Public Health, Welfare and Labor Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (12)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1016
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1016 Farrer TO CONVERT THE HOSPITAL REIMBURSEMENT SYSTEMS UNDER…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1021
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1021 Love TO PROVIDE PAY EQUITY FOR WOMEN; AND TO AMEND THE WAGE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1024
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1024 TO MODIFY THE DEFINITION OF "CHRONIC NONMALIGNANT PAIN" IN…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1025
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1025 Boyd TO AMEND THE PRESCRIPTION DRUG MONITORING PROGRAM ACT…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1032
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1032 Mayberry THE ARKANSAS UNBORN CHILD PROTECTION FROM DISMEMBE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1033
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1033 Mayberry TO AMEND INITIATED ACT 1 OF 2000, ALSO KNOWN AS TH…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1034
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1034 Fite TO AMEND THE LAWS CONCERNING HEARING INSTRUMENT DISPEN…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1035
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1035 Bentley TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS HEALTHY FOOD IMPROVEMENT ACT…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1040
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1040 Farrer TO LIMIT THE PRACTICE OF ATHLETIC TRAINING IN A NONC…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1160
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1160 A. Mayberry TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF A "SPECIALIST SIGN E…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1164
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1164 Gray TO AUTHORIZE LICENSURE BY ENDORSEMENT FOR OPTOMETRISTS…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HR1003
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HR1003 Boyd TO ENCOURAGE CONTINUED COLLABORATION BETWEEN HEALTHCAR…”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 14, 2026
Members, will you grab your seat? We'll go ahead and get started. We've got a few housekeeping things. First off, I talked to Representative Love this morning, and he wants to move without objection to Committee 1021 to the deferred list. And he's still working with a few people, and we'll get plenty of notice when he gets ready to bring it back off. Other than that, I want to pull one thing out of order, if the committee allow me. I'm going to let Representative Boyd run his resolution first.
He has promised me it's non-controversial. Representative Boyd, you're recognized without objection to the committee. Mr.
Chair, thank you for the opportunity to present this resolution today, committee members. This is a resolution that is...
If you would, state your name for the record, please. Yes, sir. Thank you. You might need to help me with a few other things. I'm out of practice, but I'll get there. Representative Justin Boyd. So this resolution is almost identical to one that we ran in the 90th General Assembly. There are some agencies that we're going to send a copy to that were added, but other than that, it's the same. But as you know, the 91st General Assembly is not bound to what the 90th General Assembly does.
So what this resolution does is it just really, it's not a bill, it's not a law, it's a resolution. It says, if passed, that the House of Representatives encourages continued collaboration between health care providers, law enforcement, educators, public officials in the Arkansas community in battling the abuse of prescription drugs in Arkansas. That said, you have it before you. If you have any questions, I'd be happy to answer them. Otherwise, you know, I'd appreciate a good vote.
Representative Love, you're recognized for a question. Not a question, motion at the proper time. Okay. Any other questions from the committee? Anybody in the audience speak for or against the resolution? Representative Love, you're recognized for your motion. Motion do pass. We have a motion. Do pass on the floor. Any discussion on the motion? Not seeing none. All in favor, say aye. All those opposed?
Ayes have it. A motion passes. A bill passes. Thank you, Representative Boyd. All right. We'll move right along with the regular agenda now, and if we could, we'll get Director Gillespie to the end of the table and hear good news on DHS. Thank you,
Mr. Chairman. I appreciate the chance to come here today
and give you a very brief overview of the Department of Human Services. It's good to meet those of you I haven't before and look forward very much to working with you this year. I'm going to take just a few minutes to walk through, as I said, a brief overview and introduce some of our directors that are here today. I know that all of you have been invited to a meeting tomorrow, Health Care 101, where we're going to take about an hour and a half and walk through the Medicaid programs in a great deal of detail.
So this is much more of an overview of the department and the areas that we serve. So if I can, I'll just get underway. DHS, as you know, is one of the very largest departments of this state. The Department of Human Services is unusual in that it ties together a group of divisions that all total have about 7,200 employees.
It's a very unique agency because of the breadth of what we do. The agency includes, we are an actual health care provider, and we provide a number of services which include direct patient care. So of that roughly 7,200 employees, we have around 3,300 of them that actually provide direct patient care. That impacts us, as you can imagine, a great deal because it's important that we meet the staffing ratios
and that we serve those people that are actually in our care. This is at ASH, the Arkansas State Hospital, which is our state psychiatric hospital. We also have the Arkansas Health Center, which is the state's nursing home, which we run. And we have the five human development centers, which we also run throughout the state. In addition, we recently have taken over on a temporary basis the day-to-day running and management of juvenile facilities.
And we have seven of those we run and one, Alexander, that we oversee the contract management. So there is a lot of active, everyday work directly with clients from that side of the house. The other element to the Department of Human Services, DHS, that impacts our day-to-day work with your constituents is that we have two areas, child welfare and adult perspective services,
where we are the entity in the state that is actually responsible for going in and providing protective services, foster care for clients. So those areas are also another significant portion of our staffing, and that actually between those two areas, it takes up about 80% of our staffing for those. The other large staffing area we have is our county operations, which is where we do eligibility and enrollment.
and in many of the state's services. So the one that is most well-known on that, of course, is Medicaid, and we do the eligibility and enrollment for Medicaid in those offices. We also do SNAP, which used to be called food stamps. We do eligibility and enrollment for that. And we do T and TANF, so Transitional Emergency Assistance. and TANF, of course, is Temporary Assistance for Needy Families,
which is run by the Department of Workforce Services, but we do their eligibility and enrollment. That's a long way to say that day-to-day, most of our employees are actually working directly with constituents, which is, to me, probably one of the greatest opportunities with the Department of Human Services. We actually, because we work with so many of the constituents in the state day-to-day directly,
we actually have the ability to begin to impact the state. We have over one million people that are currently within our programs, so over a third of the state is directly touched by our programs, and we're directly interacting with them. The department's been run for many years in a siloed manner. So each of these areas and divisions, which I'll go over in a second, have been operating their various programs. But these programs have not necessarily been integrated or worked together.
And a large part of what we have been doing, both in order to achieve efficiencies from a business standpoint, as well as to begin to actually turn these from programs where we simply enroll people to programs where we try to figure out are they making a difference and how do we use them to actually make a difference. It's that integration that's what we're looking for as we make our way through this. So just kind of with that little bit of context around us.
The other thing I'll mention is you'll see as we go through this year and as we go through our presentation tomorrow, a good bit of discussion around our budget. We have the largest budget, our budget for this current fiscal year is $8.6 billion, which is an enormous budget. The $6.5 billion of that is federal funding because many of these programs, both the Medicaid program as well as SNAP and others,
are funded by the federal government largely, and we administer them. So with that, let me move to more of a discussion around our divisions and introduce our directors and talk about what they do in each of these. All right, so we're going to start with Craig Cloud. Craig, if you wouldn't mind standing up. Craig oversees the Division of Adult and Aging Services. Craig's division, I think many of you are probably quite familiar with it because of a lot of the work that goes on,
But Craig's division not only runs adult protective services, where they are responsible to ensure the safety of the elderly in our state, but they also oversee our aging policy and long-term services and supports and how those programs and waivers are administered here. There's a lot of work going on in that space, and a number of you have been involved with that. And Craig will walk us through a good bit of that tomorrow, some of the changes and transformations coming.
I'd like to focus for a second, though, on the fact that there are a number of other programs within what Craig has there around elderly that, while they don't get attention, are incredibly important. We work around, for example, senior hunger, and that is an area that we're going to be focusing on a lot more department-wide this year, and hopefully through some of our volunteer efforts beginning to reach out on that effort a little bit more. Arkansas ranks last in the country on senior hunger.
and that's really quite shocking when you think about it. So it is an area that we're going to be focusing on, and it's one of the areas within Craig's division, but it will be something we take on as a department. Kesa Smith should be here. Kesa, has she arrived? This is the point for a grand entrance, Kesa? Okay. All right, so Kesa is...
deputy director of the department overseeing several of the divisions which we tend to think of internally as being on the human services side versus the Medicaid side and one of those is child welfare DCFS Department of Children and Family Services this is an area that I think you're all probably extremely familiar with the work of DCFS this is an area where the state has been as we talked about a good bit in the last year the state has honestly been in crisis
with the growth of children coming into foster care with the help of the legislature last year you did approve some emergency money for us to be able to manage the growth in numbers but we have begun to implement a child welfare stabilization plan and there will be a budget request in front of the legislature this year to help support that plan I think the thing I want to stress about that as we talk about it today briefly is that we have we talk
about it as a stabilization plan because this is not one of those areas where you turn things around on a dime or you turn them around simply or quickly it's an area where we have significant issues throughout the state it's going on around the country. And we're beginning to focus on a number of areas there. One of the biggest areas of focus is what I think we've started referring to internally as strengthening families. We've realized that a lot of what has happened over the last few years in this
area has been a focus naturally when you are taking in a number of children, your focus becomes on the children. And we have not had the focus in the state on the families from the biological families from whom the children are being taken and preparing those families for reunification. So there are a number of efforts that are included in this stabilization plan that focus on issues around removal, trying to set up a stronger structure around whether a child
should be removed, more support services to be provided to a family in order to allow a child to stay there safely or for the family to be able to be reunified more quickly, a focus on parents, a focus on relative placement, quite a number of areas of focus. It's a pretty comprehensive plan, and for any of you that have not been through this, we'd welcome a chance to walk you through it and share it with you. We've had a lot of support and involvement from many legislators who we really have appreciated being partners with us as we're
working our way through this. It also includes a focus on placements, trying to, as much as possible, ensure that children are placed in family-like settings. And then, finally, a real focus on our workforce and both the recruiting and the retention of our workers. I think many of you realize that we have an extremely high turnover rate among workers in that space. In some offices, it can be as high as 100% on an annual basis so it's an area where we have a real need for focus there and we also are going
to focus very heavily on financial management within that area. We have a new CFO who is very strong in that space. We are giving her additional resources so that we can ensure that the financial management is done well. Probably more than you wanted to hear about one division. I will move more quickly, but it is one where we are requesting additional money this year from the legislature, so I wanted to take a moment on it. Also within the human services side, we have child care and early education, which focuses on pre-K. Probably the area that you
will most hear about in that area is the child nutrition programs and the summer feeding programs which are run out of this department. Again, this is a department that is heavily funded by the federal government and we are administering federal programs in that space. On the Medicaid side of the house, we have five, in addition to Director Cloud's division,
we have four other divisions that really focus on delivering Medicaid through the state. The overarching division, I would say, is what's called here the Division of Medical Services, DMS. DMS is referred to colloquially around the department as the bank because in many cases, DMS is where the funding works. This is where the claims come through, this is where the payments go out, and this is where policy changes are administered.
