Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House Revenue & Taxation Committee

March 24, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (9)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1344 · 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1344”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1176 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1176”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1239 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “I'm sorry, members. It's going to be House Bill 1239. House Bill 1239. Does anybody in the 90s want to speak for…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1406 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…t first on agenda, so we're not. So disregard that. Look at House Bill 1406 on your tablets. And basically, this is concurrent from the…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1308 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ou ready to do 1308, sir? Yes, sir. Members, take a look at House Bill 1308. It will be Representative Meeks.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1402 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1402”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1662 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1662”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1866 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1866”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1890 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1890”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 15, 2026
We're going to give those folks just a couple more minutes. I snuck away from there just a little bit ago. But we'll give them a couple more minutes, and then we'll start, though. Just give me about two or three more minutes here. Thank you.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 0:30
. Thank you.
▶ Play
Members, we're going to get a start. Chair sees a quorum. First of all, members, if you don't care, pull up. We'll take something out of order without objection. We're going to do a concurrent. Actually, it was not first on agenda, so we're not. So disregard that. Look at House Bill 1406 on your tablets. And basically, this is concurrent from the Senate. We're changing. They're deleting one word on page 1, line 25. Delete the word compound. and the senate wants to add in the word they're going to okay they're just taking the word compound out and a comma is really what's going on here so I told Representative Bentley we'd take care of this for is there any discussion on this? Motion to approve the proper time Thank you Representative Laterman I have a motion on the table to concur this amendment all in favor say aye any opposed no? Thank you is Representative Ballinger in the room House Bill 1176 okay Representative Mayberry are you in the room ma'am please go to the end of the table and recognize yourself and I'll tell you that committee this is the bill that we heard last week Representative Mayberry I'm not rushing for time but just for interest of the committee's time and respect for their time and we've already heard your bill We're going to go through the due process, but let's try to keep it short as possible for us, please. Absolutely. I'm sorry, members. It's going to be House Bill 1239. House Bill 1239. Does anybody in the 90s want to speak for or against this bill? Please sign in. Representative Mayberry, how are you doing, ma'am? I'm doing great.
▶ Play
We did already go through this, and I will try to keep my comments short, but I do want to remind you, in case you forget, I had several bills that day. This is a bill that would allow people with a disability to save money so that they can have the same opportunities that other people have to take part in activities and to help take care of themselves. This is based on federal legislation that passed in December of 2014. All of our D.C. delegates, from prior to Cotton and everyone in between, not only voted for this bill, they co-sponsored the bill. So I believe that you can rest assured that their intention is that they want Arkansans to take part in this program. But they can't take part in this program unless Arkansas has this enabling legislation, and that's what you would be passing today. We have worked with DHS. We have worked with rehabilitation services. We've also worked with the state treasurer's office in fine-tuning this bill. They're all on board with it. You all heard them speak in support of it, and I would appreciate a good vote. I'm sorry, ma'am. Are you done? I am. I think we have a few that might want to speak
▶ Play
for. Any questions, members? Anybody in the audience want to speak against the bill? Anybody signed up against the bill? Okay. Ms. Loretta Cochran, are you here, ma'am? You're recognized to speak for the bill. Just go to the end of the table, please, and just recognize yourself. and you're free to
▶ Play
Speaker 21 5:07
proceed. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm Loretta Cochran. I'm a parent of a 13-year-old who has autism, and I wanted to ask Cindy Fong, who's in the audience, to stand and recognize her three children who could directly benefit from this bill. Thank you, Cindy. What I wanted to say is this is actually a pro-business, pro-independence bill for anyone who feels that it might have a slight fiscal impact. We actually have entrepreneurs in Fort Smith, for example, that are preparing and developing not only software but also hardware for individuals who cannot speak that will allow them to put these devices on different mobility devices and enable them to have a full, inclusive life in the community. And someone who can put money away into these ABLE accounts would be able to use those funds to actually buy this equipment, which may or may not be able to be provided in other ways. So this is actually excellent for our entrepreneurial community as well as our families. I already put money away in 529 accounts for my other two children. I would like to be able to provide funds for my son as well in case he's not able to attend college, also for grandparents as well, and there's a limit to the amounts, so it's not just an open-ended, unlimited account, But I think what it allows us to do is actually provide that additional independence to individuals with disabilities to allow them to have full and complete lives as much as possible in the community. Without it, what happens is, and with other things, is your worst nightmare is to have to bury your child. But for a parent with a child with a disability, your worst nightmare is your child outliving you. And there's nothing you can do to put any money aside for them. Because if you do, in their name, they lose all their Medicaid benefits. So we're between a rock and a hard place because if we don't have those natural supports, which most of our families do not, my dad's 82, that's my natural support. My son's 13. You can do the math. Thank you. Members,
▶ Play
any questions? Thank you very much, ma'am. Mark, George, are you in the audience?
▶ Play
Speaker 27 7:31
Yes, sir. I have nothing new that I didn't cover last time, so I'll pass. Appreciate the respect
▶ Play
for the committee's time, sir. Thank you very much. Ms. Eleanor Willer, are you in the audience, ma'am? I'm sorry, I disregarded that. That's actually for a different bill, so you probably don't want to speak for or against this one. I'm just getting carried away. Anybody else in the audience want to speak for the bill or against the bill? If not, members, we've heard the testimony from last week regarding this, and touched briefly on this this morning. Do I have a motion from the committee? A motion to approve. I have a motion to pass as amended because we amended this bill. Thank you very much. All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no. Congratulations, you passed your bill. Representative Meeks, are you ready to do 1308, sir? Yes, sir. Members, take a look at House Bill 1308. It will be Representative Meeks. And Representative Meeks, good morning, sir. When you get ready, you go ahead and you're free to proceed, sir. All right.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chairman and colleagues. This is a bill that I brought before you a couple weeks ago, and we had a little amendment to add to it, and unfortunately it kind of took on a life of its own. And long story short, it came back, and actually we came up with something that's very simple and accomplishes what we want to get done. As far as I know, there is no opposition to it. Everyone came to the table on this. You may remember we've had a couple bills where the business community and the assessors were at odds. Well, this one, they're actually, as far as I know, they are in agreement on this one. So but basically what this does is if you have a personal property that's been assessed that, for example, you've been assessed at five hundred dollars or five hundred thousand dollars, you think the tax should only be three hundred thousand dollars. As it stands right now, you pay the five hundred thousand dollars. It then is distributed to the schools and to the counties. You file your lawsuit. Two years later, if you win, the county's got to come up with this two hundred thousand dollars to be able to reimburse the taxpayer. So what this bill does is it says that what we're going to do is we're going to take that amount that's in dispute. So the taxpayer will pay the full $500,000. Then they'll take that $200,000 that is in dispute, and they'll put it in escrow, set it aside. So that will allow the $300,000 that everybody's okay with to still go ahead and go through the counties and to the schools like it's supposed to. And then we're going to set that contested money aside until a judgment has been made. When the judgment's been made, it's been made in the side of the taxpayer. The taxpayer gets the money back. If it's on the side of the assessors, then the money continues to flow through. And so that, in a nutshell, is what the bill does, and I'll take any questions. Mr. Co-Chair? Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Who
▶ Play
gets the interest on that money? As far as I know, it's just sitting in an escrow account, so there's no... So the bank gets it? I guess so. Well, that's a good deal for the banks, isn't it?
▶ Play
Yeah, as far as I know, it's just sitting in a court with
▶ Play
the circuit court and an escrow account with them. I noticed back in the corner we've got the new Assessment Coordination Division Director, Baruchini, that we'll be working over the next two years. And do you know whether they're in favor of this
▶ Play
bill? Yeah, as far as I know, everybody's
▶ Play
good with it. Thank you. Members, any other questions? Anybody not even want to speak against the bill? for the bill. Representative McGill. Motion at the proper time. It's the proper time, sir. I move do pass. Motion to do pass. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Likewise. Congratulations, sir. You passed your bill. Thank you, Mayor. Members, we'll take a look at House Bill 1344. Representative Saban, you ready? This House Bill 1344. Anybody in the audience who wants to speak against the bill, for the bill, please sign in. Good morning, Representative Saban. How are you doing today, buddy? Doing well, Mr. Chair. How are you? I'm doing good. Thank you. 1344. Is it on your tablets? Everybody got it? Okay, cool. Representative Saban, just recognize yourself, sir, and
▶ Play
