time, there were approximately 2,700 certified surgical technologists and a group, certainly, of non-certified surgical techs working on the job. Today, there are 5,250 certified surgical technologists in the face of the grandfather clause that was passed in 2008 and anecdotally two major hospital systems in the state of Texas abandoned grandfather clause and required all practicing surgical technologists in their facilities to move forward through either distance learning or advanced degree programs to obtain their certification which accounts in no small measure for the considerable number of certified surgical technologists in that state today. All right, Representative
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:20:50
McGee, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. So the way this is written, the surgical technologists out there practicing now that's not certified, they're
▶ Play
grandfathered in, right? That is correct. The bill provides that any surgical technologist practicing in a health care facility as of January 1, 2016, would be grandfathered into this bill. There is no additional requirement of certification. But
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:21:21
at what point do they have to become certified? And I'm reading this that after a year they have to be certified. or become certified, and what cost is that to that individual or to the institution where they work, and what is that certification process involved? Do they just take a national exam, and how much does that cost for the individual to take, and then how long is that good for? Do they
▶ Play
have other requirements to maintain that certification? The bill, Section 1718-103A, requires the Arkansas State Board to certify the surgical technologist any applicant who, under subparagraph 3, has been employed to practice as a surgical technologist in a health care facility on or before January 1, 2016. There is no requirement that that surgical technologist technologists eventually become certified. If there is an exemption for surgical technologists brought to the state of Arkansas from another state by a surgeon or physician located in this state, but if that surgical technologist meets the requirement of subsection three, they do not have to obtain certification. Only those who do not meet the requirements of subsection three, non-certified surgical techs, have to be certified.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:22:57
I'm confused. I'm a little confused with that. I mean, the way I read it is that under C is to get this provisional certification. So the state medical board is going to be tasked with developing how they're going to certify these people. And what they're going to do is they're going to say, you've got to go take a national certification exam. I don't know how the state board would certify them any other way. And then I'd be interested in what the cost would be to that individual. Because surgical technologists are not highly paid individuals. And if that's a significant barrier, that could be a real barrier for some people. They could drop out of
▶ Play
Speaker 157 1:23:40
their profession. The certification for those that are grandfathered in, they are not going to have to go take the test. and they would of course be under the they would want to get their continuing education but they're not going to have to go back to school that's what the grandfather means. Their certification is grandfathered in and they're not going to have to go back and take a test that's what that section is talking about. Okay. Representative Henderson Have
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:24:10
you kind of satisfied Dr. McGee? Okay. Representative Henderson, you're recognized for a question. I guess the problems that I kind of got with it, I've been on
▶ Play
that. Are you using your microphone? Yes, sir. Can you hear me? No, I couldn't. Better? Get it on up there. There we go. All right. I'll swallow that thing. I guess my problem that I have with it, I've been on the other end of that where we have actually recruited uh doctors and surgeons ob's um and you said that there's thousands and there are thousands of instruments but each specialty kind of has has their own and it's kind of a limited set and what i've noticed on doctors that they come in and actually go to the or they train their people I mean every doctor is different nobody wants just a cookie cutter person coming in everybody's going to have their different ways of setting up their instruments would that not just take care of that or do you think that what you're doing is kind of extending that to more training than they can possibly need I think what what
▶ Play
Speaker 157 1:25:33
we're doing is is giving them a you know knowledge of all the instruments knowledge of the OR knowledge of how that's set up and then those individual doctors can very quickly tweak a person that's already got that basic knowledge but when you start with someone that has no knowledge and have to train them I don't think that's very efficient follow-up
▶ Play
Mr. Chair yes sir but the doctors that I see come in and it might be different and but I've kind of been in the middle of quite a bit of that I mean they usually get LPNs coming in wouldn't they receive
▶ Play
some of that training as an LPN in. Registered nurses nor licensed practical nurses receive no education or training in the operating room anymore. The curriculum for nursing school changed in the late 80s when 85% of people in the scrub role were nurses. It is no longer taught. Today 85% of the people serving in the scrub roll, scrub roll, excuse me, are not nurses. They are surgical technologists and they receive anywhere from 12 to 24 months of specific training in the operating room, aseptic techniques, the instrumentation, protocols, systems, and all of this. When a surgeon comes to a hospital, he does not, in only the most limited circumstances, bring a tech. Virtually never brings a scrub tech. They bring their own surgical assistant sometime, but not a tech. The tech is an employee of the hospital. A surgeon prior, a surgeon who is on staff and granted privileges in hospital, submits a preference card. How they, what instruments they want, how they want them, where, where they do. The surgical technologist is skilled enough and, and trained enough through these programs to be able to accommodate each of the preference, preferences of individual surgeons whether it's from cardiac cases to total knee replacements to 25 instruments to 1,150 instruments in a total knee so they are that their program prepares them for that 12 months of didactic training six eight to 12 months of didactic training in medicine and an additional 12 months in clinical training before and then taking a national certifying exam which tests all All of that training and knowledge of the systems necessary to support surgical procedures.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:28:20
