House Agriculture, Forestry & Economic Development
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (8)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1553
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1553”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1701
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1701”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB554
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB554”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1564
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1564”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1823
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1823”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1963
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1963”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB7778
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB7778”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB855
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB855”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 15, 2026
We have a special guest presentation here that we'd like to hear from the economic development side of this. We have Mr. Chris Neely with Made in the USA Works. So at this time, Chris, would you please go to the end there and introduce yourself and tell us about what you all are doing to bring jobs back to the United States. Set the very end there where we can see you good.
All right, thank you. And there's a button there you push and you'll get a green light and you're good
Speaker 5
0:41
to go. I've got it. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Well, welcome. It's good to see all of you. Good to be with you today. Again, Chris Neely, Executive Vice President of Made in USA Works. We're a company based out of Bentonville, Arkansas. In fact, we're located right across the street from the Walmart home office. I was formerly with Walmart, and two years ago when Walmart announced their Made in USA program,
that is a program to purchase $250 billion in products made in the United States, I happened to be involved on that team and helped some suppliers come back and reshore jobs to the United States, specifically Arkansas. And we learned through that process that companies that want to manufacture in the United States and maybe do some of their other processes here, we're going to need some assistance. So I left Walmart last June, and we started a new company called Made in USA Works.
We actually got the name of our company from a headline in the Wall Street Journal that was talking about reshoring. Reshoring is the term that we use in bringing back manufacturing. You'll see that quoted often. And things have been changing overseas that are opening up opportunities for us here in the United States. Wages are rising in China. The cost of shipping raw materials to China and then turning those raw materials into products
and then shipping them back over to the United States, there's a lot of cost involved in that, a lot of waste and a lot of time. And in a world where Internet sales continue to go up 15%, 20% a year, you can't afford to have all that time wasted overseas. Additionally, you've got the labor differences that are starting to close between the United States and the stagnant wages that we've had here in the U.S. And then you've got just the time to market. So what our company does and what we've been doing for the last nine months is we've really been kind of like unofficial ambassadors.
for the state of Arkansas. We've met with 28 countries. We meet these countries to have them introduce us to companies that are interested in creating jobs here. And you might ask, well, why would they be interested in Made in USA? Well, they have every reason to be Made in USA because five years ago the Boston Consulting Group said that the environment here was going to change, it was going to shift, and the opportunities were going to open up. And because Internet sales continue to be such a large part of our economy
and will continue to be going forward, if you want to be relevant in the U.S. economy, especially at retail, then you need to have some of your processes here. So, for instance, I was in Vietnam a month ago meeting with furniture companies, and these furniture companies are paying a lot of money for the logistics and the cost. So you put together a table with four legs, there's a lot of space that it takes up in a container ship, and it also costs a lot of money. So send the products over here flat, and what if we set up an assembly plant here in Arkansas
and we actually do that right here? We create jobs and opportunity, but also we help them increase their sales in the U.S. Eventually the goal would be for them to set up manufacturing here, but the manufacturing piece is the hardest piece, and that's what takes the longest time. So we try to help them get their products into market, help them with their assembly, their packaging, and then eventually their manufacturing. The product selections are diverse. It's consumer products, it's commercial products, it can be food.
So, for instance, we have a company in Greece that makes olive oil and they were talking about the expense of shipping all those bottles of olive oil to the United States. I said, well, don't put it in bottles. It weighs too much and it costs you money. Put it in big vats, we put it on a ship, we send it over here, We set up a packaging and bottling company here that bottles all that olive oil, and then it's packaged here. And under the Walmart program, the $250 billion investment, if it's packaged, assembled, or made here, it counts as part of the program.
It's all about creating jobs and getting good, valued products to the customer. Additionally, in addition to furniture and consumables, you know, you have the opportunity for commercial-grade products. So, for instance, there's a company that is based out of Munich, Germany, has facilities in the United States. They make surge protection systems for large-scale facilities, distribution buildings. Well, we could go to some of our largest businesses in the state of Arkansas.
We could put these devices on there, and then eventually the hope is to recruit them to start manufacturing some of those products here. And, in fact, this company wants to now make a consumer-grade product, similar to the large-scale commercial product that they currently have. It's been ever-changing. Obviously, there's things that we need to do here at home, both in the United States and here in Arkansas, to continue to make the environment better, to make us more competitive. I know you read the headlines. You see states like South Carolina and North Carolina battling for Volvos and big car manufacturers.
But, you know, there's a lot of reasons why companies should want to come here as well, and that's our selling point, is you can't put a price tag on our location. For logistics purposes, which is everything in retail, about moving products around, you can't beat the location of our state. For instance, when you bring products in from China into the Long Beach port there in California, which, by the way, you know, they had a strike there just a couple weeks ago. If I'm a retailer, I don't want my product sitting on a ship and I can't get it to market.
It takes about eight days once that product gets into port to get to the distribution network across the United States. If we have manufacturers come here and make their products here and distribute it here, we can get it out to the distribution in two to three days. Time is money. Speed to market. So we can make it quicker, get it distributed quicker, and get it to the customer quicker who, quite frankly, wants the product yesterday. so in essence that's what we're that's what we're doing um we want to be able to work with you to
continue to look at solutions on things we can do here in arkansas uh things that we can do to continue to market and brand our state as a as a hub for manufacturing it would be nice to continue to increase the percentage of our workers who are in manufacturing the jobs that are coming back aren't the same ones that left um they're better paying they're more high tech but then that also brings problems. Workforce. I know you all are dealing with workforce issues down here at the Capitol. We're going to have to
continue to invest in our people so they have the skills, so they can take advantage of these new jobs of the future. Mr. Chairman, that's my remarks, and I'll be happy to take any questions. Okay.
Thank you, Chris. I really appreciate that. Members, does anybody have any questions for Chris here that Representative Ratliff you're recognized At this time how many companies have
you brought back from over there Well we've met with 200
Speaker 5
8:00
and right now we're working with about 20 and right now the first one I think we'll have might be a Vietnamese company that actually wants to manufacture coffee here in Arkansas, in fact I'm meeting them at the airport this afternoon to go through those negotiations they'll be here the next five days and they want to set up coffee manufacturing in Arkansas. They want to see if they can do assembly of furniture here, and they also want to buy animal feed from Arkansas and export it back to Vietnam for their cattle industry.
Good job, buddy. Thank you. Representative Hendren. Chris, we
used to make Baldwin pianos, I understand, in Conway. I know that because we got one for our daughter one time. Of course, they're gone, I guess, nowadays. we used to have all different sorts of production things in Arkansas and of course the country what do you see about like I guess we I guess we still got a guitar manufacturer somewhere out there if the federal government didn't shut them down Gibson guitars and so forth what do you see about like clothing and
musical instruments and and I guess we used to make Zenith televisions in Springfield Missouri I think is there any hope for bringing that clothing electronics computers we can develop things and and think them up and design them but then somebody else builds them and i noticed this graph of these wages this is interesting what do you think about just basic stuff like that is there any future for that yes sir that's a
Speaker 5
9:25
great question thank you um in terms of musical instruments i think as long as it's uh made of metals and wood it can
be made here um in terms of clothing that's going to be a lot harder apparel is probably going to be one of the last things to come back. It's just so labor intensive and requires so many hands on the product. But I do believe there's opportunities on shoes. For instance, there's a Chinese company that just opened a factory in Tennessee that's going to make work boots. And they're very high quality work boots. So I think there's an opportunity in that respect. In terms of televisions, absolutely. But it's going to have to start with assembly. You can't make
the panels and the electronics here right now. In South Carolina, Walmart's buying from a new company that makes the panels and the electronic parts and components. The company's name is Element TVs. They just started production last year. So they get everything from Taiwan. They ship it over to South Carolina, and then they're assembling the products with American workers there. So there is an opportunity on televisions. I'm actually in negotiations right now with a company out of China that wants to do headphone sets kind of your next generation Bluetooth and
it's the same the same company that makes the Beats headphones for anyone that's familiar with those so there's a lot of opportunities there and then we're working with another company in Taiwan that does 3D printers they want to take a value-based 3D printer to Walmart so this would be like a $349 3D printer versus the things you find on the market right now which or $1,000 plus, which really your average customer cannot afford. This would be something value-based that it's almost like the days when we first started buying HP copiers for our homes.
This is where this is going, and they have a plant in Indiana and California, and we're talking to them about doing possibly some assembly here in Arkansas. It's varied. It's almost anything, but the apparel is
Speaker 20
11:35
the toughest. Representative Armstrong. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm looking at areas that were terribly depressed in the Delta. Have you looked at those areas? Maybe we can get people trained through workforce education,
and if we can get some industry down there. It looks like you've got the Mississippi River and good transportation center out of Memphis, and that's terribly depressed down there. Have you looked at bringing industry into those areas? areas. Yes, sir.
Speaker 5
11:59
In fact, I think that's one of the regions of the state that can stand to benefit the most from a lot of these jobs so that we can be competitive with the Vietnams and Malaysias, Indonesias, and Chinas of the world. So, yes, we're working there. The Delta Regional Authority, we've been working with them, and I know that there are some incentives and
opportunities, but we've got to train our workforce. You know, it's unfortunate that 35 years ago we took technical programs out of our high schools. We just assumed that manufacturing would never come back, and the fact of the matter is it is coming back. It's cyclical. We've seen this before, and it's good that you guys are talking about that and wanting to do something about it. Thank
you, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Any other questions for Chris? Well, Chris, I have a question.
Would you all be willing to work with the committee here in the future and bring in other individuals to determine what we need to do to bring Arkansas up to par with other states and try to get more of these manufacturing. And would you just mind sharing some of the comments about what you and I discussed one day about the manufacturing site selection firms there? I think that's something the committee needs to hear. Right.
