Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

Judiciary Committee

January 26, 2017 ·Committee Room 149 ·1:51:39
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (37)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1126 · 4 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…t first uh first up today we have special order of business house bill 1126 representative collins representative collins you're recogn…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1041 · 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1041 B. Smith TO PROTECT THE RIGHTS AND PRIVILEGES GRANTED UNDER…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1265 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1265 Richey CONCERNING THE POSSESSION AND CARRYING OF A CONCEALE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1006 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1006 Tucker TO AMEND CERTAIN CRIMINAL OFFENSES CONCERNING ABUSES…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1007 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1007 Tucker TO PROTECT CITIZENS WHO ARE VICTIMS OF JUDICIAL ETHI…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1013 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1013 D. Meeks CONCERNING THE CRIMINAL OFFENSE OF INTERNET STALKI…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1045 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1045 B. Smith CONCERNING CRIMINAL VICTIM NOTIFICATION; AND CONCE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1055 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “on House Bill 1055, we're going to move that back to a special order on Februa…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1095 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1095 Johnson CONCERNING THE REQUIREMENTS FOR A CONCEALED HANDGUN…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1152 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1152 Watson CONCERNING THE ABILITY OF AN AUXILIARY LAW ENFORCEME…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1158 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1158 Petty CONCERNING THE ENTRY UNDER CAUSE OF DEATH ON A PERSON…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1173 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1173 Tucker TO AMEND AND MAKE CONSISTENT THE OFFENSES OF SEXUAL…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1175 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1175 Tucker TO REQUIRE LIFETIME REGISTRATION ON THE ARKANSAS SEX…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1177 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1177 Tucker INCREASING THE AVAILABLE SENTENCES FOR CERTAIN SEX O…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1197 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1197 Sturch TO ESTABLISH A METHOD FOR A PERSON WHO WAS FALSELY A…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1198 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1198 Lundstrum TO ALLOW AN OUT-OF-STATE LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1236 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1236 Gazaway TO PROTECT THE PRIVACY OF SURVIVING FAMILY MEMBERS…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1248 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1248 J. Williams TO CREATE AN EXEMPTION UNDER THE FREEDOM OF INF…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1249 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1249 Collins CONCERNING THE POSSESSION OF A CONCEALED HANDGUN IN…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1251 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1251 Walker TO CREATE THE "HELPING OUR PEOPLE EXCEL (H.O.P.E.) A…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1260 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1260 Maddox TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING REIMBURSEMENT FOR JUROR…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1268 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1268 Murdock CONCERNING THE USE OF AN IGNITION INTERLOCK DEVICE.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1269 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1269 Johnson CONCERNING HANDGUN TRAINING REQUIREMENTS FOR VETERA…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1299 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1299 Brown CREATING THE OFFENSE OF POSSESSION OF A HANDGUN WHILE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1312 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1312 Shepherd TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 11 OF THE A…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1314 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1314 Shepherd TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 8 OF THE AR…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1315 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1315 Shepherd TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 2 OF THE AR…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1316 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1316 Shepherd TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 13 OF THE A…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1317 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1317 Shepherd TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 14 OF THE A…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1318 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1318 Shepherd TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 4 OF THE AR…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1319 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1319 Shepherd TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 23 OF THE A…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1320 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1320 Shepherd TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE OF 5 THE AR…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1321 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1321 Shepherd TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 26 OF THE A…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1322 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1322 Shepherd TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 19 OF THE A…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1323 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1323 Shepherd TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 20 OF THE A…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB102 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB102 Rice TO CLARIFY THE LAW CONCERNING THE FINES, FEES, AND COS…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB20 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB20 J. Hendren CONCERNING THE OFFENSE OF AGGRAVATED ASSAULT UPO…”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 14, 2026
The chairman sees a quorum. A few items of housekeeping before we take up our special order of business. Without objection, I'm going to set House Bill 1041 for special order, second out next Tuesday, January 31st. So we'll have actually two items on special order that day. The 31st. And that's House Bill 1041 and second out at 10 a.m. Without objection, I'm going to move House Bill 1265 to the deferred list. And then, without objection, Representative Hammer has asked that we reschedule the special order of business he had originally asked for. on House Bill 1055, we're going to move that back to a special order on February 7th at 10 a.m. And then another important item of business for the committee is that we will be taking our committee picture at 10 a.m. next Thursday. and so if you want to be in the picture be here by 10 a.m if you want to be in the picture which we want everybody to be in the picture but we don't want to have to wait to take the picture all right first uh first up today we have special order of business house bill 1126 representative collins representative collins you're recognized to present house bill 1126
▶ Play
thank you mr chair and committee and i brought with me Eva Madison, who's a justice of the peace in Washington County and also a lawyer and expert in the field. And she and I have been working on this bill for a few years now. She actually brought it to me. And what I'm going to try and do is give an overview of the situation and then a couple points of what we think we accomplished with House Bill 1126. And then I'm going to turn it over to Ms. Madison to give a little bit more texture and more detail on the specifics, and I'll probably need her help answering questions, given that I'm not a lawyer. So here's the situation. In 1993, we passed a Civil Rights Act in Arkansas, and there were two distinct sections. There were probably many distinct sections, but there were two distinct sections that are very relevant for the discussion today. One of them had to do with employment law, And it sets out offenses in employment law, for example, retribution in the office, sexual harassment in the office, and other whistleblower in the office, etc. And in that section, it lays out penalties that violators are subject to in court cases. So if you're a small business, there's a sliding scale. If you're a large business, you're subject to higher liability rates, etc. And this is the business employment arena, and it's very clearly delineated with liability numbers. Separately, the law talks about hate crimes. And hate crimes are obviously violence against people in specific categories, and there are unlimited liability for those types of crimes. And what's happened is there are always in the law, I'm learning, different sections that can be talked about in conjunction with each other to create confusion about what was actually intended. So if in one place it says you can do this once a year, in another place it says do it this year, in another place it says do a year, I can use all that to try and say what that really means is I can do it three times this year or whatever it might be. So in layman's terms, the opportunity to compare different sections and the tweaks in words in different sections has allowed people essentially to sue for employment situations in an unlimited liability format. And so what HB 1126 does is get as crystal clear as is humanly possible that what was clearly written to any layperson in 1993 in fact becomes the law as the legislature intended it. So it does that by making three or four specific changes. And at this point, Mr. Chair, I'd like to turn it over to Ms. Madison to walk through the specifics of those for the committee. So, Ms. Madison, if you'd announce your name and who you are for the record, please. You're recognized.
▶ Play
Eva Madison. I'm an attorney from Fayetteville. Thank you, Mr. Chairman and members of the committee and Representative Collins. As Representative Collins says, I'm a Washington County JP, but I'm actually here in a different capacity today. I'm an attorney at a law firm in Fayetteville that's actually part of an international labor and employment law firm. and what caused me to bring this bill to Representative Collins, who is my state representative, a few years ago was that we're often asked in our law practice about companies looking to locate a new facility somewhere. And they routinely say, hey, what are the employment laws like in these seven states? Or how do these states treat employers if we were to enter into? How hard is it? What are the liabilities we face? And generally speaking, it's easy to say that Arkansas is not regulation heavy on employers, but one area that's become of increasing concern is some loopholes in the Arkansas Civil Rights Act that I think most people who study the act believe were unintended. As Representative Collins said, the act was passed in 1993. It was not easy. It took a long time to get people to come together on the first Civil Rights Act in the state, and it was comprehensive. I mean, it covered hate offenses. It covered discrimination by governments. It covered employment discrimination, contract discrimination, voting rights, property transactions. It covers race, religion, national origin, gender, and disabilities. What they forgot to do, I think, in the haste of passing it in 93 was to include a retaliation provision, which is a big miss because you can't really have an effective anti-discrimination statute without a retaliation protection provision. So they came back in 95 really quickly and tried to add in a retaliation provision. And in doing so, the biggest issue that arose was that although the employment provisions, which is all we're talking about with 1126, that Representative Collins talked about, were very clearly defined. There's specific procedures, there's a one-year statute of limitations, there's a sliding scale of damages. The retaliation provision didn't cover those. And so what the lawyers who've litigated these kind of cases over the years have seen is that they're taking advantage of these unlimited opportunities under the retaliation provision, but then they're bound by the limits in discrimination. So what's an example? An employee complains about race discrimination in the workplace. They go to their manager and say, I think, you know, my colleague is harassing me because of my race. And that's obviously protected conduct. They're entitled to do that. And then let's say they think they got fired for a combination, maybe for their race and for retaliation for their complaint. So what we see then in the lawsuit that follows is the employer gets sued for the harassment, which is what the statute was designed to do. But then the individual manager gets named in the retaliation provision. And having represented a lot of those individual managers, let me tell you how stressful it is for them. We're talking low-level managers that don't have much money a lot of times. They obviously oftentimes say they didn't do what they're accused of doing, and they're asking me questions like, oh my gosh, am I going to lose my house? I can't afford to hire a lawyer. You know, what do I do? And it's because of these, I think, unintended consequences in the retaliation provision that have made it possible to sue these people individually. There's other issues too, though, because it's a question as to whether the damages limits that the legislature