Judiciary Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (27)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1055
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…members of the committee. I'm here before to present to you House Bill 1055, which is in alignment with a recent Supreme Court ruling o…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1006
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1006 Tucker TO AMEND CERTAIN CRIMINAL OFFENSES CONCERNING ABUSES…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1007
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1007 Tucker TO PROTECT CITIZENS WHO ARE VICTIMS OF JUDICIAL ETHI…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1045
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1045 B. Smith CONCERNING CRIMINAL VICTIM NOTIFICATION; AND CONCE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1152
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1152 Watson CONCERNING THE ABILITY OF AN AUXILIARY LAW ENFORCEME…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1158
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1158 PETTY CONCERNING THE ENTRY UNDER CAUSE OF DEATH ON A PERSON…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1173
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1173 Tucker TO AMEND AND MAKE CONSISTENT THE OFFENSES OF SEXUAL…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1175
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1175 Tucker TO REQUIRE LIFETIME REGISTRATION ON THE ARKANSAS SEX…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1177
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1177 Tucker INCREASING THE AVAILABLE SENTENCES FOR CERTAIN SEX O…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1197
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1197 Sturch TO ESTABLISH A METHOD FOR A PERSON WHO WAS FALSELY A…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1236
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1236 Gazaway TO PROTECT THE PRIVACY OF SURVIVING FAMILY MEMBERS…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1251
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “Walker HB1251 TO CREATE THE "HELPING OUR PEOPLE EXCEL (H.O.P.E.) ACT OF 2…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1260
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1260 Maddox TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING REIMBURSEMENT FOR JUROR…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1354
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1354 Nicks CONCERNING DISTRICT COURT CLERK EMPLOYMENT.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1362
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1362 Payton CONCERNING THE RIGHTS OF A CONCEALED HANDGUN LICENSE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1367
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1367 Watson CONCERNING AN AUXILIARY LAW ENFORCEMENT OR A RETIRED…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1375
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1375 Tucker TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE FILING REQUIREMENTS…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1382
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1382 Gazaway TO ESTABLISH PROCEDURES TO BE FOLLOWED AFTER A CLAI…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1385
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1385 Lemons TO BE KNOWN AS "SHANNON'S LAW"; AND CONCERNING THE P…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1415
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1415 Shepherd TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 6 OF THE AR…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1416
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1416 Shepherd TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 17 OF THE A…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1420
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1420 C. Fite TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS DOMESTIC VIOLENCE SHELTER AC…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1433
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1433 BaltzTO PROHIBIT A REGISTERED SEX OFFENDER FROM LIVING NEAR…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1444
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1444 Ballinger TO REVISE CERTAIN EMINENT DOMAIN LAWS THAT ARISE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1453
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1453 Farrer PROHIBITING IMPROPER SEXUAL CONDUCT BETWEEN A PROBAT…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB102
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB102 Rice TO CLARIFY THE LAW CONCERNING THE FINES, FEES, AND COS…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB32
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB32 Hickey PROHIBITING CERTAIN SEX OFFENDERS FROM ENTERING UPON…”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 14, 2026
Mr. Chairman, with the chair's permission, I'd like to invite Judge Robert Hertzfield to sit at the end of the table with me, please. Mr. Churchfield. Good morning. Good morning.
May my guest introduce himself for the record, please, Mr.
Speaker 17
0:36
Chair. Yes. Hi, I'm Circuit Judge Robert Hurstfield from Saline County. Okay, glad to have you. Glad to
be here. Thank you. Representative Hammer. Thank you, Mr. Chair and members of the committee. I'm here before to present to you House Bill 1055, which is in alignment with a recent Supreme Court ruling of this past year. Judge Hurstfield approached me and asked me if I would help run this piece of legislation. Certainly, he's more of the expert in this area than I am, and basically, if it's all right with you, Mr. Chair,
I'd like to yield the mic to Judge Hertzfield to give some explanations why this rule is needed, please, or this law is needed. Thank you. Thank
Speaker 17
1:12
you. Good morning, everybody. I appreciate your giving me the opportunity to be here. I won't take too much of your time. I'm going to have kind of a brief overview, then I'll be happy to answer any questions. My understanding is there's some other folks that will testify in opposition to the bill. I look forward to hearing what they have to say as well. I'm sure you do, too. 30 years ago, it's a great way to start off, right? In the beginning of time,
30 years ago, the Supreme Court recognized a common law doctrine called active appreciation. It was a doctrine that was being used all across the country. It's common still. North Carolina, Texas, Colorado, Arizona, California, just broad swath of the country uses this doctrine. And what But what it is is basically as I can. It's kind of an obscure little provision, except when it matters, it matters.
So for active appreciation, if there is property that someone has prior to marriage, but they spend or either spouse spends a significant amount of time, effort, expertise, and developing and making the property more valuable during the marriage, then there is a presumption, not a finding, but a presumption that that time, expertise, all the work that that person put in or that spouse put in makes the property become marital property.
An example I like to give would be if you had an individual who was in high school or college and bought a screen printer for a T-shirt business, and then the next day they got married, And they spent 30 years developing that screen printer in business into Nike or whatever. And so during all that time, they're putting all their work and time and effort into the business. And then at the end of the marriage, if there were not a doctrine of active appreciation,
every bit of that would go to one spouse versus the other. And the other spouse would be out in the cold without that doctrine or without using equity, which I'll get to in a second. So a contrary example would be if you had somebody, say, who inherited some stocks. And during the marriage, during that 30-year marriage, those stocks sat there and accumulated, and there were dividends paid, and they were put back into it over that 20-, 30-year marriage or 5- or 10-year marriage, that stock sat there. Well, that would not be active appreciation.