Hi, Representative Hammer, you're recognized for a
▶ Play
question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Can you tell me how much
▶ Play
a tech currently gets paid or what's the average pay scale for a tech? Yes, sir. Thank you for the question. Currently, a surgical technologist earns anywhere from $16.50 an hour to $18.75 per hour. Interestingly, certified surgical technologists do not experience a spike in the wages or salary in those states where certification is required. We have done research in the Bureau of Labor Statistics, which has charted and compared salaries in those two instances, and there is no appreciable difference. And
▶ Play
they are always working in a medical facility or in a facility where surgeries are being
▶ Play
performed. Is that correct? That's correct, sir. Either hospital or ambulatory surgical center, the bill specifically excludes
▶ Play
office-based surgery. And I'm wondering if they work for a facility that undoubtedly has a responsibility to provide the best quality trained individuals, why it wouldn't be left up to the facility to make that determination as to whether or not the people that are in assisting the surgeons are qualified to do that? Why is that not already covered, or what is this bill going to do to make that
▶ Play
Speaker 157 1:29:56
any better? Well, you know, just as a lay person, not a medical person, I'm looking at a hospital setting, and I'm assuming that everybody that has responsibility for my care in a hospital is licensed and has a minimum requirement for education and training. I'm going to assume that the nurses, the CNAs, the LPNs, everybody in an OR suite would have a minimum requirement for education. And when you look at a hospital and you see that this is the only health professional in the hospital that is not certified, I have concerns about patient care because of that lack of a statewide standard for that profession. You've kind of done three.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:30:50
Let's move to Dr. McGee, or Representative McGee. I'll come back if you need to. Representative McGee. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'll try to be real short. I understand certification and needs for training and all of that, but I'm a physician and I work in hospitals and I work in the operating room. And at least at the hospital that I'm involved in, and I'm sure the hospital association may say something about this in a minute, but those individuals are trained to standards in those hospitals that they have to meet per guidelines by national accrediting organizations. And if we're talking about making these people now have another certification, I'd really want to know, are there any peer review articles, peer review that demonstrates that the quality of care is better with these levels of certification, or any difference, or have there been problems with it? I knew that we
▶ Play
would get to data. Thank you for the question. Data in this instance is hard to come by, as you might expect. Surgical technologists are not the focus in assessment of patient harm. It's difficult to get the data released. The health information and patient privacy ask HIPAA does not allow root cause analysis to identify all of the people and data is hard to come by. Medical care like golf is not so much all of the shots that are good. it's all of the bad shots you don't make and so it's what we but but there is data and here's what we do know that is in the medical community at the present time I want to separate briefly the treatment of medical conditions that physicians and hospitals provide for their patients and that patients enter the hospitals to cure and also and then the unrelated medical conditions that patients may and do suffer while there and that is a lot of what this certification regulations are addressed briefly 99,000 patients die every year from a hospital acquired condition not from what they go in to cure but a condition that they acquire in the hospital nearly 10 percent of those deaths are attributable to conditions arising in the operating room these These conditions include wrong site surgery, wrong patient surgery, wrong procedure, foreign retained objects, and most importantly at this point, surgical site infections. You have heard what a surgical technologist does. The search tech is the right hand of the surgeon, making sure the procedure goes efficiently and seamlessly. They are invisible. They act as the extension of the instrument and the extension of the surgeon's hands. but they are primarily responsible for the integrity of the sterile field, and they are the defenders of that field. Surgical site infections are the single leading cause of hospital readmissions in the United States. The CDC found, and by the way, the cost of those readmissions is $28 to $33 billion. It costs $25,546 per surgical site infection readmission. The CDC found that in 2010, surgical site infections counted for 31% of all hospital-acquired infections, 157,800 incidents of surgical site infections. A study just published last month in the Journal of American Medical Association, February 3rd, 2015, reported on a study of the American College of Surgeons, their National Surgical Quality Improvement Program. They analyzed readmission rates of 346 hospitals during only 12 months in 2012. There were 5,500 readmissions for surgical site infections alone. That constituted almost 20%, one-fifth, of all hospital readmissions. Now, in that context, you had asked, What do we have that shows that a certified surgical technologist actually contributes to ameliorating these things? Because remember, we can't often or always trust a patient in this. We heard at the last hearing that you trust the consumer to make the decision. The consumer is asleep. The consumer doesn't know. The consumer has no idea whether or not all the personnel in their operating room or in their surgical procedure are certified, competent, or educated. So we have two studies that point out some of the value of certification. In the state of Minnesota, they passed a law called the Adverse Event Reporting Act, and that requires every hospital by name every year to report out loud all of the 28 categories of adverse medical events occurring in that facility. Five of those 28 sentinel events occur in the operating room, And they include, as I said, wrong site surgery, retained objects, wrong patient surgery. Every hospital reports, and it's published in the St. Paul and Minneapolis newspapers. These data show that hospitals who utilize exclusively certified surgical technologists experience a 40% reduction in adverse surgical events. If you take only retained objects in that reporting, and this is from 2008 to 2015, if you take and carve out only foreign objects, the difference is over 50%. A 