carefully laid out for discrimination in employment cases, they don't appear in the retaliation section. They don't appear, the time limitations aren't the same. And the problem became really clear with the Supreme Court's decision in 2010 that looked precisely at the issue of whether an individual could be sued for retaliation individually. And the Supreme Court said based on the language in the retaliation provision that's different from the employment provision, they can be sued. So we now have a Supreme Court decision where individuals are liable for retaliation, but not for discrimination. The other changes, though, so what the bill does is it revises the retaliation provision, leaves it completely intact for anything outside of the employment realm. But for the employment realm, it just makes clear that the same provisions that apply to the discrimination section, which is 107, apply for retaliation. So in the scenario I raised, the manager couldn't be sued individually. The employer would be sued for everything. The manager would still be an accused, would still be involved, would still be deposed, but just wouldn't have that big weight of being an individual in the case. And let me just say too that I don't think that individuals are named because anybody thinks they got a lot of money, that it's going to make a lot of difference because the employer still is really on the hook for whatever they did. It's a way to escape liability limits. It's a way to escape the procedural mechanisms. One big thing it does for out-of-state companies is it prevents them from removing the case to federal court, which they're entitled to ordinarily in those kind of cases. So the goal of the big heart of the bill is to level the playing field, to close those loopholes. The other area it addresses is the hate offenses section. And I think when we all talk about hate crimes, I think we all have sort of a feeling about what that is. I don't know that we necessarily associate that with what happens at work. Certainly things that happen at work can be bad and can rise to that level, and that's what employment discrimination mechanisms were for. But the hate offenses section that was part of the original act covers race, religion, and ethnicity. So it is not as comprehensive as the employment discrimination protections that also include gender and disability. But I've litigated cases where the hate offenses statute has been used to go after, again, an individual actor. And the case that was most memorable was he wasn't even really a manager. He was an hourly supervisor, and he was accused of doing some pretty bad things, but that he said he hadn't done. He did not make a lot of money, and being in that lawsuit absolutely terrified him and didn't really do anything to change the lawsuit because he wasn't ultimately going to have to pay money. What it did was for the plaintiff, it escaped the damages caps because the hate offenses provision doesn't have a damages cap. And I just don't think that's what the legislature intended when very carefully designing these parameters and damages limits for employment discrimination. So what the hate offenses section does is it's actually almost identical in language to a Virginia statute. I don't know if that's what happened in 1993, that they borrowed a Virginia statute. But the Virginia statute reads exactly like ours, except they later went back and amended theirs to read now like what this bill proposes. They clearly had the same problem occurring. They passed what they thought was a good bill. Lawyers found loopholes like we're good to do. And then they went back and changed it and said, this provision is totally intact, But in the employment realm, you've got to go under Section 107. Let's see what else I can add. We were here before. We tried this last session. And one thing that kind of sat with me was that some of the opponents to the bill said that I was just trying to help my clients. I was just a greedy lawyer trying to help my clients. Well, I am a lawyer trying to help my clients. It would benefit all businesses in Arkansas to have more certainty in this area and a level playing field as far as procedures go. But let me be clear, this would actually streamline lawsuits and actually would result in less work for me. So to say that I'm in it for my own good is not accurate because I am truly looking out for the businesses of Arkansas. And I want those companies that call us and say, hey, is Arkansas a good place to open a business? I want to be able to say yes without hesitation. And right now I feel like I have to outline these concerns with
▶ Play
the Civil Rights Act. Ms. Madison mentioned that we ran the bill last year, and it's true, and it passed out overwhelmingly out of committee, and it passed overwhelmingly on the House floor. But in the Judiciary Committee, in the Senate, is where the legislation was blocked last time, just to be clear. Thank
▶ Play
you. So the other issue is that there is certainly a debate over whether there should be individual liability under the Act or not, and some people think there should be. And I think that's a debate, really a larger debate for perhaps another time, because the problem with the individual liability that exists under the current Act is it's completely random. As a woman, I'm very interested in the gender discrimination components of the bill. there's no way for an individual to be sued for gender discrimination under the act as it's currently written. There's not. Now an individual could be sued for retaliation, but not gender discrimination. If you use the hate offense section, if you think it rises to that level, you could sue for race harassment, but again, not gender, not disability. So I think you begin to see why it looks like, I don't think this is really the way we intended it. We intended to cover hate offenses, we intended to cover retaliation, and then we intended to have employment covered by one section with one set of rules. So the goal is not to really take anything away, but to just go back to what I believe is the original intent behind the 93 Act, which was significant. I mean, it was a significant passage to have that act passed. But I think as it's evolved, we've discovered the loopholes. So I've got all my documents ready if anybody has any questions for me. Any questions
▶ Play
on the committee? Representative Tucker, you're recognized. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair. I guess you basically just answered this, but my question was on the hate crimes, and if you can contemplate it. I guess it's outside the scope of what you're trying to do here, but whether you contemplate adding in gender or disability or sex-based discrimination in that.
▶ Play
I guess maybe that's a question for Representative Collins. Actually, the way you answered it is exactly how I would answer it. I mean, that's something we could consider at some point, but outside the scope of this. One of the things is, you know, Representative Tucker, with regard to these types of things, they're high emotion, words matter, each word. So even some cleanup language and some other things that people were talking about putting in the statute for fear that it might overly complicate or create some confusion or a question of subterfuge or whatever, we're trying to be as narrow as we can here. But I appreciate your thought. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. All right, I
▶ Play
see no further questions. We do have a few. Representative Gassaway, you recognize for a question. I just
▶ Play
have a question about, thank you, Mr. Chair. I just have a question about how this bill seems to structure things. I'm a little confused, and maybe you can clear this up. It's not too difficult for me to get confused on these things. But Section C seems to state to me that it makes a couple of exceptions. Number one is protected speech. And then subsection two is a civil action between an employee or his or her employer or between or among employees of the same employer for damages arising out of an incident occurring in the workplace or arising out of the employee-employer relationship. And all of these claims that you've talked about, retaliation, hate claims, all arise out of an employee or employer relationship. And so is this, I mean, to me, that reads as if it's an absolute bar on all hate or retaliation claims. So am I reading that incorrectly, and can you explain that to me?
▶ Play
First of all, the speech provision is in the existing law, and I think the Bureau did some cleanup work on it, so that's why it looks like it's being revised, but we're leaving it intact. The hate offenses section is actually much broader than employment. It's going to cover just what happens out there outside the workplace, what happens out in the hallway here, what happens on the street out front. It's going to cover anything. So if something, a lot of things we've seen on the Internet lately with like shouting matches at the local Walmart or something, that would be covered by that. So what's happening, though, is employment is a component of that, the way it's written, but it's just one component. So the goal would be to say for the employment claims, pursue them under Section 107, which is not being touched, so you don't have it in the bill. But Section 107 clearly says for race, religion, national origin, gender, and disability, you have a claim against your employer for what happens in the workplace. So if a hate offense happened in the workplace, you would sue the company and say, hey, this co-worker did these things to me, and I think you're responsible because it happened in the workplace. I don't know if that helps you.
▶ Play
Representative Gaspard, do you have a follow-up? I
▶ Play
think so. So to be clear, this is just dealing with hate offenses. Is that correct? Just the workplace. A workplace
▶ Play
hate offense claim. Right. It's just taking them out of the individual liability and unlimited liability realm and putting it within the parameters for employment discrimination. Okay. Representative Whitaker, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Ms. Madison, thanks for coming, by the way. It's always good to see you. I'm just curious, your response to Mr. Guesway raises a question to me. So the end result is that that co-worker, the bad actor here, are they still liable for a hate crime for their behavior? They wouldn't be personally liable. They would still be subject to any other law. So if they had engaged in an actual crime, they could be charged. If they committed a tort, they could be sued for those torts, because certainly we do see that. But it's just that if you're talking about the actual discrimination component, the goal would be to put that on the employer. Understood. But the hate crime, the actual bad act, does this take away the alleged victim's rights against that potential tortfeasor? Not for the torts they've committed, just under the hate crimes provision. Thank you.
▶ Play
Just for Claire, could you say that answer one more time? I was looking at, and I'm trying to understand, kind of to get back to Representative Gassaway's question, and then I think also to what Representative Whitaker was asking, under the subsection C that references it doesn't apply to basically protected speech or a civil action between an employee and his or her employer or between or among employees of the same employer, that last part is what I'm trying to make sure I'm understanding because is that section, are you contending that actually is different than the retaliation that you were talking about earlier? Yes, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Yes, we're addressing the retaliation in one place and the hate offenses in another. Okay,
▶ Play
and just to be clear, the retaliation is 108, is that correct? Yes. And so this bill would preclude an action by an employee against another employee for retaliation, but that employee would still have his claim against the employer? Absolutely, yes. But under 106, a hate offense, he or she would still be able to maintain an action based on the hate offense against the employee and the employer just the same. Well, if it
▶ Play
occurred in the workplace, it would be against the employer. If it occurred outside the workplace, it would be against the employee individually. But, of course, as Representative Whitaker said, if there was a tort committed, I mean, we're not doing anything about tort liability in the
▶ Play
bill. I just wanted to make sure with regard to that second part and understanding how it applies. So I think you've cleared that up for me. Thank you.
▶ Play
Person Gasway. So with respect to the employee of an employer who may commit a hate offense, in the workplace, wouldn't that be a person, let's just say that would be an intentional act in most cases, wouldn't that be a person who you would want to name in a lawsuit for a hate offense while also naming the employer if it occurred in the workplace?
▶ Play
Well, if it occurs in the workplace, the idea is that it occurred despite the employer's efforts and under the employer's watch. And so if they're acting on behalf of the employer and it happens in the workplace, federal law as well as I think the intention of this law was to put it on the employer. If they've done something that violates some other law, like a tort, because a lot of times that's what we see, there's harassment that's physical or abusive and the individual gets sued for the tort for the assault or the battery or the outrage. And that's certainly what happens. But what we're seeing is very minor incidents of harassment that don't rise to the level of torts being labeled hate offenses just so that you can get around the procedures and the damages caps set forth in Section 107. So in
▶ Play
other words, what I hear you saying is if somebody actually commits what a common person would consider as a hate crime, they're still liable for a hate crime under all these other things, but what's not enabled that currently is enabled is taking workplace retribution or something along those lines, which is in a more employment type of scenario, and moving it out from under the employment section of the law out into the hate section and unlimited
▶ Play
