Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House Judiciary Committee

March 17, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (6)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1676 · 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…ommittee members, without objection, we're going to move to House Bill 1676, Representative Meeks. Good morning, Mr. Meeks.”
Pre-2017 bill
SB79 · 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “...up today is Senate Bill 79, which was re-referred to the committee. Senator Woods, you…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1376 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1376”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1599 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1599”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1624 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1624”
Pre-2017 bill
SB484 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB484”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 15, 2026
...up today is Senate Bill 79, which was re-referred to the committee. Senator Woods, you're recognized to present Senate Bill 79. Senator Woods, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chair. Thank you, committee members. This morning I have Meredith Lowry, Coach Frank Broyles, personal attorney with me, and Joe Briggs with the NFL Players Association. And also I'd like to give a warm welcome to a new Cowboys celebrity, Arkansas native, our own Darren McFadden is here in the audience today. I'd like to say hello. And it means a lot, Darren. Thank you so much for taking time to come here today and to support this. And we amended Senate Bill 79 on the House floor a few days ago, and so the bill has been sent back for proper due pass. And so we had some agreed-to language from the University of Arkansas, and that's been engrossed. And I'll be glad to take any questions at this time, but I am close for the bill
▶ Play
and appreciate your vote. Representative Beck, you're recognized
▶ Play
for a question. Yes. I was approached about the possibility of some other amendments to this bill.
▶ Play
All other amendments at this time are hostile in amendments, and I'm not agreed to those, and I'm not interested. Thank you. Thank
▶ Play
you. Okay. Seeing no further questions. We're going to go to the list for public comment. Graham Catlett. Mr. Catlett, if you'll have a seat at the end of the table, state your name, who you represent, and then you may offer your testimony.
▶ Play
You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. My name is Graham Catlett. I am an Arkansas attorney, and I am today before you on behalf of two associations, the Motion Picture Association of America and its member companies, including the Walt Disney Studios, 21st Century Fox, Paramount Pictures, NBC Universal, Sony Pictures, and Warner Brothers. and on behalf of the Entertainment Software Association, the publishers of video games, including EA Sports. I'm speaking in opposition to this bill as it currently exists. We favored this bill and wanted to assist Coach Broyles with his bill until the Players Association added an amendment last week. We think this amendment creates a chilling effect on First Amendment protected speech for motion pictures, television, video games, newspapers, books, magazines, and theater. At the heart of these right of publicity bills is what's called the expressive use exemption. That means that television, news, films, magazines can depict individuals. However, this new amendment by the Players Association excludes from that exemption a new category where the use is not protected by the First Amendment or the Arkansas Constitution. That cause requiring proof of First Amendment protection is a sham. It requires the movie producer, the television producer, or the magazine or newspaper publisher to undergo the risk and exorbitant cost of proving that a use is permitted under the First Amendment. The bill is worded so that it creates an automatic violation whenever magazines or newspapers use names or likenesses. For instance, every photo in Sports Illustrated would create a claim. A photograph in a TV program discussing history would create an automatic cause of action. The impact is that every use presumptively creates a violation unless the publisher can show that it's protected by the First Amendment. But that's not all. The bill creates this claim for anybody. If you read the first lines of the bill, it purports to only protect Arkansas residents, but it doesn't. It protects any individual anywhere, any alien and foreigner. Surely, we don't want to create a cause of action for bin Laden's heirs for TV documentaries shown in Arkansas. No state in the United States has such a law. Now, every place this amendment has been proposed, it's been defeated. And if we adopt it in Arkansas, then there is a chance that the Arkansas courts will become havens for litigation on this issue. For these reasons, we respectfully urge you to defeat the bill as it is now written or as we prefer to eliminate this amendment that was added last week by the Players Association. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Any questions from the committee? Thank you, Mr. Catlett,
▶ Play
for your comments. I see that no one else has signed up to speak for or against the bill. I would like to hear from perhaps the representative from the Players Association and if you would could you respond to some of the issues that Mr. Catlett raised specifically with regard to whether this language has been utilized in other states and also I guess the your view as to the application of that to these other areas?
▶ Play
Speaker 31 7:55
Certainly. First, my name is Joe Briggs. I am not an Arkansas lawyer, but I am quite fond of the state. And one of the reasons why we invited Darren McFadden to come here today is because he is representative of the over 100 or so football players that have played in the National Football League that are natives to the state of Arkansas. Last week we had in the same room Freddie Scott Sr., who's also a local, who's also a native of Arkansas, who's also played in the National Football League. So we have deep connections to the state and deep interest in protecting our players who have played in the National Football League that are citizens of the state of Arkansas. One of the first comments that was made by the previous speaker was that the amendment that the Players Association, through supporting the bill that was written by Meredith Lowry, who's joining me here today, frustrated the First Amendment. It is difficult for us to understand how that's possible when the only language we added to the bill was a reference to the First Amendment and its protections that it offered to the citizens of the state of Arkansas. It is not our position that this bill has opened any new cause of action or will increase any possible causes of action that previously were already available to the citizens in the state of Arkansas. But what this bill will do is provide extra protection to the citizens of the state of Arkansas, like Frank Broyles, like Darren McFadden, like Freddie Scott, Sr., and like the people sitting around this table today, so that they'll have just that much more control over what happens to their likeness and image if someone's trying to make money off of it or use it in a commercial way. Specifically to address the questions I've been asked to talk about here as to whether this bill would be the first of its kind to use the language as was referenced by the previous speaker. That is not true. There are other states that have similar legislation, there are other states that have similar language, specifically the state of Ohio, and I'll let Meredith Lowry speak about that in just a second. But also, just this last week, we've seen Alabama and its state legislature take up a bill with almost the exact same language. And there also have been other attempts for this language to be introduced in other legislators, by other legislators in other states. But in each of those states where this language has been introduced, you would see the Motion Picture Association of America send their top lobbyists into that state to try to kill that language and remove it from the bill so that they would have the ability to do what it is that they want to do. And I think the best question to ask is what can they do, or what can't they do, rather, with the language as the bill is currently engrossed. And I'll turn it over to Meredith so
▶ Play
Speaker 34 10:45
she can say something about that as well. So in the realm of rights of publicity, the First Amendment goes hand in hand. The rights of publicity can't go against the First Amendment when it is the piece that is using those rights is truly a First Amendment issue. And as Mr. Catlin mentioned, these court cases discuss that. Our amendment that is currently being discussed does not shift the burden in these court cases. Any time a right of publicity issue comes up, there is always the potential that the First Amendment could also be involved. Ohio, like Joe mentioned, has language that mentions the First Amendment. So Arkansas is not unique in this.
▶ Play
Speaker 31 11:41
Further, we'll say from the state of New Hampshire all the way down to Alabama, as I just mentioned, language such as the language that you have seen fit to include in your bill last week is in existence, is in operation, and it's being considered by the various states as they look for new and interesting ways to protect their citizens. And we think that that's the best position to be in, and we look forward to any other questions you have for us.
▶ Play
Yeah, I've got a few other questions. Mr. Catlett, if you'd come back and have a seat, y'all stay where you're at. If you'll have a seat there to their left. Is the specific language that you're making issue as to, is that the fair
▶ Play
use exception? Mr. Chairman, it's specifically on page 8, lines 25 and 26. That's what was added that eliminates from the fair use exemption for expressive works the clear exception. And what it does is it requires the publisher to prove that the work is within the First Amendment. You'll look at A ahead of that, and it says the claimant must prove. But in B, it does not say the claimant must prove. And so it is implied that the publisher must prove. Well, isn't, I guess I'm not following, the fair
▶ Play
use doctrine, I mean, that's something that is evolved by case law, is that correct? I mean, we all can agree to that. As I understand, or what it appears to me is that this is an attempt to codify, essentially, the fair use doctrine with regard to the other statutory provisions that are being provided for here.