So when you see budgets for us, what you'll always see is that the DMS budget runs around $7 billion, and it's because that's where the Medicaid claims grow through. Now what's important to understand is while DMS is administering much of Medicaid, a good bit of Medicaid policy gets set elsewhere. So over, for example, aging policy over in Director Cloud's division, and then Director Melissa Stone, I believe Melissa is here,
Good morning, Director Stone is over the Division of Developmental Disability Services. And DDS is where policy around developmental disability population is set. And they also oversee the HTCs and the administration of that. So it is an extremely active division, both with the implementation of policy, with the
operation of the waiver services that are on out of there, which she will describe in more detail to you tomorrow, as well as oversight of the HDCs. We also have the other, as we refer to them, special needs population where policy is set is within the Department of Behavioral Health Services. And I believe Paula Stone is here today. Let me see. Great. And I don't believe Interim Director Jay Hill
was able to make it. And there's Kesa Smith. She did make it. So we had a change in leadership at DBHS, at the Division of Behavioral Health Services on Friday. Our director left and we have an interim in place. His name is Jay Hill. Jay, many of you may know Jay. He runs the Arkansas Health Center for us.
He is a very experienced administrator and he is running the division on a temporary basis while we figure out where we're going to go with it because of the transformations that are going on. J, Director Hill will focus primarily in his role, since the State Psychiatric Hospital is also part of this, on the facilities that we operate through DBHS and our overarching efforts in that space.
Paula Stone, who is an AD within DBHS, will take the lead on programs. Paula is here today, and Paula has been the lead inside our organization around the evolution of our behavioral health transformation policies. So we're thrilled that she's going to be able to remain with us and help lead us into our revised era. Part of what we will do tomorrow is talk about the changes underway in Medicaid
around behavioral health policies and our programs there so that you can see what that is going to look like once we implement the new policies in July. The other and final grouping within this Medicaid side of the house is the Division of County Operations. Is Mary Franklin here? Okay. So I should know this. I apologize, but we were all texting and emailing this morning
around multiple things going on. I wasn't sure who was gonna be able to make it. So Director Franklin runs the Division of County Operations. We have I-85 county offices. These are the ones, as I said, where we do all the eligibility enrollment. We also have a business processing center, which is run out of Batesville. The DCO is probably the area that is, you will all have the most contact with, because this is the group that your constituents go through
for any kind of eligibility determination around Medicaid or around SNAP or in any other area. DCO has done an amazing job in the last year. When I joined here last April, end of last April, For example, DCO had a backlog of Medicaid cases. I know that those of you who were serving last year were very familiar with this.
We had over 146,000 cases that were backlogged. With some help from the legislature on temporary resources, they undertook a gargantuan effort to actually get rid of that backlog by the end of the year. And as you've probably seen and heard us rejoicing, they have been able to do that and we were able to complete, at the end of the year they had less than 600 cases and all of those cases had actually been looked at, opened, touched, and figured out that
those folks actually had coverage. It was just simply a matter of doing some administrative clean up on those. It was an enormous effort. They worked through holidays, really did an amazing effort get this done so I can't tell you how much I admire the work that was done to clear the house as we go into this year what director Franklin will tell you is their focus over at DCO now shifts to two things first priority remain current no matter what remain current it is the temporary resources are gone that we're
supporting them in this way Maximus and eSystems and those are gone and so now they will be focused on remaining current themselves we'll still be providing a monthly report to the governor and publicly on a Medicaid operations so that you can see that we remain current next second part of that though is with us being current we're now able to focus over there on actually ensuring that our roles are accurate we do want to make sure that anyone who is eligible for our services has access to services we also want to make sure
they're eligible so there are a number of initiatives underway and she'll talk about those tomorrow that we'll be just carrying on as part of our ongoing operations as well as a couple of things we're going to be doing to look for new ways to keep the roles accurate but it is it is a it is a big shift for us because simple example if you do a mailing and we did a very large mailing
at the end of this year for Arkansas works as we transition to Arkansas works everyone that was in private option got a letter and so over 330,000 letters were mailed out we get returned mail when you're backlogged the return mail can't get handled. We're getting our return mail back now. We're able to handle it. We're able to take all the return mail. We have a process set up now for reviewing every bit of it, figuring out whether or not it's because there was an address issue or whether or not the person appears to not be there. We're able to reach out if no response. It means the person isn't there and we can close the case.
We have not been able to do any of that because what we didn't know with the backlog was whether or not the person had sent us an address change and we just had not been able to put it in the system. So simple things like that, because we have no backlog, we will be able to do what we need to do to keep the roles accurate. Okay, so we'll talk a lot more about some of those things tomorrow. So we have a, back over on the human services side, we have a division called Services for the Blind.
And Services for the Blind is run by Katie Morris, and they focus on providing employment services for those who are blind or visually impaired. They work very closely with other agencies outside DHS, but they are a good example. For example, rehab services, workforce services, et cetera. But they have some very, they have a real focus on trying to help employers in the state
understand how they can bring on people who are blind and visually impaired and create more job opportunities, but at the same time, they also have a focus on helping people who are blind or visually impaired be able to access the services that can get them those jobs. And then finally, over in the human services side, we run the Division of Youth Services, which is where we provide services for juveniles
that have entered the juvenile justice system. And this is an area where it's run by Betty Gooman, who joined us in August of last year. And this is an area where, over the course of this coming year, you will see us moving forward to develop plans to implement a number of the recommendations that have been made by studies on juvenile justice in this state for quite a few years. There have been a number of studies reaching usually all the same conclusions,
but the divisions and the department has never really been positioned before to try to move forward in a comprehensive way and a thoughtful way. So we'll be working very closely with the legislature and with the judicial system and with the stakeholders to help move forward in the ways that the studies have indicated we should for quite a few years. Finally, I'll mention that one of the things that will be before the legislature in terms of reorganization is to end a division that was there that focused on community services
and instead we have a new office of communications and community engagement and we are folding that division into that office. We've done that and I think you'll see some very exciting things coming out of that group Because it's our goal to make sure that we begin to communicate, well, we have multiple goals. One to communicate more, but another is to actually focus our communications across all of our divisions in a way that they are understandable. I mean, it sounds very simplistic, but government speak and jargon that comes out in all of our messaging and communications drives everybody absolutely crazy.
And it is one of our goals for this year is to really begin to make sure that the communications that come are understandable and that we are able to ensure that people take action because they know what we're trying to tell them to do. The other piece of that is we're really trying to focus our community engagement efforts. We have a new AD who is focused on nonprofit and faith-based support.
And you're going to see a lot coming out of us around volunteerism and around alignment with the nonprofit and faith-based communities. Philosophically, we believe that our job is to work in concert with the nonprofits and with the faith-based communities. And where something can be done better by those versus by government, that's where it should be. And we should be supporting them, and we should be helping them.
And we will be putting out a number of things this year, including a statewide volunteerism portal that will try to take advantage of what's out there in the state and help the volunteer activities that are out there connect back to what we're doing at DHS. And this will be done not just through this effort, but through a number of others. For example, our SNAP program requires, as many of you know now,
that able-bodied adults without dependents work or engage in volunteerism. So we're going to be able through this to provide that direct communication so that someone who is out there and needs to do volunteer work in order to continue their SNAP benefits, there will be a way for them to connect with a nonprofit through this portal and for their activity to be tracked and flowed in. So lots going on in that space, and we'll look forward to telling you about it.
I'm going to close with one final thing since we'll spend a lot more time tomorrow really going through the programs. which is our focus for 2017. Our focus, you know, we've spent the last few weeks in the department having meetings around our goals, and over the next few weeks we'll be finalizing those and putting them out. I'm sorting through over 300 goals from our different divisions right now. It's going to be a very active year. But those goals largely focus around one thing.
We're going to focus on operations this year. There won't probably be a whole lot of flash and flare, right? But we're going to focus on getting our operations in shape. And so that's, you know, the effort that was done this past year at DCO. We will be continuing, as I said, on the roles there, but we're going to be continuing looking at business processes and how we improve them. We're going to be looking at staffing. We have real recruiting issues. We have huge turnover issues in many, many departments.
We're focusing on how we fix those and get those working. One of the more exciting things that we have been working with DF&A on is that we, this year, will, by the end of the year, we hope to have launched e-procurement, where we will move to doing our procurements through an electronic portal. And this will allow all of our purchasing and procurements to be quite transparent as well as to give us a good deal of integrity and control through the purchasing system.
It will result in savings and efficiencies, but it will also ensure that we are able to take advantage of the size of DHS. If we have a simple thing, with e-procurement, if we get discounts when we reach a certain volume, well, because everyone within DHS will be buying through that portal, when we hit that volume, it'll just be automatically applied. There's a lot of advantages to going with e-procurement. We're really excited about moving in that direction this year.
We've got major IT procurements and launches coming this year. So this is going to be very much a central focus for us throughout DHS. Our MMIS, our Medicaid Claims and Payment System that we have been developing will launch this year. That is going to be a very critical launch both for the department as well as for all the providers in the state. So expect to hear a good bit from us on that and that we will be going through that in a very methodical, focused way,
hopefully doing it so that we can keep it as smooth for everyone involved as possible. Even as we do that, we are going through the procurement of our integrated eligibility and benefit management system. That is the replacement for the EEF, which is the system that we are currently using, which, as everyone knows, had significant issues launching. And so we are going through this, and this will be a procurement that we do this year
and then begin early, early development work with the idea that by 2019 we are beginning to move into the first stages of launching. We're going to do this one carefully and thoughtfully, as we have been since well before I got here. We have major program transformations underway. We will be launching this summer the transformations for our behavioral health and DD programs.
