House Judiciary Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (5)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
SB975
· 5 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “Thank you for your patience. The next item on our agenda is Senate Bill 975, Representative Ballinger, you're recognized to present Sen…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1228
· 3 mentions in transcript
Matched: “…nd the members of the General Assembly for recognizing that HB 1228 would do irreparable harm to the reputation and people of A…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB965
· 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB965”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1529
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1529”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB79
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…h smaller, far weaker little brother to the recently vetoed Senate Bill 79. Senator Woods and I earned the distinction of earning this…”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 14, 2026
the same bill we talked about earlier this year. We did a minor modification for it on the Senate side, and all it did was extend the period five more years to give people more time to
if they wanted to bring a lawsuit or something like that associated with it. I'd appreciate a good vote and a motion do concur.
Alright, do we have any questions from the committee? Seeing none, I don't believe anybody spoke to sign up or signed up to speak for or against. Seeing no more questions, we've got a motion do pass. All those in favor say aye. All those opposed, congratulations, the ayes have it. concurred in Senate amendment. All right, Senator Woods, Representative Letty, I believe,
is going to present Senate Bill 965. Representative Letty, you're recognized. Thank
you, Mr. Chair and committee. I'll be very brief. Senate Bill 965 is the much smaller, far weaker little brother to the recently vetoed Senate Bill 79. Senator Woods and I earned the distinction of earning this governor's first veto. We made several changes to this bill. First of all, it only applies to people with a domicile in Arkansas. We also allow photographers to post photos of celebrities
electronically, and they only have to take them down if the subject asks them to. We clarified the street photography concerns. There were concerns that people wouldn't be able to engage in street photography, which we did not feel was true, but we made sure that language was stronger. We also removed the First Amendment language that the Motion Picture Association of America had opposed. They are now fine with the bill. And there was one more change. But we worked with the Governor's Office on these changes. The Professional Photographers of America are very pleased with the changes we made to Section E, and we'd appreciate a good vote.
Representative Whitaker, I had you know first for question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Letting,
I guess I heard you right. I just want to hear this clearly and not with all the other stuff around it. The governor's office has looked at this and they're okay with it now? We worked with them on this language. You made the changes they wanted. Yes. In the fifth change, we narrowed
the scope, or narrowed the definition of commercial use. Thank you. Representative Bynes. Morning. Good morning.
If I'm a Memphis photographer, this doesn't apply to me?
As a subject, you have to have like say Kobe Bryant came to Arkansas and somebody took his photograph and used it in a way he didn't approve of, he would have no recourse with this bill because he
doesn't have a domicile here in Arkansas. So again, if I'm a Memphis photographer, this means nothing to me. It shouldn't. OK, thank you.
Representative Bennett, you recognize the question. Any other questions from committee?
Seeing none, it looks like we have a couple people assigned to speak on the bill, Rebecca Peterman. Rebecca, Ms. Peterman, you're recognized. If you want to go down the end of the table and introduce yourself, you're recognized.
Speaker 16
3:39
Hi, I'd like to thank you for agreeing to hear my concerns. My name is Rebecca Peterman. I'm a portrait photographer in Hot Springs and I'm also here
representing the Professional Photographers of America and the Arkansas Professional Photographers Association. We do appreciate the changes that have been made since SB 79. However, there are still some concerns under the fair use that would apply to our businesses every day. The wording a member of the public is not really specific enough to protect wedding photographers and event photographers in every situation. The second concern that we specifically
have is yearbook photographers who photograph a school and they photograph every student for that yearbook. They sell that yearbook, but it would be impossible to get a release from every parent of every student, which means that exemption C and exemption E do not cover that use. We're also concerned about if you post a portfolio picture on a website or Facebook, some other social media, and a member of the public comes on and identifies an individual
in that picture, does that put the photographer in a bad place? So those are our concerns, and we appreciate the intent of the bill. We're just a little concerned that its unintended application will negatively impact our businesses. Thank you.
Any questions? That's all right, Ms. Peyton. Thank you. Apparently no questions. All right, we've got Paul Calvert.
Mr. Calvert, if you'll introduce yourself,
you'll recognize. My name is Paul Calvert. I'm from Faulkner County. I'm here actually to speak against the actual intent of the bill. If I'm out in public, the news agencies can use my photographs, my images, for the purposes of making money. That's one of the reasons why they're in business is to make money. Why would we prevent an advertiser from using the exact same videos and photographs to make money?