▶ Play
Speaker 31 13:36
I mean, would that be a fair statement? either one of you I agree I think that that's a fair statement and I think that this is an attempt by the author of this bill along with the support of the Players Association to provide some clear guidance to the court that may be looking for where they can go to find answers to how to decide one of these issues we are simply trying to codify what the
▶ Play
case law already says Mr. Chairman if I could direct you to page 8, line 18, you'll see that the sections below, A and B, have now been amended to only apply to subsection A1B. Well, there are four use provisions, A, B, C, and D, above, but for For some reason, this amendment only applies to expressive works, and that's our problem. That's the challenge. The second part of this is that it requires the publisher to have the burden of proving that this is not or it is covered by the First Amendment. But isn't that the
▶ Play
way it normally works anyway? No, sir. If I believe that my likeness was inappropriately used by a motion picture or anybody else, I could file suit, and I would have the burden of proving certain things, which I believe is essentially codified here in A-1B. But you could respond by saying, well, that may be true, but ultimately it's protected under the First Amendment. So I
▶ Play
guess I'm not following how this changes anything. Well, this would enable that suit to be filed without any burden being put on the claimant because here it is strict liability if it is shown to be a commercial use within the terms of this statute. There is no requirement as there is in A that the claimant must prove. It is an automatic liability for every publisher that publishes a photograph. Anything you all would respond in light of my question? It's been a while since I was
▶ Play
in law school, but I also agree with you,
▶ Play
Speaker 31 16:01
Representative Shepard, that it is my understanding that anyone who files a lawsuit has to first prove their claim. And if they do not have a valid claim, then the court in and of itself could kick that claim. But then also, furthermore, under the First Amendment of the United States, and I don't claim to be a First Amendment scholar. I'll lean on Meredith again for that. But under the First Amendment of the United States Constitution and the Arkansas State Constitution, there are certain protections for anyone who files a lawsuit and has the ability to oppose that lawsuit by filing for a summary judgment claim to kick that case if they're not able to prove the necessary claim for standing to start with. So that's not a part of this bill or what we're trying to do, and I don't know that it's necessary to fully respond to that. But I will address one thing that was said about the four uses under the bill and why this only applies to Section B. I'll make a distinction between Section A and Section B that should be clear to the folks around the table, and I'll try to make it even clearer. Section A of this bill that was referenced earlier, A1A, under 4-751010, if you'll look at the categories that are included there, it specifically talks about communicative news. That's bedrock foundational supported by, protected by the First Amendment of the United States, as well as the Arkansas State Constitution. The things in Section A1B, however, are arts or commercial properties that are created by someone else. And I think what we've seen in all of the cases that have involved litigation around these subjects was that there is a need for some direction or understanding about what exactly the purpose of the product was that was created as a part of this art or commercial application. And I think that's one of the reasons why, in this bill, in this language, it's valid for us to put that amendment there that it must be
▶ Play
balanced against the First Amendment. Mr. Catlett, briefly. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I think if you look at the language of B, the exclusion is that the publisher must show that the use is not protected by the First Amendment Or, said another way, it makes a claim under this statute for any use that is not protected under the First Amendment. That greatly broadens common law. And here we are in a statute saying that, of course, anything that's covered under the First Amendment would be exempt. But if the use is not protected under the First Amendment, then that also creates a claim. So, again, every photograph in Sports Illustrated, every depiction in a documentary of any American or foreigner would create an automatic cause of action. It was said that New Hampshire adopted this rule, but the governor vetoed it. So, yes, the legislature adopted, but the governor vetoed it. And in North Dakota this week, a bill similar to this, but without this amendment, was enacted. Thank you. Thank
▶ Play
you for your comments, and I appreciate both of you providing testimony. I just wanted to make sure I fully understood the issues and what was being changed and also understand, Mr. Catlett, your objections to the bill specifically. Representative House, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. General Mills, Wheaties box, always has a team or a sports player. I guess they reissue the Wheaties boxes, what, every month or so, a couple months? Is that a work of art or is that an advertisement? You start – I'm getting the distinct impression that you're dealing with content, that it's fair use if it's one content, but it's not fair use if it's another content. and the Supreme Court has told us time and time and time again that we as a government may not regulate content. It's in the eyes of the beholder. That's my impression. I would
▶ Play
Speaker 31 20:32
appreciate y'all's thoughts in that regard. We're dealing with a Wheaties box and the photo or image or likeness of an individual that's either sports-related or otherwise famous on that cover, you would typically have a license or the permission of that person to put their image on that Wheaties box. So that wouldn't be under consideration here. What we're talking about here is if we had a bottle of barbecue sauce that had Frank Broyles' picture on it. and Frank Broyles didn't give them permission to put that picture on that bottle of barbecue sauce. And they sold that barbecue sauce and made it seem as though there was some endorsement by Frank Broyles of that barbecue sauce. We believe, and this bill would allow Frank Broyles or his family or successors in Wright to come to the court and say, we not only did not give them the right to put that picture on the barbecue sauce, But we don't appreciate the way that they're using Frank Burrell's image to
▶ Play
promote this barbecue sauce without our permission. That's it. And, Representative House, we would agree that both of those situations, the barbecue sauce and the Wheaties box, should be compensable to the person depicted. But this bill goes much broader than that. It includes pictures that are in today's newspaper. on today's news, in, as I've said, Sports Illustrated. Those are the things that we are concerned about. For instance, if we wanted a TV documentary, then that would be covered under this bill. We think that's way too broad. May I follow up, Mr. Chair?
▶ Play
Yes. Which I guess kind of gets to the root of the question then. It's compensable now under present law. What does this add? What does this
▶ Play
Speaker 31 22:29
bill add? To address the last thing that was said in answering your question, it is well documented First Amendment protected law that a publishing of a picture in a newspaper article or even in Sports Illustrated where it's a news journal and there's a relation between that athlete and that newspaper article or magazine article would be protected under the First Amendment of the United States. It would be protected in a way that that would not ever become a problem by this language that's included in this bill, which specifically says that the only thing that's a problem is if it is not protected by the First Amendment of the United States or otherwise. We have offered the amendment so that it could be clear to the state court judge that is trying to evaluate whether he has to go forward with a claim or not, that there is a body of law that he can look to for guidance. And that is the purpose that we're
▶ Play
for here today. And that's particularly the problem, is that instead of having a clear statute, there is a body of law that a state court judge would have to look to to see whether this fell within it or not. We believe the first draft of the bill that clearly excluded all expressive works makes the most sense. Representative Copeland you're recognized for a
▶ Play
question hopefully both of you could weigh in on this you seem to agree on the barbecue sauce and I think all of us can agree that if someone used someone's likeness without their authorization that would not be they would deserve compensation etc so from a non-lawyer standpoint you keep mentioned in the documentary, the Sports Illustrated, Mr. Griggs, you mentioned that a lot of those things are already protected under the present law, so what I'm trying to find out is what are you trying to get protected that's not protected? He's making claims that there are things that you know, far-reaching, you seem to think they're pretty ridiculous in what he's asserting. But you're saying the law already protects the barbecue sauce incident, and we all agree on that. So can you give me an incident that is not presently protected under the law that this law would protect? I think the better way
▶ Play
Speaker 31 25:03
for you – well, first, thank you for the question. I think the better way to look at it is with the added language that's already engrossed in the bill, what can't you do that you already can, right? So you can use photos in Sports Illustrated. You can create documentaries. You can, with the permission of a person, use their image or likeness or voice or signature to promote a product. But what you cannot do under the bill is create an avatar of a person, put it in a video game, and then say that that avatar, that exact image of a person that you've put into a video game is not something that you had to get their permission for first. That instead you could just create this avatar that's an exact replication of Frank Broyles, put him in a video game about the University of Arkansas and have him give a speech about the University of Arkansas as a precursor to you playing that football game and then say, well, we don't have to pay Frank Broyles for using his likeness, image, and voice in that video game as an avatar because that's an expressive work that was created by my computer. I think most of the people around this table would agree that that's probably
▶ Play
something we should protect against. So, and I would agree. So you're saying that presently that's not protected under the law,
▶ Play
Speaker 31 26:29
correct? Under the law as written without this amendment, under the law that was previously written without the amendment that we offered and that you guys approved last week, that would have been possible. That was an exception that was listed that has been referenced several times by my colleague to my left, that the exception for a specific work in the bill would have allowed that to happen prior to us putting the balancing against the First Amendment
▶ Play
of the United States. Yes. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. We believe without this bill, those claims already exist. So the protections for Coach Broyles and others, even without this bill, are possible. This bill we originally favored because it had clear exceptions. This does away with those exceptions for Pictures in Sports Illustrated. Now, he's right. We can still, as the publisher, go into court and prove it, but we have to go to a body of law in order to prove our exemption. The example you gave would be protected under existing law without this bill. Thank you.
▶ Play
All right, I see no further questions. Senator, Representative Beck.
▶ Play
Just to help me better understand this, if we pass this as it exists right now and there's a picture in the newspaper that there's a sports fan, I mean somewhat of notoriety in sports, is in the background of that shot, does this affect that in any way? They're not mentioned in it or anything like that? It wouldn't affect that?
▶ Play
Or would it? The language of the bill creates an automatic cause of action for any likeness that is published on a television network news show, on our ESPN, on any Fox Sports, Sports Illustrated. Now, that doesn't mean that we can't go into court if we're sued and protect against it, But that's unreasonable, and that's our point, is that we shouldn't have to worry about these automatic violations of the law. Existing law doesn't have it, and we'd be better off under existing law than with this. All right. You have a question? Representative Whitaker? Just a
▶ Play
Speaker 85 29:14
motion at the proper time. Okay. And I see no further questions.
▶ Play
Senator Woods, you recognize the close for the bill? Thank you. All right, last
▶ Play
comment. I'm just going to say this for the committee members. Page 7, line 20, fair use, commercial sponsorship. It is a fair use and not a violation if a name, voice, signature, photograph, or likeness is used in connection with news, public affairs, sports broadcasts, including promotion of advertising with sports broadcasts, or an account of public interest and political campaigns, on and on. So I hope that addresses your questions. I'm closed for the bill. I appreciate your vote. Thank you. Representative
▶ Play
Whitaker, you have a motion? Motion do pass. Okay. It's a proper motion. We have a motion do pass. Is there any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? The bill passes. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Committee members, without objection, we're going to move to House Bill 1676, Representative Meeks. Good morning, Mr. Meeks.
