House State Agencies and Govt'l Affairs 4/22/16
Video
Transcript
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 14, 2026
All right, we're going to go ahead and get started. of you three gentlemen who is here who are here do either any one of the three of you want to join me as vice
chair or do we just want to just proceed for where we're sitting all right representative fielding when you're finished with your phone call you're welcome join us at the table as well I'll go ahead and hit the gavel so I think they're going to live stream this I think several of the members are actually going to watch via live stream as well so several said that they were headed home but would join us and watch that way with that we'll convene the meeting first of all this morning I want to thank
the members who took their time to be here as well as the public it's been a rather difficult week at the capitol for all of us and I appreciate you taking the time to stay around and participate in the meeting I also want to thank Ms. Sherry Thomas who has pretty much pulled all this together herself due to me being rather hard to reach this week. So I want to say a big thank you to her. She works very hard to make sure, as well as the rest of our staff, to make sure that we have what we need to make this all work.
Purpose of the meeting today is informational. One of the things that's frustrated me over the last several years is watching us come into legislative sessions with elections-related legislation that the lines of communication haven't been open between the various interested parties, and we wind up getting to the end of the session and having something that we still don't have agreement on. So I'm hoping that we can have all the players present for items that concern people
and begin that discussion. With that, do any of the members have anything that you want to discuss before we begin with the agenda items okay I think the one of the items that we have was brought to me by my County Clerk Miss Terry Harrison regarding some issues with with petition circulation for municipal candidates and I think mr. Scott Perkins is going to present to us what the issues are there and what
we can do or what we need to be looking at to clarify that situation and get get the code in a cleaner situation. So, Mr. Perkins, if you'd identify yourself for the record, you'll
Speaker 8
2:55
be recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Scott Perkins, Legislative and Communications Director for the Association of Arkansas Counties. I appreciate y'all's time today. Got a call yesterday that we were going to have a conversation about municipal petition circulations. I'll tell you, it did stem from Terry Harris and a couple other clerks who have cited
I'm going to cite certain code here. 1442-206 is the one that Terry called about that day, sir. And it's undefined of when the start date that that candidate can start to circulate their nominating petition. We've got, excuse me, it's 102 days or 81 days is the filing that's described in the statute to turn in the petition. But the exact date of when you can start to circulate isn't clear. And that's given a couple clerks a gray area, obviously, and that's why we're getting the questions.
And just to clarify that for the benefit of the committee, during the last session we did pass one bill. It was actually my bill, so that's why I remember it, that did establish a form for other candidates and clarified a lot of the language and situation around that. So this is kind of a follow-up to that. Yes, sir. It was right
Speaker 8
4:08
in candidacy is the one I'm thinking about that you ran successfully for us, and we appreciate that. It was just a similar kind of cleanup in the gray area in Title VII.
So the code section affected is 1442-206? In my opinion, that's the
sir. And specifically the changes that you all are recommending would be to clarify the time for circulation of petitions. Are there issues with the form like there were similar to other independent and write-in candidacies, or is that something we need to address as well? Detailed issues with the
Speaker 8
4:44
form have not been brought to our attention. It's certainly something we can look at.
I would also like to say I'm not going to jump into municipal code without the municipal league being on it. It's more of a municipal bill, in my opinion. So I'd certainly like to ask them to be involved, and
I don't want to step in their sandbox, so to speak. All right. Any
questions for members? Representative Tosh, we recognize the question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Making reference to 14, was it 1442-206? Yes, sir. Do we have a copy of that?
Representative Tosh, we don't have a copy of that one. We got copies distributed for several of the other code sections that are going to be discussed. All right, I think our attorney has one here for us. yeah i'll sherry's going to bring it to you and we can circulate around to the other members as well so everybody can get get familiar with that okay thanks additional questions for members for mr perkins representative ladyman you're recognized for question
thank you mr chair uh do you know what the municipal league's opinion is on this do you have any idea
Speaker 8
5:52
have they been involved in it at all i had a conversation with mark hayes yesterday uh when we had the meeting scheduled. There is a representative of the Municipal League here. If you'd like to ask them, I believe the consensus is that we need to explicitly detail a
date of when this petition can be circulated. Who's here from the Municipal League? I'm looking around. Okay. I see Jack now. I actually spoke to him earlier and just forgot his affiliation. Jack, did you have anything you wanted to add?
but it's an issue that needs to be clarified. Okay. All right. Additional questions from members, Mr. Perkins? All right. Thank you, Mr. Perkins. We appreciate your testimony today. Yes, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair and committee members. Members, I would encourage you to work with Municipal League and Mr. Perkins to try to pull a bill together. My suggestion and one of the things that I, as we look forward throughout the summer, I am going to be asking us to meet a little more, with a little more regularity over the summer.
and we'll be fleshing that schedule out. But one of the things that I'm hoping we can get to is the possibility of some consensus bills that you all can introduce as committee bills in the next session. That tends to make them become non-controversial and move along pretty easily. So hopefully we can work towards that goal and get good consensus bills that will clean up a lot of this stuff. All right, with that, I'm going to go ahead and move on to the next item, which is a discussion of election and removal processes of election commissioners.
