House State Agencies & Govt'l Affairs Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (7)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HJR1007
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HJR1007”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HJR1027
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HJR1027”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HJR10
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…stitutional Amendments. Okay, I make a motion that we refer HJR 10-12 to the Joint Committee on Constitutional Amendments. All…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HJR1002
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HJR1002”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HJR1005
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HJR1005”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HJR1006
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “a motion that we move to refer HJR 1006 to the Joint Committee on Constitutional Amendments. All ri…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HJR1012
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HJR1012”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 15, 2026
Consideration of constitutional amendments for referral to the joint committee. I sent all of you an email at your legislative emails this morning. I don't know if all of you have received it, but to kind of update you, there is one change. The Senate committee had originally agreed to a joint committee meeting next Friday at 9. I think that has now been changed and canceled, so we are off on that at this point. We'll continue those discussions. But as of right now, we do not have a joint meeting scheduled.
So you can go back to considering your Friday morning would be normal committee at this point. And I will do my best to keep you informed of that fluid process as we continue negotiations on getting to a final resolution. Senate committee did also, as my understanding yesterday, vote to refer all Senate resolutions to the joint committee and did not restrict to six. As I noted in the email to all of you, I would prefer that we keep with the original agreement,
but I'm open to a couple different options of possibly referring the ones that we've heard. Clearly we don't need to be referring the shells and some of that sort of thing. But it would be my preference that we stay on track with what we had originally agreed to and try to limit the process so that the joint committee can narrow its focus a little bit quicker, hopefully, when we get together.
With that, I think I'm going to open up for discussion for just a few minutes, for general discussion, and then we'll go to motions. Does anybody have any points of discussion that maybe we can talk about? I see Representative Link nodding, and we'll get to you next, Representative Ballinger. Do we have to put three on the ballot? Representative Link, there's no requirement that we put any on the ballot. I don't
Speaker 4
1:58
know that we have to keep fixing the Constitution. It seems to be working. I know we want to tweak it from time to time,
but I think the public, quite honestly, would be really proud if we did not send three to the ballot and they'd look at us and say, you know, that's pretty responsible
opinion. Representative Ballinger, you're recognized for discussion. Thank you, Mr. Chair. what I would say we may kind of give parameters of the things that we should be looking at and considering like not only whether or not it's a good idea but whether or not it has any chance of making it out of the joint committee and those type of things and then actually to Representative Link's point
I would agree with that except there probably are some real things within the constitution that need to be cleaned up they're not sexy, they're not going to bring people out but things that people have presented that are just kind of good clean-up government stuff. So if we're not going to put out anything we're real excited about, a couple of these other things that are clean-up
we ought to do. So that's my opinion. Additional discussion? Seeing none, we will begin to consider some action.
Representative Gray, do you have some action you'd like to consider? Yes, I'd like to make
a motion that we move to refer HJR 1006 to the Joint Committee on Constitutional Amendments. All right, committee, we have a motion, discussion
on the motion. Representative Ballinger. I would just say that
that's exactly, I mean, I think that's a bill that's something that has been an issue,
and if we define it, then that won't be an issue anymore. So that's exactly the kind of
thing I think we should be referring out to the people. Representative Bennett, you said give you a second. You're okay? Okay. Representative Douglas, did you have
a point of discussion or question? Well, if someone could clarify for me if this is something we cannot clarify through the courts, why do we have to go through a constitutional amendment? I need that clarification.
Speaker 3
4:13
Representative Link. Representative Douglas and to everybody, obviously Representative Branscombe is close to
Speaker 4
4:18
my district and where all this began and where all the concern began. But all that it says right now, all that our Constitution says is infamous crime. It leaves it up to the courts to define infamous crime. And over the years, that definition has got kind of almost difficult to work within. and I think that we're leaving good people setting off of ballots because of the way that that's been defined.