▶ Play
I understand you have an amendment to this
▶ Play
Speaker 93 30:55
bill. Yes, I do have an amendment. It's just a slight word change to make the bill better, and I'm asking for passage of this amendment, and then I'll go ahead and speak about the complete bill.
▶ Play
Okay, we'll give the committee a minute to get those in their hands. Representative Meeks, you may
▶ Play
Speaker 93 31:22
begin. Members, again, this is just a very simple amendment. It is basically to make sure that when we're dealing with interstate compact adoptions that we make sure that we take care of kids that are coming both in and out of state. And once again, I would appreciate a good vote on this amendment, and then I'll speak more about it when we actually get
▶ Play
to the bill. Committee, do we have a motion to adopt this amendment? Representative House? All in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Amendment passed. Amendment has passed. Please present your bill. Please present your bill. And I think that's bill number 1676. Thank you. Thank you,
▶ Play
Speaker 93 32:09
members. This bill is actually one of two bills dealing with the rehoming issue here in the state of Arkansas. Representative Letting has the other part of it. and we felt it necessary to break the bill into two parts just because we wanted to focus on certain aspects of the rehoming issue. What you'll see in my bill today, House Bill 1676, is prohibiting rehoming itself, and then we also are tightening up the definition of abandonment as well as adding post-adoption services to the family planning services, and I'll talk a little bit about each of them as we go along. But the first part is on the subject of rehoming. This is a very difficult subject, and I know that folks have a lot of different opinions on it. But basically what we find out is this, is that people, you know, generally, and again, I don't want to spake to all because sometimes it doesn't happen, but generally speaking, when somebody wants to adopt a child, you know, they love children, They care about the child just like anything else. And so they'll go through, the child will be formally adopted, and then afterwards, for a variety of reasons, they will not be able to either take care of the child or not be able to handle the behaviors of that particular child. There is something called an adoption dissolution or where an adoption can be dissolved through the courts. It is rare that that actually happens because, of course, the judges, for the most part, don't like to see an adoption dissolved and want to try to make that adoption work. So what we have seen happen lately is because the courts, they have a hard time doing it through the courts, folks have gone a different direction. And what they do is they will try to find a family that they believe is suitable for that child that they think can take care of the child's needs. And what they will do is they will hand that child off to that person. Normally, they will do a transfer of guardianship or a power of attorney to allow that new family to take care of the child. And then, of course, the hope is that family will eventually go through a private adoption and actually fully adopt that child. That isn't always the case. We see it happen more with international adoptions versus an adoption through our state system. And the reason is because with international adoption, the parents are much more likely or there's a higher chance that they don't know everything about that child because they're getting it from a different country and that country may either not know what's going on with the child or they may try to hide what's going on with that child simply to get the child out of their system and onto somebody else. And so sometimes the parents don't know the behavioral, the mental, or the physical issues and they get them back here to America only to find out that they don't have the training or they don't have a capability to actually take care of that child. But what my bill does is it prohibits somebody, you know, finding somebody on the Internet, and that seems to be a popular way. They'll either find it through a group of some sort or whatever, and they will just, again, to the best of their knowledge, try to do everything they can to find a good home for that child and then just transfer it over. But what this does is this would prohibit that. they would actually have to go through the court like anybody else normally would do in order to be able to dissolve that adoption or to transfer through, again, through a regular adoption to that other family. Now, there is an exception to this, and those exceptions are like your relatives. And folks have asked me, what is this fifth degree of consanguinity? And I was able to get with some lawyers who explained it to me. And basically what it is is it's through direct relationship, meaning the fifth degree you would have to go up to mother and then to grandmother and then over to a sister or whatever and then down. So you wouldn't be able to go up to fifth cousin because you can't go up and over within the fifth degree to be able to do that. Normally it's grandparents, great-grandparents, aunts, uncles, and I think cousin is about the farthest that you're going to be able to go as far as that fifth degree is concerned. So you have that aspect of it. And so we're prohibiting it. There are some exceptions to be able to do that because we realize that, you know, and again, most of us in here probably knows a family or child that's not with their family. They're with their grandparents. They're with their aunt and their uncle so that this bill would actually allow it. It is focused right now on just adoptions. And the reason is because we want to be able, in the interim, to be able to do some further study to make sure that there are not other unintended consequences as it relates to somebody doing this with their biological child. So that's kind of the reason why we have limited it to just adoptions at this point. Another thing is on the abandonment issue, you will notice down in – let me make sure I've got the bill here. but in the other one I pulled up Senator Woods' bill so I apologize for that to make sure I get everything done here but also with when you're talking about either dissolving or you're talking about rehoming one of the things is in section 2 is abandonment we wanted to make that a little bit clearer because we don't want a family to do something out of fear. We want to make sure that they're not going to be charged with abandonment if they're trying to do the right thing and trying to get the right support for that actual deal. So in Section 2, where it talks about abandonment, where the adoptive parent has exhausted the available resources, and again, in which a child has disrupted his or her adoption, and we want to make the parents and we want to make folks know that there are resources available to help them get the assistance and the support that they need in order to actually keep that child. And I think, you know, as far as rehoming is concerned or even adoption dissolution is concerned, that we could probably lower that number if we just get them the support and the resources that they actually need. One of the main causes of this seems to be around reactive attachment disorder. And we as states, it's not just the state of Arkansas, as states in general have not done a very good job at handling reactive attachment disorder. There's still, I think, a lot of controversy about some of the methods that are used to deal with reactive attachment disorder. Of course, there's also debate on the symptoms and everything around that particular disorder as well. So, again, we're working here in the state of Arkansas at learning how to better deal with it, not only in how we place the kids in the home, but also the training that a foster or adoptive parent would receive as well as post-adoptive services. And you'll also find that, too, down in Section 3 where we've added family services means post-adoptive services. And so we're going to be working on that, again, as we go along to make sure that the family knows what resources are available to them. You know, if they come to DHS, DHS will be able to refer them to those particular resources because, again, we want to make everything work out for that child. We want to make sure that that child is not, again, after they're adopted and they think they're in their forever family, that they're going to have to be given up to another family because the family that first adopted them just cannot take care of them for that. So you'll see that in Section 5 where it says, you know, the report's alleging that a child is disrupting his or her adoption or is at risk of disrupting his or her adoption. Members, and that's the bill in a nutshell, and I'll be
▶ Play
glad to take any questions. I have a couple questions. The term adoptive parent, let's see, adoptive parent or adopted child, is that defined in the bill or is it defined anywhere else in law? do you know? And the reason I ask the question is, for example, in a foreign adoption, generally you get some type of certificate from the jurisdiction or the country from which the child is originated. But then you have to bring it, and generally you have it you go through a court process here in Arkansas. And so I wonder if that term, while I think we all know generally what we mean by it. I'm just concerned that maybe there might be a little bit of discrepancy in just making sure that the bill covers every situation. Right,
▶ Play
Speaker 93 41:50
and I think probably Lisa McGee, one of the attorneys, but it's my understanding that until an adoption is finalized here in the United States, meaning the courts have said, okay, you're adopted, that the adoption is not finalized, and before the adoption happens, it's considered adoption disruption. After that the option is finalized by the court system here in America, then you're considered the adoptive parent. And then, again, that's when this bill would actually kick in. But I'll let Lisa McGee come in and
▶ Play
direct me or have a stand on it. At the end of the table, state your name and who you represent. And then if you don't mind responding
▶ Play
Speaker 108 42:29
to my question. Lisa McGee, I'm an attorney with the Arkansas Department of Human Services. I think if I understand your question, it
▶ Play
had to do with foreign adoptions? Well, the The term adoptive or adopted child or adoptive parent, while that term is, I looked at the code, I think the only other time it's utilized is there's a reference somewhere else to a prospective adoptive parent, but it's not necessarily, actually there it's a defined term, prospective adoptive parent. I'm just wondering whether this is something that should be clarified just to make sure that the waterfront is covered, so to speak. I don't know that it is defined, other than if
▶ Play
Speaker 108 43:05
you look over in the adoption code itself on the state creation of creating a family unit, that is adoption. So to me, I don't know that you need to add the term adoptive parent and adoptive child. I mean, I think it speaks for itself in that you have the whole Title IX, the 9-9 Section 200, the Revised Uniform Adoption Act, that creates the family unit.
