Revenue and Taxation Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (16)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
SB140
· 5 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB140 Files TO PROVIDE FOR THE COLLECTION OF SALES AND USE TAX RA…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1162
· 2 mentions in transcript
Matched: “do that then? Representative Flowers in House Bill 1162, that was a bill that did impact different sources of state…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1388
· 2 mentions in transcript
Matched: “…abide by the reporting similar to the language that was in House Bill 1388.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1014
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1014 Leding TO CREATE THE TEACHER'S CLASSROOM INVESTMENT DEDUCTI…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1028
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1028 Lemons TO EXEMPT CERTAIN BUSES, COACHES, AND OTHER MOTOR VE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1031
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1031 Bentley TO CREATE AN INCOME TAX EXEMPTION FOR INCENTIVES RE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1153
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1153 Boyd TO CLARIFY THE MEANING OF "ACTUAL AND OBVIOUS ERRORS"…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1221
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1221 Sabin TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE SALES AND USE TAX EXE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1395
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1395 Leding TO CREATE AN INCOME TAX CREDIT FOR TAXPAYERS THAT EM…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1396
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1396 Leding TAX THE EDUCATION INDIVIDUAL SCHOLARSHIPS, FROM INCO…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1397
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1397 Leding TO EQUALIZE THE SALES TAX TREATMENT OF DUES AND MEMB…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1449
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1449 Dotson TO AMEND THE ANNUAL FRANCHISE TAX FOR CORPORATIONS T…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1480
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1480 Ladyman TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF "ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT PR…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1512
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1512 Davis TO REDUCE THE INCOME TAX RATES APPLICABLE TO INDIVIDU…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB253
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB253 B. Sample TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS HISTORIC REHABILITATION INC…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB282
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB282 B. Johnson COLLECTION THE AND OF DISTRIBUTION CONCERNING TO…”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 14, 2026
Okay, members, we're going to start, the chair sees a quorum. Representing Leading, you're good to pass over your bill, sir. All of them.
Representative Dawson, you're good to pass over your bill. Okay. Senator Jake Files, you ready, sir? Members, we're going to start off with Senate Bill 140, and there should be some handouts in front of you from D.F. and A also. Senator Fowles, my apologies, sir.
Speaker 11
1:08
When you get ready, feel free to proceed. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, members of the committee. Mr. Chairman, are we adopting the, are we hearing on
this amendment first? Yes, sir. I'm assuming, Representative Douglas, you have an amendment to Senate Bill 140? Yes,
sir, Mr. Chair, if I might present that, please, sir.
Please, sir. Members, this will be the first amendment on Senate Bill 140, and it'll be JLL 188 on your tablets.
JLL 188 on your tablets. Representative Douglas, you're free to proceed,
sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair, committee. Good to see you all here this morning. This amendment, all it does is clarify a little bit of language, and then it adds in some additional language that says if you are an out-of-state retailer and you do not collect and remit sales tax, then you must abide by the reporting similar to the language that was in House Bill 1388.
That's all it does. If you don't collect and remit, according to this bill, Senate Bill 140, then you have to report to the purchaser and to send out the yearly statement to the purchaser and DF&A on total dollars of sales. Thank you, Representative Douglas. Hold that thought for a second. I think we're having
trouble with our electronic devices to be able to bring that up. Just bear with us just a second. Click on the exact number.
Click on the number. One more time. Members, how many more people have trouble bringing that up?
We're handing out hard copies as well.
Members, does everybody have a copy, whether it's paper or electronic now, of the amendment? Everybody good? Any questions on the amendment? Members, any questions on the amendment? Yes, sir, Representative Hendren, you're free to proceed.
I just got the paper copy. I was able to bring up the next amendment, which I see that you're making some changes
to how you spend the income from that. But that's the next one. I guess I got that. That is not this amendment. I know. That's the only one I could get up on my computer until they've given me this paper one. So now I want to ask it about this one that's up now. As I understand the explanation you gave here, we're going to tell another state how to do things. How does that work in our United States Constitution and federal law? Are we qualified, and do we have the ability to tell Oklahoma and Missouri how to run their
Speaker 11
4:59
business? Representative Hender, we're not telling the states how to run their business.
We're creating a nexus. It's not really on the amendment. I don't know if you want to speak on the bill yet, but that's not what
the amendment does. I thought he said that if the out-of-state remoter deal didn't do it, he would have to file a report. Isn't that what he just said in the testimony when I was trying to find
Speaker 11
5:21
this on my computer? Yeah, it does add a reporting requirement to businesses that do 200 transactions and creates a nexus with them, too. The bill just deals with collecting the tax. That was my question, though.
Do we have the authority in Arkansas to tell Oklahoma how
to do anything? We're not telling Oklahoma how to do anything, Representative Hendren. We're telling out-of-state retailers, online retailers that don't have a presence here, If they don't collect and remit, they have to follow Arkansas laws. And that would be the reporting requirement. And that requirement is similar to the language in House Bill 1388, which we passed out of the House last week.
And that bill, in this language, has been upheld by the United States Supreme Court as being constitutional. So, therefore, we do have the authority. Well, I guess I'd ask a question that
we do have the, I just don't understand that we have the authority to reach across into Oklahoma or Missouri, which you know our contiguous states up here in the northwest corner, that we have a right to reach over there and tell their people how to do their business, whether a retailer or whatever they are.
But you're saying the Supreme Court has now told us that we can, one state can reach over into the next state and tell that
state's retailers how to do their business and what forms
has been upheld constitutionally. Yes, sir. Is that case cited anywhere in here? I do not believe it is. Let's see. I can't recall the exact case. It was in the 10th U.S. Circuit Court, I believe, sometime in, wasn't it about July of 2016?
We might have somebody coming that has a little bit more. Okay, members, remember, this is just on adopting the amendment as well. So, Paul, you want to just shed just
a little bit of light on that real quick? Thank you, Mr. Chair. Paul Gehring with the Arkansas Department of Finance and Administration. I am the Assistant Revenue Commissioner for Policy and Legal. concerning Representative Hendren's question pertaining to the Colorado model of the notice
requirement and also the annual reporting of sales. The case is direct marketing versus Broll. It was a Tenth Circuit decision that determined that that statutory framework was constitutional and did not violate the Commerce Clause. It was appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court and the U.S. Supreme Court in December of 2016 did not grant certain the case. One more. We're going to move on. Representative Andrew, please. That Tenth Circuit, is that the one out in California?
isn't it? That's fine. Representative Collins, you recognize,
sir? Representative Douglas, do you think that Amazon would start collecting and remitting taxes to Arkansas if they saw that these bills were unconstitutional? No, I do not. No, I do not think
on the amendment? Anybody not even speak against the amendment?
amendment? Mr. Chair, I would move do pass on the amendment. We have a motion from Representative Douglas to adopt the amendment. Any debate? All in favor say aye. Any opposed, no. The ayes have it, sir. Senator
Speaker 11
9:14
Fowles, you proceed, sir. All right. Mr. Chair, we will now discuss the bill as
amended, correct? Excuse me, sir. We have Representative Michael John Gray.