I'm not gripping about the judges, but if someone wrote, for those of us that go far enough back, and I think most of us in this room go far enough back in this room that we didn't have credit cards and everything in the 70s and 80s, and a lot of us were in college, and, you know, he could have written a $10 hot check for a pizza back then. And I'm kind of going back to one of our representatives who then tried to run for a sheriff and wasn't able to run for sheriff. He could have wrote a hot check for a $10 pizza back in the 80s
and you're no longer qualified to serve in the legislature or even as a sheriff or anything else because a hot check's been defined as an infamous crime. And so not griping at the judges, but now I'm going to gripe at the judges. Then we come along and as Supreme Court, to serve as a judge, you have to have been a licensed attorney in the state for six years. And if you remember the story, several had not renewed their license in a timely manner,
which technically made them an unlicensed attorney, yet when it was brought to their attention, they said, no, no, no, that's fine, that's just one of those technical things we want to overlook. Why wasn't that an infamous crime? If a hot check when you're in college and trying to buy a pizza is an infamous crime that doesn't allow you that you're not good enough to serve the people in this state, then why is it not an infamous crime that you forgot to renew your license as an attorney? So anyway, that would be my point for why I think that would be a good one.
I think when it gets to the public, it's going to be difficult. I think they may look at this and say there goes those self-serving legislators again. They want to be able to commit crimes and still serve. so we got we got to be careful about how we put that on
the ballot again my opinion that's what we're trying to do is just get through some opinions here i think at this point uh just a good healthy discussion is good representative ladyman uh you're recognized for a point of discussion yeah
just just to comment on uh what representative link was saying there you know things have changed over the last 20 years and you know he talked about how it was in the past
and we need to define that, who's to say that 20 years from now it won't change and there are going to be people sitting in the same room and say, hey, we've got to change this. You know, the Constitution, whether it be the state or the federal, is something we don't want to be changing every 20 years just because things change in our lives. So, you know, locking this in as a definition in the Constitution, I think, might be the wrong way to
go. I will say as a point of discussion, kind of following behind Representative Ladyman,
the way that it's defined in this amendment defines it based on statute. And so the legislature always has the ability to revisit those statutes. So there is some ability to be flexible because of that within the proposal. But you do have a point. I think it's something anytime we amend the Constitution or even refer an amendment to the people, we need to take it very seriously and be cautious about it. So, Representative Douglas, did you have an additional point of discussion, or were
you finished? I guess it still just concerns me that we cannot get the definition down without putting it in the Constitution.
And I'm not a lawyer and don't understand the process, and I think Representative Link did a great job of explaining what the problem is. But are we tacking the problem from the wrong angle? Just not sure of that yet, but I'm getting there. Thank you. Well, and I
will say that I wish there were a number of things that I wish we didn't have to tinker with the Constitution to get the courts to do. And I think that's a shared view among a lot of legislators. Thank you.
Representative Ballinger, did you have another point of discussion?
Yes, I did. I just wanted to say that the reason why he's amending it here in the Constitution is because he's been working on this for four years that I know of, trying to get this done through code, and it's impossible to do because of the fact that the infamous crimes is written into the Constitution. So the courts have said if you're going to amend it, then you need to actually amend it through the Constitution. So there's really no other place that we have to define this other than defining the Constitution,
unless the courts wanted to give us a real clear definition, but they're hesitant to do it because they've never received that direction from the legislature so it's it's kind of vicious circle about the only way we do it is referring a constitutional amendment out and this is a good time to do it because the fact that we may not get anything else out that we think it's really exciting so i think this
is just good cleanup stuff representative bennett uh you're
recognized for discussion i just want to defend our courts for a minute you know one of the things that ties
a court's hand for better or for worse is they can only address issues that are in controversy before them and that makes sense. You don't want people to just walk off the streets and go, hey court, what do you think about this? Hey, what do you think that is? Because if there's not some controversy that they have to decide then they don't have jurisdiction to make that decision. The simplest way to get a definition of this is it's actually in our divorce cases and if a few people would file for divorce based on
infamous crimes. You'd start seeing some judicial definition of what or what is not an infamous crime. I'm fine with pushing this one forward. I think it doesn't hurt anything, but I don't think we're putting it in statute unless I'm misreading this. This is actually a constitutional amendment, so it cannot be changed by the legislature.
