Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House State Agencies & Govt'l Affairs Committee

April 1, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (4)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1610 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…tative Womack to present concurrence in Senate Amendment on HB 1610. Representative Womack, you're recognized. I guess I better…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB963 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…ut objection, we're going to go ahead and take out of order Senate Bill 963.”
Pre-2017 bill
SB389 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…do have a slight delay. We're working on some amendments on Senate Bill 389, so without objection, we're going to go ahead and take out…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB993 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB993”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 14, 2026
All right, I'm going to go ahead and recognize Representative Womack to present concurrence in Senate Amendment on HB 1610. Representative Womack, you're recognized. I guess I better hit a gavel. Representative Womack, you're recognized to present concurrence in HB 1610. Thank you, Mr. Chair and committee. All
▶ Play
this is was a drafting error. There were two words that got left in that they deleted. Those two words are county or. So I would appreciate a good vote. All
▶ Play
right. Questions from the committee? Representative Walker, you recognize for a question? Was that what everyone else had a hand up for? All right. Representative Walker, let's hear your motion. All right. We've got a motion to do pass. And you, actually, Representative Walker, your motion is to concur and send an amendment? Yes. All right. We have a motion to concur and send an amendment. Is there discussion on the motion? Seeing none, all in favor say aye. Opposed? Thank you, Representative Womack. We've concurred an amendment. Thank you, Mr. Chair and committee. All right. Next up. Yes, Representative Walker, what's your question? This is your last bill that is amended before you retire. Representative Walker, it is my belief that that's my last bill of my legislative career. All right. Last
▶ Play
concurrence. I'd like to say to the committee, I don't know if they agree with me, but you have been a very fair chairperson, and I appreciate the way you have conducted business in this
▶ Play
chamber. Thank you. Well, Representative Walker, I appreciate that. I think there probably will be a few people that disagree, but I appreciate your kind words. All right. Next up, we are going to take up. We do have a slight delay. We're working on some amendments on Senate Bill 389, so without objection, we're going to go ahead and take out of order Senate Bill 963. SIG, no objection. Senator King, you're recognized to
▶ Play
present your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, members of the committee. 963 is to amend the law concerning complaints filed with investigations formed by the state board. This bill would say the state board of election commissioners shall upon request assist the law enforcement agency in its investigation and violation of election laws. If the state board of election commissioners refers an investigation to a law enforcement agency the law enforcement agency shall notify the state board of election commissioners a. when the investigation is closed or becomes inactive and whether a warrant for arrest or criminal charges have been pursued. The State Board of Election Commissioners may reopen a closed investigation for an additional 180 days if the State Board of Election Commissioners closed its investigation due to the initiation of a law enforcement investigation. The investigation by a law enforcement agency is closed or becomes inactive and the law enforcement agency has chosen not to pursue a warrant for arrest or criminal charges at this time, the investigation becomes closed or enacted. Are there questions from the committee?
▶ Play
Representative Bennett, you're recognized for a
▶ Play
question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I think this is right. This is after the investigation is closed, right? Nothing during the pending
▶ Play
investigation? Yes. Okay. Thank you. All right,
▶ Play
Representative Link, you're recognized for a question. Senator King, do you see a cost to this? Do you think this is going to be any expenditures? I mean, is this going to cost us anything to do this, to add this,
▶ Play
or what do you think? Well, typically, if they refer something to the state police, they investigate it, So that's a cost that occurs anyway. This is just basically saying if they've closed the investigation or done something, the state board can basically re-look at it. And many times in investigations into election fraud, the state police, and that's why we're, you know, one of the bills that we're doing is a voter integrity unit, which has a culmination of people, but a lot of times the state police is not, they investigate all different types of crimes. Well, elections are only held, you know, rarely, and they may not be trained in election machines, the procedures, those kind of things are new to them. That's why we brought the voter integrity unit bill that's on the floor today. So the other issue is, you know, we're trying to look and make sure that elections are run properly and the result that happens is the correct result. I mean, as I've stated before, if you look in Minnesota a few years ago when Al Franken won, they went back and had the recounts and come to find out there was a lot of fraud that happened. So you wound up having the wrong person possibly elected And understanding elections, especially statewide elections like in that one We may be having 71 counties doing a great job We may have three other counties that just had problems that you have Dealing with elections And then you may have one county that has fraud That could determine another result And the wrong candidate may get elected So this would just allow some extra time to relook and make sure the election process is vetted fairly, and after the elections, people have time to look at it. Okay, and I
▶ Play
don't, I'm sorry, Mr. You recognize for a follow-up. And I'm not really, I wouldn't say, I'm definitely arguing that. I'm just curious if you thought that this was going to bring about additional cost to the state or if you could