liabilities. Right. Okay. All right. Seeing no further questions, we do have a few individuals who've signed up to speak on the bill. The first, speaking against the bill, Mr. George Wise. Mr. Wise, if you would, state your name and who you represent, and you may make your comments. I'm George Wise, and I'm here on behalf of... Mr.
▶ Play
Speaker 63 25:51
Wise, there should be a mic there if you'll push the button. Push the button, okay. George Wise, I'm here on behalf of the Arkansas Trial Organizations Association and also all the women that we have represented who have been sexually harassed at work. The problem I have with this bill and that we have with the bill has to do with removing the ability to sue the bad actor. removing the ability. If you look on the first page where it takes out the language or any agent of the employer, that's going to make these cases much more difficult. If you can't sue the actual bad actor along with the employer, these cases are harder to win. And we've used this act in at least three examples that I could give you where there was sexual harassment person ended up being fired. We had a woman who was told give me oral sex or I will fire you. Well she didn't do that and got fired. Show me your breast or I will fire you. She got fired. Have sex with me or I will fire you. She got fired. And the employer in all those cases knew about the behavior of either the supervisor or the human resources person and didn't do anything about it. We think if you take away the ability to sue the employee, there's going to be no incentive. And I disagree with Ms. Madison about whether you really can still sue the employer if that language is taken out. I don't know how that will be interpreted. I think it could be interpreted that the employer is not liable for the actions of the employee. I spoke against this bill in 2015, and as Representative Collins noted, it was not voted out of Senate Judiciary. We spoke against it in 2013, and it didn't make it out, and we spoke against it in 2011, and it didn't make it out. So I ask you once again to consider all of the women who face sexual harassment in the workplace and to vote
▶ Play
against this bill. Thank you for your comments. Next up, we have, let's see, speaking for the bill, David Curran. Curran. Curran, my apologies. please. If you would, you can introduce yourself to the committee, who you
▶ Play
represent, and you may make your statement. Sure. My name is David Curran. I'm Associate General Counsel at the University of Arkansas system for the last year. Before that, I served seven years at the Attorney General's office as two of those as Deputy Attorney General, where I headed the Civil Litigation Division for both former Attorney General Dustin McDaniel and the current Attorney General Leslie Rutledge. Much of my practice over the years has been in the area of advice counsel on litigation and employment law matters. And so this bill caught my attention. Just to briefly recap what Ms. Madison said, when this body considered this legislation in 1993, it copied almost verbatim from the Federal Civil Rights Act, Title VII. So it has many of the exact same attributes, namely the employer is liable, not individual supervisors. So a mid-level manager at a fast food restaurant or department store is not held liable under the Federal Civil Rights Act. The employer is liable for that conduct. Secondly, back pay capped at two years. That came from the federal civil rights statute. Compensatory damages being tiered based on the size of the defendant. So smaller businesses face the prospects of lower liability caps than large multinational corporations. And then lastly, the statute of limitations. Here it's one year and then 90 days or later of one year or 90 days from the time of the EEOC right to sue letter. That also comes from the federal civil rights legislation. The retaliation provision, as interpreted currently by the Arkansas Supreme Court, allows lawyers to do an end run around all of that entire framework. So just by switching the label from discrimination to retaliation or even the word interference, all of a sudden all of that is out the window. Individuals get sued. there are no liability caps, and the statute of limitations has been interpreted to be three years rather than the shorter one year. So Ms. Madison covered that artfully. I would like to add one overlay to her comments from the public lawyer perspective, and that is, as this body knows, Article 5, Section 20 of the Arkansas Constitution provides that the state of Arkansas shall never be made a defendant in any of her courts. That's our sovereign immunity provision. Section 104 of the Arkansas Civil Rights Act explicitly acknowledges and preserves that sovereign immunity when state entities are the defendant in employment cases. When you turn around and sue an individual supervisor and name the individual as a defendant rather than the employer, you're effectively doing an end run around that sovereign immunity. So that's sort of an additional loophole that I think this legislation strives to close in addition to the ones that Ms. Madison referred to. any questions about that i'm happy to entertain thank
▶ Play
you for your comments we have one other individual signed up just actually to speak for the bill brian vandiver thank you
▶ Play
mr chairman my name is brian vandiver i'm an attorney practicing in North Little Rock, Arkansas. I've been practicing for 15 years. I primarily represent employers, but my firm also represents employees, and almost 100% of my practice over the past 15 years has been in this area of employment litigation. I've also taught as an adjunct professor six times at the University of Arkansas Little Rock, teaching employment law, employment discrimination, and disability law. I'd like to echo some of the comments made by Ms. Madison, Mr. Grant, with regard to the history of this statute, the Arkansas Civil Rights Act, when it was passed, was a combination, really, of the Title VII of the Civil Rights Act under federal law and the ADA, the Americans with Disabilities Act. The goal of this bill is to make state law like federal law, because under federal law, there is no individual liability under Title VII or the ADA. The courts have been very clear on that point. What the plaintiff's lawyers have done, they have effectively argued and utilized this theory to create this individual liability for supervisors to gain an advantage under state law that is not present under federal law. And so now what we have in practice in Arkansas, lawsuits being filed under the Arkansas Civil Rights Act in state court naming individual supervisors for litigation advantages and procedural advantages. And let me explain that. The litigation advantage is if you name an individual supervisor as a defendant, that can potentially increase the cost of defense. Potentially, if there is a conflict between that supervisor and the company, that supervisor may have to hire separate counsel. and so by doing that it gives the the employee plaintiff an advantage procedurally what happens is if you name an out-of-state company as a defendant and a supervisor who is a an Arkansas resident as a defendant then that out-of-state company cannot remove that case from state court to federal court because that supervisor is an Arkansas resident and so by simply naming that individual supervisor as a defendant, they get to keep the lawsuit in state court when otherwise, had this not been the law, that out-of-state company would be able to remove that case to federal court and enjoy the protections of federal court jurisdiction, which is the purpose of the removal statute. Our goal here is simply to make the Arkansas Civil Rights Act similar to federal law. Because like Ms. Madison says, when companies ask me, well, what about the employment laws in Arkansas? This is one of the first things I say. I say, yeah, there are a lot of advantages, but this is a big disadvantage. And it is a disadvantage because your supervisors can be named individually for retaliation under the Arkansas Civil Rights Act. And when you're trying to attract business to a state, that is not an attractive aspect. I'll be happy to answer any questions on this issue, but I fully support the bill.
▶ Play
Thank you for your comments. We have no one else's representative voucher. Representative House. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. And we
▶ Play
were just discussing a finer point. We know that there are juries in state courts and could not remember whether you have juries in federal courts on these types of actions or not. That's an excellent
▶ Play
question. Originally under Title VII there was not a jury trial, but with the Civil Rights Act of 91 and under federal law there are juries, and there's a jury trial in federal court just like there's a jury trial in state court. Okay. It's
▶ Play
been that. All right, so no further questions. Thank you for your comments. That concludes the list of individuals who signed up to speak for against the bill. Representative Collins, you're recognized to close for your bill.
▶ Play
So how do you get to be 45th in everything? How do you get to be 47th in everything? How do you get to be 39th in things? It doesn't happen because people purposefully, intentionally went out to help sex offenders or other bad guys. That's not how it happens. The regulations creep in riding on the back of good intentions, riding on the back of things we all believe in, riding on the back of things that we know would make us better in theory. But the problem is a lot of that really is taking Arkansas and breaking us outside of what other folks and other jurisdictions do and create massive problems for us from a business and employment standpoint. This is a pretty significant one, and we've got an opportunity to improve it. Now, someone might say, yes, but there is a case of an individual and an egregious thing happened to this individual, and if this law was changed in this fashion, how can you guarantee me that that individual and that individual circumstance and that one person would get everything he or she could get out of it under the current law. And I can't do that. I'm sure somebody can come up with a scenario where under the current provisions, a worthy victim would get more. But the reality is we're not going to harm our folks. What we're going to do is we're going to align with the federal government and other states. We're going to put ourselves in a position where businesses can say yes to Arkansas rather than saying, I need to go somewhere else. And if, and if this turns out to create some unintended problem that matches the worst fears of the people that are against it, I'll lead the charge to tweak and fix it. So I would ask you, my colleagues, to join in supporting this effort to help make Arkansas and this employment law match up with all of the expectations and things that the feds expect so that we're honoring the hate crimes intention, but we're also not harming ourselves from a jobs standpoint. Ms. Madison gave me a couple other specific points, but I'm not smart enough to understand what she's written here, so I'm going to close with that. Representative Gray, you're recognized for a motion.
▶ Play
Yes, thank you. I move, do pass. We have a motion, do pass. Is there any discussion? All those in favor indicate by saying aye. Aye. Any opposed? No. The ayes have it. Thank you, Mr. Chair and committee. Without objection, we're going to move to House Bill 1013, Representative Meeks. Representative Meeks, you're recognized to present
▶ Play
House Bill 1013. Thank you, Mr. Chair, committee. This right here is Internet stalking of a child. And as you know, over years, the Internet changes. It evolves. And so this law here is just trying to catch up with the times that we actually live in. It is just a minor change, but it could have a huge impact on our children here in the state of Arkansas. As you know, the Internet can be used for good, but it can also be used for bad as well. And so when this law was originally passed, it only, when you're talking about internet stalking of a child, if a meeting takes place, it had to be with an actual child in order for the person to be charged with a crime. Nowadays, we have police, investigators, and others who are on the Internet, and they will pose as a young girl and set up a meeting with these individuals who are wanting to do harm. And, of course, instead of meeting that 12-year-old girl, they're meeting the police, who would then arrest and charge the person. Well, when they originally tried to do this, the case was appealed, and that individual's charge was thrown out because our statute did not allow for an investigator to pose as a 12-, 13-, 14-year-old girl. And so now what is happening is our investigators in Faulkner County, and we do have a full-time investigator up there, They're still doing it, but instead of using this statute, they're using another statute, Conspiracy to Commit Rape. And what that does is that kind of ties the hand of that investigator to be able to do everything that he needs to do. And so, members, what I'm asking you to do is to pass this bill. It is for our children. One other change as well is that under the conspiracy to commit rape and under the original statute, it was a Class A felony. We have bumped that up to a Class Y felony because we want to be as tough on these people as possibly can. Because think about it, if they don't meet that police officer, they are meeting that 12, that 13, that 14-year-old girl, and I believe that we need to keep them off the streets as long as we possibly can. And so with that, members, I do ask for a good vote, but I'll be open to taking any
▶ Play
questions. All right. I see no questions. Representative Housh, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Representative Meeks, you just said something and it's starting to gel. Have we made the conspiracy charge carry this, if there's two or more people agree to do this act, that the penalty is now the same as actually committing the act no again they were just having to
▶ Play
use that because they could not use the internet stalking of a child because it did not allow for the investigator so our the our prosecutors up in faulkner county that's what they were having to use when they caught a person uh that was was doing the internet stalking of a child so i apologize if there was any confusions but we what we want them what we want the investigators what we want the prosecutors to be able to do is to accurately reflect what had happened, and that is these people are on the Internet. They're trying to stalk. They're trying to do harm to a child. And so what we're wanting the prosecutors to do is really bring the accurate, correct charge and put them in prison.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Gasway, you're recognized