Representative Bennett probably didn't make myself clear. It defines infamous crime on the basis of statute. But various felonies, various misdemeanors, so it ties it to those.
That was my point. We're definitely referring this for a constitutional change. Okay.
– I'd like to see this one go. The reason I've had some – in my district, you know, I have five counties, and I had some elected officials that this affected, which really was really myself was just nitpicking,
and there was no way to define infamous crime, and they're winning their elections by 80 percent. So the people there, you know, were certainly in favor of them. But I think this is an issue, and I have talked to Representative Branscombe about this and know he's worked on this for a long time trying to get it taken care of. So, you know, I think it's something we really need to look at. Thank
you. Thank you, Representative Holcomb. Additional discussion? Representative Bennett, you're recognized. And I
probably ought to look at this, but it's a hot check fraud.
So we're basically saying you can't hold office if you've ever written a
hot check. You're the lawyer. I hope another lawyer can answer that
question for you. I don't know the answer to that. Not that
anyone here would ever have done such a thing. I do know that, you know, we have had, as I mentioned, I think we've had a sheriff removed in the state for stealing a few chickens in a situation that it was questionable whether it was outright theft or not.
But, you know, it was one of those situations where somebody took a plea rather than continue to fight something in their young years and then turns around and becomes a big problem later. And so, you know, just from my point of view, I think clarification is beneficial if, you know, if the Senate committee concurred and the people concurred. But additional discussion? All right, committee, we see no further discussion on the motion.
Okay, Representative Bennett, we'll come back to
you. So this is putting it in the Constitution that the guy that stole the chickens can't serve? I'm not sure of that. No, I mean, I just want to let you know that that is what, because it has no age limit. I mean, you could have done something as a 16-year-old or a 14-year-old that's a misdemeanor, and it could have been expunged. You could have become the most wonderful person in the world, but we're now saying you can't hold office.
Now I see additional discussion from Representative Ballinger.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. What I would say is if it's a misdemeanor offense in which the finder of fact is required to find that the defendant or the defendant admitted to an act of deceit, fraud, or false statement. So the chickens probably wouldn't fall into the category. Now, the question what I'm trying to look up is whether fraud, you know, there is check fraud, but that's different than writing a hot check. So I don't know if hot check laws would fall into the category of fraud.
I don't think it would. But the chickens wouldn't fall into it because it's not something that would require deceit, fraud, or false statement. And now I
see additional discussion from Representative Link. A point of clarification, there were frozen Cornish hens. Thank you for that clarification, Representative Link. Representative Holcomb, did I see you have additional discussions? All right. Is there additional discussion from the committee on the motion? Seeing none, all in favor of the motion say aye
Opposed All right, committee, I'm going to rule that the motion has been referred or that the resolution has been referred to joint committee All right, next up on our agenda I guess we don't have an agenda on this Committee, are there additional resolutions we want to take up here? All right, Representative Ballinger, you're recognized for a motion.
I'd make a motion that we do HJR 10-12. All right, I have a motion to take up or to refer. Representative Ballinger, if you'd put that in the form of a motion to refer to the Joint
Committee on Constitutional Amendments. Okay, I make a motion that we refer HJR 10-12 to the Joint Committee on Constitutional Amendments. All right,
we have a motion from Representative Ballinger. Discussion on the motion. Representative Douglas, you're recognized for discussion I know there's an easy answer for this
but is this the only way to fix allowing the election when there's only one candidate this is the only way to fix that I want to be careful
not to argue from the chair anymore I try to restrain myself since this is my bill I'll do my best to explain um yes for the offices listed uh it is the only way to fix um i ran a bill through here it's out of the house and in the senate that addresses all the offices that can be addressed via statute
um so the ones who are listed here are um are constitutionally set and this proposal gives the legislature the flexibility to address those by statute so uh those of you who are coming back we'll have the opportunity to decide how they would do that. My recommendation to you, should it pass, would be to grant election commissions the flexibility to make that decision locally, just as we did in the bill. But, yes, that's the situation.