This is one that we've had a number of contacts about from various places, and I'll just reiterate a personal story. Many of you have heard this in committee from me when I've brought this up in ALC and various other locations, but I'm personally familiar with the situation where one of my local election commissioners actually actively campaigned for a congressional candidate to the point of wearing a T-shirt, handing out literature in the park, staffing a booth, and actually hosted a fundraiser for my opponent in the last election,
all of which are prohibited by law. He openly admits that he did that, but yet the prosecutor won't file a petition to remove him. Interestingly enough, the prosecutor is, in fact, the husband of the niece of that congressional candidate. so there's a there's a lot of things that we run into where we simply have these election commission situations where someone knowingly willfully and repetitively violates the law and
yet they continue on in their position and so we're looking at how we could potentially address those situations going forward so that people who are in that type of situation and there are others around the state that are similar would there be a process a clear and prompt process for removal and replacement so that's that's what we're looking at discussing today I think mr. Justin clay is first on our list and mr. clay if you'll identify yourself for the records you recognize
Speaker 40
9:05
to proceed thank you mr. chair members of the committee my name is Justin clay director of the state board of election commissioners but I talk a little bit about maybe how election commissioners come to be they're elected of course every county has three election commissioners they're elected in January of odd-numbered years by their respective county political party committees so the the majority party elects two members in January of every odd-numbered
year the minority party county committee of every county elects one election commissioner in January of odd-numbered years. Those commissioners are subject to removal at any time by majority vote of their respective county committees. Election commissioners are also considered county officials, and aside from the county committee potentially voting to remove a commissioner, they're subject to the same removal process
that other county officials are subject to for being unqualified to hold that particular office by a prosecutor, as you mentioned, Mr. Chair. Mr. Clay, one thing that perhaps
you can clarify for us, in my conversations with the prosecutor about this situation, his frustration that he expressed to me was the fact that he is also in a dual role as the county attorney, and as such, with those folks being county officials, He, in fact, has an embedded conflict of interest in the law, and he was struggling with how does he, while he's tasked with representing them, also fulfill his role in removing them.
And, you know, I want to be completely fair with him. Despite the family conflict, he clearly expressed a conflict in law that does exist and that, you know, clearly needs to be addressed. So I think if you could perhaps expound on that and those relationships and what specifically we would need to look at changing in law to streamline that and clarify the role of the prosecutor or perhaps hand that responsibility to someone else in that situation, I'd greatly appreciate your clarification on that.
Speaker 40
11:21
Sure. The prosecuting attorney serves, statutorily serves, as the legal advisor for county election commissions. So they're, on the one hand, a legal advisor, and then on the other hand, are the entity that would be required to bring removal proceedings for an election commissioner. So
do you have any suggestions about potentially how we could realign those roles where we could make that where they weren't in that conflict situation?
Speaker 40
11:59
No, I don't have any specific suggestions. Honestly, I haven't studied this particular topic in great detail. But it would be a policy decision of just deciding, I guess, who it is that needs to do what exactly. I'm going to go to member questions. Just a second. And one
additional follow-up to that, just a thought that I've had is the possibility of kicking that up to the state board.
Sure. Are there any legal hurdles in doing that or potential pitfalls to that that you
Speaker 40
12:42
could share with us? No, none come to mind. The state board currently has no authority to remove a county election commissioner. So if that's something that the legislature thought was appropriate, the board would need specific authority allowing them to do that. And, you know, I will say the example you had mentioned in your experience,
those are activities that would potentially disqualify an election commissioner from holding that office. And so there's a little bit of a, you know, the State Board doesn't have any authority to determine whether or not someone's qualified to hold that office either. I think that's a distinction that people don't often recognize. So if that was something that the legislature was interested in, then there would need to be specific authority given in that regard as well.
Are there any constitutional prohibitions to granting that authority by
Speaker 40
13:48
law? None come to mind. I'm going to look to my left at our staff council, Tim
Humphreys. No. All right. Questions from members. I believe Representative Dotson, did you
Speaker 55
14:00
raise your hand earlier? You're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Would there be an instance in which a conflict of interest such as this occurs that a special
Speaker 40
14:13
prosecutor could be appointed? Potentially. You know, I'm not particularly knowledgeable on that subject matter, on how a special prosecutor gets appointed, but potentially.
Speaker 55
14:22
It's not automatic that it would be required, obviously, currently, but if there was proof that a conflict of interest that was there, how would we go about setting up a mechanism in which we could have a pool of special prosecutors that are not necessarily locally obligated outside of that county. I mean, obviously kicking it up the state board would be one solution potentially, but I'm not sure exactly how a special prosecutor is selected
if it's by virtue of the prosecutor saying, hey, I have a conflict and let me have a special prosecutor, or if it's automatic in some here's the exact things that say I have a conflict and so it needs to be sent out. I would say that, at least in this particular instance, every prosecutor in the state would have a conflict for their local. If they're the local advise and consent to the election commissioner,
they're automatically going to have a conflict in prosecuting him. So it would be an automatic in probably every county in the state, not just one particular county that might have a family
Speaker 40
15:42
relation. Sure, and I'm going to attempt not to wade off into waters that I really have no subject matter knowledge of, but, you know, the prosecutor is the entity that I believe – do you mind if I get Mr. Humphreys up here? I was – because I have
I bet he can address this generally. Mr. Humphreys, if
you'll identify yourself for the record you're recognized. Tim Humphreys, counsel for the State Board of Election Commissioners. It's my understanding that the Prosecutor Coordinator's Office has a system set up already for special prosecutors in the case of conflicts, and you're exactly right. Any prosecutor in the state is going to have this conflict with regard to county election commissions.
The statute that gives the prosecutor the authority to remove a county official is the usurpation statute, which is 16-118, maybe 201, something like that. And that statute says that the prosecutor has the authority to remove all county officials who are disqualified. And the Attorney General has the authority to remove all state officials and municipal officials who are not qualified to hold their offices.
