Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

Education Committee

February 9, 2017 ·Committee Room 138 ·1:38:28
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (24)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1424 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “House Bill 24, please. 1424, House Bill 1424 Committee. There's an amendment on that. That's amendment t…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1017 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1017 Cozart TO ALLOW THE TEACHER FAIR DISMISSAL ACT OF 1983 TO B…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1020 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1020 Love TO CREATE THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY PROMISE LOTTERY SCHOLAR…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1027 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1027 Eubanks TO PROHIBIT A SCHOOL DISTRICT FROM USING PUBLIC FUN…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1029 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1029 Lowery TO EXCLUDE PRINCIPALS, ASSISTANT PRINCIPALS, AND CEN…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1042 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1042 B. Smith TO PROHIBIT SANCTUARY POLICIES AT STATE-SUPPORTED…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1044 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1044 F. Allen TO ALLOW A STUDENT TO CHOOSE WHICH GRADE IN WHICH…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1056 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1056 House TO ALLOW THE SUPERINTENDENT OF A STUDENT'S RESIDENT S…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1154 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1154 Cozart TO REQUIRE THAT ANY INCREASES IN PROFESSIONAL DEVELO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1222 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1222 Dotson THE ARKANSAS PARENTAL EMPOWERMENT FOR EDUCATION CHOI…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1266 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1266 Richey TO ALLOW A SCHOOL BOARD MEMBER OR A SPOUSE OF A SCHO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1407 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1407 Douglas TO ALLOW A PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT TO SUBMIT BY ELEC…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1408 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1408 C. Douglas CONCERNING WHO MAY SERVE AS A PROCTOR OF A TEST…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1425 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1425 Vaught CONCERNING THE LICENSURE OF TEACHERS AND ADMINISTRAT…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1435 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1435 Tucker TO REQUIRE PUBLIC SCHOOLS AND OPEN-ENROLLMENT CHARTE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1442 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1442 Davis TO CREATE THE PERSONAL FINANCE AND JOB READINESS ACT.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1456 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1456 C. Douglas TO ALLOW A SCHOOL DISTRICT TO WAIVE PHYSICAL EDU…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1457 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1457 C. Douglas TO ALLOW A PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT AND AN AN OPEN…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1458 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1458 C. Douglas TO REQUIRE A STUDENT TO PARTICIPATE IN VISUAL AR…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1459 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1459 C. Douglas TO PROVIDE FLEXIBILITY IN THE AWARDING OF COURSE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1461 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1461 Wing TO EXPAND THE NUMBER OF PRIVATE SCHOOLS ELIGIBLE TO PA…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1473 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1473 Love TO ALLOW A TAX DEDUCTION FOR CONTRIBUTIONS TO A TUITIO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1474 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1474 Lowery CONCERNING THE PARTICIPATION OF HOME-SCHOOLED STUDEN…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB24 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “House Bill 24, please. 1424, House Bill 1424 Committee. There's an amendm…”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 14, 2026
sir like call this meeting to order chair sees a quorum glad to have everyone today looks like our committee is getting to be fuller and fuller every time we have a meeting yeah all right first off i'm going to make an announcement Arkansas Community College has handed me a sheet this morning. It says, please join your community college friends at the ACC Legislative Appreciation Lunch honoring the 91st General Assembly, and it will be Tuesday, February the 14th at 1130 at Association of Arkansas Counties. Now, everybody knows what that day is, so you better have your flowers, your candy, and
▶ Play
Speaker 4 0:51
your cards ready. that could be
▶ Play
possible so anyway do not forget your sweethearts on that day please and come and join them at 11 30 at the association of arkansas counties all right madam chair you have anything to say this morning all right representative tucker if you will take the end and if you will state your name you will be recognized Thank you Mr. Chairman Clark Tucker I believe you have an amendment first off right? Yes sir and the amendment is only to add co-sponsors Add sponsors okay Alright Anybody have a question on those sponsors anybody you don't really like on there? I'm just kidding do i have a motion on the amendment i have a motion all those in favor of the amendment say aye all right motion carries your amendment has passed you are recognized to present your bill
▶ Play
as amended thank you mr chairman this bill concerns the child abuse hotline number and its availability in schools to children this was brought to my attention by a lady in texas who is working to have this passed in states across the country the issue is that in a lot of schools right now the child abuse hotline information is posted only in teachers lounges for the reporter's sake so the reporters can call in if they see a case of abuse but it's not always available where kids can see it so kids are not necessarily aware of it and in the other she this lady has told me that i guess texas is where she lives and that's the first state it was passed and they she's passed it in 21 other states at this point and the number of legitimate cases of abuse being identified and reported always goes up. And so this is just a way to make students aware that the child abuse hotline exists and let them know the information about how to contact the Crimes Against Children Division of the Arkansas State Police and let them know that they may be subject to abuse. And so I visited with a few principals in the Little Rock area about it. They were all supportive of it. they think it'll be a good idea to, you know, for the exact reasons that I've already articulated. And I've also visited with Major Ron Staton, who runs the Crimes Against Children Division at the Arkansas State Police, and then also folks in Division of Children and Family Services at DHS. And those are the two agencies that investigate and assess calls into the hotline. And they do recognize that the calls will probably go up, but that's a good thing because we'll be identifying cases of abuse that we need to identify and investigate. So that's it in a nutshell, and I'd be happy to take any questions. Any questions from Representative Meek you're recognized? Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
▶ Play
The question that I have, and maybe it's a two-parter with a follow-up, is the Department of Education going to create these signs and send these signs out to the school, or is the school going to kind of be able to be creative with their own signs, would be my first question and then the follow-up to that would be when these signs are created is there going to be any sort of I'm assuming this is aimed at for the students is there gonna be any sort of guidelines for the students to let them know maybe what does or doesn't qualify as child abuse to keep
▶ Play
them from abusing the line as to your first question and that this is not the responsibility of ADE it'll be on this just the individual school and it's It's just essentially an 11 by 17 sheet of paper that they need to post in places throughout the school, and that's in the bill about where they need to post it, and it's just a sheet of paper that they can copy off. And so there's nothing in the bill that requires them to have, as to your second question, those sort of guidelines about what constitutes a case of abuse or not. It certainly does not limit them from doing so, but it doesn't require them to either.
▶ Play
Speaker 19 4:54
Okay. All right. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Are there any other questions?
▶ Play
All right, seeing no other questions, is there anyone in the audience that would like to speak against the bill? For the bill? I'm sorry, I probably need a motion, too. I'll let him close and then we'll get a motion. But I see nobody out there that wants to speak for or against, so not yet. I'm getting a little ahead of myself today. I'm anxious to get out of here today. Would you like to close for your motion,
▶ Play
for your bill? I'd just like to let one of these brilliant representatives, he wants
▶ Play
to make that motion, let them make their motion. I think everybody wants to raise their hand and make that motion. I think you've got a great bill. So I see a motion of do pass. I was going to make it, but he said freeze. We have plenty. Any other discussion? It's do pass as amended, I take it. And yes, sir. All right. All in favor, say aye. Any opposed? No. Congratulations. You passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, members of the committee. Let's see. Do we have any other non-members of the committee that's here to run a bill? I'd be glad to let you guys step up. I
▶ Play
Speaker 27 6:21
don't see anybody in the room. Okay. Representative Vaught,
▶ Play
you're recognized to take the end of the table. And which one would you like to do, the very first one or the second one? House Bill 24, please. 1424, House Bill 1424 Committee. There's an amendment on that. That's amendment to your bill. What do I have, a motion on that? I have a motion to pass on the amendment. All those in favor of the amendment, say aye. Aye. Amendment passes. You're welcome to present your bill as amended, 1424.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm going to let Ms. Ivy speak to the amendment.
▶ Play
Good morning. Ivy Pfeffer, Assistant Commissioner for Educator Licensure and Educator Effectiveness, Department of Education. Actually, you don't have to speak to
▶ Play
the amendment because it's already been passed. You can speak to the bill.
▶ Play
Speaker 40 7:17
Just go to the bill. Okay. This one? Okay, I just
▶ Play
