House Revenue and Taxation Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (5)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1402
· 4 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1402”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB341
· 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…r. Members, I have an objection. We're going to look at our Senate Bill 341. Anybody in the audience want to speak for or against this…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB490
· 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…bjection. Representative Bragg, you ready to run your bill? Senate Bill 490, members. And everybody, just for the record, that last bil…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1178
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…ence for your amendment let's do that members we'll look at house bill 1178 it's a concurrence amendment out of the senate representati…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB925
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB925”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 15, 2026
He's probably just now getting out of bed. We're waiting on a couple of amendments to come back on a couple of bills. So I think what we're going to do, without objection, a committee won't, as usual, take something out of order while we try to get everything logistically kind of cleared up. If you reject Representative Gonzalez, that's too bad, buddy. That's kind of pretty much how this deal is going to be.
morning, so. Representative Talley, you could present your bill, sir. Members, I have an objection. We're going to look at our Senate Bill 341. Anybody in the audience want to speak for or against this bill, please sign
in for me. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Members, I bring before you today Senate Bill 341, and let me explain. This bill will assist cattle farmers and ranchers to endure natural disasters through the creation of a tax exemption,
for payments just for the disaster payments that are set up to give them a safety net. These programs only provide assistance with drought or natural disasters, put an unplanned or sometimes devastating financial burden on their operations. These payments are not designed to make them whole, but simply to help them survive the natural disasters. This legislation allows them to use the full disaster program to assist their programs and their operations to get them through that natural disaster and keep them in business. We have worked with DF&A for a financial impact on this and have received back from them this quote,
any amount of revenue impact is impossible to determine, and impact occurs only in drought years. So very, very favorable there as far as having any kind of adverse impact on our budget. Therefore, the impact will be negative to the budget. We have current support from the Cattlemen's Farm Bureau and the hardworking farmers and ranchers from across the state. We certainly appreciate a good vote. Thank
you, members. Any questions? Representative Meeks. Thank you, Mr.
Chairman. A question I have is would the cattle farmers or those that would benefit from this program,
would they have to, I don't want to say contribute is the right word, but would there be any insurance premiums or would they have to help offset this cost for this program in any way or would this be entirely bore by the taxpayers of the
state in essence? The majority of these programs are disaster payments through USDA that are included in the Farm Bill. There is a couple of those programs, like NAP has a payment where they have to pay to be a part of that program. So it's kind of a combination of the two.
Mr. Chairman. I've got a conflict of interest here because I guess I got one of these payments last year. I found out, boy, a farm we cattle guys could go in and get some money for the federal government. It's sure a joy to get it coming that way instead of the other way. Your bill right here, does this mean if we pass this bill that the refund I got from Uncle Sam last year in 2014 that I'm going to put on my income tax, that I want to pay state income tax on it?
Not for last year, sir. We're going to pick up in 15 and move forward. We lost the vote. Is it possible to
amend your bill and change that? We actually had that in there, but we amended it out. I hope we didn't lose your vote there, Mr. Hendrick. It
wasn't amended on the other end by a certain senator, was it? Probably
your son, yes. Members, any other questions? Anybody else want to speak against the bill, for the bill?
Representative Talley, I'm sorry. Representative Talley, are you closed for your bill, sir? Yes, sir. Thank you very much. Members, Representative Vaught. I have a motion for due pass. Any discussion members? All in favor, say aye. Any opposed, no. Congratulations. You passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, committee. Is Representative Shepard in the room?
Yeah, Representative Matthew Pitch, would you, yeah, yeah, please ask him to come over. members just give us just a moment here and we'll see we're trying to work through some logistics stuff here just give us just a couple minutes representative pitch you want to run your concurrence for your amendment let's do that members we'll look at house bill 1178 it's a concurrence amendment out of the senate representative pitch when you get organized sir you're recognized
thank you mr. chairman committee members what you have in front of you is a bill we voted on in the very first week of the session in this committee it got through the process went to senate in negotiating we had senator files put one amendment which is a definition amendment it's a clarification of the wording and
it passed unanimously through committee in the Senate. So we're here for concurrence. Representative
Meeks, is that a motion or is that a question? Any questions, members? Representative This is a concurrent amendment two on the motion by Representative Meeks. All in favor say aye. Any opposed, no? Congratulations. Your amendment passed. Thank
what do we got 1402 house bill 1402 with an amendment It's being passed out. We just put in the second team here without any notice, so you'll have to bear with us. I've got faith in you, Mr. Chairman.