Speaker 5
13:17
Representative Douglas and I have talked about in the future or in the past
about some of these site selection companies, firms around the country that help manufacturers determine best locations in terms of states. And I know we're working with several of them, and, you know, they make mention of the fact that we're in Arkansas. And they say, well, why are you in Arkansas? I say, well, you know, we started as a result of the Walmart initiative, and you can't get a better location than Arkansas for logistics. And they say, well, we just don't ever see Arkansas really pop up when it comes to the economic development side. And I said, well, we're going to change that.
I said, we've got a new governor who's focused on creating jobs and opportunities. We've got a legislature here that's doing the right kind of things when it comes to workforce development. We've got some work to do on the regulatory side. But we've got to be able to plant the flag here. And I think the governor is going to make a really smart choice on the next director of AEDC. We need a strong coach running that team that we can all work with. because that's really the difference maker is how your ambassadors for the state go out and sell the state.
We have a lot of great things, attributes in the infrastructure, the waterways, and the interstate systems that you all have invested in and our taxpayers. So we need to be talking about those things, but we need to be improving on the areas where we're deficient, and that's why I think we need a strong cheerleader at ADC who can
do that. Well, Chris, thank you so much. I'll tell you what, committee, I wanted you all to hear that there are opportunities to bring manufacturing back to Arkansas, to bring jobs back, and that'll solve a lot
of our problems here if people have opportunities to work. But we do have improvements we need to make. We've got areas that we can change and become more competitive in and look for these specialized niche opportunities, and that's one thing that I hope to engage the committee in more during the interim study and get a roadmap on how to get on that screen with these site selection firms and be at the top of it. But with that, Chris, we appreciate you so much coming down here and
sharing with us and also for what you're trying to do to bring manufacturing and jobs back to the state of Arkansas. Thanks, Mr. Chairman. All right. Thank you, sir. Appreciate you. All right, committee, let's get on with business here. On our agenda, we've got some that were re-referred to committee. We're going to skip over 1493 for right now. Representative Eubanks, are you ready to present your re-referral?
Yes, sir. And I believe you have an amendment to your bill. Let's go
Chair. Yes, there was some additional language that needed to be changed in this bill after meeting with Livestock and Poultry, and I thought we had gotten this before we had filed at the original time.
It deletes some investigative powers. They didn't feel like they had the wherewithal in order to conduct investigations. It just changes it that they will conduct a hearing. So with that, I'll take any questions. Any questions from the
committee for Representative Eubanks on the amendment? Anybody speak for or against the amendment? Representative Eubanks, are you closed for your amendment? I'm closed and move do pass. Motion do pass. All in favor signify by saying aye. Aye. Opposed?
Motion passes. You have passed your amendment. Go ahead with your bill as amended, Representative
Eubanks. Okay, there was an amendment passed Friday and it's engrossed and I believe the section that it covered, there was some confusion that possibly this bill required arbitration. That was never the intent of it. It was supposed to just provide another avenue for growers to pursue. It wasn't to require them to do anything. It was hopefully,
like I explained last week, just to provide another avenue to provide to possibly prevent litigation. All right, any questions from
the committee on Representative Eubanks' amended bill? Representative Hendren. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Eubanks, I
think I'm going to vote against this this morning, and the reason I am, we've got lobbyists around here. I guess you've run into some of them a few times.
And I know you're a former poultry grower, and I and my son-in-law are current poultry growers. We've been with Simmons about 20 years now. And I guess what was said to me and what bothers me about this, first of all, and I caught chickens for Petersons for four summers. That was my college scholarship, which, by the way, committee is a good scholarship proposal, I think, for everybody nowadays, but that's off the subject, I know. but all these years I've not had a problem with Simmons particularly and of course
I guess Simmons-Tysons are about the big ones left up there and I've not had a problem and one of the things that a lobbyist told me and I think lobbyists are good or bad just like politicians are but he said this is going to hurt the business climate in Arkansas bringing companies and setting up companies in Arkansas and I've done some of that and you've done some of that And I guess that really gave me pause to think if it wasn't. Now, I'm speaking in my case what I know in my constituent. If it ain't broke, I shouldn't be fixing it.
And that really bothered me because so far Simmons has been back into feed bins once in a while. You know how that happens, I guess. But they've agreed to pay for those and so on. And it's just given me pause. And I understand what you're saying because I've been in the same situation. But I don't want to take a thing now to take a step that might take a step backward from what Chris Neely was just talking about here. So are my concerns – I've got to put a question in here somewhere, right? Are my concerns unfounded?
Well, I believe they are because it's not requiring a process to take place. It's offering an avenue for them. You know, I hope it would encourage that the local resolution of any issues that growers have with their integrator. I'm glad that you've been able to work out your differences with your complex managers in a way that you're satisfied with. My experience has been that it's not always the case, and I don't think it's necessarily any things that are done intentionally. I think it's just mistakes that are made, and when you have operations as big as some of these are,
I think there needs to be an avenue. I don't want to discourage business in the least. But I think one of the responsibilities that we have as legislators is to represent people that don't have a voice otherwise. Now, you talked about talking with lobbyists. Well, growers are not organized to the point that they have lobbyists down here. You have corporations, billion-dollar corporations here, that are able to pay for people to come and represent their views. And in my opinion, I think on this case,
They're probably trying to discourage something without good reason, really. I don't think it's going to discourage business in the least. But like I said, I believe growers deserve a voice. I believe as legislators we're here to represent those that don't have a voice otherwise. One follow-up. One follow-up.
tractor to a john deere outfit and they charge me well i just let me
use a real life example i just took my f5 bulldozer to deal in springdale charged me twenty thousand dollars to repair a bulldozer i'm so glad i'm getting a salary increase down here uh now if when i'm going to get on that thing this saturday and i'm going to run it some now if it screws up and so forth is this going to lead me to want to come with a bill to say of precision sales and service in Springdale screwed up my bulldozer for $20,000, that I ought to have an arbitration packed with him, or if I take it to Payton's car dealership
and he screws up my truck. I guess what I'm saying is, the point made is, could this develop any service, any industry where I work for somebody and if you don't suit me,
I want to go to arbitration? Well, sir, right now I believe automobile car dealers have a form of arbitration that's available for them already. restaurants have a I believe something in statute that affords them arbitration like I referenced last week when I presented this, the model for this was for row crop
people with regard to seed and that arbitration committee is set up at the plant board so I think when you're dealing with a dealer on repair stuff that you set up those arrangements beforehand and find out if they're going to warranty their work and go forth. You're not in a contract, a long-term contract, with those individuals. All
right, committee. Representative Payton. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Eubanks, I appreciate you bringing this bill
and having concern for the growers. Having grown up on a farm, we had 14,400 laying hens that we grew for Thorpe Brothers and gathered the eggs, and I was able to use that money instead of going to college to buy a motorcycle. But anyway, my high school class, we caught the chickens in the broiler houses. My district is full of growers, and as I work the campaign trail, you know, they have very few requests of me, but two or three times standing outside in a man's front yard,
they ask me to keep an eye on the situation between the growers and integrators, and they do feel like they're severely disadvantaged, And, you know, when they build and make the huge investment to build the house on their property or multiple houses and the contract's laid in front of them, they don't feel like they have very much ability to negotiate that contract. It's either sign or don't sign, you know. And so I appreciate you bringing the bill. I do think arbitration is a method that is used in many industries, many organizations to try to avoid litigation when they can.
through arbitration. And I just wanted to let you know that I'll be, do you want me to vote for your bill?
That's my question. Yes, sir. OK, any more questions from the committee? Anybody to
speak against the bill, for the bill? All right. Representative Eubanks, you close for your bill? I'd like just to say one other thing. Some growers contacted me before we changed the language on Friday about the required arbitration,
and they were hearing things from the complex people, and I explained what we had done. They felt comfortable with it. But I went back, and I called several and had them contact others, and I said, if you have concerns that this is going to hurt the business, then I will pull the bill down. and they came back to me and they said no something needs to be done just to address some of these issues so they have some recourse and with that I'm closed for my bill
and I move do pass Motion do pass Committee all in favor signify by saying aye Opposed Congratulations Representative Viewbanks you have passed your bill Thank you committee Thank you Mr. Chair As amended All right, Representative Ratcliffe, you're on the queue here. He also has an amendment. You have an amendment to present to, and this time I'm going to ask the vice chair to take over here.
I need to say a man about a dog, not related to puppy mills.
Representative Ratliff, you're recognized to present your bill.
First, I've got this amendment for House Bill 1553. We're going to, if you look at the, it's on the tablet, I believe, he put it on the tablet, Paul did this morning.
It's going to exempt farm-owned co-ops and federally, United States warehouse licensed warehouses. We've been working with these guys, and we're trying to make this sort of
work. Okay. Is that your presentation on the amendment?
Yes, sir. Okay. Do I hear a motion do pass on the amendment? Motion do pass. Anybody speak for or against this? Those in favor say aye. Aye. Those no? Opposed, no. The amendment has carried. Now you're recognized to speak on the
bill as amended. Okay. This has all come about because of Turner Green. Up in my part of the country, we've got four or five guys. It's about $5.5 million in debt in this Turner Green.
