Aging, Children and Youth Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (7)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1060
· 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1060 House CONCERNING THE MILITARY JUSTICE PUNISHMENT FOR CONTEM…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1061
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “Bill 1061, I believe, is the next one on our list. Okay, House Bill 1061.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1048
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1048 D. Meeks CREATE TO CARE; EXEMPTION LICENSE A TO RESPITE VOL…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1054
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1054 V. Flowers TO DESIGNATE A PORTION OF U.S. HIGHWAY 65 AS THE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1059
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1059 House TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE OFFENSE OF VIOLATION…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1062
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1062 House TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE ISSUANCE OF PROCESS,…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HCR1003
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “As amended. All right. So the motion before us is House Concurrent Resolution 1003 as amended. And Representative Wing, did you have a motion…”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 14, 2026
We will follow the procedure that we have been asked by the speaker to do of asking one question and then if you have another question you will need
to get back in the queue and we will come back around to you as time allows. But we will only be asking one question per member at a time. And also I want to remind you of the difference in asking a question and then discussion after the motion has been made. We have had a bad habit in the past of using our question time to go into a great deal of discussion. So let's try to keep questions as questions, and then after a motion has been made, we
will have time then for discussion. We have a group with us today in the audience of ad litems and CASAs from all over the state. Would you stand, please? As a fellow CASA, I thank you for what you do for the children of the state of Arkansas, and we appreciate your attendance here today and hope that it's beneficial to you to observe our committee,
and please contact any of us any time we can be of assistance to you. We have first a presentation from our DCFS director, excuse me, Department of Children and Family Services, misha martin and you have on your desk her presentation and you are recognized thank you representative fight again
i am i am misha martin i'm the director of the division of children and family services
representative fight asked me to give just a brief um one-on-one on dcfs i'll be walking through hopefully the presentation that is in front of you um what dcfs does many people think of us as only serving the children who are in states custody also known as foster care but we do much more than just serve the children who have to be removed from their parents and we'll walk through those different kinds of cases but we do serve children in their homes and who have where there is an allegation of abuse or neglect um in addition we do receive federal
funding. So as part of our funding, we receive Title IV-E money, which is part of the Social Security Administration Act, and then we receive Title IV-B money. Arkansas receives a capped sum of money, whereas some states do receive funding based on the individual child that's in foster care. We are under a demonstration project and received a capped allocation so that we have the flexibility to use some of our federal funding to be able to serve children who are not in foster care to try and prevent removal and you can see on page two look in our mission statement our
mission is to keep children safe and help families that's really important over the past year hopefully you've seen our stabilization plan where we are focusing on the families of course safety of children is an is a priority but part of that is really helping families and engaging with families while serving children. We believe that if children can safely remain in their home with services, that's the best possible option for our children. And you can go over through page two and page three, our practice model. I'm not going to read to you every slide, but I thought it was
important for you guys to see what our practice model is. And our trainings that we give to our family service workers and family service worker supervisors is based on the practice model. we divide the state into 10 areas so you can see that on the bottom of page three that the division of children and family services has 10 regional areas we have an area manager area director that's over all 10 regions so structurally we have a central office that consists of about 110 people
including finance staff assistant directors the central registry adoption managers several of our program managers and then at the regional level we have 10 area directors who each have an assistant and then we move into the staff and you can see our staff breakout on page four so at our county offices so we are housed in the department of human services county offices and you know those county offices also have other other programs such as division of county
operations which does your snap t other services our dcfs workers are housed in the dhs offices we have a county supervisor and most of our counties in our larger counties we have unit supervisors and then what you what we have is many of you call case workers the official title is family service workers so you'll hear me refer to them as fsws that is our front line field caseworker, but that does not necessarily just mean foster care caseworker. Those individuals