want to make sure. As amended. Thank you, Mr. Chair. TESS has been substantially changed for greater school and district flexibility while maintaining the essential framework for professional support, growth, and evaluation. These amendments are based on feedback from multiple stakeholders, including the Teacher Evaluation Advisory Committee and subcommittee members, and constituent group stakeholders. They are also reflective of feedback obtained from recommendations from the SREB focus group sessions conducted in May of 2015 and in December of 2016 with the Arkansas educators. The amendment account for ESSA's flexibility and enhanced accountability to ensure that all students have access to effective teachers. And if it's okay with you, Mr. Chair, I'll let Ms. Ivy explain all of the amendments. And everybody should have the paper in front of them, and you can follow along if you've got questions that way. You're recognized.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. And before just going through each amendment, and I'm happy to do that if you would like, just some information that may help you understand why that we have a teacher excellence support system and why we are looking at making these amendments. There are at least 13 different routes for teachers to come to the classroom as a novice teacher. And so when you think about that, I think about teachers in a classroom that have all kinds of different students, all different learning styles, kids at all different levels. And that's really what we have today in our schools. We have teachers coming to schools with all different levels of learning. Some have had a traditional four-year preparation through a traditional college route. Some have had work experience and professional development and academies during the summer. some come with no preparation at all and in order for those teachers to be successful there are so many different factors at play and so one of our one of the things that we've learned over the last few years is we lose about between 25 and 30 percent of our novice teachers after three years we lose over a third after five years and therefore it is very important that we have systems in place as part of a concerted educator workforce to ensure that we are not only supporting novices, but we're supporting our experienced teachers as career professionals. And TESS, it's always been more than just an evaluation system, but the way it is currently written, so many times the requirements and the procedural parts outweigh the support components. The Every Student Succeeds Act provides flexibility for states in determining how they measure teacher effectiveness, but ESSA also makes sure that states are accountable for educator equity in ensuring that all students have access to effective educators. So the amendments in this bill are designed to address that. And I'll be happy to walk through each of those amendments if you want me to, or if you want to just ask questions about changes, I'll be happy to do questions. Are you ready
▶ Play
Speaker 48 10:55
for questions? You want to go ahead? I'll take
▶ Play
questions if you're ready. You ready? Okay. I have no hands up, so I'm asking anybody. Okay, Representative Sturge
▶ Play
Speaker 53 11:12
Thank you, Mr. Chair, it's I mean I know we've talked about it several times and I'm a little more familiar I guess and so is Representative Barker than my good friend Representative Gates is so I see if you could just kind of boil it down to where we're a little bit about what we're changing as far as Instead of mentoring being one year We're going to push it to three years instead of having to do an assessment both pre-op post-op and all that good stuff you know throughout the year how we're changing it to once every four
▶ Play
years with evidence-based and so forth okay so teachers will continue to have a summative evaluation at least once every four years and a school district could choose to do a summative evaluation more often if they if they desire that summative evaluation would consist of a rating and that rating would come from evidence. And instead of requiring a school to do a formal observation that has a pre- and post-conference and allowing some informal observations, what we've said is that we realize that there are multiple things, multiple factors, multiple measures that go into determining how effective a teacher performs. And so that summative rating would be based on evidence from direct observations of teaching it would be based on indirect observations of performance it would be based on artifacts that the teacher could provide and data and the data is going to be different depending on the teacher depending on what grade level the teacher teaches depending on what subject area a PE teacher is going to have different data to evidence student growth student progress than a high school English teacher will. Band director will have different data than a third grade math teacher. So realizing that the flexibility is there for schools to pull in all of that data and tying it back to the test evaluation framework and making those determinations. In the years that the teacher does not have a summative evaluation, there is no requirement for a rating. However, a school can still choose to look at different components and provide that feedback to the teacher, whether it's through observational feedback or through an evaluation rating. The idea is those three years when the educator is not having a summative evaluation, those are their growth years. That's when the focus is on that individual educator's professional development needs. They are able to get the professional learning that best fits their needs and move towards putting all of that together so that the year they have their summative evaluation that they are an effective teacher. Another change would be that a novice teacher would not be required to have a summative evaluation rating until they had completed three years of experience. That doesn't mean a novice teacher is not getting feedback. We actually, within the flexibility here, would possibly have a rubric with different descriptor levels of performance for a novice because a novice teacher is going to be growing and developing, emerging into an effective professional over time. So we want to give them that time to grow and develop. However, a novice teacher who is not performing at satisfactory levels may need to be put in an intensive support status, which is what the amendment addressed, to be sure that any teacher who is not at a level where they need to be can receive more intensive support that's very directed to ensure that they move to the levels they need to be so that they are advancing student learning.
▶ Play
Speaker 52 14:58
You're recognized for follow-up. Thanks,
▶ Play
Speaker 53 15:00
sir. So, Ms. Ivey, would you say that the way that you've presented the bill now, you and Representative Vaught, it's less paperwork and
▶ Play
less regulation for both the teachers and the administrators who are performing tests as it is? It is going to, yes, those compliance requirements are not going to be there, and it's going to maintain the overall framework for quality, but really emphasize the support, and the districts will be able to work with those teachers and really, truly personalize it.
▶ Play
Madam Co-Chair, you're recognized Thank you, Mr. Chair and thank you for your hard work and Representative Vaught for carrying this first of all the mentoring we've discussed this many times who in the building is selected to mentor and are you going to use the National Board Certified Teachers as we discussed, I thought would be a great idea. Is that anywhere in the bill, who is used as the mentors and
▶ Play
what their qualifications would be? Representative Douglas, it's not in the bill. Mentoring support would be extended for three years, and we are working right now with our educational service cooperatives to assist with helping to oversee that mentoring so that there would be expanded support through their specialists, through all of their work to assist the teachers. They will be working with their member school districts to determine what support is needed at that individual building level. And so through rules and regulations, we will outline some, whether it's requirements or suggestions or the criteria to ensure that the mentoring support is there for those teachers. But it really will be driven based on the needs within that co-op because we know that there are some schools where novice teachers and experienced teachers are now dealing with increasing populations of English language learners, and that may not be something that they had a lot of background in prior to coming to that school. So the mentoring support there might need to look a lot different than it would in a different part of the state where maybe
▶ Play
student needs are different. Will the need for the mentoring be evidenced in their summative evaluation through the test? In other words, you know, this is going to be individualized to each teacher, and how do those co-ops understand what's going on with that individual
▶ Play
teacher? That would be through the professional growth plan and the linking of a video observation tool that co-op specialists could have access to as well as teachers so that a specialist could video teaching a model lesson, share it with novices so that they could look at it to see best practices, share their professional growth plans. so all of that would not be within a rating component but the any of the mentors would have access to the support tools for coaching. So you're saying
▶ Play
the mentors might be outside of the school district and are they
▶ Play
getting paid? The what the design that we would like to see for mentoring would be a novice teacher quest where novice teachers are brought together in a PLC and that could occur on site it could occur at a co-op but it would be facilitated by a lead teacher and that person would be someone who had the proven expertise and experience it is possible that a co-op could ask for grant funds to pay lead teachers if they are doing some facilitation and design work outside of their regular contracted day it might be a co-op would ask for grant funds to help with sub pay if a teacher was going to be out of a classroom, but it would be designed in terms of bringing new teachers together to learn from each other in a facilitated conversation with the resources they need. I've got
▶ Play
a couple other questions. I'll just get back in the queue. Thanks.
▶ Play
Representative Meeks, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I have a question to follow up, if that's all right. Thank you, sir. My first question is I'm looking at the bill here, and on page 2, line 35, when it talks about direct observation of the teacher, it talks about you can either be presently inside or outside the teacher's classroom, and then part B says or use appropriate technology to observe. Can you kind of tell us a little bit about what that is? Are we using cameras or spying? her um so the appropriate technology we have um there are really two factors we have a lot of um teachers now that teach in a virtual platform okay we have increasing numbers of schools who um either district conversion charters or schools of innovation who have students attending virtually. So, um, therefore, um, and, and a lot of, um, research now is showing best practice around, um, teachers videoing and, um, using the, um, being able to sit down with their observer and talk through, um, just like a coach videos a game and they sit and they review film and you find those areas of strength or you find those questions and you're like, why didn't I do this? or why did I do this and so that would be the use of the appropriate video technology and I think that's something within rules and regs there could be some parameters to ensure it's not abused okay my follow-up is I know my concern I'm sure my colleagues concern is is that we look at student evaluations we're you know 30 percent of our kids are scoring proficient in math science and reading which is definitely not acceptable by any standards. How much of that do you attribute to the fact that we're turning over so many of our new teachers in the first three years? And is it possible, or how much do you think this will go towards helping get those scores up? There is research that does show that teacher effectiveness improves with experience so I think that in schools that have a perpetually high rate of turnover I think it definitely has an impact if we have a system that encourages teachers to stay and encourages them and it allows them to advocate for their professional learning so that they can grow and develop and if the system is truly measuring the effectiveness I think it will have a big impact. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Gates, you recognize. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chair. I think it's important not just showing somebody what they're doing right, but actually show them somebody that's doing it or what they're doing wrong, but to show them how to do it because you can show me all day long what I'm doing wrong, but if I'm not showing right. This also looks like this makes this less subjective on an evaluation, bringing in, you know, documents, bringing in videos, bringing in, and that is protection for that teacher who may have a conflict maybe with a staff member or personnel. Does this not protect our teachers to be able to defend their professionalism? It definitely does. Representative