▶ Play
Representative Meeks, you may have mentioned this, but does your bill apply
▶ Play
Speaker 93 43:36
to foreign adoptions? Yes, it does, and it also applies to
▶ Play
adoptions to the interstate compact as well. So I guess my concern is if there's a foreign adoption, but prior to taking the adoption to court in Arkansas, the parent decides I'm going to rehome the child or do something else, would that be prohibited under this bill? And, again, I'm supportive of the bill. I'm just concerned that we don't create a loophole or something else in this scenario. I would consider a child who's adopted in
▶ Play
Speaker 108 44:10
a foreign country that gets a decree from the foreign country to be an adoptive child. And I know that the state law in Arkansas allows a parent to come and then get a decree here in Arkansas as well. Right, correct. But I would think if they've got an adoption decree from a foreign country, we would consider that an adoptive
▶ Play
child. The only thing I would ask is, assuming this passes out a committee, is that possibly if you all would look at that as to whether there might need to be an amendment made on the Senate end. I'm not, again, I'm supportive of it. My concern is just if we're going to do it, let's make sure we cover all scenarios and that we don't create some kind of loophole in the, because I think you alluded that many times, foreign adoptions, this may be even more of an issue sometimes with foreign adoptions than even some of the more traditional means. Any questions? Representative
▶ Play
Copeland, you're recognized for a question. Representative Meeks, and this is no aspersions on DHS at all, but one, I was just flabbergasted that rehoming could even happen. and I was not aware that could even happen, number one. But from what I've heard from numerous people, that a lot of times rehoming would happen because of the difficulty, and you mentioned it, of the dissolution of an adoption. You mentioned another bill that's out there. Does it address, because what I see being a problem, If it's a real difficult thing, dissolve in an adoption, and then rehoming is not an option any longer. And then you've got a child, and typically these are, and I would guess, these are situations where a child is severely troubled and it's quite a challenge because of the length of time it takes to get to adopt. To change their mind, it had to be something pretty traumatic. Are we going to create a situation where a family, parents, adoptive parents, are between a rock and a hard place? Are we working on the dissolution side as well? Yeah, and let
▶ Play
Speaker 93 46:27
me say this, too. We have a wonderful foster care and adoption system here in the state of Arkansas. I can say that I'm living proof of that where the majority of folks, they're going to get the support. They're going to get the resources that they actually need. And the thing with rehoming is there have been so few cases, that's why it really hasn't popped up before really in any state. There have been very few states that have actually passed legislation dealing with this. This particular legislation is a model based on Louisiana that was passed last year. I think the number of rehoming that they can actually identify here in the state of Arkansas is less than a dozen. And so it's very, there are very
▶ Play
few cases of this actually, you know, happening. Can we have Ms. McGee address the term dissolution was brought up. If you would explain to the committee whether such provision even exists.
▶ Play
Speaker 108 47:32
Lisa McGee, attorney with the Department of Human Service, and it's not really a term that's in the code. You have a period of one year after an adoption's entered that you can set it aside for fraud or whatever, and after that, that's it. It's an adoption. There is no disillusion of the adoption. So what happens is that if a child comes back into, say, the foster care system who's been adopted, we work with the adoptive family, we're not able to get the child reunited back with adoptive family, then what we would have the option to do is to terminate the parental
▶ Play
rights of the adoptive parent. And the theory, correct me if I'm wrong, I mean, the theory is in adoption, when that adoption becomes final, for all intents and purposes under the law, it's just as if the child was naturally born to that mother and father, correct? That's correct. And so at that point, subject to the one-year time period that you referenced, which would be for certain extenuating circumstances such as fraud in the inducement or otherwise, that's the only exception.
▶ Play
Speaker 93 48:33
That's correct. Right, but that would not preclude a parent from going through a regular adoption process like you would a biological child if you were going to actually. Right, at
▶ Play
that point, then the only option would be the termination of parental rights, which would be by way of some other adoption process or the rehoming issue where you would transfer
▶ Play
Speaker 93 48:54
guardianship or do a power of attorney with the child at this point. Correct. But the criminal rights would still
▶ Play
Speaker 108 49:00
be intact unless it's a termination of criminal rights or a subsequent adoption.
▶ Play
That's right. Thank you for coming. I just wanted to make sure the committee was clear on that because I think it's an important point, and it's something that I know the court reminds people is that when an adoption goes final, And it's, I mean, all legal rights are essentially those of what it would be with a child and their natural parents. Any other, Representative House, you recognize for a question? Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
I know she's down there. I heard her voice, but I can't see that far. Oh, there you are. My grandmother raised eight children. Three of them were hers. The other five belonged to relatives, both near and distant. This was during Depression days. In my family, we have a, who's passed now, but we had a gentleman who was part of our family who was of no relation to us. But back, and even today, I see people place their children with aunts and grandmothers and such. I know that you've addressed the co-sanguinity fairly narrowly, but there are relationships between people that exist that have no blood connection. How's human services going to take care of those situations when I send my kids off to live with Bob Ballinger here because he's got a place to hunt and fish up there?
▶ Play
Speaker 93 50:42
I can address it just really briefly in the bill if you're just going to temporarily place those kids like if they want to go spend the summer with somebody then you have the ability to do that it only kicks in when you want to
▶ Play
do it permanently and if Ms. McGee wants to add anything to that I put in my will that I designated him as their parent But is this bill going to put DHS in those kind of family situations that are fairly common?
▶ Play
Speaker 108 51:19
It should not. If you've put it in your will, which I had when my children were minors, that I wanted someone to be the guardian, then what happens is a guardianship is established at the time of the death. Okay. And, in fact, in Arkansas we have standby guardians. So if you know you have a critical illness, you know that something's going to happen, you have the capacity when you're still alive to put the standby guardianship in place, that would take effect upon your incapacity or death. So those cases wouldn't have to come to the child welfare system unless you picked a really awful person that you rehomed your child to and someone calls our hotline in, and you've got a child that's in an unsafe situation that would meet one of
▶ Play
our trimal treatment definitions. Well, I have some really awful kids. That's
▶ Play
Speaker 122 52:02
why I want them to go to Ballinger. But, okay,
▶ Play
thank you. Representative Drown you're recognized for a
▶ Play
question I just want to understand here because he brings up a great point a very valid point and I hear this constantly especially today is what about those kids I'm constantly hearing more and more that the grandparents are having to raise the grandkids the parents just dropped them off and they just as if you know they just didn't want to raise them anymore and it seems to be something that's reoccurring and I just want to make sure that, you know, don't get me wrong, I think this is a great bill and I think this issue needs to be addressed, but I want to make sure that those close-knit family members are not going to be, say, a witch hunt in the future.
▶ Play
Speaker 93 52:51
Right, and again, this bill only affects adopted kids, so with Representative House, that would not affect him whatsoever because those are biological, and at this point there are going to be no restrictions, so it only happens with adopted kids, and again, you have the guardianship. You know, you can do things temporarily. You know, if you put that in your will, then the guardianship would go and those, whoever it is, would be able to pursue formal adoption. The bill would not actually prohibit it whatsoever. And another thing, again, this will be in Representative Letting's bill, but one of the reasons why we were looking at, just looking at adoptions right now, is because with a high percentage of kids that are adopted out, especially through DHS there's a subsidy that also follows that kid as well and so we were also you know we were wanting to make sure that that subsidy follows that child um and you know to make sure that the parents weren't just pocketing the money or doing something else with that money so but that again that'll be um looked at in a different bill
▶ Play
did you the other bill addresses the subsidy Yes, Mr. Chairman. Okay, and I would assume that if DHS were aware of a rehoming situation, then they could unilaterally terminate the subsidy, or is that what the other bill is going to address? The
▶ Play
Speaker 93 54:12
other bill will address that because some of those subsidies are basically federal passing through, and we're restricted as to what we can do because of federal
▶ Play
regulations. Okay, thank you. Representative Ballinger, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Something just came to my attention. I'm not sure, and maybe if I read it four or five more times, I'd know what it is. But on page two, lines 28 through 30E, it says, it is not a defense to prosecution for a violation of this section that the person being rehomed is actually a law enforcement officer acting within the official scope of his or her duties. What does that mean? I'm going to let Lisa, if you
▶ Play
Speaker 93 54:54
can come, just to make sure that I got it right, because I'm not sure about the defense of prosecution, so I'm going to make
▶ Play
Speaker 108 55:05
sure I get it right. And I'm not sure I have it right. This is taken from Louisiana, and best that we've been able to do after we kind of piecemealed it is, it looks like if you do a sting operation, that's what we're thinking this is. So if law enforcement says, sure, I'll take a rehome child, that's not a defense, that it was actually a law enforcement officer who was trying to get someone in on a rehoming, not an actual parent of a child
▶ Play
who was being rehomed. Okay, but what it says is that the person being rehomed is actually a law enforcement officer. So is it a law enforcement officer that looks like a little kid? I mean, maybe that's the reality. I'll go back and take a look at Louisiana to make sure
▶ Play
Speaker 93 55:43
that something didn't happen in the transcription, and, you know, again, we'll be glad to amend it. on the Senate. The fact that this came from Louisiana
▶ Play
now makes complete sense. Hopefully nobody from Louisiana is watching the live
▶ Play
Speaker 93 55:55
feed right now. Okay, I see no further questions.