Representative Shepard, you're recognized to explain your amendment. Mr. Chairman if you don't care just hold on
just a second we have a question about the amendment we just got our hands on it also just bear with me just a second please yeah it would be good thank you Mr. Chairman
Thank you for your diligence, Mr. Chairman. We're good to
go. Go ahead. You're recognized. Mr. Chairman, committee, thank you for the opportunity to come before you today. I bring House Bill 1402. There is an amendment. It actually is in the name of Representative Jett, and so I'd appreciate this amendment. Of course, the original intent of the bill was to put back
all of the capital gains exemptions that were originally taken out earlier in the session. But this amendment that Representative Jett brings, ultimately we accomplished that goal. It's just going to take a little bit more time. Members, I might add how
we're going to do that. In respect to the governor's budget, we went back on the first amendment coming out on this tax cut. We moved it to 40% if you guys recall that. On this amendment, what this will do in respect to the governor's budget and some other moving parts
that we're trying to work through on the back side of this. We're moving that 40% to 45%, and that's effective February 1st of this year. And the February 1st of this year is the date that we move that 40% to. And then FY17, first day of FY17, this amendment will move that 45% to the full 50%, so that sets everything back into motion that where we're at. and we'll discuss above the $10 million in the original bill to Representative Shepard's. With that, Mr. Chairman, I'm good to answer any questions.
Representative Flowers? Yes. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I just wanted to, I guess, express a concern, and this is the same concern I think that I expressed with the initial vote that we took at the beginning of the session with regard to the tax cut in general, my concern is that the first 50% or the lower 50% of wage earners are not being addressed in terms of tax relief, number one.
And number two, when we were meeting about this and having discussions and even with what the governor presented to us in terms of his budget and how we were going to pay for the original $100 million tax cut, that included the repeal of the capital gains. And so I guess my question would be, you know, since that time, we're looking now of rolling back the repeal at an ultimate cost, I'm thinking at about $30 million.
So my question would be, with the budget as tight as it is and with that being part of what was going to pay for the $100 million tax cut, how are we going to pay for it? Where
are we with that? Representative Flowers, thank you for your question. I certainly understand the concerns that you've expressed. Of course, I was someone that had expressed some concerns on the front end with regard to taking away the exemption because this was actually something that was passed two years ago, and I felt that really the point of bringing this bill
is to put back something that was already in place, hopefully bring some consistency to our tax code because these were things that were in place and then were rolled back. I think that as the session has progressed, I think some additional information has come forward and there's been an opportunity for leadership and the governor's office to look at how things stand at this point. I'd like to say, obviously, I would like to be able to run the bill without the amendment,
but also recognize the realities of where we stand. and I appreciate leadership working on this with the governor's office and hopefully coming to a point that's something that a majority can support. Representative Jett probably could address more of the nuts and bolts of the numbers, although I do think the $12 million is, I think the actual cost of this would be, at least initially, would be less than the $12 million.
Thank you. And I'll let DFA, John, with Chairman's permission,
want to come talk or Mr. Leathers come talk about the exact cost and say that way we're not throwing arbitrary numbers around and we'll get the exact cost of it. But I'd also say, Mr. Chairman, if you need to indulge me just for a brief second here, to your point, Representative Flowers, that Representative Saban will be running a bill next week to address some of the lower income earners as well. So this committee will actually hear that bill as well. So some of your concerns will be addressed. Mr. Chairman, with your indulgence, I'd like to have Director Leathers come to the table
and address some of the money issues, the amounts, please.
Go ahead, Representative Leathers, or Mr. Leathers.
Speaker 56
12:21
Does this mean I get a pay raise? Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Tim Leathers from BFA. With the amendment that has been set this morning, the fiscal year impact for $16 million is $6 million. Fiscal year impact for $17 million is $11.8 million.
And as the representatives have presented it today, we're in negotiations with revenue stabilization, and part of that is looking for how we would absorb the $10 million we've already put back in capital gains along with these amounts, and that would be part of that process to do that and would have to be accommodated in that process. Any
other questions from the committee?
