House Judiciary Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (5)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1660
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1660”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1884
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “Is that House Bill 1884? Okay, you recognize, without objection, you're recognized…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1908
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “All right, without objection, we're going to take up House Bill 1908.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1728
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1728”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB746
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB746”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 15, 2026
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, committee. Appreciate the opportunity. 1728 is fairly simple. It is a, I'll call it a fingerprint bill, and basically what it is, and this is endorsed by ACIC. I talked to Brad Cozart and to Jay Winters,
and they both are in favor of this and says this is happening. What is actually happening? When someone is arrested for probation revocation, they are being fingerprinted again, and this is showing up. It doesn't produce another SID number, but it does produce an additional file, scannable file. And so when an employer, a background check, they're seeing two felonies, and this is not a second felony, but it's showing up because they're being fingerprinted again.
And so what this bill does is basically says that if someone is arrested for probation revocation, they cannot be, or parole violation, they cannot be fingerprinted again for that. And the bill says if they get arrested for additional crime that is already allowable for fingerprinting, we fingerprint them again, but not for just the revocation or for
violation. Representative Copeland, the only question I have is on a violation or revocation,
what tools are utilized to just verify the identity of the individual on that? Yes,
sir. Thank you for the question. From everything I'm – the way I understand it is when they are – by identifying them, they look up their information and they see that they're already in the system fingerprinted. And I'm not sure why they're being – and I hope I'm answering your question. I'm not sure why they're being fingerprinted again. And I don't think it's any ill intent or anything because in talking to some of the
Sheriff's Association, they were not even aware it was a problem, but ACIC says it definitely is a problem, and it needs to be addressed. Is there any opposition to your bill? No, sir. No one that I've spoken with. Okay, I see no questions. No one
has signed up to speak for or against the bill. Are you closed for your bill? Yes, sir. What's the pleasure of the committee? I'll
We have a motion to do pass. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? The bill passes. Thank you, Chairman. Thank you, Committee. Representative Beck, which bill are you wanting to run? 1908.
All right, without objection, we're going to take up House Bill 1908.
be an amendment on the tablet the amendment to this bill First thing it does, I had originally co-sponsored the bill and Representative Douglas had sponsored it and it just basically switches the roles between us. So now I would be the primary sponsor of the bill. The rest of the bill, it's really just language. We had my friend here go through it and look from the legal aspect
and we changed some terms as far as some of the terms that were used in the original bill were not easily recognized in a court of law. So we changed some deals there. Plus, we added Section 2 onto this, which has to do with the court cost and who's
right. Do you move the adoption of the amendment? Yes. Okay. We have a motion to adopt the amendment. Is there any discussion? All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? The amendment is
adopted. You're recognized to present the bill. Thank
you, committee. Certainly in my area, there's a lot of eminent domain action going on. This is going on with gas line companies, with oil line companies, and we've talked somewhat about some even transmission lines in these corridors. And this is inevitably going to come to be a bigger problem because as we get more congested and and there's more need for these projects, it's just going to be more interface or interference,
I guess I should say, between some of these eminent domain things and the landowners. What this bill basically does is it gives the landowner a little bit, it gives them some tools to use when their land is going to be condemned for eminent domain purposes. I'd like to tell you about an example. I have a farm out in the country, and just recently there was a pipeline company that came to me, and we started to work out the agreement, and the next thing the person said was,
you know we have eminent domain on this project. And my next question to that person was, well, what does that mean? And he says, well, if we can't work out a deal with you, I just turned it over to another division of his company. He said, and they'll make you an offer, and that'll be what the offer is, and that's the way it'll go. Now, as a landowner, I guess I could have fought it and everything, but think about that. All of a sudden, my land is under attack, and if I want to fight back, I've got to put my money on the line to what may or may not ever be resolved.
What this bill basically does is it gives me some course of action as a property owner, And what it says is that I'm entitled to receive fair market value for my property. It also sets up a system to where if I don't agree with the price, I can take it before court, determine that fair price, and if I've been offered an unfair price, then the individuals who offer me that unfair price are responsible for that, and they're going to have to pay the legal fees as far as my costs associated with defending my rights.
And that's the general summary of this bill. I guess I could take some questions. If there's some legal questions, I'm going to let my friend here answer those.
Representative Copeland, you're recognized for a question.