We also will be launching changes in our aging, our LTSS programs this year. We have our dental managed care going live in January of next year, so we will be going through the setup of that program this year. Arkansas Works. We have already begun the shift into Arkansas Works, and in February you will see the first tracking report between us and DWS where we are referring to them, and they are then going to track,
and we will together provide a report as to who takes advantage of those referral opportunities. We're going to merge that also with a look at our SNAP referrals because SNAP has a requirement to work so that we can see how those two blend together and can also provide some comparisons between them. So business process throughout the organization. We are going to, during this year, begin moving to Lane Six Sigma, analysis of some of our processes.
We're going to be looking at an organized review of business process throughout the organization with changes to come, therefore, in future years and also a focus on budget. We are bringing in new financial players who, financial leadership and they are beginning a thorough budget review of our processes. So that's kind of a, I'm sorry I took more than your bubble was supposed to, but we are big, and so it takes a while
just to explain us. Like I said, this year won't be very glamorous for us, but I guess as you can tell, I'm a big believer if we can get the operations at DHS working and working well, there's probably nothing we can do better for both your constituents, for the budget, and for, honestly, the long-term future of Arkansas than for us to get this division agency working really well. So that's where our heads will be.
Thank you. Thank you, Director. I just want to tell you from my standpoint how much I appreciate you. You've been there right at a year now, and so much has been accomplished, and thank you for everything you've done and the long hours you've put forth.
Will you answer a few questions from the committee? I will, and I also will bring up any of my division
got one question from Representative Love. Sure. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I was just interested in your managed care,
the dental managed care piece. Who's leading that effort from your
department? Dental managed care is being led out of DMS. Don Staley is here. I didn't introduce Don. Don is here today. If
you would, could you give the words that go with those acronyms
you're throwing out, please? Dawn is with the Division of Medical Services, and she is also the Deputy Director for Health Care in the state's Medicaid director. She has multiple titles, and she is here. We are in the middle of a procurement there, so our ability to answer questions is limited on that until there is a formal award.
But Dawn is here, and within our procurement rules, we're happy
to answer questions. Now, follow up. You allow one
follow-up? Thank you, Mr. Chair. Now, are you bidding the entire packet out to just one provider, or is it going to
be multiple providers as we did in Arkansas Works? Okay, so managed care, dental managed care is being bid out to two managed care companies that will then support, so all providers will wind up in it.
So in terms of providers, meaning dentists, they will all wind up part of this system, but there will be two overarching managed care companies that will oversee it for the
state. Okay. Thank you, Ms. Gillespie. Thank
Speaker 41
37:46
you. Chair. Representative Hammer, are you recognized for a question? Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Ms. Gillespie, on the eligibility RFP that's coming out, what's the anticipated date for that to occur? I know it's this
year, but the IEBM was posted last week.
It was a draft posting, and so we'll have a draft posting out for 60 days, and then the final we'll post for 30
Speaker 41
38:14
days. One follow-up. I've got five questions in one here. Can you tell us, as far as the centerpiece of the eligibility was around the Curum product, In the RFP, are we going to be limited to the Curem, or are you at liberty to discuss that, given the status of the RFP?
And is that creating any backlog now that we've gotten the past backlog cleared? Is the staff able to keep up with
Okay. The draft procurement that is out there does not limit to Curem. in terms of what can be proposed. And I'm glad you raised the question about backlog. So our staff is able to keep current
with where we are today. Our temporary partner in this, Maximus, has done this in many states, and one of the things they said to me that I was just very proud of our folks was they said you know at one point as we were going through working the backlog down there came a point where they decided DCO and Maximus decided to work this for a while with Maximus focused only on backlog and our folks were
focused on what was coming in the door so that we could see if we would be able to stay current once the backlog was gone and that worked and Maximus made a point of telling me how unusual that was and how, honestly, how great our workforce was because they did not usually see that. And so our folks are able to do it, and the reason I'm so glad you raised it is this. Over the next couple of years, as we go through the, over the next two to three years, as
we go through the development of the new system, whatever that new system looks like, it is going to require our folks to be involved in the testing. And a part of what developed the backlog before was that when you went through, when we went through in Arkansas the process of testing and going through the development of a new system, they did not have additional workers to do it. And they were not included as part of what was set
up as, you know, temporary folks that would help do that. So they pulled current workforce to do that, which started the backlog even before you made the transition. So, we're really focused right now on making sure that we stay current. We are focused on ensuring that the plans for development, testing and transition include a business process effort so that we don't find ourselves having to pull people and get a backlog going again, quite frankly.
So that's the other reason we're going to do a business process review this year of our DCO to see if there are ways for us to be able to speed things up and implement some more time savings to be able to absorb some of the workload to come. But I really appreciate the question because we will come back, you know, over the next several years again and again, talking about things we need to do to make adjustments in order to make sure we don't ever develop that backlog again.
That's kind of beaten into our heads now. No backlog. Thank you.
Representative Leitman, do you have a question? Yes,
thank you, Mr. Chair. You're recognized. Director Willisby, I just want to say thank you for coming to the Jonesboro HDC when you were up there a few months ago. when we had our grand opening of the work center there which has taken many many years to do and it's it's a really good facility uh and i know that that you talked about trying to do more of that and i appreciate that very much uh my question is um turnover is obviously and i've
seen this firsthand is a is is the big issue i'm glad you mentioned that as one of your goals have you identified at this point maybe you can't answer this but have you identified the causes of this and is there anything that as a legislative body that we could work on to assist in that because I
know that is a big issue. It's a huge issue and I really appreciate you raising it. You know I'd love to say you know oh yes we've identified all the reasons. We have not. I know
pay plan will be coming this year and obviously pay is always a reason. We are we have a new chief human resources officer and we have a new focus that we are beginning this year to try to actually I mean as simplistic as this sounds we don't even have good measurement yet of our turnover to know which jobs are turning over and why they're turning over. So, part of our effort over the next month is actually going to be division by division
to get a handle on which jobs are turning over, why they're turning over, more with exit interviews, understand what's going on, and look and see where those people go. Sometimes they leave and just go to another state job, right? And that's because there hasn't been a career path for them. Hopefully, we will be able to begin to build some career paths. We are going to undertake a number of things in that space, but it's, you know, every area,
a simple area like the backlog on Medicaid, it takes us months and actually in many cases years to get someone to be good at actually operating the systems to do the eligibility and enrollment. And when they turn over in less than a year, it is just horrible. Over at child welfare, we see the same thing. That constant takes us six months to take somebody through the training before they can get them in the field and operational. And then it takes, of course, years for them to develop the experience.
So it's an area where stability in our workforce would save us so much money and time. I can't validate numbers yet in this space, but my Glenn Eisenhower, CHRO, told me the other day that he had had somebody do a one-time manual poll to look at it. And last year, we hired 1,400 people. That is a huge amount of turnover.
Half of them left in less than six months. I mean, our turnover is surreal. So thank you for raising it, and we will be back, but I need better data to do it. And one of the things we will also talk about tomorrow, just since you mentioned it, is supported employment. A number of wonderful things going on in that area at the HDCs with some new programs coming there, as well as in the community in general. So it's one of the areas I think we're most excited about are some of the programs that are out there.
The one in Jonesboro is great, and there's some great programs that are going to be developed at the other HDCs and some really amazing partnerships with business going on around the support of employment within the DD community. So it's a great area. Thank you.
Thank you, Director. We've got one final question from Vice Chair Ferguson. Thank you, Mr.
Speaker 58
46:06
Chairman. I wanted to go back and just clarify something about the Maximus contract. Is that fulfilled or are they still working?
They're done. Okay, thank you. Thank you. Thank you, Director, and committee members, especially the five new ones to public health. Remember, upon adjournment of Senate Public Health tomorrow, Health Care 101, very, very important for you guys to attend and listen because there's hours more of this same discussion to be heard. Thank you, Director. Thank you. All right, guys, let's go right into business. Representative Bentley, I recognize you to run House Bill 1035 if you're ready.
If you would, just introduce yourself, and you're recognized to proceed. Representative Mary
Bentley from District 73, Chairman, colleagues, thank you so much. It's exciting to start another year offering public health, and I welcome our new members. This is definitely one of the most exciting committees that we have here in the House Chambers. I'm bringing to you today House Bill 1035. As most of you know, Arkansas is ranked in the nation's health right now at 48th. Although that's better than 49th where we used to be, we have a far cry to go from our state to our state to get health in.
So really, as a member of this committee, I have been looking at it and looking at the insurmountable costs of Medicaid going forward and just looking at things, what can we do as a legislator to make a difference. And those are things that I've looked at in the interim. What can we do to make a difference in Arkansas and the health of our Kansans? And decrease the cost of Medicaid. Those things have been really forefront on my mind. So I'm really pleased that the governor has brought forth healthy, active Arkansas. I think it's a great plan. It's a great thing that we can do to get Arkansas healthier and get us far from 48th up to 30th. I'm really excited what the governor is doing.
And HB 1035 that I present to you today fits in perfectly with parts of the governor's plan to promote purchase and consumption of healthier food. According to a recent study released by the Food and Nutrition Service responsible for running the food stamp program, soft drinks were the number one purchase of commodities bought by food stamp recipients, shopping at a single U.S. grocery retailer. Bagged snacks were number four, and candy closed at the near top ten at number 11. If the numbers had been included for convenience stores, I can guarantee you those numbers would be much worse when it comes to junk food.
Today's food stamps, excuse me. These poor food choices are certainly part of the reason why the highest rate in obesity in our state is among those in the lowest income. Arkansas is the sixth most obese state in the nation. And in one of the schools in my district alone, we have increased obesity in one year by 10%. Obesity greatly increases the chance for a number of diseases, as we all know, high blood pressure, heart disease, strokes, cancer. Along with these negative health issues, we have got decreased self-esteem,
decreased productivity, and the loss of quality of life. Obesity-related diseases in our state cost $1.25 million annually. Forty percent of that comes from Medicaid and Medicare. We can, excuse me, if we have any help of bending this cost curve of Medicaid in our state, we've got to do something to make a difference. We can just continue acting like this doesn't exist and the legislature has no part, but we as a legislature can make a real difference, and that's what I want us to do today. It's some common-sense legislation that will actually make a difference in the care and the health of Arkansans.