Representative Drown, you're recognized for discussion. I think
I can help this process on a little bit. We're currently going through this in, of course, District 16, Senate District, and my district 68, which affects four, maybe five representatives because we have an elected senator that until being the only candidate goes through a general election here, and I think it's in April, we don't have somebody we can go to to co-sponsor bills on the Senate side, so on and so forth.
So this is one of those that I believe will be, I wouldn't say embraced, but accept it on both sides because it is affecting both sides, both the House and the Senate right now currently. And we tried to fix that process through. We tried to run a bill.
The Attorney General ruled it unconstitutional. Additional
discussion on the motion? Representative Bennett. One question. Would this fix that problem?
because would they take office earlier than the time they would have been on the ballot? Representative Bennett,
it is my belief based on discussion that it would because special primary election is listed here. So that would give the Election Commission the flexibility to determine whether a general election would be required or not. Then I say we move forward with this. Is there additional discussion on the motion?
Seeing none, we have a motion. All in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? All right. We'll refer that resolution to the joint committee. All right. I believe someone else had a motion that they were wanting to take up earlier. Representative Gray, you're recognized for a motion. All right. I'm up in arms of which one I want to do
but I'll make a motion that we refer HJR 1007 to the Joint Committee on Constitutional Amendments Alright, committee, I'll give you a moment
to update your tablets and then we'll take discussion when someone's ready
Is there discussion? All right. Representative Hickerson, you're recognized for discussion.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Isn't there a Senate resolution? There
is a similar Senate resolution. But none of these
are coordinated. Lowry's, Ladyman's, or the Senate? I can't speak to that. I don't know
whether the folks on the opposite ends are making an effort to coordinate. Okay, thank you, Mr. Chairman.
can talk about mine. You know, they are coordinated. They're very similar. I think they
combined. Was that your question? Yeah, well, you all might mention the numbers that you're referring to. so that the committee, I'm not able to
keep up myself. Senate bill, I'm sure Senator King has a bill or someone, I mean a resolution.
I think your question was, are we coordinating with someone on the other side that has a similar amendment to ours? Yes. Yes, and my comment was that, yes, I am talking to Senator King and we are discussing these and the differences, and they're very similar, very close. That's not on this resolution. It's HJR 1027, I'm sorry. Yes, yes, okay.
Thank you. All right, Representative Bennett, did you have discussion? No. Okay, additional discussion?
Representative Ballinger, you're recognized for point of discussion. And this is, I mean, obviously I'm supportive of sending this over here, over there, or at least I'm supportive of sending it out to the public. But at the same time, one of the things that I think we should consider is whether or not it's likely to ever make it out. And so we have a committee that's split over there, 4-4, and I don't anticipate that either the other four on the other side would support this. So I just think from a point of discussion, I think it would probably be good for us to send it over there.
But at the same time, if it boots out another resolution that may have a chance to pass,
Additional discussion. Representative Douglas, you're recognized for discussion. I'd like to see the three bills, those people with those three bills get together and see what the differences are, what are the similarities, coordinate with the Senate and see if we can't hold off on voting on a third resolution
until we hear back from a coordination and present one piece. Representative Douglas, we're
several months into this process and they've had a lot of opportunity to do that. I'm to the point that I believe we need to make some decisions. I do agree with that. I want to
make a good decision, and if they can put one good bill together, then I think that would be worth waiting on. But I would refer to the chair on that decision.
Well, I will point out that the Senate has referred all of theirs, and there is one on the Senate end, and it certainly can be amended to reflect if they choose to coordinate or we can put this one in the mix and the Senate can look to work with the House sponsor. That's entirely at the pleasure of the committee. So additional
discussion? Representative Bennett, you're recognized. I will be voting against referring this.
I mean, we're just setting our state up for another round of constitutional challenges. The court's already said this is unconstitutional, and I just am a little frustrated that we just keep spinning the wheel and spending more money on things that have already been decided.
Representative Ballinger, point of discussion. Just for a point of clarification, it was unconstitutional because it wasn't in the Constitution. So what we're doing is we're amending the Constitution, so therefore it would be constitutional.
