House Revenue & Taxation Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (10)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1703
· 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1703”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1817
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1817”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1239
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1239”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1772
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1772”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB897
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB897”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB898
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB898”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB900
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB900”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB906
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB906”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB907
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB907”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB908
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB908”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 15, 2026
Do we have enough? Representative Douglas, are you good to go, sir, for your bill? Members, we want to start off without objection. We're going to take something out of order here, as we normally do.
We're going to look at House Bill 1703. Anybody in the audience want to speak for or against House Bill 1703, please sign in. Morning, Scott. How you doing? Morning. Representative Douglas, you doing all right? Doing
an amendment you want to adopt right out of the gate? Yes, sir. We have an amendment here to 1703, and all this amendment is doing is standardizing the gallons of gas equivalent to more of a national standard to where each state's doing the same.
Several states have adopted the standard on this amendment, so I would appreciate
your consideration. Members, I have a motion for the amendment. Any discussion? All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no. Congratulations, sir. You passed your amendment. When you get ready
for your bill, you're good to go, sir. Okay, thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee. I appreciate your indulgence this morning in taking us a little bit out of order here. House Bill 1703 deals with the taxation of alternative fuels.
Right now we're in a situation where each driver, whenever they pull into the gas station and fill up with gasoline or diesel fuel, you are paying road user tax. on some of the alternative fuels, natural gas, compressed natural gas, liquefied natural gas, you're not paying that same rate. And it's a fairness issue. We have to maintain our roads. These cars go down the road, down our highways, utilizing them, but they're not paying for the maintenance and upkeep.
And with that, I'll turn it over to Director Bennett to give a little bit more insight and information on this. director
Speaker 11
2:28
bennett you're recognized sir thank you mr. chair and representative douglas like representative douglas mentioned we have really considered this more of a fairness issue than an issue that's going to generate a lot of money if you look at dfna's impact statement actually in the first year there would be a reduction in revenue
And the reason for this is because we are increasing the measurement of an equivalent gallon of this type of fuel. And then it phases in, increases over five years to where compressed natural gas would be charged the equivalent rate of gasoline and liquefied natural gas and other alternative would be charged the same as diesel tax. and any other alternative fuels would be charged the equivalent of gasoline.
You can see that the revenue is not great, and one of the reasons for that is because of the amount of consumption. Gasoline in the last 12 months, we have bought 1.4 billion gallons in Arkansas, bought about 600 million gallons of diesel. Those have been relatively flat over the last several years and somewhat declining. Alternative fuels have increased somewhat. They increased 20% over the last year.
But even at that, we've only sold a million gallons of alternative fuels in Arkansas. But this would put a more equivalent tax structure in place if this industry does continue to grow. And I will say this, that there are 41 states that have rates for compressed natural gas that are higher than Arkansas. There are 43 states that have rates for liquefied natural gas that are higher than Arkansas.
And the other states that don't have it are trying to do the same thing that we're doing right now, is put more of an equivalent structure in place for all types of fuel. And I'll be
happy to try to answer any questions. Thank you, guys. I guess my first question is, what kind of revenue are you expecting
Speaker 11
4:44
from this? You say a million gallons, Director Bennett? In Arkansas, we sold a million gallons of alternative fuel over the last 12 months.
It's bringing in less than $100,000 a year. The revenue is not great, but if this industry does grow, what's happening is these vehicles are replacing vehicles that now use regular gasoline and regular diesel tax. Well, I mean, a vehicle is a vehicle, so you've got the same congestion. For trucks that use LNG instead of diesel, they're still hauling the same weight, so they're creating the same damage. So it's really a replacement. As our revenue from normal gasoline and diesel go down,
Hopefully this revenue will go up to replace it so all of it will be held relatively constant. But it's not great. I mean, it's a million gallons compared to 600 million gallons of diesel and 1.4 billion gallons of gasoline. Has the industry or
anybody, has anybody done a study to, I know nobody's a crystal ball, but has anybody did a study to say, like, go out five years, ten years down the road, what the projection is going to be on natural gas?
Speaker 11
5:57
we have we have done our best to do it and at the i mean kind of looking at the current rate
where it's grown at 20 a year over the last few years still in in five years that's not a lot i mean compared to bringing in a hundred thousand dollars a year now it may be bringing in $500,000 a year in five or ten years, but that's countered by a reduction in consumption and revenue from gasoline and diesel tax. Members, any questions from the committee?
Representative Speaks, you recognize, ma'am. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I don't understand a lot about this, so what I'm fixing to ask, you may find out how much I really know but is it does this mean is our gasoline at the pumps right now how much are we paying for the gasoline and how much is this going to go up in in
Speaker 11
7:00
these five years okay today at the pump from the state level you are paying 21 and a half cents per gallon for every gallon
that you buy of gasoline if you go to if you have a cng vehicle you're paying the equivalent of a nickel a gallon and what would happen is in the first year we would keep it at a nickel a gallon but what you're doing because it's not actually a gallon you have to measure what goes into it and and equate it to a gallon we're making that volume bigger which means it takes more of the cng to
equal a gallon so in the first year even though the tax rate stays the same at five cents you generate less revenue because they're paying five cents on a bigger volume in the second year it goes to eight cents so it goes up three cents in the third year it goes up to 11 cents which is another three cents in the fourth year it goes up to 17 cents and in the fifth year it goes to the equivalent rate that we're paying for gasoline and diesel now so it's phased in over five years
and one of the reasons we wanted to recommend phasing it in over five years is because we don't want to have that big an increase and and have you know a little bit of a potential to hurt the industry in trying to develop. But if you go to a CNG station now, you're paying, what, $1.50 a gallon, maybe, total. Our pump price on gasoline has probably jumped up 20 cents a gallon in the
last month, and none of that has been related to taxes. It's just been related to the wholesale price. So even with this, you're not going to see the rate, the pump price of alternative fuels jump up to be equivalent to what we're paying for
gasoline and diesel. Representative Speaks, if I may add to that, this is not going to change the taxes on gasoline or diesel at all. That is staying exactly the same. This has no effect on that. What
we're doing right now if by the way do you happen to drive a cng car or a car power do you put gasoline in your car gasoline okay here's what's happening right now you're paying 21 and a half cents a gallon that goes to maintain the roads you drive on okay right now if representative if Vaught is driving a CNG car, she is paying a nickel a gallon to use the same roads.
So all this is is a way to create fairness. You know, it would be just like if you paid income tax at one rate and Representative Vaught didn't pay income tax, that wouldn't be fair. Although she'd like that. I can see by the smile on her face she'd like that. But you wouldn't like it, and it's not fair for you to use the road, and you'd be paying for the road for somebody else that's not paying for the maintenance of the roads. All this is is a fairness trying to equalize.
We're not trying to penalize anybody. We're not trying to raise taxes on anybody to get more revenue. It's a fairness to equalize to make sure everybody that is using the roads is paying their fair share. That's all it is. And really
Speaker 11
10:38
what's happening is as somebody sells a vehicle that uses gasoline, they're buying a vehicle that uses C&G. So it is a replacement. So they're buying less gasoline. They're buying more C&G, which reduces revenue.
And what we're trying to do is hold it constant. One more question. What about on your natural gas, that's the heating for your homes and that, is that going to affect that
at all? No, ma'am. This is just road use. Okay. It's only in what goes in vehicles that are going the road. Just like right now, you pull up to the gas pump, put gasoline in your car, that's where you pay the tax. You don't pay it through your utilities or anything else.
This is whenever they pull up to the fuel station or the gas pump for CNG, it will be paid right there, and it only goes to what is used to propel the vehicle down the highway. Thank you. You're welcome, ma'am. Mr. Co-Chair? Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
I appreciate you all bringing this bill. I've got
a question or two. I don't know how many of you ever go to Branson, but there was a show up there before he closed by Jim Stafford.
And I just wanted to ask either one of you if you brought your guitar today. Because if you saw that show, he would bust that guitar, and then he'd put it back together with duct tape. And frankly, this is what this bill does, and we just keep doing it. And, Scott, we've done it for 36 years down here. And then the Highway Commission, the Highway Department, comes in and says our revenues are flat, and they have been for 36 or 40 years or more. because of this 21 and a half cents a gallon and so my question there have been uh representative
douglas has had a bill to take money from education doing this and other general funds some of us would say it that way and we've tried that for years that that dog didn't hunt either and apparently it's not hunting anyway because i think that bill's done sent where some of my bills are going right dan yes sir so we've probably got
Speaker 44
12:48
some more they'll go there too kim Some more of mine, too, and that's where they ought to be, probably. But
the question is that if we don't fix this thing, we're going to come back here and do this. First, there are a lot of stuff that bothers me about this, Bill.
You're saying it's 21.5 cents a gallon if I buy gasoline, but you're going to do the CNG for 5 cents. And I guess the reason for that is the state government is going to now compensate and decide who uses what and pay them for doing it. No,
Speaker 11
13:15
sir. The purpose of this is so the people that have a CNG vehicle will, over five years, end up paying the same thing that you pay when you put gasoline in your vehicle. Why don't they pay it right now? Because that's the way the law has been written for years and years and years, and that's what we're trying to correct.
Speaker 52
13:34
But because we hadn't got this bill passed before, Representative Hendrick, that's the thing. Right now, they're paying a
nickel, and you're paying 21 and a half cents. and that's not fair to you to pay the majority of the cost out there. All this is is fairness. Right now they're paying a nickel for a gallon and you're paying 21.5 cents and anybody that thinks that's fair is just dead wrong. That's all there is to it. Well, I don't
think it's fair whenever you're saying it's 5 cents and you're charging me 21.5 cents.