50% reduction in foreign objects in hospitals that hire and insist on continuing certification and education. In Virginia, surgical infection rates were studied and data relating to readmissions for SSIs. Again, $25,500 per readmission. The hospitals in Virginia who utilize only certified surgical technologists and those credential personnel experienced an 11% reduction in the cost of readmissions for surgical site infections. And what we know, this is what we know is coming. Medicare no longer pays, and most private insurers no longer pay for readmission for wrong site surgery, wrong person surgery, foreign retained objects. They're never events that stand alone in hospital conduct. And interestingly, the Affordable Care Act is now, as I'm sure all well know, are addressing unperforming hospitals in many areas of hospital procedure, including activities in the operating room. And they are dividing those hospital performance into quartiles. The underperforming quartile will be penalized in reimbursement under the Affordable Care Act between 1 and 3 percent, that money will be given to the hospitals that have the highest efficiencies and best practices. And so I guess I would like to say in response, a windy response after all, I am a recovering lawyer, utilizing competent, capable, educated, certified medical personnel helps achieve these kinds of outcomes. and I guess I would also like to say while we are on cost and and I would be happy to discuss exactly the the the cost of education and the cost of certification but I will say what will it what will it cost hospitals to to comply with this to hire only certified surgical technologists again the data the data show that from the BLS that there is not a cost in hiring the data also shows in in the sort of the educational program the certification exam is part of the curriculum for for the the eight accredited surgical technology programs in the state of Arkansas and so the cost to hospitals and the cost of recertification is minimal. The cost of the continuing education portion of this bill, those requirements are also minimal. Achieving 15 continuing education hours to support continued certification costs anywhere from $11 to $25. All hospital in-service training, which is normally offered free of charge to the surgical technologist, count towards continuing education. So I mentioned briefly about the states, the states that hire only certified surgical technologists and the states that have adopted this law. When I joined the Association of Surgical Technologists, and prior to that I represented operating room nurses in surgical patient safety initiatives as well. When I began in 2008, Tennessee and South Carolina had passed certification requirements for surgical technologists. After I came, Texas was next in 2008, and as I said, currently there are now 5,800 surgical technologists in that state. We added Colorado, Indiana, three states, and New England, and most recently this year, Virginia. question answered yes okay represent Bentley
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:40:54
do you have a question yes
▶ Play
briefly can you tell me how many training programs we have in Arkansas and what is the cost to begin a surgical tech and what to go through the
▶ Play
program and what do we have in this state yeah there are a training there are eight surgical technology programs in Arkansas there are two distance learning programs the tuition varies from an in-state school of less than six thousand dollars to private schools of about fifteen thousand
▶ Play
to eighteen thousand dollars. One quick follow-up if that's okay. Yes, ma'am. Do you foresee a problem with our hospitals getting enough trained surgical technicians to fulfill their needs here in the
▶ Play
state? I absolutely do not, and we have a rural exception, which is normally the most, the gravest concern, and it allows a hospital to seek to find a surgical technologist from one of the, from any place. It is a national certification. It is not limited to only finding surgical technologists in this state. It is a national application of certification. Failing that in a rural or medically underserved area, a hospital may hire who the hospital wants. I might add briefly, this waiver is in place in eight of the 11 states where the law is in effect. To our knowledge, and we get reports all the time, there has never been an instance where a hospital had to hire an uncertified surgical technologist because it could not find a certified one. Members, you've heard an explanation of the bill. I have
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:42:22
no one signed up to speak for or against the bill. Does anyone from the audience speak for or against it? Yes, ma'am. If you would come to the end table, introduce yourself for the record. Tell us if you're speaking for or against it. I have my suspicions. And
▶ Play
Speaker 198 1:42:45
you're recognized. Can you hear me? I'm Jody Antritt. I'm with the Arkansas Hospital Association. And believe it or not, I'm actually really excited to speak on this bill. I'm against it, but the reason I'm excited to talk about it is because hospitals do a pretty bad job of telling you all when we do a pretty good job on quality. The speakers are actually correct when they say you just hear about the bad stuff, you don't hear about the good stuff. So I'm really excited to talk to you today a little bit about what we're doing on quality. I will say, as far as the bill's concerned, and this is kind of the takeaway message, this is over-regulation, it's a barrier to employment, and it's an unfunded mandate on the hospitals when there's not any proven impact that patient care is improved. And you all know that the patient care part is the part hospitals care about the most. Our hospitals are focused on patient care and improving quality. This is the primary mission of each of our members. So if we're talking about adding a new requirement that has been proven to improve outcomes, we already would have been shouting from the rooftops that we ought to be doing this. But this bill does not provide that for us. There is absolutely no data, no empirical data linking certification of surgical techs to improvements in patient outcomes. In particular, and I'm glad they mentioned it, let's look at surgical site infections. Everybody wants to eliminate surgical site infections. the hospital association has been participating over the last two years in a 36 state hospital engagement network program we call it the hens so you guys can insert your own chicken jokes now we've done it through the american hospital association's health research and education trust program and it focuses on improving quality in a variety of clinical areas including reducing surgical site infections. The data we have collected in all 36 of these participating networks shows a variety of ways to reduce infections in