▶ Play
Sullivan, you're recognized for question. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair. I'm looking on page 8, line 2. It says the raw data reported to and collected by the department for the purposes keeps on going there. It will be exempt from the FOI. Can you explain what that data is, please?
▶ Play
Yes. That data, and I may need Ms. Reinhart in a moment to help. She's one of our attorneys. But the raw data would be, for example, in the calculation of student growth for an individual educator. There are, in trying to determine what is the most appropriate growth measure that could be used in tested areas to determine how much growth students are showing in a teacher's classroom, we would just want to be sure that the raw data would not be something that could be requested out there. And just to make sure that, because this is a system of support and growth, if it is evident through that data that a teacher has, teacher students has high growth, maybe in one area, but low growth in another, that does not need to be an automatic point of something bad for the teacher. that needs to be a teaching point or a learning point or a decision point of a teacher who maybe has students with exceptionally high growth in language arts but not so much in math look at what it is is it that the teacher needs a professional development is it that maybe the teacher is more effective in that area and i have a teacher who could be more effective in math so we just want to make sure the
▶ Play
teacher have access to that data they will have access yes thank you Thank you, Mr. Chair. Madam Co-Chair, you're recognizing it. Yes, thank you. Thank you very much. Are the schools allowed to add requirements onto tests or deviate from the plan that's handed down from ADE?
▶ Play
According to the legislation, there are a few things that they can develop local policies around. One of those is allowing teachers that are working on national board certification to utilize some of the work that they're doing, and it may be in those cases that the timing of when they are doing their work for certification and then their summative evaluation the following year, there may be some of that work that can contribute to that following year. So the school districts would need to develop the local policies around if they're going to work with teachers in that manner another area was the inclusion of student surveys if they wanted to include student surveys they would need to develop policies around what survey would students take and how would that contribute to any decision and would it contribute to a decision and it might not in a school and then a third one would be for peer observations with if they wanted to include a peer observation process if that data weren't going to contribute so um the rules and regs
▶ Play
so apart from what you've outlined there school
▶ Play
cannot add there would there i think that would be the only flexibility that they would have in that because otherwise then
▶ Play
the system would be kept streamlined so um if a if a school was telling teachers that they had to be in leadership at the school in order to get a four let's say then you know how how does a teacher appeal that or find out if that's really part of tests you know sometimes it's used in a vindictive way or to limit the ones that get certain scores and I know these are just isolated pockets
▶ Play
but those are the ones i get i understand and um so that question there would go towards the calibration um that we would um encourage an ongoing calibration for administrators to truly understand the framework and um the evidence that fits within that framework for them to um
▶ Play
but there's no appeals process for a teacher to say this just was
▶ Play
not fair the the appeals are at the local level now the role the ADE can play is if we need to provide extra professional development on the rubric and clarity in terms of what evidence really does fit within these that that's the role that the ADE would play but the appeal so they would have to be
▶ Play
at a local level so you're talking about the the grievance process okay and then the let's see the appeals and mentor the compliance that you said you had taken out could you just give me just a brief explanation
▶ Play
of what that looks like yes and and I guess just saying compliance is taken out and it's probably that was probably too much of a generalization that I made but okay the the current system still had several compliance pieces to it so like one of the compliances was that in a summative evaluation year you had to do a formal observation and that formal observation had to be at least 75 percent of the class period or so many minutes you had to do a pre-conference you had to do a post-conference and really what that amounted to was a rush to meet that compliance so by taking those pieces out we've opened it up to say throughout the year you need to be directly observing your teacher and teachers and directly observing the performance against this rubric here so instead of people feeling like you have this big event you have to do and you really need to do all of these other observations it opens it up for a more holistic look at performance throughout the year which we know is a more authentic measure of how the quality of teaching
▶ Play
that's going on and this is my last and i appreciate it um the uh did you say that the leadership component was or or was not to be added to their ability to score on the tests i'm not sure i understand like if they are a um committee chair or they are in leadership of some kind of you know in the at the school level is that a component of the rubric it is
▶ Play
oh I see what you mean is that something that is on there that is not a specific component of the rubric itself now however within the rubric and and I don't have the rubric in front of me if those are some indicators or some things that a school district desires and that's communicated out to staff in advance um there um if the expectation is is understood there in terms of these are the things that we would want you to do as a staff i think there are some local decision making components so that worries
▶ Play
me a little because you're saying that a while ago we had the conversation that they're not able to add to you know the test requirements without you know without it being in those three you know sub components that you mentioned but now it looks like a school could communicate to their staff that this is going to be a
▶ Play
part of their personal so I think it goes back to the artifacts I think it goes back to what evidence should you provide to me in terms of the artifacts this one piece of multiple data that would go into the determination of a rating so
▶ Play
but leadership you know just taking that for example a school district's not going to have enough leadership for every teacher every
▶ Play
year and I think then that that's where a teacher would advocate in terms of what are all the different kinds of leadership opportunities that that I can show and I think you're referring to one of the components in domain for contributing to the profession and so I think that's where as teachers this gives the teachers power to advocate and say you know these are all the many different leadership opportunities that that I can show leadership both within this building and outside of that
▶ Play
but they would but would they get graded down if they are not you see what I'm saying I see it adding to it but i don't see it as something
▶ Play
they could use to take away and i think what you're describing is um a local issue that um we could probably with some um conversations within a school district probably help provide some clarity and um you know just ensure that school districts are looking at this in the right context this is not about i will say this and i'll go on this is not about checking off a list to say if you're not leading a committee you cannot be a distinguished or effective teacher this is not about that at all this system should be about the conversations and I think opening it up and basing a rating on multiple measures like we said the data the artifacts the direct and indirect observation of performance looking at the impact on students when all of that is considered, I think that makes it a much stronger system.
▶ Play
Thank you, and thank you for your indulgence of all my questions. I
▶ Play
appreciate it. There are some advantages of being a co-chair. Representative Walker, you are
▶ Play
recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I have a number of questions. I hope I can have the latitude that the co-chair had. Representative Walker, until somebody raises their hand,
▶ Play
I will not shut you up until then. Well, I'll take that back. Well, I missed the first round.
▶ Play
I guess this is the second round. On page, I think it is six, it appears that you eliminate summative evaluations. I'm sorry. It seems that you eliminate summative evaluations which address student achievement. before it says that summative assessments means an evaluation of student achievement given at the completion of a course of instruction that ultimately cumulatively measures whether the student met long-term goals for the course. Is that objective anywhere in this bill? Mr. Chair, I'm going to let Ms. Reinhardt answer if that's
▶ Play
all possible. If she'll just state her name and who she's with, she's right. That's just
▶ Play
a yes or no. I'm not trying to do anything other than get a yes or no on that. Okay. Thank
▶ Play
Speaker 137 34:20
you. I don't see it in the bill. Cheryl Reinhardt with Department of Education. And, yes, it is taken into account when there is evidence of student growth and provided by the teacher to look at whether or not his or her students are rowing. Can you just tell
▶ Play
me where in the bill it is? I see that it's specifically taken out, stricken through
▶ Play
Speaker 137 34:43
on page 6. And that's because that is a definition that is no longer used in the legislation, so that's why it was stricken. But looking at on page 3 at line 17 where we describe evidence, direct observations indirect artifacts and data primarily that's probably going to come through in data but it could come in in other
▶ Play
ways too well just a moment and let me let me stay on my point uh on that point you all on page number three you you don't require uh that data be collected you say that it may be collected and used but it's not required so how do you objectively determine student progress without some definite criteria that you can measure.
▶ Play
Representative Walker, and I'm not seeing where you say data may be collected, but the answer to that would be
▶ Play
Speaker 141 35:42
3A, section 3A. And what
▶ Play
page is that? I'm looking at page two, starting with line 25, and I'm sorry, I just may not be following where you were directing me, but data can mean teacher performance data, student performance data or overall school performance data and may include multiple measures of student growth school quality or student success not all students or not all teachers teach students who take a summative assessment so where summative assessments are given so where it can be tied to a teacher summative assessment data will be provided to the school and that data may be part of that overall rating we want to encourage though that other measures can be included in addition to just a summative assessment but recognizing that probably only about a third of teachers within a district will actually be tied to a summative assessment that their students will take this is an this is a system that is is for all teachers so therefore we want to have the ability for teachers to be able to say this is data that is reflective of my students' learning, progress, and performance.