What's fair about that? Well, it's not. That's what we're trying to correct. We're trying to get it up 21.5 cents. As I read this bill, it says beginning July the 1st, 2015. Are we in 2015 now? Yes, sir. Then it says you're going to raise it and it's going to be five cents. Well, it's
five cents last year. It's going to be five cents this year. Next year it's going to go up. We're going to keep bumping it up with this bill if we pass it out here and do the right thing to get it up to where it's 21.5 cents. We're not going to do it all at once because we don't want to hurt the industry,
but we're taking something that's bad and unfair and trying to make it fair. We're trying to get it up there to where they pay the same thing
you do, Representative Hendren. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. He's
getting tired, and I am too. I forgot where we went
Speaker 59
14:57
at after that. Representative Tucker, you're recognized, sir. I hate to follow that. My understanding is that one of the reasons why the tax has been lower on alternative fuels is both to allow the industry to develop and also to incentivize alternative fuel purchases.
And if that's not correct, I want you to please correct me. My only question is whether once you equalize these taxes, then there's basically no incentive anymore one way or the other. And I understand the revenue situation and the fairness situation, but I just am curious whether there was any consideration to leaving the alternative fuel tax just maybe ultimately a little below the oil
Speaker 11
15:33
tax just to address the incentive situation. I think there is still incentive for people to use alternative fuel vehicles because the overall price is so much lower than gasoline and diesel.
Just a year ago, when we were paying $3 plus a gallon for gasoline, you drive up Highway 65 toward Branson, and there's a CNG station over on the left, and they had a big sign out front that said it's like $1.15 a gallon. Well, everybody with a car was pulling in there wanting to buy gas at $1.15 a gallon, but it wasn't for gas. It was for CNG vehicles. So the price is still going to stay lower, and that's going to be the incentive for people to continue doing this.
So even with this increase, the price is going to stay lower. You're still going to pay less at the pump for these alternative fuels, and
you're paying for gasoline and diesel. And another thing, Representative Tucker, A lot of the vehicles out there, there are a lot of the fleets out there that are going to the CNG because it makes more economic sense to them. And a lot of these are buses, heavier trucks, and things like that that do more damage to the road there.
There are some lightweight vehicles that use it, pickups. I've seen them and a few cars around. But a large portion of it is going into some of your industrial and fleet use there. And they're the ones that just hurt the roads more. There are still incentives for people to use it, like Scott said, for the cost savings there. Then also there's the green initiative and more sustainability there, better climate.
So people will still buy them. they'll still convert their vehicles because this is a small percentage of the overall cost there. But should we really be taxing one person one rate and another rate for doing the same thing? I don't know. That's kind of iffy to me. Thank you, gentlemen. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. You bet. Members, any
other questions? if not any questions from the members
anybody in the audience want to speak against the bill is there anybody here want to speak for the bill if not representative Douglas
are you closed for your bill sir I think we beat this horse about as much as we can beat it if anybody doesn't understand what we're trying to do here make it fair and equitable for everyone we don't want anybody to be penalized we don't want anybody to be hurt we just want equality in this. With that, I'm closed. Thank you.
Thank you very much. Representative Vought? Okay, this is a motion to do pass as amended, right? Members, we have a motion to do pass as amended on the floor, but Representative Vought, all in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? No. Ayes have it. Congratulations, sir. You passed your bill. Thank you,
Mr. Chair. Thank you, Committee. I appreciate you very much. Happy St. Patrick's Day. That's a really ugly tie you have
Speaker 32
18:45
on, by the way. Thank you all. You should see his socks. You should see my bloomers.
Don't want to see that. Members, we're going to continue taking one more out of order without objection to the community. Representative Rushing, are you ready to run your bill, ma'am? Members, this is House Bill 1817 on your tablets. Thank you, Mr. Chair and committee.
It's a pleasure to be here today, and thanks for hearing us out of order. I appreciate that. Judiciary will like it. I can get back over to them and see what's going on over there. This bill, 1817, is a bill to clarify that the Statutory Foreclosure Act of 1987 applies to non-judicial foreclosures as it has been the practice for the last 28 years. Transfer taxes have not been charged in non-judicial foreclosures before. Both non-judicial and judicial foreclosures have been treated as exempt until a recent lawsuit.
You will see in your package that the DF&A shows on the physical impact statement that there's no impact to the state general revenue. This is basically a clarification to make it clear that all foreclosures would be treated in the same manner in regards to transfer taxes, as the practice has always been since 1987. And we feel that adding a transfer tax to nonjudicial foreclosure is just an expense that will ultimately be passed down to the consumer or potential homeowner in the future.
I have some of my friends here that are for this bill. If you have any questions,
they can answer them. Okay. Members, any questions?
Representative Mix, you recognize her. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Just to make sure I'm following you, this tax has not been paid since 1987? Correct. Was it supposed to have been paid since 1987? Well,
I think that's why there's a lawsuit.
I think that it was not ever clear. It had been treating nonjudicial the same as judicials. I think Michael Patek might can answer that better
than me. My name is Michael Patek. I'm general counsel for Bank of the Ozarks. The real property transfer tax was, foreclosures were exempted from that and it shouldn't make a difference whether it's a judicial foreclosure or a statutory foreclosure.
The same principle applies where a creditor is credit bidding in order to acquire property that it holds as collateral. And there's no money changing hands in a situation where the creditor is credit bidding. Okay. So the statement
where there's no fiscal impact is just because this has not been done. If this had been done according to the laws it was, and this may be a DF&A question, what would the fiscal impact have been?
Excuse me. Tim, one of you folks come to, can you guys help clear that up,
please? John? I'm just kind of curious what their position has been on this and if this was supposed to have been collected, why it hasn't been
collected, or what's kind of gone on with that. Mr. Chair, committee members, I'm John Tice with DFA. The way the real estate transfer tax is structured, DFA sells a document.
We'll sell a transfer stamp. At the point that stamp is sold, there's no way for DFA to know what type of instrument that stamp's going to be applied to. When that instrument is then filed with the clerk, the clerk looks at the instrument to make sure that the proper amount of tax has been paid. Your question was about whether the tax was due or not, and at this point, as you can see by the fact there's been a lawsuit filed, there's a legitimate difference of opinion among various parties whether that tax is currently due or not.
It is impossible for DFA to determine the impact of the tax that should have been collected because, as I said, we sell a piece of paper, a stamp, and beyond that we don't know how that stamp is used. So what we do know is there's no impact to state general revenue. The amount of state general revenue is capped at about, I think it's $2.6 million. That amount is collected regardless of whether this law passes or not,
as well as the amount of money that goes to the Administration of Justice Fund. That amount is set, and that amount is collected regardless of this law. There could be an impact on others, particularly county, I think, county aid fund, But because DFA doesn't know how that stamp's used, we don't know the answer to how much money that is. Okay, and in
y'all's opinion, have y'all or have you even formed an opinion? Is this something that should or shouldn't have been collected? Or are you kind of just waiting to see the outcome or doesn't?
Over the years, DFA was asked whether this tax was due. and our legal answer and legal opinions was that non-judicial foreclosures were subject to the real estate transfer tax and had issued opinions. The problem is we're not in a position then to administer that tax because of the fact that we don't see the instrument to which that deed is. Other than that, we'd have to audit each individual deed. And we have done some of those audits and we have made some assessments. But remember, typically we're talking very, very small amounts on most deeds.
The tax is $3.30 per $1,000 of consideration. And this will be my final question. Who
would be responsible for having to collect that tax or make that determination? Would that be the county assessor, or who would do that? I would think it would be the circuit clerk at
the time that instrument's filed has to make a decision. does this instrument have the proper amount of tax affixed to it. Okay. All right. Thank you. Thank you, Mr.
Chairman. You bet. Representative Gonzalez to recognize, sir.
Members, any other questions? Mr. Co-Chair. Mr. Tice, you say
$3.30 per thousand? Yes, sir. That's correct. You sell the stamps, but surely this banker sitting over here, or somebody knows how many foreclosures, dollars worth, estimated the past year we've done in the state of Arkansas, or maybe you all do. Doesn't somebody know that? Somebody may know it. All I can say is DFA doesn't
have that information. I wonder if somebody's in the audience today. Let me,
could I ask the gentleman? I can probably make an educated guess, but I don't have the exact numbers. Being that I'm a realtor, I know that my office down in the Garland County area in foreclosures each year we do approximately about seven million dollars worth and that's just in that area but we do go across the state and there's probably four other foreclosure agents that work that probably do about the same amount so you're probably looking about maybe 32 million and in evaluation of being done well that's
just a guess I'm just pulling out like I said there's no facts behind that yeah
In full disclosure, I've been a broker since 69. I know you don't think I'm that old, but what you've just said, you're saving $7 million down in your neck of the woods. Then could we not extrapolate and say that might be how much in the state of Arkansas? And then if you did that, couldn't you apply this $3.30 per thousand? At least that's the way we used to do things when I went to school and estimated how much that loss is that Representative Meeks was asking about.
My name is Jim Pender. I'm an attorney here in Plus County for the last 30 years. Oh, my. Now we've got trouble for sure. And I also own a title company as well. And first, let me say that the Arkansas Land Title Association, the Arkansas Bankers Association, the Bar Association are all in support of this bill. and the Realtors Association. I'm sorry, I forgot them.