that have a title of family service worker, if they are in a small county, they may do an array of services, which you can see they may be investigations, they may be foster care, they may be in-home or protective service caseworkers, they may have adoption responsibilities. In our other large counties we do more specialized services where our family service workers are able to specialize on one of these types of cases and then in addition you'll hear me talk about our support staff so we have program assistants and health care service workers those are the the workers
that try and provide support to our family service workers by helping with transportation doing supervised visits getting in the home and doing what we call homemaker services in some of our in-home cases and our health our health care workers try and ensure that our children who are in foster care are getting into appointments and making sure that their health care needs are met on the bottom of page four you'll see an outline of the different types of cases that we've had
I've kind of mentioned those when I talked about family service workers, but those are the different types of cases that we do, including supportive service cases, which I haven't mentioned. A family can come to the Department of Human Services and say that they need help, and we will offer them services. So most of our cases, a large majority, are when a call has come to the child abuse hotline, and then we go out and investigate, determine that a family needs services, but we do have a small percentage of cases where a family
actually comes to us and says, you know, we're in need of help. Can you help us? We want to keep the family unit together so we will offer services. The same array of services, which I'll talk about in a minute, to a family that's receiving an in-home service. Looking at page five, you'll see that we have 35,493 reports of child maltreatment investigated. That's for state fiscal year 2016. The hotline, which is run by the Arkansas State Police Crimes Against Children Unit,
actually accepts over 60,000 calls, and of those calls, 35,000 or over 35,000 are accepted for investigation. We had more children that received services in home than we actually did in foster care. Many people don't realize that with 6,604 children that receive services through in-home cases. At the end of state fiscal year we had around 5,100 children in foster care and for the last about four to five months we've been in between 5,100 to 5,200 children in foster care
which is about a 25 percent increase from January of 2015. When a child does have to be removed and placed in to foster care. The top reasons on the bottom of page five include neglect, substance abuse, incarceration of parent, and physical abuse. Now those numbers add up to more than 100 because you can have multiple reasons for a child coming into foster care. Many times substance abuse is coupled with neglect and so on. So there can be multiple reasons related to removal of a child.
Removal of a child is determined on whether the child is in immediate danger. And we'll walk through what happens once a child is removed in just a minute. So once we go out, a hotline gets a call. The call is accepted. We go out for an investigation. If there's a finding, we do start working with the family. But once there's a true finding, we then offer an in-home case if the child is not removed. and even if the child is removed we then develop a case plan and that's where we
do an assessment and we first do an assessment develop a case plan and start offering services to the family you can see on page six some of the requirements of the case plan and then just talking about the services that we offer in those case plans it can be a range of substance abuse treatment which we do partner with the Division of Behavioral Health to offer substance abuse mental health services whether it's individual counseling counseling for the child or parent family
counseling parenting classes we do have an evidence-based parenting program which means that we actually track outcomes we can assist with housing whether that means that we take them down to the housing department to sign them up for housing help them look for employment if they're in foster care we provide visitation and the and of course if there is mental health issues we can refer them for a psychological evaluation we try and keep a full array of services so that we can help the family and moving on to page seven when you look at foster homes i'm very proud to say
as of as of the end of last month we have around 1 674 open foster homes this is something that the department has been placing a huge focus on for the last year and even has a federal grant called our diligent recruitment grant to continue to recruit foster homes. About two years ago we were around 1,200 foster homes. So in the past we've struggled to increase the number of foster homes because we lose foster homes as fast as we can get them in the past due to adoptions or you
know they need a break whatever the reasons are so right now we're at 1600 foster homes we've continued to grow every month um i know since july of 2016 each month we've we have grown and that is something we track on a monthly basis and i and i don't want to take full credit for that because our partners are a huge help to us whether it be the call christian for kids green county i almost hate listening our partners because we have so many partners Arkansas Baptist Children's Home, so many partners who have stepped up and are working with us to
recruit foster homes. Our bed to child ratio is 0.71 and like I said DCFS recruited 856 foster homes in state fiscal year 2016 and ultimately had a net gain of 270. So moving on to page eight um those this outlines what happens once a children come a child or children come into foster care every child that is removed from their parents does have a court case and court