▶ Play
Would you explain to us and the public what you mean now by summative assessment under this new proposed
▶ Play
plan? A summative assessment would be a state-adopted assessment. A state of what? A state-adopted assessment. Is it not included
▶ Play
in this bill? The particular assessment is not included in this bill is
▶ Play
it? The summative assessment? Yes. Not specifically. Well tell me which one is now being
▶ Play
used. I'd like to know where I can go. Yes. We currently are not using
▶ Play
a summative assessment measure in the evaluation rating because that is something that we've had under review for several years now trying to meet the requirements of the former ESEA requirements. we were not able to determine a growth measure for summative assessments in the past. So we have not used summative assessment data up to this point in the rating. Now, if I may, I don't want to give you
▶ Play
Speaker 127 38:26
one more than I got some other people.
▶ Play
I don't want to kill my time, but let me ask, and I'll see how I can get both these things in. If you deny access to certain data to the public, aren't you thereby denying that data, that specific data, to the school board members? If UNIFREC say that the public cannot get it on the FOIA, school board members can't either, because the only way school board members can get anything is when it relates to personnel and executive session. So how can school board members be held accountable for data that they
▶ Play
may not be able to get in the public domain? So the growth data that is derived from the raw data will be available. the statement there is to protect the raw data that if it is being calculated that that would not be that would be protected because these could be data that are part of an employment decision and so those that that personnel data is
▶ Play
protected well I'm trying to understand how you can keep these data data's plural so how can you keep these data from the school board members who have to make use of it, even with respect
▶ Play
to addressing possible personnel decisions? The school board members are, the superintendent would be making recommendations to school board members regarding personnel. Now the overall school data is available, but when it is put in terms of an individual teacher, then there need to be certain protections in terms of employment decision and the data that go
▶ Play
into that. What are you trying to protect? Why is it necessary to protect the data the raw data when you're dealing with student achievement because i'm sorry i mean is it proprietary that you're protecting or is it something that that is so fundamental to a an individual's right which is it
▶ Play
i mean because it's individual student achievement data and the student level data is protected under ferpa well we can't get
▶ Play
that anyway now so why make this something that's inaccessible to school board members and by definition the public why make it inaccessible ferper already covers it and that may be the case i think
▶ Play
that this is to assure educators that this system is about helping them grow and develop and not something that they're going to get caught in a catch-22 when um they are they're working with students so i'll stop Now, I'd like to be on the next round. Thank you. I'm going to
▶ Play
let you hang back if you want to go again a minute.
▶ Play
Representative Speaks, you're recognized. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chair. Maybe I'm real new at this, but my question is, where does the superintendents at the local level, where are they with this? Because it sounds like a mandate, and I want to know where they stand with all
▶ Play
of it. Well, this law was first implemented in 2011, and so it's been in place for a while. And it has been seen as a mandate for a long time. It was a requirement under ESEA flexibility, the previous version of the federal law, that states have an evaluation system that included student growth as a significant criterion. ESSA has provided flexibility from that. so this is and I'm not going to speak for the superintendents there are people in the room that could speak for them but they have been part of the process since 2011 in how the system was implemented and our feedback has been that the flexibility is going to make it more about supporting educators and so that that has been the feedback that we've had from them but I I don't want to speak for them.
▶ Play
Representative Lowry, you're recognized. You don't want one. Okay. Representative Douglas, you're
▶ Play
back on? Yes, thank you. Thank you. Is there anything about this that is making the individual teacher evaluation shorter and more concise for a principal? i know we're stretching the years out and they may have less of them to do in a year's time but is there anything about this evaluation that is going to free up the principal's time you
▶ Play
know on this evaluation per teacher they are only going to be providing a summative rating for the teachers in the summative evaluation track, which would be every four years. Right now they are having to do a rating each year on every teacher.
▶ Play
But the question was, each evaluation, we're not shortening
▶ Play
that at all. Yes, because during the time that they are not, that teachers are not having a summative evaluation, that teacher is simply working on his or her professional growth plan, and therefore it's about the professional conversations that are hopefully taking place through professional learning communities, and the administrator is not having to do evaluations on those teachers, but just simply providing the feedback and support, hopefully engaged in observing the learning that's going on in those classrooms. But this is much less time because they are not having to do evaluations of every teacher every single year. Right, and it
▶ Play
is less time over the span of the four years, but you have done nothing to make the evaluation per teacher more efficient and take less time you're talking about because of the rubric um so is that a correct statement i don't know um
▶ Play
i i think i'm i i think i understand what you're asking i don't think that it is going to take an inordinate amount of time because we are no longer requiring a domain level rating um and so therefore it's an it's an overall it would require an overall rating um for all of the components i think the time factor that was taken up was trying to schedule the formal the informal the um you know multiple informals that was what was really taking the time and then having to go in and and rate each component and i would just
▶ Play
contest as one last thing that if i know you are coming to my classroom four times a year I'm not gonna I'm gonna knock a home run those four times a year and I would I would say that we would improve teacher quality by having you know those not be scheduled and by having those principals just come in with the checklist and just hit those teachers randomly I just I see this as an improvement but I see we could make the process more efficient and drive quality into the classrooms by not having this be a scheduled event but but representative Douglas under this it's
▶ Play
not a scheduled event the the rating is based on direct observation so whenever you do those direct observations and to be honest if you walk in that rubric that can be a checklist right so i think this is what you're saying there that that flexibility yes because this is this is taking away the scheduling of those things okay that's is yes that's the part i did not understand this is taking away the required scheduling of these event um processes yes i
▶ Play
think that's i think that's good thank you represent walker you recognize again thank you thank you mr. chair now this this in effect says to a teacher who's on a one-year contract that a teacher may not be evaluated in three years go three years and if they can get by for three years then they can go on to something else but the the term of the temporary licensure is three years so a person can get a temporary license go into a classroom sit there never teach anybody and then leave at the end of three years and there's no no way of that person being evaluated and that has a correlation to the what representative Meek said we I think he used the math example where 30 percent of our students are passing math that means 70 percent of failing if 30 Now, how can you improve student outcomes without evaluations of teachers that have some structure, at least by the administrator, and are not conducted on an annual basis, perhaps like Representative Douglas says, several times a year, with the times for such being unannounced or impromptu? I mean, it seems like we're going backward rather than forward in terms of addressing the ultimate outcome, which is student achievement, rather than necessarily improvement of teachers. I mean, student achievement is the main thing. We presume that the teachers are competent. Now, you apparently are giving them three years plus to get competent and to be evaluated. I don't see how this achieves the
▶ Play
purpose. Can you explain, can you make me understand that? So I'm going to try. novice teacher during those first three years it's not that they're not being evaluated this this law would give flexibility for a committee to have a unique rubric for novice teachers and that rubric instead of telling a novice teacher well you're basic or inflating a rating that you're proficient it would allow for a novice teacher to be looked at in terms of are you developing are you growing are you progressing whatever terms are most appropriate so they will be getting evaluations because in it but it may be that they're being looked evaluated and looked at three or four components at a time or maybe just domains two and three initially for a novice teacher a novice teacher cannot be proficient on all components of the evaluation framework right off the bat and by requiring right now that they have a summative evaluation every year for those first three years that is not allowing for the time for that development and support that they're going to be receiving this does not mean that there is not evaluation feedback going on that is still going to be taking place what it means is that they are not required to have a summative evaluation rating that would either inflate and say well you're you know you're at a proficient level or start tearing them down saying you're basic for these first three years so it's about that summative rating the one of the things that we've not discussed is S's requirement that states will define an ineffective teacher and report out on the rate that students are taught by ineffective teachers. We don't want novice teachers who do not yet have the experience to be rated as ineffective just because they've not had the chance to grow and develop to an effective teacher. So this is a larger look at that. If I
▶ Play
may, and then I'll be finished. Mr. Chair You're recognized I have not seen anywhere in this bill Where it simply is limited to novice teachers And most of the teachers in the state are not novice Almost by definition So You get most of the teachers caught up in this While you're intending for it to apply to novice teachers Is that right? No, sir
▶ Play
if teachers who are experienced are in that rotation and and it is currently that they have a summative evaluation once every four years a district can choose to do a summative evaluation of an experienced teacher every year if they want to but that summative rating will be required at least once every four year and um arkansas teacher fair dismissal act still applies to teachers um And so all of that still goes into play that if a teacher is not being effective with students, this tool will either help develop them into effectiveness or the process that's outlined would be the one that the school would go through to a non-renew a teacher who was not effective.
▶ Play
Representative Speaks, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I guess maybe you covered it, but what in this is going to make sure that children are not slipping through the crack. Are you looking at that