Speaker 55
17:09
So it's a broad section of code, not necessarily specifically defined for election commissioners. That's right. Is there any other county office that, and you may not know the answer to this, that would have this automatic conflict? I was going to
Speaker 40
17:29
kind of mention that. I would think any of them might. I mean, I don't know that the prosecutor serves as a legal advisor of other county officials, per se,
like he would for the election commission, but it's the prosecutor that would, they're the entity that brings removable proceedings for any county official. Don't most counties have
Speaker 55
17:51
a county attorney that would be the default, I would think, for that sort of a thing? But in this particular instance, I don't know if the county attorney would be the default for the Election Commission. Representative Dodson and maybe
somebody from the Association of Counties would want to comment,
but there are quite a few counties that, at least in the past, used the prosecutor as the county attorney. So I think that still creates – now, it's not true in many of the larger counties, but some of the smaller rural
Speaker 55
18:26
counties definitely do that. Okay. Well, that may be something broader we need to look at overall, maybe putting that responsibility with the AG's office or something for all county officials since there's not a
– there won't be a conflict there. And, Mr. Humphreys, if you could perhaps, for benefit of the committee and myself, clarify how that removal process goes down.
Does the prosecutor have the total authority on that, or do they present it to a court? Or what's specifically outlined
in the process? A user patient action would be a lawsuit in circuit court where the prosecuting attorney would file a lawsuit to have the county official removed. That's how they get their due process. And the
burden of proof on it is to prove that they're not qualified? Correct. Okay. And that's, I guess, by preponderance of the evidence in that circumstance. It's a civil action, correct?
Yes. Okay. Additional questions from the committee? Representative Ladyman, you're recognized for
a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Just a curiosity question. I mean, how many times has this come up, or has it come up in the past five, ten
Speaker 40
19:43
years? I mean, how many times has this had to be done, removal of someone? I'm not aware of any, off the top of my head, actual removal proceedings that a prosecutor brought against an election commissioner.
Tim, do you have any? Generally speaking, it has come up, but not very often. There are probably more municipal removal actions than anything else, and there's not very many of them. As far as having an election commissioner removed, I'm just not sure. I can't remember
specifically. In my experience, as I looked at this, and obviously I've spent a fair amount of time looking at it, But typically, if there's a parent conflict, the local county committee puts someone else in the position.
So it typically is handled by the county committee. There's only certain situations where the county committee is just unwilling to remove the person and replace a substitute where this comes up. And it's typically handled by the county political party committee. additional questions from members all right mr. Humphrey you're already at the table mr. clay I guess we're finished with you and your excuse thank you very much for your testimony thank you mr. chair by yourself for the record and
Speaker 85
21:10
we'll hear what you have to say sir your mics not on yet there we go I apologize good morning my name is I'm one of your state election commissioners, and with your permission, I'd like to just add a little bit to the previous testimony on certain areas, Mr. Chairman. Regarding removal of an election commissioner, there's an attorney general opinion out there
and one of the attorneys here, I'm not an attorney, but I use the words reasonable and prudent so they think I know what I'm talking about. There's an attorney general opinion out there that says once an election commissioner is elected for a term, they cannot be removed. However, the law says that election commissioners are elected. Republican Party of Arkansas in our rules, we have specific provisions to protect the removal of election commissioners for frivolous and political reasons as has occurred in some
counties, perfectly good, qualified, functioning election commissioners and they start playing county committee politics and next thing you know, the good election commissioner who's doing his job or her job that honks off someone is gone. So we have rules that says you cannot remove a Republican election commissioner unless they're found to have violated significant provision of Arkansas law by State Board of Election Commissioners
unless they don't perform their duties following the procedures set forth by the State Board of Election Commissioners. And they can also be removed for a reason any other county committee officer can be removed. We also have something in our rules that indicate that you cannot serve as an election commissioner if you are a county chairman or a county committee officer. The Democrats have entered the same thing in their rules.
And the reason for that is the exact thing that your concern was because as an election commissioner, you cannot participate in the campaign of someone on your ballot. And we just received a super attorney general opinion that really clarified the heck out of that. Back to your... Mr.
Sofer, do you remember the number on that opinion? Because I actually read that opinion, and I believe I would
I'll get it to you. All right, and I'll get staff to distribute that to the committee because it is a very broad opinion that covers a lot of this situation, and I think it
Speaker 85
24:13
will be enlightening to the committee as well. The county election commission I serve on is the one that requested it for that one reason in conjunction with Mr. Humphrey. We thought we needed that. That's the problem with the election laws in Arkansas. They need clarification. But let me just, if I may, Mr. Chair, let me just finish this.
If you don't mind, Mr. Sofer, I have a question that I want to direct to Mr. Clare and Mr. Humphreys with regard to something that you stated. Mr. Sofer indicated – you can stay there, sir. We'll come back to you. They indicated that the Republican Party had a position or had a rule requiring that someone couldn't be removed unless they were found by the State Board of Election Commissioners to have a significant violation of law. What's the process for that? the process for finding a how would the state board of election commissioners find a county
election commissioner in serious violation of state law would someone make a complaint and then the board would
review it right citizen files a complaint if there's anything to it then the board can investigate it and review it and make a determination of whether an election law was violated.
that situation? Uh-huh. Okay. If it's the, if it's a complaint of an election law that the board has jurisdiction over, that's right. Okay. I
appreciate that clarification. All right, Mr. Sofer, you guys are welcome to stay there
if you want. We may need you again. I see a couple of questions, so before we proceed, I'm going to go ahead. I think Representative Bennett has a question, and I'll take you first. Representative Bennett, you're recognized for a question. Thank
you, Mr. chair can you tell me how long that process would take i mean is there a a timeline
the board has 180 days after the complaint is filed to make a decision and if a hearing is held up to 240 days
Speaker 55
26:18
question yes mr chair recognized thank you
So if there is a findings of violation of election law that the board does have jurisdiction over, is that automatic removal? No,
Speaker 40
26:34
sir. The state board doesn't have any authority to remove a county election commissioner. If we have the authority to investigate allegations of election law violations that we have jurisdiction over, And if the board determines that an election law violation occurred, we can issue one of three types of statutory sanctions or statutory letters, or for certain violations can issue monetary sanctions.