So I'd have to say that if we decided to send this out and the public decided they did want it and they voted for it, it would become part of the
Constitution and it would be constitutional. Representative Bennett,
additional discussion. Unless we can change the federal Constitution, it is not going to change the
on guess, but there have been photo IDs that's been upheld in other places. And this is modeled off from some of those other ones that have been upheld.
So I don't think that that would be a concern with the federal constitution. What the problem was is that we didn't have the requisite number of votes, was what Harkville Supreme Court said, in order to pass and make an amendment to the election law that would require the ID that they said is an additional barrier. And so in this case, you know, it would be upheld as constitutional. Now, whether it's good policy or not, that may be another issue. whether it's even smart for us to send it over there when there's another bill that's already we know has been referred to the joint committee.
That's another issue. But from my standpoint, I mean, the question of whether it's constitutional seems to be
moved. The chair would add a point of discussion to just say that I tend to concur with Representative Ballinger's original point, which is I think there is a near zero chance of anything related to voter identification being passed out of the joint committee, and we do have one there. I'm certainly not going to oppose this motion, but I just would urge the committee to act judiciously.
So additional discussion. Representative Gray, you're recognized for discussion. This is more of a question. If
we don't think this has any chance and it's possible that we could amend the Senate bill, I mean, would it be wise for me to withdraw my motion? Representative Gray, it's
your motion and it is totally up to you what you choose to do with
Additional discussion from the committee? Seeing none All in favor of referral say aye Opposed Ayes have it Resolution is referred Alright committee What's up next Representative Bennett you've been waving your hand For the last little bit you're recognized For
a motion I move that we refer house joint Resolution 1027 To the committee
Is there a discussion on the motion? Reverend New Ballinger, you're
recognized for discussion. This is maybe kind of an old point. There is already one that's been referred to the joint committee that would be very similar to this, so just so that everyone realizes there's one there. And who knows, maybe we don't have enough that we really want to refer out that it taking up another spot would be an issue, but just as long as everyone realizes that the same basic resolution is already in the joint committee.
The Senate resolution? I'm not familiar. I know it's Senator King's, and it is down there, but SJR 5, I believe, is what staff's telling me. I would add, as a point of discussion committee, that one of the things that is always, for those of you that haven't been in joint committee before, time and maintaining a quorum is difficult down there, and the fewer items of discussion than we have down there, the better off we all are. So I'll put that in the mix. Representative Bennett, you're recognized for discussion. If
there's one on the floor already, I'll withdraw my motion.
All right. So Representative Ladyman, I'm going to go ahead and recognize Representative Ladyman for a point of discussion before I take your
withdrawal. Yeah, just to point out one difference, unless Senator King has amended his amendment, Mine has the JPs out of the mix His had them in the mix So they're different in that sense Unless he's amended his And I don't know whether he has or not So they are different in that sense His would include the JPs
Mine do not Representative Bennett, now I'm going to come back to you Do you wish to withdraw your
motion? What's your pleasure? Point of clarification We can amend these in discussion They can be amended In theory, we could amend his to if we wanted to? That is correct. Representative Leitemann, I will defer to you. You want to go forward with yours? I would like to. Then I'll leave my motion on the floor.
All right, motion is still on the floor. Additional discussion? Representative Leitemann, you're
recognized for point of discussion. Just a point of information, I guess, just so you know. I had a discussion with DFA. As you all know, I had a motion, a bill that I was going to present to add a write-in candidate, and I got a financial impact statement for that. And putting an extra line on a ballot in all the ballots in the state would have a $1.5 million impact.
Now, I have asked them to do an impact statement for this particular amendment. I don't have that back yet. I may have it by Monday. but if adding a line on there impacts the budget by one and a half million dollars removing these every two years going from two year to four year should have a larger impact as far as savings so I just want to throw that out as an extra benefit taking the line out all right additional discussion from the members representative lady but
to your point I will say that to write in adds a
separate function um so i don't know the deleting i know i don't know the answer so i'm certainly not trying to say that i do but i don't believe that deleting individual elections has the same effect on the machines that deleting deleting or adding write-ins does representative hickerson recognized for
a point of discussion thank you mr chairman and i believe that by the time if this were on there and by the time it was passed we're going to have all new voting equipment Hopefully, or in the counties, that is on the Secretary of State.