But there's an alternative, and so lawyers have to choose every day whether to file a judicial foreclosure or a nonjudicial foreclosure. The results, if I could continue the theme of fairness from the last bill, there's no government policy reason to charge a tax on a judicial, not charge a tax on a judicial foreclosure deed, but charge it on a non-judicial foreclosure deed. And so the net effect of if you decide to not pass this bill
and the result is that you charge a tax on the non-judicial foreclosure deeds, well, what the lawyers will decide is to file judicial foreclosures and they'll just do the same thing, have the same procedure, and not file a tax. It's just a matter of fairness, a matter of – and one thing to keep in mind, the state eventually gets the money because the banks don't hold on to this property, whether they foreclose by judicial or non-judicial, they eventually sell the property, and that's when they pay the tax. But they're not paying money when they bid on their foreclosure,
whether it be judicial or non-judicial, and that's why this exemption came up, I think, because they're not paying money for the property at that time. And if I bought a piece of property today, I wouldn't have to pay a tax if I didn't pay money. If I just paid less than $100, there's no tax. they're bidding in their loan and so they're not paying money they're just bidding in their debt to get the property so there should be no taxation and definitely from a fairness standpoint there's no reason to tax one form of foreclosure
and not tax the other but with no money being paid there shouldn't be a tax anyway and again eventually they sell the property just like I was talking to Matt Kendall from Arvest yesterday. He said, yeah, that's double taxation if we have to pay it on the nonjudicial. And he gave me
permission to say that. I guess, again, $3.30 per thousand times however many millions a year, I'd like to know about how much that is. And as you
mentioned that, somebody, if this tax is collected, somebody has to pay it, either the bank or the guy who lost the property. Somebody has to pay that money unless we borrow it from China. Isn't that right? Yes, sir. It's all passed on to the consumer,
so this will, in effect, go to the consumer. Could another possible fix to this be,
instead of saying, well, we're going to cut the tax for everybody, why couldn't we run a bill that says we're going to tax everybody? That would also deal with the court case you're talking about, would it not? Yes, it would. In the
court case, the judges already ruled that there will be no money damages
because the right party didn't file the lawsuit. Well, we're talking about going forward,
right? We're talking about going forward. Okay. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. If I can address
that, if we were running a bill to raise taxes, Representative Rushing wouldn't be down here sitting on this end presenting it, so just make that clear. Representative Hodges, if you don't
care, I'm going to take somebody to order here because I think Representative Collins might have a handle on this. I'm going to come back to your question, sir, if you don't care. Thank you. Representative
Collins, you're recognized. Mr. Chair, my name is Charlie Collins, and I'm a member of the Revin Tax Committee, and I'm here to answer Representative Hendren's question.
By my figurines, sir, and I didn't use a calculator, nor did I write the figures down, $3 on $1,000 up to $30 million works out to about $100,000 per year. I want to thank you, Mr. Chairman. He helped me so
much on a bill yesterday. I really appreciate that. Thank you. You're welcome, sir, as always.
Representative Hodges, thank you for your indulgence, sir, and you recognize
for your question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I just need clarification because we're talking about the $3.30 per $1,000.
and that's initially charged when the property is purchased and the deeds, you know, they collect those fees at closing. Is that correct? Yes, sir. And so we're talking about foreclosures, right? Correct. So I'm just confused. I probably should know, but I don't. The $3.30 and I agree with you that, you know, the bank's not really receiving anything for the property, so they should be charged another fee, but I'm confused. Where does the $3.30 come back in again?
When we sell the property out of real estate owned, we acquire the property, we hold it in what's known as other real estate owned, and then when we sell the property to a third party, at that point, the transfer tax is paid by the consumer.
So the tax is being paid on the back end when they sell the property. So it's not like the tax is
not ever being paid. Right. Okay. So we collect it when the property is purchased,
and then it forecloses on, and then we sell again, and it's collected again. But, you know, it varies because, you know, the price is going to be different on the second sale, or third sale, than it was on the first sale. So are you saying we're not collecting this as it stands right now? We're not getting this money or not collecting this money?
We're not collecting it when, and to clarify if I'm right, but we're not collecting it when it goes back to the bank. So when it goes from the original person or person purchaser back to the bank,
that's when it's not collected. Okay. But it is paid on the back end when the bank sells the property. Right now. Okay, I got you.
Thank you. Representative Tucker you recognize sir Thank you
Speaker 59
33:19
Mr. Chairman At the risk of hurting the prospects of the bill I do support the bill but Mr. Penner I just want to zero in on one thing you said right now you have two options judicial and non-judicial foreclosures correct yes sir and generally speaking non-judicial is preferred because it's more efficient it costs less
it places less of a burden on the judicial system and so forth is that fair and it's
faster yes that's fair And so if we don't pass this,
Speaker 59
33:44
then we will be incentivizing lawyers to choose the judicial foreclosure route, which is less efficient, costs more, and place more of a burden on the judicial system. Is that all fair? Yes, sir. That's fair. Thank you, sir. And that was pointed out
by an attorney, I might add, as well. Thank you, Representative Clark. Members, any other questions?
If not, anybody in the audience? Hold on just a second. Is there a Martha Smith in the audience who want to speak against the bill? Come to the end of the table, please, ma'am. Recognize yourself for
Speaker 134
34:26
the community. I'm Martha Smith. I'm circuit clerk of Clark County. In 2009, when I took, it's when I went into office, I had not worked in the circuit clerk's office, so there was a lot I had to learn.
In 2011, one of my girls asked me a question. There was a deed of trust that came through on a nonjudicial foreclosure, and it was going from one bank to another bank, and the amount was on there, and on the back it stamped that the correct amount of deed stamps was put on it. She asked me why the deed stamps weren't on it. Well, I didn't know because, like I said, I was new, so I started asking questions. I tried, and this was Wilson and Associates. I tried calling and asking them that question, could not get anybody to talk to me.
So we gathered up several of those, took them to our attorney, our county attorney, which is Todd Turner. He read over them, and he agreed that they should have deed stamps, or the way he read the law, they should have deed stamps. So he wrote a letter to Wilson's Associates, to Everbank, to Chase, and to Wells Fargo, and maybe a couple of more, and asked them why deed stamps weren't put on that paperwork. He got no response from anyone.
So that's when he decided to go ahead and file the civil case. The civil case was filed in 2012. It was transferred, or they had it transferred to federal court. We went to Hot Springs. The magistrate determined that it should go back to state court. And as of now, the judge did rule that we could not file for back taxes because DF&A would have to do that, but that we should proceed with the rest of it because he perceived it to state that we did, they should have been paying the tax.
What we're asking is that let the civil court take care of this. If it's ruled in our favor, we know that they will appeal it, and it will go to Supreme Court. Let Supreme Court decide it. And Todd Turner, now this is just a rough estimate, he said that he came up with $900,000 a year in unpaid amounts based on the average number of nonjudicial foreclosures in the medium home value in Arkansas. This number is very low, though, because the high bid at a nonjudicial sale is always inflated by fees, unpaid interest.
and on judicial foreclosures when they're done, if the bank retains that, they do not pay deed stamps they don't buy deed stamps, once they sell it's when the deed stamps are done non-judicial is the same way but what we were seeing with deeds of trust coming through, going from one bank to another bank and it stated, or from one name to another name, it stated in there the correct amount was put on there, and it wasn't That's what we were talking about.
Ms. Smith, will you take questions, ma'am? Yes. Representative Meeks, you're recognized for
your question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Just to make sure I'm understanding that your primary concern was not from owner to bank to another owner, but it was from owner bank to bank. It was that bank to bank transfer. Yes. That's where your primary contention is at with where we're at. Because when one bank sells it to
Speaker 134
37:48
another bank, they're making money. They're changing the name on it. So if I'm buying deed stamps for my property, I think they should have to pay deed stamps for theirs.
And I'd be interested in a rebuttal when that time comes. The next question, do you know why this wasn't collected before now? It seems like this has been going on for 30 years. Maybe nobody questioned it or just didn't want it. It says it's
Speaker 134
38:13
left up to the circuit clerks, and I want to make sure I do my job right. Sure, we appreciate that. That's why I want to make sure that the correct person, to me, the Supreme Court would be the one to decide this. Well,
I'm going to have a slight disagreement with you there. It's the legislative bodies.
It's our responsibility to determine policy and not the Supreme Court. Well, I do know, but once
Speaker 134
38:35
it gets to the Supreme Court, everything we've gathered in the last two and a half years, they will have to read all of it. Y'all don't have time to read all of it. This is true. Thank
sir? Yes. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Just one quick question. How often or how many do you have the number of how many banks actually sell a piece of property to another bank?
Speaker 134
39:02
Do you know those stats or numbers? I've got the number of the nonjudicial. Since I've been in office, I have never had a nonjudicial sale bought by an individual in Clark County. The opening bid is usually too high. and it's never ever since I've been in office a non-judicial has never sold in Clark County to an individual Representative
Hendren you recognize her another thing that I wasn't
any good at was being a banker one day but let me ask you this question is that if I sell a piece of property to my son and he doesn't pay for it and he has to I foreclose on that as an individual, not a bank. Are we talking about the same thing that would apply to him as to me as a lender, whether I pay tax by stamps or not, as it does a bank?
Speaker 134
39:58
It depends on how you word your deed when you sell it to your son. If it's a family transaction, there's no deed stamps on a family transaction.
Well, say it's not somebody that's not my son, just an individual. I finance the property and sell it to him. If you sell
Speaker 134
40:12
it to him and foreclose on it and you retain it, If you try to sell it to someone and nobody, if you do it, let's just say we do a judicial foreclosure on it, and I do a commissioner sale and I try to sell it and nobody buys it and you retain it, there's no deed stamps owed. What I'm trying to get out
there, maybe you can phrase it or the bank people can. Are you treating the banks any different than you do an individual? No. Okay, thank you.
Members, are there any questions? If not, thank you very much, Ms. Smith.