▶ Play
every year and comparing that to see where they are? So you have school and district accountability that is looking at the performance of students. The Every Student Succeeds Act, the accountability there has expanded the groups that will be reported on from school and district level performance. This bill is about ensuring that teacher quality is there because we know that, and I think Representative Walker talked about it, that teachers are the number one in-school factor that helps to determine student achievement. So this is about having a strong system of support and development for teachers so that we ultimately see that student progress and achievement. You're welcome. I ask for follow-up.
▶ Play
Thank you. Are you doing this every year of what you're saying, or is this done over a period of the four years? I mean, are you looking at these every year?
▶ Play
and if by these are you meaning the performance of students in school students yes that's a yearly yes that is um reported and looked at yearly resident lowry
▶ Play
you recognize yes thank you mr chairman um this on this whole uh issue of summative evaluations i want to see if you can help me uh look at a parallel i know with the ACT Aspire there are summative for students there's a summative test but there are also interim assessments throughout the year so is this basically the same thing that while a summative examination or a summative evaluation may only take place once every four years at least there are still interim assessments taking place in years one two three is that correct
▶ Play
yes and that is tied to an educator's professional growth plan and the progress there and at any time and an administrator can make the decision that a teacher may need to have a summative evaluation if they're not seeing the progress according to the
▶ Play
professional growth that's needed. Okay and follow up Mr. Chair on page nine it references that at the conclusion of a summative evaluation a public school shall assign the teacher being evaluated an overall performance rating i know we talked earlier about ferpa and about privacy as far as student privacy how protected or how protected is this information this overall performance rating is this something that can as representative walker was talking about a school board may want to know information Is this something that can be shared with the school board, or is it something that just remains in the personnel file?
▶ Play
And I may need Ms. Reinhardt to answer that. I think that that teacher's performance rating is part of their personnel information, so therefore it would remain there. But there is, in the school performance report statute, there is a requirement that on the school performance reports beginning, I think, in 2018, the total number of teachers and the total number who are rated as proficient or higher has to be reported for each school. And ESSA will require states to ensure students are not taught at disproportionate rates by inexperienced, out-of-field, and ineffective teachers. and ESSA has requirements for reporting as well so we would have to meet any federal reporting requirements but again some of those I don't know in terms of what the ESSA reporting requirements will entail. Thank you. Thank you Mr.
▶ Play
Chair. Representative Kavanaugh, you're recognized. Thank you Mr. Chair. Do you feel
▶ Play
that this will allow schools to keep and retain more of their teachers and with that being able to retain them they get more experience and they become more effective and in the long run that actually helps the children because they're able to teach and learn from a teacher that is more effective in the classroom yes ma'am reps
▶ Play
Speaker 182 56:44
of de la rosa you recognize i'm going to ask the reverse question of what representative kavanaugh asked if they're not good at their job how long is it going to take us to fire them through this i mean because we're talking four years here before some summative evaluation i mean some people are just not good at doing certain things so how
▶ Play
a school can do a summative evaluation at any time so the requirement is just that at least once every four years but in the interim a school can do that Teacher fair dismissal also applies, so a school that goes through the due process there and has the necessary information in place, they can take personnel actions according to legal requirements. How long does that take?
▶ Play
Speaker 137 57:35
Cheryl Reinhart. That would take as, what they would have to do is counsel the teacher, document, And then if the teacher's not responding to that, then so there's not really a time limit that can be put on that. But that could certainly if there was an egregious event, you know, school districts can always take advantage of that. No, I just mean they're not good at it. You know, not that
▶ Play
Speaker 182 58:00
there's some egregious event, but they're just they're just not good at it. I mean, in every business, that's how it is. If somebody's just not good at the job, you get fired. So I'm trying to process this because we're talking a four year period and then we've got teacher fair dismissal involved in this. And I'm just saying bad teachers staying in a system longer without getting fired because we keep trying to drag them along and get them to be better at it. And I can't think of any other industry, any other business where we would do anything like that. So that's maybe I'm just trying to prove I'm not a Pollyanna today. I don't know. So I'm being extra negative. But that's that's been what's been going through my head.
▶ Play
And remember, it doesn't have to be four years. I mean, you're stuck on four. It could be immediately. I mean, you know what I'm saying? The four years is
▶ Play
just within that four years. And on page 13, line one, I think if we look at the intensive support status, now we took the shall out and said a district may place a teacher who is not performing an intensive support status. But if a teacher is placed in intensive support status, it shall not last more than two consecutive semesters unless this teacher is substantially improved so there is that in terms of that may help you feel better about an actual time limit but again it does not under teacher fair dismissal it there is not a requirement that it has to last a certain time this is just a this would be for a teacher who was placed in intensive support status to hopefully be able to correct the areas of deficiency all right maybe to clarify my
▶ Play
Speaker 182 59:35
question And then does this bill not affect how long it takes to fire a teacher, lengthen the amount of time, or shorten the amount of time? I guess at the end of the day, that's what I'm trying to figure out. Does it
▶ Play
not affect it, make it longer, or make it
▶ Play
shorter? It does not affect it. Okay. Thank you. Representative Beck, you're recognized
▶ Play
for a series of questions. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I have a single
▶ Play
Speaker 193 1:00:05
question. There's been a lot of discussion about the
▶ Play
evaluation and whether or not we're looking at the students, which does trouble me somewhat that we're not looking at student results like that. But I trust that you guys are the professional and you know how to best evaluate teachers. The question that I have is this. Given the Fair Dismissal Act and all this, are we sure that we've crossed all the T's and dotted all the I's that we're not going to get this, the way that we're evaluating under this new process is not going to allow us at the end of that process to say, we want to get rid of this teacher, but we haven't had enough evaluations or this person hasn't had the coaching or this person doesn't, we don't have the signed documentation that this person was told this, that. And that's what concerns me about this because we could get, you could be opening a door for students, not students, a teacher to stay in the system
▶ Play
that we don't want there. Thank you. so the the current law already has these processes in place and so test does not conflict with teacher fair dismissal so the current law it already has this in place so that part of it is not necessarily changing anything so test does not conflict with teacher fair dismissal what test does is it and it does um account for student data as part of a summative rating um and if a t if a school wants to do a summative rating on every teacher every year they can certainly do that to have strong data um so um i i think that to answer your question um yes student performance data is performance data is included with the data that should be there making determinations it's on
▶ Play
Speaker 199 1:01:58
page two and it's two oh now
▶ Play
you have a follow-up to a so it is the the question I have is not and I apologize for I may confuse my question a little bit I am worried about the student evaluation part of it but that's not the question is to make sure that this that this new system actually locks hands with the fair dismissal act that we're going to have all the data we need to do what we need to do in those two systems because it does look like this is a substantial change to the way
▶ Play
that we're evaluating teachers that was the question it does yes all right any other questions from committee seeing none anybody like speak against the bill from the audience. Seeing none, I have some four. I have Ms. Nelson from the Arkansas Education Association to speak before the bill. If you would please state your name and who you're with, you will be recognize to speak for the bill.
▶ Play
Good morning, Mr. Chairman and members of the committee. My name is Tracy Ann Nelson. I'm the executive director of the Arkansas Education Association. Thank you for this opportunity to speak. The Arkansas Education Association was pleased to work with the Arkansas Department of Education to evolve the teacher excellence and support system and rise in support of this bill and appreciate Representative Vort for carrying it. This important tool to help teachers be at their best for students in this legislation eliminates much of the bureaucratic documentation that was required for teachers to present and upload in the past. As we focus on the Arkansas teacher pipeline, this bill helps to encourage educators to show their value, their expertise, and their investment in children. It also does not deliver punitive consequences as teachers get better at their craft. In that respect, it encourages success and support. Teacher growth and expertise and expanded professionalism is promoted, and we feel some of the negative sentiments around punishing teachers is lifted to encourage a more supportive environment for administrators and teachers to work together. Specifically, the evaluation rubric, which includes direct observations, indirect observations, artifacts, data, and a professional dialogue, as well as evidence of the teacher's classroom practices, the dialogue is a fundamental component of creating a collaborative environment for teachers to work within. If the evaluation finds deficiencies, professional growth plans can be implemented and observed and executed throughout the teacher's year. So no teacher should be surprised at their time for their full bloom summative because they would have been engaged all along the way. The summative evaluation allows districts to incorporate peer observations and for teachers, Engagement and exchange, as well as respect and support of pairs, creates a collegial community that is focused on successful student outcomes. This bill also institutes in TESS mentoring and support for novice teachers, which you all have talked about extensively, with a summative evaluation in their fourth year. Student growth data is provided to schools from ADE for tested areas, and schools have the ability to request a waiver from TESS and use their own system as long as it meets the federal and state standards. We believe at AEA, with respect to ESSA, TESS will prove to be a valuable tool that will enable Arkansas to be well underway to meet the new requirements of ESSA. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Any questions
