Revenue and Taxation Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (9)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1157
· 4 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1157 Collins CONCERNING HOMESTEAD PROPERTY TAX CREDIT ELIGIBILIT…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1037
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…ns, just let me know. Okay. Thank you, Mr. Miller. Members, House Bill 1037, Mr. Moore Law, Representative Moore Law, is not ready to r…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1156
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1156 Jett TO PROVIDE THAT ARKANSAS CORPORATE INCOME TAX RETURNS…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1159
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1159 Pitsch TO CREATE THE TAX REFORM AND RELIEF ACT OF 2017; AND…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1028
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1028 Lemons TO EXEMPT CERTAIN BUSES, COACHES, AND OTHER MOTOR VE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1031
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1031 Bentley TO CREATE AN INCOME TAX EXEMPTION FOR INCENTIVES RE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1153
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “.HB1153 Boyd TO CLARIFY THE MEANING OF "ACTUAL AND OBVIOUS ERRORS"…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1161
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1161 Sabin TO CREATE THE WORKING FAMILIES OPPORTUNITY ACT.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1162
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1162 C. Fite TO AMEND ARKANSAS TAX LAW CONCERNING INCOME TAX, SA…”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 14, 2026
being here today. We have a small introduction. Mr. Matthew Miller wants to say a few words. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Matthew Miller with Legislative
Speaker 8
0:26
Research. I just wanted to give you a quick heads up on a staffing change that we've made.
Joy Leonard has historically been the drafting attorney for Revin Tax. During the interim, she was promoted to administrator of our bill drafting section, which in that capacity, we've had to cut back on her drafting a little bit. She is still drafting some tax bills, but Jessica Sutton, who's the administrator of our rules section, if she looks familiar, you remember her from rules and regs, she is helping us with some drafting. She's also doing our primary intake on Revin Tax. If you want to come to her with your requests, then she's helping split them between Joy and kind of measure the load on that.
So I just wanted to let you know that Jessica is involved. She's over in Big Mac, and if you ask her at the front desk, they can direct you to her, or she's in the trifold that we handed out with all the assignments.
So if you ever have any questions, just let me know. Okay. Thank you, Mr. Miller. Members, House Bill 1037, Mr. Moore Law, Representative Moore Law, is not ready to run his bill, So we're going to skip down to HB 1156, Representative Jett. Representative Jett, you're recognized to run your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Members, basically this bill is pretty simple. It's a DFA cleanup bill. What it does is it sets the state corporate ending year along with the federal corporate ending year to make tax filing a lot easier for the corporations. And if anybody has any questions, I have a very smart gentleman sitting to my right that he will answer all your questions. Okay, members, are there any questions? Representative Johnson. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Speaker 17
2:14
the corporate returns? Currently for the 2016 filing season, which will start in 2017, the current deadline is March 15th. And the federal deadline is April 15th. A taxpayer that is filing his or her Arkansas state income tax return is also required to file their federal return with their state return.
Now, the Arkansas General Assembly already made this change in the 2015 session. session. However, the effective date of the change is effective for the 2017 tax year for returns that will be filed in 2018. We want to, after the General Assembly made the change in 2015, after adjournment, Congress made the change, so we are trying to harmonize the current deadline for the 2016 tax year for returns that are filed this year. Okay, thank you very much. Thank you,
Mr. Chair, are there any more questions? Seeing no more questions, are you closed for your bill? Yes, sir, I am. Is there anyone in the, I'm sorry, is there anybody in the audience want to speak for or against the bill? Mr. Chairman, I'll
Speaker 21
3:35
make a motion for do pass, please. Okay. Are there, do you have any motions that do pass?
I'm sorry. What are the wishes of the committee? Thank you. I'm sorry. Second. No ma'as, second. Okay. All in favor? Aye. Opposed? Representative Judette, you pass your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
proceed, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair and committee. This is House Bill 1157, and I've asked a representative from the Arkansas Association of Counties
to come and sit with me, kind of following on the chairman's lead. I'm going to present the bill, and then if I get questions I can't answer, I've got the expert to help me. So what House Bill 1157 does is what I believe all of you think is already happening. So in terms of what we intend as a legislature and what we expect as a legislature, and what I always thought was already happening, there wouldn't be any change. But in reality, what we think is happening is not necessarily happening,
and that's why we need House Bill 1157. And here are the three ways that House Bill 1157 ensures that our intent is being carried out with regard to the homestead property tax credit. The first one is that no property owner can claim more than one homestead exemption in a calendar year. What can happen now is when property is changing hands, there can be question marks based on some other law, and people are using that in order to try and enable folks to take more than one homestead tax credit exemption
in a given calendar year. And this clarifies beyond a shadow of a doubt what the legislature has said and what the amendments intend. The second thing it does is ensure that people who are not qualified for a senior discount, a disabled person's discount in their tax rates will not be able to claim those by virtue of purchasing property or transferring property from people who do qualify for those things.
And that's why this bill makes explicit the existing assessment process for real property. And then the third thing the bill does is really more of a technicality. It just enables both revocable and irrevocable trusts to qualify. So that's not a substantive change. So those are the three things this bill does to help ensure that the intent of the law, one homestead exemption per property owner, per calendar year.
And only people that are qualified for a reduction in the rate, those that are disabled, senior citizens, are able to qualify for those reductions. And with that,
I'll take questions. Any questions? Representative Hodges? Thank you, Chair. Go back to the second homestead credit exemption you mentioned. I missed that. And you mentioned something about disabled.
Does not everyone qualify for the
homestead credit? Good question, Representative Hodges. There are two animals that we're dealing with. One is the standard homestead exemption credit, which everybody gets, which is $350 per year, per property owner. There's another benefit that senior citizens and disabled folks qualify for, which is a reduction in their property taxes, and that's based on some other laws. And what's happening is sometimes people in property transfers are trying to
enable a non-qualified person to pick up the benefit of a senior citizen or a disabled person who's actually transferring the property and somehow get that benefit to accrue to someone who doesn't qualify for it, him or herself. And so what this does is clarify on both scores, the standard homestead credit that everybody gets as well as the lower rate. You only get what you're entitled to, you only get what was intended by the legislature, but it fixes two problems.
Will, Commissioner Hodges, any other questions, members? Anybody in the audience want to speak against the bill, for the bill? Mr. Collins, are you closed for your bill, sir? Yes, sir, and I move do pass. Members, we have a motion for do pass. Any debate on the motion? What's the pleasure of the committee? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? Congratulations, sir, you passed your bill. Thank you, committee, and thank you, Mr. Chair.
You're welcome. Representative Pitch, you ready, sir? You guys look serious today, is there something going on? Representative Pitch, if you don't care, recognize yourself, sir, and you're free to proceed. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Speaker 43
9:47
Representative Matt Pitch, District 76. Here to present to you, committee members, House Bill 1159, the governor's tax cut bill, officially known as the Tax Reform and Relief Act of 2017. What you have in front of you is a governor's proposal to deliver tax cuts to roughly 650,000 Arkansans, which takes the people from the last session's tax cuts. In addition to this,
if you see fit to bode it to pass, we would take of the 1.5 million taxpayers in the state of Arkansas, 1,346,000 of them would have been granted a tax cut. That's what we're after here today. How does that work? It's in front of you. I presented quite a few bills last session, but it felt like every time I presented a bill, people always still had lots of questions about the bill, its structure, and how it worked. I don't feel that with this bill. The governor's
had this bill. He's talked about it in a press conference several weeks ago, almost a month ago. The bill's been filed for a week. You've had it to see it, to talk about it. Many of you've asked ask me questions, so let's jump right in and talk about the tax cut bill, the proposal. We start with Section 7, Line 30. This section is where we deal with a tax cut, a slight change, if you will, getting rid of the cliff for those citizens whose available taxable income is in the range of,
let me get my number here just right. It takes those folks' tax rate down at the very smoothing portion of it. And really the only change is the top area on line 36, where you had 0.9% for those who were in that range. Their first $4,299 is now proposed to be 0.75%.