▶ Play
No one has signed up to speak for or against the bill. Representative Meeks, are you closed for your bill? Yes, Mr. Chair, I'm closed for the bill and I'd appreciate a good vote. What's the pleasure of the committee? As amended. Okay, we have a motion due pass as amended by Representative Ballinger. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? The bill passes. Representative Meeks, do you have another bill that you're... Yes, Mr. Chair, House Bill 1624. Okay. Without objection, we're going to House Bill 1624. Representative
▶ Play
Speaker 93 56:46
Meeks, you're recognized. Thank you. This House Bill 1624 is, again, dealing with our foster care and adoption system here in the state of Arkansas. It is several recommendations that were brought to me by the attorney ad litem program. And basically, the attorney ad litem program is another piece of the puzzle. You have DHS. Of course, you have the biological parents and their representatives. You have the attorney ad litem, who also is dealing with the case of a child, as well as CASA, may also be involved. And they all work together to try to come up with what is in the best interest of the child. And this right here, what it will do is kind of as the title says, is to increase protections for children in dependency neglect cases and to provide the attorneys ad litem with increased access to information and to improve opportunities for keeping siblings and foster care together. And this bill will address four primary issues. Number one, safety. It wants to create additional safeguards so that youth who are at imminent risk of harm are brought to the attention of the courts. It will allow judges to appoint attorney ad litems whenever they take a 72-hour hold on a juvenile in a FINS or delinquency case. Number two, it will increase transparency. It requires disclosure of previous involvement with the family by DHS and the affidavit into the court. It requires information about the siblings to a child named in a dependency neglect petition. It requires sharing of information about the case by DHS with the parties in CASA, which is a court-appointed special advocate, and allows for sharing of information maintained electronically and through uploading into the court database system. Number three, it's safeguards for siblings placed in foster care, that's Section 14, to be placed together when possible and to have continued meaningful contact if they are separated. And finally, number four, it ensures due process requiring parent counsel be appointed to minors in foster care and requiring parties in court to address whether the non-custodial parent should be considered for custody, placement, or visitation at the beginning of the case. So basically, you know, what this is doing is the attorney ad litem, they have to know what is going on with the child. They have to know, you know, have information so that they can make the best decisions when advocating, you know, for what's in the best interest of that child. And they feel that these recommendations are reasonable in order to be able to do so. And with that said, I'll be glad
▶ Play
to take any questions. I have one question on the I think it's section one it talks about the dependency neglect attorney ad litem is would be allowed to file a dependency neglect petition and I guess I'm just curious as to the necessity for that particular change.
▶ Play
Speaker 93 59:52
Well, you know, I've heard of issues where the attorney ad litem felt it was necessary because of what was happening with the child. in order to be able to bring them into custody because they thought that there was harm or the child was in danger, and they were not able to do so. And so that was why they were actually taking a look at that. I'll be glad to turn it over to the attorney here who can maybe better expound on
▶ Play
this. My name is Casey Copeland. I'm an attorney ad litem. I represent children in Sebastian County. Any adult can already file a dependency neglect petition. But what this does is it allows this state's attorney's ad litem to file for emergency relief. The situation comes to my mind where the department may have picked up one child out of a home, but for one reason or another left another or other children in the home. This would allow altogether the attorney ad litem to gather quite a bit of information on the front end and to potentially ask the court to go ahead and order the other children or child to also be removed. We don't have that right now. All we have right now is the ability to file a 30-day petition, get everybody served, and wait our turn. This would allow us to exercise that emergency power and ask the court to go ahead and bring those children in. I
▶ Play
take it as a practical matter right now. If you did want ex parte emergency relief, you would basically have to go to the prosecutor or to DHS and ask them to
▶ Play
file the petition? That's correct. And, of course, if the department has already chosen not to remove a child or other children from the home, then you've already lost that argument
▶ Play
perhaps. Does the, with regard to the dependency neglect, attorney ad litem, I take by that that you would have already been appointed in that particular case, or are we talking about something different than when
▶ Play
Speaker 103 1:01:51
you're appointed to a specific, to
▶ Play
represent a specific child? Well, currently, let's say the department doesn't remove 72-hour removal. We aren't typically appointed until the probable cause hearing. This bill would also have the court appoint an ad litem during that 72-hour period, have us or give us the ability to gain some information about the case and the children, and then file a follow-up emergency petition. So the way it is right now, we have to wait until probable cause some days later to even get appointed. At that point, the other children aren't even under the jurisdiction of the court. This will allow us in that time period to bring them to the jurisdiction of the court and ask the court to go ahead
▶ Play
and bring them in. So you can actually, under this bill, you would be able to petition with regard to children that you've not been appointed an ad litem for? That's my reading
▶ Play
of the bill, yes. Because I can do that now, any adult, of course, can file a dependency neglect petition. I can file it over a child that I don't otherwise represent. I just have to file it in the normal course. This would allow me that same ability. I think as a practical matter, I would be asking the court to exercise a hold and appoint me their ad litem at the same time. I think that's just the way
▶ Play
it would work. Okay. And I just wanted to make sure I was clear on that because I understand that, I guess, any adult can do that. Obviously, many times it might be relatives or other family members or friends who are aware of a situation. I guess I just had a little heightened concern when we were talking about individuals who have been appointed by the court as an ad litem and whether if you've been appointed ad litem as to one child, what kind of duty is owed to the other children and whether that's something that needs to be addressed by this. but as you said, you can already file the petition. It's just strictly on the emergency ex parte order that we're making the change. Yes, sir. All right, I see no questions. We have a few people who have signed up to speak. Nice. Actually, we've got several signed up for. We have one with some concerns. I'm going to we'll go to the one who has the concerns Cecile Blucher is she here? okay if you would have a seat at the end of the table state your name who you represent and then you may make your statement. My name
▶ Play
Speaker 146 1:04:52
is Cecil Blucher. I'm the Director for the Division of Children and Family Services. We are in the process of working with the Administrative Office of the Courts and CASA on potentially making a couple changes that we have an issue with. Part of it has to do with the resource issue. Part of it has to do with that 14 day notice. But it's more about how we can put a directive in place so that we can send out to the field staff so that everyone knows what information should be shared with each other and so that we're all consistent with how that's going across this state. And so I just wanted to go on record to just say that we're in the process of working with them and I really do think that we can come to a resolution so that we can all work together with this.
▶ Play
Representative Howell is she recognized for a question? Ms. Blucher, are you telling us that Passing this bill out of this committee at this time would be a mistake?
▶ Play
Speaker 146 1:05:51
Well, we just have some concerns, and it has to do with the 14-day turnaround that's mentioned in the section there. We're just trying to work out how the notice would come in, who would it be given to, if we can work within that 14-day timeframe because our clerical staff is limited in the field, So it's just how can we do that, and it's my understanding that for the most part we are able to share information in a timely way across the state, but we do have some pockets where we need to improve that practice, and so we just need a
▶ Play
directive that will help us do that. In that process, you're more intimately familiar with this process than am I. In the whole process, we have a court involved. Is that a logical assumption? Is that a correct assumption on my part? Yes, sir. Then the court can, for good cause, extend any periods if you have an area where there is no Internet service and we do have them in the state or where there are communication problems or snow problems where you can't deliver the mail. The court can always grant extensions of time. Would that fix your problem in those instances? Well, actually,
▶ Play
Speaker 146 1:07:05
I'm hoping that within our agreement with the administrative office of the court, or the attorney ad litem program in CASA that we can kind of address how those situations would be done more in a policy standpoint and in a directive standpoint without a judge having to get involved. Of course, a judge can always, you know, give us those extensions, but we're hoping that we can put something in place so that it's not even necessary to
▶ Play
get to that point. Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. All right. Thank you for your testimony. we have it's like four people signed up to speak for the bill Mary Beth Louisville you're recognized you may state your name, who you represent and you
▶ Play
Speaker 155 1:07:59
may make your statement Mary Beth Louisville, director of the Arkansas State CASA Association I work with the 25 local CASA programs across the state that provided over 1,000 volunteers to advocate for youth in foster care last year. We are fully supportive of this bill. First and foremost, what it's going to mean for siblings. This will ensure that siblings are ideally placed together, and when it's not in their best interest to be placed together, that they still receive the benefit of visitation to support those connections that they need in a very traumatic time. Secondly, it will help us with efficiency for our CASA volunteers. Most of our CASA programs serve multiple counties and only have one or two paid staff, and so getting our court reports filed can be a challenge for us. This will allow us to upload our court reports into our D-net system. We'll still file them with the court, but it won't be driving all over a five-county area to get court reports filed for our volunteers. Lastly, as Director Blucher indicated, information sharing is vital for our court-appointed advocates. We need information, but it is a challenge at times because of DCFS caseloads and so forth. So we continue to be in negotiations with her. We're optimistic that we're going to be able to reach some conclusions, but we do need the information in order to make recommendations on
▶ Play
behalf of the children. Okay, I see
▶ Play
Speaker 158 1:09:29
no questions. Thank you for your testimony. Next on the list is
▶ Play
Speaker 162 1:09:50
Amber Brenner. Hi, my name is Amber Briner. I'm an attorney ad litem, full-time. I practice in Hot Spring County, Grant County, and Yale County. And I am here to express my support of the language in this bill. I feel that the issues regarding transparency and safety as well as the wording regarding sibling connections is very important and it does provide a way for us to work together as has been noted to achieve the best interest of the children, but it provides a way to obtain this information, to get it to the court quickly, and to make sure that we have all of the avenues in place to achieve a good outcome for my clients. And I think in particular, the information about requiring disclosure of previous involvement with the family within the affidavits will allow us as ad litems to get all the information that we need to to the court to do our investigation and make our recommendations for our clients and to advocate for the things that are most important to them and in a lot of ways maintaining a sibling connection and making sure that all the safety issues that were in the home are adequately addressed by the department and the court is something that not only is it very important for us to do but it's important for us to do in the most efficient way possible So I am in support of the language that's included as well as the information sharing part of it because routinely we are gathering and requesting information from the department, working with CASA and presenting this information in the form of recommendations to the court. So having a mechanism to make these requests, to get the request answered timely, and to prepare and present our recommendation to the court, I think, is very valuable. And so I am in support of the language that is included. Thank you.