▶ Play
from the committee? Seeing none, thank you for your testimony. Thank you. Is there anyone in the audience like to speak against the bill? None yet. Dr. Lynch from the Arkansas State Teachers Association. You are recognized to speak for the bill. Please state your name and who you're
▶ Play
with, and you're recognized. Michelle Lynch, Executive Director of the Arkansas State Teachers Association. I just wanted to, first of all, thank the Arkansas Department of Ed for making this such a collaborative process as we looked at the bills and in terms of what has been going on in the field and we definitely have that perspective as we serve thousands of teachers across the state in in in our conversations in terms of how do we improve this bill and make it even more manageable we had a lot of discussions around first of all the novice teachers and that they really need a chance to grow and what does that support look like and what does a rubric look like for them. We also are very pleased that the bill now promotes peer evaluations and collaborations that we know are best practice in terms of professional learning communities. And that really works towards providing and creating that culture that we need in our schools to support student learning and growth. We see this as an equity issue. If you knew about the evaluations before tests, some teachers weren't being evaluated for years and then most of them were checklists. So now that we have this research-based framework and we know that in every district these most important conversations are going on around student learning and what's best for kids is really going to provide every student in the state a chance to have the educators and professionals serving them, having those conversations that need to be going on. It empowers teachers in that they have the power to support their own professional learning, working with their principals to identify their gaps and needs, but not being punished for that in these three years that they're not in their summative evaluation. So we just support this, and we look forward to working with ADE moving forward.
▶ Play
We do have a question for you if you would like to take
▶ Play
questions. Representative Walker, you're recognized. Thank you. Because of Ms. Nelson's compelling testimony, I'm not going to oppose this, but I still would like to have you tell me from a teacher's perspective How does the question raised by Representative Meeks get addressed? How is it that with 30% of the students achieving, and many of them achieving because of factors inherent in their upbringing and their socioeconomic status, how does this cause us to believe that that 70% of failing students are going to be improved by this methodology. I'd just like to know that from your negotiation and involvement perspective. I didn't ask Ms. Nelson that, but I thought that maybe you'd be able to shed some light on it. Sure, this framework is one as a college professor that I've always used in my classes, so I was familiar with it. But within the framework and what educators have to show that they are doing at proficient and distinguished levels are many factors that have to do with student achievement and that the artifacts they present will need to reflect the student learning that is going on in their classrooms. So that's one. I didn't understand how that related to anything I asked or anything. It doesn't give an explanation as to how you penetrate that 70% and how, you know, deferring evaluations for up to four years is going to help the students. But I take it that you all have confidence that working with AEA, you all have some influence, and perhaps the outcome would be better. confidence in the process you know that's trusting the process is what is going to be important any other questions committee thank you
▶ Play
anyone in the audience want to speak against it yet we have none I have no more listed to speak for unless there's somebody else that would like to speak for it alright
▶ Play
would you like to close for your bill thank you mr chair i just believe with so many people coming to the table so many stakeholders having a buy-in on this and and them coming up with a more flexible uh situation for our teachers and for administrators in our schools while still maintaining concerns about uh the framework I just think that this is a very well-written bill, and I would appreciate a good vote. And with that, I would make a motion for a do pass. As amended. As amended.
▶ Play
We have a motion to pass as amended. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. All those opposed, no. Congratulations, you have passed your bill. Would you like to present your next bill while you're at the end of the table? Yes, sir. There's also an amendment for that one. Yes, sir. All right, we're going to pass out the amendment. We'll let them look at it real quick. I kind of got a little hurry last time they didn't get to see that amendment. I'll let you get it on the desk first. All right, I have a motion to adopt the amendment. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? Motion carries. You are recognized to present your bill, HB 1430, 25, as amended. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair. These amendments reflect feedback from the educators, policymakers, to create an educator career continuum that promotes the education profession while providing flexibility for schools to hire quality teachers and school leader candidates and strengthen the educator workforce. The ADE has received feedback from many education constituent groups, such as AEA, AAEA, ASTA, AASCD, and the PLSB, and more. And I feel like I went to elementary just real quick there. and also from the ESSA Steering Committee and the State Board of Educators in support of these amendments. And with that, I would like again to let Ms.
▶ Play
Ivey take over. You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And as she read that, I'm going to go ahead and apologize for all of the acronyms because I know that's very frustrating, and I'll be happy to articulate each of those if I need to. Um, but, um, this bill is, um, really about, um, working to support a, an educator career continuum. Um, we, um, as, as all of you know, you've, um, had this presented to you in recent years that, um, we are seeing a continuing enrollment decrease in educator preparation programs. Um, we have, uh, really realized that that's just one of several factors that are contributing to educator shortages we about well and I'll just give you an example this is something I looked at yesterday last year we had 1,907 candidates complete an educator preparation program this year only 1,189 of them are actually working and that's pretty consistent with data over the last three years that about 40% of our candidates who complete a program do not go to work in an Arkansas public school the next year we are looking at the reasons why some of that's due to candidates who leave and return to another state or go somewhere else but a lot of it's due to the fact that we don't always have candidates preparing to be licensed and go to the areas where they're needed our educator workforce has changed and we talked about that with the last bill in terms of support. This bill really focuses on providing multiple pathways to the profession and providing some flexibility for districts to hire quality individuals and then to encourage very strong preparation of all of our candidates that we recruit to the profession. So we have different amendments here that um that we've included um but again it is um with the intent of um bringing quality people to the classroom and um if those quality people do not have a license finding the appropriate pathways for them in order to prepare and to earn a license um so the summary there kind of breaks that down and i can talk through any section of that summary or answer any questions that you might have i
▶ Play
have a question before we start taking questions on the amendment it looks like it doesn't line up with the strike language in the bill can you look at that and tell me what you see it's on page three it's showing us deleting 29 through 31 N3, but the two languages do not match up. Representative Lowry, would you like to speak to that? Representative Eubanks would you like to speak to that? She has an
▶ Play
explanation. Can you give her two seconds to get it to you?
▶ Play
Speaker 137 1:17:44
Thank you. We just called it. Well, I think they've got it for you. We were originally in the bill amending that provision that formerly was subsection 3 there. It is on page 3, line 29. So instead of amending that provision, we are actually just striking it, striking the entire provision. Okay.
▶ Play
You're striking the entire. Okay. Yes. Does everyone understand that? Okay. Okay. Any issues with that? It's a little change from what the amendment actually showed, but that's, it's the same, but it's not. But, okay. Everybody's okay with that? We'll go continue on. Representative
▶ Play
Walker, I think you had your hand up first. You're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Let's see. In your explanation of the proposed legislation under amendment, you indicate that the definition of teacher is included to include almost anybody who's working in a district of innovation, charter schools, or regular schools. Is there a limit on the number of these novice teachers or unlicensed teachers, percentage-wise or numerically, for any school or school district? or may a school be entirely constituted with these unlicensed teachers who are giving some kind of emergency certification? Representative Walker, to my
▶ Play
knowledge, there is no limit to that. ESSA will require states to conduct a calculation of disproportionality, and if disproportionalities exist where poor and minority students are taught at greater rates by inexperienced out-of-field or ineffective teachers, then states are going to have to show what actions they're going to take to address the root causes of that. But in terms of in statute, there currently is not a requirement there. Here's
▶ Play
my concern. If there is no limit on the number, a district in distress may terminate for calls or whatever. It's entire teaching staff and then hire novice teachers for budgetary reasons, especially when they're in non-growth districts. What is there to limit or prevent
▶ Play
that from happening? I don't think that there's anything in current statute to address that right now. And what this bill does is this bill is encouraging a career continuum so that anybody who might be hired, it's not necessarily encouraging the hiring of non-licensed teachers, but it is recognizing that if they are, then it would encourage them to get involved in an educator preparation
▶ Play
program and work toward licensure. Can see, can you not, where a district that has no budget growth and is under stress of regulations and other requirements of the Department of Education may see as its only recourse elimination of teachers and hiring of other teachers at a lower cost as a panacea of the problem that they face. You can see that as a possibility, can't you? And if you can, is there anything that could be taken or done under
▶ Play
Speaker 137 1:21:36
your bill to prevent that from happening? Cheryl Reinhart again. The existence of non-licensed teachers in the classroom is a result of school districts having the ability under Act 1240 of 2015 to request those waivers from the State Board. The State Board has considered those waivers in light of what the reason is that they're requesting those waivers. For the most part, the State Board looks at those reasons carefully. They would need to show the State Board that somehow the reason for the waiver is going to be a proposal that they have that they want to use a particular program and they need some waivers. Or, for instance, some of the schools of innovation, charter schools, of course, they have waivers already under the law. So, you know, unless a school district were to just not be truthful before the state board, a reason that would not be sufficient reason just because they want to lower their budgeting costs on that account. Finally, does the Department,