Use your microphone, please, sir. Amendment, Mr. Chair. Okay. Staff, does the amendment's handed out from Representative Gray? Okay. That should be, you should be looking at JLL 206 on your tablets, members. JLL 206, staff is handing out a paper copy for that amendment. Representative Michael John Gray, would you please go then to the table, sir?
Representative Gregg, feel free to proceed, sir. I think everybody has the
Speaker 68
10:25
amendment in front of them now. Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee. This amendment does a few things.
It starts out by the gist of the amendment, or the purpose of the amendment is it will designate some of the new revenue to certain appropriations. And so to do that, the first amendment you have to do is to change the title. So it is now for the collection and distribution, instead of just the collection. But the meat of the amendment that you'll find on page two starts with, after the deductions
that will already be required by law, an additional $25 million in revenue to be directed as follows. 50% of that to the miscellaneous agencies fund to be used, half to be used to AEDC for rural fire development grants, and the other half to create a program to do that exclusively for rural police departments, 35% of that $25 million to be designated to an account within the Arkansas Medicaid program trust fund, to be used exclusively for the alternative
community services waiver program, which would address the wait list, 10% of that $25 million to the Department of Education to be used exclusively for an ongoing and continual funding of Arkansas Better Chance Program, better known to some of us as a pre-K program. And finally, 5% of that $25 million to the Department of Education to be used exclusively for after-school program grants. And with that, Mr. Chair, I'll take any questions. Members, any questions on the amendment?
Representative Hendren, you recognize her? I guess, Representative Gray, that was an amendment I was looking at when I mentioned that to Senator Fowles and Representative Douglas a minute ago. But I have it here now in the hard copy. This is an effort to whatever additional revenues come in would then not just be put into the general fund, they would be specifically allocated to other things, which then could reduce costs and the performance of those other items in the budget? Yes, sir.
That's a fair assessment of it. I guess there's some other bills floating around out there to do some of these similar things, but this does it as attaching it to the budget to this particular bill, right?
Yes, sir. That's right. Thank you. Members, any other questions? Anybody in the audience want to speak against this amendment? DFA wants to speak? Paul looks like you're up again, buddy. You drew a short straw today.
Please recognize yourself again, sir. Paul Gehring, Department of Finance and Administration. Mr. Chair, we just got an opportunity to review this amendment. One issue that we have identified as possibly problematic is identifying the increase in online retail sales taxes collected in order to determine where those monies are coming from.
We certainly already have retailers that are based out of state that are sending in sales tax pursuant to the streamlined agreement. So I think that we would have to, in order to do a full analysis of this proposed amendment, we would at least want to get the opportunity to take a closer look at it, but it appears that it might be problematic for
that purpose I've mentioned. Okay. Okay. Representative Gray, you heard DFA, or you still
Speaker 68
14:15
want to proceed with your amendment, sir? Yes, sir, due respect.
This has been through review of BLR for over two weeks now. This amendment's been in discussion and through the attorneys that are the legislative staff. I recognize DFNA may have some language issues that we may need to clean up. We do that a lot here, but I think the substance of the amendment still serves the purpose that we're addressing. MR. Okay. Paul, is the problem DFA is having,
is it the money part or is it the language of the amendment, plus specifically? MR. I think certainly the
language issue might be problematic for us to make sure that this
is something that we can do. Certainly when any type of amendment or bill is filed, we certainly want to allow DFA to go through the fiscal impact process, do a proper analysis of the bill so that we can and be sure what the bill does and communicate that to the rest of the members. Okay. Representative Collins, you
it true that in Arkansas we used to have a lot of dedicated revenue streams and we moved away from that because it was a very inefficient, ineffective way to budget?
that, Representative Collins? Isn't it true that in Arkansas in years past, we used to have a lot of dedicated revenue streams to particular budget items, and we've moved away from that over time because it's a very inefficient and ineffective way to manage a
Thank you. Representative Hendren, you recognize her? Paul, would the DFA support this amendment and this application of these funds
or this problematic problem that you raised here? If we could solve that with the DFA, would you be agreeable to the application of these funds as additional funds? Would you be okay with the amendment if that were solved? I'm not sure that I could answer that
question, Representative Hendricks, until we can do a full analysis of what this amendment is trying to do. Then I guess I'd inquire the
Chair. Mr. Chair, would it be appropriate then if he could we wait until he can get an answer and come back and answer that, provide the answer to that question at least to this member
and to this committee? Yes, Chairman, I just asked the sponsor of the amendment, and he's with Will Venice Wright to run the amendment today, so that's as proper what the member's wanting to do. So we're going to proceed based on Representative Gray's,
what he's wanting to do here. So Representative Flyers, you recognize, ma'am? Well, I just wanted to get some clarification about, and my sense is that this was really a philosophical question, but about this type of distribution of funds in response to Representative
Collins' question about the efficiency of budgeting in that way. And I guess my question would be, didn't we just do this same kind of targeted distribution of very specific revenue streams when we passed out the bill that identified certain funds associated with the retired military veterans. I mean, didn't we do some of that with that bill?
The same exact thing, where we identified certain revenue streams and then identified certain expenditures to come from those revenue streams. Yes or no, didn't we
do that then? Representative Flowers in House Bill 1162, that was a bill that did impact different sources of state revenues. There was the soft drink tax that is primarily all that revenue goes to the Medicaid trust fund, and then certainly impacted sales taxes, which have not are entirely general revenue,
where his income taxes are. So I believe that I can't say that this particular amendment does the exact same thing as House Bill 1162. Excuse me,
sir. Let me just clear this up. I mean, we're going to proceed with this. Representative Gray is wanting to proceed with this amendment. So, I mean, that's kind of all academic. Certainly don't want to get off topic of what we're trying to accomplish here. We're going to proceed with this
Speaker 90
18:42
amendment. So does everybody understand that? Representative Murdoch. Thank you, Chairman. And I appreciate that last statement. But I do want to, since the DFNA representative chose to dive off into it and respond to Representative
Collins, I want you to defend that, please, when you said that, when you agreed with him that it was proven that it was an inefficient manner as to how we previously handled our budget, that it was proven to be inefficient. So I want you to give antidote evidence as to how you know that was inefficient for you to agree with
him, please. Well, certainly my response was that to a degree as to the main substance of the question as to the different forms of funding, but certainly DFA is not here to present any type
of policy or support either way, but certainly to answer to the factual request of the question. Absolutely, but the question that he
Speaker 90
19:33
asked that it was proven ineffective, and you said yes, and I want you to be able to defend that. Well, that certainly wasn't
my intention to certainly agree with the policy component of the question, but certainly to agree with the substance of the factual question that was asked. Okay. I don't think you got
Speaker 90
19:51
to the factual part. I think you agreed with the philosophical part. But since you've backed off of it, I'm okay with that.