hospitals. None of them have anything to do with requiring certification of surgical techs. The results of the Arkansas hospitals within the HEN were second in the nation, which means Arkansas was the second best. when we were participating hospitals exceeding all of the goals established by CMS. That would be the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, Mr. Chairman, for the multi-year project. So I'd like to talk about the results of one hospital in particular because we all like, we're Arkansans, we want to talk about Arkansas stuff. A small critical access hospital in our state has one excellent surgical tech on staff who has over 20 years of experience. Critical access hospitals, for those of you who are not aware, although looking at the committee I know that you all are, they are small. They have no more than 25 beds. They're rural. They're crucial for maintaining the health care safety net because they provide services that a patient would otherwise have to travel many, many miles to receive. At this hospital with our one certified tech, our one surgical tech who's a 20-year veteran, that tech does not have the certification required in this bill. This means that the tech would have to be certified under the grandfathering provision. The way we read the grandfathering provision, once she's certified, the individual would be responsible for obtaining 60 hours of continuing education over the next four years. That's in addition to all of the training that's already required to comply with both Medicare regulations and the Arkansas Department of Health regulations. And just for fun, if you guys need some light reading, these are the health department regulations for facilities and these are the Medicare conditions of participation for hospitals. They're single spaced, more than a thousand pages of regulations. The hospital has informed the AHA that the cost associated with mandatory continuing ed would be a hardship for the hospital because it is a rural facility and it's hard to come by good resources. Also, to answer your question a little bit earlier about what the test cost, according to the website for the National Association, if you're a member of the National Association, you pay to the board a $60 processing fee and then a $300 and I think it's $39 fee for an in-member. And if you're not a member of the association, you pay to the board $499. That's the processing fee plus the fee to take the test. if the hospital required the test or the tech to pay for the hours directly it could be an extreme hardship because this particular tech at our hospital here in arkansas is the sole income producer for her family and she has limited resources this is not a high-paying job as dr mcgee said earlier this is just one example of one hospital that would be hurt by this bill And here's a very, very important fact about the hospital. With this surgical technologist, who is not certified but has been extremely well trained, this hospital is among the best performing hospitals in our hospital engagement network. Their surgical site infection rate is incredibly low, and that low rate obviously has nothing to do with the certification of a surgical tech. This situation... Hold
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:48:07
on with me just a second. Representative Love. You're recognized for something. Point of order, motion,
▶ Play
I'm not sure. Thank you, Mr. Chair. It is actually a motion to limit debate to 10 minutes,
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:48:20
five minutes for each side. That sounds great. All in favor say aye. Aye. None opposed. All right, we
▶ Play
Speaker 198 1:48:28
are limiting debate. Thank you. I will be brief. I do want to also say that everything Arkansas is doing to improve care through the Payment Improvement Initiative, patient-centered medical homes, reforms coming from the recommendations of the newly created health care task force work on Medicaid, all of these are working to improve quality of care in the most cost-effective and efficient way. Hospitals simply cannot afford mandates that are not proven to improve patient care. If hospitals have regulations that force, by definition, less efficiency, it undercuts everything we're working toward in this state. So lastly, I will talk a little bit about the barrier to employment. We all know that we want to create jobs in Arkansas and make it an attractive state for all businesses. This bill would limit our hospital's ability to hire an uncertified tech, even when the uncertified person might be a better employee for the facility. I appreciate your time. I know you're running short and there may be more people to speak for and against. I'm happy to answer any questions you all have of me. Members, anyone else speak for or
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:49:35
against this? Are you closed for your bill? Would you like to close for your bill? Yes, thank you.
▶ Play
Speaker 157 1:49:52
The cost, I think, is the thing that we keep hearing. It's going to be costly to the surgical tech. It's going to be costly to the hospital, but when the surgical tech signs up for the surgical tech school, their tuition covers their test, so that $300 cost that you're talking about is already paid for in their tuition. The professional development that she spoke of, of the single mother, we have found professional development for as cheap as $17 for 12 hours, so I think we can dispatch. spell all of the cries that this will be costly to the individual or to the hospital. The data we brought to you clearly indicated a relationship between those hospitals that hire certified, licensed surgical techs and a lower incidence of site infection and other operating room incidents. i would ask that you vote for this bill it's been a a labor for me and i'm passionate about the fact that it can improve conditions so i ask that you vote for this bill because it will i think save hospitals money in efficiency and they don't have to train those in-house they can come to them ready for the job I would ask that you vote for it because all of us are at our most vulnerable state when we are asleep during an operation and we must know that there is a standard of care during that time that we don't have to wonder about I would ask for you to pass this bill and vote for it because I think it's the best thing for patients in the state of Arkansas.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:51:55
Thank you very much. Members, for an explanation of the bill, what's the will of this committee? Representative Bentley? A motion do pass. Representative Bentley made a motion do pass. Any discussion on that motion? Hearing none, all in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed? No. No's have it. Your bill has failed, Representative Douglas. Representative Ferguson, you're recognized. Thank you very much, committee.