Representative Beck, isn't the highway department already instituting this to some degree? I heard that, and could you speak to that, please? Yes. Thanks
for that question. It was the payment clause on this thing is almost identical to what the highway department is being used
as far as when they try to exercise the eminent domain. There is one difference, however. To make it a little bit more lenient, the highway department has to offer within 10%. In this bill, we actually upped that to 20% to give them just a little bit more
room within this bill. I have a question. Does your bill apply, it seems to apply only to eminent domain, but does it apply to the rights that, would it apply to the rights that are exercised by a mineral owner in the leasing and drilling of oil and gas wells?
I certainly didn't intend it. It's really just eminent domain. Those are purchased leases, right? And then, it's my understanding, but... I mean, a mineral owner
has a right to develop, to explore and produce the minerals. So there may not be any agreement with the surface owner if the minerals have been severed. And my only concern is, because we've seen other bills in the past that have attempted to restrict the use of the property by oil and gas companies in particular,
and I just want to clarify, I don't think that they utilize eminent domain. I mean, eminent domain generally is only for a governmental entity. As I understand your bill, it is only directed at the use of eminent domain. It is not directed at any use by a mineral owner or an assignee of a lease in the expiration and production of that. But I just want to make sure that that is, in fact, the case.
That is correct. I just heard a little voice tell me that, that it
didn't apply. thank you because we have had in the past there have been landowners bill of bills of rights so to speak bills that were brought that would have placed restrictions on some of that and while I'm I just would want to understand the full implication of this bill if that if that's what this covered it does not Okay. Any questions?
Representative House, you're recognized for a question. I
read through this. What does this bill do that's not already in present case law? And if you would, state your
name and who you represent, and you can answer the question. I'm
Speaker 43
10:20
Brandon Moffitt. I'm an attorney with Moffitt and Phillips, a law firm here in Little Rock, Arkansas, and I represent property owners across the state in eminent domain and condemnation actions.
The majority of this bill is in line with the current law. The only changes would be in paragraph or subpart five. grabbed them, it would be B, subpart 5, in regard to the offer. Right now, there is no requirement that the condom nor the person condemning the property
provide their appraisal prior to condemnation. And what subpart 5 requires is that anybody condemning property must provide the land owner a basis for their offer and this is important because many of my clients come to me and they say such and such entity offered me ten thousand dollars for my property and I say well how did they get to ten thousand dollars and they say I don't know you know they didn't provide me comps they didn't provide me an appraisal or anything like that so sub part five actually
requires the condemning authority to give the landowner an assessment, how they reach their offer. The only other major change is in subpart 11, which adds attorney's fees, the potential to recover attorney fees, costs, and expenses to all entities using condemnation in Arkansas. Currently only, I think in 2013, there was a provision added to the highway department's statutory scheme
that would require reimbursement if the landowner obtained more than 10% above the offer. In visiting with the highway department and really working with them over the past 15, 16 months for my clients, we looked at this and we tried to take a balanced approach. And the highway department, there was another bill filed where they had sought to raise it to 20%. And I believe that in this bill, you know, working with the sponsors, we took the 20% and think it's fair.
And what this provision really does is bring the condom nor to the table. In my experience, prior to 2013, often we would get these offers with very little, you know, we would counter offer and then they would just say, no, we did up trying the case and current costs. And that places the burden on the landowner to go get their own appraisal. I know the committee is probably not aware of this, but in a condemnation case, there's a specific type of appraisal you must have before and after appraisal.
That appraisal typically costs anywhere from $2,500 to $10,000 because they're very extensive. And so, you know, if a landowner is being offered $25,000 and they think their property is worth $50,000, they've got to come on the front end, they've got to hire an attorney, and go get at least a $2,500 appraisal just to go and negotiate. This balances the table a little bit, the bill, because number five, subpart five, says the condom noor has to give them their appraisal.
That will allow my clients to bring it to me. And then if there is a need to go litigate the case, it allows the landowner to recoup their cost if they get more
than 20%. Yes. Condemnation cases, I go get my appraiser, they go get their appraiser. Mine says that they owe me a whole bunch of money. And theirs says, gosh, you need to be paying us for even coming through here, which is great.