▶ Play
for a question. Okay. Let me just see if I understand this. My understanding is, is the way that this is written is, if someone arranges a meeting with a child and just shows up to the meeting, that they could be found guilty of a class Y felony.
▶ Play
Is that correct? That is correct. Because if the meeting is arranged and the meeting never takes place, then it's a class B felony. Okay, that is under current statutes. That is the way that it is. But if they actually meet that person, because if that investigator is not there and unfortunately happens every day that these people are doing it and they're not running into a police officer that was posing as a 12, 13, 14-year-old girl, they were going to do something to that 12, that 13, or 14-year-old girl. Statistics tell us that. Statistics prove that out. And so just because they're meeting an investigator, that is considered a crime under this law.
▶ Play
Yes, sir. Follow up. And, I mean, as a former prosecutor, I'm not trying to have sympathy for the devil here because I know that this is a pretty bad situation where someone would arrange a meeting and then actually show up to it. But under current law, if a person actually commits the offense of rape, that's a class Y felony, which would carry a penalty of potentially life in the penitentiary. But so under this statute, what you're saying is if you set up the meeting and the person actually shows up, which may just simply be that their truck pulled into the driveway, and I don't know exactly where the line of showing up to the meeting actually is going to happen, but a person who does that could also potentially spend the rest of his life in the penitentiary end of this statute. That's
▶ Play
how this is going to operate. Well, again, speaking with prosecutors, speaking with investigators, it's not just that a person actually comes. They actually ask for some way to make sure and identify that this person is actually the person that they were conversing with on the Internet. So it's not just some random person showing up that they're going to get charged with this. They actually make contact, you know, whatever item it is, so that they know that this is the person that was coming to do that horrible thing against who they believed was a 12-year-old. Let me give you an example. in one of the cases in Paltner County that just happened just a few months ago, the guy showed up not only with the items that the investigator said, hey, I need to know who you are and this is how I can tell who you are, but he also showed up with cleaning supplies, a plastic bag, and a shovel, meaning not only was he ready, if that was a 12-year-old girl, to do horrible things, but he was also going to kill her and bury her as well. And so even though he didn't actually commit the crime, thank God, because of the fact that investigator is there, I still think that we need to be able to charge them and be as tough as we possibly can so that they can stay in prison as long as possible.
▶ Play
Any other questions? All right, no one has signed up to speak on the bill. Representative Meeks, would you like to close for your bill? I'm closed. Thank you, Mr. Chair. What's the pleasure of the committee? Motion do pass. Representative Fite makes a motion do pass. Is there any questions, any discussion? All right, we have a motion do pass. All those in favor indicate by saying aye. Aye. Those opposed? The ayes have it. Thank you. Without objection, we're going to move to House Bill 1198. Representative Lundstrom. Representative Lundstrom, you're recognized to present House Bill 1198. There,
▶ Play
can you hear me? Thank you, Chairman. This bill actually is correcting an issue that was overlooked just in the process of making the law. There's always something that gets left off. Sadly, in my area, we have a problem with DWIs, people coming over from Oklahoma. They're stopped because they're driving erratically. Then the Asylum Springs police picks them up, sees that they are intoxicated, and carries on with the issue. Unfortunately, when it gets to court, it's thrown out, all gone, simply because it was an Oklahoma police officer that spotted the DWI, it does not count under the Fresh Pursuit law. This would change that
▶ Play
and correct that issue. Representative Whitaker,
▶ Play
Speaker 112 49:03
you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Just for clarity on this, He speaks of statute, violation of certain statutes. Are we talking about Oklahoma statutes? No, this is Arkansas. So how would the Oklahoma law enforcement person know Arkansas
▶ Play
law? They wouldn't, but they would know a DWI. In a fresh pursuit, if it's a bank robber or whatever, they simply pursue until caught. This, if it's a DWI, they pull them over, recognize that there's an issue, and call the Arkansas police to take over. They take over and see that, yes, they were drinking while driving. But because of that one fraction, it's thrown
▶ Play
out. Thank you. Thank you. Any other questions? Representative Blake,
▶ Play
you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Lundstrom, what's the definition or
▶ Play
parameters of fresh pursuit? Fresh pursuit is an actual concern happening in real time. It's something, for example, in a bank robbery or a DWI, the crime is actually happening, or the suspicion of a crime is actually happening. They're driving while it's erratic driving.
▶ Play
So there's a concern. Representative Rushing, you're
▶ Play
recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Lindstrom, what is the reciprocal states around us?
▶ Play
What is the reciprocal? Actually, they all, everybody has a different, you know, we don't know what the other law is. The problem is it's happening, coming into Arkansas and an Arkansas police officer is doing their job and then it's getting thrown out in court because the initial stop was an out-of-state treatment. So we don't
▶ Play
know if someone was an Arkansas resident and leaving Arkansas and going into Oklahoma, if they would throw it out and then they'd be coming back and doing the same thing in
▶ Play
Arkansas. I understand Oklahoma doesn't have the issue that we do. They've moved on. but I don't know what other states passed
▶ Play
that do. They've moved on. As in? Follow up, please. They've moved on, meaning that they can.
▶ Play
It counts in Oklahoma. It counts in Oklahoma. It doesn't count in Arkansas. Thank you. Sorry, I
▶ Play
wasn't very clear on that. Representative Blake, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Does this law
▶ Play
just affect the Solemn Springs area? Do we not have to look into the laws of Texas and Tennessee? and Missouri as
▶ Play
well? No, it is a Siloam Springs issue right now. I don't know if other cities are having the same thing, but if they do, this law will address it. You can't
▶ Play
just make a law for Siloam. Any other questions? All right, I see no further questions. It does not appear that anyone has signed up on this bill. Representative Ballinger, you're recognized for a motion. I have a motion due pass. Okay. All right, we have a motion due pass. Is there any further questions or discussion? All those in favor indicate by saying aye. Aye. Any opposed? The motion passes. Thank you, colleagues. We're going to move to the next item on our agenda, Senate Bill 102, by Senator Rice. I understand Representative Richmond is going to run that bill. And I believe we may have an amendment. is the amendment on there alright the amendment is being added to the tablet ok
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 53:17
Let me have a look at this.
▶ Play
The amendment apparently is not loaded yet. The staff is going to pass out a copy. The amendment simply adds Representative Richmond as the House sponsor. And after you take a look at the amendment, I would entertain a motion on the amendment. motion representative gray you're recognized yeah
▶ Play
thank you mr chair have i move to pass
▶ Play
on the amendment the motion to amend the motion to amend okay all right we have a motion to amend to adopt i'm sorry a little rusty little little rusty we're that's the next So the motion is to adopt Amendment 1 to Senate Bill 102. Any discussion? All those in favor indicate by saying aye. Aye. Any opposed? Okay, the amendment has been adopted. Now Representative Richmond and Senator Rice are recognized to present Senate Bill 102 as amended. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and
▶ Play
thank you, colleagues here on the committee. Senate Bill 102 is what I'd like to refer to as a fairness bill. It deals with the amount of funds that can be charged to an individual concerning seatbelts. The original intention of the legislator back in 2009 was that this fine would be $25. Since that time, it has grown. and has become more difficult for individuals out there that happen to get pulled over and find out that they do not wear their seatbelts, it could go all the way up to $100 in some cases, this particular fine. What this bill does is it does keep the fine as a violation. It leaves it in place as a primary stop. It does allow a late fee if it's not paid on time. And it does return to what the legislative intent of this bill was back in 2009 when it was initially passed.
▶ Play
Speaker 152 56:32
Prior to 2009 when the seatbelt was
▶ Play
originally passed. What we've seen then is basically a migration to what I would consider an opportunity for some local governments to go ahead and increase this fine to a point where they are taking up to a third of an individual's take-home paycheck in some cases. You make $292 a week and you get fined $100, that's pretty difficult to overcome if you're only making about $300 a week. That's too much, in my opinion and in other people's opinion and in our constituents' opinions as well. I don't think that was the original intent when this was passed. And now you're going to hear argued that, well, we need this money in order to fund the programs. I don't think that we have any fines in this state that is leveled towards anybody that is meant to fund state programs or local programs or anything else. It's good that they can use it for that, but the primary intent of giving somebody a fine is to modify behavior to remind them that they are breaking the law, not to create a situation where you have government that now relies on those fines. You will also hear argued that they can't get along without this. Well, I would submit to you that there are many other instances where they can go ahead and find somebody for something that actually endangers other people, such as failure to signal, speeding, texting. I do believe there's opportunity for our local sheriffs, our local law enforcement to make up any revenue by enforcing those laws as well. So I do not buy that suddenly people's business is going to end, that people are going to have to close up shop in order to be able to deal with these situations because we take this money away. It comes down to a fairness issue in that you have constituents out there that get up every morning, they go to work, they get a $300 check, $400 check, whatever it is to come home, and then they make a mistake and can have up to $100 of that taken out of their check. And that is very detrimental to families that are out there trying
▶ Play
to get by. All right. Senator Rice, any further comments? I'll
▶ Play
tell you what, to come down to see these digs down here, I want to compliment you. I'm glad I got to come after serving two terms on judiciary in the House, my freshman and second term on there. And let me compliment each one that serves, those with the legal expertise that this committee needs, but especially those without, like myself, any legal expertise that serves with a different set of eyes and some common sense, you are greatly needed and appreciated on this type of committee. And that's the reason I went back on for the second term in the Senate also. So thank you for that. And I do congratulate you on your remodel. So down here, let me just say quickly on there, Representative Richmond is covered, but going back to the original intent of $25 max was in the original seatbelt law before I got here. And what happened in 2009 was a good idea, and you'll find me on there as a co-signer. The problem is when I make intent and I tell people something, And I remember asking the question, is this going to be abused? Oh, absolutely not. There is not the intent that we incentivize over-enforcement and excessive punishment of our citizens for something that does not put anyone else at risk. Wearing seatbelts is great. It should be done. It saves lives. This does not change that. You still get stopped. You still get a fine. There's still a primary stop that was added later that enforcement says they need, and I understand that. It does not change that. What we are having are officers that, while they can be looking for other things, too, we've got many people focusing on seatbelt fines because it's pretty easy to spot and get people, but we're basically hammering them on the head, and I don't think we're being fair to our citizenry. Like Representative Richmond said, there are other fines that I have out here on 630 where they dart over in front of me without signaling and they turn without signaling. I had three times on the way to Little Rock this week that, you know, it's dangerous and that should be a substantial fine there. But failing to wear a seatbelt, we should not be punishing and should not be incentivizing enforcement to punish the people above board for that.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:01:29
And with that, I would take any questions.
▶ Play
Any questions from the committee? Representative Gray, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I have a question on the fiscal impact statement, like the last paragraph of it, where it was talking about that $100. Essentially, kind of what I was reading in that they weren't, DF&A wasn't able to come up with a true fiscal impact because the language of the bill was a little ambiguous. Could you address that for us