The rest of those stay the same per last session's tax cut. Item eight is where the meat of this tax cut comes into play for those citizens who make below $21,000. And you can see the proposal of what we're doing there for just those folks. Each of those has a new taxable chart there found on lines 10 through 14 of the bill. And that defines those two things together, the governor's proposal for a $50.5 million tax cut to the citizens of Arkansas.
There is a third thing that's found in this bill, and that third thing is the formation of a task force, a group of folks who are going to begin to work on what tax reform in the state of Arkansas can do to create better economic opportunities, job creation, a better way and a better path for our citizens over the next two years. The task force and its nuts and bolts and how it's laid out is there in front of you. And that occurs in section three, line 16, page two, through basically the end of the bill.
As near as I can put it, that's how you define the governor's tax cut. And the Tax Reform and Relief Act of 2017 is there in front of you. Mr. Chairman. Members, any questions? Representative
Hendren, you're recognized, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
When we, at least, I think this is the bill we partially discussed. Is this the one that we talked about last week, where there was a lady that came to the end of the table here,
that had deep research information and so forth, that she said what the impact was, the previous tax cut that we passed during the last session, that some said were for the higher end, and then she compared it to the lower end. And at that meeting, I requested that she come back if she would, and I think the committee shared that because I think every member had asked for a copy of that analysis, and she had agreed at the end of her testimony to present that in that statistical analysis because she's some kind of a research outfit.
Is that representative pitch, am I on the right bill or the wrong bill? You are on the right bill. Has that information, or is she here today to present that information during the discussion time? That's my question, Mr. Chairman.
Speaker 43
14:34
I'm not sure who that person was, having not been in that meeting. But I do have the numbers of what this bill deals with and the numbers for each category of those lines and how much change there is from those citizens that were affected last time to get to that $50.5 million?
The question I'd ask her that time, and maybe that's what you
just said, is that what I would like to see as supporting for the action on this bill is I'd ask her what happened in last session. What was it before and what was it after? Then what was it after? Then what's it going to be after this? So I can, as a member, I can see what we did the first time and now what we're doing the second time for the under $21,000. Thank you, Mr. Hengen. Representative Douglas, you have a question?
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Pitch, excuse me. I love the idea of cutting taxes. We all pay too much taxes, but we still have to operate government. We have needs. We have highways. We have education. We have developmentally disabled children that need funds. There's plenty of places for money to go. At my house or in my business, if I cut my income or my revenue, I have to cut my expenses.
Is there a correlating reduction in expenditures to help pay for this tax cut? I like the way
Speaker 43
16:03
you used the term, Representative Douglas, operating your business, because our governor has proposed this as part of how he wants to operate his business. This is a line item that has his priority put on it, so that that priority lines up with the spending and education, special needs, highways, etc. I think in this bill, the most immediate action you'll see to answer that question comes in the form of a task force who's going to focus on what real tax reform is.
Douglas, you recognize? Follow up. In layman's terms, in that kind of getting the cart before the horse, shouldn't we be doing the task force to see how we are going to pay for our roads and our schools and our other needs in the state and how to form a well thought out tax policy before we start doing the cutting? It's hard to get it back once it's gone. And I think that's your question.
Speaker 43
17:07
I would answer with a comment that Senator Hendren said in front of his committee yesterday. Like yourself, a farmer, small business owner, we tend to put a budget together of what we want to have happen. Then we tend to function around that budget. This is an item that our governor has given us in that budget. So I myself like to do what do I plan to spend? What do I plan to do? then I go put that into an action item. That's what this is. Is this what the governor is proposing for us to do?
you, Mr. Pitch. You're welcome, sir. Representative Sabin, you have a question? Yes, I do. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Pitch, I noticed in the bill that you're presenting that in the two places that are delineating where the tax cuts are going to happen, we're talking about net income. So that's net taxable income. And so my question is, is it possible that, you know, we're obviously trying to target low-income Arkansans, low-income working Arkansans here, but, you know, net income reflects what your income is
after you've taken all kinds of different deductions. So it's possible that the kinds of people we're not targeting who are making much higher gross incomes could then qualify for this tax cut
Speaker 43
18:28
as a result. I would say that's true on all taxes, that most citizens would try to get their net taxable income to their most favorable position. But that's the number that tends to be equalized. And this bill isn't about what's a fair reduction or a non-fair use of getting to a net taxable income.
I think a net taxable income is something we all face as we pay our taxes every year as citizens of this state. And that's the metric that we'll use, I think, in most tax cuts, in my opinion. Satisfy, Representative Saban? Well, I was
just asking a question. I didn't want to debate at this time, but thank
you. You're welcome, sir. Members, any other questions? We don't have anybody in the audience signed up for or against the bill on, I'm sorry,
Representative Flowers, you had a question now? Yes, Mr. Chair, thank you. My apologies for skipping over you, ma'am. Oh, no, that's okay. So, Representative Pitch, I posed a question the other day in our first meeting, and I wanted to ask you about this. I know that this is the governor's proposal, but you're carrying the bill, and so I suspect that you would be able to answer this question. And I think that, well, I'll say for myself that I believe that tax relief, especially for the lowest income Arkansans, is something that I would support, especially for folks in my district.
However, before we get to that point, I'm wondering what your comments are, your thoughts are about our even discussing a tax cut at this time with issues like transportation or highways, rather, not being fully addressed, teacher retirement, or without knowing exactly what our budget is going to look like, given that we don't know what's going to happen to the Affordable Care Act.
And we're all very clear and we know that a great deal of the savings that we've been experiencing from the Affordable Care Act is exactly what we based the $100 million tax cut that was passed last session. And finally, I know that there's a lot of talk about spending the surplus, I mean, or actually basing a lot of these kinds of cuts on projections and the surplus.
us. So I guess my question would be to you that without basing this on something that we really don't know what's going to happen next year and understanding that we really have a lot of state needs that have not been addressed, how do you explain why we would put this
Speaker 43
21:37
I want to start with the first part of your comment. And I think it's It's important that we understand a line that we talked about in my opening statement.
We are going to put 657,000 Arkansans with a tax cut. Last year we put 658, excuse me, 689,000 Arkansans with a tax cut. So that is the main reason I fully believe our governor wants to be fair and a tax cut to those citizens that owe taxes to this state. He wants them to take that, use it to the greater good.
To answer your question, though, about moving now, I want to be clear. There is no surplus in this budget. This is a line-item priority for our governor. Now, I guess you could say we have yet not voted on other things, but this is his priority. He wants this tax cut. We want a tax cut for our citizens, I believe, so we'll take that. And that's what we're doing here. We're setting a priority.
Follow-up, Mr. Chair? One more, please, ma'am. Sure. Oh, one more. How do I frame this? Pressure's on. Pressure's on. So I appreciate Representative Pitch, that answer, And I would tend to say, and I believe that at the top of my last question that I indicated, that I would tend to agree and be supportive, especially of a bill that addresses the lowest income Arkansans.
