Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

Education Committee

January 24, 2017 ·Committee Room 138 ·1:29:49
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (17)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1209 · 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1209 Lowery TO ADOPT A PRODUCTIVITY-BASED FUNDING MODEL FOR STAT…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB10 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB10 L. Chesterfield TO AMEND THE PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS COD…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1002 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1002 McElroy TO REGULATE EQUIPMENT REQUIRED FOR SCHOOL BUSES; TO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1017 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1017 Cozart TO ALLOW THE TEACHER FAIR DISMISSAL ACT OF 1983 TO B…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1019 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1019 Cozart TO AMEND THE MEMBERSHIP OF THE SCHOOL LEADERSHIP COO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1020 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1020 Love TO CREATE THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY PROMISE LOTTERY SCHOLAR…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1027 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1027 Eubanks TO PROHIBIT A SCHOOL DISTRICT FROM USING PUBLIC FUN…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1029 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1029 Lowery TO EXCLUDE PRINCIPALS, ASSISTANT PRINCIPALS, AND CEN…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1030 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1030 Bentley TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS RURAL MEDICAL PRACTICE STUDEN…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1036 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1036 K. Hendren TO PROHIBIT THE USE BY A STUDENT OF A PORTABLE E…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1042 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1042 B. Smith TO PROHIBIT SANCTUARY POLICIES AT STATE-SUPPORTED…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1044 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1044 F. Allen TO ALLOW A STUDENT TO CHOOSE WHICH GRADE IN WHICH…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1056 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1056 House TO ALLOW THE SUPERINTENDENT OF A STUDENT'S RESIDENT S…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1154 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1154 Cozart TO REQUIRE THAT ANY INCREASES IN PROFESSIONAL DEVELO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1155 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1155 Cozart TO AMEND THE MINIMUM TEACHER COMPENSATION SCHEDULE.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1208 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1208 Lowery TO ALLOW A STUDENT WHO ATTENDS A PRIVATE SCHOOL OR A…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1222 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1222 Dotson THE ARKANSAS PARENTAL EMPOWERMENT FOR EDUCATION CHOI…”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 14, 2026
good morning everyone chair sees a quorum it's good to have everybody here today also in the i'll call a gallery out there i don't know if that's really a gallery but But
▶ Play
Speaker 3 0:23
nobody brought tomatoes, right? All right. Madam Co-Chair, you have anything you'd like to say?
▶ Play
No, thank you. All right. All right. We are ready to proceed. First off, we're going to start with Senate Bill 10. Senator Chesterfield, Representative Armstrong, you're recognized to take the end of the table and present your bill. Thank
▶ Play
you Mr. Chair and good morning committee. It's a pleasure to be back in House Ed. This is a very simple bill. What it does, it facilitates the merger between the University of Arkansas System and Pulaski Technical College. It It does not refer to the other mergers that are floating around Gossel and Laker. It has nothing to do with them. What it will do is to bring them under the Board of Trustees of the University of Arkansas at Fayetteville, and it will create a board of visitors for the institution that will be appointed by the governor. It's basically that simple or that complex, and I'd be happy to take any questions.
▶ Play
Representative Walker, you're recognized Let me change my
▶ Play
Speaker 12 1:44
mind Okay, she changed her mind You're recognized That's my homeboy, go ahead Well, thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chair Senator, thank you for presenting this I have several questions if I'm allowed to ask them You have one question to follow up and then we'll go to the next one All right, would you allow me a brief preface?
▶ Play
A brief what? Preface. If the senator on the end would allow
▶ Play
that, I will. We are from Hope, Arkansas. If he wants
▶ Play
to preface, let him preface. Go ahead. My observation is that community colleges help promote the development of the communities in which they are located. And that's the history in Arkansas. And for years, all of Arkansas prospered Until the University of Arkansas became Until after Fayetteville became the nerve center for Northwest Arkansas And after then, everything else started to stop prospering So I'm curious to know how this bill will enable Little Rock I guess it is Little Rock and other communities to prosper when it's pretty clear that the record is that nobody prospers under the university other than Fayetteville and nobody grows so tell me why and what is the advantage to community development and to the enhancement of education within these local communities such as Little Rock when you have things taken over by Fayetteville which has no interest in anything other than Not Fayetteville, but the university, which has no interest in anything
▶ Play
other than Fayetteville. This will bring economic stability. It will bring academic stability. And allow me to point you to the University of Arkansas Community College in Hope, Arkansas, which has reached out and provided great training for the people in our area of the state. The university's takeover, this is not a takeover. this is a merger between two institutions that have decided that it is to their economic and academic advantage to do so. So as a result of that, I am assuming then that they have decided that this is in their best interest. And as their senator, I'm here to advocate for that. As I advocate all the time for the University of Arkansas at Hope, where I've seen more people with training in workforce technology certification than I have in a very, very long time. So we rather disagree on that. I'd like to agree with you whenever I possibly can, but I do believe that this would be in the best interest of Pulaski Tech, and
▶ Play
it would be to some advantage for the university system as well. Follow-up, please. You're recognized. Conway prospers in part because it's a stand-alone institution and environment, and Arkansas State does likewise because it has a few tentacles, and SAU has not been embraced. But of all the other places that have been embraced by the University of Arkansas, the only thing that has happened has been that everything is either stagnant or it deteriorates. Have you ever looked at the record to see what the benefit is objectively? Now, we know that you have education going on there, and initiatives continue, but hope hasn't changed. The population is still the same as it was seven years ago, ten years ago. And Phillips County, it's going down, and it's located in Stuttgart. All of the places where you have these tentacles, they don't prosper. And when anything goes to Fayetteville, when things go to Fayetteville, they stay there. They don't go to the system as a whole. So I'm wondering, what is the benefit that this has because it's linked to Fayetteville to Pulaski Tech? Now, I understand Pulaski Tech has some problems, but aren't those things that are supposed to be worked out on a local level so that the evolution can occur just as it occurred in Fayetteville years ago, just as it occurred in Conway, just as it occurred in Jonesboro, and is not occurring in the other parts of the state?
▶ Play
That's a question. That's a multiplicity of questions. And whether I answer it or not, it's not going to please you because that's your perspective. So my perspective is that this is good for the University of Arkansas, and it is good for Pulaski
▶ Play
Tech, and I'd appreciate a good vote. Representative Douglas, you
▶ Play
recognize for a question. Yes, Senator and Representative, I'm hearing that this could bring some efficiencies maybe and just some in that realm when you do combine like that, even though this is just a board, but could you speak to that positive aspect? I
▶ Play
think that both Pulaski Tech and the University of Arkansas at Fayetteville will prosper more academically. I think by providing the economic efficiencies that are necessary to provide the certifications that are part of this system, and it will enhance the ability of this state to prosper. I stand by the merger. My friend and I agree to disagree. And once again, as I said, I'd appreciate a good vote.
▶ Play
Thank you. Thank you. Representative Gates, you're recognized for a question. Senator Chesterfield, does Pulaski Tech and the U of A boards both desire
▶ Play
this to happen? Yes, they do. Thank you. Representative Meeks, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. My question is this law does not force this to happen. This creates flexibility for the Pulaski Tech to join. Either they can give the University of Arkansas Fayetteville, they can do ASU, They could join UCA. They could do any four-year institution. So this gives them total flexibility. And I guess my follow-up would be Pulaski Tech, obviously, is not the only technical institute. We've got Crawley's Ridge. That would give them also the same freedom should they decide that's in their best interest to merge. Is that correct? So we're not making anybody do anything they don't want to do here. Well, okay,
▶ Play
as long as we add that caveat because I don't want to get into the Crawley's Ridge thing, period. Right. This is about the University of Arkansas, Fayetteville, and Pulaski Tech. It gives them that flexibility. They have agreed. They have come together. They've asked us to run this bill to facilitate that merger and to establish the appropriate boards, which is required by law since there was not law allowing this before. So once again, I'd appreciate a good vote. Representative
▶ Play
Lauer, you recognize for a question. Actually, if we're
▶ Play
ready, I'd like to make a motion. Do pass.
▶ Play
Thank you for allowing that. And thank you, Representative Meeks. Once merged, how do you unmerge?
▶ Play
What's the possibility? It's not a part of the bill, Representative Walker. And you know I'm not going to sit up here and deal with this loan because we disagree on this
▶ Play
one. Well, the concern is that they don't have the option. If
▶ Play
you want them to unmerge, all you have to do is present a bill that says we're not going to merge or we will unmerge. It's that simple or it's that complex. Thank you, Senator. You're very welcome. Thank you, darling. All right,
▶ Play
before the motion, I have anyone in the audience that would like to speak for the bill, against the bill? Seeing none, Representative Lauer, you're recognized for a motion. Have a motion to do pass. All those in favor, signify by saying aye. Aye. All those opposed, no. Motion passes.
▶ Play
Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair,
▶ Play
and thank you, members of the committee. All right. Before Representative Lowry presents his no-show bill on the end, I would like to see on your desk that he did leave you a little token to help you
▶ Play
vote for him today. It is just a
▶ Play
Speaker 5 10:28
coincidence that it got to you on the day of my first bill presentation. Representative Lauer, you are
▶ Play
recognized to take the end of the table and present your bill HB 1209, and you have an amendment for that bill that we will present first. We're going to pass out the amendment for that. Mr. Chair, With your permission, I'm going
▶ Play
to have Dr. Markham join me. That will be great when she speaks. If
▶ Play
Speaker 67 11:01
you want to go ahead and introduce yourself, Dr.
▶ Play
Speaker 71 11:08