And we decided we'd try to do something along with the senator down there, that we'd put a grain and soybean and peanut owner's lien act in. And what this would do for the farmers, it gives them a lien on their grain until they get a good check. So, for instance, if I sell grain to Representative McElroy and he pays me, then it's over, the lien's over. But if I sell to XYZ Group and they give me a bad check
and then they file bankruptcy, What this will do is it will put my banker or my lender in front on the bankruptcy case. He'll be number one, and then the farmer would drop back and be number two, and then everybody else would fall in behind. So this would help in the Turner case. And also I've been visiting with a bunch of Rice people this morning, and I've also agreed to put an amendment on the Senate end
that would exempt all state licensed warehouses. So that's kind of what this will do. This will save money. It will help the farmers, and that's what we're here for, trying to help give these guys their money back. And these folks, you know, some of these guys may not ever come out of it. I'd appreciate a good vote. Any game questions? Questions by the committee? Representative
Payton, did I see your hand? Yeah, I have a question.
I don't want to belabor the point if we're all ready to vote yes. But I do appreciate you bringing this, Bill. And my question is, do you believe that if we allow the farmer to have a lien on the product, that the brokers who have become the middlemen, which is where Turner Grain was standing, they're there because the end user wants to deal with one person instead of a hundred farmers to gather up a large quantity of grain the end user would be very motivated to make sure that the
middleman the broker is solvent financially capable of meeting their obligations and they would also be motivated to make sure that the farmer is paid before they pay or when they pay the broker. Right, exactly. That's the intent of
your bill? Yes. Thank you, appreciate it. Representative House. Thank you. As I studied your bill, Representative Radliff, in sales,
we got something called Uniform Commercial Code, and there's a whole section of it that deals with sales. And there's somebody called a purchaser in due course or bona fide purchaser in due course so if if i go uh let's just say i work for a whole uh mount air corporation and i need to buy soybeans or rice hulls or something from a grain dealer and i go and buy i need i'm i'm a bona fide purchaser i got money in my hand
yes sir in due course i'm doing business without knowledge i understand that the farmer has been granted a lien but how do I assure myself that I'm buying my grain free and clear of Mark McElroy's lien what you'd have to do is be sure and go
to one of these state warehouses or federal warehouses to buy you know make sure they're covered under these exemptions okay that's that's
sir and you know these people like Turner Green that were out here I keep bringing
their name up but you know they were cotton grain what they were buying and selling and trying to make money in the middle and that's what they got caught up with they run out of grain and they couldn't get it fast enough to keep the system they had going but if you're buying a product say if you go to Riceland Foods and you're buying say rice bran you know that's that the farmers done been paid for that product based through the co-op you know and inside the co-op when they're processing that thank
you mr chair thank you any other questions
from the committee representative radliff would you agree that marketing of grain is different than marketing of livestock yes sir definitely and do you think that the problems with grain could be solved with a template of the marketing of livestock? Probably not. That's why we had to do a lot of different things on this
bill than we had. We started out with kind of a bill like we had in Livestock Lean from two years ago, but that's why we're having to change a lot of things up,
and it's a lot different than what it was on that other bill. Have you ever named a
cow? Oh, yes. Well, I've been farming for 40 years, and I've never named a grain of rice. You know the reason? because it's hard to identify the rice that I grow from the rice that my neighbor down the road grows. That's very true, very true. All right. Any other questions from the committee? Anyone in the audience want to speak for or against this bill?
Seeing none, you are recognized to close for your bill. I appreciate a good vote, and thank about those poor guys who lost all that money, and I would move do pass on this. All right, we have a motion to do pass. All in favor
say aye. Aye. Opposed, no. No. Chair rules, motion carried.
Representative Gossage on 1563. Excuse me. I can't read his right. 1582? Senator Sanders, Senate Bill 554. Representative Saban, House Bill 1701. He was out in the
Representative Saban, you all recognize to present 1701. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And
can I have your permission to bring Ross Nolan to the table with me? He's an attorney who helped me draft the bill.
You bet. Thank you very much. You'll need to identify yourself. Thank
here in Little Rock. Proceed, Mr. Saban. Thank you, Mr. Chair. This bill, really, I'm bringing this to you really as a property rights bill. It's meant to protect the rights of people who own property and may not know that a particular type of facility or
operation is going to be located next to them. And the inspiration for sort of really going after this issue through the notification process was my experience two years ago, working with Representative Branscombe and Representative Link on improving the notification requirements necessary for putting a concentrated animal feeding operation in the Buffalo River watershed. And, you know, the experience there was you
Speaker 74
35:22
had a small community, Mount Judy.
Sorry? Could I back up just a minute, Representative Saban? Did you have an amendment to this? Well, it's been amended. It was a member's own amendment. Oh, okay. It's already been engrossed. Okay. Just had a question on that. Proceed.
I apologize. No worries. No worries at all. Thank you. So as I was saying, you know, that was a small community, Mount Judy, and it was a big surprise to everybody that this big concentrated animal feeding operation was coming into their community. And so, you know, it's not so much that we're looking to create some overly burdensome regulation.
What we're really trying to do is just enhance notification, and it's really kind of a good neighbor policy. The idea that, you know, neighbors ought to know if something coming in that may affect their quality of life or their, you know, the value of their property just ought to know that it's coming. And so subsequent to that experience that I had with the Buffalo River situation, we've seen in the paper that in Russellville, a crematorium was approved to be located within a few yards of a school, which kind of caused an uproar in Russellville because, again, the community didn't know it was coming.
They missed the opportunity really to comment because they went through the whole permitting process on an administrative level before they really had a chance to know about it. And so, you know, I want to emphasize that, again, I'm not trying to create some overly burdensome regulation. I'm not saying that these facilities aren't important to our economy, that we don't want to have them. I just think that we need to strike the right kind of balance in terms of, you know, obviously going through the correct administrative procedures, but, again,
just making sure people in the community know that these things are coming. And so if you look at the bill, really what we're just having ADEQ do is create a list of these kinds of permits and create a form letter that can be mailed out to folks who are nearby and to put up a sign. And that's really it. And I know that, you know, the alarm bells have rung all over the place about it, but I promise you, I mean, the idea was not to do anything unreasonable, not to, you know, cause any real harm to any kind of business in Arkansas,
saw, but really to protect those property rights, and to the extent that, you know, I've tried to accommodate any concerns, the concerns that came to me, the main thing was that there was an idea that this is kind of redundant, that maybe there were already rules and regs that confronted this, and we kind of examined the bill, and I'm going to let Mr. Nolan speak to this, but where we saw that they might have a point was initially In the first version of this bill, we had some newspaper advertising notification requirements
in there. And we looked at it, and we saw there was some validity to the idea that some of that was already contained in the permitting process, so we amended the bill to get rid of it, because we're really trying to make a good-faith effort to accommodate any concerns. But those were the only concerns that came to me. I think we've got a good argument to make on our side that what we're proposing does does not currently exist, and that it needs to exist, and that the intentions are right to strike that balance again between good economic development, but also private property
rights and the good neighbor kind of approaches that I think we all believe in here in Arkansas. I'd like to let Mr. Nolan make a few more comments about the technicalities of the bill, and then, of course,
Speaker 85
38:51
we'll take questions. Okay. You're recognized, sir. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. The way we would hope this would work under this bill is that the department would first inventory the types and categories of permits that they issue. We've defined a few that would and would not require enhanced notice pursuant to the bill itself.
But generally, this is going to put the responsibility on the department to both categorize who will and will not get enhanced notice and what that notice will contain. And there are guidelines in there that the people receiving notice would have to learn about the administrative process and that there will be a permit application submitted within the next 30 days that is either adjoining their property, that is near their school, or near their water supply. And the hope would be is that we would increase the trust in the administrative process.
Oftentimes I get calls from concerned citizens or potential clients, and they tell me, well, I just found out that a permit has been issued for XYZ facility to be sited next door to me. Will they be able to land apply fluids right up to my backyard, or will they be able to operate at 10 o'clock at night, or will there be smells or noises or any of those things? And I say, well, you know, I'm sorry, but I can't help you. The administrative process has closed. The time to raise those concerns would have been before the commission, when the terms of the permit were being worked out before the department and before it was issued.
And those frustrations from people that call somebody like me lead to some problems with the permitting process and some frustrations that I think can be addressed by a simple letter. And that letter, of course, is the enhanced notification and the sign at the facility door. And I looked it up this morning. It cost $2.70 to send a certified letter return receipt requested. And if you get that notification back digitally, it's just $1.35.
We've eliminated the most costly element of enhanced notice, which is the newspaper requirement, because there is a newspaper requirement later on that the department administers. These letters would be sent out by the applicant before the package is submitted to the department. So it's very early in the process and lets people know what is going on. And I think it will increase confidence, public confidence, in our administrative process and the public permitting participation.
So I will certainly take any questions. Thank
you. Yep. Representative Mates, you're recognized
for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. A couple of questions. Mr. Chairman, please feel free to cut me off one hour. I notice on the bill and on page two, in your including without limitations, I notice you've got line eight talks about permits for concentrated animal feeding operations.