We cannot ignore this issue and think that things will change. This common-sense legislation will simply incentivize food stamp recipients to purchase what they were meant for, food that they can use to feed their families and decrease hunger, not for junk food that will help to lead obesity and poor health. Not only will less junk food decrease, the rise in obesity will help to improve the health of low-income, Arkansans. Foods that are devoid of nutrition weaken the immune system and making the recipients far more susceptible to infection as disease. As a registered nurse in our state I care about the health of Arkansans. That's
really one of the main reasons that I bring in this forth. I care about the kids in our state. I want the kids in our state to have soupy cups that are full of good fresh milk from Arkansas dairies and fruit juice and not Mountain Dew and Pepsi. That really decreases the dental problems in our state. Those are so many things that this addresses. We've seen 172% increase in the number of food stamp recipients in our state, and yet we have rabid increases in hunger. We just heard from the director today that we're the highest rate of senior hunger in our state. Food stamps is not working. Food stamps is broken, and food stamps needs to be fixed. We have 418,000
of our kids participating in the program, and yet hunger continues to rise. I think Not only does the current system provide for poor food choices, we also have a problem with EBT cards being sold. We saw recently in Sebastian County where 94 food stamp recipients' EBT cards were used by some convenience store owners to go and purchase food for their convenience stores. We have a serious problem. When I visit with law enforcement officers in our state, and I say, what can we do to make a difference in our state to cut down on the drug problems?
They say EBT cards being sold are a huge reason for the drug problem that we have in our state. I want to make these food cards a little more less incentive for people to sell them. I want them to be used for the reason that they were for, to decrease hunger in our state. Food stamps were started as a program for farmers to purchase, for farmers to get rid of excess commodities and to help the hunger in our state. We have gone so far from that, from what it was meant to be. I'm asking you, my colleagues, today to be courageous to make a difference and to say in Arkansas we care.
We care about healthy food. We care about our kids in our state, and we want to make a difference. And with
that, Chairman, I would appreciate a good vote. Thank you. We got questions for the sponsor before we start bringing the public up. Representative Hammer, do you have
Speaker 41
52:11
a question for the sponsor? Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Bentley, I saw in the bill that this is going to be subject to the Secretary of the U.S. Department of Agriculture.
Has this been done in another state that we know that this is going to be able to get past that approval process? Maine has got there somewhat, has gone through,
went a different route. And the reason that I did not bring this up, because I feel like we have change in leadership going on. Representative Hammer, with our new president coming in, I think we'll have a new director at USDA. And I'm hopeful at this point that, yes, we will be able to get this approved. It's common sense legislation. I think we have a common sense president coming in. and I'm hoping we will have a common-sense USDA director that will help our state to move forward.
Speaker 41
52:56
So follow-up? Recognized for one follow-up. Thank you. So we wouldn't be the pioneer on this project because somebody else is already doing it out ahead of us. Is that a
fair statement? I think we have seen other states do it in different directions. Like I said, Maine has a legislator in Tennessee just filed a bill this past week as well for junk food. I think this new report that came out, Representative Hammer, showing that soft drinks were the number one purchase of the food stamps, that we will see legislation across the nation as ours is. And I would love for us to be a pioneer in good things for our state.
up. Okay. We'll put you in the queue for the agency. Representative McGee, do you have a question
Speaker 78
53:39
for the sponsor? Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Bentley, first of all, I want to applaud you for helping us raise awareness about obesity and the health issues that it creates for our state in terms of diabetes
and hypertension and all the long-term problems. Representative McGee, can you get closer to the mic, please? Can you hear
Speaker 78
53:59
now? Okay. But my question is, if we do this,
is this not going to be an unfunded mandate on our grocers? I mean, how are we going to enforce this? Are they going to have to develop new computer systems in their stores to keep people from buying these things with their food stamps? Or how would that all be enforced? And I've got a lot of comments from the grocery industry that they really don't like this. I appreciate your question, Representative
Hammer. I'm a manufacturer in Arkansas, and I deal with UPC codes every day. And every item in that grocery store has a UPC code.
And you can simply go in there and stop those UPC codes from being funded. Right now we can't use it for alcohol, we can't use it for tobacco, we can't use it for anything. It's a non-food item. So we have UPC codes for a reason. That's the very reason that we have. And I don't think that we should say because a government program is too big that it's too big to fix. We can fix this program. That's the reason we have UPC codes. And I deal with UPC codes every day on a daily basis at my business, and they can do the same. And I understand. I also do have government contracts. We've done government contracts before, and government contracts are a pain in the neck.
They're a lot of paperwork, which, you know, and then you make a bunch of money. and they've been making a bunch of money and I understand it'll be an inconvenience and I understand that it will be an education for their tellers to have to deal with a few you know, they'll probably have some uncomfortable situations at the teller for a little while, I understand that but the point is we have a serious problem and do we want to get above 48th in our nation you know, do we want to stay down here with poor health or do we want to be the first for a change to make a real difference I want us to be the first and make a difference Thank you Mr. Chair, that's all Thank you
Representative Henderson, do you have a question for a sponsor? Thank you, Mr.
Chair. I guess the only thing I'm really looking at is maybe is there a financial impact or have you done a financial impact statement? I don't see there's going to be any
financial impact for our DHS to apply for a waiver to CMS. I would kind of think that any
time we implement a program like what you're talking about, Representative Henderson, can you get closer to your mic for me?
Is that better? Anytime that we implement a program like that, I would just think there would be some kind of physical impact. The adjustment will
be with our grocers. As far as the state, we're going to apply for a waiver from CMS, and I don't see any financial impact to the state
of Arkansas. Okay. Representative Pilkington you're recognized for a question. Thank you Mr. Speaker. A
few constituents of mine have brought up the idea of food deserts being created in Arkansas because of
this bill and I was hoping that you could address that concern that some people have about this creating food deserts within Arkansas. Aaron thank you so much. I really
appreciate you bringing up that question because we included convenience stores because we want to decrease some food deserts and uh right where i live at williams junction we've got a little convenience store right there we're 15 miles from the nearest grocery store so we all pretty heavily rely on williams junction grocery but you know what you can find at williams junction grocery you can find milk you can find eggs you can find cheese you can find milk you can find anything you want to
make a meal right there in that little convenience store for you to say to me that cutting out cokes energy drinks uh and candy is going to create a food desert i would discredit you know what i I think it might do, it might like distributors go out there to our local convenience stores and actually bring some food out there and help all of us be able to find some great food close by. This meant, food stamps were meant to provide food for families, for kids to have something to eat, and we have abused it to the point where too many of our kids are going hungry all the time because there's nothing left to eat at the house. Thank you.
All right. Representative Hammer, you're recognized for another question. And, guys, I want to refresh you all on the House rules and committee on questions. You're allowed one question, one follow-up, and then you can go back into the queue, and as everybody gets their questions answered, we'll come back to you for another question. So just so everybody's on an understanding of how the question is supposedly to work. So, Representative
Speaker 41
58:12
Hamer, you're recognized for another question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Bentley, a couple questions if I'm giving a follow-up. point is who makes the determination as to what sufficient nutritional value is is that going to
be and and that's a statement in your bill which i agree with i just want to know who's going to be the responsible party that has to determine the items that are in the grocery store that can be bought with the card and can't be bought with the card uh is going to be given that responsibility i hope that i would love to be part of
that process but we'll use dhs and we'll use our health department. We've got great folks here in our health department here that will be able to assist them in that we can start right off the top with things that don't have any nutritional value, soft drinks right at the very top of the list.
So I think we'll work with the Department of Health along with DHS and I would like to be a part of that as well as our and other
Speaker 41
59:08
One follow up. How is it that the bill will help in the issue of prohibiting the selling of the cards because that is something i've i've got a convenience store i stop at you know frequently and that's the one thing the guy tells me is you know the they go out and buy the cards you know they'll buy the cards for cash out in the parking lot and then come in use them
kind of deal of course i told them call the 800 number and report it but um how does how is the bill going to prevent that from occurring i'm hoping that the
bill and somehow will make them less attractive okay if they know they can't use that ebt card to buy cokes and candy and those things that are snack items that it'll make the card less attractive if we saw like in sebastian county where those guys are gathering up to buy snack food for their convenience store if you can't use it to buy snack food for your convenience store to make it less attractive to sell that's how it will be prohibitive that way and i hope that we will this will be the first and many
steps that we take representative hammer to get food stamps back to where they were meant to be providing food for
Speaker 102
1:00:08
our families. Mr. Chair, at appropriate time, if we have the Department of Health come to the
table, if you'd allow. We'll do. I've got one question off a statement you just made, Representative Bentley. In your bill, it only references to the Department of Human Services and not the Department of Health, and you referenced that they would have some input into this. Is there an amendment that you want to put on this going to the Senate or at some point to allow the Department of Health to help with this?
I would definitely be open to that. Okay.
Sure. Representative Miller, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Can you hear me? Yes, sir. Representative Bentley, do you feel like the original intent of the food stamp program was to provide food for hungry folks who cannot get help anywhere else? I agree. The
original intent actually was to help farmers that have excess food,
be able to take that excess food and give it back to families. So I'd like us to get back to that. We're helping farmers here in Arkansas as well as helping our
hungry families. So I think it definitely was meant for food and not for supplying soft drinks. Follow up, Mr. Chair. You're recognized. Do you feel like your bill is getting us back to the original intent where we are providing the essential food items and not and not just fluff on the side, luxury items?
Yes, sir. It's definitely what I'm trying to do to get back to essential
food items and not junk food. Thank you. Seeing no further questions from the committee, I would ask we have some people signed up to speak against and for the bill. We'll start off with against. If we could get Ms. Kathy Webb to the end of the table first. former Representative Webb. Ms. Cather, you're recognized to recognize yourself for the committee and carry on.