What would those three letters
Speaker 55
27:06
look like? I mean, is it just a slap on the wrist, or is it referring it back to the prosecutor to say, hey, this violation occurred and warrants a recommendation that this individual be removed?
Speaker 40
27:23
Is there anything that rises to that level? Possibly. The three types of letters are letter of caution, letter of warning, letter of reprimand, each escalating based on the on the violation sure the board can recommend
the board can refer complaints and allegations to the proper authority oftentimes if we receive complaints that implicate criminal allegations we forward those to law enforcement and work closely with various branches of law enforcement um and aside from that the board can make a recommendation um if if they so chose okay thank you perhaps a follow-up to representative
dotson um mr clay how often do you all um get
into those type of situations this is a fairly common occurrence or is it
Speaker 40
28:28
an infrequent occurrence or some other which situation situations where you're issuing letters of sanction sure fairly infrequent you know we have like Mr. Humphrey said we have a 180 day investigation deadline and then based on how that goes the board may
determine that a statutory sanction is warranted. I'm trying to think of the percentages off the top of my head. You know, maybe between 5 and 10 out of 60 complaints filed in 2014. Of course, we're still working through complaints for the 2016 election cycle, something like that. Okay. Representative Tosh,
you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
There's a lot of reference being made to the board.
would you just take a few moments if you don't mind and so I'll understand explain to me about the board how is it comprised how do you get on the board is it an appointment uh who serves on it what the terms are just kind of uh kind of like I said just help give me a kind of help me understand how's the board made
Speaker 40
29:38
up certainly I apologize for not uh not clarifying that so the The State Board of Election Commissioners is a seven-person board.
The Secretary of State serves as the chairman of the board. The other six members are appointments. The governor has two appointments. The Speaker of the House has an appointment. The Senate president has an appointment. And then the chairs of the Democratic and Republican parties each have an appointment. The appointments are for four years except for the legislative appointments. Those are for two years, and no person can serve more than two terms on the board.
That answers your question, Representative Tosh? Okay. Mr. Sofer, you're recognized to continue your testimony. Thank
Speaker 85
30:29
you. There's just so much that comes up, but you'll forgive me for digressing, but I'm going to back up to what Mr. Clay said, and I'm going to ask him for a number or maybe Mr. Humphrey. On the state board, during the last election cycle, we had approximately 82 complaints or something like that, and I believe we referred 12 to law enforcement.
And some of this was pretty good stuff. And to the best of my knowledge and belief, and I stand to be corrected, absolutely nothing was done. No prosecutions, nothing. And last legislative session, I came of the opinion that the state board was a paper tiger. And some of the older folks in the room will understand what that means. The younger folks, it means we have no teeth, no clout.
And we had a start in the legislation in amending 7-4-200, the 120, I knew it had two. The state board election complaint procedure right now is better than it ever has been. The current staff has been more proactive than all the previous, and I've been an election commissioner since 2003. It still needs tweaking, and we'll get around to that.
And two other things, and I'll give you the answer to the dilemma if you'll permit me. What's going to happen is if a prosecutor, whether he or she prosecutes or not, all the judges in the county are going to recuse. So you're going to be looking at a special prosecutor and a special judge. And in fairness to our prosecutor in Jefferson County, they are so swamped with felonies that I am almost embarrassed as an election commissioner for us to send anything to their
office. I mean, most of these folks have got some real serious stuff to deal with. Not that election violations is not serious stuff. Here is my proposal, Mr. Chairman, committee. We're coming up on two significant transitions on the state board of election commissioners. The answer is to create an elections state elections agency under the secretary of state
that is independent, that is to say major personnel decisions are made by a joint committee. Is that Wisconsin Tim that has that or what's the Michigan? Several states have got. And then what you need to do is we need to pass legislation giving by you can say unanimous vote or whatever they want when we have a complaint come before the state board and
It is investigated and if they find circumstances warrant removal of an election commissioner by say unanimous vote, then they file a petition with the county circuit judge and that's the end of it. Or as I think I proposed, they file a petition with the county political committee to remove that election commissioner, i.e. your election commissioner has violated. They are no longer qualified to serve.
We ask you to replace this election commissioner. Something needs to be done. In addition to the case that you experienced, Chairman, there was one in two other counties recently or three other counties that people were doing the same. The election commissioner was violating their oath, hosting fund raises, writing partisan articles for papers support so and so so and so in november complaints were made with the prosecutors and nothing was done mr so for just for
the benefit of the committee i want to kind
of give the committee a little bit of history on the legislative history around this there have been bills in at least the last three sessions proposed addressing some of these circumstances I remember in 2013 session, there was a bill proposed addressing an election integrity unit that was similar. I don't know the exact details, but similar to what you're proposing. That bill, I think, certainly didn't pass. I don't remember where it failed at. And it had problems.
In fact, I think I actually opposed that bill. But it was in the scope of what you're describing. Last session, I actually proposed a bill. I don't believe I got to the point of actually filing it, but that would address creating some sort of unit within the Attorney General's office to address these type of elections issues and move them away from the local interference. And I will just say that I think every prosecutor in the state contacted me in opposition to it.