▶ Play
see that or not. It would only be a substantial amount of cost if you had, let's say, massive problems in numerous counties. I mean, and if you had that, then spending some money to make sure that determined the right person got elected and a fair process got heard, I think is okay if that happened. Now, hopefully, we typically know after each election there's typically four to six counties that have problems or issues. you know, it's not a widespread problem that I've seen so far. That's going to
▶ Play
be my next question is how many issues do we typically see? So if there's four to six, would we guesstimate an investigation might cost?
▶ Play
I mean, do you have any idea how much an investigation might cost? The prosecutors or state police in looking into the past matters that they looked into. If you look at the issue of Hudson-Hallam that had to resign, that all came about as far as federal part. That was not initiated by the state at all. So many of these elections that are investigated actually, because they're national elections, are investigated by the feds and then followed up by the state. So
▶ Play
this doesn't even, and I'm looking at the language. You recognize for additional follow-up since I don't see anybody else representing the link. More in a dialogue here, it looks like, than a question. So this doesn't really specify who would do the investigation, so it would be hard to figure out what the cost might be, at least to the state, because it might be some federal investigations, might be some state. I guess it could even, would it ever be a
▶ Play
county? It wouldn't ever be a county investigation. No, it would be the county. But the state police, in past history, the state police has looked into it or things have been turned over to the local prosecutor. If you've ever sat on the audit committee, a lot of times we refer possible things that may have possible fraud to the local prosecutors and they look into it. This just kind of follows the
▶ Play
same thing. Okay, and thank you for the freedom,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair. All right, Representative Dotson,
▶ Play
you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Senator King, looking through this bill, a couple things that your 180-day process, would they be allowed to certify the election then, or would they have to wait until after the 180 days has expired? and kind of along with that, how long after this investigation is closed would the State Board have to initiate this process of 180 days? I'm looking back at Mr. Clay, back here with the State Board of
▶ Play
Election Commissioners. The certification of election process, it would not change the timetable of that. That's correct. But if the election outcome
▶ Play
was changed. I'm sorry. Follow-up, Mr. Chair? If the election process was I mean if the person was found to not have been elected then would you they've already been certified and seated probably in the seat within 180 days I would assume The certification would have already happened
▶ Play
by that point but this is determined if additional evidence or anything came up that the state board could possibly relook into it for 180 days So they'd be able to remove them from office
▶ Play
if they'd already been? No, they would not. There
▶ Play
would have to be something filed in court, and Mr. Clay may be, do you care if he comes and answers questions? There would have to be something after the certification process. Somebody would have to file something in court, or you would have to find something of fraud to bring
▶ Play
forth that. I'll let Mr. Clay. Mr. Clay, if you would, identify yourself for the
▶ Play
record, who you're with, and you'll be recognized to offer information. Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee. My name is Justin Clay with the State Board of Election Commissioners, and everything Senator King said was correct, this bill doesn't affect the certification process or any removal from office procedures. That would have to be done by the courts.
▶ Play
All right. Questions from the committee for Mr. Clay? All right. Are there additional questions from the committee for Senator King? Representative Holcomb,
▶ Play
you're recognized. Senator, you know, you say this, the state police would investigate you know my question is that's the most elite force that we've got in the state whether it's surveillance whether it's investigation whether it's the children the children's division in their investigation would they not involve these people and these commission boards and question them and have them involved in the investigation would that would that not be part of their plan when they're doing I mean from what I know about investigation, being a law enforcement officer, an investigator
▶ Play
usually does all those things. I'm just kind of confused there. Go ahead. The State Board of Election Commissioners currently has authority to investigate alleged violations of election laws. One of the options that we have is to refer matters to the proper authorities, which may include local prosecutors, Arkansas State Police, et cetera, we would not interfere in any way with any possible investigations that are going on with those law enforcement agencies. You recognize for your follow-up. You
▶ Play
misunderstood my question. I didn't say interfere. when the state police or their unit, their investigative unit is doing their investigation, would they not involve these boards or commissions in the investigation? Wouldn't they question them? Wouldn't they have input into it? That's my
▶ Play
Speaker 54 11:55
question. That's very possible. Yes, sir. I would think so. Okay. Thank
▶ Play
you. All right. Additional questions for Mr. Clay? All right, Mr. Clay, you're excused. Thank you. All right. Senator King, have you spoken with state police about their responsibilities under this? Is that an existing law, or what's the status on just put additional work on them versus current law?
▶ Play
Well, I don't think this puts additional burdens on them. I mean, they investigate stuff. You have a state policeman right here. They get complaints, just like from maybe even a county board. They can get complaints from an individual. They can look into maybe a prosecutor. I mean, this really doesn't change the level of participation that they're involved in. I mean, those complaints can be given, and they can look into a matter. And then they determine, and they turn it over to a prosecutor if there's possible fraud, just much like what