Speaker 153
40:51
Ms. Ava Franks, do you want to speak for the bill? My name's Ava Franks. I'm the director of government relations for the Arkansas Bankers Association. And the Bankers Association supports this bill. We think that, as Representative Rushing opened, that this is a clarification that, frankly, it's only fair that nonjudicial and judicial foreclosures
be treated in the same manner, and that is why we are here to support
the bill. Any questions, members? Representative Meeks. Ms. Ma'am,
Speaker 153
41:23
will you take questions? I will, but I would like to have the opportunity to defer to
the bankers that are in attendance, please. Fair enough. So,
Representative Meeks, you're recognized. All right, thank you. The question would be the question that I asked prior about the bank-to-bank transfers. Since that's the majority, it sounds like that's the majority of the transfers
that we're talking about here. Can you address that issue if we're selling property from one bank to another? We're not typically going from
Ms. Smith was talking about, But if a bank forecloses and acquires the property at the foreclosure sale, the same bank that made the loan, there should not be a transfer tax, in our opinion. But if another bank is there and bids, then there should be a transfer tax
because it was not a credit bid. It was a monetary bid. Okay.
And so if the foreclosing bank is the creditor, if the creditor bank, If they foreclose and you transfer it to another bank, there should be the title tax paid there. We're strictly talking about the creditor foreclosing on the property, and that's the only bank transfer we're talking about here. Is that correct? As far as what should be exempt.
Sir, you got something to add? Yes, sir. Jim Pender again. I'm not really sure, again, what Ms. Smith is referring to, but if a bank assigns the mortgage to another bank, sometimes they call it mortgages deeds of trust. Out-of-state banks use deeds of trust, and that deed of trust is assigned to another bank, and that's not a deed transfer, and I guess that may be the situation she's talking about.
I really don't know, but I agree with Mr. Patak that if a bank is just bidding in their debt, their loan. There's no money transferred, whether it's judicial or non-judicial, and therefore they shouldn't be treated differently. But if a bank sold the property to another bank for consideration, or another bank bid on it at a four-to-closure sale and had to bid money like I would have to pay money if I bid on it as a third party, then we would all have to pay transfer taxes on that transaction, as
it is now. I'll clear it up before you, Mr. Meeks.
Thank you. Representative Hodges, you're recognized, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and I promise you I won't say another word. You're good, buddy. But going back to Meeks' question, Representative Meeks, because I was confused, too, when they were talking about the banks buying the property. What happens is when a property is foreclosed on, after a certain amount of days, they have the bidding process and normally people don't want to give you the value
of the property so the bank takes the property back there shouldn't be tax you shouldn't be charged on that because you're getting that property back and now if another bank they're bidding on it and they purchased it of course there's money that $3.30 per thousand comes into play and that should be paid so So that's kind of what they're talking about as far as monetary transfer
when another entity is buying it and money is being exchanged as opposed to the bank itself that forecloses on the property if it's bidding and getting the property
back. That's correct. Whether it's a judicial or nonjudicial, the lender who loaned the money who did not get paid back the money on the loan, and they get an opportunity to bid their debt. They're not paying money. They're just bidding their debt. And sometimes the fair market value of that property is less than that debt,
and therefore third parties don't buy it. But if a third party buys it, whether it's me, you, or another bank, or anybody, they do have to pay the transfer tax because they're actually
having to pay money, whether judicial or nonjudicial. Thank you, members. Thank you guys. Is Ms. Rhonda Wharton, do you want to speak against the bill? So recognize yourself, ma'am, and you're free to go.
Speaker 161
45:52
Thank you. I'm Rhonda Wharton. I'm the Faulkner County Circuit Clerk and President of the Arkansas Circuit Clerk's Association. I've been told before that the first rule of statutory interpretation or constitutional interpretation is to read the statute or read the Constitution. Read what it says. This is clearly stated in the law that nonjudicial foreclosures are not exempt from paying the tax.
They never have been. That's been the law for the past 50, 30, 35, 50 years, however long it's been in effect. It's not surprising that out-of-state banks and companies who have not been paying the tax would try to get this law changed. Part of it is because of the lawsuit being filed in Clark County. And the judge there has ruled that they are not exempt from this tax.
If they want to be exempt from this tax when they purchase the property back, they can go through a court case, judicial foreclosure. That's a choice they have, like Mr. Pender said. But they have benefits of doing these nonjudicial foreclosures. They're cheaper. They're not as, they don't take as much time. There's things that they don't have to do in a nonjudicial foreclosure that they have to do when they go through court.
yes it takes more time for one that goes through court but that also gives the homeowner homeowner a benefit of trying to get things worked out you know if they're taking someone's home they should not benefit by getting an exemption on the taxes by not going through court they should have to follow the same rules and they should have to pay the same taxes as you and I have to
pay. I have to pay that tax when I buy a piece of property or when I sell a piece of property. I have to pay that tax and you do too and it's not fair for them to not have to do it too. The law has been very clear and it's been ruled in the lawsuit the non-judicial foreclosures are not exempt by failing to pay those
taxes they're taking money away from the state they're taking money away from the counties the counties get a portion of the the documentary stamps each month I can tell you that in my county in 2014 we had right at 250 non-judicial foreclosures filed. I don't know how many of those sold back to the bank. The biggest majority of them probably did, and I can't give you numbers on how much it was.
I just know how many were filed. Companies have been filing these deeds that falsely state that they're putting the correct amount of stamps on the deed, because they aren't. They aren't putting stamps on them at all, and the law requires them to presently. If a company wants to avoid paying these transfer taxes, they can go through a court case
foreclosure, and they get that benefit. That's one benefit of going through a court case foreclosure. With a nonjudicial foreclosure, no, they don't have the expense. They don't have the time. They don't, you know, they can get it through quicker. But then they have to pay the transfer tax. I think that that's probably a very minor part of cost compared to going through a court case. And I just don't see why they should be exempt
when no one else is. Representative Meeks, ma'am, you take a question? Yes, sir. Representative Meeks. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm hopefully not beating the horse to death here, but just trying to make sure I understand fully what we're doing here. Since we're talking about foreclosures, this tax is paid on a title transfer. Since the bank in question is the lien holder or the mortgage holder, my understanding is doesn't the bank hold title until that mortgage is paid off?
So there is not necessarily a property transfer occurring there, or am I wrong about that? Actually, the
Speaker 161
50:43
property is in the homeowner's name. I mean, you get a deed when you buy a piece of property, even if you mortgage it. You get a deed in your name, and that's recorded in the county. The property is in your name. That mortgage is a lien against the property, but they don't have title
to the property necessarily. Okay, okay. Okay, so because they don't have title, so having leaned the property in your testimony does not create an exemption to this.
No. And then my final question would be, do you know why this hasn't been collected for the last
Speaker 161
51:20
30 years if it's been the law? I do not. It should have been, in my opinion. But other than refusing to file papers, we don't really have a lot of enforcement ability in our office. Okay. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Dodson, you're recognized. And
we're fixing to wrap this up, members. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
And I apologize if this has been asked and answered before. but in the case where a judicial foreclosure process goes through like it is right now, how many of those end up paying the tax, or are all of those thrown out? A small percentage go
Speaker 161
52:04
to a third party, but the biggest majority of them, I would say, go to the bank, go back to the bank that was holding the lien. So almost none of them
are, they're all exempted through the judicial process? Yes, sir. Thank you. Thank
you. Members, that concludes everybody speaking for or against to sign in for this. So, Representative Rushing, you want to close for your bill, ma'am? Yes, thank
you, Mr. Chair. I just want to clarify that we are, the reason we brought this bill is to make clarification that hasn't been in the past, and that's what this would lend, is that clarification that we're asking for. We're not debating non-judicial foreclosures
or judicial foreclosures, because that's a debate that's all in itself in a whole different matter. But non-judicial foreclosures, they allow for a faster stabilization of the housing market, and so that's why sometimes those are preferred, because in order to get the market back stabilized, we need to get get those properties out as fast as we can. And again, we are just trying to clarify the standard of practice that's been done for the last 30 years to make sure that everyone's on the same page so we can't avoid lawsuits
in the future on what's covered and what's not covered. And so that's the purpose of my bill, and I'm close for my bill. Thank you,
Mr. Chair. Thank you, ma'am. Members, we have a motion on the table by Representative Dodson. You recognize? Representative Dodson makes a motion for due pass. Any discussion? All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? No. Ayes have it. Congratulations, ma'am. You passed your bill. Thank you. Thank you, committee. Representative Mayberry, you ready, ma'am?
Members, we're going to start off with Representative Mayberry, and this is House Bill 1239, members, on your tablets. There's going to be an amendment with this bill. We're going to do the amendment, but then on the actual bill, we will not recognize the motion. This is for presentation only. There's going to be some handouts passed along for Representative Mayberry's bill. Representative Mayberry, first of all, I apologize. I know we've taken a lot of things out of order. Just try to make it because you've got three bills we're going to take a look at here, and I thought it would be perfect to do all three of your bills together.
So I appreciate your indulgence, letting the chair take things out of order, and just recognize yourself and you get ready and you're good. Oh, first of all, we're going to do your amendment. Your amendment is just names on
amendment, right? Yes, I've neglected to add Senator Missy Irvin on our sponsored list and realized that this morning and she'd be quite upset if I didn't have her name on there. Thank you. Representative
Meeks, you want to make a motion for me, sir? Representative Meeks, do pass for the amendment. All in favor, say aye.
Aye. Any opposed, no? Members, now this bill 1239 will be just presented only and no motion, but when you get ready, Representative Mayberry, you're good to go, ma'am. Okay,
thank you. First, I want to start off just by introducing some of the people I have here, if you all don't mind stating your name and
Speaker 204
55:22
to the Treasurer of State. Carl Doddery, Chief of Field Services for Arkansas Rehabilitation. Mark
Speaker 198
55:38
disability. I'm Keith Veyer. I'm CEO at Arkansas Support Network and current president of the Arkansas Waiver Association. Welcome,
guys. Thank you. First of all, members, I hope that you will agree with a statement that I'm sure you've before that it is far better to teach a person how to fish so you can teach them or give them food for a lifetime
rather than just giving them a fish for a day. That's exactly what this bill does. It is teaching someone to take care of themselves for a lifetime. This is the Achieving a Better Life Experience Program. And this would allow someone with a disability the opportunity to put money into a savings account so that they can help themselves. This was passed by Congress in December,
mid-December of 2014. And all of our congressional delegation here in the state of Arkansas not only voted for this bill, they co-sponsored the bill. We're talking everyone from prior to cotton and everyone in between. So you know that this is a good bill. It passed with bipartisan support. There was a lot of compromise along the way to get it to where there's some safety measures in here so the program's not taken advantage of. But this is federal legislation that's going to require the state of Arkansas to enact on it.