It's interesting that we hear complaints about workload on one side, And then when you attempt to ease the workload and move that responsibility somewhere else, all of a sudden the turf protection suddenly comes up. But I think there are a number of potential ways to address this. And I would urge the committee going forward to actively look to find a consensus way to get this done. It's an ongoing problem, and we're seeing continued abuse of the situation.
And, you know, I know you gentlemen at the end of the table have, you see it on a firsthand basis, but it's something that we certainly need to look at addressing. And maybe you all have some solution that you can propose that would actually get us there. Mr. Clay, I see
Speaker 40
36:31
you asking to be recognized. Yeah, I do feel obligated to point out one thing. You know, the state board as a whole has not considered any of these specific proposals, so I don't want to give the impression that they're, you know, supportive or not of any of the items being discussed here.
But I do know that they will be happy to work with you all in any way that we can. I'll go ahead
and ask Ms. Thomas to make sure that the committee gets the contact information for each of you gentlemen and so that, and Mr. Sofer, if you'd like to be included in that as well, I think getting that dialogue going now and trying to arrive at something that will work is critically important to those of you who will be returned in 2017. Mr. Sofer, I see your hand hitting the air.
I'm going to go ahead and take Representative Bennett's question first, and then I'll come back to
you. Representative Bennett, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And trying to think through this, it seems to me that there's essentially two issues. One is when you find a violation, how do you make something happen? And the second issue is the timeliness of this, because as we all know, the closer it gets to an election, the more critical this becomes.
If, and I apologize, I can't remember who mentioned it, but it may have been you, Mr. Sofer, the suggestion that you just go back to the party who nominated the commissioner and say, we found a violation, get them out of here, get somebody else in. Can you tell me if there's problems that you foresee, and I know you haven't met as a committee, but just walk
Speaker 85
38:19
me through that. Yes, ma'am. And thank you for mentioning that because it jogged my memory.
The law says election commissioners shall be elected by their county committee in January of odd-numbered years. That has not always been the case. The tradition has been to a point, or the chairman of the county committee was automatically the election commissioner. I have seen firsthand violations of that law where the letter to the county clerk says, I have appointed so-and-so as your election commissioner.
You bring it to the attention of the political party, you bring it to the attention of the prosecutor, nothing is done. So the system is flawed from day one, okay? Okay, the party rules say that you cannot be served as an election commissioner and serve as an officer of the county committee. That is ignored. With one political party, a waiver of a district chairman is required and that election commissioner
is required to sign a statement, I understand the provisions of law on the activities that are prohibited. I do know in my particular political party several years back when I first started in this, we removed one election commissioner that just didn't get the message. He couldn't go up putting up signs. But I digress. I don't see a county committee, all of them, voluntarily complying with the directive.
I think it's going to have to be strong. It's going to have to have some teeth in it, and it's going to have to be legislated. Did I
answer the question? I seem to have been rambling. Mr. Chair, if I might, you did somewhat, but if you would go just a little further, even if there is a legislative change, if the change was that we gave you the teeth, essentially to mandate that those people be replaced is going back to the party.
I mean, I'm not saying that people shouldn't be prosecuted, but to remedy the fact that this is a time-sensitive issue, would that be a reasonable response? Well, you know, you've got violations
Speaker 85
40:53
and you've got violations, okay? if the law says you shouldn't participate in a campaign of someone on the ballot and you have specific criteria and the person's out there wearing a t-shirt and campaigning in public, they need to go.
But then you've got violations that involve felony offenses as defined in 7-1-102, 3 and 4, misdemeanor offenses. you've got two kinds of offenses. You've got dumb offenses and you've got criminal offenses. And I think the campaigning would fall, in my opinion, under dumb offenses and the other would fall under criminal offenses. So you have all different ways to approach it. But in sitting here thinking about this and talking to you, I'm a retired army and I want to back up. I think the
state board needs to deal with the state political party and let the state political party deal with their county committee. I think that would bring more satisfaction to accomplishing the goal. Chain of command, or they call it what? Chain of management, leadership in the civilian world. At the appropriate time, Mr. Chair, I'd like to close with something that you may appreciate. now that's pretty open-ended
we'll take that on a very narrow keep it germane to the topic at hand sir we've obviously known each other a while I want to regretfully tell you or tell the
Speaker 85
42:32
board if you're not aware that we're going to be losing the services of Mr. Clay on 1 July and as I told him when he told me that that if he didn't use me as a reference
I was going to whoop his butt the man has done wonders for the state board and he's been buoyed by Tim Humphreys who retires on 1 October something like
that I had also heard that and was going to get to that before we adjourned because I will say that Over the last couple of years, I have had the opportunity to ask some rather difficult and complex questions of these two gentlemen.
And they have always had high-quality answers, and I'm very, very appreciative of their service. And the state of Arkansas is much better off, and our election system is much better off because of your work. And I, for one, will say how much I appreciate it. And I'm confident that the members of the committee would echo that. those of them that have had the opportunity to interact with you. So thank you, gentlemen, and you will be missed. Thank you, Mr. Chair. With that, unless any of you have anything you'd like to add,
we'll move on to the next topic at hand. At this time, I'm going to ask our committee attorney, Ms. Waymack, to come up to the front and offer some counsel that she was providing to me privately to the committee. I think it will benefit us as we look at these topics going forward. Ms. Waymack, you're recognized. Thank you, sir. I'm Jennifer Waymack. I'm not hearing you. I'm going to be clouded. I'm Jennifer Waymack with the Bureau of Legislative Research, and as you all know...