▶ Play
And what's your bill number, Representative Ferguson? 1533. 1532. No, 33. 1533. Thank you, committee. This is the hospice association's bill, and this is Dr. Smith, who is with Baptist Health. He's a palliative care doctor, and I'll let him explain what all he does and sort of explain the bill better. But just as an introduction, Senator Irving last year ran a bill for advanced directives that we all voted for. And this is just a complementary bill to that. What doctors tell me that work with patients who are sort of terminally ill is that sometimes the advanced directives are kind of hard to put your hands on. And this just reflects what's in the advanced directives into what they call doctor's orders. It's, let's see, the POST is physician's orders for life-sustaining treatment. And that's really all the bill does. It is just a complementary bill to an advanced directive where an advanced directive is a legal document. This translates it into doctor's actual orders. and my understanding is, and I guess Dr. Smith can address it, it's sort of a colored form that's in the hospice so that when the person is transported, then the people in the ambulance and the people in the ER or the hospital, they have actual orders to know what the patient wants. It in no way tries to intimidate people into making wrong decisions or difficult decisions about end of life orders, but it does clarify that where it's in doctor's orders. I had told Ms. Wimms earlier, my father died in November, and he had an advanced directive, but somehow it didn't get transferred to the hospital with him, so he was in end-stage congestive heart failure and had Alzheimer's, and before he got very ill with Alzheimer's, He had a very, an advanced directive that outlined that he wanted no end of life resuscitation or any of those kind of things. Well, they didn't get that translated. They came in and coded him. And so my mother, I wasn't there at the time, so my mother went through about two or three hours of him dying. And finally, two or three hours, he did pass away. But it would have saved a lot of trauma for my family had they had post orders in the record instead of
▶ Play
Speaker 216 1:55:36
just the advanced directive. I'm Dr. David Smith, I am, for 35 years I was a practicing board-certified cardiologist. I now am a board-certified in supportive and palliative medicine. I am director of that program at Baptist Health, I also have a master's in bioethics. I want to explain again just briefly with a story that we see over and over again, recently a patient was transferred from a nursing home to a rural hospital. The patient became very ill and had cardiopulmonary resuscitation. That ill patient was then transferred to Baptist Health. The patient again had a cardiac arrest and underwent cardiopulmonary resuscitation. When we finally found the surrogate health care decision maker to talk about wishes, the daughter who lived in Michigan said what have you done how could you have resuscitated my demented father he had a DNR order and a do not resuscitate order is an order that was in the nursing home but it applies in Arkansas only to the institution in which it is written it is not portable. So this problem, it comes up more often than you can imagine. And it's very painful because it is painful if it is done inappropriately because DNR or do not resuscitate patients that do survive that for a great percentage of them, they don't come out like they do on television. Many of them are severely injured. So this is extremely important. And I think Arkansas needs an act to give permission for physicians to write an order to prevent these kinds of things. And again, I would point out that this isn't for most of us in this room, I hope. This is for patients who have a probability of dying within the next year or in other similar situations where it is appropriate. So the physician's order for life-sustaining treatment differs because it is a set of orders. It's an interpretation of your wishes and values of the patient. It tells the nurse or the providers what to do. It's an action line. If the patient is asking for limited support, then it becomes quite clear. Do not resuscitate. Do not shock. Do not compress. Do not intubate. They can even say do not give artificial hydration and nutrition if the patient is imminently dying, where that will become burdensome to their care. What we have many times are words like comfort measures or allow natural death, but this has to be spelled out very clearly to say what it is that the nurse supposed to do. Otherwise, we sort of leave the nurse to flying by the seat of his or her pants with the assumptions. And so these orders are very clear. The other issue is portability. It is just amazing. Most doctors and nurses sort of assume that if it was done in one other place, it's true here. And they say, well, that doesn't make sense. They made this hard decision. They had this hard discussion over in this other institution, you know, and now when it's their most vulnerable, we have to go find someone and it's very difficult. So currently there can be no valid transfer of an above or of the do not resuscitate order from institution to institution or from, if they come in from emergency medical services and they have that DNR, then we have to rewrite that DNR. So we need a mechanism and we need something that is seamless across all entities. Now how does this differ from advanced directives? We are all in favor of these, but these really are a statement of values or wishes. They always require an interpretation by surrogate. So what we have is a situation when we have an advanced directive or living will or whatever, they require the physician or provider to write concrete orders which are an interpretation of those wishes and or values. You have to have something to put those into action. So the nurse or provider can't get just a living will and say, what would you do? It takes an order in order to activate that advance directive. You know, being in the field that I'm in, in palliative medicine, it's sort of tough sometimes because some people think, well, when I walk in, my intention is for someone to die, and I have to repeatedly say, I am a supportive doctor. I want you to live. I want to live. When I wrote out my advanced directive, I really, you know, told my wife, honey, don't use this thing too fast, because I want to live. It's only when I'm imminently dying, and, you know, there are conditions, and I think one of the bestsellers recently is being mortal. It's been on the bestseller for months now. People find it very difficult to accept the fact that we are not going to live forever. Patients who have a year to live so often know that the burdens of prolonging their dying is so great that they don't want to go through that. Sometimes that's not interpreted correctly by the families because they allow. Now, we have a greater problem with prolonging dying than any concern that we might have about preventing someone to die inappropriately because sometimes we have patients who, you know, the families want to keep the check and keep the house, and they keep things going inappropriately. We have to honor those wishes. But when I say this is my limits, I recognize that when I'm going to die, I'm going to accept that then this allows that kind of planning, and it allows it to go from hospital to hospital.
▶ Play
I might say the reverse is true, too. If they choose that they want resuscitation and antibiotics and everything life-sustaining possible, then that will absolutely be done. And even if they choose the otherwise, the doctor does have the discretion to override that and save the patient when they think that's appropriate. The other thing that's in the bill that I want to point out on page 5, line 4, it says emergency care and life-standing treatment shall not be withheld or withdrawn pursuant to a physician order if the patient is pregnant with the probability that the fetus will be born live. So post-orders do not apply in those situations. they would keep the patient alive in order to deliver the child. And I guess Dr. Smith is open for
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:02:51
questions. Representative Hammer, you're recognized for your question. Thank you. And I'm
▶ Play
just trying to get my mind around a couple things, so not hostile questions, just help me understand something. With us moving in the direction that we are in the medical world as far as medical records and everybody getting to incident technology, what is the need for this legislation that can't be handled with the dnr i guess that's where is this a beefed up dnr or gives the doctors a little more latitude in the absence of the dnr or a question that's not covered
▶ Play
Speaker 216 2:03:31
in the dnr this this is really a i guess a portable dnr number one okay from institution to institution. That's one of the most important aspects of this because if you go from Saline Hospital to Baptist Hospital and you have a DNR, then it's not applicable. Does that clarify that? Can I have a little, I promise, just a little attitude to keep the train of
▶ Play
thought going? All right. So the DNR, when it's filled out at Saline Memorial and the patient is transferred to Baptist, that DNR cannot, does the family have to fill out a new DNR when they get to Baptist? Or once that DNR is filled out, is it not with the patient until end of life?
