State Agencies & Govt'l Affairs
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (19)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1009
· 5 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1009 Leding TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING APPROVED POLITICAL ACTIO…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1207
· 5 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1207 Dalby TO AMEND REQUIREMENTS FOR CAMPAIGN SIGNS AND MATERIAL…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1015
· 4 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “I just wanted to let you know that House Bill 1015, I will run at”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1047
· 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1047 Lowery TO REQUIRE THAT A VOTER PROVIDE VERIFICATION OF VOTE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1258
· 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “So we're not moving that to deferred. House Bill 1258, so we are not moving that to deferred. And Representative…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1270
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…ll 1015, House Bill 1047, House Bill 1207, House Bill 1258, House Bill 1270, and that's it. All the rest of them will be moved to the d…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1004
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1004 Blake TO CREATE THE DEMOCRACY ACT; TO REQUIRE AUTOMATIC VOT…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1005
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1005 Tucker TO REQUIRE REPORTING AND DISCLOSURE OF ELECTIONEERIN…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1008
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1008 Tucker TO INCREASE THE PENALTY FOR TAKING CAMPAIGN FUNDS AS…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1010
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1010 Sabin TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE PUBLICATION OF CERTAI…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1011
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1011 Sabin TO ACTION AMEND COMMITTEE PROVISIONS POLITICAL CONCER…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1012
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1012 Sabin TO AMEND PROVISIONS CONCERNING POLITICAL ACTION COMMI…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1046
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1046 Tucker TO PERMIT PAID MATERNITY LEAVE FOR STATE EMPLOYEES.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1065
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1065 Watson PERMITTING THE ARKANSAS COMMISSION ON LAW ENFORCEMEN…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1151
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1151 Davis TO REQUIRE THAT REGISTERED VOTERS BE NOTIFIED BY MAIL…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1178
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1178 Gray TO MAKE A TECHNICAL CORRECTION CONCERNING THE AUTHORIT…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1179
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1179 Ballinger TO DESIGNATED AMEND BENEFITS PROVISIONS PROVIDING…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1224
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1224 Wardlaw TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE LIMITATION ON CANDI…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HJR1001
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HJR1001 Ballinger APPLYING TO THE UNITED STATES CONGRESS TO CALL A…”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 14, 2026
The first item of business is for us to take a committee photo. So I think we'll go ahead and get started. I heard the photographer say that we're going to have individuals seated on this side and standing behind, everybody behind them and some seated. Okay, so if all the committee members, the state agency's committee would move over to this side of the committee, we'll go ahead and get started. I know we have a couple
of people who are missing. I just don't know if there's a more convenient time to do it than today. Yes. Yeah, and I'd say just let's listen to him. Thank you. Thank you.
All right, if members will mind taking their seats.
We do have a couple of items that we're looking at running. I do know there's also a meeting at 11 o'clock that we'll lose some members to. So, let's see if we can get business taken care of in the next 45 minutes or so. We do have at least two or three items on the agenda that we're dealing with today. So we need to go ahead and get started on doing the citizens business. The first item of business, I'd like to take up what we kind of left undone last time and
actually move items to deferred. But what I want to do is get the input of the committee as far as if there's anything that you are running or you know of or believe that may be ran in the next two meetings. That way we avoid the hassle to somebody else of having to provide the two day notice to get it off from the deferred agenda. And so, what I know that we're dealing with today is House Bill, or at least it's a possibility, I know that Representative Darby's here, so House Bill 1207.
So we're not moving that to deferred. House Bill 1258, so we are not moving that to deferred. And Representative Letting is here for House Bill 1009. So we won't move that to deferred, obviously. And I think, Representative Lowry's House Bill 1047. So outside of that, I don't know, Michelle, Representative Gray. Yes, thank you.
I just wanted to let you know that House Bill 1015, I will run at
the next meeting. Okay, so we won't move House Bill 1015 to deferred either. Thank you. Representative Davis. Mr. Chairman,
1151 is probably three weeks out. I don't mind if you want to put it on
deferred. Okay, so we'll go ahead and move that to deferred. And that way people will have a little bit of warning for you. Rock the world and bring that out to run it. So, Representative
Johnson. Thank you, Mr. Chair. 1270 was, I got notice it was going to run today and I don't know if it is.
Well, that's completely up to you, Representative Johnson. I'm ready to run it. If you want to run it, okay, then. It's nine words. Okay. And there may be a couple of these that we take out of order, because we know that there's one bill that will have a little bit more attention than others. And so if it's something like that that may not be controversial, we may take up quicker. Okay, so I'll go ahead and just to clarify, make sure that everybody is in agreement. Representative Letting, yeah, you only have one bill in here.
So other than House Bill 1009, House Bill 1015, House Bill 1047, House Bill 1207, House Bill 1258, House Bill 1270, and that's it. All the rest of them will be moved to the deferred calendar. Is there any objection to that? So without objection, I'll say the will of the committee is to move those to the deferred calendars. So Ms. Sherry, if you'd make sure that's taken care of, that's great.
The idea of that is that people will have some idea. I know that there are some concerns about specific bills. People, I get texts and calls all the time trying to find out if the bill is running or not. And so this will give them opportunities to have some idea as to what we may run and what we may not run during committee. I think that helps the citizen and everybody else. Okay. So the first item on the agenda is, and we have kind of a little bit different situation today where almost all the bills that we have are actually individuals from other committees.
So I know all of y'all are going to be missing your committee. So I hate to take up anything that could be too time-consuming first. But at the same time, who knows what the opposition will be. But Representative Letting, you are first on the agenda. So I will recognize you. Representative Letting, you are recognized for House Bill 1009. Thank
you, Mr. Chair, Mr. Vice Chair, members of the committee. I will be brief.
As you can see, House Bill 1009 is just a page and a half and very straightforward. What this bill would do is prevent any official elected or appointed to a constitutional office from registering, forming, holding, or serving as the resident agent for more than one political action committee. Constitutional officers as defined by this bill include the governor, lieutenant governor, secretary of state, attorney general, treasurer, auditor, land commissioner, members of the the General Assembly, any justice on the Supreme Court, including the Chief Justice, any judge on the Court of Appeals, including the Chief Judge, any Circuit Judge, District
Judge, prosecuting attorney, or member of the Independent Commission established by the 2014 Ethics Law. It does include an exception for legislators who serve on political action committees for legislative committees, because those legislative PACs do require that their membership be made up only of legislators. So for any majority leader or minority leader that serves on his or her caucus pack, they would still be allowed to hold or operate one political action committee for themself. Currently for the 2016 legislative cycle, the contribution limit for political action committees was $2,700 per election.
So this meant that if you had a political action committee and you had a donor willing to contribute $2,700, you could potentially get a maximum of $5,400 from that donor for that entire election cycle. when you include the primary election and the general election. As the law stands now, if this donor were particularly generous and wanted to contribute more, all the legislator would have to do to accept more money would be to form an additional PAC. You could have, and I think I'm making this name up, Friends of Arkansas PAC 1, Friends of Arkansas PAC 2, Friends of Arkansas PAC 3, and so on until you had collected, I guess, as much money as available.
I think if we have those contribution limits, we should honor the spirit of them. And that's what this bill
tries to do. Thank you. Okay. Thank you for the presentation. Representative Gray, you're recognized for
a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Letting, can you tell me exactly what it is you're trying to accomplish with this, what the problem is, and why this wasn't done when the Democrats were
in control? I think in recent cycles, we've seen more money on both sides of the aisle spent on campaigns and that we're just trying to honor the contribution limits established.
As I said, currently, contribution limits are set at $2,700 per election. This would just simply enforce the spirit of that law by making sure that a legislator could not collect more simply by forming additional political action committees. You're recognized for a follow-up.
Representative Gray. Thank you, Mr. Chair. So has this been abused in the past? And I don't make sure I understand the ethics laws correctly, but a PAC can't contribute more than a certain amount to a candidate anyhow.
So can you tell me how this
has been abused in the past? I wouldn't say that it's necessarily been abused because, again, it's not against the law. We're just trying to honor the spirit of the contribution limits. There are legislators who have served on multiple PACs. Again, that's not been against the law, so it's certainly not been out of line. We're just trying to
honor the spirit of the contribution limits. Representative House, you're recognized for a question. Thank you,
Mr. Chairman. Will this in any way prevent my wife from forming a PAC and my son and my daughter and my son-in-law, my daughter-in-law, my grandkids?
This bill does not apply to them. So this bill, this
law is very easy to circumvent, isn't it? It still could be, but then again, I would hope that anybody elected to office would do their best again to honor the intent of the contribution limits. Thank you very much, Mr.
Chair. Representative Smith, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative
Letting, in your own campaigning, how involved are you in receiving PAC money?
The 2016 cycle was the first cycle as an elected official that I've ever formed my own political action committee, and I do
have just the one. Okay, thank you. Representative Davis,
you are recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Letting, I appreciate the spirit of what you're trying to accomplish. I wonder if you consider just restricting contributions from a member's own PAC to their own campaign.