Why is it fair? Why is it just to tell the advertisers that they can't make money off my photographs, but the news agencies can? Why is there a difference? They're both speech issues. Let's make it fair. Kill the bill, please. We'll take questions. Seeing no
questions, thank you, Mr. Calvert. Nobody else has signed up. Representative Letting, do you wish to close?
Thank you, Mr. Chair and committee. We're confident that there'd be nothing in this bill that would prohibit anybody from posting a photo to Facebook. And also, we also feel that through the school photography process, there'd be ample opportunities to get releases from the parents during the school, while the kids are having their photos made. So we feel that school photographers should also be just fine, and we
would appreciate a good vote. Thank you, Representative Letting. What's the pleasure of the committee?
I've got a motion to do pass. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Those opposed? No. Sorry, Bill fails. Thank you. All right, we are going to take a five-minute recess right now. We are not adjourning. We're just taking a five-minute
recess. Great job. You'd like to ask. I apologize for the delay.
Thank you for your patience. The next item on our agenda is Senate Bill 975, Representative Ballinger, you're recognized to present Senate Bill 975. Thank you, Mr. Chair,
and committee. So we're down here doing this one more time.
Essentially, Senate Bill 975, what we've done with this is we've taken the federal RFRA and we've mirrored the language of the federal RFRA and we've incorporated how the federal RFRA is utilized in federal case law. I've said all along the legislation that I carried before was essentially the federal RFRA and we've just taken the case law from various cases that interpret the federal RFRA and applied it, put it together. And then there was a few peripheral things that were insignificant in the bill
and some of it that frankly probably i would have a hard time seeing the the application of it and when i say insignificant you know they were good to have in there but in the end fundamental purpose of this bill is that we're going to protect religion at a heightened scrutiny we're going to allow a person to believe what they want to believe without the state coming in and burdening that unless they have a good reason to do so i've said that over and over again that that's what the purpose of the bill is this bill does that same thing this bill provides those religious protections now why so why are we coming back and filing another bill when there's one that's really
good sitting on the governor's desk the reason for that is perception is that that bill is perceived to be as something that's different we've come into kind of a a firestorm of everything happening in indiana everything um you know the some other things that kind of we've created with legislation we passed as far as attention that we've we've garnered and and it's been treated is something that it wasn't. It's a good bill. I think it's good law. I think it protects people. However, coming back and utilizing the language
of the federal RFRA makes it real clear that we're not going to be doing anything any different than what the federal government is already doing. And it already is happening in a majority of the other states. And so by doing that, it makes it where we can conclusively say that this bill is substantially similar to what the majority of the jurisdictions already operate under. It mirrors what Bill Clinton signed. It mirrors what President Barack Obama voted for when he was Senator Barack Obama twice. It basically makes it where it's a lot harder for individuals to see this as something that it's not.
And so with that, I would be open up
to any questions. I see no questions. Representative
Bennett, you're recognized for a question. This is not actually a question, but it's a statement. Representative Ballinger, I appreciate your diligent efforts in reforming the language so that it does truly mirror the federal law. I think this is such an excellent example of how Republicans, Democrats, caucuses, everybody has worked very hard.
I feel so good that we're ending the session on such a good note, and I just want to commend you for all your hard work on
this. Well, thank you very much. I'd have to say that I had a governor who has a bill on his desk that he's promised to sign. I fully expected that it would have been signed into law. However, I've really enjoyed working with the 90th General Assembly, and frankly, if I can step out of here and feel like my citizens are protected and their religious freedoms are protected and I can kind of keep unity in the legislature,
I'm all for that. And so that's what this attempt is. And having said all that, I'd be still happy to answer any questions
or I'd make a motion to pass. All right. I see no further questions. We do have a few people who have
Sklar, you're recognized. Good morning, everybody. My name is Rita Sklar. I'm executive director of the ACLU of Arkansas.
We didn't testify earlier because, like everybody else, we expected the bill to fail. First of all, let me say that we'd like to thank the governor and the members of the General Assembly for recognizing that HB 1228 would do irreparable harm to the reputation and people of Arkansas. But 1228 gave us a black eye.
This bill ices it. We still need some Tylenol. And so I'm here to speak against the bill. I will say that the amendment that was just passed that says that federal civil rights, or that was just introduced, that federal civil rights will not be violated is a good thing. As we know, federal civil rights laws do not protect LGBT Arkansans from discrimination.