▶ Play
as well? And I did not, when BLR started putting this together, I did not go into details to see even who all got money for the, what is it, judicial fund. I've learned a little about it since then that's not the intent of this bill because we shouldn't be focusing on punishing again excessive enforcement of this and one thing was said I've never had a seatbelt violation in my life somebody said Rice won't get back at somebody some of the comments were said that this and that, I did not receive a contact from an elected official on this until this morning. I did talk to, and one was from one of my county judges this morning, and two others I had talked to about it. So you're not taking away the money. The money is going to be changed some. Can they make it up in enforcing other things? Yes. But again, the Legislative intent was $25 max for seatbelt violations. So whatever else that change, they can make up in other areas, I believe. Representative Blake, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Senator Rice, you just stated that you haven't looked at the funds that the judiciary fund, that the funds that will be affected by this change. Have you looked since you filed the bill? I think you'll have testimony this morning that'll
▶ Play
address those concerns. Thank you. Any other questions? Representative Gray, you're recognized
▶ Play
for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Do you know, is the Administrative Office of the Courts, are they set to speak for or against? They're not. No. J.D.'s here, but he's not signed up. Not signed up. And I don't know how to answer this properly, but to my question about the impact, would they
▶ Play
be able to possibly answer that question? We'll ask Mr. Gingrich to come up here at the end of the public comment. Thank you. Representative Rush, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Representative Richmond, I think when you made a statement that said we need to teach them to modify their behavior because they're breaking the law. And so this is a bill that kind of does that. And even though there is additional cost and it may be effective that someone may only make $300 and $25 is a lot for that person if they're making that a week. and 100 is even more excessive, but how are we going to modify their behavior if we're not making a substantial amount of punishment for, I mean, I'm guilty. I mean, I've had a seatbelt violation. I learned my lesson from it. I wear my seatbelt now. And so how do we modify behavior if we're not given a substantial punishment? And did you say this was in 2006 is when this was in? 2009 is when the $25
▶ Play
Speaker 169 1:05:40
came? When the last opportunity came. $25 goes back
▶ Play
to the initial deal many years ago. So we're talking 10, 7 years that this fine hasn't been increased at all. So, I mean, would it be a possibility that we could increase the fine to $50 and then get rid of the others? I mean, I'm just asking for possibilities. Well,
▶ Play
I'll go back to the first question as far as behavior modification. And that is, yes, I think that it's like a child. You know, you can pick up a child and spank the child, and $25 is a small spanking. You don't pick up the child and beat the child. Well, when you get up to $100, then in my opinion, that's excessive, just like taking a child and beating them, you know, with a rod or whatever else, a belt or something like that. It's not going to modify the behavior the way you want. That's abuse. And I consider when you get to some of these fines, and as large as they are, that we're not just telling someone you made a mistake, don't do it again. You're getting to the point where you're affecting their life as well as their family life over not wearing a seatbelt, which, again, that's a serious thing. I mean, you hear instances where people have had seatbelts not wearing them and somehow or another by a freak of accident, when they had an accident, they survived because they weren't wearing a seatbelt. I don't think that happens very well. And it was never the fine that got me to start wearing seatbelts. I started wearing them in California, and I could care less about the California law. It was the fact that I was flying an aircraft, and I strapped in because of the ejection seat. I had to pull the handle on that. I didn't want to go one way and my parachute go the other. And I just took that lesson and on into this. So I think that you could raise the fine to $1,000, and you're still going to have people out there who will not wear their seatbelt. I just think that the majority of people sometimes forget, get in a hurry or whatever, and it doesn't need to be that excessive as some do. I'm sorry, I forgot about the
▶ Play
Speaker 173 1:07:45
rest of your question. It's already gone. All right. Thank
▶ Play
you. Well, I am an assistant whip, and we do a lot of spanking
▶ Play
on this thing. Any further questions? Representative Fite, you're recognized for it.
▶ Play
Senator Rice, where does the money go right now,
▶ Play
the $25? That's what I'm going to allow the other testimony because that's still to be determined with some of it, and it's a little unclear with the fund that it goes into. There are some that goes local, and as it says, some is for jails. That's what enticed me to co-sign on the bill to start with. But again, we have seen enforcement step up on this. And going back to 2009, anybody that has been around here has heard me ask in legislative council all the time that I've been on there, when you take money, what did you agree to do with that money? And it's not answered your questions. I can't answer it. But people coming up will be able to. But the Arkansas State Police that don't get some fine money, according to their testimony, they've always told me when I question my own seatbelt stops, because sometimes they get where that's all one officer seems to do, if you take the seatbelt fine away, we lose $9.5 million of federal money for safety programs. So it's all tied to money. This is all tied to money. And what I tell them is don't let federal money take away from what you know you need to be enforcing just to drive numbers for the feds. So I stay on them a little bit about that every time they get a half-million-dollar grant or whatever. What did you agree to for this grant? So I think you'll have other testimony that says what this does, and you may have something that comes up here that offers something that would be palatable to
▶ Play
maybe everybody if the others get to
▶ Play
testify. Representative Blake, you're recognized for a question. Just to clarify, Senator Rice, you just stated that it's unclear who all is affected by this money, right? It is because $25 was the initial deal. It was a seatbelt fine, and it went into a certain fund to be done certain things. Has this allowed, my understanding, local municipalities to add on the court cost, add on a, I think I've seen another $20 fee, and I cannot say, and let me clarify this. I'm not saying every seatbelt fine is $100, but I've had calls from constituents and heard across the state that are many places they are. There are some that are less, and I don't understand that, other than they have not gone into some local fines on that. So that may be clarified if you allow some other people to testify. Are you comfortable passing legislation being unclear who's fiscally impacted by it? I'm not at all uncomfortable because it was not the intent of the legislature to allow what I call over-enforcement where people were, and I support law enforcement every chance I get. I appreciate the dangerous job that they do, but we are incentivizing, and I see that it is being used as an incentivized reason to stop people in that. So, again, if you'll let testimony come up, I think maybe we'll hear something to make a
▶ Play
little sense. Any other questions? All right, we do have a few individuals who have signed up to speak on the bill. First, speaking against the bill, is Mike Godfrey with the Arkansas Sheriff's Association. Mr. Godfrey, you may introduce yourself, who you represent, and you may make your
▶ Play
comments. Yes, sir. My name is Mike Godfrey. I am the director of the Arkansas Sheriff's Association and retired sheriff from Polk County. I'll have with me today, if it pleases the committee, Sheriff Rodney Wright of Saline County. Sheriff, if you'll introduce
▶ Play
yourself and then y'all may make your comments. Sheriff Rodney Wright of Saline County. Mr. Chair and
▶ Play
Speaker 187 1:12:33
committee, thank you for hearing us today.
▶ Play
Senator Rice was correct. I am one of the people that contacted him in opposition of this bill. There are a couple of issues that the sheriffs of Arkansas have with this bill, and one of them is a safety concern, and the other, sadly to say, is a financial concern. Since this bill has been in effect since 2009, $20 of each seatbelt ticket does go to the operation of a jail facility. And since 2009, that money has been built in. And if we lose that money, it's going to go back to the counties as a burden to the county to try to scrounge and find that money. And I will apologize because I don't have the figures for all 75 counties, but I was able to contact a few counties before we met today. Just as an example, Baxter County says this would cost them about $30,000. Hempstead County, $20,000. Polk County, $2,000, where I'm from. Crawford County, about $35,000. And Saline County, about $20,000. And I hate to be the person that talks about money, but since 2009, that money can only be used by the county to maintain and operate their jail. And any city seatbelt tickets that are written, that money the city uses to reimburse those jails. to hold city prisoners for them. So that is one concern that now the counties are going to have to go back and try to figure out on budgets that are already, I would say, as close as they could be to find out how to find that money. The other concerns of the sheriffs are the safety issue, and I'll let Sheriff Wright speak to that, sir.
▶ Play
Speaker 190 1:14:27
Sheriff, you're recognized. Thank you. When I was asked to speak on this bill, I actually had to call and find out exactly what our fine was for our sheriff's department because believe it or not we don't know officers wise what the fines are because that's not why we write the tickets we don't write tickets because it's bringing in revenue and a seat belt ticket for the sheriff's office is $70 I don't know what it is in other counties it could be different apparently it is but again my number one concern is safety you know you go back to what Mr. Rice said about modifying someone's behavior. I've got a buddy about three years ago asked me what a seatbelt ticket was. And I kind of off the cuff said, I think it's $20, $25. He said, well, I'll take the chance then. People, that's exactly what people think. For a $25 ticket, they'll take that risk. That's why DWIs are so high. People don't want to take that risk. Same thing with speeding i think it's a slippery slope that we're on when we do this you know in my 23 years of being law enforcement i've never written any ticket based on what it's going to bring in for our county i don't know anyone that i've ever worked with for 23 years that's even thought that we don't go out here and write tickets based on you know what are we going to what are we going to make off a seat belt ticket versus a speeding ticket or DWI. It's not true. And if you don't, if there's not, if you don't have a fine that will effectively, I guess, motivate someone not to wear a seat belt or to wear a seat belt, it's going to be ineffective, period. And I can remember on two occasions, I worked the streets for 16 years before I became up in the administration. And I hope that none of y'all have ever had to do this. But I can remember explicitly the last accident that I worked where the person didn't have a seatbelt on and their head was stuck in the windshield when I got there. I'm not saying that a seatbelt would have saved their life, but they sure wouldn't have went through that windshield. Two weeks ago when it snowed, all the offices were closed up here. I was up here in Little Rock. On my way back in my county on i-30 traffic was at a stop i called my communications asked what was going on they said we had a roll over accident on interstate about the 119 i said all right i got up there to it they just rode the vehicle back over it was a full-size truck still intact cab was not damaged it was scraped i had three rookie deputies with me we looked at that vehicle and i said well that's that's a good sign that person probably got some bumps and bruises but they're going to be okay because the cab wasn't damaged. I mean, it wasn't collapsed. Next morning, I found out that person was killed. Went to lunch that day. The person that was supposed to be behind the counter serving, couldn't have found out it was her husband. He didn't have a seat belt on and ejected him out on the concrete. Again, I don't know that a seat belt would have saved his life, but I'm pretty sure it would have by looking at that vehicle. And I was confident enough to tell these rookies that that's why you wear a seatbelt come to find out he was thrown from the vehicle and killed because he did not have one on and when you lessen the fine and lessen the consequences that's what's going to happen we do not need to do this i think there's another proposal later on to do away with seatbelt. I can't imagine. And again, I'm here to speak totally on
▶ Play
safety. Thank you. I've got a question or two, and I guess my questions, and I've asked some questions previously of Senator Rice and Representative Richmond, my questions go to the current state of the law and whether the legislation has been followed in the past and what the legislative intent was, as I understand it, under 2737-706, it states that a person shall be subject to a fine not to exceed $25. And now, during the course of this bill being filed, I'm hearing from different individuals, and I believe y'all had indicated that the fine is $75, maybe, in Spleen County. So I'm wondering, how is an additional fine being assessed? I'm trying to understand statutorily how an additional fine is being assessed and what the state of that assessment is at this point.
▶ Play