▶ Play
I see no questions. Thank you for your testimony. Next, we have, is it Renee Robinette? Thank you. And then finally, Carla Reyes. thank you Representative Meeks you may close for your bill thank
▶ Play
Speaker 93 1:12:27
you members and I'm still willing to work with Director Blucher if those policy directives are issued by the time we get down to the Senate and pass the bill in the Senate I'm willing to amend my bill to take those areas out where there are policy directives but again the four points that we said this is about safety for our kids, it's about transparency, this is about ensuring due process to make sure that our kids are well taken care of, to make sure our attorney ad litems, which are part of the bigger team, that includes DCFS, CASA, and the mom and everybody, to make sure that the communication, to make sure that they know what's going on so that they can make the best decision that they believe that is in the best interest of the child.
▶ Play
And so with that said, I would appreciate a good vote. What's the pleasure of the committee? Representative House moves do pass. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Any opposed? The bill passes. Committee without objection we're going to take up a few bills of Representative Douglas's. Representative Douglas you're recognized and if you'll let me know which bill you want to take up first.
▶ Play
Speaker 166 1:14:06
Yes, committee. If we could take up House Bill 1599 first. Okay, without objection, we're going
▶ Play
to take up House Bill 1599. You're recognized
▶ Play
Speaker 166 1:14:29
to present the bill. Okay. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee. I think this is my first time in this esteemed committee, and coming from the science background, this is foreign to me, so I hope that you will be able to see through my lack of legal expertise. But let me, to begin with, give you one statistic to start with, and that will kind of lay the groundwork, I think, for where we are heading with this. But in Afghanistan, a couple of years ago, the deaths due to the war were around 8,000. That same year, the deaths due to domestic violence were around 11,000 murders for that year. This is a huge problem in our society. And what we find is when we do have a victim that does fall to murder, that is not the first time that they have been, you know, that's not the first incident that they've been involved in. So what this bill is doing is it is standardizing a delivery system for victims' rights statewide. Do we have the same information going out through the state police, through the sheriffs, through the park rangers, through the high school police, through the college security. And we are going to help put that standardized information out there for them. We're going to work with them to get that right. What we're looking at is putting together something that looks kind of like this that would be called Laura's Card. and it would have all the information on it, front and back and inside. We're going to leave a part on there that can be personalized for each department. So the sheriff is going to have a different logo possibly and different information on it than the local police would or the park rangers or the high school or the college. So we're going to standardize this and allow it to be shot out to all these agencies to give one consistent delivery system statewide. The reason that we're calling this Laura's card, and it's the same reason that Representative Ballinger was using Laura for his law, is that we have found that we have the three faces of what we're going to call domestic violence. We have victims that fall to murder, and we have a Laura that fell to murder with her baby in her arms due to domestic violence several years back that was in Representative Ballinger's district. We also have her mother was named Laura, so she represents the victims' families that are left to pick up the pieces. And then we have a third, Laura, that is also with me today that is the face of the victims that survive. So we would like, in honor of those three faces of domestic violence, and because we had this name consistent through a lot of our cases, to be able to name this card Laura's card. And I would be glad to take any questions, and I'll let my expert that can also speak to this introduce herself as well.
▶ Play
Representative Douglas, I've got one question real quick. It looks like actually this bill, it's pretty simple and straightforward, just makes a couple little changes to help standardize it. The statement, though, is added to it to the victim's family if applicable. and what what scenarios is it given to the victim's family and i'm assuming that that's already provided for under the law anyway well if the victim is
▶ Play
Speaker 166 1:18:46
unconscious or if the victim has passed away thank you you're recognized to speak for
▶ Play
the bill if you would just state your name and who you represent and you may make your statement my name
▶ Play
Speaker 172 1:18:59
is terry edens and i'm with the arkansas Coalition Against Domestic Violence, and we're here in support of this bill. Domestic violence is very complex in that the batterer in the case of domestic violence always finds a way to re-victimize the victim using resources or using current legislation to do that, so we always support legislation that will provide more safety for victims and more accountability for batterers, and getting information like this out with Laura's card would be very beneficial to the victim, or in this case, the victim's family. Thank you. Any questions from
▶ Play
the committee? Okay, we have one person and two people have signed up to speak for the bill. Keith Boone.
▶ Play
Speaker 2 1:20:06
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. You would state your name, and then you
▶ Play
may make your statement. My name is Keith Boone. I'm a 27-year veteran of the United States Air Force, also a family member of a survivor of a nearly fatal domestic violence assault. So I'm here to speak in support of House Bill 1599. On April 7, 2012, my wife, in-laws, and I learned of the life-threatening injuries to our family member. We, like many family members before us, were in a state of shock, only concerned at the moment for the survival of our loved one. The initial shock began a journey that was totally unnecessary. We had no idea that there were numerous laws and resources available to assist victims and families in such traumatic times. No office investigating the case informed our family of the office's resources, rights, or laws giving victims rights. We initiated contact with the prosecuting attorney's office and were assigned a crime victim's advocate who only gave us information on Arkansas crime victim's reparation in the event our loved one died. We did not know who outside the prosecuting attorney's office to contact to help our family members and our family regarding the assault of my sister-in-law. We had to divert our attention away from our loved one to conduct our own research. As time went on, my sister-in-law, the victim, discovered the rights afforded to her by researching the information online. Our family, including our injured loved one, was never told of the rights or resources available to the victim of a crime. Laura's card would have been an invaluable resource to our family, providing a list of contacts and rights that a victim is entitled to under the law in the state of Arkansas. When a victim of domestic violence and their family are dealing with health, safety, and other issues, Lars Card will be a guide to a system. Like Miranda's rights for criminals, this will be a quick presentation of the rights of the victim. For the family members and victims, it will save valuable time in dealing with the aftermath of domestic violence. It will shine a light on the early steps of the long road to recovery. I encourage you to vote for this bill. I know firsthand the importance of such a resource, and I urge you to make it available for future victims of domestic violence. Thank you for the opportunity to speak
▶ Play
to you today. Questions from the committee? Seeing none, thank you. Thank you. I believe we have Ronnie Baldwin signed up to speak for the bill.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Baldwin. Thank you, Madam Chair and Committee. Ronnie Baldwin, Executive Director of the Arkansas Sheriff's Association. We have met with Representative Douglas and the Sheriff's Association in full support of this bill. As we know, as unfortunate it is, domestic violence many times is a recurring crime. So if we can get this information on the onset, maybe it could prevent some future occurrences. So the sheriffs are in full support of this bill.
▶ Play
Any questions from the committee? Seeing none, thank you. Representative Douglas, would you like to close for
▶ Play
Speaker 166 1:23:30
your bill, please? Just a word to say that most of our police chiefs and our sheriff's departments are doing this right, and we have a great system out there. We just hope that this will give us some consistency and fill in a couple of gaps, and we would appreciate a good vote. Thank you, committee.
▶ Play
Pleasure of the committee, please. Representative Ballinger has moved motion do pass. All in favor? Aye. Any opposed? the ayes have it representative douglas you have passed your bill and thank you for bringing such a good bill to this committee thank you madam chair you have another bill okay and what number is that please it's a 1631 okay go
▶ Play
Speaker 166 1:24:18
ahead please representative douglas and i would ask that uh my legal counsel bob bellinger please sit with me at the table um we we also found through this journey that I've taken with victims of domestic violence, that sometimes they are at a very vulnerable state and they are taken advantage of. And one of those areas is through alimony. Many times the abuser will lose his job, have to go to jail or whatever, and during that time, you know, they don't have an income. That's the abuser that has been convicted of, you know, abusing the spouse. And we have seen many instances where they will file for alimony from the person that they abused. And we would like to make sure that that does not happen in the future. And that is what this bill will take care
▶ Play
of. Thank you. Are there any questions from the committee? Seeing none, we'll now hear from Laura Webb who has spoken or who has
▶ Play
Speaker 166 1:25:27
signed up to speak for the bill. This is one of my faces of domestic violence, Miss Laura. She's one of the ones that the card will also
▶ Play
be named for. Miss Laura, would you please state your name? Hi, my name is Laura Webb, and I am today representing a victim of domestic violence. I was a rare instance. I was married to a federal law enforcement agent who had a six-digit salary. I'm a schoolteacher. Upon his conviction or even the potential of him losing his job due to the Lautenberg Amendment, he immediately pursued an area of domestic abuse in the area of finances and with the legal system and proceeded to immediately request alimony on my education salary for the fact that he was going to lose his job and eventually did upon his conviction. So I'm here to speak in support of House Bill 1631 so that abusers, when and if they lose their jobs, cannot sue their victim for alimony because financial abuse is prevalent as part of the domestic violence cycle.