oversight so if the department goes out and assesses safety determines that a child is in immediate danger and the child has to be removed and placed into foster care we must go to the circuit court within 72 hours and asked for an emergency order within we next if the court signs the emergency order the next hearing is a probable cause within five business days and then you can see throughout the steps of the different hearings at every stage that a child is in foster care
there is court oversight on that case our main goal of course is to work towards reunification if we cannot work towards reinfication then we look for another permanency goal and even if rights are terminated the court continues to monitor the case at least every six months until that child gets to permanency which brings me to our older youth on page nine so children who we are unable to find permanency for sadly they do continue in foster care and we do have children
who ate what we call age out if a child is in foster care at the eight at the age of 18 they can choose to remain in foster care until they're 21 if they're doing one of three things they're either in a course of treatment they're working 80 hours a month or they're getting their education and so if they continue to comply with those requirements they can quote stay in foster care and receive some benefits from the state. Looking at the bottom of page nine the reasons that
children exit foster care I think it's important to note that last year state fiscal year 2016 44 percent of our children who entered foster care were reunified with their parent. The next 28 percent were placed in permanent custody with a relative i hope you've all heard we have continued and increased the number of relative placements on the front end and that is a major goal of the department as we move through this next year is to ensure that children are placed with safe and
appropriate relatives as quickly as possible and i'm proud to say that last month there were 29 children who were brought into foster care who were placed with a relative and never had to go into an actual foster home we were able to open and place those children with a relative the same day as the removal and that's the conclusion of the presentation i hope i stayed within my 10 minutes and i'll be glad to take questions misha will
be with us miss martin will be with us frequently so you probably will not have time to ask all of your questions today we will take just
a few brief questions because we do have a rather long agenda representative Hodges you're recognized thank you madam chair I have
have the when you give the the service areas and they have different colors is there any significance to the color no just to make it just so you can see the areas better all right and was there
another question I'm sure we will have others as time goes on but thank you so much for being with us today and we'll look forward to
hearing from you in the future thank you representative I appreciate this opportunity and Representatives, if you have any question about DCFS, I'd be glad to make sure that you have my contact information.
Thanks again. I think we had some agency people who were not able to introduce themselves last week. Would you introduce yourselves to us at this time? Thank you.
Speaker 30
16:27
as well. I'm Betty Newman. I'm the director of the Division of Youth Services. I've been performing many times more on what you tell welfare side, but now I'm in the juvenile justice side. We have lots going on, which I'm aware of, and I'm glad
Speaker 33
16:46
to answer questions. I'm David Gerland, chief counsel at DHA. I'm Rene Robinette, I'm the
Speaker 35
16:53
director of the attorney ad litem program on the dependency
neglect side of things. We represent children who've been abused and neglected or involved with DCFS cases and I'll be happy to give you my business card if I haven't already and if you ever have questions about how kids are affected by the child welfare system we're happy to answer those questions.
Speaker 37
17:10
And I'm Janet Bledsoe, assistant director of the attorney ad litem program, I work with I'm Keesa Smith. I'm Deputy Director of the
My name is Laura Calhoun. Brian Welch is actually the Director of the Parent Council Program. We represent parents in independency of black cases. He is unable to be here. He's got a hearing that he tried to get continued and couldn't get continued. Thank you. Did I get everyone? Representative House,
we have a brief resolution that we're going to do before your bill. Sorry.
Without objection, we will consider House concurrent resolution number 1003 at this time. Members, that's 1-0-0-3
on this resolution, is that correct?
Yes. All right. Would you present your – this is Representative Letting. Would you present your amendment to the committee, please? Yes,
ma'am. Thank you, Madam Chair, Mr. Vice Chair, members of the committee. We will move quickly. The first change, Representative Pilkington requested to be added as a co-sponsor, so we're adding him. The next couple of changes were brought to us by a paleontologist who works in Utah and Colorado. She actually got her undergrad degree at the University of Arkansas and has been studying this specimen for the last 13 years. So she recommended just a couple of minor changes to make sure that we're as accurate as possible.
She's also about to submit a paper to hopefully make the official name of the specimen, Arkansas is Friday, until now that has remained the unofficial name, but because she has done that important work, we wanted to include her in the resolution, and that is also the reason for the final change, just so we don't complicate the naming process, we want to make it absolutely clear that the state is not trying to make any official claim to that name so that it remains free to become the official name of this dinosaur.