But I still don't, I'm still not clear, aside from the fact that we're setting this as a priority, how we justify setting this a priority, knowing that we have other essential needs that have not been addressed at a time where we're spending up all of our growth on these kinds of priorities, leaving really not a whole lot for emergencies, and again, not a whole lot for addressing highways, teacher retirement, and not knowing what's going to happen with the Affordable Care
So my question, and I don't really know how else to pose it except to say, understanding that we want this as a priority and we agree on that, but we're here to, aside from set priorities, be responsible with the monies that we have and make sure that before we sort of, before we look at, I don't even want to do an analogy. I'll just say that this is something
that we prioritize and we want to do. But how do we do this and not hurt on the back end the people that we're trying to help on the front end? I guess I want to make
Speaker 43
24:42
sure of your question. Your Your comment was, this is our priority. We want to do this, but we're worried that it's too much of a priority. No, that's not what I said. Well, I guess I want to make sure of your question then. Because if the question is, if you're setting this as a priority, we are open to saying that.
The governor has set a priority for a tax cut for the low income, under 21,000 net taxable income only folks, and that's his priority. If you're for that, then you're for this bill. you aren't for that, then you're not for this bill, because he has set that as a true priority.
Well, so you were asking clarification for my question, and I want to be clear that what I'm saying is, understanding that it is a priority for all of us, or for most of us, or a few of us,
My question is, aside from the prioritizing, how would you, as a member of this body, and then also as a sponsor of this bill, suggest that we still address other essential priorities and really essential needs and still do this on the front end without knowing how we're going to address highways,
teacher retirement, and Affordable Care Act uncertainty. I would say I'm happy with
Speaker 43
26:19
this. How do we pay for it? How are we paying for it? Well, I'm happy the governor has chosen to make this a priority. That's why I'm in support of that. I'm always in support of a tax cut when it fits into a budgeted plan, And our governor sees fit to put out a proposed balance budget with this 50.5 million as a line item in that budget.
That's what you have in front of you. Representative Scott Boss, you're recognized, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Pitch, two years ago we supported the tax cuts. And when it came down to revenue stabilization, we got libraries, senior citizen centers, and several other things with cuts. They were going to close three of my five senior citizen centers.
Can you pretty much assure me that's
Speaker 43
27:20
not going to happen this time? Assurances are always tough to give at this time, but I do know the governor plans to have a balanced budget. And in his balanced budget, this is a key cog in it, it is one of his priorities. I referenced the libraries. That ended up being the last day type deal. So that probably had very little to do with whether we did the tax cut or not.
But it is what we do as a body, is we have our RSA Act that we have a balanced budget at the end. And we are starting to set the blocks to
that with this bill. Okay. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Representative Collins, you're recognized, sir. Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. Representative Pitch, isn't it true that our net general revenue budget is over $5 billion? And so we're talking about, in an ongoing way, cutting tax rates by less than 1%. And in year one, because this is being phased in, literally only cutting them by one-half of percent
on our hardest-working low-income folks, and at the same time, we've learned from the past four years of tax cuts that our income tax revenue forecasts have been accurate to a penny over the past four years?
Speaker 87
28:35
The simple answer is yes. Motion at the proper time, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Representative Collins. Representative Gray,
you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I just want to say I had a motion at the proper time.
Thank you, sir. Representative Bragg, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Pitts, can you help me remember when we passed the last tax cut, the middle class tax cut, isn't this just a follow-up, not a promise, but a follow-up on a commitment the governor made that we would address the lower income the next
Speaker 43
29:14
round? I hesitate to answer that because I can't give you the chapter and verse, but that is the governor's intention to do tax cuts that cause jobs and economic development, and this is definitely in his plans, yes.
Okay, thank you. Representative Johnson, you're recognized, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I want to get off subject and talk about the task force for a minute. Okay. And I've been in the meetings where we saw that North Carolina did an excellent job of overhauling their tax laws, and Louisiana did a terrible job of overhauling their tax laws. And so we're looking at overhauling it completely with the staff, or making a recommendation of overhauling it completely.
And so this task force is supposed to end December 31st, 2018, correct? They
Speaker 43
30:06
have a report on December of that date. They have another report the following
September. So are we hoping to rewrite the tax law in the next general session? Yes. And is
Speaker 43
30:19
that the goal of the task force? 2019, we'll consider the recommendations coming from the task force, but there will be two reports, December of 2018, or 2017, and September of 2018.
Because the task force expires 2018, and we want to have it all done by then, and if we're going to overhaul, this doesn't mean we're going to overhaul it. Absolutely. We're going to try, we're going to look at it, and it's going to be a lot of work, and everything's on the table with that task force, correct? from any sales tax
Speaker 43
30:53
to any income tax. It is tax reform policy with the direction, if you look at the opening line at the number on the bill. It's tax reform policy that's fair to all, causes economic prosperity, and creates jobs.
appreciate you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. You bet. In reference to your question, Representative Johnson, I see it as prioritizing the needs of the state as we go forward to implementing tax policy. We all agree that our tax code is antiquated and just get a prioritized list. Since 2008, I think the tax, we have cut $557 million worth of taxes since 2008, but they're kind of all over, been all over the place.
I think the scope of this task force is to actually get a priority and a list and all of us going, as my good friends, Rep. Charlie Collins kept mentioning, getting the boat going in the right direction. Or an airplane if you're an Air Force guy. Any other questions, members? Are you included in that highway funding? We're also going to set up the funding in that task force or just, you know, we don't have to do the highway funding. Well, I mean, you know, I think that's going to be up to the community
once we get that task force running. But I think all those questions, because basically everything boils down to the budget, you know, what the numbers are. And so how we protect the budget, but how we effectively cut the tax rates for the hard-working people of Arkansas. Members, any other questions? Anybody in the audience want to speak against the bill? Anybody in the audience want to speak for the bill? Representative Pitch, are you closed for your bill? Yes, Mr. Chairman, I am closed. Members, what's the pleasure of the committee?
I have a motion to do pass from Representative Michael John Gray. Do we have any discussion on the motion? No discussion. All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? Congratulations, sir. Your bill has passed. Thank you, Mr. Chairman,
Speaker 43
32:59
and thank you, committee. You're welcome, sir. Representative Saban, are you ready, sir?
Representative Saban, just a second. Let the room kind of settle back down, and we'll start. Everybody kind of situated. Got Lynn Pickock and Tommy Wren back there holding the show up. Representative Sabin, you're free to proceed. If you don't care, recognize yourself with the
community and just head out, buddy. Okay, Representative Warwick Sabin representing District 33 in the House.
Mr. Chair, I appreciate the opportunity to present this legislation as well as to the members of the committee. And I guess where I'd start is to say that I'm particularly grateful to have the chance to present this legislation at the same time that Representative Pitch talked about the governor's tax cut. And it's not that I relish the sort of situation that we're in, in terms of the fact that they're somewhat in opposition. Obviously, they're targeting the same group.
But from my perspective, the legislation that I'm bringing to you has been pretty well vetted. I introduced the same bill two years ago with a bipartisan list of co-sponsors. And those co-sponsors joined me again, and I'm particularly grateful and honored to have co-sponsorship from the chairman of both the House and the Senate Revenue and Tax Committees, of course, Chairman Jett and Chairman Fowles over on the Senate side. And when I brought the legislation two years ago, to Representative Bragg's point,
it was really in response to the fact that every other group of Arkansans really had gotten a tax cut over the last few years, at least as long as I've been in the legislature. We passed a capital gains tax cut in 2013, of course we addressed the middle class in 2015. And so really the only group that was left out was low income Arkansans. And in looking at the strategy to address that, I looked at the earned income tax credit as a chance to do that. And the reason why I did that is because this is a policy that has been in place at the federal level for now about 30 years.