If not, Representative Meek, you're recognized. Motion do pass on the amendment. Any discussion on the
motion? Yes, Representative Flowers. I'm sorry, I don't want to belabor this. If I could be indulged, just make one point. Go ahead. Thank you very much. I just, I guess, would like to reiterate that there is an ultimate amount and I appreciate that tax relief is something I think that we all want for our constituents and support. I also appreciate the fact that this is something that was put into place
at the last session, but the point I think that I would like to make is that all of this is a matter of priorities. There is an ultimate amount that we're dealing with, and I think without the fact that we have considered or voted for anything that will address tax relief for the lowest wage earners in this state, which amounts to almost 50 percent of the people who work in the state as well as the fact that we have not come to any consensus at this point
for how we're going to address pre-K. I just think that this is premature, and I think it doesn't reflect the priorities that addresses all of our constituents, especially those who are in the greatest need and who are the hardest working, in many cases, without the benefits and support that all of us enjoy. Thank you. Any other discussion
on the motion? Representative Collins, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
I just would like to share that there's another aspect to capital and capital gains and what they do. When you invest, you create business. When you create business and economic growth, you create jobs. And I would submit that the greatest potential help of these kinds of tax policies is the job creation potential for all Arkansans, not just those who are specifically getting the capital gains reduction directly,
although I certainly recognize that priorities are tough decision calls, and that's not the only way to help lower-income people. But there is another side to it, and that's the job creation side. Thank you. All in favor
of the adoption of the amendment, vote aye. All opposed, no. Motion carried. Yes, we have another amendment. Okay, now you're recognized to explain the
bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Members, of course, there's already been some discussion essentially on this,
but House Bill 1402 after the amendment essentially will put back the exemptions that were previously taken out with regard to capital gains. The percentage exemption of 40% will move to 45% as of February 1, 2015. And then as of July 1, 2016, it moves to 50% exemption. Additionally, the exemption over $10 million will go back into effect.
And with that, I'd be glad to answer any questions and would appreciate a good vote. Members,
any questions? Anybody or not that's going to speak against the bill? Rich, was that a yes or no? Anybody that's speaking for the bill? If not, members, do I have a motion? Representative Neal? I have a motion to do pass. Any discussion, members? All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? Congratulations. You passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Thank you, members of the committee. Members, next up, let's do, once again, let's take something out of order without objection. Representative Bragg, you ready to run your bill? Senate Bill 490, members. And everybody, just for the record, that last bill was, motion was made for do pass as amended. And that's what we took the vote on, as amended.
We're having some handouts passed out on Senate Bill 490. Members, out of objection, we're going to hear Senate Bill 490. Representative
Bragg, how are you doing this morning, sir? Just fine. Thank
you, Mr. Chair. We have two amendments to run. Let's do your first amendment just with the, you're talking
about names, signatures on your first amendment? Yes, Mr. Chair. The first amendment
merely adds some co-sponsors to the bill. Members, this is the first, you heard Representative Bragg, Representative Meeks. Representative makes motion to amendment.
All in favor say aye. Any opposed, no. Representative Bragg, you're good for your second amendment, sir. Okay,
the second amendment takes one section of the bill and makes it a different effective date from the other sections. It's section six of the bill makes it an effective date of January 1, 2017. Members, any questions? on this?
Representative Bragg, do you say January 1st of 2017? Yes, but the financial impact
will be 2018 fiscal year. Mr. Leathers, can you care
to come to the table and just explain that just for the members to make sure we're all on the
Speaker 56
18:59
same page on this, please? Yes, Mr. Chairman. There's an original revenue impact. It was a one-time impact because of the way tax filings are made that would catch one month and would move it out to the next fiscal year when you move these corporate filings out.
There's a provision in there to give an extra time period to file for the corporate filings, and you would lose one month. Technically, the tax would still be due, but you push it out into the next fiscal year. And what this amendment does is it moves that out far enough so it's outside the biennium. It would not occur to our budget until the fiscal year 18 budget. And then it would be a one-time only $700,000 cost. And there's no other cost in this bill.
Members, any questions on the amendment? Anybody in the audience want to speak against the amendment? For the amendment, do I have a motion to adopt the amendment? Representative Meeks has a motion for the adoption of the amendment. All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? Congratulations, Representative Bragg. You're good for your
bill now, sir. Okay, thank you, Mr. Chair. And I also have here Randy Zook and Marvin Childers with me. There was mention made already about creating jobs in Arkansas,
and this bill addresses taxpayer fairness. And, you know, when companies come to locate to Arkansas, one of the things they look at is the tax environment. And Arkansas right now ranks pretty low in some of those categories. So this bill specifically addresses tax fairness issues, not necessarily tax rates or corporate rates, but tax fairness. The Council on State Taxation rates each state according to its tax fairness environment. Right now we have a C- rating.
If this bill passes or when this bill passes, it would bump us up to an A- rating, which would put us above all the surrounding states that we're competing with. So this time I'd ask Mr. Zook to present some of the bill.
Speaker 75
21:06
Thank you, Representative Bragg. Thank you, Mr. Chairman and members of the committee. This is a very important bill to the membership of the State Chamber and the Associated Industries of Arkansas because it does improve the climate,
the business climate in terms of tax administration. And I'd like to be very clear about one issue, about an important aspect of this. We've had incredible cooperation from DF&A in working through these sometimes sort of arcane details about the administration and procedural practices and that sort of thing, which this bill amends and changes slightly to make it easier for businesses and taxpayers to process and apply their taxes and pay their taxes.