Motion to adopt the amendment? All right, so moved. All right. Representative Letting? Oh, we need to, excuse me, we need to vote on the amendment. All in favor? Aye. Any against? All right, Representative Letting, you're recognized to present your
resolution. Thank you, Madam Chair, I have a young man here who's going to help with that presentation,
introduce yourself to the committee. My name is Mason Cypress-Ory. I'm from Fayetteville, Arkansas, where I attend the local high school currently as a senior.
Thank you. Please proceed. Welcome. Okay, so this resolution is to adopt a theropod dinosaur, Arkansas's Friday, as Arkansas's state dinosaur, official state dinosaur, which only nine other states currently have, including the District of Columbia, Texas, Missouri, and Oklahoma. so yeah we need to catch up to our border rivals
and something interesting is that currently we only have 24 state symbols and Arkansas is the 25th state in the union we kind of need a 25th state symbol if we're going to do the whole 25 thing also I feel that Arkansas is the perfect dinosaur candidate because it is the most uniquely found dinosaur in Arkansas,
meaning fossils of it have not been found in other states. Representative Letting,
add that I believe that these are the only fossils to have been found in Arkansas. This is the only dinosaur to have been found in our state. as Mr. Ori pointed out we have 24 other symbols which I did not know until he told me before the committee meeting I could probably only name about five maybe but we just feel this would be another great way to celebrate
something that is unique to our state so we're happy
Speaker 66
22:02
from the committee? Representative Meeks Thank you, great presentation and I'm sorry if I missed it but can you describe the dinosaur you said that the fossils were found. I mean, is it as big as a brontosaurus or a T-Rex, or is it a smaller dinosaur? So
if you could just describe the dinosaur for us. Yes, I can. Right now, the paleontological community,
we don't know that much about Arkansas. Only a foot bone was discovered near Locksburg, or in Locksburg now. The town is bigger. Anyways, if any of you have seen the movie Jurassic Park or Jurassic World, you know, the dinosaurs, like in the scene where Tim was like, they're flocking this way. The Gallimimus, Arkansaurus is a, basically that dinosaur's American great-grandmother or great-grandfather. So it looks a lot like that.
May have had teeth in the beak. Who knows? It would have eaten, like, small mammals, small lizards, fruit, eggs, insects, plants. It was probably really fast, maybe up to 15 feet tall, maybe 15, 20 feet long. So, like, about the size of a, oh, gosh, what did that be? It's ostrich. Ostrich is the closest size, or emu. Thank you. That was great. Appreciate it.
are just trying to repeat the words you said. I just look at them and say that word. So are they planning on an artist rendition of what they may look like? Is that something that we could, if somebody asked us that we voted this as a state symbol and we've got a foot bone, is there a way for us to kind of go and say this is where we can go and look and this is our state dinosaur?
Yeah, there are some artist renditions. One that I can name off the top of my head is by Lori O'Keefe. I want to say that one is in the Arkansas Geological Commission here in New York. And it basically kind of has like a little bump on the head kind of thing that's cool. It's a little like brownish, orange, and white, kind of like earthy tones. I think that answered
Representative Wing. Will the Arkansaurus be tougher than the Oklahomosaurus or
the Texasaurus? Okay, Oklahoma State Dinosaur is Acrocanthosaurus, and Arkansaurus, okay, it's a larger carnosaur dinosaur, so like Allosaurus, and so like the Indominus Rex in Jurassic World, Arkansaurus and Acrocanthosaurus did not eat the same food sources, so they probably would have
just like ignored each other completely, like, you know, you do your thing, I'm in Oklahoma, I'll do my thing when we hear it. It's not that how I use it now. I like it, yes. Basically, I mean, you got to learn how to do that to understand the present. Representative
Birch. Thank you, Madam Chair. How long have you been working on this? How long have
you been studying, particularly, this dinosaur? Oh, gosh. How long was I? Eight, nine?
I was a little itty-bitty. Like ten years ago. One of my first fossil books had a, it was a fossil of Arkansas, again, from the Arkansas Geological Commissioner, a little pamphlet of Arkansas, I was just like, oh, let's go with a state dinosaur, oh, not a state dinosaur, we have a dinosaur, the Arkansas dinosaur. And then when I was, oh gosh, like 13, when I was like 2013 or something, it was a while ago, and I was researching paleontology colleges, because that's what I went to, and I was looking
one website, payroll portal, and then a spot where they, like, you know, state fossil, state dinosaur, and, like, on Arkansas, and then he had said, like, there is none, but you can contact your legislator to get one. And I was like, I'm doing that, and I didn't get it, and
now we're here. Thank you so much. Thank you, Mason. You're welcome, ma'am. What's the will of the committee? Okay. Okay.