That would only affect us as members and not affect other citizens and how they may choose to operate PACs. I
might be misunderstanding the question, but this bill does only apply to elected officials. Okay, so it
only prevents us from forming more than one pack? Correct, a member of
the public would still be free to form as many political action committees as he or she likes. This would only apply to anybody elected or appointed to a constitutional office. And to be clear, again, we're certainly not targeting anyone.
This bill is strictly just about making sure that everyone's able to adhere to the spirit of
the contribution limits. Fair enough. Still, I just think it may be more direct. If you're concerned as a member forming a PAC, receiving a maximum contribution from an individual, and then that individual making a PAC contribution, and then the PAC maxing out to the same candidate, if I understand that's your concern, then why don't we just restrict contributions from a member's own PAC to their own campaign? I
suppose that could be an alternative approach, but this is the approach we brought before the committee today.
Okay, and on the, I just want to clarify on the exclusion for caucus, PACs. I think most PACs actually require three registered members. So do you have to be majority, minority leader, or is it just- No, it would be any legislator on the- Any legislator could be on a caucus PACs. Because the legislative
caucus packs do have to have exclusively membership made up of legislators. So this would still ensure that he or she could still have a political action committee for their own purposes. But
it could be any member, you didn't restrict it to officers of the caucus?
No, sir. Okay, thank you. Thank you, Mr. I have a question. I know that there is some interest, maybe even a bipartisan effort to do some kind of a broad-based ethics reform package. We're still real early in the session. I think you have lots of time to work on this bill. And what I have a little bit of concern about is how this may fit in and may actually make it difficult to do something else within that package. My question is, would you be willing to pull this down and hold on to it until
the broader package or scope could be put together in order to make sure that it all
works together? I would be if that's the preference of the committee today to pull this down. But I would hope that if there is not movement on that overall package that you've referenced, that I would be able to come back before this committee and get a vote on this legislation before
the end of session. What I've committed in this committee is, regardless of how liberal the legislator is or what party they're from or whatever,
is to try to give them as good of a fair of a hearing as possible. So I would imagine that, you know, that if that doesn't happen, not only will you have that opportunity, but I will be obligated to make sure that you have that opportunity down the road. So, you know, I don't know what the will of the committee is. You know, if there's somebody on the committee that wants. I have a sense. Do what? I have a sense. But if the will of the committee is that, you know, let's go ahead and run with this now, then let's do it. If the will of the committee is let's see how it fits into overall scope, that would be my recommendation.
But once again, I'd say I'm 1
20th of the committee. I'm willing to pull the bill down today
and discuss it further with members of the committee. Okay, I really appreciate that, Representative Letty. You're welcome, thank you. As always, you've proven yourself to be a really rational individual, so. Always. Thank you, sir. Okay, next on the, Representative Gray, are you actually intending on running your bill today? Tomorrow, or next week, okay, that's great. Okay, so Representative Dalby, yeah, Dalby, I'm so sorry, Representative Dalby, you are recognized.
I visited with Representative Lowry, and he's okay with letting you go first. Representative Dalby, you are recognized to present HB 1207. Thank
you, Mr. Chair. Members of the committee, as most of you know, I'm just a little freshman down here, So I'm going to ask for a little bit of kindness in your questions, but I'll certainly be happy to answer any. House Bill 1207, what I'm attempting to do in this bill is to codify what I think is the practice of the majority of the members,
or not only just the members, but anybody running for office. Give you a little background. Currently, the law in Arkansas, and specifically Arkansas Code Annotated 7-1-103, requires that all articles, statements, or communications appearing in any newspaper, printed or circulated in our state, intended to influence the vote, clearly contain the words paid for by the candidate, the committee, or the person who paid for the ad. And it could be your opponent. Additionally, within that same law, the law requires that any radio,
television, or any other electronic median contains these words also. So what this bill is doing, it is adding language to the existing law that would say campaign signs, campaign literature, or other printed campaign materials clearly contain the words paid for by, followed by the candidate, the candidate's committee, the person who paid for it, your opponent. And I've talked to people throughout, my colleagues throughout the House, and everybody's kind of surprised that this isn't the law already.
A lot of people thought it was. And so I'm trying to codify that into our practice. Secondly, I understand that there are people who have campaign literature already out there that does not contain these words. There is a grandfather clause in this that would allow you to continue to use that. without running afoul of this provision. It also, I had someone ask me a question yesterday,
would they have to then report these signs as in kind contributions? And the law currently, the law already in Arkansas Code 7-6-228 allows that a candidate may retain campaign signs, printed materials for future campaigns, and not required to report those materials on their campaign contribution expenditure report. As I said, this law, I believe, will bring us in line to what we currently, most people think is the law.
It's the federal law also. I would ask a favorable vote for this. I believe that it brings honesty, integrity, and openness to our campaign ethics law. Thank you for your presentation. Representative Wardlaw, you're recognized for a question.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. You know, Representative Dalby, I'm the
poor old dirt farmer, so I don't read very well. So I was concerned about the old campaign signs and how that would work, but I think you addressed that.
Sounds good. Representative Douglas, you're recognized for a question. Are you establishing a penalty somewhere in here that I have missed, or what is
the disincentive to break this law? Under the current law, the current law in regard to your newspaper, radio, television, and all of that,
falls in a Class A, Mr. Beaner, and this goes right into that very same thing. In fact, that's where this is found. Your newspaper, radio, television ad is found in that statute, and this is just adding a Section C to that statute. Okay, thank you.
Representative Womacki, I recognize for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Is it defined anywhere what the words printed campaign materials would include?
Not that I could find, Representative. I'll tell you what I'll- In Section 2 of the 7.6228, the best definition I can tell you, it says campaign signs, campaign literature, and other printed campaign materials. Follow up, Mr. Chair? You're recognized for a follow up, sorry. So the way I read that, it
would include, say, an ink pen or a nail file or something. I just, in practice of application, I just think that's a lot of words to add to a little bitty space.
I don't believe that it would do that. In talking with drafting and looking at that, it was, once again, campaign signs. It was those type of printed materials, but it was not envisioned for nail files and ink pens. But I can see your point, and I mean, I understand your point, But that certainly was never an envision or a consideration in that regard. Because I do agree, that would be an awful lot to add to a nail file.
Representative Darby, along those lines, you know, I know that that wasn't your intent. And one of the reasons I've kind of addressed the committee along these lines is, you know, it's kind of our job to make sure a good idea comes out as a good bill. And, you know, the same thing that I said to Representative Letting is I know that there's a lot of effort going on, and I kind of visited with you about this to some extent. You know, would you be willing to pull this back, make those changes, alleviate some of the concerns, make sure it fits in with some of the other things that people are working on?
Not that, you know, this is your idea, obviously you'll run a bill, but we want to make sure it's consistent with the broader package of what everybody wants to see coming out of this committee. You know, would you be willing to pull down your bill and
address these concerns? Certainly, Mr. Chair, and as we discussed the other day, and I told you I would be interested in that, I just wanted to get this out in front of the committee so that I could gather some more information, and I would be more than willing, and you and I talked about that the other day, and I certainly would be agreeable to that, because I think it's important. I think it's important to the citizens of the state of Arkansas that they see that we want to be as open,
transparent and honest in our campaign activities and we want those running for office whether I ever run for office again or anybody else in this ever runs for office that we are all above board as to what we're doing and you and I talked about that and I have no problem with pulling it down but I do believe strongly enough that this is important that we include it in an overall package. I think I agree with that and
I think that probably most committee does as well And I think that this is a good example of exactly kind of the way to do it.
As you come out, you present your idea, everyone gets a chance to hear it, develop opinions, but also get your concerns out. So I think this is exactly what the committee is supposed to do. I do have a couple of questions, if
people still have the questions. Representative Dotson. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And I guess the questions I would have, based on who would enforce this, what would the actual penalty be? I don't know if it's the Ethics Commission that would enforce this, or if it would be a complaint-driven thing,
or would it be the local police department? And then just kind of as a, would the reason that current law maybe requires printed media in a newspaper or radio advertisement to bear this paid-for branding is because that is a media, the media entity bears some responsibility before they take the order that those things are actually printed on there or disclosed in the radio.
And it's kind of hard to do that sometimes when you're talking about signage and how would somebody prove that they had the campaign signs ahead of time that were held over? I
think if I heard you, Representative, there's really three questions in there. Yes. Maybe, and I'll see if I can remember all three of your questions. I think the first one was, how do you enforce it? Well, it's enforced just like the current law is enforced.
One, obviously, there could be an ethics violation. And I have read some ethics opinions of people not putting this in a newspaper. And I think the Ethics Commission fined somebody, it wasn't a candidate themself, but fined somebody $50. Well, that was a complaint driven. Are there going to be police policing this? I don't think so. It's like any other criminal, and it's not really, it's kind of quasi-criminal,
but there's going to have to be a complaint filed if somebody's going to go that route for the misdemeanor violation. I have yet, in looking at the case law, and I don't claim to say I did a thorough brief on the law, but I could not find any case law in which that was prosecuted under that statute. It typically goes through the ethics. I think I've answered your first question. Now, let me think of your second question.