Thank you. Members, we're talking about the amendment, so let's try to stay on task on the amendment. Any more questions to the amendment? Anybody in audience want to speak against the amendment for Senator Fowles? Do I get a chance to speak on the amendment? Yes, sir, you can. As it's to my bill? The
Speaker 11
20:19
table is so long, I can barely see you down there. Well, that's not all bad. Representative Gray and I had talked about this amendment, and the reason we didn't put an amendment like this or something that dealt with the distribution of revenue in the bill before
was because we felt like it clouded and muddied the waters, especially if this bill got challenged constitutionally. And so that's why it wasn't in there. I'm not agreeable to this amendment, and I think it is something that I believe the task force should take up as they look at increased revenues. Representative Murdoch and Representative Flowers, one of the things to clarify, I think, what Representative Collins was talking about, one difference that I see is this is increasing revenues and broadening the base.
What we did and what he was talking about before was shrinking revenues, and that would be where the distinction was. And then in response to Representative Hendren, this is not a reduction of cost in the way that you ask it, in my opinion. These monies are coming out in addition to what other monies are there, so it doesn't take the place of other monies in the budget, if that was a way to respond to that. And I believe that's where that is, in an addition. Senator Fowles, you take a question, sir?
Sure. Representative Murdock. Representative Murdock. Thank
Speaker 90
21:35
you, Chairman. So, Senator, what we are doing, if this happens and the funds come to the state, those are new funds that we are getting, and so that is a new revenue stream. So when you're talking about broadening the base, what we're asking to do with those funds is distribute those funds to five needy areas, I think, that are very, as Senator Hendren mentioned, that everyone knows needs to be funded. So this is a mechanism whereby we have not grown anything. We've just found an opportunity to fund those areas that are
Speaker 11
22:05
very needed. Right. I don't disagree with that. And it's a policy decision that if 51 of you guys and 18 of us agree with, I do think that by dedicating these directly in this fashion, it creates a poison pill that I don't think there's 51 votes in your chamber. I'm not speaking for all the members, but I would be surprised if it passed with this language added to it. And that's what I'm trying to avoid. I'm trying to put us in a position where I think we have the revenues and can decide where we go with them and make a separate policy decision
instead of lumping all of it together and trying to make it
Speaker 90
22:39
happen. And understanding the position that we're in, that if it's not dedicated or not committed, then we're left to chance that it will happen. And it has not always happened, so we're just trying to make sure at the committee level Well, we can affect what happens with those revenues. I understand that position. Yes, sir. Thank you.
for your amendment? Yes, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Speaker 68
23:07
Members, and with respect to Senator Fowles and Representative Collins' points, and to I address Representative Hendren not to intend to be misleading. There are bills out there and needs out there to fund these now. So this new revenue would be dedicated to funding the ongoing needs of these that are hanging out there now. So it's a hybrid of the question you asked. It's not going to replace existing funding, but it would create a source to supply new funding for the needs that are still evident.
A lot of these needs, these are all needs that have been glaring for more than one session, and this is new revenue that we'll address them. Senator Hendren, I would be happy to sit down with DF&A and try to work out the hiccup, so to speak, that they foresee that the attorney, the legislative attorneys did not see, but only if Senator Files was willing to hold his bill until we could work that amendment out, and I don't think that's where we are today. Members, I think this is new revenue coming into Arkansas.
These are needs that have been inadequately addressed or will be inadequately addressed with our budget going forward, and I think with new sources of revenue, we should really consider this amendment. So with that, thank you, Mr. Chair. Welcome, sir. Members, you've heard the
amendment. Is there a motion on amendment? What's the pleasure of the committee? Move we adopt the amendment, Mr. Chair. I have a motion to adopt from Representative Gray. Any debate? All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no. No.
Speaker 102
24:48
Let's call the roll, Ms. Eden. REPRESENTATIVE LETTING. REPRESENTATIVE LETTING. REPRESENTATIVE COLLINS. No. REPRESENTATIVE MURDOCH. Yes. REPRESENTATIVE BALTZ? REPRESENTATIVE BALTZ? REPRESENTATIVE DOTSON? REPRESENTATIVE ARMSTRONG? REPRESENTATIVE BRAGG? REPRESENTATIVE SABIN? REPRESENTATIVE HODGES? REPRESENTATIVE DOUGLAS?
no representative hindron representative eve's representative eaves representative ferguson representative johnson representative flowers representative grey representative watson
Unknown speaker
26:05
MS. Representative Warren. MR. No. MS. Representative Farrar. MR. Yes. MR. I will be a no. I'm sorry, sir, your motion fails.
Speaker 11
26:51
Mr. Chairman. Members, I don't want to beat a bunch of these issues over and over and over again in terms of what we're trying to do, but again, just to hit some of the high points, this bill is modeled on a South Dakota bill that establishes nexus to remote sellers. As has been pointed out, I don't believe that Amazon, had they felt this was unconstitutional across the
country, would be volunteering to pay the tax. I put the use tax form on your desk there. I'm sure we've heard a lot about the use tax there's also a copy of the use tax law from 1949 in there that establishes that the tax is on the books and do this just replaces that in terms of allowing the retailer to collect the tax at the time of purchase and the point of sale and turn it into the state rather than putting the burden on the consumer and the purchaser
You'll hear probably some testimony we heard in the Senate on fairness, let free market rules apply. As it stands right now, free market is not applying. It does not apply because you can buy something in a store and pay a tax on it and walk out in your car and buy the same item and not pay a tax on it. So there's not a free market principle there of fairness. Another argument we heard was this is only for big business. Again, not true. This affects every business in Arkansas. Some of the ones that were brought up to me were a tire shop in Georgia
that's selling to some of my constituents. And the only difference was the price that they were, the sales tax, the price was exactly the same. And so this would help our local businesses as well. And I'd be happy to take any questions that might come up. Members, you
heard testimony. Any questions? Representative Johnson, you
recognize? Thank you, sir. I think this has been discussed and cussed, and I've received lots of emails over it,
and it's really not a new tax, and it does affect the small business. I have an entire store in my district and an office supply store that they directly affect, and it will help small business, and I agree with that. But you have to agree that this is a new inflow. Where it's not a new tax, it is a new inflow of revenues, And I had prepared an amendment, but I hadn't got it through. Don't know what, have not got the impact study on it yet.