▶ Play
Speaker 216 2:04:15
Well, they don't really fill out the DNR. It is an order written by a physician. So when that order, if we had a photocopy of that order and that showed up, that would have no legal authority. We would have to rewrite that order, number one. So if the patient has filled out such an order that we are proposing, they have to sign this themselves. So at the current time, you don't have to sign a DNR. This would require the signing of it by the patient or their legal representative. So that's the difference. There is no signing. you know many times patients say this or the family says do i have to sign anything and the fact is is a physician who writes that order i'll hold there mr well there's no one else in
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:05:13
queue if you want if you want to continue down that thought process you're welcome to right now
▶ Play
well and i i thought that because i remember hearing in the past where you know where's the dnr because is we can't do anything until we get the DNR. Without the DNR, it puts us in a awkward position. And I'm trying to get educated, so please correct me, but I work for hospice, and if a patient comes in without a DNR, one of the things that we try to do is to get the family's intent in the absence that the patient is not able to make the decision to get that DR in place. Will this tool, in a position where maybe a family is hesitant to make that decision because it is a you know a very emotional time frame in a person's life or the doctor then will it make it easier for the doctor then to be able to make the decision based on on his his or her medical expertise of evaluating the situation at
▶ Play
Speaker 221 2:06:17
that time okay let me make sure if
▶ Play
Speaker 216 2:06:21
this patient had been in an institution a hospital and then was moved to hospice move to a nursing home, move to another institution, a short-term nursing facility. At the current time, a new order has to be written by a physician, do not resuscitate. This would, when these delicate discussions have already occurred, and these are very delicate discussions, then if that patient comes from the hospital to a hospice, usually those discussions are already done but they're not really valid they have to be done again this makes it possible for that to be portable that that previous discussion that order is in effect when the patient goes to the hospice it is the responsibility of the physician receiving that patient to review that to be sure it's appropriate because it could be inappropriate so the patient is protected from that inappropriateness. But still, it just helps so much to give the kind of care
▶ Play
Speaker 148 2:07:32
that a patient has asked for. Okay, thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:07:39
Representative McGee, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. It's good to see you again, David. The question I have is the patient's in the nursing home, And they have a terminal cancer. And, of course, no one knows, just the good Lord knows, the day that we're going to leave this good world. But they've had discussions with their family, and they have an advanced directive of how they want to be treated. But they still have their faculties. Their mind's still good. Doesn't that patient at any point in time have the opportunity to change that? Absolutely. To say, I've changed my mind. They've thought about it two weeks, and they said, I don't, I want you to do this and this and this to change my directive. So it's totally up to the patient and their family. I can see the benefit of doing this. Okay, thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. All right. I'm seeing no further questions. We have a couple people, one signed for and one against. Rose Mims is signed to speak against this. If you go to the table, you're recognized to introduce yourself, and you're recognized to give testimony. Sure. We're one big happy family. Just grab a microphone nearby and introduce
▶ Play
yourself. My name is Rose Mims. I'm the Executive Director of Arkansas Right to Life. Arkansas Right to Life recognizes the principle that individuals should generally be able to express and implement their wishes regarding medical treatment, and we could support a version of a physician order for life-sustaining treatment form or POLST. that provides informed consent and appropriate protections that neutrally and equally enable people to direct as much as to reject life-saving medical treatment. HB 1533 fails to ensure that and contains a significant number of objectionable provisions. The bill almost completely abdicates legislative responsibility by delegating to the State Board of Health the authority to construct the content of the proposed form. This is unacceptable because many such forms used in other states misleadingly nudge vulnerable people, especially older people and people with disabilities, to reject life-saving treatment without adequate and accurate informed consent. because 5% of the insured population needs 50% of annual health care spending. Insurance companies have strong incentives to cajole those who need expensive life-saving treatment most to agree to forego it. So many insurance companies and some health care providers are hiring companies that specialize in pushing patients to complete so-called advanced care planning documents that reject treatment. the only way to ensure that a post form does not subtly or not too subtly push people to reject treatment the only way to ensure that it provides for truly neutral informed consent is for the legislation authorizing it to specify its content in detail leaving only minor details such as the exact formatting to administrative implementation because HB 1533 fails to do this it is too fatally flawed to be fixed by an amendment here and there a detailed substitute would be necessary with the legislative session scheduled to finish at the end of this month less than three weeks from now it's not realistic to negotiate the construction of such a substitute for passage this session therefore I respectfully urge that HB 1533 be put aside for this legislative session and that between the end of this session and the beginning of the 2017 session, there be full, frank, and thoughtful consultations among not just health care providers but also advocacy organizations, including Disability Rights and Older People's Group and certainly including Arkansas Right to Life. Those negotiations should also fix the numerous additional flaws in HB 15-3, which I'm able to point out. Now, there's five. First, HB 1533 contains inadequate language to protect patients to ensure that their wishes for treatment will be implemented. Two, section 20-6-210 provides that a later executed post-type form supersedes any conflicting instruction in an advanced directive. Three, the bill provides for resolution of disagreements exclusively within health care institutions without allowing for judicial recourse and without ensuring patients receive life-preserving treatment until the disagreement is authoritatively resolved. Four, HB 1533 contains an unacceptable section concerning out-of-state polls. And finally, fifth, the bill's exception in the case of a pregnant patient is inadequate. In conclusion, Arkansas Right to Life urges that HB 1533, that in light of its failure to specify the contents of a neutral pulse form with adequate informed consent and its numerous other flaws, the bill be put aside for this legislative session so that negotiations among appropriate stakeholders, including our organization, may work on an acceptable, balanced polls bill before next year's legislative session. I urge you to vote no on HB 1533. Thank you. Ms.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:13:38