What was the second question? I've forgotten the second question, but I think when it comes, you want
to repeat those or restate those? I think you covered the first two in that
statement, but the basic, if a media entity. Oh, the media question, sure, because they may be responsible for that. And so there's some, I don't know that there is a clear answer to that question, Representative Dodson. But it may be because it's media driven. but also I think that our written campaign materials are driven obviously by us,
but also by our opponents who put things out. And so I just think in this day and time that if we're out there putting something out, we need to be held responsible for the fact that we're either paying for it or somebody else is paying for it. I can't answer your question as to what the basis was. I've not gone back and looked at a historical analysis of why there was a definition. I just know that whenever I've brought this up to people either sitting around me in the house or just talking somewhere, they all look at me and they go, that's not the law?
That wasn't the law? Everybody's surprised that that's not what the law is
currently. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Gray, you recognize
her question? Thank you, Mr. Chair. I just one other concern that I had when I read through it is the word campaign and what that definition would be. So, for instance, if you've got to interfere in a primary or a general and you don't have an opponent, you're technically in a campaign, although you don't have an opponent. But then what about the following year in an off cycle year where you're not actually filed to run?
You are in office, no opposition. What about like Christmas cards? So, I guess my question to you would be maybe to look at better defining what you intend
with the campaign. And, Representative, I certainly appreciate that. And I think that the whole statute, as I recall, does not define campaign. And so, if we're going to look at an overarching ethics campaign reform, which I think is needed in our state,
That would be something I think that we would need to address in that overarching legislation. This bill did nothing but track what was in other language in the bill. We tracked it just exactly like it was written in the sections before and the sections after. Okay. So I don't think that's addressed anywhere in the law, but okay, thank you. Representative Hamer, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
As I understand right now, and I hope I'm right, otherwise somebody may file ethics complaint on me after this meeting this morning, but as I understand it, all materials for our campaigns have to be paid for out of our campaign account. And if that is the case, anybody can look at our statements and see the source of which we have paid for our advertising material for. And therefore, is the intent of this bill to potentially put somebody in a box or in a corner
if, say, I went out and paid for signs out of my pocket, but I didn't run it through my campaign account, and you want to see that listed on there who it's paid for? because in my mind, it's all going to be paid for by
wrong in that? Representative, I'm not sure that you're wrong in your assessment of that, but the old language when we assume you know what it does to you and me,
I think the difference there, and we may be splitting hairs, and I'm not trying to split hairs, By any means, I think that there are times that possibly those of us who are honest and put forth how we're spending our money and being very cautious to make sure we're dotting all our I's and crossing all our T's, that we're not going to have a problem. It's those times where we have either somebody who wants to put something out for us, you
know, and they would be required to put that on it. Or we have an opponent who is not being honest about how they're spending their money. And that's exactly what happened in my campaign. I had an opponent who was not honest about how they were spending their money or what was printed on there. So I know that's kind of a non-answer to your question, but I don't know that we're depending on each other to be honest of how we spend our money.
And you are correct. It would be in our campaign reports. I don't know about in your district, but not too many people in my district know that you can go on the Secretary of State's website and look up what the campaign report is. They go around and look at the printed material to see who's paying
for it. Well, most people in my district, trust me, it's the people outside my district I have a problem with looking at my financial reports. I understand. Follow-up, Mr. Chair. Peter, I can answer for a follow-up. Thank you, because I would commend you that if that's what the intent of the bill is for is to give ethics the ability to have a more solid case against somebody if they have something on their sign, but it doesn't match their campaign report.
So have you consulted with Ethics Commission about this bill, and have they, to the latitude, that they could wade in either way, or have you met with
them? I have talked to them, and ethics is an interesting group to visit with, and- You're not
That's okay. Let me talk to you about, I'm not trying to be a Vasey, but I'm not sure that I could answer that one way or the other, I'm not sure I got an answer one way or the
other. Does that answer your question? I think it does. The last thing is this. When you do your research and you bring this bill back, one thing I wish you'd check in on, and I'll check in just from my own personal knowledge. I know that we, with the way in which the salaries where we are aligned, and as a sitting member of the House of Representatives, when I do something,
there are certain latitudes where I can pay for that out of my expense account as I understand it. Are you intending that money that is paid for as a sitting member of the legislature when we do things also has to have this phrase attached to it in that scenario? Or could you check on that when you bring it back? Just kind of clarify that a little bit, too, if you will.
Certainly. I'll be happy to check on it, Representative. But no, that was
not my intent. Thank you, ma'am. Representative Howes here, recognized for a question. Mr. Chairman, just to make a mention that a lot of times a statute uses the term the year your name appears on a ballot,
defining moments when you print stuff, so that might be useful. Thank you,
Mr. Chairman. That may answer Representative Gray's question.
Okay. Representative Eubanks, you're recognized for a
question. Representative Dalby, you're trying to make Arkansas law consistent with federal law, is that correct? I am. Yes. Okay, does federal law address some of the issues that has been brought up as far as some of the pins or nail files or something like that?
Do you know if they address that specifically? I think it does. Excuse me, I think it does, Representative, but I can certainly check and I can have the Bureau of Legislative Research also check that out. But I think they do address those, probably in minutiae when we get to the federal law. Personally, I
don't know that I've ever seen that on those items. I haven't either. But thank you, Mr.
Chair. Thank you. Are there any other questions for Representative Dalby? All right, not seeing any other questions.
Representative Dalby, you're free to make any closing comments that you'd want to make. But I do
appreciate you coming and presenting your bill. No, I appreciate the committee listening to me. It's important. It was an important bill to me. It's an important bill to my area. And I do believe, Representative Bollinger, that as per our discussion the other day, that I'm interested in some ethics reform that lends transparency and openness to our system. So I appreciate the committee listening to me.
I appreciate you not beating up on me too bad. And, you know, I'll be
back. Well, that's great. And when I stop calling you Representative Dalby, you can stop calling me Representative Bollinger. in the room. Well,
you know, hey. Maybe I'll just call you representative. Hey, you.
That'll work. Perfect. Thank you so much for coming. Thank you. I appreciate it. All right. Representative Lowry has said, Representative Johnson, that you have the ability to move ahead. He's okay with it, so if you don't mind. Yes, Representative Johnson, you're recognized to present House Bill 1270.
Thank you, Mr. Chair and Representative Lowry for letting me do this. I kind of ended up here by accident. Alan, Senator Clark and I were discussing another bill, and I'm running it, and it's 38 or 36 Senate bill. And so when I got 38, I got 36, and so I ended up with carrying it for Senator Clark here. This is a bill to do with voting.
You're voting. It's requiring when you go to vote that you have a private place to vote. When my voting precinct, we have these little plastic tables with little walls, and you can go vote on it. We also have these long tables. If you don't want to wait for a private area, you can go to a more public area. It's not really changing that. It's just saying you will provide a private area if this person chooses to use it when they mark their ballot. And it takes away two words, adds nine.
Okay. Are there any questions from the committee? Representative Davis, you're recognized for
a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Johnson, I'm gonna split some hairs with you, all right? All right. I understand what you're saying, but when I read this, it says, upon receiving his or her ballot, the voter shall mark the ballot appropriately at a voting booth or voting machine. To me, it sounds like you're not requiring that the election commission,
whoever's running the election provides a private place, but you're requiring the voter to go to a private place. Now, I know where I vote, it's similar to what you described, and if all the booths are full, I'll just go sit down at a plastic table over the side and mark my ballot and move on. I wonder if it ought to be a May if we're going to speak directly about the voter or if you want to take voter out and reference election commissioner or
whoever's actually running the election. I really would have. I think May's probably a better.
All we want is to be sure that the voting precinct you're at has a private place if you choose to use it. If you want a private place, they've got to provide one. And it could be laundry baskets put on that plastic table. It doesn't have to be anything fancy. It could be cardboard boxes in between the chair, cardboard box, chair, cardboard. It doesn't have to be anything expensive at all. It just has to be where your ballot can be private that your neighbor can't see it. And, yes, I think May would be a better term.
All right. Thank you, Representative Johnson. Thank you, Chairman.
Representative Sabin, you're recognized for a
question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I think I understand the intent of this bill as you've described it. I just don't see the language in the bill that fulfills the intent that you've described. It doesn't mention anything about a private place. And I also think that, you know, booth or machine, you know, may be too restrictive. And also putting that kind of language into our statute when technology evolves,
it may be irrelevant to the intention that you're trying to achieve. And I just wonder whether being more specific about what you described and just saying that they have to provide a private place if somebody requires it might not be the better course. But I was wondering if
you could respond to that. I guess these are nine complicated words, but, you know, I think this is the process. How do we get a bill, bring it out here to look at it? And I appreciate your comments. And, yes, I think changing it to maybe not, say, booth per se, because that refers to a separate structure, but a private area.
Is that what you're suggesting, Representative? You're
recognized from follow-up. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Yeah, I mean, I definitely don't want to tell you how to write your own bill. I guess I just, I do worry sometimes that when we use certain terms that can become outdated or, you know, are too sometimes broadly defined when there's an outcome that you're clearly trying to achieve that I think most people would agree with, why not just, you know, go with the language that will, you know, more precisely achieve the goal. Okay.