▶ Play
Thank you for your time today. Any questions from
▶ Play
Speaker 166 1:26:44
the committee? Seeing none, thank you. I'm closed
▶ Play
for the bill. What's the pleasure of the committee, please? Tally? Sorry. Representative Tally? Motion do pass. Thank you. All in favor? Any opposed? Thank you, Pat. And I guess I don't have to pay Mr. Ballinger now. You didn't say it. Okay, thank you. Thank you, Representative Douglas. You have passed your bill. Senator Flowers. Senator Flowers.
▶ Play
Thank you, Madam Chair, and good morning, Committee. May I, Madam Chair, ask Dr. Eddie Ochoa to come with me to the table? Yes, you may. Mr. Joel, please state
▶ Play
your name. Is he on there? Madam Chairman, my name is Eddie
▶ Play
Speaker 191 1:28:01
Ochoa. I'm a practicing pediatrician here in Little Rock, and I'm representing the Arkansas chapter of the American Academy of Pediatrics.
▶ Play
Thank you. Committee, my Senate Bill 484, I believe, is a fairly simple bill. It would require schools or those that are employed by schools that refer FINS petitions, which are family in need of service petitions to juvenile court to first evaluate a child according to the law, the Individuals with Disability Education Act, a federal law, which requires evaluation by a public agency when there is an observation that that public agency may see that the child has a disability. And so this bill would provide that before the petition is filed with the juvenile court, the evaluation be attached and the assessment tools that are required as well by IDEA also be included. And all those things that the Individuals with Disability Education Act require a school to do to be compliant with the IDEA. All of that should be attached so that the juvenile court can make sure that they have a full understanding and do a ruling that is completely within their discretion to be what's in the best interest of the child. And to explain more, I'll ask Dr. Okoa, but my efforts here with this bill seek to stem the school-to-prison pipeline. We find, as we get data from the Division of Youth Services, that most of the children, 90% of them, that are committed to DYS have disabilities. It is my belief that children should be evaluated on the front end to determine whether their behavior is such that comes from a disability, which stems their ability to learn, and therefore the school should be taking measures compliant with IDEA to determine and set up an individualized education plan for the student and to recognize what behavior actually is coming from the disability. And I would ask for a further explanation from Dr. Ocoa.
▶ Play
Speaker 191 1:31:04
Thank you, Senator Flowers. Our association is for and in favor of this bill because we, as Senator Flowers mentioned, And we are also in agreement that any disabilities that the juvenile has would definitely impact the court proceeding. And just to give you a couple of examples, a child who was born with fetal alcohol syndrome, that is an illness that is characterized by abuse of alcohol during the pregnancy, we know that children who have been born with fetal alcohol syndrome will have learning and behavior problems in the future. They're at a much higher risk than a child who is not exposed to alcohol in utero. And for another example, a child who was born healthy but has a central nervous system infection, an infection like that could have a permanent effect on the brain and thereby put that child at higher risk for having behavioral and learning problems during the educational career. So we're fully in agreement that in those sorts of instances, all the appropriate evaluations should be done as early as possible with the help of the school, and all that information should be made available to a judge in
▶ Play
this sort of circumstance. Do we have any questions from members, please? Representative
▶ Play
House, you are recognized for a question. Thank you, Madam Chair. Senator, basically when the school needs to file the FINS petition, they need to
▶ Play
bring all of their records with them. all that the IDEA requires for them to be compliant. Actually, under the Individuals with Disability Education Act, there is a requirement that a school deliver to the court these records. And the records are fairly easily accessible because schools are supposed to be keeping what they call due process file. And so all the information that's necessary to see that the school has complied with the requirements of the Individuals with Disability Education Act are right there at their fingertips. Another thing I wanted to mention to the committee is in terms of payment, that was a question that was posed down at the other end of the building. And school districts get Title VI funding for this. That's from the feds. They pay. It's in our best interest as a country and as a state to make sure that our children are being educated. And when they have learning disabilities, to give them an educational plan that is kind of carved out just for them, based on what their disability or their, how would you say it, what their problem is. And so whether it be something concerning speech, whether it be something. Senator, excuse me just a minute. I think the answer to
▶ Play
my question is yes. Yes.
▶ Play
Speaker 186 1:34:18
Sorry. Thank you. Representative Rushing, you have a question? Yes,
▶ Play
I do. Thank you, Mr. Chair. My question is, does this infringe on any of the privacy rights to these child's records, being that the way I understand it, a parent can ask for that consent, but for those records to be distributed, but just taking this upon to send along with the FINS report, does this not
▶ Play
encroach on that type of privacy? I've had one attorney to write to me that was in support of this bill and pointed out within the Individuals with Disability Education Act that everything that we're asking for in this bill is not prohibited by FERPA. So it's not something that is subject to being kept private. If a school is referring a child to juvenile court, They have a responsibility and a duty to make those records available concerning that child's evaluation
▶ Play
and disability. Representative Copeland. Senator, can you help me understand what is happening now, presently? If you don't mind, just give maybe a scenario where this law would be beneficial, because I'm not sure I understand. I think I know what you're trying to do, and I appreciate it, but if you could just give kind of a scenario where now versus once this
▶ Play
law were to be enacted. I'm an attorney in private practice, and I've represented children before juvenile court, and I get in for one case. The parents came to me to represent this young person, and they had had lawyers prior to. the school had been shipping the kid back and forth. He was a special needs child, had been determined to have a disability that was recognized under this IDEA. He had mild mental retardation and ADHD. He had a speech impediment. Never did the school send his records that indicated he was a special needs child with a disability. And I find, as a practicing attorney, that this is not done uniformly across our state in the courts. And what I'm saying is I'm seeing more and more a pattern that schools are using the juvenile court to deal with disciplinary issues when, in the first instance, they've never even evaluated the child to see what the problem might be, whether that problem may be a disability. I had Dr. Schultz on the other side of the Senate Judiciary Committee, and he expressed the concern that in so many times a child that is acting out has a behavioral issue that becomes present at school. That's the only way the child knows to communicate, and a lot of times Dr. Schultz has found that was a result of a disability and the child had no way otherwise of communicating it. I just simply want schools, before they put children in a juvenile justice system, which may be subjecting that child to contempt proceedings, which could even end up having the child incarcerated, placed in juvenile detention. Before that happens, all I'm saying is let's see if this child, after evaluation, is or is not a disabled child. And if so, then let the school and require these schools to do what they're charged to do under IDEA.
▶ Play
Representative House. Doctor, this may be a question for you. I know that HIPAA prohibits disclosure of medical information except under a court order, but we're talking about the school initiating a FINS petition. Senator addressed the FERPA issue. What about HIPAA? Do you think we're okay there if the school brings forth medical information that it is obtained? Yes, sir.
▶ Play
Speaker 191 1:39:07
I believe so. We, as the child's physician, for continuity reasons, we communicate with the school all the time in terms of a diagnosable disability. So we ask the school for copies of the individualized education plan and other things that they have on file to help us in our evaluation of the child, and we share information back and forth because it's all in regard to the
▶ Play
continuity of care. If I might add, Representative House also, parents are protected. Their rights are protected. They can ask for due process hearing, emergency due process hearing, so that if they object to any particular item that is being transmitted to the court, There is a process for them to do that.
▶ Play
We have Paul Kelly signed up to speak for the bill. Is Mr.