Yes, sir, Mr. Chair. The fine itself is $25. If the state police writes a ticket for seatbelt, $25 goes to them. If a county writes it, it goes to them. If a city writes it, same situation. The additional fees are by ordinance, like the $20 that goes to the jail that I spoke of earlier. It's by ordinance. It's also by ordinance for the cities on the $20 or $25 that they can use to reimburse the county jails for holding their city prisoners, sir.
▶ Play
But what is it? Is it a fine? Is it a court cost? Is it what is it? It is not
▶ Play
a – I don't believe it's a fine. I believe it's a fee that's associated by ordinance that goes with it. Representative Ballinger, you're recognized
▶ Play
for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. For the association, I guess my question is pointed at the funding. Is that, you know, one of the things that I kind of think this committee is about is trying to carry out justice. Right. And that's what, you know, the fees and costs and fines, some of that is associated with that. But really, the fees are not. It's the fines. So we try to assess what we're going to do as far as fines to carry out justice, which I think sometimes seatbelt laws may run afoul of that even to start with. However, you know, over in Big Mac A in the morning, budget meets and appropriation bills come out. And if what we're talking about is trying to figure out funding, we ought to go have that debate over there as far as whether we want to try to divert some state funding. And, you know, frankly, the counties ought to be talking about that in their own counties, like how they're going to raise funding. And I get it. I have one of my counties that is struggling, and they're trying to figure out how they're going to pay for a jail. I mean, all that's real. I mean, we are dealing with real things, and the money problems are real problems. However, what I would say is that this discussion ought to happen when we're dealing with appropriation. I mean, do you understand kind of what my point is? Yes, sir, I do. Yes, sir. And then for the sheriff, if I have a follow-up, the the the issue i think is kind of a similar type question in in the deterrent i i had a i mean i i broke my teeth on the legislature with rolling my car five times and uh and actually i was listening to dave elswick on the on the way home that time and he was ranting about how unconstitutional seatbelt laws were and i was you know i was agreeing and amen and but i praise god that i didn't take my seatbelt off because i'd probably be dead without it so you know i believe strongly in seat belts, but the whole question of whether or not a seat belt fine is going to be a deterrent or not is not really being addressed in this bill. You know, we're talking about removing a fee, not the fine. And I think Representative Rushing has a great point that, you know, the debate of whether or not the fine ought to be increased or not, it should be a legitimate debate that a person should have. I'm probably just libertarian enough not to support it, But at the same time, I totally get what it is, and, you know, it could be all the work that people did before is the reason why I had my seatbelt on, and I'm glad that I did. But at the same time, I think that's outside of this bill. This bill deals with a fee that's associated with this that, you know, one senator and now a representative thinks is unfair and unjust. And what I would guess is that you find somebody who's willing to come back and carry a bill to increase the fine if that's what you want to do to try to change behavior. I mean, do you understand kind of where I'm going on that? I do,
▶ Play
Speaker 190 1:22:48
and I agree with Representative Rushing on that. Okay. Thank you very
▶ Play
much. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Any other questions?
▶ Play
Gentlemen, thank you for your comments. No one has signed up to speak for the bill. We have a few more signed up to speak against the bill. Mark Whitmore with the Association of Counties.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:23:25
Mr. Chairman, I think I might be able to help with Robert Griffin, the Independence County judge. I think I might be able to help clarify or get some information to the committee. DF&A has supplied some figures of what the amount to the AOJ fund would be, and they've indicated it's a million dollars, in excess of a million dollars. The county, what the county is saying is that every violation or offense in district court since Act 209 of 2009 has a fine. It's an ordinance created that each county and city can assess up to $20 on each violation or offense in district court, up to $20. That's a fine. And that's what we're talking about from a county standpoint. The state's going to lose a million dollars, and we think we'll lose a comparable amount. And that's to support our jails and support our operation of our sheriff's offices. And so that's on every violation. And what I guess Sheriff Wright from Saline County was saying, it is a slippery slope. That we rely on that as far as economics and there's a safety issue. Arkansas is the fifth or seventh most deadly state in our rural highways. So whether people elect to use their seatbelts or not results in health care costs, you know, insurance premiums. So we want to make sure you're aware of the magnitude of what we're talking about because the DF&A economic study was incomplete. And we consider that I think what people said, that if you just leave it as $25, I think you're going to not impact people's motivation or decision-making. Other than that, I would add, well, I think Judge Griffin may have some comments.
▶ Play
Speaker 203 1:25:24
Judge, you recognize? Thank you, Mr. Chair, committee. You know, the People's House, House of Representatives, it's real here at your level. Each of you impact citizens back home directly. You're trying to impact some right now on a fine. But what is happening, we're seeing that 65% of the court costs collected are coming to the state, leaving the burden of operating the courts on the local level. So when you deprive revenue, you're depriving directly the citizens you represent in each of your districts because those costs have to be made up by the citizens. It's not a revenue-neutral issue to remove a court cost and push those costs to the local level. And that's one of the considerations that I would ask from Independence County's standpoint. We spend about $200,000 extra each year to run the court system, while the court costs are sufficient to run the court if we were able to keep them locally. Those are local dollars. They're being taken from us and moved upstream. So when we see a bill that's going to deprive even that 35% we get to keep, what I would ask is you consider that if we do this, let's make it truly revenue neutral. If you want to remove the court costs from this particular bill, let's let the counties retain that amount of court costs from what the state is getting. Let's move it back upstream where it
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:26:54
should be. If I can, Mr. Chair, Leg Audit did an audit, a study, and indicated that the counties pay in excess of $46 million for the circuit court system over and above what we retain. And I think what the judge is indicating is when you look at court costs, the state consumes 65% of it. Local cities and counties just get to retain a lump sum amount that was set years ago. And so any time a bill shows up in which it impacts what we retain locally, we've already got a dynamic, which Representative Ballinger indicated, is that we've got a situation where we're not capable of running our courts and our justice system with what we have locally. And here the legislature is looking at cutting that, and that's where we've become involved is because we're concerned about our operations at the local level, which are mandatory. It's not a county library or something like that. It's our court system and our jails and our sheriff's offices. That's all. Representative Drown, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. So I just want to clarify. I've heard a lot of arguments here, and I'm starting to formulate an idea. So the initial intent of the legislature was $25 fine. That is still the way it is. the $25 fine for seatbelts. That is correct. So the additional fees that are levied are from the county and the local cities, correct? Yes,
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:28:26
and let me say this. Our Act 209 of 2009 existed on every violation. So when this seatbelt law went from permissive to mandatory, which is more recent, it was like any other violation. It's subject to that same ordinance fine. So it is a fine. So, uh, it, it never grew or anything. It just became subject to it once it became primary. You know, remember for a while, there was just a permissive, uh, caution. It became primary more recently. So our right existence, it's on nine. So every violation of the fence, you know, attorney general and everybody said it applies. We don't have exceptions and we're worried about that slippery slope.
▶ Play
So if I'm not mistaken, this is a city county issue. That's right. This is not a state
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:29:14
issue. Well, I will say this. The economic impact of the AOJ fund, which has 25 programs, from what DF&A showed me, is a million dollars. So I think it's a state and a county, local, city issue
▶ Play
as well. Representative Breshing, you recognize for a question? Thank you, Mr. Chair. So what I'm hearing right now is we're talking about court costs, basically, because there's a $25 fine that's assessed. and then the rest is court costs. But, and I'm speaking with you and for you in this question, on other traffic violations, do we not incur court costs and all of the others? And so my question is, is where would this stop? Do we go next to running a red light? Do we go next to speeding and dropping court costs? and so why would this one traffic violation be exempt from the court costs that the other traffic violations are not?
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:30:14
That would be one of our points, is that the officers have to pursue the same mechanism, and the courts have to deal with the ticket nonetheless, so oftentimes you still have those costs. And it is, just to be clear, there's two different aspects of this bill. When this bill was passed, when it became $25, you know nobody would have been under the illusion that it wasn't subject to the existing court costs which goes up mostly to the AOJ fund because we just retained what we had a lump sum which is a million dollars and also it was already subject to our act 209 of 2009 which the legislature gave counties and cities the ability to help defray the cost of operating our justice system so it never was did not grow it's always been subject to those Representative Whitaker, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Speaker 112 1:31:02
Thank you, Mr. Chair. My question was
▶ Play
answered by a previous member. Thank you. Representative Kapp, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Could you please elaborate for us on the million-dollar hit to the AOJ fund, what 25 programs that contains? I
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:31:28
think J.D. is going to do a better job than I will, but from my familiarity of it, there's legal aid, public defenders, ACIC, law libraries. There's a lot of, there's 25 of them. I think Mr. Gingrich could better elaborate. Some of them are retirement for judges and stuff. So my observation from a budget standpoint is if y'all are interested in a balanced budget, you're going to have a million dollars less. And some of that stuff goes to pay district judges and other things. So it's not like it's real
▶ Play
money. Representative Fite, you're recognized for a
▶ Play
question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Would y'all be willing to accept this if the money stayed local?
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:32:23
That's true. What we're concerned about is the local money, and that this fine money, I think I want to correct. Mr. Godfrey was indicating the cities, when they write a fine, they keep the fine. The counties write a fine, they keep the $25, and the state police does not keep their fines. It states at the county level. As you know, Judge, the counties help support state police with, you know, housing. So what our concern is is the idea of the state can decide what they want to do with their money if they want to lose a million, but we're very concerned about us losing a million dollars. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative House, you're
▶ Play
recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Always say something nice, then level your criticisms, follow up with things that are nice. I appreciate y'all coming today and talking about the budget considerations and things like that. It was very good for you to share this information. I want to tell y'all and everybody else that seems to be under the misunderstanding that the courts exist to raise funds. They do not. They exist to administer justice. And it's really disappointing to hear that conversation about how we're dependent upon that court money. Now, money's a reality. Got that. The state sends anywhere from, what, $150,000 to $250,000 a year to the super district courts to pay the salaries of the judges and the clerks and all those folks. And other funds, yeah, we've got to do something with the money. Got that. I got that. But I'll ask my question now. How many folks do y'all have to put back in the jail because they're unable to pay
▶ Play
Speaker 203 1:34:32
their fines? Do we know that? The court cost of the first thing collected, Representative House, and as I said, 65% statewide comes back to the state. But it's a misnomer to consider that we're talking about raising revenues. We're talking about just trying to pay court costs. Our district court is $325,000 a year. We are only able to retain under the Uniform Justice Act about $100,000 to do that from court costs with the remainder of about $300,000 coming to the state. So truly, it's a revenue issue for the state more so than it is even the counties or the cities. So we're only wanting to be able to pay for the courts. We're not trying to make a profit from the court. We're saying we need to be able to pay for the court from the local money that's