And that's, you know, requiring a private place, you know, should voters request it, where they can fill their ballot out. Okay, I think
those are two good, two good changes to make. Any more? Representative Hammer, do
well, first of all, have the county clerks approved this, have you run it by them, and are they agreeable to it?
This is, like I said, Senator Clark's bill, and I did not run it by them, I actually got it yesterday.
Okay, and then the second thing, if by chance this bill gets pulled down today and doesn't get hurt, I'd like to suggest something. The thing I would be concerned about is what happens if a person leaves, if it says shall and a person was to leave that area, would there be grounds to discount or to discard that vote because of the arrangements that are created in this bill? And I
think that's where going back to Representative Davis' question, change it to May, will alleviate that problem.
Okay, very good. Thank you. Are there any other questions from the committee? Getting a sense from you, Representative Johnson, we may turn you away
like we have the other folks today. That seems to be the thing. I'll amend it and come back, and if anyone else has a suggestion to make the language better, please tell me, Because I don't want to write it four or five times, let's just write it and get
it done. And that's what I would recommend members of the committee have some concerns. It sounds like, once again, you've got a good idea and maybe with this input, it'll be a really good bill, so.
Thank you, Chairman. Thank you, committee. Thank you, Representative Johnson. All right, Representative Lowry, you are recognized, if you're ready. We haven't had people signed up for other pieces of legislation, and what I've neglected to do is ask the audience, let me tell you on this, that I know that there will be some individuals who have some interests, and so we'll give you that opportunity when we get there.
But Representative Lowry, you are recognized to present House Bill 12, let's see, 1247. Thank you, Mr. 1047. 1047,
sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and thank
you, members. I see a trend developing, and I'm sure there's a lot of people in the room that hope that you would turn me away as well. But hopefully that will not be the case. I have been asked about this bill. Why am I so personally invested in the issue of voter ID and electoral integrity?
And I guess all I can say is that in 2013, when we passed the initial bill and it was vetoed by then-Governor Beebe, the veto override only made it by 51 votes. I was the 51st vote, and I was homesick that day and almost had to literally be carried up the stairs to the chamber to be the 51st vote to override the veto. Now, I'll also bring that up because I know that there will be references to the 51 vote margin.
And this is one of the main issues that we are addressing in this bill. Because we're amending, and we amended Amendment 51 in the 2013 version, we're doing that here. Because you're amending a referred or a constitutional amendment, you have to have a two-thirds vote margin. And that was the majority concurring opinion in the Supreme Court when the 2013 law was rejected and was deemed unconstitutional.
There, of course, was another reference. This microphone seems to be cutting in and out. Are you hearing me okay? Yeah. Okay. There was another reference by the late Justice Corbin that it also violated Article 3 in terms of, in his opinion, that we were adding another qualification for an elector. I think that you'll see, if you look at the bill, that we've been very careful in drafting it, that all references to any changes in Amendment 51 refer to voter registration.
changes in voter registration so this has been crafted very carefully to make sure that we're not adding a qualification to voting that we are really just clarifying the voter registration process the other thing that I have been asked or has been addressed to me consistently is that you know why why am I bringing a proposal a solution that seems to be in search of a problem, that the general idea is that there's not widespread fraud in the electoral process.
And frankly, I'm not going to spend a lot of time talking about that because, frankly, the data is difficult to collect. There is no central clearinghouse for fraud complaints and electoral process. So, you know, we really have no ability to gather that kind of empirical evidence. What we do have, obviously, are situations of anecdotal examples, and I'll just give you one that was just brought up to me recently by Representative Ballinger that he said he knew of a lady in his county that went to vote, and when she gave them her, showed the ID, and they looked her name up, they found out that she had already voted or someone had voted using her name on the other side of the county.
That really illustrates one of the problems about the potential of someone violating electoral law, impersonating you. There's no way to correct that. You might be able to research it. You may be able to track that person down. You may even be able to charge them with criminal impersonation. But at the point that they voted illegally, voted in someone else's name, you can't undo that. And that vote cancels out another person's vote that might have voted the opposite way.
So I'm not going to focus so much on the fraud that might be out there, but I'm going to focus on a problem that really is very critical. And it is that there is an eroding lack of confidence in the electoral process by the American people. A Gallup poll in 2016 said that the confidence in the accuracy of voting is only at 66 percent. And that's actually a bump up. There was a low of 59 percent in 2018.
So, in other words, in 2008, 42 percent of Americans did not have confidence in the accuracy of voting. Today, that 66 percent tells you 34 percent of Americans don't have that confidence. This is one way to proactively address the confidence issue. Now, looking at voter ID, the same Gallup poll also polled Americans on how they felt about photo voter ID.
Four in five Americans support photo voter ID. And you break that down by demographic groups, you find that even though the main opposing argument that you're going to hear is that it disenfranchises minority voters, the Gallup poll showed that actually 77% of non-white voters favor voter ID. White voters favor it by 81 percent, non-white by 77 percent.
So there's not a wide variance there in terms of support for this type of law, mainly because it does verify, it does heighten the integrity of the voting process. Other studies have looked at, and one of the other questions that's come up is that, or issues that's come up is that voter ID tends to suppress turnout. But there have been, and I will admit there have been mixed studies on that, but I'll cite three different studies from 2010 to 2013 that said perceptions of electoral manipulation lead to lower voter turnout, not specifically issues of voter ID.
The Electoral Integrity Project, a nonprofit organization that looks at electoral integrity throughout the United States, a five-year rolling study, their perceptions of electoral integrity, they look at state by state. And the state of Arkansas is listed out of 100 points or 100 indices. Arkansas is ranked, receives a grade of 63. The 49 core indicators they look at vary from looking at pre-election issues,
campaign issues, polling day, and then aftermath. 726 political scientists, who it's their business to research these things, they were surveyed, and these are the numbers they came up with. The two most critical elements when it comes to the analysis of Arkansas and electoral integrity is that while our number rating is 63 of 100, But overall, in the area of electoral laws, we only score 42 out of 100.
In terms of voter registration, which would include validity of voter registration and assuring the validity of it, Arkansas only receives 41 out of 100. So I go into all of this polling and all of this research to tell you that we really have a solution here, and we also have a problem, and the problem is voter confidence. If the voters do not have confidence in the electoral process, then it also has a very strong causal link to lack of confidence in all of the other elements of democracy. So when you hear arguments
say, well, you know, there are very few cases or incidences of dead people voting turned out to actually be just mistakes by voter registrars, that's not the issue. The issue is that we need to proactively address and we can with something that's very simple. I'm sure that you've heard the list or you've seen the list before of all the different elements that you have to do in everyday life. You have to have photo voter ID.
To board a plane, you have to have a photo voter ID. If you were still able to go to a blockbuster and rent a video, you had to show photo ID. If you were to go, whether your preference was President Obama or President Trump, if you were to go to the White House, you would have to show photo voter ID to be able to enter the White House and have a tour. So there's so many elements in everyday life that we require this. Why not it required also to maintain the integrity of the ballot?
Let me just quickly also reference two other things that have been done in drafting this bill. And I specifically asked the bill drafter to look at the Arkansas Supreme Court opinion, to write the legislation in such a way that it deals with some of the major objections. And I've already referenced one, is that we are going to be seeking a two-thirds vote of the House and the Senate, which is what is required by the Constitution for us to amend Amendment 51. But the other issue is that we have also dramatically increased the number of allowable IDs.
This is on page three of the bill, driver's license, a photo identification card, a concealed handgun carry license, a United States passport, an employee badge or identification document, a United States military identification document, a student identification card, a public assistance identification card, and a voter verification card. In 2013, the Secretary of State, Arkansas Secretary of State Mark Martin, put equipment out to every county in the state to be able to provide a free photo ID.
That equipment is still available. I believe it's, if I understand correctly, it's been brought to a central clearinghouse because it was not needed. But they can, on day one of passage of this and implementation, get that equipment out there. And anyone who does not have a photo ID is able to get a free photo ID that would qualify to verify their registration. The last thing I also want to reference is that if an individual is in a nursing home,
They do not have, and this is on page three as well, near the bottom of the page. A person who is a resident of a long-term care or residential care facility licensed by the state of Arkansas is not required to verify his or her registration by presenting a document or identification. Instead, the administrators of that facility can vouch. the administrator attests that the person is a resident of the facility and that covers their
ability to be identified for purposes of voting. So there are a lot of tweaks that we've done to this to make sure that the voters of Arkansas are not disenfranchised, but at the same time solidifying the integrity of the ballot, hoping that we can get those numbers up where people People believe, again, that the voting process is something that's valid. That this issue came up several times during the presidential campaign, not just by President Trump or candidate Trump.