And so I'm coming to you today to say we need to get this program started here in the state of Arkansas, and that's what this bill is going to do. I have worked with all the parties that you have seen here because it does involve DHS. It does involve the State Treasurer's Office. It does involve rehabilitative services. They will be the ones administering the program, running the program, and also making sure that we are adopting the right rules and regulations. The federal government will have to step in and will be putting some rules and regulations.
I will tell you, if you look on there, there's a fiscal impact on this. But that fiscal impact does not start until 2016. It doesn't start with the fiscal session that we're getting ready to develop. And that fiscal impact is $36,000. That's it. $36,000. And I promise you that you are going to see the rewards come back from that because you are going to have people with disabilities who will then be able to take care of themselves.
they're not going to be reaching out and saying help me because they're going to be able to have the opportunity that all other Arkansans have to save money they're going to have the opportunity to save money to buy a car so that they can get to work so that they can go to the grocery store they're going to have the opportunity to be able to put money aside so that they can get an education like everybody else has the opportunity to do That's what this bill is going to do.
It's going to empower people with disabilities to save money. Isn't that what we want everybody to be able to do? I'm going to let each one of them just, again, our departments remain neutral on it. You know they're not here to express an opinion, but I do want you to know that they have been a part of writing this bill and have been definitely a part of making sure that we've got what we need in this bill to make it good, sound legislation. Thank you, Representative Mayberry.
Speaker 191
59:16
I'll just be very brief. DHS, of course, as she said, we are neutral on the bill. We've been working with Representative Mayberry to make sure this bill... Excuse me, sir. Recognize your name, please. I'm sorry, Mr. Chairman. Mark White with the Department of Human Services. Thank you, sir. Thank you, Mark. This bill does affect us in that under the federal legislation, funds which are deposited into these accounts will not be considered for Medicaid eligibility, and so this will enable individuals who have a disability, who rely on Medicaid for their medical care, they will be able to accumulate some savings and use those savings for disability-related
expenses. And so that's under the federal legislation. We'll be implementing that, and we look forward to working with the rest of Mayberry and others as this program is developed
Speaker 204
1:00:03
if the legislature sees fit to pass it. Good morning. Carl Donnery, Chief of Field Services. Our agency is in support of this bill. This bill allows individuals with disabilities who have functional limitations require accommodation. Anytime that you have that functional limitation, whether it's some assistive technology,
maybe it's personal care, or maybe there's an environmental modification that may be needed with this functional limitation, that allows them to have a savings account that will not allow them to lose public benefit. Most individuals with disabilities are on some type of public benefit, and having this bill protects them, and they're not at risk at losing their public benefit, so we are in support. Thank you. Thank
Speaker 207
1:00:50
again, I want to express our thanks to Representative Mayberry for allowing us to have input on this bill.
We are supportive of the idea and the principle behind it. we see this as something similar to our 529 College Savings Program, which is administered out of our office. However, we will put the marker in the ground, so to speak, that we will be needing an additional staff person within the office to help administer this program. And while we are not asking for that currently, that is something that we probably would be looking at in the future once the rules and regs were promulgated from the federal government.
But again, we're neutral on this bill and just appreciate the input and the ability that Representative Mayberry has allowed us to have with
Speaker 198
1:01:40
this legislation. Keith Veyer with Arkansas Waiver Association and Arkansas Support Network. I have worked with people with disabilities for over 40 years, and I have always thought it's just a travesty that we force people who have disabilities is to live in poverty. You know, the limit that people can have in terms of total assets today is like $2,000.
If you get $2,001 in your bank account, you lose your Medicaid benefits, and that's just absolutely crazy. So I'm not neutral on this bill. I think this is something that should have been done years ago. We're fully in support of it, and I just would like to say real quickly that I know that there's been talk about the fiscal impact of $36,000, but I would like you to consider sort of the dynamic impact in terms of if people can save some money
and then they spend that money on items and services that relate to their disability, they will be paying sales taxes on those purchases. I think that the idea of the fiscal impact is way overblown. I think this is something whose time has come. Thank you very
Speaker 195
1:02:55
much. Mr. Chairman, committee members, my name is Mark George, and my 17-year-old daughter, Tessa, was born with Down syndrome. In economic terms, savings is the amount of disposable income
that is not spent on current consumption, but is invested to pay for future consumption. There are certain types of consumption that we as a society have determined to be beneficial to the individuals and to the economy as a whole. Examples include housing, medical care, education and job training, and income for retirement. In recognition of these important public policy goals and to motivate individuals to assume a greater share of the cost of these activities,
governments at all levels have historically used tax policy as a means to incentivize desired behavior that benefits both the person and the overall economy. For example, the tax codes allow for a deduction of mortgage interest, promotes homeownership, and new home construction. Tax-advantaged health insurance plans and health savings accounts help people purchase the health care goods and services they need to remain healthy.
As was mentioned, tax-advantaged 529 savings accounts allow families to save for future college education of their children. And we know that greater access to higher education is a key to a better trained and better paid workforce. Tax-advantaged programs from a simple IRA to a large employee benefit plan provide savings vehicles for individuals to fund their future retirement income needs. Almost every citizen in Arkansas has access to one or more of these tax-advantaged programs I had listed.
and almost every citizen uses one or more other programs. One group that does not have access to these programs is individuals with disabilities. Tessa will soon graduate from high school. Like all young people, she aspires to have a good job and a home of her own. Because she has an intellectual disability, her prospects for having a good-paying job with substantial benefits are slim. As a As a result, it is likely that she will have to rely on government-funded programs
for employment opportunities, housing, and health care for as long as she lives. She would like to be self-sufficient, productive, healthy, and a participating member of society. As was mentioned, Medicaid and SSI rules that limit a person's assets to $2,000 hours makes this tough. This limitation essentially means that an individual with disabilities,
as Julie said, cannot own or rent a home, own a car to go to work, own a computer to help them find a job, or have money to improve their education and job skills. The very act of saving money that can be used to supplement the government benefits they receive can make them ineligible for the very benefits they must have to survive. ABLE accounts will change this inequality imposed on the disabilities. The money saved in an ABLE account can be used to pay and this is it.
They have a list in the act of allowable expenses, education, housing, transportation, employment trading, assistive technology, health and welfare, and ultimately funeral expenses. These are exactly the same kind of expenses that the current tax policy is used to promote individual savings for other individuals to cover the cost of. These are the same expenses that TESA and thousands of other disabled Arkansans will
will incur as they seek to achieve their dreams and expectations. Like any tax policy adopted by a government, it will have an impact on the state budget. As I said, $36,000, barely a rounding error. But it's good fiscal policy, because every dollar of reduced income tax revenue represents savings that is invested to provide for the future of Arkansans disabilities this investment may hopefully probably will reduce the
future expenditures the state might incur to care for these individuals at a level that is fair and just for them as members of this society if it is to be the public policy of this state as it should be that all families and individuals should do what they can to contribute to their own well-being instead of relying solely on government-funded programs, then you should support the ABLE program. More than anything else,
your support for establishing the ABLE program represents an investment in the hopes and dreams of all our cancers with disabilities as they seek to realize their full potential as citizens of this great state. Thank you, sir. Thank you. So let's teach them how to
fish. Let's not just give them a fish for a day to feed them for that day. And with that, I open for questions.
Members, any questions? A very good presentation. I'll just tell the community that fiscal impact come back
$36,000 for FY16, $90,000 negative for FY17. The problem that we're faced with is we got about 50 others, $90,000 here and there. So we're still working through the process on the budget to the backside of it to see the priority, but this will be. This is a very good bill, so I appreciate you. Anybody in the audience want to speak against the bill, for the bill? Representative Mary Berry, are you closed for your bill, ma'am? You want to close? I'm closed. Thank you very much.
Members, Representative Mary Berry has agreed to pull down House Bill 1775 and take that to interim study. Now we'll take a look at House Bill 1772 and this is for real. Okay, members, we're going
to move on to a different note and what I'm about to propose to you today actually
would help take care of that $36,000 or $90,000 fiscal impact in the future to help with the ABLE bill, as well as a few other things that I'm going to talk to you about today. First of all, I know many of you took part in the State Chamber's Business 101 event. It was a two-day event where we heard from the business community, and if you were there long enough, I know that you had to walk away with a similar impression that I had. And what we kept
hearing the business community say over and over again is that we need a more qualified workforce. That message was driven home by just about every speaker that got up and talked. That there are jobs out there, but they don't have the people qualified to be doing those jobs. They're not being trained in the way that they need to be trained to meet the needs of that community. In other words, not everybody needs to go to college. We heard that over and over again. We need some students to choose to go to technical school. We need meat cutters and Kroger to be
doing those types of jobs. And we need good guidance on those jobs. So there is a program out there called Career Coaches. And if I can, I'm sorry, I should have pulled her up to begin with. I'm going to let her introduce herself to explain a little bit about what this career coaches program is. Recognize yourself,
Speaker 220
1:11:20
morning. I'm Sonia White. I'm sorry. There you go. Good morning. Sonia White McMurray, Associate Director for Arkansas Works, Department of Career Education.