you're free to proceed. Representative Warwick, Saban, District 33. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Members of the committee, as all of you are very well aware, we have passed some tax relief already this session. We passed a middle class tax cut earlier in the session, and we're also going to restore the capital gains tax cuts that we passed two years ago. And so I bring you House Bill 1344, the Working Families Opportunity Act, in order to bring some tax relief to the only segment of our taxpaying population that has not received any relief this session. And that's for those making less than $21,000 a year and those working families who got a minimal break from the middle-class tax cut we've already passed. And just to walk you through this bill, the Working Families Opportunities Act actually targets the relief that I'm talking about for working families through tax cuts that incentivize work by making them contingent on earned income like salary and wages. It would provide the approximately 279,000 Arkansans who received the federal earned income tax credit each year with an additional 1.25 percent of their federal credit amount in 2016, 2.5 percent in 2017, and 5 percent by 2018. Tax credits, like those in this bill, are our most effective tool for moving families out of poverty. That is why the Federal Earned Income Tax Credit has received broad bipartisan support since its inception in the 1970s, and it's why half of the states in our union have already implemented their own versions of it. President Ronald Reagan called the Federal version of this tax credit, quote, the best anti-poverty, the best pro-family, the best job creation measure to come out of Congress. Let me emphasize, this is not a handout. You have to work to receive the credit. The working families who would be eligible for this Working Families Opportunity Act already pay a much higher share of their income to state and local taxes than more wealthy Arkansans. In fact, the lowest 20% of Arkansans pay the highest state and local tax rates as a share of their income than any other group in our state, twice the rate as the top 1% of taxpayers in Arkansas. These credits would simply help working families keep more of what they earn. And it does not take long for those who take advantage of this type of tax credit to get back on their feet. Three out of five people who take advantage of this type of credit only use it for one or two years at a time. These credits help people make ends meet while working at low wages so that they can stay employed and take advantage of opportunities to make a better life for themselves and their families. And not only would this invest directly in our workers, but it also invest in the children and our local economies. Today, nearly 30% of Arkansas children live in poverty and many of those children are living in intergenerational poverty. However, outcomes for children living in families receiving the federal version of this tax credit show improved health and academic outcomes, greater lifetime earnings, and as a result, a reduction in the risk of a lifetime of poverty. One study found that every dollar of tax credit refunds resulted in $1.58 in total economic activity, and every $37,000 resulted in a permanent job added to the community. The bottom 20 percent of Arkansans now make less than $17,000 a year, and they get no benefit from the tax cuts that we passed this session. The next 20% of Arkansans make between $17,000 and $30,000 a year, and they only get an average tax cut of about $3 a year under the tax cut that we passed this session. This bill helps to bridge that gap, and it does it in a way that rewards work, helps reduce poverty, and invests in our children and our local economies. I want to say that I'm grateful for this chairman, Representative Jett, as well as the chairman of the Senate Revenue and Tax Committee, Jake Files, for adding their names as co-sponsors to this bill. And I also want to call your attention to a recent amendment I made to the bill that actually reduces the fiscal impact to zero in the next fiscal year. And as you see, the tax credit is phased in over three years, starting in 2016, so that the total fiscal impact in the next biennium is only 10 million dollars and I appreciate the opportunity and I'd be glad to
▶ Play
take any questions. Thank you Representative Sabin. Representative Dawson,
▶ Play
you recognize her. Thank you Mr. Chair. Representative Sabin. I have a possibly a couple questions if if we get to them but the first one I'll start with if if I I'm trying to understand on page two where it starts, the actual tax credit beginning in year 2016 is one and a quarter percent. Is that of total income or is that a one and a quarter percent tax credit of tax liability?
▶ Play
It's actually the percent of the federal credit amount. So these are people who already qualify for the federal earned income tax credit, And this is a state credit that's taking a percentage of that to create an additional earned income tax credit. So I guess a follow-up. You're good, buddy.
▶ Play
Go ahead. I guess how much of a total percentage of income would that be?
▶ Play
Can you give me an example? I mean, to be honest with you, the formula that the earned income tax credit is based upon, it's kind of a complicated sliding scale. And so it would really be impossible for me to, you know, make a calculation based on total income. That's why the bill depends on the federal earned income tax credit scale to provide the credit. And that's how the other state versions of the earned income tax credit are calculated.
▶ Play
Okay. I have another one, but I'll... Go ahead. No, you go ahead. So I'm not sure if I completely know exactly if the answer to my question was answered, or that you have an answer for it that can be found out on that one. But the second question is on page 2, line 8, I believe it is. It says, talking about the excess refund. So if I understand it correctly, if the income tax credit exceeds the tax liability of a particular individual, then they would receive a credit above that. So we would actually be paying them additional credit more than what their total tax liability is? Well, it's a refundable tax credit. So,
▶ Play
again, it works exactly the same way as it does at the federal level. And, yes, that's true. Okay. Thank you.
▶ Play
Representative Collins, you recognize, sir? Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative
▶ Play
Sabin, I know you and I have talked about this before, but I thought since we were in the formal setting, you are looking at a $40 million per year ongoing commitment. That is a significant commitment, but I agree that more tax reduction is better. So if we take the population that you are focused on, people that are making under $21,000, With the governor's new tax cut, there's actually three sets of brackets, and there's a bracket set specifically for those folks, and it starts at 0.9%. The next bracket as our income goes up is 2.4%, and then the third bracket is 3.4%. If we agreed on everything else, why wouldn't we dedicate the $40 million to reducing those brackets so we don't just get the demand side or the spending benefit of giving people a credit But in addition to the demand-side benefit, we also get the supply-side benefit of incenting more people to go to work and more people to be hired. I'm still, if we agreed on everything else and we said we want to take $40 million per year and dedicate it to this group, why not lower those brackets rather than give folks a credit regardless of whether or not their tax bill actually equals the amount of the credit?
▶ Play
Thank you, sir. Sure. Well, I think that the best kind of tax policy provides a combination of both supply side and demand side. And the reason why I believe the demand side cut is more appropriate in this case is simply because it has a more immediate effect on the economy and the lives of the people who are, in this case, earning the tax credit. If we were to do what you propose, which as you and I both know, because we've discussed it so much, I don't have any philosophical objections to, but you would be basically spending a similar amount of money from the state treasury to have a more minimal impact, not only toward the pocketbooks of the people who are receiving the tax cut or the tax credit, but also the economic stimulative effect, because as I mentioned before, what we did with the middle class tax cut is we basically gave those making sort of between that $21,000 to $30,000 range, We gave them a $3 tax cut and that $3 doesn't make a big impact in their lives and it certainly doesn't make a big impact in, you know, the economy where they might spend that $3. Whereas this tax credit delivers a stronger impact, again, to these people because they'll receive more of a credit than they would under your proposal and that money goes right back into the local economy because these are people who, quite frankly, I mean, are going to have to spend that money as soon as they get it. And they're going to spend it to buy new clothes for their kids. They're going to buy it to get, you know, repairs to their car. They're going to spend it at local businesses here in Arkansas. And so, again, that will provide an economic stimulative effect to our local economy and to small businesses. We'll see more money circulating. And that, in return, will provide, hopefully, a better impact to the state treasury, which is what
▶ Play
you and I both want as well. Mr. Chair, can I just follow up, please? And again, I won't belabor it except to just submit to you in this group that the short-term concept versus the longer-term incentive of creating that supply-side effect, I would just submit over long periods of time, is a transition in thinking that if we can get there together, I'm very, very confident we'll help Arkansas move from near the bottom in all those rankings where there's no reason in the world we should be because there's absolutely nothing wrong with us into the middle and beyond up those charts for median income and all these other things. So I appreciate your work, sir. I just think ignoring that incentive to work side of the equation over time is not serving our populace well.
▶ Play
Well, and if I can address that, I mean, again, I absolutely, you know, respect your position on this. And I understand kind of the long-term philosophical approach that you'd like to take. I just think that it's important for all of us to remember that, you know, we're basically talking about 40 to 50 percent of the people that we represent, that all of us represent here in Arkansas. I mean, we all know what the income levels are here in our state and for our constituents. And I think if you asked, you know, the man or the woman on the street what would mean more to them right now, I think they would absolutely be more in favor of this tax credit than a one-tenth of one percent reduction in their overall income tax. And I think that's political reality, which, again, to me is important, and it's just as important as setting long-term tax policy for the state. You good,
▶ Play
Speaker 68 24:18
Representative Collins? We could go on all day, but
▶ Play
I'll yield. And we have, and we will
▶ Play
again, I'm sure. Well, I appreciate your yielding. Representative Meeks,
▶ Play
you're recognized, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I have two questions, and this is something that started back when Governor Beebe was our governor, and kind of his contention was, well, we'll do a tax cut, but you have to tell us where the money is coming from. So kind of continuing that, where do you see the money, the $40 million coming
▶ Play