But, and the truth's usually somewhere in between, what's to keep a condom nor from just low-balling the appraisal? They're going to get their person to do it anyway. The condom nor or the person taking the
so this requires them to provide the owner with an appraisal. Yes. What's to say they're not going to go ahead and just give the standard low-ball appraisal? Well, there's consequences if you
Speaker 43
14:50
adopt this bill, and that would be if you end up going to court,
they're going to end up reimbursing the landowner, their attorney's fees and costs. If there's a 20% differential. If there's a 20% differential, as well as their expert fees and costs to bring the case, deposition costs, et cetera. so um i believe that that is enough incentive for a condom nor to not bring lowball offers i mean i don't the only alternative would be to add some kind of penalty clause and that's not what
we're seeking to do we're trying to level the field get everybody at the table and and empower landowners to uh make decisions about whether or not to accept offers to be provided information they'll have that one more
question i ran into a situation with a constituent uh church in uh in my district just a few weeks ago a couple months ago and um a city actually not in my district condemned a good portion of their parking lot in their church and were willing to pay for the
parking lot. However, there was no offer for damages to the remainder. Now you've got a nice church, but no place to park any cars. And I was informed by an attorney that the cities have no obligation to pay for damage to the remainder. Yet the highway department does have an obligation to pay for damage to the remainder, as I understand it. Would this change that relationship in any way?
Speaker 43
16:34
Well, the attorney you got advice from is actually incorrect.
All condom doors, just compensation encompasses damages to the remaining property. So in the church's position, and I actually have a case like this as well, the new roadway come in, remove parking. It actually could change the highest and best use of the building. And that gets into a lot of technical stuff as far as valuation and it's really kind of I'll be happy to talk to you after we get out of here so they do have to pay damages to the remaining property so for your church but what this bill would do is if the condemning authority the municipality
did not offer damages to the remainder and then when you the church got their appraisal and the appraiser included that amount, and it would exceed the 20% floor, not only would they have the opportunity to recover that in the jury trial, they would also have the chance to recover their attorney's fees cost, any expert cost, et cetera. So that's what's good about this bill, is it applies it to every condom nor that uses Arkansas law to take property. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Representative Copeland, you're recognized for a question.
Can you explain the 10 that the highway department has now and the 20 that you guys are proposing? You're proposing 20, they're proposing 10. When I first heard that, I thought, well, you're overreaching more than them, but actually it's the opposite. Would you explain that, please? Back
Speaker 43
18:06
in 2013 when the highway department statute was enacted, they have a 10% floor currently. The highway department bill, the bill that was filed this session for the highway department was to raise that 10 to 20%.
So it's actually raising the floor a little bit. We did that in part to ease the concerns about any type of, you know, 10% is not enough. You know, appraisers, there's differences of opinion and things like that. So we went to the highway department, and it's my understanding they support this bill as well. It raises the floor. It gives larger room for air on the condom door. It's a safeguard, and it gives landowners opportunity to, you know, recover their costs.
And we're not talking about 10%. We're talking about 20%. So it's something that's more reasonable that most that was raised and concerned that maybe 10% was unreasonable. So we took it to 20%, and I'm comfortable with that. All right. I see no further
questions. No one has signed up to speak for or against the bill. Oh, you have? You're recognized.
Speaker 64
19:34
Okay. You're recognized. Mr. Chairman, Mark Whitmore with the Association of Arkansas Counties. We signed up before the break. I apologize. First of all, you know, Senator Randy Laverty had a saying around here that words matter. It's like the difference between lightning and lightning bug. And what we've got here is a pretty big shift. With county government, when we do easements for roads, lots of folks are, you know, happy to get the, in that domain or happy to get the road, often donate.
In county government, it's a rare event that we even have to use in that domain. County judges are pretty judicious about that. More than fair, you go to county court, and if there's an issue, you can appeal. and that what happens in American jurisprudence, there's the American rule in which, under the American rule, the parties pay their own attorney's fees. Under the English rule, it's prevailing party pays the other party's attorney's fees. And what's problematic about this is that right now,
I assure you that county government, and you can ask Judge Fide or any of the county judges you know, that are up here at the legislature, they can go a good decade and never have to use the eminent domain. And I'll tell you what's problematic with this particular attorney's fee rule and the reason the county judges oppose it, and we just got this amendment this morning, is that if there's a retaining wall, and it's worth $2,000 in the estimation of the county, and
the landowner says they don't want to provide their land, they're not interested in the road, they say it's worth $10,000. And, you know, the people have the same right as a fair trial as the landowner. And we go to court, and the jury says $2,400. Most reasonable people would say the county was right and that the landowner was asking too much. But under this rule, this 20% rule, even with Clarence Darrow, I mean, 20% of $2,000 is $400.
dollars. So a jury would say, pay them an extra $400. And yet what would happen, based upon this way this is drafted, would be the county would have to pay their appraiser and their attorney's fees when everybody would say, well, the county won that case. And I can't explain, you know, the highway department's got an unusual rule they live under. And anybody that inquires will tell you that it is costing them a lot of money to write a
lot of checks. It doesn't necessarily achieve justice but right now we sort of live by the theory that in county government this just isn't broken. We're not aware of any instance which a county government has been a problem in the area of eminent domain and just like the highway department we're not we think that if you provide this rule that we'll just have to get the checkbook out because the lawyers will find out when these in the domains are occurring and
they're all going to be situated to say I can get you you know all kinds of money and that's not justice everybody always wants to focus on the taxpayer well the people have the right of fair trial too and this rule it's not the English rule It's not the American rule. It actually results in which a lot of cases in which the landowner was not correct, did not win the case. It's not the providing party.