Markham, we'll get that out of the way. Hi, Maria Markham, Director of the
▶ Play
Department of Higher Education. Thank you. And the reason I left the pen is because with Dr. Markham here, I know you're going to be paying more attention to her, so I needed something, you know, to let you know that, hey, I'm down here too. an amendment is being passed out to you that will need to be adopted first before we take up the bill I'll wait until you have it and we can just give a brief explanation this is an amendment to House Bill 1209 it is technically it's a hold harmless amendment that if there is a downturn in general revenues or revenues that are collected by the state that would, and you can see it in front of you, that if it affects the funding for state support institutions and it's greater than 2% less than the amount provided for the immediate previous fiscal year, then the productivity funding model would be delayed until the next fiscal year. Let me just point out that this kind of language has been present in the current funding model and has never had to be utilized, but it is there just in case.
▶ Play
Speaker 67 12:27
Any questions on the amendment? If not, do I have a
▶ Play
motion? I have a motion to adopt the amendment. All those in favor say aye. All opposed, no. Amendment is adopted. You may present your bill. Okay, thank
▶ Play
you very much. Members, this is a bill being brought to you. it is one of the initiatives of the governor's office a lot of work has gone into this Dr. Brett Powell started the work on this when he was director of higher ed and I know he is with us today he's now the vice president of finance administration at Henderson State Dr. Markham stepped right in and picked up the ball her and her staff and have gotten us to this point now the bill that you have is pretty thick but you will notice that most of the pages are actually deletions that referenced the old model, which was based on, and I'm going to basically steal from Steve Brawner. He gave a great summary of what this bill does, that the new model will be based on a college's success in advancing students towards degrees and certificates rather than simple numeric enrollment. And that's what the old model did, is they had simple numeric enrollment, You had the ADM, our 11th day, I think, in higher ed. Whatever the enrollment is, by the 11th day, then your state funding is based on that. There has been a great deal of concern that we really ought to be tying this to success. And a number of states have really done that very well. There have been studies, the state of Tennessee and Indiana, have found great success in their students being able to persist towards degrees, towards certificates. I'm kind of the bells and whistles guy, and Dr. Markham is the nuts and bolts person. So she can give you more detail as far as how the model will work. And so at this point, with the permission of the chair, I'm going to go ahead and turn the presentation over to Dr. Markham and let her be available for any questions that
▶ Play
you have. Dr. Markham, please proceed. You've already introduced yourself. Thank you, Representative Douglas.
▶ Play
Speaker 71 14:49
I want to familiarize you first with what you have in front of you. There are a couple of documents that I just provided for your information that we won't necessarily need to look through. The first is the Outcomes-Based Funding Research and Implications Study that was done by the Research for Action Group. Oh, they're about to hand it out. Okay, here it comes. I will not go through that. However, there's some information that you might find interesting on which states have adopted productivity-based funding and what their outcomes have been. There are several states that have implemented outcomes-based funding and others who are in the process of implementing outcomes-based funding. So you'll have a map there, and I'll also show you what's measured in those states. The bottom line that I wanted you to look at is on the next-to-last page, and it's the findings from those states who have implemented. And the big-ticket items there is an overall full-time students do significantly better. They have more credits that accumulate at both two- and four-year sectors. They've completed more certificates. Their degree completion, time to degree, has significantly shortened. And there's been a significant positive impact on underrepresented minorities in states who have adopted outcomes-based funding. So we can confidently say that the model has been proven to be successful in other states. So that's the document there. You also should have the master plan for higher education in our state. And I wanted you to see this because it's important to note how the productivity funding model aligns the goals of our state with the way we spend our money. So if you'll look on the first page, you can see those are our four major goals in our master plan. Our productivity funding model has been designed to support those goals and put money where it will make the most difference. The second page, you can see the principles that we used when we designed both the legislation and that we were using to develop the actual formula. The next page with the graphic, this will let you know how funding is allocated based on different types of success and we'll look at that in more detail as I present but you can see that we are considering a lot of different things as success for students and to clear up some misconception at no point are graduation rates used it's not about the rate it's about the individual student and what that student does so if you look at graduation rates for a particular institution you think maybe they're lower than others and they would be disincentivized for this that's not how that's calculated so we look at a lot of things and I'll go through those in more detail the next few pages have the detail what exactly is contained in all of those success measures so we look from everything to how many credits that student has when they complete we give institutions credit when they reach certain points of their academic career so even if a student doesn't complete but they get to 15 hours or 30 hours or 45 hours the institution still gets credit for successfully taking the student that far we weight different populations differently in our model. So students who are pursuing high tech degrees that are more expensive to deliver and more in demand in our state, they're weighted a little more heavily. STEM is a little more heavy. If it's a high demand program in the state, it's weighted a little more heavily. Also certain populations based on demographics. So if you're an underrepresented minority, we know that you're a little more expensive to educate as a rule. So we weight that student a little more heavily. If you have a remedial need, such as reading or math, the institution gets more credit for that student because it's likely that they will need tutoring and additional assistance and it takes more resources for those students to get through the pipeline so throughout the model which the model is really not contained in the bill the bill is more about general guiding principles the actual model and you have a powerpoint in front of you and i'm just kind of loosely going through that to explain it um a little more succinctly though i'm just kind of talking through the major points we've been working on the actual formula for almost two years And the work group that has worked on the formula came from a cross-section of four-year institutions, two-year colleges, system schools, stand-alone institutions. We've had presidents and chancellors, financial CFOs, people in the registrar's office, and people in student affairs. So we've had a big group that has been working on this for about two years, and we are nearing the end of that work. We're about 90% done. And the details of all of those rules will be in policy and come back to you for rules later on. So you can see in the big PowerPoint that's a little thicker what makes up the new productivity funding model. So we'll take the prior year funding as our base. We'll add the new state funding that the governor has committed to for us if we are able to implement this. And then any reallocated funding. Excuse me, let me make
▶ Play
sure all the members are on the right page and you've found where we are. Is anyone having
▶ Play
Speaker 42 19:49
trouble? We're right here. Okay, good. Thank you. I think
▶ Play
Speaker 70 19:52
we're good to go. Okay, great. Thank you. And then any reallocated funding. So if an institution has a
▶ Play
Speaker 71 19:58
big uptick in productivity, then we would reallocate funding to that institution. Whereas an institution that shows a dramatic decline, then that institution might lose some funding to an institution that's more productive. And that would come to our total funding recommendation. We have limited the total increase in the aggregate to higher education to 2%. So we'll never come and ask for more than 2% more than we did in the previous year. However, the individual institutions may receive more than a 2% increase if they show more than a 2% productivity change. So they may get more than, you know, an institution may get 10% because, you know, maybe Pulaski Tech has a huge increase in productivity. In the following year, they may get a 10% increase. However, we have capped their decrease at 2%, and that is for stability. Institutions need to be able to budget from year to year. More than a 2% decrease is a destabilizing effect on any of our institutions. over time, if an institution continues not to perform, it could result in a substantial amount of budgetary loss, but not in any given fiscal year. So the next page shows you how we have broken down our productivity measures. 80% of the measures come from effectiveness. So we're looking at credentials, and that's anything from a non-credit workforce certification to a certificate of proficiency all the way to a doctoral degree. So those are all considered credentials. They're weighted a little differently depending on cost and length of program but that's part of the effectiveness model. Also progression like I mentioned before. When students hit those milestones and those success points throughout their college career institutions will be rewarded for that. Transfer success is part of effectiveness. So if a two-year college and a four-year college work well together and they successfully transfer a student who completes a degree, both institutions are rewarded for that. Gateway course completion, we think of that as our English Comp 1 and our college algebra courses. So students who make it through those gateway courses are statistically much more likely to complete a degree. So we incentivize institutions to make sure those students are successful there. And then we're working on metrics for post-course completion. We're not really sure what that's going to look like yet. It's a little difficult, and it may not be part of our first recommendation. But those will be things like grad school acceptances, employment, and those are the two main ones, grad school acceptance and employment. So we're working on ways to gather that data. so that we can accurately reflect what institutions are doing. Affordability is 20%. That's time to degree. Does it take a student six years to get a four-year degree, or does it take them four years? So we look at that. And credits at completion. Arkansas law says an associate's degree is 60 hours. A bachelor's degree is at 120, with some exceptions. So we look at whether or not a student is graduating with that correct number of hours or if they're hanging out in school for an extra 30 credit hours that they didn't need. So we incentivize efficiency in getting students an affordable education. And then we make a couple of adjustments. We have some institutions in the state, some four-year institutions, who have a research mission. It's part of what they are charged to do. So UAPB does quite a bit of research. Fayetteville does research. Jonesboro does research. So there will be adjustments for those types of institutions to account for that. And then diseconomies of scale for some of our smaller two-year colleges. These are low-enrollment schools, and they still need all of the resources that a bigger school will need. They have to have a registrar, and they have to have financial aid offices. So we do give an adjustment for diseconomies of scale. And then the efficiency portion is a plus or minus 2%, and we look at core expense ratios for that, and that would be a way to