Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

Judiciary Committee 5/19/16

May 19, 2016 ·Committee Room 149 ·42:30
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (4)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1004 · 4 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1004 PROFESSIONALS OF UNDER PRIVATE THE Vines CONCERNING QUALIFI…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1002 · 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…e chairman sees a quorum uh the first item on our agenda is house bill 1002 representative letting representative letting you're recogn…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1013 · 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1013 TO AMEND CONFIDENTIALITY PROVISIONS REGARDING JUVENILE RECO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1011 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1011 CONCERNING THE CRIMINAL OFFENSE OF SEXUAL INDECENCY WITH A…”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 14, 2026
will come to order the chairman sees a quorum uh the first item on our agenda is house bill 1002 representative letting representative letting you're recognized to present your bill thank you mr
▶ Play
Speaker 3 0:18
chair mr vice chair members of the committee i will be very brief i know we have a couple of items on the agenda today in very limited time uh i will have somebody join me here at the table in just a a little bit. But very briefly, we are here today to discuss House Bill 1002. This is a bill that this committee and actually the General Assembly passed last year. It has to do with publicity rights. The General Assembly passed this bill and our governor in his wisdom decided to veto this bill because he decided it went just a touch too far in allowing somebody to control how his or her likeness is used once they pass. Senator John Woods, who is the main driver of this legislation, heard those concerns, and in the months since, we have worked to craft this bill. It is very similar to the bill that this committee passed last year, but some key language has been removed. You might remember, if you remember much about last session, that we added some language at the last minute dealing with First Amendment rights, and that was to appease some players' unions. That language, the governor thought, as did the Motion Picture Association of America and photographers, and I believe the Press Association also, thought it went just a little bit too far, and that's why the governor vetoed that bill. That language is now gone. So to be clear, the Press Association is neutral on this bill. The governor supports it. The Motion Picture Association of America supports this legislation, as do the photographers, perhaps most importantly here in Arkansas. They probably have more sway than the MBAA here. That's really all I have to say about the particular bill. It's got more support than it did when you passed it last year. And I'd appreciate a good vote. Thank you. Representative House,
▶ Play
you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
▶ Play
Thank you, Representative, for bringing this. In the last hour, I've heard from a professional duck hunter, shooting range operator, bowling alley owner, auto paint and body owner, and a wedding photographer who only read this bill after it was filed this morning. Is that correct? Do you know if this bill was filed this morning? I filed the
▶ Play
Speaker 3 2:31
House version of the bill yesterday. Okay. But I'm not sure when the Senate version was filed. The bills, to be clear, mirror each other. They are the same bill, but we were instructed to file both a House and a Senate bill. And I cannot testify to
▶ Play
Speaker 6 2:46
when they read the bill. Okay, so
▶ Play
it filed yesterday. Yes, sir. But they all, to combine all of their comments and concerns, the bowling team, the Faulkner County Gun Armed Ladies Association, a private duck hunt and photographs are made and posted on uh facebook which is both a social media where you discuss bowling and second amendment and duck hunting and paint and body work and that sort of thing and then somebody says i didn't give you permission i get to sue you tell me where this statute doesn't cover that situation
▶ Play
Speaker 3 3:33
fairly certain they're going to be okay but with the chair's permission i would like to invite Mr. Van Stevenson to the table to address that particular concern. Mr.
▶ Play
Stevenson, please state your name and who you represent, and then you may answer the question.