Speaker 113
1:02:14
Thank you, Mr. Chair, and thank you, Madam Vice Chair and members of the committee. And first of all, I want to thank Representative Bentley for raising awareness about obesity and about hunger in Arkansas. and at some point I would love to be able to come back and talk to you about those two issues on a different day. But I will specifically address some of the points of this bill that we have issues with. As the chair mentioned, I had the privilege of serving in the House and being co-chair of the Legislative Hunger Caucus
and I'm currently the executive director of the Arkansas Hunger Relief Alliance. And about three years ago, I had the privilege of working with a group of folks who wrote Healthy Active Arkansas, and I was able to provide almost everything that is in that document on access to healthy food and currently serve as co-chair of the Access to Healthy Food subcommittee on the operations team. And the way that the bill is written, the Hunger Relief Alliance and our member food banks,
the six Feeding America food banks, which cover the entire state. We actually have a lot of problems with the bill. We support and encourage all Arkansans to make healthy food choices, and we do that on a daily basis through programs of the Alliance and programs of the food banks. We have a program like Cooking Matters, which is an evidence-based program that teaches people how to eat healthy and cook healthy. We have a program, Cooking Matters at the Store, which teaches people how to shop for healthy food, particularly if you're a low-income person.
We have free fresh produce distribution, and we have a variety of other types of nutrition education. But as I mentioned in the current form, and I did mention this to Representative Bentley before we started, we do not support this bill. And I also want to say that she and I have worked together on other food-related and hunger-related projects, and so I applaud the fact that she's willing to work on those projects, not only for kids and families of her district, but kids and families around the state.
Access to nutritious food is not equitable throughout our state. We do have many families who live in food deserts, as one of you all raised that point, and choices are limited for folks in many of these communities. People rely on dollar stores and convenience stores as their primary grocery store because there is not any alternative. And I'd like to say within Healthy Active Arkansas, one of the points in that document is to incentivize retailers to locate in areas of food deserts,
and something that we're currently working on, And we work with convenience stores to get them to provide more nutritious offerings. But the reality is that not only do we have to provide those nutritious offerings, but we have to educate families on how to use nutritious food. And now I'm not talking about low-income families. I'm talking about all Arkansans. We are sorely lacking in nutrition education in the state. And having nutrition education is another one of the points that's included in Healthy Active Arkansas.
So I see this, you know, that there are multiple things that we have to do in order to improve our ratings in both hunger and food deserts. The legislation also says that the federal guidelines on WIC would be used as a basis for DHS to identify healthy foods. And the WIC program, which is an outstanding program, was designed for pregnant women, for infants and children. And the WIC guidelines would actually not be appropriate for senior citizens
or people with diabetes and high blood pressure and heart disease. Eating healthy costs more money. Families and individuals who qualify for SNAP are low income, and they make difficult choices. Our Feeding America food banks, who work with over 1,000 pantries all across this state, Know that on a daily basis families choose between paying rent and buying food, paying the utility bill and buying food, buying medicine and buying food.
Do you take your sick child to the doctor or do you buy food? Do you have the car repaired so you can get to work or do you buy food? So we want to do everything we can to work with you all to improve the health of Arkansans, but we feel like this would have a negative impact on the health of many SNAP beneficiaries. And because I didn't know a whole lot of time in advance that I was going to be here today, I just want to say a couple of other things about SNAP.
Most people are not on SNAP for an extended period of time. Before the recession in 2007 and 2008, the average length of time that somebody was on SNAP was less than a year. And since that time, it's increased to a little bit over a year, but people, by and large, don't get on SNAP and stay on SNAP. Now, I don't like any abuse of any federal program, but I do want to point out while we can talk about some instances of abuse,
SNAP does have the lowest abuse rate of any federal program. Again, any abuse of a program is too much. And I just want to say one last thing. In the article that talked about the soft drinks, I want to say 15 paragraphs down into the article, the article actually disputed the headline of the article and said that people who are on SNAP and people who are not on SNAP buy soft drinks in almost the same proportion,
and it missed a lot of other articles. So I would say while we have a problem to fix with healthy eating, with obesity in Arkansas, and also with hunger, we would submit that House Bill 1035 would have a negative impact on the health of many SNAP recipients. Thank you very much. I appreciate your time.
Thank you. Ms. Webb, would you take a few questions? Sure. Representative Bentley, you have a question?
Actually, I have a motion at the proper time. Okay. Representative Pilkington, do you have a question?
Yes, I do. Okay. You recognize. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. You talked about healthy eating habits, but don't you feel that this bill would help generate healthy eating habits? I know the way I shop is I shop the way my mother shops, and so I took a lot of, you know, just I followed her habits, and I feel like this will help create healthy habits so that the younger generations, when they are growing up,
they think, oh, I'm going to buy the same things that were in my kitchen. And so if you were in a low-income home that had these restrictions on it, then because you were on SNAP, then you would be used to buying these healthy products. Even when you were an adult and you had more incomes, you're still buying healthy products because you learned
Speaker 113
1:09:44
good nutritional habits at a younger age. Thank you, and I appreciate your question, your comment, Representative Pilkington. And I don't feel that it would help because while I learned a lot of things from my mom about healthy eating habits as well,
there are many people who don't know, many adults who don't know what healthy eating habits are and who are not able to pass those on to their kids. And while that is very true or often true in the low-income families we work with, it's also true in other families. And I think having nutrition education in the schools would be a better way to help with healthy eating habits and to provide more of the programs that we provide which teach people how to shop and teach people how to develop healthy eating habits would be a better way.
I read a study recently that said, like with a kid, it takes a kid about seven times to try something that's new before the kid is going to like or not like the food. And now I'm a fortunate person, and when my great-nephew comes over for dinner, I can give him something, and if he doesn't like it, we can go to our refrigerator and we can pick out something else for him to eat. But I know that there are many times when moms tell us that they try to provide healthy choices for their kids,
and, you know, it doesn't always work the first time or the second time, and that's one reason I'm a huge proponent of more nutrition education.
We've got Representative Lundstrell. Do you have a question? Yes. I
was listening closely to what you were saying about healthy eating choices, and I can't begin to tell you I'm a little bit confused. How is it healthy eating choice not to encourage someone to get rice and beans and potatoes, but it's okay to get candy and Cokes?
As a taxpayer, I want to see people have healthy choices, and I'm glad to help somebody that's in need, But I'm discouraged that we would say it's okay to grab a candy bar when we're talking about diabetes, heart disease, hypertension, rice, beans, ground beef. These are things that people need. Candy bar we can do without. So I applaud Mary Bentley, but I'm a little concerned. I would think you'd be cheering and leading the
Speaker 113
1:11:59
And I cheer and lead the parade on healthy eating choices because that's why we work to provide access to healthy food. But I'm also very concerned about points of this bill, and I think that one can be cheering healthy eating choices and still have concern about points in this bill. And for one thing, if healthy eating choices cost more money, then what are you going to do? Are you going to be hungry? A pound of rice and beans first. I'm sorry to interrupt. A
pound of rice and beans versus a candy bar, you get much more.
Is that your follow-up? Yes, I'm sorry. Thank you. Sorry, I was listening so closely to what she
Speaker 113
1:12:40
was saying. I understand. I've done it before. I'll do it again. And I appreciate your follow-up, and I appreciate your concern. If those things cost more, then are you going to be able to buy enough food to feed your family? Now, I don't typically eat that kind of food, but occasionally if I'm really, really hungry and I'm driving through someplace and that's all they have, I have to admit that I'm going to buy a candy bar or something or some chips or something to fill me up until I get to that spot.
But I think I hope that we can look and consider folks who don't have some of the same options that we do, and let's make healthy eating easier for
everybody in Arkansas. Representative Ferguson, you've got
Speaker 58
1:13:24
a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I don't know a lot about the WIC guidelines. What are your concerns about the WIC
Speaker 113
1:13:32
guidelines? Well, I'll give you one example in the WIC guidelines. For example, you can buy yogurt in WIC guidelines.
You're very restricted on the type of yogurt you can buy, the size package yogurt you can buy. And if you're a senior person in Arkansan, you might not be able to eat a 32-ounce container of yogurt. in the time before it would go bad. You can't choose, like, kinds of tuna that you can buy. You can buy one kind of tuna. I think all in all, the WIC lines for infants and children and pregnant moms are pretty good guidelines,
but they don't necessarily, they weren't necessarily drawn up for people who have high blood pressure or are seniors. All right. Representative Womack,
you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Ms. Webb, do you think there's a difference in healthy eating and
sufficient nutritional value? And the reason I ask that question is I hear us talking a whole lot about eating healthy, and in my mind that would be very different from what the language the bill uses when it deals with sufficient nutritional value and insufficient nutritional value.
Speaker 113
1:14:50
Well, that's a good question. And, yes, I would think that there is a difference, but probably not a lot of difference. I may have to get you to rephrase or say that question again. Nutritional value and healthy eating, which
seems to be what we're talking. That's been used a lot in this testimony, and I was just curious if you thought there was a
Speaker 113
1:15:19
difference. I mean, I look at nutrition guidelines on things that I buy, and I try to eat healthy,
so I think there's probably some difference, but we tend to use those things interchangeably. Thank you, ma'am. Thank you. Seeing no further
questions, thank you, Ms. Webb. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Representative Bentley, and thank you, committee. Representative Payton,
Speaker 113
1:15:39
thank you, Mr. Chair. I'd like to make a motion. I'll take your motion. I
move that we limit debate to five minutes per side. Thank you.
Committee, we've got a motion on the floor to limit debate to five minutes on either side.
Let me clarify what this means for the new members. This would include all questions and answers, closing for the bill. So I don't know, we'll see when this passes, if Representative Bentley wants to reserve time for closing. You got a question, Representative Love? I'm just waiting for
right. Is there any discussion on the motion? Representative Love. Thank you, Mr. Chair. As I
look around the room, I see a lot of grocers.
I see a lot of people that are concerned, and I think limiting debate to five minutes would not do this subject enough justice. So if we could, I mean, I'm all for limiting debate, but five minutes for each side would not give ample, I don't feel it would give ample time for the issues to be addressed. So if we could, if you would consider making your motion at least 15 minutes for each side, that would be better than just five
minutes. Representative Love, this motion is non-debatable.
I'm sorry for allowing that. All right, thank you, Mr. Chair. We're going to carry on
with the vote. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. All those opposed? No. I rule the no's have it. And we will go ahead and call up the next speaker. And Mr. Paul Calvert is here to speak for the bill.