So I think that could all be built in, I would think. So just a discussion point. Committee staff has
advised me that there is an impact statement on Representative Ladyman's proposal, and she's working to get it for us right now. Additional discussion? Seeing none, would the committee like to wait just a moment until we get that impact statement, or do you want to move forward with action on this?
All right, I'm seeing a lot of heads nodding that we'll move forward and we'll get that impact statement later. And I've just been handed it. And just for a point of clarification, revenue impact shows savings, unknown amount. It does decrease ballot programming costs. would provide savings to the Board of Election Commissioners during preferential primary runoffs and some savings to counties and municipalities during general elections, all undefined.
So with that, committee, is there additional discussion? Seeing none, we have a motion to refer to joint committee. All in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? All right. that HJR 1027 has been referred to joint committee. All right, Representative Fite, you're recognized. Representative Miller, you're recognized for a
motion. Yes, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I would like to make a motion to refer HJR 1002 to the joint committee.
All right, committee, I'll give you a moment to update your tablets, and we'll begin. How many is that? Okay. All right, committee, is there discussion on the motion? Representative McGee, you're recognized for motion. I'm sorry, you're recognized for point of discussion. Point of discussion.
But by doing this, Representative Miller, if this goes through, has there been any impact statement on how much this is going to save the state?
Do you know? No, sir, I don't know. I just like the idea. Oh, I do, too.
to save us money. Well, I don't think there's any doubt about that. And every time it seems to me like every time we meet down here, we manage to grow this thing. So the less we meet, the smaller
All right. Thank you. Representative Douglas, you're recognized
for point of discussion. I do remember from some of Representative Dan Douglas' testimony that if we do need to take up an issue that is fiscal or otherwise, a special session is cheaper than the fiscal session. So I don't know what the numbers are, but we still have the possibility of taking up issues in the offseason
and it being less expensive. Thank you. All
right, additional points of discussion. Representative Holcomb. Well, I
personally like the idea. I like the bill. My only concern, you know, we're catching a lot of flack about the commission and the raise, and I'm just wondering if they're going to say, you know, you're getting raised and you're doing less work. That would be my only concern, but I think personally, I think it worked fine before,
and I think when we come in for the official session, it's just a big mix-up,
so just comment. And the chair will remind the committee that we have referred four at this point. Representative Hickerson, you're
recognized for point of discussion. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I just wanted to point out that this is also a Senate resolution. I believe it's Ingram. I believe that's correct. But there is also a Senate resolution to this same. I do believe they coordinated those, but I could be wrong.
And important discussion from the Chair. I'll echo what Representative Holcomb said. The Salary Commission is making their final decision on, I believe, the 16th, and they have made their decision based on the fiscal session being in the mix. So Representative Fite, you recognize. Representative Miller, you're recognized for
important discussion. Thank you, Mr. Chair. A little bird just spoke in my ear and said between the House and the Senate, a fiscal session cost a little over $800,000.
And just for the House, we're looking at upwards, you know, around $400,000 or so. So that's just something to think about. I like the idea. Additional discussion. Representative Ballinger, you're
I don't know how many were going to – well, you indicated it wasn't necessarily a hard number, but I don't know how many we're going to refer out. But if we do refer this, then it would be three of our referrals
or three that we could amend that are already actually in joint committee. So as much as I like the idea and I think we should have the discussion, I would say this is probably one that I would suggest us not refer out, or at least not until we are sure that there's not, you know, at least two more. I mean, you know, that essentially would mean that we'd only have one more that we'd refer out. So since this is already in the joint committee, I would suggest us not refer this one out for that process.
Representative Bennett, you're recognized for a point of discussion.