▶ Play
Mr. Chairman, my name is Van Stevenson. I'm Senior Vice President of State Government Affairs for the Motion Picture Association of America. And Representative, could you repeat the question? Because I was distracted in the
▶ Play
back room. I apologize. us. Mr. Chair, with your permission. In the last hour, I have heard from a professional duck hunter, a shooting range operator, a bowling alley owner, an automobile paint and body shop, and a wedding photographer, all of whom say, I take photographs of my work and my patrons and what we do and what we discuss second amendment issues uh bowling uh we're getting married and all that stuff and i photograph a lot of people and i post these photos on my web page where we discuss second amendment and weddings and paint and body work and duck hunting and somebody says i did not give you permission to use my likeness i am suing you tell me where he's going to fail in his lawsuit under the
▶ Play
statute? Well, I think that they would be exempt. If you looked on page six, line 29, where they talk about exempt uses, photographs are exempt. Works in the public interest are exempt. As long as you're not using those photographs to promote goods, services, or merchandise there be no basis for a lawsuit and if it makes makes you any more comfortable Facebook and Google both support this language in the in
▶ Play
the legislation okay a shooting range operator is big on second amendment maintains a web page where they discuss concealed carry permits and they discuss self-defense and they discuss accuracy of various weapons or ammunition loads and all of that sort of thing, but it's run actually by a company that's in the business of shooting. How do you distinguish between, hey, these are a fine bunch of ladies that came in and shot with us versus standing up for their Second Amendment rights versus I'm promoting my
▶ Play
shooting range? Well, I think that's an interactive discussion between parties, and there's no implied endorsement of the shooting range operator. If they took a picture and said, I support you coming to this range without permission, that would be a violation because you're promoting that particular business. But if it's a discussion online, that's perfectly permissible because you're not promoting or endorsing it just because it's on his website. So we're regulating content now? No. On the contrary, I think that what you're doing is providing a broad-based exemption that protects those particular rights. And at the same time, you're striking a balance by protecting the rights of individuals like former Coach Broyles from commercial exploitation. In other words, somebody can't use his name on a product or put his name on a business without his permission. May I continue,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair? It says at the top of this website, Bob's Bowling Alley and Jane's Shooting Range. and they're talking about Second Amendment, then they're talking about patrons who come in and spend, how does the court determine that they're promoting the commercial operation or enjoying their Second Amendment rights? What's the standard for testing under this statute? I know what it is under common law, but what is it
▶ Play
now under this statute? Well, I think that you'd have to give me an idea of what the use is. Are you using a picture in an association with the business in an implied endorsement or in an advertisement on his website for his business? Or is it purely a discussion or a website where people are chatting back and forth about Second Amendment rights? Well, now it's intent we're regulating. No, I think it's very simple. It's making sure that a person's image persona is not used without permission in the promotion or advertising of a particular business, period. The rest, and that's why there's a broad-based exemption in there to protect the kind of uses that you're talking about. Because I would say, I mean, here, for example, on page 7, In line four, it talks about the exemption, a work of political, public interest, newsworthy, comment, criticism, parody, satire, transformative recreation, or a work or authorship. That covers exactly the kind of examples that you're giving. Yeah, I see it. A work, what
▶ Play
work, if you're shooting at the shooting range, what is the work?
▶ Play
Well, a work could be a picture, it could be writing, it could be a video.
▶ Play
Any matter of expression? Mr. Chairman, thank you. I may come
▶ Play
back if somebody else has some questions. Representative
▶ Play
Gates, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you for leeway. I don't sit on the committee. We had talked earlier, and I have a rather growing business in my district that's in the business of producing artwork that has, whether they're movie stars or players or whatever, and then they sell those at auctions, charity auctions and that type of thing. uh this bill would in no way infringe on that because this solely deals with an image or identity a name or something used for the purpose of promoting somebody else's business or their product is that correct that that's correct representative and
▶ Play
and in fact um within the bill and again on page seven um if you go down to line 13 it talks about that work and the examples that you and I talked about this afternoon, photographs, et cetera, by an institution of higher education or by a non-profit organization club or supporting foundation that has authorized the institution of higher education and established solely to advance the purposes of the institution and then it continues. So I think that those are
▶ Play
aptly covered here. So if I may, if a photographer takes a picture of the governor or takes a picture of whoever and then decides that's a marketable, you're in the movie business, if a movie star where they shot a movie here on the grounds, if somebody took a picture of that, of the movie star, and then turned around and was able to find a market and sell it, this would not prevent the selling of that photograph that that person took themselves.
▶ Play
Not at all, because the person, once you take the picture, in fact, anybody in this room with a phone that takes a picture, you own that copyright, you own the rights to that picture, and as long as you're not violating somebody's privacy and there's no expectation of privacy and it's an individual, you know, it's a famous individual, you're covered.