Speaker 116
44:35
with the Bureau of Legislative Research, and as you all know, we do not take policy positions at the Bureau. we're here for legal counsel in any way we can assist you and and what representative Bell was mentioning is from a drafting perspective we were talking about this I know that mr. clay and mr. Humphries I think both kind of touched on it but one of the things that you do need to consider is what the
grounds for removal are and we're kind of speaking nebula nebulously about removing members or creating a removal process in doing that the process can vary depending on why a particular member is going to be removed and qualifications are one reason for that someone lacks a qualification to serve as a member of a county board or any elected office for that matter another
issue would be and you know the misdemeanors and felonies for the election laws under 71103 and 71104. With both of those, if you commit one of those that are convicted, then you no longer are eligible to hold public employment or office. And so in that situation, it's not so much a qualification that requires that you can no longer hold the office as it is an affirmative act, something that you've done while being a member or after you were elected. So I guess generally speaking from a drafting perspective, when you are thinking about
it in terms of a removal process, it's also important to consider whether or not what you have in your mind as a reason for removing a particular person is actually a legal grounds for doing so and what the process attends to
that is. Questions for members from Ms. Waymack? All right,
Representative Douglas, you're recognized for a question. I hate to come this late to the discussion, but in a case in my area, there was something committed,
but I couldn't get the state to really pin it down. uh so you know what what oversight do we have over seeing that through well representative douglas that is my way that
has been discussed quite a bit already today that's why i worried about go back and watch the video of today and i think that's not a problem i think it'll actually answer those questions and also um mr humphries and mr clay um elaborated quite a bit on that um take it up with them and not a problem that
want to go there again I'm just glad you've discussed it and I'll catch up later but that was a problem we couldn't it was done but we couldn't get any we couldn't get it pinned down at this that's that's that's we've spent a lot
of time working on that this morning it was way back thank you for your advice thank you sir all right I know of one other item is representative fielding still here did he step out okay um we'll go ahead did he leave or did he step out um all right
there's there is he he had brought an item to my attention and i'll go ahead and do my best to preface it um a concern that he had and we're probably back to mr humphries and mr clay but um he brought an item to my attention about a pie and maybe the secretary of state's office may also be able to elaborate if someone's here from there. Okay. Is he out there? Okay. I know he was here this morning and we're working our way to him. He had a concern about a pilot project
that was being conducted with regard to voting machines that created a printout that was then, the paper ballot was then fed to an optical scanner and concerns about privacy with regard to those ballots, the election worker actually seeing the printed ballot before it was fed to the optical scanner by that person, so that election worker was actually able to connect that ballot directly to the person casting the ballot. Is anybody here familiar with what I'm talking about?
He's brought that to my attention. And the fact that that printout, in fact, wasn't private. I see a brilliant elections attorney down there. A.J., if you'll identify yourself for the record, you're recognized. A.J. Kelly with the Secretary of State's office. That process would be
Speaker 124
49:10
no different than the process for any of the optical scan ballots currently in use on the M100s. There really is no difference. If you want to turn it over so that no one can see it, you can turn it over and the election worker wouldn't see it.
Okay. I wish he was still here. He had a pretty specific set of circumstances where it was apparently becoming pretty obvious that there was a privacy concern. We are going to meet again most likely next Friday, so hopefully maybe we'll be able to have him here or he can provide additional information for me so that I can communicate that with you and we can get to that more specifically. I'd be happy to talk to him any time as well. Okay. You may want to make contact with him this week as well and see if you can work through that
so we can have a little better understanding of what actually is occurring there. All right. Thank you, Mr. Kelly. You're welcome. All right. One additional issue, and I don't know if anyone's here today who wants to comment on it. I didn't place it on the agenda because, again, it was a rather hectic week. I didn't have time to work through it. In Lone Oak County earlier this year, I know we had a situation where a couple people weren't placed on the ballot by the clerk, and subsequently a court put them back on the ballot. Does anybody know the specifics of what occurred there
and how we might clarify state law to avoid that problem in the future? Anyone like to offer their C.A.J. coming back? Mr. Kelly, you're recognized, and hopefully you can clarify for us exactly what went down there legally and if there's clarification in the law needed in the future. A.J. Kelly with the
Speaker 124
50:50
Secretary of State's office. The matter went to a very rapid trial on the merits of the case in Pulaski County. The secretary was named as a defendant and actually prevailed in getting himself dismissed.
Long story short, the clerk believed that two people did not qualify to be on the ballot for technical reasons. They quickly challenged that in court as they are allowed to do. The judge ruled in their favor, and they were restored to the ballot. In my mind, it does not require a legislative change. Most people who heard what the judge said would understand that he, the judge believed that it was a clear misinterpretation by the clerk more than anything else,
and that misinterpretation was corrected, and they were both on the ballot,
as far as I know. Dropping back then to my Association of Counties folks, um scott is there something that you all are looking at doing differently with regard to ensuring that your clerks uh understand that area of law better or where where are we headed with that uh scott
Speaker 8
51:58
perkins association of arkansas counties uh thank you mr chair uh the actual issue came down i don't want to get too much into uh into the cases we were not directly involved but there were fields on the political practices pledge that were not filled out uh was my
understanding is the technicalities that Mr. Kelly had mentioned. As far as any legislative clarification or answer, we don't foresee any needed. I agree with AJ's comments on that. I think it comes down to just identifying the issues. Every clerk in the state is certainly aware of this issue because of the proceedings in Lone Oak County. Education and sharing the bad things that happen and how to proceed forward. And
I mean, the clerk's association is, I'm sure, actively communicating that type of information to their people
and hopefully avoid that sort of circumstance going forward. Certainly. All right. Thank you, gentlemen. Well, wait a minute. I see Representative Bennett has her hand in the
air. You're recognized for a question, Representative Bennett. Well, Mr. Chair, I just have to defend Lone Oak County since I live there and represent that county. Now, I do think that in this situation I think they're correct. There's a great process in place. It worked the way it should have worked. There were some signatures missing on things that were required.