from? from? Well, I mean, to me, the $40 million, that impact doesn't occur until 2018. And, you know, I don't want to minimize that at all. But, you know, when we look at the tax cuts that we've already passed, when we look at the, you know, the budget projections and the surpluses we've been seeing, I think we all could probably agree that in the next biennium, meaning, you know, with, you know, by the end of 2017, that the $10 million, you know, is very achievable. And I, you know, again, there's enough support, I think, for this kind of tax relief, at least in my conversations with other legislators and even with the governor's office, although I want to emphasize the governor's office has not said they're supporting this bill, but I would think that all of this is achievable. And certainly within the next four years, you know, with everything that's going on terms of how we're budgeting and what we're projecting. I think it's certainly achievable if we make it a priority. And we've made other tax cuts a priority. We've made other spending a priority. I think this needs to be a priority in order to bring more tax relief to the only segment of the population that hasn't
▶ Play
received it. Okay. And, you know, obviously, whenever we have an opportunity for a tax cut, I'm with you. But I guess the thing that probably disturbs me the most about this, and it's in response to something that Representative Dotson had said, or that you had testified to, is that we're looking at the potential for people to get more back as a refund than they put into the system. So in essence, what's happening is taxpayers of Arkansas are paying other taxpayers money. So you're taking tax dollars from one taxpayer and, in essence, giving it to another just for working or being another taxpayer. And I have a problem, or how do you justify taking money from one taxpayer and just funneling it through and giving it to
▶ Play
another taxpayer? I don't see it that way. I mean, I see it as, you know, that is, in essence, what's happening, though. You're taking tax dollars from one person and giving it to another. Well, we, in other contexts, obviously have tax refunds made available to taxpayers all the time. I mean, when you itemize your taxes and you, you know, figure them out, oftentimes people get a refund. And this is a refundable tax credit. And I think the idea is that, you know, this policy has worked so well over the last several decades at the federal level to move people out of poverty where we're not spending money on other types of social services. And so we see this as an investment in moving people out of poverty more quickly in order to reduce the overall tax burden on other citizens. So the idea of, you know, the way you portrayed it was we're taking money from one person and giving it to another. And, you know, I don't see it that way because what we're doing is we're making an investment in moving people out of poverty so that they're not a burden on society in other ways because we all end up shouldering that burden one way or the other through all of the other social programs that we have. And, again, we have a tax policy in place, we set up credits, we set up our deductions in such a way that it's possible for people to receive refunds. This is mainly set up, I think, in a very responsible way so that the refunds are targeted to people who are working, who have families, and who are moving their way out of poverty and just need that extra boost, which, honestly, per person is not huge. huge. I mean, nobody's getting rich off of an
▶ Play
earned income tax credit. Representative Fite, you recognize, sir? Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Sabin, I have some concerns about the comments by DF&A on fraud. Sure. Would you address those, please? I'd be glad
▶ Play
to, because I noticed those comments as well, and with Mr. Tyson, our other friends from DF&A in the room, I'll say this directly to you. I think it's their responsibility, obviously, to bring that to our attention. There are often things in the fiscal impacts that we as legislators may disagree with or have trouble with. I think that they have to obviously call attention to that, but you could say that there's a risk of fraud in any part of how people try to game the tax system or anything else. I don't think that the instances of fraud in this case are any more likely than in any other part of our tax code. But, again, I mean, all I can do is object. I can't. It's a qualitative rather than a quantitative statement, in my opinion. Representative Fyte,
▶ Play
you good? You want DFA to respond to that, sir, or are you good with that answer? Yeah, Tim, if you don't care, I appreciate it, sir. Just recognize yourself and pick
▶ Play
Speaker 76 29:51
up on Representative Fyatt's question, please. Mr. Chairman, Tim Leathers from DFA. We know from the history of tax credits where you get back more than you pay, where you can't track them back to the amount that was withheld for withholding and do a check on that, that there are more opportunities for fraud. The IRS has recognized that. and the few states that have these credits where you get back more than what was withheld from your paycheck. And that's where that comment comes from. We just thought obligated to make that as a general rule so if we had issues in the future. And that's where that comes from.
▶ Play
Representative Fyde, you good, sir? I am. Thank you. Thank you. Representative Lateman, you're recognized, sir.
▶ Play
Representative Saban, I just had a follow-up on what Representative Meek said. They're trying to understand if this is not a reduction in the tax payment that these people make and it does not come from another taxpayer what other source of money is there? Where could this money come from? It doesn't come from the taxpayer or from another taxpayer where does it come from?
▶ Play
The money obviously comes from the Treasury which is supported by all of us as taxpayers. I guess my thought on that is, again, you know, we have a tax system in place where people can get, take deductions on their taxes and receive a refund. And I've never heard anybody complain about that in the same way. And obviously that money comes from the same place that this money would come from. So, you know, it's, again, a proven policy that's really helped to move people out of poverty quickly, which is why I think, you know, we make a value judgment as policy makers as to the best way to, you know, invest in our people and our communities and use our money as responsibly as possible. Thank you. Representative Flowers, you recognize, ma'am?
▶ Play
Thank you. I guess no one is going to be surprised that I have a comment about this, and I think that... Well, excuse me, Representative Fliers, please make that.
▶ Play
I mean, we're kind of getting carried away on
▶ Play
the comments. Please make that. A question? Yes, please. Okay. Thank you. I will do. So, Representative Sabin, we've heard a lot in this discussion about the short-term nature of this bill. But as a sustainable measure and as something that would be permanent, can you talk about how over time, based upon the advantages that you've discussed, what that impact could look like for the state and for the lower half of our Arkansas's income earners? Sure, well, I mean, I definitely appreciate the
▶ Play
question because I think when we consider all of these tax cuts that we're presenting and the policies that we're trying to adopt, if this works the same way it has worked at the federal level, if it works the same way that it works in other states, we're moving people out of poverty, we're increasing their incomes, they contribute more to our overall economy in the state, and obviously there's a benefit that comes back to our state treasury as a result of that. And so I think, again, this is, when we consider the fiscal impact, it's obviously we only see the subtraction, because that's DF&A's job, is to tell us what the subtraction is. What some of us all, I think, get frustrated with, including Representative Collins, is that we don't calculate all the time the benefits that come back as a result of this. And again, if our version of the earned income tax credit works as well as it has worked over the last several decades, and this is a data-driven, proven policy that's worked to move people out of poverty and help them contribute more to the economy, then I would submit that the fiscal impact to the government certainly will be reduced significantly and certainly will be doing more to improve not only our overall economy, but the lives and the futures of our citizens.
▶ Play
And can I have one more follow-up, Mr. Chair? Yes, ma'am. And then with regard to the notion or the perspective that one group of taxpayers would be paying for another group of taxpayers, from my vantage point, I see that that's sort of what we do. We have priorities and we have taxpayers who put into the system and then we decide how we can best invest in the state and make it better for everybody and make it better for the state, whether we're talking about a super fund or TIF districts or subsidies to specific industry. I mean, that's kind of what we do. So with regard to how we'll be paying for this, I just want to be clear. As we're continuing to look at economic growth in the state and a lot of these policies that we've voted on as a body, are you looking at the economic growth that we're anticipating based upon the tax cuts that we did or even the repeal of the repeal of capital gains if the idea is that we're doing all of these things to expand the growth of the economy and that we'll look for more return. Are you anticipating that the economic growth that has paid for or we're looking to pay for some of the other tax cuts and tax relief that we've provided will pay for this
▶ Play
as well? Well, certainly I think that's the hope and, you know, quite frankly, as I said in response to Representative Collins earlier, I think having a sort of diversified portfolio of tax cuts and credits make sense. And again, insofar as we all agree that the middle-class tax cut was a good idea and that restoring the capital gains tax cuts were good ideas and those cost money and they will have an economic stimulative effect, you have to also then follow that logic through to say that this tax credit will also have the same economic stimulative effect and is worth the investment.
▶ Play
Thank you, Representative Saban. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you,
▶ Play
ma'am. Representative DeEase, you recognize, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair. You may have already answered this question, but will people who benefit from this, at any time, will they get more
▶ Play
money back than they've paid in? it's a refundable tax credit, there is the possibility that they will receive a credit in excess of what they paid in taxes. Yes, that is correct. And like I said, the same way that, you know, deductions work for those people who itemize.
▶ Play
Thank you. Representative Dawson, you
▶ Play
recognize her? Thank you, Mr. Chair. And this is just kind of in response to the last thing that was said. And I have another question after that that's separate. But just there's been a lot of talk about credits and deductions. And nowhere in this bill are we talking about deductions. This is an actual credit, not a deduction. A deduction being something that you owe and then you get a reduction in your tax liability. This is a credit payment regardless of whatever your deductions happen to be. So, but my question is in the last section there, section D, what is the cost for DF&A that has to annually notify taxpayers of their potential eligibility? Is there a known cost of what that's going to? The fiscal impact, I think, had
▶ Play
some mention of that, but But, I mean, you know, I don't have that information in front of me. Mr. Tice, I know, is standing up and moving toward the microphone. Mr.
▶ Play
Chair. Go ahead, John. Mr. Chair, committee members, I'm John Tice with DFA. In the revenue impact, we said that that could be substantial. Since the bill has been filed, we've done a little investigating, And we've come up with some other ways to provide that notice. So were I doing the impact today, I would say that's a minimal cost. We've come up with some ways to provide that fairly