That would be the very definition of a passive appreciation. So the value of increase in those stocks would not be marital property. Another example I think would be appropriate would be timberland or oil leases, where there's this money coming in, the person who owns it, who's lucky enough to own it, whether by purchase or inheritance or whatever, that property, if they're not actively working on it, and the word would be significantly active, working on it, then that is non-marital property.
So those are the contrary examples. That was the rule in the law for three decades, and the rule of law around the country even before that. And so last year, the Supreme Court looked at it, looked at the statutes in a particular case, and said, well, without commenting on whether this is fair or not, we don't believe, as the Supreme Court of Arkansas, that that doctrine tracks the statute. And so we're going to throw out that doctrine.
And what they said was that is a policy decision that the legislature should make. And so here we are. You're the legislature. You're obviously the judicial committee. This is where we're starting to essentially put back in place law that had existed for decades. And I think it's a fair law and it's a good law. The reason that I'm here is because precedent should have value, consistency, predictability. These are things that judges and lawyers and people who are involved in litigation prefer.
They like to know what's happening, what to expect, how to advise their clients, and judges like to know how other judges are expected to rule, and so they can be in line with what's fair. And if you have consistency and predictability, then you have fairness. And if you have different judges applying the rules differently, then it becomes and certainly seems unfair, even if it might be fair in that individual case. So there is, again, a presumption that this would be marital property.
Under Arkansas law, a divorce court, judges have broad discretion, broad fairness powers, broad what's called equity. And equity, as I'm sure most of you know, if not all of you know, it doesn't mean equal. It means fair. So, for instance, if there was property that was defined as marital under this doctrine, if one person had put in all the work let's say a woman had put in all the work and the husband was a layabout no good for nothing was bad and had done lots of bad stuff and had spent all the
money and was a jerk and the judge said well this is marital property but it would not be fair for this for the husband to have half of this or potentially any of it and so the judge is going to use equity and lay out why that would not be fair and then the Supreme Court or the Court of appeals would determine whether that was fair or not. So it's really more aligned with what we all think of justice is, you know, what is fair, what seems unfair, and let's do what we can to minimize the opportunities for there to be unfair rulings. My understanding is that some of the
testimony will be about expense as far as expert witnesses or additional effort it takes to evaluate property? Well, if there's enough property to evaluate and have experts testify as to value, then there's probably enough for a little bit more in there for experts to testify. I've been a divorce judge for eight years, and experts are helpful. Sometimes they're not as helpful as they think they are, but it's something that is a part of a case. Frankly, if there's a situation where
there might be premarital property, and it's a case where they might wind up having to hire experts, that might be a good case for a prenuptial agreement, if there's inherited money or other things like that. There's ways that are to protect assets and to secure assets that are certainly appropriate without risking leaving somebody out in the cold, or, you know, which would be individual cases would be bad but frankly risking more diversity among decisions across the state
so you want the reason to have it in the statute and the reason to have the doctrine apply is because you want the judges in Bentonville to make the same kind of decisions as the judges in Camden do or in El Dorado or Wynn and so having this doctrine spelled out and and applying it as a presumption which gives a judge flexibility if it's not appropriate to do so he doesn't he or she does not have to do so, then that's the better way to go. So I think that's the big picture. I'm certainly happy to take any questions or listen to any comments or have you yell at me or laugh
at me or whatever. Anyone on the committee have a question? Representative
House, you're recognized for your question. As I keep reading the statute, I keep thinking of another scenario that I encountered a number of years ago. A wife brings a farm with her into the marriage. Husband works diligently for 25 or 30 years, a fairly long marriage,
so she could stay home and she was driving fence posts and cutting hay and all that sort of stuff. By him working outside at the factory, he provided the food and the lights and all that stuff. Well, his efforts didn't directly contribute to the appreciation of that value, but his efforts kept her alive and supported and all that while she caused the accretion. How does that scenario fit?
I mean, it's an economic partnership, too, besides a spiritual and all that other. All other important stuff like love and
Speaker 17
9:45
happiness, that's good, too. Yeah, yeah. Somebody's heard about that. That would apply in this case as well. So if either party does the work during the marriage, they're using, I think a good way to think about it is, you know, we have obviously money is a resource. But in a marriage, as we all know, or anybody who's married knows or had, you know, folks who are married, time is a resource also.
And so if you're spending 18 hours a day of your marriage time working on a business, then there are sacrifices that are made. And there are tradeoffs that we all make as we're trying to make it in this world together. And in that case, that active appreciation doctrine would apply because it's either spouse. And so if they're putting those resources of the marriage into it, whether it's money or not, it is a resource, which is time, effort, stress. you know the in that case the wife might might have yelled at the husband because she was really
worn out about the you know the cows coming home too soon or too late or whatever and he had to deal with that stress so there's there's things that occur in a marriage that are broadly speaking taking into account so that kind of situation that you described the portion of her time that was increased not the original farm but the portion of value that increased during that marriage would be presumed to be marital. But that doesn't mean it has to be marital. There could be other factors
that would apply. And then even if there is marital property, then the judge also has equity where he can or she can divide the property not equally. And so if the mom or the dad, so I said mom, but the wife had a hundred thousand or let's say a thousand acre farm in East Arkansas and had rice and all this other stuff on it and the husband worked and did some stuff and they were pretty happy until they weren't happy. If she worked on it and kind of kept it up
and had sold duck leases and stuff, that's fine. But if he didn't need the money because he was a multimillionaire also, the judge could say under equity, this is her family land, this is what I think is fair, he's taken care of, she has the farm and I'm going to let her make sure that she keeps that farm. And so equity comes back and solves a lot of problems. I'm really glad that I primarily operate in a court of equity because I like to do what's fair. But I love to have guideposts. Thank you.