If the one that's referred is the one that Senator Ingram put forth, is that the one we're referring to? Senator
Ingram's is a Senate proposal. Right, but that's the
one we're saying is already in the mix. Senate referred all of their SJRs. The reason I'm bringing that up is I'm a co-sponsor on that. We decided not to go forward with ours because of this one here. So we're perfectly happy to push this one forward and not ours.
All right, additional discussion from the members? Representative Gray, you're recognized for discussion. Well, I
guess in Representative Bennett, did they not refer all of them? Or did – could we – what I'm saying is could we still use – could we still look at the one on the Senate side and just be one less we refer out on this side? Since yours is
there anyhow, if they're referring them. Quite frankly, I haven't read the two since we decided to go forward to be sure they're exact.
If they are, yes, you could do it either way, but I just wanted to make that point. The
chair will just remind the committee, as I've said earlier, one of the things that makes this process very difficult is the number of proposals involved, and I would encourage you to take every step to limit the number of proposals that we have to consider in joint committee. It will make that process much simpler. And as someone indicated, we have already duplicated, I believe, two Senate proposals or have some that are very similar.
Encouraging this process to narrow down and encouraging people to begin to get together and amend bills to achieve a common objective is very important at this stage of the process. We need to get this thing wrapped up. So with that, that will be my point of discussion. Representative Dotson, you're recognized
for point of discussion. Thank you, Mr. Chair. With having one already in joint committee and having already put two duplicates in there, I don't think I would want to put another one in there like this.
Speaker 117
38:24
Just throwing that out there. Additional discussion from the committee. Representative McGee, you're recognized for
there then that narrows the discussion in the joint committee Representative McGee, there's certainly no requirement that we send, as Representative Link I think is indicating that we send any at all but the issue just from past experience
having participated in two rounds of this now, one is an onlooker and one is a participant, I can tell you that it is difficult enough just because of the sheer number that we deal with. So my strong admonition to the committee is, and I'm not saying this specific to this one, but we have sent four. We have several more in the mix. I would encourage you to avoid duplication when possible, and I'll just leave it at that. Okay.
Representative Miller, you're recognized for a point of
discussion. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And in order to save time, I've spoken with Representative Bennett, and she has agreed to get with Representative Douglas and Senator Ingram and work all this out over there on theirs. So we'll just yank this one and move on. All
right, so you're withdrawing your motion? Yes, sir. All right, so the motion has been withdrawn. All right. with additional items of business.
Representative Wardlaw, you're recognized for a motion. I'd like
to make a motion to refer Representative Shepard's HJR1005. We've all watched the judicial elections in the past and seen the disturbing TV ads come forth, and I think we need to do as much as possible to address that, so I'd like to refer this one to the joint committee. All right, committee, we do have a motion and want to
begin discussion. I do want to remind the committee we are at 949.
The House goes in session at 10 o'clock, and we must adjourn prior to 10 o'clock. So with that discussion from the committee, Representative Ballinger, you're recognized for a
point of discussion. I like the motion, and I like Representative Shepard's resolution, but I also like Representative Dotson's resolution. And I don't know if, I mean, to me, I think that for the, and that's HJR 1016, I'd love for the discussion to incorporate both. So is it, I mean, I guess what we could do is we could refer both of them out there,
but if that gives us our six, it would cut off another person. But I think that the discussion essentially is going to be the same discussion, maybe two different ways of doing the same thing. But anyway, that's just my point is that, you know, if we're limited to one or the other, I would go with Dotson's just simply because it
does a little more. Additional discussion? Representative Hickerson, is that a point of discussion or is that just waving your pen in the air? All right.
Additional discussion from the committee. Representative Dotson, you're recognized. Of course, I'm partial to
1016, since it's mine, but I think it is a little bit broader than 1005, and certainly, if we can only have one, I would certainly prefer that, but the will of the committee. All right. Additional discussion from the committee?
All right. Representative Bennett, was that an appointed discussion? It
is. You're recognized for a point of discussion. I do believe that 1002 has a more likely possibility of getting support from the bar. Now, 102 has previously been passed. I'm sorry, which one? 1005, I'm sorry, because it only applies to the Supreme Court and the Court of Appeals. I think that's a good starting point to see how that goes.