Hello, ladies and gentlemen. I'm glad to be back this year. Some of you know I had a pretty serious accident, so it's back in the summer. But I'm back, and I'm kicking. I'm Paul Calvert. As many of you know, I'm just kind of an advocate for liberty and justice issues. I think this is kind of a no-nonsense piece of legislation. I'm going to disagree with the former representative. I think eating healthy generally is relatively, more or less, quite a bit less expensive than eating junk food. Chips are expensive.
Soft drinks are expensive. You go to the gas station and pick up a 20-ounce soft drink, it's like, what, a dollar and a half or two bucks right now? that's crazy um so right now you can eat you can get rice is cheap and nutritious dry beans are cheap and nutritious bananas are dirt cheap nutritious um carrots are pretty cheap even the baby carrots at walmart i think are like a dollar a pound in the little package is super convenient to eat and they're just awfully nutritious they're just good for you um bananas are cheap i already said that um sweet potatoes a lot of foods are very cheap chicken leg quarters
a lot of times are like 60 cents a pound or maybe less sometimes sometimes you see those for like 35 cents a pound if they're on sale that is dirt cheap food that's nutritious and if you overeat some of that stuff like the chicken you might get fat on that but it's good nutritious food and it's not expensive the fact is that if we if we're dumping a bunch of junk food down people and and facilitating that i think i think it's it's facilitating the the obesity problem that we have among poor people and and and i see this as a landlord i i see this with my tenants a lot
times people are having problems because they tend to make poor decisions not everybody sometimes you have people that are injured or other situations but a lot of times people will make poor decisions and they become obese it's because they lack self-control I think this is one of those things that can help with that somewhat and I think it's reasonable and I will take
questions. Seeing no questions we thank you for your testimony. Representative Hammer did you have
please as a proper motion non debatable and that would limit debate to 10 minutes on either side please remember that the closing for the bill will be included in the four side all those in favor say aye aye all those opposed the motion passes we will keep time at the desk and with that we'll move on to the next speaker. If we can get Mr. Paul Roten from Edwards Food Giant to the table. I would remind, we have quite a few speakers to speak against. Please do not hit on the same subjects
as the previous against speaker and try to keep it as brief as possible. Thank you. If you would introduce yourself for the record and you're
Speaker 138
1:20:30
recognized to carry on, Mr. Paul. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Good morning. I'm Paul Roten with Edwards Food Giant.
Speaker 139
1:20:36
On behalf of our 760 employees in 13 locations across the state. It's a privilege to speak to you this morning regarding House Bill 1035. Representative Bentley, I would like to commend you on the idea and the effort you've put forward to make the SNAP program more efficient in the
state of Arkansas. While I agree with you in theory, I want to share with you a few concerns we have as a family-owned Arkansas-based business. First, let me say I'm a big fan of streamlining government programs, for removing unnecessary red tape, and for the cost savings that generally come with these efforts. On paper, this seems like a good idea, but I feel the theory is much different than the reality. This bill that's presented before you today addresses the idea that this could possibly create change, but doesn't address implementation or management at the retail level.
It doesn't address the new state agency that could be a requirement to manage and consistently determine which items are healthy and which items are not. And it doesn't address the number of new state employees that would be needed to continually do analysis on constant changing pack sizes, ingredients, and package types. If this legislation were to pass, where would this additional funding come from to implement and enforce this at the state level? In terms of real-world implementation at the retail level, all of the burden from this legislation seems to be put on retailers.
and the burden could be unbearable for small businesses like ours, not to mention those retailers across the state that don't even have scanning capabilities. The consumer food industry currently includes almost 300,000 unique, individually labeled items or SKUs. The average grocery store in Arkansas carries approximately 45,000 different items and is tasked with reviewing up to 15,000 new items per year. the proposal to restrict snap choice would lead to a government created food list
that indicates good food or bad food these 300,000 food and beverage products and the additional 15,000 introduced every year would need to be analyzed in a database maintained by someone cost to administer these ongoing changes will especially be burdensome to grocers And I agree with Representative Bentley's comments that there is a fraud problem, but I think rather than limiting foods and adding complexity to an already complex program, efforts should be focused on improving efficiencies, these fraud reduction efforts, and nutrition education.
One person mentioned earlier the current restrictions such as alcohol and tobacco, which are done by departments. And we're talking about getting into line items and having a skew of five items and four of them being acceptable and one of them not. And I just think that becomes very, very burdensome on businesses in Arkansas. Another issue to be considered is increased transaction time for all Arkansans. If this bill becomes reality, imagine waiting in the checkout line behind a single dad with his two children
while he is being told by the cashier that the box of olive oil triscuits he picked up are not SNAP eligible because they contain more calories than the hint of salt-flavored Triscuits. Sir, you will have to go back to aisle 21 and swap these out. Who's going to determine the characteristics of healthy? Is it calorie-based? Is it sodium-based? Is it based on fat grams? Is it gluten-free? Depending on these many characteristics which have yet to be determined, you could have calorie scenarios where diet soda was deemed healthy and acceptable,
yet orange juice was not, and therefore not an eligible SNAP item? Or a fruit punch flavored juice cocktail deemed healthier than apple juice? What about artificial sweeteners? Would these be banned, or would we be in essence naming these the new health standard? Representative Ferguson, you mentioned the WIC program, and I want to mention that briefly. The biggest difference for us as retailers and business in the state of Arkansas that's a prescription-based program, meaning those participants meet with a Department
of Health employee monthly or quarterly to discuss their food parameters and what they need for their healthy diet. And in this bill, there's no mention of that, and there's also no funding allocated to hire that state staff to meet with these individuals on an ongoing basis to determine what's healthy and what's not. This bill would cost businesses across the state a tremendous amount of money and would almost certainly lead to a large number of new regulations for our company. Take a moment to think about a federal health insurance legislation from several years ago
at the federal level. I think we can all agree that we do not want to hurry up and push any bills through in this great state without fully understanding the future consequences. As I mentioned before, on paper, this certainly seems like a step in the right direction, but without a true implementation plan to include costs to implement and manage, This is a bad bill for Arkansas and bad for Arkansas businesses. And I guess my question is, as Arkansans, are we truly open
for business? I would let you know that you're halfway of the time.
It's five minutes. Thank you, sir. I'll yield my time. You can do whatever you want to do, but I'm letting you know. Okay. Would you take
questions? Certainly. Representative Love, do you have a question? I just wanted to know the fiscal impact, too. You're from Edwards Food Jotters. So, number one, you're one of my constituents. because there was food giants in my district, but what is the fiscal impact to your company's bottom line? It
Speaker 139
1:26:15
would be tremendous. I don't have a number for you.
I just know it would probably, in our scenario, require an upgrade of register system, which average store, that's $100,000. So you're looking at, for us, a little over $1 million, depending on the specifics of the plan and how it came back. So it would be a tremendous burden. and then I guess the biggest cost would be an ongoing cost of employees and the maintenance. And the real thing is we want to do what's right as retailers. We want to be above the law. We want to do the things that are supposed to be done.
And if we don't get the information from the state or the federal government in this case, I'm not sure where that would come from because it's not yet been determined. But if we don't get the information we need to follow the rules, it's hard to follow
the rules. Follow up, Mr. Chair. You're recognized. In order to carry out this plan, would you have to cut any jobs? Do you see any potential job cuts, job losses, or store closings?
Speaker 139
1:27:15
We'd have to look at that on an individual basis, but any time you look at increased cost,
I think everybody at the table is probably aware of the margins in the grocery industry and the competition that's there. So it would be something we would certainly have to entertain is possibly cutting jobs in lieu of technology.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you. We have Representative Ferguson, Vice Chair, has got a question.
Speaker 58
1:27:42
Yeah, and I understand what you're saying if you have a whole list of products. I guess we do alcohol and tobacco. How burdensome would it be if we just did product groups?
Say we say no soft drinks, no candy. I mean, would that be burdensome?
Speaker 139
1:27:58
It would be less burdensome if we were to do that, but, again, it goes back to who's going to tell us what's defined within that department. Is water a beverage? Is flavored water a beverage? With 300,000 items, it becomes very, very hard for us to manage without the staff at the state level to help us.
Okay. Thank you. Representative Gonzalez, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And be mindful, they have eight minutes
burnt already, two minutes to go. I'll be quick. Okay, go ahead. As
Speaker 139
1:28:40
a grocer in Arkansas, are you required to take SNAP benefits? No. But there are some requirements that if you want to participate in one program, you have to participate in others. So it may disqualify us from accepting WIC in certain areas for those people in need
if we weren't taking the SNAP program. Thank you.
Representative Payton, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. So you mentioned tight margins in the grocery business. I owned a shell station for a time, and I understand some of that. But what's the difference in the profit margin on sugary drinks and potato chips versus a bag of potatoes and a bag of rice
Speaker 139
1:29:17
or beans? I can't speak specifically to that. And we don't have a – the problem is not with trying to do the right thing. The problem is with who's going to maintain this database and give us the information we need to effectively do it.
Well, and, of course, my question is to the point that, you know, what would be limited by this bill is some of the items that have the highest margin of gross profit for
Speaker 139
1:29:40
the grocery chain. Not necessarily. I mean, chips is one of our lowest margin items. That's something that was mentioned earlier by Representative Bentley. Okay. So I don't
think that's fair. Well, then you answered my question. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you for your testimony. We have approximately 40 seconds left.
There's three people left to speak against. I've got Charlie Spakes, Dennis Farmer, and Ms. Seals. So if you guys want to get together, who wants to take up to 40 seconds? Don't you go with a four next? If we could just go on record, I can limit what I
was going to say. You have to go to the end table. We've got 40 seconds, the three of us? You've got 40
seconds, and I've got three of you left. So if you all want to get together, I'm giving you that option. Charlie needs Charlie.
Speaker 166
1:31:06
And we need to also say we have five members. All right. Y'all guys ready? Yes.
recognized to carry on. Charlie Spakes with the
Speaker 170
1:31:26
Arkansas Grocers and Retail Merchants Association. I'll hit just some quick points maybe not mentioned.
Something not brought up is state line stores. So I think there definitely can be a fiscal impact of people on state lines, Fayetteville, Memphis, El Dorado, Texarkana, simply going over state lines because it's a federal program. It would be perfectly legal for them to go purchase their groceries. elsewhere, which will harm grocers in-state and also could affect sales tax because 70% of SNAP members don't get full benefits.