And from the very, very beginning, it was a bipartisan effort. And in fact, Ronald Reagan, when he was president, called this his favorite anti-poverty program. And the reason why is because it's really the most effective way that we've seen to number one, incentivize work, and number two, move people out of poverty. Number three, reduce dependence on social services, and number four, stimulate the economy. And I'll go into some of the detail on that. I don't want to get too deep in the weeds, but suffice it to say,
the way that federal earned income tax credit works is that it does offer a credit when people are earning a certain minimum amount of income. And then there's a pretty, not so complicated formula, but at least it has some sophistication to it, where the amount of the credit increases as people earn more income, and if they have more members of their family, up to a certain point. And then as people start earning even more,
the amount of the credit actually goes down and kind of eases people into, you know, obviously having a more stable and more sufficient level of income, which is obviously the goal. So it's been designed by some very smart people to be as efficient as possible. So we're not spending more than we have to on this credit, but we're certainly achieving the goal of, you know, targeting this low income population and moving them into the workforce. And for that reason, I think it's a better policy than what the governor is offering.
And obviously, I've made that case to the governor's office over the last couple of years. But I think it's important to kind of have this juxtaposition here today so that people can at least hear sort of both sides and how these policies work. If you look at my legislation, it's pretty simple because it offers basically a 5% credit based on the federal earned income tax credit. So the legislation just simply goes off the same formula as the federal government. That's what's happened in all of the other states that have implemented their own version of an earned income tax credit.
And I'll say that if you go ahead and look at all the other states that have done it, they've all experienced a lot of success with it. And most of the states that do it end up increasing the level of the credit because it's so effective. And my understanding is, Louisiana, for instance, just to the south of us, has adopted their own version of the EITC. And because it's been so successful, they are moving toward increasing the level of that credit here this year, and there's an effort underway. I'm going to read to you just a few things from some budgetary experts,
so you kind of understand that when I tell you that this is an effective and proven policy, that this is not just me conjuring up these ideas. This is coming from a couple of pretty well-respected institutions. The Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, for instance, says that research indicates that families mostly use the EITC to pay for necessities, repair homes, maintain vehicles that are needed to commute to work, and in some cases obtain additional education or training to boost their employability and earning power.
So again, we're talking about not only helping people move out of poverty, but They're stimulating the economy because those dollars that these families are receiving as a credit, go right back into the local economies to repair their homes and to buy their kids clothes. And they're serving the local businesses here in Arkansas. The CBPP also says that the EITC is designed to encourage and reward work. A worker's EITC grows with each additional dollar of earnings until reaching the maximum value.
This creates an incentive for people to leave welfare for work and for low wage workers to increase their work hours. This incentive feature has made the EITC highly successful. Studies show that the EITC encourages large number of single parents to leave welfare for work, especially when the labor market is strong. And they go on to say specifically a highly regarded study found that EITC expansions the most important reason why employment rose among single mothers with children during the 1990s.
The EITC was more effective in encouraging work than either welfare reform or the strong economy. And then as far as addressing reducing poverty, they say that in 2015, the EITC lifted about 6.5 million people out of poverty, including about 3.3 million children. The number of poor children would have been more than one quarter higher without the EITC. The credit reduced the severity of poverty for another 21.2.
I'm sorry, the credit reduced the severity of poverty for another 21.2 million people, including 7.7 million children. And then I'm going to read you one other just very quick couple of things from the Tax Policy Center. They say that research shows that the EITC encourages single people and primary earners in married couples to work. And then they say if the EITC were treated like earnings, it would have been the single most effective anti-poverty program for working age people, lifting about 6.5 million people out of poverty,
including 3.3 million children. So when we talk about how we want to spend this money, because some of the debate that just happened around Representative Pitch's bill was about the wisdom of, you know, extending more tax cuts and, you know, how we're going to pay for things. And, you know, if we're going to have that discussion about spending that money and spending it in the most efficient way possible, I think we want to make sure that we're targeting this tax credit to the people that we say we're targeting it towards, who are the low-income working families of Arkansas.
And I had made the point, at least through my question that the governor's tax cut plan, while I think conceived for the right reasons, because it's a simple cut to the marginal tax rate. It doesn't necessarily, or at least efficiently, target the people that we say we're targeting. There are going to be people who benefit from the governor's tax cut who are not low income working families. They are people who are making well above the income levels that we're targeting.
But because of deductions, and because this is based on net taxable income, they're going to qualify for the governor's tax cut as well. Also, as we all know, we have a kind of odd income tax system here in Arkansas. And maybe not everyone knows this, but it's a little weird because we all kind of get taxed for the amount of income that we earn within each respective bracket. not necessarily a blanket rate for all of our income that we're earning. So if you're earning $100,000 or something like that, you're kind of getting taxed for
those bits of income that you make inside those lower brackets. And then you get that highest rate just for the amount of income from where the highest rate starts up to what you're earning. And I hope I simplify that, it's complicated and it's sort of odd, but that's how it works here in Arkansas. So obviously if we're going to cut these rates in these brackets that the governor is proposing to do, then really everybody is getting a tax cut, not just the lower income Arkansans. And I would argue that let's do what we say we're trying to do.
Let's give a tax break to the people who didn't get it. Let's do it in a very efficient way. And the earned income tax credit is the proven over decades method to accomplish that. while making sure that we're not sort of offering tax cuts to other people. And I think that's part of the reason why my proposal is $10 million cheaper than the governor's. If you look at the fiscal impact statement, what I'm proposing is $40 million. What the governor is proposing is $50 million. And we're trying to watch every penny.
We've got a lot of needs. We're also going to have to find offsets. And if you ask me, there are offsets that the governor is proposing, such as removing the exemption on unemployment benefits, which I think, again, if we're trying to help low-income Arkansans get out of poverty, I think the last thing we want to do is impose an additional tax burden on those who, by definition, are looking for work. You don't get unemployment benefits unless you're engaged in looking for work.
And so why would we add an additional tax burden for the very people who are doing the right thing and who are in the least position to be able to afford that? So let's look at something that's more efficient economically, that's more proven as a policy, that's more targeted, you know, and that is the earned income tax credit. For that reason, this legislation not only has the support of the chairs of our revenue and tax committees and others, but Entergy Corporation has endorsed the bill and will be testifying on its behalf.
Southern Bancorp, the largest development bank in the United States, supports the bill. And we'll be testifying on its behalf, and I just found out this morning that March of Dimes wanted to enthusiastically register their support as well. So, again, this is really about a policy that I think is well vetted. It's one that is not a kind of cobbled together response, but rather one that preceded the proposal that we just heard previously. It's one with bipartisan support.
It's one that will truly create an incentive for people to move from welfare to work, to reduce poverty, to reduce dependence on our social services, and again, to stimulate the economy here in Arkansas. And with that, Mr. Chair, I'd be glad to take any questions. Thank you,
Representative Hendren. You're recognized, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
I'm going to ask a question that I guess I'm supposed to know the answer to, but I'm not. I thought maybe when I was sitting here in these fancy high-back chairs that cost a million dollars for room,
the best I can find out so far, that I'd understand this, but I don't. And there may be two or three people watching at home back in the hills that don't know the answer to this question either. But what it is, I thought I was coming along with this because you were saying income earned tax credit or something like that. And then, instead of going to helping me, you went to say an EITC, and that didn't help me any. So I think I know what this means, but if you could put it on the bottom shelf here for me and probably nobody else on this committee,
but just me and whoever else might need it, does this mean instead of a tax cut on when I fill out my income tax, I don't pay as much tax like I guess this last bill we just passed out of here does? That's what that does, right? Yeah, that reduces the marginal tax rate. Now, this EITC, see, I've learned how to say that. This EITC we're doing here, tax credit, and I've heard this around here for years down here, and I've always wondered what it meant, so maybe you can help me today. Does that mean instead of paying income tax, I'm going to get a check from their government?