The clerk flagged them. It was brought to a court's attention, and it was immediately rectified. So I think the current law takes care of that position. Just wanted to say that. Mr.
Speaker 8
53:29
Chair, actually, the last detail that helps clarify Ms. Bennett's point is that the signature or the technicalities that weren't felt on the form was discovered after filing period had closed. Obviously, if it's discovered during filing period, you're going to work through that. Most clerks are going to certainly take care of that paperwork properly.
Well, additional questions from members? All right. I have just one more comment, and I'm from Lone Oak County as well. So I don't want it to be a Lone Oak County bashing testimony. You know, the code says shall not change after that party filing part. So obviously the clerk read that in a very strict sense in this sense. and didn't it feel like she legally could change or call the candidate and come in and change that form after the filing period had closed. So that's really the sticking point on this issue. I guess that leads me to a follow-up.
Is there not a process with maybe the clerks or someone when you encounter that type of situation to ask for advice from other people or ask the Secretary of State's office or ask somebody rather than just making a summary judgment on your own? I would advise clerks in that situation to contact their
Speaker 8
54:44
county attorney and their local county council. Do you know if that was done in this case? I'm not sure. I'm absolutely certain that it was done.
Okay. Again, appreciate the information. Thank you, gentlemen, for assisting us. With that, Representative Douglas, you have something to add? Well, it may be on another issue. Okay. So if you're going
to release them, then, or do you want me to ask away? We're finished with them, and this is
an informational meeting, so we have most of the experts in election law in Arkansas sitting in the room. So if you have a question regarding that, fire away. Well, at great
fear of asking another redundant question,
but please feel free to let me know as I know you're shy about that. Um, the question we had in Crawford County was that we had, uh, individuals that filed against our county judge, or for county judge and for sheriff that had a criminal, um, they, they had just come out of jail, blah, blah, blah. And we could not get a decision about whether they were certified to be on the ballot.
and the individuals that were running would have been unopposed if we had had that decision and, you know, got through the expense and that kind of thing. So what is the process of who makes the final decision about somebody being certified and making that decision to say, no, they are not on the ballot? Okay. I think this
is going to go back to the team of Clay and Humphreys.
And we already discussed that. We have not gone there today. I do want to say that that is a situation that there was a considerable amount of effort expended to try to correct during the 2013 legislative cycle. And former Attorney General McDaniel and I actually did a lot of work on it and actually reached an agreement, but the session ran out on us. And it just wasn't something that was a priority due to the number of bills
that we were working with back in 2015 session. It was work that has been worked on. former representative greenberg did a lot of work in the area of um back when he was in the legislature it's been something people have been trying to reach a resolution on and there are some constitutional concerns and some privacy concerns that come into play um and i hope i haven't disparaged anybody that filed for office i think everything
was public record and it was already uh sentences were imposed this was not this has been a lot this has been a long-term
issue in the state and i think um i i would encourage the members of the committee to go back and contact um mr mcdaniel or myself if you'd like to see what we did on it we got we got to an agreement that i think everybody was fine with and that we had agreed was constitutional um obviously you know we're not the judicial branch but we had we had worked through it very very carefully and i think we had we had something that was a good piece of legislation and we literally didn't have time to amend it to get the correct language in it,
and the session ran out on us. I know there's a consensus in my county that something needed to
be in place to solve that. Get with me, and I'll pass that along to you. I want to bring the team of Clay and Humphreys, or whichever one of them wants to address it
up, to provide their insight. Because we were told that it was the state police that had the ultimate decision because they
had elections. I'll tell you that based on my experience around it, nobody can tell me who has this yeah that's kind of where i thought mr clay you're recognized
Speaker 40
58:41
thank you mr chair justin clay state board of election commissioners i'll take a crack at this and if i misspeak um somebody can correct me uh candidates when they file for office they fill out paperwork and on some of that paperwork that they sign says under penalty of perjury i am qualified to run for this office and and if i uh if i'm elected i'm eligible to hold the office and the political practices pledge, I believe, has a specific statement on it
regarding the felony disqualifications and an acknowledgment that the candidate understands those. So when they file for office, they file with the county clerk's office in this instance. The clerk takes the filing, certifies that list to the county election commission. The county election commission places those names on the ballot. they don't make any judgment as to whether or not people are indeed qualified. If somebody has a question about a candidate's eligibility for whatever reason,
felony conviction, residency requirements, whatever the case may be, only a circuit judge can make those determinations as to whether or not a candidate is indeed eligible to hold office. Files with the circuit judge. Who does it
fall to to do that? Is it your local committee? Is it the individual? Is it the county clerk? Any one All of the above Any of the above Any voter in a jurisdiction would
have standing, correct, Mr. Clay? I believe that's correct And you would file with the county
County Circuit Court, as I understand it Circuit Court Okay Representative Douglas I'll also say that I would recommend, again, discussions With former AG McDaniel And Former Rep Dan Greenberg both of whom have put a considerable amount of time into research on this. Thank you. I think there's quite a bit of ground that you won't have to plow. If you'll visit with those gentlemen and myself, we can, I think, help you get to a resolution on it.