Representative Petty, you're recognized for a question. Representative Gray, you're
recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. So make sure I'm understanding this right. So essentially, kind of what I'm understanding is that you would be changing the presumption is what we're doing here. So you're changing it from currently you have to, it's not marital property to start with,
and then you have to show that you put time effort into it. So you're changing it to it's automatically. No, we still have to
Speaker 17
12:55
show what the difference would be. And the, well, I lost some train of thought there, the, when you say I'm changing it, I'm actually restoring it because this was a law for 30 years. And this is what the Supreme Court had said was a law until last year. So there is a presumption, but you still would have to prove that there was value.
So this is where experts might come in or spreadsheets or whatever as far as what the difference was between the merit. So the T-shirt business increased in value from $1 to $1 million. Well, that's generally pretty easy to show, although sometimes small businesses can be tricky as far as what the value is. But that's the difference between start and finish and taking into consideration the amount of work that was put into it. So this spouse would testify I worked every day, or I didn't work in that at all.
So I might have a stock in a business that is a family business that I didn't do anything with. I just got a dividend well that would not have been appreciated by that person's work and so it wouldn't count so it gets really complicated really quick and I don't want to bore you with that kind of explanation but that's to answer your question is to restore the presumption that exists but there's still evidence in court and testimony and all that stuff still comes into play like it would in any other case okay and a follow-up Mr. Chair you're recognized thank you
Um, when I'm looking at this bill, it just says a spouse. It doesn't say which spouse, so it doesn't matter. So essentially, if you've got someone who, this t-shirt business, if either spouse put time and effort into it, it then becomes marital property to be split evenly. Right. That's the law that
Speaker 17
14:40
it was under Lehman. In fact, Lehman was a case just like that. The husband had put all the effort into the business, and the wife was, even though they had been married 31 years, she was left out in the cold until the Supreme Court said that
doesn't seem fair to us, and so we want to apply this doctrine. However, even though it's split, that doesn't mean, again, it goes back to equity, that doesn't mean that it has to be, even if it's marital, it doesn't necessarily mean that it's divided down the middle. We're not in California where you just chop it down the middle. You take into account other things, and that's what the judges would do and say, well, he did that, but she did these other
things, and so let's find the best solution. Okay. This just seems kind of backwards to me. Instead of, you're essentially saying if either spouse, even if one had left the state for 10 years, came back,
they're still married and they get divorced, it's automatically saying because one of the spouses put the work in, it's now considered marital property. So the person that put all the work in now has to prove to a judge that the other spouse did nothing. So it changes that presumption from, you see, I guess I'm trying to explain. I hear what you're saying, but that's not that
Speaker 17
15:47
hard to do. If one person didn't do anything, it's not that hard to show it. How is it that hard to show
it the other way? I guess what I'm saying is what's wrong with the law the way it currently stands?
If it's not that hard to disprove, why is it that hard to
Speaker 17
16:03
prove? It's not hard to prove because the math is there and the testimony would be there. But what you're doing by having the doctrine apply equally across the state is making sure that it's consistent across the state and that it's
predictable. Okay. I guess maybe, and I keep going. I'm sorry, Mr. Chair. I guess maybe what I would like to see is the current principles that are in the statute, maybe what we haven't followed for 30 years, but what's in statute applied evenly. Is it not currently applied evenly?
Speaker 17
16:31
There are many judges that do a fantastic job across the state, and I tried my best to be one of them. But it's better for all of us to have clear rules that are spelled out as a starting point. And then you look at the individual facts of each case. There are some cases where it is obvious that it would not be fair to follow that, and it's a presumption. It's not an automatic, and that's the word you used while I go, that it's not accurate. It's not automatic. It is a presumption, and then you have court, and then we hear the case, and we hear both sides. Thank you.
Sure. Thank you. Representative Maddock, you're recognized for a question. Thank you. I have a couple questions about this. I have a couple concerns. I may be looking at it incorrectly, but you've talked about substantial time and 18-hour days and a lot of those things. But when I look at this, it just says, unless I'm looking at it incorrectly, it says when the increase in the value of the property of this section resulted from the time, effort, or skill. So there's nothing about substantial or significant.
And I guess the concern, the first thing I thought about was like timber lands. You know, like where I live, people have timber interest. They may go and drive and look at it two or three times per year. And I'm afraid when a court or a lawyer reads this, they're going to say, well, it's just time. It doesn't say substantial. It doesn't say significant. And then the presumption, and I know what you're saying, but presumptions are strong. When there's a presumption in the law, it's hard to overcome, in my opinion. So am I missing something on substantial?