You would only get a refund if the amount of the credit as calculated by the formula was more than you'd actually paid in taxes over that year. But it is a tax credit, so again, it's formulated, you know, again, I've kind of explained, It's a formula that's based on how much you earned that year and the size of your family. Is the reason
we don't call it a refund is because the person getting this hadn't paid anything in? Not everybody gets a refund. Just help me with this. The bottom line is when I do this, I'm getting a check back from the IRS instead of sending a check.
Is that right? Let me put it this way. You don't necessarily get a check back unless, again, the credit is more than what you paid in. There are plenty of people who get tax refunds at the end of the year after they've calculated it because of deductions and credits and all that. I mean, people get checks back, not just folks who get the EITC. Let me explain one other thing that I think is really critical here. The main reason why this credit was designed as a refundable tax credit, which is what you're talking about,
is because low-income Arkansans pay a disproportionate amount of their taxes in the form of regressive taxes like sales taxes and gas taxes, and that burden is not obviously covered when all we do is cut the marginal tax rate. And so we're talking about moving people out of poverty, and we're talking about trying to create incentives for people to work instead of relying on welfare and other government programs. And so we have to take those things into account, because if you look at the charts, our low-income Arkansans have a greater tax burden
than those who are wealthier, and that's just a
fact. I'm abusing this, and I'm not asking, but is it a tax check, a check coming back from the government for a
tax credit? It's possible that people would receive a tax refund if the amount of the credit is greater than what they paid in. I
think I've got it. Thanks. Yes, sir. You're welcome, sir. Any other questions, member? I'm sorry. We've got Representative Dodson. We do have a list. Recognize, sir. Members, let me just add, and Representative Henry did not do this,
but let's keep it to questions only here, if you don't care. You did good, but let's just keep it to questions. Other than you don't look very good in the chair, the good-looking chair anyway, didn't help you in any way anyway, but let's stay on task with the questions, if you
don't care. Gibson, Dotson, you recognize. Thank you, Mr. Chair, Representative Saban. So if I understand this correctly, this would actually tie the state's liability to 5% of whatever the federal rate or EITC happens to be.
So we are tying something to an external source we have no control over as a percentage. So this could go up over the course
of time without our control. Well, our control would be the percentage of the federal EITC. But of course, because it's connected to the federal, it would be 5% of the federal EITC,
yes. So it would go up if they, I think that answers that question. Follow up, Mr. Chair? You bet, buddy. I think Representative Hendren kind of covered this,
that in fact someone could potentially get a tax credit back that exceeds what they've paid in. So you, in effect, would be taking money that other taxpayers have paid in and handing it or redistributing it to some that- Well, I wouldn't want
to like, for instance, a show of hands in the room for everybody who's ever gotten a tax refund from the IRS. But I'll raise my hand, and I've gotten one. And it's just because we have laws in place that dictate what exemptions and
what deductions and all of that. And sometimes we mess up if we take too many exemptions or too few exemptions when we fill out our forms when we get employed and things like that. But I wouldn't ever call it taking money from somebody else and giving it to someone, I would say that you have laws on the books, and we all abide by the federal tax policy. And if the calculation works out one year that you get something back, and the next year that you pay something in. That's just the way it works for everybody, regardless of whether you're talking about the EITC or anything else.
And if I may, one final. Looking at the fiscal impact on here, obviously it's $40 million and one just passed out of here that was $50 million, if my math is correct, that's about $90 million if both of these were to pass. One of the concerns and the other comments toward the bottom of the first page in here is that there's about a 23% to 27% federal earned income tax credit fraudulent type fraudsters,
close to 25% of fraud. So if this is to pass and we have similar type amounts, that would be, you would expect around $10 million worth of state fraudulent expenses? Well, let me address
the fraud issue, because that's something that comes up a lot when the EITC is discussed, and usually by its detractors. And I do have a list of sort of bullet point responses to that. I'm going to read two of them to you, but suffice it to say that I think the numbers of fraudulent EITC claims can easily be debated.
But the first thing I'll just say is, according to the CBPP, it says many times fraud isn't really fraud. 40% of EITC claims that were found to have errors during audits ended up being cleared when they were investigated by the Taxpayer Assistance Service. And then also it says, for context, the EITC error rate is much lower than many other error rates. This includes errors in business reported income. The IRS found that 56% of business income was unreported in 2006, which is about 10 times higher than the EITC overpayments in that year.
So, you know, we can obviously have a very healthy debate about whether, you know, the fraud exists at the level that some people claim, but I certainly don't think it would be $10 million worth here in Arkansas. And I'll say one other thing. Most people right now aren't even claiming EITC if they're eligible for it, and a lot of people see that as being the biggest problem. Here in Arkansas, we've got a lot of people who don't know that it exists, and they qualify for it, and they don't even claim it. So the idea again that fraud is the biggest issue, I think is erroneous.
I think that really the bigger problem is that people have the opportunity to take advantage of something that can help them move out of
poverty. And they're not doing it because they don't know about it. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Collins, you're up. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Sabin, my hero, Milton Friedman, when he invented and designed the negative income tax, declared it the best policy to help people. So from a welfare perspective, from a welfare and benefits perspective.
But his concept was that it replaces existing welfare, and that's where the funding comes from. So my question to you, sir, is let's say we get changes in Washington, D.C., to health care. Today we have a massive health care benefit for low income people. Would you be comfortable paying for this down the road, say coming out of a task force, by using a reduction in the amount of Arkansas tax money that we're currently using to support health care policies for the same group?
So, Representative Collins, I appreciate the question. And I think you and I probably had similar conversations with similar people, if I had to guess, because I've heard that concept floated by some people I respect a lot, and I'm certainly willing to- I'm glad they're listening to me. to keep that in mind for sure. I mean, for me, I'm just trying to kind of stay with this right now in terms of just the merits of the EITC itself as opposed to a simple cut in the marginal rate, which I know you're passionate about, by the way. But so, I would keep anything like that under consideration to answer your question.
I'm sorry, Representative Flowers. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Sabin, you heard earlier when we just discussed the governor's tax proposal presented by Representative Pitch, me ask a question about how we justify passing another tax cut, given the uncertainty of
our budget and what we're even working with, with regard to the Affordable Care Act and the savings that we've experienced with that, but also with the anticipation that that that health care coverage could be overturned and eliminated without a replacement. And also other essential needs like our highways and teacher retirement has not been addressed.
And so we don't know what the impact on our budget will be with regard to those issues. So I'm just wondering what your thoughts are about that, and how do we as legislators move forward with passing a tax cut at all with those issues still sort of laying out there, even though
we support this as a priority? Right. I mean, obviously, that's sort of the million-dollar question or the, I guess, several tens of millions of dollars worth of question. I think, you know, I bring this because the governor and the legislature have indicated that, you know, we're going to be pursuing tax cuts.
And this is not the end. You know, there will be more tax cuts after we get through with this round. And I want the EITC on the table for people to consider on its merits because, again, you know, if we're going to do tax cuts, I think that we need to do as much as we can to help move our working Arkansans out of poverty. I think we all agree that anybody who is willing to work and can find a job shouldn't have to live in poverty,
shouldn't have to make those choices about, you know, between utilities and food for their family. And so that's really kind of the challenge for us here in this state at this time. We need to kind of address the biggest problems we have before we go after the other ones. And so if we're going to cut taxes, which I think your points are valid in terms of the wisdom of whether or not we do that with all these other priorities. But if we're going to do it, let's look at a policy that's proven that, again,
that incentivizes work, that moves people out of poverty, and that helps address all of these kind of bigger issues around food insecurity. And just everything else that we're dealing with that actually makes government really more expensive in the end. Because whether you're talking about healthcare, Representative Collins, or anything else, when people are struggling the way they're struggling, the burden falls on everybody one way or the other.