And then in line E, it talks about permits for confined animal feeding operations. So I definitely see an emphasis on the feeding operations. My questions would be is what, and you kind of already talked maybe about the cost, but what would be the cost to AEDQ in implementing something like this? And secondly, by having this new requirement, and I really like the idea of having those lists made available, what all the permits are for everybody um but my concern is is does this um new i don't want to say
who but this new requirement would that extend the length of time that it would take a new business to be get to get permitted or regulated so can you can you address the cost
Speaker 85
42:52
issue and the length of time issue sure i believe your question is cost to adq first um i i would hope it'd be pretty minimal. Representative Sabin referenced Act 1511 of 2013. They have already gone through a rulemaking process very similar to this, Reg 6.207, which of course came back to this body and was approved and is now in the Arkansas Pollution Control and Ecology Commission Reg 6. And that was a pretty
non-controversial rulemaking. The ADEQ did support the Act 1511 commission with Deputy Director been a field serving on that and, of course, a representative of the Farm Bureau and myself and two other representatives appointed by the governor and the Agriculture Committee. So, the form of this notice was vetted by private citizens with the support of ADEQ and then adopted through a fairly non-controversial rulemaking. So, I would hope that the burden to the department would
be pretty minimal, especially considering they've already been through this once. Now, let's see, the second The second question, please remind me of time. The length of time it would take for someone to get. I think this is, you know, it's not an impediment after the application has been submitted. So, I mean, it's a prerequisite to submitting your permit application. You know, and that's up to the facility when they can get that done. But when they're ready to submit it, they should be able to do it pretty quickly. And I can tell you from, you know, having done some work for industry and commerce, you know,
your biggest factors are going to be securing your engineering and writing your permit and that sort of thing. So I would hope that writing a few letters would not be a burden on, you know, what we've defined here, a major air facility, a major water facility. These aren't, you know, the things that we've exempted, like a car wash or a general permit for a stormwater. I mean, these are going to be sophisticated people that are capable of getting four to five letters out the door and posting a sign at their facility. So, I mean, I think that
as far as cost versus the benefit to the public knowledge, I mean, it's to me, it's a no-brainer. It's going to far outweigh any burden to the applicant. All right.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. At proper time, I'd be interested in getting ADQ's
feedback on this. Okay. Representative Branscombe, did you have
Speaker 94
45:09
a question, sir? Yes, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair. On page 2, line 25, where it says permits to go out to one-time
land application. Now, probably I know where you're going with that, but let's say things get real wild sometime in the future and get real complicated. What about, so if, can I take that to mean that if I want to put fertilizer out on one of the fields as a one-time land application, that would have to have a,
Speaker 85
45:45
when I'm going to put fertilizer out? Well, Well, the permits for a one-time land application are exempt, and the fertilizer would not be captured by that anyway.
But a permit to – so that's the exempt list you're looking at, A, B, and C, 25, 26, 27. Those are ones that we are giving as examples that should be exempt from enhanced notice. We don't think those are – So then enhanced notice covers – major environmental impacts to the local environment is how we've defined it. That could be big.
All right, thank you. Any more questions? Representative Payton. Uh, thank
you for coming, and I probably have a question for Representative Sabin more than anything else. Sure. Number one, some issues have been brought up about a cost, and have we done a fiscal impact statement
been a fiscal impact statement. Okay. I'd like to request one. But also, you've used the hog farm as an example a couple of times, and
you kept making statements about these things coming in. And my understanding was those were already landowners and property owners and already lived there, and they decided to use their own property to have a hog farm and you start off by saying your bill was property rights. Does it do anything to help the people who are choosing to use their property in a certain manner? I'd just like
for you to clear up that I don't think they were moving into the area. I take
your point. I acknowledge it and my language which was not probably as precise as it needed to be, because you're right. I mean, they did own that property and they didn't come in. I guess by coming in, in my mind, it was the idea that this was a new operation that obviously the community didn't know about when they found out about it. It was after the fact, and they couldn't really make their voices heard on it. And so that was, I think, the frustration that we responded to with the legislation that we passed two years ago in a bipartisan fashion.
So I have my question, can we get a fiscal impact statement? I have absolutely no opposition to getting a fiscal impact statement. I think the only reason why there wasn't one was I'm not sure that, again, to the state that there's any additional sort of burden or expense that is anticipated administratively, but I'm not opposed to doing that. Okay, thank you,
Mr. Chair. Yep, Representative Armstrong, you had a question next. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Speaker 20
48:36
I don't know who this question goes to, but do we have any notifications in place now? And what's the difference between the notifications we have now and the notifications that you're
Speaker 85
48:51
talking about in this bill? Well, generally, Reg 6.207 encompasses a lot of what we're doing here, but that is limited to permits under the National Pollution Discharge Elimination System for CAFO. so that that's the model we've used for the for what we've got here today now
generally in a permitting process after the adq is drafted a permit it will go out for public comment and the adq or the applicant or adq will direct the applicant to put notice in the in the classified section of the newspaper for about three days and that doesn't go to anybody specific but that that's why we eliminated the newspaper requirement here because I believe there could have been an argument that there is some duplicity there. But again, we've eliminated the most costly part of this bill
and focused on what's to be done by the applicant before the application is submitted. So these are new. It's new. Yeah,
Speaker 85
49:57
out of his pocket? Yes, that would be the $2.70 for the return receipt requested. And depending on how close they are to particular facilities, they could have to do four to six of those letters and then post a sign at the road, closest public road to the facility.
And I, you know, I don't know what a sign would cost, but it just has to be a two by three sign that says there's going to, there's going to be an application for a new environmental permit submitted for this facility. You know, kind of similar to what you might see at a construction site or a rezoning sign in the front of a house for a building permit or something like that. So again, I would reckon to guess that the cost of the applicant would be $20 to $30 tops.
Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Any more questions from the committee? Representative Hendren? I don't see anything in here. What happens if this is not done? What's the penalty or what's the result or what happens if
Speaker 85
51:04
this law is not complied with? Well, we haven't prescribed any enforcement measures here, if that's what you're asking. What would happen is that if they submitted an application to the department without the certified letters attached,
then upon first review the department would have to say your application isn't complete, just as if you hadn't filled out a certain form or done something. So then they would have another 30 days to send out the letters and get that application in as complete. So without any
legal action whatsoever, if this is not complied with, who determines whether it's complied with or not?
Speaker 85
51:39
It would be the department that determines when an application is administratively complete. Whether they've complied with the provisions in this bill?
from the committee? Representative Davis. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
When I first read this bill when you first started talking, I thought you were talking about the department sending out notices, but to be clear, you're talking about the facilities, the permittees would be required to send out all these notices, correct? Correct. Okay. I can follow your justification for notifying adjacent property owners, but can you tell me what's your justification for including county judges and mayors as well?
because, correct me if I'm wrong, but I believe any of the permits that you have listed in here already do public
fact that MPDS permits are required to do two public notices, one of which lasts for a period of 30 days. I believe that all the permits currently require public notice. And you're
Speaker 85
52:45
talking about in a newspaper, correct? Correct. In the classified section? Correct. Well, I think what our experience is with the crematorium and some other people that I've spoken with
is that people don't look at the public notices buried deep in the classified section. So what we've done is target the people who would want to most know about the permit going in or the facility applying for that permit, I should say. And I should also point out that this isn't something that they're going to have to do over and over again. This isn't for a permit renewal. It's for a new permit, a new facility, when people
Speaker 115
53:19
should be most informed about changes that are about to occur close to them.
I won't disagree with your argument about notifying adjacent property owners who are just average citizens like us, but to notify county judges and mayors, there's already obviously significant regulatory burden and oversight on trying to get a permit like this to draw in local governance as well, can really pile on the burden on somebody that's trying to get a facility in place. Facilities which, I'll point out, nobody wants them next door to them, but they're a fact of life.
They have to go somewhere. And so in a lot of ways, I think you are just making things more difficult here. Now, another thing I want to ask you about is you said that, you know, you pointed out that they only have to do this the first time or they're getting a new permit, But I do want to make sure other members of the committee see that it does require that they maintain basically proof of all these notifications for the length of the permit so we could be talking about, you know, this is another requirement on the permit holder to maintain records for years and years.
Speaker 85
54:28
Right. And quite frankly, Representative Davis, I operated a national environmental compliance program for car rental companies for a couple years. and retaining records of your permit application is standard business. I mean, you don't throw your application away after it's approved. That is absolutely standard in the compliance business. Mr. Chair, do you have one more? Go ahead.
Would you agree that all this could be accomplished in rulemaking rather than statute?
Speaker 85
54:59
Well, that's exactly what we're doing here is authorizing the Arkansas Department of Environmental Quality to initiate a rulemaking to
do these things. I think we're dealing with more than that because we're being specific about which permits, which types of facilities have to require or have to provide the notice and all. I believe wouldn't the department already have the authority to do this in rulemaking and select which permits require the enhanced notice like they did for the hog farms? You
Speaker 85
55:28
mentioned 6.07 or whatever it was. Well, 6.207, of course, came from Act 1511 of 2013.
Okay. And so that was a specific authorization for a specific issue. And so now we're authorizing a similar rulemaking and providing examples of do's and don'ts and a standard for the department to go out and complete this list of which ones will, which ones won't. That will go to the commission, or excuse me, it will come here first. Any rulemaking promulgated presented to this will come here first and then go back to the commission. So, of course, legislative review will be subject to legislative review. I just want to be careful. A
lot of times something happens one time, so we pass a law to address something that happened one time,
like the crematorium, for example. And, you know, earlier in this session on a different subject that had to do with ADEQ, we were dealing with a law that was put in place ten years ago, and it was cumbersome, it was burdensome. At the end of the day, even the department didn't like enforcing it because it was a headache for them. And it gets changed every time the legislature comes to session to try to make it work, and I just want to make sure that we don't create another one of those monsters because something happened one time. Thank you,
Mr. Chairman. All right, committee, any other questions on the bill?
Does anybody in the audience speak against the bill? For the bill? Against the bill. A little quicker with a thumb next time. Keep up here. We've got bills
Speaker 131
56:59
to run. Go ahead and introduce yourself, Jeff. Yes, sir. I'm Jeff Pitchford, Arkansas Farm Bureau. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, members of the committee. I know there's been some interesting questions that have come from the committee
and some of those comments I think we are in support of as well. With some concerns that we have on the duplication of those that are going into this permit process, I know it's been talked about, let me pull it up here on my technology, It's been talked about 6.207, you know, and that was something that we worked with in the last session, but to try to – it's right now in rules and regulations,
and we feel like that's the best place for that and to have it there that gives the flexibility. We don't want to tie ADQ. We don't want to tie their hands, and by putting in the code, we feel like that does lock it in. And this way, ADQ and others in the industries and those who are trying to get these permits would have the flexibility and the ability to come to the legislature and come to ADQ and go through the process and not be overburdened. And so that's kind of our position that we have on this bill.