As amended. All right. So the motion before us is House Concurrent Resolution 1003 as amended. And Representative Wing, did you have a motion to pass? All right. Representative Meeks, you had a motion? He's already got it. All right. Okay. All right. All in favor? Aye. Opposed? Congratulations, Mason. and thank you so much for being with us today
and sharing your great wealth of knowledge on this subject. We appreciate your calling this to the attention of Representative Letting and bringing this before the state of Arkansas. And I believe your father and brother are here with you in the audience. Would you stand for us, please? Thank you. Thank you. Oh, my family members, thank you. Thank you, Mason, and congratulations. You're welcome. Thank you. Thank you, committee. Representative House, what is the first bill you will be bringing to us today?
House Bill 1060. Mason, you'll be glad to know that these gentlemen in uniform are here to get approval for a set of
We will exact revenge. Madam Chair, thank you. State Representative Doug House, I'm pleased to introduce to some of you for the first time is former State Representative Jeff Wood, now Lieutenant Colonel, the Staff Judge Advocate for the Arkansas National Guard.
And with your permission, Madam Chair, he'll be doing the presentation since he knows these bills inside and out. Thank
Speaker 92
28:25
you for being with us. Thank you, Madam Chairman. Jeff Wood, Arkansas National Guard. As the committee will probably recall, last session we brought the first rewrite of the Military Code of Arkansas since like 1969. It was a very huge bill. And so as we've done a few court-martials since then, we've noticed there was a few things that we missed. And the first issue was on House Bill 1060.
This bill simply raises the amount of a contempt fine from $100 to $500. And the $500 level is what you would see in a civil court
these days. I'd be happy to answer any questions. Representative Walker. Thank you, Madam Chair. Is this statute already a part of the law?
How do you all determine or define menacing word? Sometimes any word could be regarded as menacing. So, I mean, is there a definition of menacing that applies here? Representative, excellent question. This comes straight out from the UCMJ. Unfortunately, I should have brought a copy with
Speaker 92
29:41
me, but we go by the military definition of a menacing word. I know in the five court-martials we've done recently, We haven't had that issue come up, but on the military side, we do use a manual for court mortals, which would have that definition.
Unfortunately, I just do not have it with me. Follow-up, Madam Chair? One follow-up. Thank you. This extends to non-military persons, though. So if it extends to non-military persons, I'd like to know if I come out there and get into an argument with you or someone else, whether or not you may have me punished because you don't like what I've said under the definition of the word that I use being menacing, however you choose to describe it.
So how do you protect against free speech? Again, excellent question,
Speaker 92
30:38
Representative Walker. We do have, on the military side in our judicial system, we do have a military-trained judge. So our judge is required to go to Charlottesville for five weeks and receive all the proper training on these definitions. But we can always pull this bill down and come back, Representative, I can get you that
definition if you'd prefer. Unless there's some compelling reason for presenting it, I'd like to know,
because this authorizes anybody here in this committee or any place on the military establishment or in the presence of a military officer to be punished for whatever that person says without any limitation or standard. So if you would, I'd appreciate it. All right, Madam Chair, we'll pull that bill down. All right, thank you, Representative House. And you have other
Bill 1061, I believe, is the next one on our list. Okay, House Bill 1061.
Speaker 92
31:42
You're recognized. Madam Chair, Jeff Wiggin, Arkansas National Guard. In this statute, we're simply amending it to mirror the UCMJ and raising our statute of limitations for a court-martial from three years to five years. Currently, it's three years, and just with the operational tempo we have that we've run in some issues where it's come really close to hitting that statute of limitations because we'll have an issue come up at an annual training, which is once a year. By the time a victim comes forward, particularly in sexual assault cases, there's been some time passed with that issue.