This is not about reducing rates or eliminating anything other than some administrative sometimes hurdles, but maybe inconveniences might be a better term. But I in no way want to imply that it's anything other than that and also to express our appreciation to DF&A in the process of working up this bill. As Representative Bragg said, it will improve our standing relative to surrounding states.
And as you know, at the end of the day, when businesses are choosing places to grow or expand or start up, tax administration can have an impact. And it's an important aspect of whether or not we're in the hunt for some of these important location decisions. I'd like to ask Marvin Childers, who chairs our tax committee, to explain some of the particulars of the bill, because he's much more familiar with them than I am. My role here is just to say this is a really good bill,
and we would appreciate a good vote from
you. Thank you. I thought you was going to tell us your roles be the pretty one at the end of the table. I didn't know. I wouldn't go that far, Representative Jett, although it would be a true claim. Well, I don't know about
Speaker 78
23:12
that. So Mr. Parks, you recognize yourself, and you're good to go, buddy. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. members of the committee. I'm Marvin Childers. I am co-chairman of the tax committee at the state chamber. And as Randy said, I mean, this bill was driven by the cost scorecard. And you've got some information from cost that was handed out.
I would be remiss if I didn't also say a special thanks to DF&A. We have worked on this bill for many, many months. And as you can imagine, we started on one end and DF&A started on the other, but after several meetings, we found common ground, and I appreciate DF&A's work. What I'd like to do is just briefly step you through. Basically, what we looked at was the scorecard, and there are actually eight points on the scorecard.
We weren't able to reach agreement on one, so we left it off. That's why, as Representative Bragg said, we may still be an A-minus as opposed to an A-plus. But the seven sections of the bill deal with the other seven scores on that scorecard. In Section 1 of the bill, basically, the scorecard talks about even-handed statutes of limitations. And in the previous law, that statute was eight years, and you can see we've cut that to three.
Section 2 of the bill extends the claim period for refunds and offsets in audit situations. So in Section 2, if a taxpayer was audited for underreported income and DF&A can now go back, say, six, seven years, This would also allow the taxpayer to look at their records,
and if they had deductions or claims for refunds, they would be entitled to make those claims for the same period of time that DF&A is auditing the taxpayer. But I would point out, and this is one point where we agreed, the taxpayer under-reports their income and finds claims for refunds. Those refunds shouldn't be more than the tax that was assessed, And that was a compromise that we reached with the Department of Finance and Administration.
Section 3 of the bill changes the taxpayer's burden of proof in tax appeal cases from clear and convincing evidence to a preponderance of the evidence. Section 4 of the bill provides some transparency. All opinions or decisions that DF&A reaches in tax cases or tax issues now will be made available to the public on their website. They'll simply redact the taxpayer's information.
They'll be made available. Section 5 is a big deal with cost. It's a pay-to-play. Previously, a taxpayer who attempts to appeal a tax decision from DF&A had to pay all of the tax before they could appeal. This changes that and eliminates what we call or in cost calls pay-to-play. Section 6, as you've already heard from Representative Bragg, it adjusts the corporate income tax return filing dates to April 15th.
and then section 7 lengthens the period to file claims for overpayment and the period for filing claims for business overpayments of local taxes as to cities and counties is extended from 6 months to 1 year Mr. Chairman, that's the basics, the nuts and bolts of the bill and I'd be glad to try to answer any questions from the committee. Well, first of all, my apologies. I think
I called you Marvin Parks a while ago, so please don't hold that against me. I guess my first question, Marvin, would be, has Municipal League or City or County, I mean County Association,
Speaker 78
27:30
none of those folks, any pushback on any of this stuff? Initially, Mr. Chairman, we had that, in Section 7, we had the six months to three years and we, on the Senate We amended the bill to one year, and the cities and counties both appeared in the Senate committee,
and I think we have representatives from the cities and counties here, so I would not want to speak for them. But they did not speak against the one year
in the Senate. Okay. I'll see what Mr. Jones, if he's got anything to say later on here in just a little bit.
Members, any questions? Representative Meeks? Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Last go-around, last, I guess it was in the fiscal session, we had the issue with the tax on the sand with the oil and gas haulers.
Are you familiar with that issue? Just a little bit. I'm just wondering if this had anything to do with that because it sounded like they were trying to make sure that on the tax code language that we're using the plain language and trying to keep that in a box and not allow broad interpretation or reinterpretation of that? Is that one of the goals or no? I do not
Speaker 78
28:44
think this bill addresses that. Okay. All right. Thank you. Members, any other questions?