▶ Play
cheaply. Members, any other questions? Representative Tucker, do you recognize her? Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, Representative Saban, for bringing this bill. Just to address the point that's been raised by a few members about citizens of Arkansas receiving more back in income tax credit than they pay in, and that is really limited to what they pay in income taxes. Is that right? That's correct. Follow it, Mr. Chair? Well, I'm just going to go with it. And so I was walking in late to your presentation, but I thought I heard you say that as a group, this category of taxpayers really pays a higher percentage of their income in sales and property taxes, and so I know it's probably impossible to ascertain the exact amount because it would probably vary on a taxpayer-by-taxpayer basis, But would it be fair to say that however much they receive back beyond what they pay in income taxes, that that particular taxpayer is paying more and making up for that and the percentage of their income that they pay towards sales and property taxes?
▶ Play
I think that's an excellent point. And, again, I mean, it's difficult to quantify all of that. But as I said in my opening remarks, the lowest 20% of Arkansas taxpayers pay the highest state and local tax rates as a share of their income than any other group. And it stands to reason because, again, you know, if you're making a small amount, you're paying the tax rates that we have. And you're probably spending most of your money on goods just to sort of feed your family and keep yourself clothed and housed. You're paying a lot of sales tax, especially, you know, if you live here in central Arkansas, for instance, in the district that I represent. So I think that's an excellent point. I think that's something that's really important to keep in mind, and I
▶ Play
appreciate you mentioning that. Thank you, Representative Tucker. Any other questions, members? Anybody in the audience want to speak against the bill? Representative Collins, you're recognized. Speak against the bill, sir.
▶ Play
Speaker 107 40:48
I have two choices. Two choices. vote for
▶ Play
everything I wish I could do and expect somebody else to sort it out. And that is more comfortable. It's more desirable. I'd rather do that. I wouldn't make people upset. I wouldn't get sideways with my friends like Representative Saban. And just more people would be happier, certainly in the short term. I'm even fine with the number, $40 million a year. I'm fine with targeting the group of folks that are our low-income earners in Arkansas because I am a firm believer and I would say the biggest champion for income tax relief around. And I believe we need to focus it on all taxpayers, every one of them, the job creators at the top of the scale, the middle-class taxpayers at the governor's plan just focused on, and our lowest, hard-working Arkansans. So there's two ways we can do it. One way is to take those tax brackets, and all of us are very familiar with them, and start lowering them to the tune of whatever number we can afford. And if we're concerned that the dollar-per-person number is not high enough, let's find a way to slow the growth of government spending so that we can increase the amount of tax relief that we target against all working Arkansans on the income tax tables, including and focused on our lowest income earners. I just think it's a superior way to go because you get both effects. You get the economic demand side of effect of $40 million going into the economy, and you also get the incentive-creating effect of lower tax rates on work. And so while I love the idea of helping these folks, there's nothing that I think is more vital to the interest of our state than supporting and growing the class of folks that start and learn skills at the bottom of our income ladder and work themselves up over time. And so I have 100% alignment with the spirit of where Representative Sabin is going. I just disagree on the method and I think that the way to do it is to take whatever we can afford from a budget standpoint that we want to put against this challenge and reduce the tax rates. They start at .9, they go up to 2.4, then 3.4. There's a lot of room to go. And when the thing gets to zero and the income tax rate on low income Arkansans is zero, then we can talk about the need for an additional methodology to help incentivize more work. So let's help these folks. Let's do it in a way that does both things, the demand side and the supply side. And with that, Mr. Chair, I appreciate your letting me come down here. You're welcome, sir. Mrs. Willard, you're in
▶ Play
the audience. You want to speak before the bill, ma'am? Please take a seat, recognize yourself, and you're free to proceed, ma'am.
▶ Play
Okay. Thank you, Mr. Chair. My name is Eleanor Wheeler. I am a policy analyst from Arkansas Advocates for Children and Families. The federal version that this bill is based on has received broad bipartisan approval from the beginning because it supports working people and has been the most effective measure ever enacted to help families leave poverty behind. The Working Families Opportunity Act would piggyback on the federal version, which has proven to encourage considerable numbers of single parents to leave welfare and enter the workforce. Federal earned income tax credits did more to increase employment among single mothers than either welfare reform or the economic recovery during the 1990s. These types of credits help people make ends meet while they're starting their careers at low wages so that they can stay employed and work their way up to better opportunities and they simply work. The The federal version of this credit program lifted 6.2 million people out of poverty in 2013. As it has been discussed, many of those who would benefit from this credit were left out of the recent economic recovery and the generous tax cuts passed earlier this session. And the working families who would be eligible already pay a much higher share of their income to state and local taxes. The lowest 20 percent of Arkansans pay the highest state and local tax rates as a share of their income than any other group at twice the rate as the top 1 percent. Local economies are also going to benefit from this program because taxpayers claiming this credit tend to spend the money in their local communities on things like groceries and clothes for their kids. Finally, the Working Families Opportunity Act is simple and cheap to implement because it's simply a percentage of the federal version which is already in use. Right now, Arkansas is missing out on one of the best anti-poverty measures ever introduced. Half of the states in the U.S. are already benefiting from state-level earned income tax credits like the Working Families Opportunity Act. Thank you. Thank you, ma'am.
▶ Play
Any questions? Tim, do you need something? You want to speak? I'm sorry, Tim. Okay, so you want to take a seat at the
▶ Play
Speaker 76 46:38
table and talk? Thank you very much, Mel. Mr. Chairman, Tim Leathers from DFA, as you know, we've been consistent with the impact on all the revenue proposals that have come before the committee, and the message that have brought is that we have worked some in the budget and if we add to those then we're going to have issues with the budget representative sabin has amended and moved this out so there's no impact in the first fiscal year of the biennium but there is 10 million in the next and then when you come back in two years waiting on you there'll be a second year of that biennium a $40 million impact that is looming out there on the horizon. So we want to make sure that we make that point as we have with all of the other impacts that we have that this has not been accounted for in the balanced budget as we're working, trying to piece that together here in the last few days of the session. Thank
▶ Play
you very much. Members, anybody questions for I keep calling you Representative Leathers. I know you keep wanting that pay raise, but you're not going to get it, buddy. Anybody else in the audience want to speak against the bill, for the bill? Is that a yes, ma'am? For the bill, ma'am? I'd like to
▶ Play
Speaker 116 48:09
speak on the bill. Is that for the bill, ma'am? We are a private foundation, so
▶ Play
we cannot take a position on Sorry, ma'am. Recognize yourself
▶ Play
Speaker 116 48:16
and tell us who you're with, please. I'm Reagan Gruber-Moffett. I'm Associate Vice President with the Winthrop Rockefeller Foundation. And we'd like to speak on the bill as a co-investor in state and refundable tax credits. At the Winthrop Rockefeller Foundation, we have a mission to improve the lives of our Kansans. And And we have set a goal to move Arkansas out of the bottom ranks on indicators of economic opportunity and education and move us to the top of the ranks. And it's in that light that we think it is critical to invest in refundable tax credits. And as such, over the last five years, we've spent approximately $800,000 to help Arkansans claim the Federal Earned Income Tax Credit. Most of my prepared remarks are repetitive of what other folks have said. But we at the Winthrop Rockefeller Foundation believe that the Federal Earned Income Tax Credit and similar state tax credits are the most effective poverty reduction program that exists in the country. Most of the statistics that I have in my prepared remarks have been shared by others. But we have seen through our investments that these tax credits have impact on individuals and also on communities. So data from recent tax seasons shows that there were over 300,000 EITC returns filed, bringing in $757 million. dollars, and that many of the folks that receive these credits use it to pay off debts, buy items that they wouldn't otherwise, or to invest in the future through education or otherwise. There's been some discussion here about what other states have done. Other state EITC programs latched onto the federal EITC range from 3.5 percent of the federal EITC to 40 percent of it. And what other states, many of whom began adopting these state EITCs in the mid-'80s have seen is that the administrative costs of such a state tax credit is minimal, less than 1% in most places. And as such, those dollars go into the hands directly of those who need the tax funds and are able to be used directly for poverty reduction. So we believe at the foundation that tax credits are an important tool to change the face of Arkansas and are here as a co-investor in such a thing to talk about why it's important as a poverty reduction strategy. Thank you. Thank you, ma'am. Any
▶ Play
members, any questions for this lady? If not, thank you very much. Representative Savings, you want to close for your bill,
▶ Play
sir? Yes, Mr. Chair, and I'll make it very brief. Really, in my close, I just want to address the only person who spoke against the bill, Representative Collins, just to say that, again, he and I have great discussions about tax policy, and believe it or not, we kind of agree on more than we disagree about, usually. In this respect, you know, I think it's really important to point out that all of the testimony that you've heard indicates that this is a proven policy. Again, this is proven through decades of implementation. It works. There's data to back it up, and I think if you're going to pursue a policy, again, to give tax relief to people at this level, this is the proven way to do it. Also to his point about his desire to see relief for this tax bracket, I'd like to just say that this is the only proposal in front of you that brings relief to the only segment of the population that hasn't received tax relief during this session. And talk is cheap, and when the story of this session is written, what we do on this bill will determine whether we actually put our money where our mouth is, so to speak, and gave tax relief to those people who have been left out thus far. And with that, I'd appreciate a good vote.