▶ Play
audit does. So, currently, the state police has to investigate these anyway, or this shifts the responsibility? They can investigate.
▶ Play
You have a state policeman I'll defer to right there. Representative Tosh, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Let me just point a conversation here. Actually, the procedure that's used is that if there's an incident or a crime that feels like it's been committed, It will go to the prosecutor. The prosecutor has to request an investigation by the state police. It's automatically not sent to the state police. A crime of this nature can only be approved for investigation by the state police through the prosecuting attorney's office. That doesn't change this in any way.
▶ Play
Okay, but the state board can refer something to?
▶ Play
The procedure that should be followed is the state board would refer it to the prosecutor. The prosecutor would review the file and then in return would make the decision whether or not to involve the state
▶ Play
police. But this bill really doesn't address the investigations part of this. So
▶ Play
it looks to me like if I'm reading the bill correctly that this is shifting the investigations of local election complaints from the county board referring to the local prosecutor to the state police and bringing those to the statewide level where the state board is taking those over.
▶ Play
Is that, am I reading your bill correctly? No, I think what the bill is to say if the state board of election commissioners refers an investigation to a law enforcement agency, the law enforcement agency. I'm sorry, Senator King, I'm looking
▶ Play
at the other bill. Sorry. The question was incorrect. I had bumped the wrong button here. All right, are there additional questions from Senator King on this bill? All right, seeing none. Is there anyone here from the public speak for or against the bill? All right, seeing none, Senator King, are you closed for your bill? Yes, I'm closed. All right, what's the pleasure of the committee? I've got a motion by Representative Walker, do pass. All in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? Aye. Chair will's ayes have
▶ Play
it. Thank you. Do you want me to present 993 or come back after the next bill? Do we have
▶ Play
that amendment yet? Let's go ahead and move on to 993. And, Senator King, perhaps in your presentation you can address my question that I inappropriately directed to the previous bill. You're recognized to present.
▶ Play
Mr. Chairman, thank you members of the committee this bill is about if you understand I was for a time I was an election commissioner so I have served on the election commission this would bill would allow if you had individuals making complaints now that doesn't mean that they come in there and they're unhappy about the election and they just vent or they have to submit a written complaint to the county board This just kind of brings some more accountability in our elections where you have the county board. And understand, as I said before, a lot of these counties are good people. They just get together, try and do a good job, make sure the results are. They may have problems or whatever it is. But if they've had a written complaint, a description, the name of the complainant, the contact information of the complainant, and the description of the facts or circumstances associated with the complaint that the state board election commissioners shall investigate the violation of regularity on this section. And all we're trying to do right here is determine valid complaints, look at possible problems that happen in elections, irregularities, that it could at least be looked into. Election commissioners, whether they're Democrat or Republican, they're appointed by the local county parties. They are not elected officials. They're only accountable to their local county parties, and this would just allow the State Board of Election Commissioners to be able to have these complaints if they want
▶ Play
Speaker 72 17:25
to look into it. Okay, Senator King, I want to go
▶ Play
to page 2, line 5 and 6. This looks like mandatory investigation language. Is that what you're getting at there, that the state board must investigate these complaints?
▶ Play
What we're saying is if somebody takes the time to make a complaint, put their name on it, put their address, be able to do those things, send it up to the state board, then, yes, they need to look into it. Now, that doesn't mean to what level. It may be that they may look into it, contact these people, and, you know, figure out that it is just a problem, the right result wound up happening. I mean, the level that they look into it could be extremely minimal, or it could be that maybe there's a problem or issue that takes further looking into it. No different than we do with legislative audit, that we may have audit look into as members. I mean, I've been chair of audit. You may have them look into a certain matter out there with a county fair board or that. that. We may have them look into it, and it determines that maybe we need to come and do a special report audit and have an official report on something. Do you have
▶ Play
any idea how many complaints of this nature would happen in a typical cycle? You know, I mean, maybe
▶ Play
Mr. Clay could answer if he's heard very much about that. I don't know.
▶ Play
Mr. Clay, do you have information you might be
▶ Play
able to provide? Thank you, Mr. Chair. Justin Clay, State Board of Election Commissioners. We don't have statistics on written complaints that were filed at the county level that were not forwarded to us. I think this bill would simply require that when that happens, a written complaint is made at the county level that it's forwarded to us for us to investigate and look into.
▶ Play
And this does say that you shall investigate, so you're going to have to conduct an investigation. Yes, sir. Do you all believe you have adequate resources to handle
▶ Play
that? I believe so. Given the unknown nature of the number of complaints? I believe so. And just to be clear, the State Board doesn't have a position, per se, on these pieces of legislation. But I think this bill follows what we would do currently in practice. So, no, I don't think any additional resources would be necessary. Senator King, do