Be glad to answer any questions. Any questions for Mr. Pitchford? All right. Is there anybody else to speak for the bill? Against the bill? Representative Seidman, are you closed for
your bill? I'd like to close real quick. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I really do appreciate the questions. I think they were good, and a lot of them we really did try to anticipate with the legislation we wrote. And, you know, specifically to Representative Davis's concerns, you know, first of all,
throughout this session, I mean, I think we've passed a lot of bills that have been things that, you know, You know, we've really tried to urge our agencies to focus on through their own rule making. And so I don't think this is very unusual. I think it's in keeping with a lot of the things that we do here in the legislature to ensure transparency and accountability. And that's certainly what this bill is intended for. And the other point you made about responding to a one-time incident, we've had two of these big incidents in the last two years. I mean, with the hog farm on the Buffalo River and the crematorium in Russellville.
And we've really tried to focus these enhanced notifications on those really major operations. And so I think, you know, two in two years is enough to say, you know, let's clarify it. And we're not clarifying it with overly burdensome regulation. We're doing it with a few certified letters and a sign, which is really not very expensive. And to that point, I just want to say one last thing, because it was sort of another thing that was going through my mind as we were putting this legislation together. As many of you know, I used to run a magazine called The Oxford American. And a few years ago, we bought a couple of buildings on Main Street in Little Rock.
It's where Juanitas used to be. And we renovated into our headquarters in a restaurant. And because those buildings are in the Capital Zoning District Commission, anything that we did required basically this exact kind of notification. And we were just a small little nonprofit, but I was the guy sitting there, writing the letters, stuffing the envelopes, taking them to the post office, and sending them by certified mail to everybody who lived within a certain, or anyone who owned property, excuse me, within
a certain distance of those buildings. In fact, I think it was more burdensome than this was, because I think that it was a greater distance, and I had to go get a survey to find out, had to pay for a survey to find out who all owned the property. It was something. So I was thinking, if I could do that, and with a little nonprofit, then anybody who's putting a concentrated animal feeding operation, or a hazardous waste, or a disposal facility, or a pollution discharge elimination system. These are big deal things. They've got staff people, they've got big budgets, $2 for a certified letter and a little
bit more for a sign. For transparency, for people to know what's going on because they're not reading the classifieds in their local newspaper, I wouldn't have brought this bill if I thought it was severely a regulatory burden or something that would impede economic development, because that's not what I'm about. I think we do have to strike that balance. And so I would just ask for your consideration, and I would appreciate a good vote.
Thank you. All right, Representative Sabin, it's closed for his bill. What's the wish of the committee?
Any motions from the committee? Representative Sabin, I'm sorry your bill has died to the lack of a motion.
That's OK. I appreciate it, and thank you for
the time. Thank you, sir. Next up, Representative Neal, you're here to run one for Senator Sanders. Let's get after it and hear what you've got to say.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman, committee. Senate Bill 554 is part of the governor's balanced budget proposal that he made back in January. The governor proposed shifting $5 million from the Oil and Gas Commission into general revenue, and that's what this bill would do. Their gas assessments are approximately $10 million annually, and their operations are roughly half that. They have built up a fund balance of over $30 million. Can we
keep it quiet? We're trying to listen to testimony here.
They have built up a fund balance that exceeds $30 million, and a combination of excess revenues and a large fund balance provide flexibility to redirect half of this funding to GR. Okay.
Representative Niels, explain the bill. Any questions? Representative Makes, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Just a real quick question on is
there any concern, and I know about where the fund balances are today. I just want to make sure going forward with the decline in oil and gas prices
across the country, is there any concern that the income coming into this fund is going to create a situation in the future where oil and gas is not going to be able to meet their needs? That's a great question, Representative.
They feel like the fund balance is high enough that they'll be able to look at this every year and determine whether or not they need to change it at that time. All right, thank you. I've got a motion at the proper
time. Any more questions for Representative Dale? Anybody speak against the bill, for the bill?
Representative Neal, are you closed for your bill? Yes, sir. Representative Meeks, you're recognized for your motion. I do pass. Motion to do pass. All in favor signify by saying aye. Aye. Opposed? Motion passes. Congratulations, Representative Neal. Okay, let's go on down the list. Representative Saban, I think, said he was going to pass over his next bill here. Is that correct? He's gone. Representative Meeks, you're next on the queue.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. What I want to do with this bill, there was a lot of discussion on this and a lot of interest on this. And there seemed like that the committee did recognize that this is an issue that does need to be looked at. However, there were some concerns about what the right approach to this issue was. And so what I'm going to do is I'm going to ask the committee to put this bill into interim study. That way we can continue to take a closer look at it in the interim. and give it a little more time. It's something that does need to be addressed, but talking with the cities,
they just want to make sure that we do it in the proper way. So with that, Mr. Chair, I'd just make a motion that we refer this to interim study.
Okay, I believe that has to be done in the house there, so we can do it there. So we'll see. Does it have to be done in the full chamber? Yes. We can't do it. Okay, okay. Okay. But thank you for that. So we'll move on. Representative Dotson, are you here to run your bill? All right, Jim. We've got several bills and we need to get through here, so proceed.
Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee. I do have a letter I'd like to hand out to the members of the committee,
if I may be able to. You bet. Ms. Kendrick, could you help represent
Dodson out there? this bill HB 1823 is a bill that let me get it out in front of me here this bill the letter that
I'm passing out to you is a copy of a letter that that was sent and started the thought process on this bill. Basically, take a little bit of a background and take a step back and kind of go through where this started. There was an appraiser in northwest Arkansas, where I'm from, who had been in the appraisal business for a couple of decades and left the state of Arkansas and elected not to put his license into inactive status because he was going into a different profession
and was leaving the state. Didn't think he'd ever be back to Arkansas. And as you can tell from this letter, went through some circumstances that I think it said family required him to return to Arkansas. His wife was missing home. And so they moved back to Arkansas and trying to find employment and decided to try to go back into the appraisal business. and having not put his license in an active status it was therefore expired he went to the
appraisal licensing board and said hey i would like to get my license reinstated or put it back into an just an inactive status so i can go ahead pay the fines pay the penalties do the continuing education and reinstate my license to the proper proper way to do it made the request apparently this is not a new precedent. It had happened 20 years ago by someone that he had been aware of and they declined that. So he tried to make an appeal to the full licensing board
and they declined it as well. So what this bill does is provides a provision in law for all state board licensors, licensing agencies, commissions, or whatnot, to require them to provide a means for people who have put their license in, let them lapse or expire, go into an inactive status, as long as they're in good condition, good standing when they let
them lapse or expire, to provide a proficiency testing for reinstatement or a letter of recommendation, some sort of a qualifying to say that they previously had licensure experience in that field to allow or to make a accommodation for them to go through and get reinstatement of that licensure. That was where this bill began in the thought process and it expanded as well into more of a recruitment and retention tool hopefully for the state of Arkansas
in allowing for those that come in and decide they're going to be residents of Arkansas that they can also have some reciprocity if they were in a field outside of the state of Arkansas and they can demonstrate experience in that profession or that field that the board would adopt some sort of rules to allow them to get an Arkansas licensure in their field. This happens quite a bit, at least where I'm from, where people come in and there's a trailing spouse.
That can make a decision for somebody whether they relocate here to this state or they don't relocate to this state if their spouse can't find employment here in their profession or their field. And so to finish up with the story that I started with, like I said, the board declined the request and said you have to start over from the very beginning. And let me put this kind of in a nutshell to wrap this up a little bit.
To start over in this profession at the very beginning, you have to go through training and apprenticeship and all that. However, since the time that he went through this, now to become an appraiser you have to have a four-year degree before you can even start the apprenticeship. So in his mid-50s, this gentleman has almost no way this decade even to get back into a field that he's proficient in and knows the market has been a license in good standing for a couple of decades in the state of Arkansas in the past
and just checked the wrong box and made a mistake. We need to correct this not only for this gentleman but for anybody in the future that might have similar circumstances. And
any questions. Okay, any questions? Representative Shepard. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Dodson, in looking over this bill, one question that comes to mind, it looks like the application of this bill or what it mandates is that the licensing board, they have to adopt a rule basically to streamline the process for a resident or soon-to-be resident of the state to obtain their license.
And I'm just wondering whether there's been any discussion about whether that's allowed under law. I know, and maybe Representative House might recall as well, I think that there's a pretty famous United States Supreme Court case that basically said that licensing requirements for members of a bar association, I believe it was Virginia, that they couldn't prefer residents of their own state over a resident of another state. and that that restriction was struck down.
Maybe Representative Whitaker might remember. And I'm just wondering whether there's been any discussion about whether a residency restriction would stand up under law or whether this is possibly setting us up for court challenges or otherwise. I'm sure that you probably know
the answer to that better than I do, being an attorney yourself. I'm not 100% certain. As I understand it, when we put something into law, then that becomes the law.
So if this bill were to pass, then that would be a pretty good standing to at least begin the process and have that discussion. If there was conflicting laws with regards to that, I don't know the answer as far as whether or not. That has not been addressed or raised to me previously. Representative
Speaker 20
1:12:29
Armstrong? Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Dodson, how long can your license stay in an inactive status and what's the requirements to put it in an inactive status?