▶ Play
you. Thank you, Representative Saban. Representative Tucker. Members of the motion do pass. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed say no. No. Sorry, Representative Saban, your bill has failed, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee. Thank you, sir. Members, we'll move on to House Bill 1662.
▶ Play
I guess I better get over here before I can tell how to do it. Thank you. The computer's thinking, Chairman Jett. I
▶ Play
Speaker 129 54:34
think I saw it there.
▶ Play
I'm seeing more amendments. They're supposed to be on there for
▶ Play
Speaker 130 54:52
some reason. We're passing it out because it is not populating on the Pablin
▶ Play
side. 1866. 1662. Okay, members, it's the House Bill 1662, and I understand an amendment is being passed out now because we've got some problems with the computers apparently. Chairman Jett, you're recognized to explain
▶ Play
your amendment. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Members, what we found is we run into a problem where airplanes being somebody in another state owns an airplane and the airplane is being sold to somebody in a different state other than Arkansas. We have several places in the state of Arkansas that does very good as far as brokering the airplanes or working on the airplanes or doing pre-buy inspections on the airplanes. But what we found out, a lot of these companies, a lot of people would use those services, will not use them because they're afraid that DFA will collect, or the state of Arkansas will collect sales tax, use tax on these airplanes. And basically what they're doing is they're just passing through the state. They're never being located in the state. They're not being registered in the state. So really what this amendment's doing, and I'd like to get a copy of the amendment before I kind of really get cranking on this thing, make sure we're talking about the same thing. But really what we're doing is we're cleaning up the language to let airplanes that somebody owns in a different state, say, for example, thank you, ma'am, say for the state of North Carolina, and it's being sold in the state of, say, California. And, for example, in Mena, Arkansas, there's several different places that will do refurbished airplanes that will do pre-buy inspections, paint, or whatever. And these places could actually pick up those airplanes as far as doing business, but a lot of folks won't use those folks because of the fact that the state can, if the airplanes get sold while it's in the state, it could capture the use tax. So this is kind of an economic development type bill. And with that, with the chair's indulgence, I'd like Mr. Chad Cozzi to speak on this as well.
▶ Play
Speaker 134 56:55
Identify yourself and your recognition. Chad Causey, Executive Director of the Arkansas Aerospace and Defense Alliance. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and members of the committee. We certainly appreciate Representative Jett bringing this bill forward. What we found in the industry is that, and in our conversations with DF&A, that these transactions occur quite regularly where we have an out-of-state seller of a plane and an out-of-state buyer of that plane. That plane may be brokered from here, and they bring that plane here for purposes of the sale, but it's never intended that that plane will stay here if it's purchased by an out-of-state buyer. Secondary to that is Arkansas has a very robust maintenance, repair, and overhaul business here in the state. We have several companies that work to overhaul and provide maintenance repair on private aircraft, business jets, on commercial aircraft as well. So we have situations where those planes change hands, and what we have now is we've found that a lot of times, in order to avoid the uncertainty of whether or not that tax would be due here in the state, they will actually fly that plane to another state where they're more certain, conduct the sales transaction there, and then bring that plane back to conduct the work in Arkansas. The problem with that is that now there are many states, many of our neighboring states that advertise the fact that no types of taxes would be collected on those transactions. So we might be potentially, and we are, we think, losing some business where they would like to go and do the sales transaction and do the pre-sale inspection and the accompanying work that would happen after the sale in one spot. So what we're hoping to do with this bill and what we appreciate about it is that it would clarify what we believe is existing law, that no taxes should be collected on these types of transactions where you have an out-of-state seller and an out-of-state buyer, and that plane won't reside here in Arkansas except for the purposes of a limited time in order to complete any maintenance, repair, or overhaul work to be done.
▶ Play
Any quick? Mr. Chair, I would add that this is revenue neutral, and I certainly appreciate DFA and those folks working diligently with us to get this where this needs to be.
▶ Play
So thank you, guys. Any other discussion on the amendment? Motion by Representative Meeks to adopt the amendment. All in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed? Okay, now Representative Jets, you're recognized to explain your bill as amended.
▶ Play
Is that correct? That's correct, sir. And, members, you just heard pretty much the nuts and bolts of this bill. we did we drafted the legislation and then within discussion with DFA the language just wasn't quite right to suit those folks so basically what the amendment was is to address their concerns to make sure we're all operating within inside the scope of the law so with that Mr. Chairman I am closed Any questions? Representative Meek What the chairman's
▶ Play
indulging I was wondering if DF&A can come and kind of give us their side if that's okay Representative Meeks, you heard me
▶ Play
just say I was closed, didn't you?
▶ Play
I'm sorry. Go ahead, John. Thank you, Representative Meeks, for putting me in trouble, too.
▶ Play
Yeah, yeah. Misery loves company. Identify yourself, please. Mr. Chair, committee members, John Tice with DFA. As Representative Jed explained, under current Arkansas law, if you have an out-of-state seller of an airplane and an out-of-state buyer of that airplane, but the plane happens to be located in Arkansas at the time of that sale to have repair modification work done. Under current state law, the law would say that's a taxable transaction in Arkansas because the transfer of the ownership occurred here. As a practical matter, we have looked at these transactions over the years, and we find that Arkansas is not currently collecting any tax because buyers and sellers are doing what Mr. Causey explained, that for the transfer, they will fly the plane to one of our surrounding states. That would not tax that transfer, and that's why you see the zero revenue impact. Ordinarily, we will have the revenue impact prior to committee, but because this amendment wasn't adopted on the bill, we've not gotten that revenue impact on your systems, but we do have copies of that with us today if you need to pass that out. And so
▶ Play
just kind of following up on that, if somebody from Texas was buying a car from somebody in Louisiana and they just happened to meet in Texarkana, that would be a taxable event in Arkansas? Cars are a different situation, but if
▶ Play
you had used just about any other example besides a car, the answer would have been yes. Okay. All right. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
▶ Play
Speaker 98 1:01:47
Representative Dodson. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
So what you're saying, here we go. That's what I was looking for. Appreciate it. Never mind.
▶ Play
Representative Speaks. Thank you, Chairman. Last night I heard a little bit about this. Isn't there a lot of jobs that this will bring in several of the
▶ Play
counties? Yes, ma'am. Say, for example, MENA keeps coming to mind because on their airport they have several different people that refurbishes airplanes or sells airplanes or whatever. and basically what's happening is these folks are losing out on these airplanes getting to work on because when somebody flies an airplane in to have it worked on, they're actually going to sell the plane with the intention of selling the plane. What they'll do is they'll take the airplane and say to Texas. I think we decided, and DFA can correct me if I'm wrong, I think Kansas, Texas, Tennessee, maybe Louisiana actually has this law in the books. So what they'll do is they'll fly a plane, say, to Memphis, for example, and take advantage of that and have the plane worked on in Memphis, do the paperwork for selling the airplane and move the airplane on over. If they didn't, what they'd do, they'd come to, say, fly the plane to MENA. They'd do the work, and then they'd fly the plane back out of the state of Arkansas over to Memphis, Tennessee, for example, do the paperwork, and the airplane moves
▶ Play
Speaker 146 1:03:20
on over to California. Are you through? Representative Lemons. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Is there a limitation as to the maximum tax that can
▶ Play
Speaker 147 1:03:28
be collected? I think it's 6.64 or something.
▶ Play
The current state sales tax rate is 6.5%, and then there's local tax that would be applied. The local tax would be capped on the first $2,500 of purchase price. Okay, so the cap is $2,500. That was my
▶ Play
Speaker 146 1:03:41
question. Yes, sir, and that's for the local tax only. Any other question? Anybody that always
▶ Play
wants to speak for the bill, against the bill? Not representative of me because you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm
▶ Play
going to redeem myself here if the motion is passed. As amended. All right.
▶ Play
You've heard the motion. All in favor? Say aye. All opposed? Motion carried. Congratulations, Mr. Chairman. Thank
▶ Play
you very much, sir. And, Mr. Chairman, with your indulgence, can we do House Bill 1402 while I'm down here? I reckon. This is 1402. What we're doing, we're going to clean up the language of Representative Shepard's capital gains.
▶ Play
You're recognized to explain House Bill 1402. Members,
▶ Play
this is Representative Shepard's capital gains bill. What this is, yesterday when he was going to the floor to speak for his bill, We found that inadvertently BLR had struck the language from January 1st to February 1st. That 50%, it was crossed out. And basically what this is, is he went to the House floor. We worked out an amendment really quick. He went to the floor yesterday. That was his amendment that you guys voted on on the House floor yesterday. He gets re-referred back to the committee, and that's what we're voting on right now, the amendment that you voted on yesterday on the House floor, which actually puts that back in January 1st to February
▶ Play
1st, that 50%. Any question? Representative Meeks. Motion to adopt the amendment. To pass the bill in its new form, I think she says. Yes. Thank you. Got it. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed? Motion carried.
▶ Play
Speaker 139 1:05:34
Thank you, members. You've got to sign this bill. This is a position of power. Okay, more down, too.
▶ Play