As the drafters desire, this law is as close to a state could come to codifying federal RFRA into state law. Unlike the drafters, however, we do not think this solves all the problems posed by the original RFRA. For like the 1993 federal law, this bill does not contain an express protection ensuring continued fair balancing of civil and religious rights. Enacting a 1993 federal law does not put Arkansas's law where it should be in 2015.
As has been said in here, the ACLU supported the federal RFRA in 1993, which was the same year Arkansas passed the Civil Rights Act. Our concerns with RFRA began in the 1990s, when the legal standards of the federal RFRA, compelling government interest, least restrictive means, substantial burden, were used in multiple cases to allow discrimination against unmarried heterosexual couples
based on a person's religious beliefs. The 1993 federal RFRA isn't the right solution for Arkansas in 2015 because its language has been proven to be used to discriminate. The right solution is not to have a RFRA at all because religious liberty is protected by the First Amendment and the Arkansas Constitution and the Arkansas Civil Rights Act. And I have to correct some statements that have been made here, preachers, ministers, rabbis,
do not have to marry anybody they don't want to. No law could make them do that. And if one were passed, the ACLU would be the first to fight that law. And the same goes for students wearing yarmulkes in schools. That is allowed now. And we don't need a RFRA to do that. So as a show of good faith, to help address some of the defects of this law, we ask that you do everything in your power to do two things.
First, to address some of the defects inherited from the federal law by providing explicit protections for civil rights as part of the Arkansas RFRA. Second, add now missing and needed protections to our state civil rights law to protect against discrimination based on age, veterans, or military status, gender identity, and sexual orientation. We recognize that this bill could prevent us from experiencing the disastrous results of legislation
like HB 1228 that takes the RFRA well beyond its original, sorry, its original intent, the consequences of which would certainly undermine our ability to prosper as well as our ideals as a state and as a nation. We could debate whether or not this bill repairs the damage done to our state and our reputation from that effort.
But the law will not be righted absent express civil rights protections. And even then, it will not be righted. It will be made better. Thank you very much. I
see no questions. Thank you for your testimony. Next on our list, we have Jackie Martin. Ms. Martin, you may take a seat at the end of the table, state your name, if there's any organization you represent, and then you may offer your testimony.
Good morning. Can you hear me? Because I'm kind of congested. Every time I come to this building, my allergies act up. I don't know why. But I kind of want to put a face on this for the legislators today of a person who has deeply held religious convictions regarding several issues based on what God's word says to my heart and labels it as sin.
and that I try not to do because the Lord knows I commit enough sins of my own. But this is the point I want to make. I am the director of music for my church, and I'm also a classically trained pianist. And I've played for weddings, I've played for many events, recitals, whatever, in public. And since this has become an LGBT issue and I look at the reports on TV and I read what's going on in the newspaper,
I'm actually now scared, frightened to participate any longer in playing and sharing my music with other people because I'm afraid I will be charged with discrimination if I refuse to play for a same-sex wedding because my faith, my heart, what I believe when I read God's word says that is something I shouldn't participate in. I don't invite others to participate in things that I consider to do wrong that I do wrong.
And quite honestly, at this point, I really don't think I can continue providing that service to my church, to my community, in sharing my music, because this has become about the LGBT movement, instead of allowing me as a human being to have my own religious conscience, and how my God leads me to live
that out, and now a skill set that I've been doing since I was four years old is in jeopardy, Because this has become so politicized. I don't judge people for what they do and their choices that they make. I have to live my life, though, because in the final analysis, in my faith, I believe I will be facing God Almighty in the end.
And I have to give an account for me. I can't point my finger to other people. Well, they did this and make myself a pillar to be better. My main concern today is being able to continue to provide music and practice what I believe in my heart that my God tells me is the right way to live life. And that is in jeopardy today.
Because when I compare HB 1228 to SB 975, what I've noticed is the definitions have been taken out that were in HB 1228 that made it extremely easy for me to understand what is a compelling interest. What is religious conscience as defined by law? I mean, I know what it is as a person, but what does the law say about it? The other thing that was taken out was the section on remedies and penalties.