And that was to give us a credit on our income tax returns for sales tax to help offset, because like you're not, Arkansas consumers are going to have outflows out of their pockets, and they feel like it is a new tax. And I feel like we should look at how to make that less impact on them. And of course, put this money to good use when we get it as well. So I guess my question is, would you be willing to let us try to get all this together before we run this bill forward?
Speaker 11
30:02
Yeah, I appreciate where you're coming from. That can be done in a separate bill for sure. And I would appreciate moving forward as this. I think when we start tying credits and redistribution, I think we bring real questions in constitutionality. And if this does get challenged and does come up, I think it may kick it out just for those simple reasons. But I would like to see that things like that be brought up separately. And there's no reason why they couldn't be. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Welcome, sir. Representative Collins, you recognize her?
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Senator Files, isn't this a question about what we're talking about here in enforcement action? Haven't we had discussions with the Washington DC folks? And they've been telling us for years, Arkansas, you need to learn how to manage your own house. You need to learn how to enforce the laws that you have on the books. And do you think this is a good enforcement mechanism if a day after you passed it in the Senate, the number one violator of Arkansas intent changed their approach?
validity in it. Yes, sir. Any other questions, members?
Representative Flowers, you recognize mail? Well, I just want to say for the record that I'm very much in support of this for a number of reasons, and many of which have been stated at the same time. I'm very supportive of the amendment that just failed by a hair. And given that DF&A came with a concern that we have not had an opportunity
to flesh out and have a vote on the amendment as a clean amendment free from DF&E's review. Representative Flowers, excuse me, ma'am. I hope there's a question coming
here. Thank you. Thank you. So I would like to
ask that we move to table the bill to give us more time to make those corrections in the amendment. I can accept that motion, ma'am. We don't
have a primary motion on the table yet. That's procedural motion. Okay. Thank you. Welcome.
Any other questions, members? If not, we're going to move to the against. And the for portion of it, in the audience, we have several people want to speak against the bill and for the bill. We start, excuse me, Representative Gray, go ahead. Make a motion to limit debate. Hang on just a second.
Do you have time limit in mind, sir? Two minutes each side. I'm sorry sir, we're going to look that up just a second here.
Speaker 68
32:59
Stand by members, we're going to make sure we're going to do this right. Mr. Chair, I'd amend that to five minutes each
side if that would be easier. Stand by here, we'll make sure this is debatable and we'll make sure we're going to do this right.
Okay, members. Representative Hendren, your question is, sir, to limit debate. That's non-debatable, and that's going to take two-thirds of the quorum to do that. So the motion on the table, members, is it's going to be non-debatable. The motion is to limit debate. Five minutes aside, be in mind, members, for the people speaking for the bill, that comes off of the closing arguments for the bill, and that is non-debatable. Mr. Collins. MR. Mr. Chair,
since there's no discussion on this, can I make an alternate motion?
MR. You can, sir. MR. I'd like to make a motion that we limit debate to 15 minutes a sign.
That's my alternate motion. MR. That is proper. That is proper. MR. No, sir, you cannot. MR. No, sir. MR. No, you only have two alternate motions, one substitute motion on that. So we've already got the substitute motion here. So the question is now 15 minutes aside. All in favor, say aye.
Aye. Opposed, say no. Nay. The noes have it. Representative Gray, your motion, sir. I'd like
We have five minutes, non-debatable. All in favor, say aye. Aye. All opposed, say no. No. The ayes have it. Okay, so it's going to be five minutes aside, for and against. Five minutes aside, four and against, and the closing argument is going to come out on the closing arguments.
So we have against Mr. Paul Colbert. You recognize, sir? Okay. Mr. Paul Colbert, recognize yourself, sir, and you feel free to proceed. My name is
Paul Colbert. I'm from Faulkner County. I'm here speaking on behalf of myself. I'm not speaking on behalf of any business or entity, and I'm not taxpayer funded either. That's totally on my own dime. I'm not a lobbyist. I agree that sales taxes are often very, um, that unfairly cause hardship for
in-state businesses for competing across state lines. However, I think the obvious solution to that problem is to stop these oppressive taxes on the in-state businesses rather than imposing in them in a manner that I believe is unconstitutional on out-of-state businesses. Well, history, first I'll read Article 1, Section 10 of the U.S. Constitution. No state shall, without the consent of Congress, lay any impost or duties on imports or exports, except what may be absolutely necessary for executing its inspection laws and the net
produce of all duties and imposts laid by any state on imports or exports shall be for the use of the Treasury of the United States. And it goes on. Just after the Declaration of Independence was adopted and England was basically run out of the country, the colonies were operating under the Articles of Confederation. One of the problems with that, from what I understand, is that they were charging basically pretty high tariffs between state purchases for interstate commerce, basically.
And so what the U.S. Constitution did to help alleviate that problem was to establish free trade between the states. and that essentially eliminated and outlawed tariffs between states, i.e. imports and export taxes, essentially identical to what y'all are attempting or what y'all are voting on today, taxes between states. I think it's illegal. I think it's unconstitutional. I think it's a bad idea, and I wish for you to vote it down.
I'll take questions if you'd like. Thank you, sir. Any questions? If not, we're going to move to Mr. Randy Land. You're going to speak for the bill? Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Yeah, recognize yourself, sir. Proceed. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, committee members.
Speaker 127
37:30
I'm Randy Land. I'm the executive director of the Arkansas Home Furnishings Association. Our association is 89 years old with over 500 members, and over half of those are in the state of Arkansas. Most of those stores are second- and third-generation stores. These stores collect and remit sales tax. And like I explained earlier at another bill, Hank Brown with Hank's Furniture collected $3.4 million last year in sales tax and remitted,
and he paid $600,000 in property tax. That's $4 million that the people that we're talking about today out of state are not remitting to this state. These stores, and I know looking around this room and knowing most of you in this room, you can actually remember a store in your city or county, a furniture store that's gone out of business in the last few years. we've lost over 50 retailers in the last few years 50 furniture stores that's a
huge number in one state this size these stores were going out because the third generation coming in they didn't want to tackle the internet sales because people were actually coming in and showing where they could get it for the same price but say save by not paying sales tax that's not fair these stores are the people, the backbone of your community, the ones that support your schools, the ones that's in your Rotary, your Chamber of Commerce, your Lions Club, and all the civic clubs, and your churches
with your police and fire. These are supporters. Sorry to say, these people are out of state or not. I ask you today to look at this very close. My guys just want what's fair. That's all they want. It's not a new tax. It's not a new tax. In 1949, this law was passed, and it was because of one company, Sears and Roebuck. This is a catalog that my granddaddy gave my dad, my dad gave to me. You can buy a bedroom suit in here for $14.95, a whole solid oak suit. Sorry, we can't do that today.