▶ Play
Kelly here, please? Thank you, sir. My name is Paul Kelly. I'm a senior policy analyst, and I represent Arkansas Advocates for Children and Families. We support this bill. We think that it is very important that we know what the schools have done to intervene with kids who are at risk of finding themselves in the juvenile justice system. This bill will hold schools accountable for their ability to implement what is required by federal law to assist children with disabilities and to make sure that they have been given all due, that the schools are making a good faith effort to deal with the underlying problems that are likely causing the reason that they are being brought before the court. And I concur with the problem of especially kids with disabilities being dealt with in juvenile courts and in fact adding another risk factor to their lives that will in fact criminalize in a way their behavior. And we just want to make sure that schools make a good faith effort and document that so the judge and everyone else would be in a better position to do what's right for the kids and keep them out of the court system only
▶ Play
if that's needed. Thank you, Mr. Kelly. Representative
▶ Play
Beck. Yes. I'm curious as to where are the schools? I hear a lot of people talking. Where are the
▶ Play
schools on this bill as far as? I've talked to, they call them local education agents, and we have a state education agent that is at the Department of Ed. I haven't talked to that person. But the local education agents that are responsible for the special education and seeing that the rights of parents and students and the testing, the evaluation, and setting up the meetings for the individualized education plans, all of those that I've talked to are in support of this. We have teachers that have even come to me that have complained that some schools are, you know, they feel reluctant because maybe the superintendent or they are pressured into not actually making the recommendation for a child to be evaluated when they know that a child should be evaluated. So we need something that's in the law that would require schools to do what is right by these children before they are referred to juvenile court. We're not talking about criminal conduct when we're speaking of FNs petitions. We're talking about just incorrigible behavior. I hope that answered your question, Representative Beck. but I haven't found any teacher that is in opposition to this. In fact, I'll share with you this. I was at a function a couple of Saturdays ago, and it was an event honoring some retired teachers, and I told her what my bill was about. And she said to me, they need that. and she remarked how she looks at the daily paper and sees young people that have been arrested, sentenced to the Department of Correction, who she knew had a problem early on when she was teaching. And if you look at the statistics in our Department of Correction, You find that same little database where you have adult prison population that is mostly with limited IQ, dropped out of school. And to me, that is evidence that we did not do a good job when they were younger and in school. any other questions all right um does not
▶ Play
appear anybody else has signed up to speak for against all right uh ms hickman if you'll take take a seat at the end of the table
▶ Play
Speaker 216 1:45:20
Connie Hickman Tanner representing the judges on this bill our judicial council actually opposes this bill while we agree that special education should be addressed in our courts we feel this bill is overreaching and broad and have great concerns about the way this bill was drafted If you look in Section 1, Section 1 delineates the very specific things that have to be added now to the petition. First, let me tell you, FINS cases are status offender cases in our courts. They are when a juvenile by nature is truant, a runaway, or I love this one, willfully disobedient to the lawful commands of their parents. That's almost any adolescent, isn't it? If you have adolescents in your home. They're very concerned that requiring when school districts file petitions, they mainly file petitions for truancy. In fact, there's another section in the education code that when a juvenile reaches or starts to exceed the number of unexcused absences, they must file a truancy petition. It's imperative that we get those as quickly as possible before the kid misses the semester. And so we have to get those petitions timely. And the judges are concerned that this will delay the processing of those cases. To the question that Representative Rushing raised about the parents' consent, We disagree with Senator Flowers and her interpretation of the law. Actually, under IDEA amendments in 1997, it does require when a school reports a crime on their campus that a youth with a disability, that they are to report to the person they commit the crime to. They're supposed to give not only the disciplinary records that they have, but also the special education records. but it says subject to FERPA. FERPA is the Family Education and Privacy Rights Act. That says the parents must consent to the release of those records. So parents must release to the records being released. Parents have to release the records of the educational records. It's not HIPAA, but it's FERPA. So when intake, when juvenile officers normally do an intake, they've been trained to ask if there's special education issues and would they consent to releasing those records. That's one way we try to address it. Another way we try to address it is defense counsel often brings this case, these issues up to the judge so that the judge can consider it at disposition. That's another way to address it. These issues are very important and the court should address them, but we have a concern with how it's addressed. It also appears that we're trying to really litigate special education issues in our courts when actually there's a process for that already dealt with in the special education law. If you look at Section 2, it's now asking our juvenile courts to determine if the special education law is being complied with. This is going to be a burden for our courts to now take on something that there's already a federal law in process to protect our parents. Both our education laws, we're dealing with 504 of the Rehabilitation Act and IDA. They are parents' rights bills, and there is a process in both of those for them to make sure there's compliance with. And I'm happy to answer any questions.
▶ Play
Okay, I see no questions. Thank you for your testimony. Does not appear anybody else has signed
▶ Play
up to speak for or against the bill? Senator Flowers, would you like to close for your bill? Yes, thank you, Mr. Chair. I'd just like to respond to what Ms. Hickman-Tanner has represented to the committee. There is a process that allows for redress for complaints, objections by parents of children that are underage, under the age of majority, and that is through due process hearings. And what my bill does, it simply says that before a school can refer a student to the court for a fiends petition. Go through all the things that the federal law requires. It doesn't ask for the court to litigate the child's IDEA rights. It only says prove to the court, the school, prove to the court that you have complied with the law that governs disabled children and evaluate them. If a child's not evaluated to be disabled, there's not an issue. But if a child has been evaluated based on observation and the idea that truancy cases need to be speedily handed to the court, even in truancy cases children can be expressing through their truant behavior a disability and so I'm asking the committee to consider this bill. I think it's a good bill I think it's needed and I'm asking for a good vote. Thank
▶ Play
you. Thank you Senator Flowers. What's the pleasure of the committee? I do not see a motion, so the bill will just remain on the agenda. Thank you, Senator Flowers. Representative House.
▶ Play
Mr. Chairman, in the audience, the Honorable Joe Volpe, United States Magistrate, has graced us with his presence.
▶ Play
Welcome, Judge. We're going to go without objection to Representative Bell. He has two bills we're going to try and run. Just one? That's a good question. Why do we not applaud judges? We should. Given that my dad is a former United States magistrate, I truly appreciate the work that our magistrate judges do. So thank you for being here.
▶ Play
Representative Bell, which bill are you here to present? 1376, Mr. Chair. And I believe your staff's already putting out an amendment. And at the proper time, I would request that you all
▶ Play
adopt the amendment. Motion. Okay. Representative Ballinger makes a motion to adopt the amendment. Any discussion? All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? The amendment's adopted. You recognize to present the
▶ Play
bill as amended. Thank you, Mr. Chair and committee. This is a bill that you all previously sent to the floor. After some discussions with a variety of interested parties, I wanted to come back and do two things. Clearly expressed that the legislative intent is to encourage the mothers who are affected here to get treatment and to move forward with their lives and not exclusively to punish those who are trying to make a turnaround. Also, narrowing the scope of the statute from the broad battery statute into the very narrow area of the injection statute just to tighten the bill up a little bit. So I believe the bill is a better bill than the one that you previously passed. It is slightly more narrow in scope, but it does more clearly express the legislative intent. With that, I'd be glad to take any
▶ Play
questions. Any questions from the committee? Representative Bennett, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Can you tell me what 513-210 is? I'm sorry, I haven't
▶ Play
had that. That is the injection portion, injection of a chemical portion of the battery statute. All right, I see no further questions.
▶ Play
Representative Talley, you recognize for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. So
▶ Play
if they take the medicine orally, it's okay? Well, they've got Tylenol or something like that,
▶ Play
and it causes it. This doesn't address anything medical. It'll only address illegal drugs that are scheduled.
▶ Play
Any other questions? I do not believe anybody signed up to speak for or against the bill. Representative Bell, are you closed for your bill? I am, Mr. Chair. All right. What's the pleasure of the committee? We have a motion do pass as amended. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Any opposed? The bill passes as amended. Thank you very much, Mr. Chair, members of the committee. Is Representative Letting still here? It's not up here, so. All right, committee, we're approaching the noon hour, and we've been directed to try and allow everybody to go to lunch at noon. So I do intend on having a meeting upon adjournment. I recognize that may be later in the day, but we still have quite a few bills on the agenda, and hopefully we can address some of the bills that maybe won't take too much of our time. We can go ahead and get some of those things out of here. So without objection, we're adjourned.
▶ Play

Agenda

SB79

0:19 - 30:34 86 segments 9 speakers

HB1676

30:34 - 57:06 85 segments 9 speakers

HB1624

57:06 - 1:14:33 56 segments 10 speakers

HB1599

1:14:33 - 1:28:28 41 segments 10 speakers

SB484

1:28:28 - 1:53:07 65 segments 12 speakers

HB1376

1:53:07 - 1:56:05 13 segments 4 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Matthew J. Shepherd Chair Unverified
71 segments
Senator Jon Woods Unverified
6 segments
Representative Rick Beck Unverified
4 segments
Graham Catlett Unverified
26 segments
Speaker 31
24 segments
Speaker 34
2 segments
Representative Douglas House Unverified
17 segments
Representative Donnie Copeland Chair Unverified
10 segments
Speaker 85
1 segment
Representative Sue Scott Unverified
15 segments
Speaker 93
46 segments
Speaker 108
8 segments
Speaker 122
1 segment
Chair Unverified
2 segments
Representative Bob Ballinger Unverified
4 segments
Casey Copeland Unverified
9 segments
Speaker 103
1 segment
Speaker 146
6 segments
Speaker 155
3 segments
Speaker 158
1 segment
Speaker 162
5 segments
Speaker 166
16 segments
Speaker 172
3 segments
Speaker 2
1 segment
Keith Boone Unverified
5 segments
Representative Dwight Tosh Unverified
1 segment
Laura Webb Unverified
2 segments
Senator Stephanie Flowers Unverified
30 segments
Speaker 191
6 segments
Speaker 186
1 segment
Representative Laurie Rushing Unverified
2 segments
Paul Kelly Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 216
7 segments
Representative Nate Bell Unverified
5 segments
Representative Camille Bennett Unverified
1 segment
Representative Brent Talley Unverified
1 segment