So you'll find that over half of their cart will be paid with their own money. Mr. Spakes, that's
the end of your time. I appreciate you. Yes, I appreciate it. I don't make the money, but just follow them. Arkansas Public Policy panel is also opposed to this. All right, that's all we can hear. All right, Representative Bentley, we have no one else signed up to speak for. You recognize the close for your bill? Does anyone else in the public speak for the bill?
Okay, Representative Bentley, you recognize. Colleagues, thank you so much for allowing me to bring this bill for you today. And in closing, I just want to say a couple things. I love Edwards Food Giant. I go there and shop regularly and will continue to do so. I'm not meaning for this bill to be cumbersome for these grocery stores. We're simply wanting to limit those things that are really, we have proven to be causing obesity in our state. We will make this as simple as we possibly can. The bill title says we want to limit junk food, and that's what we want to do.
And I will promise you that I will work in that effort to make sure that it's food groups that will limit foods that are high in sugar, foods that have no nutritional value. And we'll work towards getting food stamps back to the good program that it was, feeding our cans and the good things from Arkansas farmers. and that's really where I'd like to be. I'd like to say that I don't think this will be more expensive for folks because, like we said, you can buy a bag of potatoes for it, you can buy a bag of chips. I think we can look at things and we can use this as an incentive to increase the health of our Kansans, and it's exactly what we want to do is incentivize good things,
good choices, and good foods for Arkansas, and I appreciate your courage today. And at the proper time, I have a
motion. Any questions for a sponsor? See you now. It was a pleasure, committee. Representative Bentley, I think you have a motion. I have a motion due pass. Thank you. We have a motion due pass on the floor. Is there any discussion? Representative, we don't need a second. Is there any discussion on the current motion?
See you none. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. All those opposed? No. I'll rule the ayes. I have it. I need two hands. I got two hands, and we will proceed. I'm going to real quick go through the rules on the roll call for you guys. Rule number 29, when a roll call is required, the roll will be called in seniority with the vice chairman being called next to last. And chairman last, for a member's vote to be counted and recorded,
he or she must vote yes or no or present when their name is called. They'll be called twice. Is that right? Yes. During the roll call vote, when a member's name has been called twice, I just went over that, so we're good to go. We'll
Speaker 179
1:34:59
Highest, I'm sorry. Representative Love. Representative Hammer. Representative Branscombe.
Representative Branscombe. Representative Meeks. Yes. Representative Ritchie. No. Representative McGee. No. Representative Miller. Yes. Representative Womack. Yes. Representative Payton. Yes.
Representative Ladyman. No. Representative Lundstrom. Yes. Representative Bentley. Yes. Representative Gonzalez. Yes. Representative Boyd. Yes. Representative Henderson. No. Representative McCollum. Yes.
Representative Coleman. Yes. Representative Pilkington. Vice Chair Ferguson. Chair Ward-Long. Receiving
the qualified votes, the bill has passed. Thank you, Representative Bentley. All right, we've still got one more bill to go.
Representative Mayberry, are you ready to run your bill, 1033? Okay, if you would, find your way to the end of the table, and we'll get
Speaker 195
1:37:03
started. You have not voting? You were not voting? Yeah. There wasn't no reason to. No. It doesn't
Speaker 195
1:37:17
Does it say 5-0? To change it going forward, to start with a low seat. It's kind of a courtesy to the guys at the high that if it's passed or failed, there's no reason to have to vote. Is that too hard? We don't have to say the waiting list. Is that the waiting list? It makes no difference. It just gives the younger members a chance to figure out how to vote. Maybe, I don't know. Let's leave
That's the key. We waiting on somebody to help you, Representative?
Speaker 201
1:37:59
Mr. Chair, I was actually going to ask Melissa Stone with the Division of Developmental Disabilities to join me. Okay. And I see her coming. Other side.
If you would, have you and your guests introduce yourself for the record, and
Speaker 201
1:38:29
then we'll get started. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm State Representative Andy Mayberry, and I appreciate you all letting me come back into the legislature and have this as the first bill that I've introduced in my my return and with me I have Melissa Stone most
Speaker 209
1:38:45
of you yeah thank you hi Melissa Stone director of developmental disability services with the Department of Human Services this is
Speaker 201
1:38:57
House Bill 1033 and just a little bit of quick background in the state of Arkansas we have a developmental disability waiver waiting list. There had been a list that had accrued over some period of time several years ago that a parent of one of the children who was on that list had sued the state of Arkansas and the court ruling was that the state had to eliminate that list and so several years ago about ten years ago that list was completely eliminated and
and it was back down to zero, but then immediately began to accrue more individuals onto that list. And so it has reached a stage now that there are about 3,000 families that are on that list, and the ones who are at the top of the list, they've been there nearly that entire time, about 10 years. And so the state very much needs to address this issue. It's not only a legal issue, but a moral one as well. and this is a first step in that and this is the first significant step that
we've been able to make in quite some time what this bill would do is take about eight and a half million dollars that has been earmarked in the tobacco settlement that is no longer being used it was originally earmarked for a program that is not being utilized at this point in time and this is annual funding that comes in and this would redirect that money to be able to go towards eliminating at least a portion of that waiting list for the DD waiver now this would trigger about 20 million dollars in federal funds as well bringing in a
total of approximately 29 million dollars that would then address the first 500 to 900 families on that waiting list and with that I don't know if Melissa if you have any additional comments about the bill itself why My thanks. And since this has been a long meeting, I will understand if we have a quick do-pass motion. I don't know if
that's going to happen, but we do have a few questions.
Representative Love was the first to raise
hands, so I'm going to let him go first. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Mayberry,
Speaker 201
1:41:17
what program are you all talking about that is no longer? If you'll reference in the bill on page 2, line 5, 4D, you see creating and providing a limited benefit package to adults age 19 to 64.
And Melissa, if you could explain exactly why this is
Speaker 209
1:41:42
no longer necessary. So Representative Love, those particular individuals that were covered under this bill are now being covered under a different coverage package. So the money
is accruing annually. Okay, so we had tobacco settlement money covering these individuals, but now they're covered by the ACA? Is that what you're saying? And so I guess what I'm interested in is the way discussions are happening with Arkansas Works.
If Arkansas Works is cut, then what happens to these individuals? Is there a plan there that would pick up coverage on these individuals? I mean, if we utilize this money for something else. So I don't want to overstep.
Speaker 209
1:42:31
I think Dawn Staley has actually left. I wish she was still here and she could speak more towards this. But I think that, of course, we would not want anyone to lose coverage
if individuals that are on the ACA, if something different is put into place that would replace that or modify it, or if it's completely eliminated, we could discuss it at that time. But right now the money has been accruing annually since the ACA went into effect and these individuals are covered.
Speaker 201
1:43:04
And Representative Love, if I may follow up to that as well. If indeed some kind of, certainly we are in a time that we don't know exactly
what the future may hold with different things, certainly if something were to happen to Arkansas Works, there's 300,000 people that we have to address in some shape, form, or fashion, and certainly we're going to do as a legislative body, and I believe our executive branch as well, the best that we can to address the needs and concerns of all Arkansans as well as just the state of Arkansas in general. Okay, well, I would just want to follow up.
Yes, yes. Sorry, Mr. Chess, my follow-up. I would just like to go on record as saying I'm all for supporting this piece of legislation
only if there was a trigger. I mean, because if we move away from the ACA, it's just going to leave. How many individuals is this program serving currently? Currently zero. I mean, zero, yes, currently zero. But what I'm saying is if we cut the ACA, how many people were being served? How many people were being served? So I don't have that number, Representative Love,
Speaker 209
1:44:10
but I can get that for you. How many people fell into this category that moved on to the ACA? Correct. I'd be happy to get that for you.
Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you. I'm
Speaker 58
1:44:27
going to recognize Vice Chair Ferguson for a question. I guess I'm a little confused. Is this one-time
Speaker 201
1:44:32
$8.5 million money, or is it ongoing? No, this is annual funding of $8.5 million from the tobacco settlement. This is a part of the chart plan from 16 years ago, an initiated act, and it earmarked this ongoing funding for this specific purpose that is no longer being utilized.
And so for the last two or three years, $8.5 million has been coming into the system, but there was no designated purpose for it. This is a plan to redesignate that money that can go toward eliminating this developmental disability waiver waiting list. Okay, you've clarified.
Speaker 201
1:45:10
not one-time funds. Okay, thank you. It wouldn't serve the purposes of eliminating the waiting list if we did that. People, yes.
Representative Hammer, you recognize for a question? Thank you,
Speaker 41
1:45:25
Mr. Chair. The number that is currently on the waiting list now, is it still around 3,000, 2,500, or 3,000? According to Ms. Stone, yes. Follow-up question, Mr. Chair? You're recognized for one. Thank you. Don't take this as I'm not supportive of the idea. I'm just trying to anticipate any repercussions that will come as a result of our decision. If I remember right, we originally got sued because we weren't taking care of all the people that were on the waiting list.
With us only taking 500 to 800 off of that waiting list of 3,000, what is going to be the selection process, and how is it going to keep us from having a lawsuit filed against us by the rest that are not included in that that say why did they get chosen and I didn't? I'll have
Speaker 201
1:46:16
an answer to that, but if Ms. Stone could address the selection process. Absolutely.
Speaker 209
1:46:22
So as Representative Mayberry said, you're correct. We've had people waiting on the wait list since 2007.
At this point in time, we do not think it's equitable to make a selection based on need rather than just how long people have been waiting. States do that differently in each state. Some look at the list and determine who they believe is more more um deservant of getting a slot when slots are opened up we say this is the first step in a greater plan that we've been working with at dhs to completely eliminate the list we think this
is a very good first step um as you guys know it will take some time to start serving this many people and we hope that by the time we get these people up and running on the waiver that our long-term plan of how we're eliminating the list will come to
Speaker 201
1:47:18
fruition. And if I may follow up just briefly, because it is a waiting list of 3,000, quite honestly, to eliminate that list, it would need to be, in a real-world setting, would need to be done incrementally because we don't have the number of people out there trained right
now to be able to eliminate an entire list all at once. So it needs to be in steps, and it just so happens that we have the funding right now to be able to take that first step. And now, as I said, this isn't the ending point. This, I would hope, would be a beginning point to complete elimination of that list.