This issue or this concern about the validity of America's voting. And so this is something that we can do here in Arkansas to protect the integrity of the ballot. And at that segment, I will go ahead and finish and and reserve the right to close after questions and other testimony. Thank you, Representative Lowry. Are
there any questions from the committee? Representative Hammer, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. On the
driver's license, and I'm trying to remember the federal government, if I remember right, and correct me if I'm wrong,
just came out or are required to have a yellow star, I think, on the driver's license now. Are you familiar with that requirement? I'm not. Well, the reason I was bringing that out is because it's intended to be on there for the purpose of preventing identity theft. And depending on how far this thing progresses along, you've got driver's license, but if the federal government is putting out stronger restrictions on that, maybe something you want to look at on the driver's license portion of this before it gets down the other end if it gets out of here this morning. And then the second thing would be, and I could look this up,
but you're on base on all this stuff. So when it comes to the nursing home administrator, they could, and this has literally happened in the past, where they have loaded up people out of the nursing homes and gone. And does it have anything to do with the competency of the person that they're taking from the nursing home to vote that they are not being taken advantage of by, say, a nursing home administrator who loads up a bunch of people, takes them a vote, and says, here's how you vote?
Well, thank you, Representative Hammer. I will tell you that I think that this is another area that needs to be addressed. I've heard from one constituent that told me she was extremely concerned. She has power of attorney over her mother, and yet the nursing home administrator was able to go in and help her mother, who is suffering from dementia, fill out an absentee ballot. And the daughter said, you know, I have power of attorney.
I should have some legal right and my mother should have legal protection to make sure that that is not done unless their approved guardian or power of attorney is present. So, you know, that's, again, another anecdotal example, but I'm sure since you've referenced it that there are numerous examples of concern and potential abuse. And I think that there is a need for other legislation related to that. All right. Thank you.
Representative Gray, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I know, Representative Lowry, I had talked with you about this once before, trying to get my concerns taken care of. But, you know, we had Act 595 of 2013 that essentially did this same thing. And it was challenged in the Supreme Court, it was challenged on the basis that it added an additional qualification to the right to vote. And a majority of the Supreme Court did come back and say they did agree with that.
And part of that justification was that the General Assembly did not have the power or authority to add an additional requirement, whether it be 51% supermajority or whatever. So although I'm a co-sponsor on this bill and I do like having to provide photo ID to vote, My question would be, why do you think this will suffice when I believe and some of the constitutional attorneys that I've spoken with believe that we will need an amendment, a referred amendment to the people in order to change the Constitution?
Absolutely. I referenced this a while ago that former Justice Corbyn, who, as you know, passed away recently, was the only justice to actually reference the adding a qualification element, Article 3. The concurring opinion from the rest of the majority referenced solely the fact that we were amending Amendment 51 and did not get the required two-thirds vote. We only had 51 votes.
So the answer to your question is that this is a totally different bill. We have written it in such a way that it references directly voter registration, which is covered under Amendment 51, not Article 3. We have, frankly, almost entirely different makeup of the majority of the Supreme Court. And I think we have something that can pass the constitutional test. Follow-up, please,
Mr. Chair. You're recognized. Thank you. And I'm not an attorney, so I've learned my way through this, through some research.
But it's also kind of my understanding that once the Supreme Court, so they did reference that about the General Assembly, But the Supreme Court, so now I'm sidetracked, the Supreme Court did not have to go any further. They were able to invalidate it. So there are certain steps in their thought process, and they stopped at this level. My concern is that you're plugging a hole, and we're going to go up to the next level where they're going to say it is required by a vote of the people to change the Constitution to add this amendment.
So my fear is that you end up getting this through. We end up getting an amendment, a referred amendment out to the people, and people are going to be confused. Why is it, it's already on the books. Why are you, why is there an amendment before the people? All the while, we're tied up in a lawsuit on this bill. So I just, I have concerns. I don't know where, you know, constitutional attorneys, where we would go to actually validate my questions.
But thank you. Well, and thank you, Representative Gray. And I believe, I mean, I haven't seen the witness list, but I think that you're going to be hearing from an attorney who represented the side of asking for the 2013 Act to be declared unconstitutional. and he'll probably give you a totally different and probably, I will say, because I'm not a lawyer, more qualified opinion. However, you're right. The three justices that concurred did not go to the next level.
They just focused on the two-thirds vote margin. We don't know what is in their minds, and some of them are not on the court anymore. So we have a new court makeup, and I think it is, I think when you're talking about 80 percent of Americans, and I would have to extrapolate and say that that probably fits Arkansas as well. We owe it to the people of Arkansas to attempt this, to allow a full vetting of it. It doesn't prevent us being able to refer to the voters a constitutional amendment as a backup,
but in the meantime, this does put in place voter ID for the 2018 electoral cycle if needed, and then the constitutional amendment that's voted on by the people would not be implemented until 2020. So we're talking about kind of kicking the can down the road, whereas the integrity of the ballot needs to be done now. Thank you. Representative Ladyman, you're recognized
Representative Lowry, there's a lot of flexibility in here. You've added a lot of different articles of identification, So that's really good. You know, I think the goal of everybody here would be 100% turnout to vote, everybody accurate, and all that. One of the biggest concerns that I hear people say about this is what if someone shows up to vote and they don't know about this or they don't have any kind of identification on them or available to them.
You know, you're at the poll. You don't have this available. is there any provision in the bill that would give them an opportunity to find out what the requirements are and give them an opportunity to obtain those necessary documents? Okay. In answer to
your question of, and I was preparing for a different question, they would really go through the same process of finding out where their polling place is, all those things that that information would be typically available.
However, if they get to the polling place, they've not seen the prior notice that they have to have the ID and they don't have the ID. They are allowed, according, and this is on page four, starting with line nine, a provisional ballot can be cast by a voter who did not present a required document or identification card, and it shall be counted if the voter returns to the county board of election commissioners or the county clerk by 12 noon on the Monday following the election. So they would not be turned away. They would be able to cast the provisional ballot, and then that ballot would be counted.
As you know, the results are not certified typically until the following week, so their vote would be allowed. Thank you. All right, are there
any other questions from the committee for Representative Lowry? Representative Saban, you're recognized for a
question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I just wanted to return to the point that Representative Gray was making about adding a qualification for voting because I don't think it's a consideration that should be minimized.
The scenarios that you presented as far as where we are asked to show a photo ID, whether that's visiting the White House or going to an airport, those aren't constitutionally protected rights. And I was just wondering if you could respond to the idea that there are citizens who maybe have very strongly held libertarian beliefs. And they don't want to have a photo ID that's issued by the government. They want to live free, they don't think they should be required to do that.
And yet, they also want to be able to exercise the right to vote. And how do you square putting an extra qualification onto a right that's sort of fundamental to our democratic republic and people being able to exercise those rights guaranteed by the
Constitution? Representative Saban, I would have to respectfully disagree with you that we are not adding a qualification. And I'll give you as an example of this on page eight. When we look at the legislation, what you will see many times is, as you know,
new language is underlined, stricken language has a strikethrough. And starting with line 18, what we have here is that the current law or the amendment that's on the book says that you are required to present proof of identity. That's been stricken, and instead of in its place is verification of voter registration. I would submit to you that proof of identity is more of a new qualification than verification of your voter registration.
And in that case, if it had been taken to the Supreme Court, that may have been a more valid argument that that adds a qualification. There are also other provisions in here that reference. Let me see if I can make sure I can find the page. On page 4, a voter can provide an affidavit stating that the voter cannot provide documentation under subdivision B5A1 of the section because the voter is indigent or has a religious objection to being photographed.
Now, I don't know if being a libertarian is a religious objection, but I would imagine it could fit under there that they can provide an affidavit that they have a legitimate objection and that that can be taken into consideration. Follow-up, Mr. Chair? Yeah, you recognize for a follow-up. Thank you very much.
I did notice those provisions, and actually there was a provision next to the one that you were originally citing on page 8 that I was going to bring up.
up just because when you're voting absentee for instance, you're requiring a copy of some kind of identification to be included with the absentee ballot. And just to return to the provision that you just brought up on page four, you bring up the idea that a voter is indigent and could have these objections. But the realistic possibility that somebody is going to be able to go to the trouble of making photocopies of things these days. I mean, a lot of people don't own a photocopy machine, don't have access to one.
The idea that they would be able to provide an affidavit toward that end, especially if the scenario in which they're required to provide that affidavit is that they are indigent. I just think you're adding a lot of new qualifications and requirements to what should be a very basic and accessible right to every citizen in our state. And I think it's something that needs to be answered in terms of why are we
asking people to do one more thing simply to exercise that fundamental right that they have as a citizen of Arkansas and a citizen of the
United States of America. Right. Thank you. Seeing no further questions, we'll move to comments, I'm sorry, Representative
Ferguson, you're recognized for your question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Lowry, yep, just one quick question. In the bill, I think on page three, you mentioned public assistance ID cards or voter verification card.
What sort of public assistance are we talking about? Because I've seen some public assistance identification cards, they don't have a photo ID on them. Right. And your voter registration card does not have a photo ID on it. Am I
correct in that? The voter registration card does not have a photo ID, but the voter verification card that could be provided for free by the Secretary of State's office does. And let me also just make one other point, and this is kind of in reference to what Representative Sabin was saying, is that, well, Representative Lowry, it seems like you're adding a lot of different qualifications.