And under the National Guard, we don't have CID like they do on active duty. We don't have an internal mechanism for investigating. So NGB and D.C. sends down investigators for those cases, and it can take an upwards of six months to a year for us to get an answer back from them. And then occasionally we'll refer those cases to the civilian authorities to review whether they want to prosecute on the civilian side. And so when you pile all that up together, we get really close to that three years really fast, and so we're wanting to expand it out to five years.
This would not be retroactive, of course, so it would go into effect, if passed, it would go into effect and only apply to future conducts.
It would not go back. Are there any questions by the committee? Representative
Speaker 103
33:02
Tucker. Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you for being here, Mr. Wood. And so on line 25 of the bill, it strikes out the crimes that are applicable under this section, desertion in time of peace or with perjury to an offense. And so I'm just wondering what the implications of that change are.
Speaker 92
33:20
Excellent. The reason we did that is Arkansas in 1969 adopted the Uniform Code of Military Justice just in its entirety. And the Uniform Code for Military Justice gets updated quite frequently. We just don't update our statute that much. That was a language that was used at the time of Vietnam, and when we went back to run this bill, we used the more current language, so we pulled that
Speaker 103
33:44
section out. Follow-up, Madam Chair? Yes, yes. Thank you. And so right now, I'm just – so what's changing exactly?
I mean, what offenses are covered under court
Speaker 92
33:56
marshals? And that's a real excellent question because under the Arkansas Military Code of Arkansas, we're not in the criminal code of Arkansas. We have what we call the punitive articles. We've got mainly military offenses themselves, and we have our own punishment limitations. For a general court-martial, we're limited to 200 days confinement per offense, so we're outside the Arkansas Military Criminal Code. And so this would cover all those type of offenses that are in the Military Code of Arkansas,
which can arrange from failure to following an order. We do have sexual misconduct, sexual harassment. Unlike the active duty, we don't have the resources to prosecute rape, sexual assault, all the bigger type offenses, so we defer those to the civilian courts. Okay, and so this would not affect the statute for rape or murder or some kind
Speaker 103
34:45
of like that? No, no, no. Okay, all right, thank you very much. Representative Walker.
All right, thank you. Were there any other questions? Is there anyone in the audience who would like to speak for or against the bill? Representative House,
would you like to close for your bill? Yes, Madam Chair. Ladies and gentlemen, these offenses, the Arkansas Military Code, affects only those members of the Arkansas National Guard who are in a duty status and is always designed to maintain good order and discipline among the troops.
That is the purpose of the military code. Otherwise, civilian law covers most of the more serious and even less serious offenses. Theft, certainly all the felonies are covered under civilian law, so these are all offenses that perhaps any of us would never be touched by civilian law can be imposed upon a soldier or an airman because of the need to maintain good discipline and order among the ranks. Thank you, Madam Chair. Closed. What are the wishes of the committee?
Do pass. All right. We have a motion do pass on this bill. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Against, no. Okay, congratulations, Representative House. You have passed your bill. Thank you,
Madam Chair. Madam Chair, would you consider Bill 1062, please? 1062. You're recognized. Thank
Speaker 92
36:29
you, Madam Chair. Jeff Wood, Arkansas National Guard. This one simply clarifies for the rules that we added the word or military judge in there.
A strict reading of the statute, you know, you could interpret that, that our current military judge isn't able to, you know, issue these mandates and subpoenas, so we just added that just for clarification to make sure it's clear, in fact, and unquestionable that our judge can issue these. I'd be happy to answer any questions. Are there questions of the
committee? Is there anyone in the audience who wishes to speak for or against the bill? Would you like to close for your bill, Representative House?
I am closed, Madam Chair. Thank you. What are the wishes of the committee? Do pass. Okay. All right. Representative Gates moves motion do pass. We have a motion of due pass on the bill. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Against, no. Congratulations, Representative House.