And 20%, when we're doing easements, county roads, attorney's fees are a whole lot more than easements. When we do a county road, we're widening the road or putting a road out there to benefit people's property, the value before and after. I can assure you attorney's fees are a lot more money than these easements. So the cost of building county roads and when we ever get to build them or widen them it's going to go up. If you don't believe me ask the highway department because they've just got a big checkbook out and yes they would
like it to go up from 10 to 20 percent but if you look at other states a lot of people have the American rule a lot of people have the English rule but this is none of the above. This actually will result. I had over 70 jury trials and you go into court arguing over what person's lands were and an appraiser can come in 10 or 20 percent but sometimes landowners just don't want to give their land and they're not going to resolve it. But 20 percent is the difference between
how much some trees are worth or rose bushes and oftentimes the landowner is not the prevailing party. They were wanted two, three times that, very commonly so. So we would ask, I mean, this just came up today. I would implore you to talk to your county judges. Is it broken? Do we need to put attorneys on the counties when there's nothing wrong with the counties? Do we need to have the attorneys injected in the county court over road easements?
this would apply in a lot of other cases but we would suggest that if it's not broke on the county level why pursue this
thank you for your comments I see no questions we have someone signed up to speak for the bill Rita Looney if you'll state your name and who you represent and you may make your statement
Speaker 65
25:29
good afternoon I'm Rita Looney I'm Chief Counsel at the Highway Department.
And Mark and I are, sometimes we share the same opinion about attorney's fees and such, and in fact, I share the same opinion that I don't like the idea that we are required to pay attorney's fees and costs on these cases. But two years ago, when I sat before this same committee, some of the same people, some of you different folks, There was a bill that was not introduced by the Highway Department. In fact, we opposed it, but this body enacted the law whereby people whose property is condemned by the Highway Department
are entitled to receive attorney's fees if the amount awarded is 10% more than what the deposit is. Well, my argument then and my argument today is 10% is de minimis. That is just the difference between the opinion of two reasonable appraisers. And because that is such a low threshold, it requires, or at least in good business judgment, a hard look at those deposits and whether or not it's just more efficient to settle cases than to risk.
As Mr. Moffitt said, quite frankly, these appraisers, it's expensive. And so with a 10% low threshold of that difference between what was deposited and what the jury awards, we could have a little sliver of property that we're acquiring for $1,000 to expand the width of a road. and if that jury gave them $1,100, it could cost the state as much as $25,000 for a $100 difference.
That's the kind of thing that is the reason I'm here to support this bill to increase that threshold from a 10% threshold of the difference between what we've deposited to what is actually awarded so that there is more reasonableness in looking at the jury verdicts and then also the award of attorney's fees and costs for those parties.
Thank you. John Wilkerson, you may take a seat and you will be speaking against the bill.
Speaker 67
28:02
John Wilkerson with the Municipal League I don't want to belabor a lot of Mr. Whitmore's points I will say that I was just notified of the bill as I walked into the committee this morning I don't think it's any fault that Mr. Moffat or Representative Beck this all happened very quickly and I appreciate Mr. Moffat sitting down with me and talking with me about the bill and I certainly understand his points and as far as a 20% increase we obviously have no objection to the highway department getting that but um since this is happening so quickly and since it's this is really a watershed
change for the way that cities do eminent domain um we don't know we can we're worried about what it will do we want to make sure that we can at least have a chance to look at what it could do and maybe maybe at least sit down and try to figure out a way through this and and i try to get to the committee a little early this afternoon with representative beck so i apologize we did talked with Representative Douglas, and she has agreed to meet with us tomorrow morning before State Agencies Committee to talk about this bill. Again, the intent of the bill is not,
I certainly understand Mr. Moffat's points, but because it's such a big change, we'd like at least a chance to make sure that we have our arguments in a row, and we can come back to you and tell you exactly what we know it's going to do. I can tell you what I think it's going to do, but there's some issues here that this the way eminent domain law works, this may allow an inverse condemnation which is not an eminent domain to get rolled into this bill because the way the law reads so this may not just be about eminent domain, it may be about inverse condemnations and so
forth. So we would just at least like to have the chance to sit down, analyze this and have a real discussion about it. Thank you Mr. Chairman and the committee members. Okay, I see no
questions. Thank you for your testimony. I believe that's everybody we had signed up. Representative Beck, you're recognized to close for your bill. Thank you,
Mr. Chairman. I understand all the points that we're trying to make here,
the opposition to this bill we're trying to make. But if you really boil these down, what this bill says is, as a landowner, it's in the person who gets eminent domain's best interest to make you a good offer. The scales, you're right. We could delay this, and we could keep the scales tipped way in the favor of eminent domain, and people could just keep running over private individuals' properties. I'm well amended to come back the next time.