Thank you, Representative Hammer. Representative Miller, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Representative Mayberry, would you feel like this is you said it's a first step and would you be open to supporting a second step if done possibly this same session or otherwise? I mean, do you think this is a first step and we need to wait two more years until we take step two? Representative Miller, if you've got
Speaker 201
1:48:36
an idea to be able to take
step two forward, I'm happy to visit with you about that because I would like to see us do this
proper time, Mr. Chair. I got you noted, Representative Miller. Representative Pilkington, you're recognized for a
question. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Andy, real quick, how many waiver slots will this cover? Do you want to address how
Speaker 209
1:49:04
that would... So it'll cover anyway between 500 and 900 slots or individuals, depending on what the outcome of their independent assessment states that they need.
Follow-up? Yes, sir. What is the current status of this waiver then?
Speaker 209
1:49:19
So we are operating a waiver right now that has about 4,000 people on it. These 3,000 individuals are on the wait list for that waiver. That waiver is at CMS awaiting renewal. We hope that with the administration change that we will see some movement on that in the next few weeks. Thank you.
Thank you, Representative Lundstrom. You're recognized for a question.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. What steps are being taken to ensure this waiver is cost effective? Can
Speaker 209
1:49:51
I have a follow-up? So the request or proposal for the third-party vendor who will be performing independent assessments not only for DDS but also behavioral health and the Division of Aging and Adult Service clients will go into effect July 1st.
Stone, if you would use the full name for the departments and not the acronyms. I'm trying. Just so we
Speaker 209
1:50:14
get everybody acclimated. So the Division of Behavioral Health Services, Division of Aging and Adult Services,
and Division of Developmental Disability Services. So mouthful. We have put together a request for proposal that's been out and had vendors bid on it, and we're in the process of awarding that contract, and they will be doing third-party independent assessments starting July 1. The outcome of where you fall and the money you receive will be based on the independent assessment. Did that get your question answered?
That gets me. I have one more. Assuming this becomes law, will this current waiver allow new beneficiaries? Yes. So just
Speaker 209
1:51:01
like any other waiver with CMS, you set a cap of the amount of slots and the amount of funding, so we'll go in and we'll ask for that to be raised to cover these
Speaker 201
1:51:17
beneficiaries. And if I may, Mr. Chair, all of these are excellent questions, and they're wonderful questions that we do need to address,
but they I don't know if they pertain specifically to this bill as to what this bill is doing is just simply redirecting funds to the existing program as it is but they're excellent questions and we do need to address those thank you
representative Mayberry I'll make that call going forward but I do think they pertain to this bill because I
Speaker 201
1:51:50
think that I think those were very pointed directly at this bill and those are all very good.
Thank you, thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Boyle, you're
recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I just was thinking back. I was on the Health Reform Task Force in the last General Assembly, and one of the things that was done is we surveyed, or not we, but the consultants surveyed several of these families and looked at all the different services that could be provided. And so one of the things is if you didn't pay someone to stay at home and you looked at all the other services, we could take care of a lot more people.
So the way this is going to be implemented is it would also cover the in-home, you know, so I want to stay at home with my person just so I know exactly what
Speaker 209
1:52:44
we're doing. So you have a lot of information on this that others probably don't. But, yes, there was a key service left off of that survey that was sent out to families, which was that one-on-one staff member that helped an individual be independent and live in the community, which we refer to as supportive living staff. This would be the foray.
So any service available under the waiver would be available to these clients. It would just depend on how many hours and at
what level. One follow-up. So just to be clear, have you, has there been, I guess this would be to Representative Mayberry more, but has there been consideration to just limit it to the other services other than the one key
Speaker 201
1:53:33
service you said was left off? Just to clarify, thank you. There have been some discussions about a tiering of different offerings and such as that,
And what we would like to be able to do is to, I think, long-term anyway, and Melissa can jump in here, is that there may be an opportunity for more people to receive the types of services that they need to be able to help in the here and now and the day-to-day and be able to broaden this to more people in a shorter
amount of time. Representative Hammer, you've got a really quick question, right?
Speaker 41
1:54:10
Yes, sir. Thank you. As we sit here right now today with the waivers that are sitting at CMS,
do those waivers have specifically stated in them that we are going to use an independent assessment tool to make the determination for the population we're trying to identify? So the waiver
Speaker 209
1:54:30
sitting at CMS says that we are moving towards conflict-free case management, and that has four elements, and one of those elements is a mandatory independent third-party assessment. So, yes, sir. Okay, thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
I've got one quick question myself, just sitting here listening, and I'm breaking my own personal rule here, but can you give me an average cost per individual? And I understand the assessment is going to change a lot of this and could find out that this $3,000 may not need to be on the waiting list. Am I right or wrong, and can you
Speaker 209
1:55:09
give me an average cost of each individual? So to the first question, the average cost currently is about $54,000 for just your waiver services. And then if you have any kind of, on top of that medical Medicaid spend,
that's an average of adding about $18,000 per person for the total average cost. All of the individuals that we are discussing on the wait list, We have verified around 2,900 of them by certified mail, phone call, or in-person. They have all filled out the application and been deemed to meet the eligibility criteria. Okay. Thank you. Thank you, Representative Mayberry.
And I'll move on to the public. Is there anyone, seeing no further questions, is there anyone in the public speak for or against the bill? Seeing none, what's the pleasure of the committee? I got a motion due passed by Representative Payton. Discussion on this motion? Representative Ladyman, do you have some discussion? Yeah, I do.
I really had a question, but you didn't see my light, but that's okay. No, I didn't. Just a comment. You know, I was going to ask the question. Some of these people have been on this waiting list for 10 years. I know some people that are on this waiting list personally, and I understand not wanting to spend money, not wanting to waste money, and I have the same questions about efficiency. But there are 3,000 people on this list. I could almost guarantee you there are 700, 800 people on this list that need this service, and some of them I know personally are not getting services.
Is that not true, that some of these people are out there and they're not getting any
kind of service? Do you know that? Is that okay?
They can answer that in their closing. Okay. Okay. But in my opinion, there are people that need this service badly, and this is money that is not being used currently. I think it would be a very good use of this money. So I would recommend a vote for it. I misspoke
Representative Lehman. They've already had, I guess I didn't ask them for their closing,
but they've already had their closing out the motions on
the table. I think most people would agree with you. That's okay.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Any other discussion? All those in favor say aye. All those opposed? The ayes have it. Motion passes. Bill passes. Representative Mayberry. Thank you, colleagues. Seeing we're running out of time, I'm going to go ahead and adjourn this meeting. I want to thank each and every one of you all for staying in your seats.
It's unheard of to have 20 members sit here for two hours, so thank you guys. lot. We stand adjourned.
Agenda
PRESENTATION Cindy Gillespie, Director, Arkansas Department of Human Services
Scope of Practice Bills Will be Considered in Committee During the Week of February 13, 2017 - February 17, 2017
HB1034 Fite TO AMEND THE LAWS CONCERNING HEARING INSTRUMENT DISPENSERS.
REGULAR AGENDA Subtitle Number Sponsor
HB1016 Farrer TO CONVERT THE HOSPITAL REIMBURSEMENT SYSTEMS UNDER THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM TO DIAGNOSIS-RELATED GROUP METHODOLOGY.
HB1021 Love TO PROVIDE PAY EQUITY FOR WOMEN; AND TO AMEND THE WAGE DISCRIMINATION LAWS CONCERNING PROHIBITED CONDUCT AND REMEDIES FOR VIOLATIONS OF THE WAGE DISCRIMINATION LAWS.
HB1024 TO MODIFY THE DEFINITION OF "CHRONIC NONMALIGNANT PAIN" IN THE COMBATING PRESCRIPTION DRUG ABUSE ACT.
HB1025 Boyd TO AMEND THE PRESCRIPTION DRUG MONITORING PROGRAM ACT TO ALLOW ACCESS TO THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PRESCRIPTION DRUG PROGRAM.
HB1032 Mayberry THE ARKANSAS UNBORN CHILD PROTECTION FROM DISMEMBERMENT ABORTION ACT.
HB1033 Mayberry TO AMEND INITIATED ACT 1 OF 2000, ALSO KNOWN AS THE TOBACCO SETTLEMENT PROCEEDS ACT, TO REDUCE THE DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILITIES WAITING LIST; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1035 Bentley TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS HEALTHY FOOD IMPROVEMENT ACT.
HB1040 Farrer TO LIMIT THE PRACTICE OF ATHLETIC TRAINING IN A NONCLINICAL SETTING.
HB1160 A. Mayberry TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF A "SPECIALIST SIGN ELECTRICIAN".
HB1164 Gray TO AUTHORIZE LICENSURE BY ENDORSEMENT FOR OPTOMETRISTS; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HR1003 Boyd TO ENCOURAGE CONTINUED COLLABORATION BETWEEN HEALTHCARE PROVIDERS, LAW ENFORCEMENT, EDUCATORS, PUBLIC OFFICIALS, AND THE ARKANSAS COMMUNITY IN BATTLING THE ABUSE OF PRESCRIPTION DRUGS IN ARKANSAS.
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Jeff Wardlaw Chair
Unverified
Representative Justin Boyd
Unverified
Representative Fredrick J. Love
Unverified
Frederick Love
Unverified
Speaker 41
Speaker 47
Representative Jack Ladyman
Unverified
Speaker 58
Representative Mary Bentley
Unverified
Speaker 78
Representative Ken Henderson
Unverified
Representative Aaron Pilkington
Unverified
Speaker 97
Speaker 102
Representative Josh Miller
Unverified
Speaker 113
Representative Robin Lundstrum
Unverified
Speaker 120
Representative Richard Womack
Unverified
Representative John Payton
Unverified
Paul Calvert
Unverified
Speaker 138
Speaker 139
Representative Justin Gonzales
Unverified
Kamara Seals
Unverified
Speaker 159
Speaker 162
Speaker 163
Speaker 166
Speaker 170
Speaker 178
Speaker 179
Speaker 195
Speaker 5
Speaker 197
Speaker 201
Speaker 209