Representative Flowers, you good, ma'am? Yes, thank you. I'm not used to you not having a follow-up. You had me
messed up. He answered my question. Thank you. Representative Dan Douglas, you're recognized, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And Representative Saban, I really appreciate you trying to help lift people up out of poverty. That's something that we all need to strive for. Sometimes, though, in reality, when something looks good on paper and
it sounds good, it doesn't always work out so well in the real world. For example, I used to manage a plant. And one example, I had a single mother there that had three children. She qualified for the federal income tax credit. she had a boyfriend that lived with her that they refused to get married because their combined income would put them higher
and she would not qualify for the earned income tax credit. It kept them from getting married. Then when they got their money back to help lift themselves out of poverty, They bought $2,500 worth of mag wheels and tires to put on a $1,500 pickup. How does that help lift people out of poverty, sir?
dangerous to do in this kind of environment
is to cite one example as proving an overall sort of whole. I mean, I don't know anything about the people you're talking about. I do know that, you know, the EITC, the credit actually increases if you're married as opposed to whether you're single. So if they didn't get married for that reason, then they were definitely doing it wrong and probably needed some education. If I had to guess, that situation probably has a lot of other factors in it that don't have anything to do with the merits of the EITC.
All I can do, Representative Douglas, all I can do is point you to 30 years of a track record at the federal level that's been documented, that's been studied, that's been debated, and that's ultimately been endorsed by members of both parties because it's one of the rare situations where both parties really feel good about the policy because it does all of the things that all of us want to see happen. And it does it very effectively and very efficiently, which, as we all know, is very rare.
So that's why I think the policy deserves to be considered and implemented here in
Arkansas. Representative Johnson, you're recognized, sir. Are you done? Yep. Okay, cool. Members,
any other questions? Representative Collins. Representative Saban, I would just like to ask if you'd be willing to go and look again at Representative Pitch's bill, The way that you described marginal income tax rates and high income benefiting, et cetera, applies on the federal code and
it applies in virtually every other state in the union. But in 2015, Arkansas changed our system to a three bracket structure. And people making more than $75,000 will get exactly zero benefit from the governor's plan. Fair enough, but it is
true that there are people in the income levels above what we're targeting here that will get a tax cut that they wouldn't get under the EITC, and that's a fact.
And that can be demonstrated in any number of graphs that I could show you here.
Members, any other questions? We're going to move to the audience. We have several people to speak for and against the bill. First up will be Mr. David Ray. Are you still here, sir, to speak against the bill? Please, if you don't care, recognize yourself at the end of the table. And you're free to proceed, sir.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. My name is David Ray with Americans for Prosperity, and I'm here today to speak in opposition to this bill. As has been mentioned several times, this bill creates an earned income tax credit, which is, as has also been mentioned, a refundable tax credit for individuals with a low tax liability. And while it is technically administered through the tax code, it is primarily a spending program. It is a wealth redistribution program, as noted by the DF&A legal analysis of this bill,
which says that it, quote, could make a portion of the state credit a subsidy to some Arkansas taxpayers. As it was discussed in questioning, even more notable is the fact that the federal earned income tax credit, which is what this bill seeks to emulate, is a program that is riddled with fraud. The Washington Times reports that some 28 million Americans claim the EITC in 2014, costing taxpayers approximately $66 billion. The IRS estimates that 27% of those
payments, totaling $17.7 billion, were unjustified. So the fraud and abuse rate of this program is staggering. And I think it would be naive to think that a state-level program similar to this wouldn't similarly be taken advantage of with fraud. In fact, the DF&A impact study only reinforces this point, and it says, in part, quote, there is a strong potential for an increase in fraudulent claims.
Fraudsters may also file more state paper returns that will not have to go through IRS checks and verification for federal credit. The bill does not require an apportionment of the credit for non-residents, creating the possibility that non-residents will receive credits that exceed income earned in Arkansas. In summary, I would say that the EITC is an easy target for those who would seek to commit fraud because it's refundable. You can simply file a false tax return and see if the Treasury sends you a check back.
If we want to encourage work for low-income individuals, which I believe is a goal that we would all share, then let's reduce and eliminate, wherever possible, personal income taxes, which penalize work and productivity. And I would argue that the committee just did this a moment ago by passing Representative Pitch's bill to reduce marginal income tax rates on low-income Arkansans. This bill carries a fiscal impact of $40 million, and given the substantive nature of this
legislation, and given the fact that many other tax reform and tax cut proposals have been shelved in deference to the governor's low-income tax cut plan, wouldn't it make sense to simply consider this proposal as part of many other tax cut or tax reform or credit ideas that would be considered by the legislative task force that is to come? In conclusion, the EITC is the nation's largest cash welfare program for low income households.
This committee should not create a new welfare program for Arkansas that's designed to emulate the one at the federal level that has a 27% fraud rate. And with that, I would encourage you to oppose this bill. Thank you, sir. Members, any questions
for Mr. Ray? If not, thank you, sir. Thank you. Mr. Darren Williams in the room, speak for the bill. How are you doing, buddy?
I haven't seen you in a long time. Recognize yourself, sir, and you're
Speaker 124
1:06:51
free to proceed. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Good to see you as well. To the chairman and distinguished members of this committee, particularly those that I had the pleasure of serving with in the 89th General Assembly when I was sitting in your seats, First, I want to thank you for your service. We appreciate your time and dedication to trying to promote positive policy that impacts the people of the state of Arkansas.
You don't often get thank yous, and I wanted to say thank you because I've sat in your seats, and I know how much time and effort this takes. I want to commend Governor Hutchinson, Representative Sabin, Chairman Jett, Senator Fowles, and others who are sponsoring this bill. and the entire legislature who are really looking to provide tax breaks for working families, for the lowest income Arkansans. I think that's a laudable priority.
I think that should be addressed, and I appreciate you all doing that. For too many Arkansans who get up every day, go to work, work long hours, extremely hard for their families, they find themselves having more month at the end of their money, and they just can't make ends meet. We often refer to them as the working poor. And you may ask, what does a CEO of a billion-dollar bank have to do with this issue?
Well, I would suggest that there's probably no person that knows more about your personal finances than your banker. And as a CEO of a development bank, one of the largest development banks in the country, really that focuses on trying to lift people out of poverty, focuses on trying to create economic opportunity, focuses on mission activities that really try to help people build wealth and make the American dream possible for everyone. Since 2005, Southern Bancorp has run a volunteer income tax assistance program in a number of our sites.
We have over 44 locations in Arkansas and Mississippi, primarily in the Arkansas Delta and in South Arkansas. And in those sites, we have filed 21,000 tax returns since 2005. Returning $42 million to the folks in Arkansas from tax refunds. Half of that 42 million has been in the form of EITC. And I see when people get this money, they do exactly what Representative Sabin said. They rehab their homes. They provide repair for their cars.
They provide clothing and shelter for their families. They spend this money. So I would say this legislation, as Reverend Saban has said, has a proven track record. The concept and idea first introduced in the 1970s by President Ford, expanded in 1986 by President Reagan, lauded by Republicans and Democrats alike as an outstanding program to help working Americans. And I would suggest that we build upon that long history, the federal government level, and the 26 other states in the District of Columbia who also have passed a state EITC
to make this possible to benefit the working families in the state of Arkansas. This bill is pro-family. This bill is pro-work. This bill is pro-business. Pro-family because it allows families to make ends meet. It allows them to do the things necessary to make a living. This bill incentivizes work. It's a refundable tax credit. If you do not have a job, you will not benefit from this legislation.