If we find that 20% is too tight, we've already talked to the people who deal with 10%. We've taken it to 20%, and they seem to think 20% is going to be fine. It's just a fair bill. Landowners deserve to be offered a fair amount. You just heard the – I'm sorry, I didn't catch your name, but talk about how the reason we need to go up to 20% is because she felt that that was within the realm that a good appraiser could give you for the property.
So what that says is instead of you, whether it be whoever, goes out and says, okay, your land's worth $1,000 because I said it's worth $1,000. Well, now you're going to be on the mark for that, all right? And I'm going to go get an appraiser, and your little shoot-from-the-hip appraisal is going to cost you the cost of that. And that's all this bill does. It says make a fair offer, give the landowner the right to his property, to their property, excuse me. And anyway, I guess I'll close from a bill, and I'd appreciate a good vote.
Do recommend do pass as amended. Okay, we have a motion. Do pass as amended. Any discussion? All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? No. The ayes have it. The bill passes as amended. Thank you, committee. I'm going to try and take up two more bills. Representative Hammer.
Is that House Bill 1884? Okay, you recognize, without objection, you're recognized to present House Bill 1884. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
For the sake of time, may I introduce my guest today to speak on this? I'm
Speaker 80
32:44
Lieutenant Cora Gentry with the Arkansas State Police. I supervise the concealed carry section. I'm going to
put a real small front porch on this when we get to the question period of this bill, Mr. Chairman. That's a good idea. I respect for the we've got to be somewhere. This bill is intended to address issues associated with individuals
who move into Arkansas from other states and have a concealed weapon permit. There are a few points to consider that we need to consider when we bring this bill before us. Number one is not all other states have the same standards of expectations of somebody that carries a concealed weapon permit such as Arkansas. Some have some very loose standards out there in reality. And the other thing is that once somebody establishes residency in the state of Arkansas at a certain point in time, they need to get a concealed weapon license as it would pertain here to Arkansas.
So this is intended to help in the process, make it as simple as possible, and make it seamless in the transfer of somebody who moves in from out of state that moves into this state and how they go about getting their permanent license. And with that, I'd like to let Cora maybe add a few more points, and
Speaker 80
33:57
we'll open it up to questions if that's okay. Okay. Fine with me. I think you summarized it very well. Are there any questions? This does not affect any license that we honor. We still honor any other state's license, so this just applies to people that move into Arkansas standards for Arkansas residents.
All right, I see no questions. I don't believe anybody has signed up to speak for or against the bill. Representative Hammer, are you closed for your bill? I'll close and ask for a do-pass. We have a motion to pass. Any discussion? All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? The bill passes. Thank you. All right, the final bill we're going to take up, Representative Ratliff. House Bill 1660. We've got an amendment.
Speaker 90
34:49
Mr. Chair, we have an amendment we need to adopt. You recognize? We have an amendment that we need to adopt. I think it's been passed out. Okay,
it should be on the tablet. Yes. Is there a motion to adopt the amendment? Representative Vines? Sure.
We have a motion to adopt the amendment. Any discussion? All in favor of adopting the amendment, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? All right, you're now recognized to present the bill as amended. House Bill 1660. Okay, folks, this bill is
Speaker 90
35:36
an act to modify the calculation of parole eligibility for certain inmates in the Department of Correction with controlled substance felonies. The reason I bring this bill before you guys is I've got a couple of folks
back home that's been incarcerated for the last 35 to 40 years, and they'd like to get out and go home. They're both in their 60s, and, you know, they're not going to be any harm to anybody out there now. And they're going to be, in my opinion, they're going to be a burden to the prison system because they're getting older and needing health care and need was replaced and all these type things. But I would really – and I feel like the new laws that we have now is these guys are sentenced under an older law,
And it really did create a – and it might help prison overcrowding if we need some of this. All right.