▶ Play
paid on court costs. Yeah, and our jails and our police departments and our sheriff's departments and our retirement system and all those
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:35:21
other things. And I want to agree with you, Representative House. We think it's sinful and problematic that for all these decades that the state, rather than using general revenue to pay for district judges, rather than using general revenue to pay for retirement, has been using the court system. Exactly. Meanwhile, they've been taking money away from us so we can't operate our courts and our local criminal justice. Like I said, the leg audit says $46 million we spend over the circuit court costs. Exactly. And it's similar in district court.
▶ Play
What you're illustrating is something that we have a problem with our Constitution. I believe it's Amendment 30 or 33 where we say we're going to collect this money and we're going to earmark it for that. And we're going to collect this money and we're going to earmark it for this. And so when the refrigerator breaks, we don't have a savings account to run and grab to get a new one because that's the problem. Now,
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:36:12
we would love for you all to go for general revenue and let us retain more locally. We agree on that. This is
▶ Play
a discussion that needs to be in the budget. The question here is we're saying as a matter of law, a proposed law. Are the sponsors still here? They will not. Glad to see. Glad to see. What is fair and just for not wearing a seat belt? And I think, I don't know how the vote will go, but I think the consensus may very well be that $25 for not wearing a seatbelt is a fair and just penalty, and no more than that. And so if we're adding another, I've heard, $75 in court costs, according to what we've heard, that's just not fair and just. and I'm sorry if the revenue we're going to lose it, the state's going to lose it too the county's going to lose it, everybody's going to lose it but these institutions do not exist just to raise revenue and I hope y'all understand
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:37:15
that. We're just here to supply information. Thank
▶ Play
you very much. Thank you Mr. Chair. Alright, I see no further questions thank you for your comments we have one other individual signed up to speak on the bill Amy Johnson. Okay. She was signed up to speak against the bill, but she'll pass. I guess at this point, I'll ask Mr. Gingrich to come up and respond to Representative Gray's question about what the fund supports. And if you'll state your name and who you represent. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm J.D.
▶ Play
Speaker 232 1:37:57
Gingrich with the Administrative Office of the Courts. And I'm looking, there was somebody from DF&A here just a few minutes ago, and these funds that, there are three components that this bill impacts. There are two fines. One you've heard relates to jails. One is the general fine. Both of those are, those revenues all remain at city and county level. The third component is the court cost, and it is, so there's a $25 fine, up to $25 fine, up to a $20 fine. And then the third component is the $25 court cost, which does come to the state, to DF&A, the Administration of Justice Funds section, which is a part of DF&A. And those funds are dispersed to a number of state agencies that have always received court-caused revenues historically, but they came to state agencies. And the other thing, I guess, to say is that probably about 75% of those what are identified as state agencies are paying for what used to be county expenses for parts of the court system. So, for example, when the AOJ started paying a significant portion to the Public Defender Commission, those were costs that used to be paid by the counties but were transferred to state responsibility. They're funded out of this new state revenue, but they're for folks that are working at the county level. So my perspective would be that there's not a separate state interest and a county interest and a local interest as it relates to the operation of the court system. It's a shared interest with monies coming and going in different places for that enterprise. And I would also say that consistent with what Representative House has said, But it's certainly the position of judges at all levels that it's much more appropriate to fund the court system from general revenue, not from fees that are charged to users. But it costs money to run the court system. And so if money is taken from one area and not provided from another area, then you can't run the court system. And I'm happy to answer any specific question, Mr. Chairman. I don't have the fees as to the specific amounts of money that specific programs funded out of AOJ would lose as a result of it. The DF&A projection now shows just a little over a million dollars that came to the AOJ fund from this specific $25 court cost on seatbelts last year. Representative Boundary, did you have a question? No, I'm sorry. My mic's
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:40:52
on. Representative Tucker, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Gingrich, I just have
▶ Play
the, I pulled up a list of the funds that I believe the AOJ fund supports, and I just want to make sure I've got the right list, and we're talking about some of the same things. Mr. Whitmore recited a few of these things, but we're talking about Crime Victims, Reparation Revolving Fund, Prosecutor Coordinator's Office for Law Enforcement and Prosecutor Drug Enforcement Training Fund. Is that right? Yes. Crime Information System Fund, State Police Retirement Fund. So those are the kinds of things we're talking about. Public Defender Commission, Legal Aid. Yes, sir. I've got the right list. Okay, thank you very much. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chairman. all right i see no further questions all right that uh i believe that concludes everyone that had signed up for public comment representative richmond senator rice uh you recognize to close for your bill. If I
▶ Play
might make a statement, I'll let Representative Richmond wrap up.
▶ Play
I appreciate all the testimony and the questions, and I think we've all learned a little bit more, and I appreciate the sheriff that testified about what he does in his county, and it's passionate always about the seatbelt laws and lives it's saved, and we're not talking about that. It doesn't do away at the fine. But I have personal testimony from a former city officer that said they were told to their officers, your overtime is being paid out of seatbelt fines. That was four years ago. I'm still working on it. I don't have a problem with cities trying to pay their bills and all. But again, incentivizing is very concerning.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair, and thank you, committee. I appreciate the time and the questions, and I appreciate those that come up here and testified with some very good points. And, again, it goes back to my concern. You hear about paying court fees and things. Well, this particular bill would not, if you took it to court, basically all bets are off. So what they're doing now, you're paying court fees even if you plead guilty and never go to court, and that money has been divided up, those kind of fees. And that's what causes me the concern. I just feel like we're piling on. However, there were very good points brought up here and things that we need to consider. And Representative Howes made an excellent point. He said it much better than I ever could that our judicial system isn't meant to fund local government, state government, or anything else. It's meant to enforce the laws and keep us safe. And I think that's something that we need to take forward and consider. And because of that, at this point, Mr. Chair, with your permission, I'd like to go ahead and pull this bill down so that we can take a look at it and do some more work. That way I'm not putting the committee members here at this time in a position where they've got to try to make a decision. I know that all of you want to vote for it simply because of my pleasing, wonderful personality. And the last thing you would want to do is vote against something and make me unhappy. But there were some great questions here and some very good points, and I appreciate that. So with your permission, that's what
▶ Play
I would like to do. Without objection, we'll leave it on the agenda, and we'll take it up at another time.
▶ Play
Speaker 153 1:44:33
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you,
▶ Play
committee. Appreciate your time. Okay, committee. We've got, there were a couple other bills here, but I don't see any other sponsors. I'm going to ask for the indulgence of the committee. You probably noticed on the agenda that there are a number of bills that I filed yesterday that were assigned to our committee. They're all code revision. They're from the Code Revision Commission. They're technical corrections. I was informed late last night and then confirmed this morning the speaker would like for me to get these out of committee today so that we can take them up on the floor next Tuesday or possibly Wednesday when we kind of have a lull based on the two-day calendar. And so what I would ask, I guess if Representative House will come take the chair, I'd like to present these technical corrections. If we can get them out of committee, if anyone has an issue after we leave committee, let me know. And if I need to hold on to it before we run it, but in trying to work with the speaker on scheduling for next week, because these bills will not be batched on the floor. I mean, we have to take them up one by
▶ Play
Speaker 194 1:45:51
one. Representative Ballinger. I think you just answered my question. We can batch them here, though. Is
▶ Play
that correct? I would like to make a motion to batch them if the committee is. That's fine with me. Okay. My motion is that we batch these bills in committee unless somebody objects to one of them that needs to be pulled out.
▶ Play
All right. And so we have a motion. Is there any discussion? all right so we've got a motion after conferring with rebecca what what i would like to do is we'll hold the motion i'm going to go to the end of the table generally present the bills and then i'll let representative house chair the committee and then we can vote on these all at once but just to make sure we've complied with with all the technical requirements of the rules normally i would have to go to the end of the table so i'm going to go ahead and do that today and then we'll vote on them all as
▶ Play
Speaker 243 1:47:09
a batch. Which two? There's actually HB, we're starting at HB 13, 14
▶ Play
and we go all the way to HB 13, 12. One at
▶ Play
Speaker 65 1:47:20
a time? All right, let me see which, okay.
▶ Play
HB 13, 12. Okay. Okay. Colleagues, we're going to take up consideration in sequential order HB 1312 down to HB 1323. They are all technical correction bills. Without objection, we'll hear a presentation on all these bills at one time.
▶ Play
Any objections? Mr. Chairman, you have the floor. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. These bills, to give a little background, particularly for the new members, there is a commission that is created under Arkansas law. It's the Arkansas Code Revision Commission, and this commission is made up of a few legislators and also some other appointees to the commission. The commission is responsible for the publication of the Arkansas Code. So when you see the red and black code books, The commission is responsible for the publication of that. The commission also meets to reconcile, it could be errors in grammar, it could be inconsistency in terminology, and the commission attempts to reconcile any discrepancies and clean up the code for purposes of publication and also for ease of understanding and for consistency. This commission, we meet, I'm on the commission by appointment of the speaker. Representative Vines was, or former Representative Vines was on the commission. He left the commission at the end of his term. So right now I'm the only House member on the commission. Senator Raper is on the commission. Former Senator Johnson was on the commission, but when he concluded his term, he left the commission. So that's why myself and Senator Raper are the sponsors of this legislation. uh generally these are they're all technical corrections as you can see uh it's just a lot of cleanup it could be renumbering uh if anybody's worked on drafting a bill you you've seen that many times a lot of these technical corrections if the if the bill drafter can take care of it when you're working on a bill in one area sometimes they'll say we need to go ahead and clean this up too this this is a lot of the same type of thing it's just that we we try and pass a number of bills to clean all this up and it does it is very tedious work. Vince Henderson over at BLR is is our primary staff person and spends a lot of time on this. We have commission meetings and I believe our last commission meeting was at the end of the year. The commission has gone through all of these proposed changes or edits and these bills are drafted based on the recommendation of the commission and so uh as i mentioned earlier the the speaker would like to get these out of committee today so that when we get to i believe tuesday and maybe wednesday we can take some of these up on the floor uh when we might have a lighter day of business so i would uh i would move uh that we uh well i'll be glad to answer any questions But otherwise, I would move that we move to pass on these House bills that I've introduced. Are there any questions? Mr. Chairman, I accept your
▶ Play
motion. Is there a second? Is there a second? Any discussion? All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? You understand this was voting on all the number that we announced. Okay. Mr. Speaker, anything else? is there uh
▶ Play
i don't believe anyone else is here to run a bill and so just a reminder we've got two special orders next tuesday the special order that was previously set for next thursday has now been moved back to the following tuesday and our committee picture again is next thursday at 10 a.m so announced all right anything else we're adjourned You
▶ Play