No, we're actually adding a lot of different options for the voters. Those are not qualifications. They're not requirements that they can provide an affidavit. It's not a requirement that they can cast a provisional ballot. Those are all options that are made available to deal with any of these concerns that's put out there. We have the language there about a public assistance identification card, you're right, they don't have photographs. but we've put the language in there in case at some point we have a change in maybe trying to accommodate
that the public assistance cards would require a photo and they could use that. So it's really a workaround to be able to provide as many options as possible. Let's get a follow-up,
Mr. Chair. Yes, sir. You recognize the follow-up? Now, with the public assistance card right now, your legislation, a person could vote with that public assistant card, even though that card doesn't have a photo ID with it. But the election official could deny them the opportunity to vote if they don't see a photo ID, if they don't have one.
Am I misunderstanding? Well, the critical issue here is ID, of presenting ID. We go through the feudal, and frankly, I don't really understand it. Our electoral judges ask for ID, and if you say you don't have one, well, you don't have to have one. I mean, you know, why put our judges through that facade, really, of asking for something that doesn't have to be required? We are asking for identification, verification, okay?
We're trying to give as many options as available, and if they don't provide a photo, So this language here says that that assistance card could be used. And the registrars will just have to be trained to know that that is one that would be
allowable. One quick follow-up, Mr. Chair, if you please. Your recommendation, one more question. Is there any physical impact that this legislation might cause that you
know of? The only physical impact that I would be aware of would be the Secretary of State
providing the equipment for the photo ID machines, and they've already been paid for. They're already collected, they're ready to be sent out. There's no additional calls? No.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you. Representative Sabin, do you have
a question? Yes, Mr. Chair. I just wanted to clarify something, just to ask you, because you did say that you're providing options. But I want to cite some language that I see here in the bill, and for the benefit of the committee as well.
So I understand option versus requirement. Again, going back to page eight, which you had cited and I had brought up the absentee ballot situation. Line 21, lines 20, 21 talk about any person desiring to vote in this state shall. It's not may, it's shall. And then jumping down to lines 22 through basically 27. They have to present this verification of voter registration.
And then down in section B, submitting with the ballot verification of that voter registration in the form of a copy of all of these things. And I was talking about the fact that, I mean, going through the motions of having to provide photocopies of things along with absentee ballots. It creates new qualifications, new requirements that kind of get in between a person and them casting their ballot. And I just was wondering if you could clarify how
those are options rather than requirements and qualifications.
They are all verifications of voter registration, which is allowable. We have the power to be able to amend anything that relates to voter registration. If that includes verification, we can do that with the two-thirds vote. Thank you. No further questions. We'll go ahead
and move to public testimony. What I want to do is just remind individuals that, you know, of course, we've already went over 11 o'clock and we'll lose some people who have to attend the other meeting.
But what I would say is that, you know, I want the public to have the opportunity to be heard. Just if you would recall, if your comments have already been echoed, you just may let people know that that's the case, and just try to be mindful of individual's times. You guys are the citizens, so I want you to have a voice, but at the same time, what will happen eventually is one of these rogue members of this committee is going to make a call for immediate consideration and we'll be done. So if you would be mindful so that we can get as many people the opportunity to speak as we can.
So, having said that, the first person, we're going to do as much as we can do for and against. But the first person who has signed up to speak on this bill is Warren Sears, S-E-A-R-L-S, Searles. Okay, thank you. If you don't mind having a seat and then introduce yourself for the record. Thank you, Mr.
Speaker 155
1:15:42
Chair. Mr. Vice Chair, for the opportunity. My name is Warren Searles. I'm speaking today on behalf of
AARP Arkansas in our opposition to this bill. The right to vote, something that I've exercised for over 60 years, is very vital to our democracy. And it's so easy to put impediments in front of people that make it difficult to vote. Even the language of this bill, strikes me, is difficult for even the members of this committee to understand fully, let alone voters.
I'd like to mention as well that ARP Arkansas has 300,000 members in the state, most of whom we hope vote, but we don't want to see impediments added to their voting right, their willingness to vote, their willingness to select legislators that will fairly represent them. And this is such a vital opportunity. We've talked about, heard about free voter ID, that machines
are available in a county. Counties are not necessarily small. Uh, we have a lot of people, Arkansas being a rural state, uh, who live in rural communities or live outside of those communities, don't have immediate access to the county seat to get a voting, voter ID picture taken, uh, to get that piece that they will need in order to vote. And that seems to me to be one of the things that will encumber voting. We should be looking for, as was mentioned
by Representative Lowry, for more people to vote, to get people, to get a, what a great statement would be to other states, the United States of Arkansas could say, we had 70% of our eligible voters voting in a fair, honorable election, or maybe 80%, because we wanted them to vote. We wanted to hear their opinion. We wanted to fairly represent what they were looking to have representatives for. There's been a lot of studies, and I'm not going to go into those
because I want other speakers to certainly have the opportunity to speak. AARP does favor fair and honest elections and the mechanisms to get to fair and honest elections. It was mentioned a moment ago about the cost of implementation of the legislation in a constitutional amendment. We need to keep in mind that one of the larger costs may very well be the challenges in court.
So it's not just taking a picture. There are other costs that need to be recognized, that need to be anticipated. it, but keeping in mind that the basic objective is to try to get voters to the polls to vote so that you as legislators can fairly represent them in their wishes. This is a difficult task that you have before you to figure out how to get voters to the polls, knowledgeable voters, without any encumbrances to doing that.
That's difficult, but that's the job before you. Your job is not to make it more difficult, and it's a tough, tough job, but it's what you're charged with is to figure out how can we get more people to the polls to have a fair and representative election. I just want to check and see that I don't forget anything that's important. Let me close with this. And that is AARP Arkansas with its 300,000 members certainly supports improving voter access and maximizing participation. We see this legislation and a constitutional amendment as an impediment to that objective. Thank you for the opportunity to speak.
question. Representative Hammer, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Is it your position, speaking on behalf of ARP, that all 300,000 members of your organization disapprove with
Speaker 155
1:20:12
this piece of legislation? No, sir. I cannot speak directly to 300,000 members and their desires. But we would certainly like them to be heard, and we would not like to see an impediment made to that opportunity to elect representatives that reflect their views.
But I do speak on behalf of AARP Arkansas, and our organization does have 300,000 members within this state. But I don't portend to speak for them individually. Follow-up, Mr.
you are throwing that number around with a lot of potential weight behind it, what number do you think of the
Speaker 155
1:20:56
300,000 actually opposed this bill? Sir, Representative, I would not conjecture on that.
I don't have numbers, but I can assure you that we will speak to our members in opposition to this bill. They will vote or take a position as they see fit, and we think we can present a fairly decent case to them that this is an encumbrance, not an enhancement to their voting right, a very basic right. Mr. Chair, may I? You're right, can I ask for one more question?
One more, thank you. So you are speaking on behalf of your 300,000, but you're trying to be careful to make sure that you're saying, are you injecting your personal opinion in this? Or are you injecting the personal opinion of 300,000 people? Because I know some AARP people that are current members of your organization that are on the opposite side of what you are saying. So to get in front of this committee, I want to know, is this a personal opinion you're expressing, or in your official capacity, you are stating this position?
Speaker 155
1:22:10
I am stating, sir, the position of AARP Arkansas, a policy position to oppose this legislation. I would never be so crass as to say that I can speak for any individual of our 300,000 membership. But it is a voting block that needs to be considered. I don't know what our percentage would be, but I think it would be great once the issue is explained. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Representative Gray, you're recognized for a question.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. And I guess just to follow up on Representative Hammer's question, Under whose authority with the AARP are you presenting this today? Do you have a board, a director? Who gave you
Speaker 155
1:22:56
the direction to testify to this today? We have an executive director. We have a volunteer president who heads up the executive council, of which I'm a member. I was asked if I would present the AARP position that is stated by our Executive Director,
our Assistant Executive Director for Advocacy, and I accepted that responsibility. Representative Gray, you are recognized
for a follow-up. Thank you. So based on what I've just heard, are you telling me that it's the position of one person, the Executive Director, who's
Speaker 155
1:23:36
taken this stance without consulting any of the membership? No. Membership has been consulted. It is also a national policy of ARP itself, which has nearly 38 million members.
We speak as a body for issues that have been studied, that we've looked at, that we've considered, and we take our basic principles, which is voter access, voters' ability to properly elect their representatives, take that position. If we see legislation that seems to encumber that, then yes, we as an executive body set forth a position on that legislation. Thank you. And Mr. Chair, if I
might, as I end this. And you're recognized. Thank you. As I end this, I would like to say that I can tell you that my parents are both members of AARP and they were never asked what their stance was on this position. So I would question whether or not you actually asked the entire membership what their thoughts were on this. And as I listen to you sit at the end of the table and threaten representatives by their, you know, being voted out of office or you, you know, are going to suggest to your membership how to vote, I might also add that it does require a
membership to be in AARP. And I'm going to surmise that a large portion of those 300,000 people might decide they don't want to be members of AARP any longer. Would you consider that to be a fair
Speaker 155
1:25:10
statement? Thank you. Any member of AARP may elect to be a member or to not be a member based on stated policy of AARP. That's certainly their right. That's the same right we're asking for all voters that they be able to vote if they care to
and they can vote by giving up their membership in ARP if that's their desire. That certainly is part of a democratic system. But ARP does take positions, and I'm proud of those positions. I don't know what a vote would be, but a vote may come as a result of this legislation, and we'll see. Jefferson Wardlaw, you recognize her question. Thank you, Mr.