▶ Play
you have a fiscal impact statement on this bill?
▶ Play
No, I don't think one's required. I haven't went through this whole process, and it's been filed, and Mr. Clay just stated he didn't think he needed additional resources. If he did, certainly I've been one of the most physically responsible people up here with my voting record, and if you look at costing more, then certainly we'd have to have more resources. Right now, I mean, Mr. Clay just testified that he didn't think so, and I hope not. But as I said before, when you have elections and you have irregularities, you have a situation come up. We had a few years ago, before anybody else in the legislature, including myself, you had the Senator Crumley issue where the Senate actually had to verify and vote on him to seat him after they determined there was fraud that happened in that election. So by doing some of this, it could be proactive in that you don't have a, as I mentioned before, have a statewide recount of the other states. I participate in the NCSL's task force on elections. If you sit through presentations where they have to have a statewide recount, you're talking about a lot of money that's going to have to be spent to try and determine what the right result is Senator King I guess my
▶ Play
concern is we've had testimony that there's an unknown number of these complaints that are out there we've had testimony we have adequate resources to cover something that's unknown I've got some concerns about the ability to adequately predict what this is going to cost. Well, I know that we just had Mr. Clay think
▶ Play
that it's done. Then how long have you been in your job? How long have you worked for the State Board of Elections Commission? I've been there three and a half years, been the director for two. And at my time in the legislature, you came up and testified against my bills when you had concerns, correct? I don't think I've ever testified against any of your bills. or you've taken positions to get my bills, and, you know, that's okay, and that's part of the process. But, you know, I mean, I think that when somebody takes the time to make a complaint, then having some accountability to look into it to make sure the right result got happened, then could be proactive,
▶ Play
too. All right. Representative Walker, did I see you with a question? No. Okay, Representative Douglas, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
I think just from having an experience with a local county election committee, I saw that the people in our county had no voice, and there was no due process. You know, we took a complaint. A law was obviously broken, and they decided to do nothing because they had the power to do that. And we appealed to you guys about this issue, and you really had no power to go back in and tell them what to do. So I may be misspeaking there, but it appeared that was what was going on. And what I see with this is this gives people who are voters a due process and a voice to be able to be heard when they feel like their voting rights have been, you know, discounted. Am I on the right track here?
▶ Play
Exactly right. From your experience, you've seen that. And I've seen in elections where county boards of election commissioners have went to counting ballots without a public notice, without anybody around. I've seen that multiple times. And, folks, there's no excuse for any county election, Republican or Democrat, to go and start counting ballots and determining election results without a public meeting, without notification of the candidates, that, number one, is illegal to do that. Now, that could be just because it's a mistake, but yet what it does is it puts doubt in the integrity of the process when, you know, controversial bills. Every one of our bills are put up on the board on how we're going to vote. So that process is open to the public. If it wasn't open to the public, as I mentioned in those cases, then people start to question the result. So this bill is just like Representative Douglas said. It's about allowing citizens to possibly have a voice and look into determining their elections and make sure that we get the right result and have some accountability.
▶ Play
Representative Douglas, you're recognized for follow-up. And I would hope that in just having this in place would cut back on irregularities and that, you know, going forward we may have a cleaner process because they know that they're going to be more accountable to the people. So regardless of how many we have at this point, I would think that they would be diminished in the future because we have this process in
▶ Play
place. And the other thing is, if they're making frivolous complaints, then that's able to be re-looked into. And people, the State Board, could actually verify that people out there are doing the right thing, too. All
▶ Play
right. Additional questions from the committee? All right, Mr. Clay, you're excused. All right. Does anyone here from the public speak for or against the bill? All right. Seeing none, Senator King, we'd like to close for your bill. I'm close. Representative Tosh Alright I have a motion due passed by Representative Tosh Discussion on the motion Say none All in favor say aye Opposed Congratulations Senator King you've passed your bill Alright committee Senator Stubblefield are you still here with us Okay We still don't have the two amendments that we're waiting on for your bill. Committee, what we need to do here, I think, is stay in a recess, get those amendments located, have a little bit of discussion on those amendments, and come back. I can't see that clock. I'm showing 1143. We do have another meeting at 1215. Let's stand in recess for 10 minutes. Amen.
▶ Play

Agenda

HB1610

0:06 - 2:16 8 segments 3 speakers

SB963

2:16 - 15:39 59 segments 8 speakers

SB993

15:39 - 26:57 34 segments 5 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Nate Bell Chair Unverified
29 segments
Representative Richard Womack Unverified
2 segments
Representative John W. Walker Unverified
2 segments
Senator Bryan King Unverified
43 segments
Representative Camille Bennett Unverified
1 segment
Chair Unverified
7 segments
Representative Jim Dotson Unverified
5 segments
Justin Clay Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 54
1 segment
Representative Dwight Tosh Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 72
1 segment
Representative Dan M. Douglas Unverified
4 segments