Speaker 17
18:04
I think substantial, that is, when we were drafting it, that was discussed, and I think that would be a fine amendment. Okay. The discussion was along the lines of if it's a minimal time, then there's
minimal money. Right, but this opens it up for minimal, and then you're stuck with the timberland or all
Speaker 17
18:28
the other small business issues. I have no problem with changing it to have substantial. Okay. but that's up to obviously y'all and many representatives of Hammer,
but that's fine as well and would certainly correct any problems that you might have on that issue. Could I have a
follow-up? Matt, you're recognized for a follow-up. My understanding of divorce laws as it is now is you, as the court, you have a lot of power to divide marital property and non-marital property in any way you want to to make it equal. I mean, you can do that now regardless
Speaker 17
19:03
of if we pass this bill or not, correct? Under equity and under, there's a, actually it's 9, 12, 3, 15, you have the power as a judge to allocate non-marital property.
There's a certain list of things that you're supposed to use and you're supposed to get, it's more complicated and it's more, sets out more requirements because there has to be written findings. But that is the catch-all. And again, there's lots of catch-alls in divorce law because every case is so different. um but you can do that and that in fact they've the court referenced that in more as a well we can do this because it's not changing much right right that's that's it's in there but it still leads to uh less predictability in the law because you're having if you're applying equity in cases
across the state again that's where there can be things that get out of whack unless and until the Supreme Court addresses it, but they're, you know, a tiny percentage of the cases that get decided to actually make it to
the Supreme Court. Could I have one last question? One more. And the last follow-up, and I think you know the answer to this, but you also have the ability to award alimony, do
Speaker 17
20:15
those things to make any offset. Less so now, but yeah. Yeah, I don't reward alimony very often anyway because of law and because of different ways of approaching. Things are different now mostly but uh
sure okay thank you sure represent the whitaker you recognize for a
question thank you mr chair thank you for coming judge sure the
word presumption you know every everybody that gets uh studies for a bar exam that's one of those words that jumps out and you go uh-oh um here you know it is this a case where if i'm if i'm representing the party who brought the original property in, do I have to come in and rebut that presumption? Are we using presumption in that sense of the word? Are we talking a burden shift to me to
rebut that this is marital property up front as an initial part of my case
Speaker 17
21:11
in chief? Well, there has to be a fact established, which is that there was property at all. So, I mean, presumptions are important, but they're not all-consuming. So, it's hard to answer that question as far as, I guess you're talking about the burden of proof.
Yeah, is there a brand shift here? Because when we see presumption, that's the first thing part of my lawyer, part of my brain goes, ooh, did the burden just shift
Speaker 17
21:42
prove that there is a business, and you have to talk about what the business is and that there was time and effort and skills put into that business by a spouse. So the word presumption really doesn't, I hadn't really contemplated it that much, but it really doesn't do much to do anything because you're still having to prove that. And once you've proven it, that would be the same as meeting proof with proof after the fact anyway. So the answer to your question is no.
Thank you. seeing no more questions we will now go to the audience mr mike davis is signed up to speak against the bill if you would take your seat at the end of the table oh sure good morning mr davis you would just state your
Speaker 73
22:36
name for the record please my name is michael a davis i'm from magnolia arkansas i'm a oil and gas operator owner of timberland father of two
daughters in their mid-30s okay you recognize which thank you i'd like to thank the chairman and the committee for time to let me speak today i i wish it were a perfect world i mean i wish we all got married to our high school sweetheart we all had the house and the picket fence and the dogs and the cats and all that. It's not. Some of us get married in our teens, some in our 20s. Some get divorced in our 30s, get remarried in the 50s. I can set out for
you two real-world scenarios that have occurred to me. I have received both inherited property and gifted property. I inherit an interest in an oil well that was my father. We are an oil and gas operating company. We do actively go out and do the work in the field. I inherit a well. I pay the estate taxes on that well. That well has two zones that are capable of being productive.
When I inherit the well, it's producing out of one zone. During the course of the marriage, that zone reaches its economic limits. I go out there, I physically do the work, I plug off the lower zone, re-complete in the upper zone, and thus increase the value of that asset. Under this proposed bill, time, effort, and skill, that increase in value becomes marital property. Spouse didn't pay the taxes on it.
The spouse didn't inherit it. I inherit it. I've been gifted timberland. Those of us that gift timberland to our children and our grandchildren or have it gifted to us, it's typically gifted into the name of the child. Very rarely is it gifted into the name of the spouse. If I do nothing more than be a good steward of what I've been blessed with and go out, get a forester, take care of the timber,
tend to it the way I'm supposed to tend to it. It was a gift to me, family property that had been in the family for years and years and years. It increases in value because I'm a good steward of it. Under this bill, that becomes marital property. I just don't see that that's the way it ought to be. This bill is gender neutral. It affects a lady coming into a marriage with assets the same as it affects a man coming into a marriage with assets.
The bill is extremely vague. And I also think, you know, there are ways, as the judge said, to protect your assets when you go into a marriage. We can form a corporation the day before we get married. We can have a prenuptial agreement. I personally don't care for those. I've never seen one yet that I felt like was blanket that covered every scenario. Plus, in my mind, if I ask you to sign a prenuptial agreement before we get married,
I'm going into the marriage with the supposition that it's probably going to fail. I don't like to go into any endeavor thinking that it's going to fail. Thank you
for your time. Representative House, you're recognized for a question. May I ask
you a question, please? I'm trying not to make it personal, and I don't want to, but we'll just use the same scenario that you mentioned about the oil wells and putting them into production and all that, and that's a noble thing to be doing.