But this bill or this law was passed because they were selling so many products by this catalog that they had to remit sales tax. We really appreciate you thinking about this with us and taking this so serious. Not only does the state can use and need this money, but please, let's consider these guys that's working so hard to keep their stores open.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Randy, will you answer a
question? Absolutely. Mr. Vice Chair, you have a question? Yes, Mr. Landon, I appreciate you being here today. You mentioned the law of 1949. Yes. Do you have that law in front of you? I do not. Okay. Do you mind if we bring somebody down and have them explain that law to us? Absolutely. Thank you very much. Would you mind going down?
Yeah. Thank you. Hold on just a second. Representative
Speaker 90
40:54
Murdoch, do you have something? Yes, Chairman. Thank you. I have a motion to extend debate.
The purpose of the motion is to try to extend the debate so that we can hear everyone that has traveled for the second time to this committee meeting for this purpose. We want to make sure that we give you consideration. So I'm going to say 15 minutes
Speaker 132
41:11
each side. I will extend debate. Is that in addition to? Yes. Yes, sir. That's what my motion will be. So
right now, on the four, you have one minute and 36 seconds. So members, to understand this, this is going to be 16 minutes and 36 seconds is how this is going to work.
Everybody understand? So the motion is that all in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, say no. So we just added 15 minutes aside to addition to what we have. So for the fours, you have 16 minutes and 36 seconds. Okay. Let's go back to Paul. You want to recognize
yourself and add on to that, please? Paul Goering, the assistant revenue commissioner for the Department of Finance Administration. I believe that the question from the vice chair was the foundation for the compensating use tax of 1949. DFA did make copies of that from the actual 1949 Acts
book. We have brought and made copies that were made available to
the members. Okay. Can you give us a brief synopsis of what it says? I mean, it
looks like it's 10, 15 pages here. Certainly. The brief synopsis of that, of the compensating tax or use tax in Arkansas is that the sales tax was enacted in 1941 here in Arkansas. And those sales applied to the transactions that were between, that were occurred in the state of Arkansas between
retailer located here and a customer here in Arkansas. Now, following that 1941 sales, gross receipts tax in 1941, you had the situation where you had out-of-state companies that would sell their products by catalog or by other means. And Arkansas residents were able to purchase those items. And since the retailer was not located here in Arkansas, you did not have a mechanism for the collection and the remittance of the tax.
So certainly the legislature responded in 1949 to shift the responsibility for paying the tax to the actual consumer that had the item brought to Arkansas or either they either had it delivered to Arkansas or they purchased it outside the state and it was brought into Arkansas and finally came to rest here within this state. It is a companion tax. It has the same tax base. It is collected in the same fashion, but certainly it is the equivalent of the sales tax, but
certainly it's paid directly by the taxpayer. It's not collected by the retailer. Okay,
I guess this is a question I'm going to ask. If this law is
already on the books, why do we need another one? The issue that has been presented to states is that the problem with that under the Quill case back in 1992 in the U.S. Supreme Court, the Quill case stated that you had to have a physical presence within the state in order for the state to extend their ability to require
an out-of-state company to collect and remit tax. The issue is what constitutes that presence, what constitutes that nexus. And this approach in the South Dakota bill that's the subject or the model of Senate Bill 140 is, it establishes an economic nexus, which is the approach that has been taken in several states that have a current law on the books that's the equivalent, as well as you'll see in the handout that DFA has provided, there are several states that are
currently trying to enact a South Dakota equivalent in their states as well. You have, in the model of the economic nexus, you set a threshold that you need at least $100,000 in sales per year within Arkansas or 200 separate transactions to establish that nexus. I guess my question is,
levies the tax on an item that is finally brought to rest within the state
of Arkansas has been on the books since 1949. The issue that I believe that the South Dakota approach is trying to address is to make sure that there are, the state has the ability to have retailers that are located out of the state that don't have a physical presence but have a economic presence in the state of Arkansas to make sure that they are collecting or emitting tax. Thank you. Thank you, sir. Mr.
Speaker 145
45:45
Ripson Officer. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and I guess a follow-up on Vice Chairman Farrar's question.
So if it's creating an economic nexus here, has the question been answered by DF&A? Or, Mr. Land, do you know how much revenue would be generated by this nexus or non-new tax? MR.
Speaker 127
46:02
I mean, I have no, I mean, there's no way of knowing. The figure that I've heard would be a minimum of $40 million. MR. So you
Speaker 145
46:13
have absolutely no idea. But the DF&A. So DF&A, could you answer that for us?
MR. Well, what might be helpful, Representative Armstrong, is that we currently collect use tax in the state of Arkansas well over $200 million per year. And so certainly you have many businesses, many individuals that are already paying the tax that is already owed. The issue is, in terms of being able to put a number upon what would actually be the amount of collections if all online retailers were complied with this bill that fell within the provisions of this bill is that currently DFA,
we just don't know the extent of the purchases that are being made by out-of-state retailers. You have no estimation of that? Well, there is a 2012 study that put that figure. I think the low number was between $30 million, $40 million. The top end was approximately $100 million. But certainly it's a number that is hard to quantify, and we want to be able to, we don't want to speculate as to a definite number
Speaker 145
47:22
until actually the collections are being. Fair enough. So between $30 and $100 million we're looking at here that we are guesstimating, and we just failed to pass an amendment to identify places that those resources could go. Rep. Armstrong? I understand, Mr. Chairman. I apologize. I'll pass on my follow-up question. Thank you. Thank you. Mr.
Land, you done, sir? Yes, sir. Okay. We're going back to, again, Mr. Josh Waters.
Are you here to speak against the bill? Please go over the end of
the table and recognize yourself. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you to the committee for extending debate on this very important topic. I very much appreciate that. My name is Josh Waters. I'm an attorney for political strategies, and Conduit for Action is our client, and I'm here to speak against SB 140. First, I wanted to address kind of something that was already discussed,
but I plan to address as well that we believe this is a new sales tax. The current law is already being discussed as a use tax, and this would create a new sales tax on the seller. I think there's three main reasons why we know this is a new sales tax. First, we had a separate bill that is not a companion bill, House Bill 1388, and that was dealing with an enforcement mechanism on the use tax that is on the books. Second, which has already been addressed, if this is not a new sales tax,
then why do we have a separate bill from HB 1388? And I think most importantly, we know this is a new sales tax because currently this bill is unconstitutional. Um, it was discussed about, um, the constitutionality of this bill. I wanted to make sure I addressed the distinction with the Colorado bill, which was HB 1388. That conduct for action has not taken a position on that bill. We do believe that's an enforcement mechanism on the use tax.