I see no questions. We're going to go to the list to speak for and against the bill. First up, Bob McMahon speaking against the bill. If y'all would make room for him at the end of the table. Sure. if you would state your name who you represent and you may offer your testimony
Speaker 92
36:58
thank you mr chairman committee members i'm bob mcmahon with the prosecutors association i'll be very very brief the prosecutors obviously are opposed to this bill for a couple of reasons a little bit of background here in 2011 when act 570 was passed it was a compromise between prosecutors and and everyone else involved including the governor's office and many of of you all that are still here for that. One of the things the prosecutors would never agree to, and it was part of the reason we were able to compromise on that bill because this was not put in there, was the fact that we opposed any retroactivity. What this bill does is does
exactly that. This would counter truth in sentencing. People made decisions with jury trials, with parole eligibility in mind. So decisions were made based on the law at the time. And in fact, even defendants knew their eligibility when they cut deals that they may have negotiated a plea on so for those two reasons um we are still opposed to this bill similar bill was filed two years ago we were just as consistent today and we opposed it then and we oppose it now and i'll be happy to answer any questions all right i see no questions thank
you for your testimony thank you mr chairman going back to the list we have mr frolich recognized to speak for the bill. If you would, state your name, who you represent, and then you may make your statement.
Well, my name is Larry Froelich. I'm a public citizen. I fancy that I represent the inmates and some of the administrators in the Department of Corrections that I've talked to, none present here today. But if you mean I'm getting paid, well, I'm not representing anybody.
I appreciate the opportunity to participate. We start out by praising the body that we're in front of, but I can sincerely say that the people at this legislature are so hardworking, and I'm very much impressed with your work ethic. As I said, I'm thankful and proud of you and humbled by the opportunity to participate in this process. process. So what I'm going to do is I'm going to tell you about why this bill is needed, how it would work
and why it's a good idea. Basically the purpose of House Bill 1660 is to reduce prison overcrowding, create space by accelerating parole eligibility for a targeted group of inmates basically drug offenders sentenced under serving sentences which exceed the amounts currently allowed by law. And there's some
background to that. And the nature of the background that I'd like to draw to your attention is that in 1970 this state had a total of 1,369 inmates, men and women, 1,369. We've had a 50% increase in population basically. And so if we were punishing people at the same rate, incarcerating them at the same rate, we would expect to have about 2,054 in our system.
Instead, on Monday, we had 17,800 plus, almost 900 inmates in the system, directly in the prison system, 2,456 waiting in the county, plus another 1,605 locked down under community punishment, which means we've got almost 22,000 people in the system now, which is 10 times as much as we would expect just based on the population increase. And I certainly do not believe that the people of Arkansas are 10 times as wicked and evil
as they were in 1970. Now, a lot of things have changed, and maybe we are a little bit more wicked, but the main thing that's changed was the Controlled Substances Act, which was passed in 1971 just as the increase started. Now, what we were trying to do with that act was to try to incarcerate our way out of the drug problem.
I mean, plain and simple. Lock them up and throw away the key. And as years went on, we just increased the punishment for drug offenses so much that for the last 25 or 30 years, the punishment was the same no matter how much it was. A thimble or a suitcase was the same. life in prison, same as the murder. So, in other words, small amounts were punished the same as large amounts. Now, over the years, law enforcement developed techniques that were
very efficient and effective at apprehending and convicting petty drug dealers. And as a result, our prisons are now filled to overflowing with petty drug dealers, grinding out their lives behind bars, $22,000 a year, to the taxpayer. Now, our laws are like our father, and father needs to be respected, and the laws need to be respected, but punishment needs to be proportionate,
and when father can be too strict sometimes, and that's where we were, and so some years back, We lowered the punishments. We made them proportionate. And so the way this bill would work is like this. Let's suppose that somebody was sentenced to prison for 60 years for the sale of a half a gram of cocaine. The current punishment for that amount is 10 years.
And so what this bill would do would allow for the calculation of parole based on the maximum punishment for the offense that the inmate committed. And so in that case, it would be 10 years rather than the 60. Now, Patrick Robertson was a petty drug dealer here in Pulaski County. In 1992, he sold a half gram of cocaine to an undercover agent. He was 19 years old. We sentenced him to 60 years in prison.