I don't know if this fits you or not, and it doesn't matter whether it does or not, but let's say we're talking about a 30-year marriage, Meanwhile, she's cleaning the house, raising the kids, taking them to soccer practice, sleeping with you, cooking your meals, nursing you when you're sick, get hurt, taking care of all the kids. And then you would find it offensive after 30 years, she would be able to share in the value of that oil well?
follow up but like you said we don't live in that perfect world that's recognized for a follow up yeah so those kind of people don't ever get divorced and not split assets so you're not answering my question okay that's fine thank you
Seeing no other questions, we'll go to the audience.
Mr. Davis, thank you for your time. Thank you. I don't have anyone to speak for the bill, so we'll go to Mr. Sam Hilburn, who's speaking against the bill. Mr. Hilburn, if you would, just have a seat at the end of the table and state your name
for the record, please, sir. My name is Sam Hilburn. I'm an attorney in North Little Rock, and I have been practicing for 44 years. And my practice has evolved in primarily domestic relations.
I have five other young attorneys who work with me. I probably have one of the heaviest domestic relations practice in the state. And I'm in a precarious position. I tried a case before this young man. I'm 74, so I can call him a young man. I tried a case, Friday, and here I am opposing him. I've already read it. Oh, great. One of the problems you run into, there are several problems.
I think we should leave it, as the Supreme Court said, in the case of Moore v. Moore. There's two ways to solve the problem of these inequities that if you have a situation where, and for the record I probably represent or I have in 44 years represented probably 65 percent of my clients have been female and I don't mean this disparaging or anything but generally in my experience the female has been the one who didn't have the property and it was the male who had the
property and so I've had to fight very hard you know to see that she got what she was entitled to if she had a 30-year marriage or a 20-year marriage or whatever it might be. One of the problems you get into in trying to evaluate this appreciation, you have to have a baseline. What's the baseline? What was that property worth when you got married? And if it was 30 years ago, who are you going to bring to tell me or tell the judge, what was that property worth 30 years ago?
And then you get into, well, how much did it appreciate? i've had these cases where i have to go hire an expert who's going to come in and and it's an educated guest now if you get to talking about oil i've got to go somebody to know something about oil and and i guess what i encounter mostly is farmland and like i say if you're up there from jonesboro on down the flyway back when i was a kid that was just good old farmland and it might
be worth $500 an acre, $700 an acre, or $1,000 an acre. Now, we know what farmland's going for right now, but all of a sudden, you know, people said, I like duck hunting. So I've got a little swamp on my land. I had never been able to farm, and I said, I'm going to start renting that out to duck hunters. And then you have got appreciation, and you've got problems as how much did it increase the value of that land that I can now duck hunt on it
that I couldn't before. You go up there in Clebron County, you know what, 10 years ago, you could have bought some of that land for maybe $700, $800, $1,000 an acre. All of a sudden, we've got the gas companies coming in here and that land has skyrocketed. No one did anything. but I guarantee you if there's someone getting a divorce up there that old boy is going to say I did a lot of work on developing this stuff
and when you get money hitting the table when you're talking about oil, gas, farmland and farmland that's been down in my county I'm from Lawrence County, I'm an old country boy coming to town there's people that had that land back in the 1800's and it's still coming through the family if it's now marital property the question now gets into do you divide the land now to get them paid that's been in the family and you intended to stay in the family all those years?
So in trying to evaluate the appreciation I have to hire an expert. Well the other side is going to hire an expert because they counter my expert. I'm going to say it didn't increase but $100,000 and he's going to say it increased $10 million. Then what's the judge going to do? You've got to find me, so I don't believe both of them. Then he's got to substitute his judgment for somebody, and if it's like most of them, most of the judges I know are not lucky enough to be old men, and I wish I were.
I wouldn't be doing this. So you get into a very difficult situation, and it costs money to hire these experts. I've hired experts who I've been in a case for months, and they come in for a couple of months to come testify, and they charge more than I do. And it costs more than what my legal bill is just so you can have somebody, well, it increases much, and the other one says, no, it didn't. It drags out the divorce.
It increases the animosity. Particularly if you've got children involved there, that builds exponentially is when they get to fighting over dollars and dragging it out and having to spend money. And it's my experience when I'm representing generally the one who doesn't have the money they don't have the money to even hire an expert it becomes very difficult for those people to try to hire an expert to put forth their case I said I could put forth a case if I could hire an expert but I'm just going to have to get up
there and wing it so I think this now so what's the solution here there's two things that are available to people right now you can make an unequal distribution of marital assets they always have a house well 99% of the time they own a house if they if they got the kind of money they're going to be fighting over we're not going to divide it there's a house there that judge can divide you know normally you're going to have to sell that house and split the
money is what they do or one buys the other one out but there's other assets if you got that kind of money there's other assets that can be uh given to that person who's suffering and our alimony now it's it's always you you cannot imagine the angst i get from people when they mention that word that's like a bad word that alimony but the judge can give it and and that alimony that alimony can can even that up and if you've got a real nice asset worth asset worth something that you
don't want to divide you should be able if it's farmland you can lease it if it's farmland you can make money on it if it's an oil you can make the money to pay that alimony to equal that out now it may be a whole lot of money i've had them one gentleman had his business but he's paying $35,000 a month and that sure did equal it she walked out with eight thousand eight million dollars worth of property now that's an those don't come along very often those don't come
along but it equaled it and he kept his business and he is worth a couple hundred million dollars and he's still going but she's she's living a good life I'm not always that fortunate to have clients with that kind of money. But there's ways, the two ways, unequal division of those assets and alimony can even that balance or help balance it out. But otherwise, it just costs too much money to hire the experts on deciding the appreciation. Now, in the language, it says time.