And as Representative Mayberry was starting to talk to you about as a career coaches program, we work with our school districts in providing an opportunity for our students beginning in the eighth grade through 12th grade to get a better understanding of what they need to do to get ready for life after high school going into the workforce and so many of our students have have great ideas about what they want to do they just don't know how to get there so we put together a good workable plan with them and we assist them in working that plan consistently until they get through high school going on to the next step whether that be
going to a technical institution going in directly to the workforce or going on to a two or four year college and we've had great success with that program. We've been able to partner tremendously with our business industry community because we are assisting them in getting a better employee. We help students to better understand what it's going to take to go into their career field, what education they need, what training they need. We allow students to be able to get that taste of that life while they're still in high school so they can determine if the path they're on is going to work for them and if it's not then they can make adjustments early. So I know that I was told I would share a
a few things about the program, but I'll just stop there in case
there's something else we need to talk about. That's good. Okay. Okay. So I wanted to understand a little bit of what I heard at Business 101, and I knew of this program, but I also know that there's not funding directly to this program, and that it's kind of on shaky ground, and we need to find some money to help support this program so that it can be something that's implemented all around the state eventually. So another comment that we heard over and again at Business 101 was not only a trained workforce,
but a workforce that will actually show up and do the job. To me, that was one of the saddest parts is that we kept hearing the business community is, we just want people to show up 9 to 5 every day. Okay? I mean, that's a problem. That's a real problem our businesses have. And I have another solution to that. one of the reasons why some of those folks don't show up every day is because they have kids at home. Kids at home that are being sent home from school sick. I can give you a specific example
where I had a school nurse come to me one day and tell me that basically tried to show the importance of that school nurse in that school that day. She left school for about an hour to attend a meeting. And when she came back, there was a student that was going to be sent home for the day from school. And when the nurse came in, she said, why is the student being sent home? And the school secretary said, well, she came up here and she said she wasn't feeling well. And so I was
going to send her home. I took her temperature and it was a little high. So the parent had already been called to come pick up the child. So that's disrupting that day's work for that employee. OK, I'm sure a boss is not too happy about the employee having to go pick up a child. Then because there is a suspected fever, the child has to miss school another day because they're not allowed back in school for 24 hours. So a day and a half of this employee not being able to be there because their child is being sent home
from school sick. Well, when the school nurse got in there, she took the temperature and she said, you know, this child really is not that sick. Let's let her have some water and let's let her rest for a little bit. And sure enough, the child was okay. The child returned back to the classroom so she could go and continue her studies. She didn't miss a day of school. She didn't miss a day and a half of school. And the employer had an employee working that day and a half instead of being sent home.
I know you all are probably tired of me talking about school nurses. school nurses are vital to our economy in many different ways and so yes can our school nurses also benefit our workforce absolutely so those are two issues and two areas that I see very much need some help in being funded so where is that funding going to come from I am not a person that likes to complain about things without a solution
It drives me crazy. It's a pet peeve of mine when people sit around and they just complain about stuff and they never actually try to work on a solution. So I've spent the last six months trying to figure out where in the state government budget are we going to find some money to help fund these really important programs. Back in August, I have a 10-year-old daughter who has been making some jewelry. I think I have on some of her earrings today. I want to make sure that if she's starting her own business that we're doing things correctly.
So we opened up her own business and I applied for a sales tax permit. So we're collecting sales tax for my daughter's little business called Fantasies. When I got my information to fill out to remit my sales tax to the state, I looked at it and I was reminded of something that I actually knew about but kind of forgot. When you remit your sales tax to the state, when you collect that sales tax, you keep 2% of it. And when I saw that, I went, why do you get to keep 2% of that?
I actually felt guilty. Now, I'll tell you, we're remitting about $5 or $9 max, okay? My daughter's not selling a whole bunch. But the point is, is that I felt guilty as a collector of the tax and keeping that. Because I know that taxpayers, when they vote for a sales tax, they expect that that's going to go towards transportation, towards education, towards our jails, whatever it's supposed to go towards. I've never voted for it to go to a business. Have you? So I began asking
the question. My background is journalism. I ask lots of questions. Sometimes they lead me down roads. I really wish I had not gone down, but they lead me down this road. So first of all, one of the questions to DF&A at that time is, how do other states handle this? And if you look at this sheet of paper that got turned into you, you should have on your desk. There are actually only 27 states that allow a vendor discount. Now, I will tell you there are five states that do not have a sales tax, so you kind of have to throw those states out. But there are several states
that offer no early discount when you pay by the 20th of the month, no discount. And if you look here at the percentage, Arkansas gives 2% back, and there are many states that give less than 2% back, again, for paying early. And then if you look at the maximum for each month, we're on the high end. $1,000 a month we give back to the business for paying early. Now, I have asked
DF&A, are we seeing that businesses are more likely to pay early because of this incentive? And the response was that actually the businesses really are more incentivized to pay on time because they don't want to pay a late fee. When they pay late, they're going to face a great penalty. So they're going to pay early regardless of whether that sales tax discount is $1,000 a month or $500 a month. So I believe that there's some room to play with here,
either lowering that percentage or lowering the sales tax discount cap each month. Now I want you to turn to the next page because you might be saying, why are we talking about this? Well, my next set of questions not only was how does this, you know, how do other states do it? My next question is how much money does the state not see because of this discount? It's $23 million.
$23 million of taxpayer dollars that never come into the state. So I think there's some money to play here, play with here. I think we need to look at this and analyze this and say, is this the best way to handle this amount of money? Also in discovery, realize that there is no cap for our cities and our counties. So the cities and counties all along have never had a cap of $1,000 a month,
and our state has, and that's really unfair too. I'm just trying to make things fair. That's all I'm trying to do. I'm trying to make things fair. so if you will look at the next page and this is the legislative impact statement and you will see if we lower that cap to $500 a month and lower the percentage rate to one and a half percent this is what happens to our our revenue in fiscal year 16 which would not be
impacted the whole year. So look down at fiscal year 17. The impact to state revenue is $7 million. There would be $4 million back into general revenue, nearly a million dollars back into educational adequacy. We would get money back into the property tax relief fund, the conservation tax. Highway department would get a little extra money too, half a million dollars. Educational Excellence Trust Fund, educational adequacy, central services, and constitutional officers.
Also, our cities and our counties, now this would be divided among all those cities and counties, would get back 11, nearly 12 million dollars. Don't you think some of these cities and counties that would get this money back and might already be thinking of asking for a sales tax increase would say, oh, never mind, we don't need the sales tax increase. It might prevent some of our cities and counties from saying we need to have another tax. If any of you have a better idea, if you think
the cap should change in a different way or the percentage should change in a different way, I'm open to that. This is what my proposal was because I felt that it was the most fair. Let me explain to you how this affects big business in the state of Arkansas. The discount, I'm just going to use because it's the most obvious, Walmart, okay? The discount to Walmart for that sales tax, it's not per store.
It is $12,000 a year. So this would impact one of those big chains like Walmart or Dollar General, Family Dollar, Kroger. This change would affect them in one year by $6,000. That's not a huge impact on those big businesses. For me, personally, $6,000 is a lot of money. But to them, it's not a whole lot of money. And this is just bringing it back into a fair level with other states and what they do.
If you look at where the $500 mark is there, if you'll go back to that second page that I have there, you can see right now that only 431 businesses actually qualify or make it up to that $1,000 cap. 881 make it up to that $500 cap. And when you analyze how much revenue that business is bringing in each month to make that $500 cap,
it's a business that is bringing in $380,000 a month. This is not going to impact them. It's going to impact them, and you will hear from businesses who say this is horrible. I promise you that. but it's not going to make that big of a difference for what they get in return they will get a more qualified workforce they will get healthier children
they will get students who are able to stay in school and parents who are able to continue to work and we can also help support an ABLE bill which will help our people with disabilities save money so they can take care of themselves and on top of that not have their hand out to say I need more This is a good bill, and I'd appreciate a good vote. Do
you have questions? Members, any questions? Yes, sir. Representative Fite, you recognize, sir.
Speaker 195
1:24:32
Representative Mayberry, what is the penalty if a business fails to get their sales tax in on time?
We'll have to let DF&A answer that to answer that correctly, but I believe it's pretty high. Mr.
Chair, committee members, John Tice with DFA. The penalty is 5% per month, up to a maximum of 35%. In addition, there's interest at 10% per year. Thank you. Can I do a follow-up, Mr. Chair?
Speaker 195
1:25:03
You bet, sir. Okay. I know as a small business, and I operated one for about 18 years, You know, I collected money for the state, the county, and the city. And the 2% did not seem like much for handling the money for the state. That's what I felt at the time.
ask back that do any of us get a credit or money back when we pay our income tax early?
No. Do any of us get money back when we pay our workman's comp early? No. do any of us get our money back when we pay any of those other state fees early so it's it's part of doing business and and again i i just i felt kind of guilty if my my daughter's amount we're not getting money back with the amount of money we're we're doing but i just felt like that's not what that money is intended for and most people when i bring this
up. They are never aware that there was ever a 2% discount, and they go, really? Well, that just doesn't seem right. So I understand that businesses, and without those businesses, they are, they're collecting the money for us, and that's why I'm not saying get rid of the sales tax discount. I'm not advocating that at all. I do understand they have an important part in this. I just think that we need to be a little bit more fair and look at how other states are doing it as well, and try to make the most use out of those dollars and again when the business community is coming to us and
saying we have a problem we want a more qualified workforce this is a solution to give them a more qualified workforce. Representative Gonzalez you recognize
sir. Thank you Mr. Chair. I sat through that business 101 as well and another thing that I heard during that was how Arkansas is not the most business-friendly state, and a lot of that was because of our tax policy.