He's still there. We've already spent $450,000 punishing him for a $100 black market transaction. He's got another 14 years to serve if this bill isn't enacted, another 14 years to serve before he's eligible for parole. That's another almost $300,000. dollars, we will have spent a quarter of a million dollars, three quarters of a million dollars, punishing this one person. Now, this is not an isolated case. I have several here. Dwayne Withers,
life in prison for six grams. Maximum punishment for him now is 20. Reginald Knowles, 40 years for less than a tenth of a gram. Raimondo Edwards, 60 for four-tenths of a gram. Charles Wilson, 40 for or less than two-tenths of a gram. So we're really beating ourselves up with these guys. Now, this bill has been carefully crafted and looking to get the maximum gain, the greatest gain, with the least risk.
And there have been expressed concerns, and I'm familiar with the concerns that would be expressed by the prosecutor's office, Now, so I'm going to address some of the unstated concerns by saying what this bill does not do. First thing, it does not reduce any sentences. It accelerates parole, but it doesn't reduce any sentences. It will not benefit any violent offenders, and no sex offenders will get one bit of benefit from it.
It benefits no inmate out of this target group, which is people serving sentences that are no longer allowed under current law. The change will affect no permanent change in the parole laws, because it only affects this targeted group convicted before August of 2013. And once they're done with, well, then there's no permanent change. And so it only targets a fixed number of inmates.
Second, there's no automatic release. The fact that the parole eligibility is pushed up, the inmates still have to go in front of the parole board. If they've got violent offenses, or there's some concern about whether or not they can function outside of a prison setting, then we can turn them down. And so there's no automatic release, and it won't cost us anything. In fact, this will be revenue positive because it's cheaper to have people on parole than it is to have them in prison.
Now, it will result in some early release for certain inmates, and that's the purpose of the bill. And some people are just opposed to that. I understand that. They're there. If they're there, they belong there, and I don't want them to get out. But the problem with that is the cost. Now, this bill would task the department with a new assignment, but it would only be to have to be done once.
Now, we feel like that there are three good reasons to enact this bill. I might say I understand that something happened in 2011 and a deal was struck. I hope that doesn't mean that we won't forever be barred from further reform. But we have three good reasons to grant the relief, and I would say that it's the right thing to do, and it will save us a lot of money.
Now, two of the reasons have to do with the twin purposes of prison, the twin purposes of incarceration. and I call them the twin pillars of criminal justice. Punishment and deterrence. Punishment and deterrence. Now, since the targeted group are serving sentences that can no longer be imposed on anyone, their continued punishment is not a deterrent to anybody.
So, all right. So, there's, So continuing to punish these inmates serves no deterrent factor, and that eliminates one of the pillars of the justice system. The other is the punishment. We have to punish people for doing wrong, but we've reconsidered the amount of punishment that's appropriate,
it. And so now I think that punishment beyond the maximum allowed by law really doesn't serve any good purpose. And I know they struck deals based on how it was then, but that's why we have so many people in the prison. Now there's a third reason. And the third reason is that the present legal situation has created two categories of inmates. That
is, those receiving two categories of inmates, classes, receiving unequal punishment for the same crimes. Now, I know that the inmates and their families feel like that's unfair. We got people sitting in there, some coming in and leaving before these other guys and And they're still there. They're people now getting probation for what people are serving 60 or 100 years for. And so, and it also creates, I know it creates administrative problems for the department
inside because they can't explain to the inmates why people are coming and going and they've done the same thing that they've done. So we feel like that this is a compliment to the rest of the forum and that what most of what we've done mostly by increasing probation officers and doing the other good things that we're probably going to do is we've done prospective in the future. What this bill does is give us some relief now.
And it will create now. And we have the equivalent of two and a half prisons full of people waiting to go in, in the county jail. And no violent offenders will be of benefit, and it's a targeted group. This committee in the past, and this legislature in the past, has done the hard part. You've lowered punishments. You ran the risk of being accused of being soft on crime.
So you've done the hard part. But so far, you've left the harvest in the field. there's millions of dollars to be saved and so we would urge you and I would urge you to pass this act, pass it out of committee and reap the harvest of your past labors thank you thank you Mr. Froelich I see no
questions, thank you for your comments we're going to go back to the list, John Snyder Mr. Chairman, in the interest of time I think of Mr. Mann's
thank you I believe that's all we have signed up on Mr. Young, you signed up earlier I'll go ahead and recognize you for future reference for everybody we do, when we come back in we have a new sign up sheet for staff purposes they have to start over Mr. Young will recognize you I would ask in the interest of time to keep the comments brief we have something that's very important to the speaker later
and if I let this go much longer, I may not be sitting in this chair the
Speaker 107
51:52
next time this committee meets. I certainly understand that, Mr. Chairman. Thank you for allowing me to speak again. Again, I'm Dennis Young. I was on the parole board for 10 months. Just recently was replaced on January the 21st. I can't tell you how many fouls come up as these people have been indicating. These folks need to be out of the system.