Agenda

Subtitle Sponsor Number

HB1126 Collins TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF "EMPLOYER" AND THE HATE OFFENSE AND RETALIATION PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CIVIL RIGHTS ACT OF 1993.

2:34 - 39:43 96 segments 9 speakers

REGULAR AGENDA Sponsor Subtitle Number

HB1007 Tucker TO PROTECT CITIZENS WHO ARE VICTIMS OF JUDICIAL ETHICS VIOLATIONS; TO CREATE A CAUSE OF ACTION AGAINST JUDGES AND JUSTICES WHO HAVE BEEN CONVICTED OF CERTAIN OFFENSES; AND TO CREATE AN EXCEPTION TO JUDICIAL IMMUNITY.

HB1006 Tucker TO AMEND CERTAIN CRIMINAL OFFENSES CONCERNING ABUSES OF PUBLIC OFFICE; TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING ABUSE OF OFFICE; AND TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING ABUSE OF PUBLIC TRUST.

HB1013 D. Meeks CONCERNING THE CRIMINAL OFFENSE OF INTERNET STALKING OF A CHILD.

39:43 - 48:11 21 segments 4 speakers

HB1041 B. Smith TO PROTECT THE RIGHTS AND PRIVILEGES GRANTED UNDER THE ARKANSAS AND CONSTITUTION; DECLARE TO STATES AND CONSTITUTION UNITED THE AMERICAN LAWS FOR AMERICAN COURTS.

HB1045 B. Smith CONCERNING CRIMINAL VICTIM NOTIFICATION; AND CONCERNING THE RELEASE OF A PERSON WHO COMMITTED A CRIMINAL ACT AND WAS ADJUDICATED TO HAVE A MENTAL DISEASE OR DEFECT.

HB1152 Watson CONCERNING THE ABILITY OF AN AUXILIARY LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER TO CARRY A CONCEALED HANDGUN AND TO BE EXEMPTED BE FROM THE LICENSING REQUIREMENTS TO CARRY A CONCEALED HANDGUN.

HB1158 Petty CONCERNING THE ENTRY UNDER CAUSE OF DEATH ON A PERSON'S DEATH CERTIFICATE WHEN THE PERSON WAS EXECUTED DUE TO A SENTENCE FOR A CAPITAL OFFENSE.

HB1173 Tucker TO AMEND AND MAKE CONSISTENT THE OFFENSES OF SEXUAL INDECENCY WITH A CHILD AND SEXUAL ASSAULT IN THE FOURTH DEGREE; AND TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF "SEXUAL ABUSE" UNDER THE CHILD MALTREATMENT ACT.

HB1175 Tucker TO REQUIRE LIFETIME REGISTRATION ON THE ARKANSAS SEX OFFENDER REGISTRY FOR A PERSON CONVICTED OF RAPE WHEN THE RAPE INVOLVED THE USE OF FORCE

HB1177 Tucker INCREASING THE AVAILABLE SENTENCES FOR CERTAIN SEX OFFENSES WHEN COMMITTED AGAINST A FAMILY OR HOUSEHOLD MEMBER.

HB1198 Lundstrum TO ALLOW AN OUT-OF-STATE LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER TO FOLLOW A VEHICLE INTO ARKANSAS TO INVESTIGATE A VIOLENT CRIME, A FELONY, OR THE OPERATION OF A VEHICLE WHILE THE DRIVER IS INTOXICATED, IMPAIRED, OR UNDER THE INFLUENCE.

48:11 - 52:50 27 segments 7 speakers

SB102 Rice TO CLARIFY THE LAW CONCERNING THE FINES, FEES, AND COSTS THAT MAY BE ASSESSED FOR A VIOLATION OF THE MANDATORY SEAT BELT USE LAW.

52:50 - 1:48:12 167 segments 28 speakers

HB1236 Gazaway TO PROTECT THE PRIVACY OF SURVIVING FAMILY MEMBERS OF A LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER WHO DIES IN THE LINE OF DUTY; AND TO EXEMPT CERTAIN LAW ENFORCEMENT RECORDS FROM DISCLOSURE; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

HB1248 J. Williams TO CREATE AN EXEMPTION UNDER THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT OF 1967 CONCERNING CERTAIN LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIVE RECORDS.

HB1251 Walker TO CREATE THE "HELPING OUR PEOPLE EXCEL (H.O.P.E.) ACT OF 2017"; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES.

HB1260 Maddox TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING REIMBURSEMENT FOR JUROR ORIENTATION COSTS.

HB1265 Richey CONCERNING THE POSSESSION AND CARRYING OF A CONCEALED OR UNCONCEALED HANDGUN; TO ESTABLISH A LICENSE TO CARRY AN UNCONCEALED HANDGUN; AND TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS

HB1268 Murdock CONCERNING THE USE OF AN IGNITION INTERLOCK DEVICE.

HB1269 Johnson CONCERNING HANDGUN TRAINING REQUIREMENTS FOR VETERANS OF THE UNITED STATES ARMED FORCES AND CURRENT MEMBERS OF THE UNITED STATES ARMED FORCES WHO APPLY FOR A CONCEALED HANDGUN LICENSE.

SB20 J. Hendren CONCERNING THE OFFENSE OF AGGRAVATED ASSAULT UPON A CERTIFIED LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER OR AN EMPLOYEE OF A CORRECTIONAL FACILITY; TO PROVIDE A MORE SERIOUS PENALTY FOR KNOWINGLY DISCHARGING A FIREARM AT A LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER.

HB1299 Brown CREATING THE OFFENSE OF POSSESSION OF A HANDGUN WHILE INTOXICATED; AND CONCERNING THE PLACES AND LOCATIONS A CONCEALED HANDGUN LICENSEE IS PROHIBITED FROM CARRYING A CONCEALED HANDGUN.

HB1312 Shepherd TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 11 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING LABOR AND INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS

1:48:12 - 1:48:24 1 segment 1 speaker

HB1314 Shepherd TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 8 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING ENVIRONMENTAL LAW.

1:48:24 - 1:48:24

HB1315 Shepherd TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 2 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING AGRICULTURAL LAW.

1:48:24 - 1:48:24

HB1316 Shepherd TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 13 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING MUSEUMS.

1:48:24 - 1:48:24

HB1317 Shepherd TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 14 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERING LOCAL GOVERNMENT.

1:48:24 - 1:48:24

HB1318 Shepherd TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 4 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING BUSINESS AND COMMERCIAL LAW.

1:48:24 - 1:48:24

HB1319 Shepherd TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 23 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING PUBLIC UTILITIES AND REGULATED INDUSTRIES.

1:48:24 - 1:48:24

HB1320 Shepherd TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE OF 5 THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING CRIMINAL OFFENSES AND THE CRIMINAL LAW.

1:48:24 - 1:48:24

HB1321 Shepherd TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 26 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE OCONCERNING TAXATION.

1:48:24 - 1:48:24

HB1322 Shepherd TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 19 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING PUBLIC FINANCE.

1:48:24 - 1:48:24

HB1323 Shepherd TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 20 OF THE ARKNASAS CODE CONCERNING PUBLIC HEALTH AND WELFARE.

1:48:24 - 1:51:41 7 segments 2 speakers

HB1249 Collins CONCERNING THE POSSESSION OF A CONCEALED HANDGUN IN A PUBLIC UNIVERSITY, PUBLIC COLLEGE, OR COMMUNITY COLLEGE BUILDING.

DEFERRED BILLS

Subtitle Sponsor Number

HB1095 Johnson CONCERNING THE REQUIREMENTS FOR A CONCEALED HANDGUN LICENSE FOR A CURRENT OR FORMER MEMBER OF THE UNITED STATES ARMED FORCES.

HB1197 Sturch TO ESTABLISH A METHOD FOR A PERSON WHO WAS FALSELY ACCUSED OF A CRIMINAL OFFENSE TO MAKE A CLAIM FOR REIMBURSEMENT FOR HIS OR HER EXPENSES PAID TO AN ATTORNEY IN DEFENSE OF THE FALSE ACCUSATION.

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Matthew J. Shepherd Chair Unverified
67 segments
Representative Charlie Collins Unverified
17 segments
Representative David Whitaker Unverified
37 segments
Representative Clarke Tucker Unverified
3 segments
Representative Jimmy Gazaway Unverified
9 segments
Speaker 63
5 segments
David Curran Unverified
6 segments
Brian Vandiver Unverified
9 segments
Representative Douglas House Unverified
14 segments
Representative Stephen Meeks Unverified
12 segments
Representative Robin Lundstrum Unverified
12 segments
Speaker 112
2 segments
Representative Charles Blake Unverified
25 segments
Representative Laurie Rushing Unverified
11 segments
Chair Unverified
22 segments
Representative Michelle Gray Unverified
5 segments
Senator Terry Rice Unverified
15 segments
Speaker 152
1 segment
Speaker 169
1 segment
Speaker 173
1 segment
Representative Lanny Fite Unverified
2 segments
Mike Godfrey Unverified
7 segments
Speaker 187
1 segment
Speaker 190
9 segments
Representative Bob Ballinger Unverified
9 segments
Speaker 203
6 segments
Representative Trevor Drown Chair Unverified
3 segments
Representative Sarah Capp Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 232
6 segments
Representative Marcus E. Richmond Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 153
1 segment
Speaker 194
1 segment
Speaker 243
1 segment
Speaker 65
1 segment