If I have a lawsuit filed against me for discrimination because I refuse to play for honky-tonk, I have to hire an attorney. Who's going to be in line to pay me back all the money I'm going to be out because attorneys charge exorbitant rates nowadays? that remedy has been taken out of SB 975 so I either just stop enjoying the musical career that I've had my entire
life so that I don't get sued where I can't afford to pay anything or have to sell my house to be able to afford to pay the attorney's fees and any fines that accompany that. So I just wanted to come here this morning and explain to you what my thought process is on this whole issue and to put a human face on this on the opposite side of this argument. I am not denigrating the other side of the argument at all. All I'm trying
to do is present to you a person who has a deeply held religious conscience on many issues and how that is jeopardizing my ability to continue to perform and do something that I love doing and sharing with other people. And I'll take any questions, and I appreciate your time this morning. Thank you for your testimony.
Thank you. Next on the list is Rebecca Peterman. Speak. Okay, so all right. Then we have two more. Paul Calvert to speak against the bill. Paul Calvert from Faulkner County. I
may not know what I'm talking about on this, but in the intent portion of this bill compared to 1228,
1228 had the requirement of strict scrutiny, And in place of that, in the intent portion, it mentions that it should be applied as a couple of cases. I believe it was Wisconsin v. Yoder and it was Sherbert v. Werner and Wisconsin v. Yoder. And as I look at those cases, I don't really want our law to be applied like that.
And maybe this legislative intent doesn't apply in court in most cases. I'm not an expert in that field. But when I look at those cases, Wisconsin v. Yoder doesn't look like a case of strict scrutiny. It looks like a case of pretty low scrutiny. And like I said, I may be wrong about that. But it just looks like a case, almost a no-brainer case. And the Sherbert v. Werner almost looks like it burdens the employer. And feel free to tear me apart on that. I'm willing to learn.
Does that conclude your testimony? Yes, sir. I was asking for questions if you wanted to. We get to ask the questions around here, so thank you for your testimony. All right. We have one final person that signed up to speak on the bill. Actually, for clarification, John DePippa. If you would, have a seat at the end of the table. If you're representing any organization, please identify that, and you may offer your testimony.
Mr. Chair and members of the committee, thank you for being here.
My name is John DePippa, and I am a Dean Emeritus and Distinguished Professor of Law and Public Policy at the University of Arkansas Little Rock, William H. Bowen School of Law. I do want to say that although I work there, I do not speak for the school. And so what I'm saying today is based on my understanding as a scholar and as a personal citizen. I also wish to commend Representative Ballinger and Senator Hutchinson and everyone else in the legislature who worked so promptly to respond to the governor's concerns and come up with what I think is a good first step.
By incorporating federal RFRA, you've accomplished a number of things, not the least of which is you've put into state law language that other courts have dealt with. And so there's at least a common language that this state and other courts can now speak regarding religious liberty. So I do believe this is a good first step, taking in good faith in the spirit of compromise. I wish, however, that the bill had included a more expressed statement that it does not, cannot be used to defeat a claim under a civil rights law.
That's still an open question under the federal law and under many state RFRAs. Many states have adopted similar kinds of provisions. Texas, for example, when they adopted their 1999 RFRA, included a statement that said it could not be used to establish a defense in a civil rights claim. This morning, legislators in Indiana have proposed even more express language delineating that it cannot be used in very specific cases, including race, gender, age, sexual orientation, etc.
I believe that would be a necessary piece of this bill now, if not now, then in the future. Indiana goes even a step further and makes it clear that the law could never be applied to pastors or religious organizations. And I think that also needs to be part of a compromise bill. In the end, let me just take a moment to say I used to favor these bills. I've been a scholar of this area for 31 years since I've been in legal education. I followed RFRA, but I, like other people in this area, have changed their mind about their value,
including Professor Marcy Hamilton, who is one of the drafters of federal RFRA. In the end, however, I think compromise is important, and this bill is a good first step toward what I think is the right balance between religious liberty and equality. Thank you. All
right. Thank you for your testimony. I believe that's all that we have signed up. Representative Ballinger has moved.
Do pass and is closed for the bill. Is there any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? The bill passes. If there's no further business to come before the committee, thank you for your work and your patience today. Without objection, we're adjourned.
Agenda
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Speaker 1
Representative Rick Beck
Unverified
Representative Marshall Wright Chair
Unverified
Representative Rebecca Petty
Unverified
Representative David Whitaker
Unverified
Representative John T. Vines
Unverified
Speaker 16
Paul Calvert
Unverified
Representative Matthew J. Shepherd Chair
Unverified
Representative Bob Ballinger
Unverified
Representative Camille Bennett
Unverified
Speaker 42
Rita Sklar
Unverified
Jackie Martin
Unverified
John Depippa
Unverified