So it is very much pro-work and incentivizes work, because the more you work, obviously, the larger the credit. And, in fact, in the states that have had this, you see people often seeking to work additional hours, understanding that this is a significant benefit. But it's also pro-business, because folks who receive this income, unfortunately, they're not in a position often to save that income. They spend that money. They put it right back into the economy in buying products and services that further stimulate the economy. So, as you all debate the various tax cuts that you seek to pass and have decided that it's a priority for this General Assembly, I would suggest that this be on the table.
I would suggest this is probably a better vehicle than the previous bill that you just passed because it is targeted, it is limited, and actually it costs the state less money. And it addresses exactly the folks that we're trying to address. So, with that, I appreciate your time, your patience, and listening. And again, it's a pleasure to be in front of
you again. Representative Williams, you answer a question, please,
sir? Absolutely. Last year, Trofer, are you recognized, sir? Yeah, and you may not be a last participant or a representative savior, you may. At the top level, you have two-and-a-half kids, you make $60,000, you less than 50 or whatever that number is.
What is the max that earned income credit gives in the federal level? Because it's a bell curve. You don't get paid if you're zero. You get high if you're a certain amount, and it goes down to zero at a certain point. Do you
know what that level is at the top point? You know, obviously, like I said, it's based on a formula. I'm going to give you what the CBPP said as of October 21st, 2016, so not too long ago. And this is, of course, for the federal EITC, so, you know, keep that in mind.
But it says, when filing taxes for 2016, which is due this April, working families with children that have annual incomes below about $39,300 to $53,500, depending on marital status and the number of dependent children, may be eligible for the federal EITC, so that's the top end. Working poor people who have no children and have incomes below about $14,900 or $20,400 for a married couple can receive a very small EITC, so that's the low end.
And in the $20,015 tax year, over 26 million working families and individuals in every state, so that's nationwide, received the EITC. Does that answer your question? What kind of, I guess what? Okay, during the 2015 tax year, the average EITC was $3,186 for a family with children, boosting wages by about $265 a month, compared with just $293 for a family without children. Okay, well I guess
my point is, you said the max would be about $3,000 for a family, if I'm not.
For a family with children. And remember that the proposal before you would be 5% of that at the state level.
So you're telling me that the state of Arkansas is going to give $150 and that's going to make a difference in whether they build, fix their house. It's more than what the governor's offering
in most cases, I'll tell you that. And we can show you those numbers too. Okay, I'd like to thank you. And do you want me to recognize you, because I don't know what you're giving.
Yes, Mr DePippa, just grab a seat and you might be able to put some clarification on this. You're probably the smartest
a few bosses here, so I'm not going to shortchange them. I understand. My
Speaker 131
1:14:00
wife's probably watching this stream live, too, so. Representative Ferrer, I'm Joel DePippa, Senior Counsel for DFA Revenue Legal Counsel. and the maximum amount at the federal level for the earned income tax credit is $6,266 if you are working at that maximum amount and you have three or more qualifying children that would be there.
Speaker 131
1:14:24
the $6,000 tax credit? That information we didn't have immediately available, but just the maximum credit because it is that shifting formula where whether you're married, how many qualifying kids, and those factors go into what was described by Representative Sabin earlier. But the maximum amount we were able to quickly verify was at that 6,266 level with three kids who qualify, etc. Okay. But
Representative Sabin's bill is not going to mess with the federal
in it. It just adds 5% more to that total that the state
Speaker 131
1:14:56
of Arkansas will have to pack. The state of Arkansas would pay 5% of that amount. Of the $6,000? Yeah, 1 20th of that amount would be what Representative Saban's bill would be asking for from the state. So an extra, if my
change, yeah, okay, all right, okay, thank you. Thank you, anybody else in the audience speaking against the bill?
not signed up. Up next will be Mr. Paul Means from ENERGY. Paul, if you don't care, just recognize yourself and
you're free to proceed. Paul Means, Mr. Chairman, I'm Paul Means, and I'm here today representing ENERGY Corporation. Actually, I work for ENERGY Arkansas, but we have sister companies in Mississippi, Louisiana, in the southeast part of Texas, and we're all part of the larger energy corporation.
And the CEO and board of directors of our larger corporation feel that, in addition to just making money, we need to be a good corporate citizen. And we aspire as a corporation to contribute to a society that is healthy, educated, and productive, where none of our customers live in poverty and the environment poses no threat to future generations. And to work towards that aspiration, we have formed what we call the Energy Charitable Foundation, which is funded by the Board of Directors and our stockholders. It's somewhat similar, you may have heard of the Wal-Mart Foundation, that there's a lot of educational initiatives.
We have an energy charitable foundation and we focus on a bit of a different direction. We recognize the economic reality of our service territory in the Mississippi Delta is that approximately 25% of our 2.6 million customers live in poverty. And we believe we have a moral obligation and a business imperative to help find lasting solutions to bring them out of this poverty. And one of those that we support is the Earned Income Tax, EITC.
I'll just go to it, it's hard to say all that at once. And as part of that initiative, we have sponsored for a number of years, like Southern Bank Corp, what we call Super Tax Days, We'll bring the volunteers into a local community facility and advertise to the community so that folks can come in and have a trained tax preparer, help them prepare their tax return to properly claim their EITC credits. Last year we helped about 5,000 taxpayers here in the state of Arkansas.
And I wanted to address something that hasn't been brought up before, but Um, the research shows that the people, when they get these tax credits, go out and spend it, and they spend it on such things as groceries, clothing for their children, um, furniture for their house. Um, they can spend as much of half of what they get paying off past due bills and debts. Um, some of them save it. Some of them invest it in moving and buying a home. Um, they spend a lot on home repairs and car repairs.
These are all dollars that get spent in the local community where they live. And to that extent, EITC can be a bit of an economic stimulus to the businesses of the community, just much like the things that we do in terms of economic development. Because as they spend it, that's increased sales in these businesses. And if we treat that like we would bring in somebody that's going to open a new business, those increased sales lead to income for those businesses. They lead to an increase in the state's gross domestic product, they can lead to more jobs in the businesses.
So, it's not just helping the people receiving the refund or the credit. It also helps the businesses, the community where they spend it. We're working with ULR on a study, and you can come up with a range of values. But you can say that for each dollar you invest in EITC, depending on the circumstances, we can get a return of four or ten times benefit to the local economy. And so, I just wanted to put that before you. We as a corporation do support EITC, and I would urge you all to give it a serious consideration.
Thank you, and I'll answer any questions you might have. Representative Hendren, you're recognized, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Paul, maybe you can help me as I try to decide how to vote on this thing. This other bill we just passed was going to cost $50 million. I hear this is just going to cost $40 million, and you say you're for this one, and I done just voted for that other one. Now, if you were sitting here in this chair and you like this one too, would you vote for this one and make a total of $90 million, or would you not have voted the one for the one that I just voted for?
Representative Hendren, I would not presume to advise you how to vote and exercise your judgment. Well, my
constituents will. Yes. You can look at these as being complimentary approaches to
helping the folks of Arkansas and helping the economy. Can I assume from that, then, you'd go for the $90 million, and your Walmart foundation and your foundation
would make up if we got a shortage? I will certainly take that to them, sir. Thank you,
sir. Any other questions? Mr. Means, I appreciate it.