Anybody in the audience wants to speak against the bill, for the bill? Do we have a motion for the bill? Representative Davis? Representative Davis makes a motion for do pass. As amended. Any discussion? All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no. Congratulations. You passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair and committee. You're welcome. Members, since we're doing all these out of order, we'll do one more out of order without objection. Representative Rushing, you ready, ma'am? Members, this be Senate
Senate Bill 925. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I have my person of knowledge here with me, Ed Alice, on behalf of the utility companies and AT&T. Senate Bill 925, basically it will apply when a disaster strikes Arkansas. The utility companies they will bring in, as you know, they bring in electric and telecommunications and gas companies from different states to help us out of our situation at the time.
And right now, they are having to pay Arkansas taxes as a non-residence for coming in for those temporary services when they're really not here but just to help. And so 925 will temporarily suspend normal non-resident income tax requirements. these can only be suspended in limited emergencies that are declared by the governor or by the president. It's a temporary exclusion for 60 days or if there's an extension by the governor or the
president then it will go into effect for as long as they say that will. The benefits to the state is that we can kind of return to some kind of normalcy because every time that we're out of business and there's a, I think Vilonia was a very good example, some businesses got hit. They were not able to collect the sales tax, so we need to get up our businesses and our infrastructure back running as quickly as possible in order to keep our sales tax coming,
in order to keep our businesses thriving. And the revenue impact statement that DNF&A has said is the impact is speculative based on whether and when the disaster occurs. As more states enact this legislation, there will basically be limited revenue impact. Right now it's enacted in 12 states and it's being pursued in Arkansas,
Oklahoma, Louisiana, Mississippi, Kansas, and Texas. and I will open it up for questions that hopefully I or Mr. Ellis can answer Thank you, can I have Tim you don't care to come to the table, I just got
one quick question for you please sir, I don't know if any other members got a question Mr. Chairman Tim Leathers from DFA, thank you Tim I guess my question would be how did you work through the methodology, what was your thought process of this being revenue neutral
I don't know if you call it
Speaker 56
32:08
revenue neutral Well, the end result here. Yes, sir. We look at this. We have a situation when if our folks leave the state to these other states that have adopted this law, then we get that income tax so it offsets this. So that's the logic behind it. More and more states are doing this. It makes it fair for these businesses that have an emergency situation and for the communities there to be able to get those people in. And, you know, we know it creates a lot of confusion on the taxpayer's part
and trying to do it for that short period of time. And, frankly, probably a lot of that gets lost in the shuffle and may not get reported right. But it was that offset because we will get, if someone leaves here and goes to the other states that have this, then we will still be able to collect that tax
to offset that. Thank you very much. That's a good explanation. Members, anybody have questions for Mr.
Speaker 88
33:06
Lemons? You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Is there a definitive timeline as to how long this would exist after a state of emergency?
Is it 30 days, 60 days? It's 60 days. It is
60, okay. Unless it's extended by the President or the Governor. Okay, thank you. President Collins. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Rushing, I just want to make sure I understand. So we've got two disaster workers. They're in two different states. Currently, if they were assigned to disasters in the other person's state, there's some double taxation, there's complexity, administration, and all types of other things. And where we're headed with passage of this bill is that the disaster workers in each state,
regardless of where they're assigned to do disaster work, will be paying home state income taxes. So the bottom line is, when this is all said and done and the other states have joined us, no worker will be paying taxes in two different states and Arkansas workers will be paying Arkansas income taxes even if they do disaster work in another state. Is that correct ma'am? That's a
Members, any other questions? Anybody not? Representative
Gene, he was just yawning. I thought he wanted a question so. Anybody honest want to to speak against the bill, for the bill. Representative Rushing, you're closed for your bill, man? I'm closed for my bill. Thank you, Representative Jett. You bet. We have a motion for due pass from Representative Dotson. Any discussion? All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? Congratulations, you passed your bill. You bet. Is Representative Bentley in the room by any chance? We're done, right?
Members, without objection, we're going to adjourn. Thank you.
Agenda
SB341
HB1178
HB1402
SB490
SB925
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Matthew J. Shepherd
Unverified
Representative Brent Talley
Unverified
Representative Stephen Meeks
Unverified
Speaker 14
Representative Kim Hendren Chair
Unverified
Senator Missy Irvin
Unverified
Representative Mathew W. Pitsch
Unverified
Speaker 32
Speaker 56
Representative Charlie Collins
Unverified
Representative Ken Bragg
Unverified
Speaker 75
Speaker 78
Representative Laurie Rushing
Unverified
Speaker 88
Speaker 91