Additional discussion from the committee Representative Dotson you're recognized for
point of discussion With regards to HGR 1016 I know that's not the one we're discussing currently but there has there have been a few amendments to it if you do pull that up and look at it a couple of things to point out as differences is the fact that HGR 1016 does have a little bit more legislative oversight The 15-panel committee that is appointed, the appointment process has four members of the legislature
that get to help select those Supreme Court nominees that the governor would select from, as well as a Senate confirmation process of that nominee after selected. So that's a little bit of a difference. In addition, it does also provide for elections, a change in the process of elections, of the rest of the judicial as well as prosecuting attorneys. So it's a little bit broader amendment than what HJR 1005. Representative Hickerson point of discussion. Yes
and I read this but it's been a good file Representative Dodson does that not put party politics back into it? They run by party on some of these offices that are non-partisan. I may have misread it and it's been a long time. I should have reviewed it I guess. Representative Hickerson, I don't mean
to interrupt, but I want to remind the folks in the audience that you are not permitted to approach the representatives while they're at the table. Please do not do that. All right. I'm sorry, Representative Hickerson.
Does it allow for partisan Republican-Democrat running again? What it does is it strikes the language
in the Constitution that's currently there that requires that all judicial elections
be nonpartisan and puts it into the purview of the general assembly. to decide by law on an ongoing basis in the future, just similar to what prosecuting attorneys are done right now, which we did a couple of years ago. So the legislature in the future would have the ability to decide that
instead of having to go through a constitutional amendment process. It opens
it up. Thank you, Representative Dodson. I thought I saw that in
there. Representative Ballinger, you had a point of discussion. Going to that, on clarification, The Supreme Court, though, would be selected through this process, so it wouldn't be an election at all, similar to what Matthew Shepard, or represents Shepard's bill. At the risk of upsetting my friend, Ms. Representative Wardlaw,
I'd like to actually make a substitute motion that we refer out HJR 1016. All right. We have a substitute
motion. Discussion on the substitute motion? Representative Ladyman, you're recognized for point of discussion. Well, both of these. I do want to remind the committee at this point that we have to be in session in six
minutes. I'll be short. Both of these bills I've read. I've talked to Representative Dobson and Shepard about the details of these. One of the big differences that I think is the confirmation by the Senate of the governor's appointment is in Representative Dobson's bill.
It is not in Representative Shepard's bill. for that reason I
would support Representative Dobson. All right well the motion currently before us is the substitute motion of Representative Ballinger. Additional discussion on the motion? All right seeing none all in favor of referral of SJR 1016 say aye. Aye. Opposed? No. Uh, Representative Ballinger, I'm going to have to rule that your motion fails.
Um, all right, committee, um, we need to wrap up here pretty quickly. Is there, is there an additional motion? Mm-hmm. Representative. Representative Wardlaw? I
would, uh, echo my previous motion to refer HJR 1005. Immediate consideration. And that motion is in
order, um, and, uh, I'm not going to take your immediate consideration motion representative hickerson we're going to go directly to a vote um so um with uh
uh committee we have a motion to refer hjr 1005 all in favor say aye aye opposed i'm going to rule that the ayes have it and that hjr 1005 has been referred our committee are there additional motions representative bennett i move
that the referral process cease. All in favor
say aye. Opposed? All right committee, get to session. We're adjourned.
Agenda
HJR1012
HJR1007
HJR1027
HJR1002
HJR1005
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Nate Bell Chair
Unverified
Speaker 4
Representative Bob Ballinger
Unverified
Representative Michelle Gray
Unverified
Chair
Unverified
Speaker 3
Representative Jack Ladyman
Unverified
Representative Camille Bennett
Unverified
Speaker 44
Representative Mike Holcomb
Unverified
Representative R. Trevor Drown
Unverified
Speaker 74
Representative Mary P. "Prissy" Hickerson
Unverified
Speaker 79
Speaker 13
Representative Josh Miller
Unverified
Representative Jeff Wardlaw
Unverified
Speaker 64
Speaker 109
Representative Jim Dotson
Unverified
Speaker 117