Well, I'm not sure for every license. I think there's probably a lot of different, depending on the licensure board or commission, the profession or industry, there are probably a variety of different answers to that. I believe it was five years for the appraisers, five or six years that they could have it in an active status. And this particular gentleman, if I recall correctly, since he had left in, I believe it was 2009,
that it was coming up sometime in 2015, the end of that six years. So I think he had like a year, and then there was five years on top of that that he could put it into a semi-inactive status and then go into a full-blown inactive status later on after that first year. But I believe it was six years total, and then five years somewhere in there. I don't know the details on this particular – for every particular license, I mean. Thank you, Representative Johnson. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Any other questions for Representative Dockton? Representative Hendren, go ahead. Does this just apply, what is there, a board that licensed these appraisers? Yes, there's a, I believe it's actually in the name of
this, the Appraiser License and Certification Board. Have they taken a position on this bill? I'm unaware of one that they've taken, no. I would imagine they'd probably be opposed for us overruling them.
Mr. Chairman, after this question, I'd like to see if maybe they're on the list or not on the list. Does this just apply to that board as a real estate agent for a long time? How does this affect the real estate licensing and
the real estate commission board? Well, I have actually, the real estate folks did contact me on this bill, And I did incorporate and made an amendment in here to try to accommodate some of their concerns. I think I've hit the majority of them. They haven't come out with a position that I'm aware of either supporting it or opposing it.
But I have tried to incorporate. One of the things that they did ask me to include in here, for instance, was with regards to criminal background checks, that they'd be required, since they're currently required for realtors, that that also be required for reinstatement or anybody moving into the state so that folks would have to comply with the same background checks, continuing education, and things of that nature if they were to become an Arkansas licensee.
What about professional engineering? I haven't been contacted by them. Would this affect them, though, or qualify to them? This would apply to any licensing board or commission in the state so that they would have to adopt rules to accommodate this provision. Okay, Representative
Fuaduker, I think you were next. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative, I'm just going to follow up on something that Representative Shepard brought up,
and I'm hoping we can just get a quick answer. On page 2, lines 5 and 6, it's at subsection B1 is a resident of the state or will be a resident of the state when he or she practices the profession. Can you explain why you all felt that was necessary? Because currently I can live in Oklahoma, and if I comply with all the training, all the requirements, paid all the fees, take any necessary exams,
and submit myself to the jurisdiction of a professional board. I don't have to be a
state resident to do that. Well, that was actually something that in the list of things I was trying to work with the realtors in particular that they requested to clarify within the provisions of this bill that someone needed to be a, since there's already reciprocity agreements for various things if you're a non-resident, that this very specifically be for folks who were going to be permanent residents of the state, had moved to the state to reside within the state.
Now, I don't know if they had attorneys that brought up those concerns or were aware of that provision in the past. And so that's the first I've heard of it as
far as a concern. I'd feel better if that weren't in there because currently right now, sure, if I had for many years, the early years of my practice, Arkansas did not have reciprocity on law licenses, but nothing was to stop me from going to Oklahoma, studying their bar and paying the fee
and submitting myself to their jurisdiction and becoming a licensed Oklahoma attorney or any other state. Sure. My concern is that you have to show that you are a resident or you will be a resident, and I just don't, I worry. And your problem is not that you're conflicting with just any old law. And I don't want to get too deep in the weeds, but we have a thing called dormant interstate commerce clause problems where you start telling people states aren't allowed to treat the residents of other states unreasonably different than their own.
And, you know, this whole thing grew out of the problems we had with the old Articles of Confederation where states were printing their own money and they weren't take yours and they wouldn't let you work there because you weren't one of them. I would feel better if you could go back to whoever drafted that line for you and give
us a little better justification for that. Well, the goal is not to affect any non-resident reciprocity that someone from out of state has with Arkansas. This is for them to acquire a resident license.
This is a requirement that was put into place so that if they had a full Arkansas resident license, that they had to be a resident. They couldn't be someone who was living out of state. That would be a non-resident license, and under the reciprocity agreements that we currently have in place with various states. So I think that was the goal of this line. I don't think it addresses any of the non-resident license requirements that we currently have. I don't believe this touches that. Well, in the understanding that's probably the best
Thank you, sir. Any other questions for Representative Dodson? If not, we have to speak against the bill. Melanie, he's speaking 38. Oh, excuse me. Okay, we have somebody here who doesn't know whether they want to speak for or against it. Michael Luz, you want to come up and speak? You may have made up your mind now. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, representatives.
I'm going to speak against this bill at this point in time. I represent the- Please identify yourself, sir, and who you're with. My name is Michael Luce. I'm the executive director of the Arkansas Board of Examiners and Counseling. We license mental health practitioners at the professional counselor level and marriage and family therapists. All of our laws, our enabling legislation, and all of our standards for licensure are drafted and put into our law. So this bill would literally force us to go back and redo enabling legislation and rewrite all of our rules and regulations.
We do accept candidates for applicants for licensing from other states. And we do this through endorsement with stipulations. They are required to meet our minimum standards because they're crafted and written into the law. For example, I'm going to give you my story. I was licensed here originally in 1980. For those folks who may be familiar with our licensing, I'm right now looking at 5,980 is the number of a license file.
So I left the state, and I went to teach at the University of Wyoming. I was tenured at UW. My wife got tired of four-letter words, wind, cold, and snow, said I want to go back home. So I called Dr. Thomas up at the board, and I said, Ann, I'm coming back. I need to know what I need to do for my license. And she said, Michael, the rules have changed. And they added a psychopathology and a psychopharmacology class that was essential to our practice these days, very legitimate concerns.
I told Dr. Thomas, I teach these classes. And she says, I know, it's ludicrous, isn't it, Michael? I said, yes. She said, there are no exceptions. I had to register and take my own classes to be able to be relicensed in this state because it was required in the law. Not because I didn't have the competencies or skills, but I had to live up to the standards that are there in our legislation. When other folks come to the state these days from other jurisdictions,
many of them don't have a psychopharmacology class on a transcript. Many of them don't have a marriage and family class on a transcript. Those are required by law. So when they suit up and show up and come for their oral exam with our board, providing they have met all the other academic standards, We will license them by endorsement, saying, OK, we're going to license you, and you have one year to complete a psychopharmacology class. Most of the states don't require as much supervision as we require for our licensees.
We require 3,000 hours. The ratio on the first 1,000 is 1 to 10. We have a rigorous process to govern the licensees we credential. So sometimes they come in and they don't have enough. Some states will only require 400 hours of supervised practice before they license. Most states require around 2,000. Arkansas has had these rigorous standards for 36 years.
Other states have patterned their licensing laws after hours. We were the second to adopt licensing and the very first to enact licensing. So going back now and having to rewrite our rules, regulations, and amend the law would really be something problematic for our board. And I cannot speak for social work or psychology, but I suspect they would have the same or similar sort of a problem with this legislation. Thank you. Okay, thank
you, sir. Any questions for the speaker?
All right. John. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'll attempt a question. I was catching most of what you're saying there. So the rigorous standards that it takes to be a licensee in your field, if an Arkansas resident meets those standards, practices for several years, leaves and drops their license and comes back, you would expect them to go back through 3,000 hours of training and meet those standards
again? No, no, no. What would happen is we would have to say, well, okay, where are you working,
and let's see what you've been doing. And once they've been licensed here and moved to another jurisdiction, if they're fully licensed there five years or more, we can give them their license back without any of those other kinds of additional things. So it really is about if they're licensed here initially and move someplace
else. Is that not what this bill accomplishes for other fields and other licensures where if they leave and they come back, they can be
reinstated? I don't know what this bill really is saying about some of those things. That's kind of my concern because the way that this bill is written, for example, in good standing in any state at any time,
and I'm going, well, no, somebody coming from another state with 400 hours of supervised practice coming to this state, whether they're licensed in Oklahoma, Oklahoma, Missouri, Louisiana, Tennessee, Texas, all of our border states don't have as stringent requirements as we do. somebody who's been licensed there for a good long time will come here then they might have some supervision to do might have a class to take if our students who are licensed here fully licensed go someplace else maybe Ohio and Florida
and California might be the only states where they would have to do anything different because we are so restrictive and out of necessity for the occupation that we have. If they go there, come back to Arkansas, there's no problem with licensing. In fact, we can also give a non-practicing status and we encourage practitioners who leave the state to maintain non-practicing status. They have to do the same continuing ed as every other licensed practitioner, but for $50 fee every two years, they can have an
active license in this state. They just can't practice anywhere else. They'd have to do their state things,
but they're welcome to come back home. Thank you. Any more questions from the committee? Thank you, sir. Appreciate your testimony. Anybody speak for the bill, against the bill? Representative Dodson, are you ready
to close for your bill? Yes, Mr. Chair. Members of the committee, just to point out, currently boards, as the testimony was given, have the discretion, but there's no
requirement to allow reinstatement of license. And that's really what this bill tries to attempt to address for the residents of Arkansas to try to give them the opportunity to go to work, highly trained professionals in their fields, to give them the ability to get back to work if they've previously held an Arkansas license. And I'll point one more place to page two, lines 20 through 24
that the licensing entity may require that sufficient competency in the particular field be demonstrated by proficiency testing, letters of recommendation or both and with that I would certainly appreciate a good vote and helping getting Arkansas residents the ability to get to work Alright committee you've heard the
bell, what's the rest of the committee? committee there's a motion
do pass all those in favor signify by saying aye opposed representative from where I'm standing it sounded like the nose had it so not seeing any signs for a roll call I'm sorry your motion has failed thank you Mr. Chair members of the committee
appreciate it alright next Senate Bill 778 Representative Shepard are you going to present that one for us pretty quick here thank you Mr. Chairman
committee I'm here on Senate Bill 778 it was filed by Senator Malik this bill basically is some permissive language that allows the oil and gas commission to adopt a rule or order related to the leasing of certain mineral interests. I've got the Director, Larry Bingle, and General Counsel Shane Corey are here as well,
and with the Chairman's permission, I'd like to have them come to the table to answer any questions. Either one. I would just, you know, remind committee, really the intent behind the bill is to allow the Oil and Gas Commission to adopt some rules that may help to streamline the leasing process, particularly, and it's focused on, or the intent is to focus on mineral or royalty
interests that are primarily less than one net acre within a unit. So we're talking about a very small interest. The law already requires notice to be given, and this would just allow the oil and gas commission to adopt some additional rules to help to expedite it, but it would still preserve certainly the due process rights of those interested parties. And I would remind the committee that any rule that's ultimately adopted by the Oil and Gas Commission
obviously has to come back to the legislature for approval. So we would obviously have that opportunity to review anything that they bring forward.