▶ Play
Representative Ballinger, you're recognized
▶ Play
for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. My concerns that we'd had originally, and I think even now, may be addressed in, well, it's at the top of page 7 in paragraph C. so it's in subsection 475 1110 and then c and what i what i just want to make sure it covers this is in a photograph or likeness where an individual appears as a member of the public an attendee of a photographed event or a public place the individual and the individual is not named so as long as you're taking a picture of people shooting at your at your gun range and you could post that on there and a lot of exciting people even if you can recognize people there that would be exempted because they're not specifically named where become a problem is if if we said you know we put up the gun range and you said you know bill jones and you know bob jones had a good time at the range then you'd be in violation of this ordinance if you're promoting the range yeah if it's if it's a promotion or an implied endorsement that's correct okay um then going back to the the question that represent gates asked and it just brought up a new issue a new new question i didn't have before but is this only the the prohibition is only against the promotion of a of a business or business interest i mean because it almost seems like you know you are engaged in in a business interest by actually selling an item with that person's image on it and what i would just do since you know this bill better than me could you point out where that wouldn't be included
▶ Play
under this legislation so so in other words i'm trying to
▶ Play
i'm trying to real simple what what you you you had told right represent gates that's not a problem right and i hadn't even thought about it being a problem until he he brought it up my question is you know why is that not covered under this legislation And this may be my own ignorance to legislation, but is it so narrowly defined that
▶ Play
it would not pick that up? Well, I think it comes down to, in the case that you're saying, potentially a judgment because if it's an implied endorsement or it's promoting the business and you're doing that without permission, potentially there could be litigation. But, again, if the examples that we talked about earlier where you're going back and forth, you're posting, you know, pictures about activities and so forth, and you're not directly promoting or advertising, then I would submit that would be exempt.
▶ Play
Right. But, you know, I think that I'm comfortable with this paragraph. I think it covers the biggest parts of what my concerns would be. But if a person takes a picture of some movie star who's in Arkansas and then they market that picture, either they put together a fundraiser, but they sell it. They're making money off of it. And you may be able to point directly to the position, a place in here that would exempt that. But I'm just kind of concerned about whether your answer on that is 100% right. and there it probably is but where is that where would that be
▶ Play
covered on here well okay in the in the exact in the exemptions in the exemptions it also talks about a photograph or likeness where the individual appears as an attendee etc is in a public place therefore if a movie is being photographed in Little Rock, you take a picture of Harrison Ford and you market Harrison, you sell that, you own the copyright, you're exempt. It's no different than if I shoot a television series and I sell it to NBC, I'm doing the same thing at a different level. And if it gives you any more comfort, the 10 states that have passed very similar, if not identical, legislation in terms of the exemption, I'm not aware of any case law where there's been a problem based on the examples that you all have been given.
▶ Play
If I may, Truman. I'm not even sure that there shouldn't be some property rights in a person so you can't sell their likeness. I'm not not even necessarily arguing that point. But, you know, in the language of the bill itself, I don't see a specific exemption that covers exactly what Representative Gates is saying his his constituent does. And then within the language of the bill, you know, if a person has an individual property right in their likeness, in their image, in their voice, in their whatever, then how I mean, you just have to try to explain to me why that wouldn't be covered.
▶ Play
Okay, if you go on page 7, go to line 30. It also exempts the distribution of photographs for license and sale or other transfer to third parties or to promote or advertise such activities. That covers it right there. So distribution of photographs for license and sale. So the example that you gave is covered right in that section 2, E. So in other words, by any person practicing the profession of photography or his or her representative to distribute photographs for license and sale or transfer to third parties or to promote or advertise such activities.
▶ Play
Okay, so they would be a third party. So if he doesn't actually take the picture, but he's selling the picture, He's putting the likeness of Harrison Ford on a blanket, and he's selling the blanket. Then he is covered by this because he's a third party? Yes. Okay.
▶ Play
Speaker 53 18:28
All right, no other questions.
▶ Play
Any other questions from the committee? All right, moving to the public comment. Mr. Stevenson, do you have
▶ Play
any further statement to make? No, just to reiterate our support, and we've worked over the last year with the Broyles Foundation and their representatives, and we think it strikes the right balance between protecting the rights of free expression and also advancing the ability to protect exploitation in commercial settings.