And I'll go back to this first page and look at our sales tax rate. We're actually one of the higher rates on this size. That 2% discount, to me, actually brings us back down more in line with other states. So that concerns me that we're going to make our state even less
business-friendly. Well, if it was such a great recruiting tool to begin with, because we are pretty high with the $1,000 limit. Why hasn't economic development been spreading this all around saying,
hey, come to Arkansas, we've got a great sales tax discount. I don't think it's a recruiting tool for any business. I don't think it's on their radar screen that this is that big of a deal. So I don't see it. I just don't see
it that way. I would agree that it's not a great recruiting tool, but why would
we take a step backwards? I don't believe this is taking a step backwards. I'm hearing the business community saying, we need this, and this is an opportunity to give that business community what they're saying they need. We can't just suddenly make a program happen.
We can't suddenly – we need help to do that. And I was listening there, and I heard over and over again, we need help. This is a way for them to invest in something and get something in
return. I guess I just have a problem with forcing investment. Thank
you. President Meeks, you recognize, sir. Thank
you, Mr. Chairman. The question I have, and I do appreciate that you're trying to find solutions to problems.
This workforce development is something that I know Senator English has been working on for quite some time to try to find some of these answers. The question that I would have related to this, the purpose of the 2 percent, of course, is to compensate businesses for their costs to collect these taxes on behalf of the state. Have you done any research on what the actual cost is to businesses? Because you and I both know that if this were to be reduced,
that cost of business to Walmart is going to be passed on to the consumer. and the net effect is we're all going to be paying a little bit more. So can you kind of address that for us a little bit?
Absolutely. First of all, I'm going to remind you that Walmart, business like that, again, it's a hit of $6,000. I don't know how much that divided among the whole state or whatever, but I understand your point. Now, is that $6,000 a year, a month?
$6,000 a year. So, just doing a quick calculation, is that saying that Walmart only has $300,000 worth of
state sales tax a year? No, no, no, no. Because, again, this discount applies one time. So, it's not per store. So, they're not getting the discounted Benton Walmart, Bryant Walmart, Little Rock Walmart, or whatever. It is a one-time amount, and they hit that $1,000 max and go well above that. Right. So, but yes, I, let me, let me address that. And that's actually what the other bill 1775
that I hope to send out to interim study would address. Because when I did bring this up to the business community, they did come to me and they said, hey, you know, this, this, we're hurt by sales tax. And let me explain how we are hurt by sales tax. And what they said was that when we use our credit card, okay? Businesses really don't like for us to use our credit card because they get an interchange fee on that. Let's just say we're buying a $100 product and there's 10% tax.
You're in a, I'm trying to use easy numbers here, and you run your credit card. The business is going to be charged approximately 3% interchange fee on that entire $110, okay? And so they're saying that it's unfair that they're being charged an interchange fee on that $10, that that's included in there. And I agree with that. And that's why we put together House Bill 1775. It is something that has been looked at in other states. Senator Jeremy Hutchinson also tried to
look at this issue last session. I believe that there's a lot there that needs to be looked at and needs to be studied. But if we're going to help them with the sales tax interchange fee, then I think that if you look at $17.75, I lowered the sales tax discount to $50 a month. And they would come out far ahead. And so I still want to push to help those businesses with that sales tax interchange fee. I think it's something that definitely needs to be addressed and would help these businesses in the long run.
But I can't do that today. So the hope is that we can, as a committee, as a legislative body, continue to look at that and see how we can help those businesses with that. But, you know, you've got to give a little bit here to get a little bit there, and that's all I'm trying to do is everybody work together to come up with a common solution.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Members, any other questions? Representative Gonzalez, you recognize her?
Thank you, Mr. Chair. You know, going back to using Walmart as an example, and I think that concerns me even more that the total impact to a corporation like Walmart
is not just $6,000 a year, but we're talking about a $23 million impact. So who's that on? I mean, that's on the backs of our small
businesses? Well, first of all, keep in mind we're not getting rid of the sales tax discount. It's still there. So it's not a $23 million impact. If you look on 1772, it's a $7 million impact because we are not getting rid of that discount completely.
We're dropping it to $500 as a maximum. Most businesses never reach that $500, and I'm sure DF&A can answer these questions far better than I can, but most businesses don't make that maximum amount, don't ever get that high. But, again, the same concept applies. I mean,
just because we reduced it from the $23 million to $7 million, I mean, your corporation is still only responsible for $6,000 of that. The rest of it is coming from somewhere.
Most businesses will not be affected by this. Does that make sense? because most businesses never make that $500 cap. So they're not going to be affected by this change, especially the smaller businesses. Okay. Thank you. Members, any other questions? If not,
we're going to move into the against and the for. Ms. Polly Martin, you want to come speak against the bill, ma'am, please?
and clear my name is Polly Martin I'm president of the Arkansas Grocers and Retail Merchants Association this is almost a slap in the face because we do lose so much money on a mandated it's mandated by the state that if we do business and we sell a a product or a service or anything that we have to
remit sales tax on, that we have to collect and remit it at 2%. Representative Mayberry said it wouldn't be but $6,000 to Walmart, but there are 881 other businesses that will be $6,000 to also. And I think Representative Gonzalez was right. It's just not a good policy to say we're going to punish business. I wasn't involved in the Chambers 101.
I've never been asked to be. I sure wouldn't have given this recommendation. Representative Mayberry asked if you got any discount for paying early your income tax or if you got a discount if you bought something. But does anyone in the state work for free that's mandated to do a job? I don't think so.
In the bill, it states that the reason the fee was put into place was because when sales tax was first put in, that it was all done by hand. There are still businesses that do it by hand. You know, feed stores, and they'll sell a farmer a bunch of stuff for their cattle, and it's $12,000 a day is all you have to do to start to be penalized.
Instead of saying it $380,000 a month, that's about $12,000 a day, and that's not a whole lot. Somebody goes and buys a saddle or a mattress and bed or a refrigerator. You know, it doesn't take long to add up to $12,000 a day, and then they start being penalized. At 2% is one of the higher interest vendor collection fees.
and with a cap of $1,000 that was put into effect when the state was lacking money and they saw what Walmart had made of themselves by staying in Arkansas and having all these sales, big purchases in Arkansas, and they actually went after our larger corporations. This isn't just retail either. It's your utility companies. It's your telephone company. It's your lawn companies, and particularly in a commercial lawn business, that does a lot.
So it's not just your brick-and-mortar store. Yes, there are 27 states that have a vendor collection allowance. There are five states that don't. That makes 32 states. And Texas has a different type. They do get extra. extra. If you look on the bottom, it's footnoted in the bottom of the thing Ms. Mayberry gave out. We would just encourage you not to penalize our businesses and to say we are a friendly
state. We're adding more and more retail. We have a new retail location, huge shopping center going in out by Bass Pro, and this is a slap in the face. Welcome to Arkansas. We just reduced your sales tax collection allowance. Please vote no on 1772. Thank you, Ms. Martin. Anybody
speaking for the bill in the audience? If not, Mr. Steefe, I'm sorry, go ahead, sir.
If you don't care, keep your remarks kind of brief. I'm not trying to be diligent or
obnoxious to you, but respect for the committee's time. I'll be brief. Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee. My name is Chris Felines, Executive Director at the Association of Arkansas Counties, And we appreciate Representative Mayberry and specifically the efforts to bring in line the county and city sales tax rebate structure with the state. That's one thing that has been an issue for our cities and counties for some time.
with no cap in place and the 2% rebate back to retailers that remit quickly versus the $1,000 cap for the state. We have always thought that that should be more in line for the cities and counties with what the state gets, and that's why part of the numbers you saw today are large for the cities and counties. it's because there is no cap in place now.
And so we would appreciate your consideration, whether on this bill, any bill in the future, to take a look at that specific issue for us and help us try and get that more in line with what the state of Arkansas is getting. And just quickly, for a dollar that is spent in Madison County with a 2% county sales tax structure, that county gets back 95 cents. There's a 3% administration fee from DF&A, and there's a 2% chargeback that goes back to the retailer.
So I agree with the point that Ms. Mayberry, Representative Mayberry, made earlier that there is not real transparency in the sales tax charge. So with that, I'd be happy to answer questions. Any questions, members? If not, thank you,
Chris. Appreciate you. Thank you. Steve, you want to come down to the table and speak against the bill? Like I said, please keep your remarks kind of brief for
Speaker 245
1:40:43
us. Mr. Chairman, members of the committee, thank you very much. Very briefly, I'm with Steve Farron with the Arkansas Oil Marketers Association,
and we're not Walmart. We're your corner convenience store. There's some 2,000 of them in the state. And two things about the bill that we have trouble with. The bill assumes that the 1930 retailer had costs, but the 2015 retailer does not. Again, from a gasoline standpoint, in 2010, our guys had to invest in payment card industry upgrades. It was as much as $25,000 per store just to continue to take credit cards, and over 60% of our members of our sales are credit cards.
And then now we're having to do EMV. You've seen your new credit cards with the little chips. We're having to upgrade our equipment in October of this year and then again in October of 2017. So the 2015 retailer has ongoing costs associated with making sales and collecting the sales tax. The other thing is improvement of workforce development. Sure, we're for that. But when you talk about workforce development, the industries, the manufacturers, the professionals, the educators, all the workforce gets improved, and we as retailers don't care to have to pay for everybody's workforce.
We would like to be part of the problem but not pay for everything. Thank you very much.
Thank you, Steve. appreciate you being brief. Anybody in the audience want to speak for the bill? Drew, are you here to speak against the bill, or do you leave? Drew Crawford, are you here? If not, Mr. Representative Mayberry, you want to close for your
when you look around at other states, there are some states that don't give back any discount. You've collected the sales tax, give it to the state. I'm not saying that. All I'm saying is let's drop it from $1,000 a month to $500 a month, level it out. I don't think there's any business that's not going to come to Arkansas because we've suddenly dropped the amount from $1,000 to $500 dollar cap. It's not been used as a recruiting tool. I don't think that it's going to stop any
business from locating here, and I think that in the long run, our communities are going to be better off because the money that's being collected for the sales tax is going to the purpose of which that sales tax has been approved by voters. I think if more and more voters knew where that money was going, they'd be asking the same questions. Thank you, ma'am.