Mr. Clay, do you have anything else to add? Thank you. Any other gentleman in the back, you were requesting to be recognized. Do you have business to come before the committee? Yes, sir. All right, if you'll take the end of the table and give us your name for the record, who you're with, and what the reason for being here is, I'll be prepared to take your testimony.
Your mic is not on, sir.
Oh, there we go. My name is Brian Poe, and I'm the director of elections for Pulaski County. and I just wanted to make you all aware of some possible issues that we might be encountering in this upcoming general election. I'd just like to also introduce our county attorney. Adam Fogelman, Pulaski County Attorney. Basically what it comes down to is, just to give you a quick history of it,
in last year's session, the 2015 session, the legislature passed Act 1281, which enabled the school districts to call for the school election to be held on the same date as the general election. This year, in early April, we were informed by the State Board of Education that the Pulaski County Special School District would come out from under supervision of the state.
and that they would need to re-elect their board. And the commissioner of education informed us that they would like us to hold that election in conjunction with the general election on November 8th. This creates a number of issues as the law currently stands that will make administration of this election very difficult and create a great deal of confusion amongst the voters in Pulaski County. there are basically two laws that we're looking at that as they stand now will make this into a
much more complicated election than it needs to be 614 102 a2 requires that all school issues be held on a separate ballot so for so in that instance the school school issues the board of directors and the millage cannot be placed on the general election ballot what this essentially means from a practical standpoint from an on-the-ground standpoint is that we will need to program two separate ballots for the general for that date we'll have to have a general election
ballot and a separate school election ballot since they will have to have separate programmings that means that at each of these polling locations where we have the plaza county special school District, that's for 74,000 voters in Pulaski County at 55 different polling locations, that means that we'll have to have two separate sets of machines to read those ballots. And since we'll have to have two separate sets of machines to read those ballots, we'll also have to have two separate sets of poll books so the poll workers know which ballots
to give or which ballots to give to voters who come to those polling locations. So, what we have is a situation to where at 32 of our polls that are located completely within the Pulaski County Special School District, people will have to come, check in, vote in the general election, and then they'll have to go through a separate line to vote in the school election. In addition to that, we have 23 polls that have 7,000 people, or actually, let me back
up. That's one of our major issues right there, is that it being a general election, as you all know, or as you may not know, I don't know, whenever the state purchased equipment using Hava money for us in 2006, they basically gave us enough election equipment to conduct a general election. Well, since we're already conducting a general election and we'll need additional machines to conduct the school election on that same day, we'll end up having to spend an additional $20,000 leasing that equipment from ES&S, which is the voting equipment vendor.
So that's one part of it. The second part of it, and in addition to, you know, the confusion that it creates at the polls, because basically what you're doing in that situation is you're doubling the time that the people at those 32 polls are going to wait because they're going to basically they're going to be having to go through two separate lines. In addition to that, there's also 614-106-A4-B which requires that in a school election
the polls be physically located within the school district. Well, this creates a situation where we have 7,230 voters voters at 23 different polling locations in addition to voters who live in the Pulaski County or people who are in the Pulaski County Special School District but live in Saline County or Lone Oak County, these folks are going to have to go to two different polling locations to vote in the general election and the school election.
So, for instance, if I live out by Winfield United Methodist Church and that's my polling location, then what's going to have to happen is I will have to go to one polling location in order to vote in the school election, and then turn around and go to a different polling location to vote in a general election. So with the laws kind of as they are now, that creates an issue for us, and while it does create administration issues, our biggest concern is with voter confusion and with how
it will affect the general election, given that, you know, based on all trends that we've been seeing, it's going to be a record turnout this year. Mr. Poe, quick question for you. Yes,
sir. Did your office suppose House Bill 1422 during the last session? No, sir. I believe you're incorrect, and I believe if someone will check the video, you'll find that you did. Which one was 1422? That was a bill that actually corrected the issues that you're talking about. while making that transition is my bill so i'm very familiar with it yes sir like i don't
i don't recall i don't recall our office it's uh it sounds to me like just based on your testimony today that you you have two key issues yes sir the issue of requirement for a separate election yes sir and the issue of requiring the polling places to be located within the school district yes sir assuming that those two issues were corrected what other issues would you have if those issues were corrected we
upcoming special session allowed legislation on the call that corrected those two issues you would be able to hold the school election in november without issues absolutely thank you representative Bennett you're
recognized thank you mr. chair I'd like to request could you offer up a suggestion for a fix could you come up with language mr. Fogelman that may be appropriate for a question for you provide it to this
Speaker 154
1:08:27
committee I'd be happy to work with anybody on this committee and the Bureau of legislative
research to to do that all right additional questions from the committee Thank you, gentlemen. You're excused. Thank you for your time. Is there additional business needs coming for the committee today? If not, I want to say a big thank you to everybody for being here on Friday, particularly for the members after the week that you've had that you took the time to be here today. Thank you, and hopefully this was beneficial to you going forward, and we'll try to continue these throughout the course of the summer and at available opportunities.
Agenda
A. Call to Order
B. Opening Comments by Representative Nate Bell
C. Discussion of Petition Circulation for Municipal Candidates
D. Discussion of Election and Removal Processes of Election Commissioners
E. Committee Discussion
F. Other Business
G. Adjournment
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Nate Bell Chair
Unverified
Speaker 8
Representative Dwight Tosh
Unverified
Representative Jack Ladyman
Unverified
Speaker 32
Speaker 40
Speaker 55
Speaker 58
Representative Camille Bennett Chair
Unverified
Speaker 85
Speaker 86
Speaker 90
Speaker 14
Speaker 116
Chair
Unverified
Speaker 124
Brian Poe
Unverified
Speaker 151
Speaker 154