▶ Play
Thank you. We have a couple individuals signed up. Paul Calvert. Mr. Calvert, if you'll have a seat at the end of the table, and you've signed up to speak against the bill, you can
▶ Play
make your statement. Yes, sir. Thank you, committee. My name is Paul Calvert. I'm here on behalf of Liberty and Justice. That's what I generally try to deal with. But part of my issue with this bill, I think it does violate free speech on an essential, basic level. I think one example I think that wasn't really addressed here is that if you had a case where you had two competing businesses in the same town, and one of them did good work and the other one did shoddy work, and the business owner who did good work, He decided he's going to run a commercial ad about his competition saying Bill Smith over across town does shoddy work, and you should come to my business because we do better work. I think he would be using that person's name, and I think that would violate this legislation. And other just basic free speech issues, the local newspaper could run that same so-called hit piece, which is true. So long as it's true, it's not defamation. The newspaper could make that same claim in a news article, and I think that would be covered under this legislation. It would be fine. It would be legal. But if the business owner ran the same piece of information with the same names or photographs or whatever it was, then the business owner could be in violation. He could be sued for putting out true information about his competitor and using his name. So I think this is a pretty clear violation of the basic fundamental right of free speech. And I'll take
▶ Play
questions. Okay, I see no questions. Thank you for your comments. Next up, we have Philip Hobby signed up to speak for the bill. Mr. Hobby, if you'll have a seat, state your name and who you represent, and
▶ Play
Speaker 61 21:27
then you may make your statement. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm Phil Hobby. I represent the Arkansas Professional Photographers of America. The way the bill is presently written, we support it without any amendments. Any questions? Any questions?
▶ Play
No questions. Thank you. I believe we have one other signed up here to speak against the bill, Angie Davis. Ms. Davis, if you'll have a seat at the end of
▶ Play
the table, state your name, and then you may make your statement. Hi. My name is Angie Davis. I'm a professional photographer, and I have an issue with the part of the bill on page 7. It starts at line 25. It says to exhibit and display photographs in a personal portfolio through physical media or digital media unless the exhibit and display is continued by the person practicing the profession of photography. Ms. Davis, can you move the
▶ Play
mic, move closer to the microphone? Oh, I'm
▶ Play
sorry. Like I said, I'm nervous. Sorry. Anyway, so if I take a photo of someone on public property, I put it in my portfolio. If that person comes to me and says, you know, I don't want you to use this photo, I have to take it down. And I own copyright of this image. This is my intellectual work. I've worked hard to make this image. And I think I should be able to use it in order to run my business and to get more clients. It just seems only fair. And that's even if I use their name or not use their name. That's just their face. And not to mention us being a freelance photographer for the paper in the past. If you're out and about and you take a photo of someone, whether they're famous or not, you can use it as a professional photographer. Why do famous people get more privacy than I do? I'm not a famous person. Someone can take my photo and they can use it. I'm not on the list. Who am I? But if I take a photo of someone that's on the list, how am I supposed to know that they're on this list if I don't know these rules? What if I'm not from Arkansas and I'm a photographer that's been brought in by another company? And I'll take questions, too. Representative Gray, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. And I'm just trying to follow what you were saying, and this may be for someone else or the bill sponsor to answer later. But if I start on page 6, line 28, where it shows exempt uses, and I go down to line, page 7, okay, line 7, page 26, what did I say? page 7 line 26 it actually says to exhibit and display photographs in a personal portfolio I mean that you're it this is exempted through your work is exempted through this subchapter but
▶ Play
doesn't it mean in that paragraph that if they say no I don't want you to use that I have to take it down that was my my understanding. Hold on
▶ Play
Speaker 72 24:50
just a second. It's really confusing. I'd like the bill sponsor to
▶ Play
answer that question because there's language right above where it specifically exempts that's not in that paragraph that exempts.