You've passed your bill. Thank you, Madam Chair. Would you consider Bill
Speaker 92
37:42
All right, you are recognized. Thank you, Madam Chair. Jeff Wood, Arkansas National Guard. This clarifies that something we changed last year. We basically enacted a statute that said, you know, our court-martials would follow all of the manual for court-martials and rules, and when we had a couple of attorneys arguing at our last court-martial over some procedures, it was pointed out that, you know, a lot of the UCMJ and manual for court-martials are done by executive orders of the president. He has no authority over military courts of Arkansas, and so we wanted to make it clear that the governor is the commander-in-chief
and executive of the Arkansas Army National Guard could have the authority to tweak some of those rules or just adopt them in whole and part because a lot of the manual deals with things like rape and assault that we'll never do and our appeals process is quite different because of the way that active duty is set up. So this gives our commander-in-chief the ability to kind of adopt the rules that apply and the ones that don't, that it's not questioned that they don't apply. Be happy to answer any questions.
Are there any questions by the committee? Is there anyone in the audience who would like to speak for or against this bill? Would you like to close for your bill, Representative House? I am closed, Madam Chair. Thank you. What are the wishes of the committee? Do pass. Okay. Representative Hodges, you're recognized for your motion. Motion do pass. All right. We have a motion due pass on House Bill 1063.
All those in favor say aye. Aye. Against, no. Congratulations, Representative House. You have passed your bill. Thank
you, Madam Chair. Madam Chair, excuse me just a moment. Madam Chair, as an introduction to Bill 1064, if you will consider that one. Yes.
House Bill 1064, does everyone have that pulled up? You're recognized.
Thank you, Madam Chair. Madam Chair, this is a bill that the Adjutant General of Arkansas asked the state to amend its criminal code on the crime of impersonation of a member of the, pretending to be a member of the United States Armed Forces or the National Guard. There have been instances such as the Bologna tornado, a severe accident involving some possible chemical spills in which a person in a military uniform arrived, represented themselves to be the National Guard and usurped local authority under that guise.
It's not very much different than impersonating a police officer, which we would all recognize as an offense under the state. This adds if a person impersonates a member of the Armed Forces of the United States or the state of Arkansas. With that, I would pass it to Lieutenant Carwell. Thank you, Madam Chair, Jeff
Speaker 92
40:52
Wood, National Guard. Just a couple of things to follow up on this. This does require a criminal intent to injure, defraud, harass, or intimidate,
so this wouldn't cover someone who just put on their old uniform, ran out of their house to try to help out. There has to be that, you know, the criminal element to it. And secondly, the statute, you know, as the bill was written, I wish you had the whole statute there, but as the statute's written, current law says, you know, someone who pretends to be an officer or employee of the state government other than a law enforcement officer, I think if you took a look at that, this would really already apply to our soldiers who are on state active duty. It's just a lot of individuals don't realize that those are state employees because when we go out,
It still says United States government on our uniforms and everything else. So the Enlisted Association thought it was real important just to make sure that we put it in the code section so people that were trying to take advantage of a chaotic situation like a New Madrid or an earthquake or a civil disturbance that people wouldn't try to profit from that. It doesn't involve really the stolen valor issue. It's not a free speech issue. The Supreme Court ruled on the federal Stolen Valor Act. So it's really designated that criminal intent and people interfering with military operations in the domestic sense.
there any questions from committee members? Representative Walker. Thank you, Madam Chair. Senator, since the statute does not, since it does have penal possibilities, is it possible for you to have this amended to be precise in saying that criminal intent is an element of the statute?
I mean, as it is now, it's just that, you know, if I come up and say, hey, man, I'm a member of the National Guard, I could be punished, but there's nothing to say that I have criminal intent or not, and if I say it, then I'm going to be punished, or anybody else is going to be punished, possibly. I understand discretion may always come in, but I'd feel a lot more comfortable if we put in that this has to be consequential and it has to relate to some intent to defraud or do something other than simply talk.
Thank you, Representative Walker. The statute in question is 5-37-208, and it provides in another part of that statute the criminal intent necessary. Of course, when our bill drafters draft, they only draft that portion of the statute that is being changed. But it says a person commits criminal impersonation in the first degree or in the second degree. In this case, if the person doesn't act in his or her pretended or assumed capacity or character
with the purpose to injure, defraud, harass, or intimidate another person and the actor. And then this statute goes on to add that particular conduct, which is wearing the uniform of the military. So I think your concern is merited, and it is addressed in the statute. It's just not in this bill, which is several paragraphs down from where the intent part of the statute.