signal to our legislature that our institutions are operating efficiently and we are not too administratively bloated and we are doing what you've asked us to do with our money. So that's the reason for that. So I think I've already explained it, But just to tie this back to our master plan, our four big goals are completion, adult enrollment, our attainment gap, and affordability. So all of the metrics that you can look through at your leisure directly address one of those goals. So we have aligned all of that. The following pages, I won't go through all of them, but we have provided about ten examples of what a student might look like with their risk factors, with their degree choices, and how their journey through college might impact the institution that serves them. And I apologize, I think a few of you are missing pictures on the first couple. And just for your information, the squares that represent the points, those are not to scale. They don't represent an actual weight. It's just to give you a visual representation of the areas that institutions would receive credit for those students. For instance, let's flip over to Sophia. And we have her attending ASU Newport, which is a two-year college. she started her journey at 25 which means she is a non-traditional student which is one of our attainment gap age groups she was academically underprepared which means she needed some remediation in both English and math she works full-time throughout her college career so she had to attend on a part-time basis and she ended up graduating with an associate degree in nursing and we also know about Sophia that she is Hispanic and that represents one of our underrepresented minorities. So she has an additional risk factor. So when you flip over to the next page, you can see all of the moments in Sophia's career as a student where she would have garnered points for her institution. Her associate's degree, reaching that degree with risk factors in a high demand field, she reaches seven points, which seven, of course, is not the actual number of points. Progression. So at many points throughout her career, she reached progression points. She had three progression goals, so she got to 15, 30, and 45 hours before she actually reached her degree. With her risk factors, that's 12 points. So you can see there, her progression, she actually got more points for progression than she did credentials. So depending on the student's characteristics, that's where their points will lie. She made it through her gateway courses. She was a remedial student, so she got bonus points for getting through college algebra and her English course. And then she graduated with a correct number of credits at completion so she got points for that too since she was a part-time student the time to degree really didn't apply because she was going at her own pace so that's just one example and that's the only one that I'm going to cover but you can see there are about 10 of students that just run the gamut from their financial situation to their their demographics to their age and their academic preparedness level and what those students chose to pursue as a career and you can see how the institutions would garner points during that process. Before we
▶ Play
move to questions, one thing that I would want to emphasize, in most of the research and looking at other states, you will notice that it's always referenced as outcomes-based education, and there's a good reason why the state of Arkansas's model is is termed as productivity model and it's because of what dr markham just mentioned that there is a waiting uh that's not just tied to i mean obviously our goal is to get students to completion but where you have underrepresented minorities there is a waiting for persistence if this if the average student in that group uh you only makes it through two semesters and they make it through four semesters, there is still a credit to the university or the college for that underrepresented minority persisting towards, hopefully towards graduation. And so some of the different weightings also apply to certificates, associate degrees, and there are a number of other measures that the universities are undertaking that are pretty exciting one program called 15 to finish where they're really encouraging students to and the research shows that a student even a freshman will do better taking 15 credit hours than just taking 12 that gets them to graduation in four years rather than it taking five or six so there's going to be significant savings to the student or to the student's family so at that Mr. Chairman We're open for questions. All right. Representative Sullivan, you
▶ Play
are recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
And I follow a lot of the data here and really appreciate the work. I really appreciate the individual outcomes and how this tracks individual students and really targets their progress. Do you see the guiding principles, including the productivity? Of course, that would change based on the environment. But do you see those guiding principles as applicable to broader populations in public education? Going down to public ed to K-12, for example. Well, I do see that. And one of
▶ Play
the things that I'm going to be coming to this committee later on is the issue of remediation. You know, there are some great models out there. For instance, Henderson State University has a program where they reach down as far as, I believe, the 8th grade in working with some of the local high schools, junior high and high schools, to prepare the students so that they are college-ready, so there is less of a need and hopefully zero need for them to be remediated when they get to the college or university. So I do see some synergy happening, and programs like that are very encouraging to see that kind of partnership taking place.
▶ Play
Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Thank you, Representative Lowry. Representative Walker, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm a little concerned again about the necessity for this bill and what its likely consequences are going to be, in part because we have some institutions that are favored by high-achieving students who are subsidized, in part because of their ACT scores and coming from Texas and other places like that. So it is expected that they are more likely to graduate, especially with the support they get. And some institutions take on the character of Ivy League schools where what goes in comes out. Nobody fails. Hardly anybody fails. So some schools may be regarded as haves, while the others may be regarded as have-nots. So if you were to apply your model in the last five years, is there any way that you can tell me who the losers would be and who the winners would be? And losers include those people who are able to, those institutions that are able to retain, to attract and retain good faculty and pay them well without their salaries going down on the basis of the so-called accountability or whatever you call it. I mean, I'd like to know, is not this a model really for making the weak weaker and the strong stronger rather than addressing the needs of the children where you are taking into account that not everybody can move from Monticello or from Poin or from other small places to Conway, Fayetteville, or Jonesboro.
▶ Play
Speaker 71 31:40
Thank you for that question, Representative Walker, because it gives me an opportunity to explain a little more about the guiding principles for this model. one of the things that has been most important to our group is is representing all institutional missions and protecting access to areas of the state that are not as prosperous or have a higher population of students who have these risk factors and that's the very reason we applied the weights to those types of students so when you look through your your materials that i i gave you you can you can compare a student to um if you want to compare an ivy league student who came in completely prepared, no financial need, academic scholarship, those types of things, with a student who does come in with some need, you'll see that those students that come in with need in various aspects garner far more points for their institution, which equals more money for their institution than those that are easier to educate. So we have been very purposeful about creating a weighting system that did not disincentivize institutions, either two-year or four-year, from effectively serving those populations that reside and typically attend their schools because that's what we have asked them to do. We want them to serve their local communities and their local populations. So, I mean, you haven't seen the actual funding recommendations because we're still working on the model. I can't tell you which school is going to lose or gain today because that has not been finalized. But I can tell you that in the model runs that we have done, as we've seen things fluctuate and we see that we are disincentivizing certain behaviors that we don't want to disincentivize, we've added weightings to those types of students to protect that access to higher education. And
▶ Play
a critical part of that also is the cap on the 2% loss. If there is a campus, as you refer to as a loser campus, that the loss would be minimal per year. And these numbers are based on rolling averages. It's not just a one-time snapshot. it looks at a three-year rolling average, and so the modeling has been done based on that, and they are adjusting, and the weighting is significant towards those underrepresented minorities. So I think that they've really worked very hard in terms of putting this model together where it will be able to benefit all levels of higher education, and two-year colleges, four-year students who are really just wanting some type of a certificate. And I think that the representative examples that she gives of the students also show a cross-section of those types of students. Mr. Walker, did you have
▶ Play
a follow-up? I have. Yes, I do. We have several members in the queue, so let's
▶ Play
remember to be very concise. Well, just a moment. I'll defer to the other members in the queue,
▶ Play
and then you come back to me, if you will. Okay. Representative
▶ Play
De La Rosa, you had a question? Thank you, Madam Chair. The issue that I have with this is that the bill that we're passing is essentially a shell. It does not contain in it any of what this model actually is. It's just top-line information. and i don't see anything in there that says that the final model is going to come before the legislature before it's implemented so what kind of safeguard do we have that something's going to be implemented that we're actually approving because we're we're just we just be approving a shell right now and
▶ Play
that is something that has been discussed and i have been assured that this though this process will be in flux and it will be worked on uh it will come before the legislature for final review but that's
▶ Play
not in the bill would you be willing to put that in the bill I
▶ Play
believe it is covered by covered by policy language and if you You'll give me just a second. Lines 30 through 32 on page 1. The board shall adopt, and this is referring to the Higher Education Coordinating Board, the board shall adopt separate policies for two-year institutions of higher education and four-year institutions of higher education. Okay, go ahead.
▶ Play
Speaker 71 36:24
Any policy that gets adopted by our board is required to come through the APA group for adoption. So that's existing language in law. We can't pass a policy without it coming through legislature.
▶ Play
Who's APA? I don't know what that is. Administrative procedures. The Administrative Procedures Act Okay, so that comes It comes through
▶ Play
the legislature in what form Does it come through as a review After this Has been done, like, you know, the rules Have been promulgated and it comes through ALC And, you know, it's looked through that way Or I guess my question is, is if it's going to Come through The legislature at some point in time when the Model's actually developed why do we have to pass it right now why don't we just pass it when the model comes through and
▶ Play
pass it that way well you have to you have to pass this to switch from the old model to the new model so i mean you're actually it's a significant we don't have the new model well well but it's a significant sea change in terms of what the model applies to the old model applied to just the the students in seats i mean that are actually the enrollment uh so to even get to that point where you're putting together the model, you have to change the general thrust of what the funding would be based on. And one more thing. We don't have the authority