▶ Play
Speaker 75 25:09
I just want to confirm that. Are there
▶ Play
any other questions of this particular witness all right thank you for your testimony uh we have no button nails signed up representative letting you're recognized to close for the bill thank you mr chair
▶ Play
Speaker 3 25:29
and i apologize representative gray i did not hear your question but i'd be happy to answer it representative
▶ Play
gray you can restate your question thank you
▶ Play
mr chair i'd just like for you to answer like a rebuttal to what she had to say because in exempt uses on page six you know a visual work a work of art those are all exempted and I just want
▶ Play
Speaker 3 25:55
to clarify. That is correct. I know the photographers had concern about the bill that was passed last year but we addressed those concerns and so to my knowledge all the photography groups that came forward last time were no longer in opposition to this bill. To use our governor's own words this bill strikes a balance between protecting First Amendment rights and artistic license and allowing an individual or family to have just a little bit more control over how his or her likeness is used. This is essentially the same bill that we passed last time but it has more support behind it this time around. Are you closed for your bill? I am sorry yes thank you. All right
▶ Play
what's the pleasure of the committee? We We have a motion. Do pass. All those in favor indicate by saying aye. Aye. Those opposed? No. The bill passes. Thank you. Without objection, we're going to move to House Bill 1013. Representative Meeks, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chair. Committee, this should be fairly non-controversial. It's a little old bill that does do something, and it's very important, which is why we're here today with it. All right, here we go. House Bill 1013 amends the confidentiality section of the statute pertaining to juvenile records of the Division of Youth Services and juvenile detention facilities. The current law does not allow the Division of Youth Services to share information with modified research or evaluation projects. This bill would allow the Division to share confidential information with research and evaluation projects if the Division determines the project has value or can assist the Division in development of policies to advance juvenile justice. Although confidential information will be shared, the researchers and evaluators are prohibited from re-disclosing or publishing confidential information. The reason that this bill is needed is to provide research on the implementation, a validated risk and needs assessment in the pilot sites as our state moves to statewide implementation. Validated risk and needs assessments for juveniles show the risk for recidivism, low, moderate, high, and identify the static and dynamic risk factors for reoffending so courts can tailor services to better meet juvenile needs. The Arkansas Supreme Court Commission on Children, Youth, and Families received a grant, and this is why we're trying to do it during the special session. They received a grant from the MacArthur Foundation and the OJJDP to implement a validated risk and needs assessment, and it includes a research opponent. So under current law, they would not be able to use that grant money to be able to carry out this particular research. So states that use validated risk and needs assessments have shown a reduction and out-of-home placements, recidivism, and improved outcomes for youth. So with that said, I'll be glad to take any questions. If not, I would appreciate a due pass.
▶ Play
All right. I see no questions, and no one has signed up to speak for or against the bill. Are you closed for the bill? I'm closed for my bill. Thank you, sir. What's the – we have a motion due pass. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? The bill passes. Next on the agenda, House Bill 1004, Representative Vines. And we have an amendment on House Bill 1004. represent vines you recognize to present your amendment to house bill 1004 yes sir
▶ Play
thank you mr chairman it's wonderful to be back with this illustrious committee today i have a an amendment that i believe is being handed out we had some duplicate language in the bill that basically uh scrivener's error for lack of a better term that we had to adjust and
▶ Play
fix so that's what this amendment does okay any questions regarding the amendment we have a motion to adopt the amendment all in favor say aye any opposed the amendment is adopted representative vines you're recognized to present house bill
▶ Play