how much time and then and it uses time effort how much effort skill if if you inherited farmland or you inherited oil leases that wasn't any skill in that you didn't do anything you just happened to hit and i think now i'm not too much of an oil man but i know down there in south arkansas when i was a lot younger they quit pumping the oil wasn't as good and then all of a sudden all sky high and they're pumping down there
re-pumping those oil wells, redoing those oil wells and you know the value has gone up and down so I'm saying you have to hire experts to make those determinations and it becomes very costly for the litigants and it drags it to me it drags it out and it does there's those other ways again unequal distribution of property alimony it's the easiest way to solve it thank you mr
chairman members of the committee thank you seeing uh seeing no questions for mr hilburn and uh no one else has signed up to speak for or against the bill representative hammer are you ready to close for your bill i am mr
chair i would like to make a request to the chair but i'll respect whatever you decide i know typically when it comes to closing the legislator handles that and I do have some closing comments but be honest with you because I'm not an expert in this matter would it be permissible to let the judge respond to some of the
options as part of my closing it'd be very short
I'm going to allow that representative hammer thank
Speaker 17
37:53
this rule does again which was has been in effect
for the last 30 years and i'm not aware i'm sure there are cases where that somebody was very unhappy about it but i'm not aware of any that were um dramatic i haven't heard any stories today about how bad it was back in the bad old days last year about the active appreciation um what the rule does it fixes the starting line and mr hilburn is an excellent attorney he's in my court all the time i he i get along with him well i don't bury me neither will whatsoever um for him to have a different difference of opinion it's a policy decision that's what you
guys do is make policy and i believe the policy that was in effect of having a starting line where the marital resources that are used count for marital assets. Whether it started off on a technicality before the marriage or not, to me, if you're using marital resources, it ought to be counted towards what they did together as a couple. If somebody disagrees with that, I'm not mad about it. I told Representative Hammer yesterday on the phone. He's like, you know, I don't have a dog in this hunt
other than I like the law to be predictable. I married a girl from South Arkansas, but she wasn't rich. Okay, so I'm not getting anything out of this other than trying to make sure that the rules are there. She's beautiful, by the way, and very intelligent, but she was not rich. But I think having a starting line where we know what the rules are, they can be evenly applied across the state, and it's fair and clean and clear, and then if there's adjustments that need to be made, the judges have that authority. That's what I think this bill would do, and I hope that you all vote for it.
If you don't, we'll do what we can to keep it fair. So thank you. Mr. Chair, as I listen to the comments of today and everything, the first thing I'd like to bring out is that a marriage is between two individuals. I've been married for 38 years, and in reality, I believe that when I made those commitments, I took the old-timey vows seriously, till death do you part. During the course of that journey, there have been times when we wanted to walk away, but because of values and principles that nobody in this room can legislate.
It comes from a deeper and a higher power than anybody sitting in this room. You know, we have made it 38 years. She's never driven a T-post in her life, wouldn't even know what it is, but I'm going to stay married to her anyway. The reason I bring that into the conversation is because I am not in a position to determine sweat equity value on one side or the other. Now, the question was brought up about gender neutral. Well, last time I checked the Supreme Court, we really don't have any control on that, and that's shame on us, and this is a result of that, of a society that has failed to identify marriage being between a man and a woman.
So I think that argument's out the window by basis of what the Supreme Court has ruled. Maybe someday that'll change, personal editorial. However, whenever it is that an individual marries another individual, there is going to be sacrifices on both parts. In my opinion, when they come into that marital relationship, they come in knowing, and I've never counseled a couple that said we got married with the intent of getting divorced. Now, there are a lot of ways, and it was mentioned by one of the people that spoke against it,
that if you have reason or you have pause, you can get a prenuptial agreement or any of those other kind of things. There are avenues to protect yourself. If you have to exercise those avenues, that's your personal choice. I would caution you, if you've got to exercise those, you might want to get an extra couple weeks of marital counseling before you go into it. But at the end of the day, we're dealing with a situation that has been brought to us because of a ruling by the Supreme Court. With that, I'd just like to point out a few things to close. Number one, this is going to bring a standard of consistency that will allow with what the Supreme Court says,
we've got a little gray in this area, we need it cleared up, that's the legislature's job. That's what we're trying to do today. Somebody mentioned about the cost of expense. I read a book one time that said if you read five different books on a subject matter, for all practical purposes, you're an expert because there's only so much that can be said about any matter. And I would just bargain, I would almost bargain to reason that an attorney that has been around a long time knows which experts to call and which ones not to call.