▶ Play
Speaker 71 37:50
to promulgate policy on this until the legislature has approved it. So we have to do this before we can create the policy. Okay. Representative Meek, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I
▶ Play
have a question and follow-up, if that's okay. Okay. All right. Thank you. My first question is and hopefully I'm not putting the cart before the horse here but on the implementation of this because it sounds like there's a lot of points that's going to have to be gathered are you looking at a computer program that's going to gather all these points and is it going to be audited to make sure that it's all done and can be implemented in a cost effective manner and that there's not going to be any tweaking of the points to make our institution maybe look a
▶ Play
little bit better than it's supposed to can you speak to that for my first question well I think that that goes straight to representative de la rosa's question that uh as they do the modeling there and the conversation with the higher ed coordinating board in conjunction with those from the various institutions it will come before the legislature to make sure that that tweaking has not created something totally different from what you're approving today right i'm not talking about the model but i'm talking about the practical
▶ Play
side about when the institutions report okay we've got this many points this year how is that going to be done from a practical standpoint i can i can
▶ Play
Speaker 71 39:10
answer that if you'd like um we have a current student information system that we use and the institutions they input raw data to us they don't they would never report we have a thousand points they would say you know they would turn in their student files we run all the models at the agency level at this point we're able to do that it's very labor intensive we are looking at other programs that could do a better and more efficient job of housing and calculating the information, but we do currently have that, and no, it's not the institution self-reporting what they
▶ Play
think they should have. Okay, good. The second question I have is on this master plan goal that you have. Your goal number two is to increase enrollment of adult students by 50 percent in a year and a half, and I'm all about shooting for the stars, but I'm just wondering how realistic that goal is when you think about the different
▶ Play
Speaker 71 40:02
forms that an adult student could take at especially for a two-year institution which is where we see most of our non-traditional students we think it's realistic it could be a student doing a short-term certificate or coming back to school for some workforce training so we think that it is that's where we are in our attainment gap that's where we are behind other states so that's the goal that we've set for ourselves How many additional students are we talking? I would have to pull the data on that. I'm not sure how many headcounts. And it's not related to this legislation. Right, right, right. But we have some other programs that
▶ Play
are also going to incentivize adult populations returning to school that you'll hear about in the coming weeks. Okay. Yeah, and there's a number of moving parts to that. You know, the lottery scholarship, for instance, sets aside a significant amount of money for nontraditional students. And as someone who, you know, has taught night classes and had a lot of nontraditional students, that's certainly a population that we want to have in college because they're very serious. I mean, you know, they've been out there and they understand, man, I've got to get back and I've got to get more training or I've got to get this diploma. And so it's a very, you're right, it is a lofty
▶ Play
goal, but it's one that's achievable. All right. I look forward to hearing more about
▶ Play
that. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Gates you recognize for a question. Thank you Mr. Chair. So as I understand it this bill if becomes law will change our funding and basically link it to success if roughly 45% of our high school graduates currently require remedial classes. Colleges will be very concerned if school if students come from schools and they are able to see that maybe a school is sending them students that require more remedial classes that they may communicate better to our high schools that a larger percentage of their students maybe are not coming as prepared as what a certificate may indicate will that not also help our our high schools to indicate to them that you're sending us kids that your certificate maybe doesn't really indicate are prepared for college level classes? Is that not a side benefit? Well, absolutely. And I think that that follows up on Representative Sullivan's question earlier is that there is a partnership, a synergy that happens there. You know, one of my concerns has been the cost of remediation, especially at the four-year universities. in most in many of those cases where most of them the students are taking remedial courses but they're not getting any college credit for it and they're they're spending the same amount as if it were a credit earning course many of the four years are actually starting to implement a program i think a co-requisite where the the students take a three-hour course say it's in college algebra but they also have a fourth hour that could uh technically i mean i guess you could look at it as a remediation lab if they're able to be remediated they get the three hours credit whereas in the past if they were just taking a straight remediation course they wouldn't get the credit so so there are some things that are going to be dramatic benefits to the students and what you know we hope certainly that they would be um that they would be college ready that they would be remediated or ready to take those courses and not have to go through the remediation process. One follow-up if I may. Thank you. In Garland County we have several of our high schools that if you started last year as a freshman and took the right courses you could actually graduate from high school with an associate's degree because of their partnering with some of our colleges. How How would students that are high school students that are going through this process, how will this affect their funding, and how will that affect that? Certainly. Thank you for that question as well.
▶ Play
Speaker 71 44:13
Students who are enrolled on a concurrent basis are only represented in our model in a couple of places, so we don't look at those students like typical college students because they don't require the college to invest as many resources. The high school many times are investing those, and they're already being funded through education for that. But we do give credit to the institutions of higher education when those students get to those progression points. So if they get to 15 hours, 30 hours, and if they get a credential. So the example that you mentioned, National Park is partnering with some schools in Hot Springs to do that. So National Park would receive recognition at three different progression points, and then at the credential as well.
▶ Play
Representative Walker, you're recognized for another question. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chair. I'd like for you to explain why it's necessary to go forward today, but that's not my question. I'd like for you to do that as a part of your response. I'm concerned because we're making these judgments on the basis of something being quickly presented without any real evidence that it will change anything or it will help the people who need education the most because it is very clear that when we start looking at the students who are most well-prepared, The ones according to, first of all, in Arkansas, hardly anybody is well-prepared because according to the results of the test, all of the people, two-thirds of the people who took the last test for academic achievement failed those tests. I mean, that's one reason we stopped the test and then we know that the students who are in the south and the east don't finish high school as much as the ones in the north and west and we know that the ones in the south and east are more poor than the ones who are in the north and west and while you may factor those things in It is a real problem in trying to bring about equity and fairness, especially when you're trying to uplift everybody in the state. And the other concern that I have is somehow or another here. We are favoring college education in four years when several models now exist that show that four years are not necessary to be very successful. and I bring to your attention Zuckerberg and Gates who have outachieved almost everybody without four years of college and finally we sit around this table and I don't know how many people are college graduates but at some point I'd like for us to just look at this college thing for what it is not all of us are college graduates in fact I suspect that less than 50% are and there's no correlation in terms of our success as legislators. Can you get to the question? Well, the question is, yes, I will, but I want to finish that preface. Here we are talking about the value of education. We know that it has some value, but we haven't seen what its value in Arkansas is. Now, my question is, how is this going to improve the value of education and the benefits of our students other than by giving them perhaps more, at least giving the institutions better recognition as better institutions by saying that they do better than others, always ranking people. How does that profit our state by calling some schools, highlighting that they are failures, and others by highlighting that they are rewards when they already have all of the attributes of
▶ Play
reward to begin with? Representative Walker, education is always entertaining. connected to to economic issues and uh you know study after study has given us information of earning capacity based on your progress in education whether there's a certain level of earning capacity if you receive a ged a certain uh earning potential if you receive high school diploma to your degree for your degree so this is going to be you know whatever the level that the student is able to achieve, this model is going to incentivize that for the universities to make sure that the students are able to reach those critical markers so that they are able to have greater earning potential. In part, to also answer your question of why we're making this change is that there is plenty of evidence that this particular shift in model does work in other states that are very similar uh to to arkansas and we like to think that arkansas is very unique but there are a lot of uh characteristics that are similar the study the tennessee and the indiana study credit accumulation in both two and four year sectors in tennessee there was an increase overall the students do significantly better under this model but the the significant part i think to your question is that there's positive impact on many of the metrics for full-time pell students and underrepresented minorities and I think that the the work that's already taken place in the modeling properly weights that and make sure that there is inclusion for all categories of our universities and I think that the issue also of capping by 2% the amount of loss really different I mean it takes away I think that that attitude of saying that there are winners and there are losers because you are giving the university or the campus an opportunity without a dramatic downturn in any one given year to be able to adopt programs that will be able to be properly weighted so that they are able to achieve just as well as the other campuses. Did you have any kind of
▶ Play
follow-up? I have four more people in line to do questions, and we're going to try to move off of this if that's
▶ Play
okay with everybody. Representative Hodges, you're recognized. thank you Mr. Chair I just for clarification you said that that the overall higher ed pie so to speak is limited to a two percent increase every year but a single institution is not
▶ Play
Speaker 71 50:56
correct thank you for that question two percent would be the maximum increase in total education higher education funding that we asked for but that two percent would then be allocated to those who had a productivity increase so that two percent would be allocated out among those who performed very well so an individual institution