▶ Play
does the State, does the Archangel Education Association support this too? Representative Walker, I think that
▶ Play
they are going to speak in support of this bill.
▶ Play
They are in line to speak, yes. Any other questions, Committee? Seeing none, does anybody like to speak against the bill in the audience? Seeing none, Ms. Nelson, you're scheduled to speak for this bill. You know the drill.
▶ Play
Good morning again, Mr. Chairman and members of the committee. My name is Tracy Ann Nelson. I'm the Executive Director of the Arkansas Education Association. So this is a very difficult situation because Act 1240 has made waivers a very, in our estimation, onerous situation, but we remain concerned about the drastic decline in the pipeline of people coming into the teaching profession. No doubt the erosion of all sorts of things for educators, which include benefits, additional burdens, low pay and low morale, contributes to why people are not choosing the profession or choosing to leave and do something alternatively. This bill seeks to address the crisis of the pipeline by providing an additional entry point for educators to work toward licensure, which is what we support completely. there should be a framework for educators to be in the classroom with children and the only way to do that in our estimation is through licensure while seeking to keep standards high for students. Through the career continuum it also acknowledges the dedicated career educators and helps to build them in the profession as they can work to becoming teacher leaders in their school buildings and in their school systems. AEA supports the bill and appreciates the department's work to maintain a strong teacher pipeline while ensuring students benefit from having highly qualified teachers in each
▶ Play
classroom in Arkansas. Thank you. I'm there, Representative Walker. You're just going to have to remember to leave that mic off when you're
▶ Play
not using it. It's just hot. You're recognized. Thank you. Let me take a district like Mariana. I saw Representative Murdoch here and I wish he were here. His wife's the superintendent. Let's assume that they are up against fiscal distress again and they need $40,000 and they have a teacher who's making $65,000 based on tenure and they can meet their budget concern by terminating that teacher and taking getting a novice teacher who may not even have a degree for $25,000. I mean And isn't this somewhat, isn't what you're doing here somewhat encouraging that result? I understand you have fair teacher dismissal and all those other things. But do you really want to get rid of your experienced teachers in situations where you have non-growth districts and allow them to be replaced with novice teachers who have to go through a process and then where their likelihood is going to be that they're not going to be there after three years? I mean, do you
▶ Play
really support that? I think we're picking amongst things that are not the best choices, and we have to make difficult decisions in light of all of the pressures that districts and families are facing. I think that school districts understand the value of seasoned teachers and what their contribution is to student success. And we know from data that teachers meet their successful stride with students after five years. So it would dissuade the district to get rid of teachers that have that experience because those are the very teachers that help students to be successful. When you have the pressure of finance versus, you know, experience, we trust that the school system led by the superintendent the school board if there's one in place and the families who are invested in the school district can make the best decisions for that community we don't aea is not supportive of educators who are not licensed in the classroom because we think it diminishes the profession and it diminishes the value of the training that teachers get to be successful with students. But we cannot, in light of the pipeline, pretend that we can just stand in our position of no while students need more and more educators. Thank you. Mr.
▶ Play
Chair, may I also add? You may. And Representative Walker, this bill also encourages a teacher career continuum to recognize advanced licenses and teacher leader endorsements. So it's actually encouraging teachers who have invested into the profession as career professionals. It is encouraging them to lead from the classroom, not leave the classroom for advancement. So that is part of this bill, and I just wanted to make sure that that was
▶ Play
said. If I may, here's my concern. If a district faces fiscal distress by meeting one of the criteria for being in fiscal distress, which is being below budget and having more debt than revenue, I'm concerned that the district does not address it by dealing with the novice teacher approach that you all embrace and getting rid of teachers who may be demonstrated as competent and I don't know how you do that where you have declining growth districts and declining revenue but it would seem as if you'd want to have those students with the best teachers that they can who are in declining growth districts rather than having novice persons because it's just a matter of time before, at least for the time that you have, because it's just a matter of time before those districts are going to go out of existence anyway. So my concern would be that the students there get the best options that they can instead of there being measures taken in order to prolong the continuation of the district and have it kept out of the designation of fiscal distress.
▶ Play
That's my concern. I don't know how you address it. Thank you. I'm going to hold for just a sec.
▶ Play
I'm going to let my co-chair make a little announcement real quick. Committee, thank you for your indulgence. My school district from Greenwood is here. They're right there back there at the door. You can see some finely dressed young men there with them. I'm not sure how many. Yeah, there they are. their waving. They're here today with Susie Wilson from Greenwood Administration and they have accepted the Carolyn Pollan's top five highest achieving alternative education programs in the state. So quite an accomplishment and I'm so proud of them and thanks for dropping by education committee. So, thank you guys. We're back live. Sorry to interrupt. If you want to answer that.
▶ Play
Mr. Chair, I'll withdraw my question because of time. I don't know that it will change anybody's mind one way or another. Thank you, Representative Walker. Mr. Chairman, can I address
▶ Play
his concern anyway? I'm going to let
▶ Play
Representative Meek ask his and then you make it hit them all at the same
▶ Play
time. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and the bill's sponsor may also want to weigh on this. On the core licensure areas that are laid out in the bill, we've got early childhood, English, math, science, social studies, art, music, foreign language. I know one of the purposes of this bill is to try to encourage teachers to come into the pipeline that are probably already professionals in other areas to try to get them to come into the teaching profession. and one of the primary areas that i know as a state we've been struggling is in the technology and the governor's coding initiative um is that an area that perhaps needs to be added to this core requirement or are we still able to bring those you know technologists and scientists and whatnot to give them those alternative licensing under this proposed change and that's on page top of page six bottom page five Representative Meeks I think that the reason why those areas are identified specifically in here is identifying them as core content areas for other purposes within the bill and these were core content areas as defined under No Child Left Behind and these were areas that if a district is hiring a teacher under the waiver from licensure These teachers in these areas would have to have at least a four-year bachelor's degree and demonstrate content knowledge in these areas. So these were the ones that were previously identified, and we carried those over. But it would not in any way limit someone coming in with computer science or anything like that. It would actually give you more flexibility to hire in your career tech areas or in those computer science areas. These are there to ensure that if a teacher is teaching under a waiver, that they do have minimum qualifications. All right. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Any other questions?
▶ Play
All right. Is anyone in the audience would like to speak against the bill? Anybody else for the bill? Seeing none, would you like to close for your
▶ Play
bill? Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Again, with so many people coming to the table, I want to thank the department for bringing everyone to the table and everyone working together to try to come up with a good alternative. So with that, I would ask for a good vote and a
▶ Play
motion of do pass. As amended. As amended. We have a motion to pass as amended. Seeing no discussion, all those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? congratulations you have passed your bill okay from now on since we've had so many questions asked today the next bill only gets one question from anybody i am going to present house bill 1154 i do not see representative douglas so i'm going to ask represent meek to temporarily take the chair As
▶ Play
acting chair, do I get to bend that rule, Mr. Chairman? Right now, you are the chair. You do whatever. All right, and once you get
▶ Play
settled there, Mr. Chair, you are recognized to present your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and thank you, Committee. I'm here to present a bill that we worked on during the interim and had passed some adequacy in the adequacy funding, some money to actually take care of this bill. And this is
▶ Play
House Bill 1154 for the committee, correct?
▶ Play
1154, and this is an act that requires that any increase in professional development funding each year be used on professional learning communities and for other purposes. And I'll just state this. This is a pretty simple bill. It's really small, and that's exactly what it does. The new money that we proposed in the adequacy funding last year in the bill actually goes to this in two years. It's basically about $4 million each year, a little bit more than that, and it goes towards the professional learning communities. I met yesterday with 11 of the 15 co-ops. They are all on board with this bill. I think everybody, I've not had any emails against this bill like I have Charlotte's. She's going to run. So, sorry about that, Charlotte. But I think it's a good bill. It's going to bring PD to a different level. And I think what we're going to do, we're trying to close the gap. And I think this is, from what we can learn in the ideas of what we have to do differently with the PLCs, differently than what regular PD is, this will help close the gap and bring everything to a higher level. That's what we're after. Representative Walker, I see you down there. I'm ready for questions. All right.
▶ Play
Representative Walker, you're recognized, sir. Because of your stellar work on this and explanation and other support for it, I make a motion that we pass this without discussion. I'm all for
▶ Play
that. Is that a motion for immediate consideration? I'm closed. All right. So you're closed for your bill? I'm closed. All right. Does anybody want to speak against the bill, for the bill? Seeing none, Representative Cozart, I assume you're still closed for your bill? Still closed. All right, so I've got a motion from Representative Walker. Do pass. All in favor, please say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no. Hearing none, congratulations, Mr. Chairman. You have passed your bill. Thank you, Representative Walker,
▶ Play
in committee, and Mr. Chair. Thank you. And you're welcome to close the meeting if you want to.
▶ Play
All right. Got a motion to adjourn without objection.
▶ Play