Thank you, members of the committee. Welcome, sir. Is Ms. Wilder in the audience? Ms. Will, if you don't care, go to the
end of the table, recognize yourself, and you're free to proceed, ma'am. Thank you, Mr. Chairman and members of the committee. My name is Ellie Wheeler. I work for Arkansas Advocates for Children and Families, and as an organization, we always keep an eye out on the lowest-income kids and families in Arkansas and do analysis on what bills are best for those low-income kids and families, and we believe strongly that
this bill is the best option for helping our most vulnerable families move into the middle class for good and encouraging work. This bill is a targeted way to help those families make ends meet. And as was mentioned before, research shows that most of the earned income tax credit funds are spent on catching up on bills, school clothes, school supplies, and basics that families need.
to be successful. It was mentioned earlier on the last bill, there was a question about some previous data that was requested from our organization. I believe that it was sent out earlier to Representative Hendren and Jett, but I do have copies for anyone who didn't get it. If you would like to see, I don't know if you want to pass it around. Would you like to have these materials passed around that was mentioned earlier today? Yes, does the members want to look at them
real quick? We're going to move on here really quick, but I also want to have honest, open, fair debate.
So I've been here for a while. Staff, if you
don't care, please pass those out. Thank you. And I will be brief. Essentially, what this material goes over is that we do have a higher total state and local tax burden for the lowest income residents in our state. and an EITC would help those lowest-income citizens lower their overall state and local tax burden. It does some analysis of where we are now and what happened during the previous session,
and it also compares the EITC bill with the low-income tax bill. Both of them do help low-income families, but as you can see at the very bottom, The EITC is much more targeted towards a narrower group of low-income families and would be much more beneficial to those families. And because of that, we'd like to see the biggest bang for our buck. We want to make sure that the money that we're spending is going towards the families that we intend it to go towards. We know that money spent through EITCs increases infant and maternal health.
It leads to better education outcomes, increased college attendance, better job outcomes down the road. So there's a long list of benefits that are proven through this type of program that we have seen. And it's also important to keep in mind what types of families we're talking about when we're helping them with earned income tax credits. Of course, it is those lower income families, but those families include 32,000 veteran and military families in Arkansas, 173,000 young workers who are beginning their careers,
in nearly 300,000 of our most vulnerable kids who would benefit from this type of bill. If our goal is to help working families move into the middle class and encourage work in the most cost effective and efficient way, this is the bill to go with. And with that, I would
appreciate your support on this bill. Thank you, ma'am.
Any questions? Representative Saban, you want to close for your bill, sir? If it's okay, I'll make a very quick close. I mentioned at the beginning that I didn't relish the opportunity to have a conflict with the governor.
Let me put it that way. I have a ton of respect for the governor. I really appreciate the fact that he is trying to address this population of working families with a tax cut. But I do think it's healthy for us to have a policy debate. And again, I'm grateful to Chairman Jett and the members of this committee for allowing that to happen today so we could hear both proposals side by side. We could compare the facts and the merits. And I think that one thing that's important when we consider the politics of this is
that the governor gets to be the governor all year long for four years and perhaps longer than that. Those of us in the legislature, we get to meet in regular session once every two years. And so we have a very limited opportunity to offer our ideas to our colleagues. And so to the extent that this proposal is getting to be heard alongside what the governor is asking for, I think is important. I think it's good to have this exchange of ideas because, again, I think it's great for the governor to provide leadership and to tell us how he'd like to do things.
But it's important for us as a separate branch of government to offer our own ideas and to put those out there on the table. And I say all that because I do want to address Representative Hendren's question about the $90 million question, I guess you could say, where you've got a $50 million tax cut and you've got a $40 million tax cut. In my mind, you know, this is a process of, you know, being in the legislature. It's not about, you know, just scoring the touchdown. It's about, you know, playing the whole four quarters of the game, which is something I wish the Razorbacks would do, but that's a whole other story.
So there's a process to get worked out. And, yes, we passed Representative Pitch's bill. My hope would be that this committee would pass my bill as well. And we've got a process to work through here in the House. We've got a process to work through on the Senate side. We have the governor who provides leadership and input as well. And perhaps there's room for compromise. I don't know that for a fact. Certainly I'm pretty certain that we can't do $90 million worth of tax cuts. So something's going to have to give somewhere. But I think if you, you know, heard this presentation and you see some merit in this proposal, then it would be very beneficial for this committee to allow the full House to hear both proposals.
And, you know, we'll respect the process in whatever way it ends up in the end. But that's why we're here. That's why we get together. That's why we make the trip to Little Rock every couple of years. And I think it's important to have that process play itself out. So with that, Mr. Chair, and members of the committee, I would truly appreciate a good vote on this bill. Thank
you, sir. Members, what's the wishes of the committee? Have a motion from Representative Flowers? Yes, do pass. Any debate on the motion? All in favor on the motion, say aye.
Aye. Any opposed, no? No. The ayes have it. Congratulations, sir. You passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee. And members, before you guys take off, we're still working through Representative Fyatt's bill on the veterans tax cut and how we're going to pay for that. And we have one more bill on, so I'm thinking just tentatively we'll meet next Thursday and we'll take a group picture for the committee. So probably we'll not meet Tuesday, but coming back next Thursday will be a meeting, group
picture. And I'm thinking maybe the veterans bill will come, don't hold that to me, but as always we'll get that information out. We're going to be working through these bills in order as we go forward. Thank you very much. And with that, we're going to adjourn this meeting.
Agenda
HB1037 Wardlaw TO REGULATE THE SALE OF TAX-DELINQUENT PROPERTY; AND TO PROHIBIT OWNERS OF TAX-DELINQUENT PROPERTY FROM BIDDING ON OR PURCHASING TAX-DELINQUENT PROPERTY.
HB1156 Jett TO PROVIDE THAT ARKANSAS CORPORATE INCOME TAX RETURNS BE FILED BY APRIL 15 BEGINNING IN THE 2016 TAX YEAR; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1157 Collins CONCERNING HOMESTEAD PROPERTY TAX CREDIT ELIGIBILITY; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY
HB1159 Pitsch TO CREATE THE TAX REFORM AND RELIEF ACT OF 2017; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1161 Sabin TO CREATE THE WORKING FAMILIES OPPORTUNITY ACT.
HB1162 C. Fite TO AMEND ARKANSAS TAX LAW CONCERNING INCOME TAX, SALES AND USE TAXES, AND THE SOFT DRINK TAX; TO SUPPLEMENT THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID TRUST FUND TO OFFSET DECREASED DEPOSITS FROM TAX REVENUES.
Deferred Bills Subtitle Sponsor Number
HB1028 Lemons TO EXEMPT CERTAIN BUSES, COACHES, AND OTHER MOTOR VEHICLES FROM SALES AND USE TAXES.
HB1031 Bentley TO CREATE AN INCOME TAX EXEMPTION FOR INCENTIVES RECEIVED UNDER THE COMMUNITY MATCH RURAL PHYSICIAN RECRUITMENT PROGRAM.
.HB1153 Boyd TO CLARIFY THE MEANING OF "ACTUAL AND OBVIOUS ERRORS" ON THE PART OF A COUNTY ASSESSOR IN THE ASSESSMENT OF REAL AND PERSONAL PROPERTY; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Speaker 1
Speaker 5
Chair
Unverified
Speaker 8
Representative Joe Jett Chair
Unverified
Representative Bob Johnson
Unverified
Speaker 17
Speaker 21
Representative Charlie Collins
Unverified
Representative Monte Hodges
Unverified
Speaker 33
Speaker 43
Representative Kim Hendren
Unverified
Representative Dan M. Douglas
Unverified
Representative Warwick Sabin
Unverified
Representative Vivian Flowers
Unverified
Speaker 72
Representative Scott Baltz
Unverified
Speaker 87
Representative Ken Bragg
Unverified
Representative Jim Dotson
Unverified
Speaker 58
Speaker 39
David Ray
Unverified
Speaker 124
Speaker 131
Speaker 135
Ellie Wheeler
Unverified