▶ Play
Speaker 116 51:13
would get their share of that two percent and it could be much more than two percent
▶ Play
quick follow-up if you don't you're welcome so then for example for a single institution that has really done well under this system that say does get a 10 percent increase under this scenario i guess what is it that the institution has done is it that in 2016 when we added up all this institution's points they had this level and then the next year or three years from then we add up that institution's points and it's they have 10 percent more points do they get 10 percent more funding or how exactly i guess would an institution do
▶ Play
Speaker 71 51:49
let me walk backwards from that they would get um yeah 10 percent of that two percent increase that we requested for higher ed if if there was a two percent overall increase the way we would um look at their productivity increase, we're using three-year rolling averages, and we're comparing three years to the next three years. So in any one year, a dramatic increase or decrease will not likely impact a school significantly because we smooth that out over those two, three-year rolling averages. Representative
▶ Play
De La Rosa, you're recognized for a
▶ Play
question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I've got actually a question for both ends of the table. First of all, for for this end of the table um we don't have the model right now but yet we're referencing what the model is going to do you know the model will do this much so is there a model or is there not at this point in time like where where are we in the development of this because you're speaking like there is a model and and it's going to do this and this and this but yet we don't have
▶ Play
Speaker 71 52:54
a model to to look at certainly thank you representative del rosa and i'll just refer you back to some of the materials that I gave you not everything is going to be in the bill obviously but you can see let me see which is the best one to look at all of the components of the model are on this graphic so you can see what percentage of funds are linked to what types of productivity and what is made up within that so that's the very broadest view and then as you flip back through that it gets more specific so the pieces of the pieces we start high level and we go down so yes this has all been determined and this will be part of the policy that you approve not today but later on um so the model is in place but we're still in the data collection process we're making sure that we have correct data for all the institutions before we make a recommendation on funding have the schools seen this yes the schools have been helping us um work on this for the last almost two years we've had a large representation of all types of institutions i've presented to the presidents and chancellors on a couple of occasions dr powell did before i did the chief academic officers have seen all of it so and the registrars so people in research academics and finance have all been on board okay um
▶ Play
if if i may ask a question at this end of the table i might ask one across the table too just to be just you know to be fair everywhere um i have a question for staff so just to understand the procedure of exactly what we're doing what we're authorizing what the procedure is going to be going for i want to make sure that i'm not authorizing something that we're going to come back and we're going to be locked into later on and we we can't change anything we don't have any more power because i've had that happen before where you say yeah yeah later on y'all can change it and then it turns out all we can do is rubber stamp something so i'd like to know what the process would be as this flows through with policy
▶ Play
how this would flow through our system we have to have legislation so they can go forward with this policy that they're working on their plan and then once that plan they'll put all the fine details into it that are not in what you're seeing today that will go before rules and for policy they'll make their policy then it'll go before rules and regs and that
▶ Play
will be passed from there so rules and regs will be the ultimate decision makers on yes this model not the education
▶ Play
committee no no ma'am rules and regs is
▶ Play
the final and when when would that be approximately
▶ Play
Speaker 168 55:21
it would depend representative de la rosa on when the agency promulgates the policies and forwards them to the appropriate staff of the bureau to get on the rules and regs agenda i would anticipate it would be sometime in the fall but that's dr markham may have a better timeline about that than i do we
▶ Play
Speaker 71 55:37
plan to present our proposed policies to our board in april and once our board sees those then they will come over for the governor's office and the legislature to take through the rules process so i'm not sure what the meeting schedule is for that well it'll be during the interim
▶ Play
so we just would set it up yeah that we meet monthly so it can be
▶ Play
anytime that they're ready and it gets on the agenda but it would be rules and regs committee not education committee that determines yeah an education funding i just want to be clear i want I want
▶ Play
to know where this is going to proceed. I would, Mr. Chair, I would assume that it would be allowable for Department of Higher Ed to make a presentation to the Joint Committees of Education so that. And it can, but Mark's
▶ Play
going to give you a little input on how that works.
▶ Play
Speaker 168 56:26
Representative De La Rosa, there have been occasions where rules and regs will refer a proposed regulation or policy to a standing committee for its review and input prior to their final consideration of a rule and regulation. That certainly is a possibility here. If they get that formula and look at it and have questions, they may refer it to the Joint Education Committees for their input back to the Rules and Regulations Subcommittee of Council before they make a final decision. Again, ma'am, that's certainly a possibility. I won't tell you that it's going to happen, but it's certainly possible that that could do it.
▶ Play
Speaker 3 56:58
That's up to Rules and Regs. We meet monthly also. Okay. Any other questions from you? Thank you. Representative Vaught, do
▶ Play
you have a question? Thank you, Mr. Chair. I have
▶ Play
a motion at a proper time. I already have someone with
▶ Play
a motion, so let me get through my question. Representative Beck. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I probably should first apologize to my seatmates. I've got paperwork scattered all over here. We've gotten quite a bit of data today at one point here. And I also apologize for not being better prepared, and maybe you've covered this question. But if a student needed remediation And I'm assuming it goes under this This 80% in the model I guess I'm unclear as to how That student If I took a student that needed remediation And then that student progressed through I would get some kind of points And then if I took that student And they didn't make it through I would get some type of points So I'll just go on a little further, because my point is this, what would keep, if the matrix wasn't right, what would keep a university from not recruiting students from certain school districts that aren't completers? And by doing that, they would actually be hurting the individuals that this bill claims to help, or the model would claim to help. Thank you, Representative
▶ Play
Speaker 71 58:28
Beck, for that question. I think first we have to realize that all of our institutions, four and two-year, they have different admission standards already. So we have some institutions in the state that it's not their mission to serve remedial students, and they already require a higher level of ACT score and GPA to get in. So it's not likely that they're going to begin recruiting remedial students based on this model. However, we have some institutions that that's central to their mission. We have an open admission for your institution in the state that that's part of their role in our state to take students who are academically underprepared our two-year schools 80 percent of their students have remedial needs and that's their population in their local community so there are incentive there are incentives in place to serve remedial students and serve them well so there are several places within the model that those remedial students will show up for institutions who do have that as part of their mission to serve them when they get to those progression points not only do they get a progression point they get a weighted progression point because we recognize that the institution has invested more in that student over time. Their credentials are weighted a little more heavily. When they get through their gateway courses, their entry-level freshman courses, they get more weights because that is a risk factor. So they start out remedial. We look at them when they start. So once you had an academic under-preparedness notation, you are always considered more at risk. So that institution serving them well would be highly incentivized to continue to serve those students but to do a good job with those students.
▶ Play
Speaker 169 59:57
Follow-up? You're recognized. So you're saying
▶ Play
that this is not going to really affect these individual institutions as to working with students with remediation? Yes, no? You're saying that students who don't take them now probably aren't going to take them? I don't believe
▶ Play
Speaker 71 1:00:18
that it will because institutions who are set up for remedial students are prepared to handle those remedial students. So we're incentivizing those to continue, and we're funding them to continue, whereas institutions that are not are not going to invest significant resources to attract those students.
▶ Play
Thank you. Okay, you're sneaking in there after I told you four was it. All right, Representative Gill, you're
▶ Play
recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. One question. Did I not hear a statement that says not everything is in the bill? Did I hear that? Will we be voting on a bill where there's something missing? Help me.
▶ Play
The only thing that is not in this are the specific weightings. You've heard the report from Dr. Markham about those weightings, but as far as the detail of how each different category of student is weighted to provide the funding, That specific information cannot be developed until we pass the legislation and then rules are promulgated. But then they will come back. And I think what Mark Hudson said is probably likely that rules and regs would refer this to the Joint Committee on Education so you would get a full report on this, on what those weightings are, before it would go for review.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:01:56
Thank you. okay last question very very quick thank you can i get your commitment that this education committee will see this final model before it goes into effect because that's my issue here is that we are handing this off and it's going to go through someone else and the people on rules and regs are not going to care about my schools the way that i care about my school so i want to make sure that i still have voice in that and i feel like i'm i'm handing that off right now so as long as i'm i know at some point in time i'm going to see this again with it filled in before it becomes final then then i'm comfortable with it but i i want that i want some sort of
▶ Play
commitment that that's that that will occur i i will certainly make the commitment that i will go directly to the chair of rules and regs and ask that when this comes before them that they refer it to the joint committee so that you get to hear it before it's actually reviewed and finalized. Can the Department of
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:02:52
Higher Ed show it to us in a committee meeting prior to it even go under rules and regs?
▶ Play
Speaker 192 1:02:58
I believe Representative Davis can speak to that.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:03:02
Hey, I did get to ask a question across
▶ Play