Agenda

HB1154 Cozart TO REQUIRE THAT ANY INCREASES IN PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT FUNDING EACH SCHOOL YEAR BE USED FOR PROFESSIONAL LEARNING COMMUNITIES.

HB1266 Richey TO ALLOW A SCHOOL BOARD MEMBER OR A SPOUSE OF A SCHOOL BOARD MEMBER TO BE A VOLUNTEER OR A REGISTERED VOLUNTEER UPON APPROVAL OF THE SCHOOL BOARD.

HB1408 C. Douglas CONCERNING WHO MAY SERVE AS A PROCTOR OF A TEST OR ASSESSMENT ADMINISTERED UNDER THE ARKANSAS COMPREHENSIVE TESTING, ASSESSMENT, AND ACCOUNTABILITY PROGRAM ACT.

HB1424 Vaught TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING THE TEACHER EXCELLENCE AND TO AMEND OF SUPPORT SYSTEM; ARKANSAS CODE THE PROVISIONS CONCERNING ADMINISTRATOR EVALUATION.

HB1425 Vaught CONCERNING THE LICENSURE OF TEACHERS AND ADMINISTRATORS AND LICENSURE EXCEPTIONS; TO AUTHORIZE A TIERED LICENSURE SYSTEM; AND TO ALLOW DISTRICTS TO BASE COMPENSATION ON LICENSURE LEVELS.

HB1435 Tucker TO REQUIRE PUBLIC SCHOOLS AND OPEN-ENROLLMENT CHARTER SCHOOLS TO POST THE CHILD ABUSE HOTLINE TELEPHONE NUMBER.

HB1473 Love TO ALLOW A TAX DEDUCTION FOR CONTRIBUTIONS TO A TUITION SAVINGS ACCOUNT IN THE ARKANSAS TAX-DEFERRED TUITION SAVINGS PROGRAM TO BE CARRIED FORWARD TO SUCCEEDING TAX YEARS.

HB1042 B. Smith TO PROHIBIT SANCTUARY POLICIES AT STATE-SUPPORTED INSTITUTIONS OF HIGHER EDUCATION.

PENDING FISCAL IMPACT Subtitle Number Sponsor

HB1222 Dotson THE ARKANSAS PARENTAL EMPOWERMENT FOR EDUCATION CHOICE ACT OF 2017; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

HB1407 Douglas TO ALLOW A PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT TO SUBMIT BY ELECTRONIC MEANS ANY C. SIGNATURES REQUIRED FOR REPORTING PURPOSES.

HB1442 Davis TO CREATE THE PERSONAL FINANCE AND JOB READINESS ACT.

HB1456 C. Douglas TO ALLOW A SCHOOL DISTRICT TO WAIVE PHYSICAL EDUCATION REQUIREMENTS FOR A STUDENT WHO PROVIDES PROOF OF PHYSICAL ACTIVITY; AND TO EXEMPT A STUDENT WITH A PHYSICAL EDUCATION WAIVER FROM PHYSICAL

EDUCATION GRADUATION REQUIREMENTS.

HB1457 C. Douglas TO ALLOW A PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT AND AN AN OPEN-ENROLLMENT PUBLIC CHARTER SCHOOL TO DEVELOP A PLAN FOR THE USE OF AN ALTERNATIVE METHOD OF INSTRUCTION TO BE USED ON DAYS WHEN SCHOOL IS CANCELLED.

HB1458 C. Douglas TO REQUIRE A STUDENT TO PARTICIPATE IN VISUAL ARTS OR PERFORMING ARTS IN EITHER GRADE SEVEN OR GRADE EIGHT.

HB1459 C. Douglas TO PROVIDE FLEXIBILITY IN THE AWARDING OF COURSE CREDITS; AND TO ALLOW A PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT TO DEVELOP AND IMPLEMENT A PLAN THAT ENABLES A

TO EARN COURSE CREDITS BY DEMONSTRATING SUBJECT MATTER COMPETENCY.

HB1461 Wing TO EXPAND THE NUMBER OF PRIVATE SCHOOLS ELIGIBLE TO PARTICIPATE IN THE SUCCEED SCHOLARSHIP PROGRAM; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

HB1474 Lowery CONCERNING THE PARTICIPATION OF HOME-SCHOOLED STUDENTS IN INTERSCHOLASTIC ACTIVITIES.

HB1017 Cozart TO ALLOW THE TEACHER FAIR DISMISSAL ACT OF 1983 TO BE WAIVED IF A PUBLIC SCHOOL OR PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT IS UNDER STATE AUTHORITY AFTER BEING CLASSIFIED AS BEING IN DISTRESS.

HB1020 Love TO CREATE THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY PROMISE LOTTERY SCHOLARSHIP PROGRAM; TO PROVIDE FUNDS TO EVERY CHILD BORN IN ARKANSAS TO BE USED FOR COLLEGE TUITION.

HB1027 Eubanks TO PROHIBIT A SCHOOL DISTRICT FROM USING PUBLIC FUNDS TO PAY A TEACHER'S OR CLASSIFIED EMPLOYEE'S MEMBERSHIP DUES IN A PROFESSIONAL ORGANIZATION.

HB1029 Lowery TO EXCLUDE PRINCIPALS, ASSISTANT PRINCIPALS, AND CENTRAL OFFICE EMPLOYEES WITH A MULTIYEAR EMPLOYMENT CONTRACT FROM THE DEFINITION OF "TEACHER" UNDER THE TEACHER FAIR DISMISSAL ACT OF 1983.

HB1044 F. Allen TO ALLOW A STUDENT TO CHOOSE WHICH GRADE IN WHICH TO TAKE THE COLLEGE AND CAREER READINESS ASSESSMENT.

HB1056 House TO ALLOW THE SUPERINTENDENT OF A STUDENT'S RESIDENT SCHOOL DISTRICT TO WAIVE THE REQUIREMENT THAT THE STUDENT ATTEND PUBLIC SCHOOL FOR ONE (1) ACADEMIC YEAR TO BE ELIGIBLE FOR A SUCCEED SCHOLARSHIP.

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Bruce Cozart Chair Unverified
44 segments
Speaker 4
1 segment
Chair Unverified
7 segments
Representative Stephen Meeks Unverified
118 segments
Speaker 19
1 segment
Speaker 27
1 segment
Representative DeAnn Vaught Unverified
14 segments
Speaker 40
1 segment
Speaker 48
1 segment
Speaker 53
2 segments
Speaker 52
1 segment
Representative Mark Lowery Unverified
33 segments
Representative Mickey Gates Unverified
2 segments
Representative Dan Sullivan Unverified
1 segment
Representative John W. Walker Chair Unverified
50 segments
Speaker 137
9 segments
Speaker 141
1 segment
Speaker 127
1 segment
Representative Nelda Speaks Unverified
4 segments
Representative Frances Cavenaugh Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 182
6 segments
Representative Rick Beck Unverified
6 segments
Speaker 193
1 segment
Speaker 199
1 segment
Tracy Ann Unverified
16 segments