Okay. You're recognized or anything else? All right, members, you heard the bell. Any questions? Representative Makes? Thank you, Mr.
Chairman. Just a question. On page two, it looks like we're adding language that says,
in the absence of agreement between the parties, the Oil and Gas Commission, and then we're going to add or by the director of the Oil and Gas Commission. So are we giving the director, and maybe Mr. Bengel can answer this, are we giving him opportunity to do things that normally the full commission would have to do and what would be the benefit or negatives of that? I think the rest
Speaker 169
1:31:06
of that section is on to say that that would be a true statement. I would have authority, but only after the rules adopted by the commission.
So if the commission chose to not give me that authority, I would not have that authority. It would all be spelled
out in administrative rules. Okay. I just want to make sure that we weren't creating an opportunity for the director, not to say that you're a bad director, but in the future that we might get some way where a director is going to do his own thing and ignore
the commission. So that's just what I wanted to verify. Thank you. Representative Payton, you have a question. Yes, thank you, Mr. Chair. Does this preserve the standard that somebody being integrated would receive the highest royalty that's offered in that section?
Speaker 169
1:31:48
Yes, this does not change that. What this does is just address the hearing provision, an opportunity for hearing. Notice would be required as we do now. Notice would be given as we do now. the opportunity to be from a mandatory hearing to an opportunity for hearing, but all the bonuses, royalties, best offer, that would all be maintained. Okay. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. If
I may, I think this is very much akin in my mind to what we allow in our courts as far as like a default judgment. Right now, if an individual is sued and they don't file an answer,
you don't have to go for a hearing. You can present an order to the judge saying, yes, we gave notice. they never responded, would you please enter this judgment. Currently, by statute, there's a hearing requirement. So these notices, which many times there are a number of notices that go out, and to the best of the, I guess, the individuals who are exploring and potentially drilling the well goes out to a number of people.
This just simply would allow some flexibility that the commission could adopt a rule that if after that notice, that if there's no response, they could adopt a rule that there would be no need for a hearing because, again, there's been no response from the noticed party. So I think it's very much akin to what we have in the court system. One of my concerns, this is obviously Senator Malik's bill, but I was contacted by an individual related to the Oil and Gas Commission as well
in support of this bill, but one of my concerns has always been preserving the due process rights of those mineral and royalty owners to make sure that they are respected, which they still clearly would be, but I think it's something that will help to make good use of the Commission's time if the rule is adopted going forward.
If I could follow up, I had another question. You made reference to the fact that this would only address small acreage, acreage. And I'm looking in the
bill to see where that language is. That
Speaker 169
1:33:57
language would eventually be in the rules that would be adopted. The specification sets of the acreage. It's not in the statute. It just opens up the opportunity for
rules to be written to address that. So could you tell us what the standard is now
Speaker 169
1:34:13
on acreage for integration? There is no standard for I mean any parcel regardless of size is subject to integration. So if this
passes, any parcel, regardless of size, is subject to this new rule?
Yes. So you could own 200 acres?
Speaker 169
1:34:28
But only if the rule allowed that to be the case. We would have to adopt rules to specify the acreage you could be integrated. What is your intent
Speaker 169
1:34:43
intent, this was an industry bill. It was not a commission bill. Senator Malik and the industry worked, and we helped work on the language. The intent and the development of this bill was one acre or less.
But the statute does not specify that that's the limitation of one acre or less. Okay. Thank you,
Mr. Chair. Okay. Any more questions from the committee? Not saying any. Anybody speak against the bill, for the bill? Representative Shepard, do
you close for your bill? I would just briefly say to Representative Payton's question, I actually had another bill. My bill did address specifically it was less than one acre. When I saw Senator Malek was running this, I got with him, and he asked if I would carry it.
Obviously, there's flexibility here. I mean, all I can speak was what was the intent originally, but you're correct. I mean, this is giving the Oil and Gas Commission permission to do that, But I would remind the committee that any rules ultimately come back to the legislature. So this is the way I view it is just allowing them to start the process to look at this. But I want to be clear with everybody. I don't want anybody to think I'm trying to misrepresent anything here. But you're correct that there is flexibility there.
Okay. With that being said, Representative Shepard disclosed the first bill. What's the wishes of the committee? Here do pass. All those in favor signify by saying aye. Aye. Opposed? Motion carries. Your bill is passed. Representative Gene, have you got a bill that you can run real quick? Yes, sir. All right. Fast as fast can be, you'll never catch him.
You're recognized, Representative Gene. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, members of the committee. This is Senate Bill 855. It's by Senator Sanders, and what this is is amending what we do on unpaved right-of-ways. If an unpaved right-of-way has been closed and not used for a year, the property owner has to put a gate across it. This can be oil-filled roads. can be right-of-ways that go in and out,
electrical, old abandoned electrical right-of-ways, and this is locked and has a gate on it, it can be reverted back to him and the easement will be done away with. It does not deal with anything to do with the Arkansas State highways, nothing to do with any county roads, paved or unpaved, that are cared for by the county, any kind of improvement district, levy districts are not included, and roads with any first- or second-class city,
any roads, does it matter, does it pertain to them? Can I entertain any questions? Any questions? Representative Bragg? Okay, I'm not quite clear
on what this is doing. If you have a private road that's gated, so what effect is this? I'll let Mr. Hal
Kemp, if you'll identify yourself. I'm Hal Kemp. I'm
Speaker 185
1:38:10
an attorney here in Little Rock, and I'm a farmer in Madison County.
Representative, these are unpaved rows. Most often they're created by easement instruments that are filed of record that grant the public the right to use the road. They're oftentimes farm-to-market type roads. The farmer or landowner feels like that he wants to reverse the granting of permission to the public to use the road and puts a gate across the road and locks it. At present, the public has seven years within which to act to preserve their right to use the road.
This bill will reduce that time period down to just one year in order to give the landowner relief from having to bear the inordinate expense of maintaining the road and the liability exposure if somebody gets hurt on the road. So it's merely contracting the time period down for the public to exercise their remedies if they have them. Oh, I
understand. If there was no previous lease or easement, it wouldn't be relevant to the ownership. That's correct. Okay, thank you. Okay, any other questions for Representative Jane? Representative House? This question
may be from Mr. Kemp, so essentially you're changing the statute limitations for an action on real estate, which has been seven years for, gosh, what, 150 years, and you're going to change it to one year? That's correct. Thank you. Okay, any
other questions from the committee? Can anybody else speak against the bill, for the bill? representative jen are you closed for your bill yes sir i move do pass okay committee motion do
pass all in favor signify by saying aye aye opposed no motion carries representative you've passed your bill all right next we have a representative fight here uh represent fight You're here to present House Bill 1564, and you just passed out some pretty pictures for us, so thank you. You are recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you,
committee. This is my first time before you, and I'm bringing you House Bill 1564.
I live out in the country, and it is a magical place. We have cats and dogs that appear by magic. Recently, we had a septic tank that appeared on our property by magic. We've had sinks appear by magic, all kinds of construction debris and other things. And I imagine most of you who live in the country have had a similar experience. However, I have discovered that dumping is not just a country issue, a rural issue. It's also an urban issue. And I have with me today Mr. Gary Moody from the Audubon Society.
Mr. Chair, may I recognize him? Certainly my representative. he was sharing with me and the pictures we're bringing you is of a cleanup in two sites in little rock last weekend as part of a beautification project and you can see that this is very much an urban project as well the bill i'm bringing before you today would do two things it would strengthen the law by imposing penalties against dumping where we can prove who did the dumping and secondly
it would give local law enforcement and state law enforcement agencies with this authority ability to recoup some of their costs for the cleanup and the restoration when they are able to prove the person who has done the dumping. And if I may ask Mr. Moody to speak briefly about their project this weekend. Go ahead, sir. Introduce yourself. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, members of the
committee. My name is Gary Moody. I'm a native Arkansan, and I serve as the Public Affairs Director for Audubon, Arkansas.
I prepared some nice typed remarks, but I think they got passed around with the photos, so I'm going to wing it for you today. I wanted to share with you the results of just a cleanup that we did just this last weekend with the Arkansas Canoe Club and some other volunteer organizations at two parks here in Pulaski County, at Benny Craig Park and Gillum Park. Oh, thank you, Representative. This weekend we had 95 volunteers joining us at those two parks here in Pulaski County and in a period of three hours they helped us collect 3.93 tons of debris
and 1.36 tons of recyclables from those two locations. In addition we collected about a thousand pounds of shingles also. While part of this total was just your general standard litter, The vast majority of it came from finding and cleaning up illegal dump sites. The photos that we passed around are some of the dump sites that we ran across that day and picked up. Our haul this weekend included a handgun, a TV, a mannequin, construction debris, 52 used tires, and a lot of removed shingles.