Mims, let me ask a couple questions. I know everybody's tired here, but let me ask you a couple questions. One of the things you're talking about is, I think you or your organization, both whatever's concerned about the forms being formed not by statute but by rule, if you will. Keep in mind that we now oversee all rulemaking. So we would still, the legislature would still be in control of those forms because we oversee all rulemaking. Now, obviously I didn't write the bill and I don't want to go through all five, but I want to be sure you and your organization understand that the legislature would still be in control, just not by statute. And that's how we're doing a lot of things. It leaves us some flexibility, but we're still in control of it, but I know Representative Hammer has a question. I want to go, well, I won't. Representative Hammer, you're recognized. Well, it's actually a question
▶ Play
of the chair. Yes, sir. I understand what you just said, but not all 100 members have a voting right in that process. Is that correct? It
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:14:36
would be, I think, 25 of the House members. Isn't that how many is on council, Representative Branscombe? There's 25 members on council. Yes, sir. But there's only 20 members on this committee so at some point in time you've got to break down things right I'm just we're dealing with life that's that's all thank you we frequently do yes sir all right members any other questions seeing none thank you Miss Mims we have Miss Lita Lisa is I always say Vaden is it Vaden Vaden if you would introduce yourself for the record and you're recognized
▶ Play
Speaker 226 2:15:15
to begin good morning I'm Lisa Vaden I'm the executive director for the hospice and palliative care association of Arkansas we represent over 30 hospice providers throughout the state we serve well over 7,000 patients a year in Arkansas I'd like to clarify the POLST is so much more than just a DNR. It's an actual care planning tool that the patient completes with their physician when they're at a point of being terminally ill. Whether they're in hospice or not, when they're having the discussions with their physician about how they want to progress with their care, then the physician uses this form in collaboration with the patient and or their surrogate about what their desires are and it's not just about resuscitation it's about nutrition comfort measures different areas that we know will most likely have to be addressed as this patient progresses in their illness or their disease and because it's portable and it is a physician order then it follows the patient regardless of what facility or care program that they're in and it can be changed at any time it's a here and now order and care plan so three months down the line the patient's mindset may change about the way they want their course of care to be taken and then they can revamp this order with their physician so I would just wanted to share that it's much different than a than a DNR and it really is a care planning tool for the physician and the patient. We at the Hospice and Palliative Care Association support this bill. We think that POLST is good for our patients, for their families. We think it ensures continuity of care for our patients and puts their preferences over all of their care on paper in a physician order for many to follow. So I'm open for questions. Representative Meeks, I'll get to you
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:17:23
in just a second I want to clarify Representative Hammer, our great staff who's always on top of everything that I'm always wrong about also reminded me that with the case of all public health rulemaking, it has to go through the public health committee during the interim and then rules and regs and then through the council so yeah, it's a good number of people seeing it Representative Meeks, you're recognized for a question Thank
▶ Play
you, and I'm not a necessary legal scholar and this question could be for any of the folks there on the committee But it would just seem to me that why do we even need a law to be able to, I guess, have a form? And I realize it's a life and death situation, but there are so many business contracts and everything else that we don't do, you know, that we don't regulate here as far as the legislature is concerned. Why can't you all just create a legal form yourself or do it in a will? I don't know if there's other avenues rather than us having to pass a bill to allow this to happen. So whoever wants to answer that question
▶ Play
Speaker 214 2:18:24
of the three, please do so. That's an excellent
▶ Play
Speaker 216 2:18:27
question. In fact, we, as our committee met, tried to go and we actually went to the Arkansas Department of Health to ask if they could just devise the form. Their legal scholars looked through this and said that it had to do with the practice of medicine, which they could not do. So we have already gone to them asking them without having to take this step. and this was the only way we could get this enacted.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:18:58
All right, members, there's no one else signed up to speak for or against this. You've heard an explanation of the bill. Would
▶ Play
you like to close for your bill, Representative Ferguson? Yes, just I know the different groups that have interest in this, as he said, have met. And as he said, we were advised to not do the form and statute, that it should be done and come through rules on the Board of Health. I think it's good legislation. You passed the advance directive of legislation last time, which is exactly complementary to this. This just takes it to the next step where it's simpler for it to be transported with the doctor's orders. I appreciate a good vote. Thank you. members
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:19:43