the table. Look at that. So just as the former rules and regs chair of ALC, if any member ever requests that a rule be sent to the subject matter committee for review prior to review by rules and regs. I can imagine a chairman ever not doing that. The rules are available prior to rules and regs committee meetings. You can talk to the rules and regs committee staff, and they can provide those as well as their summaries of the rules. The request could also be made in the full AOC committee that it be sent to a subject matter committee prior to final approval by AOC. so I can't just in my experience I can't imagine a situation where it would not be sent here for
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:03:49
review okay I'm not on ALC so I can't make that request but you could make I could make the request
▶ Play
Speaker 197 1:03:55
of the chair though I will make the request I should
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:03:58
be on that easy to do okay all right as long as I got try to make that commitment that at some point in time I will see this again that that that's what I'm looking for right now it gives me a much more uh
▶ Play
better comfort level with it thank you all right seeing no more questions on the at the table, is there anyone in the audience like to speak against the bill? You want to speak against the bill? Alright, you are recognized to go to the end of the table and speak against the bill. Please state your name and
▶ Play
who you're with and then you're recognized. Good afternoon, I mean, good morning. My name is Annie Bryant I am a parent and grandparent in the Dalloway School District in Pine Bluff, Arkansas And I'm speaking against this bill I haven't had the opportunity to read it And I apologize for that, but I will go back and read it But the reason that I'm against this bill is as I've sat here and listened to you discuss the bill From what I understand, this bill is going to lead to a segregation and a grouping of people who look like me, who live in communities like my community, into certain universities and certain areas who may not have the same amount of resources as others. And I see that as a problem because many of the people from my community who may not be that first choice that you would choose for the upper level educational places, it's not by their choice. there's an inequity in education in our communities and we are being doubly punished and I would ask all of you to look very closely at it and think about that. Thank you. Thank you. Does anyone in the audience
▶ Play
like to speak for the bill? Against? you want to
▶ Play
Speaker 101 1:06:31
close for your bill yes mr. chair thank you i know this is probably taking a lot
▶ Play
longer than we had anticipated but it's a very complex uh issue and the reason it's so complex is because it is going to be a significant step forward for the students and the state of arkansas i think it is um i know that there are others out there that could have spoken in favor of this bill and I hope I'm not speaking out of school, but since this has been in press accounts, I know Dr. Bobbitt with the U of A system has given his full support of it. I know Dr. Welch has also spoken positively of the work that he's done towards this, and I know some representatives have actually talked to the folks in their communities with their local colleges, and the Community College Association, I know Mr. Stovall is here, and they have also been involved in this and support this change. So I appreciate your time, your patience, and I make a motion to pass. As amended. As amended, thank you.
▶ Play
All right, we have a motion. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no. No. Motion passes. Congratulations. next we're going to go to house bill 1030 represent bentley you are recognized to take the end of the table and present your short bill we have some information we're going to pass out among you if anybody has any more questions about representative lowry's bill i'm sure there'll be someone to be glad to explain some more of that to you while they're Passing that out. Representative Bentley, I see you have some people joining you at the table. If you would go ahead and have them introduce themselves, then that way they can speak at any time they need to. Push
▶ Play
Speaker 211 1:08:56
those buttons, please. Thank you, Chairman. I'd be happy
▶ Play
to. Maurice Rigsby, UAMS. I'm Tammy Henson. I'm the Administrator for the Rural Practice
▶ Play
Program. Representative Bentley, you are recognized to present your bill.
▶ Play
Thank you, Chairman. Thank you, colleagues. Totally different subject for you guys to look at today, but I think it's very good for us to bring this to the education community for you guys to understand the significance of the lack of physicians in rural Arkansas. This bill is really an adjustment to a bill that's been around here for a little while, but as we can see with many legislations passed, we need to make some tweaks and make some changes because we have unintended consequences on legislation that we pass, and this is really to fix some unintended consequences is the crux of the bill. So before we get started, I've got Tammy Henson with me from UAMS, and she's going to give us a brief overview of the Community Match Grant, why we have it. You guys have a map that shows you needed areas. We have another handout that shows you how many physicians you have in each area in your counties, and then also a brief overview from the UAMS on what the program does. So we're going to try and keep this short, but we're also going to use this opportunity to give you guys a little education on the Community Match Grant in Arkansas. So we'll give Tammy a few minutes. Maurice is going to give us a brief history and I'll come back for
▶ Play
to show you the overview of the bill thank you thank you for allowing us to be here this morning just a brief overview the the community match program it was changed in 2007 to where we would have physicians leaving residency and going into qualified rural communities it's primarily for primary care there are eight different fields in which they can practice, and it's been expanded over several years, but it's family medicine, internal medicine, pediatrics, med-peds, OBGYN, general surgery, ER, and geriatrics. And for going to work in a qualified community, they receive $20,000 per year for a total of $80,000.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:10:59
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. As a matter of history, when Commissioner Key and Shane Broadway were in the legislature in 2007, there were major changes that happened to this law. The Community Match Program was created in 1995. 1995 changes to it. And so in 2007, what happened was during that time, I was the staff person for the ALC litigation subcommittee. And so what was happening then was medical students were being provided funds by communities and the state to make a commitment to go into rural communities. But in 2007, the General Assembly realized that there were a lot of defaults, and the Attorney General's office was defending a lot of lawsuits. And so what was happening was the students were being paid to go through medical school. They made the commitment, and once they graduated, they kept past the communities on to somewhere out of state. And so that left the communities and the state on the hook for funds. and with the responsibility of trying to track down these students. And so this was a double whammy on the rural communities. They were out of the money and then they weren't able to recruit the physicians they needed for their communities. So in 2007, the law was changed by the General Assembly to place the funding on the back end. So once the graduate completed a residency program, they at that point made the commitment with the up to two years to go into the community. So that was a four-year commitment. And so that was a more beneficial process for the communities. And so the legislature again was really concerned about kind of how these communities would be and didn't want them to be in the lurch. So in 2007, 2009, the law was really tightened to make sure that there wouldn't be any defaults. And so there was really strict language that was put in place at that time. And so for the change that Representative Bentley is making today is to make sure that those incentives, that incentive income for rural physicians can be extended to a different segment of the graduate population. Okay, so as
▶ Play
we can see, the bill in 2007 did a great job. No longer are we having these physicians leaving the boat. They're going to the community. There really has not been any defaults since they made the changes in 2007, but there was one little group of folks that were not included, and so this bill, if you look on page 7, lines 13 through 17, is really what we're trying to address in this bill for the main part. so if a student is a graduate of one of your high schools and decides that they want to do part of their med school in the caribbean or somewhere and then comes back to america and goes into the residency for uams and then wants to go to their community hospital they're not allowed to do that because they didn't go to a board certified i'm a hospital that was in excuse me a med school that was in the united states they did part of their med school out of the country so because of that they were not able to go back to the rural community where they grew up so we're doing And this is very narrow, very strict, and all it does is there, it allows a resident of Arkansas and a citizen of the United States prior to enrollment in the foreign medical school and has been licensed by the Arkansas State Medical Board to be allowed to be a part of the community match grant. So we're saying folks that went to school here, graduated from their local high school, did part of their med school in a foreign med school, came back to the United States, was board certified, they're going to be allowed to be a part of this community match grant. And I know five students right now out of the Fort Smith area That is going to affect so this is going to affect All of us as you can see that we really Need these primary care doctors Back in the rural communities and so As we were going in there to address This one issue there were some other small Issues that were in the bill that need to Be addressed as well to help The board that does The community match grant to be able to Do exactly what they wanted to do so we just Tighten up a few things but this on page Seven is the biggest thing that we're Trying to address in this bill so So at that point, I'll just take any questions that anybody might have on what we've presented so far.
▶ Play
Representative Vaught, you're recognized for a question. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair. And you may have said this, and I might have missed it, but how will we know if the school in a different country is comparable to our school in the United States and that they'll be getting the same type of education and can do the same things here that they could
▶ Play
do there? Yeah, and that's why we have UMS on board to help us because they have to be certified by Arkansas State Board. So
▶ Play
we'll let Tammy address that a little bit as well. Thank you. There are certain benchmarks when you're in medical school. You have to pass certain, they're called step exams, and as long as you pass those, the Arkansas State Medical Board will issue you a license. So they're pretty equal, so if you pass those, then you're qualified. Follow-up, please. You're recognized. Thank you. So will they pass a test here or just the test there? They have to take the American. Thank you. That's what I want to make sure of.
▶ Play
Thank you. And I want to briefly say there's absolutely no opposition by the medical board, state medical
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:16:43
board, on this at all. Representative De La Rosa, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Where does the money from this come from? I mean, I see it says it's loan and scholarship. Scholarship implies money being given. Where does that money come from? That's one
▶ Play
of the things we're trying to clean up in the bill. Well, initially when the program was first started, they were given the money as a loan. And as they worked in the community, it was converted to a scholarship so that they wouldn't have to repay the money. It's only considered a loan if they default. But in this new program that started in 2007, they received no money up front. So there's no loan, there's no scholarship. It's basically if you go and work in a qualified community, you receive $20,000 a year. Every quarter, it's paid out $5,000 a quarter. But you don't receive the money until you actually do the order.