A follow-up, Madam Chair. Yes. Since this is related to an amending an existing bill, wouldn't it not be better to just have this as a portion of the bill already present so you would not look elsewhere for these determinations or definitions or exceptions? I mean, I'd feel more comfortable if you had the whole bill and this became an amendment to the entire law that we already have.
Thank you Representative Walker. No sir I disagree. Otherwise we would have page after page of existing law already on this piece of paper that's not affected at all. But your question was whether there was an intent provision. Yes sir it is in the statute. The bill drafters don't reprint the entire code. Of course we could go back to the first sections of our criminal code where it talks about intent, state of mind, penalties and punishments and all of that which which indirectly are affected but are not repeated here.
So this is the way the bill drafters at our Bureau of Legislative Research drafted it. I think it's correct. Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you. Any
other questions? Is there anyone in the audience who would like to speak for or against this bill? Would you like to close for your bill, Representative House? I
am closed, Madam Chair. Madam Chair, may I approach Representative Walker because I want him to feel comfortable.
I do have a copy of the entire statute in my
hand. Thank you. You don't have to, Doug, because I always take your word you're a pretty honorable man as far
as I'm concerned. I love you, too. With that, what are the wishes of the committee? Okay, we have a motion due pass on House Bill 1064. All in favor, say aye. Aye. Against, no. Congratulations, Representative House.
You have again passed your bill. Madam Chair, thank you so much for hearing these presentations. May Lieutenant Colonel Wood and I be excused
from your committee. Yes, thank you for being here with us. Thank you for
your service. Thank you, colleagues. Thank you, Colonel. I believe that's everything that is before our committee today. Did we have any announcements or anything from the committee members? If not, with that, we have concluded our business and we are adjourned.
Agenda
PRESENTATION
Arkansas Department of Human Services, Division of Children and Family Services, Mischa Martin, Director
REGULAR AGENDA Subtitle Sponsor Number
HB1048 D. Meeks CREATE TO CARE; EXEMPTION LICENSE A TO RESPITE VOLUNTARY PERMIT CONCERNING VOLUNTARY RESPITE CARE; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1054 V. Flowers TO DESIGNATE A PORTION OF U.S. HIGHWAY 65 AS THE DELTA RHYTHM ‘N’ BAYOUS HIGHWAY.
HB1059 House TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE OFFENSE OF VIOLATION OF AN ORDER OF PROTECTION; AND TO CRIMINALIZE THE VIOLATION OF A MILITARY ORDER OF PROTECTION.
HB1060 House CONCERNING THE MILITARY JUSTICE PUNISHMENT FOR CONTEMPT.
HB1061 House CONCERNING THE STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS FOR MILITARY JUSTICE.
HB1062 House TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE ISSUANCE OF PROCESS, MANDATES, OR SUBPOENAS FOR MILITARY JUSTICE.
HB1063HouseTO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE PROCEDURAL COURT RULES OF MILITARY JUSTICE.
HB1064House TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING CRIMINAL IMPERSONATION IN THE SECOND DEGREE.
HCR1003Leding TO DESIGNATE THE ARKANSAURUS FRIDAYI AS THE OFFICIAL STATE DINOSAUR.
HR1004Boyd URGING STATE AGENCIES IN ARKANSAS TO COOPERATE IN IMPROVING LITTER CLEAN-UP STATEWIDE.
HB1184D. Meeks TO REQUIRE STATE BOARDS AND COMMISSIONS TO PROMULGATE RULES FOR
TEMPORARY LICENSURE, CERTIFICATION, OR PERMITTING OF SPOUSES OF ACTIVE DUTY SERVICE MEMBERS.
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Chair
Unverified
Representative Monte Hodges
Unverified
Speaker 18
Speaker 28
Speaker 30
Speaker 33
Speaker 35
Speaker 37
Speaker 40
Laura Calhoun
Unverified
Speaker 41
Representative Greg Leding
Unverified
Mason Cypress-Ory
Unverified
Speaker 66
Representative Mickey Gates
Unverified
Representative Carlton Wing
Unverified
Representative LeAnne Burch
Unverified
Speaker 89
Speaker 92
Representative John W. Walker
Unverified
Speaker 103