for an explanation bill what's will this committee have a motion do pass any discussion of that motion seeing none all in favor say aye all opposed so no chair rules knows have it all right reps in Ferguson your bill has failed we're gonna hear a representative Eves I know we're past time folks but he has said here since what about 8 45 this morning I think is when you came in here. So, and he promises me, although there's no such thing as non-controversial. What is that bill number, Representative Eaves? 1636. 1636. Surely there's not an amendment on that, is there? There is. Okay, so we have to hear the amendment first. You're already down one strike. Let's see, the amendment's on the tablet, members. you recognize present your amendment thank you mr. chair and committee the
▶ Play
Speaker 229 2:20:44
amendment simply adds back in language that was stricken we added back in students and interns and we added back in the American Medical Association into the original bill that's the only
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:20:56
thing that changed members for an explanation of the amendment what's will the committee what we do to adopt the amendment all those in favor say aye any opposed the amendments adopted you recognize, present your bill, 1636. Thank you. I'll make this quick. I know you're all
▶ Play
Speaker 229 2:21:11
ready to get out of here. There's a major shortage of primary care physicians in Arkansas as well as the U.S. Two cities in Arkansas, Jonesboro and Fort Smith, are starting DO medical physician training in 2016. They plan to graduate 265 medical doctors who will be looking for internship or residency training programs beginning in 2020. According to UAMS, there are not enough residency slots programs to support the current graduating medical doctors. Over 60% of osteopathic physicians seek primary care specialties. So what is critically important in growing our own medical doctors is the data that reports 60% of the residency graduates take jobs within an hour of their residency training programs. The current law neither appropriately identifies the accreditation for the MD allopathic body nor recognizes the osteopathic body. The current statute lists the American Medical Association as the accrediting body for MDs. The correct body is the American College of Graduate Medical Education. This body accredits the postgraduate training programs and the institutional sponsor for the allopathic profession. The osteopathic accrediting body is not even listed in the current statute. Their body is the American Osteopathic Association and they accredit osteopathic postgraduate training programs. Unity Health Hospital in White County will be unable to get their doctor of osteopathy program, if that said that right, program up and running by July 1st of this year because current Arkansas law does not properly identify the American Osteopathic Association as the approving authority for hospitals teaching osteopathic medical students. So in a nutshell, that's what's being added to the bill is the accrediting body for osteopathic doctors. I'd be happy to answer any questions. Before I even to the bill why is
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:22:51
there an emergency clause they have to be at our
▶ Play
Speaker 229 2:22:54
trade this has to be in play implemented now because the training program at White County Medical Center and maybe others will start in July of this year are they not already training the program is just now being set up and that's how they discovered the the omission of the osteopathic accrediting body so they kind
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:23:15
of started a program without accreditation that's what it sounds like And this is supposed to be non-controversial? It's non-controversial. Representative Hammer, you're first. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Two questions then. So if we don't vote this through, what happens if they've already got up and run in and out? It's kind of like we're asking for forgiveness instead of permission. What happens? I understand. If it's okay with the chair, I'd like to ask Jodi Ann Tritt to help me with that question.
▶ Play
Speaker 198 2:23:47
Hi, I'm Jody Ann Tritt with the Arkansas Hospital Association. Actually, they haven't put the cart before the horse, even though it might seem so, because the program can't start until July the 1st. So had we not had an emergency clause on the bill, you know how long it takes bills to become active. It would have been August or so, and the slots needed to open up on July the 1st so that folks could enroll in those residency programs at the right time and make the accreditation steps appropriately.
▶ Play
Speaker 148 2:24:14
Thank you. One follow-up, please. Yes, sir.
▶ Play
You made a statement that I'd like you to tell me how you can justify it or how you substantiate the fact that you said, and with considering who's added on to this bill as sponsors, that there's a recognized shortage of doctors in this state, and I'd like you to support your
▶ Play
Speaker 229 2:24:41
statement, please. All right. The information that I get regarding that topic came from Unity Healthcare in Light County.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:24:47
from ray montgomery the ceo any other questions members for an explanation of the bill anyone signed up speak for against this bill saying none anyone audience come forward for against it saying none what's will this committee but do pass representative makes any discussion as amended that's right do pass as amended any discussion on that motion seeing none all in favor say aye all opposed say nay eyes have it congratulations and we're adjourned
▶ Play

Agenda

SB426

1:21 - 5:35 18 segments 6 speakers

HB1609

5:35 - 7:25 5 segments 2 speakers

HB1747

7:25 - 1:08:57 177 segments 15 speakers

HB1142

1:08:57 - 1:53:02 113 segments 11 speakers

HB1533

1:53:02 - 2:21:07 74 segments 11 speakers

HB1636

2:21:07 - 2:25:29 16 segments 5 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Chair Unverified
93 segments
Speaker 3
1 segment
Representative Bruce Cozart Unverified
4 segments
Representative Stephen Meeks Unverified
11 segments
Representative Robin Lundstrum Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 25
1 segment
Representative DeAnn Vaught Unverified
4 segments
Representative Kenneth B. Ferguson Unverified
12 segments
Representative Dan Sullivan Unverified
14 segments
Speaker 51
20 segments
Speaker 59
67 segments
Speaker 83
10 segments
Speaker 88
1 segment
Speaker 105
1 segment
Speaker 100
1 segment
Representative Fredrick J. Love Unverified
8 segments
Speaker 126
1 segment
Speaker 140
1 segment
Representative Kim Hammer Unverified
17 segments
Bill Phillips Unverified
7 segments
Speaker 157
27 segments
Catherine Sparkman Unverified
38 segments
Representative Ken Henderson Chair Unverified
5 segments
Representative Mary Bentley Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 198
14 segments
Speaker 216
20 segments
Speaker 221
1 segment
Speaker 148
2 segments
Rose Mims Unverified
10 segments
Speaker 226
5 segments
Speaker 214
1 segment
Speaker 229
8 segments