When I was a representative, I was real tough on crime, too. I'd gained votes. I thought it was the right thing to do. I helped pass three strikes, and you're out. Some of those folks are still in the prison system right now, and we've got people that were incarcerated two, three years ago. They're up for parole right now, and we've got people in there right now that have been in there 15 and 20 years for the exact same offenses that these people did just a couple of years ago.
The people that did them a couple of years ago are out on the streets. The people that did them 15, 20 years ago, they're still there. Now, who says that's fair? I don't know. I guess that's up to y'all. There was one inmate one day when I went down to Cummins, I believe. He carried my boxes in. We carried those big files in boxes, and we always had somebody down there to carry them in and out for us. This inmate was given a 47-year term for less than 2 grams of cocaine.
That same day, I interviewed someone who had the exact same offense. He was given three years. He was before me for parole. Who says it's fair or not? I don't think it's necessarily unfair, but as these people have said, we have a crying needs for beds, and those beds need to be filled by the heinous crimes.
Let's let some of these folks out who aren't going to do very much damage or little damage or no damage, and put the bad, bad people behind the bars and keep them there. Thank you, and I'll be happy to
answer any questions. I see no questions. Thank you for your testimony. Thank you. Representative Ratliff, would you like to close for your bill?
Thank you all. All right. What's the pleasure of the committee? Representative Whitaker? Motion do pass.
As amended? As amended. Can we have a motion? Do pass as amended. Is there any discussion? Representative
House? Back in the 80s when I was practicing some criminal law, the kind of rule of thumb was if you were first offense, you got out on basically one-sixth of your sentence. But there were some parole eligibility rules, depending on the kinds of offenses that you were sentenced to. It seemed like it was harder to gain good time
if you were convicted of a violent offense than it was if you were convicted of a drug offense, for instance. And that was kind of the rules that we played by. So a guy could go out and commit a heinous crime, a murder or a battery, and would take a plea to a drug offense because you come up under some parole eligibility rules that are more relaxed than the violent offense.
And if I understand the discussion, that's why the prosecutors were mostly concerned about retroactivity at that time because of the rules that everybody played by prior to 570, I think it was. Am I correct? I thought so. So you're right. A conviction for 3.2 ounces of cocaine 10 years ago or 15 years ago and 3.2 ounces of cocaine today are treated differently.
But what of the background of the original sentencing? What were the charges? What was the plea deal? What else was going on? how can we make a blanket judgment about all inmates knowing that there are other factors involved that we don't have in front of us. So based on that, I can't support this bill. And I'd love to clean those prisons out, but I can't do it.
So thank you, Brother Ratliff, for bringing it. I do appreciate it.
Any other discussion? Okay, we have a motion. do pass as amended. All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Aye. I'm going to rule the no's have it. Thank you committee. Appreciate your time. Thank you representative Ratliff. Committee there's one other bill that I've been begged and pleaded to run and if in representative house I'll recognize you and if anybody if there's a question or it turns out to be controversial we're going to pull it down and we'll do it
next next time. Yes sir. Senate bill 746 just requires a court clerk at a district court to provide an electronic or paper accounting of the monies that they handle on a monthly basis to the treasurer, to the county treasurer. So the court takes in money. They need to report that to the treasurer once a month. That's it. Apparently there's no firm guidance on how often they do need to account.
It's checks and balances. Did I say anything wrong? No, sir. That's it. Then I move it be passed. All right. Without objection, we're taking up Senate Bill 746. Representative House has spoken for the bill. I don't believe anybody has signed up to speak for or against the bill. Representative House is closed for the bill. It's moved due pass. Is there any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? The bill passes. Thank you, committee, for your work.
Agenda
HB1728
HB1908
HB1884
HB1660
SB746
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Donnie Copeland
Unverified
Representative Matthew J. Shepherd Chair
Unverified
Speaker 12
Speaker 21
Speaker 23
Representative Rick Beck
Unverified
Speaker 26
Representative Douglas House
Unverified
Speaker 43
Speaker 64
Speaker 65
Speaker 67
Representative Kim Hammer
Unverified
Speaker 80
Speaker 90
Speaker 92
Larry Froelich
Unverified
Speaker 107