Is Representative Ballinger in the room? Representative Gates in the room? Let me just second for Representative Gates. Did we say we were going to shoot him a test? Okay, members, I think here's what we're going to do. I'm going to give just a minute for Representative Gates, but I think the game plan is the Speaker that asks us to clean up all the House bills today. If for some reason we can get a hold of these folks, we might come back this afternoon just for a couple minutes, get off the House floor. We've got two more bills that we can run under net revenue neutral, And then Thursday, we're going to take up some Senate bills. The Speaker asked us to clean up the House calendar today. And then Thursday, work on Thursday on the Senate bills. I know there's three or four Senate bills out there floating around. I'm hearing I talked to Senator Fowles this morning. He's pretty much after today, he's pretty much got the Senate shut down. So that's kind of the game plan. So any discussion on that? You want to go ahead and run yours, Representative Davis?
▶ Play
Speaker 51 1:07:13
Go ahead, sir. What's the number on
▶ Play
Speaker 115 1:07:27
that? Members, 1890. I do not. I do not. He has an amendment.
▶ Play
Does members, everybody have a copy of the amendment 1890? Representative Davis, I just want you to know that's my only copy. You're taking it from me, so I'm flying blind, which could be a good thing. That'd be all right. Does everybody have the amendment? I do not. Give us just a little bit more second here, Representative Davis, and we'll get started. Just recognize yourself and go ahead and proceed when you get ready, buddy.
▶ Play
All right, Representative Davis. Members, we'll have an amendment to the bill. Talk about that first. The bill currently has two sections. The second section would have required vendors and retailers to submit their A&P taxes through the Department of Finance Administration rather than to their local municipalities. The amendment deletes that section in its entirety, so nothing changes with the way A&P taxes are collected.
▶ Play
Any questions? Anybody in audience want to speak against the amendment, for the amendment? If not, do I have a motion? to adopt the amendment. Representative Fyatt, you recognize, make your motion, sir. Make a motion. Motion for adoption for the amendment. All in favor say aye. Any opposed? It is amended, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, committee.
▶ Play
This bill's pretty simple. All the opposition that I'd heard to it previously was in regards So that's Section 2 that we just took off with how A&P taxes were collected. So we're down to Section 1 now. And Section 1, essentially, I'll put it in a – I'll just give you an example to make it pretty easy. If you go to the grocery store and buy a loaf of bread, it's taxed as groceries, and you don't pay A&P tax on it. If you go to a bakery and buy a loaf of bread that also serves, let's say, sandwiches in that bakery, it's taxed as food for consumption on site. So it's taxed like it's a meal or like a restaurant. So it's subject to A&P taxes and other things. This does not make it so that it's taxed like groceries, but it does exempt it from the A&P tax. So there's no revenue impact to the state. It will just reduce A&P taxes to your local municipalities, and it's only for bread that is not consumed on site.
▶ Play
That's it in a nutshell. Thank you. Can you
▶ Play
give us a kind of definition of what AMP tax is? Advertising and promotion. So a lot of municipalities, it's a sales tax on top of a, you know, in addition to standard sales taxes, typically levied on restaurants, maybe hotels. I'm not completely sure about that. And then the A&P taxes, advertised promotion are then, you know, theoretically used to promote the city or, you know, events or what all might be going on in town.
▶ Play
Representative Dodson, do you have a question? Yes, Mr. Chair. Representative Davis, do you have any idea exactly how much revenue we're talking about,
▶ Play
roughly? I don't have any idea. It would be different for every. I think it could be different for every municipality based on, you know, they don't all have an A&P tax. The rate could be different in every municipality, so that's hard to say. So
▶ Play
it could be significant or it could not be on local, individual, community-by-community basis?
▶ Play
It would just depend on the community, yeah. Thank you. Representative Meeks. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I think you may have already answered this. On DF&A's fiscal impact statement, it talks about the need for additional employees to administer the A&P taxes. Was that done away with the Section 2? Correct. That was due to Section
▶ Play
2. We took that off, so nothing changes for DF&A. Nothing changes for the state. No additional employees, none of that.
▶ Play
Members, any other questions? Anybody want to speak against the bill, for the bill? You recognize her? Or go to the end of the table and
▶ Play
Speaker 147 1:12:54
recognize yourself, I guess, a better way of saying that. Mr. Chairman, I'm Mark Johnson. Specifically to Representative Davis, pretty well covered most issues. A couple things this does I want to clarify, and this is mainly to answer Mr. Dotson's question. This would only affect – excuse me a second, sir. Who are you with again? I represent some bakeries in central Arkansas that are having to pay this tax for items that are purchased. Specifically, one is Dempsey Bakery that specializes in gluten-free products. And this came to my attention, Mr. Chairman, because I was made aware of a situation where a mother had to buy gluten-free bread for a child that was gluten intolerant and found that she was paying 11% tax on that compared to whatever it is now, 2% plus the local tax on a loaf of Wonder Bread. So it's discriminatory against, the way we're doing things now, it's discriminatory against small businesses and specialty bakers such as this. But the issue that Representative Dotson brought up, this would not change if, for example, a bakery like Dempsey or any of the others in town that also sell, you can go in and have a sandwich made of the bread or a cup of coffee or some cookies, that is still subject to the A&P tax because at that point you are a restaurant. But if you order a birthday cake or something that's taken away, then this would exempt that from it. The difference being that the advertising promotion tax was originally enacted to provide revenue for local entities, and certainly Little Rock is the biggest in this, to promote tourism into the community. Think of it as a user fee on tourists to promote more tourism. But to tax the bread of a mother who has a child, gluten intolerance has probably never been the intention of it. And this would just clarify that and would only affect those municipalities that have an A&P tax at this time. Now, Department of Finance and Administration pointed out that asking them to collect it would change. We'd have some problems with some interstate compacts that we have, and Mr. Tice explained that to me, and we're glad to delete Section 2. The original purpose of Section 2 being there was to protect the privacy of the taxpayer, but Representative Neal had a separate bill, which has already passed the House, that would accomplish the same purpose. So that was the real main purpose of Section 2. So this would, Section 1 would take care of everything we wanted except for the portion that hopefully will be taken care of when the Senate passes Representative Neal's bill protecting the privacy of the taxpayers. I'll be glad to answer any questions. Representative Collins, you recognize? Thank you
▶ Play
very much, Mr. Chair. So it's kind of like if a restaurant serves alcohol, it's kind of a combination of bar and a restaurant, and a bakery is kind of like a combination of a grocery store and a restaurant. And so just as we wouldn't charge alcohol tax on a hamburger that you order at a restaurant that serves alcohol, you're asking for a similar treatment that you don't tax the grocery items like a loaf of bread the same way you treat the restaurant items, correct? That's a very good analogy, and thank you, Mr. Collins. He's pretty good at
▶ Play
Speaker 173 1:16:25
that. Yes, sir. Reverend Dyson, you're recognized, sir.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm not sure if I've got a really good analogy here or not. But if I understand this correctly, so if you go into Walmart and they have a deli or a bakery there, and they sell cakes or something like that, those would be exempt. but the prepared deli foods are not exempt under this. That's the present situation, yes, sir. So we're carving out a special section just for bakeries? Well, I
▶ Play
Speaker 147 1:17:01
would say, let me twist it a little bit differently, sir. I would say we are treating that loaf of Wonder Bread. Actually, we're not treating it because we're actually taxing the Wonder Bread at an even lower rate, at the gross, at the food rate. But we are changing the difference between something that's taken off-premises for consumption, like you buying a loaf of bread to take home for your child to make sandwiches with, versus the sandwich that's prepared there and you eat it there. That's the differentiation that we're making on this. The bread is the same, but by treating it a loaf of local, small business, bakery bread, and not treating it as a restaurant, unless it's actually served in there as a restaurant, then we're treating it, it has to be for off-premises to gain this exemption. Follow
▶ Play
up. You bet. I guess an example you used, you talked about a baked cake. And so that would be an exemption from this. And according to this, as I'm reading it, baked goods sold. So if they come in, they buy the cake, and they're taking it out of there. But that's the purpose kind of of a bakery is more baked goods like that. You come in, you buy a bunch of donuts, whatever it happens to be, and you take it off premises to consume. How would you differentiate the sale of that sort of baked good, say if that bakery didn't have a sit-down area where they're consuming on site? into the weeds here on a something that's traditionally been taxed as an A&P tax taxable item and trying to really separate that and causing even the small business a lot more headaches on what's a pass-through tax for the consumer I think I could
▶ Play
Speaker 147 1:18:59
answer it this way Representative Dotson. If a bakery was simply a bakery, there's no tables, you can't go in there and eat it, you must carry it off the premises, then their status would stay the same. The problem comes when you have a municipality that has an advertising promotion tax of 2%, or I guess it can be less than that. In Little Rock, it's 2%. The A&P applies that tax to not just the restaurant portion, but everything that's sold in that business. So what we're trying to do with this is to treat it the same way it would be kind of a two-tier. If you're only going in there and ordering a cake, buying a cake, buying a loaf of bread and walking out. It's the same as the bakery that doesn't serve patrons to for on-premises consumption. Have the same treatment. The problem comes is there's no there's no either or under the present law. If you sell one sandwich a year then you must collect the restaurant tax and this basically differentiates between the two. The The business would continue to tax, the 2%, the A&P tax would collect that on something that was consumed on premises, just like another restaurant, or shall we say a full-time restaurant. The bakery, if you go into Walmart, for example, I think you're using this example, if you buy a cake that was baked in a factory in Missouri and it's sitting on the shelf, then it has one tax treatment. If you buy a cake that was baked in the back by one of the local employees of the Walmart, then it's taxed differently. And that's what we're trying to clarify here is that if you have on-premises and off-premises consumption, the on-premises makes you a restaurant and therefore should be subject to the A&P tax. This would keep the loaf of bread that that mother that I described from being taxed as if she were paying in a restaurant. And I'm sorry if, as you said, we may get in the weeds. I'm trying to keep us out of there. Thank you. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair. I'm not sure if somebody might be here from A&Ps that can speak to this or not, but I'd like to hear their perspective if