Are you closed? Yes. Thank you very much.
Members, does anybody have a motion? Ms. Mayberry, for lack of a motion, your bill does not pass, ma'am. I'm sorry. Members, we're going to go about 10 more minutes to 12 o'clock. Representative Dyson has some cleanup language, I think, from the land commissioner's office. Representative Dyson, when you get to the end of the table, I think there's going to be some amendments on these bills as well. We're going to start off with Senate Bill 897 will be number one that we'll do.
Mr. Dawson, when you get to recognize yourself and your guests, and I understand your amendment is just to put your name on the bill. Is that correct? Yes. Representative Meeks, should I have a motion? Representative Meeks makes a motion for the amendment to put Representative Dawson's name on this bill. All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no. Let it show that this amendment, this
bill has been amended. Thank you, Mr. Chair. This is clean-up language between the land commissioner's office and I think
Bill, our staff, has been working with them and I have with me the land commissioner's office. They can answer any questions or give you a little bit more detailed explanation of this bill. Good morning. I'm Carol Lincoln,
general counsel with the Commissioner of state lands office and you recognize Mike go ahead ma'am thank you we'll start
with Senate bill 897 basically what this does is it clarifies the definition of homestead as it relates to notices that we have to give on our tax sales as you all know there are a number of different homesteads that are granted throughout our law. This particular homestead though is the one related to the $350 credit
that you can receive at the county level on your homestead. So basically we're just saying that when we have to comply with the law dealing with notice for homesteads that this is the homestead that we're talking about the way that we are notified of this homeless homestead is that when the property is transferred to our office from the individual counties the county collector will flag which parcels of delinquent property our homesteads so again what we're doing is
just clarifying exactly what homestead that we're talking about okay so Basically, what we're talking about is just clarification
of definition of a homestead, right? Yes, sir. Representative Collins, you recognize. Motion at the proper time, Mr. Chair. Thank you, sir. Members, any questions? Anybody speak for or against the bill in the audience? Representative Collins, you recognize. Make your motion, sir. I move. Do pass as amended. A motion do pass as amended. Any discussion? All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed?
Congratulations. You passed your bill. Members, we'll go to Senate Bill 898 now. and I need a motion for an amendment. Representative Meeks. Representative Meeks makes a motion for the amendment. All in favor say aye. Any opposed, no.
Dodson. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'll turn it over once again. Yes, 898 basically does two things. First, in Section 1, it actually corrects an era that wasn't taken care of in 2013.
In 2013, all of the redemption periods following a tax sale were amended from a 30-day period. I'm sorry, litigation period was amended from a one-year period to a 90-day period. So basically Section 1 is just coming in and correcting that time period to a 90-day period. Then Section 2, it's a little confusing because it looks like we're trying to do something
about folks with a mental incapacity, minors, and members of the United States Armed Services. But actually what Section 2 does is it amends out a special time period that was given in an O-law to people in confinement. So basically we're removing the extra amount of time given to people in prisons to redeem their property.
And that's really all that Section 2 does. Thank you. Any questions? Representative Collins? Motion at the proper time, Mr. Chair. Thank you, sir. Anybody in the audience want
Speaker 260
1:48:47
to speak against the bill? Representative Ease, did you have a question? Do you recognize, please? Thank you.
You may have said this, and I missed it. Why are you changing it from one year to 90 days? Because in 2013, all of the other time periods were changed from a one-year period to a 90-day period. This one just kind of fell through the cracks and didn't get changed.
You're welcome. Anybody want to speak against the bill, for the bill? Representative Dawson, you closed for your bill, sir? I'm closed. Representative Collins,
you recognize the motion? I move that we do pass
as amended. Any discussion? Representative Collins makes a motion to do pass as amended. All in favor, aye. Aye. Any opposed, no. Congratulations, you passed your bill. Representative Meeks, we're up on Senate Bill 900. Do you have a motion? I have a motion to adopt the amendment. Any discussion?
All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? Representative Dyson,
Bill 900, sir. I will. Well, I heard to explain the bill. You're doing very good. Senate Bill 900. Just by background, way of background, the state has roughly 20,000 parcels of tax delinquent land certified to it each year. What Senate Bill 900 does is it just clarifies the fact that the state land commissioner cannot be responsible for maintaining all of those parcels.
In other words, if the grass gets too high or if a building needs to be torn down, the commissioner of state lands cannot be responsible for actually doing that on all of those parcels. Thank you. Representative Collins. Motion at the proper time, Mr. Chair. Thank you,
sir. Anybody not just want to speak against the bill? Do you have a question? Representative Meeks, you recognize me for your question.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. So if the land commissioner is not responsible for doing that,
then who would that responsibility, if anybody, would that fall upon?
Actually, there are two options that a city has, you know, when they're facing these particular problems. One, they can go ahead and do the work on their own, the mowing or the tearing down or whatever it takes, and then they can file a lien on that property and foreclose on that lien. The other option they have is that they can certify the amount that it has taken to clean that piece of property up.
They can certify that to the county tax collector, and then the tax collector can send that on to us to try to collect it at the time that we sell the property. We can't always do that because some properties just won't be sold for those additional fees attached to it. But when at all possible, we will certainly try to collect that for the cities. And, you know, really who should be responsible for it are the folks who actually own the property and let it go tax delinquent.
All right. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. You're welcome. Anybody in the audience want to speak against the bill? For the bill, Representative Dawson, you're closed for your bill. I'm closed, sir. Representative Collins, you're good to make your motion, sir. I move. Do pass as amended. Representative Collins, make a motion. Do pass as amended. Any discussion? All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no. Congratulations. You passed your bill. Members are moving on to Senate Bill 906 now. Representative Meeks, you're good to make your motion for the amendment. Yes. Representative Meeks makes a motion for adopting an amendment.
All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? You're good to go,
buddy. Thank you. We'll move on and turn this over one more
time. Senate Bill 906, it basically says the same thing that Senate Bill 900 says. It's just amending another portion of the statute that addresses these types of fees. Members, are there any questions? Anybody in the audience want to speak against the
bill? For the bill, Representative Dotson, are you closed for your bill? I'm closed. Representative Collins, you're good to make a motion.
I move. Do pass as amended. I have a motion. Do pass as amended. Any discussion? All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no. Representative Dotson, you're on a roll, buddy. Senate Bill 907, two more members. I have a
say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no. You're good. All right. Senate Bill 907. Senate Bill 907, we put this together in response to a request from the Legislative Bureau a year or so ago
to begin to look at some of our old statutes and determine whether or not any of those could be repealed as being obsolete. And so Senate Bill 907, it includes those older statutes that we no longer use. They're not pertinent to today's statutes or today's scheme in selling tax delinquent land. So basically, this is just a cleanup bill to repeal obsolete laws.
Thank you, ma'am. Any questions, members? Anybody in the audience want to speak against the bill, for the bill? Representative Dotson, you close for your bill. Representative Collins, you agree to make your motion? I move. Do pass as amended. Representative Collins, do pass as amended. All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? Congratulations, you passed your bill. Senate Bill 908, Representative Meeks. Representative Meeks makes adoption of the motion for the amendment. All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no?
Representative Dotson, you recognize. Senate Bill 908,
last one. Senate Bill 908, when someone wants to challenge a tax sale, we sell property, and then they have a right to challenge that sale to try to get it set aside through either our office or through litigation in the courts. One of the things that is required on the front end before you challenge a sale is that you have to post the amount of taxes, penalties, and interest
that are actually due on the property before that challenge can go forward. And 908 basically just says that if you're going to challenge a sale, don't post the money with the commissioner of state lands until we request that you do so. It just gives us an option because so many times people will send in the money to cover the taxes and we're really not quite ready to receive it.
So it just gives us an option to say, okay, now's the time you can send in your money, and that's what we're asking in 908 to have the authority to do that. Thank you, ma'am. Any questions,
members? Anybody in audience want to speak against the bill for the bill? Well, Andy Gibbon, you're not even going to come speak for your own bill all day today? She is. She is. Representative Dodson, you closed for your bill? I'm closed. Representative Collins? I move do pass as amended.
I have a motion to do pass as amended. Any discussion? All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Congratulations. You have passed your last bill. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair and members of the committee.
Thank you. Appreciate a good vote on the floor.
Maybe. We might work that out. I've got a couple bills coming, too, so that's going to be it for today. We hit 12 o'clock right on the nose, so I appreciate you guys' patience, and we'll come back and do it again Thursday. Thank you. This meeting is adjourned. Thank you.
Agenda
HB1703
HB1817
HB1239
HB1772
SB897
SB898
SB900
SB906
SB907
SB908
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Joe Jett Chair
Unverified
Representative Dan M. Douglas
Unverified
Speaker 11
Representative Nelda Speaks
Unverified
Representative Kim Hendren
Unverified
Speaker 44
Speaker 52
Speaker 59
Speaker 32
Representative Laurie Rushing
Unverified
Speaker 74
Representative Stephen Meeks
Unverified
Michael Patek
Unverified
John Tice
Unverified
Speaker 98
Jim Pender
Unverified
Representative Charlie Collins
Unverified
Representative Monte Hodges
Unverified
Representative Clarke Tucker
Unverified
Speaker 134
Speaker 143
Speaker 153
Speaker 156
Speaker 161
Representative Julie Mayberry
Unverified
Speaker 187
Speaker 204
Speaker 191
Speaker 195
Speaker 198
Speaker 206
Speaker 207
Speaker 220
Speaker 216
Representative Justin Gonzales
Unverified
Speaker 130
Polly Martin
Unverified
Chris Felines
Unverified
Speaker 245
Speaker 231
Representative Jim Dotson
Unverified
Speaker 260
Speaker 267