Chair. I listened to Representative Gray's questions, and they were a lot along the lines of where I was going.
But in this policy that you referred to, we have other agencies in the state similar to AARP, like Farm Bureau, and they have policy meetings around the state with different members. Is that happening with AARP, or you guys just make this policy up as you go, or where
Speaker 155
1:26:21
does it come from? No, sir. We do meet across the state. We have chapters. We have hubs where we meet with our membership. We make presentations to our members. We speak with them. We interact with them. We get opinions.
The question was, do we get an opinion from every member of our organization, which would be 300,000? The answer is no, sir, not to the best of my knowledge. Representative Wardlow, are you
recognized for a poll? Well, you know, Farm Bureau has policy as well, and they don't reach every single member either, but they have county boards, and they meet once a month or once a quarter or once a year. And, you know, before they come to the table, those county boards that came together and formed that policy.
And can you give me some reference to when these meetings take place, where they take place? Are
Speaker 155
1:27:17
they regionalized? How does that happen? Uh, yesterday I was in a meeting of 50 some, uh, ARP members, uh, that, uh, we discussed these issues with them. They are all part of, uh, live in central Arkansas. They're considered part of our A-team. Many of them are here in the audience today. Uh, the issues are discussed openly, freely.
They can express their opinions, uh, and those are taken into consideration. That happens in other places as well, addressing members of AARP, members who are citizens who attend our meetings. The issues are brought up. I was at one in Arkadelphia last week. We discussed these issues. They have a right as citizens to either agree with our position or disagree with our position, as you do as well.
So we're not forcing this on anybody. It is a stated position that we think is well thought out and represents the
bulk of our membership. Thank you. If there's no further questions, then if you don't
other than thank you very much for the opportunity to speak in opposition. Thank you. Okay, Mr. Soffner, you're recognized to speak for the bill.
Good morning, ladies and gentlemen. My name is Stuart Soffer. Sorry. I'm a state election commissioner, but I've also been a county election commissioner since 2003. I'm also twice retired, retired Army officer, well, actually a chief warrant officer, which is equivalent to a colonel, and don't take my word to that. Ask any chief warrant officer, and I'm retired government service. And I want to thank the gentleman who spoke before me for reinforcing my decision to not join AARP.
Thank you very much, sir. the current law as written about voter ID is ridiculous you come in to vote the election clerk says would you well after they ask you your name rank uh serial number would you like to show ID well gee you really don't want to but if you do anything from a hunting license to your laundry list. It's ridiculous. And regardless of what happens, it needs to go. This bill does not
disenfranchise anyone. And what I just love is when, and I've come to this committee for a lot of years, when people come in here to testify about what happens at the polls, they don't have any hands-on knowledge. I've been working the polls since 1998. I know what goes on. And I can tell you that the vast majority of people automatically take out identification now with the new voting equipment it becomes more imperative because we have these electronic poll books which
are very similar to these little things in front of you and a voter presents an arkansas driver's license they scan it it pulls them up it facilitates the process it's really a wonderful thing. And most people have no problem with it. But I just made a couple of quick notes. This bill doesn't disenfranchise. It contains a free alternative. And if it's a problem with absentee ballots, then when they request an absentee ballot, they can request an affidavit
to be mailed with the absentee ballot. This is not rocket science. And I'm not trying to be facetious. I'm a New Yorker. Forgive me, but New Yorkers are in vogue these days. I'm at a loss to understand why opponents believe Americans of African descent and Hispanics are not as capable as Asians, Native Americans, Caucasians, and others to use the alternative.
You know, it just, it's embarrassing to make that. You talk about election fraud, there's two kinds of fraud, voter fraud and election fraud. It mainly impacts municipal and local elections. In Pine Bluff, two elections ago, over 4,000 people were registered to vote by an operative of a political party. I looked at those voter registration applications submitted without identification.
Many were in the same handwriting. Numerous ones were for vacant lots, and others, people didn't know they were registered to vote. And of 4,000 people registered to vote, there was no discernible increase in voting in those wards because word got out. The FBI is now investigating that. And when I hear about all these things with voter fraud and everything else, you can refer to the prosecuting attorney if you catch it after the fact.
But let me tell you, prosecuting attorneys, Arkansas State Police and the FBI have got other priorities. In Jefferson County, we refer numerous instances of people voting twice, fraudulent and all that. The prosecutor doesn't have time. He has got serious felonies to deal with. The State Board of Election Commissioners, of which I've served since 2012, by the way, referred, I believe, 11 to the FBI, the Arkansas State Police, or county prosecutors in 2014.
I think it was last October, or it could have been earlier. We asked them, hey, how about an answer? We hadn't heard anything back. We hadn't got an answer to our request for an answer. So what I'm telling you is there is a very valid need in our country to know who is coming in to cast a ballot because it affects local and municipal elections and county elections more than national.
And just give me one second. It's not an impediment to vote. What is the impediment? How do you get to the polling place, most of you? You drive. Are you going to tell me that you drive without a driver's license? You know, the arguments just go on and on and on, and they just don't make sense. And I think I have covered my notes. Are there any questions I might add, answer for the committee? Representative Leidyman, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Mr. Soffer, did I pronounce that correctly? Soffer.
anything but late for lunch. Well, one of the things you said fascinates me. Being kind of a tech guy, you said that we have equipment where if I have my driver's license or something like that, that could be scanned, it could be scanned, and you'd have the information quickly. You know, I see that as an improvement instead of an impediment to vote.
If you've ever stood in line to vote for a couple hours like I have, and many of you probably have, But something that would speed up the process would be an improvement rather than, you know, an impediment to vote. The question that I have, would that speed up the process? Would that improve the efficiency of voting and maybe move the lines along faster? Do you think
that would do that? It would do more than that, sir. It would, A, improve the efficiency of voting. B, if a voter shows up at the wrong polling site, these poll books identify the correct polling site to include a map, and it saves the election clerk the time to call the county clerk, who, on election day, their phones ring busy most of the time.
It saves the election clerk the time to make out a referral slip. It's just mainly a matter of, here it is, this is where you need to go. And the other thing it does is it reduces the arguments, because any time you tell a voter you're at the wrong polling place, they want to debate the issue, and inevitably they either walk out upset or you have to vote them on a provisional ballot. So absolutely, yes, sir. Thank you.
Thank you. Seeing no further questions, I appreciate your coming testimony, and I apologize.
I've known you for a long time and still get your name wrong. Oh, I'm sorry, Representative. Okay. All right. I appreciate you coming and testifying and letting your opinion
be heard. If I may close, we'll make one close. This is why it's important when we have these kind of discussions that you have someone testifying who has gotten their hands dirty working elections as opposed to people sitting back and looking from afar. Thank you, sir.
Thank you. I appreciate it, Commissioner. Representative Tosh, you're recognized.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I make a motion
for immediate consideration. Okay, that motion is not debatable. So all in favor, say aye. Aye. Opposed? Okay, the ayes have it. So having said that, we'll move directly to the motion. Do I have a motion from the committee? Okay, I have a motion do pass from Representative Wardlaw. Any discussion on that motion?
Okay, no discussion. Then if you're in favor of due pass, say aye. Aye. Opposed, say nay. Nay. Ayes have it. Congratulations, Representative Lowry, you've passed your bill. Representative Davis, are you prepared to run your bill? This is actually Representative Gillen's bill, Speaker Gillen's bill. It is 1258.
Representative Davis, you are recognized to present House Bill 1258. All right,
thank you, Mr. Chairman. Committee, as the chairman noted, this is actually Speaker Gilliam's bill, just running it for him. This bill makes a couple changes to the Arkansas Public Employee Retirement System Board. Two changes primarily. The first is, rather than requiring 10 years of employment with a state, to reduce that to five, reason being five years, you're vested in the retirement system.
So at that point, you should also be able to serve on the board. Secondly, currently, if there's a vacancy on the board, the board itself reappoints or not necessarily reappoint, but fills the vacancy. This bill would change it so that the governor fills a vacancy. That's it. I'll take any questions. Are there any questions
from the committee? Okay. Okay. Representative Sturge, you're recognized for a question. Thank
Speaker 186
1:38:48
you, Mr. Chair. Representative Davis, this is not any different than what other boards do.
For example, teacher retirement also has both active and retired members on it as well, and that's kind of what we're doing here with public employee retirement, correct? That's correct. This came
up, if you remember back, I think it was in a special session, when Speaker Gillum had looked at a lot of boards and commissions and was trying to get things better aligned. This was something they ran across and just couldn't get it in the special, So we've got it
now. Okay, is there any other questions? Okay, we do have one person who has signed up to speak against the bill, Ms. Gail Stone, if you're still in the room.
If you would, please introduce yourself for
Speaker 189
1:39:33
the record. Good morning. Thank you, Mr. Chairman and members of the committee. I will apologize in advance for the disjointedness of my comments. I anticipated this bill was going to be assigned to Retirement Committee, it being concerning Title 24, Chapter 4, which is retirement law. But I understand that there is general favor with this bill. It's just that there are certain ways it is written that are problematic for us, and I would ask for consideration for perhaps an improved draft.