▶ Play
And let me address that real quick for you. $10,000 comes from general revenue, and $10,000 comes from the hospital that they're
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:17:43
going to. Yeah, it's a community match. All right. That's what it's a community match. I didn't see a fiscal
▶ Play
impact study for this, so that's why I'm curious. Only on K-12 has fiscal impacts.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:17:53
Anything in higher ed does not have to have it. Okay.
▶ Play
But this affects general revenue. This is not changing anything at all. No change in that whatsoever It's only addressing the one fact That if you go to part of your medical school In a foreign medical school You can come back I just didn't know
▶ Play
Speaker 234 1:18:09
if it had any monetary impact There's absolutely no change
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:18:12
in that It's not increasing the expenditures for the program It will be the same that's been appropriated previously Okay, thank you Representative
▶ Play
Davis, you recognize Thank you, Mr. Chairman Representative Bentley if the goal is to get new doctors to go into rural areas why don't we limit this to people who are from arkansas i mean if moralton needs a primary care physician why don't we care if they're from arkansas or tennessee or
▶ Play
okay if you look at the whole bill that can be from another state we're only saying that we want to uh allow this one exception for residents of arkansas to go to a foreign medical school but if you go to school in tennessee and you want to come to arkansas worker you can still get the community match grant we're just saying for those folks that go to a foreign medical school uh those folks have to be from arkansas and a u.s resident beforehand but it's still a number of students uh that's one of
▶ Play
the questions why i mean if a kid from tennessee went to a foreign medical school came back got licensed to practice in arkansas um did a residency at uams i mean why not let them use it too i mean wouldn't that just increase your pool of people that you could
▶ Play
have incentivized? Well, the reason that we're trying to narrowly define it is because we have a lot of people in our residency programs that are from other countries like India or Pakistan or Italy, but their goal is not to stay here. They're here to get a residency, but if they can spend an extra four years and knock $80,000 off of their educational debt, they're going to stay for four years, and then they're going back home. I've spent a lot of time in the residency programs, and I've talked with them, and every one of them want to go home. They don't want to stay here. So if we open it up to non-Arkansas residents, the odds of them staying here are very slim. So we really just want it to be. Staying more than four years. Correct. Our long-term goal is to have them stay here long-term
▶ Play
and complete their plans. I understand that's a goal, but four years
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:20:13
is four years, right? Yes. Representative Davis, I think it's a great question and I think it's something that we need to discuss in the future. Representative Bentley introduced the interim study last summer, and we went before ALC, and some of those questions actually came up. And I think trying to define the universe in a very narrow way is also based on the appropriation, the funding that's available to make sure that we can, based on the applications, fund the ones that we do have. So I think your question is very important for the future discussion to talk about expanding so again this was a kind of a compromise to get this sliver through but what you're saying is a right and appropriate and should be discussed with this body and i'm sure we will be talking about that further let me let me just say this andy i appreciate your thought the point is right
▶ Play
now we have much more residents than we have money so i would love to increase the funding because we really do need to increase the funding really put put our money where our mouth when we're 49th in the nation for access to care in Arkansas. But right now, that's all the money that we've got. We have more students right now than we can even fund. So I added this a little bit to hopefully get a few more folks out there, but we're going to have to increase the funding before we're going to add any more residents. So at this point, we have much more applicants than we have money. So until we can get some more money, I didn't see the need to add any more at this point, but I'd love to add more down the road for sure if we can find some more money. Okay. All right. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Sullivan, you're recognized for a question
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. How would this impact the School of Osteopathy at ASU? Are they included in that? Yeah, they're
▶ Play
both included ASU and the one in Fort Smith I
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:21:56
think Tammy has numbers because there are DO graduates that are participating in the community match program already so this is after they've graduated, after they've completed the residency program, so there have been DOs, I think, who have been in the community match program and completed the match program around the
▶ Play
state as well. Okay, thank you. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chair. Representative Gates is recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. One, I represent small communities, and when those small communities lose their schools because they've fallen below the threshold, their sense of community goes away, and then it's harder to attract young professionals because they don't want to put their kid on a bus and bus them 45 minutes to school. So if we don't do those things that incentivize. So I think this is good in incentivizing them. Will this, I had a friend that had a hard time getting to a medical school, so some of them go to the Caribbean, some of them go to Mexico places because their universities may have openings where some of ours may not have openings. So this just doesn't – it opens it up so that we maybe have Arkansas students who have been waiting to get into med school, haven't had a slot, so they choose to go somewhere else. And when they go somewhere else, this just keeps them being from precluded.
▶ Play
You're exactly right. Okay. Thank you. President Walker, I thought you wasn't going to do it. Thank you. Let's be clear. This is not a bill to improve access to healthcare. Rather, it is to prevent default with respect to the state participation in financing the likelihood of a person staying and providing healthcare to the people of underserved communities. Is that right?
▶ Play
I would really have to disagree with you because I had residents contacting me that wanted to go to their rural Go back to their rural roots and serve in their rural hospital And they could not because the bill as it was without this change that I'm making now So I'm sorry I have to disagree with you on that, Representative Walker But I know of five residents that would love to go back to their rural hospital And this will help them to get there to be able to afford
▶ Play
to get there And also, Ms. Maurice would like to address that as well. Thank you Before he does, I would like to address the question of funding Isn't it true that the funding for these rural areas, and I must certainly point out that most of the people in underserved communities happen to be of a different race than I. So the people who are not being served in Newton County and places like that have the same needs for health care as those people who live in Washington County and Pulaski County and Garland County. So has the budget, have we improved or increased the budget to allow more physicians in rural areas across the state in the last few years? I'd like to know just, first of all, what it is and whether or not we should address that without trying to make sure, first, that we prevent default.
▶ Play
Right now it's about $356,000 per year. I'll let Tammy address that because she's more in tune with
▶ Play
the exact numbers on that, Representative Walker. That's fine. $356,000 allows 35 doctors.
▶ Play
No, every year we can accept 13 people in the program based on the money that we are provided. Well,
▶ Play
this is really so minimal until it doesn't have any possibility of benefiting any large number of people. Reverend Walker, that's really not what
▶ Play
this bill is about. Yeah, we can only fund as many physicians as we have funding. I mean, we only have enough money to fund 13 physicians
▶ Play
every year. Here's my question. Yes, certainly. Those 13, where are
▶ Play
they? Well, we have, I track about 200 physicians, and they're all over the state. Where are
▶ Play
the 13 that you fund right now?
▶ Play
Oh, they're in medical school. And then we have two programs in the Arkansas Rural Practice Program. One, we give funding to physicians coming into medical school, and when they leave residency, they choose where they want to go and practice. The other program, which is the one we're talking about today, is a community match, and they choose their community when they're going into practice, and that's when they receive them.
▶ Play
My question is the same. Where do they go? I'd like to know the counties to which they go. Can we get that for you? You really need that today. Well, the reason I'd like
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:26:43
to have it is so that we can. That's something they probably don't have on them. Representative Walker, I think the important thing is, as I mentioned before, the 2007 and 2009 acts were to prevent default this um act here is to to expand the opportunities for other medical graduates to be able to go to the communities but also representative bentley's goal was to to create education with the isp and today so that we can all have a full awareness of what we need to do to increase our medical workforce in rural and other underserved areas So, again, she decided not to run the bill last week so that more of you could be here and so we can have a better audience to really socialize this information so we can really work in a collaborative way like Representative Davis articulated earlier. So I understand what you're saying, and we want to expand it. So I think this is the opportunity to start that process to looking at those areas. Hey, I'm from Nevada County, and you know that we don't have a hospital there. My mother still lives there. So I understand what you're saying. And so I want to make sure that we can, in a proactive way, address your needs, address what Representative Davis said, and also achieve what Representative Bentley is working on as well. Thank you. Representative Meek, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Okay, I'll hold that for now. Any other questions from the table? No other questions? Anyone from the audience would like to speak against the bill? For the bill? Would you like
▶ Play
to close for your bill? I appreciate this opportunity to bring further awareness to the need that we have for rural physicians in Arkansas. I appreciate you guys, your time today, and let's just make this the beginning of a discussion that we really need to have in our state to increase funding to help get more rural physicians out there. And I appreciate that opportunity, and thank you all
▶ Play
so much for the time today. Rick Zimbeek. Motion, do pass. I have a motion, do pass. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? Motion passes. Thank you, and congratulations. All right, before we leave, just a couple of things. We will have a meeting on Thursday. I'm not sure what bills will run, but if you have a bill that's on the table or on the agenda, be prepared to run it if you're going to be here. I also have a bill up here that was from Representative Broadway last year. brought away she ran a bill for the brighter better futures program and better futures high school program with what we're doing with that since she's not a representative I told her I would help her get this going and we're just combining those two and changing a little language to clean up language if anybody would like to sign on to it I do have the sheet here anything any other information or from anyone without objections we're adjourned
▶ Play