▶ Play
somebody's out there. Okay. I'm not quite sure there is. Representative Dodson. Does anybody not address Representative Dodson's question? Any other questions, members? Representative Ferguson, you recognize her?
▶ Play
One quick question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Help me to understand, if we're talking about a convenience store that sells sandwiches, hot dogs and hamburgers and ham and cheese sandwiches, that they're going to take off-premises. There's a convenience store right around the corner from here that does that. Are they affected
▶ Play
Speaker 178 1:22:03
by this? Because it's off-premises, and you use the term off-premises.
▶ Play
Speaker 147 1:22:06
It would be if they were currently treated as a restaurant, And I'm not sure I can tell you, Mr. Ferguson, whether or not that particular type of business currently would be. It's a convenience store. Yes, sir. But they sell sandwiches. Yes, sir. This would exempt the sale of the baked goods from the tax, if they were currently being taxed that way. If they're not being taxed that way, there would be no change in their status whatsoever.
▶ Play
Representative Ferguson, I'm going to take a shot at that. The bill specifically says baked goods to the gross receipts or gross proceeds received by a bakery from the sale of baked goods sold for off-premises consumption. A convenience store, I don't think, would ever be defined as a bakery. So I don't think this changes anything for them. One follow-up. Yes, sir. Go ahead.
▶ Play
So the sandwich would be taxed as an A&P tax, the sandwich. if they went in there and bought a sandwich, ham and cheese, and took it off-premise. That would be taxed, but not the baked product. They would have to bake it on-site. So in
▶ Play
your example of a convenience store, you know, I haven't seen any convenience stores where they actually make anything on-site. They're generally just warming stuff up. So if that's currently taxed, like it's prepared food, like a restaurant, it would be subject to A&P tax, it will continue to be taxed. So this will not change its status
▶ Play
for them. President Eugene, you recognize her? That's just kind of clarification. What we're doing here is if it's value added, if a bakery is fixing a sandwich and putting it together, that's value added, that's still going to be subject to the A&P tax. Just a straight loaf of bread that they bake and come out of the oven, that's what we're talking about. Thank you,
▶ Play
sir. You said by Representative Collins, that's starting to rebuff on him. Members, any other questions? Thank you very much. Representative Davis, you close for your bill, sir? I close for the bill, and I'd
▶ Play
move to do pass. Members, we have
▶ Play
a motion to do pass in discussion as amended. Do pass as amended. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Any opposed, no? No. Congratulations. You passed your bill. Thank you. Thank you for your time. Representative Gates, you ready, sir? Members, this will be House Bill 1866. And there's going to be an amendment with this bill as well that we're passing out now. Representative Gates, just give us a minute, get the amendments passed out here, and we'll get started. Everybody have a copy of the amendment?
▶ Play
Representative Gase, you're free to proceed, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair, committee. I guess we need to deal with the amendment first. The amendment was a recommendation from DF&A to add a line in there that just says the total refund of overpayments for an extended audit period of time will not exceed the total amount assessed. And I'd appreciate a good vote on this amendment. Members, any questions on the
▶ Play
amendment? Anybody in the audience want to speak against the amendment for the amendment? Do we have a motion for the amendment? Motion depends. We have a motion from Representative Laideman. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no. Representative Gates, your amendment has passed and you're free
▶ Play
to proceed on House Bill 1866. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Currently, the law says that if you as a taxpayer find that in the last three years you've overpaid your income tax, that you can apply for a refund of that overpayment. However, anything past that three-year mark is water under the bridge, you lose it. However, the state of Arkansas can go back, let's say they audit you for six years. in that audit period past three years if you they find that you've overpaid them you don't get that overpayment but if they find an over underpayment you have to pay the underpayment amount so what this bill does it says if the state of Arkansas chooses to audit you and they audit you past that three-year limit at which we're not going to touch but if the state audits you past three years if in middle of that audit it is found and determined that you've made an overpayment any overpayment will go towards any underpayment during that audit period with the understanding that's what the amendment did said if an overpayment during that extended period and we're only dealing with the extended period here if any overpayment would be greater than the amount owed the total amount would be a wash. So if you've got the latest revenue impact statement, there is no impact on the state revenue. I'd be open to any questions.
▶ Play
Members, any questions? Tim, does DFA have any thoughts or want to add anything to this one way or the other? You guys are good with it? Thank you very much. Anybody not just want to speak against the bill? For the bill? Members, y'all had time to read over everything? Do we have a motion? Representative Gates, are you closed for your
▶ Play
bill, sir? I'm closed. I appreciate a good vote.
▶ Play
Motion passed. I have a motion. Representative Lateman. As amended. Any discussion? All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? Congratulations, sir. You passed your bill as amended. Thank you, Chair. Committee. Members, does anybody do we have any other members here that has a bill that does not have fiscal impact that want to run a bill that you know of we're trying to find representative Ballinger real quick here we're trying to clean this out this morning but we don't have to come back this afternoon so just give me about 30 seconds here so if we can get a hold of representative Ballinger here to run his I think if we can get this one ran this morning, Representative Ballinger I think, Representative Lemus did you have, you want to present a bill that had fiscal impact, is that correct sir? Yes sir, yes and it has impact. Has impact, okay we might circle back around on the back side of this afternoon. We'll work that out. Let me talk to the speaker on that and see. Actually, we might do, if we just have maybe a couple Senate bills Thursday, we might just throw that in there with that if you don't care. You're going to put this, yours and in them study, what you're planning on doing, sir? I believe that's what we're doing. Okay. We'll take a look at doing yours maybe Thursday with, we got, I think, two or three Senate bills that we'll take up Thursday, all right? If that's okay with you? We have one more today, as I know of. Okay. Thank you. And if we get to Representative Ballinger here, it's going to be 1176 members. House Bill 1176.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 1:30:26
Thank you.
▶ Play
Speaker 187 1:30:56
Okay, members, we cannot find Representative Bounder. We're not
▶ Play
going to sit here all day, so. Can he come? That works for me as well. So if you guys are all in agreement, we'll do that. We'll just give them a couple more minutes here. We won't recess out or anything, but we'll just sit tight here. Thank you.
▶ Play
Speaker 189 1:31:56
They got to a one. They didn't have a four. So I'm going to see the second one. These are the second one. The second one is going to go on. And they said, well, I've seen that. They went to the third one to find out. And so I'm going to get there until late today. So this was going to be a four. Members, I
▶ Play
think Representative Bowling is going to be here in just a second. Thank you.
▶ Play
Speaker 189 1:32:26
Thank you.
▶ Play
Speaker 196 1:32:56
Good of you to join us, buddy. I appreciate you. We're good.
▶ Play
Are you on the run? Oh, yeah. No, we're waiting on you. You have our full undivided attention, but that's how much we like you. We stayed here for 30 minutes waiting on you. You're free to go ahead and proceed when
▶ Play
you get ready. Well, thank you. That's quite an honor. Okay. This bill, which I don't even know what the bill number is, 17 something or other. 1176. No. Okay. I'm way off. So 1176. This is revenue and tax also. Oh! All right. It really is a simple clean up bill. I'd like to think that I'm the guy that decided to give a tax break to 100% disabled veterans, but some guy a long time ago has already done that. So they're on a your real estate taxes 100 percent disabled veterans are exempt. Now the problem is different counties treat that differently when a person becomes exempt, actually becomes, you know, becomes eligible for it, or, you know, gets their letter and all that stuff, or they move into a new area. Some counties do it exactly the way this bill proposes it, and what they do is they prorate it so the time that he didn't own the property that tax would still be owed when he owned the property he wouldn't know any tax which makes perfect sense but some some counties will do it in a variety of different ways I've worked with the assessors try to come up with a way that's this balance that makes sense for everybody and that's what this bill does the revenue impact should be negligible because we're only talking about people who are a hundred percent disabled veterans and either become disabled during that year or they they are they move and and also probably majority of the counties already do it this way so the reality is that maybe you know in the thousands you know less than ten thousand dollars would be my guess but there's no way of figuring
▶ Play
it out thank you and just point of clarification you did ask DFA try to do your fiscal
▶ Play
impact making I did wait we had three different organizations that tried to do the the fiscal impact and what I've got is a letter saying that they can't do the fiscal impact. So eventually, that's what Richard Wilson, I think he sent it to the committee, saying that it's impossible to figure out exactly what it is. Thank you. Members, any
▶ Play
questions? Anybody in honor you just want to speak against the bill? For the bill? Representative Ballinger, are you closed for your bill, sir? I am closed. I appreciate a good vote. Do we have a motion, sir? Motion from Representative Gazzalda, do pass. Any discussion? All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? Congratulations, sir. You passed your bill. you bet even though you didn't know what bill it was or what committee he was in you do good work buddy yeah we'll just get you on the house floor we'll work you over ok here's what we're going to do as far as I know right now I'll circle back around on the house floor make sure nobody else is going to run a bill this afternoon but right now we're still on the agenda for this afternoon but I don't anticipate us coming back but we'll get out of notice we'll announce it and then we'll come back Thursday I know we have about three senate bills and maybe a couple I think representative Douglas also has a bill she wants to put in interim study as well so that will probably be our last meeting probably Thursday so any discussion then we are adjourned thank you all very much
▶ Play