And so as far as the expense, there's going to be expense either way. And with regard to that, how much is truth and how much is right worth? I think that's part of what this law will help achieve. With regards to, you know, and I appreciate Judge Hertzfield bringing this, not because he is a constituent, which he is, but because of the fact that he even used the terms himself as a judge, he would like to have some guideposts established to clarify this so when he has to do what he's got to do as a judge that I've never had to do,
that he wants to know what the parameters are and clear up some of the issues that have been brought as a result of what the Supreme Court has said. How many times have you ever heard a judge say that they want to have some clear guideposts? I think that within itself identifies the fact that this is something that would be worth going forward with. With regard to, let's see, the comment was mentioned about not knowing what things were worth 30 years ago. I know exactly what my house was worth 30 years ago. I know exactly with Google and everything
else today, if you don't know what things are worth 30 years ago, you probably don't want to know for a reason. No disrespect intended, but you can go back to what the property values were. You can go back to what the labor rates were. You can go back to a lot of resources and determine what the value was years ago. Now, everything mentioned as arguments go on before today, and they're going to go after it today. If I could Google it quicker, I would. I had it on my phone, but Representative House opened the door to quoting scripture down here this year.
But Acts 19, verse 32 refers to the fact that the people were in a turmoil and they didn't know which way to go. One thing I think that this law will do, as the judge said, and I think that that's going to give them some guideposts so that no matter what happens, because when we get done here today, even while we sit here, somebody's filing papers for divorce. I'm going to marry people that I know with all probability, I hope not, I pray not, might end up in divorce because that's life. But if this law helps give clarity to judges like Judge Hertzfield, who's willing to come here and ask for some guideposts, I think that within itself.
Now, here's the one thing I'm going to say because the judge, I think, indicated it would be a good improvement to the bill before you. If you vote this bill out of here today to what Representative Maddox said as far as the word substantial, I will address that and make sure it's amended on the Senate end and address that issue because other than we just need to make up our mind, I haven't heard anything else that would stop this bill from clearing out of here. And I would respect Representative Maddox and the fact that the judge was agreeable to amend that when we get to the Senate and if we get out here with that, I'd appreciate a good vote.
Okay, the committee heard Representative Hammer speak directly to the amendment. What's the pleasure of the committee? Got a due pass. Is there any discussion on the motion? Representative Gray,
you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I feel that the burden of proof with this shifts from the requesting spouse who claims they're entitled to equity based on time and effort to the spouse who brought the property in originally into the marriage.
So I feel that this is a shift in the burden of proof, essentially. To me, I guess, and I wrote this down to make sure I got this right, current law is clear and plain. It just doesn't agree with a Supreme Court ruling. I feel the Supreme Court ruling was in direct conflict with the original law and the intent of the law. If the current law is not plain, then let's clarify the language while leaving its intent intact and not shifting the burden 180 degrees.
So I do plan to vote no on this bill, and I just wanted to explain why.
Thank you. Okay, so we see no other discussion. All in favor, say aye. All opposed, say no. No. Representative Hammer, I'm sorry, but the bill has failed. Thank you, members, for your time this morning.
Okay, without objection, we're going to move to Representative Petty's House Bill 1158. Representative Petty. Thank you, Mr. Chair and
committee. and I'll try to be real quick. I know everybody's probably getting hungry by now. The bill that I bring to you today is 1158, and the basis for this bill is that as of right now
in the state of Arkansas, when a person is executed for capital murder on their death certificate, it says homicide. This was brought to me, of course, by some crime victims, and to change this is the right thing to do, and I want to talk just quickly about it, for the purpose of transparency, accuracy, and characterization of the truth of what has happened and what the death certificate needs to actually say is the manner of death is pursuant to a judicial sentence,
execution, and the cause of death would be lethal injection or electrocution, and that is the two that are in this state. Like I said, again, this was brought to me by some crime victims, and it's a right thing to do, and I will entertain any questions. Seeing no questions. No
one has signed up to speak for or against the bill. Representative Petty, are you ready to close for your bill? Yes.
Again, this is the right thing to do, and I would ask you for a due
pass okay yeah what's the pleasure of the committee gotta do pass any discussion on the motion see no no discussion yeah all in favor of representative Petty's bill say aye all opposed say no representative Petty your bill has passed congratulations thanks
you.
me to chair the committee today thank you for being patient with me and understanding and thanks to rebecca for getting me through this today and i appreciate all of you and this committee is adjourned thank you
Agenda
HB1055 Hammer TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF "MARITAL PROPERTY" FOR PURPOSES OF DIVISION OF PROPERTY IN AN ACTION FOR DIVORCE.
HB1007 Tucker TO PROTECT CITIZENS WHO ARE VICTIMS OF JUDICIAL ETHICS VIOLATIONS; TO CREATE A CAUSE OF ACTION AGAINST JUDGES AND JUSTICES WHO HAVE BEEN CONVICTED OF CERTAIN OFFENSES; AND TO CREATE AN EXCEPTION TO JUDICIAL IMMUNITY.
HB1006 Tucker TO AMEND CERTAIN CRIMINAL OFFENSES CONCERNING ABUSES OF PUBLIC OFFICE; TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING ABUSE OF OFFICE; AND TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING ABUSE OF PUBLIC TRUST.
HB1045 B. Smith CONCERNING CRIMINAL VICTIM NOTIFICATION; AND CONCERNING THE RELEASE OF A PERSON WHO COMMITTED A CRIMINAL ACT AND WAS ADJUDICATED TO HAVE A MENTAL DISEASE OR DEFECT.
HB1152 Watson CONCERNING THE ABILITY OF AN AUXILIARY LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER TO CARRY A CONCEALED HANDGUN AND to be EXEMPTED FROM LICENSING REQUIREMENTS TO CARRY A CONCEALED HANDGUN.