However, SB 140, the, which is similar to the South Dakota bill is a new sales tax. I think it's also important to point out in South Dakota, they have no income tax, and their sales tax is only 4.5%. And even in Colorado, their income tax is 4.63%, and their sales tax is 2.9%. Currently, Arkansas is 48th in the nation when it comes to the burden of sales and use taxes on the local and state level.
And, you know, I firmly believe this is a new sales tax and would increase the burden on everyday Arkansans and consumers. One other thing I wanted to address on the constitutionality of this bill, I think it's been mentioned in the court case of Quill Corporation v. North Dakota. The Supreme Court held in that decision under the Quill Doctrine, a presence or nexus in the state is a fundamental requirement before a state can levy a sales tax on a purchase.
That would make this bill unconstitutional. South Dakota did pass this bill, and it has already been challenged. I think an important thing to remember with South Dakota and Arkansas, we're in the same Eighth Circuit. So this would be a duplicative case that could end up in the same Eighth Circuit. And so my question is, should the taxpayers be forced to fund a duplicative test case that's already in the process of going up to the Supreme Court. I believe in the intent and findings section of this bill,
it talks about a concurring opinion that's used as, I guess it's being used as a way to bring this forward and say we should challenge this. But in that very same opinion, what you might not know is in a concurring opinion, It's not the Supreme Court precedent that's upheld. That's just an opinion by a separate justice. But in that same opinion, it's Direct Marketing Association versus Brawl,
which the justice in a concurring opinion says, yes, we may need to relook at this doctrine. In the very same opinion, under the majority opinion, which is the Supreme Court precedence, it states, and I quote, But under our negative Commerce Clause precedents, Colorado may not require retailers who lack a physical presence in the state to collect these taxes on behalf of the department. I would argue that under recent Supreme Court opinion that this continues to be unconstitutional based on that quote from the majority opinion in Direct Marketing Association v. Breaux.
In fact, in that opinion, it told the state, it was a procedural issue, it told the state we're taking it back to the Tenth Circuit and come back on appeal. And that opinion is where, hey, let's test this. Well, Colorado actually did test this, and the court decided not to hear it and denied cert. So I think that's an important aspect to consider here as well, the constitutionality aspect. And with that, in the interest of time, I know other people have traveled, so I would just close and I would ask for a no vote on this.
And if this bill does move forward, I think it's very important that we direct wherever these revenues, you know, this new tax, these new revenues, we direct where those need to go. I think that would be very important as well. So I appreciate your
time. You take a question, sir? Yes. Representative
Collins, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm not very good at legal mumbo-jumbo, but I'm more straightforward. Why do you think Amazon agreed to start collecting and remitting this tax in Arkansas the day after this bill passed in the Senate committee?
I think, thank you for your question, Representative Collins. I think Amazon, you know, just ideally, they would be very supportive of a bill. They are the e-commerce giant. And so they have a comparative advantage over small mom-and-pop startup e-commerce companies who would feel a heavier burden with this bill. So I think Amazon would support this. They have the comparative advantage and the cost and the people already in place to collect and remit this tax.
Then let me ask you the opposite question, sir. Why have they fought it for the past six years? Why have they fought the language? Why have they not collected and remitted Arkansas sales tax and fought every effort to enforce their collection of it over the last six years if they're in favor of collecting
and remitting? I mean, I can't speak to what their motives are to do that. I would just say, economically speaking, they would have a comparative advantage over these smaller mom-and-pop e-commerce companies.
And so that would be my suggestion is a reason why. I can't say specifically there are reasons for not doing it in the past. I know there are some other states that don't do it currently, but I couldn't say why Amazon specifically has fought that. President Hendren, you recognize her? Let me just
ask you this question summary and result. Do you think Amazon or any other outfit that's out of this state and doing business as a state, do you think that's where we ought to look to examples
to how we serve the people that send us down here in Arkansas, whether we ought to pass an increase in tax or how we spend it? Do you think we ought to call Amazon
and ask them how we should vote? I think we should. Personally, I think we should, just my personal opinion, look to the constituents and look to their feedback. At the end of the day, the taxpayers and the voters are the people who elect the representatives, And I think that's who should have the same.
Members, any questions? Thank you, sir. Thank you. For the bill, I have a Curtis, and I can't recognize the last name. Ms. Ferguson? Mr. Ferguson, go to the end of the table, and please recognize yourself,
sir, and you feel free to proceed. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm Curtis Ferguson. I'm a retail furniture merchant from Saline County, and I should have been a doctor the way I write.
I'll tell you, like Elizabeth Taylor told her eight husbands, I won't keep you long. I'm here to report on the war, the war I've been fighting for at least 15 years, and we're out two typewriters writing to you and your predecessors and to Congress about fairness in tax. We collect tax on people, and we send it in like we're supposed to do, and up to now
We have lost the war, but as of last Friday, we planted the flag on Mount Sarabuchi and have won a battle, a big one. And that's one big gorilla down, but we've got several of them to go. And I'll give you just, I'm not going to give you any precedents except just local stuff. You know, in Saline County, keep this in mind, Walmart paid $448,431 in property tax in Saline County.
And they done $18 billion on the Internet, and I think Amazon done $160 billion. So Walmart's paying their tax on sales of Internet sales, and they're paying property tax and working a lot of people, they paid $340,000 to the school districts of Saline County, and Amazon didn't pay nothing. Now, I'll just tell you about the Ferguson family, which is what we do. In order to do business in Saline County, we paid $90,000 in property tax,
of which $46,000 went to the Bryant School District, of which Bryant School District is not well-funded today. They got a four-mill tax before the voters coming up in March, which is going to cost my family $4,000. Now, that has to be passed through, just the additional millies. That has to be passed through. Now, had this tax been collected all these years on sales tax and it had been distributed
in the normal manner, of which 59% of the Bryant District's revenue comes from state, they wouldn't have to pass the tax to raise my tax bill for $4,000. So we're going to pay it one way or the other, and the fairness in paying it is getting those that are buying and reporting it. So I'll quote a little scripture to you. we're unevenly yoked, which you understand if one horse is pulling in one inch, you're
going to go in a big circle, and that's exactly what's happening. The brick-and-mortar people of the state of Arkansas are paying the local school district taxes. They're paying for the city taxes. They're sponsoring the ball teams. They're putting out sponsoring the Halloween carnivals and all the other things that local businesses do, and the Internet sellers are eating our lunch, and when you have a 10 percent less, when you could buy for 10 percent less, and the average profit margin of the type
business I'm in is 6 to 10 percent, you're going to wipe it out right quick. So if they are relieved of the tax and I am not, then it makes a huge competitive difference. We work 70 people in Saline County. We have a presence there that we intend to stay, but why should we have to fight Wayfair and Furniture.com
to furnish a showroom for folks to come in and look at the stuff and then buy from them, not pay the tax? Anyway, you see in the articles every day in the paper, the Pine Bluff Council is out of money. They need the tax. So if this tax had been paid like it should have been on retail sales, everybody would have enough money. I just realized that I'd been in the wrong fight all these years. After calling the DF&A and getting a copy of the CU1, you know, we should be spending money.