Sadly for us, this outing is very, very typical. We do these cleanups quarterly, and all of the sites that you see there were cleaned up less than a year ago by the same organization. So it's a recurring problem we run into. While we know that this bill isn't a silver bullet, so to speak, and it's not going to entirely eradicate the problem of illegal dumping, we hope that by strengthening the criminal penalties and arming our enforcement entities with that stronger option, that we could increase the likelihood that those cash-trapped and overworked organizations
could spend more time enforcing the laws on illegal dumping and help reduce this problem. So that's why Audubon's here today on behalf of our 4,000 members in Arkansas, asking you to support this
bill. Okay, thank you, sir. Questions from the committee? Representative Bragg.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. What kind of evidence is required to convict
someone? That would really be at the discretion. of the court, but we would hope that they would leave something with their name and address. We have actually had that
happen on our own property, that bags of trash had numerous things proving the person's name and address, and then that's left up to the local law enforcement or to the Forestry Department or Game and Fish or whoever's investigating to prove that that's actually the person. In the case of a septic tank, sometimes there is a number on it that can be traced back and you can eventually find out, but a lot of this would be at the discretion of law enforcement. Thank
Chair. I was county judge for 20 years, and I want to say
thank you for bringing this bill. I fought illegal dumping the whole time I was there. I had cameras and everything else, but one of the problems I had was law enforcement coming in and enforcing it, And, you know, they say, well, we've got bigger fish to fry, we've got rapists, we've got murderers. And one thing, and I'm getting to a question here, the $2,000 fine, do you think that that might be something that would keep the law enforcement?
You know, they say, man, I'm not going to fine somebody $2,000 for dumping a tire. And don't get me wrong, I love the bill. I'm just wondering, do you think that this might be a deterrent from them enforcing the fine, that the fine might be too high? I'm hoping it
would be a deterrent to people dumping, that they would say, you know, this is not something that's going to be just treated lightly anymore, that I could get in some really serious trouble here.
And if I may, Representative, we talked about that at Audubon as well,
but we wanted to point out that this bill does leave the civil and admin penalties in place as well, So it will be up to the enforcement officers whether they want to go civil and admin or if they
want to pursue criminal for the worst offenders. Representative Jane, you're next. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Fyde, I appreciate you bringing this bill, but I do have a problem with it. We get back to prison overcrowdedness, and a lot of us know that prison overcrowdedness is prosecutors and judges that are angry with people,
send them and fill up our jails and our prisons. And I see where this has imprisonment in the bill, that that could be part of the punishment. And I'm just thinking, you know, does that language really need to be in here? And I want your thoughts on that.
Again, it could be. It doesn't have to be. And we left, as Mr. Moody just said, we did not remove the administrative or civil penalties. So there's a lot of leeway here as to what the person could be charged with.
they don't have to be hung by their necks until dead. You know, we can go all the way up to more severe penalties. Well, just
a follow-up. I mean, it's in here, and where we get in trouble on overcrowding us is prosecutors and judges that are mad at people rather than putting away the ones that really need to be put away, and I just have a problem with that, but I thank you for bringing this bill forward.
We were adding that as an option, but we left in place the administrative and civil penalties, so they have a wide variety of things from which to choose.
Tara, thanks. Representative Hendren was next, and then Representative Payton. We'll get to you. I'll try to be quickly
about this. I wish you had had a way to put a person's name on a beer can whenever they buy it and throw it out on the road. But I don't guess we figured it. But one thing that's interesting to me is that I've got a neighbor who lives down the road from me, and sometimes he dumps his trash in a dumpster out behind there. And I guess this is how you find it, whodunit, is that he's got letters in there and stuff that's got it.
And he just happens to be a state senator on the other end. And if I don't like what he does, can I go get one of his sacks of garbage that's got his address, letters addressed in it, take it out of there, go down and dump it in front of my house or his house, and whenever you all pick it up, it's obviously that guy that did it. Now, how do you handle something like that? Again, he could
get in serious trouble for trying to – or you could – I got lost in the story there. I'm the one that's framing him. Okay, you're framing him. You could get in a lot of trouble for trying to frame him,
and he could probably easily prove that you did that because you've done it before. So he could prove that – That's all I
want to say tonight. I think character goes into that, Representative Payton. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Representative Feit, I definitely sympathize with what you're trying to do here, living three and a half miles out in the middle of nowhere myself. I've been the recipient of many gifts left on my property. However, it's already illegal. And I have little or no faith that the perpetrators are going to study this change in the law
and that it will discourage them because now we have a new or higher fine. And I doubt that they'll even know it unless one of them gets caught. And one of the questions that was brought up earlier about whether this may actually discourage enforcement because you have a minimum penalty of $2,000. Since this is already illegal, can you tell me exactly what is it that your bill does? I mean, is it just the increase in penalty?
It does two things. It increases the penalty, and again, they don't have to use that part of it. If they don't want to use that part, they can go to the original administrative and civil penalties, which are still in place. This just gives them another option if they want to go to the more severe penalties. And the second thing it does that will make it more attractive to our enforcement agencies is that they get to keep part of what they recoup, the money that they recoup, in having to pick up this and prove the case and make things right again to restore.
Of course, their first priorities are going to be murders and rapes and robberies and that kind of thing, but if they know that they get to keep some of the money from this restoration process, they are going to be more willing to spend the time in investigating, and no, the criminals won't be looking at this and saying, I better not do this, it's a stiffer penalty now, But our law enforcement agencies will be looking at this, and they will be more willing to invest the manpower in doing some of these, catching these illegal dumps, people who are doing illegal dumping.
Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. All right, Representative Meigs, you're next. Thank you,
Mr. Chair. Again, unlike everyone else, I kind of like the intent of what we're trying to do here, but with a lot of this stuff, as you know, the devil's in the detail. And I noticed in one of the sections of the bill we're making an unclassified felony. This is C1, subsection B. It says if the person recklessly causes pollution of the water or air in a manner that's not permitted by law. And so we're taking this from dumping. Now we're getting into air pollution and water pollution.
And if we don't have the permission of the state, then suddenly anybody's going to be in violation of this
rule. Well, that's a part I didn't touch. That was already in the law. I left it alone.
That's not new. Well, I mean, in your bill, it's underlined,
so that's new language. It's underlined, but it's not changed. There's no change
there. Okay, I'm confused then. Okay. That was my question. Is this, you know, if we make this a felony, if someone does get caught doing this, now all of a sudden, you know, the right to vote, the right to hold office,
all those things are going to be affected
you, Mr. It's just giving one more option that we could go all the way up to a felony. But, again, they have a wide plethora of choices. I have one quick question.
Representative, if a certain pickup going down the road with a legislative license plate on it happened to have a feed sack blow out of the back, could that kick them out of office there? Would that be a good way to get out of here?
I don't know the answer. Representative Payton, you're recognized. Okay. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Is this, if you're the landowner and you have a stack of tires on your property and local law enforcement is motivated by this new act, would you be subject to being penalized under this because you have what they consider to be a dump on your property that you put there yourself?
This is not addressing the landowner. This is addressing the person who's found to have done the dumping. So if I myself dumped on my own land, I probably would not be asking law enforcement to help me catch myself. Does that make sense? It makes
sense, but I've not read anything in the bill that would make that, draw that line. and we're talking about how this bill and the fines may motivate law enforcement to Representative I think I may be able to answer your
question this bill nests inside of sub chapter 5 of that code and it's just one portion of that and the other portion there is a definition of what constitutes illegal dumping and something that you were to do on your own property would not does not meet that definition of illegal dumping thank you thank you Mr. Chair All right,
any more questions for Representative Fyte? Seeing none, is there anybody speaking against the bill, for the bill? Representative Fyte, are you closed for your bill? I would just
like to say Arkansas is a natural state,
and it's not hard to take debris away in the right way. We just have people that are being lazy and not doing that, and I just want to make it harder on them. I'm calling this beautification instead of anti-dumping because it just sounds better. But this is just an attempt to put some teeth into the law and make it less attractive to make our state ugly. Thank you. Appreciate a good vote. Okay, committee, you've heard the bill.
What's the pleasure of the committee? I have a motion do pass. All in favor, signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed? No. Representative Fyatt, I'm sorry, but I believe your bill has failed. This is my first launch, and I have to do that. And it breaks my heart to have to be the one to tell you that, my dear.
out. Sorry, Representative Fyatt. Okay, Representative Letting is going to pass over his bill right now. Is there anybody else that's got a quick bill? We've got two or three minutes. Try to wrap some of these up. Representative Jack, you want to present your bill quick? It says to amend Water Resources Conservation and Development Incentives Act, 1802.
No, you don't want to run it? Okay. Okay, anybody else? Going once, going twice, we're adjourned. I'll
Agenda
Presentation
HB1963
HB1553
HB1701
SB554
HB1823
SB7778
SB855
HB1564
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Dan M. Douglas Chair
Unverified
Speaker 5
Representative James Ratliff
Unverified
Representative Kim Hendren
Unverified
Speaker 20
Speaker 24
Representative Jon S. Eubanks
Unverified
Speaker 41
Representative John Payton Chair
Unverified
Representative David Hillman Chair
Unverified
Representative Douglas House
Unverified
Speaker 61
Chair
Unverified
Representative Warwick Sabin
Unverified
Speaker 85
Speaker 74
Representative Stephen Meeks
Unverified
Speaker 94
Speaker 96
Representative Andy Davis
Unverified
Speaker 115
Speaker 131
Representative Micah S. Neal
Unverified
Representative Jim Dotson
Unverified
Representative Matthew J. Shepherd
Unverified
Representative David Whitaker
Unverified
Speaker 154
Michael Luce
Unverified
Speaker 169
Representative Lane Jean
Unverified
Representative Ken Bragg
Unverified
Speaker 185
Gary Moody
Unverified
Speaker 195
Representative Mark D. McElroy
Unverified
Speaker 205
Speaker 209
Speaker 212