1004 as amended thank you mr chairman friends you'll see this is house bill 1004 it deals with the qualifications of professionals under the private security agency private investigator and school security licensing and credentialing act if you'll recall in the 2015 session we passed house what was then senate bill 164 brought to us by our good friend senator hutchison that addressed this these topics and this relates back to when we did away with the professional licensing board for security commission security guards well when we passed that law and that bill last last i don't know february march whenever we did last in the regular session as with anything it had some unintended consequences and we are starting to feel those as we go to re-license these commission's security guards the people that fall under what used to be that the supervision of that board so what this does is it walks back some of those provisions specifically what it does is allows some of the folks that work in security firms, alarm firms, folks that come into your house to install those type measures, if they were under the current act, the way the law is written now, if they have any conviction of any type, they're done. They can't be relicensed. There's no mechanisms to relicense them. So what we did with this, through the governor's office, state police, private industry, a hodgepodge of friends and colleagues, We've taken it now where we're still going to keep the bad guys out, but we're not going to consider felonies that are, I mean, excuse me, misdemeanors. I overspoke there. Misdemeanors that occurred more than 10 years ago and we're going to allow those people to be re-licensed because the way it was, you've got a whole sector of that industry that was going to be wiped out. Now, is it perfect? No. But it's a step back from where we were because as it is now, none of these people, and they may have been in the business 10, 15, 20, 30 years, would be able to be relicensed. And I can't speak on every account, but a bulk of these dealt with failures to appear. That seemed to be the common problem that we were facing in a lot of these that was a failure to appear. You'd have a speeding ticket or a minor transgression of some sort, a misdemeanor, and whether you dealt with the underlying aspect or not, these failures to appear that would stick to your record would knock you out under this. The way the act is written now and the law is, it's harder to be employed under this act than it probably is to be in law enforcement. So what we're doing here is simply walking that back, not all the way, not going to fix everything, can't save everyone, but hopefully it's a reasonable compromise that will allow folks in every one of our districts, I would venture to say, some peace and some ability to continue to pursue their livelihood. I do have some folks from State Police, some of our friends from State Police are here, including the Colonel. I think we have some others if need be, and we'll be happy to answer any questions that you may propose. Representative Bennett, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I've been trying to compare. Apparently, this is a different bill than we were sent earlier by the governor's office. But I just want to clarify, the earlier bill we were sent allowed people to continue to work pending approval of the license. And is that now removed from this bill? I think that's – I'm told it still should be in there.
▶ Play
I think that as policy, they're still allowed during that appeals process, but I can definitely bring state police to the table to answer that. Yes, 4B, 16 through 21. Thank you.
▶ Play
Okay, so it still is in there. And I want to apologize. I'm not sure.
▶ Play
There were a couple of versions bouncing, so I'm not sure what you're – and I didn't mean to sound vague, but when this was first proposed, it's kind of changed since then in a lot of ways. So I'm not sure what we're
▶ Play
referencing, what was sent out. And if I might, Mr. Chair, one other question. On page 3, line 33 and 34, where it talks about being denied if you were ever convicted of a crime involving a firearm or a crime involving the use of alcohol while in possession of a firearm, could you be convicted of a boating or a hunting or fishing crime and then you're as a kid and now you're denied from getting a security license? So if you're boating on, let's say
▶ Play
you come down to business in Garland County and spend a lot of money at Lake Hamilton or Lake Ouachita. You're driving
▶ Play
a boat and you've got alcohol with you and you happen to have a concealed carry permit, and you've got your gun with you. Well,
▶ Play
did you commit that crime? Were you using the firearm? Was it says they're involving the use of a firearm? Are you trying to hold me up
▶ Play
Speaker 99 36:07
while we're doing that? You got anything good? I don't
▶ Play
even have a boat. I can't afford one of those. I'm out of alcohol. I might need one. I'll probably find you some of that. This just, I love the intent of this bill. I think this is desperately needed to correct an overreach that we did in the last session. I guess I'm just a little bit concerned that, you know, we've now changed the definition of misdemeanor. Before it was theft, sexual offenses, and violence, and now it's anything with an element of dishonesty or a crime against a person. Well, I could argue that a failure to appear involves dishonesty, so I'm trying to figure out what kind of misdemeanors are not covered by this. You know, I've got a gentleman in my district that committed a crime as a juvenile. He pled guilty because the judge and the prosecutor promised him it wouldn't show up on his record. He did everything he was supposed to do, met every condition. and they broke into, like, cut a fence in an electrical plant, did everything he was supposed to do. He never was convicted. The record was sealed, and he can't get a license because we still pull up juvenile offenses, and it doesn't matter whether you did everything you were supposed to do, and that just seems dishonest to me.