If we're not going to pass this bill and let the sellers pay the tax, we should spend some of the state's money on an advertising program to let people know they owe the tax. What we have here in this state is a delinquency problem. Out of a million, let's just say a million people bought on the Internet in 2016, if If they did, 999,932 of them are delinquent today because, according to the paper, 68
people have paid the tax and sent one of these reports in. So you've spent a lot of money on a lottery to raise some money for the state. I believe if you've got a 50 to 100 million dollar possibility on what folks owe, you'd have a lot better chance of filling up the state treasury on this than you would the lottery. So what I'd like to do is to encourage you guys to pass this on to the seller, because I think if you've done a survey of the million that we're just saying bought on the Internet,
if you've done a survey of them and asked them what they'd rather do, pay the tax when they buy the merchandise or fill out another form, I think they'll pay the tax and be glad to do it. Now, this is not a new tax. We all need to understand this is not a new tax. We need to read this form. It simply says if you buy it and if you use it, you put it in your inventory, you store it, you owe the money. And what I'd like to see is this bill passed in order to let the seller collect the tax,
remit it to the state, and you guys spend it wisely as you always have done. Thank you. Thank you.
Members, keep in mind there's only four minutes left to close for the bill. Representative
Speaker 145
1:02:27
Armstrong, you got a question? Thank you, Mr. Chair. So wouldn't you agree, I think I heard you speak to the funds that you guys are using your local communities to go towards schools and several other programs. Wouldn't the responsible thing for prudence be for us as lawmakers to identify ways to properly
allocate these funds as opposed to just collecting the tax and
then saying we'll decide on the fly? I think that the way the state allocates the funds now are very fair. I think everybody gets their fair share. The school district gets their fair share. The counties, the cities, you've had the mayor of Little Rock up here wanting money. Why don't you just keep the same distribution system you have now? And if you have some left over, then give us an income tax refund or take the tax off of groceries. I don't think you asked me, so I'll tell you. I think you need to leave it alone just like it is.
and not micromanage the income. It's not like the tobacco money or the big pharma money where it's coming in. It's $100 million. I know it's $100 million. That's close. It's $100 million people owe on the merchandise they're buying. Representative Hendren, you recognize, sir, and there's only two minutes and 58
seconds for the sponsor to close for us. I'll take 38 to 30 seconds maybe.
You know, all right, about your $4,000 you mentioned. And I guess one of the things I'd ask you this, then you have complete confidence that if we dump another $100 million down here,
that we won't grow government, we won't start another program, we won't spend it on something else, we'll send it to help you with your $4,000 increase in property
taxes. I trust you to spend it wisely. I think that the distribution system is fair, and I think everybody gets their part. And the talk is already about reducing the income tax, and I'd sure take a refund if you want to give me one. I'd like to have it, like to have less tax. And I'd like to see if this tax comes in, a reduction of the grocery tax, which helps everybody.
So I don't think anybody's complaining about the way you guys are spending the money. I think it's
okay. Thank you, sir. Mr. David Ray, you want to speak against the bill? And just, members, the sponsor has two minutes and one second to close for
this bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman and members of the committee, and thank you for the opportunity to extend debate on this bill. My name is David Ray with Americans for Prosperity, and I'm here to testify in opposition to Senate Bill 140.
For the past 25 years, the Supreme Court has held under Quill Corporation v. North Dakota since 1992, that absent congressional action, states cannot force companies without a physical nexus within their borders to collect and remit sales tax on behalf of the state. As has been mentioned, this bill is unconstitutional. I think the bill itself acknowledges this point on page two in line 34 where it says,
quote, existing constitutional doctrine, calls this act into question. Given the fact that this bill is based on an almost identical bill in South Dakota that is currently being litigated, and the intent of this bill is to incite a lawsuit, a test case, I feel that this effort is redundant and duplicative. In addition to deviating state resources on an unnecessary lawsuit that would distract our efforts from more meritorious work,
I would point out that the Supreme Court has provided a mechanism to address this issue, and that is through congressional action. If every state were to adopt its own tax compliance dragnet, almost anyone attempting to start a business online could suddenly become the subject of costly government audits from nearly every tax jurisdiction in the country, from which there are nearly 10,000. There's been a lot of discussion of fairness for brick-and-mortar stores, but there hasn't
been a lot of discussion about fairness for taxpayers also. We can split hairs about what's a tax or a fee or a new tax or not a new tax. But in my opinion, that misses the point. And the question that we should be asking ourselves is if this bill passes, will more money end up in the pocket of the state and less money end up in the pocket of citizens? And the answer is yes, by some estimates, as much as $100 million or more. I think the average citizen just following the newspaper headlines for the past couple of weeks
could be forgiven for wondering why this committee chose to and why the legislature has chose to reduce taxes by 50 million dollars one week and then turn around and increase them by as much or more than 100 million the next week lastly I believe that if this bill were simply concerned with leveling the playing field for brick-and-mortar stores versus online retailers then it would do something to offset those new revenues with the corresponding tax cut for citizens. And with that, I would encourage the members of this committee to please vote
against Senate vote 140. Thank you. Thank you. Members, we have two minutes and one second. People speak for the bill and the sponsor does want to be able to close for this bill. So up next is Mr. Nicholas Palmer. Sir, keep in mind you have two minutes, one second. The sponsor does request
Speaker 160
1:08:07
to close for Chris, Bill. Yes, sir. Thank you. I'm Nicholas Palmer, and I work for the Arkansas Home Furnishing Association.
Now, just to harp on a few things, make it short and sweet, this is about competition for me. In my job, I'm losing stores that are closing down because competition is now available. And just as an example, providing advantages is what I do. So having retailers that are available to not collect sales tax is an advantage that I cannot offer to my stores. So that is an advantage I feel is unfair, and I would like to just bring competition back to the state of Arkansas. Thank you, sir. I appreciate that.
Mr. Rich Huddleston, speak against the bill? Different bill. I'm sorry, sir? Oh, sorry. A different bill. Okay. Okay. Mr. Ellie Willer? No, different bill. Different bill as well? Okay. Can we have everybody finish speaking against the bill? Senator Fowles, you want to speak or close for your bill, sir? You have one minute and 27 seconds. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, members of the committee.