Agenda

HB1020 Love TO CREATE THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY PROMISE LOTTERY SCHOLARSHIP PROGRAM; TO PROVIDE FUNDS TO EVERY CHILD BORN IN ARKANSAS TO BE USED FOR COLLEGE TUITION.

HB1030 Bentley TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS RURAL MEDICAL PRACTICE STUDENT LOAN AND SCHOLARSHIP PROGRAM AND THE COMMUNITY MATCH RURAL PHYSICIAN RECRUITMENT PROGRAM TO IMPROVE AND INCREASE ACCESS TO HEALTH CARE IN MEDICALLY UNDERSERVED COMMUNITIES.

1:07:41 - 10:41

HB1042 B. Smith TO PROHIBIT SANCTUARY POLICIES AT STATE-SUPPORTED INSTITUTIONS OF HIGHER EDUCATION.

HB1056 House TO ALLOW THE SUPERINTENDENT OF A STUDENT'S RESIDENT SCHOOL DISTRICT TO WAIVE THE REQUIREMENT THAT THE STUDENT ATTEND PUBLIC SCHOOL FOR ONE (1) ACADEMIC YEAR TO BE ELIGIBLE FOR A SUCCEED SCHOLARSHIP.

HB1154 Cozart TO REQUIRE THAT ANY INCREASES IN PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT FUNDING EACH SCHOOL YEAR BE USED FOR PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT COMMUNITIES.

HB1155 Cozart TO AMEND THE MINIMUM TEACHER COMPENSATION SCHEDULE.

HB1209 Lowery TO ADOPT A PRODUCTIVITY-BASED FUNDING MODEL FOR STATE-SUPPORTED INSTITUTIONS OF HIGHER EDUCATION.

10:41 - 1:08

SB10 L. Chesterfield TO AMEND THE PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING GOVERNING BOARDS OF TECHNICAL COLLEGES; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY

1:08 - 1:29:39 309 segments 31 speakers

PENDING FISCAL IMPACT Number Subtitle Sponsor

HB1019 Cozart TO AMEND THE MEMBERSHIP OF THE SCHOOL LEADERSHIP COORDINATING COUNCIL.

HB1208 Lowery TO ALLOW A STUDENT WHO ATTENDS A PRIVATE SCHOOL OR A HOME SCHOOL TO ENROLL IN AN ACADEMIC COURSE WITHIN THE PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES.

HB1222 Dotson THE ARKANSAS PARENTAL EMPOWERMENT FOR EDUCATION CHOICE ACT OF 2017; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

DEFERRED

Number Sponsor Subtitle

HB1002 McElroy TO REGULATE EQUIPMENT REQUIRED FOR SCHOOL BUSES; TO REQUIRE THAT CERTAIN SCHOOL BUSES BE EQUIPPED WITH SEAT BELTS; AND TO ENFORCE THE USE OF SEAT BELTS ON SCHOOL BUSES EQUIPPED WITH SEAT BELTS.

HB1017 Cozart TO ALLOW THE TEACHER FAIR DISMISSAL ACT OF 1983 TO BE WAIVED IF A PUBLIC SCHOOL OR PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT IS UNDER STATE AUTHORITY AFTER BEING CLASSIFIED AS BEING IN DISTRESS.

HB1027 Eubanks TO PROHIBIT A SCHOOL DISTRICT FROM USING PUBLIC FUNDS TO PAY A TEACHER'S OR CLASSIFIED EMPLOYEE'S MEMBERSHIP DUES INA PROFESSIONAL ORGANIZATION.

HB1029 Lowery TO EXCLUDE PRINCIPALS, ASSISTANT PRINCIPALS, AND CENTRAL OFFICE EMPLOYEES WITH A MULTIYEAR EMPLOYMENT CONTRACT FROM THE DEFINITION OF "TEACHER" UNDER THE TEACHER FAIR DISMISSAL ACT OF 1983.

HB1036 K. Hendren TO PROHIBIT THE USE BY A STUDENT OF A PORTABLE ELECTRONIC DEVICE IN PUBLIC SCHOOL; AND TO ESTABLISH A SECURE, DESIGNATED AREA WITHIN A SCHOOL WHERE A STUDENT WILL DEPOSIT HIS OR HER PERSONAL ELECTRONIC DEVICE DURING THE SCHOOL DAY.

HB1044 F. Allen TO ALLOW A STUDENT TO CHOOSE WHICH GRADE IN WHICH TO TAKE THE COLLEGE AND CAREER READINESS ASSESSMENT.

Page 2 of 2

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Bruce Cozart Chair Unverified
36 segments
Speaker 3
2 segments
Senator Linda Chesterfield Unverified
14 segments
Speaker 12
1 segment
Representative John W. Walker Unverified
30 segments
Representative Dan M. Douglas Unverified
6 segments
Representative Mickey Gates Chair Unverified
55 segments
Representative Stephen Meeks Unverified
30 segments
Speaker 5
1 segment
Speaker 67
2 segments
Speaker 71
49 segments
Speaker 42
1 segment
Speaker 70
1 segment
Representative Dan Sullivan Unverified
4 segments
Chair Unverified
37 segments
Representative Grant Hodges Chair Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 116
1 segment
Speaker 168
2 segments
Representative DeAnn Vaught Unverified
3 segments
Representative Rick Beck Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 169
1 segment
Representative Gill Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 192
1 segment
Representative Andy Davis Unverified
6 segments
Speaker 197
1 segment
Annie Bryant Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 101
1 segment
Speaker 211
1 segment
Representative Justin Gonzales Chair Unverified
15 segments
Speaker 234
1 segment