HB1158 PETTY CONCERNING THE ENTRY UNDER CAUSE OF DEATH ON A PERSON'S DEATH CERTIFICATE WHEN THE PERSON WAS EXECUTED DUE TO A SENTENCE FOR A CAPITAL OFFENSE.
HB1173 Tucker TO AMEND AND MAKE CONSISTENT THE OFFENSES OF SEXUAL INDECENCY WITH A CHILD AND SEXUAL ASSAULT IN THE FOURTH DEGREE; AND TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF "SEXUAL ABUSE" UNDER THE CHILD MALTREATMENT ACT.
HB1175 Tucker TO REQUIRE LIFETIME REGISTRATION ON THE ARKANSAS SEX OFFENDER REGISTRY FOR A PERSON CONVICTED OF RAPE WHEN THE RAPE INVOLVED THE USE OF FORCE
HB1177 Tucker INCREASING THE AVAILABLE SENTENCES FOR CERTAIN SEX OFFENSES WHEN COMMITTED AGAINST A FAMILY OR HOUSEHOLD MEMBER.
HB1236 Gazaway TO PROTECT THE PRIVACY OF SURVIVING FAMILY MEMBERS OF A LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER WHO DIES IN THE LINE OF DUTY; AND TO EXEMPT CERTAIN LAW ENFORCEMENT RECORDS FROM DISCLOSURE; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY
Walker HB1251 TO CREATE THE "HELPING OUR PEOPLE EXCEL (H.O.P.E.) ACT OF 2017"; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES.
HB1260 Maddox TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING REIMBURSEMENT FOR JUROR ORIENTATION COSTS.
HB1354 Nicks CONCERNING DISTRICT COURT CLERK EMPLOYMENT.
HB1362 Payton CONCERNING THE RIGHTS OF A CONCEALED HANDGUN LICENSEE.
HB1367 Watson CONCERNING AN AUXILIARY LAW ENFORCEMENT OR A RETIRED LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER CARRYING A CONCEALED HANDGUN; AND CONCERNING RETIRED LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICERS.
HB1375 Tucker TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE FILING REQUIREMENTS FOR A PETITION TO QUIET TITLE; AND TO ABOLISH THE REQUIREMENT THAT A PETITIONER SEARCH VOTER REGISTRATION RECORDS.
HB1382 Gazaway TO ESTABLISH PROCEDURES TO BE FOLLOWED AFTER A CLAIM IS FILED AGAINST A SMALL ESTATE.
HB1415 Shepherd TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 6 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING EDUCATION.
HB1416 Shepherd TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS TO TITLE 17 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING PROFESSIONS, OCCUPATION. AND BUSINESSES
HB1417Sturch CONCERNING THE OFFENSE OF SEXUAL SOLICITATION; PROVIDING FOR IMPOUNDMENT OF MOTOR VEHICLE; AND PROVIDING FOR HUMAN TRAFFICKING AWARENESS EDUCATION FOR EDUCATORS
HB1420 C. Fite TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS DOMESTIC VIOLENCE SHELTER ACT; TO CREATE THE DOMESTIC VIOLENCE SHELTER FUND; AND TO ESTABLISH PROCEDURES FOR FUNDING DOMESTIC VIOLENCE SHELTERS
SB102 Rice TO CLARIFY THE LAW CONCERNING THE FINES, FEES, AND COSTS THAT MAY BE ASSESSED FOR A VIOLATION OF THE MANDATORY SEAT BELT USE LAW.
HB1433 BaltzTO PROHIBIT A REGISTERED SEX OFFENDER FROM LIVING NEAR A FACILITY WHERE A PERSON WITH A MEDICALLY DIAGNOSED MENTAL DISABILITY OR PHYSICAL DISABILITY.
HB1444 Ballinger TO REVISE CERTAIN EMINENT DOMAIN LAWS THAT ARISE OUT OF PROPERTY RIGHTS SECURED UNDER THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION, ARTICLE 2, § 22.
HB1453 Farrer PROHIBITING IMPROPER SEXUAL CONDUCT BETWEEN A PROBATION OR PAROLE OFFICER AND A PERSON BEING SUPERVISED ON PROBATION, PAROLE, OR OTHER COURT-ORDERED REASON.
SB32 Hickey PROHIBITING CERTAIN SEX OFFENDERS FROM ENTERING UPON A PUBLIC SCHOOL CAMPUS UNDER CERTAIN CIRCUMSTANCES.
HB1385 Lemons TO BE KNOWN AS "SHANNON'S LAW"; AND CONCERNING THE POSSESSION AND SALE OF BLUE LIGHTS AND LAW ENFORCEMENT INSIGNIA.
HB1197 Sturch TO ESTABLISH A METHOD FOR A PERSON WHO WAS FALSELY ACCUSED OF A CRIMINAL OFFENSE TO MAKE A CLAIM FOR REIMBURSEMENT FOR HIS OR HER
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Kim Hammer
Unverified
Speaker 17
Representative Dwight Tosh Chair
Unverified
Representative Douglas House
Unverified
Representative Michelle Gray
Unverified
Representative John Maddox
Unverified
Representative David Whitaker
Unverified
Speaker 65
Speaker 73
Speaker 77
Sam Hilburn
Unverified
Speaker 93
Representative Rebecca Petty
Unverified
Speaker 43