Speaker 11
1:09:14
I appreciate the opportunity to close here. To address a couple of the issues, taxpayer funding, a challenge. I talked to the Attorney General's office who felt like it would not be a problem at all with the data they have. And as you all know, there's a lot of misinformation. People can sit down here and say, this is a new tax, and this is that, and this is that. But we have heard testimony very clearly that this replaces an existing tax while there may be an increase in revenue. What I would say briefly in closing is that 45 states have come on board with Amazon,
and I would ask you to not let, like good, be the enemy of great. We all pass bills. We see bills that are not perfect, that don't do everything we wish they would do, and we vote them out of here because we believe in the merits overall. and I would ask you to take that matter of policy and advance this bill to the floor so that we could have a further debate on it, not just for us, but for our citizens and our community. This is the right thing to do, and I would ask for a vote in support of fairness and equity, and I appreciate your consideration. Thank you, sir.
Members, we've heard about an hour and 15 minutes of this, so I guess we're ready to take the vote here. What's the pleasure of the committee? Motion do pass. As amended. Motion do pass as amended. Any debate? All in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed say no. No. Call the roll, Ms. Eden.
Speaker 102
1:10:57
Representative Letting. Representative Letting. Representative Collins. Yes. Representative Murdoch. Representative Bolts. Representative Bolts. Representative Dotson. Representative Dotson. Representative Armstrong. Representative Armstrong.
Representative Bragg, Representative Saban, Representative Hodges, Representative THE BENANCE BIDEN'S SUBMISSION. THANK YOU, REPRESENTATIVE DOUGLAS. REPRESENTATIVE workshop. REPRESENTATIVE HENDRINE REPRESENTATIVE EEVES, REPRESENTATIVE EVES, REPRESENTATIVE FERGUSON, REPRESENTATIVE
FERGUSON, REPRESENTATIVE JOHNSON, REPRESENTATIVE julieFRreichen. REPRESENTATIVE JOHNSON. REPRESENTATIVE FLOWERS, REPRESENTATIVE FLOWERS. REPRESENTATIVE GRAY. REPRESENTATIVE GRAY. REPRESENTATIVE WATSON. REPRESENTATIVE WARN. REPRESENTATIVE Farrar I'm sorry sir
that was fun Is, uh, Representative Speaks, are you in the room, ma'am? We're going to let the members, we're going to let the audience kind of clear out, and then we're going to take up, uh, Senate Bill 282.
Bill 282. Representative Speaks, just give us a couple of minutes. Let's let the room clear
up. Representative Speaks, just recognize yourself, ma'am, and feel free to proceed.
Thank you so much. I'm here to talk about Senate Bill 282. There is only two things that this bill, that we're changing on it. is the five-day working for collectors and them to return their money, their tax money and that to the treasurer, giving them 10 days to do that. And the other thing is we are doing away
with the school district coordinators. Those were all cleaned up on and never has been cleaned up, but they were done back in 2015, so we're just cleaning that part up and giving the collectors the opportunity to where everybody can come together and they'll have 10 days to turn their taxes over to the treasurer so she can get them back to the school districts and the different entities where they go.
And I'd be happy to answer any questions, or I'd appreciate a good vote. Thank you, ma'am. Is there any pushback from
the county collectors or treasurers? This is their bill. This is agreed upon bill with everybody concerned. Right. This is the
Association of Counties bills. Representative Johnson, you got a question, sir?
Thank you, sir. Members, any other questions? Anybody in the audience want to speak against the bill, for the bill? Representative Collins, you're recognized.
I move do pass on the bill. We have a motion for do pass, any-
Agenda
REGULAR AGENDA
HB1395 Leding TO CREATE AN INCOME TAX CREDIT FOR TAXPAYERS THAT EMPLOY A RECENTLY RETURNED VETERAN.
HB1396 Leding TAX THE EDUCATION INDIVIDUAL SCHOLARSHIPS, FROM INCOME EXEMPT TOAWARDS, AND GRANTS FROM NONPROFIT VOLUNTEER SERVICE ORGANIZATIONS.
HB1397 Leding TO EQUALIZE THE SALES TAX TREATMENT OF DUES AND MEMBERSHIP FEES FOR CERTAIN CLUBS AND FACILITIES; AND TO LEVY A SALES TAX ON DUES AND MEMBERSHIP FEES TO CERTAIN FACILITIES AND CLUBS.
HB1014 Leding TO CREATE THE TEACHER'S CLASSROOM INVESTMENT DEDUCTION.
HB1449 Dotson TO AMEND THE ANNUAL FRANCHISE TAX FOR CORPORATIONS THAT ARE IN THE PROCESS OF LIQUIDATION.
SB140 Files TO PROVIDE FOR THE COLLECTION OF SALES AND USE TAX RATHER THAN USE TAX ON SALES BY CERTAIN REMOTE SELLERS.
HB1480 Ladyman TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF "ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT PROJECT" UNDER THE LOCAL SALES AND USE TAX ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT PROJECT FUNDING ACT.
SB282 B. Johnson COLLECTION THE AND OF DISTRIBUTION CONCERNING TO LAW THE AMEND /DELINQUENT PERSONAL TAXES.
HB1512 Davis TO REDUCE THE INCOME TAX RATES APPLICABLE TO INDIVIDUALS, TRUSTS, AND ESTATES USING THE REVENUES DERIVED FROM THE COLLECTION OF SALES AND USE TAX FROM SELLERS THAT DO NOT HAVE A PHYSICAL PRESENCE IN THE STATE.
SB253 B. Sample TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS HISTORIC REHABILITATION INCOME TAX CREDIT ACT.
DEFERRED BILLS Subtitle Number Sponsor
HB1028 Lemons TO EXEMPT CERTAIN BUSES, COACHES, AND OTHER MOTOR VEHICLES FROM SALES AND USE TAXES.
HB1031 Bentley TO CREATE AN INCOME TAX EXEMPTION FOR INCENTIVES RECEIVED UNDER THE COMMUNITY MATCH RURAL PHYSICIAN RECRUITMENT PROGRAM.
HB1153 Boyd TO CLARIFY THE MEANING OF "ACTUAL AND OBVIOUS ERRORS" ON THE PART OF A COUNTY ASSESSOR IN THE ASSESSMENT OF REAL AND PERSONAL PROPERTY; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1221 Sabin TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE SALES AND USE TAX EXEMPTION FOR SALES
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Joe Jett Chair
Unverified
Speaker 11
Representative Dan M. Douglas
Unverified
Representative Kim Hendren
Unverified
Representative Vivian Flowers
Unverified
Speaker 55
Representative Charlie Collins
Unverified
Speaker 68
Speaker 54
Speaker 90
Speaker 102
Representative Bob Johnson
Unverified
Paul Calvert
Unverified
Speaker 127
Representative Joe Farrer
Unverified
Speaker 132
Speaker 136
Speaker 145
Josh Waters
Unverified
Chair
Unverified
David Ray
Unverified
Speaker 160
Speaker 167
Speaker 151
Speaker 169
Representative Nelda Speaks
Unverified