As Representative Davis said, vesting is with five years, but I would suggest, based on our experience, that even people with five years terminate and take their contributions with them. In other words, they're not invested in retirement. Furthermore, people with just five years of service work for other people. So, them getting to a retirement committee meeting, which can take all day long, it's problematic for them.
And by boards and commissions rules, any member of the board that does not show up for three meetings may be replaced by the governor. So, the continuity on the board becomes problematic. I would respectfully ask that that remain at 10 years. Furthermore, what Representative Davis indicated, I don't see in the actual drafting of this bill, it would appear to take off all retirees, and therefore our retirement population,
which is 34,000 people, would not be represented. If his intent is to allow retirees to be on this board, as I think there should be proper representation, I think we need to reword it. And then finally, Section 3, which is do not codify, seems to point at a single individual. And I wonder about constitutionality of, you know, a one-person bill. Perhaps that part could be reconsidered.
I'm happy to work with the drafters or the sponsors of this bill. I understand that it's going to go, but I think it could be in an improved form. And finally, we recognize we have issues with representation on our board. On our non-state side, we have three positions. It used to be easy to fill city, county, and state division. Back in 87, the school division was put into teacher retirement. That's cafeteria workers and janitors.
We no longer have a population to select from. Therefore, we have a disproportionate number of city members or county members on the board, and that can lead to certain kind of inter-board conflicts. I think there are other ways we can recompose our board that would still do what the sponsors of this bill want to do, and I would just ask for that consideration. All right, Representative Tosh, you're recognized
Ms. Stone, just for clarification, I understand, and I'm sure it's probably in the heading of the bill here, but exactly which retirement board is this going to
Speaker 189
1:42:54
affect? The Public Employees Retirement System, which is state employees, all county employees, and those cities that have chosen to join APRES, 175 of
a follow-up. But there's no changes being made in the other state-funded retirement systems,
as I think you stated as the teachers, state police, APERS. Yeah,
Speaker 189
1:43:21
we administer state police, judicial, and APERS. APERS is the only one being approached. My understanding is teachers is not being affected by this, nor local police and fire. Or the state police, correct? No, not the state
police. Not the state police. One more question, Mr. Chair. You're recognized for one more question. Help me to understand the difference in why we're making a difference in what we're I'm not understanding what we're trying to accomplish here as compared to the other retirement boards.
And I really need to know if the language in the bill. Is there no retirees on this board for the representation of the retirees? Is that
Speaker 189
1:44:05
what you're telling me? The way myself and staff read this, it would take retirees off the board. Judging from Representative Davis' testimony, that was not the intent, but that's how we read it. Okay,
Mr. Chair, I'm going to say that question for Representative Davis. Okay.
Representative Houns, are there any other questions for the committee? Okay, I appreciate you coming and letting your voice be heard. Thank you, sir. Thank
you. Representative Davis. Yeah, I'll address Representative Tosh's question in my closing. So the bill states that the governor shall appoint a state employee member or a non-state employee member to fill the vacancy for the remainder of the unexpired term within 30 days. So my understanding is while you currently have three retired members on the board, we don't have any active state employees on the board.
So we have three retired members on the state board. Is that not correct? Okay, well, I'll take that back. We do have three retired people on the board, though. Okay, we do have three retirees on the board. This would recreate vacancies in those three positions. My understanding is the governor can appoint, then, as it says, either state or non-state employees. Not non-state employees. Either, yeah, non-state employee, trustee leaves, participating public employee, Governor shall appoint a state employee member or a non-state employee member.
So I think he could put another retiree on there
if he wanted to. All right, are there any other questions? Okay. Representative Wardlaw, you're recognized for a motion. All right, we have a motion do pass from Representative Wardlaw. Is there any discussion on that motion? Okay, all in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? All right, I'll roll the ayes have it. Congratulations, Representative, you pass your bill, or the speaker's bill.
All right, are there any other issues that we need to consider, anything else? There's no other bills we need to run, I don't think. All right, well, hey, what I want to do is say I'm proud of this committee for doing the state's business. I think that we did a good job of vetting bills, and I appreciate the sponsor.
Agenda
HB1009 Leding TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING APPROVED POLITICAL ACTION COMMITTEES; AND TO PREVENT A MEMBER OF THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY FROM FORMING MORE THAN ONE (1) APPROVED POLITICAL ACTION COMMITTEE.
HB1010 Sabin TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE PUBLICATION OF CERTAIN CAMPAIGN FINANCE REPORTS.
HB1011 Sabin TO ACTION AMEND COMMITTEE PROVISIONS POLITICAL CONCERNING CONTRIBUTIONS; AND TO PROHIBIT DIRECT CONTRIBUTIONS BETWEEN POLITICAL ACTION COMMITTEES.
HB1012 Sabin TO AMEND PROVISIONS CONCERNING POLITICAL ACTION COMMITTEES; AND TO POLITICAL COMMITTEES TO FROM ACTION PROHIBIT CONTRIBUTIONS DIRECT CANDIDATES.
HB1015 M. Gray TO CLARIFY PROPER PROCEDURES FOR VOTING PRECINCTS IN COUNTIES THAT HAVE ESTABLISHED VOTE CENTERS.
HB1047 Lowery TO REQUIRE THAT A VOTER PROVIDE VERIFICATION OF VOTER REGISTRATION WHEN VOTING; AND TO AMEND AMENDMENT 51 OF THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION.
HB1065 Watson PERMITTING THE ARKANSAS COMMISSION ON LAW ENFORCEMENT STANDARDS AND TRAINING TO MAKE ADDITIONAL SALARY PAYMENTS ABOVE THE BASIC CERTIFICATE LEVEL.
HB1151 Davis TO REQUIRE THAT REGISTERED VOTERS BE NOTIFIED BY MAIL OF THE DATES FOR CERTAIN SPECIAL ELECTIONS; AND TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING SPECIAL ELECTIONS.
HB1178 Gray TO MAKE A TECHNICAL CORRECTION CONCERNING THE AUTHORITY OF THE STATE M. BOARD OF ELECTION COMMISSIONERS TO IMPOSE CERTAIN SANCTIONS.
HB1179 Ballinger TO DESIGNATED AMEND BENEFITS PROVISIONS PROVIDING DEATH TO BENEFICIARIES OR SURVIVORS OF POLICE OFFICERS.
HB1207 Dalby TO AMEND REQUIREMENTS FOR CAMPAIGN SIGNS AND MATERIALS.
HB1224 Wardlaw TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE LIMITATION ON CANDIDACY FOR MORE THAN ONE ELECTIVE OFFICE.
HB1258 Gillam TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING MEMBERSHIP AND VACANCIES ON THE BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF THE ARKANSAS PUBLIC EMPLOYEES' RETIREMENT SYSTEM; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1270 Johnson TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING ELECTIONS AND BALLOTS.
DEFERRED BILLS Sponsor Subtitle Number
HB1008 Tucker TO INCREASE THE PENALTY FOR TAKING CAMPAIGN FUNDS AS PERSONAL INCOME; AND TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF ARKANSAS LAW RESULTING FROM INITIATED ACT 1 OF 1990 AND INITIATED ACT 1 OF 1996.
HB1005 Tucker TO REQUIRE REPORTING AND DISCLOSURE OF ELECTIONEERING COMMUNICATIONS; AND TO RESTRICT THE AMOUNT OF MONEY SPENT ON CAMPAIGN COMMUNICATIONS PRODUCED IN COORDINATION WITH A CANDIDATE FOR OFFICE.
HB1046 Tucker TO PERMIT PAID MATERNITY LEAVE FOR STATE EMPLOYEES.
HB1004 Blake TO CREATE THE DEMOCRACY ACT; TO REQUIRE AUTOMATIC VOTER REGISTRATION; AND TO AMEND AMENDMENT 51 OF THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION.
HJR1001 Ballinger APPLYING TO THE UNITED STATES CONGRESS TO CALL A CONVENTION FOR PROPOSING AMENDMENTS PURSUANT TO ARTICLE V OF THE UNITED STATES CONSTITUTION.
Page 2 of 2
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Bob Ballinger Chair
Unverified
Representative Michelle Gray
Unverified
Representative Andy Davis
Unverified
Representative Bob Johnson
Unverified
Representative Greg Leding
Unverified
Chair
Unverified
Representative Douglas House
Unverified
Representative Carol Dalby
Unverified
Representative Jeff Wardlaw
Unverified
Speaker 17
Representative Dan M. Douglas
Unverified
Representative Richard Womack Chair
Unverified
Representative Jim Dotson
Unverified
Representative Kim Hammer
Unverified
Speaker 99
Speaker 82
Representative Jon S. Eubanks Chair
Unverified
Representative Warwick Sabin
Unverified
Speaker 106
Representative Mark Lowery
Unverified
Representative Jack Ladyman
Unverified
Representative Kenneth B. Ferguson
Unverified
Speaker 155
Stuart Soffer
Unverified
Speaker 179
Speaker 186
Speaker 189
Representative Dwight Tosh
Unverified
Speaker 107