▶ Play
All valid points. I think a couple of comments on that. As we all know, you can seal, expunge, I think, our act that our former friend, our good friend, not former friend, still friend, but former colleague, Representative Nate Steele, his seal act of, I think, of 2013. As great and good as that is, we all know that if you do a crime, there are ways to find out about it. There's not a big barrel in the middle of town that we take all the records and go burn them those things have tentacles and they still exist in some form or fashion but i think the one thing i would point out under this is no matter what if we do nothing your guy is going to be out anyway all this is doing and i and i understand and you and i have talked about it and i and i can sympathize with someone that's been in the industry that long but if we do nothing at this point it doesn't matter that guy that guy is never going i mean not never but is as the law is written now or and or with this bill he doesn't get licensed anyway that's the law the way it is now right wrong or indifferent all we're trying to do is walk it back and correct some injustices we can't we can't correct all of them but i do think it's something that makes may demand some attention in that upcoming 2017
▶ Play
Speaker 94 38:49
session all right see no further questions no one
▶ Play
has signed up to speak for against the bill representative vines are you closed for your bill absolutely you want to make a motion absolutely motion do pass as amended as amended all those in favor say aye aye any opposed the bill passes as amended uh i'm going to turn it
▶ Play
Speaker 109 39:18
over to the vice chairman chairman committee Representative
▶ Play
Shepard, you're recognized. Present House Bill 1011. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. House Bill 1011 is a bill sponsored by myself and Senator Hutchinson. We've worked with the governor's office. Actually, the governor's office is the one that brought this bill to us to remedy a situation that has arisen in light of a recent Arkansas Supreme Court case. As you can see, House Bill 1011 deals with Arkansas Code 514110, which is the act that concerns sexual indecency with a child. The particular provision in question is 514110, subsection A4. The court interpreted the statement, I'll read Section 4, that a person commits sexual indecency with a child if, with the purpose to arouse or gratify his or her sexual desire or sexual desire of another person, a person who is 18 years of age or older, causes or coerces a minor to expose his or her sex organs to another person, and the actor is, and then there are certain classes of individuals that would fall into this category. The court interpreted the statement of exposure to another person as not covering the individual who induced the child to make that exposure. And so the court indicated that the statement another person was not the actual actor. And so, in essence, there would have to be a third person there in order for that particular section to be applicable. And this bill simply clarifies that that exposure could be to the actor, the wrongdoer, or to another person. And so it simply clarifies and essentially reaffirms what I think the legislative intent was all along. The other changes that were made are just strictly some suggestions from BLR to bring some consistency to that particular section. With that, I'll be glad to take any questions. Seeing no questions, Representative Shepard, are you closed for your bill? I'm closed for my bill, and I move do pass. Got a motion do pass. All in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed, motion passes. Bill passes. Thank you. Members, that concludes our business for today. I would just say pay attention to the agenda going forward as to whether there's bills that make their way to our end from the Senate, but I appreciate your work today. With that, we're adjourned. We're adjourned.
▶ Play

Agenda

HB1002 THE FRANK BROYLES PUBLICITY RIGHTS PROTECTION ACT OF 2016. Leding

0:08 - 29:20 94 segments 15 speakers

HB1004 PROFESSIONALS OF UNDER PRIVATE THE Vines CONCERNING QUALIFICATIONS THE SECURITY AGENCY, PRIVATE INVESTIGATOR, AND SCHOOL SECURITY LICENSING AND CREDENTIALING ACT; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

29:20 - 39:38 34 segments 7 speakers

HB1011 CONCERNING THE CRIMINAL OFFENSE OF SEXUAL INDECENCY WITH A CHILD; AND TO Shepherd DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

39:38 - 27:30

HB1013 TO AMEND CONFIDENTIALITY PROVISIONS REGARDING JUVENILE RECORDS; AND TO D. Meeks

27:30 - 42:30 47 segments 8 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Matthew J. Shepherd Chair Unverified
31 segments
Speaker 3
10 segments
Representative Douglas House Unverified
11 segments
Speaker 6
1 segment
Van Stevenson Unverified
20 segments
Representative Mickey Gates Unverified
4 segments
Representative Bob Ballinger Unverified
10 segments
Speaker 53
1 segment
Paul Calvert Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 61
1 segment
Angie Davis Unverified
6 segments
Representative Michelle Gray Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 72
1 segment
Speaker 75
1 segment
Representative Stephen Meeks Unverified
4 segments
Representative John T. Vines Unverified
18 segments
Representative Camille Bennett Unverified
8 segments
Speaker 99
1 segment
Speaker 94
1 segment
Speaker 109
1 segment