Agenda

HB1406

2:12 - 3:22 3 segments 2 speakers

HB1239

3:22 - 12:00 25 segments 6 speakers

HB1344

12:00 - 53:38 117 segments 17 speakers

HB1662

53:38 - 1:04:43 42 segments 13 speakers

HB1402

1:04:43 - 1:07:39 7 segments 5 speakers

HB1890

1:07:39 - 1:25:01 53 segments 10 speakers

HB1866

1:25:01 - 1:33:33 24 segments 6 speakers

HB1176

1:33:33 - 1:36:40 8 segments 2 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Joe Jett Chair Unverified
72 segments
Representative Julie Mayberry Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 21
5 segments
Speaker 27
1 segment
Representative Stephen Meeks Unverified
15 segments
Representative Kim Hendren Chair Unverified
11 segments
Representative Warwick Sabin Unverified
46 segments
Representative Jim Dotson Unverified
16 segments
Representative Charlie Collins Unverified
13 segments
Speaker 68
1 segment
Representative Lanny Fite Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 76
5 segments
Representative Jack Ladyman Unverified
1 segment
Representative Vivian Flowers Unverified
6 segments
Representative Les Eaves Chair Unverified
1 segment
Chair Unverified
1 segment
John Tice Unverified
7 segments
Representative Clarke Tucker Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 107
1 segment
Eleanor Wheeler Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 116
8 segments
Speaker 129
1 segment
Speaker 130
1 segment
Speaker 134
4 segments
Speaker 98
1 segment
Representative Nelda Speaks Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 146
2 segments
Speaker 147
17 segments
Speaker 139
1 segment
Speaker 51
1 segment
Speaker 115
1 segment
Representative Andy Davis Unverified
10 segments
Speaker 173
1 segment
Representative Kenneth B. Ferguson Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 178
1 segment
Representative Lane Jean Unverified
1 segment
Representative Mickey Gates Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 187
1 segment
Speaker 189
2 segments
Speaker 196
1 segment
Representative Bob Ballinger Unverified
5 segments